Gaming and Lotteries Bill, 1955—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–202 of 403. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1955 ›
I move amendment No. 1:—
In the definition of "gaming", line 19, to insert after "game" the following:—
"(whether of skill or chance or partly of skill and partly of chance)".
This is a drafting amendment of the definition of gaming and its purpose is important. It removes from any possibility of doubt in anyone's mind that when we come later in Section 4 to define unlawful gaming we are referring to games of skill as well as games of chance.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:—
To delete the definition of "slot-machine".
There are two kinds of slot-machines dealt with in the Bill. The kind which is absolutely prohibited under Section 9 and the other kind dealt with in Section 4, under the heading of unlawful gaming. The second kind can only be operated at circuses, carnivals and funfairs, etc., under the provisions Section 6, 7, and 13.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:—
In page 3, between lines 38 and 39, to insert a new definition as follows:—
"stake" includes any payment for the right to take part in a game and any other form of payment required to be made as a condition of taking part in the game but does not include a payment made solely for facilities provided for the playing of the game;
This is one of the drafting amendments I referred to in moving amendment No. 1. As I explained then, it is in the interests of clarification and furthermore, it is necessary in order to bring within the provisions of unlawful gaming a type of competition devised since the Bill was circulated which would enable a person on buying an article, such as a song sheet, to become eligible to take part in a game for prizes without directly hazarding a stake.
Comment on this
The definition of "lottery" in the Bill sets out that it includes all competition for money or money's worth involving forecasts of future events or of past events, the results of which are not yet ascertained or not yet generally known, and I suggest that the Minister should alter that definition. It is not possible, I respectfully submit, to forecast a result which has not yet been ascertained but may possibly be generally known, and how the Minister can argue under this definition that a forecast can be made of a past event is beyond me. The definition here suggests that a past event can be forecast, which is ridiculous. The definition also says: "the results of which are not yet ascertained or not yet generally known", and I take exception to the phrase "generally known". It suggests that some people may know the result of a race or some other such event.
Comment on this
For the sake of argument, the result of the Kentucky Derby would not be generally known, but a few individuals might know it, so that I suggest that the definition should be completely changed, on the grounds that you cannot forecast the result of something which has already happened and, therefore, the word "generally" should be knocked out.
Comment on this
Would the Minister clarify the point raised by Deputy O'Malley in relation to the definition? I think this matter should be examined. I am not a lawyer, but it strikes me that some of the amendments will make even more work for the lawyers than the Bill would have done as it first stood.
Comment on this
It may be a very worthy object, but it is our job to make these provisions as clear as possible.
Comment on this
I trust Deputy O'Malley will not misunderstand me, but I do not think there is anything in the point he has put. However, I am sure the Minister will have it examined by the draftsman to see if there is any possibility of a loophole. The forecasting of past events does, of course, sound rather peculiar; but it is conceivable that some people might have a little pool or lottery in a public-house on what happened in America two or three hours earlier; they would not know the result, and that would clearly be a lottery because the result would not be known generally. But somebody in America might know the result and it is to catch that sort of thing that the definition is framed in this particular way. Really the definition is put in to catch all sorts of evasions which might take place if the word "lottery" was not defined in the widest possible way.
In considering this Bill, it should be kept clearly in mind—I mention this because I found it difficult to understand the Bill until I got this clearly into my mind—that lottery includes games of skill as well as games of chance. Hitherto the accepted definition of lottery was the forecasting or deciding of something by lot or chance and the usual defence in a prosecution was to establish that the game involved a large element of skill. In order to prevent that element coming in it was decided in this Bill to have a general definition of "lottery" to cover everything, even where skill is involved.
Comment on this
How would this affect people forecasting the scores in hurling matches, football matches and so forth?
Comment on this
It does, but there are provisions in subsequent sections which possibly cover what the Deputy has in mind.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:—
Before Section 4 to insert the following new section:—
4.—(1) No person shall promote or assist in promoting or provide facilities for any kind of gaming—
(a) in which by reason of the nature of the game, the chances of all the players, including the banker, are not equal, or
(b) in which any portion of the stakes is retained by the promoter or is retained by the banker otherwise than as winnings on the result of the play, or,
(c) by means of any slot-machine not prohibited by Section 9.
(2) Such gaming is in this Act referred to as unlawful gaming.
(3) Gaming shall not be unlawful if no stake is hazarded by the players with the promoter or banker other than a charge for the right to take part in the game, provided that—
(a) only one such charge is made in respect of the day on which the game is played, and
(b) the charge is of the same amount for all the players, and
(c) the promoter derives no personal profit from the promotion of the game.
Sub-section (1) prohibits any person from promoting or assisting in promoting or providing facilities for unlawful gaming. The House will observe that the offence is not for unlawful games but for the promoting or providing of assistance in unlawful games. The person we want to get after under these gaming provision is the fellow who runs a gambling school or a gambling saloon for his own personal profit.
Comment on this
I appreciate that the definition of gaming must have given the draftsmen considerable difficulty. There is a doubt in my mind in relation to this proposed Section 4. The Minister has made it clear that the object of the section is to catch promoters of certain types of gaming. One of the types specified in sub-section (b) is as follows:—
"in which any portion of the stakes is retained by the promoter or is retained by the banker otherwise than as winnings on the result of the play, or"
It seems to me that proprietors of golf clubs might be promoting gaming where sweepstakes are held on matches and such proprietors could conceivably be caught under this section inasmuch as they would be promoting gaming in which portion of the stakes is retained by them since it is not unusual for a club to retain part of such sweepstakes as a means of augmenting the income of the club.
