We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - City and County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1954—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 149–303 of 303. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill City and County Management (Amendment) Bill, 1954
Enacted

No. 35 of 1954 ›

I understand three amendments are being discussed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The three amendments are being discussed but is the Deputy concluding on his own amendment?

Comment on this

I do not know that the question of concluding arises. If there are other speakers who wish to add their views after my own I consider I am entitled on the Committee Stage to reply to them again.

Comment on this

While I am satisfied there is sincerity behind these amendments, still I am not going to support them. I am 18 years in public life and a man in public life has to take the rough with the smooth. The appointment of rate collectors is, perhaps, one of the roughest jobs we have in our county council but whether it is rough or not it is our duty to stand up to it and take our decision. Whether we like it or not county councils are political in the main and they will vote politically and work politically. There is nothing we can do about it and we must accept it. As far as my county is concerned I could be one of those who could readily support the amendment because for 15 or 16 years the political Party in power have appointed their rate collector at any time that suited them. However, I am satisfied that taking everything into consideration the rate collector position in my county is wholly satisfactory and I do not think there was one bad appointment. I would not oppose it because I think it is one way of getting a small appointment for our own men in our own county.

When an appointment is advertised in the newspaper eight or ten small farmers or workers from the area will put themselves forward for the appointment. They may belong to the different political Parties. The Party may have a meeting the night before and decide which of their men they will vote for. I find nothing wrong with that. We could do that ourselves as Fianna Fáil have done in some cases. Perhaps if my Party was in the majority we would have a meeting too to see which of the eight or ten men we would support, first, second or third. I see nothing wrong with that except that the public have left Fianna Fáil in power for 20 years. In my county they made 20 or 30 appointments but the public gave them that democratic right.

I had hoped these amendments would be withdrawn. They may be sincere but the present position leaves the only hope of a small man in a country area getting a position. I can honestly say from long experience that not one of those men has failed in his job. There was honesty and sincerity in every one of them. I could have voted for the Fianna Fáil man just as I could for my own because I found they were all decent and honourable men and it made no difference to me which side of the House got that appointment. Perhaps in the course of a few months my side of the House will be in the majority in the Meath County Council and will perhaps be able to exercise the same power as Fianna Fáil have exercised over 20 years. I expect we will operate in that way, but I know the men who were appointed over a long number of years are a credit to the community. It is one of the few functions that are left to us.

We are all crying out against the County Managerial Act taking away our powers, but here is a little power we have. It is an awkward little power. People are afraid to face up to it, but I was never afraid to face up to anything, big or small. I would not be afraid of voting openly for any good man. I have done it before. The fact that you vote cannot fail to make enemies. In public life you have to take the rough with the smooth. I am one of those who believe in men in public life standing up to their responsibilities. If they do not feel like doing so they should step out of the way. They should do their duty or get out.

I am satisfied that there is no need for this amendment. If rate collectors are to be appointed, let every county council appoint its own. As Deputy Corry suggested, there could be a selection committee appointed by the county manager to select rate collectors. We all know that their votes will be cast in a certain direction. For all we know the county manager may use his political leaders and appoint the man he thinks they should appoint. I think an open vote at the county councils is the right way to select rate collectors.

Of the men who have been put forward for these positions there is not one who could be turned down. They are a decent type of people, maybe drawn from the working class or the small farmer class. Those of the small farmer type may have ten acres of land on which they cannot live, and they say: "Here is a nice little job in my area, and if I am able to secure it through the vote of the council I would be glad to get it." That is the type I want to see getting these jobs. We have people coming from the South of Ireland and up to the Midlands to Dublin, and if they can secure these jobs, well and good. This is a case where counties can appoint their own rate collectors, and I think it is the right way. It makes enemies for every one of us, but we are bound to do our duty.

I say again that an open vote is the best way of appointing rate collectors, and that public representatives should not be afraid to have the courage of their convictions and make up their minds honestly and publicly.

Comment on this

Mar duine ná raibh ina chomhalta de chomhairle áitiúil ariamh agus nach bhfuil aon chuimhneamh aige ar a leithéid, le cúnamh Dé, is dóigh liom go mba cheart an gléas atá ann fé láthair ag comhairlí áitiúla chun bailitheoirí rátaí do cheapadh d'fhágaint mar atá sé. Do réir mar a thuigim an dlí, níl bac ar aon chomhairle chontae ar mian leo é dhéanamh na postanna so do líonadh tré scrúdú comórtasach nó in aon tslí eile a cheapann siad bheith oiriúnach. Do réir mar thuigim an scéal, tá an chumhacht sin ag na comhairlí contae.

Táthar ag gearán anso gur baineadh na cumhachtaí a bhí ag na comhairlí áitiúla díobh nuair cuireadh an tAcht Bainisteoireachta i bhfeidhm agus táthar ann atá ag iarraidh go láidir na cumhachtaí sin fháil thar n-ais, mar a deirtear. San am céanna táthar ag moladh ins na leasuithe seo an chumhacht seo a bhí ag na comhairleoirí contae i gcónaí, bailitheoirí rátaí a cheapadh de thoradh vótaí na gcomhairleoirí, a bhaint díobh feasta. Ní thagann an dá rud le chéile. B'fhearr, i mo thuairimse, an scéal d'fhágaint fé mar atá sé fé láthair agus gan glacadh leis an leasú.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Giles was very near the mark when he stated that the appointment of rate collectors led many to a political graveyard. I also think that factor is influencing some of the speakers who have spoken against the existing system. They want to run away from the local pressure groups. All of us who are members of local authorities know that appointments of this kind can be annoying and awkward, and can, in practically all cases, have political repercussions. I think, in principle, that an elected representative of a local authority should be the last to cast away that small power which has remained. We are all aware that there are small, influential groups in every constituency who make it their hobby and pastime to cast reflections and aspersions on the public representatives. You will always find that Smart Alec who will try to imply and impute that elected representatives, who were once honest men, are people who have fallen from a great height, "the last resort of rogues and scoundrels," as somebody once said.

