Committee on Finance. - Vote 63—Health.
Contributions 1–173 of 312. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That a sum not exceeding £6,737,940 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending the 31st day of March, 1957, for the salaries and expenses of the office of the Minister for Health (including Oifig an Árd Chláraitheóra) and certain services administered by that office, including grants to local authorities, miscellaneous grants and Grants-in-Aid.
The Estimate now before the House shows a net decrease of £17,110 on the amount voted for the year 1955-56. Most of the sub-heads show only slight variation from the previous year, but sub-head H—Grants to Health Authorities—is increased by £971,000, while sub-head K—Grant-in-Aid of the Hospitals' Trust Fund—shows a reduction of £1,000,000. Before making the customary review of the services in the current year, I would like to deal with the two last mentioned sub-heads.
The Estimate of £1,250,000 for Grant-in-Aid of the Hospitals' Trust Fund is a realistic assessment of the amount that will be needed to supplement the fund in 1956-57. As I mentioned last year, the subvention from the Exchequer in aid of the Hospitals' Trust Fund has been overestimated since 1953-54, when it was first decided that the Exchequer should contribute specially to the fund so that hospital building works would not be held up for lack of money. In 1953-54 the Estimate of £4,500,000 proved to be £1,600,000 more than the amount needed. In 1954-55, the amount estimated was £3,500,000 but only £2,000,000 was required. For the year just ended, the amount provided for this Grant-in-Aid was £2,250,000 but the amount which it was necessary to transfer from the Exchequer was £1,000,000 less than that figure. One and a quarter million pounds will again be sufficient this year to supplement the Hospitals' Trust Fund and, with this subvention, it is expected that the resources of the fund will be adequate to meet all the calls on it.
One of the reasons for the decreasing demands made on the Exchequer to aid the Hospitals' Trust Fund is the continuing and welcome increase in the income from the Hospital Sweepstakes. In 1950, the amount accruing to the fund from the sweepstakes was £946,000; in 1951, £1,160,000; in 1952, £1,256,000; in 1953, £1,584,000; in 1954, £1,774,000, and in 1955, £1,899,000. In estimating the Grant-in-Aid of the Hospitals' Trust Fund required for next year the income from sweepstakes has been taken to be the same as in 1955. In other words, with the addition of £1,250,000 from the Exchequer, the amount available for grants from the fund will be over £3,000,000 next year, of which over £2,000,000 will be spent on building works and about £800,000 on other grants, including payments to meet the deficits of voluntary hospitals. I would like to make it quite clear that in making these calculations I have not in any way cut the scope or speed of the hospital building programme.
The programme which was drawn up in 1948 is going forward without any diminution and with the least possible delay. It was originally hoped that it would be completed about now but this hope was not realised in circumstances already explained to the House. About two-thirds of the programme has, in fact, been completed and paid for, involving grants from the Hospitals' Trust Fund of about £20,000,000 in the last seven years, but it is now clear that the programme will not be finally completed until the early 1960's. Four major schemes, costing about £6,000,000, represent a large part of the programme still to be carried out. These are the new St. Laurence's, St. Vincent's and Coombe Hospitals in Dublin, and the new Regional Hospital in Cork. The planning of these projects has taken a much longer time than was anticipated but building work on them should be in progress during the current year. Certain urgent works not provided for in the original programme are also being proceeded with.
I now turn to the other main sub-head of the Estimate, i.e., the amount required for the grants payable to local health authorities which, at £7,946,000, represent an increase of £971,000 over the previous year. These grants meet half of the cost of the local health services and any increase in the sub-head reflects a corresponding increase in the amount met from local authority funds. In fact, the total cost of the services in the coming year is expected to be £15,580,000, an increase of about £2,000,000 on what they cost last year. This increase is due to a number of factors, the more important being the improvement of the services for the groups covered at present, the recent increases in salaries, wages and other costs, and the extension of the services to further groups.
As the House will be aware, I have recently made regulations, operative from the 31st March, the effect of which is to make persons in the middle income group eligible for hospital and specialist services. Mothers in the middle income group will also be entitled to a maternity service and to an infant welfare service for their infants up to six weeks of age. I will have more to say later about this extension of the services.
I think it important here to draw a distinction between the increases in local expenditure which can fairly be attributed to this extension alone and those which would have occurred whether or not the services were made available to the new classes. A large part of the increase of £2,000,000 is, in fact, attributable to improvements in existing facilities. The many new beds which have become available in local authority and voluntary hospitals, improvements in dental services, ambulance services and nursing services, increases in capitation rates to voluntary hospitals—and increases in salaries, wages and prices, account for over £1,200,000 of the increase. These factors would call for an increase of this order whether or not the new groups were admitted to some of the services. The estimated cost to the rates and the Exchequer of extending the services to the new groups is, in fact, £780,000.
At this stage, perhaps, I should refer to a matter which has occasioned some comment in recent weeks—that is, the effect of the health services on local rates. Some of the criticism on this score gives the impression that the total cost of these services is being borne on the rates. This, of course, is not the case. Next year, the Exchequer will pay almost £8,000,000 towards the cost of local health services, that is, half the total cost. It may not be realised that as late as the year 1947-48, the Exchequer contributed only about 16 per cent. of the amount spent on health services in that year. Nowadays each health authority receives annual grants from the Exchequer equal to the total paid from local funds. In other words, the State now contributes 50 per cent., as against 16 per cent., of the cost of the health services and the local authorities' proportion has gone down from 84 per cent. to 50 per cent. In terms of money, the State paid £900,000 in 1947-48 and the local authorities £4,700,000; each will pay about £7,800,000 in respect of the year 1956-57.
The State's contribution has gone up by £6,900,000 and the local authorities' by only £3,100,000. This latter figure represents an average increase of about 4/8 in the £ on the local rates since 1947-48. If we assume that the new State grant had not been introduced in 1947-48 and that no extensions or improvement of services took place since then, the local authorities' contribution of £4,700,000 to the costs would, in any event, have increased by up to one-third, or £1,500,000, to make allowance for cost of living and price increases since then. We may thus deduct this from the £3,100,000 and say that for about £1,600,000—i.e. for about 2/5 in the £ on average on the rates —the local authorities will have developed the major part of the new services under the Health Acts of 1947 and 1953. The increase of £2,000,000 in the gross cost of the services in the coming year will call for an average rate increase of about 1/6 of which only about 7d. will be due to extension of the services to new groups. I feel it necessary to draw attention to these points in view of some misleading criticism outside the House.
While I am on this point, I would like to make certain other facts clear. The services which are now being extended to the middle income group are based entirely upon the Health Act, 1953, which was drawn up and passed by the previous Government. I have made it known on a number of occasions that I opposed the passage of that legislation through this House, that I do not regard it as the best, or the ultimate in the matter of health legislation for our people and in our circumstances but that, in order to remove health services as far as possible from the realm of Party politics, I undertook to implement the Act virtually in full, and to try to make it workable and acceptable to all who are concerned.
We are now at the stage when the two most important groups of services have been extended to the middle income group—that is, the hospital and specialist, and the maternity and infant services. These improved and extended health services cost money, of course, and half of that cost falls on local funds. That position is not of my making; it arises directly from the Acts passed before the present Government took office. From the very outset it was made clear by my predecessor that the new services under the 1953 Act would be provided by local health authorities and that half the cost would have to be found by those authorities.
