We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 60—Office of the Minister for Social Welfare (Resumed).

Contributions 194–431 of 431. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

It was never intended to withdraw it. Surely the Deputy does not believe that. Does he not think that we have a little bit of political sense? Does he think we would go to the country and say: "We are reducing the national health benefit"? Fine Gael, when they took 1/- off the old age pension, were fired out and that was a lesson to everybody.

Comment on this

You were thrown out also.

Comment on this

You were thrown out because you did not do what you promised to do. Let us come back to the old age pensions. When the Coalition came into office the old age pensioners in the cities and towns had 15/- and in rural areas 12/6. I want to repeat that I did not accuse Deputy Desmond of telling a deliberate falsehood because I know he would not be capable of doing it, but his memory is wrong. On 1st April, 1947, the pensions were increased in cash in the rural areas to 12/6 and in the cities and urban areas to 15/-

Comment on this

In the rural areas that I am conversant with was it not fromthe home assistance officer that the old age pensioner had to get 2/6?

Comment on this

I will answer that. If the Deputy will look at the Dáil Debates at that time he will see that the Dáil voted £2,000,000 on the last day of March, 1947, to cover the increase and from that date the post office books were over-stamped, because it was done in a hurry, and the Post Office paid out to old age pensioners in the cities and towns 15/- and in rural areas 12/6, and the local authorities were told that they could pay another 2/6 in addition to that if they liked. I invite Deputy Desmond or any other Deputy to put down a question to me and I will give all these particulars with day and date for them. Deputy Norton came along and he raised the old age pension to 17/6 in all areas in 1949. We came along in 1951 and we raised it to £1 for everybody, and in 1952 we raised it to 21/6 for everybody. That is the history of the matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Beegan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Beegan) Fianna Fáil

We raised the lower income ceiling also.

Comment on this

What are we told about the cost of living? The cost of living when we came into office was 109 and it is now 125. If we liked to argue the point that the pension was 17/6 a week when we came into office, the cost of living has gone up 16 per cent. But we raised the old age pension by much more than 16 per cent. Therefore, I say that the Labour and Fine Gael Deputies who talk about the miserable pittance of the old age pensioners are condemning themselves because they left the old age pensioners in 1951, even taking the cost of living into account, with a lower and more miserable pittance than they have to-day.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is true. The Deputy knows well it is true but he will not admit it. It is all right for Deputies to talk about the miserable pittance, but they left them with 17/6 when going out in 1951 and now they have 21/6. I will go this far. We will admit that they were taken very shortly, that the Labour Party believed that Fine Gael were with them in giving 2/6 toold age pensioners and did not know that Fine Gael were going to play a trick on them when they brought in the 2/6 by having a general election. We will admit the Labour Party were sincere in giving the 2/6. Even so, when Deputy Norton brought in the 17/6 in 1949, he said—Deputies can go back and read the speeches—that the old age pensioners were now being looked after as they should be. In other words, everything was properly done in 1949 and they had as much as they could expect, under the circumstances, and so on.

Comment on this

Read your 1932 speeches.

Comment on this

We will take the effort of the Labour Party in 1949 as being a sincere and generous effort and forget about 1951 and work up from there. The cost of living is 25 per cent. higher now than in 1949. Therefore, if we were to do as well as the Labour Party who gave this Magna Charta to the old age pensioners in 1949 we should add 25 per cent. to the 17/6. What is that? I think it is about 4½d. more that we should be giving. It is extraordinary that the Labour Party which was so satisfied in 1949 should now have held us up for two days talking about the miserable amount we are giving to the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

We will hold you up again.

Comment on this

We know, of course, that you will do it again. This talk has been going on for two days because we have given 4 ½d. less than we should have given according to Deputy Norton's Magna Charta of 1949.

Comment on this

Butter was not 4/2 a lb. in 1949.

Comment on this

That is all it comes to— 25 per cent. on the cost of living. There was a Deputy speaking yesterday—I think it was Deputy Rooney; he would be capable of it—who said that the cost of living had gone up on the old age pensioner by 7/4. He took a loaf of bread, a stone of flour, a pound of butter, a pound of tea—imagine a pound of tea in the week for an old age pensioner—and a pound of sugar andhe added them up and got 7/4. It was a nice simple way of doing it, I must admit. These are the sort of mathematics we get from Deputy Norton, Deputy O'Leary and other Deputies of that kind.