My colleague, Deputy Corry, spoke of the competitive examination, but I think that that is only part of the job. Again, the question arises: how are we to select the interview board? I think that most speakers have said that the system of appointment which has been exercised up till now has produced the right type of man. No speaker—while many admitted that most of the appointments had a political back-ground—implied that rate collectors, once they were appointed, used their offices to the detriment of the people who might have voted against them.

There was a lot of talk about appointments by the majority of a political Party, but there are very few councils on which any Party has a clear-cut political majority.

I always think that the successful rate collector in most counties will have to depend—while he may have to find a political Party to sponsor him— invariably upon support from other political Parties. Besides being a successful candidate, he is, in many instances, a super-diplomat. I think that the system of appointments which has been exercised up to now has given satisfaction, and I see no reason whatever why we should change it. Why should we hand the appointment of rate collectors to the county manager, to the selection board or to the Appointments Commission?

Deputy Giles said that no man should be afraid to go out and cast his vote in the open, as we do on county councils. We know that there are hidden things in other forms of appointment, and that there is a long line from the bottom to the top. We are well aware of that, but that particular system and that particular form of exertion is not spotlighted, nor can it be. I think that anything done in the light of day can be kept under observation, and if there is any member of a local authority who does anything dishonourable he is soon found out. It is invariably found that an intelligent electorate will soon eliminate that individual and render him innocuous.

Comment on this

I have never been in favour of the Appointments Commission or of the County Management Act. Therefore, I am in favour of the local representatives having the power of electing rate collectors. If I had my way they would have complete power and control. As a previous speaker said, if there is anything dishonourable done in a county council or a corporation down the country it is out in the broad clear light of day. However, if anything dishonourable is done by the Local Appointments Commission it is done behind the cloak and dagger and nobody will ever know about it.

We have to take the measurement of appointments made all down through the years. I have taken a keen interest in the local affairs of the city where I was born. I have noticed that whether the Party I support was in power or whether the Party I oppose was in power they elected a good deal of officials—some of them higher officials than rate collectors—and every one of these officials was well worth his salt. Every one of these officials was a front line man. I doubt if we would have got better officials from the Local Appointments Commissioners. We have got some officials from the Local Appointments Commissioners and, while I am on the subject, I might say that I do not like to see strangers sent hundreds of miles to take up appointments.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not discussing the administration of the Local Appointments Commission.

Comment on this

I was drawing a comparison.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not discuss any appointment made by the Local Appointments Commission. There is a regular method for challenging that, if the Deputy so desires. The Deputy will deal with the three amendments.

Comment on this

Let me come back to the subject of rate collectors. Some people here are of the opinion that county councillors should not have that power. The borough council to which I belong have not that power. We should have that power. Recently in County Waterford there was the election of five rate collectors. There was a division in the ranks of Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and everybody in the council. Five very good men were elected. I doubt whether we would have got five better men from the Local Appointments Commissioners. As a matter of fact, I would say I am sure we would not have got five better men from the Local Appointments Commissioners. God knows how we would get them from the Local Appointments Commissioners. As a Deputy beside me has just asked me, how would we get them? My answer to that is God alone knows.

Let me repeat that there is too much hobbledehoy with small groups of people here and there throughout the country who have not the pluck to be in any political Party but are always picking on the people who go out and do their duty in public service and public administration. I am talking of the people who are always getting up in various self-elected bodies and little organisations here and there throughout the country and finding fault with this, that and the other. These people never offer themselves for public service but, at the same time, they are frequently behind motions such as this. They hold up their hands in dismay when somebody with political opinions is voted into an office. If, like the rest of my Fine Gael colleagues, I am appalled if a Fianna Fáil man is elected a rate collector, the Fianna Fáil Deputies are likewise appalled if a Fine Gael man is elected—but we will put up with that because I would prefer the present system. I am old-fashioned enough to believe that, when the Irish people go to the polling booths and elect representatives, these representatives should have much more power and control than just the electing of rate collectors.

Comment on this

I have listened to quite a number of the contributions which were made to this debate. Many of the speakers have had great experience on local authorities. My experience is very limited, but during my membership of a local authority we have appointed some rate collectors and we have done so by the system of open vote of members of the county council. I am going to vote to-night for the retention of that right. During his visit to the local authorities, the Minister for Local Government was asked to take this right away from them. I can assure the Minister that that does not represent the views of the elected representatives of the Wicklow County Council. That county council is comprised of two Parties— the Fianna Fáil Party and the Labour Party: I think there is one elected Fine Gael representative there and the rest of them are Independents. In the last year, there was a 97 per cent. collection of rates and that is good enough for me. I believe the present system is all right.

Comment on this

I should like to comment on what a previous speaker has said—that the views of the elected members were taken into consideration by the Minister in preparing this amending legislation. That is somewhat similar to what we have heard from both sides of the House about the feelings of members of local authorities. It is suggested that there is a feeling of annoyance amongst the elected representatives on local bodies at the thought of this power being taken from them. It is extraordinary what little heed was passed on the views of members of local authorities when the County Management Act was rammed down their throats. From both sides of this House, the whole appeal has been: "We, as members of local authorities, believe we should have far more power than just the appointment of rate collectors." Was it not the votes of people on both sides of this House that took away the powers from these local representatives? The elected representatives in this House cannot ride two horses at the same time to-day.

Comment on this

They rode them on different days, of course.

Comment on this

It has been put forward here that it is dishonest on my part to submit these amendments. I challenge any Deputy to show me where I have been inconsistent in my remarks with regard to the powers of local authorities. Possibly, if I had 44 or 48 years' experience on the job, I would be bound to have made errors. It is a well-known fact that the longer you are in public life the more you learn about the evils of it. My argument has been that it is wrong to have Party politics brought in to the appointment of rate collectors. We had a very honest contribution from every member of the House. Deputies set out exactly what they believed and made no bones about it. Both sides have stated they were satisfied that the main qualification necessary for the appointment was political pull.