It is, therefore, rather surprising to find certain Opposition Deputies now lamenting the effect of the Act on local rates, and trying to place the blame for it on the present Government. I do not think that is a very fair approach to a difficult problem and I hope that, during the debate on this Estimate, these basic facts will not be in dispute.
Before going on to give some information on the operation of the various services in the past year, I propose, as is customary, to give the House some information on the vital statistics for 1955, which have recently become available. These figures are provisional at this stage. The number of births in 1955 was 61,575, giving a rate of 21.2 per 1,000 of the population, which was very slightly below the previous year's figure. Deaths were up a little at 36,525, giving a rate of 12.6 per 1,000 of the population. Marriages were also up slightly on the 1954 total, at 16,137, a rate of 5.5 per 1,000 of the population.
There has been a gratifying decrease, once again, in the figures for infant mortality and maternal mortality. Deaths of infants under one year of age totalled 2,249 as compared with 2,364 in 1954, making the 1955 rate 37 deaths per 1,000 births, which is the lowest on our records. There were 65 maternal deaths due to childbirth and pregnancy, four less than in the previous year and the lowest figure ever recorded in this country.
The number of deaths from all forms of T.B. has again fallen—from 1,005 in 1954 to 860 in 1955. This latter figure gives a rate of 30 per 100,000 population, which is much less than half the death rate recorded from this disease as recently as 1951. The same satisfactory trend is not, unfortunately, followed by cancer which continues to be one of the major health problems of our time. Deaths from this disease totalled 4,559 in 1955 giving a rate of 157 per 100,000 population, the same as in the previous year. Cancer deaths have shown a slight but continuing increase in recent years: this phenomenon is apparent in many other countries, too. We now have, however, in addition to the older established specialist cancer hospitals, one of the best-equipped cancer hospitals in Europe—St. Luke's Hospital, Rathgar—which is run by the Cancer Association of Ireland, and this association is in process of extending its services to provincial centres.
Deaths from many of the infectious diseases, other than T.B., have declined remarkably in recent years and, in some cases, it is possible to record further improvements in 1955 Measles accounted for 15 deaths, compared with 33 in 1954. Scarlet fever caused two deaths, one less than the previous year; and poliomyelitis caused five deaths, compared with 14 in the previous year. Another welcome improvement was in the deaths from diarrhoea-and-enteritis in children under two years of age, which reached a new low level of 152 deaths. On the other hand, there were increases in the number of deaths due to typhoid fever, whooping cough and diphtheria. Typhoid fever accounted for four deaths in 1955 as compared with one in the previous year; whooping cough caused 39 deaths, six above the 1954 figure; and diphtheria caused 14 deaths compared with five in 1954.
I would like to say a special word about poliomyelitis and diphtheria. My Department is keeping in touch with developments in other countries regarding the use of anti-polio vaccines and the matter is being considered at the moment by the Medical Research Council. With the help of a grant from the Hospitals' Trust Fund, the council is at present conducting a survey to determine the concentrations of poliomyelitis anti-bodies in children in this country. The results of the survey should be useful in deciding the age groups of the child population in which the use of an anti-polio vaccine would be most beneficial.
With regard to diphtheria, a disturbing feature was the increased incidence of this highly infectious disease last year. In 1955, there were 77 cases throughout the country, mainly in Dublin, involving 14 deaths. A few years ago, it might have been pardonable to think that victory over this disease had been almost achieved. In 1953, the number of cases had fallen to 29 and only three deaths were caused. This vast improvement on the epidemics prevalent up to about ten years ago was due mainly to the widespread immunisation of young children but, unfortunately, the very improvement in the position seems to have led many persons to believe that the disease had become almost extinct. The increased number of cases and of deaths last year has proved, if indeed proof were needed, that the danger of diphtheria is still present and that the more children who are left without the protection of immunisation the greater the risk of outbreaks and of deaths. I therefore take this occasion again to appeal to parents to make sure that all their children are immunised, if possible soon after reaching the age of six months. A combined immunisation against diphtheria and whooping cough can also be given if necessary.
While deaths due to infectious diseases in general have become fewer since pre-war years, the same cannot be said about fatal accidents. Last year accidental deaths of all kinds, including those due to transport accidents, falls, burns and scalds, drownings, etc., totalled 1,020. This is a staggering figure when compared, for instance, with the total of 860 deaths due to T.B. Apart from the deaths due to accidents, there are, of course, innumerable unrecorded injuries caused by accidents of various kinds, many of which leave people permanently injured. A great number of these deaths and injuries due to accidental causes, especially in the case of young children and old people, could be avoided with reasonable care and caution.
I now turn to the hospital building programme. Over the past year, from Donegal to Kerry, I have seen ample evidence of the progress made in providing first class hospital and clinic facilities throughout the country. Among the major projects completed were the regional sanatoria at Dublin and Cork, which between them supply 946 additional beds and the Regional General Hospitals at Galway and Limerick of 525 and 286 beds respectively. The new 133-bed Orthopaedic Hospital at Gurranebraher, Cork, and the new District Hospital at Cahirciveen came into commission some months ago. Another important addition to our hospital facilities was the new 80-bed genito-urinary unit at the Meath Hospital, Dublin. A newly reconstructed and extended wing at St. Kevin's Hospital, Dublin, has made 228 beds available for medical patients. The completion of the extensions at St. Mary's, Drumcar, and St. Raphael's, Celbridge, has made available extra accommodation in these homes for 530 mentally defective boys. A new establishment for 240 mentally defective girls was opened at Sligo and an extension for 180 boys at Our Lady of Good Counsel Home, Glanmire, County Cork, will be completed within a few months. Two new county clinics were opened at Wexford and Portlaoise, and 70 dispensaries were completed in various parts of the country.
As I mentioned earlier, work on four further major projects—the new St. Vincent's, St. Laurence's and Coombe Hospitals in Dublin and the new Regional Hospital in Cork—will be under way during the year.
The high operating cost of our extensive hospital system is already a matter of some concern, and the indications are that costs will be higher in the future, not only by the addition of new facilities but also because of the high running expenses when compared with the simpler but, of course, less suitable and less effective older buildings. In relation to our population we already have very extensive hospital facilities by comparison with other European countries and, before embarking on further building programmes, we will have to be satisfied that we are making the best use possible of existing hospitals. My Department has this question constantly in mind and with the solution of some of our health problems it will be possible, by a reallocation of buildings, to ease the pressure on certain types of hospital beds.
An example of this reallocation is the reversion to the Ballinasloe Mental Hospital Authority in December last of the premises at Castlerea, which had been in temporary use for several years as a sanatorium. These premises will accommodate about 450 mental patients and already nearly 300 have been transferred there from Castlebar, Sligo and Ballinasloe. The full range of modern treatment for mental illness will be provided at Castlerea, and direct reception of patients from a suitably defined area is being arranged. It is also intended that a unit of about 100 beds there will be allotted to mental patients in the western region who are suffering from T.B.