In a later sub-section it is proposed not to make such an eventuality illegal. Sub-section (3) provides:—
"Gaming shall not be unlawful if no stake is hazarded by the players with the promoter or banker."
If the sub-section were left like that that would probably obviate the difficulty I have in mind; but the sub-section goes on to say: "Provided that (a) only one such charge is made in respect of the day on which the game is played." Deputies who have a certain amount of experience of sweepstake competitions in golf clubs know that it is quite a common practice for two cards to be put in by players. It seems to me that if a player puts in two cards—he will be charged twice— the committee promoting the match may be involved in an unlawful gaming enterprise. I would like the Minister to look into this and, if possible, make the section a little clearer.
Comment on this
I too have some doubts like Deputy Declan Costello. Sub-section (1) states:—
No person shall promote or assist in promoting or provide facilities for any kind of gaming—
(a) in which by reason of the nature of the game, the chances of all the players, including the banker, are not equal.
Is it lawful, or will it be lawful, in the Minister's opinion, if it can be proved that the chances of all the players taking part in the game and the banker are equal? That is the first point. If the chances are equal, will the game be lawful? The word "or" occurs at the end of that sub-section. I think that should be "and". Sub-section (b) states:—
"... in which any portion of the stakes is retained by the promoter or is retained by the banker otherwise than as winnings on the result of the play."
To my mind that is very ambiguous. In sub-section (3) (a) it is stipulated:—
"Only one such charge is made in respect of the day on which the game is played."
A charge of £5 or £10 could be made by a club providing the necessary facilities. In other words, what I am pointing out is that a group of promoters could make a very heavy charge of, say, £3, £5 or even £10 to run a gambling school such as poker, forty-five or whist. The Minister made very clear, when he introduced the Bill, what exactly he had in mind, but I think that the Minister should make this section much more specific.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:—
To delete paragraph (b) and substitute:—
(b) the gaming does not extend over a period exceeding ten days and has not been carried on during the preceding three months as part of the show when being held at that place or anywhere within three miles of that place, and
There are two reasons for the amendment. The first is to make it quite clear that in this Bill we are concerned only with gaming at these shows: we are not concerned with the shows themselves and accordingly they can continue as long as the owners want to stay, provided the gaming does not go on for more than ten days.
The extension of the period from a week to ten days is the second point. The representatives of travelling showmen asked for an extension so that they could stay over a second weekend. The amendment is designed to enable them to do so and I recommend it to the House. The draftsman has also taken the opportunity to alter the wording a little as some Deputies found that the reference to "area" in the section as introduced was confusing.
I should like to add a word on the substance of this provision. It is designed to deal with a particular type of show—the circus or travelling show which stays only a short time in any one place. The object of the provision is to let such a showman have some games of chance—and some lotteries also as will appear later— without any formality. Some Deputies may say: "Why not let him stay a month or two or three if he wants to?" My answer is that if he wants to stay a long time, and wants to carry on gaming all the time, there are other provisions in the Bill to provide for him: he is not the type of showman for which this particular section caters. I am satisfied from my discussions with showmen that there are a number of showmen to whom this section will apply, and I suggest to the House that because of the nature of their business they can and should be exempt from the requirements which the bigger showman who stays for a longer period must be asked to comply with. If the period were extended to, say, a month, we obviously would have to impose the same restrictions as on carnivals—and that is not going to help the showmen concerned at all: quite the contrary.
Acceptance of my amendment involves rejection of amendments Nos. 6, 7 and 8 put down by Deputy Moran.
Comment on this
Deputy Moran has an amendment to this section which says that "three miles" should be substituted by "one mile". We have not yet heard from the Minister why he decided the distance should be three miles.
Comment on this
If the distance were a mile the showman could switch around for one week and come back again. I have it on good authority that the three-mile limit would be much better for all concerned.
Comment on this
That would be so in the case of different parishes. Are we sure this does not apply to cities and towns?
Comment on this
I wish to say that I support this idea of the three-mile limit. If the rural areas are to have a chance the Minister should stick to his three-mile limit.
Comment on this
Another amendment in Deputy Moran's name suggests that the word "week" should be substituted for "month".
Comment on this
So long as a showman does not carry on gaming in excess of the stipulated ten days there is nothing to prevent him from applying to a court.
Comment on this
In connection with this ten days' condition, I presume this applies to small showmen in rural areas.
Comment on this
A number of Deputies are anxious that the existing facilities for amusement which the people in rural areas enjoy are not taken away or that they do not make it so difficult for the showmen that they will pack up. Is this condition of ten days to be taken as consecutive or can the showman run gaming for two days in one week, three days in the next and so on?
Comment on this
Yes, but if the showman is staying for six weeks may he not break up his ten days over that period?
Comment on this
I would like that matter clarified. There are times when it would be wet for four days and when the showman could not run any gaming.
Comment on this
The second part of the section would take care of that matter. It says: "and has not been carried on within that area during the preceding three months".
Comment on this
I may be very slow in this because I cannot understand why, if a man wants to stay in one place for a month, he should not be allowed to spread his ten days over that period.
Comment on this
He would possibly get in under Section 7 or he might be catered for under another section under which he would be entitled to get a licence.
Comment on this
I think it would be better if the position were clarified as to whether or not the ten days must be consecutive. I do not believe it is of any great importance but I think it would remove that particular doubt.
