Finance Bill, 1954—Committee (Résumed).
Contributions 1–148 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1954 ›
I move amendment No. 9:—
Before Section 15 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) The duty of customs imposed by Section 20 of the Finance Act, 1952 (No. 20 of 1952), shall in respect of tobacco imported on or after the 1st day of October, 1954, be charged, levied and paid at the several rates specified in Part I of the Fifth Schedule to this Act.
(2) The duty of excise imposed by Section 19 of the Finance Act, 1934 (No. 31 of 1934), shall, as on and from the 1st day of October, 1954, be charged, levied and paid at the several rates specified in Part II of the Fifth Schedule to this Act.
(3) Sub-sections (3) and (5) of Section 19 of the Finance Act, 1934, shall apply to tobacco which is chargeable with the duty of excise imposed by sub-section (1) of the section at a rate specified in Part II of the Fifth Schedule to this Act and for the purpose of such application references in the said sub-sections (3) to (5) of the said Section 19 to Part I of the Sixth Schedule to the said Finance Act, 1934, shall be construed and have effect as references to Part II of the Fifth Schedule to this Act.
(4) The rebate on hard pressed tobacco mentioned in sub-section (2) of Section 17 of the Finance Act, 1940 (No. 14 of 1940), shall, in respect of any such tobacco sold and sent out for use within the State by any licensed manufacturer on or after the 1st day of October, 1954, be at the rate of two shillings and eight pence per pound.
(5) For the purpose of this section, importation shall be deemed to take place at the time when the entry of the relevant goods under the Customs Consolidation Act, 1876, is delivered.
This is another of the series of amendments which I have moved to this Bill, the purpose of which is to reduce taxes to the extent that members of the present Government, and Deputies behind them, had suggested was possible prior to the general election. The most remarkable thing about the discussion upon these amendments is that no member of the Government has thought fit to explain to the Dáil why it is not possible to reduce these taxes now. They had repeatedly asserted in the past that these taxes were unnecessary and had expressed confidence in their ability to reduce them, if the opportunity were given them. Deputies will recollect that the present Taoiseach had said that he would repeal these taxes in ten minutes if he became head of the Government, and that he would resign in one minute if he found himself unable to do so.
Perhaps equally remarkable is the fact that during the course of the debate not a single Deputy sitting behind the Government thought fit to ask the Government as to why a reduction is not possible. These Deputies seem to have forgotten completely the confidence they expressed before the election in their ability to force the Government to reduce taxes. Should they not now ask for an explanation as to why it cannot be done? Not a single one of them has sought that explanation. Apparently they are content to vote to maintain these taxes without knowing why. The definite pledges and undertakings given by them to the electorate are still fresh in our minds. The speed at which they are discarding these pledges and repudiating their undertakings is rather nauseating. They should at least make some pretence at seeking a reasonable explanation as to why it is necessary to maintain these taxes at their present level.
If the Government will say that these taxes cannot be reduced, that the revenue that they will yield is required for the purpose of meeting the cost of necessary Government services, then the position will be clear to the public. The issue between us during the course of the election campaign was whether these taxes were necessary or not. We said that they were necessary, that the Budget could not be balanced without the revenue which they represented except at the cost of a serious curtailment in the scope of Government services. Deputies opposite said that these services could be maintained and taxes reduced at the same time. If that was not so, will they say so? If the explanation is that the Government has now found out, and Deputies behind them are beginning to suspect, that during the election campaign they were talking nonsense and, if they stand up now and say so, it will end this discussion. We know they were talking nonsense. They are beginning to suspect it. Some members of the Government know that in that respect we were right and they were wrong but will they say that?
Will the Minister for Finance stand up and say that he is resisting the reduction of these taxes because he cannot forgo the revenue which they will bring in? That is the explanation which the Dáil is entitled to get, an explanation which the public will understand. It is treating the Dáil with contempt for Ministers to ask the House to resist these amendments without giving a reason for that resistance. It is treating the public with contempt, in view of the declarations that were made to them and the promises that were given to them, to refuse now to cut down these taxes without giving a single reason for maintaining them.
Do Deputies not think their constituents are entitled to an explanation of the votes they gave yesterday? Is there one Deputy opposite who will attempt to give that explanation? If that explanation is not given it merely demonstrates the contempt that Deputies have for those who voted for them.
Comment on this
For Deputy Lemass to get up in this House and talk in terms of the word "nauseating" is, to say the least of it, the most impertinent suggestion that could be made to this House by that Deputy. Deputy Lemass knows very well—no one knows better, as I have already said—that these amendments are nothing but a piece of showacting, play-acting and disgraceful play-acting at that. Deputy Lemass knows that he has no case to make in respect of them and, because he had no case to make, he adopted the normal course adopted by a person who has no case—he put up here a case attempting to put into our mouths a case that was never made.