Other progress has also been made in improving accommodation for mental patients. New units have been completed at Portrane Mental Hospital, with 268 beds, including a special 20-bed unit for children. A new 80-bed unit at Grangegorman has been completed and occupied while preliminary work has commenced on another similar unit at the same hospital. Planning of an infirmary unit for Cork Mental Hospital is in the final stages. A similar unit for Ardee and admission units at Ardee, Carlow, Castlebar, Cork, Grangegorman and Waterford Mental Hospitals are being planned. Additional staff accommodation at Limerick Mental Hospital is nearing completion; the building of a nurses' home at Monaghan and a staff home at Mullingar has started, and work is about to commence on the nurses' home at Kilkenny; nurses' homes at Carlow, Cork and Ardee Mental Hospitals are being planned.
All of these projects will provide additional and improved accommodation for mental patients, but far more extensive improvements would be needed before the amenities at our mental hospitals could be said to be satisfactory all round. The small expert committee which I appointed last year to consider and make recommendations as to the practical steps which could be taken to relieve overcrowding in mental hospitals has submitted an interim report which deals with certain important aspects of this problem, namely, the extent to which the present overcrowding is attributable to the increased receptions and to the retention of senile patients, and the possibilities of reducing or controlling such receptions without detriment to the persons involved and of accommodating these old people elsewhere.
Receptions of persons over 65 years of age have increased from 345 in 1934 to 1,066 in 1954. The average resident population of mental hospitals aged 65 years and over increased from 2,566 to 4,717 over the same period. The committee's recommendations are being dealt with as a matter of urgency. It is hoped that as a result of other suitable residential accommodation becoming available, some relief of the present overcrowding in mental hospitals can be arranged.
I might mention that the numbers of voluntary and temporary patients received into mental hospitals during the past year again showed an increase on the previous year's figures, thus maintaining the upward trend which these figures have shown since the coming into operation of the Mental Treatment Act, 1945. In 1947, when the Act first came into operation, 376 voluntary patients and 772 temporary patients were received. The corresponding figures for 1955 were 2,033 and 2,449, respectively.
As regards mental hospital out-patient clinics, 1,704 sessions were held during last year, at which there were 4,823 attendances. The increases in the numbers of voluntary and temporary in-patients, and the large numbers of attendances at out-patient clinics, indicate a welcome willingness on the part of persons with mental disorders to seek the skilled treatment and advice which can substantially improve their condition. The percentage of recoveries amongst both voluntary and temporary patients continues to be very satisfactory.
I mentioned earlier the fact that deaths from T.B. have continued to decline and dropped to 860 in 1955. Though it is gratifying to be able to record this, there is no room for complacency. The T.B. death rates in England and Wales, Scotland and the Six Counties are still a good deal below ours. Moreover, we must take account of the number of new cases of T.B. coming under notice which, although showing a small but steady decline in recent years, still totals more than 6,000 a year. In other words, while the death rate from T.B. is decreasing noticeably from year to year, the number of new cases of the disease is still large enough to require prolonged and extensive effort if the disease is to be eradicated.
As all new cases of T.B. arise from contact with infectious cases, the large numbers of new ones found each year indicate that there are as yet many infectious cases not yet diagnosed. In tracing these undiscovered cases, improved field services—mass-radiography, tuberculin testing, etc.—play a most important rôle, but in addition to the intensive efforts of health authorities and their medical staffs, the maximum co-operation of medical practitioners and of the public at large is needed. An excellent free service is available throughout the country to help in diagnosis at the early stage, when treatment is most effective. Close co-operation with the local authority's medical staff will prove advantageous to the medical practitioner in the treatment of his private patients, and will help the chief medical officer of the area in tracing cases of the disease. The general medical practitioner, with his knowledge of his own patients, is in the best position to secure their co-operation in availing themselves of the facilities provided by the T.B. service and in inducing their families and other contacts to take the necessary precautions of having X-ray examination and, if necessary, B.C.G. vaccination. I arranged recently a meeting of chief medical officers and medical superintendents of sanatoria to discuss the T.B. problem and, as a result of their discussions, an intensification of the campaign against T.B. may be expected in all areas.
We now have sufficient beds for T.B. patients throughout the country, and health authorities are able to provide hospital accommodation virtually immediately it is required. In fact, the demand for beds has fallen in recent years, as the following figures will indicate. The number of beds required for adults suffering from respiratory T.B. was 5,143 on the 31st March, 1951. This figure increased each year to a total bed requirement of 6,052 on the 31st March, 1954. On 31st March, 1955, the number of beds required had fallen to 5,607 and, whilst I have not final figures for the end of last month, provisional figures indicate that the bed requirement fell to about 5,000 at that date.
In effect, therefore, the demand for beds for T.B. cases having reached a peak early in 1954 is now falling and, with the virtual completion of th regional sanatoria, is satisfied and it has been possible to close a number of hospitals formerly used for treating T.B. patients. I have already mentioned the Castlerea institution. The next largest which has been closed is Rialto Hospital, Dublin, with 279 beds. This is being converted for use as a general hospital connected with St. Kevin's Hospital, Dublin. The T.B. hospital at Mallow, with 149 beds, was closed in July last, when the patients were transferred to the new Regional Sanatorium at Sarsfieldscourt, and the premises will be used as a general hospital for the North Cork area. The 50 patients in the Pigeon House Sanatorium have been transferred to the Dublin Regional Sanatorium. The Auxiliary Sanatorium, Kilkenny, which accommodated 37 patients, was closed in October last and is now available for other purposes. The small T.B. hospital, St. Carthage's, Lismore, was also closed a few months ago, but for the present is being held in reserve. In addition to the places which have already been made available for other purposes, it is intended that Heatherside Sanatorium, County Cork (172 beds), Monaghan T.B. Hospital (144 beds), St. Kevin's T.B. Hospital, Rathdrum (38 beds) and Naas Sanatorium (44 beds) will also be closed as sanatoria and diverted to other uses. Heatherside Sanatorium will be transferred to the Cork Mental Hospital authority for the relief of overcrowding in the mental hospital. Monaghan T.B. Hospital will also be occupied by mental patients as an admission unit and to relieve overcrowding in Monaghan Mental Hospital. St. Kevin's, Rathdrum, will be used as an extension to the County Home and Naas Sanatorium will become a maternity hospital.
It is inevitable that a reorganisation like this should cause a certain amount of inconvenience to patients who may have to be transferred from one hospital to another, and to the staffs. Nevertheless, it is essential that the available hospital accommodation should be put to the best possible use in the interests of all patients for whom local health authorities are responsible.
The number of persons receiving maintenance allowances under the infectious diseases service on 31st March, 1955, was 8,529 and the amount paid during the 12 months ending on that date was £576,638. Most of those drawing these allowances are persons undergoing treatment for, or recovering from, T.B.
One important aspect of the T.B. problem is the rehabilitation of recovered patients to enable them to take up suitable employment when they have been discharged from hospital. The Rehabilitaton Institution, Limited, has centres for ex-T.B. patients in Dublin, Cork and Limerick for training women in garment making. There is also a centre in Dublin for training men in woodwork, and some furniture for the regional sanatoria was produced at this centre. Woodwork training for men is also provided at a residential centre in Toghermore, County Galway, which is under the control of a separate local committee.
