We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1954—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 120–252 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1954
Enacted

No. 28 of 1954 ›

Deputy Seán Dunne is reported in the Meath Chronicle——

Comment on this

We heard that before.

Comment on this

He said that the prices of bread, butter, tea, sugar, cigarettes and the workers' pint would be reduced immediately. Have they done anything about that? We know too what the Labour programme was—immediate reduction in prices and taxation. We were going to have a Budget overnight and immediate reductions. They were to bring about an immediate reduction in all these things. They reduced the price of butter by 5d. per lb.; that is the only reduction they brought about, and it was brought about by borrowing. The prices of many commodities have increased since that time. What is the Government doing about them? All the Parties constituting the Government promised during the last general election that they would prevent the cost of living rising any higher. What are they doing about the present price of beef?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want butter reduced? Will the Deputy reduce the price of butter?

Comment on this

Will the Minister for Industry and Commerce, will Deputy Larkin or the Labour Party take any steps to prevent a rise in the price of meat? Meat is an essential commodity. Has anything been done about it?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy serious?

Comment on this

Has the Prices Advisory Body done anything about the rise in the price of meat?

Comment on this

What about your 17-point programme?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies should allow Deputy Allen to make his speech without interruption. The Parliamentary Secretary will have an opportunity of making a statement and so will his three colleagues sitting in front of him, if they so desire.

Comment on this

This Bill is the only programme before the people of Ireland and before Dáil Éireann to-day. That is the only programme of the Government in office, by the grace of God. That is the programme the Government must honour and that is the programme in relation to which it must keep its bond with the people.

Comment on this

Is it the one that is breaking your heart?

Comment on this

You are the man who was going to reduce taxation by £1,000,000.

Comment on this

And maintain the subsidies and keep down the cost of living.

Comment on this

He is the financial wizard in the Government.

Comment on this

Just like yourself, and I admit it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must insist that Deputy Allen be allowed to make his statement without interruption. Every Deputy will have the same opportunity if he so desires. Deputy Allen on the Supplies and Services Bill.

Comment on this

And I would suggest that he would use the third person.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have already drawn his attention to that.

Comment on this

Interrupters should do the same.

Comment on this

Deputy Casey in the Cork Examiner on the 29th April, 1954, stated:—

"The first point in the Labour Party programme is that the cost of living must be kept within the means of the ordinary people."

I am sure the ordinary people who support the Labour Party are well satisfied with present-day conditions, but Deputy James Larkin was not very satisfied here last week when, by innuendo and by threat, if you like, he told the Government what was coming to them if they did not reduce the cost of living: the Labour Party would neither associate with nor take part in any Government which would not take steps to make bread, butter, tea, sugar and other essential commodities again available to the people at prices which they could afford; the Labour Party was openly pledged to that policy. What have they done about it? They are an essential unit of the Government. Can they face the people to-day without hanging their heads in shame? The only result is that out of borrowed moneys they have reduced the price of butter by 5d. They were pledged to bring it down to 2/9. It is 3/8. When will they take steps to reduce it to 2/9?

The present Tánaiste and leader of the Labour Party is reported as saying:—

"Fianna Fáil Deputies by voting for the increased price of tea, sugar, bread and flour and for the higher taxes on cigarettes, beer and tobacco, have been active conspirators in the attack on the people's standard of living."

Active conspirators! The Tánaiste, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, has to-day in his hands the powerful weapon—the dangerous weapon, as it was called when Fianna Fáil was in power—of the Supplies and Services Bill. He is backed by all the machinery of State. What has he been doing about reducing the cost of living? My own county-man, the Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy Corish, is reported in the Independent of 30th April, 1954, as saying:—

"The first point in the election programme of the Labour Party was the reduction of food prices and the use of subsidies on essential articles of food to achieve that object. Labour was very definitely committed to this."

Deputy Oliver Flanagan, now Parliamentary Secretary, on the 24th April, 1954, just after the Budget, and not so very long ago——

Comment on this

A lot of things have happened since.

Comment on this

——is reported as stating: "I think the Budget is a disastrous insult to the people. The least that we expected would be the removal of the taxes on bread, flour, tea, sugar and butter." Deputy McGilligan, as reported in the Irish Press on the 22nd February last year, exactly 12 months ago, stated: “We say, as we did in 1947, that prices are too high and we still say that we can cut them down.” The present Minister for Agriculture, as reported in the Dundalk Democrat on 20th February, 1954, stated: “The policy of Fine Gael is to reduce the cost of living.” He said a few moments ago here that he promised nothing.

Deputy McGilligan was chosen by his Party during the election campaign to make a broadcast on behalf of his Party. Not very long before the general election he is reported in the daily Press on the 8th May, 1954, as saying: "When State expenditure has risen to its greatest heights there must be economies ready to hand for a Minister who is serious in his quest for them and who knows how to go after them." He added: "There was little doubt that savings in the hands of Government amounting to several millions a year could be secured without much effect. A distinct change of policy was required, however, and a new outlook on the part of Ministers was demanded if the reduction of £20,000,000 and upwards desirable in everybody's interests was to be achieved." A reduction of £20,000,000 was to be achieved if Deputy McGilligan had any connection with the present Government. He has a connection. I am sure he has a powerful influence over the Government.

I am sure the Minister for Lands will tell us whether the Government has succeeded in making even a part of this £20,000,000 reduction. We will be glad to hear from the Minister for Lands on that point. He is a member of the Government. I am sure he is a powerful and influential member and he will lend his hand as part of the Government machine. The present Taoiseach had a scheme for further investment. As reported in the Irish Times on 26th May, 1954, he stated: “Fundamental changes in relation to finance and economic institutions are to be made. These to be evolved quietly and in co-ordination with the interests affected and based on the strict recognition of the importance of a sound currency.” And was the currency taken over by this Government sound currency?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Currency and financial policy do not arise upon this.

Comment on this

I want to suggest this, as a point of order, that the Supplies and Services Act at present in operation allows and gives them full authority and complete control over finance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not. The Supplies and Services Act does not give them power over currency.

Comment on this

With all respect, I say that this is a relevant matter, and money would be the service in this respect.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no use in quibbling about this matter. The exact wording of the measure is before the House.

Comment on this

I do not know what services we can have. Money would be one. However, we will get away from that.

Comment on this

The means to a service.

Comment on this

I take it that repatriation of external assets would be in order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

No.