The other night, during the course of the discussion on the Second Reading of this Bill, I went to some pains to show, and gave quotation after quotation from the general election campaign, that the complaint of the Fianna Fáil Party at that time was not that we were promising too much but that we were making no promises. Now they come to us to-day and try to make a different case altogether.
Deputy Lemass knows full well that the quotations he read yesterday from Mr. Costello and others dealing with the £10,000,000 taxation were quotations—though he did not give the dates of them—of what was said in 1952 and the Deputy and the House know that there is a very different situation to-day from the situation that obtained in 1952. At the time of the Budget in 1952 current expenditure was estimated in my predecessor's Budget speech in April 1952 as being £94,826,000. This year it was estimated by my predecessor as being £109,935,000. If we are to discuss 1954, let us discuss it in terms of 1954 and let us not try to make the dishonest case, as Deputy Lemass made yesterday and wishes to repeat to-day, of treating 1954 on a 1952 basis.
Comment on this
I want to draw attention to one matter. Deputy Lemass spent a lot of time last night giving us quotations and reading for the benefit of the House advertisements appearing over the names of candidates in, I presume, the election campaign. In one of the morning newspapers the words of Deputy Lemass in which I am interested are reported exactly, as follows:—
"In another advertisement it stated: ‘The Labour Party seeks the support of the people in the forthcoming election so that they can bring about a reduction in the price of tobacco, cigarettes, beer and spirits—Vote No. 1——'"
and the candidate's name happens to be my own. I am asking Deputy Lemass, through you, Sir, to give the date on which that advertisement appeared.
Comment on this
There is only one leaflet and it is here. It is in my possession. I have no complaint against the reporter whose report appears on the morning paper. He is just doing his work and he reported what was said in the House. The Official Report of yesterday's debate will prove that Deputy Lemass said "another advertisement". Being my own director of elections I can say that there was but one leaflet issued and I defy anyone to show that such was stated.
My sole reason for intervening now is to let the House know that Deputy Lemass has been politically so dishonest that he is prepared to say advertisements appeared. Unfortunately he barked up the wrong tree when he referred to a Deputy who had but one advertisement throughout the whole campaign. I believe I am entitled at this stage to ask Deputy Lemass either to prove in substance the correctness of his statement or openly withdraw it here—one or the other.
Comment on this
It is most unusual for a Party the size of the Fine Gael Party, that is supposed to be a responsible Party, to run away from its election pledges and to give no excuse. The Minister for Finance described as play-acting and disgraceful play-acting the moving of amendments in the House to give effect to the promises upon which Fine Gael got sufficient votes to form a Government. The 15 lawyers in Fine Gael may parse and make fine points as to what they promised and what they did not promise and what they were pretending to promise but the average voter in the country was asked clearly by the leaders of Fine Gael and by their supporters and canvassers to vote for the Fine Gael candidates in order to "throw high taxation and high prices overboard." Every voter in the country who looked at the hoardings during the general election campaign could see 20 feet square advertisements appealing to the voters to "throw high taxation and high prices overboard." The only thing that has been thrown overboard by Fine Gael since they came into office were their promises.
Comment on this
Fine Gael themselves will be thrown overboard when the people get a chance to have a crack at them again. It is a most disgraceful proceeding that when the members of the Front Bench of Fine Gael and the other Parties are reminded of the promises upon which they got support, they giggle and sneer and snigger in this Dáil. At least they should have some sense of shame but there is no shame in them.
Comment on this
They were prepared to promise anything in order to get votes and, to show the people how deeply they were fooled, they immediately throw their promises overboard.
Comment on this
Do I understand the intervention of the Minister for Finance to mean that he is repeating the statement that the Parties comprising the Government did not promise to reduce taxation?
Comment on this
The intervention of the Minister was to the effect that the quotations which the Deputy read out yesterday and which he pretended were made in 1954 were in fact made in 1952.
Comment on this
The quotations I read from the present Taoiseach or any Minister were from the Dáil Debates and I gave the column and the number of the volume. There was no question of any pretence about it.
Comment on this
Is there now a definite statement that the Government and the Deputies supporting the Government did not promise a reduction in taxation?
Comment on this
You stated yourself during the election campaign that we did not promise anything. Will the Deputy withdraw the unfounded and untrue speeches which he made during the campaign? He cannot have it both ways.
Comment on this
I told the people that these were phoney promises, that you did not mean one word of them.