Comment on this
The showmen themselves have accepted this. We discussed the whole matter with the showmen.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:—
At the end of paragraph (d) to insert "and", and to add to the section the following paragraphs:—
(e) no player may win more than the value of ten shillings in each game, and
(f) neither taking part in nor the result of a game entitles the player to take part in any other game or lottery or otherwise to receive or be eligible to compete for any money or money's worth, and
(g) notice in writing of the dates of gaming at the show has been previously given by the promoter to the sergeant in charge of the local Garda Síochána station.
This amendment deals mainly with the imposition of a limit of 10/- on such games. I am glad to be able to state that I discussed the matter with a number of showmen and they said it would not impose any hardship on genuine showmen.
Comment on this
This stipulation recurs in other sections. As the Minister mentioned, 10/- is odds of 20 to 1 when 6d. is the maximum stake. But the fantastic position arises in these pongo parlours where anything from 150 to 200 players participate in the more popular seaside resorts. Does the Minister appreciate the fact that if 200 players pay 6d. each, the promoter takes £4 10s. out of each game and that all the unfortunate patron gets is 10/-?
The Minister's statement, that he is getting odds of 20 to 1 is correct, but this is in my opinion most unjust, and if the Minister is attempting to give amusement to people and at the same time couple that with some justice, then he is not achieving his purpose. If there is an average of 40 games in a night one could lose 10/- on the night. Against that if the promoter with 200 players in an average size arcade has 40 games, he takes his £4 10s. out of each game and will so get £180 altogether. Is not that the position? It is no wonder that some people in the amusement arcades were delighted with some of these provisions.
Comment on this
We feel that for a prize of 10/- a large number of players, such as 200, will not be content to play all night.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not put in a percentage of the takings in each game, or would the Minister not consider the present system which the promoters themselves operate? They advertise on a small blackboard that the pool is 30/- and deducting 10/- for running expenses, the prize fund is £1. If more people come in for the next game the pool could go up to 70/- and after deducting the 10/- the prize fund would be £3. When people move away, it might fall to as little as 5/-.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not realise that what he is suggesting is illegal and these people could be put out of business if the law were enforced? What is being done here is to provide a reasonable opportunity for reasonable games.
Comment on this
If only one-third of the total takings when say 60 people are playing at 6d. each is to be given back—I think that is not fair.
Comment on this
There are many thousands of pounds in the Sweep and here there is only 10/- each time as prize. I do not believe that the proprietor is going to get as much as £1.
Comment on this
If you have a limit of 6d. on the bet what is the great need to limit the prize? Why is there not an opportunity given to the speculator to get more?
Comment on this
I agree with the limit being put on the amount paid in stake but I do not see the sense in limiting the prize money to a sum of 10/-.
Comment on this
This Bill is not to encourage gambling but to discourage it and to allow a reasonable amount of amusement. If we want to let everyone rip and try their hands at getting substantial money in prizes the approach to this Bill would be different.
Comment on this
When the Taoiseach says this Bill is to give amusement he should know it is a fact that many of these people do not go in for amusement but with considerable business acumen——
Comment on this
I submit that is gross hypocrisy in a nation in which the normal instinct, I might say, is gambling. An unfortunate elderly man or woman can derive amusement from these games even though they are not able, due to age or for other reasons, to go to Shelbourne Park or Harold's Cross——
Comment on this
——where there is no control. The State is very glad to bring the tote into the greyhound tracks now. It is recognised that the State can derive revenue there as it already derives revenue from the racehorses. I am very glad that Deputy McQuillan supported me on this point —I would be quite satisfied with a stake of 6d. if the punter were protected. But he is getting no protection. He can play all night and 40 games would cost him £1 but if he wins one game he gets only 10/-. Perhaps a percentage could be brought into the Bill or the figure of 10/- could be raised to 30/-?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley is quite incorrect in saying that revenue from either horse or greyhound racing is derived purposefully and by way of recognising horse-racing and dog-racing and thereby recognising gambling. The amount of revenue that is got is only incidental. The purpose of the revenue and the purpose of dealing with the greyhound racing by the tote is—so far as horse-racing is concerned —to encourage the bloodstock industry and in the case of the dogs to see if we can regulate greyhound racing in the interests of the public generally.
Comment on this
We must also remember that the showman's business gives a good deal of employment. We can have no doubt about that. I think the 6d. stake is correct but I think when you limit the stake to 6d. that in itself will control the prize money. I suggest that the promoter be allowed to fix the prize. As the Deputies know, you might have 60 people in one of these places in one day and you might have only 20 the next. I suggest that it should be left to whoever is running the show to limit the stake money.
Comment on this
I am not asking that the showman should take £5 and pay out £4 10s. They would be glad to do that. I suggest that they should be allowed to fix the prize money in fairness to the stake.
Comment on this
I ask Deputies to consider that the purpose of this Bill is not to encourage gambling but to discourage it. If the Deputy makes the case that we ought to encourage gambling then that is a matter to be considered. Do you want to encourage gambling or not?
Comment on this
I do not think my suggestion would encourage it half as much as having betting offices all over this city and other cities.
Comment on this
Arising out of matters mentioned by the Taoiseach—he said the main interest in encouraging the tote was in the interests of the bloodstock industry and that a new Bill to encourage the greyhound industry would also be introduced—I appreciate that, but nevertheless the whole system of totalisation and betting has operated to the benefit of successive Governments. Last year £5,750,000 was wagered on racecourses and another £6,000,000 in bookmakers' offices, making a total of £11,750,000 wagered last year in this country, and look at the substantial cut which the Government took from that. The amount of money wagered on the totalisator was £1,936,000.
Comment on this
The tote took its cut for the advancement of the bloodstock industry but the Government took their cut from the bookmakers.
Comment on this
You cannot include with the bookmakers what the tote takes. They are two different things.
