We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1956—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–243 of 448. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1956
Enacted

No. 4 of 1956 ›

Because of the fact that the debate on the Vote on Account has pretty well covered the ground on the matters which would ordinarily be discussed on this Bill. I do not proposed to delay the, House for any very long period. Neverthless, I think it might be well that some of the matters discussed should be spoken to by a Labour member—in particular the suggestion that what this country needs very badly is increased production. I think all, of us, no matter on which side of the House we sit, would agree that it would be a good thing for this State if we could secure increased production. But while I have heard that suggestion made from many sides of the House I have yet to hear somebody indicate how that increased production is to be obtained.

With regard to increased production in agriculture, I do not feel competent to hazard a guess as to how that desirable state of affairs is to be achieved. All I would say is that, in my opinion, the giving of grants and the system of coaxing have been tried and, apparently, are unavailing. I would suggest that if some penalty was now imposed, some deterrent placed on the farmer who does not give the desired increased production, it would be more effective than the system of coaxing by way of grants.

On the industrial side, I hear a good deal of talk from management, and the people who are responsible for management, on the desirability of getting the workers to give increased production but when we on the Labour side, or in the trade union movement, ask for a share in consultation in the management of these enterprises it is denied us. We are told that the problem of how to run a factory is a function reserved to the management only. Why should the workers in a factory increase the effort which they now make, without having the slightest knowledge as to whether they are working themselves out of their jobs or not. That has been the effect on many workers in many factories here. They were induced to give increased production by bribes of efficiency bonuses and, after a short time, they were reverted to the old system of work, with a new daily average chalked up against them, and they were compelled to keep that average, an average which they had struck having being bribed into it by inducements of higher pay. After a short time many of these workers found themselves laid off because stocks had been built up sufficiently to permit the laying-off of a big percentage of them.

Now if the workers are assured on certain points they will co-operate. One of their points is, I suggest, that it will not mean unemployment for them or for their colleagues; secondly, that they will be paid for the extra work they do and, thirdly, that that increased production will be reflected in a reduced cost in the price of the commodity if it is for sale on the home market.

The problem facing the country is that of increased production. I understand that a committee was set up a number of years ago which had as its object an examination of the potential of the whole State, both agriculturally and industrially. If the Government are desirous, as I know they are, of increasing output both in industry and agriculture, I would suggest that some similar body should be set up to examine the problem as a whole and contrast the figures they arrive at against the normal population of the State, thereby striking a figure, or a standard of living, which we hope to give our people. They could appoint then, if they so saw fir, officials to act as liasion officers, or in some other capacity, who would move from factory to factory or area to area, in order to secure between management and workers the co-operation necessary to achieve the desired result. We, in the Labour Party, will be quite willing to do our part. The factory is the employer's profit. It is not only his profit but it is his only and his sole method of living.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The speech made by The Minister for Industry and Commerce when introducing the Supplies and Services Bill was further evidence, if further evidence were needed, that the Government does not know where it is going or what it is trying to do. Every statement we get from a Minister regarding the intention of the Government is rarely fulfilled; every forecast which they make is rarely proved accurate. We find them now denouncing as impracticable or undesirable the courses of action they were recommending only a few short months ago. The mismanagement which has characterised the Government in every phase of activity is particularly obvious in relation to the matter of prices. Prices, the trend of prices, the actions and intentions of the Government in regard to prices are the matters which are relevant to this Bill.

This Supplies and Services Act is kept on the Statement Book primarily for the purpose of giving the Government power to control prices and, if there is one thing this Government expressed its intention of doing, it was to control prices, to reduce prices by a more effective system of control than they had found in operation in 1954. It is right that this occasion, the submission of this Bill to continue the Act for another period, should be availed of to test the competence and efficiency of the Government by reference to its record in regard to prices.

Before the general election which put the present Minister for Industry and Commerce over there, it was a common theme with all the Deputies now sitting opposite that the system of price control then in operation was ineffective and inefficient. Amongst the many pledges which they made to the electors in the months prior to the General Election of 1954 was one to introduce another more efficient, more effective and more comprehensive system of price regulation. I do not know when that pledge of the Government was put into the wastepaper basket, when that declared intention of the present Minister for Industry and Commerce was allowed to die. It must have been very recently.

This is an annual Bill. Year after year, the Dáil has been asked to renew the powers which the Government exercises under this Supplies and Services Act. Twelve months ago the Minister for Industry and Commerce was here, as he is to-day, urging the continuation of these powers for another year and he said then that this new legislation which was to enable the Government to control prices, to fulfil their election pledges to reduce prices and replace the outworn, absolete, inefficient system of Fianna Fáil by a new and effective system, would be introduced within that year. The Minister pledged himself to the Dáil, as an argument in favour of the passing of the 1955 Supplies and Services Bill, that he would make every effort to produce this new system of price control and the legislation that was to set up this new system, as soon as possible. He would try to do it, he said, within 12 months.

All that has now gone by the board and the Minister tells us that he would feel a considerable reluctance at this point of time to substitute for the now familiar arrangements new and untried arrangements for price control. The "obsolete inefficient arrangements" of Fianna Fáil are now the familiar arrangements with which the Government is reluctant to part and the brand new efficacious system of price regulation, about which all the Deputies opposite were eloquent during the election campaign, is not going to appear. The Minister said he was reluctant to produce it, or reluctant to replace the present familiar arrangements with a new and untried system.

But why has this now legislation not been produced? The Minister was frank enough in telling us the reason why he changed his mind. When he changed it, I do not know; but he has now announced the change, and Deputies opposite have got to take it whether they like it or not. This new system of price control is now not going to be introduced—I want members of the Labour Party to note these words particularly—because, as the Minister said himself, prices will continue to rise and the Government does not know what to do about it.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if the Deputy is quoting, he ought to quote the exact words and give the authority.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

That will be a pleasure. I am sure I shall be quoting them many times in the next few months.

Comment on this

The Deputy prophesied in Kerry that the price of bread would go up. I hope he will prove more accurate now than he did in Kerry.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I will most certainly be accurate.

Comment on this

That will be something new for the Deputy, will it not?

Comment on this

The Minister did not see fit to put up a Labour candidate in Kerry.

Comment on this

Why should they?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I am quoting from column 216 of Volume 155 of the Official I Report:—

"It is for this reason that I feel a considerable reluctance, at this particular point of time, to substitute for the now familiar arrangements, new and untried arrangements. It would be most unfortunate if any new price control arrangements became at the outset associated in the public mind with the rising costs inseparable from a general inflationary situation and the harmful economic consequences which inevitably follow, or became discredited through inability to hold prices stable in circumstances, like those at present prevailing, in which increasing costs stem primarily from external factors which it is beyond the capacity of any authority here to control."

Comment on this

That is different from what you said first.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

We cannot keep order when there are misstatements attributed to us.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

All interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

What does that mean? Does it or does it not mean that the Government is not going ahead with its declared intention to introduce legislation for the establishment of a new system of price control, first, because prices will continue to rise, secondly, because the Government can do nothing about it and, thirdly, because they do not want to have the blame for the continuing rise in prices placed upon whatever system of price control they may devise and substitute for the present one. Is that not what the Minister said, and if he did not mean that, what did he mean?

Comment on this

I did not say what you said at first.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

That is what I said at first.

