Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 1–138 of 269. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I think I made it clear that it is now pretty generally agreed that the economic future of us all, whether we live in city, town, or village or on the land itself is, in the last analysis, dependent on the success or failure which attends our efforts to expand production from the land. It is most urgently necessary for everyone in this House, and in the country, to bear in mind one factor in relation to the expansion of agricultural production that does not as yet apply to the expansion in our industrial industry and it is that our domestic potential for consumption, though very much expanded, has now almost reached its limit with the result that increased agricultural production, in the main, must be for export.
A great many people over the last 17 years have become so accustomed to living in a seller's market that they forget, or are prone to forget, the fundamental change that is introduced when we find ourselves in these times in a buyer's market. We are back once more in the atmosphere of pretty acute competition in the foreign markets in which we trade. Fortunately we have been able by a series of trade agreements, principally with Great Britain, substantially to mitigate the severity of the impact of that competitive atmosphere; but, more and more as it impacts on us, our success or failure to expand production here will depend on our ability to expand it on terms which will enable us to meet competition, and beat it, both as to quality and price in the markets where we trade.
Bearing that in mind, I do not think we can doubt that the future of expansion lies mainly, but not exclusively, in the realm of live stock and live-stock products. I have indicated how urgently necessary it is that we should increase our cow population. One of the most remarkable phenomena of Irish agriculture over the past century has been that, though the total number of cattle has fluctuated quite widely from time to time, our total number of cows and heifers has remained virtually stable; and nothing is more urgent in our present situation than that we should exert every effort to increase our cow population.
Now, when it comes down to the concrete question of how this is to be done, I have a pragmatical mind: it seems to me the only way to do it is to keep more cows, and the only way to keep more cows is to try to persuade our farmers to retain more of the heifers bred on their holdings and send them to the bull. One may ask not unnaturally why they have not done that in the past and I think, when one comes to examine that question, one is forced to the conclusion that one of the reasons is that, while our farmers are pretty well as good as any farmers in the world in respect of tillage techniques, it is undoubtedly true that we have fallen far behind in a proper appreciation of the capacity of grassland to produce, with the result that the quality of much of our grazing land and meadows is deplorably low.
This leads me then to ask the question as to how best that problem can be surmounted? I think we are providing the answer to that problem reasonably well, but it behoves us to persuade the farmers to avail more energetically of the facilities which are being afforded them now and which were not available to them in the past. Those facilities may be numbered as, first, the supply of ground limestone which is an essential prerequisite to improving our grasslands; and it is important to remember that we now have available unlimited supplies of ground limestone at a price which brings it within reach of every farmer who is prepared to use it. The second thing that is urgently necessary is that the farmer should know what essential constituents his land lacks in order to evoke its maximum output and, to do that, soil testing facilities are essential.
It is satisfactory to know now that we have at Johnstown Castle in County Wexford a soil testing laboratory second to none in Europe or, indeed, I believe, in the world, the facilities of which are available to the farmers on more advantageous terms than are such facilities available to any other farmers in the world, because our farmers need only ask the agricultural instructor or the parish agent to come and test their soil and that will be done free of charge and a report made, without any cost of any kind, as to what the particular farms may require.
There is no doubt that at the present time what the grassland of Ireland first requires is an adequate supply of lime, phosphate, potash and nitrogen; and it is the duty of the Department of Agriculture, as it is of the county committees, to direct the attention of the farmers to the necessity for these things and to their availability. I think it would be of service to the agricultural community if all of us who have an opportunity of reaching that community directly would emphasise to those who are habitually taking conacre at the present time for the accommodation of their surplus stock that if they would spend one half the rent they at present happily pay for conacre on the purchase of lime, phosphate, potash and nitrogen and apply them to their own land, they would be able to carry their cattle on their own land, and, at the same time, by a process of residual values, they would greatly improve the quality of their own land, thus fulfilling the injunction of getting from it its maximum output, always provided they leave it in the autumn a little better than they found it in the spring.
It is true that a great deal of the land of the country has been in a state of chronic dereliction through waterlogging and excessive fencing, through the occupation of too much land by shrubs and ditches, through the overgrowth of much land by scrub and bush and rock. I think the land rehabilitation project is making good headway towards the elimination of these obstacles, thereby increasing production. Now, all this is primarily referable to the increased output of cattle and milk, but we must not overlook, as some of us are too often prone to do, the very important contribution that can and should be made to the economy of our small farmers and medium sized farmers by the keeping of greater numbers of sheep. I am happy to see from the returns that the numbers of our sheep are steadily increasing and I like to recall that very energetic measures were taken over the past eight years by the Department of Agriculture to improve the quality of our mountain sheep by the introduction of very large numbers of imported rams of the highest quality, the results of which imports are now being seen in the quality of the wool and of the character of the blackfaced sheep on our mountainsides and indeed on the sheep which normally are reared and fattened on the lowlands as well.
We are unfortunately late in starting in the eradication of bovine T.B. By a series of circumstances into which it is not necessary to go to-day, it has been possible for Denmark and Holland to travel further and faster in that direction than we have been able to do. There is no use in pining over the past. We put our hand to the task of eliminating bovine T.B. in this country when the bovine eradication scheme was launched a little over a year ago. I think we may justly claim to have found ourselves much more fortunate than we had any right to anticipate.
We took, as the House knows, three areas for intensive eradication—County Sligo, County Clare and the parish of Bansha and two adjoining parishes. The incidence of the disease in the Bansha area was much what we anticipated and was undoubtedly high. The incidence in Clare was not alarming but substantial and it manifestly presented a relatively long-term problem for its complete eradication. Our experience in Sligo, however, has been so encouraging as to persuade us that it is not impossible that, within the next year or two, we shall be able to designate Sligo as the first T.B. free area in this country. It is our purpose, when we have reached that stage, to require everybody in the area to participate in the task of eradicating T.B. just as we would require them to eradicate anthrax and foot-and-mouth disease, if it appeared in any part of the country; and then, by the erection of a cordon sanitaire around Sligo, gradually to expand to the adjoining counties a T.B. free status so that, within the foreseeable future, we may have a substantial area in that part of the country which shall be eligible for the style and title of an attested area under the terminology commonly employed in international practice in the elimination of T.B.
An essential part of that scheme for the elimination of bovine T.B. is the facilities which are being made available to co-operative creameries to install pasteurising plants to handle the skim milk which is being returned to the farmers. I am happy to say that advantage is being taken of the 50 per cent. grant that is available to those who install the plant, and we hope that every creamery in the bovine eradication area will have that equipment in the early future. I think it is true to say that, in respect of the entire County Clare, all the creameries have it or are in the process of acquiring it, and I hope that we shall be able to make a similar report in respect of Sligo at a reasonably early date.
The next item in our expansion programme must be pigs. Over a short term, pigs have the greatest potentiality for dramatic expansion because you can expand the pig population very much more quickly than that of cattle or sheep. When one came to ask oneself what required to be done in order to bring this about, it seemed to me that the first essential was to ensure, as far as our resources would permit, that that hazard in pig production, which has operated always heretofore to restrain full scale expansion, would be removed. And that hazard was the danger that, when the number of pigs increased, the prices would collapse. Bitter experience in the past persuaded those who produced pigs that that habitually happened and, accordingly, the Government has authorised me to inform pig producers that for the next 12 months—and we intend to maintain it thereafter—there shall be a minimum guaranteed price for pigs of Grade A quality delivered to bacon factories.
It may be well if I make it clear what that provides. It provides that every pig going into the factory shall be graded under the supervision of the officers of the Department of Agriculture who normally attend there for veterinary inspection purposes. Over and above that any farmer has a right to go and see his own pigs graded if he wants to. In respect of any pig which attains to Grade A, he is guaranteed that he will receive not less than 235/- per cwt., no matter how many pigs are delivered to the factory. He may receive more but nobody can offer him less.
A constant source of complaint has been that it is a terrible hardship on a man, who delivers a pair of pigs to the factory and discovers that they are 1 or 2 lb. overweight; he is heavily cut and his pigs reduced from the relatively satisfactory price provided for Grade A pigs down to the relatively unsatisfactory price provided for Grade B pigs. I have tried to meet that situation, and the way I have tried to meet it is by establishing a new buffer grade. Grade A pigs will be pigs from 1 cwt. O qr. 8 lb. up to 1 cwt. 2 qr. O lb., with certain fat measurements which are set out in the Order, and anybody delivering pigs within that definition is guaranteed not less than 235/- per cwt.
Then I have asked the bacon curers to produce what I call a buffer grade —Grade B1. For pigs with those fat measurements but which fall within the range of 1 cwt. 2 qr. 1 lb. or 1 cwt. 2 qr. 7 lb., they will receive 230/-. If the pig falls into Grade B ordinary, I do not seek to fix the price at all, and the same applies in the case of Grade C and what is called Grade X, if it falls below the very minimal standard fixed for Grade C. I think that will be some contribution to the problem of the man who feels a deep sense of grievance if his pig has gone 1 lb. or 2 lbs. over the maximum prescribed for Grade A, as a result of which he is called upon to bear the full impact of the reduction which, we may anticipate, would arise as between Grade A and Grade B pigs.
At the same time, as from May 1st, there will be no restriction on the export of live pigs. Deputies may ask me: "What do you expect the result of that will be?" I would like to say that I do not know. Some pig dealers take the view that they will be able to build up a large market for live pigs, and the view has also been expressed to me that they will find it very difficult. However, it is a free open market and those engaged in it can make the best fist of it they can. I shall be very glad to see them export as many pigs as they can find profitable markets for, and I will be very glad to see the advantages of that accruing to the farmers who produce the pigs. I do not know what contribution that is going to make to stability but this, at least, seems certain: it will be an additional guarantee of assistance to the prices generally available for pigs of all grades if there is an alternative market available for them through pig export channels.