Comment on this
An amount of £11,750,000 was wagered last year in bookmakers' offices and on the course and the Minister is talking about a limit of 10/- to discourage gambling.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the amendment has been brought in in order to cut out gambling as far as the poorer section of the community is concerned. I am sure the Minister can produce any number of letters in connection with widows who have been left without anything for themselves and their children because of this terrible game of pongo. That, I understand, is one of the reasons why this particular section has been introduced to this Bill—to prevent people from spending all their wages on a game of pongo. Yet we have bookmakers' offices scattered all over the country and only last week I saw applications by three different individuals to set up fresh bookmakers' offices in an already overcrowded area.
In these bookmakers' offices a man can gamble away his whole week's wages and leave his wife and family without anything to live on for the remainder of the week.
On the other hand, if a poor family go to the sea and if the mother and father and the older children go to an establishment where pongo is played, they go there to meet their friends and have a friendly chat. There is some kind of social amenity in this but, nevertheless, they have to be saved from themselves by limiting the amount of money they can make in a bet. I am not objecting to placing a limit on the amount they can bet, but I have not heard any serious reason advanced why there should be any limit on the amount they can win. If there is a feeling in the House that there should be a limit surely the amount of 10/- is a partly one when the value of the £1 to-day is only 8/6 in comparison with what it was in 1938.
The place where pongo is played performs a social function in many areas and I think it is far better to have people going into such places and spending a few bob and perhaps winning a £1 or 30/- than to have them going into a bookmaker's shop and losing all their wages and leaving their wives and children without means of subsistence. If we are serious about preventing gambling why not tackle the matter at the proper point? Do not attack that section of the community which is the weakest and the most vulnerable.
I know well that if the Government is serious about tackling gambling they will keep far away from the bookmakers because these people can protect themselves and they form another very strong vested interest. If we have these strong vested interest talking back to the Government they will be listened to, but there is nobody to speak for the poor individual who walks into a pongo school and lays a bet of 6d. and then is told by the proprietor that by law 10/- is all that he can win.
Comment on this
It seems to me that there is a considerable amount of misapprehension about this section.
Comment on this
You are still encouraging gambling. It must be remembered, as I say in connection with the misapprehension, that at the present moment all this kind of thing is illegal. We could have left them there and not brought this Bill in at all. What we are doing is providing reasonable facilities under the law so that the law will not be brought into disrepute as it has been in the past by the law being enforced in some places and not in others. We are giving a position where people can come into a particular circus or show, knowing that they are doing something legal, something reasonable and something which is not encouraging gambling.
Deputies must make up their minds whether they want to encourage gambling or not. If they want to discourage gambling for high stakes and to leave the position where there will be a reasonable amount of amusement without the excitement of heavy gambling, I suggest the section in the Bill is the proper approach. The House should make its choice. To bring in the number of betting shops that there are around the country or the fact that betting on horse-racing is allowed is entirely irrelevant to the present consideration.
My recollection is that the imposition of the duty on bets and the provisions in regard to betting shops were brought in, not for the purpose, primarily, of raising revenue, although it did that incidentally and does it now, but for the purpose of regulating something which was going on anyway in an illicit fashion and bringing it out into the open. Before the betting tax was put on there were, as we knew as students—I knew—betting men around the corners of the streets, taking slips and going to the bookies.
Comment on this
That is the trouble. It may be that there is an evil there. I am very far from saying that there is not.
Comment on this
There are only two points I want to make. If betting shops are wrong, why should we try to put the pongo shops in competition with them? Why should we try to make the prizes more attractive, to take them away from the betting shops, if betting and betting shops are wrong?
The second point is this: pongo places are not full all the time. The seats around the table are not fully taken up. Very often the proprietor has to put up the prize to attract a crowd and he gets very little out of it. He is not operating the whole year round, whereas the betting shop is operating the whole year round.
Comment on this
Judging by this debate it would appear that some Deputies never play pongo. Pongo is another name for house, which has always been condemned in this country. The game is called pongo, baseball, lineup and by other names in order to get around the difficulty. When there is a small crowd at a pongo stall in a carnival the cards are only 2d. and the proprietor gets half the collection and puts so much into the pool. If the pool is not won to-night, the crowd goes back on the following night. I have known cases where the cards were anything from 6d. to 1/-. When pongo started first there was a limit to the number of cards of 38. As time went on there was no limit on the cards and the showman had the big advantage, instead of the people who were playing. That is the case at every show, even those organised for charity.
Forget about the seaside for the moment. Think of towns where charity bazaars were organised. Men and women were losing their wages, playing up to one o'clock at night, waiting for the shilling card or trying to win the pool. That is why some protection for these people is necessary. In the city and towns and throughout the country pongo is played under various names and the working people are fleeced. I often lost 50/-. One night there were two of us to divide the prize. I got 5/- and my partner got 5/-. There could be 100 cards out. That is where you need the protection, to limit the number. In that way you would be doing something to help the player. The showman should not be allowed to issue up to 80 cards and give only the same prize as he would give if there were 30 people playing.
Reference has been made to horse-racing and dog-racing. The poor people that I have in mind do not attend such race meetings. It costs 10/- to go into the ring and therefore the workers do not go there. It costs 2/6 to get into a greyhound track. These two things are entirely different from pongo. They were legalised by the Fianna Fáil Government and betting shops were licensed.
Comment on this
My experience of showmen is that they are as decent a lot of men as any other men in the country.