Comment on this
I admit that. That is the purpose of the amendments. I have no doubt that this is an object lesson in political honesty to the Irish people. Is there any Deputy opposite who did not, in the course of the election, promise a reduction in taxation? Of course there is not one. Everyone knows that on every occasion on which they spoke in public and in every document they issued they suggested that there would be a reduction in taxation and, specifically, that a reduction in the taxes on beer, spirits and tobacco would follow the change of Government.
Comment on this
In view of the statement made by the Deputy in the House, I am asking him to say what paper it was in and what was the date.
Comment on this
In my possession is the one and only leaflet published by me as a candidate, and I am prepared to have a committee or anyone else examine it and see if there is one word in it to support the charge made by Deputy Lemass——
Comment on this
I am quoting from a leaflet issued by the Irish Labour Party.
Comment on this
I am quoting from a leaflet issued by the Irish Labour Party headed: "The Labour Party Programme."
Comment on this
This is the one which was issued during the general election.
Comment on this
The one you quoted yesterday stated specifically "Vote for Dan Desmond." You are caught out again.
Comment on this
I am going to quote from a leaflet issued by the Labour Party in respect of all their candidates.
Comment on this
I am going to read it and I will keep on reading it as long as necessary and I will not be stopped by Deputy Morrissey's interruptions.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Deputy Lemass yesterday attributed to Deputy Desmond a certain statement in my hearing. Deputy Desmond has stated here and offered to prove that he made no such statement.
Comment on this
Is it not therefore incumbent on Deputy Lemass to withdraw the statement he made yesterday that Deputy Desmond issued this leaflet with "Vote 1 Desmond" on it or substantiate it?
Comment on this
I did not say Deputy Desmond issued it. He is a member of the Labour Party, is he not?
Comment on this
Is the Labour Party programme published during the election campaign——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Deputy Lemass yesterday purported to quote from a document. The existence of that document has been questioned by the Deputy who was named by Deputy Lemass. When a Deputy purports to quote from a document, it is the custom to name the document and to produce it. The Deputy is not now naming the document. He is naming a document which he did not refer to yesterday in relation to Deputy Desmond. He has been caught out.
Comment on this
The Chair has no means of knowing what is in the document. These are all matters of fact, not matters of order. The Chair has no means of discovering what Deputy Lemass read from or what Deputy Desmond issued.
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I ask you, am I not entitled to protection when I can prove that a false statement has been made in this Chamber?
Comment on this
The Chair has no means of discovering whether Deputy Lemass made a false statement or not.
Comment on this
I want to deal with the question of a false statement. Here is the leaflet issued by the Labour Party. Was it issued on behalf of Deputy Desmond, or is he repudiating it? Did he repudiate it during the election campaign? It is headed: "The Irish Labour Party Programme".
Comment on this
You read out that leaflet yesterday as if it had at the bottom of it "Vote 1 Desmond". Does the Deputy admit that?
Comment on this
The leaflet I have is the leaflet issued on behalf of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass has been called upon to speak and he is entitled to speak and may not be interrupted except on a point of order. Deputy Desmond raised a matter which he considered a matter of order. The Chair has ruled that it is not a matter of order. The Chair has no means of advising himself as to what happened in respect to the document spoken of here. Deputy Lemass must be allowed to continue his statement without interruption.
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I ask you what protection will be afforded me against a misstatement? Am I not entitled to some protection?
Comment on this
It is in the nature of things that statements made on one side of the House will be contradicted by the other side of the House and the Chair has no means of reconciling these differences.
Comment on this
Is it correct that there have been occasions here when, members having repudiated statements made by other members, these statements had to be withdrawn?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy repudiating this? That is the question.
Comment on this
Let us test the Deputy's honesty. Is he repudiating this document?
Comment on this
Deputy Desmond must allow Deputy Lemass to make his statement without interruption. The Deputy may feel aggrieved, but he will be allowed an opportunity of saying what is the correct position according to him.
Comment on this
The Chair is protecting the Deputy as far as is necessary. The Chair has no means of ascertaining whether Deputy Lemass is making false charges or otherwise.
Comment on this
It will. This document will be read in every constituency in Ireland. I will answer my own question. This document is being repudiated by the Labour Party. It is headed: "The Labour Party Programme." This is what the document says:
"The Labour Party seeks the support of the people in the forthcoming general election so that it can urge the new Dáil to give effect to the following measures which the Labour Party believes will provide prosperity and security for the people."
Comment on this
Number 2 is "Reduction in the Price of Tobacco, Beer and Spirits."
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass must be allowed to make his speech without interruption. Other Deputies can present the position as it appears to them afterwards.