Comment on this

Do you remember when you said in the Budget that 1/6 would meet the cost of living on the old age pensioners?

Comment on this

Yes, meet the cost of living, as the Budget of that year had changed it. As I said already here, no Party in this country—I do not know about any other Party in any other country—Cumann na nGaedheal from 1922 to 1932, the Fianna Fáil Government after that or the Coalition Government, at any time purported to give the old age pensioner what would cover his rent, rates, tobacco, Deputy Flanagan's pint a day and the diet that Deputy Desmond laid down that would be given to an agricultural labourer. It was never contemplated that that would be given. When Deputy Norton brought in his Bill in 1949, which had the full approval of the Labour Party, it did not cover all that, even at what those items cost at that time. He did not cover in 17/6 what it would cost for food for an agricultural labourer. It was 3/4 per day for an agricultural labourer at that time; seven times that would be 23/-. That exceeds the 17/6 already. Then there is the pint a day, the two or three ounces of tobacco, the rates and all the rest. No one ever contemplated doing it. The most we can do for the old age pensioners is to help them. You may use that against us if you like. The most anyone can ever do is to help them. The great majority of old age pensioners have help through relatives and so on. I admit that some of them have not, that some have nothing else to get, but what can we do about it? We are helping them as much as we can.

I could go through these other things as well. I could take the sickness allowance. There was a lot of criticism about that. Deputy Flanagan said a man should get the full wage when sick. Deputy Hickey was talking about 4 ½d. for a meal. That was the sort ofstuff we had. Take a man with a wife and two children, the most favourable case for myself—I do not see why I should not, as the Labour Party and Fine Gael were not behind the door in that, either. He gets 50/- a week and there would be also 2/6 for the second child—more than he had in 1951—that is 52/6. If he was a sick man in 1951 he got 22/6. He gets 52/6 now. That more than covers the cost-of-living increase. If Deputy Hickey is right—I did not check his figures—in saying that a man with a wife and family has only 4 ½d. per meal now, what had he in 1951 per meal—and why was Deputy Hickey silent in 1951 about it? I could say the same about the unemployed men. I want to repeat that I am not saying this because I think the sick man or the unemployed man is getting enough. I am saying this to expose the hypocrisy of certain Parties who, when they see that social welfare benefits are increased considerably over what they did, attack us as if nothing at all was done.

Comment on this

It is not enough.

Comment on this

Of course it is not enough. We all know that.

Comment on this

You gave the judges £450 and not a word about it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The Minister must realise that his Social Welfare Act was not opposed by this Party.

Comment on this

Of course, it was not.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Is there any harm in looking for more?

Comment on this

Not a bit of harm. Deputy Corish made a reasonable speech here, but when Deputies say Fianna Fáil did nothing it is hard to stick that sort of thing—from Deputies who were so mute during the Coalition time. It shows the mentality of the Labour Party—they are on to us to do more, but when they were there themselves they never got on to Deputy Norton to do anything.

Comment on this

How do you know?

Comment on this

They never said a word here. They may have got on to himbehind closed doors, but they got no result, anyway.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is entitled to reply without interruption. Deputies have already had an opportunity of making their statements.

Comment on this

How did he vote in March, 1951?

Comment on this

He is dead nuts on the Labour Party, but only for the Labour Party he would not be a Minister in 1932.

Comment on this

Unemployment benefit was attacked also.

Comment on this

Take a single man in that.

Comment on this

Stop the interruptions !

Comment on this

Why should I take a single man?

Comment on this

You try it and see.

Comment on this

Surely we should take the man with a family who is worse off. The man with a wife and two children is the man you would have a bit of pity for?

Comment on this

Try it the other way.

Comment on this

All right, but let me take this one first. The unemployed man with a wife and two children had 35/- under the Coalition Government. Things were grand and there was no motion put down to increase it or anything else.

Comment on this

They increased the stamps on the employed.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen is coming to the Minister's help.