That brings me to a problem which confounds the mind of many people and that is whether we have the best type of pig in this country or not. That is one of the most difficult of all the questions to answer because you are in this position. The type of pig we have in this country is intimately familiar to us all. It is as old as human wisdom that distant hills look green and far off cows have long horns. Anything you do not know and that some other fellow has looks lovely, but the thing you have yourself you are always inclined to regard as rather pedestrian.
There is another element that a lot of people forget. It is that the man who has the new thing is in on the ground floor and the louder he toots his horn about the virtue of the new thing of which he is exclusive possessor for the time being, the higher he can jack the price to anybody who wants to purchase half of his output. Deputies have probably noticed that in Great Britain two or three years ago the fortunate few who bought first drafts of the Swedish landrace pigs got the most incredible prices for sows from people who were eager to share in this bonanza. The price has gone back considerably now, but over and above that those who rushed in to participate in the bonanza were not aware that they were buying something more than the pig. A great many of them were buying a risk and our friends in Northern Ireland who admitted the Swedish landrace pig in the early stages discovered to their horror and dismay that there had turned up in Northern Ireland that which had never been there before—a most obscure and dangerous pig disease from which this island had been free up to that.
Fortunately, by diligent exertions on the part of our friends in Northern Ireland they have pretty well succeeded in stamping out the disease of atrophic rhinitis, an outbreak of which threatened them there. I am being pressed to throw open the gates and let in the landrace pig, the representation being that the landrace is so much better than the strain of pigs we have. I do not believe it is. I believe there are good Swedish landrace pigs just the same as there are bad ones, just as I believe there are good large Irish pigs and bad ones. Even if I make the concession that the generality of landrace pigs has possibly reached a higher level at this stage than the generality of large Irish white, I am convinced that it would be folly to run the risk of bringing in something which will attack our pigs for whatever passing advantage there might be available in having a limited number of Swedish landrace pigs at fancy prices available to our farmers at the present time.
But I could not honestly take up that position if I were not in a position to add that we are pursuing with all the energy we can command the task of progeny testing and raising the standard by a process of selection of our own large Irish white pigs. We have inaugurated progeny testing in an experimental way at Ballyhaise and a progeny testing station where progeny testing can be done by the best possible methods is in process of erection at the Munster institute.
That is not all. In addition to that, we have, with the collaboration of the Pigs and Bacon Marketing Board, set up a system in every factory whereby a constant watch is maintained to see if any exceptionally high proportion of Grade A pigs is coming from any particular district and wherever that becomes manifest we send an investigation officer to that district to see if we could identify the boar which is passing on this peculiarly desirable factor in the progeny that is taken up in the factory. So far, these efforts have been attended by some measure of success. Where we establish that a particular boar seems to be producing an exceptionally high proportion of high quality progeny we are endeavouring to use his progeny as boars to let out or to sell to other breeders so that the excellence of his produce can be disseminated as widely as possible.
That procedure is attended by its own perils because sometimes when you establish the desirable quality of a boar either at a progeny testing station or through this procedure in the factory by the time you get to the boar he has been turned into sausages or has met with some disaster. We had one instance in which we thought we had identified a boar but by the time we reached his residence the boar was dead. He had met with an accident. That happens from time to time.
Nevertheless, you do identify a number of them and it is along those lines that I would hope to establish in due time that the large Irish white would produce at least as high a percentage of Grade A pigs as would suit our export trade and provide our bacon factories with as high quality a pig as is available to a bacon factory in any part of the world.
That does not finish the job because when our farmers have delivered to the factories the highest grade pig the quality of the bacon depends upon the skill of the curer who produces the bacon. We have in this country some curers who are as good curers as can be found anywhere but we have some curers who are not. It was a source of constant difficulty and anxiety to me how best to deal with the curer who is getting the right quality of pigs all right but who is not producing the right quality of bacon and who by putting inadequately cured bacon on the British market may do serious injury to the reputation of Irish bacon as a whole.
I have felt bound, therefore, to set high standards and high accommodation and equipment in Irish bacon factories as the minimum that will be accepted in regard to bacon curing in future. I have got to bear in mind what will be reasonable requests on established firms so as not to present them with a programme of re-equipment and reform which if enforced ruthlessly would wreck them financially but I have got to give notice and make it perfectly clear that in the defence of the agricultural industry as a whole I must ensure that reasonable accommodation is available in bacon factories to do justice to the pigs that are slaughtered and cured there and that people who have not got the resources themselves must seek the resources, not to carry out any fancy or unnecessary frills in the equipment of factories, but to bring these factories up to the minimum requirements of modern bacon curing. We cannot all try to produce bacon in factories equipped in a style that was appropriate to 1880, and sell the product in a market which is being supplied in 1956 from the four corners of the earth.
I spoke of the knowledge we now have of the relative merits of our own breed of large Irish white pig. I think it may be of interest to the House to have some information which I give them most tentatively and under every sort of warning that the conditions under which these progeny tests were carried out are experimental and could not be deemed to be identical with the conditions obtaining in progeny testing stations recognised internationally, as our new progeny testing station at the Munster Institute will be when it is built. But, subject to those emphatic reservations, we have conducted and completed two progeny tests to-day. Another, the third, is in process of completion at the present time.
In the first test, there were 74 pigs on test and in the second, 71. The average weight of the pigs at eight weeks was 34.67 lb. in the first case and 36.75 in the second. The average weight at slaughter in the first test was 193 lb. and in the second 190. The food conversion rate, which is a very important factor, and this not at all under ideal conditions, was 3,369 in the first case and 3.502 in the second. The killing out percentage was 75.57 in the first test and 76.93 in the second test. The length of carcase, measured according to the Danish system —and there are two systems— averaged 93.5 centimetres in the first test and 94 centimetres in the second test. These are figures that I have compared at length and they compare very favourably with the Danish figures. There are a number of other criteria here set out by which carcases are judged but, when you bring them down to the point of grading, we have had this not unsatisfactory experience. In the first progeny test 67.5 per cent. of the pigs graded A; in the second progeny test 76.3 per cent of the pigs graded A. In the first progeny test, 23 per cent. of the pigs graded B; in the second progeny test 16.6 per cent. of the pigs graded B. In the first test only 9.5 per cent. were graded C; in the second test only 7.1 per cent. graded C. That means that, in the first test, we had over 90 per cent. of the pigs grading A and B and in the second test we had nearly 93 per cent. of the pigs grading A or B. That is by no means perfection, but it is not at all bad. I think it would be a ridiculous procedure to throw away the position we have, that is, of having a population of that breed free from very grave disease and exchanging it for the Swedish landrace which certainly, in our opinion, is a vector of atrophic rhinitis and which we very much doubt will produce a result substantially superior to that result as of to-day.
Comment on this
I will find that out for the Deputy. I have not the details by me at the moment. However, we doubt if the foreign breed of pig would give us superior results. We have little or no doubt that, given the maintenance of progeny testing, we can secure that that disease-free variety of pig can be raised in its general strains to a level which will compare very favourably with the best any foreign country can produce.
Comment on this
Would it be possible for the Minister to make that information available with the particulars of the food ration—on the restricted basis the Minister has mentioned?
Comment on this
I will certainly look into that. However, when I come to discuss the food ration, that brings me to another point which I wish to emphasise to-day. I would ask the House to give very special attention to what I am going to say. We have had a long tradition in this country of importing maize wherewith to feed pigs. Prior to the 1939 war, so long as we proposed to remain in the export business, there seemed to me to be an unanswerable case for leaving access to these cereals such as maize freely available to the pig rearer of this country. We have to remember that the food which a pig producer in this country feeds to his pig is as much the raw material of his industry as cotton is to the spinner or yarn is to the cloth weaver or metal is to the man who is making pots and pans. Nobody would ever suggest that you should ask a factory to manufacture pots and pans for export to a foreign market and tax the iron which has to be imported wherewith to make them. There was not a doubt that, prior to 1939, maize was an incomparably cheap foodstuff for pigs compared with any cereal we could produce in this country.
Comment on this
Pollard was a by-product of the flour mills. My principal concern was access to grains primarily intended for the feeding of live stock. Maize was infinitely cheaper than any grain we could produce in this country. The varieties of barley which we grew had so low a yield per acre as to make them luxury grain for the purpose of feeding pigs. They were primarily grown in our conditions for malting and only as the raw material for malting. Now, in 1948, we introduced into this country Ymer and Herta barley, the short straw high yield feeding barley from which it became possible to get an average return in the order of 40 cwt. per acre and, in the hands of an exceptionally skilled grower, yields of three tons per acre were not unknown. However, the moment we popularised these varieties of barley in the country we were faced with the knowledge that, in certain areas, they tended to fail. It quickly became manifest to all that which was known to the experts all along, namely, that you cannot grow barley and you cannot grow beet in the absence of lime.
The difficulty was that oats and wheat and divers other crops would grow on relatively acid soil, but that beet and barley died completely away in the absence of lime and there was no source from which that well-nigh universal shortage of lime in the West and a great part of the South and Midlands could be procured until adequate lime grinding capacity was established in the country and it was possible for a farmer anywhere to get a sufficient quantity of ground limestone to correct the acidity of his soil. It is now possible for any farmer in any part of the country to say with a reasonable degree of confidence that any ground that will grow oats or wheat will grow feeding barley, if its lime status is corrected. I cannot say that as an absolute rule without exception, but reference to his parish agent or the agricultural instructor of the county committee of agriculture will readily inform him as to the general rule in that regard. The result is that it has now been brought effectively within the reach of every farmer, small or large, to grow on his own land a cereal which, value for value, is as good as maize for pig feeding and the yield now obtaining is comparable in money value to the cheapest maize available in the world.
In these circumstances, and, bearing in mind the acutely competitive nature of the market in which we have to trade abroad, I would like to direct the mind of Dáil Éireann to the question of the pursuit of a course which, subject to the approval of the Dáil, I propose to adopt, that is, to persuade the pig raisers of this country to produce pigs from home-grown barley and skim milk. I make that addendum, skim milk, advisedly because any man who tries to raise pigs on barley without skim milk is courting disaster, unless he incorporates into the barley a suitable percentage of some other protein food such as meat meal or fish meal where these are available. The man who tries to feed pigs on barley without skim milk or meat meal or fish meal is heading straight for disaster, but the man who feeds pigs on barley and skim milk, if he adds about 1 lb. of salt to the cwt. of barley, and no more, has, I believe, a full and adequate diet for pigs.