Comment on this

The high rate of interest payable for any supplies or services?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

No. It is financial policy, and does not arise on this.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Government dealt with it at some length.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has done that before.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy proposes to deal with the points made by the Parliamentary Secretary I will allow that.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary talked about inflation across the water, about the danger of greater inflation to our economy, arising out of that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy proposes to reply to that I will allow him to do so.

Comment on this

I feel it is in order dealing with money matters, inflation, the Central Bank, and all these things.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Central Bank does not arise on this.

Comment on this

It was dealt with this evening, with all due respect. However, I do not propose to dwell much longer on this matter. Twelve months ago, the present Tánaiste who introduced this Bill to the House a few days ago, filled many columns of the debate on the Supplies and Services Act. He charged the Government at that time, the Fianna Fáil Government, with neglecting to use machinery of that Supplies and Services Bill that the then Deputy Lemass had in his hands. He said that Deputy Lemass allowed the prices of goods and services to increase without using that machinery. I want to put the question to the Tánaiste what he has been doing during the past seven months, with the adequate machinery he had, to prevent a rise in the cost of living? Has he been doing anything to prevent the prices of essential commodities from increasing? Has he succeeded with that machinery as he described it: "very dangerous and very adequate machinery" which has been in his hands for the past seven months? What has he been doing about it? Has he succeeded in any way in bringing down the cost of living? No. All this talk which went on during the last election campaign may be all hypocrisy. The Deputies beyond are admitting it now because of their inaction and because——

Comment on this

Rubbish!

Comment on this

——of the fact that they have done nothing about it. The machinery of State, all the powers required to do something about it, were in their hands. They have been unable to prevent the cost of living increasing. We are not charging them as they charged us when we were the Government. It is quite possible—we admit it—that many commodities will increase in spite of what any Government can do. That will never be admitted by any Party forming the Government, or was not admitted when they were in opposition. The dishonest campaign which fooled the people of this country, and which continued month after month preceding the last election, was something, I think, for which each group and each member of that Government should be on their knees apologising to the ordinary rank-and-file, to the decent, honest, hard-working people who live down in the backwoods and byways of this country.

They were fooled by the concentrated effort of three or four groups filling them with false promises, promises which they knew could not be kept. Each and every Party, all the leaders of the Government, all the back benchers, knew that quite well. They knew they could do nothing about it, and deceived the people for the purpose of getting into office. It is up to the Government to honour the promises they made, to deliver the goods they promised, to reduce the price of sugar, bread and butter, and all the essential commodities, to reduce the price of the poor man's pint about which we have heard so much, to reduce the old age pensioners' bit of tobacco, as it was described here. The responsibility is now on the shoulders of the Fine Gael Party, the Labour Party and all the other satellite Parties supporting the Government. It is now up to this Government to take this matter seriously. Each Party should get up and apologise to the ordinary common people, or they should honour their pledges solemnly given to the people in the last election.

Comment on this

I had hoped when making my maiden speech on this Bill to be able to make a reasoned and possibly constructive contribution. I have been so incensed by the utter nonsense and poppycock which has come from the opposite benches that I can only hope I shall not be too much diverted from the points I wish to make. At the outset let me tell the Deputy that far from apologising to the people for failure to keep our promises, we are very satisfied on this side of the House that the people are getting good government, and will continue to get good government for the next five years. Furthermore, as a member of the Labour Party I would not, and will not, withdraw one single promise made by me to the people in regard to the cost of living or price reductions. I hope and feel that I will never have to go back on the promises then made.

Deputy Colley seemingly kept reminding the Labour Party of its attitude towards subsidies in 1947. Other Deputies reminded us that we made promises, and that we took too much credit for the reductions which took place regarding the price of butter and the Standstill Order on tea. They have said we made promises to bring down the cost of living. They read out a list of commodities, including cocoa, sugar, sweets. Deputy O'Malley, who referred to these commodities, did not specify the amount by which they were increased but most Deputies will agree that I am very well aware of any increase that takes place in consumer goods and that I keep a very vigilant eye on prices. If I appear to be a little impatient because the Government is making haste slowly, I am satisfied that an honest endeavour is being made, not only to maintain prices at the present level but to bring them down and I am confident that they will come down in the very near future.

We have been told that we misled people by our promises, that we knew we could not keep those promises. I would remind Fianna Fáil of the 15th point in the 17 points programme of 1951. That programme was signed by Eamon de Valera. It was to maintain subsidies and reduce the cost of living.

At columns 89 and 90 of the Official Report, Volume 128, Deputy Lemass, in reply to a question addressed to him by Deputy Declan Costello, gave particulars in relation to increases in prices that had taken place since 13th June, 1951. Deputy Costello had asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce if he would state in relation to each of the following commodities: butter, milk, cheese, flakemeal, peas, beans, soap, paraffin oil, beef and mutton, and so on, the increases in prices that had taken place since the 13th June, 1951; whether or not such increases were recommended by the Prices Advisory Body; whether or not the Prices Advisory Body held public meetings in respect of the applications for such increases.

From the 21st June, 1951, up to and including 1st November, the following increases took place: butter went up 2d. per lb. No public inquiry was held. It was not submitted by the Government to the Prices Advisory Body. Milk increased by from 1/4d. to 3/4d. per pint in various districts. There was a public inquiry before the Prices Advisory Body. On the 22nd August the price of cheese was increased by 4d. per lb. in the case of Cheddar, 5d. in the case of block cheese and 7d. in the case of cheese sold in portions. There was no public inquiry by the Prices Advisory Body. The price of peas and beans increased by 1½d. per 12-oz. packet of peas and at the rate of 2d. per lb. in the case of canned peas and beans, on the 28th June, 1951. There was no public inquiry by the Prices Advisory Body. In the case of paraffin oil, there was an increase in price of 1½d. per gallon on the 19th July, 1951. There was no public inquiry by the Prices Advisory Body. The price of cocoa was increased by 2½d. per quarter lb. The date of the increase is not given but the application was made on the 21st June, 1951, and there was no public inquiry by the Prices Advisory Body. The price of ale increased by 1d. per pint draught and 1/2d. per half-pint in bottle, on the 24th July, 1951. There was no public inquiry by the Prices Advisory Body.

