Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 163–337 of 337. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I never heard anyone using that phrase but one. I have seen many Ministers come and go in this House, and I make this statement here definitely, that I have never yet heard of any Minister using that particular phrase, but he was practising the opposite as far as agricultural policy was concerned.
Comment on this
You will pardon me when I tell you that the one Minister who used that phrase first was the greatest Minister for Agriculture who ever came into this House.
Comment on this
Pardon me if I am saying anything wrong about those who are gone. Far from me to do so. I had experience of them here, too.
Comment on this
To my mind and to the minds of the people, the late Paddy Hogan was the greatest Minister for Agriculture who ever came into this House.
Comment on this
I hope we will be hearing a few words from Deputy Murphy later on. Until then, let him keep cool and we will know where we are. I want to know from the Minister when he is going to import the sorghums. He has gone back now to the milo maize. When is he going one step further? I remember having to bring in samples of what the Minister paid the money of the people of this country for. I had to bring them in here and exhibit them for him—the Australian oats, the Iraquian barley and the sorghums. They were all lined up here and he could come over and have a look at them.
The Minister has apparently decided to go back to the same policy. This idea of "grow enough barley for yourselves" is all cod and the Minister knows it. The Minister knows— and it is the reason why the agricultural labourers' wages are low and why the agricultural labourers are clearing out of the country—that there is only one costed crop in the country, that there is only one crop produced by the farmer on which we can say: "There is the cost of production—pay us that and a fair profit." That is the beet crop, the only crop to-day on which the farmer knows he is going to get the cost of production, plus a fair profit.
Comment on this
Beet. So far as wheat is concerned, I would advise Deputy Kyne and Deputy Tully to go back a few years and read the speeches of their colleagues on wheat policy.
Comment on this
That will not do any good to the farmers.
Comment on this
Even though the Deputy might come from a rancher county, a county to which we had to send up men to show them how to plough, he might learn a little. If he reduces the price paid for what the farmer produces by something from 14½ to 15 per cent., as the Minister has done in the case of wheat, what can he expect? Does he expect the farmer to continue growing that wheat, or is it his intention to carry out now his declared purpose when he said that beet had gone up the spout after the peat and the wheat, and God-speed the day. That is the Minister for Agriculture we have now and this is the first result of his policy, carried out with the collusion and assistance of the Labour Party in this House.
Comment on this
That is the support they have given and this is their method of increasing the wages of agricultural workers—by cutting the wage of the tillage farmer by 14½ to 15 per cent. That is their policy and their method of increasing labour on the land and ending the flight from the land. Is there any other industry to-day which would be prepared to take that rap of £3,600,000 in respect of two articles of their produce alone and put up with it? That is the method adopted by this mixum-gatherum Government.
Comment on this
Not as much as would make a batch of bread, and the Fianna Fáil cumainn were annoyed——
Comment on this
So far as the economic war is concerned, we can thank the gentlemen opposite who helped out Britain right through the economic war by every means in their power and by every kind of sabotage that could be done on this nation.
Comment on this
If Deputy Murphy does not cease interrupting, the Chair will have to take action. He should allow Deputy Corry to make his speech.
Comment on this
I listened to Deputy Lynch to-night taking us for a walk back and marching up and down as he told us all about it. We fought it and we won it without the assistance of the saboteurs and if there are farmers in this country to-day who are enjoying that reduction of 50 per cent. in their annuities, they need not thank the Deputies opposite for it.
Comment on this
That is one thing that is certain. However, I do not wish to go back on it. I would like to hear from the Minister what is the policy of his Department to-day. Can we have any definite policy from them? Are they prepared to cost barley and wheat and to justify the reductions?
Comment on this
I want the Minister to inform us what the cost is and to state whether that farmer has as much profit as the farmer in Deputy Davin's constituency had in 1948 as a result of the Minister's policy.
Comment on this
I am glad to see that the Parliamentary Secretary has come into the House. I would love him to go back and read the speech he made here in November, 1948, and then have a look at what the Minister did since he came back. He might then ask himself whether he was going to help the Minister to rob his constituents again.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary should read that speech. He did not pay much for Tulyar out of the £5 per ton which was got for the potatoes grown in the Parliamentary Secretary's constituency in 1948 at the behest of Deputy Dillon, Minister for Agriculture. He did not pay much for him out of the rats fattened on the grain in the Parliamentary Secretary's constituency in respect of which he told us it was impossible to find a market.