Comment on this

Nonsense!

Comment on this

I cannot see how that can be challenged. Where the appointment is made at present by the local authority on a so called open vote, it is the man with the greatest political pull who will secure the job. That is the system, and evidently that is considered to be the most desirable system by the major Parties here. The discussion we had during the last two and a half hours and for three hours last week will be of great assistance in the future, when the people realise that Fianna Fáil have had 16 or 18 years of this and, now that the local elections are coming off next June, the people on the opposite side let the cat out of the bag and say, in the words of their representatives: "Fianna Fáil were able to make the appointments on local authorities for 17 or 18 years when they had a majority: our day is coming, so why should we accept these amendments?" They have been very fair in expressing their views.

I am in thorough agreement with portion of the contribution made by Deputy Giles. I should like to see the small farmers' sons and relations appointed to these jobs in rural Ireland. If the system I suggest is brought into operation, they will have every chance of being appointed. At present we have competitive examinations for typists, clerical officers, staff officers and others on the local authority and it is the small farmers' sons and daughters from the rural areas who sit for those examinations and are appointed on a panel. What is wrong with including rate collectors on that panel? Is it necessary for small farmers' sons to use political power to be appointed as a staff officer? I do not think so. The main things are his qualifications, his intelligence, his standard of education and general suitability. I want to see a similar line of approach in the appointment of rate collectors.

If we take the contributions of Deputies on both sides who have spoken against these amendments, I do not think it is unfair to suggest that their argument was, first, abolish the Local Appointments Commission and, secondly, abolish county managers and make all the appointments by the local authorities. That has been the argument from both the Fine Gael side and the Fianna Fáil side of the House. Deputy Giles rightly said that, for months before the appointment of a rate collector, the knocker was worn off the door of every local representative. If Deputies are logical in their arguments about restoring powers to local authorities, the unfortunate county councillors will need new sets of knockers every week, on account of the rapping for the appointment of gangers, clerks and other positions.

The Minister for Social Welfare made a very reasoned statement and a reasonable type of contribution to the debate. His argument to those opposing the amendment is: "If you are serious and if it is a question of principle that is worrying you, why is it that this is the sole appointment left to county councillors?" I accept what the Deputy from Monaghan has said, that the majority of men elected to local bodies are honest men. It is a slur on them that the appointment of rent collectors and other appointments were taken away from them. Regarding the line of thought put forward by some—I think Deputy Kelly from Monaghan—I never suggested that the local representatives were dishonest, but I believe they should be saved from unfair and undue pressure.

The open vote is suggested by Deputies here as being in operation in various counties, but that is utter nonsense. The actual final vote before the county council is an open vote, with every potential candidate watching over the shoulder of each county councillor to see how it is going; but the appointment is made before the council meets at all. That is what I want to get rid of. I do not care what Party has a majority in a council, I do not think these jobs should be given to individuals who happen to have been loyal friends of a political Party for a number of years. That is the basis they are given on now. I hope that cannot be construed as a suggestion that these men who are appointed are bad men or evil characters. I am not saying a word against the individuals themselves, but I am saying that the system which selects men on the basis of political jobbery is wrong. The argument has been put up to me and others: "Have you produced evidence that rate collectors have been dishonest or that the system has not worked in a satisfactory manner?"

There was never any intention on my part of suggesting that rate collectors who have been appointed on a political basis have been dishonest or inefficient. I have never suggested that; I suggested that the main qualification for appointment has been pull within the political Party. Let us take it that there are three appointments of rate collectors to be made by a county council; that Mr. X happens to be organiser for a political party and is a single man; and that we have Mr. B. a married man with a small holding of £3 or £5 and four or five children within the age limits—we find the organiser to the political Party is selected and given the job, while the man with the wife and family is turned down because he has not the political pull the other man has. Is it not time that system was changed if at all possible?

Comment on this

What guarantee have you that any other system will appoint the man you are talking about?

Comment on this

If that is the argument put forward, all I can say is that it is an argument in favour of doing away with the Local Appointments Commission, the county managers and local boards in general.

Comment on this

Is there any guarantee that if you do away with the present system they will appoint the married man as against the single man?

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Killilea that we will not have perfection. I am making no claim that these amendments will give a perfect solution. It will satisfy me—and I think Deputy Killilea and others will agree —if the same system can be brought into operation as applies to the appointment of young men and women in a county as clerical officers, typists and so on. If we consider that system to be working reasonably well and subject to the minimum of political pressure, then I see no reason why we should not include the appointment of rate collectors in it.

I would ask Deputies to accept these amendments on that basis, to accept No. 5, No. 6 or No. 31. I do not know if I am in order at this stage in suggesting that the most satisfactory way of getting what Deputy Corry and others want, a competitive examination basis, would be by accepting amendment No. 31. The reason a county manager enters into it is a technical one. It is not my desire that the county manager should make the appointment but, as Deputies know, there are technical difficulties involved in drafting suitable amendments. I am not an expert in drafting amendments to meet the wishes of all sides of the House, but I felt we would have to get a decision on this basis, that it was fairer all round to everybody that the appointment of rate collectors would be on the same basis as other officers of the local authority, rather than on the basis of political pressure alone.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the new sub-section be there inserted."

Tá 18
·
Níl 77
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it that covers amendment No. 6?

Comment on this

There would not be much use in my pressing my amendment, having regard to the view expressed on the amendment in the names of Deputies Sheldon and McQuillan.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In page 8, sub-section (10), to delete paragraph (a), lines 23 to 27, and substitute the following paragraph:—

(a) Where an office of manager becomes vacant the local authority shall with the sanction of the Minister appoint a person to be manager temporarily until a permanent appointment is made but such temporary appointment may be terminated by the local authority with the sanction of the Minister at any time.

