Committee on Finance. - Vote 70—National Development Fund (Resumed).
Contributions 1–119 of 229. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I wish to criticise the administration of the National Development Fund since the change of Government, with special reference to a particular proposal which had been examined and approved by the Taoiseach. As the Minister himself explained, part of the money was set aside for projects for the well-being of the Gaeltacht. As the Act sets out, this National Development Fund is applicable only to works which could not in the ordinary process of things be dealt with before the year 1957. The experience has been, in relation to marine works, that the prospect of getting anything worthwhile done by any county council in any part of the country, not to speak of the poorer counties in the West, before 1957 was very thin indeed. The western councils have stated time and time again that their finances were unequal to the task of meeting the urgent problems of the west coast and particularly the west coast islands.
I think it was particularly shabby, as I said last night, that because of a slight error made by the technical officers in relation to a proposal for one of the Aran Islands, Inis Thiar, the sanction which had been given on the original report of those technical officers and which subsequently had to be withdrawn in favour of an alternative proposal——
Comment on this
The technical officers never approved the substitute proposal that the Deputy suggested.
Comment on this
There were three proposals for Inis Thiar. The three of them were submitted by myself, both as a Deputy and subsequently as a Parliamentary Secretary. One of them was for the improvement of the main landing place, the pier; another one was for the provision of a slip for currach fishermen; and the third one was for the improvement of a place on the eastern side of the island to facilitate the landing of turf in the summer weather, where about a quarter of the island's supply is landed when the weather is suitable. By some mischance, these technical officers reported on the wrong place. The report came in and was duly approved, because the Taoiseach could not be expected to know all the details of a proposal of this sort and he took it that the matter had been dealt with, that the people appointed and qualified for the purpose had done their job well; and without hesitation he sanctioned the expenditure of a sum of £8,000.
As I say, it was discovered a short time afterwards that the recommendation had been in respect of the wrong place. That mistake was corrected as quickly as possible, but the substitute proposal could not be approved by the Taoiseach, for the reason that in the meantime a general election had taken place and the Taoiseach felt that it would not be proper for him to sanction expenditure of money, seeing that his term of office was coming to a close. I understand that the etiquette of such situations is that you leave these matters for the attention of the succeeding Government. That etiquette need not have been applied, in my opinion. Were it not that the Taoiseach paid particular attention to it and was particularly observant of the etiquette in the matter, he might very easily, in the circumstances, have given his approval to this proposal, without having committed any serious breach of this practice which has come into vogue in situations subsequent to elections when it is obvious that a change of Government is pending.
I say without any hesitation, and with all the more vehemence because of the Minister's interruption, that the treatment of this particular proposal was particularly shabby. The island of Inis Thiar is a very remote place. It is a Fíor-Ghaeltacht island. Surely if there was any doubt about it both the Minister for that Party as well as anybody on this side of the House would be expected to have no hesitation in giving the benefit of any doubt that might have existed in favour of a remote place like Inis Thiar.
Comment on this
The Deputy's facts are correct and if the Minister would set on foot an inter-departmental inquiry, I would be prepared to go there and state the facts in greater detail.
Comment on this
The fact is that the Board of Works engineers submitted an alternative proposal estimated to cost a sum of £11,000 and that that proposal had come in from his technical officers. If the Minister for Finance is again going to treat these people on a punctilious point such as he has now put forward, I say his attitude is particularly shabby. Does the Minister not know that this alternative proposal came in for £11,000?
Comment on this
Does the Minister deny that a recommendation for the expenditure of £11,000 for the improvement of the main landing place at Inis Thiar came in from these technical officers? Can he deny that?
Comment on this
What is the use of quibbling about a piece of paper that was put under the Taoiseach's nose? These people had decided to improve the facility. It could not be done by the ordinary process in vogue all down the years. The National Development Fund was brought in for just such purposes as these. I say it is treating these people in a very shabby fashion to delay for a period of nine months a decision on something of vital importance to them. I think, having said that much about it, I have said enough to pin-point the matter and stress its importance small and all as the sum is in relation to the total figure of £6,000,000. I have said enough to stress and emphasise its importance in a discussion on this subject.
The Fíor-Ghaeltacht in this particular case is the place in question. The Fíor-Ghaeltacht has got a great deal of lip service all round this House. I want to ensure that the efforts that were made to transfer some of that lip service into solid, substantial service will not now be jettisoned on any footy and technical point. A footy and technical point it is.
Comment on this
Can the Minister for Finance give me a satisfactory reply to the question I put, namely, why should there be a delay of nine months on a proposal which had reached practically final form? Was it not only a matter of submitting the thing to the Taoiseach and getting his O.K.?
Comment on this
I do not want to delay any longer on it. It is certainly a very striking commentary when we recall all the glowing talk about how the incoming Government was to handle the National Development Fund, how they were to repatriate our foreign assets for the purpose of building up the country and how a new Budget would replace the old one for the same purpose and give employment to all. As I said, it is very difficult to have patience, when, in spite of all these rosy promises, you find a blanket of complacency settling down over the Coalition on all these promises which were forgotten. In fact, the good work which had already been in train was thrown overboard.
Comment on this
This proposal for one of the poorest areas in the country which is a Fíor-Ghaeltacht area, a proposal which was essentially of a character contemplated in the setting up of this National Development Fund, has been thrown overboard. So far as I know it has been thrown overboard. I put down questions on two occasions within recent months to the Minister for Local Government who, I understand, is charged with the responsibility for Oifig na Gaeltachta agus na gCeantar gCúng. All he could tell me was: "We have not yet made a decision in the matter". It is quite obvious to me that no decision was made. What I wanted to find out was when he was going to make and honour a decision already taken?