This brings me to the wider problem of rehabilitating disabled persons generally. As the House will be aware, some months ago I invited a number of prominent people to become members of a special body which will investigate the extent of the various types of disablement in this country, and the facilities available for rehabilitation and which is charged with the duty of making recommendations regarding the best means of enabling disabled persons to secure suitable employment. This body, known as the National Organisation for Rehabilitation, will also examine the problem of finding employment for rehabilitated persons. The organisation has already appointed a full-time medical director. I understand that they have made a start on their activities and I hope that when introducing next year's Estimate I may be able to give the House more information regarding the progress made in this field.
I would not like to leave this matter without referring to the trojan work carried out on behalf of particular types of disabled persons by a number of voluntary bodies. The fact that it has been decided to set up a State-sponsored body to deal with this problem on a wider basis detracts in no way from the good work already done. A central body, designed specially to look into the national problem of all kinds of disablement and to make recommendations to local authorities and to the Minister for Health on how the problem should be tackled, is necessary but the voluntary bodies already in existence can help in no small measure by making available their expert knowledge on the subject. The new organisation includes representatives of a number of such voluntary bodies among its members. A grant is being made from the Hospitals' Trust Fund to enable the organisation to get on its feet.
Under the Health Act, 1953, health authorities are responsible for rehabilitating disabled persons in their area and they have power to provide equipment, training facilities, etc. When, as a result of the investigations of the National Organisation for Rehabilitation, we will have gained a clear appreciation of the problems of rehabilitating and training the disabled, we will be better equipped to see how these difficulties should be tackled, and the health authorities will be enabled to go ahead with their functions in this matter. In the meantime, since 1st October, 1954, they have been paying maintenance allowances to certain chronically disabled persons. Up to the 30th September, 1955, over 13,000 such allowances have been granted and nearly 3,000 were under consideration on that date.
I have already referred in a general way to some of the effects from the financial point of view of the extension of certain services—the hospital and specialist services and the maternity and infant welfare services. I think that this might be a suitable time at which to mention what the extensions are.
On a number of occasions in this House I have explained why I could not agree, in the summer of 1954, to seek to give effect to Section 15 of the Health Act, 1953, which relates to hospital and specialist services. My experience over the last 18 months confirms me in the view that to attempt to give effect to the regulations made by my predecessor providing for the introduction of those services in August, 1954, would have given rise to chaos. In fact, had I attempted to do so, I would have had to answer a charge that I had attempted to sabotage the Act. In arriving at my decision I was fortified by the recommendation of the National Health Council established by my predecessor.
With increased facilities and following long negotiation with the persons whose goodwill was necessary for the provision of the services, I decided towards the end of the last year that it would be possible to extend the services to the additional groups last month. Section 15 is now in operation for all the persons specified in that section, including the additional groups comprising dependents of insured persons, all those in the middle income group and the "hardship" cases. The same applies to Section 25 which relates to choice of hospital.
The specialist services will be free to all the eligible groups. The hospital services under Section 15 will be free to the lower income group (including insured persons and their dependents in that group) but persons outside that group must pay such amount as the health authority may decide, within a limit of 6/- per day, except in the "hardship" cases when the charge may be higher. This is in strict accord with the terms of the Act.
By making use of the facilities in the voluntary hospitals and with the development of specialist services at local centres, the facilities are now available, generally speaking, for a good service for all the eligible groups. There will still be gaps here and there in the services, but with a little patience on the part of all concerned, it should be possible to fill these gaps relatively quickly and I hope that by the time next year's Estimates are being debated in the House it will be possible to say that all aspects of the services are working smoothly and satisfactorily.
Up to recently, insured persons who satisfied certain contribution conditions have been entitled to completely free hospital services. Under the new arrangements, insured persons who are not in the lower income group may have to pay up to 6/- per day for those services. That position is as contemplated in the 1953 Act and I think the persons concerned have no legitimate grievance, since the contribution conditions have been modified in favour of additional groups of insured persons, and dependents are now eligible as such for the first time.
The free hospital service provided for treatment of T.B. and other infectious diseases will not be affected in any way by the extension of this new hospital and specialist service to the middle income group. Persons suffering from T.B. and certain other infectious diseases will still be able to obtain all necessary hospital or other treatment completely free of charge.
Up to recently only women in the lower income group were entitled to the free medical care service in respect of motherhood and to the free medical service for infants up to six weeks of age. Under the arrangements now in operation, women in the middle income group also have the benefit of these services, including midwifery services for domiciliary confinements and hospital services where necessary.
There will be no charge for hospital services for eligible women or for their infants as in the case of general hospital services under Section 15 for the middle income group and the "hardship" group. Section 25 (choice of hospital) will apply to maternity and infant hospital services in the same way as it applies to Section 15 patients.
There is an aspect of the maternity care service I would like to emphasise. I am advised that many of the complications arising at confinements have their origin in the failure of women to seek medical supervision and advice at an early stage in the pregnancy. There is no reason why any woman in the eligible classes should be without such supervision. The doctors who will provide the maternity service under agreements entered into by them with health authorities will be only too willing to see their patients at an early stage and to give them all the attention they need in the waiting period. In addition, in most areas women will have a choice of doctor available to them. I appeal, therefore, to women to make proper and intelligent use of the service in their own interests and in the interests of the unborn child. If they fail to do so, they are failing in their duty to themselves, to their families and to the nation and the public money spent on the service will have been largely wasted.
The 1953 Act provided for the extension of the maternity and infant services to women outside the lower and middle income groups subject to the payment of annual contributions. I propose to defer bringing this part of the Act into operation for the present. The House will recall that in January, 1955, I set up an advisory body to consider and report on the feasibility of introducing a scheme of voluntary health insurance against the wide range of modern medical costs, including the costs of maternity. This body may find it possible to recommend a scheme which would, if introduced, provide cover against the expenses of confinements. Many women might wish to meet these expenses by means of private insurance arrangements rather than to obtain the services needed from the health authority in return for an annual contribution under the Health Act.
Tentative proposals for the reorganisation of outdoor nursing and domiciliary midwifery services have been drawn up and issued to interested parties. Discussions have been held with them and no significant objections have been raised to the proposals. In formulating these proposals I have kept in mind the desirability of encouraging voluntary effort in this field. The existing voluntary nursing associations have given excellent service to the public in the past and one effect of my proposals should be to provide them with the opportunity of continuing to do so.
It is my policy to make available the services of a nurse, employed either by a voluntary association or by the health authority, in each dispensary district as soon as it conveniently can be done and, arising out of the extended maternity services, to enable all midwives who desire to do so to participate in the service so that eligible patients will, as far as possible, in addition to a choice of doctor, have a choice of midwife for domiciliary confinements. Private midwives will be paid a fee for each such case attended.
The scheme under which a maternity cash grant of £4 was payable by health authorities in certain circumstances continued during last year. From the commencement of these maternity cash grants on the 1st January, 1954, up to the end of September last, 48,000 grants had been paid. These grants are payable only to women in the lower income group, that is, generally speaking, women who are entitled to the free general medical services for the poorer sections of the community.
A circular was issued last year to local health authorities containing recommendations as to how child welfare clinics should be organised. There is now a statutory obligation on health authorities to provide a child welfare clinic in towns with a population of 3,000 or over. They may also set up child welfare clinics in smaller towns if they wish and some authorities have availed of this discretionary power. The total number of cities and towns in which child welfare clinics are held, or proposed to be held in the near future, is over 70.
