Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).
Contributions 1–172 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When dealing with this matter last night I pointed out the enormous improvement that has taken place in our agricultural position to-day as compared with 1951. I pointed out that the increase in the value of our exports of cattle alone for the first nine months of this year, as compared with the first nine months of 1951, was roughly £6,000,000 and that the exports of our other agricultural produce amounted to £43,530,000, as compared with £21,125,000 in 1951. The total increase in the value of our agricultural exports was £27,500,000 in two years. That clearly shows the change that has taken place in so far as our agricultural policy is concerned, due to the change of Ministers, and the change of policy has worked out to the improvement of agriculture generally and of the farming community in particular. That gives the lie to those who have argued up to recently that the agricultural community were not doing their share in relation to increasing production.
Comment on this
The total increase in the value of domestic exports was some £30,000,000, and £27,500,000 of that sum represents the increase in the value of agricultural exports. Those figures speak for themselves.
Comment on this
That shows that we have now got over and brought back into production again the 52,000 milch cows that vanished out of the country on the declaration by Deputy Dillon of a price of 1/- per gallon for milk. That is one instance. We have now an increase of some 80,000 cattle since 1951. We have 80,000 more to-day in the Twenty-Six Counties than we had when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture. Clearly there has been an enormous improvement in the numbers of our cattle.
Comment on this
I have pointed out that we have not yet got the results due to the improvement brought about in the sowing and harvesting of 98,000 extra acres of wheat. That shows that the Irish farmer has not yet sent wheat up the spout after the peat and beet— God speed the day! Neither have we got the results of the 112,000 extra tons of beet grown this year. Our milk and chocolate crumb industry shows an increase as compared with 1951—a rather extraordinary increase from £2,000,000 in 1951 to £14,000,000 in the first nine months of this year in the exportation of that commodity. These are somewhat extraordinary figures and they prove that in so far as agriculture is concerned Fianna Fáil policy is the correct one.
Comment on this
I have not got the exact figures of the reduction in the import of maize but if Deputies look up the figures they will find that the reduction is a pretty extensive one, foreign maize having been replaced by barley grown by our own farmers. The fact that we have 160,000 more pigs to-day than we had in 1951 proves that the barley is not doing them any harm.
Comment on this
Their condition is improving and it must pay the Irish farmer to fatten pigs on Irish barley, despite the arguments advanced by Deputy Dillon and his colleagues some few years ago. These facts speak for themselves and I, for one, am very glad, as far as our agricultural policy is concerned—mark you, it took a lot to do it—to hear the "hear, hears!" from the late Minister for Agriculture because of the improvement brought about by the implementation of our agricultural policy as against his. It says a good deal for that agricultural policy when we have the plaudits of the man who decried it some years ago. A lost sheep is always welcome to the fold.
Comment on this
I am afraid I could not reciprocate with honesty if I knew the lost sheep was the Deputy.
Comment on this
Considering that the Deputy found himself accepted in the fold, fired out into the wilderness, and brought back again into the fold, I think he should reciprocate.
Comment on this
It is not so many years ago that the Deputy was evicted from the Fine Gael Party and now he is back again.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry has some of the sheep too. Some of them were evicted out of his Party and now they are back again in it.
Comment on this
I am dealing with this Estimate as I find it. I would normally welcome any increased grants for the purpose of putting the county roads in order. When one remembers that the bulk of the money received through the medium of taxation for these roads is not used on them but is put to other uses there is undoubtedly a sound argument and a firm argument for an increased grant for roads, particularly after a period of three and a half years when these roads were robbed of some £6,000,000 in grants. That was the amount of the reduction in grants for public roads during the period of office of the inter-Party Government.
I suggest that the general policy as regards roads is a bit overdone, that there is an inclination on the part of the Government to give grants for main roads and not to worry about the road that is used by the ordinary taxpayer.
Comment on this
Portion of the development grant that comes under this vote is being used to offset that policy.
Comment on this
I was only going to point out in passing the condition of affairs in Cork, where the number of fatal accidents has been trebled, due to the straightening and widening of roads and where there is a demand for the lighting of the roads to prevent further accidents.
Comment on this
I was dealing last night with the position as regards industry and urging that a large portion of the development grant should be used to establish industries. I was suggesting that permanent employment should be provided for our people in industry rather than partial or short-time employment on roads and drainage. I cannot see any reason why a large portion of this money should not be used to extend the steel industry. I have raised this matter by question and in debate in the House from time to time. There is a part of a tin-plate mill that has been lying idle for nine or ten years while we are importing tin, tin plate and tin cans to the value of £2,500,000 per annum. In these circumstances that factory should be put under way with a view to providing permanent employment for a certain number of men instead of spending this money on relief schemes. There is scope for doing that and there is an opportunity to provide such permanent employment.
A number of towns in this country suffered severely in the past by the change-over from a British Government to an Irish Government. It is about time that industries were set up in these towns that would provide permanent employment. I cannot help wondering at the delay there has been in establishing industries. I have made a suggestion here on previous occasions which should be carried out that the so-called Industrial Development Authority, which is blocking the advance of industry in this country, should be got rid of. The sooner it is got rid of the better.
I noticed from a reply to a question by Deputy Desmond yesterday that there has been practically no change in the number of civil servants in this country in recent years. The burden that has been created in this matter is one that the country could very well do without. The figures speak for themselves. As compared with 1939, there has been an increase of some 9,000 civil servants. If a certain number was sufficient to do the work in 1939 the same number should be sufficient to do it now. There is no justification for the extra burden of some £3,000,000 that has been caused by this increase in the number of civil servants. I had hoped, when the matter was dealt with here before, that there would be some change in the Government attitude on this matter. The people of the country have to be careful. Taxes are mounting. The general burden on the taxpayer has mounted. While there has been an increase, as I have shown, in the value of agricultural exports, that money should be put back into providing productive employment for our people in this country.
Comment on this
It is a welcome sound to hear from the benches of Fianna Fáil rejoicing in the increased output of the agricultural industry. The House will have noticed and attach due significance to the fact that when those rejoicings were voiced they related to the increased exports of cattle and the increased exports of agricultural produce—pigs, sheep, beef, mutton, pork, cattle. It is not necessary for me to remind the House that the cattle that were exported in 1952 were born in 1949 and the cattle that were exported in 1953 were born in 1950, and the cattle that will be exported in 1954 were born in the spring of 1951. But I remind the House that that trend of expanding production dates back to 1948 and it is visible in 1949 and in 1950. There will be Deputies in Fianna Fáil who say: "Well, if there was expanding production then, was not it the cattle that were born in 1945, 1946, 1947?" Yes, it was; everyone of them; but, there is this difference: that if Fianna Fáil had remained in office in 1948 they would have got their throatscut, but in 1948, 1949, 1950, 1951, 1952 and 1953 there were no calves' throats cut.
What is the statistical fact? Fianna Fáil was in office from 1931 to 1948. The statistical and inescapable fact is that the average annual loss of calves from death and slaughter during those 18 years was 80,000 calves. There were factories in this country devoted to the business of slaughtering calves, and there was a loud outcry when I closed them down. As a result of a campaign for the elimination of disease in calves, initiated in 1949, and as a result of our closing down the calf factories, the annual mortality of calves in this country was reduced from 80,000 to something in the order of 10,000. Let the House remember that the first 70,000 calves that were born and survived in 1950 were exported this year, and if we estimate their value conservatively at £50 per head it would represent an addition of £3,500,000 sterling per annum to the value of our livestock exports, not for one year but for year after year after year. Well may Deputy Corry rejoice. I welcome that at last in the ranks of Fianna Fáil we have got one voice to proclaim that the performance of the farmers in this country is deserving of high praise.
When did they change their tune? Are people's memories so short that the White Paper of 1951 is forgotten? Do Deputies forget that the financial policy of this Government was founded on the statement in the White Paper of 1951 that the most optimistic forecast could see no contribution being made to the restoration of our balance of payments by an expansion of agricultural exports? Are people's memories so short that they forget that Fianna Fáil campaigned this country on the slogan that the farmers of Ireland were not able to show increased production commensurate with any other agricultural country in Europe? That was their theme, that if we looked at Denmark, Holland or any other agricultural country, they were forging ahead but that our farmers were stuck in the mud.
I said then that our farmers were doing a better job than the farmers in any country in Europe and, startingwith a greater handicap than any other agricultural country in the world, they were going ahead at a rate that reflected credit upon them and that held high hope for the economy of this country.
Who was right? Show me a country in the whole of Europe that can show an expansion of agricultural production and exports commensurate with the expansion that our farmers can show over the last five years. Remember where our farmers started from. In April, 1948, there were less cattle in Ireland than at any time in the 20th century, less sheep, less pigs and the land was in a state of greater dereliction than at any time since the Famine of 1847. That is where our farmers started and they caught up on and surpassed every agricultural community in the world at a time when, by their own election, they determined to withdraw from the international butter market by stipulating for prices for milk that made Irish butter unsaleable in any competitive market in the world.
I ask this House to reflect on two fundamental economic facts because if they are lost sight of or if they are incorrectly interpreted, as certain as we are in this House, this country will go down to economic ruin. They are two perfectly simple facts. One is that the agricultural industry of this country must export or this nation will die. Every industry, every economic activity in this country depends on our ability to export agricultural produce profitably, and if that power should ever perish in our people the standard of living of every creature in Ireland, whether he be a trade unionist, a civil servant, a doctor, a lawyer, or anybody else, even a farmer, will sink down to subsistence level. In the last analysis every citizen depends for his standard of living on the land and the people who live and get their living on the land. If they make a profit, the whole community will prosper. If they are driven back by losses to subsistence farming, the whole community's standard of living must sink down to that of a pauper.
We tried the experiment of compulsory wheat. We tried the experimentof forcing the farmers, whether they wanted to or not, to grow a crop. I told the Government of that day that they would get nowhere with compulsion, that compulsion meant a steady diminution of yield and there was only one way of getting production from farmers, that was to take steps to make the product of their labour profitable for the producer.
You can get as much wheat as you like grown in this country if you pay 80/- per barrel. You will have a surplus of wheat. You will have out of next year's crop an exportable surplus of wheat from this country—that is as certain as we are in this House— and we will join the French who are paying their farmers 39/- per cwt. for wheat and are hawking their flour in the City of London at 25/- per cwt., and are unable to get anyone to buy it. We will be doing exactly the same but that is our own business. If we want to grow wheat in any quantity, we can grow it by paying a price for it. You will never get a crop in any satisfactory way by trying to compel farmers to grow it because the net result of it will be that you will get a steadily diminishing return per acre on the land both in quantity and in quality.