Comment on this
If the Deputy were a watchful Deputy he would have sought to have that scheme implemented during the time of the last Government.
Comment on this
We made progress in a very short time with it. We cannot understand why it takes nine months to decide the expenditure of £10,000. If that is to be the yardstick for the administration of the rest of the money, well then it will not be spent before the three years' period for the life of this fund has expired.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Government criticised the expenditure of the money in relation to roads. He made a comparison between the allocation for main roads and that for county roads. He pointed over to this side of the House and said that was the sort of thing the Fianna Fáil Government did. He will get a whole lot of people on this side of the House who will agree with him that a change in that particular respect might very usefully be made but what I want to say to him is that, when this Party formed the Government, they did not go into these technical details which the Parliamentary Secretary is now so perturbed about. They did, in fact, leave the selection of these roads to the technical officers both local and in the Department of Local Government to work out these details themselves.
Comment on this
I was speaking about the expenditure of some of these funds on county council roads. I thought we had left Inis Thiar in the category to which it had been allocated when the fund was first set up. Will we leave it so? Can the Minister be persuaded to leave it rest for the remainder of my participation in the debate? I am agreeable if he is.
On the question of the main roads versus the county roads, the local engineers have nothing at all to do with these Gaeltacht schemes. On the question of main roads versus county roads, a good case could be made for what the Parliamentary Secretary said that, in fact, possibly not too high a proportion of money in respect of individual jobs but too high a quality of work was probably decided on by the local engineers and the engineers in the Department of Local Government. On that he is going to get a whole lot of people to agree with him. At all events, it was a technical matter which was left by the previous Government to be decided by the technicians. If the last Government made a mistake in that respect, then the Government to which the Parliamentary Secretary belongs can correct it. It is not a case of taking a global sum for main roads and of comparing it with the bulk sum on county roads. The nature of the complaint is the quality of the work which was been decided on by the local engineers in respect of a given job.
In my own constituency, I could point to jobs that have been carried out in which, in my opinion, the quality of the work is too high. I think that a lesser standard of performance would have met the problem quite well enough, and that more of this money might be freed for the benefit of the county roads. I do not think that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government had much of a peg on which to hang any substantial complaint.
Comment on this
Deputy Bartley might continue to make his statement and ignore these interruptions which are very disorderly.
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe read quotations from speeches which were made by Deputy Dillon, the present Minister for Agriculture, when the debate on this fund was taking place in December of 1953. One of the ugly appellations which Deputy Dillon applied to the fund was that it was a slush fund: in other words, that we were going to use it to bolster up a bad case in the by-elections. There is one thing that I can say, and it is that whatever slush one finds attached to it in the mind of the present Minister for Agriculture, we have not seen much of it in practice. Here is one thing that was not done in relation to it. The political administrators of this fund when Fianna Fáil were in office did not communicate privately with particular T.D.s and Senators down the country about individual decisions on expenditure. They did not write to T.D.s and Senators——
Comment on this
Will the Deputy leave me alone for a moment and he will hear if he has a little patience? They did not write to T.D.s and Senators and tell them, early on, what was going to be spent in such a district out of, say, the Tourist Roads Development Fund. According to the news which we have been given in the West of Ireland, the present Minister for Finance wrote to one of his Party politicians some time in the month of January and gave him a list of roads to be improved in the year 1955-56 out of the tourist roads development programme, and he gave him that information before it was given to the Galway County Council. I am telling the Minister that this news appeared in print. We all read it.
Comment on this
It could not be 1954-55, because the list of roads mentioned was not the 1954-55 list, which was already public property.
Comment on this
——telling the public in County Galway that the Minister for Finance had written to a certain member of the Oireachtas telling him that certain roads, particulars of which were set out, were going to be improved in the coming financial year. When I inquired from the Galway County Council for verification, I was told that they knew nothing about the matter, and that no such information had yet been conveyed to the County Galway roads staff.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not the fair haired boy in relation to the getting of this information before the Galway County Council. It was not the Deputy who was favoured. Perhaps he should take a note of that and perhaps he is taking a note of it.
Comment on this
I am telling the Minister for Finance about the news item which appeared in a newspaper.
Comment on this
Will the Minister for Finance say whether he did or did not write a letter to a member of the Oireachtas giving him a list of the roads in West Galway to be improved in 1955-56 season under the tourist roads development scheme, and that he gave that information?
Comment on this
In any event, the Minister admits that out of some fund, whatever the correct label for it may be, he did write to a member of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
Yes, the county council verified that when I inquired. They said that they knew nothing about it. There were no slush tactics of that sort used when Fianna Fáil were in office. They did not give, in advance, information for the purpose of building up their own political fortunes whether or not a county council election was pending. I think it comes badly to make these attacks of slush tactics in relation to the administration of this fund when, in fact, these doubtful tactics apparently have been employed by the present Administration only. I possibly would not have spent quite so long addressing the House on this matter if the Minister for Finance was prepared to show a more considerate attitude towards the places which really should get first consideration and attention from this national Parliament. We should be more solicitous to see that the remote places which have not got the same daily contact with the current of Irish life as other places were in particular catered for out of a fund which was set up for the purpose of doing things that had no prospect of being done from any other source. I can quite accept that some delay in order to comply with formalities might have taken place, but I would not have spoken so long or so vigorously on it if I could get any sort of promising reply from the Minister for Local Government, who is responsible to this House for the administration of Oifig na Gaeltachta agus na gCeantar gCúng, which is the funnel through which, in the main, these proposals for the welfare of the Gaeltacht come.