This amendment is intended to cover the eventuality which might arise on a council failing to pass a resolution requesting the Local Appointments Commission to recommend a person for appointment as county manager and to cover the interim position. The amendment seeks to delete paragraph (a) of Section 5 and substitute a new paragraph. The new paragraph provides, in effect, that, where the office of county manager becomes vacant, the local authority shall have power, with the sanction of the Minister, to appoint temporarily a county manager until a permanent appointment is made. It is to obviate a situation in which, where there is a vacancy in the county managership, some temporary official might be appointed by the Department and left in a semipermanent capacity. It is to ensure that the local body would have full power of control in that situation.

The amendment also tries to safeguard the position of the Minister by providing that any person appointed would have to be sanctioned by the Minister. It seems to me to be an amendment which should not cause very much difficulty. I do not know if the Minister has any opinion on the amendment or whether he would consider he can accept it or some similar provision.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the House discuss amendments Nos. 7 and 8 together?

Comment on this

They are not quite the same.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

They are practically the same.

Comment on this

I think the same principle is involved.

Comment on this

My amendment reads:—

"Before Section 6 to insert a new section as follows:—

When it becomes necessary for a local authority to make a temporary appointment of an officer or employee pending the receipt of a recommendation from the Local Appointments Commission of a person for permanent appointment, such temporary appointment shall be made by resolution."

The purpose of my amendment is really in line with the spirit of the Bill, as interpreted for us by the Minister and other Government speakers, to give more power to the local councils. Now, the appointments I had in mind when putting down this amendment were appointments about which the county councils would not have to make up their minds in any event in relation to the qualifications of the candidates. For instance, if a doctor is to be appointed, it is quite obvious that he must have qualified as a doctor before, in fact, he can be in the running for the appointment; the same is true of the other executive positions to which this amendment refers. This would have one decided advantage, I think, and that is that the manager in each case would proceed with all expedition to secure the making of the permanent appointment, seeing that the temporary appointment was not of his own making, and I think it would be desirable that permanent appointments in all cases should be made as soon as possible.

There is, therefore, at issue the question of taking from the manager the power of making a temporary executive appointment and handing it over to the council. I take it the period or duration of such appointments would be short. It would certainly be much shorter than it is at the present time if an amendment of this kind were the law. As I said in my opening remarks, I think this is within the spirit of the Bill which the Minister is recommending to the House and I do not see that there can be any serious objection to the amendment.

Comment on this

I regret that I am unable to accept either amendment. I will deal with amendment No. 7 first. At the moment sub-section (10) of Section 5 provides that temporary appointments to the office of manager shall be made by the Minister as at present. That is the law at the moment. The purpose of this amendment is to enable the local authority to appoint a temporary county manager. Now, let me deal first of all with the drafting of the amendment. A county manager is not only manager of a county council; he may be manager of a number of urban bodies in his particular county. The amendment, as drafted, does not specify which local authority will have the appointment of the temporary manager. Can each of them select its own? Can the town commissioners of Ballydehob, for instance, select their own temporary manager, and the county council likewise? I could not possibly accept that amendment as at present drafted. Neither does it specify that this appointment will be a reserved function. Again, I could not accept it on that account.

Comment on this

Surely that is easily remedied.

Comment on this

Possibly. I am merely dealing with it as the amendment stands at the moment. The amendment suggests that the local authority will have the appointment of the temporary manager subject to the sanction of the Minister. Can we not visualise a county manager dying suddenly? Once he dies all executive functions cease. Can we imagine the county secretary calling a special meeting of the county council—he would have to do that—and asking them to appoint a temporary manager? But it is not the county council which appoints the temporary manager. They appoint him subject to the sanction of the Minister. His name has to be sent up to the Minister and his qualifications have to be studied and examined. The Minister may not be satisfied that he is the ideal person and he will send down a further request to the county council saying that he will not accept this particular individual and asking them to send up another name. Then another meeting of the council will have to be called to select a second man.

An obstructionist local authority, politically opposed to the Minister of the day, would keep on sending up names merely for the purpose of holding up the entire business of the local authority. That would be a very serious objection in my opinion. At the moment when a county manager wishes to vacate office, the Minister may immediately, within 12 hours, appoint a deputy. I think that is the most expeditious manner in which to carry out the business of the local authority. It is ridiculous to suggest that in a scattered area, such as my own native Donegal, every time the county manager gets ill and takes a few days or a week off a special meeting of the council should be held to appoint——

Comment on this

Surely the section and the amendment only deal with an actual vacancy. If the manager is ill for a few days the question of a vacancy does not arise.

Comment on this

I agree. I have been unfair to the proposer of the motion. The Deputy, however, sees the other argument. In the event of a sudden death there would have to be a special meeting of the local authority for the purpose of appointing a temporary manager. The Minister may refuse to sanction that appointment. Another meeting would have to be called and the entire business of the council would be held up. The only objection I see to the amendment is that the local authority would not be in a position to deal with the matter as one of urgency. I am in sympathy with what both Deputy MacBride and Deputy Bartley have said but it is a question after all of dealing as efficiently and expeditiously as possible with the business of a council. To suggest that a meeting should be held, accompanied possibly by a wrangle as to who should be appointed, and the appointee's name sent up to the Minister for sanction would take a considerable time and then the Minister might not accept.

With regard to Deputy Bartley's amendment, only a very small minority of local officials are appointed by the Local Appointments Commission. The majority are appointed in a different manner. If we accepted this amendment the majority would still be appointed by the manager in accordance with existing procedure and statutory regulations and only a minority would be appointed by the local authority. I think it would be very unfair to draw a distinction. Clerical officers and library assistants are appointed by the manager. If this amendment were accepted a distinction would be drawn because under this in the small minority of cases where appointments are made by the Local Appointments Commission the Deputy wants the temporary appointment made by the local authority and not by the manager. I think that distinction would be very unfair.