Fix a price that makes it remunerative to produce wheat and you will get as much wheat as you want but that production of wheat does not matter a damn to the fundamental economy of this country. You can produce wheat, butter, sugar in this country at any price you like to mention; it becomes purely a question of what our people are prepared to pay for it or what the Exchequer is prepared to pour into it by way of subsidy but it has no economic significance whatever, except in so far as it represents a charge on the public purse. The only thing that matters is profit and the amount of commodities that can be exported at a profit to the man who produces them. It has become clear to everybody now, though it used not to be so clear to the Fianna Fáil Party, that profitable production consists of live stock and live-stock products.
Here is a warning, the first fundamental economic fact, that I ask Deputies to grasp and to remember. Profit for a farmer is not primarily a question of price. Profit for a farmer is the difference between the price he can get for his finished product and what it costs him to produce it. We are back in a world where we do not control the price available for our agricultural exports any longer. We have got to go out and seek the best price we can get. I want to warn Oireachtas Eireann that when we are out looking for markets for our farmers, for pigs and pig products in competition with the Danes who have all the maize they want at £22 per ton, our farmers cannot profitably compete with them if they have to pay £32 per ton for the same maize. I warn this House that, whatever codology is talked here, there is no escaping the fact that there is no degree of efficiency, no degree of industry, no degree of skill which will enable any small farmer to offset the handicap of having to pay £10 per ton more for the raw material of the pig industry than his competitors in his principal market.
There is a rough approximate calculation that it takes 8 cwt. of meal to rear a pig from the point of conception to the point of slaughter. If we have to pay 10/- per cwt. more for our feeding stuffs as compared with what our competitors have to pay for the same feeding stuffs, on every pig we produce the small farmer of this country has to give up £4 per pig. £4 per pig! Think of what that means. If you keep a sow and she produces ten bonhams at a litter, the first thing that happens is that you lose £40 before you make a penny. If a man is struggling to get two litters in 12 months, if he has a pretty good sow and is a careful farmer and can bring ten pigs out of each litter to maturity, can you conceive an Irish Parliament laying on that man the obligation to forgo £80 of his profit before he can even enter the market with his competitor? Then he has got to be sure that the factory that processes his pig is going to put his pig, in the form of pork or bacon, on the market in as good a condition as the Danish factoryor he will have to take another cut because of this, be sure; the bacon factory or the slaughterers are only going to pay the farmer what the end product realises on the export market, less the processor's margin of profit, less the trade unionist's rate for slaughtering the pig.
All these charges represent a reduction in the profits that ultimately go back to the farmer. He has lost £80 on two litters of pigs. He has got to meet his competitor in London and he has just to hope in God that the processor who put his product on the London market will treat it as well as the Danish processor treats the Danish pig. If he does, the Irish farmer in Mayo, Sligo, Donegal, Clare, Kerry or West Cork is going to get £80 less for the two litters of his sow than the farmer who lives ten miles outside Copenhagen. It is not that the Danes have some power or that the British have some power to frustrate us, because we grasped the British under the 1951 trade agreement whereby we linked our price for pork and pigs, not to the Danish price but to the price payable to the British farmers. Our farmers' loss is due to nothing that the Danes do or that the British have power to do. It is due solely, entirely and exclusively to what our own Government does to our own people.
Think of what we are doing. The claim is that you must keep the price of maize at 32/- per cwt. so that the farmer who has a surplus of barley that he does not want to use himself can sell it at a profit. We are to get the profit for that farmer who sowed so much barley that he cannot consume it on his own holding, not out of the Exchequer, not out of the British consumer but out of the small farmer who breeds pigs in Donegal, Sligo, Mayo, Galway, Clare, Kerry and West Cork. Is there anybody in this House left with a capacity for saeva indignatioagainst the exploitation of the small people, for whom we stand trustee, by the powerful and the well-to-do? I see small farmers growing their couple of acres of barley and potatoes and feeding their pigs. But in the industry theremay be a man who has used up his own patch of land to produce all that he can, and he goes out to buy more feeding stuff so as to expand his output. He then comes up against the fact that his own Government taxes him to the tune of £4 per pig the moment he goes to buy the raw materials to expand his production. I want to ask this question: is there a factory in Ireland, in Dublin, Cork, Limerick, Galway, Waterford or any other city which finds itself confronted with a demand that it will pay for its raw materials 10/- per cwt. more than its competitors and which must try to export at a profit at the same time? There is not a factory in Ireland that would not close its doors and sack its employees without hesitation if any such demand was made upon it.
I remember that we were not 12 months in office when a factory not 100 miles from this city presented the Government with an ultimatum some three weeks before Christmas that they would lock their doors and put every man working in the factory on the streets if they did not get the tariff on their commodity raised by 50 per cent. When they were asked to pause and allow an examination of their application to be made, the answer was: "There will be no pause; they are all under notice and we will shut down on Saturday." I often regret that we did not harden our hearts and deal with that situation, but we did not want to see the men turned out on the eve of Christmas and we gave way. I would have taken over that factory and taught them that they had a responsibility to the men who worked in it as well as to their own pockets. But the one thing they were determined on was that if their profit was not provided for there would be no work and there would be no production, and it never dawned on any one to say: "Your duty is to tighten your belt, lower your standard of living, sell your Chrysler car and go around in a Ford Anglia." They would have laughed at him. Their answer was: "No profits, no work."
Comment on this
Not if I had the handling of it. It is a privilege by which the tariff racketeers put a charge on the farmers. What I object to is this. If you want to run rackets of that kind, at least exempt the raw materials of the agricultural industry from their depredations. I believe that if we had the right to operate the agricultural industry in this country without an increased cost on its raw materials thrust down upon it, we could carry them all. But I am warning this House that if the raw materials of the agricultural industry are to be perenially enhanced in price and our farmers are required to sell competitively in a foreign market, we are walking head on into disaster.
There is no use telling me that if you increase the price of netted wire, if you increase the price of barbed wire, if you increase the price of timber, if you increase the price of cement, if you increase the price of feeding stuffs, if you increase the price of fertilisers, that that has no effect on the agricultural industry. Think for a moment of the camel's back. You can lay on straw by straw by straw and the camel staggers on, but when you lay on the last straw and the camel falls, it is not only the camel who dies in the desert but the man who is riding it dies with it. As sure as we are in this House, the whole Irish nation is riding through a dangerous desert on the back of the agricultural camel, and it would be well for those who depend on the camel's survival that they should see in time the peril of continuing to raise these costs.
I was reading an oration delivered by the Tánaiste recently. The brazen-faced audacity of that man fills me with awe. He took upon himself to deliver a lecture to agriculture to remember that the days of the feather-bed were over. My God; feather-bed ! Think of all the crazy structures that man has been responsible for erecting in this country, not on afeather-bed, but on a feather mountain, and if you take one feather out of the mountain the whole structure he has put up will come cracking round his ears. Think of the agressive insults of some of the tariff racketeers in this country, who demand not only a 90 per cent. tariff but a quota so as to ensure that if anybody resists their demand, if any consumer hesitates to pay their maximum demand he will be brought face to face with the fact that he will either pay their demand and like it or do without, because our own Government will say that no more than a certain limited quantity of that commodity is permitted into the country. If the consumer is not prepared to pay the racketeers' price for the substitute he will blooming well do without it, and then I am told that agriculture should get off its feather-bed.
Agriculture is carrying about 40 feather-beds on its back and on top of each feather-bed is reclining a stout industrialist and, not infrequently, he is riding round the feather-bed in a Chrysler or Rolls Royce to show how independent he is. Agriculture is told by the Tánaiste, the patron of these gentlemen, that it must get off the feather-bed. We are told that the Minister for Agriculture is going to open negotiations with the British Government for a new trade agreement in January and he is going to London to discuss with the British Government prices for Irish agricultural produce with a notification from the Deputy Prime Minister of Ireland that agriculture is on a feather-bed and it is time for them to wake up and get off it. What will he say in London when that obiter dictumis produced and he is asked to face reality and to realise that his own far-seeing colleague discerned the fact that his predecessor, Deputy Dillon, put them on a feather-bed and it is damn well time to wake from Deputy Dillon's feather-bed and face the hard realities referred to by the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass? It is nearly as stimulating as the Taoiseach was on the eve of the National Loan when he said that he was going to run a national loan every 12 months.
Comment on this
I wonder how many people in the Department of Industry and Commerce or how many of the people who frequent that Department would care to join with us on our feather-bed? There is not an industrialist in this country who would not die of starvation in six months on the feather-bed to which the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, referred. There is not a small farmer in Ireland who would not retire in affluence after five years in trading under the conditions which the most minor industrialist habitually enjoys at the expense of the farmers at the present time.
Let us have no more talk about the agricultural community living on a feather-bed. The previous Government got for the farmers of this country from the British Ministry of Food no more than they were entitled to, and it was no feather-bed. If Fianna Fáil has any idea in its mind that it is a feather-bed, they had better wake up to the facts of life. If they claim that the small farmers are to go back to the level of peasants, they ought to remember the advice I gave Mr. Webb, the British Minister of Food: "You will get no more cheap food from Ireland; if you reduce the price you are prepared to pay, you will get no eggs from Ireland." If this Government proceeds on the assumption that they can continue to whittle away the margin of profit available to farmers on their production, by raising their costs of production steadily, they are going to wake up one day, when it is to late, to the fact that the land of this country has gone over to subsistence farming and there will be no surplus margin for the trade unionist, the industrialist, the public servant or the professional man to live out of. And remember, if that happens twice in our time, it will take much better men than anybody in this House to put it right. That is a very grave thing to realise.
Since this Government came in, consider what has been done. We put prices of essential feeding stuffs anything from £6 to £10 a ton higher than anything our competitors in the British market have to pay. We put a tax on fertilisers. We raised thetax on a tractor drawing milk to the creamery from £6 10s. to £36 per annum. We are about to pass a Bill through the House which will levy a further £100,000 on the rates chargeable on land. We are going to increase the rates by at least 2/- and it may be 5/- per £ per annum in respect of the Health Act. All that expense has to be met out of agricultural production on the land and out of the profit. We all know by experience of compulsory wheat that there is only one way to get production out of the land and that is to make it profitable. Surely it is time we woke up to the fact that, if we make every branch of agriculture unprofitable the whole thing will dry up, with consequential disaster for this country.