The main groups at present eligible to receive dental services are the lower income group, children attending national schools, in respect of defects discovered at school health examinations, and children attending child welfare clinics, in respect of defects discovered at the clinics. The services provided for these groups are yet far from adequate and I have pressed all health authorities to improve the services administered by them. The reaction of health authorities generally has been favourable, improvements have already been made and at the moment 20 additional whole-time posts are in process of being filled. Where services are not sufficiently developed to provide full dental care for all those entitled to such care the unanimous advice I have received is that children should be given priority in the obtaining of dental care. I have accordingly advised health authorities that they should concentrate on the making available of an adequate service for children in preference to other eligible classes. When, therefore, the additional whole-time men are available their services will be utilised mainly for children. I would like to emphasise that these additional appointments will not solve the problem of the inadequacy of health authority dental services and that the need continues for considerably improved services. Until the position is improved materially for the existing eligible groups I do not propose to seek to extend dental services to additional groups. The Department of Social Welfare is, however, continuing its scheme of dental service benefits for insured persons.
Generally, the year which has just passed has, I feel, witnessed a very considerable achievement in regard to the vexed question of health services. Relations with the professional groups on which any Government must rely for the provision of services are now, I think, better than they have been at any time in recent years and with the implementation, virtually in full, of the Health Act, 1953, the acrimonious political controversy which has been a feature of the services should be at an end. Much still remains to be done in the matter of improving facilities, but for the future in the altered atmosphere, I think it should be easier to secure these improvements. On the question of helping groups outside the present eligible groups to gain access to health services which they may need from time to time, I have already mentioned the advisory body which is considering the question of voluntary health insurance and that I expect the report of that body shortly. I want to emphasise that the purpose of this body's deliberations is to consider whether and in what manner it is possible for the State to supplement the individual's efforts to provide for himself. The Health Act has been criticised because in some cases individual effort was in danger of being supplanted by the services it sought to provide under the aegis of the State. Now that it has been found possible to implement the main features of this Act the way is, I hope, clear to consider proposals under which—apart from necessitous classes—it will be the State's main concern in relation to the provision of personal health services to help each individual to provide for himself. The obvious way of doing this is by means of a practical scheme of health insurance. When the report of the advisory body is available it should be possible to plan for such future developments in an atmosphere of goodwill and co-operation.
Comment on this
The Minister, towards the end of his statement on this Estimate, appealed for an end to the controversy that had raged for so long over this health legislation. Earlier on in his statement he interpreted criticisms in relation to the administration of the Health Act as a continuance of controversy. Speaking for myself, at any rate, I have always been in favour of the Health Act. I have always been free, and still am, to criticise certain aspects of it and certain impacts of it particularly on local authorities. If there has been very serious controversy in the past, it was certainly not from this side of the House when the Health Act of 1947 was introduced and when it was implemented further in 1953.
Now that the Minister has responsibility, and for the time he will have responsibility for administering the Health Act, perhaps he will accept the position that, as regards those who did not oppose the Health Act but felt themselves bound to fight for certain things, that is not a continuance of the controversy over the Health Act but just a filing of criticism against a Department of State in relation to the Act as it affects local authorities who have to play their part, not only in implementing it but in paying for it by raising the necessary money from the ratepayers.
The Minister recently, when he received a deputation, produced a number of figures based on percentages and he has again referred to them to-day. He has made the comparison between the percentage of health administration costs previously borne by local authorities in 1947-48, when 82 per cent. of their cost was borne by the local authority and only 18 per cent. by the State, and the percentage costs to-day which are on a 50-50 basis. The Minister wants to suggest by that that local authorities have saved the difference between 50 per cent. and 82 per cent. Of course, it is a ridiculous and childish attempt further to confuse the situation.
In 1947-48 the valuation of the City of Dublin was slightly above £2,000,000 and the rate levied by the local authority was 25/- in the £, so that the total income of the local authority was somewhere around £2,770,000 from rates. To-day the valuation is over £3,000,000 for the whole area and the rate that will now be fixed will bring in over £6,000,000. If we take that for the purpose of argument, is 80 per cent. of £2,770,000 not less than 50 per cent. of £6,000,000? Is that not clear to the Minister?
Comment on this
The expert on finance who went down to Clonmel recently and told us not to believe there was any scarcity of money ought at least to keep out of this, because on this I know what I am talking about and the Deputy does not.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary wants to prolong the agony to that side of the House by interjections I will welcome them, but I want to make a serious approach to this matter and to make an appeal to the House. I have said that this type of compilation thrown at the public is confusing and misleading and proves nothing; yet it is suddenly thrown to a deputation and now flung across the House. In 1947-48 the Health Act was not even implemented and when a national Health Act is introduced, is it not to be expected by the public that, as national policy, the national Government will seek to bear its part of the cost of such Health Acts and not by peculiar devices make savings of payments previously borne by them and transferred to the extent of 50 per cent. to the backs of the ratepayers?
I mentioned last year and several times throughout the year that at one time hospitalisation of insured workers was the responsibility of the Government. The cost of that to the State, over and above the payment by way of the insured worker's stamps, represented a loss to the national Exchequer of a sum in excess of £300,000 per year. Whether it was as a result of action taken by the Minister's predecessor or by the Minister himself is beside the point; the fact is that the care of these insured workers was transferred recently to the local authorities.
Comment on this
I said "transferred recently" and 1954 is sufficiently near to be referred to as "recently".
Comment on this
I was not. I said I mentioned it last year. The Minister must be a little careful to-day in trying to put me off the track by surprise interjections, as to which, I shall refer later, because to-day I have come along, having considered carefully all the points I intended to raise so that I would be sure of my points.
Comment on this
Prior to 1954, a loss of £300,000 in connection with insured workers was borne by the national Exchequer. That is not to be contradicted, I take it. As a result of the transfer of responsibility in this matter to local authorities, in 1954, and of the fact that the Government is responsible for only 50 per cent. recoupment of the cost, the Exchequer has saved 50 per cent. of that amount. We are agreed on that.
In that connection, I feel that the Government is bound to consider a request that, because of that new burden on the ratepayers as a result of the enactment of legislation which made that transfer of responsibility possible, the State should be prepared to say: "Very well, in that connection we will give you an additional grant over and above 50 per cent. of the cost." I make this request now, particularly in reference to an Estimate which is down by £1,000,000, whereas the rates are everywhere up as a result of the Health Act, that the Minister should consider giving back to the local authorities that £150,000 by way of grant over and above the 50 per cent. recoupment.
The Minister referred to the fact that included in the Estimate is a sum of £800,000 which includes payments to hospitals for deficits. I do not think the Minister will dispute that that is in his statement. Will the Minister deny that last year his payments to hospitals to meet deficits was in excess of £800,000?
Comment on this
It does not matter to a local authority where the Minister's money to pay deficits comes from if the local authority has to pay its share by way of a charge for beds.
Comment on this
So I am right. There was a sum of £600,000 estimated last year. The Minister found it cost him £250,000 more. Therefore, the deficit account last year reached £850,000. The Minister has not said how much of this £800,000 is for deficits. I do not know whether it is estimated at £800,000 or £600,000 for this year.
I am coming to point No. 2 of criticism of administration of the Health Act—the creation of an adverse situation for ratepayers and local authorities. The Minister, through the power he has under the law, signs a document and says to local authorities that, as from such and such a date, the amount of money they will pay for beds for the poorer people for whom they have responsibility will be increased from 16/- to 18/-. The local authorities are not consulted, are not asked any questions about it.