Comment on this

It is not. The Deputy is suffering from amnesia.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The principal characteristic of this Government is its complete mismanagement of the nation's business and behind that is its incapacity even to pursue a straight course in any matter, even in these matters in which they appear to have made up their minds as to what they are going to do. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was talking about the new, efficient system of price control which he was going to introduce last year to replace the absolete inefficient system of Fianna Fáil. Now that intention is being reversed. We are going to have the old familiar arrangements which in these circumstances are preferable to any new arrangement. We are going to have that because, as the Minister said, prices will continue to rise and because the Government can do nothing about the continuing rise in prices, they think they can escape some of the political consequences of that situation by not proceeding with their intention to establish their own system of price regulation and demonstrating in its operation how inefficient it would certainly be.

How the tune has changed during the past year. Last year when this Supplies and Services Bill was before the House the Minister for Industry and Commerce was assuring the Dáil that "the Government are trying to get the prices of essential commodities down. That is our policy" he proclaimed. What about their policy? When are the members of the Dáil and the people in the country going to see this policy in operation? Did prices come down during the past year? Will the Minister say what happened to prevent him and his colleagues in the Government fulfilling their policy. "We are trying to get the price of essential commodities down. That is our policy." How many essential commodities went down in price last year? Will the Minister name one? Is there any Deputy opposite to name one essential commodity the price of which was reduced last year?

Comment on this

Butter.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

We will come back to butter in a moment. This statement was made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce last year, 1958. Was there any change in the price of butter last year? No, there was no change.

Comment on this

It was 5d. a 1b. cheaper than when you were in office.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

It was reduced by subsidy in 1954 but in 1955 the Minister for Industry and Commerce was talking about bringing down the price of essential commodities. Will Deputy O'Leary name one that came down in 1955? Can he name any that went up? He will take good care not to do that.

Comment on this

You put them all up.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

A few went up in 1955. Will the Deputy mention them?

Comment on this

You put them up.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

On this question of prices there is silence from the Labour Deputies.

Comment on this

What is wrong with the policy?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

That is the very question the Minister for Industry and Commerce asked last year. He asked was there anything wrong in trying to reduce prices? And then he went on to say: "Is there anything wrong in exercising all the ingenuity at the Government's disposal in trying to re-reduce prices now? Is there anything wrong with it? Why did he not do it? Is there anything wrong in trying to reduce prices now? That is the very question the Minister asked last year and the Parliamentary Secretary asks now. What happened the time again in this House to the Deputies supporting the Government to be honest with the people, to tell the people why it was they found it impossible to fulfil that declared policy or why they did not try. Are we going to have the Minister again proclaiming that it is their policy to reduce the price of essential goods? Is he going to turn around, sweeping his arms towards the benches behind, to ask is there anything wrong with reducing prices? We heard him speaking yesterday like a director of the Central Bank with a toothache, and no director of the Central Bank was ever so concerned, so enthusiastic for the policy of austerity as the Minister for Industry and Commerce showed himself yesterday.

Comment on this

The directors of the Central Bank were all nominees of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The point that arises on this Bill is the Government's miserable failure to make even an effort to reduce prices last year. I remind Deputies opposite it was only two years ago, they were proclaiming to the world they had a system of price regulation which they were going to introduce, replacing the inefficient system of Fianna Fáil, that would bring down all prices and keep the cost of living within the limits of the purse of the poorest man. Everybody was going to be better off because prices were coming down. What happened? Will you be honest with the people and tell them why you did not find it practicable, why you are running away from these pledges which were given so liberally and so glibly two years ago? Do you not think that now that you have started upon this process of trying to educate the ordinary Irish people in economic realities, you should go the whole way and tell them the truth about prices?

This price gag you played at the general election paid its dividends; you got the votes and you got into office. You cannot possibly hope that the same gag will work twice, or do you? Does any Deputy opposite think he can go to the next election and get returned on a promise to reduce prices? Is there any Deputy opposite who would have the hardihood to stand up in public at a meeting and promise to reduce prices? Does he think he would get away from that meeting without hearing some very sarcastic comments from the ordinary people attending it? This gag will not work twice. Therefore you may as well as honest. It will not cost you anything.

Comment on this

There is no £3 10s. on the dole now.

Comment on this

What about the 14/- a week Fianna Fáil promised?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Twelve months ago the policy was to reduce prices. Twelve months ago there was nothing wrong with this idea that the cost of essential commodities should be brought down. Twelve months ago the Governments was going to use all the ingenuity at its disposal to reduce prices. It exercised some of that ingenuity in relation to tea. Last year the Minister said here on the Supplies and Services Bill that he would hold the price of tea at the level at which it was when they came into office. Mind you, during the election they were not promising to hold the price of tea at the level at which it then was. They were promising to reduce it below that level. They were contending amongst the people that the price of tea was unnecessarily high and that it could be reduced. They even had a device for bringing about a reduction in the price of tea which some of them spoke about, but after a few months in office they had given up that hope and were limiting their aim then and their policy to keeping the price of tea at the level at which it then was. Why was not that done? What happened the price of tea? Will Deputy O'Leary tell me by how much tea went up?

Comment on this

We do not grow tea.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Deputy O'Leary quite correctly remarks that this country does not grow tea. I assume the Minister for Industry and Commerce knew that 12 months ago.

Comment on this

What did the ex-Taoiseach say about tea?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Twelve months ago the present Minister for Industry and Commerce said that the Government would hold tea at the level at which it was when they came into office.

Comment on this

And they did for 12 months.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

No, for six months. Look what happened because of the mismanagement, because of the utter incompetence with which that situation was handled. The people of this country are now paying 3d. a 1b. for tea more than any other country in the world.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

There is a tax in the price of tea.

Comment on this

That is a falsehood.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

How much is it?

Comment on this

Look at the prices yourself on the markets.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

How much is it?

Comment on this

Why are you asking me? If you do not know, why are you asserting?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

My calculation is 3d.

Comment on this

Your calculations have never been right.

Comment on this

You said it was 3/- too cheap last year.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

For the purpose of keeping, over the period of the local elections, the price of tea at the level at which it was when Fianna Fáil left office, money was borrowed from the banks and then, when the Government decided that they could not go on borrowing money from the banks for the purpose of subsidising the price of tea, the price of tea was put up and it was put up by more than was justified by the increase in the price of tea in the world market. It went up by a little extra—the amount necessary to pay the interest on what was borrowed from the banks and to provide for the liquidation of the bank debt. My calculation of the amount which the people of this country are paying per 1b. of tea to pay that interest and sinking fund charge is 3d. How much is it?

Comment on this

You borrowed £6,000,000 from the bank during your period for the purchase of tea.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

That was a normal business transaction, the financing of stocks which were held as security for the advance.

Comment on this

The people paid 6d. per 1b. more for tea when you were in office, for interest charges.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

When I left office the people were buying tea at the cheapest price in the world.

Comment on this

The people lost more than 2d. for one complete transaction of 2,000,000 1b.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

This is the tea you were thinking of buying in Mincing Lane. Ask the Minister about that. He will tell you about that now.

Comment on this

Why did the people get rid of you, so?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I am still wondering about that. Possibly they are too.

Comment on this

Has Kerry not cured you of the wonder?

Comment on this

He will not have to wonder much longer. There are a few more lessons coming.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this

It will be all clear now in a minute.