Do you remember the time you were told the method of resolving our balance of trade difficulties was a reduction of imports? That is when it was fashionable to say nothing could be hoped for from an expansion of exports. Have any of you looked at the trade returns? Deputy MacEntee, I rejoice to understand, is rapidly returning to his full and normal health and we may expect to see him active in the public arena again at an early date. Most of us in the House appreciate that, after the hard knocks which are given and taken in this House, underneath we entertain for one another a warm solicitude. Deputy MacEntee stated publicly that by reducing domestic consumption he hoped to redress the balance of trade by reducing imports. He, accordingly, formulated a proposition that our people were eating too much and living too well. He raised the price of all foodstuffs and most commodities our people consume, so that they would be able to afford less and thus cut down imports. He then proceeded to point to the trade returns and say: "Behold! Imports have gone down." He hoped that nobody would discover that one of the reasons for the decline in the volume of imports was that the stockpile, the existence of which he vigorously denied, was being used up. His colleague, the Tánaiste, proceeded to produce the stockpile as his alibi for the unemployment that was beginning to manifest itself and the alibi for theunemployment was the stockpile: "There can be no production until we have used up all that we have here." So Fianna Fáil used up the stockpile.
Now look at the trade returns. Domestic—total imports: June, 1952, £11.45 million; June, 1953, £14.46 million; July, 1952, £12.62 million; July, 1953, £15.61 million; August, 1952, £9.88 million; August, 1953, £13.07 million; September, 1952, £11.89 million; September, 1953, £13.40 million; October, 1952, £15.05 million; October, 1953, £18.44 million. The stockpiles are gone and the imports are now running from 20 to 30 per cent. in excess of what they were last year when the stockpiles were under process of consumption. What would have happened to us already if the dismal forecast of the 1951 White Paper had not been belied by the events?
The 1951 White Paper could see no hope of any early contribution by exports to the solution of the balance of payments problem. But what is happening? The domestic exports were: May, 1952, £7.17 million; May, 1953, £9.14 million; June, 1952, £8.13 million; June, 1953, £9.18 million; July, 1952, £7.88 million; July, 1953, £9.86 million; August, 1952, £8.50 million; August, 1953, £9.57 million; September, 1952, £9.43 million; September, 1953, £11.27 million; October, 1952, £9.06 million; October, 1953, £10.40 million.
By the end of this year our exports will have attained the total of £105,000,000 sterling. Ask yourselves what they were in 1947? Ask yourselves, if the trend in 1947 in our exports had continued, where would we be to-day? On our beam-end. Ask yourselves what is going to happen if the present trend in import prices and volume continues. Remember this. Import prices have been steadily falling. Look at the volume of imports. The increase in June over last year is 33 per cent. in volume; the increase in July is 30 per cent.; in August, about 40 per cent.; in September— speaking now in terms of volume—it is from 4.14 to 4.71. Look at the increase in the volume of exports in every oneof the months, beginning in June: June, from £3.12 to £3.60 million; July, from £2.71 to £3.41 million; August, from £2.83 to £3.15 million; September, from £3.16 to £3.78 million. What would have happened to us if the increase in our agricultural exports had not redressed the balance of our increased imports and in addition— and lots of people forget this—replaced £4,000,000 worth of exotic exports represented by sweetened fat and minced meat—which disappeared completely— and the gap left there by it had to be filled before our agricultural exports showed anything upwards on the previous year on the total figure.
I am asking this House to face this problem. Either we make it an absolute economic rule of this State that no fiduciary measures by the executive and no legislation of this House will operate to increase the cost of agricultural industry or we shall all perish. I add, as an addendum to that, that if that rule be accepted and the same agricultural policy is pursued in the future, we have here in this country the prospect of a better living—I am saying "a better living"—I am not saying a richer living or a more remunerative living, but a better living for our population than is available in any country in the world—and I include the U.S.A. Denmark, Holland, or any place else you like to name.
I have no desire to see our people adopt the standard of living acceptable to the Danes or the Dutch. I have no comment or adverse criticism at all to make about it except to say that I would be a damn sight happier as a farmer in rural Ireland than I would be as a farmer in Jutland or in Holland. Let the Danes and the Dutch have any kind of life they want, but if any man in our country wants to swop our way of living with that of the Danes or the Dutch then I think he is just crazy. Our method of life and our system of living is much preferable to that obtaining in the U.S.A. Others may disagree with that statement. That is why a great many people go to America although they have perfectly comfortable homes here in Ireland. They want to go. I have no complaint about it. In our day, the Leas-Cheann Comhairleand I went to the U.S.A. and we came back again. Plenty of others stay there and they have as much right to stay there as the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and I had to come back. Is it not madness to throw away that potentiality for the want of thought? I wonder if it is for the want of thought or whether it is some crazy malice.
Let me draw the Taoiseach's attention to a very strange transaction. The Taoiseach may remember that while we were in office I formulated the parish plan. The purpose of the parish plan was to bring within easy reach of every farmer in Ireland the most modern technical training available for the exploitation of the land. That plan was contemptuously rejected by Fianna Fáil. Yet, last week, I saw that the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Education went down to Boherbue and announced that one of the greatest revolutions in agricultural practice in this country was the making of agricultural instruction of a high degree of efficiency immediately available to approximately a thousand farmers supplying Boherbue creamery. If the Minister for Education and the Minister for Agriculture consider that the greatest boon that could be conferred on the farmers in the Boherbue creamery supply area is to have brought within their reach the parish plan formulated by our Administration three years ago, why will the Taoiseach not tell his Minister for Agriculture to take out of the file in the Department of Agriculture the scheme that was formulated and that is ready for operation to-morrow?
Comment on this
I will tell you. It was one of the most damnable things ever done. I got the 27 instructors appointed. I was ready to take over South Tipperary, Longford and West-meath. A brat organised a strike because the salary scales available to agricultural instructors could not be fixed until there was a general realignment of the scales payable to all public servants. The Appointments Commissioners appointed the men. When the fellows went down to gettheir warrants of appointment there were pickets outside, operated and run by a brat who was himself in a good job and is still in it. That is the reason. It took me 12 months to circumnavigate that conspiracy, smash it and get back under way again. Then, and only then, was the plan to go forward. Then we went out of office and our successors said the whole scheme was a fraud. All I am asking is that we do for the three parishes in every part of Ireland what the Minister for Education say is eminently desirable in Boherbue. I agree with them 100 per cent. I would be delighted to see my successor acquiring all the kudos of the groundwork I did in that regard. The maps are there, the counties are divided up into parishes, the whole administration is devised. Even the officer technically qualified to administer the plan is there in the Department, I believe, with nothing to do at present. He is there for that purpose—to run the particular kind of instruction and technical services identical with those envisaged for the Boherbue creamery administration area.
I quite agree with the Minister for Education and the Minister for Agriculture. The key to increased production is not compulsion, not telling the farmers where to get off but putting within their reach, for those who want it, access to the best methods and to the best information and providing the link with the Department of Agriculture which will bring the farmer on his land into contact with the admirable schemes made available by the Department of Agriculture but which it is extremely difficult to get the farmers to bring into operation on their own holdings partially because they do not know about them and partially because they have nobody in the locality to explain them to them. Do Deputies realise this astonishing fact? When I wanted to communicate to the farmers of this country the value and the urgent need for the use of phenothiazine and hexachloroethane, I had no means of contacting them except by sending out ½d. postcards.
I sent out about 250,000 halfpenny postcards because there was no otherway in which I could communicate directly with our farmers. I had to get the postman to bring a postcard to their homes and to drop it in their letter-box—a postcard explaining the value of these two things. The Minister for Agriculture has no direct contact of any sort, kind or description with the farmers of this country. If he wants to communicate with any farmer on any particular problem he must detach a member of his staff and send him down the country with a special assignment. The Minister for Agriculture has no means of making direct contact with the farmers of the country at all.
In my judgment, the Taoiseach is daft about most things but, in regard to matters of education, he is usually pretty rational. It is a source of constant surprise to me. On this matter of agricultural education, I assure him, he could with great advantage employ himself and the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Education. If he will urge them to extend to other areas of the country exactly what is being done in Boherbue, he will make a greater contribution to agricultural production than anything else done in the 16 years of his first administration and the two years of his second.
I want to refer now to what I regard as the second fundamental economic fact in our lives. It is not how much money the Irish Government think it expedient to borrow at any time that matters so much. What really matters is what they spend the money which they borrow upon. We can borrow money with great advantage and spend it on the capital development of this country, in the confident anticipation that our expanding national income derived from increased production will carry the burden without the slightest difficulty, if we spend the money right; but if we borrow money and fritter it away, we can cripple the country, or if we admit the principle that the moneylenders of this country have the right to hold the community up to ransom for 5 per cent. interest on the money they require for national development.
Remember that the acting-Minister for Finance has laid it down that the sole reason we elected to pay 5 per cent. on the National Loan was that the Irish Government thought it was a good thing to give any investor in that National Loan an attractive return on his money. That is his own testimony repeated and emphasised. What does that mean? That policy resulted in the past two years in this phenomenon that a young man who got married in 1949 and borrowed money from a local authority under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act wherewith to build a house for himself and the family he hoped to raise, who bought the land, built the house and went into possession was told: "You will have to pay 22/6 per week for 30 years and then the house is yours," while his brother, three years later, who bought an identical piece of land side by side, who borrowed from the same local authority and who built the very same house, subject to this consideration, that the cost of building materials had come down in the meantime, was told, on going into that house, that he would have to pay 32/6 per week over the same period of years.
Who in this House does not know that hundreds of such fellows gave up hope of building their houses and joined the queue of people asking the municipality to build houses for them, with two consequences? The first was that on every house not built under the Small Dwellings Act the municipal authority and the Government lost £500, because it cost the municipal authority and the Government £500 more to provide a municipal house for rent for that man than it would have cost them to help him build a house for himself. The other consequence is that a friend of mine living with his wife and two children, one an infant of about four months and the other two and a half years, in a single tenement room in Dublin is told, when he asks for a house, that they cannot even consider his case for another 18 months because of the queue of people who are living six and five in a room who must be provided for before they can attend to him.