I should like to say to the Minister, through the Chair, that there is quite a number of public representatives who, as well as serving on a local authority, also serve on hospital boards and they know the situation from both angles. What does an increase of 2/- in respect of a bed mean? It means in the case of the Dublin Corporation, that they have to find an extra £59,000 per year of which we get back 50 per cent. from the Minister. In other words, it costs us roughly £30,000 which is the equivalent of nearly 3d. in the £ on the rates.
It is not so long ago that the bed charge was 8/-. It was doubled to 16/-. Now, as deficits in the hospitals increase, instead of those deficits being met out of the Exchequer, they are met as to 50 per cent. by the local authority.
In this connection, may I point out to the Minister that, when Fianna Fáil left office in 1948, they had established a fund of some £6,000,000 to £7,000,000 which had been saved from the income from the Hospitals' Trust Fund and which had been invested specifically for the purpose of bringing in money to meet hospital deficits, amongst other things? After the advent of the Coalition Government in 1948, that fund was almost wiped out and, as a result of the commitments the Government made after the change of office in 1951, it was completely wiped out. The income which was originally designed to meet this very position was dissipated and the capital moneys were taken and used for the building of hospitals elsewhere. I say that a Government which has taken those steps has no right to come to a local authority and say: "You must now meet your share of these deficits and, as they increase, we will increase your charges."
Comment on this
I think the action taken was right and the person who took it is now a member of your Party.
Comment on this
It was not done by the Minister's predecessor in the Fianna Fáil Government. It was done by the Minister for Health in the 1948 Coalition Government.
Comment on this
The Labour Party can keep out of this because they will have enough to answer for in the next few weeks when unemployment will be rife in the city, because of their action.
Comment on this
I say that a prudent Minister for Finance, realising that there would be deficits as a result of increased treatment of poor people who previously had no treatment, would realise that it would be unfair to have the burden of cost unevenly divided and would make provision for the investment of the millions of pounds of money to bring in money to pay for these people. I object to the dissipation of these millions of pounds, with the result that these deficits exist which the ratepayers are now asked to meet because of a mistake which the Government made.
Comment on this
Surely the building of hospitals and the provision of beds is not the dissipation of funds?
Comment on this
That is the responsibility of the Government. We are in favour of the building of hospitals, and I once, by question and answer in this House, adduced conclusively that, under the Fianna Fáil Government, more hospitals were built than would be built by any of their successors, no matter how long they were in office.
Comment on this
I am saying this, and I say it emphatically, that it was a grave mistake for the Coalition or inter-Party Government to have dissipated that £7,000,000 which was bringing in a substantial amount of money and which saved the ratepayers the need to subsidise the deficits which arise in the administration of hospitals.
Comment on this
The cat is out of the bag. If the Minister will go over the records of this House, he will find a definite undertaking from his then colleague that that was in the knowledge of the Government and that these deficits would be met out of taxation. I am telling you it is on the records of this House. I raised it then, and it is no use for the Minister to shake his head now. If he likes to say that is not so, I will get the record and read it for him. That is the difference between what Deputy Casey has in mind and what I have in mind.
I am not objecting to the treatment of our people in hospitals. We are responsible at least for this Health Act and we stand over it. It is the colleagues of the members of the Labour Party who opposed it and fought strenuously against it and between them and us the controversy raged to which the Minister has referred.
That is point No. 2. I am not going to quarrel with the Minister as to whether it is 7d. or 10d. in the £. A couple of weeks ago he said 7d.——
Comment on this
Do not misquote me; I said 7d. generally, which, in Dublin, would not exceed 10d. I can send the Deputy a copy of my speech and he can see that I said "generally".
Comment on this
I know; the Minister to-day said generally the cost of the new services would not exceed 7d. He did not say: "except in the case of Dublin". But he did say when we were down with him on a deputation— and I am not quarrelling with him over that—that the new services now being brought in would not cost possibly more than 10d. in the £ in the City of Dublin. That is a fact. We are not grumbling about that; but what we are grumbling about it that, behind the backs of a local authority like Dublin, which has to pay so much out of rates from its citizens for the administration of these health services, the Minister makes agreements with the Medical Association and with the hospitals for payments to them for services already existing for years and for which they got no payment before. We have to pay 50 per cent., but we are told nothing about it.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that the Minister himself made these agreements, without consulting the representatives of the local authorities?
Comment on this
I repeat the Minister made agreements for payment of fees for services already being given, without consulting those who had to pay for them. What does this mean? We are suddenly told in the City of Dublin—as, I suppose, every other local authority is told—"As from now, you will please provide a sum of money to put 15 per cent. of the cost of your beds into a pool out of which the hospital staffs in voluntary hospitals will now be paid." I do not know yet the full terms and conditions as to how this is going to work out. The 15 per cent. pool is estimated for the coming year to be £75,000 of which we recoup half, another 3d. in the £ on the rates for an additional cost, not for a new service, but for payment for a service which was already in existence and for which previously there was no charge.
As the Lord Mayor of Cork, Deputy McGrath, points out, it really means that your bed is no longer 8/- or 16/-; if you take the new figure, it is 18/-, plus 15 per cent.
Comment on this
When the Health Act was going through, there was a state of chaos in this country and what is worrying Deputy Briscoe is that the chaos is no longer there.
Comment on this
The Minister has organised it all right; he has made chaos throughout the country. I am protesting against the Minister having made agreements to pay 15 per cent. in fees to staffs of hospitals who always gave their services free.
Comment on this
The Minister's predecessor was not prepared to pay these fees and these demands. The whole objection to the Health Act was not on moral grounds at all, but on the grounds of the fees to be paid to the medical profession. The Minister's predecessor was not prepared to meet these demands, but the Minister did meet them, and that is how he got agreement with the medical profession. We now have to pay them, without having been consulted and without knowing how the scheme is going to work.
Specialists were always attached to the voluntary hospitals. They had certain privileges and rights in these hospitals with regard to having their own beds, their private patients and students, and there were clinics held. We now find that the Minister has agreed that these specialists will be paid, as far as Dublin is concerned, for their services in the out-patients' departments, services which have been given since the hospitals were established. They are to be paid £50,000 a year for these services which are to be called sessions. Fifty per cent. of £50,000 is £25,000 and that is another 2d. in the £ on the rates. We were not consulted about this and it is not a new service.
The next thing we find is that the Minister has decided on a new method of payment for the X-ray services. If some of us had not been members of hospital boards, we would not have known what was going on, because Dublin Corporation was not consulted and was not made aware of how the new scheme was going to operate. I found out that a circular was issued to the hospitals giving them instructions as to how the scheme was to work. On last Monday I spent the whole afternoon with the officials of the Dublin Corporation trying to find out how they estimated that the increased cost to fall on the ratepayers was £33,000, less 50 per cent. They did not know how that amount was estimated and I had to get in touch with a Dublin voluntary hospital and ask them for a record of an average monthly working of their X-ray service.