Comment on this

Yes, they increased the contributions on him—that is all they did. Now it is 50/- plus 2/6 for the second child. He has got an increase of 40 to 45 per cent. The cost of living has gone up 25 per cent., so the unemployed man if he knew the truth—I do not expect he will be told the truth by any of the Parties opposite—wouldsay: "I may be badly off, but at least Fianna Fáil have done better than the others for me."

Comment on this

He is badly off, because the work is stopped.

Comment on this

What did the Minister do in 1951 when Deputy Norton's Bill was here? He and the rest voted against it. There were to be pensions at 65.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Desmond has already spoken. Deputies should allow the Minister to conclude without these interruptions.

Comment on this

We want to remind him now and again.

Comment on this

He is looking for it.

Comment on this

Take the contributory widow's pension. She had, when the Coalition Government was going out, 22/-, 26/-, 27/- or 28/- according to the occupation that her husband had held and the area of her residence. That is, if she had two children, of course. Now she has 38/-

Comment on this

She is made up with that, according to you.

Comment on this

She is better off than under you, anyway.

Comment on this

She never was worse off.

Comment on this

She got an increase of from 26 per cent. to 72 per cent. That covers the cost-of-living increase. The non-contributory poor woman who was not insured at all and who had two children, had 22/- to 26/- then ; she has now 32/-. She has not fared as well as the other lady, but she has got an increase of from 20 to 30 per cent. Take unemployment assistance. The man with a wife and two children, if he was living in a town, had 28/-: now he has 38/-. That represents an increase of about 26 per cent. If he was living in a rural area, he got 18/-: now he has 28/-. That represents an increase of 38 per cent. All round, every one of these increases would more than cover the increase in the cost of living since 1951.

I have been asked what did we do in 1951. Deputy Davin constantly asks me that question and Deputy O'Higgins tackled me with it yesterday. They accused me of voting against an increase in old age pensions in 1947. I should like to deal with that. It is the only thing that they can cast at me. Last night, when I heard Deputy O'Higgins talk, I felt that I must have a great record for social welfare when the only thing that they can cast against me is that I voted against a cock-eyed motion which was moved by Fine Gael in this House on 20th March, 1947. It was the silliest and the most cock-eyed motion ever moved in this House. This is how it read:—

"That Dáil Éireann is of opinion that the basis upon which income is assessed for the purpose of the means test in the case of persons entitled to old age pensions, blind pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions, requires revision and in particular that in assessing income for such purpose, no cognisance should be taken of (a) gratuities paid to a pensioner by members of his or her family whether in cash or in kind; (b) any benefits received otherwise than in actual cash, and (c) casual moneys earned by the pensioner, and requests the Government to take all necessary steps accordingly."

That motion was in the names of the late Deputy Dr. O'Higgins and Deputy Costello. Deputy O'Higgins described him last night as the "Leader of the Opposition". I suppose I can accept that from all Parties—that Deputy Costello is the Leader of the Opposition.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Is that meant to be a slight on Deputy Costello?

Comment on this

I just want to know where I am. I suppose I can accept it that the Labour Party accept Deputy O'Higgins's statement that Deputy Costello is the Leader of the Opposition.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

We will not be answerable to you, no matter what our position is.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

This is a point of order, Sir. Deputy Costello is the Leader of the Opposition. The Minister and the country know that well. There is no necessity for any facetious references by the Minister.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Deputy Mulcahy, as Leader of the Opposition, is paid a Government grant.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Sit down.

Comment on this

And, for the information of the Minister, Deputy Norton is the leader of the Labour Party. The Minister knows that well.

Comment on this

I thought that.

Comment on this

And Deputy Cowan is the leader of his own Party.

Comment on this

And Deputy Dr. Browne is the boss.

Comment on this

The Labour Party is an independent Party. It is not under any other Party. It is entirely independent and under neither Fianna Fáil nor Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Deputy Cowan is the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

He does not claim that. I should like to get back now, if I may, to this motion which was proposed by Deputy Costello—I do not know how I will describe him now.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You will shortly be describing him as the Taoiseach. The very moment you give the people a chance of indicating their views, Deputy Costello will be the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I started to deal with this motion, which was moved in 1947. I said that (a)—gratuities paid to a pensioner by members of his or her family, whether in cash or in kind— was already allowed, but that Fine Gael did not know it. They brought in a motion which showed their interest in the old age pensioners. With regard to (b)—any benefits received otherwise than in actual cash—I said that the old age pensioner is already allowed that, too, but that Fine Gael did not know it. They put down amotion in order to create a bit of trouble, I suppose. They did not know what the old age pensioner was entitled to receive. They wanted me to accept a cock-eyed motion that did not mean anything, because the old age pensioner had it already.