Comment on this
I do not know whether Deputy Davin, the Parliamentary Secretary, took part in the discussion amongst the higher ranking members of the inter-Party Government as a result of which they shipped the present Minister for Agriculture to America in order that they might get somebody who would put a floor under oats even in December, 1948. I wonder whether Deputy Davin took part in that discussion? Perhaps it was Deputy Davin who advised that they had better send Deputy James Dillon to America.
Comment on this
Was it Deputy Davin who advised that they had better send the Minister for Agriculture to America which gave us a deputy Minister in the person of the late Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, God rest him, who had to come in and put a floor under oats?
Comment on this
I would advise the Labour members to go back and read it with him and see what he said about the activities of the present Minister from May, 1948, to November, 1948. I wonder how they will like it. I can tell the House it will make very nice reading. It might even educate Deputy Tully and it might give him an idea of the wages paid to agricultural labourers on £5 per ton for potatoes. Let Deputy Tully get the volume and read it and see what Deputy Davin told us about the conditions under which his unfortunate constituents were placed by the activities of the present Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary might move down to the Front Bench to make his interruptions.
Comment on this
But they are at the root of all our tillage. You have to put in a grain crop as a start off followed by a root crop. If the members opposite keep carrying on as they are there is a place for them on the Western Road in Cork known as a mental hospital. I think we call a similar institution Grangegorman in Dublin.
Comment on this
I want to know what the Minister's policy is regarding wheat. Does he want wheat? On the first occasion we went to him this harvest he told us he had a headache for a month wondering what he was going to do with the wheat surplus. When we went to the millers last January they told us they had no wheat surplus. Who was right and who was wrong? Where was the surplus? I have two figures given by two different Ministers on the same day. The Minister for Agriculture coolly said that there was only 3 per cent. of the wheat unmillable. On the 30th March, 1955, Deputy O'Sullivan, Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, told Deputy Walsh that the total produce of wheat in 1954 was 9,776,000 cwt. He went further and stated that there was an average of a ton to the acre. We had 486,368 acres. That was on the 30th March. On the same page of the Official Report, column 986 of the 30th March, 1955, there is a question by Deputy Walsh to the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Deputy Walsh asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce if he would state the quantity of Irish wheat of the 1954 harvest purchased for milling, the quantity not yet used, and the quantity of imported wheat mixed with the Irish wheat already used for the making of flour and bread. He was told that the quantity of undried Irish wheat of the 1954 crop purchased up to the 12th March, 1955, for milling was 393,000 tons. On the one hand, you have the Parliamentary Secretary telling us that there were 488,000 tons and, on the other hand, you have the Minister for Industry and Commerce telling us that there were 993,000 tons. That is a difference of 95,000 tons.
I suggest that that 95,000 tons, or 96,000 tons, was the wheat that was unmillable—the wheat that was produced by the farmers but was not accepted by the millers; and that gives you far more than the 3 per cent. laid down by the Minister for Agriculture as the amount of wheat that was unmillable; it is around 20 per cent. From our knowledge and our experience of the last harvest in the country we know that figure is borne out. Despite all that and despite that condition of affairs, this Government comes along and decides to cut the price paid to the Irish farmer for his wheat by 14½ to 15 per cent.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy charging that he got a doctored answer in reply to a question of his in this House?
Comment on this
I said there were two answers given, one by the Parliamentary Secretary and another by the Minister.
Comment on this
One was the quantity of wheat produced and the other was the quantity of wheat purchased at the mills.
Comment on this
There was no question in relation to wheat being presented to the mills and not accepted.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture said 3 per cent. was not accepted. The Parliamentary Secretary stated there were 488,000 tons of wheat produced. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said there were 393,000 tons of wheat accepted at the mills up to March, 1955. That is a difference of 95,000 tons. The Minister for Agriculture says that only 3 per cent. of the wheat was unmillable. I want to know what became of that 95,000 tons of wheat. Perhaps somebody could tell us what happened to it.
Comment on this
There is a difference there of 95,000 tons. According to my figures, instead of 3 per cent. of the wheat being unmillable after the last harvest, this 95,000 tons were refused by the millers, and that represents something between 20 and 25 per cent. of the total amount of wheat delivered.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy get one ton per acre?
Comment on this
I would not grow wheat if I only got one ton per acre. The only place where you get less than one ton—actually it was less than seven cwt. —is above in Meath where they plough every second sod. I was up there on one occasion and I saw wheat being planted; a fine pair of horses, a brand new corn drill, two men sitting on the top of it and they galloping up and down the field.