Deputy Bartley said on the Second Stage of the Bill that if the elected representatives had power to appoint such temporary officers it would have the effect of speeding up the manager's request to the Local Appointments Commission. In actual fact managers usually send in their request before the vacancy occurs, and I can assure the Deputy that, if any delay takes place, it is not due to the manager neglecting to send in the names to the Local Appointments Commission. Managers have been repeatedly requested not to wait until vacancies occur before approaching the Local Appointments Commission.

Comment on this

I was wondering if amendment No. 29 could be taken in conjunction with the present amendments? It seems to cover the same ground.

Comment on this

I suggest that this has nothing to do with the points raised already.

Comment on this

I would be inclined to agree.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this

The only argument the Minister has put forward is that the amendment would affect only a minority of appointments. Is that the only objection he has?

Comment on this

Of course it is a fundamental and it is an accepted principle of the managerial system that the county manager should have control of staff and it has never been suggested that that control should be taken out of his hands, with the one single solitary exception, the one we have discussed here for six and a half hours.

Comment on this

The Minister knows, as well as we do on this side of the House, that managerial control of councils was very largely experimental when it was introduced and I think on both sides of the House everybody had an open mind about it and everybody was prepared to support whatever legislation would be necessary to make good the deficiencies which experience showed up in the managerial system. Now, one of the greatest complaints, the fundamental complaint, is that it has taken too much power from the elected representatives and concentrated it in the hands of what has been described as bureaucracy. I want to help the Minister in doing what he says is the purpose of this Act, giving back as much power——

Comment on this

The Deputy did not try to help his colleague when he was drafting the Bill.

Comment on this

Will the Minister come this far with me? Will he agree we have now much more experience than we had then?

Comment on this

In 12 months?

Comment on this

Well, we have 12 months' more experience anyway. In any event the Minister has said several times that the purpose of the Bill is to give back as much power as possible to the elected representatives.

Comment on this

I consulted them for that purpose and not one of them asked me——

Comment on this

I do not think we will go into the Minister's consultations now; we are not all quite happy about the manner in which they were carried out whatever the results have been. If the entire results are contained in this measure, some of the comments of the Labour Party, I am afraid, are being justified. However, all I want to do in this amendment is to follow in line with the spirit that the Minister says is behind this Bill——

Comment on this

Oh, yes, I accept that.

Comment on this

—and give back as much power as possible. Can the Minister point out—apart from the slight departure from what he says is the principle of managerial control— any serious objection to giving to the local authority the power to appoint a doctor or a county engineer or an accountant or to make some such appointment for a very limited period until the machinery of the Local Appointments Commission has been brought into operation?

Comment on this

Yes, I will give you an answer. Take, for instance, a dispensary district out in an isolated area where a doctor suddenly goes sick. Deputy Bartley wants me to call a special meeting of the local authority to appoint a doctor temporarily in his place, even though a doctor may have a pain in his tummy and wants a week's holiday. We are continually appointing—county managers are continually appointing—temporary dispensary doctors to replace men who have been taken ill and the Deputy wants to call a special meeting of the local authority every time we have to make one of these temporary appointments. I think it is better, simpler, and less costly on the taxpayers as it is, because all the local councillors will have to receive their travelling expenses if they come to one of these meetings and if this suggestion were accepted they would be meeting practically every week. In our county alone we have at least 30 or 40 doctors. Each doctor may be sick, let us say, once a year and if you are going to call a special meeting of the council every time you want to appoint a deputy or a locum tenens, I think, if the Deputy considers it, he will see the danger, the expense and frustration of the whole thing.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us, if the council would have to be called together formally because the local doctor had a pain in his tummy, how were these tummy pains dealt with in pre-managerial days?

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon. I did not catch what he said.

Comment on this

The Minister is reducing his argument against the amendment to the ridiculous. Does he not know that there have been a great many cases before managers were ever thought of in which doctors and other executive officers of local authorities became temporarily incapacitated? How were these temporary vacancies dealt with then? Surely the Minister is not offering, as a serious objection to this amendment, a temporary indisposition of a doctor or other officer?

Comment on this

I understand they were actually dealt with retrospectively. The council was merely a rubber stamp. Somebody filled the job and the council dealt with it when they met.

Comment on this

What is the objection to doing it that way now?

Comment on this

I object to the council becoming a rubber stamp. If the Deputy wants them as a rubber stamp he can have them, but I will not.

Comment on this

I think the Minister has made quite a strong case against Deputy Bartley's amendment. As regards the amendment standing in my name, I do not think the Minister has made a strong case. His approach seems to be illogical because it seems to me that we have spent the last few hours in discussing whether or not it was right for a county council to have the power to appoint rate collectors, and the House decided against me that it would be a gross infringement of the civil liberties of county councils if they were not allowed to appoint rate collectors. The issue in my amendment is whether county councils should have the right to appoint temporary county managers, or whether the Minister should have that power exclusively. Now the attitude of the Minister is—"by all means, let county councils appoint rate collectors but let me appoint county managers, even in temporary capacities." It does not appear to be very consistent with the earlier attitude adopted by the Minister and the Department.

Comment on this

But the Deputy sees my reason for it—in the case of a death?

Comment on this

I see it only to a very limited extent. I was just trying to recollect while the Minister was talking, cases in which there had been vacancies, and I feel the positions were left vacant for some considerable period by the Department.

Comment on this

I do not think that is right. All executive functions cease in such a case and we would not have left it open.

Comment on this

There are provisions for appointing a deputy manager, and I believe in a number of cases there is a deputy manager to cover the period during which a county manager is indisposed, or away or on leave or something like that. Presumably, in the fortnight, three weeks or month following the death of a county manager the deputy county manager could perform the functions of county manager without grave difficulty.