Comment on this

When the members on the Government Benches are silent I will make my point of order. I want to suggest that there is deliberate obstruction of Deputy Lemass by the Government Party in not allowing him to speak in this House.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not complaining.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These interruptions must cease or the Chair will take action. Every Deputy is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

The assumption is that he speaks the truth.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The aim is not to prevent me speaking; the aim is to get away from this 3d. on tea. All the barracking starts as soon as I mention the 3d.

Comment on this

You said all that in Kerry. It did not do you any good.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Threepence a lb. on tea for five years, every householder will continue to pay, because of mismanagement, because of incompetence. They got no value for that. That is the price of Government mishandling of that situation.

Comment on this

They paid 6d. extra under you for interest charges and you know that well.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Government's policy 12 months ago was to hold the price of tea at the level at which it was when they came into office. It is now 2/- a lb. higher. Why?

Comment on this

There is no slave labour now in India and other countries. That is why. You have to pay the people of India.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Deputy O'Leary and his colleagues said that they would not support any Government which did not bring down the price of tea, bread, drink and cigarettes. They even told the people that they would get a pledge from the Government that these reductions would be brought about before they would vote for it.

Comment on this

They did not get a standstill Order. You did.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Did not you say that? There is silence now. The barracking has stopped.

Comment on this

The standstill Order was your business.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Bread was another commodity.

Comment on this

There was 70/- a ton for wheat the night before you were thrown out of office that had to be paid for.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

What did the Democratic Senator in Washington have in mind when he presented the green donkey to the Taoiseach? It may be he was expressing the opinion of the Irish people far more accurately than he knew but surely, if there was anything the Government did not want, it was another green donkey.

Comment on this

They did not create him Chief Rain-in-the-Face.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

There is one value it may have. It may solve the problem of a candidate in Leix-Offaly for you. Let us get back to the price of bread.

Comment on this

You said that had gone up.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Is it going up?

Comment on this

You said it during the Kerry election.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Am I, as a member of this House, representing a constituency in Dublin City, entitled on this Bill to ask the Government is the price of bread going up? Again there is silence.

Comment on this

You said it was going up last month, did you not?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I said it would go up after the by-election.

Comment on this

You may be a good card player but you cannot change your cards that quickly.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Will the Minister say here and now that it will not go up?

Comment on this

You said it would go up the week after the election.

Comment on this

Answer the question.

Comment on this

The question is a fraudulent question.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Minister may have a certain reluctance in signing an Order increasing the price of bread. That is not the way they are going to handle that situation. The Taoiseach brought the bakers in already and suggested to them that they will deal with this bread situation by decontrolling its price. Is that what the Government have in mind?

Comment on this

That is a falsehood.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

That suggestion was made by the Taoiseach to a deputation of bakers.

Comment on this

That is a falsehood.

Comment on this

Did the Minister promise the master bakers when they gave an increase in wages that they could increase the price of bread?

Comment on this

That is a double falsehood.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I have to take the Minister's word that what I have said is not true.

Comment on this

And what Deputy McGrath has said is doubly untrue. I never saw the master bakers to promise them before that case was heard.

Comment on this

Your officials did.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I say the Taoiseach met representatives of the bakers when the Minister for Industry and Commerce was in America and put to them that, instead of making an Order increasing the price of bread, the Government was considering decontrolling the price of bread.

Comment on this

You said "offered.""Offered them" you said a few minutes ago—"offered them" decontrol.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Will the Minister say exactly what did happen?

Comment on this

I will when I am making my own speech.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Anyway, the Minister has said that what I have said is not true.

Comment on this

What Deputy McGrath said is doubly untrue.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

This problem of the price of bread is not an emergency one. From the day that the Fianna Fáil Government decided that we were going to produce Irish flour in Irish flour mills and as far as possible from Irish grown wheat, we set out to ensure that the possible effects of that policy upon the consumers of bread would be minimised and the price of bread is controlled under permanent legislation and not under the Supplies and Services Act. Long before the war there was an Act passed hero for the regulation of the price of bread in relation to the price of flour. Is that legislation going to be repealed? Is all the talk which the Deputies opposite indulged in before the election about reducing the price of bread, about vigorous action to bring down the price of all essential commodities, going to end up in the complete stripping of controls and the creation of a situation in which those who sell these commodities can charge what they like?

We have had some questions here to-day regarding biscuits. Again, I accuse the Minister for Industry and Commerce of gross incompetence in handling the situation which developed following the Government's decision in the Budget of last year to withdraw the subsidy for flour used in the manufacture of biscuits. I say the biscuit manufacturers tried for months to get from the Government some decision as to what arrangements were to be substituted for those that prevailed previously. I do not know to what extent deterioration of conditions in the biscuit trade, the laying-off of workers, about which the Labour Party appear to be so unconcerned, is directly attributable to that change or is in part attributable to other circumstances, but it is obvious that there has taken place in that industry during the most year, since the Government altered the arrangements which operated for that industry, a very considerable worsening of conditions involving the closing of one factory and a reduction of employment in others.

Is the Government going do anything about it? I urged them when they brought their proposals here in the Budget last year to effect this saving on the flour subsidy by withdrawing the subsidy on flour used in biscuit manufacture—a saving, I think, of about £500,000—to consider again what the consequences of that act might be. I pointed out that that was an industry which was not merely of considerable importance from the point of view of employment but also as an exporting industry which was helping to contribute to the reduction in the trade deficit about which Ministers are now so concerned, but, instead of getting a modification of views from the Government, a position was allowed to develop in which those engaged in the industry did not know where they were for weeks, did not know what prices they were going to pay for the flour they were using. They were using flour making goods not knowing what it would cost them, while pressing for a decision from the Minister for Industry and Commerce and unable to get it.

The Government said it was going to use all the ingenuity at its disposal to reduce prices. Well, the ingenuity at the Government's disposal has put prices up to an all-time record. There never was in the history of this country a time when the price level was as high as it is now——

Comment on this

And the wages level.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

——and it is going up. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has warned us that an upward movement in prices is in progress; it has not stopped yet. The Minister for Finance has repeatedly warned us that the worst has yet to come. Has the Government thrown in the towel completely? Have they now abandoned all pretence that they can do anything to influence the course of prices? Do they not realise that by far the most important problem before this country at the present time is how to bring about stability in prices?

I said here in the debate on the Vote on Account that all the exhortations of Ministers and of representatives of the savings committee to the people of this country to save money are wasted if they cannot hold out the promise that the money saved now will buy as much in 12 months' time as it will buy to-day, that it will not have depreciated in value by reason of a continued rise in prices.

Comment on this

Could you guarantee that?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Undoubtedly there is no prospect that we will be able to secure in this country the development we must have, unless we can make resources available by increasing sayings but the essential condititon of getting that expansion in savings is some prospect of price stability. Will the Government hold out any prospect of price stability? Are they going to try to do anything to keep prices stable? Have they any idea in their minds now as to how it might be done? Two years ago they were gaily forecasting a rapid reduction in prices, an improvement in the standard of living by reason of a reduction in prices—what is their view now?

I am sure Ministers do not like the new tune they have to play nowadays. There is a popular song which goes—I think—"We wish we were young and foolish again". It must be almost the theme song——

Comment on this

Do you want the cattle prices down?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

As the cattle prices have gone down, will the Deputy explain why meat prices have not gone down?

Comment on this

They have gone up——

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Can we get an explanation of that?