It does not augur well for the early completion of the formalities in respect of this proposal to find the Minister for Finance adopting the same evasive attitude as has been adopted by the Minister for Local Government in regard to parliamentary questions. I hope that what I have said in relation to this matter will produce a change of heart, because it seems to me it is a change of heart that is wanted and that whatever deficiency in the mechanics of putting the proposal forward existed, it must have been remedied long since, and that really it is a decision that is required, if the Minister would be big enough to approve of a decision, even if it were made, or even if it were formulated or even if it were advanced almost to the final point of conclusion by his predecessor.
Comment on this
Even though I interrupted Deputy Bartley, I am inclined to agree strongly with his suggestion that such places as Inis Thiar should get special treatment under this fund. I appreciate with him the difficulties of people living in remote islands such as the Aran islands and I feel sure the problems which apply there are typical of those which affect islands around the coast of the constituency of Cork West, which I represent. Of course, it is rather peculiar that Deputy Bartley should be so critical about the treatment meted out by the present Minister for Finance, having regard to the fact that since this fund was made available Deputy Bartley enjoyed a post as junior Minister in the former Government, and I believe if he displayed the same interest on behalf of the people of Inis Thiar when he was Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture as he now displays when he represents West Galway as an ordinary Deputy that the necessary improvements in Inis Thiar would have been effected long ago and that he would not have occasion to trouble the House with them to-day.
Every Deputy in this House welcomes the Supplementary Estimate of £3,000,000 for national development but even though the term national development is used I am afraid it is not very national in the true sense of the word. The tendency, so far as I can gather, is that all such moneys made available for development in this country are usually utilised in very few centres, such as Dublin, Cork, Waterford and the bigger cities. The main problem we have to face up to is that no matter what Government is in power—the present Government just as much as the last—rural Ireland and, particularly, remote areas are forgotten. Reading the Minister's statement we find that more than £500,000 of this money is to be put into harbour development in the City of Dublin. We find that an almost similar sum is to be put into harbour improvements in the City of Cork, so that taking these two works alone, harbour improvements in Cork and Dublin are going to eat up over £1,000,000 of this money.
While I believe that these improvements may be necessary, at the same time I am of opinion that if we looked at this measure from a national viewpoint much more essential works could be carried out with that £1,000,000 in other parts of this country. The big question that we have to face up to is the fact that in rural Ireland we have people leaving every day, particularly for England, in order to eke out a livelihood denied to them at home. The great dread of every young person in this country at the present time in rural districts is that he or she will have to emigrate in order to earn a livelihood. That is the position, and I had hoped that when this National Development Fund was first inaugurated money would be made available in a much more substantial way for carrying out effective improvements in the rural districts, but now we find, as indicated in the case of the bulk sum of £1,000,000, that the bulk of the money is to be spent in Dublin and other large centres.
I think it is about time that this Government got it into its head that decentralisation of industry and decentralisation of all public works are essential. That was the policy carried out by Fianna Fáil, and it seems the present Minister's attitude has not changed too much from that policy. I, as a Deputy representing a rural constituency, want to impress that fact on the Minister very clearly here to-day. The main question I think which confronts this House is: are we utilising the £8,000,000 already made available under this fund to the best advantage of this nation? I am rather doubtful if we are. So far as I can see, no benefits whatsoever have yet accrued to the constituency of West Cork from this measure and judging by what I have read about it very little benefit is likely to accrue unless there is to be a change of policy. It is my duty here representing that area, as it is the duty of other rural Deputies representing other rural areas, to impress on the Government and on the Minister that rural Ireland will no longer stand for being forgotten. They are entitled to a fair share of whatever is going.
If we examine the position that obtains to-day we find that there are more than 70,000 people unemployed. We find that the main problem confronting parents in Ireland, particularly in the rural parts of the country, is how they are going to provide a livelihood for their growing families, for their sons and daughters, seeking and hoping for any chance they can get of securing that livelihood at home without having to emigrate. It may be said that it is a rather difficult question, but what strikes me forcibly is this fact: if we take the number of unemployed people in any particular district in Ireland at the present time we find that we may have 100 men unemployed in a particular area and we will take it they are getting unemployment assistance or benefit, and taking those in receipt of unemployment benefit, in the case of a married man with a wife and two children, he is receiving 50/- a week paid out by the State, and I know no man in my constituency who would prefer unemployment benefit to work.
On that basis, the Government cannot find money to provide productive employment, but the Department of Social Welfare, apparently, must provide money to pay unemployment benefits and assistance allowances, which the people dislike. It is a very peculiar position. In West Cork at present, people are drawing unemployment benefit and unemployment assistance in areas where plenty of useful work could be provided.
I believe there is no co-ordination whatsoever between the different Departments. If we examine the matter from this viewpoint, we find that the present rate of wages paid in Cork is £4 9s. 0d. per week. The State pays 50/- per week to a man as unemployment benefit. That money is dead. There is no production whatsoever so far as that 50/- is concerned. If the State added 39/- more, then we would have a return for that amount. Which of the two is the better? I believe some scheme could be devised in the Departments to supplement what the Minister for Social Welfare pays to these people, and bring it up to a figure which will enable them to give a week's work instead of drawing money for nothing. That is my viewpoint.