Can anything be dafter in a sane community? Can anything be dafter when we have money, raw materials, idle men, condemned to the labour exchange or to emigration, and fellows wanting to get married and to build their own houses, than to say: "No, we will not let you. We are going to lend £62,000,000 sterling to the British Government so that their citizens can build houses at 2 per cent., but if you want to borrow money, you must pay 6 per cent."? Is that not daft? The British Government have before Parliament now a Bill identical with the Bill which Deputy Keyes brought in here when he was Minister for Local Government, providing that, if a man can put down £100, the British Government will either advance the money to him to build his house or will indemnify the building society who are prepared to advance only 80 per cent. of the valuer's value of the house. The British Government say: "Give him the balance, and, if he puts down £100, you carry the risk of 80 per cent. of your valuer's valuation and we will indemnify you for the differential. We want to provide that young men earning weekly wages who have a reasonable prospect of being able to pay the rent and who put down £100 are certain to get the necessary finance at a price they can afford to pay to build their houses."
That is in a country where building is most rigorously controlled because there is a shortage of workers, a shortage of materials and a shortage of money—they are borrowing money from us—but here in our country where there is a surplus of materials and of money—we are lending it to Great Britain—and a surplus of unemployed men who are emigrating to Great Britain to build houses for the British people, we say: "No, not less than 6 per cent., and, if that means 32/- per week which you cannot afford to pay, go and live in a tenement room."
Here, however, is the most remarkable miracle of all. Look around the House at Deputies on every side. There is not one who wants that, except the Minister for Finance and the acting-Minister for Finance, one of whom isignorant and the other silly. Not one average common sense Deputy who lives amongst his neighbours, either in Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour or any other Party in the House, wants that; but there is a kind of mysterious enclave into which the common people must not intrude and at the portals of which Deputy Aiken and Deputy MacEntee stand like Gog and Magog, except that one is a big Gog and the other a little Magog, saying: "Let none of you enter here where angels fear to tread, and we are the angels. Keep out—you must not discuss these matters."
Comment on this
No; let us get this clear. I am sick of hearing people say that civil servants do this and central banks do that. Civil servants do nothing but what we tell them to do. Central banks take instructions from this House and there is no power in this country strong enough to challenge this House, if the Executive has the intelligence and the courage to oppose it.
Comment on this
Let us put the cap where it fits. There is no use denouncing the Central Bank for doing its job, the Department of Finance for doing its job or the bureaucrats for doing their job. They will do what the law requires them to do. We make the law and the Government of this country propose to us the laws that can be made. Do Deputies think that if I brought in a law to-morrow requiring what Deputy Keyes tried to achieve, that any man with £100 would be able to build his house at the rent he could afford to pay, I should be likely to get it passed Who would block it? The Government would block it.
Comment on this
Did you not hear Deputy Aiken, the acting-Minister for Finance, say from the opposite benches three days ago that he fixed the interest charges?
Comment on this
Wait a moment. I want to tell Deputy Davin that in this case it was he who did it. The Government did it.
Comment on this
No, no, no. There are no ghosts to dominate this House. That is a fact I know because when some people started waving ghostly garments when we were in this House we said: "Look boys, come up in your lounge suits and throw off the white sheets and we will tell you what you have got to do and if you will not do it we will go to Oireachtas Éireann and ask it to make you do it." They took off their white sheets and proved to be most public spirited citizens who said: "Your mind is made up, Minister, and we will do it." There is no mystery about that. This is the sovereign Parliament of this Republic and there is no power in the world superior to it in this country.
Comment on this
No, sir. Let us get that out of our minds. The Minister has made a perfectly clear declaration that it is Government policy and that they fixed the rate of interest.
Comment on this
They did not. You had a silly, vain little man as Minister for Finance who wanted to present himself to the country as a pillar of orthodoxy greater than the crisis that confronted him. He sold that gag to the Fianna Fáil Government who knows as much about public finance as my foot. It was only when they were in it up to their necks that it suddenly dawned on them they were travelling a ruinous and iniquitous path. Why did they swallow it? Here is something which I think is shocking and wicked. I believe the Taoiseach was party to it. I think he committed a crime. I think he did allthat as part of their dirty campaign of trying to denigrate the work we did. I think they did all that in order to provide circumstantial evidence for the allegations they were making that we had crippled the national finances and had been recklessly spending the assets of the nation. In order to lend verisimilitude to that slander they made an announcement.
First of all, let us remember the story. They said they would not have enough money to pay civil servants at the end of the year and that they dare not float a loan in the autumn of 1951, as Deputy McGilligan had declared his intention of doing. Actually, while he was going out of office he converted a 5 per cent. loan to a 3½ per cent. basis. He got two-thirds to three-quarters of the total loan converted. The following autumn his successor said he dare not seek a loan and he spent in five months £24,000,000 in cash that we left for him out of the American Loan Counterpart Fund.
Comment on this
He said we left him in debt until we nailed that to the desk. In the autumn of 1952 he went to the country and borrowed money at 5 per cent. and the loan has ever since stood at a premium. The consequence of that decision which Deputy Aiken said from these benches three days ago was taken freely by the Government was to throw thousands of men into the ranks of the unemployed builders' labourers, thousands as emigrants to Great Britain and it prevented hundreds of people from building houses who would otherwise have built them. It drove a number of small contractors themselves into the ranks of the unemployed. I met a small contractor——
Comment on this
——registering at the labour exchange with six labourers who had been working for him. He was now bankrupt and had to seek a job himself, and all that because Deputy Aiken, the acting-Minister for Finance, said they determined it was a good thing and that if people were going to lend the Government moneythey should get a good rate of interest on it.
Comment on this
I do not think so. I think that was all done for one diabolical purpose, that of denigrating their predecessors in office. We were told the Local Authorities (Works) Act had spent its usefulness and that money was not going to be provided by this means for improvements. There was no more work to be done. Does Deputy Davin remember that?
A national development fund is to be established by statute if you please. We are planning to borrow £43,000,000 this year for capital works but we had to pass a Bill to borrow £5,000,000. We know what that is for—the two by-elections. Remember the biscuit factory in Ballina? "Vote for Deputy Calleary and you will all eat chocolate biscuits in Ballina. Vote for Deputy Lahiffe and you will all be making frills in Loughrea. Vote for whoever they are going to put up in Cork and Louth and there is £5,000,000 of good public money." Can you picture them licking their chops already as to how that is going to be spent but in case there should be any doubt about it the Tánaiste has taken up the theme already?
He says that he is going to borrow £1,000,000 from the Development Fund for the roads. Is it necessary to pass a Bill to establish a development fund to get £5,000,000 in order to borrow £1,000,000 for the roads? There is £500,000 for urban and rural improvements schemes so that Dundalk and Drogheda can be catered for with the right hand and Dunleer, Louth and Ardee can be catered for with the left hand. And in case anybody should be overlooked there is a further sum for minor drainage works. Under what statute? The Local Authorities (Works) Act.
Comment on this
Did those minor drains cease to carry water since 1951? We heard of the chosen people coming to the shores of the Red Sea, the waters of which rolled back and they walkeddry-footed across it. Was there a miracle performed on the minor drains of Louth from 1951 to the eve of the Louth election? Were they all dried up at source until the by-election began? Why was it deemed expedient to stop the Local Authorities (Works) Act two years ago and borrow £500,000 to start it again to-day? Is not that good substantial evidence of malice? Was it not stopped because they wanted to represent the thing as being ineffective and unprofitable? Why have they slowed down the land project?
Comment on this
What was their first great executive act in respect of the land project when they came into office? I am told, though I have never seen it, that Deputy Thomas Walsh so far degraded himself—I am going to state his further title though he ought to be ashamed of this gesture as a Minister—as Minister for Agriculture as to make an executive Order under some statute with a long title changing the name of the land project. Can you believe that? An Order has been made, sealed with the Minister for Agriculture's official seal, signed by Thomas Walsh, Minister for Agriculture, changing the name of the land project. That was his first contribution to the work. His second contribution was to announce that he wanted to sell the machinery; and the third contribution, to announce that the whole project in Connemara was a fraud and that he proposed to wind it up. And he made a bold bid to wind it up until the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Bartley, came up from Connemara and said: "My life would not be worth an hour's purchase if you stopped the project in Connemara," and I am sure Deputy Duignan had a word in season to say, too, about it. But whatever was said by either of them the project is going ahead in Connemara.
The Taoiseach may be told that work under the land project is not being damped down. Would he be surprised to hear—for I would be glad to send him the letter if he would—that a farmer who put in his application to have his land drained in County Waterford on the first day the project was made to apply to that county received a letter within the last couple of months telling him that although the pipes had been piled on his land two years ago, as certain outlets required to be cleared before the land could be suitably drained and the limitations of public finance forbade the undertaking of the clearing of these outlets in this year, the work on his farm had not been undertaken heretofore and could not be contemplated until next year, three and a half years after he had put in his first application? Remember, probably one of the reasons why the outlets could not be cleared was that you suspended the Local Authorities (Works) Act with which the land project was interlocked and working closely. The Waterford County Council would have cleared these outlets and all these works on the various farmers' places could have been undertaken once these outlets had been cleared but you wound up the Local Authorities (Works) Act.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach ought to open his mind and his ears to the facts. You are now proceeding to borrow money from this pseudo development fund to recommence operations under the Local Authorities (Works) Act.
Comment on this
Because of the principle which the Deputy was pressing some time ago, that the purpose for which money was being spent was the most important thing.
Comment on this
Certainly. Could any purpose be more important than the clearing of outlets to enable land in the area to be drained?
Comment on this
They stopped the scheme because they said all the economic plans were exhausted. Everything that could be done effectively had been done.
Comment on this
It was very substantially reduced. Will the Taoiseach accept that? I draw his attention to the fact that the land project was held up, very probably as a result of that reduction.
Comment on this
Yes, they are. Perhaps the Taoiseach would send for those responsible for the project and ask them how many applications they have filed with which they could have dealt if they had not been told to stop. Perhaps he would ask the Deputies of hisown Party to tell him how many representations they have had from their own constituents about applications to have land drained which are outstanding for over three years. I put it to him—unless there is a very different rule obtaining in his Government from that which obtained in the Government of which I was a member —if the attention of the then Taoiseach was drawn to the fact that applications were waiting for three years to have the benefit of the scheme which was supposed to be administered by my Department, I think Deputy Costello would have inquired from me, as Minister for Agriculture: "How is it that the people who applied three years ago to benefit under a scheme administered by your Department can write to me and enclose a letter from officers of your Department to say that the work cannot be contemplated for another 12 months, although you, as Minister for Agriculture, authorised the deposit of drainage pipes on their holdings three years ago?"