Comment on this

Cattle prices have gone up. You said last week the bottom had fallen out of the market.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

And then the meat prices have gone up?

Comment on this

I do not think he said that.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Last year the Minister said in his most dramatic manner that the Government would keep its promises to the people or explain why not. Well the time to explain is now.

Comment on this

We will decide when to do the explaining. We will decide when that time will come and you cannot his the table and say "now".

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Mark you, the decision, perhaps, does not rest altogether with the Government. Have not the people to whom the promises were made something to say in this regard? Surely they are entitled to say something?

Comment on this

There was a lot of them in North Kerry.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The one thing I said in Kerry, which has been proved to be 100 per cent. true, was that if the Fianna Fáil candidate was not successful, Government Deputies would claim the result as justifying them in defaulting on their pledges. Now that statement has been proven to be strictly accurate.

Comment on this

Do not take yourself too seriously because the people do not.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I do not know if Deputies opposite think that some explanation is due from the Government in regard to prices or not. What I am saying is that on this very Bill 12 months ago the Minister said that they would get prices down or explain why they failed. I submit that this is the occasion—the reintroduction. of this Bill into the Dáil—upon which that explanation should be given to the Dáil and to the Labour Deputies, because they want that explanation. After all they have to go back from the Dáil to their constituency organisations and to the trade union bodies the members of which are undoubtedly anxious to get the explanation.

Comment on this

We went back for the local elections.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

What explanation will the Deputy give them? Will Deputy O'Leary tell the Dáil what explanation he gives to the people of Enniscorthy when they ask him——

Comment on this

I headed the poll.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

And if the Deputy can think up another good gag he might even do it again.

Comment on this

And your man went down.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Leary should not interrupt.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

It must happen now and again that somebody stops the Deputy in the street and says: "When are these promises that you made going to be fulfilled? When is the price of any commodity going to come down?" I am sure Deputy O'Leary is not stumped for an explanation, but I think he would be greatly reinforced if he had a word of explanation from the Minister. I am not sure that he is going to get it, but it is no harm to remind the Minister of what be said 12 months ago—that they would get prices down or explain why—and to invite him to give the Dáil that explanation now.

I have said that it is the extreme incompetence with which the affairs of the State have been administered in almost every Department of the Government that is the main cause of most of the present problems facing our people.

Let us set out their record briefly. They said they were going to reduce prices. They said: "We are trying to get the prices of essential commodities down. That is our policy." Those are words used by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Since then prices have gone up and they are still rising. They used all the ingenuity at their disposal and the net result was that prices went up and are still going up. They were going to reduce taxation. That is something they would like to forget now. They were to reduce the cost of Government by £10,000,000 and to reduce taxation in consequence.

Now the Minister for Finance has issued a threat about the forthcoming Budget. According to what they say it will be a difficult one. Not one of them is now saying it is their policy to reduce taxation. Not one of them is now holding out that bright prospect to the people of this country. Or are they? I have said it may be their tactics to build up fears about the increase in taxation in the Budget so that anything they produce may be regarded with relief by the community. They are building up apprehensions now so that any little imposition that may be necessary will be accepted with relief. I do not know if an increase in taxation is necessary. Probably the taxes imposed last week are the first instalment of the 1956 Budget so that the rest of it will be a little more pleasant than the first part. But they promised to reduce taxes and taxes went up. They were to reduce the cost of capital. Deputy O'Donovan, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, spoke on this Bill last year and said it was the policy of the Government to bring down the cost of money. Does the Deputy remember that?

Comment on this
John O'Donovan Parliamentary Secretary to the Government (Mr. O'Donovan) Fine Gael

So it is.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Let us see how successfully that policy was fulfilled. The Minister for Finance is now crying because the cost of money is going up. He is crying because capital is scarce and dear. What a successful policy that was. I admit that the Parliamentary Secretary was only repeating what the Taoiseach had said before him.

Comment on this

That has been and is my own view.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Parliamentary Secretary made that statement on this Bill last year and perhaps he will intervene this year with an explanation as to why that policy did not work. Six months ago the whole Front Bench of the Government were slapping their chests because bank charges had not been allowed to go up, because the charges for overdrafts or loan accommodation had not been allowed to increase, and within a few weeks the Minister for Finance was going not to the Dáil, but to the Dublin Chamber of Commerce announcing that the banks——

Comment on this

Within a couple of weeks?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

A few weeks.

Comment on this

Ten months.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The debate on our motion regarding the Government's financial policy took place in October.

Comment on this

When did the Government make the decision about the bank rate?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

In December.

Comment on this

You said a few weeks.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Within a few weeks of their statement they announced a new policy and said the new policy was far better than the old. A short time ago we had the Minister for Finance describing this balance of payments deficiency as a fetish. I want to bring up that word again—a fetish, a bogey created by Fianna Fáil to mislead the people. We had the Minister for Industry and Commerce saying that those who said the Irish people were spending more than they could afford were mentally deficient. We had the Attorney-General, Deputy McGilligan, saying it was utter nonsense to assert the Irish people were spending beyond their means. How quickly that cry has changed. Now faced with this deficit in the balance of payments they have panicked, not that their panicking produced any worthwhile proposals to ease the situation, but we have now this amazing result of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Leader of the Labour Party, paraphrasing the report of the Central Bank and we have the Minister for Finance saying "ditto" to all that.

Incompetence, mishandling, mismanagement in every Department have added to our problems, I do not say that even the most competent Government in the world, even a Fianna Fáil Government, could have solved all the problems, but they could have prevented them developing at the rate and on the scale they have developed under the Coalition. These are not the only problems. There is the growing threat to our fuel supplies. I warned the Government that the British authorities were forecasting the day when Britain will be unable to meet her own coal needs, much less have a surplus to export to us. What are the Government doing about that? This is the Bill which gives them the powers to control the supplies of essential commodities. Are there any more essential supplies than fuel? They are putting back the electricity generating programme. The power stations in Offaly, in Longford and elsewhere, which were to come into production this year, are put back until next year.

Comment on this

That is not true. The Government have done nothing in that field at all to put them back.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The stations which the E.S.B. said in 1954 would come into operation in 1956 will not come into commission until 1957.

Comment on this

The Government have not put them back.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Then we get a ludicrous statement by the Minister that the board is producing more electricity than it can sell.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

It is utter nonsense. There is no country in Western Europe where the per capita consumption of electricity is so low as it is here. In some countries in Western Europe the per capita consumption of electricity is four times what it is here. Did the E.S.B. say they had more current than they could sell and, if so, what are they doing to sell it? Does any Deputy believe that? If they have more current than they can sell, where is the E.S.B. staff of commercial travellers to sell it? The E.S.B. were never in that position. From the end of the war— we will leave the war out of it because it was an exceptional period—they were never more than one step ahead of the growth of the demand for current, a demand which was not stimulated by any action on their part. They barely kept ahead of the demand and there were years during that, period when it was doubtful whether they would be able to keep ahead, years when they had to go to large electricity consumers like Cement Ltd. and ask them to be prepared to shut down at short notice so that the power they were using could be made available for hospitals and other such institutions, for domestic lighting and other purposes.

While it is true that I pressed them to get ahead with the construction programme, first because I felt we should be in a position in which the board would have to go out to sell current to bring about the improvement in the standard of living of our people which a higher per capita consumption would represent, I did not ever ask the board to do something that they said could not be done.