Comment on this
As I understand the position, Deputy Desmond regards it as misrepresentation of himself to say he stood in the election for the Labour Party programme.
Comment on this
The case is made now that it is a lie to say that Deputy Desmond stood for the Labour Party programme.
Comment on this
Is this document a product of my fertile brain? Is this Labour Party programme repudiated now? Is it?
Comment on this
There was never a document issued by the Labour Party or anyone else quoting what you said yesterday, saying that Deputy Desmond's name was at the end of it.
Comment on this
If Deputies persist in interrupting I will have to name the Deputies who so persist. Deputy Lemass is entited to speak and should be allowed to do so.
Comment on this
On a point of order, has it not been the customary practice, during your time and the time of your predecessor, that when a Deputy got up here and denied a statement or challenged the accuracy of a statement attributed to him here, the other Deputy—if he was an honourable man —would accept the assurance given?
Comment on this
I have to assume, and do assume without reserve, that every Deputy is an honourable man, but there is no statement. Deputy Lemass has not made a statement and been asked to withdraw it. He has not made any statement that he has been asked to withdraw.
Comment on this
I cannot verify or examine every document, and do not know whether Deputy Lemass has made a correct statement or otherwise.
Comment on this
On a point of order, could Deputy Lemass not produce the document which he purported to refer to yesterday?
Comment on this
That is no trouble. I am going to produce it all over Ireland. It is the Labour Party programme, published in all the newspapers and by leaflet all over Ireland—and it got votes for the Labour Party.
Comment on this
Deputy Desmond's case, I understand, is that he did not stand in this election for the Labour Party programme.
Comment on this
Deputy Desmond's case is that he did not issue that leaflet and no one issued it for him.
Comment on this
I have already said that if Deputies persist in interrupting I will name the Deputies who do so. I am giving that as a last warning.
Comment on this
The Labour Party all contested the election on a programme which included——
Comment on this
The group of Deputies calling themselves the Irish Labour Party conducted the election on a programme which included the reduction in the price of tobacco, beer and spirits. Did they or did they not? Was that your programme or was it not?
Comment on this
Was that the programme of the Irish Labour Party or not? It was, of course, and it was the programme on which Deputy Desmond and every other Deputy opposite contested the election and sought votes.
Comment on this
They are now systematically, vote after vote, going into the division lobbies to repudiate that programme. They will do it again in five minutes' time. Is not that so?
Comment on this
Those Deputies undertook that if elected they would vote here for a reduction in the duty on cigarettes and tobacco. That is what this amendment relates to. They will not vote for it, but against it. They are going to vote to keep up the taxes imposed on cigarettes and tobacco. Is not that right?
Comment on this
I will forecast that when the division is called Deputy O'Leary will vote to keep up the price of cigarettes and tobacco.
Comment on this
That is the only thing I am trying to establish—that you are now repudiating the policy on which you sought election. May I remind them that the Leader of their own Party, the present Minister for Industry and Commerce, gave this undertaking to his constituents:
"In view of the serious effect of increased taxation—"
this is a quotation from a circular letter sent out by Deputy Norton to his constituents—
"—on cigarettes, beer and spirits, which no doubt has had an injurious effect on your trade, I trust you will find it possible to give me your No. 1 vote in the forthcoming election and kindly ask your relatives and friends to do likewise, so that with the aid of the Labour Party—"
Deputy O'Leary need have no doubt as to which Labour Party he was referring to. "With the aid of the Labour Party" and of Deputy Desmond—that is not in it: that is my interpolation—
"—I may advocate in the new Dáil a reduction of the taxes which so adversely affect your business and consumers generally."
Is there one of them going to stand up here now on this occasion and advocate a reduction of the taxes on those specific items?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy stand up and say here: "I think they should be taken off"? He will not.
Comment on this
Will the Minister for Finance endorse that expectation of Deputy Dunne's ?
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Dunne will tell us. Deputy Dunne said in the course of his election campaign: "They will be taken off immediately." In fact, he said they would get an assurance from the Government before they joined it that those taxes were coming off. Is that not so?
Comment on this
That is what the reports in the newspapers said.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy repudiating the accuracy of the Press report?
Comment on this
I would advise the Deputy to examine it very carefully and to let us know whether he repudiates it or not.
Comment on this
This is what has been proved—it is in the Meath Chronicle of the 14th May, where the Deputy is reported as speaking in the Market Square at Navan. Is not that specific enough? He will find the words I quoted in that report. If he was inaccurately reported, if those are not the words he used, there is a duty on him to go back to the Market Square in Navan and tell the people who were listening to him that he did not mean that and gave no such promise.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy go back to the Market Square in Ballina and tell the people about the biscuit factory?
