Forestry Bill, 1955—Second Stage.
Contributions 141–287 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1955 ›
If it is not I will be very glad to hear the Minister say otherwise but what I have said is what I have read.
Comment on this
No, it is not. That man will have the same freedom on the portion he will be left as he had over the whole lot before.
Comment on this
How can he have the same freedom in the confined space of one acre as he would have in 100 times that space?
Comment on this
He would not own it but he would have freedom to move over the common. The Minister is getting away from the point that he himself has made. If the Minister wants to contradict that, and that is not his intention, that he does not want to squeeze these people out, that he is going to take the gun if necessary to defend them, let him say so, and more power to him if he does. But he cannot speak with two tongues, one on the motion last week and another on the Bill to-night. He cannot ride two horses at the one time going in opposite directions. That is an impossible task for the Minister of all people and I would ask him to try to get himself out of that predicament when he is replying.
Comment on this
If it does not take the Minister as long as getting in the other night when he had the opportunity and would not take it. In regard to the Bill proper, it is difficult to get around to it because there is so much talk that is not relevant at all. Let us consider that Bill as it now stands. It is something which the Minister feels will give power to the Forestry Division that they do not enjoy and because of the lack of that power to take over land the Minister feels our forestry and reafforestation programme has been rather curtailed. First and foremost, I agree that is so in very many cases although not in all cases. However, we want to deal with this matter as meeting the needs of the majority of cases. Therefore, I feel that this part of the Bill dealing with the acquisition of commonages is something that will attain the end we have in view and had in view in our Private Members' motion discussed here last week.
Let me say that the second part of that motion has been completely overlooked by the Minister so far as registration is concerned. He has not given any concrete proof that those increased activities of the Land Commission that we all hoped for will take place in the West of Ireland, in the congested areas and along the west coast generally. He does go along talking in figures and percentages, some of which are not very convincing. One, for instance, that I came across just a little while ago, he mentioned the other night. I hope all the Minister's conclusions are not based on such figures, because very little weight could be placed upon them. The Minister said, at column 901, Volume 153, of the Official debates of the 16th November, 1955:—
"...at 31st March, 1955, the total area of land held for forestry purposes in the congested districts was 95,000 acres. In March, 1943, the area was 36,000: therefore, over a period of 12 years, we have practically trebled the area of land devoted to forestry in these regions."
If that is a conclusion that the Minister can stand over I believe that he is wasting his time in this House. If, by having on hands to-day 95,000 acres of land as against 36,000 12 years ago, anyone could hold that we have trebled our acreage devoted to forestry in a particular region, he must be a genius. As a matter of fact, it could well be, from those figures, we are doing less in the congested areas to-day than we were, though I am not saying we are because I do know we are doing something more. But to base an argument on the grounds that because you have to-day more lands on hands in those areas than you had 12 years ago, you have trebled your area of land devoted to forestry in that region, is absolutely ridiculous and should be corrected for the purpose of keeping our records at least fairly straight in the House. What I am trying to get at is that the Minister came along with other figures later on to prove how much he was doing in the western regions. I hope the figures quoted are a little more reliable for the purpose of drawing conclusions than those two figures quoted earlier.
The Minister went on to say that at the present time 38 per cent. of the total planted each year is now being planted in the western regions. Does the Minister consider that 38 per cent. is enough?
Comment on this
Could we not then get some proper reply from the Minister? Asking the Minister if 50 per cent. was not enough or if 75 per cent. was too much, is a question that the Minister naturally would not answer. He did not answer it for the reasons I have but for the reason that he is afraid to say whether it should be 50 per cent., 70 per cent. or 80 per cent. The real point, however, is, 50 per cent. of what? Is it going to be 50 per cent. or 40 per cent. of 12,000 acres, 15,000, 20,000 or 30,000 acres. That is really what I want to get and that is where I am afraid the Minister will fall down on this job. By the tone of his speech to-night he has completely somersaulted from the state where he described himself as a fanatic about this business of forestry. Does the Minister still regard himself as a fanatic in putting forestry ahead?
Comment on this
The Minister still believes the word "fanatic" was correctly used in that direction.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture should take himself off to some quiet corner and learn a little about the Department he is in instead of fussing and buzzing in here about something of which he knows nothing.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary would allow me I would proceed. He is not as good on that side of the House as he was on this.
Comment on this
He is in the wrong place to get away with interruptions. It does not do him any good; it does not do the Government, any good and that might be dangerous to his position.
In regard to this matter of the western regions getting a fair deal in reafforestation, the Minister has not given us any hope in this Bill and, if he has given us any hope anywhere else, he certainly has not enshrined it in the Bill. The western regions are well suited to reafforestation. There the land is available. The people are available and employment is needed in those areas for these people and afforestation is the only means of employing them. The Minister is well aware of all this. He comes from the West. I do not intend to rehash the reasons for a larger share of planting in the West.
I do want to get from the Minister why he has not indicated in his speech here to-night a firm promise that he will agree to the terms of the motion that was put down last week and will give to the West, the western seaboard, the north-west between 60 to 70 per cent. of the total annual plantation. The Minister is not prepared to go further than to say that he has already mentioned the figure of 44 per cent. I question very much whether or not 44 per cent. is an accurate figure. The figure that I have in writing at the moment is at column 904 of the speech of the Minister last Wednesday. It says 38 per cent. We can take that figure. That figure is much too low. I want the Minister to realise that. In this Bill, he has yet an opportunity. There is still time to bring in something that will indicate and will ensure, no matter what Minister may follow, whether he is from the East, West, South or North, that the western regions, the undeveloped areas, the congested districts, the Fior-Ghaeltacht, will get their due and will get from this House and from this Government a reafforestation programme suited to their needs.
In those areas afforestation can do much more good than it is doing in the other parts of the country in which it is being carried on and afforestation is the only thing that can be done in those areas. Why not get it done? Why should not the Minister, as Minister for Lands and as a westerner, ensure that that will be secured, not only for next year or the year after, but for the years to come and that afforestation will become associated with the West and the undeveloped areas to a very large extent?
The Minister has failed utterly in regard to that matter. I would ask him, even at this stage, to try to get down to this matter and even on Committee Stage to enshrine something in the Bill that will give as a right to the West, a much higher percentage of the annual planting than is being given at the moment and, by putting that in the Bill, ensure that the West cannot get less in future.
The Minister may say that planting carried out in the West has increased over the years, from 22 to 44 per cent., allowing him his own figures. The fact remains that if the total number of acres planted each year should fall for any reason, the number of acres planted in the West will fall. I know that at the moment in my county there is an unlimited amount of land available for plantation, which should be planted. That applies to every county in the West. The Minister can do this job if he wants to do it and I would appeal to him to get down to it and to have it done. The Minister should not let other people, either in the Cabinet or in his Party or in other Parties, put him off his track. He should not allow them to turn him from being a fanatic in regard to plantations into someone who would take the view of the man from the East and give the East the same as the West. The East is getting much more in many other directions. Here is something that can be given to the West and more of which can be given to the West. I ask the Minister to give it. Do not be misled by others. Do not be pushed into the position of letting down Connacht men by failing to grasp this opportunity.
I ask the Minister to see to it that what I advocate will be done and that in future we will have a greater annual planting programme over-all and that the percentage of the total planting done in any year that will be carried out in the West will be in the region of 50 to 75. The Minister can do that. I am asking him to do it. If he does not do it, he will have his own people to answer and the people from the West in general will give their answer in due course. On the other hand, if the Minister should do this job in the right way and look after the interests of his constituencies and these other areas, he will get his just reward at the next election.