I found that in some cases an X-ray examination takes from half an hour to 35 minutes, if the matter is a serious one, and, in other cases, it only takes about five minutes. For the sessional purpose, one could safely reckon that four people could be dealt with in an hour. Now the question arises as to how the payment for the X-ray services is to be operated. Is the radiologist to remain in the hospital for the three hours of the session for which the pay is 4½ guineas, plus half a guinea for X-rays? Or can he take home the X-ray photographs and read them at home, and will he be paid for the time he takes to read them and to prepare his report on them?
The Minister is making all these regulations, but he is not consulting the people who have to administer those regulations and who have to pay the cost of them. The Minister has gone through a whole series of these things, without saying to the local authorities: "This is what I have been asked to do; this is what I think I ought to do; this is what I am going to do; what have you to say about it?"
We find that outside our control there are institutions which make demands on the local authorities. These are statutory institutions and, in the City of Dublin, we have the Dublin Board of Assistance. These institutions are also involved under this Health Act and all we know in the Dublin Corporation this year is that we are being asked to pay to the Dublin Board of Assistance £98,000 more than we had to pay last year.
Comment on this
We have. They are statutory bodies. They are also told: "That is what you have to do." If there was any consultation with them, or from them to us, or a round table conference, we might have some idea of what we were doing and what the money required from us was to be expended on.
Comment on this
I presume that the Dublin Board of Assistance prepares its own estimates and that the Dublin Corporation representatives on the board of assistance have a say in the matter.
Comment on this
There is a commissioner for the Dublin Board of Assistance. He runs the hospitals and makes up his estimates on the basis of what he is ordered to do in regard to health matters by the Department of Health. There is no use in Deputy Casey trying to pull the Minister out of the position I am trying to place him in.
Comment on this
What I am objecting to is the principle that is now being established of a Department of State, which is jointly responsible with the local authority for the running of the health services, not consulting with that local authority. The Department which is so jointly responsible should consult with the representatives of the people as to the operation of these schemes, the cost of which falls heavily on the ratepayers.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the Health Act to say that the Minister must consult with anybody.
Comment on this
The Health Act does not say that the Minister should not consult with anybody. The Health Act does not prevent the Minister from extending to local authorities the courtesy of saying to them: "I am going to do this and what have you to say about it?" Where does the Health Act authorise the Minister to go back over retrospective services and say: "Because of the Health Act, I am now going to make you pay for something which you got for nothing before."
Comment on this
If Deputy Casey believes that, what I am saying must have some justification. If he feels that the Minister is entitled to do this because it was not specifically stated in the Health Act, as a public representative of a local authority there was nothing to stop him when he was, I believe, with his colleagues in the Labour Party, pressing for the implementation of this Health Act asking for an amendment to it that such consultation should be made. I know the Fine Gael Party, if they had not been pressed by the Labour Party, would never have implemented this Act to the extent that it is being implemented.
Comment on this
They would have sunk it and when they could not sink it they tried to drive it on the rocks.
Comment on this
I am trying to show how the Minister behind closed doors got agreement from the medical people to operate the Health Act at a cost to the ratepayers, through their local authorities, without their having being consulted. In connection with the health side the mental hospitals have sent in a statutory demand for another £33,000 as have also the fever hospitals for another £33,000. There was a time when each local authority would estimate its own expenditure and all the estimates would certainly be subject to examination and control.
Comment on this
I said it was the Dublin Corporation estimate in which is to be included an additional £33,000 for additional charges in the administration of the Health Act in fever hospitals.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy would discuss the national Health Estimate and not merely the Dublin Corporation estimate?
Comment on this
I am discussing the national Health Estimate in so far as it affects the premier local authority.
Comment on this
I will talk about it here until I am blue in the face provided I am in order according to the Chair; I will not stop if the Minister does not like it. Having given certain figures here, we have a just claim—I take it that other local authorities may feel the same—for an additional contribution from the central funds towards the cost of administering the health services in the City of Dublin if only to the extent of those services which are now costing money and which previously cost nothing or where there is a transference of obligations from the Central Fund on to the backs of the local authorities for the purpose of making savings in the national Exchequer. That is the case I make and I believe it will be accepted by a lot of other people. Our estimates in the City of Dublin this year for health services may rise to the equivalent of some 2/9 in the £, nearly 2/- of which is not for new services but for commitments made to a large extent by the Minister in agreements in regard to which we had no say whatever.
Comment on this
That is not so. The full effect of the cost of the new services in Dublin will be under 10d. in the £.
Comment on this
The Minister is not trying to interrupt Deputy Briscoe, but is endeavouring to put him off.
Comment on this
If he wanted your protection he would say so. The Deputy knows a great deal more about this than Deputy Aiken does.
Comment on this
May I repeat again that the impact of the new services, plus the new fees for old services will cost the ratepayer of Dublin somewhere about 2/9 in the £ altogether?
Comment on this
Does the Minister really believe that the new services, plus the fees he is agreeing to pay, are covered by 10d.?
Comment on this
The Minister is completely wrong. Let him ask his legal adviser. If the Minister would take up a pencil he would find out that an increase of 2/- per day for beds——
Comment on this
That has nothing to do with the health services. It has nothing to do with the new services.
Comment on this
The Deputy should keep quiet. He is a member of a Government who decided to do that as a deliberate matter of Government policy. He knows nothing about the matter.
Comment on this
The Minister has admitted what I am saying—that the increase in bed charges is for the purpose of reducing the deficit charges to the Government.
Comment on this
I am carrying out in that connection the policy of my predecessor. If he were speaking he would not run away from it.
Comment on this
The Minister will now be telling us that he is carrying out Fianna Fáil policy in everything.
Comment on this
I say emphatically that of the 2/9 increase in the burden on the backs of the ratepayers of Dublin in connection with the administration of the Health Act generally, 10d. is due to new services and the balance is due to new charges on old services.
Comment on this
The Minister says that is not so but I want to show him it is so. If you add up £59,000 new charges on beds to save deficit charges to the State; £75,000, the 15 per cent. pool, to pay the staff of hospitals who previously operated without these fees; £50,000 for specialist fees in the clinics and £33,000 extra because of a new method of payment for X-ray service, you will find that comes to £217,000.
Comment on this
That makes it about £108,000. Does the Minister know how much that sum represents on the rates of Dublin?
Comment on this
Does the Minister not realise there is a figure here—extension of services and increase of classes, £76,000—that I did not include in my figure; and that is 7d. for new services. Does the Minister want to add that now to the 10d. and find out how much it is?
Comment on this
There is no point in trying to help the Deputy, because he either closes his mind or refuses to use it. He might be a lot better off, if Deputy Aiken would leave him alone.
Comment on this
Bonus on salaries will cost us £50,000; extension of services to new classes, £76,000. I left those two figures out. I left out the £6,000 for child guidance. I was only picking out new charges on old services, amounting to a considerable sum of money, and I was pointing out that all this had been done without any consultation whatsoever with the elected representatives of local authorities. I object strenuously to that and I say it was part of the bargain struck by the Minister with the medical profession in order to get their goodwill in the implementation of this Bill.
Comment on this
Certainly. Is there anything wrong with that? Does the Deputy want to have these services operating smoothly and well, or does he not? Does he want a state of hostility and strife between a Department of State and the medical and nursing profession?
Comment on this
I happen to have statutory responsibility as Minister for Health, responsibility given to me by the Deputy's Party.
Comment on this
And, if the Minister did not want that statutory responsibility, could he not have changed it very easily?