Comment on this

What did you say it would cost?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

£500,000.

Comment on this

The only thing that Deputy Davin can throw at me is that I voted against that cock-eyed motion. Of course, the Labour Party voted for it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The Minister said that the old age pensioners already had the benefit of the provisions of that motion.

Comment on this

With regard to (c)— casual moneys earned by the pensioner —I said that it was estimated in my Department that it would cost about £500,000. I did not say that we could not afford it. If Deputy Davin can find any record that I said that we could not afford it I shall be interested to see it.

Comment on this

The point is that you voted against the motion.

Comment on this

I gave my reasons for voting against the motion.

Comment on this

You also voted against the other one on the 2nd March, 1951.

Comment on this

I would much prefer to hear what the Minister proposes to do about the present plight of the old age pensioners, the blind pensioners and the widows and orphans than to spend our time now going back to what happened in 1947.

Comment on this

I will read out (c) for the House again—casual moneys earned by the pensioner. Bear in mind that that is what the Fine Gael Party wanted us to accept. I said that I did not agree with the motion. I further said that if the Fine Gael Party would put up a proposition to do away altogether with the means test we would discuss it butthat we would not agree to the sort of proposition contained in the motion which they moved in this House on 20th March, 1947. I pointed out the position of an old woman who continues to work for an old client by doing two days' charring a week and who gets 6/- per week for it. I pointed out that, under law, that 6/- counted against her as means. If the Fine Gael Party wanted to change the law, why did they not tackle the case of the poor charwoman?

Comment on this

For one thing, they were not 16 years in office, like Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary always tries to defend Fine Gael. When I was explaining to the House what the motion meant, I looked up to the press gallery and saw the journalists there. Of course, there were different people there then. I asked the House to take as an example a journalist who has retired from regular work and who, let us say, has a large pension. If that man writes an occasional article he will get five or ten guineas for it but that will not count against him. I asked the House if I was expected to vote for a cock-eyed Fine Gael motion, and to please Deputy Davin, which would debar a poor old charwoman who is regularly getting 6/- per week for doing two days' charring for an old client while a casual worker such as a retired journalist or a retired barrister can do occasional work whenever they feel like it without being affected. If a retired barrister gives an opinion and charges ten or 20 guineas, that will not count against him. If a retired journalist writes an occasional article for a newspaper and gets ten guineas for it, that will not count against him. However, a poor old charwoman who is getting 6/- a week for doing two days' charring would have to submit to having that amount put down against her as means.

Comment on this

That is a cock-eyed argument.

Comment on this

Fine Gael wanted me to vote for that motion. The Labour Party voted for it; they would vote for anything like that.

Comment on this

You voted for your own pension.

Comment on this

Let the Minister give us some more of that. I am enjoying it.

Comment on this

I was asked for my objection. I said that I could not accept (c)—casual moneys earned by the pensioner. I pointed out that (a) and (b) were there already and accepted. Fine Gael did not know that (a) and (b) were there already. I said that I could not accept the motion and I gave my reasons. Since that day, the 22nd October, 1947, every time a discussion arises here on social welfare, Deputy Davin asks me what did I do in 1947 and why did I vote against the motion.

Comment on this

And in 1951.

Comment on this

In spite of all that I have said, the next time a discussion on social welfare arises, he will remind me again. Deputy O'Higgins has taken it up now. Is it not a great tribute to me that this is the only thing they can say against me so far as social welfare is concerned?

Comment on this

That is a cock-eyed argument.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

The Minister flatters himself.

Comment on this

I certainly do, if that is the only thing you can say against me.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

There is a big "if" there.

Comment on this

Somebody said to-day that it would be much better to remove the means test altogether. I often get an estimate of that. I think I would favour it if I could get the money.

Comment on this

Look for it and we will support you.