In the face of those facts will anybody deny that the project was slowed down? I think you did these things for no other purpose than to denigrate your predecessors. That was a criminal wrong. That exceeds the bounds of decent politics. You have no right to leave people in tenement rooms; you have no right to deny a farmer the opportunity of having his land rehabilitated in order to lend verisimilitude to the slander you wish to promulgate that your predecessors dissipated the national resources.
I could speak on many things but I would like to focus the attention of the House on these two fundamentals if I could: if you go on raising the cost of production in the agricultural industry you will destroy us all. If you continue on the principle that it is right to pay 5 per cent. or 4¾ per cent. for money borrowed to develop our own country while you are lending it to Great Britain at 2 per cent. you are defeating the best interests of our people; and as an addendum to that if you borrow money and then spend it to buy votes in by-elections you will ruin thiscountry irretrievably. You charged us, when we were in office, with dissipating the resources of this nation, and you said that when you came into office you found debts without the wherewithal to pay them. We demonstrated that there were no debts, but that there was £24,000,000 of cash money.
Comment on this
Observe the old war horse how he skips from debts to commitments. That is a jump we made you take in Wicklow—off the debts, on to commitments. Yes, you found millions of pounds worth of commitments that we proudly and confidently made, resolutely determined to fulfil them to the last farthing. Show me a single one of them that you brought into this House to cancel. There is a challenge. This is the Taoiseach's Estimate, and I glory in the fact that when he came into office in 1951 he found millions of pounds worth of commitments into which we had proudly and resolutely entered in the name of the Irish people. Show me a single one of them that Fianna Fáil brought into this House to cancel.
I will give now a catalogue of the commitments that we found when we went into office, that we brought into Dáil Éireann and said: "There is a commitment that our predecessors entered into and we are now going before the people to cancel it; we are not going through with it." We found a plan to buy Constellations and to operate them. That was a commitment that we brought into this House and we cancelled it. We said that we would not keep that commitment.
Comment on this
Yes, and we invested the money in houses and hospitals, in the rehabilitation of the land and in the employment of our own people rather than in flying high-heeled actresses across the Atlantic. Who says that we did wrong?
Comment on this
Deputy Killilea has now been brought in to cause a riot, but there will be no riot. You will see Deputy Corry rambling in in a few minutes, and others coming in, too, but let them riot amongst themselves outside. Let us have this catalogue of commitments, one after the other. There was another commitment that we found when we came into office. C.I.E. was building a bus station, and it was going to cost them, was it £3,000,000? We got notice from C.I.E. that they had no money to buy coal to run the engines. We wanted to know what they were going to buy the coal for. We said there was no use in having a bus station if they had no buses to run into it, and that they ought to buy oil for the buses. We bought the bus station, and we planned to take the civil servants out of Árus Brugha and put them into the bus station. We said that we could evacuate the Castle and so dispose of Fianna Fáil commitment No. 2. There was another commitment. There was a plan to spend £9,000,000 on Dublin Castle. In connection with it, there was a beautiful model which had cost £1,500 to make.
Comment on this
When we came in that model was there. It took up the whole of the table in the ante-room to the room where the Government met. It was so big that there was not room on the table to write a halfpenny postcard. The plan was to spend £9,000,000 on the Castle. That was commitment No. 2. We came into Dáil Éireann and we cancelled that. We said that it could wait until we saw how many civil servants we could evacuate from the Castle, from Árus Brugha and from 17 other buildings in the city. We said that, when we had evacuated the College of Science and had provided alternative accommodation for UniversityCollege outside the city, there would be much more accommodation for civil servants, and that we were not going to spend £9,000,000 on Dublin Castle. We cancelled that commitment. We told C.I.E. that we would take over the bus station. If we had not taken it over it would never have been built, because C.I.E. had not the money to pay for the slates, the glass or the cement to cover the steel girders that had been put up. Deputy Norton took it over, paid for it and made it available for the Department of Social Welfare. That was commitment No. 3. These were the commitments that we brought into Dáil Éireann and cancelled them.
We had debts of £10,500,000 which our predecessors had left us and which Deputy McGilligan had to repay out of the £12,000,000 which he raised by way of a public loan in the autumn of 1948. We paid them. Then we had coal sailing up the Liffey to us in boat-loads. We did our level best to cancel that commitment. In connection with it we were told: "No, that is a contract and there is Government signature to that contract." Deputy MacEoin used to be interviewed every now and then and asked when was the commission going to be paid on that contract. We did our best to turn back the boats which were coming up with African coal. We found that we could not turn them back, and we had to pile the coal in the Phoenix Park, where it poisoned the ducks in the President's pond, and, having buried the ducks, we had to pay commission on the blooming coal. Then we found that we could get no one to burn it. It was African coal.
There was another commitment which we tried to cancel. Some Deputies may have forgotten this one. When we came into office logs were coming into the Park at the rate of 200 tons a day, or was it 1,000 tons a day?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach can check the figures, but everyone knew that the State was losing a very large sum on every ton of logs that was coming in. Was there an impending fuelshortage in the city at that time? Was there the danger that grates in humble homes would go without supplies? There was a certificate from the Department of Supplies to the effect that there were enough logs in the Phoenix Park to furnish a prospective demand for logs in the City of Dublin for the next ten years, and that it was then a problem of extreme complexity to know where they would put the blooming logs. We asked: "Well, if that is so, why do the logs keep coming in?" We discovered that a decision had been taken to stop the logs on the eve of the by-elections in 1947. And then somebody said: "Oh my God, such a time to stop the logs coming in! Let them come!" And they got such a shock in the two by-elections that they forgot all about the logs and they kept coming in, like the dip candles in Windsor. It was like the time that George III ordered that 1 lb. of dip candles be delivered to Windsor in 1750 and they kept coming in. The dip candles were forgotten about until 1847 when Prince Albert discovered that they were still being delivered. Similarly they forgot here that the logs were coming in, from where they were coming and where they were going.
We stopped the logs. That was a commitment of Fianna Fáil, and we came into Dáil Éireann and told Dáil Éireann that it was a commitment of Fianna Fáil which we proposed to terminate. That is the way to deal with commitments. Let me ask this question of the Taoiseach who says he found commitments from our Government when he came into office—I have catalogued for him a tithe of the commitments we found when we came into office and had to cancel—let him catalogue for me one single commitment that he found in the whole of the Government that he thought it prudent or right to cancel when he came into office? There was not one. There was not one that he dared to cancel. He discovered on examination that every one of them was good for Ireland and the Irish people.
Comment on this
Our attitude was not the attitude of the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is a very orderly Deputy as a rule except when he shakes down that lock in front of his brow and then he is liable to become skittish. Well, it is no thinner than my own. If he wants to make Delphic interjections I cannot complain, but I do not know what he means when he says his attitude was not the same as mine. I regard him as the greatest curse and affliction that ever came upon the Irish race and I would regard it as catastrophic if he and I had the same attitude or if we thought alike. The fact that he is the greatest curse and affliction of the Irish people does not alter the fact that he is a very agreeable man with whom to spend an evening. Apart from that I would not expect to find him thinking as I do but I do not know to what particular aspect of our activities he refers when he makes that observation.
My purpose is to prove that he found no debt when he came into office but that he found £24,000,000 of cash in the Loan Counterpart Fund and £6,250,000 of cash in the Grant Counterpart Fund and that he has the £6,250,000 of cash still and accrued interest thereon, and instead of going for a loan in the autumn of 1951 he elected to spend the £24,000,000 in cash that we left there as a reserve fund and postponed his borrowing to the autumn of 1952 when he negotiated it at 5 per cent. with the consequences I have described.
So I ask him to grasp a simple fundamental economic fact that it is not the quantity of money spent that matters but how we spent it and on what terms we borrowed it. I want to make a clear distinction between a commercial loan on the one hand and Government borrowing for national development on the other. I want to ask this question in Dáil Eireann with fullest deliberation: where is the Deputy or the Minister who will get up to argue with me that it is right and proper, prudent and conservative for the British Government or the United States Government to borrow£600,000,000,000 sterling free of interest to purchase guns and ammunition and the machines of war, all of which are to be dissipated in smoke leaving no asset after them but victory (God bless the mark), and that it is criminal, reckless, revolutionary and Bolshevik to borrow money on similar terms to house your own people, to rehabilitate your own land, to hospitalise your own sick and to increase your own national income?
I do not understand how that case can be made. I do not understand how it is prudent or right to require the municipality of Dublin to pay 5 per cent. to an insurance company on a loan of 20 years' duration to house the people of our city while we lend £63,000,000 to the British Treasury at less than 2 per cent. I do not see why it is right that the Government of this sovereign Republic should of its own volition elect to pay 5 per cent. to the moneylenders for money we require for the benefit of our own country while we lend three times as much to the British Government at 2 per cent.
Comment on this
I am not aware that we paid 4½ per cent. I understand that the rate of interest on the Marshall Loan was 2½ per cent. with five years free of interest and I would like to remind the Deputy that when his Party took office in 1951 if they did not approve of that transaction, there was £24,000,000 in cash which he could have carried round to the American Embassy and taken £24,000,000 at least off the account.
Comment on this
No. There was £24,000,000 there in cash in the Central Bank which could be drawn upon at a moment's notice by the Minister for Finance. I do not say that he had £24,000,000 in sovereigns banked up against the corner of the wall.
Comment on this
But if the Deputy wanted to pay £24,000,000 back to the American Ambassador there wasnothing to stop him. Do not let us forget that within three months of the Government coming into office they were providing all the dollars that the mincemeat manufacturers required for the purchase of raisins and prunes. Now if we could get dollars to buy raisins and prunes, were not dollars available to liquidate the £24,000,000 that we wanted to pay back to America?
Comment on this
I want to make this clear. I know the Deputy is slow of comprehension. Suppose these five sheets of paper were bank notes and each one represented a £1 note. There were 5,000,000 times as many bank notes as there are sheets of paper there.