Comment on this
I think it is very unfair to be talking about them in this way. If anything is to be limited, I prefer that we should limit the stake to a smaller amount and give a fair prize for it. If you are serious about doing away with gambling, why not limit the stake to 3d. and leave the 10/-? I have played pongo and I think the fairest way is that the prize would be limited according to the number of players and the number of stakes received.
Comment on this
At a travelling show or circus how are you ever going to limit it to the number of players?
Comment on this
We are all agreed on that. Are you going to leave it wide open, to have it as big a game as anyone likes to put it?
Comment on this
I think the Taoiseach's suggestion would solve everything. He suggested 60 players at 2d., that is 10/-. Ten shillings would be split and 5/- would be retained. In the Bill, 6d. is the stake. Therefore, why not leave the maximum prize 30/- and everyone would be satisfied?
Comment on this
Is it not being overlooked that by giving a higher return of 30/- or £2 to the person who hazards the stake you are seeing that he is not skinned or robbed and does not lose excessively? If the winnings are raised from 10/- to 30/- does not that guarantee that a person who wins goes home with a lot more in his pocket?
Comment on this
That is all right if he wins but if he does not win, he loses just as much.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:—
To add to the section the following new sub-section:—
(2) For the purpose of paragraph (b) of sub-section (1), the promotion of a lottery shall be deemed to be the carrying on of gaming.
The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that a circus or travelling show may not, having had gaming for ten days at a place, then proceed to operate lotteries and thus prolong the playing of gambling games outside the intention of the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:—
To delete paragraph (c) and substitute:—
(c) gaming at the event does not extend over a period exceeding one month, and.
The provision, as it stands, refers to the period for which the carnival or other event is organised. What we are really concerned with, however, in the Bill is, of course, the gaming at the carnival, and as this is so, I suggest that the time limit should apply only to the gaming and not to the carnival itself. It is not a point of much practical importance but, for the sake of consistency, the amendment is desirable.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:—
At the end of paragraph (e) to insert "and" and to add to the section the following paragraphs:—
(f) no player may win more than the value of 10/- in each game, and
(g) neither taking part in nor the result of a game entitles the player to take part in any other game or lottery or otherwise to receive or be eligible to compete for any money or money's worth, and
(h) notice in writing of the dates of gaming at the event has been previously given by the promoter to the sergeant in charge of the local Garda Síochána station.
This is similar to amendment No. 9 made in Section 6 which specifies the value of prizes and notice to the police of the dates when gaming is carried on.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:—
To add to the section the following new sub-section:—
(2) For the purpose of paragraph (c) of sub-section (1), the promotion of a lottery shall be deemed to be the carrying on of gaming.
This is similar to amendment No. 10 on Section 6 and is for the same purpose, to ensure that, if lotteries and gaming are carried on at a carnival, the overall period within which they may be carried on is one month.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:—
Before Section 8 to insert the following new section:—
8.—(1) In this section—
"qualified individual" means an individual who, during the period of 12 months preceding a given date, has had his usual or principal place of residence in the State;
"qualified company" means a body corporate in the case of which both a majority of the members and a majority of the persons exercising control and management are qualified individuals.
(2) Nothing in Section 6 or Section 7 shall render it lawful for a person to promote, assist in promoting or provide facilities for gaming to which Section 4 applies unless—
(a) that person is a qualified individual or a qualified company, and
(b) if that person is acting on behalf of another person, that other person is also a qualified individual or a qualified company or an unincorporated body of persons, each member of which is a qualified individual.
(3) This section does not apply to an individual who is merely assisting in the promotion of gaming in accordance with a contract of service.
This amendment proposes to put in a residence qualification for persons promoting gaming at travelling shows, carnivals and so on. There is another amendment, amendment No. 20, to be moved later, the effect of which will be to apply the same test to applicants for licences for amusement halls and funfairs. The need for a residence qualification arises from the very nature of the business; the promotion of gaming is particularly open to sharp practice and fraud. It is, therefore, desirable that those engaged in this business should be living here, so that if there are grounds for criminal proceedings or grounds for complaint, the person concerned will be available to answer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:—
Before sub-section (3) to insert the following new sub-section:—
( ) This section does not apply to the playing of a game where no stake is hazarded by the players other than a charge for the right to take part in the game, provided that—
(a) only one such charge is made in respect of the day on which the game is played, and
(b) the charge is of the same amount for all the players, and (c) the promoter (if any) derives no personal profit from the promotion of the game.
As Section 8 stood, the prohibition on gaming, defined in Section 2, on licensed premises might be held to include the playing of collective games, such as whist or bridge drives, or darts or ring competitions which are generally promoted for charitable or sociable purposes. This amendment will enable games played in such circumstances to be carried on without infringing the law.
Comment on this
I will allow the Deputy to make the point, but the amendment was put to the House and nobody spoke, so I declared it carried.
Comment on this
Sub-section 1 of amendment No. 14 says:—
"‘Qualified individual' means an individual who, during the period of 12 months preceding a given date, has had his usual or principal place of residence in the State".
The words to which I object are "has had his usual or principal place of residence in the State". I respectfully submit that the interpretation of that is going to lead to the greatest difficulty, and it is very important that there should be no doubt at all in the mind of the district justice or any other person as to what "a qualified individual" means. I submit that the present definition is much too lax and ambiguous and will give rise to a lot of difficulties. For instance, if a very big English bookmaker has a mansion down in Buckinghamshire and another mansion in Ballsbridge, which is his principal place of residence?
Comment on this
Why can it not be set down in a common-sense way, such as "where he lives for the greater part of the year"?
