We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 132–284 of 284. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

John O'Donovan Parliamentary Secretary to the Government (Mr. O'Donovan) Fine Gael

Did he want to sell Panaslipper?

Comment on this

Is not the whole point behind my raising of this matter that God alone knows who wants to sell Panaslipper or how the National Stud is being administered? This is what Mr. Reynolds had to say when approached by the Press:—

"A director of a company, and particularly of a Government company, cannot disclose confidential information and consequently I cannot make a statement except to say that I resigned from the board this morning. I think in fairness to the board that the Ministers concerned should permit the directors to publish all the facts concerning the purchase and sale of Panaslipper."

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

I am quoting from Pravda. I am quoting from the Irish Press of April the 11th, 1956. A similar statement appears in the Irish Times of the same date. The Ministers for Finance and Agriculture stepped in. Why did they not step in when the Minister for Finance took up 45,000 shares as we learn now? Why did he not step in then and say: “All right. This horse Panaslipper was bought for stud purposes and not for racing.” No. We had Mr. Joe McGrath giving Panaslipper to the National Stud for £45,000 when he could have sold the horse for £75,000. What did they do with it? They started to race a horse that was bought for stud purposes with the disastrous results we know.

It is about time the National Studwoke up to the fact that they are there for the purpose this House decided under the Act of 1945 or else they might as well disestablish themselves and open up as "tanglers" or horse-dealers. Certainly their only purpose is to obtain the best stallions for the benefit of the breeders of this country. I would even go so far as to say that they had no business acquiring mares for breeding themselves. We had a result of that. We had two horses running in the name of His Excellency the President of Ireland also with disastrous results. Be it to their credit, the balance sheet looks well down through the years.

Comment on this

They did very well.

Comment on this

Consistently, down through the years.

Comment on this

I find it hard to follow the Deputy. Is he for or against the board?

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary were here when I commenced my remarks——

Comment on this

I have been listening to them all the time.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary is not in the dark, but I and the majority of the people in the country are in the dark. All we need is a little elucidation from the Minister and I object strongly to his failure to make any reference whatsoever to this matter in his opening remarks.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Deputy is condemning the board or not.

Comment on this

If I could get sufficient facts and if I could find out who was responsible for certain activities — the Minister for Agriculture or the National Stud — I might be in a better position to deal with it. If it were the National Stud directors I would not be long removing them and certainly, since the Minister has powers under the 1945 Act, he is open to criticism. Deputy Flanagan, the Parliamentary Secretary, will appreciate my point, that I am looking for information. Take, for example, some of the appalling decisions of the directors. Take Whitehall for instance. They bought Whitehall for £6,890. Would the Parliamentary Secretary be interested to know what the National Stud leased Whitehall for in 1953 and 1954? He was leased to a gentleman in County Kildare, whose name I can give if necessary, for £140 a year in 1953 and 1954.

Comment on this

It could have been a good price.

Comment on this

And yet in the same year, 1953, he actually took in £1,039 in stud fees. After that they leased him for £140 a year. There was no question of infertility there. I am giving these examples to show that something is wrong. It was said that Fianna Fáil appointed four or five of these directors. Possibly that is correct. I am not interested in who appointed them but if I were the Minister for Agriculture I would put out the lot of them very quickly if they were responsible for the appalling conduct of the affairs of the National Stud at the present time. I hope that in his reply the Minister will give us some information on this matter.

I do not want to go through the whole question about Tulyar again but some interesting statements were made when I asked the question on the subject on the 9th November, 1955, and when I raised the question on the adjournment that night. This is what the Minister for Finance, acting on behalf of the Minister for Agriculture, said:—

"The National Stud was set up by Act of this House and, by Act of this House, the choice was made as to the manner in which the stud would be run. The House then determined that it would be run, not by a Government Department, but by a company set up under the Companies Acts, with all the legal implications that involves, as regards the board of directors."

That is reported at column 675 of Volume 153 of the Official Report. Dealing with the sale of Tulyar the Minister said, as reported in the same volume:—

"The decision to sell Tulyar was taken by the unanimous resolution of the board of the National Stud."

That is what the Minister thinks. Section 25 of the National Stud Act of 1945, sub-section (5), states:—

"The company shall furnish to the Minister for Agriculture such information in relation to the policy, activities and decisions of the company as the said Minister may from time to time require."

I cannot see how a Minister is to be informed if he does not inform the secretary of the board of directors that any major change in policy should be notified to him. I am quoting from the Minister for Finance when he said:—

"The Minister for Agriculture informed the board that the question of the sale was a matter within their discretion."