I know that animal dieticians would qualify that considerably and advocate an ounce of this and a quarter ounce of that, and doubtless those who are in a position to introduce these refinements into their feeding may find them rewarding, but I dare to generalise and to say that any farmer who will feed his pigs on barley meal and 1 lb. of salt to the cwt. of barley meal and skim milk or meat meal or fish meal, has a full and adequate ration for his pigs. It also has this immense advantage, that in respect of the small farmers they can grow the bulk of it on their own holding and without giving any profit to the bag manufacturer, the wholesaler or the retailer, or to the miller other than their local miller. They can reserve for themselves the profit on their own crop and on the end product produced from it, the pig, instead of selling their cereal and then buying it back after it has passed through the hands of the miller, the wholesaler, the shopkeeper, the transport company, the bag manufacturer and all the others who take a bite out of it in the process of converting it from barley into a compound or straight feeding in a bag.
I do not want to say that there may not be farmers in the country whose special circumstances make it more convenient and advantageous for them to feed their pigs on a suitable compound feed, notably those who have not ready access to skim milk, but as regards the small farmer, who particularly stands in need of advice of this kind, I would say to concentrate on barley meal and skim milk with a lb. of salt to the cwt. of meal, bearing always in mind that salt, while excellent in limited quantities, is deadly poison to a pig if given to excess. Many are those who, leaving a bag of salt in a pig-sty, came back to find the pigs all dead, because pigs will eat salt until they die; where a little is good a surfeit is poisonous.
However, these are too intimate details to go into on an occasion of this kind. What I would suggest is that we should aim to ensure that in the long run we would grow all the coarse grain required for the pig industry and that, as we approach that stage, we would be justified in proposing to the pig feeders that from, say, September to December or even later, while supplies of barley are readily available from home sources, we should import no maize or coarse grain. This course is to be justified by this test, that the farmer who grows his own and feeds it to his pigs will get a better profit on the operation than the farmer who buys coarse grain through the shop or the mill for the same purpose. We have no right—I want to emphasise this and this is the appropriate time to say it—to subsidise the relatively wealthy grain growers of the East at the expense of the poor pig producer in the West, but we have the duty to cast our eye around and see how best we can marry the interests of both to the advantage of the country as a whole.
No matter how earnestly we put our minds to that task we must realise that the best way for the pig producer to procure the coarse grain he requires on which to fatten pigs is to grow it himself and it is only for that part of his requirements that he cannot produce upon his own holding that he should have recourse to the merchant or the mill. From the national approach, seeing that we now have a coarse grain available which is the economic competitor of imported grain, we will be wise, without undue upset to anybody, to urge on all to avail of that grain which can be produced from our own soil before we supplement it with such additional imports as may be requisite from foreign sources.
One of the great difficulties about a new departure of that kind is that if you declare an absolute famine of maize from September to December or January and then use up to all your domestic supplies of barley and go over to maize, you run the serious risk of killing half the pigs in the country because you cannot change a pig's diet from barley to maize in 24 hours. It must be a gradual process of adjustment. But you run another risk. If the whole pig producing community adapt themselves to the use of parley for four months of the year and then find themselves for the remaining seven or eight months dependent almost exclusively on maize, by the time the seven or eight months are over they do not want to change over to barley; they have got accustomed to the process of using maize.
Therefore, I must seriously consider whether it is necessary or desirable to import supplementary supplies to those which we shall produce at home, and, where prices are comparable, instead of importing maize, we should seriously consider importing barley.
Comment on this
Rome was not built in a day, and it is only fools who would try to do it, but I think that is the right line of policy on which to proceed and that what we are doing is something that would commend itself to the prudent man. But it could not be done, and it cannot be done, without ground limestone and without the varieties of barley which I am happy to remember I was primarily responsible for introducing eight happy years ago.
I am glad to be able to give Deputies ad interim information on the ration given to pigs and I shall, of course, be glad to send Deputy Walsh a copy of it. For the first period of fattening, that is from 45 lb. until they attain, I think, a weight of 112 lb. live weight, the ration is, barley, 50 per cent.; oats, 10 per cent.; bran, 5 per cent.; pollard, 22½ per cent.; grassmeal, 2½ per cent.; fishmeal, 5 per cent. and soya bean meal, 5 per cent. It will be noted that in the area where these progeny tests were proceeding supplies of skim milk were not available.
From 112 lb. to 200 lb.—these were live weight figures—the ration was 55 per cent. barley, 10 per cent. oats, 22½ per cent. pollard, 2½ per cent. grassmeal, 5 per cent. meat and bone meal, and 5 per cent. soya bean meal. One lb. of salt and 1 lb. of limestone flour—per cwt., I think—was added to all rations. Vitamins A and D were also added. Pigs were fed to appetite until 6¼ lb. of meal were consumed. Feeding was then restricted to 6¼ lb. of meal per diem until the pigs were finished. Up to a certain stage—I think up to 112 lb.—they were fed ad lib., then, for the final part, restricted to 6¼ lb. of meal per diem. There is, of course, a very important matter to which I must refer——
Comment on this
They were bought from a number of pedigree pig producers, a number of whom are already co-operating with the Department in a litter testing campaign to determine the fecundity of each sow. That diet, with all the trimmings in it, is, in fact, closely related to the diet ordinarily used internationally in pig progeny testing stations, but as you will observe, if you leave out the soya bean meal, the fishmeal, the grassmeal and so on, it is the kind of diet available to any Irish farmer, and if, for all the frills and furbelows, you substitute skim milk, even without the grassmeal and the soya beans or the fishmeal or the Vitamins A or D—I am not saying it might not be better if a farmer was in a position to put these in—I am convinced, particularly if in the final stage he restricts the pigs to not more than 6 or 6½ lb. of meal per day he will get a reasonably high percentage of Grade A pigs.
There are one or two other things to which I want to refer. One is in regard to a new departure which has been embarked on in the course of the last 12 months in connection with purchases and equipment—these purchases are already completed—being planned for the farm at Backweston, near Lucan, which is designed to form part of our pedigree seed production programme. The aim there is to expand the work of testing varieties of seeds and the production of what I believe is called a mother-stock of suitable varieties of wheat, barley, oats and grass seed which can be distributed to be grown under the supervision of the Department of Agriculture as certified Irish seed of these various varieties.
I think the highest compliment that can be paid to any certified seed scheme is that in so far as we have had a surplus of certified seed wheat available we have had inquiries from abroad to purchase it. I would like to see these certified seeds ultimately made available to the farmers of this country on the basis that if they did not want to pay for them there would be plenty of others who would be glad to pay for them and to get them. I think the less protection we have in respect of seeds which farmers have to buy, the better for everybody. The aim ought to be to produce certified seed of so high a reputation that it requires no protection from any competitor in the world but will be eagerly sought by all, both at home and abroad, on its merits, and value-for-value in competition with seed from any other source.
I want to refer to the parish plan, but before doing that I would like to catalogue shortly certain services which we now have and which, looking back to the recent past, we had not— certain services which I think are vital to the successful campaign to expand agricultural production in this country and without which it would have been impossible to do so. I refer principally to the ground limestone scheme, the soil testing facilities of Johnstown, the land rehabilitation project, the farm building scheme, the pig progeny testing scheme, the bovine T.B. eradication scheme, the creamery milk pasteurisation scheme, the parish plan and the pedigree seed production of wheat, oats, barley and grass seed, all of which I am glad to report to the Dáil, were organised under the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
I put them in catalogue form so that you could argue about that until the cows come home.
Comment on this
I would like to refer to the parish plan. I feel it is probably agreed on all sides of the House that one very vital adjunct to any campaign to expand production is to bring within the reach of individual farmers the know-how of how best to exploit the potentialities of his land so as to secure the best possible results permanently. There are various services available under county committees of agriculture, but I want to make this clear, that where the farmers in any area seek the service of a permanent parish agent to help them and their neighbours in three adjoining parishes, they may seek it from the county committee of agriculture, and if the county committee of agriculture is prepared to supply it—well and good. But if they do not supply it, I want to fix all with full and fair notice that I have no intention whatever of allowing any vested interest successfully to prevent me from bringing within the reach of our farmers the expert advice without which they cannot get for themselves, for their wives and families from their holding a decent living and the production that the land should allow.
I know of my own personal knowledge of farmers who could greatly increase their yield, and who would greatly increase their yield, if they had at their disposal the advice which they require in order to achieve the results they would like to achieve. I know from personal experience of parish agents who are working under my Department in the country at the present time of the dramatic and superb results that have been secured as a result of the co-operation of farmers who sought that advice and got it and manifested their zeal and hunger for these facilities.
I intend to proceed until I have ensured that every farmer in this country has at his service the kind of advice he wants and the kind of advice to which he is entitled. Where he gets it from is a matter of indifference to me. If he can get it from the county committee of agriculture, he is quite welcome to do so, but, if he cannot, he will get it, on application, from me.
I reiterate, that in cleaving to that policy resolutely I want to pay a tribute to those who inaugurated it first in this country. Amongst the parish agents serving under my Department at present there are two categories, one, of the men who hold degrees in agricultural science and who have been appointed in the course of the last 12 months, but, over and above them, we dispose of the invaluable services of the old parish agents who were sent out originally under the Congested Districts Board, of whom there are 111 at present functioning in my Department.
These men were sent out as parish agents 50 years ago by the Congested Districts Board under the chairmanship of the late Cardinal O'Donnell, the late Dr. Kelly, Bishop of Ross, and the late Father Denis O'Hara, parish priest of Kiltimagh. I believe that these men knew their theology and loved their country just as well as any of the men of this generation and I am proud to follow in the footsteps they first made when they recognised the urgent need of bringing the right kind of advice and instruction to the small farmers of this country 50 years ago.