Comment on this
If I had stayed I would have been a big asset in educating Deputy Giles. I have given the figures and I would like the Minister when he is concluding to render an account for his statement to the public that only 3 per cent. of the wheat was unmillable and to account for the 95,000 tons of wheat.
Comment on this
Let the Minister answer. The Deputy should not try to fool himself. He is too young for that.
Comment on this
He will, and I will try to help him all I can. I want the Minister further to explain into what mixture did the £20 per ton barley purchased from the Irish farmers last harvest go and how it is that there was an increase in the cost of the pig ration of £4 0s. per ton immediately after that barley was delivered.
Comment on this
The barley was bought or produced at £4 per ton less than the price guaranteed by the Minister's predecessor.
Comment on this
And the Minister's predecessor lost £250,000 and charged it to the pig feeder. That is perfectly correct.
Comment on this
The dear Deputy is one of those children who was brought into the class and taught his lesson; he took it in and now he is going out to see if he can find bigger fools to swallow it, but he definitely cannot.
Comment on this
I am the only one to-night to speak on the Estimate and I am dealing item by item here with the Minister's activity since he came into office. I am endeavouring to find some explanation for his activity. I am endeavouring to find why a Minister paid by this State to protect the interests of the agricultural community has by his activities robbed that community of £3,600,000.
Comment on this
It is not limestone the Deputy was taking all this evening or he would not be talking like that. Do not look for any more now. I want to know from the Minister if he has any guarantee from Iraq that he will get feeding barley in here next harvest at £20 per ton seeing that, within one month of purchasing the Irish farmers' barley this year, his agents, Grain Importers, Ltd., paid from £28 to £30 a ton for it. Will the Labour Party consider for one moment why the Irish farmer and the Irish agricultural worker should be turned into the "nigger" for the foreigner in order to produce something so cheap here as to cheapen what the foreigner sends in? Do they believe that the Irish farmer and the Irish agricultural worker should be brought down to that condition of serfdom?
Comment on this
Of course they do not, but Fianna Fáil did.
Comment on this
Within one month of the purchase of the Irish farmers' barley at £20 per ton the Minister for Agriculture imported barley from Iraq at from £28 to £30 per ton.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is able to make a speech, I hope he will get up later and make it. I will sit and listen to him.
Comment on this
My reason for asking what guarantee the Minister has—and I think this House should know it— that feeding stuffs, barley, maize meal and pollard can be imported into this country next year at less than the prices that the Irish farmer is getting is that if he has that guarantee—well, then, he has some justification for the prices paid, but, as Deputy Lahiffe said to-night, there are two ways of looking at this. I have always been a supporter of Irish industry and I hope I always will be, but we heard questions asked in this House last week in which it was stated that artificial manures are £6 per ton cheaper across the border in the northern counties of this nation than they are here. If we are to be asked to produce at less than the British farmer, we are entitled to say: "Very well; we are entitled to get our artificial manures as cheaply as Britain gets them," if we are to compete in the British market and not be—as the Minister said—priced out of it, in eggs, butter and bacon. What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.
If we are to have free trade by the apostle of free trade, the Minister, on the one hand, then let it be free trade all round and let Deputy Norton account to his workers when he goes into the country for the unemployment of some 2,000 or 3,000 men who are working at present producing artificial manures for the farmers of this country. Let him go out and account to them for that. Let him go to C.I.E. and tell them and their workers that the quantity of freight that they will be drawing this year will be 50 per cent. less than last year and that the lorries will be idle.
Comment on this
It is not my hope. Seventy per cent. of the total freight carried by C.I.E. is involved in the transport of goods for the Irish Sugar Company. What is the reduction in the beet acreage this year? Let Deputy Davin ask himself that.
Comment on this
I want to know, and I want produced in this House by the Minister for Agriculture, the guarantee he has got that he will get wheat into this country next harvest, and at what prices? I say to the Minister that he should know, that he and the departmental advisers surely knew in the months of September and October last year the prices that would have to be paid for foreign barley. Surely they knew, and if they did why did the Minister come along and on the plea that he wanted cheaper feeding stuffs rob the farmer of £400,000? Why did that Minister come along this year and pick out the fortnight before the Beet Growers' Association were to meet Messrs. Arthur Guinness, as the period on which he was going to announce his 40/- a barrel for barley?