On the 7th July, 1951, sewing thread went up by from 2d to 2½d. per reel of 100 yards. There was no public inquiry by the Prices Advisory Body. Cigarettes went up by 1/2d. per packet of ten on the 19th October, 1951. There was no public inquiry by the Prices Advisory Body. Petrol increased by 1/2d. per gallon from 27th July, 1951, and by 1½d. per gallon from 29th October, 1951. There was no public inquiry. Sweets and chocolates increased on various dates without any public inquiry. Timber increased on the 1st November, 1951. In the case of imported red wood there were increases ranging from £11 15s. to £19 15s. per standard of 270 cubic feet; in the case of pitch pine, an increase of 4/2 per cubic foot and, in the case of Douglas fir, 3/8 per cubic foot. On the 1st January, 1952, or the 2nd January, peas were again increased and beans by 2½d. a packet.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be good enough to give us the information in connection with the beef and mutton?

Comment on this

I am just giving the reply Mr. Lemass gave. It is not given in this. I am trying to point out that, while Fianna Fáil, with their tongues in their cheeks, are trying to give the impression that this Government is keeping none of its election promises with regard to prices, they themselves got into power on a similar promise and made even less attempt. Since the Government took office where increases have taken place in prices there have been public inquiries held before the Prices Advisory Body, and the consumers were given an opportunity, in a limited way, to make a case for and against and to listen to the reasons given.

While I agree that the Prices Advisory Body is not all that the consumers would like it to be, I still say that, far from using it as a screen, the Minister is making good use of it and is giving it more work to do than it got since the inter-Party Government went out of office. There was not a single public inquiry held by the Prices Advisory Body in the whole of 1953. For one whole year Mr. Lemass stifled that body and gave it no function. It was not for want of getting applications from consumers. If Deputy Lemass examines the files he will find from the Lower Prices Body and the Housewives' Association numerous applications for investigations into increases and demands for reductions.

I suggest that the Minister should consider widening the powers of that body. With Deputy Larkin, I would ask him to ensure that adequate representation is given to the consumers. The members of the two bodies that would be likely to attend the inquiries on behalf of the consumers are not skilled and efficient and expert in economics and have not access to the information which we would like to have in order to help us to break down the costings and the information given by the various manufacturers and distributors seeking increases. We find even the Department of Industry and Commerce reluctant to give us information which might help us to make a case for the consumers. Therefore, I would ask the Minister to consider widening the powers of the body, if necessary, and increasing the personnel.

I would suggest that an intensive and rigid examination of distributing costs be carried out in an attempt to cut out unnecessary and wasteful handling and to eliminate many unnecessary distribution costs. Furthermore, I would like the Minister to consider seriously the establishment of a bureau which would give the consumer protection from inferior quality goods, apart from protection from high prices. I would draw his attention to the fact that when food packing firms in this country are exporting to Great Britain they must maintain a certain standard of quality. If, for example, stewed steak is being exported from this country to Britain it must contain a certain specified amount of beef, vegetable and fluid. If it falls below the specifications it is not allowed into Great Britain. These tins come off the belt in the factory in hundreds and, if a tin falls short of specification, it is not destroyed but is sold to the Dublin, Midland or Cork consumer. The extraordinary thing is that it is our Department of Agriculture that passes the tinned food for Great Britain. In other words, the Irish consumers are paying our Government to protect the British housewife while no one protects us. There should be a bureau of standards or some section of the Department of Industry and Commerce to see that, apart from price, we get value for what we pay.

I would also like to refer to the inspectorial system in the Prices Section. I noticed that a certain firm of food packers who are protected by Government Order twice got an increase in the last three years in the price of a certain commodity on the basis that they were packing an article in 12-oz. and 6-oz. packets. I now discover that the 12-oz. packets have disappeared in so far as the gross weight size is set out on the outside as 10-ozs., while the packet is the same. The Minister will have inspectors going down to Moore Street and prosecuting a dealer down there because her ounce weight is a shade light, but we have nobody going around to make sure that goods which are protected by proprietary names are in fact up to quality, standard and weight. I should like to know if the Department has ever tried to ensure that consumers are protected in the matter of getting full weight in the case of firms in this country with counterparts in Britain which pack soap flakes, soap powders, corn flakes and so on. In Great Britain, a 6-oz. packet of Persil must contain 6 ozs.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy now going into the administration of the Department?

Comment on this

Well, yes; maybe you could put it that way.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy seems to be dealing with the administration of the Department which would come up for discussion more relevantly on the Estimate.

Comment on this

I am trying to work it in on the basis——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I noticed that.

Comment on this

——that the scope of the Bill is wide and that it deals mainly with prices. I feel that it is up to each one of us on all sides of the House to ensure that the consumer gets not only her goods at the proper price but gets quality goods and the quantity she asks for. If I have gone beyond the confines of the debate, I apologise.

Again, I will take a chance on this. I should like to suggest as a further measure towards the protection of the consumer a little more co-ordination between the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Agriculture. There is too much passing of the buck between one and the other. If we raise a question about the price of an agricultural commodity, Industry and Commerce say that is not their function, that it is a matter for Agriculture, and Agriculture say: "We are only concerned with producers' prices. The consumer is a matter for Industry and Commerce," and between the two we find that the producer is not getting a fair price for his goods, while the consumer is paying more than too much. I think a little co-ordination there would bring about some sort of cohesion and eliminate unnecessary profiteering between the two, producer and consumer.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

In what specific goods would the Deputy say there is an excess price from profiteering?

Comment on this

It is not customary to interrupt a Deputy in his or her maiden speech.

Comment on this

I am speaking generally. Take eggs as an example.

Comment on this

And Deputy de Valera is long enough in the House to know that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not customary to interrupt at all—or at least it is not orderly. Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll is in possession.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am sorry.

Comment on this

To clarify what I mean for Deputy de Valera, who is a colleague of mine and who, I am sure, is as sincere about this as I am, in relation to consumer goods produced in this country from the farm—eggs, bacon, vegetables and so on—there is no co-ordination at all between the two Departments, the one catering for the consumer and the one catering for the producer, and remember that they are two most important sections.

A lot has been said about our keeping the price of tea at a standstill and we were asked where is the money to come from to subsidise butter and we had talk about borrowing to pay for the food we eat. I should like to make a few suggestions as to where the money could come from and in this connection I wish that I were Minister for Finance. I believe that there are 12,000,000 acres of arable land in this country, excluding bog and forest land. A £2 tax on every acre would give £24,000,000.

Comment on this

The Minister for Lands is listening to you.

Comment on this

I think it is worth consideration. If you like, you can exclude small holdings, but you cannot get the farmers for income-tax and they are almost derated. A £2 tax on every arable acre would bring in a considerable sum. It would give us the money for the things we hope to do. I should like also to ask the Minister to consider seriously my suggestion of a purchase tax. If Britain can get £400,000,000 from purchase tax and £84,000,000 from cosmetics alone, surely there is some justification for such taxes here. I do not see why it cannot be done. We want money; we want better old age pensions, better blind pensions, better unemployment and sick benefit; and I think that in that way the least hardship would be imposed on anyone.