The world is changing and the standard of instruction required under modern conditions may be somewhat more exhaustive to-day than it was then, but it does seem, probably, appropriate that in this day and age the parish agent, acting directly under the Minister for Agriculture in this country, should be a graduate in agricultural science. That is not in any way to belittle the incalculable services that have been and are being rendered by the Department of Agriculture parish agents in the congested areas of this country.
I would like Deputies to bear in mind that, sometimes, when they read statistics—statistics are queer things in the hands of those who want to use them for their own purpose—about the multitudes of advisers available in Denmark and Holland, it might do them no harm to study the qualifications of a great many of the instructors in Holland because they will discover that, beside them, our parish agents of the Department of Agriculture under the old Congested Districts Board scheme are the equal or superior of a great many of the instructors that are at present serving under the Government of Holland and who are recorded for the benefit of the people of this country as being agricultural advisers in the same context as we refer to the graduates who are functioning as county advisers and parish agents under our several schemes here.
On the Continent the same type of parish agent as we provide in the congested areas of this country is very widely available. I think, probably, it is good that we should aim at a system ultimately manned exclusively by graduates in agricultural science but, obviously, the limits imposed upon us by the availability of such graduates must constrain us to travel very much less fast than we would if the supplies of trained personnel were available.
Deputies may wish to know what the prospects are of our tillage output this year. I am not in a position to say with any degree of accuracy what it is likely to be but, subject to the most exhaustive reservations which must be made at this stage of the year, it looks approximately like as if the acreage of wheat will be something similar to what it was last year; the acreage of feeding barley appears to be very much greater than it was last year; the acreage of beet appears to be something about what it was last year and the acreage of other root crops is as yet unascertainable because as Deputies are well aware, they are at present still being sown.
There are certain other details of which I would like to inform the House but I can do so in an abbreviated style, I think. Most Deputies have received a copy of the White Paper which I circulated for their information. I would like to direct their attention to every paragraph of that paper but with special reference to bog reclamation on pages 26 and 28 because that describes a project which is proceeding in collaboration between the Department and Bord na Móna, where Bord na Móna is placing at our disposal areas of cutaway bog, where they have removed the turf and the best methods for its prompt conversion to arable land are being studied by the scientists of my Department.
I would direct the attention of Deputies to the paragraph dealing with the cattle artificial insemination service because there they will learn that with the construction of the insemination co-operative in the north-west area we will, I think, have completed this service for the whole country. Deputies are no doubt aware that a good deal of controversy attended the establishment of the artificial insemination centre in the Sligo-Donegal-Leitrim-Mayo-Roscommon area. It was of a character which I did not think was unreasonable on either side and I was profoundly reluctant, in the early stages, to appear to take one side rather than the other but I was finally constrained to come down on the side of artificial insemination by the urgent necessity to control certain bovine diseases rampant in that area, notably trichomoniasis, and veterinary science, I think, has established that the reduction of that particular disease without the availability of artificial insemination is impossible. That consideration finally persuaded me, having weighed up the pros and cons of the case made on both sides, that I had a duty to press forward and I am happy to say that I think I now have the collaboration of most of the co-operative dairy societies in the area who have combined to form a co-operative to administer the artificial insemination service throughout that north-west part of Ireland and, with its establishment, that service will be available to farmers, large and small, in all parts of the country.
I would refer Deputies to the demonstration plots scheme on page 31 and to the farm buildings scheme on page 30. The farm buildings scheme falls into two tiers. One is that which is applicable to a wide range of farm buildings and the other is in respect of the double grant in respect of cow-byres for those who participate in the bovine T.B. eradication scheme. I am bound to tell the House that the demand for this scheme seems to be almost unlimited, and we have to fix a global figure which will be available in each financial year. Those for whom provision cannot be made out of that global sum will have to wait until next year when more money is available.
I would refer Deputies to page 27 of the notes which deal with the peatland experimental station. I went into that matter, Sir, in some detail when introducing a Supplementary Estimate recently—so recently that I do not think it is necessary to trouble the House with detailed information on it again. I should like the views of anyone who feels he would be in a position to give advice with regard to the elimination of the warble fly. To tell the truth, so long as there was a control on the price of hides, I did not see why the farmers should be asked to eliminate the warble fly for the benefit of the hide merchants who bought the hides cheap and sold them dear. Now there is a free market for hides and the benefit of any plan to eliminate the warble fly should accrue to the farmers. How can the warble fly be eliminated? I do not know how to eliminate the warble fly.
Comment on this
It is being done under my Department on Whiddy Island at the present time and in Loophead in order to demonstrate that it is physically possible to do it. I am sure Deputy Aiken does not mean to be provocative but he could not say anything more obviously absurd than to suggest that the warble fly has been eliminated on individual farms. How can you eliminate a warble fly on one farm? You cannot put up a notice saying: "Trespassers will be prosecuted" if the warble fly comes in from the next farm. A man can kill the warble flies which may infest his own cow, but what good does that do him? It is the neighbour's fly that might come in and sting his cows that is the trouble.
Comment on this
They can jump across a ditch. If the Deputy ever saw cattle gadding in a field pursued by the warble fly, he would marvel at the distance it can travel. I do not think Deputy Aiken fully excogitated that interjection before he made it. If the solution of the problem was so simple as that we would have no trouble at all. A notice could be put up stating, "Warble flies prosecuted if they enter here" but I cannot prosecute a warble fly.
Comment on this
Fortunately, a selective disease was discovered which would affect the rabbits and if the Deputy could tell me of any selective disease which would affect the warble flies he would be regarded as a benefactor, not only in Ireland but throughout the whole world, and F.A.O. would undertake to pay him many thousands of pounds. It is exactly what Deputy O'Leary has in mind that I am thinking of. If we could get some systemic drug and administer it to cattle in order to destroy the warble in the cow's system, that would be the ideal solution. If we could find some drug which could be administered in order to kill the warble fly in its passage through the cow's system, then the elimination of the warble fly would be, not an absolutely easy, but a relatively easy problem to solve.
The real problem is the one to which Deputy Aiken inadvertently referred. He pointed out that it does not matter how many warble flies you will cope with. If one farmer in one parish fails to collaborate, he will breed enough warble flies to warble the whole parish. We had a scheme with inspectors and that scheme became a laughing stock. I do not know which was the worst, the warble flies or the warble fly inspectors. A good many thought the inspectors were the worst. They did nothing and could not do anything. They were given an impossible task.
I did consult with those who manufacture the preparations for the destruction of the warble fly and suggested that if they could introduce some indelible dye, a proviso could be made similar to the Sheep Dipping Order. I was told that is not practicable. I wish we could devise some means to destroy the warble fly.
In order to demonstrate the possibility of eradicating the warble flies in a restricted area, we are carrying out experimental demonstrations, one of which is on Whiddy Island because we know that on a sea-girt island the thing is certainly possible and you could extinguish the warble fly in two or three years. The second experiment is being conducted at Loophead, which is a peninsula. We are seeking to eliminate the fly on a peninsula.
think that probably can be done and it will give us a good deal of information as to what area you require in order to remove the danger of infestation. If anybody can give me help as to some practical scheme for eliminating the warble fly, I would be very grateful for his assistance. I can assure him that his proposals will be carefully considered.
There are two matters upon which I ask the assistance of Deputies. One is the popularisation of Strain 19. One of the things at which we ought to aim is the elimination of contagious abortion from our cows because, firstly, it is the cause of immense loss to our stock-breeders and, secondly—and this is the more important aspect—because it is the source of undulant fever which affects human beings. This disease is contracted from the consumption of milk from cows infested with contagious abortion. I do not know if everybody is aware of that. A person may become infected with the very grave disease of undulant fever from the consumption of milk which is contaminated.
Contagious abortion can be eliminated and we have the means of doing it. All the farmers should get their cows and heifers inoculated against contagious abortion. The inoculation is not an expensive procedure and rarely has to be done more than once. It is very nearly a 100 per cent. effective protection, if the beasts do not come into intimate contact with massive infestation in the early stages after inoculation.
We are trying to continue as much propaganda as we can through the newspapers and the veterinary profession and I would be grateful for further suggestions as to how we could persuade a greater number of farmers to avail of this important remedy, particularly farmers in the dairying areas and, indeed, everywhere, although the disease is certainly more common in the dairying districts than in other parts of the country.
The other matter to which I wish to refer is the eradication of white scour in calves. We do not know, and I do not think anybody knows, the full extent of the calf mortality from white scour. There are certain areas in which calf mortality must have gone up to 60 per cent., due to white scour. I do not say that that is the average over the entire country, but in certain areas white scour has come to be regarded as almost the norm. We now have a certain cure and preventative for white scour. It is cheap and is readily available in any chemist's shop in any town in Ireland. I am trying to make that knowledge widespread throughout the country. The veterinary profession are doing their part and in so far as Deputies can help to popularise that knowledge, I should be greatly indebted to them for doing so. Any details required will be available on application to the Department of Agriculture.
I am discharged, I think, from going further into this matter by referring Deputies to the White Paper I have circulated. I will conclude as I began. The whole economic future of this country depends on our success or failure in expanding agricultural production. I must say that the number of highfalutin theorists that are now appearing in the guise of agricultural economic advisers have become as common as the warble fly, but they have little practical application to our problems. It may be that I have not got a sufficiently theoretical mind. If I have not got it now, it is too late for me to try to develop it, but I prefer the pragmatic approach.
The first and most important approach to expanded agricultural production is the improvement of the quality of our grass land. I put my faith in the reseeding of grass land, where that is necessary, and in the application of sufficient quantities of lime, phosphate, potash and nitrogen in the other areas. The second step is the expansion of the cow population. I know of no other way to bring that about than by convincing the mind of the farmer that he should keep two more heifers, where formerly he kept five; four more, where formerly he kept ten, and eight more, where formerly he kept 20. That procedure will pay the farmer, even though he has not sufficient equipment and labour to milk them all. Let the farmers have the calves to suck on the surplus cattle which they are not equipped to milk for the time being. The farmers will find that that procedure will pay them well when they come to sell the calf in six months' time and also if they want to sell the heifer, should she not prove suitable as a milch cow.