The Minister made some points here to-night in regard to overplanting. He based his remarks, I take it, on advice from the experts. One of the things suggested was that if more timber was planted than is regarded as necessary for the home market, there would be a surplus and that that would be disastrous. Is there no export? Is there no output of any kind for timber?
Comment on this
The Minister to-night said, in so many words, that if we passed a certain figure of plantation in a year and continued at that rate, if we passed a given figure somewhere around 12,500 acres, we would be exceeding our home requirements.
Comment on this
What does the Minister propose to do with what exceeds our home requirements? When he made that statement about 12,500 acres, was not the Minister trying to indicate that it would be a bad thing or a difficult thing if we found ourselves in 40 or 50 years' time with more timber than we needed?
Comment on this
The Minister here in this House to-night—if he wants now to deny it—indicated in so many words that timber in excess of our requirements will be produced in 40 or 50 years' time if we plant annually a greater amount that 12,500 acres.
Comment on this
In quoting that figure, possibly, I am being rather uncharitable to the Minister but I do not think so. He said a number of other things.
Comment on this
I am not deliberately misquoting what was said. I believe that the Minister is well able to look after himself, without a legal adviser in the second row as he had when Deputy MacBride was in the House and when he was attacked.
Comment on this
I will not be too severe on the Minister. I am only trying to get this straight. It is not straight. Perhaps that is something with which the Party to which Deputy Collins belongs are rather familiar and perhaps that is why he can see through something that is crooked and I cannot. If I have got the wrong slant on the matter I will ask the Minister to indicate that now. Is the Minister afraid that the surplus timber that might be produced in 40 or 50 years' time would cause a problem?
Comment on this
Of course the Minister did. I have quoted what the Minister said and the Minister has agreed that he said it.
Comment on this
I gave a figure of 12,500 acres and I never mentioned a word about exports. If we were in a position to export the produce of 12,500 acres. after supplying our own needs, it would be a very happy position.
Comment on this
You and the whole Government would go floating down the river after it, just as in the case of Tulyar, if you got money for it and dollars at that. There is timber from Kerry lying in Dun Laoghaire at the moment and I wonder if it is for the construction of a raft upon which the Government can float out after they have gone to Limerick next month.
Comment on this
Interruptions must cease and I must say that I have very little sympathy for people who invite interruptions. I say that to both sides of the House.
Comment on this
The Minister referred to the possibility that there may be a surplus of timer in this country 50 years hence as a result of the action of himself and the Government. Is he worried that there may be? Did he state to-night that he is worried that in 50 years from now there may be a surplus of timber in this country? Is the Minister worried or is he not? That is all I want to know. If he is, has he considered that the population may be much greater in that time, and that our needs may be much greater and that we may be using much more timber than we are to-day? On the other hand there is the possibility that we may not need timber at all. I feel that if the Minister had that idea at the back of his mind it may influence him to be less ardent in putting forward the 25,000 acre programme than he was when he was, as he said himself, a fanatic about this question of afforestation. I do not think he should worry as to what we are going to do with the surplus of timber, if we have it in 20 years' time. Even if there was no utility for it and even if timber was not needed, an increased acreage of timber will be an added attraction to this country, although it is already well endowed with natural beauty. I feel that the Minister should not worry any more about this position.
Comment on this
I feel that the Deputy is worrying too much about 50 years' time. I am not concerned with the argument but with the repetition of it.
Comment on this
I will not concern the Ceann Comhairle with the argument or with the repetition of it in the future. The fact still remains that the Minister has not given any hope to this side of the House that he is going to be generous about reafforestation. There is nothing in the debate to indicate to any of us that he is prepared to plant more than 12,500 acres or that he is prepared to go as high as the 1949 target forced on the then Government by Deputy MacBride. If he is not prepared to give us that undertaking there will be quite a number of people throughout the country who will be confused and particularly the people in the West.
I appeal to the Minister again to insert something in the Bill to give to the West its just due in regard to forestry. We are not getting it at present and we have no indication that the Minister is prepared to pay more money for any land he may acquire under this Bill.
It was too hard to get land in the past and it will be too hard to get it in the future unless more money is paid for the land when we are looking for it. A pound or two pound per acre added to the very heavy cost of afforestation will not sink the ship. I ask the Minister to consider that, in addition to the facilities he will be granted in this Bill, he should also pay a little more money for land in the different areas that he goes into. Very often the land in the West, because of its very scarcity, may be worth much more to the land holder than good land is worth in the wealthier portion of the country.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is not serious in asking that question. Does not the Minister realise that the majority of the land required at the moment is offered to the Department? When a person comes along and offers his land the natural conclusion is that he wants to sell. The number of sales under such circumstances will naturally be very high and the number of break-downs very low. When you come into a district under this new law, where commonages are the usual run of things, you will come up against the problem that there will be many more break-downs on the question of price unless you insist on using your rights under the Bill, which I hope you will, in order to increase the amount of land in particular in the West.
There is one thing that the Minister has already been asked to clarify. That is with regard to the position of the person who objects to his portion of a commonage being taken over. The Minister has already been questioned on this point, and it is only because I think the Minister gave the wrong answer when he was questioned, that I want to ask him again how that matter would be cleared up. Is it the position that if one or two or three persons, holding a commonage, object to having their rights acquired the Minister will, under this new Act, deal with those people by giving them one, two or three parts of the commonage as a common holding, or will he give them one-twentieth of the original commonage each?
Comment on this
Another part of the Bill deals with something which it described as an easement. Apparently there are two sections, one dealing with easements and one dealing with commonages.
Comment on this
There are two kinds of commonage, one where the owners own the fee simple or the ground. The other deals with commonages where they have grazing rights. Section 14 deals with one and Section 5 with the other. Under either section, they can have their portions separately or in common.
Comment on this
Irrespective of whether they own the ground or have just grazing rights? If there are between one and ten objectors to the commonage being taken over and if all these people want their portions fenced separately——
Comment on this
I am not disputing the apportionment. It is agreed that somebody higher than themselves will decide what portion they will get. The point I want clear is whether each individual will get his apportionment sealed off and fenced.
Comment on this
But earlier the Minister said something about having in mind the fencing of the separate portions and I immediately thought that we would be spending on fencing more than we would be paying for the land itself. If this were done I could visualise a ridiculous pattern being created.
Comment on this
I quite agree. The position therefore appears to be that if there is more than one objector in any commonage they will collectively get a portion of the commonage—a fair and proper proportion—closed off to themselves but not individually fenced.
Comment on this
The proportion of the commonage will be marked out for the two or three or four objectors and they can divide it later between themselves if they wish.
Comment on this
That is so. The only fence we will put up will be on the forest side. That is as far as we will go.
Comment on this
In conclusion I should like to say that as far as we on this side of the House are concerned we welcome the Bill in so far as it goes. We are sorry it has not gone further and, if there is any way in which the Minister, before Committee Stage, could bring in some amendment which might mean greater activity in the west of the country, I would be delighted as would many of the Minister's own constituents.