I will be quite frank. I will tell the Minister exactly what was operating in our minds when we put down this amendment. We felt that very often vacancies in major posts of this kind are left unfilled for a very long period and that inevitably there would be a tendency on the part of the Department to put in some official as acting county manager who would be left there for a very long time before the appointment was made. It was to obviate that eventuality. It was to obviate having departmental officials acting as county managers in various county councils, while a new county manager was in process of being appointed. We felt that if the appointment of the county manager was left in the hands of a county council in a truly democratic fashion, restoring full powers to the local authority, there would be less tendency on the part of the Department to appoint some of their officials to administrative positions in county councils. That was the purpose of the amendment and I do not see that there is any very grave objection to it. There is very little more I can add. I do not know if the Minister could see some method of reaching a compromise on it or not.

Comment on this

To be quite honest, I cannot understand the mind of the Minister at all. I do not know whether it is because I am too far south and he is too far north or not. Apparently, the same kind of mind is being brought into this as was brought in in the difference between Youghal bridge and the bridge in Athlone. There is about the same line-up.

Comment on this

Ballyhooly bridge was mentioned to-day.

Comment on this

Here is the Minister fighting hard for four hours to preserve to the local authority the right to appoint rate collectors and sticking to his guns and winning. Now, when it is a question of the appointment of a deputy county manager he twists around and says that he must go up to the Department to be appointed. The Minister's argument is completely ridiculous. I say that as a member of a local authority for the past 30 years. What happened when a county secretary fell ill? Did not the man next in charge step in and take over? Was not that the way it was done? There was no special meeting called to appoint a temporary secretary who, in those days was far more important than the manager is now. There was no question of sanction from the Department of Local Government. Cannot this matter be settled very simply? While the manager is all right and has no pains in his tummy, the county council can appoint a deputy to act whenever the county manager is ill or absent for other cause.

If you wish, let the matter be submitted to the Department of Local Government for sanction. That deputy is there always in that capacity to act as manager if the manager for any reason is absent. I cannot see any reason for the Minister's objection to that course. It is a procedure that has stood the test of time and to which there was never any objection by the Department of Local Government before the County Management Act was introduced. That procedure was always carried out. If the county secretary fell ill the county accountant took over. In this case why should not the county council make the appointment? With all due respect to the Minister and his Department, I say that the county council has a far better knowledge of the capabilities of its officers than either the Department or the Minister can have.

I hope it is not because the Minister has got a pain in his tummy through walking around the Lobby that his outlook on this matter has changed. I would be very sorry if that were the case but some great change seems to have taken place in the Minister's attitude in the last quarter of an hour.

Comment on this

There are places worse than the tummy where one can get a pain.

Comment on this

I cannot understand the Minister's attitude. I have no more faith in a selection board set up by managers than I have in any other method of appointment. I see too many queer things coming out—including Youghal bridge. However, we will have that out later on.

Comment on this

It was not the county manager who fixed Youghal bridge; it was the county council.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not discussing Youghal bridge.

Comment on this

I cannot see any grounds for the Minister's attitude. The Minister has visited every county council in the country and has said to them: "What do you want? If there is anything wrong in the County Management Act, I will give you full and free permission to correct it, to change it".

Comment on this

They did not ask for this one. Neither did the Deputy when he was addressing the county council.

Comment on this

No. The Minister knows what happened—I do not know—in the delays which occurred. When a Minister is expected at 12 and he comes at 4.30, we know what happens in the meantime.

Comment on this

Nothing happened to the Deputy.

Comment on this

No. In view of the Minister's attitude on amendments Nos. 5, 6 and 31, in which I supported him, I cannot see why he has a different attitude in regard to the amendments of Deputy MacBride and Deputy Bartley. I cannot see any fair ground for that change. It is as bad as the decision he took between the Black-water and the Shannon.

Comment on this

In addition to what I have already said, I think it is but fair to say to Deputy MacBride that we do not want the manager to be the creature of any particular section. We want him to try to hold a balance. If you have two candidates on the staff of a local authority and both are ambitious enough to become temporary managers they will pull strings and, if one of them is appointed, he feels possibly, or may feel, that he is under obligation to certain sections of the council who sponsored him.

Comment on this

He cannot under this Bill. Then what about rate collectors?

Comment on this

They have not got the same functions.

Comment on this

They compile the Voters Lists.

Comment on this

That is a statutory obligation only and is quite a different thing altogether. They may be penalised if they do not do their duties properly in that respect.

Comment on this

And there are checks afterwards.

Comment on this

Yes, there are checks. Under this particular Bill, it is proposed that the county councils will send the statutory request to the Local Appointments Commissioners and not to the Minister, so that there will be no delay. The councils are the people who will make the request and accordingly, as I have pointed out already, there should be no undue delay on their part in making the application. But supposing for a second that the council had the appointment of temporary officers and at the same time that they had the power to make the statutory request to the Local Appointments Commission, they could appoint one of their pets and they might be very, very slow in sending in their statutory request to the Local Appointments Commissioners. They might delay a considerable time if they had the power to make a temporary appointment. If Deputy Bartley had considered that point he might see the objection.

Comment on this

That could not happen under my amendment.

Comment on this
Kathleen O'Connor Mr. O'Connor

There was a provision under which the chairman of the council could appoint a temporary manager in the event of the existing manager withdrawing or resigning from his appointment.

Comment on this

That still remains in the case of a deputy but we are dealing with temporary appointments here, not with the appointment of a deputy.

Comment on this

There is only a matter of hours between the two types of appointment.

Comment on this

I think there is no difference between the two. The Minister has been referring to fundamental principles in relation to these appointments. How fundamental is the difference between the appointment of a deputy and the appointment of a temporary man? It is not easy to see what the difference is at all.

Comment on this

There is a very big difference.