That is the sale of Tulyar for £240,000. It was not a matter for their discretion when they decided to sell Panaslipper to Mr. McCarthy for £75,000. There was a complete changeover then. Is it true that there was consternation when it was learned that Panaslipper was to be sold? Is it true that the Minister for Agriculture was on the 'phone to the National Stud before they formally decided, on the 6th March, to sell Panaslipper to Mr. McCarthy, and that the Minister intimated to the directors that he would have no objection?

Comment on this

You will get it all in the Irish Press,

Comment on this

Is it also true that the Minister for Finance, at his behest, had a Cabinet meeting called and that their decision was not to sell Panaslipper?

Comment on this

You have it all before you.

Comment on this

I have a good lot of it anyway.

Comment on this

Is there not a substantial difference between the two transactions?

Comment on this

There was a difference between the two. The Minister for Finance informed the board that the sale of Tulyar was a matter for their discretion but the minute they sold Panaslipper there was a big change.

Comment on this

How long was Panaslipper at stud here?

Comment on this

Three years.

Comment on this

That was not too bad.

Comment on this

It was not and it was a hell of a pity that you did not keep him at stud. In that three years, £39,000 was earned in stud fees alone.

Comment on this

Would it pay for the interest on the money?

Comment on this

Not at your present rate of interest for housing.

Comment on this

That was the time Deputy MacEntee made the rate 5+per cent.

Comment on this

The progeny of Tulyar was worth 5+per cent. in those three years. On an investment of £250,000, we made £500,000 and even the Parliamentary Secretary, the financial genius of the Coalition Government, will agree that 200 per cent. profit after three years, and still to have the goose that laid the golden egg in our possession, is very good business. In eight months, this country got £700,000 and by the end of the year over £1,000,000 and of that some £600,000 came in in dollars. Ninety-eight of the progeny of Tulyar were born.

The Minister for Finance went on to say:—

"The Government agreed, and I agree, with the Minister for Agriculture that in any question where the stud is concerned it has got to be run directly by the directors of the stud. The only alternative you have is to keep them in office or to get rid of them."

What is the Parliamentary Secretary going to do? Is he going to keep this body in office or are they capable? The Minister went on:—

"You cannot blow hot and cold at the same time. You cannot leave the directors in control of the company and at the same time say that you will not permit them to carry on their job."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy give the number of the Volume?

Comment on this

It is Volume 153, No. 4. Now we see the switch-over. Everything was left to the directors where Tulyar was concerned but not when Panaslipper was being sold. Panaslipper was bought for £45,000 and was being sold for £70,000. That £45,000 invested by the Minister for Finance brought in no return in all the months that they ran Panaslipper. They ran him in England three times and also in America and he did not win a race. There was no interference then by the Minister. The official statement issued was:—

"In June, 1955, the directors of the Irish National Stud Company, Limited, intimated to the Minister for Agriculture that they desired to purchase Panaslipper for stud purposes. Following their request, the Minister for Finance took up and paid for a further 45,000 £1 shares of the company to enable the company to complete his purchase for this purpose. On March 5th, 1956, the board of the stud company determined to sell the horse. No member of the Government was then informed of this decision."

There is the crib. They are cribbing now but there was no crib when Tulyar was sold. The official statement issued by the Government Information Bureau goes on to say:—

"On March 15th, 1956, the Minister for Agriculture learned for the first time, through the Press, of the intention to sell the horse."

Comment on this

It was not in the Irish Press they learned of it.

Comment on this

He must have been the only individual in this country to have to wait until the 15th March to hear of the intention to sell the horse when every man, woman and child knew of the deal which Mr. McCarthy contemplated. It was about time that they woke up to the fact after it was known all over the world. Of course, that is the value of indecision. The Government takes about 12 months to make up its mind on any point.

Comment on this

There are times when that is not a bad fault.

Comment on this

The statement goes on to say that the Government felt that the proposed sale of the horse was a major change of policy in which they should have been consulted and that they did not desire to sell the horse. The Minister goes on to pay great tribute to the attitude of Mr. McCarthy, the American. I have no doubt that he is very deserving of that praise. The Minister stated that he had a legal lien on the horse and that if he had wished to do so he could enforce that agreement. I would like to give another quotation. It is interesting, in passing, to reflect for a moment on what Deputy Blowick, now Minister for Lands, had to say when Tulyar was being debated:—

"It is no trouble, apparently, to the present Government to come in here—"

that was the last Government

"— and demand £250,000 for the purchase of this horse, but why is the Government taking such a long time to tell the milk producers the price they are going to pay them? Are they taking any steps to spend £250,000 to promote the production of beef or milk?"