Comment on this
I think it is only right that this debate would be brought back to its proper perspective. I do not know whether it was done wittingly or unwittingly, but Deputy MacBride construed certain parts of the Minister's statement in a way which I cannot accept. The situation apparently is that in the course of his speech the Minister made reference to a technical report prepared by Mr. Cameron which was styled a rough survey of the plantable land in this country, estimated at a figure of 1,200,000 acres. The Minister indicated that this Bill is very likely to make available certain lands that have not yet been offered; the Bill may give the Forestry Section the right to make title to lands that have not been offered because of title difficutlies. It envisages that the figure mentioned by Mr. Cameron may be substantially increased. Let us take the figures as we find them. The Minister in his speech dealt with the envisaged programme, Deputy MacBride, by some queer twist, took this speech to be a deliberate abandonment of the target of 25,000 acres. No matter how I read the speech I could not concur with that interpretation.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy what this means: "It will be another five or ten years before we can get beyond the experimental stage?"
Comment on this
I would say it means exactly what it says—that in relation to a certain facet of the work in which they are doing a lot of experimental work on bogs and so forth, it will be quite a number of years before the Department have accumulated sufficient data in that sphere. That does not mean that the target of 25,000 acres has been abandoned. I should like to say that I have no objection to Deputy McBride asking me these questions as I go along. From Mr. Cameron's estimate we take it that there are 1,200,000 acres available. The Minister envisages that in 50 years we will have arranged for the planting of all that area and that is as near to 25,000 acres a year as makes any difference. If the purchase of land is improved and we get more land on offer, I take it that the Minister's target within the 50 years will be substantially in excess of 25,000 acres a year. Therefore what the Minister intends is completely at variance with Deputy MacBride's interpretation of the speech.
Comment on this
These cheap tricks will not work. Deputy McBride wants me to apologise now for something which I never said.
Comment on this
Let us get back to the reality of the problem. Deputy MacBride, apparently, took some exception to the fact that technical data now being collected by the Department show that, to a certain extent, there was an appreciable error in the estimate Mr. Cameron made of the land available for forestry. At best, Mr. Cameron was put in the position that he was asked to map out a programme on a rough-and-ready estimate of the amount of land that would be available, given rough-and-ready figures as to the type of land that would be available and on these to calculate the type of wood that land would produce. Since that report was issued the Forestry Department has been able to test technically what the yield per acre of the quarter-girth—in which he was so interested—in fact was, and the result was that, instead of the yield being 59, it has in reality worked out at 84. That naturally leads to a reduction in the figure which Deputy MacBride cavils at. In other words, instead of having to cut the extent of forest that would be necessary, if the yield were 59, we will only have to cut the extent of forest that is necessary, because we know that the yield is going to be substantially in excess.
Comment on this
Believe me, I am able to deal with this better than the Minister.
Comment on this
No, just this particular argument. The position is that this point is in relation to what Mr. Cameron estimated were our commercial needs at home. Now, who but Deputy MacBride has brought the suggestion into this House that that was our optimum aim in forestry?
Comment on this
I never envisaged forestry—nor indeed in fairness to him did Deputy MacBride—on the basis that having reached the stage at which we could supply our own needs we would then be in the position to supply a tremendous amount for export. I am thinking that the Minister in his argument was dealing purely with the question of the requirements set out in the Cameron report and he said that in order to meet these it would be necessary to plant 12,500 acres per year. That would be half of our requirements, and to meet our requirements as set out, to give us half our commercial timber we would have to plant 12,500 acres. The 12,500 acre figure has come into this purely in relation to the Cameron report and the fact that the investigations which the Department have been making in relation to that have been distorted—
Comment on this
——have been distorted out of that pattern into something else. The position I take it is this. I have been a very severe critic of the Forestry Department: I have gone to the trouble of doing a bit of research and, whatever may be said about the last 35 years, I think it is due to the Department to say that at least in the last five years they have shown a tremendous capacity for expansion. I will deal before I sit down with the facts and figures in relation to my own area and my own county.
The Minister comes in here and says it is only possible for him this year to plant 15,000 acres of land and keep up at the same time the necessary work on forests that are in a state of development necessitating either replanting of seedlings that have not grown or thinning. There may be some difficulties here. I am sure there must be technical difficulties because I think in dealing with growing forests or planting of plantations there must be a certain amount of technical skill and knowledge necessary. I presume one of the Minister's difficulties at the moment in view of his expansion programme with the development of a considerable number of new centres may be that for no other reason than the fact that men are not available, he may not be able to expand employment as rapidly as possible. Even if you take the unskilled work I understand there has to be a certain amount of skilled supervision.
Comment on this
We have been given many reasons why there has been on progress but it is the first time that particular reason has been advanced.
Comment on this
Deputy MacBride does not appreciate the fact that there is some technical knowledge and skill necessary in relation to certain facts of afforestation.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy say then that we should first have a technical Director of Forestry—fill that position first?
Comment on this
I could not agree less. I think if we had sufficient good foresters on the job——
Comment on this
Let us proceed on the reasoned basis. The Minister can plant 15,000 acres this year. This is not anywhere in the region of the 25,000 acres a year that we want but at least it is a step in advancing and expanding the area that is being planted each year.
Deputy Derrig, when speaking, became agitated about the pool of land which you must have in reserve if you are going to step up your planting. I think that is not a rational approach. Whatever difficulties may arise about the pool, when we have reached full development in forestry, we should certainly not allow a consideration like that to hinder us from stepping up planting.
To return to what is fundamental in this whole thing, because the Minister made a speech which was not, strictly speaking, relevant to the Bill at all, we have got away from the realities of what is before us. I feel that the Bill has merit in so far as it goes, but I honestly believe it is only skimming the problem. I do not for one moment suggest that by means of a Bill we can suddenly create some kind of Utopian situation for the Forestry Department to enable it to burst out into this great worthwhile national development that we all envisage, but I do think when we come to deal with the problems which a Bill such as this suggests— problems of defective title and commonage—we should have gone on to deal with what has apparently been a burning question with a number of Deputies from the West and which in some respects affects myself in my constituency. We should have gone on to deal with the problem of many people who are prepared to offer fairly extensive, rough, inferior holdings to the Forestry Department if they can get an exchange of some kind of reasonably economic holding in its place. It is not as burning a problem with me as it may be in the areas of some of the other western Deputies.
I think the Minister as a western representative should have endeavoured to deal with that problem in this Bill. If we are envisaging this Bill as something which will enable the pool available for forestry purposes to be substantially increased that problem should have been faced up to and, with the Forestry Division directly under the control of the Minister, it seems to me it should have been both practicable and possible to work out a simple scheme whereby people in the position that they can offer fairly large holdings suitable for reafforestation should be able to take advantage of some system of interchange with the Land Commission. I make that suggestion quite seriously. I think it is one upon which there would be a good deal of unanimity in the House. It is, indeed, something which would complete the pattern.
Because of the Minister's methods of introducing this Bill, there has been a very wide avenue of discussion. I am anxious to know from the Minister what exactly he hopes to achieve, particularly in relation to some of the old-established forests in County Cork, such as Lisgoold and Kilworth. My information is that the intake of land in these old forests is practically negligible. Instead of expanding from these centres, the work now is devoted purely to growing and developing forests, as distinct from new plantations. I know from discussions I had that the story may be substantially different in the western areas.
I am anxious to know whether this Bill will enable the Minister to deal with many of the problems that have been presented through the offers of land in the Beara Peninsula, where commonage exists on the hillsides or in the submarginal land. Will this Bill facilitate the taking of the large tracts of land that have been offered throughout Bandon, Macroom, Ballingeary and Inchigeela area? Will the new venture embarked upon by his Department in Glengariff be effectively enhanced in its land intake by this measure?