Comment on this

The Minister made some reference to the analogy between the functions of a council in relation to temporary appointments and a rubber stamp as an objection to my reply to his very trivial objection. The temporary appointment of a doctor in the case where the existing doctor was temporarily indisposed was mentioned. Does not the Minister know that the councils are no more than rubber stamps in relation to all appointments that come from the Local Appointments Commissioners at the present time?

Comment on this

The councils have no functions in it at all; it is the manager.

Comment on this

All right, but the councils have provided the money in any event.

Comment on this

They strike the rate but the unfortunate ratepayer pays the money.

Comment on this

The council raises the money through the rates. The Minister will have to give us some more cogent reason for refusing to give back to the councils the right, for instance, to appoint a county engineer.

Comment on this

Deputy Bartley does not take the engineer into account in his amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister took examples. He took the case of a dispensary doctor who suffered from some slight indisposition. Now I am taking the case of a county engineer.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not take that when drafting his amendment.

Comment on this

Are not all engineers appointed by the commission?

Comment on this

So are doctors, and if a doctor wants to appoint a locum tenens——

Comment on this

I quite agree. My amendment refers to all appointments that come from the commission and in so far as it is necessary to appoint a temporary person to hold an appointment until the permanent appointment is made. The Minister has given us no more cogent reason than the fact that these appointments, taken all in all, represent only a small minority of the appointments made by local authorities——

Comment on this

Who would have to hold a special meeting to appoint, for instance, a locum tenens.

Comment on this

If I understand Deputy Bartley's amendment correctly, it means that where one of these officers of the council either dies or resigns, his job is, for one reason or another——

Comment on this

That is not in the amendment as put in.

Comment on this

I would ask Deputy Bartley to clarify that.

Comment on this

The amendment deals with appointments pending appointments made by the Local Appointments Commissioners.

Comment on this

It is not very plain.

Comment on this

If the Minister is basing his objection on some technical reason like the phraseology of the amendment, will he accept the spirit of the amendment seeing that the amendment is being offered by me as being in line with the spirit of his Bill?

Comment on this

I accept the spirit in which the amendment is offered.

Comment on this

If the Minister accepts the spirit of the amendment——

Comment on this

I did not say the spirit of the amendment but the spirit in which it is being put in.

Comment on this

All right, but can the Minister show me where the effect of this amendment is contrary to the spirit of his Bill? It is designed to give back to the elected representatives as many of the powers as possible.

Comment on this

They never had this power except as a rubber stamp.

Comment on this

Yes, they had it in pre-managerial days. Surely the Minister knows that the comparisons that have been made by Parties supporting the Government have been based on local government as we now have it compared with local government in pre-managerial days. Local authorities did have this power in pre-managerial days.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question: has he in mind temporary appointments or the appointment of deputies?

Comment on this

Let me give the Minister a contrary case. Assuming, let us say, that a county engineer dies and it is found necessary to make a temporary appointment until such time as the permanent appointment can be made, my amendment is designed to give the power to make that temporary appointment to the county council.

Comment on this

Listening to this cross-talk between the Minister and Deputy Bartley, I think it is apparent that the Minister is under a misapprehension. The Minister up to now has based what I thought was a very strong argument on the question of the appointment of deputies. He was referring to officers such as doctors who are temporarily absent from their post due to sickness, or for some other reason, for a short time.

Comment on this

Or in a case where the doctor might drop dead.

Comment on this

I am talking about the position where the holder of the office is absent for a short time.

Comment on this

I will accept that.

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Bartley's amendment was based on that assumption.

Comment on this

I quite agree.

Comment on this

That undermines the case put up by the Minister against the amendment.

Comment on this

Except the case where the doctor drops dead.

Comment on this

We will have to get clear, that in the case of a doctor or any other officer being temporarily absent——

Comment on this

I said "dropped dead".

Comment on this

We are seeking then by this amendment to give the council power to appoint an officer in cases where an officer dies, resigns, or becomes——

Comment on this

I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy, but I would like to clarify the matter. Would the Deputy suggest then that a dispensary be left vacant, with no medical officer appointed to it, until the local council would meet and appoint a temporary doctor? Is that the Deputy's suggestion?

Comment on this

I appreciate that argument but the Minister did say that it would mean that you might have a council meeting every week to appoint a doctor. That is not so.

Comment on this

I would not say that.

Comment on this

They would not die that fast.

Comment on this

I am glad we have clarified the matter.

Comment on this

I think the Minister ought to accept this amendment. I understand he is not accepting it and I am surprised at that in view of the professed tendency of the Bill towards giving more power to the elected representatives of the people. This is a trivial matter, if you like, but it is a step in the right direction towards giving more power to the elected representatives. If we cannot trust the elected representatives to make a temporary appointment pending the selection by the Appointments Commission, of a person to fill the vacancy permanently, they are hardly worthy of being trusted as representatives of the people at all.

I understood the Minister in his reply to state that the likelihood would be that the council would be canvassed for temporary appointments, that a section of the councillors would lean towards a particular candidate and that thereafter the successful candidate might feel under an obligation in some way or other to those members of the council who supported his appointment. That again is taking a very poor view both of the person who has been selected to fill the vacancy and of the representatives who would appoint him. Under the present system, where temporary appointments are being made in some cases by a local board selected to make the appointment, everything is not satisfactory.

There is one thing that would be in favour of the suggested method of selection even for a temporary post; whether the period would be short or long the appointment would be made openly and above board and the public would know whether the candidate whose merits were outstanding was the person selected or not. All of us know cases where local boards have selected what obviously was not the best qualified candidate.

Comment on this

For example?

Comment on this

It might not be fair to give an example but I could give one. If the selection were made by resolution of the council, as asked in the amendment here, it would certainly be publicly discussed and those supporting a particular candidate could state what were the merits of the candidate whom they were supporting.