Comment on this
Now, if the Deputy had earned £500,000 every year since he was born, that was the amount that was lying in the Central Bank. If the Deputy were Minister for Finance and wanted to do so, he could have gone down in a cab and loaded the £24,000,000 into the cab, whipped up his horse and driven round to No. 10 Merrion Square and taken it in his own hands and given it to the ambassador. If he wanted to give him dollars, he could have gone to the Minister for Finance and said: "Instead of buying prunes and raisins to make into mincemeat to send to Great Britain, buy dollars."
Comment on this
Wait a moment. Buy dollars so that I can deliver my carload of dollars to No. 10 Merrion Square. But you did not do that.
Comment on this
I am glad the Deputy has asked a question for I am always pleased to undertake the education of Fianna Fáil Deputies. He wants to know why we borrowed dollars from America. I will tell him. I am glad the Deputy is so anxious to learn. We had plenty of money.
Comment on this
The Deputy wanted, first of all, to know why we borrowed the dollars. Is not that so?
Comment on this
Now the Deputy will hear why, whether he likes it or not. The Deputy has probably heard of the European Payments Union.
Comment on this
Very well. He knows that in 1948 the European Payments Union was in dire distress for want of dollars. In fact, they were buying more from the United States than they were selling to the United States and they had no dollars wherewith to pay. The Deputy knew that. He also knew that his Government had made an arrangement to become a member of the Sterling Pool in 1932 or 1933 after Great Britain and the United States went off the gold standard. Did the Deputy know that?
Comment on this
Can the Deputy tell me when it was formed? It was not formed until 1933. We joined it and we had access to the dollars we required. In 1948 Great Britain had no dollars. That was the position.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot say that my arrival knocked all the dollars out of the British Treasury. Itachieved many remarkable things, but that was not one of them.
Comment on this
You made arrangements that we would not draw on the British Sterling Pool for dollars.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen must allow Deputy Dillon to speak. He must cease these unseemly interruptions.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy want to know on what they were spent? They were spent on petrol because we did not want the Deputy travelling up and down to and from County Wexford on a bicycle. They were spent on rubber. They were spent on oil because we felt the Deputy might like to lubricate the wheels of a cart he might be using for fear they would screech going along the road.
Comment on this
I do not require it. There was a variety of commodities that we could not get anywhere else except in America, and we, therefore, wanted dollars. We told the American Government we were prepared to take advantage of dollars for the purchase of these things on the clear understanding that when the terms of the loan provided that we should repay them we could not give any undertaking in the year after that we would have any dollars, but we would certainly have sterling; and the Americans replied: "Is not that our headache? If we are prepared to lend the dollars and prepared to take the risk that you will only have sterling wherewith to repay them, why should you worry about that?" We said: "That is all right," and we borrowed the dollars we required.
What happened? It is as well for Deputy Allen to understand this. We wanted petrol. A petrol importer purchased a tanker of petrol at Baltimore and he had to pay for that petrol in dollars. He came to his own Government and his own Government lent him the dollars. He took those dollars and paid them to the oil company at Baltimore and the oil company then released the tanker. When the tankersailed up the Liffey he sold its contents to garages all over the country and when the garages paid him for the petrol he came around to the Department of Finance and he paid into the Department the sterling equivalent of the dollars he had been lent. That sterling was put into the Central Bank to have it there ready wherewith to repay the American Government when the debt fell due in respect of the Marshall Aid Loan. Now, does the Deputy understand that? There was never one penny net debt due by the Irish Government to the United States Government. For every dollar we borrowed we had the dollar equivalent in sterling sitting in the Central Bank, there available to be drawn out to pay the Americans.
Comment on this
The Deputy is quite mistaken. I know the Deputy will find difficulty in grasping that. But our forecast was right, because now the instalments are falling due and the Minister for Finance has no difficulty to-day in getting all the dollars he wants to pay every instalment as it falls due. When he seeks the wherewithal to pay the instalment, the money wherewith to purchase the dollars to pay that instalment is there in the Central Bank to his credit. There is not a penny net debt—not one penny—and we had every dollar there on interest for five years. £48,000,000! Remember, if that money had been borrowed on the same terms as those upon which the Minister for Finance borrows we would have had to pay £12,500,000 in interest on it over the period for which we actually had it free of interest from the Americans. Now, does Deputy Allen say that was a bad bargain?
Comment on this
Our problem is that we have too many dollars at the present time. That is our problem. Our problem is that we do not want all the commodities from the United States for which we have dollars available forpurchase. We would be entitled to draw more dollars from the Sterling Pool than we are actually drawing, if we wanted them. Our problem is to put up a case for keeping our claim on the Sterling Pool alive. Is it not time that Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party opened their eyes?
Comment on this
Did we not get value for that expenditure? Remember, the Government did not spend a penny of it. Every penny of it was spent by businessmen who used it to import commodies that were necessary and that our people wanted. Is not that what money is for? Would the Deputy have preferred to have put it in a stocking? We used it to buy crawler tractors and machinery to develop our land. We used it to provide the commodities that our people wanted. Was that wrong? We thought it was right. We thought it was a good thing to do. Now the Deputy finds that there is money in the Central Bank wherewith to buy the dollars that are in abundant supply to pay every instalment that falls due, and there has never been the slightest embarrassment or difficulty in meeting these instalments as they fall due. The Deputy has discovered two years too late that the whole business was a mare's nest, that he was made a fool of and sent down the country to prophesy that the country was going bankrupt. But it did not go bankrupt. He was sent down to tell the people that the farmers were lazy and indolent and incapable of expanding agricultural production and that there was no prospect of expanding agricultural production or of doing anything to redress the balance of payments; this year he has discovered that our exports have gone up to £105,000,000. It is not the sins the Deputy and his Party has committed that matter. It is the sins they have in contemplation. It is not too late to redeem his often perjured soul. If the Deputy looks back on the litany of destruction the Government have wrought on this country over the last 20 years——
Comment on this
——the Deputy must lose a night's sleep every now and again. But it is not what has been done that matters. It is what will be done that matters. The Deputy and his Party can do either of two things: he can turn over a new leaf, or get out. I do not give a hoot which. But, in the name of our people and of our country, do one or the other quickly because, if you do not, it may become utterly impossible to retrieve the disaster you have brought upon us.
Comment on this
I am glad that Deputy Allen reminded Deputy Dillon that it is rather a pity he had not in mind these excellent financial principles about which he has discoursed to us so long and so volubly, not to say tediously, when he and his colleagues were entering into their commitments for the borrowing of £48,000,000 in dollars, to which reference has been made. Deputy Dillon spent a good part of his time twitting the Minister for Finance because he had the temerity to say that if we are to pay interest, let it be 5 per cent. or whatever it may be, it is better that our people should secure the benefit of that interest than the foreigner in Wall Street or Lombard Street or wherever he may be.
Away back in 1935 Deputy Dillon warned us against the dreadful fate of countries like Newfoundland that had to go borrowing with their hats in their hands. During the course of our term of office we have seen what happened to New Zealand, one of the most prosperous countries on the face of the earth from the agricultural point of view. We have seen New Zealand and Australia in dire straits because they were unable to get their affairs in proper order and had to borrow in London to carry on their trade and economy.
I thank Deputy Dillon for his kind good wishes to my colleague, the Minister for Finance. If he had been here I am sure he would have reminded Deputy Dillon of what he stated in this House on the 19th March, 1953— column 808:
"Now, one of the very substantial items in the bill which the countrywill have to vote next year will be the sum of £1,200,000 to be paid as interest on the Marshall Aid Loan. As I have said before, if that loan had been raised in this country and the interest were to be paid free of tax as the interest on the Marshall Aid Loan is being paid free of tax it would have represented an interest rate of all but 5 per cent."
That is the interest—£1,200,000. The question has been frequently asked in this House, where are the assets, where is the production as a result of the transactions in connection with that loan which will enable that interest of £1,200,000 per year to be cleared? Remember that in 1956 not merely the interest but the principal on all these millions of dollars will have to be repaid, not in sterling but in dollars.
Living in this fantastic fairy world where Deputy Dillon believes dollars can be had for the asking, does he believe that the Irish people are fools, that they are completely devoid of intelligence, that they do not understand that the great British Empire was brought almost to bankruptcy early in 1952? Deputy Dillon and his leader—if he is his leader—Deputy Costello, have been trying to persuade us that we in this country are very badly off, that we are in a terrible plight, due entirely to the misdeeds and diabolical machinations of the present Government whose only interest and object in political life, apparently, is to discredit their predecessors even though by so doing they are injuring the interests of the country. We will fight Deputy Dillon and beat Deputy Dillon in any constituency, as we have fought and beaten his colleagues and himself in many an election on that question. We can leave it to the Irish people to decide whether the leader of this Party and his colleagues are honest or not in the policy that they have put before the people and in the steps they have taken to right the situation, steps that they considered necessary since they came into office.
Comment on this
We will declare the election when it is necessary. When Deputy Costello came into office he went to the trouble of assuring the Irish people that he did not want elections, that elections were very expensive and costly, were upsetting to the trade of the country and created a great deal of uncertainty. So long as the Government have a majority in this House and so long as they have not gone beyond the normal term of office it is a question entirely for them as to when they will go to the country.
It is a perfectly scandalous state of affairs that a Deputy, a former Minister of a Government, should try to pour odium on the Minister for Finance because he paid those who invested in the recent Irish National Loans the interest which was necessary in order to raise the money. Deputy Davin may laugh. Deputy Davin should read the newspapers and compare what the Australian Government had to pay recently for a loan of a much smaller amount of money, in London, with what we paid here. They were not successful in rasing the finances they were looking for. If Deputy Davin looks at the terms of the New Zealand loan he will see that they compare very favourably with the terms that we gave.
Comment on this
We have no apology to offer. If it would not be wearying the House too much I would quote the learned Senator Dr. George O'Brien, Professor of Political Economy in University College, Dublin whom Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance, called to his aid. If Dr. O'Brien was satisfied with a policy and passed it as suitable then, of course, it was to be taken as absolutely A.1. Senator Dr. O'Brien has recently given us certain facts to ponder. He certainly has suggested that we ought to pay our people or whoever we can get to invest in our national capital development sufficient to enable us to raise the necessary funds. I do not know what the alternative to that may be. May I remind Deputy Davin, who is very fond of interrupting when these financial questionsare under discussion, that when his friends over in Britain had charge of the affairs of that country they were forced under Sir Stafford Cripps to bring in large Budget surpluses amounting over a period of years to over £2,500,000,000 in order to finance capital expenditure? You either have to finance it as they did through Budget surpluses or you have to raise it by way of loans, and in order to raise the necessary funds you have to pay the price that the borrower considers reasonable having regard to the competition which you will meet in the money market.