In conclusion, I want to say, as a Deputy who was elected mainly because the people in Dublin North Central believed I would continue to focus attention on price injustices, that I am quite satisfied that, when this side of the House goes back to the people at the end of our five years in office, they will say: "Well done, thou good and faithful servants. Go back and finish the job you started so well".

Comment on this

I have been very interested in listening to as much of this debate as I could and in reading the many speeches made on the last occasion this Bill was before the House. I am interested also in many of the suggestions put forward in lieu of a defence. I think the last suggestion made by Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll to impose a tax of £2 on every acre of land will cause much more consternation than the suggested tax by somebody else of £1 per bullock exported. I can understand certain Deputies making statements which, if they were correct, would mean that something could be done, but it is easy to make the suggestion that we must cut out distribution costs between producer and consumer. When you examine that, you find that you have to cause unemployment by throwing out of employment those engaged in the distribution of the very goods produced by the one and consumed by the other. It just cannot be done. If we break the figures down, we find that distribution costs include railway freights.

The upkeep of our railways is based mainly on the distribution of our goods. We cannot distribute them without that cost and without intermediate labour costs.

When I hear people talking about profiteering and about margins of profit, I often wonder why they do not break down the costs of goods as they are sold and find out the percentage cost of raw material and of labour and find out to what extent these are costs on the back of the consumer, and also find out whether, if even the full profit margin were taken away, it would be possible to reduce the price of the article at all. I remember saying in this House that, relating the annual profit resulting from a turnover to the actual item consumed, if you attempted to reduce the price of the article by its fraction cost of profit, it could not be reduced at all. I agree that you can sometimes control costs of raw materials, if you are producing them entirely, because you can lay down maximum prices and a person can produce them or not as he wishes.

I was rather sorry to hear Deputy J. Larkin directing his fire mainly against Deputy Lemass. Speaking here last week, he said that no legislation to control prices by Deputy Lemass could be accepted by Labour. I think that Deputy Larkin in years gone by admitted that if any one Minister for Industry and Commerce did a certain amount of good for the working people it was Deputy Lemass, through the legislation passed under his administration by the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

Not on price control.

Comment on this

I say that Deputy Larkin's speech contains many swipes at Deputy Lemass and it was a statement of non-confidence in Deputy Lemass, whether in relation to protection of the people regarding the cost of living or whether it was something else. I do not know what he meant, that Labour would not accept any price legislation that might be introduced by Deputy Lemass.

I do not know why the members speaking for the inter-Party Government or the Coalition are taking the line they are taking. The line taken on this side of the House is not a criticism of the Government for not being able to lower prices or, in some cases, not being able to stop them rising. The criticism of all Parties on the other side—and Deputy Larkin admitted it—is that the public were entitled to conclude that commitments had been made in the direction of promises to reduce the cost of living. The criticism from this side of the House is just to bring to the mind of those of all Parties that they misled the voters and deliberately misled them, by their statements in the last election, into believing that prices were unnecessarily high and that corrective measures could be brought about to reduce those prices and that that would be done.

I emphasise this: we are the first to admit that the present Minister for Industry and Commerce is confronted from hour to hour with changing circumstances and changing conditions, resulting in changing prices, all of which arise from matters beyond his control and that all he can try to do is to safeguard the general interest of the public by seeing how he can help the people who suffer by those changes. I am not suggesting that the Minister can to-day, under present circumstances, do anything about an immediate correction of the sudden high increase in the price of meat. It is a matter that will need general Government discussion. There is a danger that our country could be denuded of cattle by the attractive high prices there are to-day to export our cattle, apart from the fact that it is impossible to segregate meat consumed here as distinct from meat that goes abroad. It is a problem that the Minister has to face.

The Minister for Agriculture was talking about tea to-night. I do not know if any of those who have spoken have gone back to last year to read what Deputy Dillon said on tea. He challenged the then Minister for Industry and Commerce, on the Supplies and Services debate, to abandon the method by which tea was being bought for the people of this country, and he said—and he was talking from his own knowledge and experience as one who had bought and sold tea—that if it were freed it would fall by from 6d. to 1/- per lb., that it was only as a result of peevishness by Deputy Lemass, who was then Minister, against the Mincing Lane dealers—because they let us down in the war years by withholding supplies —that he was, for that reason as one of the reasons, keeping this tea importing concern alive and the second reason was to enable them to profiteer at the expense of the public. What would have happened if Deputy Lemass as Minister for Industry and Commerce had believed anything other than what he said then, that Deputy Dillon was talking utter nonsense. The price of tea to-day would have been up as high probably as 8/- a lb.

We are not finding fault with the Minister for Industry and Commerce because tea has risen. It is not his fault. We do not grow it here and we are at the mercy of the tea suppliers. But when Deputy Dillon, the Minister for Agriculture, was talking about tea to-night he started to quote the Prime Minister of Ceylon. Now, the tea situation of the world to-day, as explained by the Prime Minister of Ceylon, goes a long way further than what the Minister for Agriculture said. It is clear to me what the Prime Minister said. He said, first of all, that Malaya as a tea-producing area ceased to be an exporting country in tea because of the war situation there. India, as a tea-producing and tea-exporting country, has found now that, due to her own increased standard of living, tea is consumed among her own people to a greater extent and at higher prices at home. Then he also pointed out that the Government of Ceylon had engaged in a great deal of propaganda to try to increase the consumption of tea in the world, that that has had more success than was anticipated and that it, together with the other situations, has resulted in the simple issue—that the Minister must admit is the situation—that you have a greater demand than there is a supply and the buyers who buy the teas abroad buy them at auctions in a free market and everywhere except here tea is a free commodity. The result is that our buyers have to compete with the buyers who can get better prices abroad, and we have the situation now—not as anticipated and as prophesied by the Minister for Agriculture that if tea were let loose here free it would drop— that tea has increased in price, and anything about its reduction is only a pious hope and that it is also very improbable that anybody can say when the price is going to fall.

The Minister for Agriculture asked, first of all, what would we have done under the circumstances if we were over there and had we a better suggestion to make than what they believe the situation to be, that if the Government allows the cost to remain as it is to the consumer, by postponing, either by subsidy or otherwise, any difference between what it is sold at and its cost, you may be able to hold the loss over until tea comes down so low that at the present price it would be sold actually at a profit and then the matter could balance itself out. Now, I do not think the present Minister for Industry and Commerce is prepared to say that is the solution, that he would even hazard a guess here as to when the prices of tea will fall to a low level and as to how low they will fall. I think it is impossible to say.