We will have local elections this year and it is expected that the people will select representatives who are capable of carrying out their duties as local representatives. I am afraid the Minister is not showing much faith in the new councils to be set up if he is not going to trust them with this little bit of power that is being asked for under this amendment. I think that on second thoughts, when the Minister takes into consideration that this Bill is supposed to have a leaning towards giving more powers to local representatives generally, he will not hesitate to give this little extra power.

Comment on this

I am surprised the Deputy did not make the suggestion when I asked for suggestions. I am surprised he never made the suggestion to Deputy Smith when he introduced the Bill last year.

Comment on this

I was making many suggestions.

Comment on this

They are not on record.

Comment on this

I think I even had amendments submitted not dissimilar to this one, if I remember rightly. However, when the Minister was telling us how much power he was going to restore to elected representatives, one would not even dream of suggesting a trivial matter like this. Surely if the Minister's Bill is worth what he claims it to be, he will not hesitate to give that little extra power to the new council which will be elected in June next and thereby do away with this system which prevails at present of making appointments by local committees which does not seem to be satisfactory to anybody. I strongly urge that the Minister should accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I would like to know what is the present position. I am not conversant with it and the Minister might enlighten us. We know that a doctor must be at hand 24 hours a day, 365 days in the year. Are we going to wait until a council sits and let a fortnight go by before an appointment is made? I would like to know the present position before I would agree to any change.

Comment on this

I think we had the question of principle discussed here for six hours on the appointment of rate collectors, and I suggested to the Minister that there were Deputies in this House trying to ride two horses in the same race. The Deputies who are opposing this amendment now and who voted against the three former amendments are attempting to ride two horses at the same time. I was practically accused here of casting a slur on members of local authorities when I suggested the removal of the power we discussed under the previous amendment. Here is an amendment to restore powers to the local authority and it is being turned down. I cannot understand that unless it is showing a mentality — this is not towards the Minister for Local Government — a general mentality on the part of the Custom House——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is responsible for the Bill. The officials do not enter into this at all.

Comment on this

——unless it shows a desire on the part of various Governments to be little members of local authorities. If power is left to play cat and mouse with regard to the appointment of rate collectors, why should the Minister for Local Government, when higher responsibility can be given to them, turn down the suggestion as outlined in this amendment? I am putting a case, repetition if you like, but as far as the Minister and members of the Opposition are concerned they are restoring more powers to local authorities. As far as I am concerned, I will personally oppose that amendment because, if a man is to be consistent in this House, he must show, in a logical way, the arguments which he puts up for amendments which follow each other so closely that he cannot just vote a different way on each of them.

The same abuses can creep in if this amendment is accepted, as are apparent at the present time in the appointment of the gentlemen to whom we have been referring for six hours— the rate collectors. If we have a dispensary doctor appointed on a temporary basis, and if it is left to some resolution of a county council, there will be general canvassing immediately. If there are two doctors in for the temporary appointment as dispensary doctor, each of them will have to prove that his political record is good enough to get the votes of whatever party has the majority on the council. It is a matter of bringing politics straightway into it. I find myself supporting the Minister in resisting this amendment, but I think that the Minister should be accepting the amendment if he was being logical in his argument on the former amendment on rate collectors.

Comment on this

I suggest to the Minister that he is opposing the principles of his own Bill. The Bill states:

"The purpose of this Bill is to amend the City and County Management Acts so as to give to the elected members of local authorities greater and more detailed powers in regard to expenditure, and greater powers of direction, supervision and control over the actions of city and county managers generally, and to make certain minor amendments in the law relating to city and county management."

That is the purpose of the Bill—to give the elected representatives more power. Will the Minister kindly accede to the request of his colleague and tell us how temporary doctors are at present appointed, and who appoints them? I think it would be enlightening to know that. There is no difference whatever between the line we are taking in this and the line we took with regard to rate collectors. The only difference is that the Minister is drawing a line of distinction. My only objection to those two amendments is that they are not going far enough. I think the manager would be a lot more human, and would pay a lot more heed to what the representatives would tell him, if he were elected by the people. I think it is a huge joke to bring all high appointments before the Local Appointments Commission or selection board.

Comment on this

I do not think a statutory body should be described as a huge joke. It is a statutory body.

Comment on this

I do not mind whether it is statutory or monumental. I am just judging this thing as I see it. If the Minister would tell us to-night who will appoint a temporary doctor——

Comment on this

Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

We would have to pay his travelling expenses to go down and do it.

Comment on this

The temporary doctor to fill the vacancy might be appointed by the local home assistance officer until the next meeting.

Comment on this

The next meeting of what? Are we going back to the old days of the boards of guardians?

Comment on this

I am telling the Minister what does happen to my knowledge. I think I have as long a knowledge of local government as the Minister has. I have 30 years of experience, and I can tell the Minister how they are appointed at present. The Minister was requested by one of his colleagues to tell the House how they were appointed, but he was cute enough not to answer.

Comment on this

I did answer.

Comment on this

I told the House they were appointed by the manager.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon, they are not. They might be sanctioned by the manager after they are a week working.

Comment on this

The manager might never know they were appointed.

Comment on this

In the ordinary course if a doctor died suddenly, say, in Cobh, you could not expect the manager to be pulled out of bed to be told: "You must appoint a temporary man immediately."

Comment on this

We take it that somebody will have to be pulled out of bed, and why not pull the manager out? It is easy enough to do that, but it is not so easy to pull all the councillors out and bring them to a meeting.

Comment on this

I do not want to be pulled out of bed at night. I am putting the case to the Minister that, having opposed the taking away the power of appointing rate collectors, I cannot see how he can completely turn about now and oppose giving those powers which are, after all, the principle of the Bill. If one is right the other is right. I am supporting Deputy MacBride's amendment because I consider it is a wise one. I have given the Minister previous instances of what has gone on for 30 years. If anything happened to the secretary of the county council in pre-managerial days, the accountant always stepped in and did his work. There was no noise about it.

Comment on this