Comment on this
That is a question of fact, too. If the Deputy will not mind my interrupting him—this phrase "usual or principal place of residence" was the phrase suggested by the draftsman as being the one least likely to cause any difficulty and one which has been interpreted by court decisions from time to time, so that most lawyers know where they stand on it. If we depart from it and set down any other definition, it will lead to far more trouble than the Deputy imagines.
Comment on this
Sub-section (1) proposes that the licensee of premises licensed for the sale of intoxicating liquor shall not permit gaming on the premises. It is gaming which is not permitted on the premises and gaming, as defined, means playing a game for stakes hazarded by the players. I should like to make it clear that, as I understand the Bill now, we are forbidding the playing of games on licensed premises, such as "rings", which are played on licensed premises for a small stake and other similar types of games played very frequently in such premises throughout the country. We are prohibiting these types of games taking place on licensed premises.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 15 deals with that position. It allows darts and bridge and whist drives in hotels and that class of thing.
Comment on this
Is it not clear beyond any question of yea or nay that, when this Bill becomes law, a publican can play any game—whist, forty-five, or poker—in a portion of the premises where drink is not usually served, if the players are friends of his and if he entertains them and pays for the drink himself? Is it not definite that, when the Bill becomes law, whist, poker, forty-five and darts can be played on every licensed premises?
Comment on this
The law at the moment is that you cannot play them and even cannot play bridge or whist, and it is in order to ease that position that the amendment was put in.
Comment on this
I think it is going to ease a few people out of the licensed premises. When speaking on the Second Reading the Minister said:—
"Section 8, which prohibits gaming on licensed premises, and Section 10 which provides penalties for cheating, are simply restating existing law. It is intended, however, that where there is only one charge in respect of the day on which the game is played, the charge will not constitute part of the stakes hazarded by the player and in consequence playing of games such as whist or rings or darts, in which there are no side-stakes, but in which the player hazards his entry fee in a competition to win a prize will not come within the definition of gaming and will not be prohibited on licensed premises. This is simply a case of removing the technical offence which is at present committed by the operation of some of these harmless games in public-houses, licensed hotels and clubs."
That means, if what the Minister states is correct, that darts can be played for a bottle of whiskey. Darts could be played with a bottle of whiskey as a prize. A game of forty-five could be played——
Comment on this
I am glad to hear that. Sub-section (2) of Section 8 states:—
"This section shall not prohibit the licensee or his private friends—"
Have some of us public friends?
Comment on this
I think the word is superfluous.
"This section shall not prohibit the licensee or his private friends from playing cards for stakes in a part of the premises other than that in which the sale of intoxicating liquor generally takes place."
Everything in this Bill is governed by "generally" and the Bill is full of ambiguities. Why did the Minister not state that he would have to take them up to his private sitting-room or the private portion of his house? He could sell drink three or four times during the year and I am just trying to envisage what will happen if vigilant young Guards read up these provisions.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:—
In sub-section (1), lines 12 and 13, to delete "that is to say, any machine".
This is a drafting amendment and the purpose of it is to make quite clear that the section does not prohibit all slot machines used for gaming. Slot machines not used for gaming are not, of course, affected by the Bill. There is no ground for believing that machines used for the sale of cigarettes or chocolates are prohibited. The Bill prohibits only those slot machines which deliver cash prizes or tokens, which the promoter undertakes to exchange for cash or which would operate the machine again; in other words, the Bill prohibits machines such as the "Bell-fruit" machine; it prohibits them whether operated in the ordinary way or by a token coin.
Comment on this
That is not the statement the Minister has just made. He said that all machines apart from those used for the sale of cigarettes or chocolates would be prohibited. Will he give an example of the type of machine and the type of prize he has in mind? Some type of machine was mentioned by the Minister.
Comment on this
The one-armed band. I wonder would the Minister specify the type of machine. I think the best description is what is known as the claw lever type. By the insertion of a coin and the manipulation of handles one can take out a box of chocolates or a cigarette lighter perhaps.
Comment on this
They are not caught. Perhaps it is only fair to say they may be caught under another section but permitted to be carried on under the provisions of that section.
Comment on this
No. They are not, the absolutely prohibited slot machine, the one that gives money or money's worth or a token that can be exchanged for money.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:—
At the end of paragraph (c) to insert "and" and to add to the section the following paragraphs:—
(d) no player may win more than the value of 10/- in each game, and
(e) neither taking part in nor the result of a game entitles the player to take part in any other game or lottery or otherwise to receive or be eligible to compete for any money or money's worth.
This amendment is similar to amendment No. 9 in Section 6 and amendment No. 12 in Section 7; the same considerations apply.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:—
Before sub-section (3) to insert the following new sub-section:—
(3) A certificate shall not be granted unless the applicant shows that he is not disqualified by Section 8 from the promotion of gaming under Section 6 or Section 7.
This is a consequential amendment. The purpose of this amendment is to apply to applicants for amusement hall licences the residence qualification which has already been discussed in connection with the promotion of gaming at travelling shows, Section 6, and carnivals, Section 7.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:—
Before sub-section (3) to insert the following new sub-section:—
(3) It shall be a condition of the grant of a certificate that music or announcements of any kind whatsoever shall not be broadcast by any method from an amusement hall so as to be audible outside such amusement hall.