It might be better for us to be a little less critical at times of the Forestry Branch and to get down to concrete achievements. While I am not satisfied that the figure has reached the optimum that it could and should reach, I am gratified that the intake of land in my area has been substantially increased. I was amazed to learn from the Department last week that they have some 6,000 acres in process of acquisition in West Cork and over 5,000 acres under inspection at the moment. It would be unfair not to give credit in a situation like that—that is a substantial forward impetus—and I have been outspoken in my criticism of the Department's lethargy in the past.
It is a tragedy that we are inclined in this matter to go into side issues which lead to a clash of personalities or to a bitterness which should not show itself. We all appreciate now— and nobody more than Fianna Fáil, who for 20 years did virtually nothing about afforestation and are now quite worried about it—that there seems to be a tacit understanding to leave the past behind and get on with the job of afforestation so that there will be a future for timber and timber by-products. It is unfortunate in that situation that the genuine anxiety of some people may lead to friction, a friction stimulated merely by an honest exuberance to get the job done. I feel that the clash that arose between Deputy MacBride and the Minister was a clash of personalities rather than of principles. I think the Minister is anxious that afforestation should expand as rapidly as possible and I do not think Deputy MacBride has been altogether fair in interpreting the Minister's speech as he did.
The task before us is an immense task. The present expansion is commendable when one remembers that forestry is merely a subdivision of the Department of Lands, that it is hampered by a lot of unnecessary detail, that it has not got sufficient staff, that it has not its own examiners, and that it has not got its own investigation staff. That is a tragedy. It is these administrative difficulties that hold up progress. Taking all these into consideration, the expansion has been significant vis-á-vis other Government Departments. It is our anxiety to increase the rate of expansion and to put more impetus into the job. That should not be misconstrued by the Minister. It is a genuine expression of goodwill in relation to something that is common case.
In the development of forestry we have an immense potential of national wealth. Apart from that, we have a tremendous potential to stem the haemorrhage of emigration from the western seaboard and to establish a pool of permanent and continuous employment within the Gaeltacht and Fíor-Ghaeltacht areas. That is why I say the Minister should have gone further in this Bill and dealt with what has become a substantial problem in the western areas. There are many people who are really not so much seeking payment for their lands from the Forestry Department in these áiteanna iargcúlta as some kind of economic holding to live on, on which they could get down to the job of making an economic unit of that in which to maintain their family and themselves.
This Bill, as far as it goes, will undoubtedly have the goodwill of the House generally. While I deprecate the manner in which the measure was introduced and the false atmosphere in which this debate commenced, I do feel it is necessary for me to correct any statements that may have been distorted. It is up to the Minister to indicate that we are not wrong in our conception of his anxiety to go ahead, push up to the 25,000 acres a year plantation and to exceed it if it becomes practical and if the pool of land becomes available for him so to do.
It is also necessary for the Minister to appreciate that this Bill is not going as far as many of us would like. The Minister waxed eloquent here on the question of compulsory acquisition and was threatening to become a militant leader if these rights were to be invaded. There is none of us asking the Minister to push on and trample arbitrarily on the rights of individuals. What we are asking him to do is to take the powers in legislation that will enable him to push ahead with the practical development of our forestry plan and not afford some person who might be activated by any improper motives or by any desire for obstruction, protection by law that will enable him to defeat the better interests of the nation as a whole.
I do not believe that that type of difficulty or obstruction in relation to isolated islands in a large plantation would ever come from the type of people who enjoy the right of commonage or who indeed are offering their poor holdings for forestry purposes. It is in that spirit, I think, that anybody in this House suggested that the Minister should take unto himself certain powers that would enable him to obviate difficulties unreasonably put in the way of the advance of a great national project like afforestation. It is not right for us to use intemperate language or ill-advised vociferousness in relation to these particular necessities because throughout the legislation of the State in relation to other Departments the principle of compulsory acquisition in extremis causis is acknowledged. For the Minister to suggest that it would lead to interference with anybody's rights is to my mind either cynical or else deliberately misconstruing the situation as it exists.
I do not wish to weary the House. Whatever about the Minister being a fanatic on forestry, I have no hesitation in admitting that I am one and that I hope before I die to see much of the area that was once adorned by forests throughout West Cork replanted by his Department, and as long as my voice is in this House I will keep pressing and driving until it is done. I feel the Minister and Deputy MacBride distorted the whole trend of this debate and that the twittering countercharges they had against each other were slightly unworthy of both their positions. It would be far better for us all if we accepted the situation that we are all pushing onwards as quickly as possible in a unanimous spirit to the maximum total target in reafforestation and that, having given the Minister whatever expedition we can in the passage of this Bill, having urged him to improve it in any way that might make his task easier, we should say: Cuir uait an chaint agus lean leis an obair.
Comment on this
This Bill has been received well, generally speaking, as will every Bill dealing with forestry be received. I have been in this House for many years and when legislation on forestry was introduced a spirit of goodwill prevailed and encouragement was given to the Minister to push on with the scheme. To-night I have learned something that I never knew before about forestry. It is rather weird. I am told that by taking out of production each year 10,000 acres of land that hitherto produced cattle, sheep or goats, had some tillage on it, or perhaps grazed some cows, which undoubtedly represented a big sum of money nationally each year, by destroying all the assets and removing the people who made their living on it, we are all going to grow much wealthier.
I am in complete disagreement with the Minister and with every Deputy in this House who has spoken on those lines, that trees will give more employment and increase the wealth of Ireland. It is absurd. I have years of experience of the growing of forests and the person who will tell me that you can give greater employment by growing trees than by producing cattle, sheep, and so on, does not know what he is talking about. There is employment for the first three, four or five years in the drainage and fencing of the land. After planting, a small number of men would be employed to weed and care the young plantation. There is a long stretch before any further employment is provided. Undoubtedly, there is big employment when the timber is ready for cutting. That is the period of real employment.
So many people have disagreed about what the Minister said in his speech that I do not want to raise any trouble but I think he said that 50 years was the period taken to mature. That is absurd. I have seen timber grown on bogland which matured in 25 or 30 years. Excellent timber can be grown on bogland if care is taken in planting. I have seen trees dug up that were 100 years old, at the bottom of which there was a deposit of blue marl which had been put there when the trees were planted and which seemed to make the difference. I wonder what our forestry people are doing in that direction.
There is a great dependence on exports. We were waiting on expert advice for many years back. For many a year I discussed in this House the necessity of planting some of the mountain slopes in Leitrim and I was told again and again that experts had found it to be unsuitable. At a later stage, an international expert was brought here and surveyed the area in question and his opinion was that trees could not be grown at such a height over sea level, on bog. I said that it was not bog. I recognised that the foliage that I saw growing there was not grown on bogland. I dug the surface and brought up alluvial soil where I had been told there was bog. We had experts here, not merely Scottish, English or Irish, but continental. The reports of the experts are regarded as if they came from wizards. In my view there is nothing like a practical test.
A lot of the theory on afforestation is waste of time. Timber can be grown in many places where it has been grown before, but were also want to grow it where it has not been grown before.
Are we to take out of production so many thousands of acres which to some extent contributed to the national wealth and which maintained a certain number of people? Are we to take away this means of livelihood for this number of people in order to plant trees? I disagree with the man who says that by growing trees you give as much employment as can be provided on the same area of land when it is devoted to agriculture. It is untrue and misleading to suggest that.
Let us get people of common sense to deal with this problem, people who know the facts. Where ordinary farming is carried on, the surrounding towns and villages benefit. The farming community go into the towns and villages to buy their domestic requirements. If we substitute forestry for that type of farming we destroy the countryside and the towns and villages. We also destroy the schools. We take away the need for churches. We take away the need for the excellent roads we have built. We will do that if we recklessly proceed with a forestry scheme in the belief that land that is planted can maintain as many people as can be maintained on the same land when used for agriculture. This matter should be approached cautiously so as to ensure that we will not substitute trees for people. Let us make sure that we do not destroy permanently all the amenities that pertain to civilisation. There is wealth in trees but we should not, in order to produce that wealth, retard progress.