Secondly, we should extend our output of sheep and lambs, bearing in mind that the old market for ewe mutton has practically disappeared and its place has been taken by a highly competitive market for lamb.
Thirdly, we should expand our output of pigs for live export and conversion into bacon for export, mainly through the medium of barley and skim milk. If these things are done, then I believe that the land of Ireland is capable of providing for us all a high standard of comfort in our own country.
If these things are not done, I do not care what else be done, it will not be possible to provide for our own people in our own land. I have no doubt that, by bringing facilities within the reach of the farmers of this country, they will do their job. I know that the philosophy has been preached that that is not enough and that over and above that, it may be necessary to line the ditches with Civic Guards and to recruit the full of ten fields of inspectors and to equip them with bulldozers to break down the farmers' ditches and gates in order to make them do what the Minister for Agriculture thinks they ought to do. I stake my reputation on the plan of providing the facilities for the farmers and helping them to get from the land the maximum it is capable of producing. If that fails I freely concede that the other policy may become necessary. If that day should come, I would leave the prosecution of that policy to someone else.
Comment on this
I move:—
That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration.
I do so, not for the purpose, as the Minister stated in his opening speech, of widening the scope of the discussion, but to register our disapproval of the ineptitude of the Coalition Government, and particularly the Minister, as regards agriculture. The Minister, on Thursday evening, opened his speech on the Estimate by making a charge against the Irish Press in connection with cattle prices. The Irish Press did nothing other than to print factual market reports that had already been published by the Independent and the Irish Times. The Minister went out of his way to talk about racketeers and Fianna Fáil speculators in cattle. Let us just consider some of the statements reported in other papers and see how they compare with the reports of the Irish Press on 2nd February. We have some reports going back much further than that.
The first one we have is from the Irish Farmers' Journal of 21st January, 1956, where the headline is “Drastic Fall in Cattle Prices.”“Beef Price Shock.” On 28th January, 1956: “Foreign Beef Affects Markets. Leaner, Lighter Beef Wanted.” On 4th of February, 1956: “Stores Still Slow.” On 11th February, 1956: “Heavy Cattle Fall”; and on 3rd March, 1956: “Hope for Better Cattle Trade.” On 10th March: “Beef Men Shocked. Market Trends—Cattle Prices Fall Sharply.” On 17th March: “Another Bad Day For Beef.” On 24th March: “Beef Prices Steadying”; and 7th April: “Beef Goes Up Again.” These were the reports that appeared in the Farmers' Journal long before there was ever any mention of the fall in cattle prices in the Irish Press. On 8th December, 1955, the Irish Independent had a heading: “Prices Firmer For Bigger Supply.” On 15th December the Irish Independent had a heading: “Quieter Tone And Lower Prices”; and the text reads: “There was also a quieter tone at the store markets, where cattle that made over £6 6s. were the exception. A feature of these sales was the number of local farmers who bought stores for feeding.” On 19th January, 1956: “Prices Reflect Trend at British Centres,” and there follows: “The downward trend in dead meat prices, which has been a feature of market reports from British centres during the past few days, had repercussions at the Dublin Cattle Market yesterday when prices fell to the level of a few weeks back.” On 25th January, 1956, the following appeared: “The much lighter supply may have had the effect of helping to steady the cattle trade at the Dublin Market yesterday. Whatever the reason, it was easier to sell all sorts of stock; and while prices did not show any changes compared with those of a week ago, the opinion of the trade in general was that the market could have handled a slightly better supply.”
Comment on this
No, there is no mischief in that. I am merely reading the reports as they appeared from week to week. On 18th January, 1956, according to the Irish Independent:“Prices had got to the peak” and, said the exporters, “expenses are rising. Cattle prices have reached their peak and are tending to fall. With expenses rising the outlook is not as attractive as we would wish it to be.” So said Mr. Leonard Ferris, chairman of the Irish Livestock and Cattle Traders' Association. These are the reports that appeared in the other papers. Was it not wrong then for the Minister to come in here on Thursday evening holding out the Irish Press as being responsible for the fall in prices? The Irish Press was merely giving a factual report of the markets, as they were, during the months of January and February. Of course, the Minister used this as a red herring. He was not prepared for his Estimate on Thursday evening and he had to come in here and talk about something; and he started by making this slashing attack on the Irish Press. We were not expecting that. We were expecting the Minister to say something about agriculture, but we did not get it. The attack had to be made at the first opportunity because of the by-election in Laois-Offaly, or something like that. It will be used there probably as it was used in Kerry, and it was in order to clarify the position, that I have quoted from these other papers this evening.
Let me come back now to the statement made by the Minister in relation to the expansion that has taken place in the cattle population during 1954-55. We have the enumeration for January, 1955, which gives us the total number of cattle. In January, 1955, the number was 3,983,000 and in January, 1956, it was 4,069,500 showing an increase of 86,500, or 2.2 per cent. That may look good on paper, but we must ask ourselves: does this represent more cattle produced? Does it represent more calves born in the year 1955? It does not. That figure is simply found by calculating the amount of frozen meat, chilled meat and tinned beef which was not sent out last year, but was sent out the year before. That is how we find the additional number of cattle. Our exports of chilled and frozen meat were down in 1955. Chilled meat and fresh meat were down to the extent of 95,897 cattle. That is what it represents, calculating four cattle to the ton. Frozen meat was down by 9,477. There was an increase in the number of cattle which went out in the form of tinned meat, but the net loss to the country was 93,115 cattle.
We are told that there has been an increase of 86,000 in the enumeration through that reduction of 95,115 cattle in our exports. Our exports of live cattle showed an increase of 1,547 in 1955 over 1954, that is, calves to bulls in all categories, fat bulls and stores, fat cows and heifers, stores, cows and heifers, milch cows and springers and calves. The position, therefore, is that we have less cattle produced in 1955 than we had in 1954. If we had maintained our export of frozen and chilled meat in 1955, we would not have that number of cattle on hands to-day.
In 1954, we exported 711,542 cwt. of fresh or chilled meat and in 1955, we exported 232,054 cwt. That shows the first drop we had. Again, it represents a further drop in frozen meat and, as I have already said, the only increase there was, was in frozen meat. We have, as the enumeration indicates, a reduction of 136,000 in our pig population and we have a reduction of 115,000 in our poultry population. The only category in which we show an increase is sheep. We have 195,600 sheep. We have a reduction in tillage of 80,000 acres. Is there anybody who has the temerity, in face of those figures, to come in here and say that our agriculture is progressing and that we can look upon our agricultural economy as improving? There has been no improvement in output. There may have been an improvement in value, but there has been none in volume.
The Minister now talks of keeping four more cows where a man has ten and two more where a man has five. Why? What guarantee has the farmer who keeps the extra two or the extra four cows that he will get rid of his stock?
Comment on this
The British market was there in 1954 for our chilled beef and frozen beef, but it was not there in 1955.
Comment on this
We walked them out to the extent of over 600,000. There has been no reduction in that. Is there any guarantee we can walk out more?
The Minister stated, when he was talking about this racket in the Irish Press, that these market reports were going to do tremendous damage to the British Farmers' Union when they were negotiating prices under the prices review. But how could our supply of beef and stores to the British market determine any change in prices? Our total quantity of beef going into that market, taking all the classes of cattle—stores, beef, and every animal we send out—represents anywhere from 125,000 to 130,000 tons of beef, out of a consumption of 900,000 tons. What about the Argentine sending in almost 300,000 tons? Would one not think that the sale of their beef at 1/7 per lb. had a far more damaging effect on the British farmer when he went to negotiate prices than the fact that something about prices appeared in the Irish Press or the Irish Independent here in this country? The Minister did not refer to that. As far as we are concerned, we supply them with about 13 per cent. of their meat requirements. The Minister has been stating that we should export more and more, but we find that in 1955 we were not able to export what we had or as much as we exported the year before. The really important thing, as far as I can see, is that the Minister gave no explanation of why this drop in demand took place—why we had not the same demand in 1955 as we had in 1954.
Comment on this
The Deputy has heard many rumours and many reasons have been given for that. But the Minister has at his disposal in the Embassy in London agricultural representatives who could have gone around to the principal markets, found out the trend of those markets, and got a general picture of what was happening. In that way, the Minister could have notified the Irish people and the farmers of this country of what was happening beyond. It would have helped and there would not be any question of racketeering. Fianna Fáil would not have driven the farmers to the markets with their cattle, if they had been able to get a true picture of what the situation was like in England. But nobody knew; they were in the dark; and they were left in the dark.
A similar situation regarding poultry existed some years ago, but to-day there are weekly reports in the papers. I claim credit for introducing that; and the same thing could be introduced in regard to cattle. These reports could be made available to enable the people to see the trends of the different markets throughout the country. People could form their own opinion. I know we have been told that it was because of the big consignments of meat from the Argentine that there was no demand for our chilled and frozen beef; and we have been told that there was no demand for our cattle in the winter, because there was no fodder in England. We have been told so many different things that we do not know which is the right one. But we do not know that, as a result of the drop in demand last year, we have about 93,000 or 94,000 more cattle to get rid of than our normal production for the year should amount to.
Comment on this
The price is not better than it was 12 months ago, nor within £2 or 30/- as good as it was this time 12 months.
Comment on this
At this time 12 months, cattle were making £8 a cwt. or up against it. They are not making that yet. I hope they do make it, but I suppose it is not likely. However, it was not a question of price, was it? What stopped the English farmers and the English buyers from taking our cattle last year? There was an unprecedented price paid in the months of April and May, and even up to June last year, but then there was a complete drop. Our cattle for the latter end of the year were not going out in the same numbers as in 1954. Our dead meat trade is finished—completely finished.