Why did he pick out that particular period to make the announcement? In order to sabotage the organisation that was endeavouring to get a price for malting barley. Why did he pick out that particular week for it? When we went across there we were met with flaring headings in the papers—"I promise the farmers that they will get 40/- per barrel for their barley next harvest." That, of course, was produced to us by Messrs. Arthur Guinness when we went to make a price for 824,000 barrels of barley. That is the kind of stuff we get. That is the kind of assistance for which the people of this country are paying that Minister £2,500 a year, for the help of sabotaging their prices.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not appear to be able to read the Estimate for that figure is not in the Estimate for the Minister.
Comment on this
I am not worrying. All I say about the Minister is that it would pay the farmers of this country to send him to the biggest hotel they could find in America and keep him there free. They would save a good deal of money on it.
Comment on this
Deputy Rooney may not make a remark like that to a Deputy of this House. He must withdraw that remark.
Comment on this
I want to draw attention to the fact that Deputy Corry referred to the Minister's salary as one of £2,500. That figure is not in the Estimate.
Comment on this
My figure is based on a statement made here by the Minister himself in which he said he was getting that "mangy salary". I think those were the words he used.
Comment on this
Yes. I am glad Deputy Dunne corrected me. That was what he called it, and that was the figure he quoted. He might have increased it since—the poor devil wants it, I suppose. However, those are a few matters on which I want information from the Minister. I want him definitely to give the House the guarantees he has for his policy in wrecking the tillage farmers of this country. I think we are entitled to that.
We hear a lot of talk here about dairies and dairying. I think it rather an extraordinary policy that the bovine tuberculosis scheme, instead of being put into full force in the dairying counties, was reserved for counties where there is very little dairying and very few milch cows in the population. One would think that, with a policy like that, if it is to do any good, the first place it would be tried out is where milk is being supplied to large cities and towns for human consumption. One would think that the Government would endavour to get rid of bovine tuberculosis from the first in the dairying counties. Take, for instance, Deputy Madden's constituency which supplies Limerick City or portion of the Parliamentary Secretary's constituency from which milk is sent to Dublin.
One would think that the scheme would be tried out first in such places in an endeavour to eradicate the disease where it is doing the most harm. I suggest to the Minister that the areas from which milk is being supplied to cities should be the first areas to get the complete benefits of the scheme for the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. There are five or six dairying counties—and there are only five or six of them altogether. I have noticed that those particular counties are very carefully excluded so far as putting the scheme into full operation there is concerned. Surely the Minister will not say that Sligo is a dairying county? Surely the Minister will not say that County Clare is a dairying county? Only a portion of Tipperary goes in for dairying. I suggest the Minister should try out the scheme in Cork.
Comment on this
Would the Minister listen quietly and I will tell him what is happening—because I know. I ask for a man to test my herd. Say I have ten cows gone down and five or six heifers. I sell these reactors to another farmer who does not realise what he is buying. Therefore, you are not getting rid of the reactors. That is what is happening. If 20 per cent. or 10 per cent. or even 5 per cent. of the cows go down under the test those cows are immediately sold to another farmer. That is not eradicating the disease. It only gives the cute boy a chance of getting out while the going is good. The Minister should look at that aspect of it because it is a very serious aspect indeed.
Comment on this
I suggest the Minister should put the scheme in full operation all over, and make one job of it, whatever its cost. In the piecemeal way it is being done, it will take 20 years. I can assure the Minister, further, from my knowledge of selling in-calf cattle, that the British will not wait for 20 years for tuberculin-tested cattle. With regard to our in-calf and calf heifers for export, the British will not accept non-tuberculin-tested cattle. Surely this is a subject which can be discussed in a non-political way? Surely we can go into this with a free mind, each one endeavouring to do his best and to help in the solution of the problem? I am telling the Minister what I know from my own experience is happening.
If the Minister will take up the paper any day and look at the livestock advertisements he will see advertisements such as this: "Six heifers for sale.""Ten heifers for sale." A man goes to see the beasts that are for sale. He asks whether they have been tuberculin tested and is told that they have not. However, he consults the veterinary surgeon as to whether the man selling the beasts had his herd tested. These six or ten heifers that went down under the test are now being pawned off on a neighbour. If we set about eradicating bovine tuberculosis then let us do it properly. Let us not have three or four counties clear of it and have the position that we will be shifting cattle in and out of those counties.
Comment on this
I am telling the Minister what is happening from my own knowledge. I am sure there are Deputies sitting on the Government side of the House who can bear out my statement as to what is happening. I see it happening every day of the week.