The wording of the amendment may not be altogether satisfactory. It is not my intention to interfere with fancy fairs or carnivals which broadcast from fields or public parks. The case I have in mind is that affecting the city business centre. In O'Connell Street at night one will hear a musical broadcast from one of the principle restaurant windows in order to draw attention to the trade. This is not a very pleasant practice. Down in Talbot Street there are two public halls vying with one another in trying to attract patrons. There, music is blared forth from morning until night and the result is that the ordinary business people cannot carry on their trade to their satisfaction. This is a great nuisance to traders. I appeal to the Minister to consider the matter and take some steps to stop this interference with traders in the centre of the city. I do not want to interfere with the musical attractions provided at seaside resorts during the holiday period but I do not think this practice should be permitted in the heart of the city. It is disconcerting to find this practice in the principal street in Ireland, O'Connell Street. There should be some method of control. Another type of business has crept into Grafton Street. I refer to the public auction.
Comment on this
I did not think it would be tolerated there. So far they have not taken to ringing a bell. I appeal to the Minister to consider some favourable amendment of the Bill to deal with the situation I have outlined in the interests of the traders who have complained.
Comment on this
I should like to draw the attention of the House and of the Minister to the fact that this amendment, if accepted, could be very dangerous. The abuses which Deputy Byrne has in mind could go on even if this amendment were accepted. The danger is that if this suggested improvement were applicable to dance-halls a crank living beside a dance-hall could object and have his objection sustained to some kind of legitimate amusement. I know the outrage some of these blaring amplifiers cause in built-up areas particularly during election times.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:—
To delete sub-section (4) and substitute:—
(4) The certificate shall specify the period in the particular year to which it relates for which the licence is to be issued.
I feel this amendment will have general acceptance. It leaves it to the courts to decide the period within which an amusement hall may operate in any year. Acceptance of the amendment involves rejection of amendments Nos. 23 and 24.
Comment on this
The section as it stands provides that the certificate shall specify the period for which the licence is to be issued, beginning not earlier than Easter Sunday on any year and ending not later than the 30th September, in the same year, as the courts might decide. There is something in the Minister's amendment that would leave it to the discretion of the courts but I cannot see from a practical viewpoint why the certificate should not run for the whole year in the same way as dance-hall licences run for 12 months. I would suggest to the Minister that in the interest of uniformity the section would specify a yearly licence.
I would suggest there is no good reason against that. If there is one thing more than anything else that tends to bring the law into disrespect it is to have different interpretations given on similar issues by different district justices. This House is the place in which the period of the licence should be defined and I see no reason why the House should not do so; I can see no reason why it should be left to the discretion of the district justices to interpret the period during which a licence should run because from a practical point of view the place to decide the duration of the licence is here. We should not leave it, willy-nilly, to the discretion of every district justice throughout the land.
Comment on this
Is there to be no reply to Deputy Moran's point about the varying interpretations which district justices make in these matters? Justices who we assume take their duties very seriously in matters like this are placed in an unenviable position because other justices in other areas might treat their duties lightly. There should be some uniformity of practice in a matter of kind.
Comment on this
I think it was not intended that any disrespect should be shown to Deputy Moran's point. I think it was decided it was better to leave it to the District Court to fix the period of the certificate rather than to have us here putting down our foot about a certain period which would cover the entire country. Such a decision of ours would cover different areas where different conditions obtain. In some parts of the country a month might be adequate while in others 12 months might be desirable. Interested parties, we thought, might make a case in the courts. In the City of Dublin there are certain hall owners who want to stay open all the year round. They can go into the court and make the case that this has been the practice for years and that it should continue. They can give their reasons to the court. You have remote country areas where a month might be sufficient and I think if Deputy Moran goes into the thing carefully he will see it is better that there should be different periods for different areas because the circumstances alter according to the different parts of the country. Anybody interested who has a case for a 12 months' licence can make it before the judicial authority.
Comment on this
Why, in no section of this Bill, is there provision whereby the District Court must take into consideration the standard of construction of buildings when applications are made before it?
Comment on this
It can be done under sub-sections (c) and (f) of Section 16, which deal with suitability of premises.
Comment on this
Does that cover existing premises, some of which are in a deplorable condition at the moment?
Comment on this
I would again ask the Minister to consider the point I raised and have an amendment brought in on Report Stage. I believe serious consideration should be given to the desirability of having these licences run for a year and not to leave the matter to the discretion of the different district justices. I can see the point the Taoiseach has made, particularly in relation to Dublin, where this thing has been going on for years, but the point is that by this Bill we are legalising something that up to the moment was held to be illegal. I think there should be uniformity as to the duration of these licences. I think the Taoiseach's point does not apply here because I suggest that in this Bill we are taking steps to legalise something that has been accepted for 100 years as illegal. We are creating a new law and I suggest the duration of the licence should be the same as in the case of dance-hall licences. We all know that different district justices have different views and different approaches. You have some district justices who look upon pongo or roulette as being worse than original sin, whereas you have another justice who possibly himself has played the games and regards them as harmless.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy help us by suggesting the period for which he suggests the licence should be granted?
Comment on this
A year. I am suggesting that if the applicant fulfils all the other necessary conditions he should be able to apply for and get a yearly licence just in the same way as the dance-hall owner who may apply for a yearly licence even though he may hold a dance only once a month. The way I am suggesting is, to my mind, the only practical way. What is sauce for the goose should be sauce for the gander.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:—
Before Section 15 to insert the following new section:—
15.—(1) No application for an amusement caterer's licence (other than a temporary amusement caterer's licence for a defined period not exceeding two months) shall be made or entertained unless the person making such application has, at least one month before the hearing of such application, published a notice of his intention to make such application in a newspaper circulating in the district in which is situate the place to which such application relates.