I cannot understand the scheme the Minister has with regard to commonage. The Minister wants no compulsory powers so far as taking land from people is concerned. Therefore, he is going to adopt a form of satisfying everybody who uses land in commonage. He assumes that a certain number of people using land in commonage will agree to give up their rights and that those who may not want to give up their rights will be compensated out of a pool created by the land that is handed over. If they take over 1,000 acres, and a half of it is to be distributed amongst 50 people who have to be encouraged and induced to give up their land and if the other half has to be given to people who refuse to part with their land, where are you going to get the land for forestry? If we give these people anything less than what they have they will not agree to give up their own land. Probably we would have to give them double what they have at the moment and in that case we would have nothing left for forestry. I cannot follow the Minister's plan there.
This commonage question is a very difficult one apart altogether from the goodwill of the people about their rights. You have these commonage lands, such as mountain land, which often run into several thousand acres. Everybody whose lands abut on that mountain has the right to graze cows and sheep and they do this practically all the year round. If these people are deprived of the right of grazing these mountains, which abut on their own land, it means wholesale confiscation of their means of living. You must. give them some substitute for what you are taking from them. There are periods in the summer when these people can get their grazing free and they can sell at the end of the year. It means the existence of many of them and if you take the right of commonage from them you deprive them of all they have.
This will mean a clearance as effective as any that ever took place in this country. If the grazing rights are taken away from these people, their holdings will not be enough to live on and many of them will be left derelict. They cannot possibly live on them without the grazing rights. It seems to me impossible to deal with this question effectively without doing serious damage. I would like very much to have a fuller discussion on this point than it is possible to have across the floor of this House. I do not see how we can improve our lot by taking thousands of acres of land out of production every year and putting it to a use that cannot give a return for 50 years. I want a better explanation of this matter than has been forthcoming so far. There are plenty of areas suitable for timber in this country which could very easily be used for that purpose.
Somebody mentioned Bord na Móna as being the most suitable body to take charge of land for forestry but I think that Lands and Forestry is a better combination than to put them into two separate Departments. The utilisation of cut-away bogs is one of the most practical proposals we could discuss. It is ten or 15 years ago since I raised the question in this House that when the Land Commission was dividing bogs, these boglands should not be split up into allotments or plots amongst various owners some of whom never cut a bag of turf on their allocations. Some of them cut their turf and others did not, with the result that there was no uniformity of drainage. We have all over the country great areas of bogland with holes dug by different owners which now contain a permanent content of water and for which there is no means of drainage. I advocated that there should be no such thing as allotments of that sort but that each bog should be drained and fenced and given to the tenants as they required it for their allocation of turf year by year.
Acres of that bog are now useless, useless because it cannot be drained. If it had been left to common drainage, it would now be useful in many districts for enlarging tenants' holdings because it can make excellent tillage land. It could also be used for forestry purposes. If you look around the bogs that have been put out of production owing to bad management by the Land Commission you will find a lot of land that could be put into production for tillage and also for the planting of trees.
These areas that have been mentioned are ones that may give rise to difficulty but look at the area where there would be no difficulty in acquisition and which would not cost any money. Look at the area of land along the embankment of the railways. Grass grows there for a period of the year until it becomes inflammable and then goes on fire and sometimes does a lot of damage. Trees could be planted along these slopes and embankments. These lands are capable of growing trees as well as any other land. Look at the acres of land along our roads that are lying derelict and waste. That could be put into timber and it would be better to plant these waste lands than to go down the country and take away the rights of commonage from the people. The people will object to these rights being taken away and I can see no prospects for the development of forestry if these are the lines you are going to follow.
Is not that sheer destruction? When the trees come in the people go out, no matter what the Minister may say. Will the Minister tell me whether or not it is his intention to take 10,000 acres of land out of production each year and to grow trees upon it? Is it his intention to take land out of production, no matter how small that production may be, and to turn it over to afforestation?
Comment on this
Indeed I am not. I am dealing with the problem intelligently as I see it, but I am not against accepting the proposal made if I can see it is for the general good. If some person, with more knowledge than I have, like the Deputy, will show me that trees will provide more wealth on the land to be acquired than did the husbandry of the small farmers who worked it I will accept the proposal. But can trees provide as much wealth or maintain as many people as did these small farmers who owned a little bit of grazing, a few cows, a few cattle, a few pigs, or a few hens? Will the growing of trees maintain as many people as that kind of husbandry has done? I have listened to the discussion this evening on the great benefit this will be to the West. Some Deputies have asked for increased interest in the project by the people of the West. I warn these Deputies, before they give continued support or acceptance to the scheme, that it has been my experience that when the forests came in the people went out. The families who went out because of the trees never came back. I have often met people on the trains coming to Dublin as a result of this forest-growing. Some of them came from a large estate——
Comment on this
It is perfectly fair but it is not true to say that either in Glenfarne or Drumkieran any people were forced out by forestry operations.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not know that the case of the Drumkieran people was one of the strongest points I ever made in this House? I asked the Minister to look after the migration of the people of that place. Does the Minister know that he has done nothing for the people of these two areas in the years that he was in office, that his policy and planning have been deliberately fixed so that these two areas would be left out? How many migrants did the Minister take from the three counties in the West In the last three years? The Minister refuses to tell me. The number taken from the County Mayo has been in excess of the total number taken from the other areas in the North-West.
Comment on this
The Minister was not in the House when Deputy S. Collins was speaking. Deputy Collins made an excellent point when he said there should be a pool of land provided, not merely for the growing of timber but also for the provision of compensation for those from whom bad land was taken for afforestation. But more land is being taken now than in the Cromwellian clearances. The Minister should say to these people that afforestation is nationally a good investment from the long-term point of view. He should say: "We have now taken a pool of good and bad land. We are not going to drive you out without shelter or means; we will give you land somewhere else." The Minister should stop this planning to have the West of Ireland cleared of families and replanted with trees. There is a danger that he will succeed where Cromwell failed. That seems to be the present policy of the Government. I think do agree that the Minister has a difficult job but I do not think he is planning along the right lines. I think there is no alternative in front of the small farmers of County Leitrim than to move out and I say that trees are a very poor substitute for families.
Comment on this
I welcome this Bill and congratulate both the Minister and the former Minister for their contributions. Before proceeding further, I feel I must refer, if only briefly, to the speech of Deputy MacBride. Having listened to him this evening and on previous occasions on this subject of afforestation, one would be inclined to form the opinion that he wants the whole country to believe that he is father and mother of afforestation in this country. I certainly do not share that view.
I have also formed the opinion that Deputy MacBride has devoted some time to reading forestry books not written by experts on the subject. It appears to be his practice on his way from the Four Courts to call at some of the second-hand bookshops in Bachelor's Walk or in Moore Street, buy literature on forestry and swallow it hook, line and sinker. It is regrettable that a man of his standing and his experience of public life should behave and speak in such a way as he has spoken here this evening. I feel his main objective is to try and discredit the present Minister for Lands as well as his predecessor. One thing is certain in any case—he has not succeeded in his purpose this evening. He went so far as to say he was prepared to have a vote of "no confidence" on this issue. Having listened to Fianna Fáil Deputies and having heard them speaking in favour of this measure and giving an assurance that they propose to support it wholeheartedly and cooperate in every way possible, if he is to have that vote of "no confidence", it seems to me as if he and his two boys will be on the far side of the House and everyone else on this side. He will not have much company on this vote of "no confidence" on the forestry issue. Therefore, I think Deputy MacBride must feel ashamed —that is if he has any shame left, if he ever had any—of his contribution here to-night. I regret that I have to be so hard-hitting in my speech on a subject of this kind but I feel it is very necessary when you have such irresponsibly cheap talk going on.