Comment on this
I did so. May I again say a word to the Deputy on that? The Deputy implied that I did something harmful to Ballina in trying to get a factory there. I did my best, but there were circumstances which defeated that effort. They were fully explained by the solicitor to the company—who was, I think, the Fine Gael election agent in that constituency—and they were published in the local Press.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy before and I tell him again that when I left office on the 2nd June that project was very much alive. There is one thing now that can kill it again and that is the Deputy making it a matter of political controversy. If the Deputy is interested in having that factory established, he will shut up on that subject. If he wishes to find out whether that is true or not, he can do so by having a word with the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment is to give Deputies an opportunity of fulfilling their election promises to reduce the taxes on tobacco and cigarettes. That is why it is here. When Deputies vote on this amendment they will be voting to fulfil those pledges or voting to repudiate them. There can be no question whatever but that a specific undertaking was given by every one of them that those taxes would be reduced and reduced immediately. That is what the public understood when they voted for them. Were the public so completely wrong as Deputies now suggest? I do not believe that it is possible to get 75 or 76 Deputies in this House of different Parties all of whom are prepared cynically to repudiate their election pledges at the first opportunity they have of giving effect to them in the way suggested here yesterday. Surely there is one honest man amongst them who will take this opportunity of voting to do the things he undertook to his electors he would do.
Comment on this
The only honest man in Irish politics, according to the Irish Times, is sitting behind you.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister for Finance if it is not a fact that when the Budget was introduced— from which Budget this Finance Bill is a natural consequence—they did not then vote against that Budget because of the very objections they had to it as stated by them during the election campaign? Will the Minister for Finance now tell us the reasons which prompted Fine Gael and the Labour Party to vote against the Budget? If my recollection is correct, during the discussion on the Budget all the arguments were put forward which were subsequently used in the election campaign. If it is not fair for us to say that the public were misled by the statements made by the candidates who now form the coalition groups and that the public were not entitled to imply from all the leaflets and speeches that Fine Gael, Labour, and so forth were against our Budget because of these particular taxes, would they now say what reasons prompted them—all of them—to vote against the Budget and now to change round and vote for the Finance Bill that enforces all the items of the Budget?
The Minister for Finance says that you cannot have it both ways. If anybody wants to have it both ways, I think it is the Minister for Finance. He wants to suggest that he was correct when he opposed the Budget and voted against it, and he wants to suggest that he is correct now in voting for the Budget proposals by opposing these amendments.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy mind quoting the appropriate Dáil Debate in which I so voted, as he suggested?
Comment on this
There was no vote on the Budget. The Deputy should try to be more accurate in his statements.
Comment on this
I asked a question: I did not make a statement. My recollection is that Fine Gael in particular and also the Labour Party were opposed to the Budget and they were opposed to the Budget on the grounds that it contains taxation levels which they said were too high. It contains excise duties on beer, spirits and tobacco which they said were too high. Either they were correct when they had that view then or they are correct now in their view that the levels of taxation are not too high.
Throughout this discussion, Deputy Lemass has sought to make it clear that when Fianna Fáil introduced the Budget they introduced it with all these items which they considered necessary to meet the expenditure. The opposition to it was that they were not necessary. Now, we have those who opposed the view of Fianna Fáil, when Fianna Fáil were in Government, arguing in favour of the maintenance of the Budget as introduced and of its consequential taxes and excise levies. By taking the same steps to-day as they took yesterday and voting against these amendments, they will only be confirming to the public that there was no other course open to Fianna Fáil than the course which they took in the Budget which they introduced immediately before the election.
The purpose of having Fine Gael and Labour vote on these amendments is to have on record the fact that what they said before the election and throughout the course of the election campaign was nothing but nonsense, if it was not a deliberate attempt to mislead the public into believing that what they advocated could be accomplished. I cannot speak with any certain knowledge of the position outside Dublin City or outside the confines of my constituency but I believe that very many of the people who voted for Fine Gael and Labour in my constituency did so in the belief that they would get these reliefs—reliefs to the extent that these amendments try to bring about.
The leaflet that Fine Gael published with the pictures of the pint of stout, the lb. of tea, and so forth, and the two prices—the pre-1952 price and the price ruling at present—was for no purpose other than to make people believe that, by taking off these taxes and excise duties, these commodities would be brought back again to the 1951 price level.
Comment on this
The price that was implied by way of a picturesque promise was 2/10 a lb.—not 5d. off 4/2. However, the Coalition Government will probably have to think about butter again at a later date. I do not think it is in order for me to discuss butter now or to discuss the question of relief in respect of the price of butter.