(2) Every person applying to the District Court for the grant of an amusement caterer's licence shall—
(a) in case of an application for a temporary amusement caterer's licence for a definite period not exceeding two months give to the superintendent of the Garda Síochána and the secretary or town clerk of any public authority within whose district and whose functional area respectively is situate the place to which such application relates at least seven days' notice in writing of such application, and
(b) in every other case, give at least six weeks' notice in writing to the superintendent of the Garda Síochána within whose district and to the public authority within whose functional area is situate the place to which such application relates.
(3) The notices specified in subsections (1) and (2) hereof shall state the number and kinds of games proposed to be carried on and the other forms of amusement to be provided.
This goes back to what I suggested here on the Second Stage. My reason for putting down this amendment is to point out to the House that under Section 15 the procedure prescribed would in my opinion be unworkable, that is that "the intending applicant for a certificate shall give 28 days' notice in writing of his intention to each local authority within whose administrative area the premises to which the application relates are situate and to the superintendent of the Garda Síochána for the locality", and that "the notice shall state the number and kinds of games proposed to be carried on and the other forms of amusement to be provided", and that "the applicant shall also cause a notice of his intention to be published at least 14 days before the hearing in a newspaper circulating in the locality".
This would mean that the intending applicant for this licence would have to start off by giving one month's notice to each local authority, and that might mean a county council, an urban council and town commissioners, and to the superintendent of the Gardaí. Then he must also cause notice of his intention to be published 14 days before the hearing in a newspaper circulating in the area. My objection to that matter is that this—and I think there are other sections which would also come into this matter—makes the procedure that is proposed under this Bill in its entirety very cumbersome. Local authorities, as envisaged originally under the Bill, would have to consult between themselves, come to a decision as to whether they would in fact allow the man to operate in their area, and then all this other cumbersome procedure would have to be gone through.
What I am suggesting is that notice would be served on them, as I have set out in my proposed amendment, and then it is open to the local authority to come in and object or record their objection before the district justice who will be hearing the application. I think from the factual point of view, this is the way the matter should be approached. I think the procedure is cumbersome as laid down in the Bill at present and that it would really be beyond the applicant's ability to comply with the regulations as laid down. The different periods set out are cumbersome and wrong. Under the procedure as proposed in this amendment, the local authorities will get due notice and if they wish to come in and object they may do so as they do come in to object to dance-hall licences because they consider the halls structurally unsuitable, or need alterations, or that the number of people attending them should be limited. They would have all these facilities to do that. I think the same procedure should be adopted here so that the local authorities could explain their views and ask for any limitations that might be desirable before the court at which the application is being heard. I do not know whether the Minister has considered this matter since I made the point when speaking on the Second Stage. I do not know the Minister's views now and I would like to hear from him.
Comment on this
Section 15 provides that advance notice of intention to apply for a licence must be given to the local authority and to the superintendent of the Gardaí and further that a notice must be published before the application is heard. This gives the opportunity to parties resident in the area to come in and object if they so desire. Deputy Moran's amendment would nullify the whole spirit of the Bill. It would give a chance to individuals without any licences to come into an area and exploit the people. Therefore, I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I still do not quite understand what the Minister's intentions are under the Bill. I shall summarise it briefly and I want to know if this is the position. Does the Minister contemplate that, first, an amusement caterer has to apply to the local authority, that they then have to sit down solemnly and decide whether they should allow him to have a licence or not? Having gone through that he has to come along then under this proposed court procedure and give a month's notice. Then he must give 14 days' notice in the newspapers before the court application. If I am misreading this, the Minister will no doubt correct me but that is the way is appears to me.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is misinterpreting it—I hope I am not. Under the section as it stands, all one is required to do is to give notice of his intention to apply for a certificate of the court under Section 16 within 28 days. One also gives notice in the newspapers. The section merely provides for the giving of notice to the local authority and to the Gardaí in order that if they wish, they may come in and be heard in court just as notice must be given if there is an application for a new licence. The local authority has not to sit at all; they merely get the notice. If they do not wish to come into court, they do not have to.
Comment on this
If the Taoiseach is correct, I will accept that. There is only one other matter arising and that is the proposal to allow for a temporary licence. It may and will happen, obviously, in practice that people who did not consider applying say at the annual licensing court, would if applying later have to give at least one month's notice, then 14 days' notice by publication. I want to know if the Minister has considered the position of an applicant who by force of circumstances or for some particular reason would apply possibly for one licence for a special event?
I want to know whether the Minister has considered the position of the applicant who, by force of circumstances, or for some particular reason, would apply, perhaps, for only one licence for a special event and possibly for a very short time. What I want to provide for is that in that case he could, without wasting all this time, apply for a temporary licence for a week or a month or for whatever period he requires it. The Minister can visualise the case of a very small travelling showman who leaves one town after a couple of days and goes on to the next. He may be only waiting in one town for two or three days or for a week. Under this Bill as it stands he cannot wait in any town at all because he cannot get a licence.
This section applies only to a man with fixed premises in Dublin or who sets up in a seaside resort such as Galway or Tramore for three or four months of the year. Such a man will be thinking of making his application for a licence three months before the summer season will begin. He will have his notices furnished and the newspaper advertisements published and so on. But take the position of the small man who moves around from place to place and week by week. Such a man would want a multiplicity of licences to operate under the section as it is drafted. He would want a separate compartment for legal advisers and it would be practically impossible for him to keep track of the applications in every county and possibly in every big town. He could not possibly operate otherwise or he would be breaking the law.
I suggest that the Minister should accept a procedure whereby a particular person who is not staying in one place for any more than 14 days or a month can apply for a licence without publishing the notices in the newspapers or giving notice to the local authorities. I suggest that such a man, at 48 hours' notice, could go into the local Guards and then go into court and get a licence. That kind of man has not been provided for in this Bill.