Comment on this

Indeed you did.

Comment on this

What about Screeb?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Perhaps I had better correct myself. The board once said it was not possible to use milled peat for the generation of electricity. They have changed their minds now.

Comment on this

You got them to put up stations where there was no turf.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Where?

Comment on this

I will take you down on an excursion and you will see the stations. There will be a nice monument to you.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Something very interesting has been said here now. I pressed them to erect four stations, one in Kerry, one in Clare, one in Galway, and one in Donegal, all designed to burn hand-won turf, stations which would take the whole of the surplus turf produced by private individuals in these areas at reasonable prices. The board did not want to do it because they felt it was not an economic proposition, that it was a social welfare scheme. I agree the primary purpose was social. In fact I said to the board that if they did not want to do it I would set up another authority which would run the stations and sell the current to the board. The board did not fancy the prospect of another electricity authority and said they would run the stations themselves. I admit the idea was that these stations would take over wherever turf was available and that they would not be operating at all when turf was not available either because of weather conditions or because there was some other market for the turf. I feel that the effort which is being made to give to these areas the tremendous benefits which a secure market for hand-won turf represents is completely inadequate. I see advertisements offering 50/- per ton for turf delivered at the stations being published but apart from these advertisements there is no sign of any inducement being offered to expedite turf production. I am also conscious of the fact that the £200,000 allocated out of the National Development Fund to provide the roads leading to the stations has not been spent. I do not know if there was a change of policy there.

I hope the Minister will not allow any arguments from the board to dissuade him from proceeding with the erection of these stations, which have, undoubtedly, a social purpose. The amount of current they would produce would be comparatively insignificant but they represent for these areas a higher standard of living for the people living in them. I hope there is no pressure coming from the board to the Minister to drop these projects and if there is such pressure I hope he will resist it.

In my view we have not yet got into the position in which we have enough generating capacity to enable us successfully to propagate the use of electricity in this country and, if we are facing a shortage of coal as I fear we are, the demand for current will increase considerably and rapidly. There must always be some surplus generating capacity. We cannot at the peak hour of the peak day of the peak month take the risk that a temporary breakdown in one single generating unit will throw the whole scheme out of gear. There must be some surplus generating capacity and I do not believe that we have that. The demand for electric power has been increasing by 80,000,000 units a year and we are not getting new generating capacity established to meet that rate of increase.

Comment on this

The generating capacity is well in excess of the consumer capacity. Let the people who know talk about that.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The consumer capacity varies from the lowest point on, I think, the 20th June to the highest point on the 20th November and at 6 o'clock on the 20th November there is a demand for current more than double the demand at the lowest point. The board must have installed capacity to meet that demand.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

If that is so, the board's plans are at fault. They can only justify that statement on the grounds that there is no obligation on them to sell current. The board has never tried to sell current.

Comment on this

They have been trying to sell current for the past six months.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

They never have tried to sell current. They never were in a position to do so.

Comment on this

That is a libel on the board and the staff.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

I do not care how the Minister describes it. I am stating what I know to be the position in that regard. I would be astonished if, over in Fitzwilliam Square, the senior engineers of the board are not laughing up their sleeves at the preposterous statements made in that regard.

Comment on this

They are laughing at you. The matter has been discussed since you made that statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

There is, in the minds of the Fine Gael Party, the idea that the right place for an Irishman is under a stone in a bog. They think that we should not have the same standard of civilisation as people in other European countries. We will not have touched our proper rate of demand until we have put it up to the same level as has been reached in other Western European countries where the people have a reasonable standard of living. I hope that the Fine Gael mentality is not corrupting what is left of the independence of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

Who was it described the Shannon scheme as a white elephant?

Comment on this

The blue shirt is wrapped around you.

Comment on this

There seems to be some of it in your mouth.

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

Everything which the Coalition Government put their hands to they make a mess of it. Even the plans which were going reasonably well when they came into office are now operating in a haphazard irregular way since they got control. There used to be a legendary king called Midas who had the faculty that everything he touched turned to gold. There is something completely opposite to that in the Coalition Government because everything that they touch turns sour.

We are going to oppose this Bill. We do not think that this Government is to be trusted with the powers and responsibilities which the Supplies and Services Act gives them. I do not think that any Government is to be trusted with these powers. We took these powers in the exceptional years of the war and we retained them to handle the abnormal difficulties of the post-war period. The Fianna Fáil Government took a decision in 1953 that that Act should lapse; that it was not right for any Government to hold the power of directing by Order the lives and the business of our people.

There was an obligation placed then on every member of the Government to come to the Dáil to get, by legislation, any of these powers which he thought it necessary to retain. We took that decision and every member of the Government was notified that by the end of 1954 the Act would cease to operate. They were notified that they had to bring into the Dáil legislation to retain powers which they might require to retain.

Some of that legislation has already appeared before this House. Other Bills which we had forecast will, no doubt, come along. That decision was announced to the Dáil by me, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, when I brought in the 1953 Supplies and Services Bill. Since that we have the 1955 Act and this 1956 Bill continuing the powers for a further period.

Comment on this

Was there no Act in 1954?

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

The Act which I had passed in 1953 was to continue the powers for 15 months instead of the usual 12 months in order to give members of the Government time to consider the terms of whatever legislation was deemed to be necessary. I said last year, and I repeat, and I speak with the experience of one who was a member of a Government for 20 years, that every Department of State is extremely loath to part with powers which they have once obtained. There seems to be an idea in the heads of civil servants that a situation may arise at some time in the future when the exercise of these powers will be necessary. And only a Government that realises the importance of it and insists upon that change will be able to strip these Departments of their exceptional powers. That must be done; and the Dáil, I think, should register its disapproval of the failure of the Government to get rid of this Supplies and Services Act in 1955 by refusing to continue the powers conferred under the Act for a further period.

Giving these powers to the Coalition Government is like giving a hatchet to a child. It is as dangerous as that. One does not know at what it will take a swipe next. Government incompetence can, in time, bring this country to disaster. I realise that there is nothing much we can do about it. The Government has a majority in this House, a majority which will for a time continue to support it. The Labour Party, in whom no doubt some sections of our people still repose some hopes, will not use their power; they are mute in face of what the Government is doing — not mute of malice but mute of discretion. The other groups and Deputies who support the Government are just like dumb sheep which will go wherever they are driven.

The situation that faces the country is, therefore, a very dangerous one. Twice before in my lifetime the Fine Gael Party brought this country to the brink of ruin, brought it to a position where even the retention of our political freedom appeared to be a matter of some doubt. Now, once more, under Fine Gael leadership, the country is being brought on the same road again. There are some people in this Dáil who can stop them. The ordinary people outside have not got a chance to stop them yet. We cannot stop them as an Opposition because they have a permanent majority here. But there must be somebody opposite who must realise that this is a far more serious matter than Deputy O'Leary would suggest.

Comment on this

Another civil war!