That was Deputy Blowick, now Minister for Lands. The present Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, then attacked Deputy Walsh, Minister for Agriculture at that time. He had this to say:—

"It is no good for the Minister to shelter behind others and say this is not his decision, that it is a matter for the directors. This is the people's property and, no matter by whom the decision is taken, the people have a right to be told what the position is and be able to judge on the true facts when they are properly presented."

Then we had Deputy Crowe. Listen to his little intervention:—

"Apparently it is very hard on the Minister for Agriculture to grant an increase of 3d. or 4d. to the sorely-tried dairy farmers who are the heart and soul and the life-blood of the nation at a time when the cost of production has gone up immensely, and it has gone up immensely within the past two years. I consider it is very unwise of the Minister to pay out £250,000, as well as the cost of insurance, etc., at a time when we are told by the Minister for Finance that we are on the verge of bankruptcy."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy got that off at speed. The Minister is not responsible for what every Deputy sitting behind him says.

Comment on this

I was only showing the attitude of certain people.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is responsible for policy and administration, but he is not responsible for what other Deputies say.

Comment on this

But the Deputy is responsible for the Minister.

Comment on this

Now the Minister for Finance, Deputy Sweetman, through the Government Information Bureau, praised the attitude of Mr. McCarthy in agreeing not to exercise and enforce his lien on Panaslipper. In my opinion, that put the nation in a very embarrassing position, to say the least of it. It is embarrassing to think that we should have to kow-tow to Mr. McCarthy, or any American, or indeed any other individual for that matter, and say: "We are sorry. The National Stud definitely did agree to sell, but we would ask you not to go through with it." Here is what Deputy Sweetman had to say, when he was just Deputy Sweetman on 26th February, 1953, in relation to Tulyar:—

"It has been suggested, however, by people who know far more about this than I do, that no sire will ever be successful in the American climate in the same way as it would be successful in this climate. So far as I am concerned, I feel that I must rely for judgment in this matter on the people who I believe are experts at their job. They wee undoubtedly the authorised agents of the Irish people and as such were entitled to make the contract they did make. We cannot turn around now, as they were authorised in that respect, and tell them that on behalf of the Irish people we propose to welsh on a contract duly and validly made."

A contract duly and validly made!

"For that reason, if for no other, I personally feel constrained to support the proposal."

What a change there has been since. We do not hear any screaming from the Labour Party now of the failure to obtain £70,000 from the sale of a horse. We do not hear any criticism from the Minister for Health, Deputy O'Higgins, about the National Stud and the fantastic sums of money which passed through the hands of its directors from year to year. Indeed, this matter of the National Stud could be discussed interminably, but I do not propose to prolong the debate any further.

I appeal to the Minister again to let the House and the people have a clear-cut statement on the whole position. We had, as everyone knows, until public opinion and the smaller breeder forced a change of policy, the National Stud making a complete farce out of this syndication of Tulyar. We all know who got the nominations. We all know that in the first year there were very few nominations given to the people Tulyar was intended to benefit, namely, the small breeder. It is noteworthy that one or two gentlemen appeared out of the hat and perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government will explain to us the extraordinary coincidence of one individual coming out of the hat three times.

Comment on this

I was not there.

Comment on this

Two or three gentlemen were lucky enough to obtain a nomination at £600, which was a giveaway really as far as Tulyar was concerned.

Comment on this

The position is still not clear. Is the Deputy for the directors or against them?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary can very easily make up my mind. The Minister could have made up my mind if he had, either in his introductory statement or in his explanatory memorandum, referred to one of the most important sections of agriculture here, namely, the blood-stock industry. I only hope that when the Minister comes to conclude the debate he will give a clear-cut statement to the House as to his intentions. Were the directors of the National Stud incompetent and will the Minister, remove them for their incompetence? If they were not incompetent, did the Minister and his colleague, the Minister for Finance, exceed their powers by giving certain directions to the directors?

As I have already said, we had a resignation from the directorate of the National Stud, Mr. Reynolds. I say it is a pity he did not go long ago. It is a pity he did not go when Tulyar was sold. It is a bit late in the day for him to be expressing his disapproval, but I suppose better late than never. Now he has restrained himself from making any statement on the matter. He has put the onus on the Ministers involved and he has suggested that they should explain.