I am not against social welfare benefits. I realise that they are essential, but at the same time in a small country like this with less than 3,000,000 people, I think it is scandalous that more than 70,000 people draw that benefit at the present day. As a result of drawing it, they are debarred from taking up employment under penalty of being brought before the courts. That is the forceful point I want to make.
I want to add that the most degrading thing, in my opinion, for any man in this country, is to go into an exchange, sign on the register, trot around to the guards' barracks in order to get unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit. Of course, so far as the benefit is concerned, he and his employers have made contributions towards that. Would it not be much better if something were done to offset that happening? I am a complete believer in doing something to end that system. I cannot find words adequate enough to condemn a system of paying money to able-bodied people for nothing. It is a bad and rotten system which should not obtain in this country if a proper approach were made to the problem of providing employment by some Government, inter-Party, Fianna Fáil or any other.
I made my position clear in this House a few years ago on this question of paying money by the Department of Social Welfare. I asked could any effort be made by the Department of Finance at that time, and the Department of Social Welfare, with a view to getting this money which is paid out in unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance as a fund to subsidise employment. It would be better to start some industries even though at first they might not be economic, but subsequently they would be economic, and give general benefit. I think it would be better to utilise all this dole and assistance money in that direction. I believe the principal problem which confronts the Minister, and not only the Minister, but the Government, is the solving of the unemployment question. The Minister could probably ask where could the money be got. I can tell him: it is by getting back part of the money paid out to——
Comment on this
The Deputy is travelling very far. The Deputy cannot advocate legislation on an Estimate. I allowed the Deputy a good deal of latitude, but what the Deputy suggests cannot be done.
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that the Chair is the authority on relevancy. I told him that it is not relevant, and that he must not advocate legislation on an Estimate.
Comment on this
I did not misunderstand the Deputy. I gave him a good deal of time to make his point. In order to do what he wants done, legislation would have to be introduced and carried through this House. The Estimate may not be utilised for the purpose of advocating legislation.
Comment on this
I would like then to close with a few remarks on this particular point. I had in mind a suggestion that if the money made available—£8,000,000—under this National Development Fund was used with the money paid by the Department of Social Welfare, plus a little more, I think it would provide full employment, and thereby eliminate unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit for which no return comes. I will leave it at that. I think I am right in making myself clear that I am not against the payment of benefits to deserving applicants, but I believe that the Minister should take steps to see that the need for those benefits should cease.
To provide employment, I believe there are many fields to which we can turn our attention. Again and again, I have agitated here for a survey of the mineral resources in West Cork, and I believe Deputies of other constituencies have made similar agitation, unfortunately without result. In my constituency there are men idle, drawing benefit, while nearby there are extensive deposits of slate and barytes. Such useful minerals could be made available if a little extra money were granted to these districts towards development. I am sure when the development work would be completed that these industries, small though they may be, would stand on their own feet. We are sick and tired of agitating for such development. Again and again I mentioned that so far as the slate deposits in West Cork are concerned, in the Roscarbery-Leap area, there is a wide field. I hope that the present Minister for Finance will take more cognisance of that than his predecessor did.
Another important field for development is the fishing industry. Deputy Bartley referred to the hardships of the people all around the coast, and I heartily agree with his remarks. I have stated in this House before that unless these people get some attention from the Government life in these districts will fade out altogether in the not so far distant future. I wonder how much of the £3,000,000 which we are asked to vote will go towards the development of this industry. I saw little or no mention in the Minister's statement to the effect that the fishing industry was getting any money.
Another useful means of providing employment which would be of benefit to farmers and give productive employment, would be the improvement of by-roads and county roads, especially roads leading to farmhouses. Funds were made available by the first inter-Party Government in a rather liberal way under the Local Authority (Works) Act. They were reduced by Fianna Fáil, almost completely wiped out. Now they have been increased by £100,000 and I hope we will see in the Minister's Budget statement that they will be increased by at least £1,000,000 because that type of money serves a dual purpose in helping farmers to get their water-logged land drained and in helping workers to get productive employment.
I wonder what has the Minister for Finance in mind so far as helping the small uneconomic holders in this country is concerned. Is any help from this £3,000,000 going towards these people? One of the most hard-pressed sections of the community, their position has been mentioned by me and other Deputies time and again, so there is no need to repeat the question but I ask the Minister to take cognisance of the plight of these people and to give them some aid to develop their holdings and to live in reasonable comfort.
Let me come to one of the major problems of all, the position of provincial towns. Industry is completely centralised in Dublin and in the other big cities. The towns are fading away and business is receding, due to a number of factors. One of the principal factors is that around every town, particularly in the South of Ireland, you have a number of creameries selling all commodities, which hinders the business in the towns and reacts adversely on them. I am not going into the question whether it is right or wrong because people's views differ on the matter, but when business is taken away from the town by creameries and so on, I believe some other help should be given to them. The only help that can be given —and I have mentioned it again and again—is by the establishment of some useful industries in the provincial towns and doing away with this business of centralising everything in Dublin. In passing I might say that if suitable land were available contiguous to Dublin City I am sure the oil refinery would be here, too.