Comment on this
Our people have not been an experienced people in this matter of investment. We have very many millions of pounds on deposit in our banks, unfortunately. I wish that our people, and particularly our farmers, would invest that money in home enterprise——
Comment on this
——let it be either State capital projects or private undertakings, but I would remind my friends on the other side that their adviser Dr. O'Brien has suggested— and I think his words merit careful consideration—that the credit of the country is an asset of great value indeed. Like many another thing when your money or your credit is good you do not value it, but the moment your credit goes, the moment your assets disappear and you are reduced to the position of making the very best terms you can with the foreign lender in order to try and secure funds from him at almost any cost to get you out of your difficulties, you will then realise the value of having your finances in order and your credit sound.
We have been reminded and advised over and over again by foreign experts who have studied our position in regard to our international trade and in comparison with the affairs of other countries to look, for example, to Switzerland. How did Switzerland getinto the position that a country like Australia goes to her to borrow money, that she is in the position that her currency is the hardest in the world, and that it can look the American dollar, even, in the face? Has it attained that position by deficit budgeting, by not paying its way, or by establishing a name for itself in the world as a nation which will live up to its undertakings, which will see that its budget is balanced, that its currency does not depreciate, that its credit is unquestioned, and will take all necessary steps to see that its financial position is maintained in a sound condition?
We have not that tradition. We have to build it up, and the first task is to try to induce our own people first to buy Irish goods and, secondly, to invest their savings in Irish enterprise. Deputy Davin does not understand that even nationalised undertakings, even in socialist countries, must secure the necessary savings either through taxation, through contributions from the working population, or through loans, let them be forced loans or voluntary loans. Capital investment projects of the type that he would like and that we all would like to see brought into operation entail very heavy expenditure and the funds necessary are large for this country.
It has been pointed out that they come to about £39,000,000 during the present year apart from the £5,000,000 which the Government is to provide annually for the National Development Fund. That money has to be raised and has to be paid for, and it is not in the same category as industrial investment used to be, what is called equity investment, where the investor took the risk. He saw what he considered was a good proposition and put his money into that proposition. If it succeeded and he got a good profit, well and good. If through unexpected circumstances or competition or something else occurring he was not able to reap the profit he had anticipated and in fact he suffered a loss he had to put up with that. Under the system of State capital investment the charges on the CentralFund are very heavy. They are about £2,000,000 larger in amount this year than they were last year. All of that money is going to pay the charges on capital that has to be raised. Deputy Davin and his friends are in the happy position that they can criticise and be wise after the event. Whichever way the cat jumps and whatever way the story goes we may be sure they will have criticisms. The Government after full consideration of all the circumstances in their negotiations with the banks in order to raise the funds that were necessary considered that the payment of the interest at the rate mentioned was necessary, and that is all there is to it. We are a Government of collective responsibility, and it is just nonsensical to pretend that the Minister for Finance is doing something or carrying out some policy with which his colleagues are not in agreement. In budgetary matters or in financial matters, while the responsibility rests mainly on his shoulders, undoubtedly he naturally takes into consultation and takes advice with his colleagues.
Comment on this
There is an effort being made to set up a mythical bogeyman, a kind of a cockshot or Aunt Sally. The money in the Irish banks is the money of the Irish people, whether they be farmers or workers or business people. It is their money, and it is nonsense for Deputy Dillon or Deputy Davin or anyone else to say that the Government is investing their money here, there, or anywhere else. It is their money and they are quite free to invest it where they wish. We are doing our utmost to encourage them to invest it at home; but this is not a totalitarian State, and if you try totalitarian methods in this delicate and important matter I wonder whether you will get just the results you expect.
In a publication by an Englisheconomist, Mr. Durban, which has been described as a textbook to which the former Prime Minister of England had recourse—there are very few social economists, but being rather curious as to the lines on which they would work I read Mr. Durban's book —I find statements like the following: "The only way in which accumulated capital can be financed is by withdrawal of part of the funds earned by the socialised industries through the workers employed in them to finance the capital items in the industrial budget. Surpluses arising in socialised industries must not belong to the workers in such industries. They must belong to the state."
Even if we went over to complete socialisation, we would still have this problem. If we do not secure investment in the normal way through the well-recognised channels, then it will be found, as it has been found by the Labour Government in Britain, that to run nationalised industries, if finance cannot be raised in any other way it must be raised through the internal funds of the organisation of the industry and, if necessary, by contributions from the workers themselves. The myth that you can create credit and the necessary finance for the capitalisation of these industries out of nothing has been exploded. Everyone knows that if the Central Bank, the banks as a whole or the financial institutions generally of this country were to adopt that policy, you would simply have runaway inflation.
Comment on this
How is she repaying it? She is not able to pay it, therefore, the £ has depreciated steadily. The money for the last war was spent when the people were worked up to a great national effort. They were prepared to do things in war-time that they are not prepared to do in peace-time.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has said that the National Development Fund is being set up as a "slush fund" for election purposes. When Deputy Dillon set up the Connemara development fund or the rocks fertilisation process, which he set on foot with such a great blare of trumpets and advertisement in the Sunday Independent,was it not on the eve of the by-election that followed the death of the late lamented Deputy Mongan?
Comment on this
Neither the Department of Finance nor any of his colleagues knew anything about the land reclamation scheme until he went to some obscure part of the Midlands and, without taking cognisance of anybody, announced to the world this wonderful scheme for the reclamation of the land of Ireland over a ten-year period at a cost of £40,000,000. He is learning now that there are farmers who applied to have work done under that scheme when it was first introduced who have not yet been reached, but how many thousands of applications did Deputy Dillon leave behind him when he left office? Has he ever made a calculation as to how long it would take, working both the Government machinery and the other side of the scheme, before all the farmers who had sent in applications would be reached? If we were to take the figures of expenditure on the actual work of land reclamation and the amounts payable to farmers or about to be paid during the first few years that the scheme was in operation, it is quite obvious that the work would not be done in 20 years, 40 years or maybe 100 years. Even the thousands of applications that were in could not be reached for several years to come.
This scheme was in operation before Deputy Dillon and his famous land project were ever heard of. It was then called the land reclamation scheme and was operated by this Government for many years on a system under which we paid 50 per cent. of the cost of the actual workcarried out by farmers for the improvement of their land. That was not good enough for Deputy Dillon. He must buy hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of machinery, create a bureaucracy, a regular hierarchy of officials, and have the situation that only one-fifth or one-sixth of the total expenditure in the early years went on the actual work, the remainder going into overheads and the provision of machinery. How long would it take before the ordinary small farmer would have been reached under Deputy Dillon's wonderful scheme or did Deputy Dillon consider the small farmers and their circumstances at all when he was getting in all this machinery at an enormous cost? Was he thinking of Pat Murphy in Mayo or Pat Jones in Kerry, I wonder, when he paid out as much as £100 per acre for the fertilisation of the rocks in Round-stone or £60 or £70 per acre for the reclamation of land belonging to large landholders, some of whom received many thousands of pounds? Did he pay more for the reclamation of land than the Land Commission was paying for the most fertile land in this country when they acquired it?
I am surprised that the present Minister for Agriculture took over this commitment that Deputy Dillon left behind him but he did take it over and he has succeeded in reducing the cost, not in any endeavour to discredit Deputy Dillon but because, as the Taoiseach pointed out, we must have regard to the value we are getting for the money. The £2,500,000 we are spending on this land reclamation project must be measured against the various other schemes upon which £2,500,000 could be profitably expended, from the point of view of the employment given, the amenities created or the increase in the productive power of the country secured. Therefore, the Minister for Agriculture, I suggest, was acting in the best national interest and in the interests of the scheme itself, if it were to be made rational and to have regard to the real circumstances of the country, particularly of the small farmers, in encouraging a situation by which we would get the farmers themselves to do the work, make their own arrangements withcontractors and then recoup them to a greater percentage of the cost than they were actually getting under Deputy Dillon's administration.
In order to encourage the farmers to do that we increased the grants. We did that because we realised that it is the small farmers who should benefit by this scheme. We realised also that the less administrative costs, the less overheads and the less bureaucracy you have and the more you get people themselves, whether they be the farming community or others, to operate these schemes themselves, the better they will be and the more efficient and the more economical in the long run.
I am not going to go over again the historical references that Deputy Dillon has made to the Opposition when they came into office. He said they found certain debts and he denies that they left debts behind them. He first used the word "debts" and then changed it to "commitments." The first thing I did when I became Minister in 1951 was to go down and tell the people in my constituency that very formidable financial obligations had been left by our predecessors upon our shoulders, and particularly upon the shoulders of the Minister for Finance, to clear up. One of them was in regard to C.I.E. to which reference has been made. C.I.E. was nationalised by the last Government but they took no steps either to increase the transport charges to enable that organisation to reduce its losses or to secure the necessary finances from the national Exchequer to have it subsidised. Neither one thing nor the other had been done and when we came into office we found that there was a recoupment of interest amounting to £433,000 and there were losses amounting to £1,900,000 to be met.
There was also the question of the Civil Service arbitration award. It is true that the last Government could say that they left office before they had an opportunity of carrying into effect their intention of honouring the arbitration award. They specifically promised, however, that they would carry the award into effect and we considered it necessary to fulfil thatundertaking and we had to provide the necessary finances to do that. To put that award into effect in the first year cost £3.6 million and in the following year about £3,500,000.
There was also a sum of a £1,000,000 for old age pensions. When, under pressure, the social welfare legislation was introduced by Deputy Norton, the then Tánaiste and Minister for Social Welfare, he had a clause introduced into it to satisfy the back bench supporters of some of the Parties, and secure their support for the measure by increasing the old age pensions. No provision was made for that, and it cost, roughly, a £1,000,000 a year.
Deputy Dillon now, apparently, suggests that all the Government had to do when they came into office was to throw overboard commitments like those to C.I.E., the Civil Service and the old age pensioners. He knows that that was quite impossible either politically or, I venture to say, morally. There are certain commitments which Governments enter into, and it would be dishonourable, whether we agree with them or not, and damaging to the national interest in a different sense if, except in very exceptional circumtances, Governments were just to refuse to carry out particular financial commitments of that kind entered into by their predecessors.