Comment on this
I have the advice to offer that the Minister's piecemeal policy of taking one county now, another county next year and another county the year after that again is not succeeding and cannot succeed. It will not succeed and it cannot succeed.
Comment on this
If that is the only advice the Deputy can give me, I say the Deputy should not bother his head about the matter.
Comment on this
When the Minister is concluding, I should like him to tell us how long it will take to get tuberculosis-free cattle in this country on the present policy. That is what I would like to know from him. In my opinion, it cannot be done. Over a long period of years it would be impossible to do it. Here and there in every country there are herds that are tuberculin-tested and that are found to be free but when reactors are discovered they are not destroyed; they are transferred to some other farm.
Comment on this
You meet them everywhere. I have seen herds giving a 97 per cent. free result on test. I have seen other herds, not too far away from them, showing as high as 30 and 40 per cent. reactors.
Comment on this
The English papers will love that.
Comment on this
There is another extraordinary thing that has come under my notice, that is, that the calf that is reared in an open shed as against the calf reared in a closed-in house has no tuberculosis, or very little tuberculosis, that the confinement and the atmosphere of the closed-in house is largely responsible for tuberculosis. That is my experience in talking to the vet when he makes his visits.
Comment on this
Every Minister so far— this is not personal because it appertains to all Parties—who has gone into the Department of Agriculture seems to be injected with the Shorthorn needle the night he takes office. No matter what their opinions may have been before that, they are immediately injected with the Shorthorn needle and every Minister for Agriculture without exception, whether from this side or the opposite side of the House, says that the Shorthorn is the best cow in the world and the cow most suitable for our purposes.
Some years ago any time one attended a meeting to discuss agricultural matters, one was advised to visit Denmark or Holland to study the way they do things there. That was a very common idea with farmers who found themselves a bit prosperous. They would go to see how the other fellow was doing it. Perhaps it was a good plan. How is it that we find a breed of cows in Denmark whose average milk yield is over 800 gallons per cow?
Comment on this
Compare that with the average yield of our cows and ask ourselves the reason for the discrepancy.
Comment on this
The cows are not better fed. I have seen cows fed to an extent that the milk they give would not pay for their feed and they were unable to come up to that yield. They were Shorthorn cows.
Comment on this
Shorthorn cows could not do it. You will see a miracle anywhere just as I am seeing the Minister over there. These miracles happen.
Comment on this
The Shorthorn has been bred and cross bred and cross bred again and cross bred again. He is a mixture of the old Scotch beef bull and some kind of dairy Shorthorn that existed at one period in this country. I knew one very prominent breeder. I met him one day coming up from Cork Show and asked him how he got on. He said he did not get a premium and that he had nine animals there. "By Jove," he said, "I will get them the next time." He came to the Dublin Show and bought a beef bull there and two years afterwards at Cork Show he won first prize, second prize and premiums for his bulls.
Comment on this
Then they were double dairy Shorthorns after that. As against that, the Friesian has been bred for milk and has continued to be bred for milk. That is the difference between what we call a milk breed and the other breed. I say seriously to the Minister that it is unfair and unjust to ask the dairy farmer in the creamery districts of this country to keep Shorthorn cattle.
Comment on this
It is Government policy, unfortunately. The Minister's Department will not give a premium to a Friesian bull. Why? They give a premium to a Hereford, to a Poll Angus and to a Double Dairy Shorthorn. What is the reason for refusing to give a premium to Friesian cattle? These are questions I would like the Minister to attend to. They are very serious questions so far as we are concerned. We see our competitor in the British market with cows that give 800 or 1,000 gallons on an average, whereas the average here is about 350 gallons.
Comment on this
How does the butter fat in the case of Friesians compare with the butter fat in the case of Shorthorns?
Comment on this
I have tried both and it is 20 years since I kept a Shorthorn. I kicked the last one out through my gate and thanked God to be rid of it.
Comment on this
There was no price for calves then.
Comment on this
Why would the Deputy not favour Jerseys on that basis, seeing that their butter fat content averages about five and goes from that up to six?
Comment on this
I can only give the Minister the benefit of my experience. I am a milk supplier to Cork City out of a Friesian herd. I get my milk tested for butter fat once every three weeks by the Cork Corporation and I pay for it.
Comment on this
But, from the point of view of the creamery farmer, why not go the whole hog and breed Jerseys? From the creamery point of view, why not go over altogether to the Jersey, which gives from 5 to 6 per cent. butter fat?