The fact is that the price of tea was one of the items that was referred to in the general election as being too high so far as the consumer was concerned. That was the comparison that was made with the 1951 price. The implication was that the price of tea would be brought down to the 1951 price. Personally, I am not making argument to-night as to what was the best way to do it. What I do say is that the Government, if they wanted to implement the promises which were implied in their speeches, should have brought tea down to the 1951 price, whatever method they adopted. Even the present method might have been adopted, but they are not going to get out of it by saying that the price of tea has gone out of their control to a new high level and that they are protecting the consumer at present, and up to September, from the impact of this high price. What I say is that, whether it went high or not, there was a method which they could have adopted to reduce the price of tea to the 1951 level.

I listened to Labour Deputies addressing public meetings during the election. I listened attentively to them, and I heard speeches of this type being made: "Are you going to allow the Fianna Fáil Government, because they allow these goods to be at these prices, to continue to have you living in starvation and in utter misery," as if at that particular time the working-class people were getting no tea, bread or sugar or getting them in such meagre proportions that it was impossible to live on them? I knew, of course, that that was nonsense. A lot of people thought, even those who had adequate supplies and a reasonable standard of living, that if prices were reduced they certainly would have a better standard of living, and that the saving on the cost of those items could be used for something other than food.

A lot of fuss has been made about the 5d. that has been taken off the lb. of butter. According to statistics, 40 lb. of butter are consumed per person annually in this country. That means that if everybody consumes the amount of butter which the statistics show is the average, there is a saving of 4d. per person per week. I know that the working-classes use very little butter. They have a certain amount of butter and add to it by using margarine. If the argument is that butter was too dear at 4/2 per lb., it is also too dear at 3/9. There is no great saving. If there was going to be some saving, the amount of money involved by reducing the price of butter by 5d. per lb. could have been applied to something else. When Fianna Fáil brought about a reduction of a halfpenny in the price of the loaf, there was a great deal of jeering and gibing. I see that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government is nodding his head. I will give him a present of this: that a reduction of another halfpenny in the price of the loaf would have been of greater value and would have been a greater saving in the average working man's home than the 5d. off the lb. of butter.

Comment on this

The voter did not think that.

Comment on this

He did not vote purely on the basis of getting 5d. off the lb. of butter, but on the basis of getting all prices down to the 1951 level. When the Parliamentary Secretary goes forward at an election again, whether it be immediately before or after the Budget or in five years' time, he will find that what I am telling him will happen.

Comment on this

You will not have promises thrown back in your face?

Comment on this

I made no promises. The promises were all made by you people. I tried, when addressing audiences, to warn them not to believe that these things were going to happen.

Comment on this

In 1951?

Comment on this

I am talking of 1954. Again, in 1951, I made no promises. Whenever I addressed a meeting, I dealt with the policy of the Party that I belong to, and I warned the people in 1954 not to believe these things— not to make the election an issue of bread and butter when the result was not going to be bread and butter. I appealed to them to think, but they believed what they were told and got a reduction in the price of butter.

If the Tánaiste were to get information from his Department as to the average number of loaves consumed in the households of the working classes, I suggest that he would find that another halfpenny off the loaf would mean far more in the way of a net saving than the 5d. per lb. off the butter which is consumed in these households. Butter is consumed in very small quantities in the households of the large working-class families.

Comment on this

It is costing twice as much to reduce the price of butter by 5d. per lb. as it would to reduce the price of the loaf by a halfpenny.

Comment on this

It does not matter to me what it costs, but it makes the case worse for the Tánaiste if it costs twice as much to take 5d. off butter as it would to take a halfpenny off the loaf. It makes my argument. What I am saying is that if a penny could be taken off the loaf at the same cost to the State, it would be of real benefit to the working man who is rearing a large young family.

Comment on this

But then he would have no butter for the bread.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste knows much better than I do, and I give him credit for knowing it, that in the working man's house of the type I am speaking of, in very many cases, if there is any butter used, it is a very small amount. The reason is that these people make the margarine go further because it is cheaper. From the point of view of nutriment and of nourishment, it is argued that there is very little difference, if any, between butter and margarine.

Comment on this

It spreads better.

Comment on this

Probably it does. I do not know. I am not an expert on spreading butter or margarine. The Coalition Government are trying to spread butter as far as it will go— further than it will go. The whole existence of the Coalition Government to-day depends on how far this butter story can be spread, but the ordinary man or woman knows that, where there are five or ten loaves going into a house to-day, a penny off the loaf would represent a saving of 8d. to 10d. a day.

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking of a 1d. off the loaf after putting 3d. on it.

Comment on this

It is no defence for the Coalition Government to say: "You did something other than we did." That is no defence for your own wrongdoing. It reminds me of a story I heard many years ago of two mothers who were bemoaning the fate of their two sons who had been locked up for battering two different individuals. One mother said: "Ah! your son got what he deserved; he did the thing very roughly; he beat the man up this way, but my son was a gentleman; he slugged him from behind and the fellow never knew what happened to him." That is the kind of defence that is being put to me now.

Comment on this

You have missed the point.

Comment on this

The public have not missed the point and that is what I want to reiterate.

Comment on this

You have not the majority:

Comment on this

I agree we lost the majority because they were sold a pup.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Interruptions must cease. Deputy Briscoe should be allowed to make his speech without interruptions.

Comment on this

From my knowledge of the City of Dublin, if the people had an opportunity to-day we should see where the majority would go because the people are disappointed. They were led to believe the pint was to be reduced; sugar was to be reduced and that tea was to be reduced. The price of meat was too high. Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll did not point out the increase in the price of meat during the years from 1951 to 1954 and compare it with the increase in the price of meat from 1954 to 1955. It was a considerably bigger jump.

I want to repeat that I am not criticising the Government for things that are happening because I know they are beyond their control. What I do criticise them for is that they are still trying to point out that they are living in the atmosphere of the last election and, as the speakers in the Labour Party say, the Government are hastening slowly and implementing and keeping their promises. We do not know what is going to happen in the world around us. Therefore, we can only make provision to be sure that we secure for our people the absolute essentials. Talking about threatened inflation will not help the situation.