Comment on this
Mr. Lemass

This is more than a question of getting votes. We do not care. We are not interested in the political consequences. But we are interested in the well-being and welfare and future livelihoods of our people. It is that which is at stake because of Government incompetence. There must be some people in some of the Parties supporting the Government who realise that that is at stake and who will exercise the influence they may have to bring a halt to this march of incompetence, this continued mismanagement of the nation's business. There must be some people who will do that, not because it will bring votes in an election but because it is their duty as Irishmen and their duty to the people who sent them here.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass referred to-day to the election programmes of the past. The main burden of his complaint was that the prices of essential commodities had not been reduced. But he failed to refer to the fact that wage levels had been increased so that wage earners could meet these increased costs. I was surprised to hear Deputy Lemass refer to the Supplies and Services Act of 1953 which, he said, would be altered at the end of 1954. Deputy Lemass must remember that the Supplies and Services Bill comes before the House each year before 31st March. In 1954, therefore, he had an opportunity once more of doing away with this measure if he so wished.

This Bill relates to the control of prices, including food, clothes, fuel and rent. That is the basis of this Bill. It is designed to keep a fair balance between prices and wages. If we did not have this legislation we would have to replace it by some other legislation with a similar purpose and a similar effect. It has been necessary for us to decide whether the existing legislation should be replaced or kept in force for a further period. Now this legislation has been found, not alone during the war years but since the war years, to be reasonably effective and in the changing circumstances over the years, since the end of the war, this legislation has been found reasonably flexible in meeting those changing circumstances. Our complaint against the Fianna Fáil Party is that they always failed to preserve a fair balance between the cost of living and the level of wages. We have only to look back and see what has occurred. We remember that Fianna Fáil put up the cost of living by 23 points from 1951 to 1954.

Comment on this

Put it up?

Comment on this

They put it up 13 points in their Budget. They put that Budget to a vote here and got it passed. In the ultimate the cost of living went up by 23 points during that period, but wage levels did not increase to the same extent. They did not keen pace with the cost of living, and that was our complaint. There is a clear example of what happened in the case of the civil servants. Towards the end of 1954, the employees of the State put their case to an independent judge and he decided, in their favour, that the margin between the level of their incomes and the cost of living had been made greater by the policy of Fianna Fáil in increasing the prices of items included in the index.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for a Deputy to quote a judge or a person adjudicating and to say that that person said, in his judgment, a "political reason".

Comment on this

I withdraw the word "said" and I will substitute "decided".

Comment on this

The Deputy said that the judge said that Fianna Fáil put up the cost of living.

Comment on this

There was a man put in a certain position and he was asked to judge as between the civil servants and the State. He decided that the margin between the level of the cost of living and the level of earnings in the Civil Service had been made greater by the policy of Fianna Fáil in increasing——

Comment on this
Seán MacCarthy Acting-Chairman (Mr. MacCarthy) Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy speaking from recollection or making a quotation?

Comment on this

I am speaking from recollection, and my recollection is very clear and very correct.

Comment on this

Is that what the judge said?

Comment on this

I did not think I was to be questioned by the Chair.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that the judge said that it was because the Fianna Fáil Government increased the cost of living.

Comment on this

I am not being allowed to make my case on this point, but I shall persist until I am allowed.

Comment on this

Subject to the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this

My complaint is that, so far as the cost of living is concerned, Fianna Fáil allowed the cost of essential goods to go up and, at the same time, kept down the level of wages. If you like, they did not allow wages to chase the cost of living at a uniform rate. When the margin as between the level of the cost of living and the income of the civil servants was made greater than it ought to be, the civil servants put their case to an arbitrator, if you like, to decide as between the State and the civil servants. Having considered all the circumstances, that arbitrator decided that the case made by the civil servants was the correct one and that the margin between their income and the level of the cost of living had been made greater by the action of the Government; and he awarded them retrospective pay.

Now I come back to the point I was going to make, had I been allowed. The civil servants were granted retrospective pay because the arbitrator decided that Fianna Fáil had allowed the margin to grow greater. But the Fianna Fáil Government decided not to pay that retrospective award. They decided that the State would not pay that money although it had been awarded on an independent decision. That is the civil servants' side of the case so far as the margin between wage levels and the cost of living is concerned.

Are we not correct in assuming that the same position existed in the commercial world between the wage levels of our workers and the cost-of-living increases that occurred during those years? The margin probably became greater there, too, than existed at the particular time which was the basis of the argument. The point I am making is that so far as the inter-Party Government is concerned we are taking steps to ensure, and have adopted a policy which ensures that wage earners, people in business and people receiving incomes from other sources, will be enabled to keep pace with the cost-of-living increase if there is a rise.

It was suggested that the Fine Gael Party promised to reduce prices. When that case was made it was intended that the margin between the cost of living and the prices would be reduced, and we have done so. Although the cost of living has gone up a number of points the average level of our people's earnings has gone up a greater number of points. Consequently, the people were compensated for any rise in the cost of living.

I have heard the Fianna Fáil Party advocating a reduction in prices of certain commodities but do not forget that they are, in effect, advocating a reduction of wages which form the basis of those prices. We should hear from Fianna Fáil whether, if they suggest we should reduce prices, we should also reduce wage levels. That is the effect of the case being made by Fianna Fáil but they would not use those words. They would not ask us to reduce wages but they would ask us to reduce prices which form the greater part of the wages being paid to our people. A suggestion regarding a reduction of prices is a suggestion of a reduction of wages.

Comment on this

Not at all. More production can give you lower prices at the same wages. Your neighbour the Parliamentary Secretary will agree.

Comment on this

I was amused to hear the Deputy stating what his Party never succeeded in doing during their three years of office. Prices of imports were going down all the time.

Comment on this
Seán MacCarthy Acting-Chairman (Mr. MacCarthy) Fianna Fáil

These running commentaries may be entertaining but they are out of order.

Comment on this

Why do not the Fianna Fáil Party say that they want wages reduced again? That is the point they are in fact making but they do not want to use those words. We know they were very fond of the Wages Standstill Order and at the same time they allowed the cost of living to get out of control. We remember the conditions that existed in 1948 when we took office, nearly three years after the war. People were on a ration of two oz. butter per week at a rationed price. We used this Supplies and Services Bill in the years which followed to enable us to adopt a two-price system. The two-price system enabled us to give a larger ration of a ½ lb. of butter per week. Eight oz. per week were given instead of two oz. at the same price as Fianna Fáil were giving the people two oz. In addition to that they had the opportunity of purchasing any extra butter at the normal cost. We used this Bill also to give to the consumer a ¼ lb. of tea instead of a ½ oz. at the same price as in 1948. In addition to that we gave them all the tea they wanted at 3/- a lb.

Comment on this

What is it now?

Comment on this

I will tell you that later. Our people could buy tea by the cwt. at 3/- a lb. under the inter-Party Government and in the following 12 months even the widow or the old age pensioner who wanted a 1/4 lb. of tea in the week had to pay 5/- or 6/- a lb. for it. Deputy Lemass talked about reductions in prices. This Bill enables food prices to be adjusted upwards and downwards. I would like to remind Deputy Lemass that when this Government came into office in 1954 we reduced the price of bread and we also reduced the price of butter by 5d. a pound.

Comment on this

When was it reduced?

Comment on this

1954, I think, if you will look up the records.

Comment on this

That was not the halfpenny Fianna Fáil Budget?

Comment on this

The Deputy has a good memory. It was a reduction.

Comment on this

By Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

I think your greatest achievement was putting 3d. on the loaf.

Comment on this

I am sorry Deputy Lemass is not here because he knows himself we also used the powers under this Bill to keep the price of butter down by 5d. a lb., costing approximately £2,000,000. That reduction of 5d. a lb. was a contribution of £2,000,000 to the dairying industry of this country. The fate of that industry was in the balance when we took office in 1954. In February, 1954, a strike took place and the farmers refused to sell the milk. The demand for creamery butter was falling very rapidly because the Fianna Fáil Party had put the price of butter so high. The inter-Party Government reduced it by 5d. and the sales of Irish creamery butter continued.