Comment on this
"The beast alive is worth gold; when he is dead, he must be sold." That is the old saying.
Comment on this
Is it not a good thing for the farmer to have two markets? He had the live cattle market and he had the dead cattle market. He could very well escape the racketeers in that case. Now he has only the one market. He is at the mercy of the shippers.
Comment on this
Previously we were sending out a great quantity of meat from our factories and they were giving good employment. The offal was retained here at home; good use was made out of it, and good money was made. Deputy Fagan does not want that.
Comment on this
He is not interested in whether we give more employment or not. He would like to see the offal going across the water to John Bull.
Comment on this
I suppose that is the Coalition's policy. I am glad we know what their policy is and what is the policy to which the Minister subscribes. He has not contradicted the Deputy and I assume he is prepared to subscribe to the view expressed by Deputy Fagan regarding our cattle.
Comment on this
The Minister was in very chastened mood this evening, not a bit like the Minister who came in here on Thursday evening. I suppose, on reflection, he thought it better to adopt the other method. So much for the cattle industry.
Let us now have a look at the tillage side of the picture. I am glad of one thing: that the Minister has changed his mind about maize. Maize will no longer be our principal feeding stuff. The Minister is now going over to barley. We were talking about barley, trying to get our people barley-minded in 1952, 1953 and 1954, but when the Minister came into office, he killed that scheme. He put maize back again on the free market.
In the early part of 1954, feeders could buy maize on the free market. They had to take a quantity of barley with it because we wanted to get them barley-minded. As I have said, the Minister killed that scheme and now he sees the folly of his action and he is coming back to our policy. In 1952, we started with an admixture of 12½ per cent. barley. We increased that to 25 per cent. and eventually to 50 per cent., and now the Minister talks about a 50 per cent. barley admixture. But the damage has been done to our exports of pork and bacon. Is it any wonder our exports of pork and bacon went down? No answer has been given by the Minister or by anybody else regarding these reductions. I wonder would this have any bearing on it: on 1st June, 1954, when Fianna Fáil went out of office, the price of pollard was £20 a ton; on 28th of June, it was raised to £20 10s.; on 16th August, its price was raised to £21 10s. a ton; and on 7th September to £25. Is it any wonder the people went out of pig production?
Their profits were gone. On 19th May of that year, pig meal was £29 15s. a ton. On 1st September, it was £29 15s., but on 11th September, it was £30 15s. Again, is it any wonder the people went out of pig production? The cost of their feeding stuff was going up and the price of their pork coming down. You have the results of that to-day. There has been a reduction of 136,000 pigs. In all, this year, we have a reduction of 8,000 sows, 200 boars, 68,000 pigs of three months of age and upwards and 59,000 pigs under three months. The inducement that the feeder had was taken away from him and the result is he had no option but to get out of bacon production.
Now the Minister has guaranteed a price of 235/- a cwt. as a minimum price, but he has told us nothing at all about the carcase levy of 4/7. Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll has left the House. I intended to ask her if she was satisfied with the fact that the Dublin consumer will have to pay that levy in order to subsidise first quality bacon for John Bull.
Comment on this
I am sorry Deputy James Larkin is not here. The Minister will remember that, when he opened the Border, Deputy James Larkin told him to close it and he did close it. If the Minister wants to recapture the bacon and pig trade, it will be necessary for him to induce our people to produce pigs. He is not going to do it when he is charging such fancy prices as £26 a ton for milo which can be bought for much less on the free market. The barley can be bought for less than the £26 he is charging.
Comment on this
It was bought for less this year. Perhaps it was not purchased, but it certainly was offered for £22 a ton. All this adds up to one thing. We want to register our disapproval of the manner in which agriculture is being conducted. Everybody knows the losses the farmers of this country sustained during the past year and a half. Exports of pigs, of pork, of sausages, of bacon hams and tinned ham have been reduced to the tune of £3,000,000. In the export of cattle, the farmer in this country has lost £5,250,000. Almost £2,000,000 has been lost in the export of chocolate crumb, which, added together, makes a loss of £10,500,000. We have paid over £13,000,000, nearly £14,000,000, for imports of wheat, barley, maize and other feeding stuffs.
The Minister stated recently that our adverse trade balance must be attacked on two fronts, on the imports front and on the exports front. This does not give us any indication that the Minister is going to make a fight on the imports front when we see £14,000,000 down for commodities that could be produced at home. This has been a settled policy which is characteristic of the Minister and the Coalition Government. It is policy which will drive up our adverse trade balance. It is not so long since the Minister was talking about buying in the cheapest market. Now he has changed his mind. You can buy wheat and barley at the ends of the earth cheaper than you could produce them at home, but of what use is that, when you are exporting your own people, because you have nothing for them to do at home?
You can have mass emigration and buy cheaply at the ends of the earth. But is that good national policy? That is the policy being followed by the Coalition Government and that is the policy the Minister's attitude in this matter will lead to. We are expecting the foreigner to produce commodities we can produce here at home. Live stock are our principal export and no explanation is given as to why that export dropped by 95,000 cattle in 12 months. No explanation has been given as to why our chilled and frozen meat trade went. Our policy for 1951 to 1954 meant a higher income for farmers. Any item you may mention realised more money; costs of production were lower than they are to-day; and the volume of output went up. That policy, if followed, would have given us increased agricultural production. There was an incentive and an inducement offered to the farmers at the time, and they responded to it.
We were reaping the reward in 1954 until the policy was changed so radically in that year when the price of wheat was slashed. That was the first thing that was done to stop our people from giving us that production they had been giving in 1953 and 1954. The price of feeding barley was reduced. These were two items that the tillage farmer was relying on the Government to subsidise. They were both subsidised crops. Then, for one reason or another, the Minister failed to protect chocolate crumb and went to the other extreme of subsidising butter for export. He paid an export subsidy on butter. If he had put that subsidy into the chocolate crumb industry— there was a free market at the time value for about £158 a ton—we could have gone into the free market with very small subsidisation and the value to the country would be very substantial. I am talking now of the production of chocolate crumb in preference to butter. It takes 700 gallons of 3.5 butter fat milk to give one ton of chocolate crumb and the value of 700 gallons of that milk converted into butter is £52 10s. 3d. at present prices. Its price, converted into chocolate crumb, is £63 8s. 9d.
Comment on this
You bring it down to 3.20, with the addition of skimmed milk to it: that is chocolate crumb. Therefore, in actual fact, it is not a 3.5 milk you are selling. You are saving money on that. It is not as valuable as 3.5. Only 3.2 is going to the chocolate crumb factory. It is adulterated with skimmed milk in order to bring down the butter fat. But it is making £9 per 700 gallons more than butter. As I say, there was a market for it at £158 a ton.
Comment on this
I am, in this way. The farmer's price at the creamery is based on 3.5 butter fat. In the chocolate crumb factory, it is based on 3.2. The comparison is in the price.
Comment on this
If a farmer were sending his milk to a creamery at 3.2, he would not be getting 1/6 a gallon for it. He is getting that now for his 3.5. Therefore, the value of the whole milk at 3.5 is practically equivalent to the price he would pay for the skimmed milk. There is very little in it. The only difference was £4 19s., which prevented the chocolate crumb manufacturers from going into the free market. Only a very small subsidy would be required to make up that amount and give them the right to enter into it. There was an open field there. The Dutch have gone into it now. We could have gone into it.
Comment on this
Why did you not use that £9 you were talking about? You said there was a difference of £9. Why was that not used in respect of chocolate crumb?
Comment on this
There is such a thing as transport. You have to make provision for transportation to the British market. The difference was £4 19s. when all these items were taken into consideration. The subsidisation of chocolate crumb at the time would have been of greater benefit to the milk producer and the country generally. That market was wide open. We are talking now of getting rid of our surplus milk. You cannot do it in the form of butter unless you subsidise it very highly. We are not able to compete with New Zealand in the British market because their price is so much lower than ours. They are selling at 375 whereas we are selling at 448.
Comment on this
The difference of price prohibits us from going into the British market. That was neglected; I do not know why. In 1953 it was value for over £9,000,000. Now it has been reduced to something like £5,000,000. Possibly, as time goes on—when conditions improve for Fry-Cadbury beyond and if they erect new factories, as they may, and as they have threatened to do—we shall produce no chocolate crumb except in Carrick-on-Suir. It will be the only one left. That business has gone from us because we neglected to look after it ourselves. The same thing applied regarding the export of our bacon, so far as the price of our feeding stuffs is concerned. That is something that could be remedied. We made provision to remedy it but that was changed also. The present Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, and the present Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, seem to have some bee in their bonnet as to how this money was to be found and disposed off. They even threatened to produce files. I should like to see the files. There was a certain sum of money in that fund when I was leaving office which would have enabled the price of coarse grains to be kept firm. There was a sum of £117,365. That has disappeared. The Minister for Finance says it was used to meet the flour subsidy. That was not right. It was to meet the subsidy so far as home produced pollard was concerned, which was a very small quantity at the time because it was late in the year. Only six weeks or, at the outside, two months remained.
The Minister has mentioned that he does not think there will be any improvement in the wheat acreage this year. What is the general policy of the Government regarding wheat? Are they going to continue a guaranteed price for wheat or are they not? During the 1954 elections, the Taoiseach said they were guaranteeing the price of wheat for five years. At that time the price was £4 2s. 6d.
A few months afterwards the price was slashed and the period of five years seems to have been forgotten. It is now a two-year term. That five year plan has gone. What is the future of wheat-growing in this country? Is it the intention of the Coalition to import wheat? Conferences are being held in London at present. This House has no information regarding the quantity of wheat the Coalition expect to get out of the pool. The Minister has not told us what the Government intend to do regarding that.
The arrangement, as you know, in the past was to get 275,000 tons provided it was at a certain price. The price will be lower now. I heard this morning that the American farmer is being guaranteed two dollars and it will probably be lower in price than it was in the past. Does that mean our Government will buy in the cheapest market and that there will be no wheat grown by our people? Our farmers would like to know what the future holds regarding wheat production.