Comment on this

I do not expect that the Labour Party would agree to give me the money, considering that, in 1952, when we gave £7,000,000 in social services and when we brought in taxes for the purpose, they even voted against the increase in income-tax, even though the increase applied onlyto the 18,000 most wealthy people in the country. Are we to expect a Party like that to support us?

Comment on this

This is the real crossroads talk.

Comment on this

They will, of course, support us in giving more to the old age pensioner and the widow.

Comment on this

The House will remember the effort to remove the means test in the mother and child scheme.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

And will remember the time when Deputy Cowan was waging war on Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

When we ask for the money, Labour will go in with Fine Gael, will follow the Fine Gael Whip, and vote against the tax whatever it may be, as they did in 1952, as they did when they voted against the increased income-tax in 1952 and when that increase, as I say, applied to only 18,000 of the most wealthy people in the country. These are the men who say to me: "We will support you if you raise the old age pension." Of course, they would, if I could get it out of my own pocket or out of the air, but if I look for the money, they will not support me.

Comment on this

Look for it in the right quarter.

Comment on this

Where is the right quarter?

Comment on this

Get it from the imperialists and the industrialists.

Comment on this

Where is the right quarter?

Comment on this

Take it out of the banks.

Comment on this

I do not want any support from the Labour Party in increasing these pensions. What I want to see is the Labour Party putting down a motion, supported by Fine Gael—because Fine Gael ought to support them sometimes, as they always support Fine Gael—setting out the increased benefits and the taxesthat will bring the money in. If they do so, we will find it very hard to resist it. I do not say that we will accept it, but we will find it very hard to resist it. Let them try it, anyway.

Comment on this

Follow Deputy Norton into the Lobby to-night and you will see what will happen.

Comment on this

Promise, and then go to the country. Let us talk about this suggestion for no means test. Old age pension costs £2,000,000 and does every Deputy not agree that, if we do it for the old age pensioners, we will have to do it for the widows, because we could not very well leave them out? That is another £1,500,000, making a total of £4,000,000. There is the problem—it will cost £4,000,000 to do it. If the Parties opposite like to make this a non-Party issue, I shall be glad to meet them.

Comment on this

We will be delighted.

Comment on this

And tell us where we will get the £4,000,000.

Comment on this

Get it out of the Dublin Castle money.

Comment on this

Dublin Castle! That is the sort of help we get from that Party, and it shows the sincerity of these Deputies. They have no sincerity whatever in this matter.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

On a point of order, when some speakers from this Party attempted to say how money could be raised for the purpose of increasing the benefits under the Social Welfare Act of 1952, they were ruled out of order, and I suggest it is not reasonable to allow the Minister to continue in this strain when we were not allowed to refer to it.

Comment on this

Nothing was stopped.

Comment on this

The Labour Party voted against every tax we proposed, including the increase in income-tax.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

No, that is untrue.

Comment on this

It is easy to prove itfrom the records. If the Parties opposite are sincere, let them come along with that proposition and let them make it a non-Party issue. Some Deputies tried to give the impression that the means test is more severe now than when we came into office in 1951. When we went out in 1948, the means test in respect of old age pensions ranged from £21 to £29, according to the area. If a person had anything more than that, it counted against him for pension purposes. Deputy Norton made that £29 to £39, and in our Bill we made it £52 10s. He went up by £10; we went up by £13 10s.

Comment on this

You put the cost of living up—he did not.

Comment on this

I dealt with that before the Deputy came in and I do not want to deal with it again. I do not think that Deputies would wish me to do so. The Deputy can read all about it. These figures refer to the widows' means test. It was £59 in 1947 and was raised to £96, and in our Bill it was £130 15s. In the case of the old age pension, it was £15 12s. 6d., and anything over that began to count against the applicant, up to 1949. Deputy Norton raised it to £22 12s 6d., by £7, and we raised it to £52 10s., or by £30 over that figure.

Comment on this

Was there not a circular sent out to social welfare officers asking them to raise the income assessment in the case of certain applicants?

Comment on this

I am giving figures in relation to the means test.

Comment on this

Did you issue a direction to social welfare officers to make higher assessments?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy cannot make a second speech.

Comment on this

He is only asking a question.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He is not in order in asking any question.

Comment on this

Was that not an instruction to make higher assessments?

Comment on this
John Lynch Parliamentary Secretary to the Government (Mr. Lynch) Fianna Fáil

It shows the bad case they made in the debate.