Am I wrong in pointing out that the bad harvest and the bad weather have brought about a scarcity in potatoes and that potatoes at this time of the year are twice as dear as they were this time last year? Is the Government to be blamed for that? Could I not get out and say on the hustings that, when we were in Government, potatoes were £9 per ton and that now they are £18, and blame the Government? Obviously, circumstances beyond the control of the weather brought that about. I would have to make some other approach in order to see that people would get enough potatoes at some kind of a reasonable price if the situation worsens or gets out of hands.

I would like to ask the Tánaiste to say frankly to the House whether he is now not satisfied that the method introduced by his predecessor with regard to the acquisition and maintenance of stocks of tea is a good one, and that particularly under present circumstances it is a good thing it existed and proved helpful to him to cope with a situation which would have got out of hands obviously if that method of bringing in tea and distributing it was not available? I would like the Tánaiste to be prepared at least to say that is so.

Comment on this

His predecessor was going to abolish that system.

Comment on this

His predecessor was not going to abolish any system which would make us depend on Mincing Lane, and Deputy Larkin knows that.

Comment on this

What about the monopoly?

Comment on this

I will ask the Tánaiste why he is maintaining this monopoly. If it is a monopoly why is it being maintained?

Comment on this

Are we not going to end bulk buying?

Comment on this

Who is going to end it?

Comment on this

The Tánaiste's predecessor.

Comment on this

He did not do it. First of all, we are accused of things we did but now we are going to be accused of things we might have done but did not do.

Comment on this

Did you not decide to do it?

Comment on this

We decided that the tea would come in from the countries where it was produced and that if and when the situation became normal it could go back again to freedom of buying. Deputy Lemass referred to the matter here and I might as well quote since the question was raised. At column 1675, Volume 142 of the Official Debates, the Minister for Agriculture —he was then Deputy Dillon—said:—

"Mr. Dillon: Let the Minister take off control for a month and we will give him a demonstration that will take the breath out of him.

Mr. Lemass: Every tea merchant knows that you are talking nonsense.

Mr. Dillon: Take the control off for one month—there is no difficulty about taking it off for a month or two months and putting it back again, if the event does not transpire as I declare it will—and the price of tea can be reduced by at least 6d. per lb. My constructive proposal is: Take it off altogether. Why have we got it on? Why are the people of this country being constrained to pay 6d. a lb. more than they ought to pay for it? I will tell you, because I happen to know. A certain small group of tea wholesalers in this country came to know that the Minister had a bee in his bonnet and that that bee was that at the beginning of the European war, supplies of tea from London were suspended. The Minister's quarrel, however, is with the then British Government, which has long ceased to exist, and the existing British Government dislikes it more than the Minister dislikes either of them. He is quite resolved that he is going to carry on that quarrel, not with the British Government but with the wholesalers of tea in the City of London. They never wanted to cut off supplies of tea from Ireland. The more tea they sell, the more money they make.

Mr. Lemass: The Deputy does not know what he is talking about.

Mr. Dillon: Oh, go fish. I was selling tea when you were cutting calico down in Capel Street.

Mr. Lemass: I know who stopped our tea during the war.

Mr. Dillon: The British Government.

Mr. Lemass: The British wholesalers.

Mr. Dillon: Oh, go fish. Why should a wholesaler refuse to supply his customers? The British wholesalers did not rise up to wrap the green flag round them and then proceed to cut off their noses to spite their faces by refusing to supply tea to their customers. They would sell tea to Johnny Dog if they were paid, but they were told by the British Government not to sell any more tea to Ireland because the British Government wanted to keep all the tea for their own people."

I will not read out all this business about tea, but Deputy Dillon's information about the sources of supply of tea, in spite of his protestations of a lifelong knowledge of the tea trade, is fantastic. I would recommend Deputies to read the verbatim report. I am trying to approach this matter from the point of view of how it has affected those people who took the majority from us and transferred it to the inter-Party Coalition Government. They believed that prices would be reduced. I believe that some of the Labour spokesmen believed it could be done. I believe the Tánaiste, as Deputy Norton, also believed that if he got control of the Department of Industry and Commerce he might be able to devise ways and means through control and examination that would assure some benefit to the people. I am satisfied now that the Tánaiste is up against a very tough situation—a situation he just cannot cope with. There will have to be some other approach.

Deputy Larkin, when speaking, showed that he is pulling himself out from the situation of live on and hope. He says—and I can understand his point of view—that certain commitments were made. It is impossible to carry out most of those commitments. What he is concerned with is to see a continued improvement in the standard of the people he represents. Therefore, he does not believe any more that this Prices Commission are going to produce any results. Did the Deputy not say that he was going to support a new series of wage increases? Does the Deputy want me to quote him?

I will come back to that matter in a moment. I understood the position to be, that the only way to deal with the matter was by way of an increase in prices and from the manner in which the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government spoke about inflation that is obviously what he had in mind. What I am concerned about is—take, for instance, the question of the rent charge in the cost of living. There was a lively and active discussion to-day on the pros and cons and the method of operating the system of differential rents for tenants of local authority houses. Rent is a very severe item in the cost of living of the working classes. Rents are based on the costs of production of houses, the cost of acquisition of land, and labour content is a very high content in the building of houses: so is material, and also the acquisition cost of land to build the houses on. The higher the wage goes, the higher the materials go, the higher the cost of the houses, and obviously, so consequently the higher is the cost of the rent.

What are you going to do about it? If wages go still higher—and particularly during the next five or ten years when the housing programme will still remain at its present high level of drive—there will be again an increase in the rentals of these houses. The local authority is not in business for profit; the State gives generous subsidies towards the cost of houses and generous subsidies towards the cost of borrowing money for the building of these houses, although it is only on a percentage basis or on limited figures, but this is what causes the fluctuations. I said before—I am sure the Minister has made a study of specially selected industries engaged in the production of goods for, if you like, consumption by the public—and he can see himself to what extent the margin of profit is the cause of the breaking of the backs of the people from the point of view of high costs.

I think it was Deputy Larkin who also said—I made a note of it but I have not got the column here—that if we do not do something within three months there will be further serious increases. Deputy Larkin says at column 605 of Volume 148:—

"Some of us have the feeling that the index has not changed more than one or two points, that the situation is not serious and that, maybe, if we hold on for a couple of months more, the index will drop to the previous figure. My fear is that we are in a situation which, if we do not try to deal with it now, will develop in the next two or three months to a point where we shall not be able to stop a really significant increase in prices and the cost of living, because prices are like a snowball."

He mentions a few items—I am not going to blame the Tánaiste if that happens. I am not going to blame him if the first item which Deputy Larkin mentioned, coffee, goes up in price, but I would like him to consider whether it was fair, first of all, or whether it was wise, now that they have the Government in their hands to have accused us when these situations arose and when we were confronted with them.