Let us consider the other cereal crops, barley and oats. In relation to malting barley there is a very definite arrangement. Guinness speak largely for the brewers and distillers and their price generally fixes the price; they are restricted to purchasing about 750,000 barrels and the total quantity of malting barley required is less than 1,000,000 barrels, so that that can be grown in a very limited acreage. Malting barley is not even as important as oats because of the low acreage, 120,000. Feeding barley now being produced will in time take the place of wheat and of oats, but we do not want that to happen. Instead of having 1,700,000 under the plough, 3,000,000, acres should be our target. It represents only 25 per cent. of our arable acreage, I suppose the lowest in Europe. Is it any wonder that it has been said by visitors to the country that we are the most expensive feeders in the world, that farmers here feed their cattle on beef steak?
We can do with 3,000,000 acres and produce more, but again we want to know what the policy is; the farmers of the country want to know what the policy is both in regard to wheat and barley. Are we to have this new maize policy that the Minister mentioned this evening? Is he going to introduce a prohibition on maize imports and concentrate on barley? We would like if the Minister would state for the people if it is now our intention here to prohibit the importation of maize and produce our own barley instead.
Comment on this
He qualified it, if the Deputy remembers. When the Deputy reads the report he will find that, but we would like to have it made more clear with the qualification removed. The other matter which is agitating the minds of a great number of our people is the future of the dairying industry. The Minister made a promise some time ago; of course we have arrived at the stage when nobody accepts the Minister's promises as being very reliable. They have changed so often that they have now become unreliable. The Minister promised some time ago that we would have the milk costings report before the end of March. We have not seen it yet.
Comment on this
The Minister has not received it; otherwise we would have it. That has been the stock answer for two years, that the Minister has not received the report and consequently is unable to produce it.
Comment on this
The Minister has one responsibility in this and that is to provide the staff. If he provides the staff, he will get the report. If more staff were put on it he would have it in a week. There is no use coming in here and telling the House that he is not responsible and that he is unable to get the report. It is only a matter of putting staff on the job and then he would have it in a week.
Comment on this
Might I assure the Deputy that the commission has been invited to take over any staff it wants and I now invite them in public to bespeak any staff they want and it will be provided? That invitation has been tendered to them for the past six months.
Comment on this
I understand that only trained staff are of value at this stage of the inquiry and that they are working as fast as they can.
Comment on this
I am only telling the Deputy what was told to me, that only trained staff is of value now. But lest there be any ambiguity I now in public declare that the commission can bespeak any staff they want to expedite the preparation of the report and they will have it.
Comment on this
Fair enough, but the people are clamouring for the report. If I were in the Minister's position, I would put in all the staff of Merrion Street that was required to produce this report and stop this clamouring and agitation.
Comment on this
There is no delay so far as the supply of staff is concerned. The Deputy will agree with me that I cannot with propriety interfere with the discretion of the technical director appointed by him.
Comment on this
If I were in charge of the commission now I would have the report long ago. That is the only answer I can give the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister went further than that. He stated outside this House, I think, that he has already seen figures that would indicate a substantial reduction in the price of milk in the Dublin area. I think he was reported as saying that he had come across figures or was told unofficially that such was the case.
Comment on this
It was a most opportune time to make the statement because it was coming into March. It might have had a preventive effect but it did not succeed.
There was one matter to which I want to refer in connection with ground limestone, about which we have been hearing so much recently. I was glad to see that the Minister hopes to go to the million mark this year. There has been an expansion every year over the past few years since people began to see the benefits that accrued from using ground limestone, but we are depending on C.I.E. to a very great extent for the distribution of ground limestone. That is most unfortunate because C.I.E. for some reason or other seem to be very unconcerned whether ground limestone is being used in the greatest possible quantities or not. I have here a letter addressed to a quarry owner who had a truck working and he had applied for a second truck but it was refused. It is stated in this letter:—
"It is an essential requirement that each load is signed for on delivery and it would seem you deliver loads at times when farmers cannot be expected to be available. At this time of the year it is dark at 7 p.m. and no delivery should be made after this——"
Comment on this
I am very glad it has been. There was a man prepared to work three shifts, but C.I.E. came along and told him he could not work three shifts. I am glad the Minister has fixed that matter up.
The Minister has talked about farm buildings and the grants that were being made available for the erection of cow-byres in areas where the scheme for the eradication of T.B. is in progress. There has been no increase in the amount granted for reconstruction work or for the erection of cow houses since 1953. The same grants, the same amounts of money, still apply and there has been no change. Does not the Minister think it is time, in view of increased prices, cost of labour and cost of materials, to try to increase that grant? The same situation arose in 1953. We examined it. We increased the grants from 25 per cent. to 100 per cent. in some cases. That is one matter, an increase in the amount of grants being made available. The other is that I am informed—I do not know whether it is correct or not— that in the case of a farmer getting a grant for the erection, say, of a cattleshed or house and who got a grant in 1954 or 1955, no matter what size house was erected, whether it was 120 or 240 square feet, if he applies for a grant for a similar house now he will be refused because he has already availed of that grant.
Comment on this
It does not matter, so long as he has availed of the grant at all. If he has already got a grant he will not get a second.
Comment on this
Yes. Many farmers might not be in a position financially to go ahead with the building completely. For instance, they might like to erect a house of say 480 square feet, but find that their finances would not enable them to do so and build only 240 square feet in 1955 in the hope that they would get a further grant in 1957 to complete the work.
Comment on this
It would be a continuation of the original house, or it would be based on the area of 120 square feet on a graded basis. I think the Minister is wrong in not making these grants available.
Comment on this
I think the position is, you can build only one building and get one grant, but suppose you build for less that the maximum number of cows——
Comment on this
——you could then finish it and you would get a second grant to finish the cow-house. Suppose you build this year for only ten cows and your circumstances improve in three or four years, you can get a further grant to extend the cow-house to accommodate up to 15 cows, which is the maximum.
Comment on this
I am not speaking of cow-houses but of other houses, houses for machines, cattle-sheds or granaries.
Comment on this
The Minister can then see the reason behind my case. The farmer may not be in a position to go ahead and complete the work in one year. I think he should go into this matter and see if something could be done.
Comment on this
Not wishing to give the Deputy the slightest offence—did he look into that matter when he was Minister and what was his judgment?
Comment on this
I shall look into it, so. It is a question that has occurred to me and I think it applied to cow-houses. We decided that if a fellow could not afford to build a cow-house for 15 cows, he could build for six to ten that year, and then get another grant to finish it. Otherwise we felt that it should be a case of one building, one grant.
Comment on this
Thank you. I was glad to hear the Minister talking about the development of the certified seed wheat scheme and I hope the other schemes for barley, oats and grass and all the rest, will go ahead as well. I was just wondering, when I heard the Minister state that our export trade devolved on our live stock, what is to prevent us developing an overseas trade in seeds?
Comment on this
Why not expand that and develop it? We could send out a few hundred thousand tons of wheat to where the Swedes are sending it just as well as the Swedes. Is it not a matter that should concern the Minister and his Department—to see if there is any opportunity there? If there is he will find the farmers here prepared to grow that wheat and develop an export trade. The same thing applies to barley and oats.
The Minister spoke of the warble fly at length here this evening. I believe the warble fly is doing tremendous damage to our live stock, causing loss of meat, loss of milk and loss of hides. I think this is really a matter where our young farmers, Macra na Feirme, the National Farmers' Association and Muintir na Tíre should co-operate and get out and do this work. Throughout the country now, we have cattle markets being erected run by the National Farmers' Association and young farmers' clubs, and I think one of the stipulations laid down by the directors of these cattle markets should be that no cattle suffering from warble infestation should be permitted to go into these sale yards.
It would be one of the penalties imposed on people who have warble-infected cattle. That is the only way in which it can be eradicated. It will not be done by kid-glove methods. It must be got rid of and there must be some penalty attaching to it. The matter is too serious not to be taken seriously. It represents a loss of about £8,000,000 or £10,000,000 to the country every year. There is no great hardship attached to it. I suppose farmers are unconcerned about it and are not paying the attention that they should to its eradication. If there were something to indicate the seriousness of warble, such as the penalty I have suggested, we might be able to get something done in connection with it. I do not mean that any other penalties should be imposed, but the one I have suggested would, in my opinion, have the desired effect. It is only by securing the co-operation and help of the organisations throughout the country that success can be achieved. There are very few houses now in rural Ireland that have not in them a member or two members of these organisations or associations and these organisations should be able to give a helping hand.
I understand there was a report made recently by Dr. Hammond. Is there any hope of that report being circulated?
Comment on this
Thank you. Another matter about which I have been told is the grading of pigs. Does this mean that the liveweight basis for purchase will be discontinued throughout the country? I have been told, again, that, in parts of the Midlands, buyers are going around offering a flat rate of 230/- a cwt., without any grading. In my opinion, that will kill the scheme that has been introduced by the Minister of a guaranteed price of 235/-. If buyers pay 230/- for ungraded pigs, the position will not be improved.
Comment on this
And farmers will be inclined to sell on a liveweight basis at 230/-, if there is any danger of the pigs being graded C.
Comment on this
On reflection, I think the Deputy will agree that we both are anxious to increase the percentage of Grade A pigs.
Comment on this
There used to be a great trade in Birmingham for what is called the Birmingham cutter.
Comment on this
If we are going to sell them to Birmingham, the less talk we have about them being Grade C, the better. Is that not right? We will call them Birmingham cutters.
Comment on this
I was glad when the Minister mentioned the type of pig he will have in the progeny testing stations. I think last year, on the debate on the Estimate for Agriculture, I made the suggestion to the Minister that he should get his men into the factories and select the pigs of top grade, have them tested and have the sows and boars followed up. That is the only way in which the best bacon pig can be found, and not, in my opinion, through the pedigree pig breeders. Most of the pigs produced by the pedigree pig breeders that I have seen are good pigs for show purposes, but a lot of them are damn bad when they get on the table.