Comment on this

They did not increase? They continued?

Comment on this

They increased. The statistics again will show that when we reduced the price of Irish creamery butter to the consumer the quantity being consumed increased. We heard Deputy Lemass talking about pledges and promises but did we ever read a pledge or promise so clear as Point 15 in the Fianna Fáil programme which they enunciated in 1951 to maintain food subsidies and to control prices? In less than 12 months they increased the price of bread by 3d. a loaf; they increased the price of butter by 1/4 a lb. and they also increased the prices of tea, cigarettes, beer and spirits.

The only thing they took off, of course, was the tax on the dance halls. That was the contribution which they made to the national economy that year. So, when we hear the Fianna Fáil Party talking about pledges and promises and undertakings given, let them never forget Point 15 of their own programme which, in fact, was thrown overboard at the first opportunity. That point is supposed to have been a promise to five irresponsible Deputies who came into this House and changed the Government although they had been elected to vote against Fianna Fáil in the nomination of a Taoiseach. Those five gentlemen were not returned to this House when they went to the electors and asked them once more to send them into the Dáil to turn their coats.

Comment on this

Take care that they may not be back again soon.

Comment on this

They were responsible enough to be Ministers in a previous Government.

Comment on this

There is no danger.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Both the House and the country will be far more interested in the present Bill, if the Deputy comes to it.

Comment on this

I am speaking, Sir, about the circumstances which brought about the reversal of Point 15 in the Fianna Fáil programme.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

That is not in this Bill.

Comment on this

No, Sir, but this Bill refers to the maintenance of food subsidies and the controlling of prices. That is what I am speaking about. I heard Deputy Lemass talking about the purchasing power of the £. That was a very brazen reference because, if he goes to the trouble of looking up the records, he will find that from 1932, when the Fianna Fáil Party came into office, to 1948, when they went out of office, the purchasing power of the £ dropped 10s. That was a fair contribution towards the reduction of the purchasing power of the £ in the space of 16 years. The purchasing power of the £, of course, has fallen since. The Fianna Fáil Party do not seem to remember that at least they cut the value of the £ in half over the period of 16 years.

Let us remember, when we are considering the cost-of-living level, that we must take three things into consideration. We must see what is the total national income. We must see whether it is going up or coming down and if the level of wages is keeping a reasonable distance in front of the cost of living. These three factors will contribute to stability. I agree with the remark of one of the Deputies opposite that when we have taken these three aspects into consideration, the fourth and the most important factor to the nation is productivity. It is on productivity that our policy should be based. Our efforts should be directed towards an increase of productivity because in productivity lies the possibility of prosperity and improvement in the standard of living.

I heard Deputy Lemass talking about the standard of living. Is there anybody here who will compare the standard of living that existed in 1948 with the standard of living that exists at the present time, after two terms under the inter-Party Government?

Comment on this

You may say that again.

Comment on this

Is there anybody who remembers the 100,000 families in Dublin City, sleeping on staircases and in hallways, waiting for houses after eight years of Fianna Fáil before the war and three years after the war? In addition we remember the weekly ration of 2 oz. of Irish creamery butter in this agricultural country and the fact that people had to go under the counter for a rasher. We hear from the other side of the House all this talk about pigs. Let us remember that in 1948, when we came into office, a good price for bacon was about 130/- per cwt. and at the present time the price proposed to be guaranteed for grade A bacon, when we have a surplus to export, is 235/- per cwt. At that time there was a complete shortage of bacon in the country.

We remember also that there was a shortage of cattle and sheep in the country. The total value of our exports at that time in live stock was only approximately £40,000,000. Let me remind Deputies, when there is all this talk about the adverse trade balance, that the adverse trade balance in 1947 was £30,000,000, although the total value of our live stock exported was £40,000,000. The total value of our live-stock exports at the present time is approximately between £110,000,000 and £120,000,000. They are comparing the adverse trade balance of to-day with the adverse trade balance of 1947, which was £30,000,000, in relation to live-stock exports of £40,000,000.

Sir, I am in favour of this Bill being continued because I am satisfied that in the circumstances and in the changing conditions it is reasonably effective.

Comment on this

I propose to be very brief in my comment and to deal with one specific matter only. Before I do so I want, without any discourtesy to the Parliamentary Secretary, to inform him of the point I make and the subject matter of my remarks so that he may reply to-night. Otherwise, I shall ask here to-morrow for special time to have this matter discussed. I want, in an uncontentious manner, to have the Minister's view, if possible, to-night so that the time of the House will not be taken up to-morrow and he will be saved and I will be saved the trouble of having this thing thrashed out ad nauseam.

In order to ensure, as far as the Acting-Chairman is concerned, that I am keeping within the rules of procedure on this particular Bill, I want to assure the Acting-Chairman that the matter to which I intend to refer is definitely a matter that comes under Supplies and Services. The subject matter has already been dealt with under a Bill that was passed in this House last November, the Control of Exports (Temporary Provisions) Bill, 1955. In his opening statement on that Bill the Minister said, as reported in Volume 153, column 943, of the Official Debates:—

"Powers of this nature sought to be afforded by the Bill is already available to the Minister for Industry and Commerce under the Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946, but I have felt it desirable to provide a firmer basis for powers, the necessity for which arose largely out of the emergency conditions which prevailed from 1939 onwards."

Therefore, in so far as the matter concerned is related to that particular Bill of 1955, it can also be raised on this Supplies and Services measure.

To get down to the actual matter in question, it is in connection with the supply and processing of waste paper in this country. Deputies may be aware that in recent weeks — within the last three weeks — a statement was published in a number of daily papers that the save waste paper campaign which had been so successful for the last two or three years was in jeopardy and that the paper mills in this country that had been taking the waste paper had decided, in view of the glut that was brought about through imports, to cease taking the supply of waste paper from the rural areas and from the city areas in Ireland.

Comment on this

Is that quite right about the cut being brought about by imports?

Comment on this

I quote the Irish Times of March 13th:—

"The National Waste Paper Company of Waterford has so much waste paper on hands that it has informed collectors that it will not accept any at least for three or four weeks. The reason for the present glut, according to an official of the Waterford company, is that nearly every parish in Ireland is collecting waste paper now."

That is the company's statement, but I propose to show the House, from statistics available in the Minister's own Department, that is completely untrue; that this glut has arisen, not through collections in rural Ireland, but through imports of waste paper from Bristol, Belfast and other centres.

Comment on this

Did you not say a few moments ago that you read in the paper that it was due to a glut of imports?

Comment on this

That I said it was in the papers? Well, I hope the Parliamentary Secretary is not suggesting that I am misquoting the paper?

Comment on this

I intend to argue that the glut that has come about is due to imports rather than to extra supplies on the home front as suggested by the particular companies themselves. For the past couple of years the two leading mills in Ireland, namely, the Killeen Paper Mills and the National Board and Paper Company in Waterford, have, through various publicity campaigns, urged the people in rural Ireland and in the cities to collect waste paper and they said if this waste paper was collected a reasonable price would be given by these two mills so that that paper would be processed and used at a later date. We know that all over Ireland prominent, high-ranking churchmen asked the parishioners to embark on a "Save Waste Paper" campaign. That appeal was made and met with a wide response generally. People began to become thrifty with regard to paper and they felt if they collected it they would get reasonable remuneration. Apart from that, they felt they were doing a good day's work for the country by helping to reduce this balance of payments problem.