Is it not better that there should be an acceptance of certain fundamental principles in matters of Government and that the people should not be misled? I am not going to throw bricks at the Minister if coffee goes up because he cannot help it. I am not even going to say what he should do about it so far as coffee consumers are concerned. That is his own and the Government's right—to make decisions. When the decisions are made I might criticise them or say whether I liked them or not, or whether I thought they could be improved on. But that is the Tánaiste's responsibility and he must now face the situation of an increase in prices of meat, and I am sure he must also concern himself as to whether, with present high prices now being obtained for live cattle, there is not in fact a danger that we will be denuding our stocks of breeding cattle and also making it possible for the future that not only will meat prices be high but that it will also be in short supply. Are any steps being taken?

I would like the Tánaiste to say so, if he will honour me by making a reference to anything I have said. Can he assure us that this particular aspect of what is becoming a problem is being kept in sight and that there is a realisation of possible danger there to our live-stock breeding, to our future prices and also to everything connected with the live-stock industry in this country? I think in this year 1955 it is futile to talk of a tendency in the world for a reduction in the prices of the main item that goes to make the cost of living—food. It is the desire of everybody here and abroad that the standard of living should be improved everywhere, and if that is the case there is no hope of us ever being able to get the natives of Malaya back to the position where they worked for 1/-or maybe 2/- a week and we were able to get their rice for about 1d. a lb., because they were not able to buy it. Rice is now used considerably in countries where it is grown and there is a standard of wages existing in those countries enabling the people to buy their own native foodstuffs. Consequently we have to pay the 9d. or 10d. a lb. that it costs here at present.

There is no hope for us in looking forward to a return of the situation where half the world in slavery will produce food to feed the other half that is keeping them in slavery. There is a tendency all round, as there is here, to have an improvement of conditions so that they will at least be above a certain minimum. The more you have consumed at home and abroad of your own products the higher will the prices go. That is what we have to face, and I agree with Deputy Larkin that is what we should keep our eyes on, that side by side with these situations arising, and an increased cost of living, we should assure our workers against their standard of living being affected, whatever means may be used, including increases in their wages. I have always held that view but I am amazed at Labour to-day trying to defend the situation that exists and hide it from themselves and from their supporters.

Comment on this

That is different from what you said in 1945.

Comment on this

What I said? Would the Deputy quote me? It is all very well to say: "This is what you said then and this is what you say now"— quote what I said. I like to be quoted. I have always stood for a certain side and Deputy Larkin knows it, and he should know that I would like to see him being more frank than he has been —and he was fairly frank. I said before I was going to quote Deputy Larkin because he challenged what I said from recollection as not being what he said himself. At column 617 of the same volume he says:

"I want to close on one note that I think is important. Quite clearly, it is not prices in themselves that create the problem: it is the relationship between prices and wages and salaries. From that point of view we should bear in mind again that, after all, the objective of our whole national economy, whether it be industrial or agricultural, is not just to produce goods; it is to provide a standard of living for our people and, we hope, a rising standard. Up to the moment the only way in which the people can measure that standard is by the relationship between prices and their income. It is for that reason that it is so important that the Government and the responsible Minister would pay particular attention to the situation that is developing. There is uneasiness, there is a growing fear that prices are starting now on an upward path and will get out of hand; and that, not through any lack of desire to try and tackle the problem of prices, but, if you like, through lack of knowledge, lack of competency or just ordinary practical difficulties, there is not going to be any effective control enforced against those rising prices.

I am particularly concerned with this problem because I have to look at it from the other angle; and already those who speak for the trade union movement are starting to speak out aloud. Already it has been stated quite openly that if the present situation is to continue, if the trade unionists—and the trade unionists are a very important body in this country; first of all, in the Twenty-Six Counties they represent some 300,000 workers and, with their families added, they represent a very considerable section of the whole population—if the trade unionists, who have on several occasions since the emergency tried to make their contribution to stability in prices, again find they are to be disappointed and that the commitments that we have made, members of Parties in this House, in respect of prices and price control will not or cannot be given effect to for any reason and that price stability is not going to be maintained, that prices are again starting to rise, then the trade unionists are starting to make it very clear that they are going to look after themselves because quite clearly nobody else will do it for them."

If that is not what I called it before, a fair summary from memory of what the Deputy said, I would like to know where I was wrong.

Comment on this

You should read what I said beforehand.

Comment on this

I said Deputy Larkin was pulling himself away from the commitments he made, that he believes now, whether it is through incompetency—I did not use that expression; that is the Deputy's own expression; and whether he means his own Tánaiste, or whether he means the Department or both combined or the Government, I do not know—or for whatever reason, that what was undertaken as commitments cannot be met. As I say, the Deputy was pulling himself away from the situation——

Comment on this

You cannot be pulling yourself away when you admit the commitments.

Comment on this

He is pulling himself away from those who are apologising for the delay in carrying into effect these promises and he is pulling himself away from those who say they never made such commitments. The Deputy is showing his hand, and I am not finding fault with him.

Comment on this

What are you doing?

Comment on this

I am just trying to expose the situation that is developing. There are some members in those benches who say they never made such promises, that the people were fools if they went away with any such idea of commitments. There are some amongst his own Labour Benches who spoke to-night and said: "We are going to carry out the promises. We are hastening slowly but we will bring things to the conclusion we promised and the people will say at the end of the five years: ‘Well done, you did what you undertook to do.'"Deputy Larkin is putting himself into a separate category: "I do not believe it can be done," he says, "but I do admit there were commitments made. I do not know why it cannot be done, but whatever takes place the standard of living of the people must be preserved."

Comment on this

What is wrong with his other argument?

Comment on this

I do not know why it is so hard for me to get people to understand. I am trying to point out that I am satisfied that the public believed in the 1954 election that they were being offered an opportunity to bring into being a Government that would remove the hardship that was wilfully imposed on them by the Fianna Fáil Government, giving them a chance to abolish all these hardships, ending unemployment, ending emigration, bringing down the price of commodities to the price that ruled in 1951. Now I say there are still members on those benches who say: "We never made any such promises. We never gave any such undertaking." There are some who say: "Yes, we did, and we are going to see that they are carried out. We have made a good start with butter and before the five years in office are over we will have accomplished the rest." Deputy Larkin says: "I am of the opinion that some commitments were made." He did not say he made them himself and I do not accuse him of that. Some commitments were made. People believed they were commitments but he is of the opinion that for whatever reason they are not likely to be, or they cannot be, carried out.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

I have read the report——

Comment on this

Did he not put it this way: if it is not possible to reduce prices, then in order to maintain the standard of living the people's income has got to be increased, the end really being to raise the standard of living of the people?