Comment on this

We heard about the 1951 proposals, and we are told that we voted against them. We brought in an amendment because they were not as good as they should be, and we argued that they should have remembered children's allowances, old age pensions and widows' pensions in the scheme. By the time the Bill reached the Dáil, Deputy Norton had embodied a proposal in relation to old age pensions.

Comment on this

At 65.

Comment on this

Not at 65, at that time. He brought in a proposal with regard to old age pensioners, and our attitude was that he should withdraw the Bill and bring in a better Bill because we wanted him to increase widows' pensions and children's allowances as well. What was the attitude of the Labour Party? It was: "We will not give anything to the widows or in respect of children's allowances." To our suggestion that the then Minister should withdraw the Bill, the Parties opposite said no.

Comment on this

Let the Minister be honest now.

Comment on this

Look it up and you will find that it is a fact. It was a bit of debacle, so far as the Labour Party were concerned. The general election came along and that was the end of it. Such as the proposals were, they dealt with sickness, unemployment, unemployment benefit and old age pensions, but did not deal with widows or children's allowances. These were brought into our scheme, and, even though Deputies on the Fine Gael and Labour Benches may say to me: "Look at our proposals," the fact is that there was nothing done for widows and orphans or for children's allowances in these proposals and, what is more, nothing was intended to be done for these people. Even in their motion to-day the Labour Party have shown their bias against children's allowances. They did not include them to-day.

Comment on this

You are dead nuts on the Labour Party.

Comment on this

You must be afraid of the Labour Party in Wexford.

Comment on this

You need not court them. They will never join you again. You have the boys. Keep them now.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Everett cannot make a speech at this stage. The Minister is in possession.

Comment on this

He is not telling the truth.

Comment on this

He never did.

Comment on this

I would not like to have Deputy O'Leary's definition of what truth is.

Comment on this

What did you say?

Comment on this

If Deputies would only calm down I could talk about something else. Some Deputies asked for an explanatory leaflet on the social welfare regulations. An explanatory booklet is being prepared. The intention is, as has been the practice for some years past, to reissue this booklet and bring it up to date from time to time. The booklet will be issued in the very near future and will deal with all the regulations now made. As I have said, it will be brought up to date from time to time.

Deputy Blowick made a claim here. I suppose I should deal with it. He spoke about children's allowances. Deputy Blowick is not here now, but when he spoke yesterday he said——

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance is the man who will give you the money for our motion.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick said that there would never have been children's allowances without him and his Party, that they made us bring in children's allowances.

Comment on this

And we did.

Comment on this

He claimed more than that. He said he made us bring in a lot of other beneficial schemes.

Comment on this

Faith, we did.

Comment on this

Could Deputy Cafferky, speaking for Deputy Blowick, say we ever did anything wrong?

Comment on this

An awful lot.

Comment on this

Why did you not stop us then? There you are now. That is enough about that.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

You had better read out what the Minister for messages brought in.

Comment on this

A lot of help it would be for the poor old people.

Comment on this

It is very clear what the Labour Party voted against when we wanted to give money to the old age pensioners. Here it is:—

"That surtax for the year beginning on the 6th day of April, 1952, shall be charged in respect of the income of any individual the total of which from all sources exceeds £1,500 and shall be so charged at the same rates as those at which it is charged for the year beginning on the 6th day of April, 1951."

Who voted against that? Deputies Brendan Corish, William Davin, James Everett, Michael Keyes, Thomas Kyne, James Larkin, Johnny O'Leary, William Murphy and Dan Spring.

Comment on this

And Dr. Ryan.

Comment on this

Was Tulyar in that?

Comment on this

And that was the Party that was all out to do something for the old age pensioners. I gave them an increase out of moneys that we got in the way of tax from individuals with an income of over £1,500 and the Labour Party voted against it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Was that motion taken on its own?

Comment on this

It was. That Resolution was taken on its own.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister what he is quoting from? It is the usual procedure to quote the volume.

Comment on this

It was Resolution No. 1. That is what it was.

Comment on this

What was the Resolution?

Comment on this

I read it out—that thetax in respect of the income of any individual in receipt of £1,500 a year be increased. That was on the 2nd April, 1952.