Now we find that after all the encouragement, the save waste paper campaign has resulted in a large supply of waste paper being made available, a first-class organisation for its collection being set up and quite a number of experts being employed in the sorting of it. We find the two companies now responsible for initiating this campaign have suggested that due to the increasing amount of waste paper available in Ireland they have to refuse to take further supplies. What is the real position? In January of 1956 alone imports under the heading of "Paper—waste, old paper" we had 21,799 cwt. valued at £14,736. From January to December of 1955—that is the previous 12 months — we had 506,816 cwt. of waste paper imported and the cost of that was £347,834.

Comment on this

You are wrong there; the figures seem wrong.

Comment on this

£347,834?

Comment on this

For how many cwt?

Comment on this

For 506,816 cwt.

Comment on this

Well, January was down substantially.

Comment on this

I only quote January to show that waste paper is coming in at the present moment from abroad when the firms maintain that they have a glut of waste paper from Irish sources. Yet here in January we have this amount being imported from abroad.

Comment on this

Well, it was down anyway.

Comment on this

Let us get this clear. The argument, according to the spokesman of this National Board and Paper Company, is that the reason for the present glut is that nearly every parish in Ireland is collecting waste paper now. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce were alert enough, he would exercise the powers conferred on him under the Supplies and Services Act or under the Control of Imports (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1955 to ensure that this mess would not have taken place and that there would be rigid control over the importation of waste paper while suitable waste paper supplies were available from home sources. That is the point I want to make. Nobody would for a moment suggest that a complete prohibition on the import of waste paper should take place: no such unreasonable suggestion is made, but the point I want to make is that when the supply is available from home sources of a reasonable type, equal to the imported commodity, why should the people be deprived of an opportunity of selling waste paper here and why should these companies or mills be allowed to import it at the same time?

Comment on this

You have a good case there.

Comment on this

All I want the Minister to do is to examine this position forthwith. It is not next week I want him to do it. He was asked about it last week and I understand he has sent one of his officials to some of these people concerned. So far no decision has been taken although a number of experts in the processing of waste paper have lost their employment within the last week.

Apart from dealing with the immediate crisis that has arisen with regard to supplies, I want the Minister to have this thing thoroughly examined, because there is a lot more in it than meets the eye. These two particular mills to which I have referred — one in particular at any rate — got substantial credit from the Industrial Credit Corporation in order to carry out its work. It is financed by Irish capital and the loan given to it is at a relatively low rate, only a very low rate of interest being charged.

There are tariff facilities made available also, ranging from 37½ to 50 per cent. to protect the industry against foreign competition, and yet we find a company like this set up with the help of home capital, with a large loan made available to it by the Irish people, turning down waste paper given by the Irish people in order to give preference to imports of that commodity from Bristol, Belfast and elsewhere. There is no justification for that position where a Government or a Minister has the power to ensure that that position is remedied.

I gave figures here. The sum of £347,834 was expended on the importation of waste paper. That works out at an average of £13 to £16 per ton spent abroad on waste paper. Now let us look at the figure given by these two mills for waste paper collected here in Ireland. I want to make it clear to the House that in the two categories of craft and printed paper the home supplied waste paper is of equally high standard as that imported. But there is a vast difference in prices. The average price per ton for the imported article is £13 to £16 and the home collector gets at the maximum between £4 and £6 per ton for Irish waste paper.

Comment on this

I take it the price is ex the town in which the paper is collected. I am sure freight charges would be 10/- to 12/- a cwt.

Comment on this

I have not taken into consideration the freight costs of the imported commodity, but I know that £4 to £6 is the price given by the home collector. Before it reaches the mill the cost to be added would probably be 15/- to £1.

Comment on this

Per cwt.?

Comment on this

No. Per ton.

Comment on this

I am not disputing the Deputy's case but I am afraid he is not equating the prices fairly. He is not adding the cost of collecting the paper in towns throughout the country and of taking it to Dublin or elsewhere.

Comment on this

As I said, I am not sure of the freight costs attached to the imported commodity. I take it it is included in the £13 to £16 per ton, but I am not sure. If we allow £1 a ton for the cost of the transport of Irish waste paper it should satisfy Deputy Barry's anxiety.

Comment on this

It would be much more than £1 a ton.

Comment on this

I do not think a fair price is being given to the home supplier.

Comment on this

The freight charge would be at least £5 a ton from the average town.

Comment on this

I have pointed out that the highest quality craft paper, when taken into the mill in Waterford, is paid for at the rate of £10 per ton. That is the maximum. For the other type of paper the maximum price paid is £6 per ton at the mill. That is the fairest way I can put it. You can compare that highest price of £6 with the £13 to £16 paid for the imported commodity. I shall not make any charges here against particular firms, but I want the matter to be thrashed out with the Minister because to-morrow I can assure him I will make charges in the House if there is not a specific guarantee that he will have the matter clarified. I can produce enough evidence to have an inquiry held into the whole set-up of one of these companies.

One of the reasons why I felt it desirable to raise this question on this Bill was the statement made by the Minister himself last November when he introduced a Bill for the control of exports. He stated:—

"There remains a short list of essential industrial raw materials including, for example, timber, aluminium, scrap and waste paper which are still in short supply and the unrestricted export of which could seriously disrupt our industrial production and industrial employment."

The Minister then asked for special powers to prevent the export of an essential industrial raw material called waste paper. That power was given to him by this House but the particular mills which require this commodity failed to accept it and at the same time we allow foreign waste paper to be brought into the country, thus harming not alone the drive for waste paper collection but the livelihood of many of those engaged in the processing and classifying of this waste paper.

I will not say anything more about it at the moment. It is the only matter to which I wish to refer on this measure and I do hope the Parliamentary Secretary will convey my remarks to the Minister because I feel sure that when he examines the situation this evening he will take the necessary steps to remedy the situation. The mills might be prevailed upon to take surplus waste paper which now lies in the hands of collectors throughout the country because much of it is going to waste at the moment. The serious situation could arise where those people who are enthusiastic enough to act as voluntary collectors for desirable parochial purposes will no longer continue the drive for waste paper and that campaign will die out. That would be a tragic thing to allow to happen especially when we in the House have the power to ensure that protection is given to all home suppliers by reducing the quantity imported. In order that the home surplus will be immediately taken, an embargo should be put to-morrow on the imported article.

I want to emphasise to the Minister in a general way that when he is carrying out an examination of the position he will get his experts to compare, category by category, the imported waste paper with the home supplied commodity so that he will be able to ensure that the same situation does not arise as existed in the bacon factories. Where the bacon factories are concerned, the farmer had no come-back because he had to take the word of the particular factory as far as the grade of pig is concerned. The Minister for Agriculture is now in a position to have inspectors on the job and I see no reason why a Department of Industry and Commerce inspector would not be present in these paper mills to decide as to whether the Irish-supplied waste paper is equal in quality and standard to the imported stuff. If such is the case the Minister should ensure that a proper price is paid for the home material — that the home collector will get as good a price for waste paper as is paid for the imported material.

Comment on this