Comment on this

No, to keep it where it is.

Comment on this

No, we can do both.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It all depends on what you can do.

Comment on this

What is inconsistent in the argument?

Comment on this

I am trying to accuse as deliberately as I can the members of the various groups who make up the Coalition or inter-Party Government of deliberately or ignorantly misleading the public into believing that certain things could be done which cannot be done because they are beyond the control of the Government. I am not abusing the Government or accusing them of incompetency or anything else because they cannot do it. In fact, things are getting worse from that point of view and I am not blaming them for it. What I am trying to bring to their minds is that the people will not easily forget the pup they were sold in 1954. As Deputy Larkin says, there is grave uneasiness outside. What he calls uneasiness I called grumbling which is developing from disillusionment and disappointment.

We have been asked what about subsidies. There are still very substantial subsidies in operation and I do not know whether Deputy Larkin will support me in submitting a protest I want to make. There is now a tendency to transfer from State expenditure certain items of expenditure to the local authorities. This seems to be a new device. If that is the way taxation is to be cut it should never be cut.

Comment on this

The Health Act. That is yours.

Comment on this

No. The Deputy is not getting out of it that easily.

Comment on this

You were one of the supporters of the Health Act.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy not direct the Health Act.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputies may not draw the Health Act into this debate.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring not to do so. I should like to point out that persons in industrial employment have been having their cards stamped and their contributions go into the health services weekly. Prior to a couple of months ago their hospitalisation charges were paid by the Social Welfare Department. Now that expenditure has been transferred to the local authorities with, I agree, a 50 per cent. recoupment. But the State is holding on to their weekly contributions and on top of that, in order to reduce the commitment of the State on the deficient accounts of hospitals, the local authorities have been ordered now to pay a higher rate per week for patients in hospitals.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely that is not a matter which may be discussed under the Supplies and Services Bill.

Comment on this

I mentioned it with the proviso that I should bow to your ruling on its relevancy. All these are little things that are bound to show themselves later. The public will become educated.

Comment on this

But are you not father of the Health Act?

Comment on this

I am not its father or its mother.

Comment on this

And the Deputy is now running away from his child.

Comment on this

I admit to relationship.

Comment on this

And I think the Deputy is a rather uncomfortable relative.

Comment on this

I am far from being uncomfortable. I admit that I supported the Health Act.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputies must get back to the Supplies and Services Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy is now leaving his child before it is 12 months old.

Comment on this

It is not my child. I said I was not the parent—that I was not the father or the mother or the uncle or the aunt. And I am sorry the child was still-born.

Comment on this

Do not take too much pride in that since you are its father.

Comment on this

Indeed a certain child brought in in its place had a lot of its limbs missing. I referred already to subsidies and to the fact that Fianna Fáil, as a Government, introduced subsidies at a time when they thought it was the best way to try and keep things fairly balanced and if ever it happens, in spite of certain Ministers' references, that war does come again the Minister may find himself constrained to adopt some similar device in order to keep an even distribution. But do the Deputies who speak about subsidies even recall that side by side with subsidies there was rationing? I would not expect the Tánaiste to put a subsidy on tea to-day without at least having to ration it in whatever method he thought was sensible. If the subsidy were removed he would of course also remove rationing. The Labour Party were the greatest opponents of subsidies. They wanted no charity. They did not recognise at the time that there were scarcities of commodities and that it was these scarcities that caused this particular line of thought. We may be faced with a similar situation again sooner than we think. Of course I hope not, but remember next time we shall be talking with a certain amount of experience behind us; we shall not be wallowing in the dark without knowing from day to day what is going to happen.

I should like to point out that there is still a substantial subsidy in the matter of bread, flour, wheat, or in whatever from you like. There is a substantial subsidy and in fact some people think it is too high and that it should be cut. It will be interesting to know after this year's harvest what effect, whether derogatory or otherwise, the action of the present Government will have on farming. I notice too that the Labour Party are still trying to shake their flag of doubt about the industrialists. The Tánaiste now is in a position where he has an opportunity of seeing whether the native industries set up here in recent years have in fact brought about a good example of workmanship on the part of the operatives, whether they have grown up satisfactorily and whether they have become better and better as the years have gone by. The Tánaiste can now go around and see the industrial effort; he will be able to contribute to the starting of new industries; he will be able to see the costings of existing industries, whether or not he makes them public or not. I think he may even have that right. He can see whether the industrialists are managing their affairs prudently.

In industry, you cannot assume that you are going to have a certain exact output every day of every week and in every week of every year. Neither can you have exact costings. Your costings will not be the same for different periods. You must make provision for the ups and downs, for bad times, for losses you may suffer and for losses caused by a strike, for instance, during which you may not be able to ship your goods. But taking the overall picture, I do not think the Tánaiste could say deliberately to-day that our industrialists as a whole are profiteers, taking advantage of the tariffs situation or of any other circumstance or condition. I think he would be the first to admit this as a result of his personal contact and as a result of his visits. I am glad to see him going around to the other side and agreeing that our industrialists are making a big contribution to the creation of employment.

I think it can be deduced from Deputy Larkin's speech that you can control every private enterprise in the same way as a State or a semi-State undertaking—that you can limit its profits to certain maximum level. But as I said before, bring in any article you like and show me that, by taking away from the owner of the industry all the net profit that is left after the deduction of income tax, corporation profits tax and all other taxes, you are going to reduce the cost to the consumer and I should be very glad to see it.

Comment on this

Did I say that?

Comment on this

No. But the Deputy has talked about controlling the profits. Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll has also talked about it. Deputy Larkin also talked about the Prices Advisory Body. First of all he said that it was not functioning, that he did not think it was doing its job properly. What does that mean? It means that if they examine people's books and see that what I am saying is correct and that, therefore, they cannot reduce prices, the result to the Deputy and to some of his colleagues will be that because that is the case he and his colleagues are not doing their job properly. The Prices Advisory Body was not designed by Deputy Lemass. It was set up by the first inter-Party Government. The personnel was chosen; it was not changed by the subsequent Fianna Fáil Government. It is a good thing to have that body there. That body was not interfered with in any way. One could still go before them when the last Government was in office. Now we are told this body cannot do what Labour wants it to do and it is, therefore, no good.

Comment on this