Comment on this
The people put the Government here and the Government appointed me, and I have to do the job.
Comment on this
There is another point I want to make. We believe there is need for some kind of residential qualification in connection with the treatment of people under this Health Act. We have knowledge of things that are happening. For instance, a person employed in Dublin brings up a relative from the country. He, or she, gives an address, care of this person, who is resident in the city. He, or she, then gets all these services and the Dublin Corporation has to pay for them. Now we do not want him or her not to be treated, but we believe that, in the case of a person receiving treatment on that basis, the charge should be transferred back to the local authority in whose area that person lives. We have cases of people coming up here seeking work and they are not here any longer than a matter of a few days when they qualify for treatment at the expense of the Dublin ratepayers.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Parliamentary Secretary is very dense. I said I wanted regulations with regard to residential qualifications. I said that the person could be treated here, but that the charge should properly be borne by the local authority in whose area the person is normally resident.
Comment on this
Dublin has so many Corkmen in it that I think we can be classed as being very "decent" indeed. I think the Minister might have consulted us in relation to this additional charge on hospital beds. I have had a calculation made and, taking it that there are 365 days in every year—I hope nobody will dispute that——
Comment on this
The Deputy is thinking of Leap Year; maybe it was good to him! Taking it at 365 days, that means there are 1,885,955 bed days in Dublin. At 16/- per day, that means that the hospitals will have £1,508,000 per year income from all their beds, there being 5,167 beds. Now, the corporation has gone into the figures over a period of years in relation to the number of cases for which the corporation is responsible and we estimate that our cost of institutional treatment for the period 1955-1956 at 16/- per day was £496,000; in other words, we used in the City of Dublin, of all the beds for which the citizens pay through the rates, roughly 32 per cent. We believe, therefore, that before we are mulcted in the extra 2/-, there should be some examination into what happens to the other 68 per cent. of beds in the Dublin hospitals. How are they occupied? What fees are charged? Why should we, who receive a smaller percentage of the total beds available, have to meet the increase on its present basis, a basis calculated without any knowledge on our part?
Surely the Minister must now realise that there is another side to this matter. I do not believe he knew until this very minute that we only use 32 per cent. of the available beds in the City of Dublin. Surely we are entitled to know how the other 68 per cent. are charged and to what extent, if any, they are subsidised quietly, while not qualified for such, at the expense of the Dublin local authority. We would like an examination of all these things. We would like to know whether we will be asked to pay in the dark, as it were. I want to tell the Minister now that there is a certain temper running in our local authority and, if the Minister proceeds on these lines, he may find himself some day faced with the position where we will say we refuse to adopt that part of the Health Act payment; and the Minister will then have to deal with the position under the law.
Comment on this
What the Deputy is aiming at is to prevent health services being provided for the people in this city.
Comment on this
I am not. Does the Minister seek to suggest by his interjection that the medical profession——
Comment on this
——attending our hospitals would refuse to treat the poor of Dublin if, for instance, we refused to pay this £50,000, sessional fees, to the specialists? Is the Minister suggesting they would do that? That is what he is suggesting. What I am suggesting is that this is a mean way of transferring responsibility from the State on to the backs of the ratepayers, and transferring to them also charges previously borne by the State and charges previously not in existence for services which were not in existence. This catch-cry that the new services are only costing 10d. and the old services only cost so much is quite another story.
I want to bring some other points to the Minister's attention. In our estimates—perhaps the Minister will make a note of this; it was mentioned to him at a conference by the city manager, but I do not think he thought it of sufficient importance to make any comment on it—we have to provide this year £46,000 for payments made in connection with health services now disallowed by the local government auditors. Mark this: these are transactions which took place five years, and over five years ago, and, because the local government auditors are behind in their work and are now only auditing our books for five years ago, they are now disallowing all kinds of health payments and are thereby putting on the backs of the ratepayers another £46,000, of which the Minister will not have to pay 50 per cent. Is this another device of saving the national Exchequer——
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would permit me to point out to the Chair that I have no responsibility for the arrangement of Local Government Orders.
Comment on this
May I put it this way? If an expenditure of £46,000 on health services had been previously incurred, and the Minister normally would have to pay £23,000 of that, the 50 per cent. recoupment, is he not sufficiently interested in some way in seeing that the auditors, who audited health payments of which he has to pay 50 per cent., should be up to date in their work?
Comment on this
Might I ask if that Order was carried out five years ago, is it not likely that the surcharge would take place?
Comment on this
No, because I have a note here that most of the officials concerned in this particular transaction are no longer available and are unable to answer what it is all about.
Comment on this
May I repeat for the third time that I have no responsisibility for this? It is a matter the Deputy can raise on the Local Government Estimate.
Comment on this
If in fact the ratepayers will have to pay this £46,000 delayed action disallowance, will the Minister pay his portion or will he say under the rules, "I get out of my contribution"? I will have to deal with it in the normal way. I will probably have to raise is with Local Government. It is certainly a scandalous situation.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy going to be allowed to deal with a matter in respect of which I have no responsibility?
Comment on this
I think I have been very close to the rails. I will deal now with the matter of deficits in hospitals. This concerns the Minister. I was on an inspection only last Thursday in Hume Street Hospital, of which body I happen to be a governor. It was the turn of a colleague and myself to have an inspection of the place. What did we find? When we went into the secretary's office he was glued to the telephone, and he could not leave his seat because he was awaiting a call from the Department of Health to tell him when he was going to get his interim payment of the deficits. If he did not get it that day or the next day, he would not be able to pay wages next week. He had reached the limit that the bank had allowed him and the payment was overdue. Maybe Easter intervened—normally he would have got the cheque on the 1st April—but the fact is that he did not get his payment and he was "all of a dither."
That happens in other hospitals. I asked the Minister previously—I think I was on a deputation to him—could he not design some method of accepting an estimate of what the deficit is likely to be for any particular hospital and to say to them: "We will pay you an amount on account each month and at the end of the year, when you send in your books for audit, we will pay the balance then." There is a number of hospitals concerned and I do not know what messages have to go down and back for payments, but the vicious part of it is that the average deficit of a hospital is not below £10,000 or £20,000 per year and they have to pay bank interest on an overdraft while they are waiting to get payment in respect of the deficit. In each deficit there is, of course, an addition as a result of the high interest charges for the overdraft.
Surely the Minister could arrange to say to these hospitals: "We have now long experience of each of you. We know what your deficit is likely to be. In the case of Hume Street, if it is to be £12,000 this year, less an allowance off the deficit, because you are allowed to take in certain stocks of medicine which you previously had to hold in reserve to meet a deficit, we will give you £900 a month and at the end of the year, after the certified audit, we will give you whatever balance is due." Could the Minister not do this instead of having the present position?
These hospitals are being run by public-spirited people who give their time and their services free, who are interested in the welfare and the treatment of the patients and who are very worried when they go on an inspection of a hospital, or go into a board meeting, and the registrar or secretary states: "We are up to our necks again; there is a letter from the banks saying we must not issue cheques; we cannot pay wages; what are we going to do?" The Minister will have to do something about that.
Comment on this
I have increased the capitation payments by 2/- per day and I have increased the deficit payments—the amount payable for deficits.
Comment on this
No, the deficit payments. The amount to be paid in reduction of deficits was increased this year as was also the capitation payment.