It is rather surprising now that we will have £8,000,000 in this fund that only £1,500,000 has already been spent. I am not too conversant with the position, but I have a feeling that a larger proportion of this money is being expended on administrative costs than should be. Take a small project such as the improvement of a small pier down the country. It will have to be surveyed by several engineers before the work is finally approved by the Department. I cannot see why all these journeys and all this type of expenditure is necessary. I take it for granted that a contributory factor in holding up schemes which have already been sanctioned is this fact of having too many surveys and too many reports.
Comment on this
The Minister in his opening statement indicated to the House that although schemes totalling £5,750,000 had been provisionally approved, not more than £1,500,000 of that money was expended and I believe my remarks are quite relevant.
Comment on this
The Deputy is discussing the cost of investigations and I cannot see how it can be discussed on this Estimate.
Comment on this
What I do not like to see happening is that rather too big a percentage of this money should go in administrative costs. I am telling the Minister that at least some of this money will probably be ultilised in harbour works and such other types of work and that there should be some reduction in the number of surveys made. I know of a few little schemes in my own constituency and they are being surveyed again and again. The surveying usually lasts about two years and I am doubtful as to what it costs. In conclusion, I strongly appeal to the Minister to give more attention to the provincial towns and to the rural districts. I feel sure that if he gives them attention he will have the blessing of the people as a whole and he will go a long way towards removing this unemployment which exists, particularly in the towns and in rural districts, and go a long way in making life much brighter than it is for the people of this country.
Comment on this
Ar an gceist seo, Forbairt Náisiúnta, caithfidh mé cur síos a dheánamh ar cheist na dtithe, go mór mhór tithe na bhfeirmeoirí beaga faoin dtuaith. Freisin, ba mhaith liom cúpla rud do rá mar gheall ar cheist na muirighne. Baineann an cheist seo leis an bhfadhbh a bhí á plé ag an dTeachta atá tar éis labhairt ar shaol mhuintir na tuaithe.
One of the important problems we are up against in examining the question of the flight from the land and rural depopulation is the question of the houses for the small farmers, particularly those under £20 valuation. The State has been very liberal in the grants it has offered to small holders for the erection of houses and I would like to point out there are a number of small farmers who never can avail of these grants. Conditional on the grants or loan is the fact that half the house must be completed before a grant or loan is given. The walls must be up, the roof must be on; then when the inspection is reported half the grant or loan will be paid. Take the position of a small farmer in my own constituency on a £5 or £6 valuation. Where is he going to get the credit to get the cement even if he is doing the job himself with a few artisans? Where is he going to get the timber, the slates, the wood and the various other things to get to that point at which half the very generous grant is given?
This, to my mind, is a national problem. Seventy-three per cent. of our farmers live on valuations of £20 and under and they have been untouched, and their housing problems have been untouched, by all the legislation that has been passed through this House. Deputy Murphy dealt with two things—he dealt with the repairing of the boreens and with the flight from the land. A man living at the end of a boreen does not maintain a cul-de-sac. Though his land may be of greater fertility than that of a man living at the mouth of the boreen, if it is put up for sale it will not realise half the price of the land at the mouth of the boreen for the very obvious reason that access to his land is very difficult and because the man living beside the main road has every facility.
It is no wonder then that he does sell his land and that he does fly from it. He has no way of getting into his farm and he has no way of erecting a new house. Another fact which we must consider is that farms are getting bigger and bigger. That applies in every county; it applies in the maritime counties in the West of Ireland as well as to Leinster and we want to ask ourselves, when examining the rural economy of Europe and the position of the small farmers in Spain, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Germany, should something not be done for the small farmers of this country from the moneys available under the National Development Fund. We should see what can be done in a country like ours where we have no heavy industries, and we must pay particular attention to this matter of the erection of houses for that class of small farmer. I strongly advocate a positive programme along these lines. I strongly advocate an examination of this problem, and with it an examination of what can be done about the repair and the maintenance of the boreens.
In Leinster, leaving out for the time being the other provinces, there are 44,607 holdings of £20 valuation and under, according to the Statistical Abstract of 1938. Many of these may have disappeared since. Recently I asked a colleague of mine from County Mayo if they had disappeared to any great extent in his county and he said they had not. That problem remains and it will remain until we tackle it and until we give financial aid to the man at the end of the boreen. If we do not give this man financial assistance to erect his new house his old one will topple and the rural population will continue to disappear.
On this question of emigration I think our approach should be as realistic as possible, It has been pointed out to me that emigration has had its good effect as well as its evil for the nation. In certain parts of the Midlands it was the habit for the whole family to grow up into bachelors and old maids. Eventually there was none left and the farm was given to charity, or sold, or something like that. Now there is a new approach to things in the Midlands. The young people have discovered that they all cannot inherit the farm, that the farm will eventually go to the eldest. So the others make way for the eldest son to get married and in that way, in that particular area, emigration is not such an evil thing as some people make out. Accordingly, there are more marriages as a result; there are more young marriages than there were from the turn of the century to 20 years ago.
But returning to the problem of the erection of houses for the small farmer I should like to repeat that this is a problem that should be tackled and examined. To the problem of the boreen there are two approaches—the one of repair and the other of maintenance. Year after year hundreds of thousands of pounds had been devoted to minor improvement schemes and to rural improvement schemes. To the latter there is a contribution by the beneficiary and to my mind the money spent in this way has been money poured down the drain pipe. The money spent there is being spent on the main roads and the farmer living along these roads has to fence his ditches and to breast his hedges in order to let the sun in on the road so that there will not be future uneconomic expenditure on the maintenance of the roads. On the other hand, when we throw anything from £200 to £500 into a boreen we make no condition whatever about the ditches and the hedges so that the boreens eventually become closed in like the jungle in Africa and if you bring a motor-car through the boreens it is scratched on either side.