Comment on this

Read it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

What is the full Resolution?

Comment on this

Here it is again:

"That surtax for the year beginning on the 6th day of April, 1952"—

It does not say here to cover the old age pensioners but that is what it was for—

"shall be charged in respect of the income of any individual the total of which from all sources exceeds £1,500 and shall be so charged at the same rates as those at which it is charged for the year beginning on the 6th day of April, 1951.

(3) That the several statutory and other provisions which were in force on the 5th day of April, 1952, in relation to income-tax and surtax shall have effect in relation to the income-tax and surtax to be charged as aforesaid for the year beginning on the 6th day of April, 1952.

(4) It is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act, 1927 (No. 7 of 1927)."

Then the question was put.

Comment on this

There is nothing about old age pensions in that.

Comment on this

The question was put.

Comment on this

Give us the volume.

Comment on this

The volume is 130 and the column is 1172. As I said, every Labour member present voted against it.

Comment on this

That was Tulyar money.

Comment on this

Now they come along and ask me to give more money to the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

Try it to-night.

Comment on this

Let us come back to another calm subject.

Comment on this

More facts.

Comment on this

Deputy Murphy of Cork complained that Dáil Deputies had not the right of approach to the appeals officer in the case of old age pensions. I must say that I am against that. We should aim at seeing that every person in this country who is entitled to a benefit, whatever it may be, should get it without the intervention of a Deputy or anybody else. I hope we will be able to do that before long. That is why this Act was drawn up in that way so that there would be an appeals officer and so on. I can tell Deputies —they will be able to find out whether I am telling the truth or not—that I never interfered—I have not the power to interfere—with any decision made by the appeals officer. I often asked for a report. If a Deputy writes to me in connection with the case of some person, I ask for a report and I send the report on as I get it.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

You have no authority to interfere?

Comment on this

None whatever.

Comment on this

Then would a litigant have any need to have counsel in court?

Comment on this

He will not see the judge in his chambers.

Comment on this

The next point was one raised by Deputies Murphy and Flanagan in connection with a man working on the roads who has a wife older than himself. He is 67 years of age and the wife is 70. For half an hour Deputy Flanagan gave me a lecture on doles and charity. I cannot understand the plea on behalf of this man. Why does not the man support his wife when he is working? Why should he get an old age pension when he is working? Why should he not support his wife? I cannot see any case at all for an old age pension in that case.

Comment on this

When she comes to a certain age she is entitled to it.

Comment on this

That is a different matter. We have not legislated for everybody to get a pension at 70 years of age. If we did that it would be all right. We have brought in old age pensions at 70 years of age for people who qualify and in order to qualify they must qualify on means. If the man is earning more than £4, then his wife cannot get the pension. In any event, I do not see the case because he is supporting his wife.

Comment on this

How could two people live on £4? Have sense, man.

Comment on this

If he has more than £4 that is the law. If he had more than 30/- when the Coalition was in office his wife would not get it.

Comment on this

People were not paying 4/2 for butter.

Comment on this

The people had not to pay 4/2 for butter.

Comment on this

And 9d. for the loaf.

Comment on this

I gave all the figures in respect of these things. Deputy Flanagan says the man could not live on £4. I say if he had 30/- in the time of the Coalition he could not get a pension for his wife.

Comment on this

The cost of living was lower.

Comment on this

You maintain that an old woman of 70 years, the wife of a worker——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy has already spoken.

Comment on this

We would like to get clarification from the Minister.

Comment on this

We have heard Deputies here from Fine Gael and Labour in the last two days making the allegation that Fianna Fáil did nothing for social services. As a matter of fact, if we took the global figure—I suppose it is the only figure we could take—of what we paid out through the Exchequer from 1932 we would find that it has increased by £16,000,000, and during the term of office of the Coalition Governmentit increased by a little less than £1,500,000. Therefore, if you take the years we were in office as against those in which the Coalition were in office, we could now sit down for 14 years. That is a long time.

Comment on this

Too long.

Comment on this

We could sit down and do nothing and still have done more per year for the 14 years than the Coalition.

Comment on this

You will be sitting for 14 years after the next general election.

Comment on this

You are too long in office. You have gone stale.