Comment on this
The good pigs that are going to the factories should be followed up. We should concentrate on them and find out the area from which they came. In that way, progress will be made.
It was for the purpose of registering our disapproval of the manner in which agriculture is being conducted at the present time that we put down the motion to refer back the Estimate. Unless we get a guarantee that there will be a change of policy on the part of the Government, we will oppose it to the end.
Comment on this
I fail to understand why certain members, even of the Minister's Party, or of the combination opposite, have not come in here to take up the running now. It would be their duty to do so and to express their opinions or suggestions regarding the agricultural policy of the Government.
I am sorry that the Minister started on the note on which he did. This is an Estimate that should be dealt with in a very serious, very cool and common sense manner, because of its vital effect on our people, not merely the agricultural section, but all sections of the community.
My opinion on this question of the Irish Press depressing cattle prices is this: it was the fat cattle which were first hit. People who have any knowledge of the live-stock trade know that those people who put in their stock to fatten bank on selling them at a certain time and understand the limitation of the food they require to feed them. If it so happens that the price drops at the particular time when the reserve is running out, they have very little option, and it would be very difficult for them to take the Minister's advice, to hold them over to the end of April. In fact, it is quite impossible for them to do so.
Comment on this
There are good farmers in Kildare, Meath, Laois and Louth and they sold their cattle because they did not have the grass. The weather was pretty severe in February and during the period in question, particularly in the east of the country. It was much more severe in the east than in the west at that time. I do not see how anybody who was running out of the food reserve could turn the cattle out in that type of weather. They certainly did not have the grass for them.
Cattle prices are something about which it is very difficult to give an accurate forecast and I think it is very foolish for a Minister in any Government to claim credit for high prices for cattle and to try to disclaim responsibility when there is a reduction because, in the main, cattle and live-stock prices are something over which no Minister for Agriculture in any Government in this country has any real control.
It is just a question of supply and demand to the British market; it is the old story over again of our total dependence on our exports of live stock to the British market. If the British people could find better beef, better mutton or better meat of any kind at one-eighth of a penny a pound cheaper in the farthest part of the earth, even in Communist China, they would throw us to the winds to-morrow morning and purchase it there. I am glad to see that the Minister is slowly but very surely being converted to the Fianna Fáil policy as regards agriculture.
That is the policy, in so far as it is humanly possible, of self-sufficiency. He was not helpful to that policy in the past, but conversion, even at the eleventh hour, is, I suppose, better than no conversion at all. I think it is a very good thing for him now to encourage the production in this country of all the feeding requirements of both the people and their live stock. He has told us about what is being done in his Department in order to produce good wheat and good seed wheat. I think that is a step in the right direction, but there is one thing for which I cannot forgive the Minister. It is not so much the reduction in the price of wheat, which was a very great blow at a time when there should not have been anything like such a drastic reduction in price after the very severe harvest. What I cannot forgive the Minister for is the raising of the bushelling from 60 lb. to 63 lb.
I think that was undoubtedly a mistake because I believe the percentage of wheat bushelling 63 lb. in this country, save in an abnormally summer-like and harvest-like last year, is very small indeed. I believe that wheat bushelling 60 lb. is very good wheat. A better policy would be to adopt a sliding scale upward and downwards—to increase the price by so much for wheat bushelling over 60 lb. and reduce it for wheat bushelling below 60 lb. If the Minister had left it at that he would find that the acreage of wheat would be quite high though not nearly as great as when the price was £4 2s. 6d.
It is almost too late now but, if the Minister had made an announcement a month ago that he was reverting to the 60 lb. bushelling, I think we would have a far greater acreage of wheat this year than last. The imports of maize, milo and other such things had a very adverse effect on the price of oats during the last harvest. Oats is a very important crop. It is very fine feeding for cattle or sheep, whether the cattle be cows, dry stock or calves. I have heard it in this House from the Minister himself that oats should be moved off the farm on the hoof. That is all right for people in a position to do that, but there are numerous farmers in the West of Ireland whose land is more suitable for growing oats as the Minister knows than for any other cereal crop. They grow oats as a cash crop to enable them to pay the first moiety of their rates at the end of September or to meet other obligations at that time of the year. They are not in a position to put in sufficient live stock to absorb or use the amount of oats they can grow on their small holdings. That is why I say there should be restrictions placed on the importation of maize and other feeding stuffs, because in that way the farmer in Leinster or in Munster and, to some extent, in eastern Connacht, would give a reasonable price to the smaller farmers for oats as a feeding stuff. Surely, 28/- per barrel for good oats or from 30/- to 32/- per barrel was a very poor price, and was no inducement to farmers to go in for increased acreage this year.
That was a price which was very uneconomical and I do not think anybody could produce oats at any profit whatsoever at a price of that kind. It must have been cheaper than any imported feeding stuff. The farmers were not very well organised, they were not very well able to advertise the commodity, just throwing it to a merchant who is now charging from 52/- to 55/- per barrel for oats for which he paid only from 30/- to 32/-. The merchant certainly has more profit and less labour out of it than had the farmer who produced it.
The Minister has given advice to the House which, in my opinion, is very good advice. He has advised farmers to keep more cows and, if they are not in a position to milk them and to sell the milk to the creamery or in a town, to rear calves on it. That is all right for people in a position to avail of that advice, but there is a goodly section of our farmers who are not in a position to do that. There is the old saying of cutting the gad next to the throat if you are being strangled by the tie and the farmers have to sell off perhaps very good heifers at a time when they could be mated to a bull or sent to an insemination station. Consequently, many farmers are not in a position to put the Minister's advice into operation unless there is something done to help them.
Perhaps the Minister will say that they could get a loan from the Agricultural Credit Corporation. They certainly can, but the rate of interest is very high and the increase in the rate of interest which has been permitted by the present Government, even though they said they would keep it back a year ago, has made it very difficult for farmers to adopt the advice of the Minister. To do something in that line to encourage farmers to increase their breeding of calves, from heifers and cows, I think there should be something by way of loan made available, in respect of which neither principal nor interest would be collected for at least 18 months. I think that would be a very great incentive.
I do not suggest that money should be handed out to every farmer. I believe the Minister, with his parish agents, his county agricultural instructors and his many types of inspector, would be able to set up an organisation to ensure that any money given out in that way would be given to people who would make use of it in the proper way. I know very well that it might be abused and that is the big danger in doing anything like that. On the other hand, I believe that there could be safeguards and that the responsible officers of the Minister's Department would only recommend people who would avail of the scheme for the purpose for which it is intended. There are other things to be taken into account as well. The people who would avail of that scheme would require a certain amount of housing accommodation in the winter period when the calves would be young. When the weather became severe, these farmers would need shelter for their calves.
Comment on this
If we all go into the one thing and all sell at the one time, the price would be very depressed. That has been the position with everything over very many years. That is the reason why our farmers are inclined to close their ears to the appeals made by the Minister and various other Ministers to increase production. Even within the last few days, we have had the example of the wheat conference at which the importing countries state that the exporting countries have such a great surplus that there should be a reduction in the price. Other people are fighting on the other side and it is a question of whether they are going to give it to them at the reduced price, or destroy the surplus, as they did once before and then demand their full pound of flesh for the requirements of the importing countries.
The same is true as regards any other line of production. This is a matter that should be very thoughtfully examined and its implication should be explained very fully to the people. It should be explained to them how great the national importance of increased production is. It is not an easy thing, in view of tradition if you like, and in view of their experience in the past. They ask why they should produce a lot more in order to give cheap food to other sections of the community who are not increasing their return in any way. Certain sections of the community, as the Minister knows, have got increases time and time again. I am not saying that they were not entitled to those increases, but they are not working a minute longer and one bit harder, while the farmers are expected to work harder and to work longer hours in order to get this increased production. That is the kernel of the whole difficulty—the question of increased production, versus a kind of half production and the question of asking the farmer to take the same price for double or treble his production. There will have to be some adjustment and some great inducement given to the people before they will respond as we would like to see them responding.
The Minister has referred to ground limestone. Ground limestone is very cheap—there is no doubt about that. Nobody can find fault with the price they have to pay for the limestone delivered to them. I am glad to say that the people generally in my part of the country are availing of the scheme and using ground limestone in increased quantities. The same is true of fertilisers. I think the people are becoming more fertiliser-minded every day and that is a good thing.
The land reclamation scheme has done very fine work in a great many instances, but in a number of cases I believe that the money is being wasted on the type of land on which all this elaborate reclamation work is being carried out and which will not give a proper return for the next 60 years. I believe the Minister and the experts in his Department should examine carefully the question of mole drainage. What a good deal of the land in this country is suffering from is surface water. If that could be got away and the pan broken by way of subsoiling and if we had mole drainage, I believe that a very great improvement could be made in the land at far less cost than all this elaborate drainage, with the use of piping and the rest of it.
Comment on this
I am, but I think it should be more general and that there should be a survey of every county to see which districts would be suitable for mole drainage and which districts would be suitable for reclamation.
The Minister has been talking about the warble fly. I know that is a great loss to us and a great national loss, but the farmers do not see that. It is very difficult for them to see it. We hear a lot here about the necessity of improving the quality of our wool. There was an Act passed here about 1946 or 1947 about the marketing of tarred wool, but the strange point about that is that the farmer who has complied with that Act and responded to the appeals made by the Minister and his Department as regards keeping the wool clean will not get a penny more for it than those who bring in their wool with the tar daggings on it. If we are going to put our wool in its proper place on the world market, it would be a reasonable step for the Department to require that all wool should be purchased by grade, because it is no incentive to one farmer, or to 20 farmers, in a district to do what he, or they, have been asked to do, when another farmer gets away with it, the merchant accepting the wool with the dirt and the daggings on it and giving the same price for it. Actually, the price works out to that farmer's advantage because there is more weight in the fleece.