Comment on this
Well then, the Deputy must be used to stone walls. There must be nothing but stone walls in the Deputy's constituency. I am talking about the provinces.
Comment on this
There are no thistles in Meath, either. We have ploughed them out and we have machinery to cut them down.
Comment on this
Anyway, going back to the particular point I was making before being interrupted by the Waterford Deputy, the relevancy of the point, I think, should be quite clear with all respects to the Chair. I understand from statements made here that the Minister is prepared to give a substantial sum towards the cutting and the breasting of hedges along main roads and I now want to advocate further that a sum should be transferred to the county roads so that money could be provided by the county councils for this work. These roads would first have been declared public roads. The boreens could, in that way, be properly maintained.
Comment on this
If he had the Deputy would have found that the Minister for Local Government did that yesterday.
Comment on this
Right. There is another point I should like to make in connection with the main highways. Many of our towns are very, very old and want their streets widened in the worst way, and I think that the State should come in here and help out the local authorities in the provision of compensation to people affected by street widening programmes. To give an example, I shall explain the position in Athlone. Athlone is a very old town and its main street, Church Street, is very narrow. Thanks, however, to the Church of Ireland authorities in the town, a big area of graveyard has been given in order that the street might be widened. A local house occupier has also decided to give premises up for the same purpose, but the sum involved is very big and I think the State should come in here and help out the local authorities in the payment of compensation, because what applies to Athlone applies to various other towns up and down the country.
The Minister should consider the point of view I am putting forward in relation to the giving of some State compensation to help out the local authority where street widening is concerned. I did not see this morning's papers, but I think the Minister will agree that the destruction to roads from the 8th December last onwards has been unprecedented. In the Midlands we have suffered very severe snow storms and the roads have deteriorated much more than they usually deteriorate in a normal year. Not only should this grant be increased but increased grants should be given towards rehabilitation in regard to roads, and where the grants remain unexpended at the end of the financial year, it should be permissible for the local authority to carry those grants over into the next financial year instead of returning them to the Department.
Deputy Murphy talked about the wonderful work that was done under the Local Authorities (Works) Act and he criticised the Fianna Fáil Government for cutting down the grants under that Act. I do not agree with Deputy Murphy that wonderful work was done. I think there were some shocking abuses under that Act. There was certainly grave abuse in the Midlands at any rate. The works carried out were not of a lasting nature. There was no contribution towards future maintenance. Indeed, it was money down the drain.
Comment on this
I cannot see how the Deputy can discuss the Local Authorities (Works) Act under this Vote.
Comment on this
I shall not pursue it any further. I merely intervened to make two points, namely, the repair and maintenance of boreens and the necessity for helping the small farmer with the low valuation who is not in a position to avail of State grants or local authority grants for the purpose of erecting a new house.
Comment on this
I heard Deputy Briscoe and Deputy Bartley quote here something that Deputy Dillon, now Minister for Agriculture, said when this National Fund Bill was first introduced; he was quoted as describing the fund as a "slush" fund. I do not think he was far wrong. I and several other Deputies at that time, then in opposition, stated that the Bill was mere camouflage because two by-elections were pending. It is obvious from the course pursued in this debate that it was a ridiculous and unnecessary piece of legislation because we are discussing here in a sense generally—possibly some Deputies may be discussing in a particular way — the Estimates for the various Departments. However, since it has become an Act and has been accepted by the present Government and the present Minister for Finance we must only continue to make whatever use we can of it.
Comment on this
Surely the £2,500,000 put into this fund from the Road Fund could quite properly be left to the Department of Local Government. In actual fact it really is left there. I cannot understand where this fund exists at all. Money is put into it from various Departments. Why not leave the moneys in the various Departments and let the Departments do the work? Is it not the Departments which will do the actual work? It is the Department of Local Government which will spend the £2,500,000 put into this fund from the Road Fund. A sum of £250,000 will be devoted to projects for the Gaeltacht. Is it not the Gaeltacht services branch and the Department of Lands which will carry out that work? The Board of Works would be responsible for the special employment schemes and so forth.
It was ridiculous, in the first instance, to set up such a fund. Now that the fund is there, however, we can only consider the best means of expending the money. Deputy M.P. Murphy took exception to the fact that £500,000 is being spent on the development of Dublin harbour and £400,000 on Cork harbour. That represents practically £1,000,000. All these works may be necessary. It is, however, a good thing that there was a change of Government or we would have had another £2,500,000 or possibly £4,000,000 spent on the renovation of Dublin Castle, and another £600,000 on the Bray road. I hope these schemes will not be proceeded with and that the money that was set aside for these projects by the Fianna Fáil Government will be spent in the area in which I consider the greater portion of it should be spent, namely, the Gaeltacht or, as some would describe it, the undeveloped areas. To enable that to be done a minute survey of the Gaeltacht areas should be carried out at the earliest possible moment in order to find out the requirements of the particular areas involved, such as drainage, land improvement, the rearrangement of uneconomic holdings and the transfer of uneconomic holders to other areas, the improvement of the fishing industry, and the improvement of the roads.