Deputy Costello spent a good deal of time telling us how badly off the country was, but he admitted that. it is perhaps a little better off than it was last year. With the exception of the general catalogue of complaints and platitudes, I find very little depth or very little of value in his contribution to the debate. It bespeaks rather the advocate from the courts who hurriedly seizes a brief and uses it in the short time at his disposal to make his appearances in An Dáil to traverse the same ground he has already covered so frequently in the past few years. In the first place, there must be more than a few people who are a little better off than they were last year. Looking at the figures, I notice that the note circulation, which for the ten months ending in October, 1952, averaged £60.374 million per month,has risen in the corresponding period of 1953 to, £65.818 million, an increase of £5.4 million or 9 per cent. There is, therefore, nearly £66,000,000 in circulation in each month and, presumably, it is being spent; it is being exchanged.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Davin will be able to find some means of preventing people from going to racecourses, but I do not know of any way of doing it.
Comment on this
The bank deposits during the first part of the present year increased over last year's figure by 6 per cent. Even the railway receipts are up since January. The chairman of C.I.E. has announced that he hopes the company will be £500,000 better off this year. He has expressed his belief that when the new programme of capital construction is in operation it will be possible to bring about a reduction in the present heavy losses and he is hopeful that in time it may be possible to eliminate those losses altogether. I am sure that we all wish the board every success in their efforts. But, while C.I.E. is making progress, endeavouring to cut its losses and hoping to eliminate them altogether eventually, the number of private motor-cars in the country is increasing. That is not a proof that we are in the terrible state of misery and penury which Deputy Costello suggests.
Comment on this
They may be bought on the hire purchase system. Deputy Costello said that there were serious indications of anxiety, that people are fearful and timorous of the future. That must be the atmosphere down in the Four Courts. Perhaps when they are confronted with the bills of theirlearned counsel, those who find themselves in the unfortunate position that they have to have recourse to them may suffer from one of the numerous diseases, thrombosis or otherwise, which afflict people these times. But there is no evidence on looking around the City of Dublin or along the roads of Ireland at the present time that there is any great financial depression. Quite the contrary.
Comment on this
He may be. The number of new private motor-cars registered in the September quarter was 3,818, or 1,003, as Leperello would say in the opera, more than in the same quarter last year. Last year the national income increased by £30.8 million or by 8.3 per cent. over 1951 to the figure of £404,000,000, and the real national income is estimated by the statisticians to have been 16 per cent. higher in 1952 than in 1938. Due largely, no doubt, to increased agricultural output, the national income is steadily increasing, but the figures I have quoted represent only an income of £136 per head of our population, which is still low in comparison with the figure for other countries. It is quite clear that a higher level of production and output and, therefore, an increased national income are necessary to maintain our economy in a prosperous condition.
When Deputy Dillon was referring to the dreadful things the Government were doing—how they were in league with the financiers, some extraordinary secret kind of organisation which the bankers have, as if the bankers are not, as I have mentioned, simply the custodians of the savings and deposits of the Irish people—he conveniently forgot, as did Deputy Costello, that we had a devaluation crisis which came on rather suddenly in 1949 and which seemed to take the previous Government unawares. They had to take a hurried decision and they decided to follow the English example and devalue—there was no way out of it. In doing so, just as in investing the Counterpart Fund moneys in sterling assets, they admitted that there wasa certain situation there which it will take time to alter. It cannot be altered overnight or suddenly. That devaluation which the Irish Government felt themselves compelled to put into operation here was described by the present British Prime Minister as the penalty the British people had to pay for the failure to take proper measures in time.
Later on, we had the Korean war, with the boom in prices—fantastic, in some cases. There, again, the Government of the day got into rather a state of panic and instructed wholesalers, distributors and business people to stock up for all they were worth. We are still suffering the effects of that stocking up, that building up of huge stocks at a time when prices were reaching fantastic levels. It was obvious that, when prices began to fall, there would be difficulty in liquidating these stocks and the cost of financing them and enabling the people who had these stocks to carry on with their business must have been very considerable.
Deputy Costello went on to refer to unemployment figures and said that the percentage unemployment had grown here more than in other countries; but, in order to examine that question, I suggest one first has to ascertain what the basis and structure of the register of unemployed persons in other countries is. For example in the Scandinavian countries it may be as I think it is the case that only those who are unemployed trade unionists are registered. In this country, a very large number of rural people are registered—in normal times up to about 45 per cent—and in taking 1951 and comparing it with the present year Deputy Costello conveniently forgot as did all the critics of the Government who have used the increase in the figures on the live register as a means of trying to prove that unemployment has increased under this Government and so on, that a very large number of people are now registered, due to the operation of the Social Welfare Act of 1952 who were not registered before. Persons of 65 years of age can draw unemployment benefit right up to 70 years. Thatwas one of the benefits granted to the working people under that Act introduced and passed into law under the guidance of the present Minister. That has brought a large number of people on the register.
The means test has been extended and persons who were not eligible for benefit and assistance before are now eligible. Moreover, a large number of people are on the register and still are not in receipt of assistance because their means are too high. Let us take landholders, for instance. A certain number of these will have been taken off the register during the currency of the Employment Period Order and will come back on the register, but these people may be in the category in which, although under the recent legislation they are in receipt of credits, and up to the passage of the Act should not have been on the register at all, they will not actually receive assistance until their time comes round again. According to the official returns for mid-November, 1953, an increase of 3,265, as compared with last year, which is largely under the heading of agriculture, is attributed wholly to the operation of the Social Welfare Act and it has been calculated that, prior to the coming into operation of these Employment Period Orders—at that period of the year—a total figure of perhaps up to 6,000 persons were on the register who would not have been on it before the passing of this Act.
The live register does not tell us the numbers in receipt of unemployment assistance who were in employment last year. It does not tell us whether they were in casual employment, how many have come on the register for the first time or how many have returned from Britain—I believe there is a large number—who are drawing their benefit here. What we do know with regard to the numbers in insurable employment is that, on the 18th November, there were 495,270 men and 229,027 women—a total of 724,927—in insurable employment. Last year's figure which, I admit, is not entirely comparable by reason of the fact that the Social Welfare Act has changed the conditionssomewhat, was 500,000, and the figure at the same period in the previous year, 489,000.
The Opposition, I suggest, are finding it difficult to have it both ways when they tell us they are delighted the farmers are receiving high prices for their produce, and, at the same time try to reconcile the desire we all have that the agricultural community should be as prosperous as possible with the argument that the Government are responsible for the increase in the cost of living, which is due in large measure to food prices. Last night, we had a motion to have the question of milk prices considered before the costings commission reported, and the House did not feel it should take action until it had the full facts before it. Deputy Costello stated not once but several times that the reason his Government left office was that they refused to increase the price of milk. I believe that, milk being an essential foodstuff, particularly for children, and since milk has to compete with beef and various other products which I need not enumerate, those who tend animals and have their care day after day, week after week and month after month should receive an economic price for their produce. I think they deserve it far more than other sections of the community who are clamouring either for relief or increases.
In any case, it is recognised by all Parties that the State has a certain duty, let the level of prices for milk be what they may, to keep milk producers in production and, if possible, to increase yields and output, and it is recognised that the quickest and best incentive is the incentive of price. In the case of wheat and beet, it is common policy that the prices guaranteed by the Government so far should be continued. The increased acreage, the better yields and the satisfactory position with regard to these important crops means that we are going to have more sugar and more wheat and will be less dependent on foreign supplies, and, although it may involve adjustments and certain difficulties which will have to be resolved, nevertheless, the money will be in circulationin our own country, benefiting our farmers, our workers, our transport organisation and our towns.
The agricultural price index has increased between September, 1952 and September, 1953 by 30 points, to 322 or roughly 10 per cent. and it is very satisfactory that the level of prices has been so good for farmers during that period. It has had the consequence also, as we have seen in the case of eggs, that at certain periods the housewife may find it very difficult to pay the price demanded, but we cannot have it both ways. If we want agriculture to be prosperous and want the farmers to get a good return, we have to put up with these difficulties, and I think that, on balance, the general national interest, the interests of the people as a whole, are better served by having a prosperous and, I hope, a very prosperous, farming community than otherwise.
We have the example of the United States of America which has made it a firm keystone of its policy that the prices of farm products must be maintained. It may involve at certain periods a reduction in acreage, but the maintenance of economic and fair prices for the producers of farm products is the very basis of prosperity in the nation's economy. The Government have, through many schemes in operation under the Department of Agriculture and otherwise, done a great deal to provide State moneys for amenities and conveniences for farmers. We would like to see ways and means devised by which assistance to the agricultural community would be directed into channels which would achieve the speediest return in the way of increased output from our land.
No doubt, that is largely a matter for the farmers themselves. It is a process of education that they should adopt better methods, but the Government has not neglected any occasion to bring home to them the importance of putting land under the plough and treating it with adequate supplies of limestone and fertiliser, if we are to get the best return and to be able to compare the output from the land of this country with what has been secured elsewhere. The Minister forAgriculture recently referred to the main problem before Irish agriculture, that is, the stepping up of the yield from the areas under permanent grass. There are certain counties in the State which have a comparatively small amount of land under tillage—some of them perhaps only 8 per cent. and certainly less than 10 per cent. There is no doubt that the country would benefit immensely, agriculture would be more prosperous and our productive capacity permanently improved, if we could get our farmers to bring the plough right around their farms and to use the various Government agencies which are there to assist them in improving their land, in fertilising it and getting the utmost out of it.
Reference has also been made to the work being done by the veterinary services and it is rather alarming that the Minister for Agriculture has had to call public attention to the fact that stock owners are not availing themselves of the facilities in existence. He has reminded us recently that one of the most costly and damaging diseases of our live stock, contagious abortion, could probably be eradicated, if livestock owners would only take full advantage of the opportunities which offer and the facilities given for vaccination.
I started my remarks by referring to the question of national investment and the problem of raising moneys to finance these large capital projects. Last year, current savings, estimated at £30,000,000 as compared with the disinvestment in the previous year, are stated by the official statistical returns to have financed up to 77 per cent. of our domestic capital requirements. The Government would like to urge upon our people to invest their moneys in Irish enterprises. They believe there is security here and a yield which cannot be equalled elsewhere and it was for that reason that, on behalf of the Minister for Finance, I called the attention of the Irish banks recently to the fact that the increase in their resources and assets enabled them to stock up their portfolios with larger holdings of national or municipal stocks.