The Minister was blamed here because he introduced a number of matters that might not appear relevant to this Bill. I am convinced he was forced into that position. We are aware that Deputy MacBride has gone round the country in recent times and on previous occasions and has availed of cheap dinners and lunches——
Comment on this
That is what I am coming to. Recently, Deputy MacBride was in Cork at a luncheon and referred to the activities of the Forestry Department. He was not satisfied to confine himself to attacks on the Minister; he also attacked the Minister's staff. I want to say at this stage I am not without appreciation of all our forestry staffs have done over a period of years. I think they have done very good work. I think the proof of that is there in that over a period of years we have an increased acreage of planted forests in the country. The fact that year after year forestry has increased is, I think, a great tribute to the forestry men, both in the centres down the country and in the Department headquarters here. I am prepared, as one Deputy in this House with a reasonable knowledge of their activities and work, to pay them that compliment and do it very gladly.
I was proud to hear the former Minister here this evening speak in support of this Bill and give valuable advice and criticism which he was in a position to give because he had experience of that Department. While I do not agree with everything Deputy Derrig and his Party says and does, I must pay him this tribute—that he has a first-hand knowledge of the problems and difficulties with which the present Minister is confronted and has it over a very long number of years. Like many of us, he was reared in the heart of congestion and saw it first-hand in his native district. Not alone that, but he traversed more than once many of the districts where forests are now growing when it was not very safe to do so. It is heartening to think that in one who is now at the helm, and in Deputy Derrig who was once in a similar position, we have men with enough common sense to apply sanity and reason in their approach to this whole question of forestry which is vital from the point of view of national economy and the amount of employment it gives.
It is heartening to the Irish people to think that there are in this House men of common sense prepared to apply a common-sense approach to the problems—and they are problems— and who are prepared to offer fair and honest criticism on such subjects as this. I think that the people will at least appreciate the fact that the people opposite on this occasion are most helpful and co-operative.
I listened also to-night to Deputy Blaney from Donegal. Donegal's problems are much the same as those in my own constituency. I join with him in stressing the importance of making the West of Ireland generally what I might describe as the timber yard of the West. The Minister and Deputy Blaney also spoke along the lines of advocating more and more forestry for western districts. It will be appreciated that in other parts of the country where you have more arable land that forestry in many cases would be detrimental to national economy and instead of doing good by planting, you might do quite a lot of harm. I am with Deputy Blaney in advocating more forestry for the West and I agree that a special case could be made for the West because it would be appreciated that in western areas we have quite a lot of non-arable land, which would be suitable for forestry and should be planted. If special attention is given to the West I think the rest of the country should not grudge it the little prosperity or benefits that might bring.
Deputy Collins referred to another matter which would be very desirable. I think he was the only one to refer to it. It is a matter with which the Minister, myself and other Deputies in this House are quite conversant. When we speak to people of voluntarily giving up a tract of land to the Forestry Department for the purpose of getting a greater area of land available for forestry, we find almost invariably they say: "Can you give me an exchange holding? I will gladly leave. I will give up my 100 acres of poor land if you give me a holding of 35 or 40 acres of arable land. I would be only glad to get out of here."
Deputy Collins expressed regret that the Minister had not some provision in his Bill for that type of case. To my own knowledge, the Minister is aware that these questions are being asked and that we have to point out that you have, on the one side, the Forestry Department and on the other the Land Commission, and that it is the Land Commission which deals with the rearrangement of holdings and the relief of congestion. I agree with Deputy Collins that if anything could be done in that respect it would be most helpful from the point of view of increasing the pool of planting land available. I can appreciate, of course, that there are difficulties in the way. If we are to have forests in an area we will have to have a certain amount of employment and people prepared to work on those forests. One cannot move everybody out of that particular block and then prepare to transport labour ten or 15 miles at a later date.
Deputy MacBride suggested the setting up of a board on the lines of Bord na Móna or C.I.E. I listened with great attention to the present Minister and to the former Minister, Deputy Derrig. Both of these are men of experience and they have expressed the view that the Forestry Branch, as at present constituted, is the most suitable body for dealing with this matter. I am certainly more inclined to take their viewpoint as against that expressed by Deputy MacBride.
We all know that when it comes to a question of acquiring land for rearrangement, division or afforestation, very often the Department of Lands has to work in close co-operation with the Forestry Branch in order to iron out the many difficulties that arise. I have in mind a situation that arose in my constituency last week where it was absolutely essential that the Forestry Branch and the Land Commission should meet on the spot to iron out difficulties. I am sure that situation could equally well arise in other parts of the country. Deputy Derrig pointed out that if we remove control in this matter from the Department of Lands and give it to some board such a board would not be accountable to this House and forestry would no longer be within our control. He pointed out that Deputies putting down questions about the activities of such a board could get no information. We all know what happens when questions are asked in connection with C.I.E. and various other bodies.
I think that would be a most unsatisfactory situation. Indeed, it would be highly dangerous. It is only fair that in a matter of this kind the elected representatives of the people should have some say and that the Minister in charge should be answerable to this House. That is the only way in which we can have some say in the direction of policy.
I disagree to a very large extent with what Deputy Maguire has said. He referred to the taking up of land which might be regarded as poor quality land; he argued that this is bad policy. Now I am wholly incompetent to decide or to judge as to what is or is not suitable. I think the same is true of Deputy Maguire. I am not now trying to belittle his opinion in any way but I certainly could not stand on the roadside and decide whether land is good quality land or bad quality land or whether it is suitable for forestry or tillage. Therefore, I think that statement was a rather sweeping one.
He said that many areas should not be planted with trees and that they should not be taken over. We should not set ourselves up here as experts on technical matters. That is outside our competence. The forestry inspector has spent a large part of his life in college making a particular study of these things and he is naturally more competent to decide what is plantable and what is not plantable. Deputy Maguire seems to ignore the fact that quite a considerable acreage, even in his own area, would, if planted, give considerable employment. He seems to rule out altogether the idea that forestry gives employment. Not alone does it give immediate employment, but it also provides long term employment to the generations that will follow.
The tourist industry is important to the economy of our country. Forest centres take the barren look from the country and it is noticeable that in the areas where forests have been established tourists have been attracted. That is an added advantage. It must be remembered, too, that forests will help to dry our climate. In the long run they will even effect an improvement in temperature.
There is one matter about which I feel very strongly. I refer to the compulsory acquisition of land for afforestation. I do not like compulsion in any form. In this country it is against the grain to use compulsion. The more you compel an Irishman to do something, the more he will pull against it. If there is a reasonable approach, on the other hand, much better results will be achieved. We have heard a good deal about the old cry, "To hell or to Connacht". Every Deputy admits that it is in Connacht that forestry should be advanced. I am a descendant of those who were driven on to the mountainside. I am proud of the fact that I was reared in that tradition. Let it be clearly understood that the question of compulsion to the descendants of the people who resisted the landlords, without any weapons, is anathema. They defended their religion and their rights. It is unthinkable that a native Government would use compulsion to order these people out of their homes.