In relation to roads, Deputies, members of local authorities and the people in general were glad to discover in this morning's Press that a sum of practically £1,000,000 extra was to be devoted to the further improvement of roads. I understand it is the rule that the engineer attached to the local authority requires that a road must be a certain width in order to be steamrolled. I think it is 16 feet to 20 feet wide. I would suggest in relation to the further improvement of county roads that, irrespective of width, they should be steamrolled.
Comment on this
In the carrying out of improvements my suggestion would save a lot of money and a greater portion of the roads could be steamrolled if a width of 16 to 20 feet were not insisted upon. In years to come, when there would be further money available, the roads could be extended and widened.
Quite recently, £80,000 was devoted from the National Development Fund for the purchase of boats, free of deposit, in Gaeltacht areas. That would purchase only about ten 50-feet boats and I hope that provision will be made from the fund in the coming year for a further £80,000 or more, if possible, because it is necessary to develop the fishing industry in the Gaeltacht areas. As another means of improving fishing, money should be devoted to the greater protection of our territorial waters.
In order to brighten the lives of people in undeveloped areas it is necessary to extend rural electrification, even to the remotest glens. In order to do that, it may be necessary further to subsidise the E.S.B.
More money should be devoted to forestry because in the Gaeltacht, mountain and remote areas, forestry gives the greatest employment, not only temporary employment but almost permanent employment. It has the further advantage that it will confer future benefit on the country.
As turf generating stations are being erected in some areas along the western seaboard it is absolutely essential that at the earliest moment there should be full bog development. New roads should be built to the bogs and old roads should be repaired. In making the survey that I have suggested, consideration should be given to the question of what local industries it would be possible to establish in such areas. If such industries were supported locally they would be entitled to grants under the Undeveloped Areas Act.
It is in the way that I have suggested that real development can take place in the areas that require to be looked after in a special way, the Gaeltacht areas, if we are to keep our people in these areas and if the language is to be saved. It is only by brightening their lives and enticing the people in these areas to stay at home that such areas can be made prosperous.
Comment on this
The importance of this Estimate demands that every Deputy should express his views on it, however briefly. At this stage of the debate practically every point has been covered and one must necessarily be brief. I remember speaking in this House when the National Development Fund was first introduced. The debate took place on the last occasion the House sat before the Christmas Adjournment, 1953.
I believed then, as I do now, that the establishment of the fund was a step in the right direction to provide for work, productive and otherwise, that could not be provided for out of ordinary expenditure as accounted for in the annual Book of Estimates. It is not necessary to refer to the scorn and ridicule that was poured on the scheme at the time by people who now occupy the Government side of the House. I thought it was a pity that that was the approach at that time because I do not believe that any member of the then Opposition believed that the fund would be used otherwise than honestly in the development of work and the provision of employment which was then very necessary and which is still, unfortunately, very urgently needed.
"A slush fund" was the common description applied to the fund. I hope the last Deputy who spoke did not really mean what he said. If he rereads his statement in the Official Report he will find that he said that he believes still it was a slush fund that was introduced, that the present Minister intends to carry it on. I do not think he believes any such thing and I know the present Minister, while he may have said otherwise, did not believe it was slush money then. It was an unfair attempt to malign an important scheme which will always remain, no matter what Government is in the House, and will grow in importance from year to year. The speech of every Deputy, no matter how much he condemned it, goes to prove how much the fund was necessary to carry out, even in a small way, the many projects enumerated by the last speaker. If only £1,000 were given to each of the projects mentioned here, millions would not finance all the useful schemes mentioned, for most of which no provision is made in the Book of Estimates.
I can visualise hundreds of schemes on which this fund can be used and in respect of which no other provision is made. I suppose every Deputy could supply the Minister with a list of works which would consume the entire fund. Naturally, we do not want to see it all spent in Dublin or Cork, but I am sure the unemployed in both cities would be glad to get a share of it now. Unfortunately, along the western seaboard there is another outlet for the unemployed. When their names disappear from the register at the employment exchange it usually means that they have bought a single ticket to cross the Channel.
I do not want to mention again all the various things to which I would like to see money devoted out of the National Development Fund, but I would like to impress upon the Minister that in the allocation of this money he should keep uppermost in his mind the fact that the congested areas are becoming depopulated and the cities, like a magnet, are attracting the population into them, to nonproductive employment or the dole, while one by one the cabins on the hillside cease to send up smoke as year by year they become derelict and vacant. This does not tend to an improvement in rural conditions.
While the provision of money for harbours and landing places is essential, the Minister in the first place should take steps with regard to the lack of technical advisers in the marine section of the Board of Works. There seems to be little or no technical staff available in that particular section, the fisheries section of the Board of Works, to undertake the huge amount of work which is lying there, which is crying out for attention and which would provide employment in two ways, first, in the actual carrying out of the work and, secondly, in the giving of better facilities to the inshore fishermen using them or to fishermen in other ports where there are craft large enough to go out into deeper water.
One would think, listening to some of the speakers on the opposite side, that Fianna Fáil had only marked time, but Fianna Fáil in their time used money to develop areas where it was found useful and they did not spare it when it was found that it gave a good return. I have only to cite a place like Killybegs in my own area as an example of a place where we have built one of the best harbours in Ireland, where we have the best fishing fleet in Ireland, as a result of development, where we have a quick-freeze plant, a fish meal industry, a boat-building industry and a kippering station—and the development has only been scratched yet. If the Minister will extend a generous hand, there is no telling where development in that direction may end. I hope there will be no curtailment or easing off of the assistance for the development of projects so useful in so many ways in relation to giving employment in the undeveloped areas such as the area I have mentioned.