Comment on this

The point is that at the 1951 election we promised to do what we proposed to do. The Coalition promised to do what they had no intention of doing. The people believed us and did not believe the Coalition.

Comment on this

Not at all. What about the bluebells?

Comment on this

What about the subsidies?

Comment on this

What about the 17 points?

Comment on this

And the four bluebells?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister might be allowed to conclude.

Comment on this

Including the bluebell from Strasbourg.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Some of the Deputies said you could give old age pensions to everybody and save it on administration. That claim was made by Deputy Palmer and we all know that he is a man who has some knowledge of figures. Can Deputy Palmer do a sum like this—can he subtract £8,000,000 from £2,000,000? If he cannot do that, what he suggests is impossible.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach could do that.

Comment on this

He said we could double the pension for everybody and save iton administration, in other words subtract £9.5 million from £2,000,000!

Comment on this

I simply gave that as an example of where some portion would be saved.

Comment on this

You did not make that clear.

Comment on this

You should have got the British Encyclopaedia or the Oxford English dictionary. They would have cleared it up.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That would be your dish.

Comment on this

That is the Taoiseach's dish. When is a Republic not a Republic?

Comment on this
An Leas-Ceann Comhairle

That has nothing to do with the motion.

Comment on this

Another proposal was to abolish the means test.

Comment on this

Will some of you shut up?

Comment on this

I think you ought to put the motion, sir. We have listened to enough of this nonsense.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You cannot take it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the interruptions would cease the Minister could conclude.

Comment on this

I am going to finish now.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I am glad the Opposition have applauded that. We are asked to vote for a certain motion here put down by the Labour Party and I have not the slightest doubt that Fine Gael will vote with them. I have not the slightest doubt also that if Fine Gael came in to-morrow they would have no notion of implementing it because the Fine Gael Party are always ready to vote for a thing, always ready to support something but never to do it. The only promise they ever carried out was to take the 1/- off the old age pensions in 1929. They never did anything else for social welfare but theywill vote for this, they will vote to have contributions increased all round——

Comment on this

There would be no need if you brought back the £70,000,000 from England.

Comment on this

——and the Labour Party are foolish enough to rely on that support. We will not support this motion because we do not promise anything we do not give.

Comment on this

What about the 17 points?

Comment on this

If I am in order I will deal with the 17 points.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They do not arise.

Comment on this

Give us the 17 points. We would like to hear them.

Comment on this

We will deal with them on the Taoiseach's Estimate.

Comment on this

I move to suspend Standing Orders so that the Minister can give us the 17 points. Will you take a motion so that the Minister can deal with them?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair cannot accept such a motion.

Comment on this

I am sorry for that because we would love to hear the Minister dealing with the question of the 17 points. They have a fine fruity flavour.

Comment on this

They compare very favourably with the ten points of the Coalition. We are not going to vote for this motion. We will make no promises unless we are going to carry them out. We brought in increased benefits on 1st July, last year, which is only a little over a year ago, and I think it is unreasonable that the Opposition should seek to have them revised so quickly. I think the Parties opposite realise that, and I think the Labour Party know very well it is only a motion of this kind——

Comment on this

That annoys you.

Comment on this

——that could get thesupport of unscrupulous Deputies in Fine Gael, and other Parties. That is why they put it down, to get the biggest vote they could against the Government, but everybody in the country will have contempt for it. Everybody will ask why they did not do something for three and a half years.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

They did. I heard the Minister admit the last time he spoke that there had been the same increase when Deputy Norton was Minister for Social Welfare as his previous three years.

Comment on this

Yes, you brought in £1,500,000.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Brendán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It is as good as your three years.

Comment on this

But that was not very much. Since that £1,500,000 was brought in, in less than three years we brought in £7,500,000.

Comment on this

And put up the cost of living 22 points.

Comment on this

We got the money in spite of you and in spite of the Labour Party, and we had to do it in spite of you. If we were to agree to this motion now and give increased benefits to all these various classes I have not the slightest doubt we would have to go then and, in spite of the Labour Party and in spite of the Fine Gael Party, get the money to do it. Is that not insincerity at its worst?

Comment on this

There is no bother in getting the money.

Comment on this

You are welcome now to your insincerity and your support for this motion.

Estimate put and declared carried.

Comment on this