People like Deputy MacBride who express such viewpoints and such sentiments have very little appreciation of the true sentiments and feelings of the Irish people. Let Deputy MacBride try that on. He will meet with a very warm resistance. I do not wish to misrepresent him, but I gather that is his idea. These people had a struggle to live on these mountain holdings. In many instances they were not able to make a living and the father of the family, and perhaps the mother, too, had to emigrate to England, to Scotland or to some other part of the world to find the ready cash to supplement the meagre income at home. It is incredible that anyone in this Parliament, an elected representative, would defend such a policy. Let me warn him here and now: "Hands off such holdings."
We must get the holdings by co-operation and by paying the proper price for them. On that subject, I am not satisfied the full price is being paid to many people surrendering land for forestry purposes. These people have put up with great trials and difficulties and helped to save this nation down through the years in one emergency or another. We remember that during the last emergency these poor people in mountainy holdings went into the bogs in their neighbourhood and produced the turf that supplied this city and other cities throughout the country when we could not get fuel elsewhere. These are the people in whose interests I am speaking to-night. Let me say that there is no question of the Forestry Department or any other Department thinking they can come along and, by force of law, acquire compulsorily from these people, because their sons and daughters, grandsons and granddaughters are well able to resist such attempts; they have proved their mettle in the past and would prove it again if necessary. Therefore, let there be an end to this nonsensical agitation about acquiring land compulsorily and trying to browbeat such people.
One paragraph in this Bill empowers the creation of machinery by which the Minister for Lands can purchase an interest in lands held by a person with defective title provided such person has enjoyed interest for at least six years. Any of us who are conversant with this whole subject of land acquisition know very well the difficulty about acquiring commonages, the difficulties about title in regard to these mountainy holdings. As I have already stated there are, particularly in those areas, cases where there are very large families and many of those people had to emigrate to England or America. Perhaps the father, who might be the registered owner, died intestate. Many difficulties have arisen in the past and if this Bill has the effect of clearing up those difficulties—and I believe it will to a very large extent—then I can see that much more progress will be made in the matter of increasing our acreage of land under forestry. I do not think this Bill is a cure-all for these difficulties that exist but at least it is going part of the way. I believe it will help to a considerable extent and that you will have a big flow of land coming in immediately this Bill becomes law and it will be possible for our officers in the Department of Forestry to acquire land much more readily.
The Minister recently made reference to the progress of afforestation in the congested areas in County Mayo. In particular, I am glad to see a substantially increased acreage in our own county. In 1950 there was only one such forest covering 650 acres in the county. That was at Foxford. Now there are six forests which have been opened at Doolough, Lough Carra, Nephin Beg and Nephin Mór, Tourmakeady and more recently at Glenamoy, making the total acreage now devoted to forestry about 11,000 or 12,000 acres, with approximately 150 men employed. I am particularly glad that due to the handing over of the Glenamoy area to the Forestry Section the Bangor Erris area will benefit from that and that in the same region at a place called Shanettra a new forest centre of approximately 14,000 or 15,000 acres will be opened at an early date. In this particular area, as in many other areas, you have quite a lot of unemployment and this new forest centre should alleviate the position.
We look forward in Mayo and, I suppose, in Connacht generally to this Bill bringing increased prosperity and confidence to our people. This native Government is anxious to find machinery for acquiring land at an economic price, at its full market value, at the earliest possible date. It is very easy for people to talk recklessly and carelessly about acquiring land, about planting thousands and thousands of acres without any regard to the difficulties of acquisition and the many other difficulties there are even when the forest is planted.
I am glad to think that in this House this evening with the exception of one individual namely, Deputy MacBride, who came in here for no other purpose but to cause trouble, to pour filth in all directions, there was a common sense approach to this problem. While we are not all agreed about the technical points connected with forestry in one way or another, it is heartening to hear that an Irish Parliament, a Dáil, can meet this evening and express views freely and frankly and that we can have cooperation and goodwill on all sides. I, personally, on behalf of my constituents, wish this measure every success because it is something for which we have been waiting a long time, something that will give us an approach to a difficult problem in our constituency. The question of title and the many other difficulties that do exist as regards land acquisition for forestry purposes will, I think, be relieved considerably when this Bill is implemented.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Does the Chair deem it advisable to call on any Labour Deputy in this debate?
Comment on this
The Deputy shall cast no reflection, even by inference, on the manner in which the Chair calls on Deputies.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Clann na Talmhan and Clann na Poblachta have already contributed.
Comment on this
The Chair can call only one Deputy at a time. Only two Fianna Fáil Deputies have spoken, two Fine Gael, as far as I know, and one Independent Deputy.
Comment on this
I will not argue with the Deputy. The Chair calls on Deputies in accordance with precedent. Deputy Moran.
Comment on this
The discussion on this Bill has been rather interesting if it is only because of the arguments that have arisen and particularly because of the Parties concerned in the arguments. I had thought that this extraordinary upsurge in national confidence created by the inter-Party Government was going to shed such a pall of harmony over the nation that we would never have reached the stage when we had Deputy MacBride speaking in the tone of voice in which he spoke to the Minister or that we would hear him scarifying Deputy O'Hara as he did to-night. In the first instance when Deputies on this side of the House claimed that this measure was brought in as a result of the motion tabled by myself and my colleagues, and the Minister for Lands denied that and said it had nothing to do with it, I thought at the time the Minister was not being quite candid. I am now inclined to accept the Minister's explanation that our motion had nothing to do with this Bill because it has been quite patent from the disclosures in this House that this Bill has been brought in in an endeavour to keep a firm front before the public between the different Parties. Evidently the Minister did not get the draftsman to do the job well enough for Deputy MacBride, however, and instead of pouring oil on troubled waters he has thrown a spanner in the works and now we have the position we have witnessed to-night as between these Parties.
There are some important, fundamental matters to be dealt with in this Bill. Having read the Bill, I am very much afraid that it can best be described as a stunt. I am sorry to have to disagree with my colleagues who, possibly, took the explanation issued in the White Paper but I wonder how many Deputies have read the Bill section by section and have seen what it implies.
I propose in due course to deal with that aspect of the Bill, the way its proposals differ completely from what is set out in the White Paper and what the Minister is trying to put over on the House but, first, I want to discuss the question as to whether or not the Department of Lands is the suitable body to deal with afforestation. I had an open mind on that question for quite a long time but I am now quite satisfied that the Department of Lands is not competent to deal with afforestation. If we take the purpose for which the Department of Lands was originally created, that is, the relief of congestion, and the poor progress that has been made with that fundamental national problem, I do not see how they can deal with the question of afforestation if it is to be dealt with as a national problem and if forestry is to be a national asset.
The best test as to whether the Department of Lands, or the Department as at present constituted, is the proper body to deal with this question or is capable of making even the slightest progress in the matter is to look around one's constituency to see what endeavours have been made to organise the community or to get lands suitable for afforestation. Is it not true that where land has been made available it has been made available in the main by private effort, by people getting together in a local area and trying to get the Department to take over land for afforestation, instead of the Department trying to get after the people? Every sincere Deputy knows that that is the position and that that is the first fundamental test on which the Department falls down.
The effort for afforestation is coming from the people, from private bodies and not from the Department whose job it is to get the land. Perhaps it is that the officials of the Department of Lands Forestry Branch have too many other duties thrust upon them. Perhaps it is that they regard this matter as being down the list in importance compared with the question of land acquisition, division and rearrangement. The fact remains that no progress worth while has been made and, in my view, no progress will be made unless some type of body is set up to deal with it, some body or section that will be answerable to this House, whose job will be to get the suitable land.