We have the tweed industry in Donegal, and while we would like to see money spent on capital development, everybody will applaud the spending of money on something which is productive. In the world-famous Donegal tweed industry, we have an industry that is going from success to success and the Minister's predecessor did not spare money when it was found that its expenditure would improve the facilities for, employment in and development of that world-important industry, and we think it would be a crime at this stage not to give the necessary impetus to the development of that industry to the point to which it could develop and consequently put the Gaeltacht and undeveloped areas of Donegal in a position in which there would not be a single person on the unemployed roll.
These are only some of the many things one can easily visualise on which money can be expended out of the National Development Fund. It is wrong to say that the fund is unnecessary, that provision could be made in the ordinary Estimates, because, from examination during the year, many projects can be mooted which will require assistance and the usual red tape which is entangled in the Estimates which are voted annually would not attach in the same way to grants from the National Development Fund. In fact, that is or should be one of the features of the fund—that little or no red tape should impede progress on any project financed out of that fund. When we were on the other side of the House, the members of the present Government were always loud in condemnation of any effort we made to provide extra money, because it was a very nice thing for their constituents to read next day how they had opposed the raising of extra money by any means whatever, but when it comes to a question of spending, they are quite glad to have this money in their coffers, and they will not fail to try to take all the credit they possibly can out of the expenditure of that money.
Comment on this
The Deputy must realise that there was a minus quantity in the Exchequer when I took over on 2nd June.
Comment on this
If the Minister will keep quite for one moment, I will point out one particular instance. However irrelevant it may be, many Deputies have already cashed in in relation to mentioning the grants out of the Road Fund this year. Where did the Road Fund come from? Where did the increased Road Fund come from?
Comment on this
Deputies opposite voted against the provision of the money which they are now boasting they provided for roads. They went into the lobby and opposed it, but that is where it comes from. It was a very popular thing to oppose it, because it was with no great enthusiasm that we introduced the increased road tax. It was a lovely thing to oppose it, but it is an even lovelier thing now for them to boast about the spending of it. They cannot have it both ways. They cannot oppose the raising of money and, at the same time, boast about how they can spend it, and that is what is taking place now. When the Minister says that we left nothing, he forgets that he, too, voted against the provision of that money in the form of the increased road tax, although he is now cutting in on the debate to boast about the extra money available. A Government can do many things if it has the money, but it can do very little without it.
Comment on this
Now the Minister who was loudest in his condemnation of any effort to increase these funds while on this side realises what he can do with the extra money and he has definitely made no effort to curtail the revenue derived from the things he then opposed and which now bring in these moneys. But that is not the point about which we should be concerned in this Estimate. We are interested in the fact that we have the National Development Fund which can be used in many ways to develop the country in order that more people can have a better standard of living in it and find employment here, and so to frame national policy that eventually the maximum number of people will live in the maximum degree of comfort in their own country. Anybody who says this is not a useful means towards that end is either speaking against his mind or does not know what he is speaking about.
I see in the National Development Fund the forerunner of a great effort that will, or should eventually, lead towards the development of many projects in this country which otherwise would never be undertaken. I think every Deputy who has spoken in this debate has already enumerated quite a few of them. I hope the Minister has taken cognisance of the fact that practically every Deputy who has spoken so far on this fund has agreed that something should be done with regard to the particular road which is neither a county road nor a main road, which is nobody's child, and which is neglected except for an occasional special employment scheme or rural improvements scheme grant.
Everybody concerned must now fully appreciate that the accommodation road which is not in any way the responsibility of the county council or of the local authority has become an important factor in our national economy and that something must be done to provide continuity in respect of the maintenance of such roads. Up to the present, we have been making the best of a bad job. Money was allocated annually for these roads in proportion to the unemployment figures in the electoral area concerned. The money had to be expended within a particular period and the unemployment figures were taken in relation to a particular period.
That system is outmoded. These roads are no longer rights of way for carts, donkeys, or anything else. They are now used for tractors and heavy lorries and they are used the whole year round. Many of the people who are using the bogs or other lands to which such roads lead are depending almost entirely on their being able to bring their transport over these roads. Something must be done immediately if these roads are to be kept in a state in which they can be used continually by this new mode of transport which has come along in this mechanical age. If the present Government do not do it, then, as soon as we become the Government again, we shall have to do it——
Comment on this
——until we shall have to take responsibility for adopting means whereby these roads will be accepted as a national liability. I believe that the present Minister is politically wise. I hope he will heed the general appeal that has been made by Deputies to do something for such roads and to provide for their repair and maintenance. I hope that either the Minister or his counterpart in the Cabinet will formulate a plan whereby these roads will be maintained. I hope more money will be diverted to them thus ensuring—irrespective of the number of unemployed in the area— that, at any time of the year when the work requires to be done, a grant will be made available for the carrying out of the work forthwith. It will be agreed by all that that is essential. Sometimes, during the turf haulage season, roads completely collapse. The position then is that the local people must wait for a special employment scheme grant—and sometimes that is not given. As a matter of fact, they might opt for a rural improvements scheme grant under which the people will contribute a portion of the money. Sometimes the difficulty arises that, because of some petty grievance, some of the people will not collaborate and then the whole scheme is held up. That system will have to be departed from, and the sooner the better. I congratulate the Minister on his complete confession——