There are various Departments that have officials throughout the country. Those that spring to mind straight away are the officials of the county committees of agriculture who are in touch with people in remote areas and who, if given a lead or directive from some section of Government, would be able to point out places where the people are willing to have a mountain or other land that would be suitable for forestry taken over. There should be some section whose business it would be to go to the people and to organise public opinion in local areas in favour of making land available. That is number one.
Number two, of course, the overriding consideration in this matter as in the question of land acquisition for the relief of congestion, is the question of the price that will be paid. Each one of us knows that, in these times particularly, unless a reasonable price is made available, the people will not surrender their rights over lands that they own and the Department will not get land that is suitable for forestry unless they are prepared to pay for it.
These two questions go to the very root of this problem and the quicker the House faces it, the better. If we are to make the progress that has been suggested or set our eyes on a certain target we must face these two fundamental problems first. Whatever the origin of the row between the Clann na Poblachta Party and the Government may be, there is one thing clear from the Minister's statement on this measure—that running right through it the Minister said in no uncertain way that he at all events has changed the target, the 25,000-acre target.
Comment on this
I will quote it chapter and verse for the Minister. On page one of the Minister's statement he says that the idea of a State authority acquiring land, save for some very limited and localised project such as an airport, and in so doing running counter to the whole activities of the Land Commission is completely unacceptable to anyone who has the interests of Irish farming at heart. That is the first item set forth by the Minister. The next is on page three, where he refers to the target of an annual planting programme of 25,000 acres and says:
"Reverting to the target of an annual planting programme of 25,000 acres, that figure was, as I have explained, adopted as a suitable target in the absence of precise estimation of future timber requirements and it represented a mathematical allowance for planting over 50 years the 1,200,000-acre figure derived from the rough plantable land survey— itself a figure with considerable conflicting margins of error."
These were the figures on which the 25,000-acre target was based, obviously, and the Minister is careful to point out to us that the target, evidently, was based on wrong figures or, certainly, that there has now been a mathematical allowance of error made for that figure.
The Minister goes on to say, at page four:—
"The total forest acreage required to meet in full future potential commercial timber consumption would thus be 580,000 acres or, say, 600,000 acres. That ultimate objective would call for the planting, on a 50-year rotation, of only 12,000 acres a year. These are cold realistic figures and their significance cannot be brushed aside by any frenzied or delirious screaming for more, more, more planting to pull up for our present grossly inadequate timber supplies."
Here the Minister says, it would seem to me, if words have any meaning, that 12,000 acres a year would meet our commercial requirements.
Comment on this
And that anyone who goes beyond that figure must belong to this screaming class who are looking for more and more planting. He goes still further and he says:—
"We are now planting at a rate sufficient to meet our commercial timber needs in 45 to 50 years' time and there is nothing more we can do on that front except to ensure that the Forestry Division is given a proper opportunity to maintain and develop the plantations in the proper way."
In that paragraph he sets forth his belief that we are now planting at a rate sufficient to meet our commercial timber needs. Down at the end of the next page he says:—
"In this way forestry can be relied upon to bring a lasting benefit to the economy of the congested districts and other undeveloped areas in western counties whereas a madcap rush to plant the blanket bog of the western seaboard would assuredly end in dismal failure. It may be another five or ten years before we can get beyond the experimental stage in this work and fix a definite annual target."
So apparently there is no target fixed for the congested areas. Has the Minister completely gone away from the target of 25,000 acres which was laid down and does he feel that if we can maintain our present progress we are doing very well? If that be so, and from these quotations I cannot see how it can be otherwise, let us be candid and say so.
I object to "stunting" on this question of forestry. If the Minister says and believes that in the foreseeable future our rate of planting must be from 12,000 to 15,000 acres a year the people should be told that and we should go on that basis. It is idle to pretend to the people that to-morrow or the week after or next year the figure is going to reach 25,000 acres if we believe ourselves that 12,000 or 15,000 acres is the limit. The people are entitled to know what the goal is and if the Government is planning a goal of 12,000 or 15,000 acres a year the people should be told that.
In column 901 of the debate on the motion the Minister said:—
"I think it was Deputy Moran from South Mayo who chided me for doing too much in the west, particularly in County Mayo. It is a strange turn of the wheel to find him now as a signatory to this motion stating that we are not doing enough."
That is a blatant lie and the Minister well knows it. I never made any such statement.
Comment on this
The Deputy will withdraw that remark. He must not characterise a statement of any member of this House as a lie. It is unparliamentary and must be withdrawn.
Comment on this
Very good, Sir. I withdraw that remark. This canard which he has placed on the records of this House is a complete misrepresentation of anything I ever said and I want to deny it in a most emphatic manner. What he is referring to is where I had exposed another stunt of his in connection with this question of forestry—where he arrived outside the town of Louisburg with about 14 Press photographers, eight or nine land officials, seven or eight members of the Clann na Talmhan Party and a bulldozer and planted a whin bush and then wanted to make out that that was afforestation.
Comment on this
The Deputy has plenty of room to travel on the Second Reading and on the remainder of the motion.
Comment on this
You will know and I hope the House will know before I finish here to-night.
There are one or two other matters that I would like to direct the attention of the House to. In column 906 of the debate on the motion the Minister said:—
"I am having introduced a Bill which is going as far as humanly possible to go under the Constitution and as far as I am determined to go at the moment. Both myself and every other member of the Government will oppose any attempt to acquire land compulsorily for forestry."
This is a statement of the Minister. What have we here in this Bill? The most of it is concerned with the acquisition of land compulsorily for forestry. The most of it is for the purpose of taking land for forestry from people who do not want to give it. These are the sections enshrined in this Bill although the Minister told us a couple of nights ago that he and every other member of the Government will oppose any attempt to acquire any land compulsorily for forestry.
Comment on this
The whole of some of the sections deals with compulsory acquisition. All the sections dealing with acquisition in the principal Act refers to acquisition for afforestation purposes.
Comment on this
The Minister tried to put over the idea that he would not take land compulsorily for afforestation while, at the same time, this Bill has several sections for compulsory acquisition. That should be made clear to everybody. I do not say that in certain circumstances the compulsory powers should not be used, but what I do object to is the stunt of trying to put over that the Minister would not use compulsion when we are dealing with a Bill which is chock-full of compulsory powers.
In the same column, in the same debate, the Minister says:—
"We have a body which acquires land compulsorily for the relief of congestion, but that is a different matter from going into a farmer's house and telling him: ‘You get out of your farm and go where you like as we want it for growing trees.' If there is to be anything of that nature, I, for one, will head men with guns to defeat it. It is for the good of everybody to know what a red-hot question this is."
It certainly is a red hot question. Because of this promise of the Minister, who seems so concerned with Deputy MacBride's mythical sniping at the mythical Clann na Talmhan Party and at the Minister, the people were concerned that the Minister had taken down the gun to lead the army. Prices fell on the stock exchange when the word got out that the Minister rides again. I think that the Minister should not be allowed to frighten the country in this way. I think that the Taoiseach should reassure the country that these things will not happen and that he should endeavour to keep the Minister from taking down his gun again. It has had a devastating effect on the peace-loving people of the country and before any further preparation is made to move troops by the people across the Border the Taoiseach should reassure them that Deputy Blowick is not going to take down his gun.
As for the Bill itself I think it is a stunt measure because there is not a thing in it that is going to add 100 acres of land to the goal for afforestation.