The onus is now on the Minister for Agriculture to let us know in his reply — those of us who represent the small breeders and the large breeders — whither goest the National Stud? In what direction is it proceeding? What policy is fixed? If there is no policy, could there be a reshuffle now and could we put it back again on a proper footing, back to the position it was in when it commenced in such a worthy manner? In the interim it has seemed to deviate and unfortunately it was encouraged in that deviation with the consent of the present Government in allowing the greatest sire in the country to be disposed of. We have not yet heard from the Minister if that money has been paid. The condition of the sale of Tulyar was that the money would be deposited and after 30th June Tulyar would depart for the United States. We have not heard anything about the money, even though we may hope. In the case of Panaslipper the Minister went to Mr. McCarthy and said: "Look here, we know you bought the horse but we want him here." I suppose he would not consider going to Mr. George Hancock and saying: "Look here, we want Tulyar; he is the greatest sire in the world." I do not know if the Minister will do that. No one knows. The Parliamentary Secretary has urged me time and again to state whether I am for or against the National Stud. Candidly I cannot form an opinion because I have not sufficient information. Like everybody else, what I am saying is purely surmise on my part.

Comment on this

We found the Minister for Agriculture curiously pessimistic in his statement at the opening of this debate. He started off with the most ridiculous charges against the Irish Press, and on the subsequent day when he continued to speak on his Estimate, he did not seem to show the same breezy optimism which has been characteristic of him. One of the things we noticed is the fact that for years the Minister for Agriculture has been accustomed to take 1947 as the base line for comparing agricultural production, when the country, had been afflicted with the worst weather for 50 years and when the country had been without proper fertilisers or agricultural machinery for seven years as a result of a world war; it has been his practice to compare the rate of production at that time with whatever period he chose to take, either between 1948 and 1951 or subsequent to that period.

We do not know whether it is because the Minister for Industry and Commerce has supplanted the Minister for Agriculture in regard to agricultural statistics; in any event the Minister for Industry and Commerce announced last night that production was unchanged since 1906. The curious thing about his statement is that I believe he has been a little bit too pessimistic. I believe there has been a small increase in output since 1906. Therefore, whether it is that the Labour Party section of the Coalition Government decided to take over the job of announcing main agricultural statistics and to deprive the Minister of the opportunity of comparing production in these two ridiculous sets of years or not we do not know. But we do know that the Minister opened his remarks with his comment on the Irish Press which we regard as absolutely farcical. Whenever I asked any farmers in Longford who read the Irish Press whether they sold their cattle because of the character of the strip heading in that paper, they laughed at me. They thought it was the biggest joke they ever heard.

I do not know whether the Minister for Agriculture likes to insult farmers and to imagine they have complete absence of any common sense or understanding of the market position, or what purpose he thinks he can serve in making remarks of this kind. In any event, I could not find any Fianna Fáil farmers in County Longford who, staggered by the strip heading in the Irish Press, sold cattle they otherwise would have kept. However, I found a good many farmers, with different Party affiliations including that of Fine Gael, who for personal reasons of their own were forced to sell their cattle without having to consider the Irish Press, because they could not afford to keep them, because retention did not fit in with their rotation or for many other reasons of their own. They were annoyed with the Minister for Agriculture — they were not laughing— because he was giving an entirely false reason as to why they were selling their cattle; and they were selling them at a considerable loss to themselves.

The Minister could not necessarily be held responsible for that but that is what I discovered in regard to this whole matter and we think, on this side of the House, that the Minister is simply escaping from his responsibility as he did previously when he compared the present production effort with that of 1947. As we always said in this House, you only have to go two years back to 1945, after five years of war, to find that the production level had shown practically no increase. Of course, if you select figures for two particular years you can prove anything in agriculture. You can boast around the country madly that the number of cattle under one had gone up to 1,000,000. If you look back to the book of statistics you will discover that the number of cattle under one reached 1,000,000 during the term of office of Fianna Fáil and before that. It depends on which two years you take in order to prove a bogus case.

The Minister failed utterly to face the challenges with which he is confronted at the present time. One of the challenges he has to face is his contribution to dealing with the balance of payments difficulty, dealing with the situation whereby our exports went down in 1955, whereby many forms of agricultural production decreased in 1955 and imports went up. So far the only contribution we have had from the Government is an emergency levy to reduce imports. The other contribution the Minister for Finance does not care to advertise is the credit squeeze that is going on. It is just as well to mention the negative help that the Minister for Agriculture is getting so far as this side of the problem is concerned, that there is at this moment the continued credit squeeze which affects every class of the community, the non-productive element more than the other, but it is the greatest assistance the Minister for Finance has in reducing imports and probably is of more value than the emergency levy.

We are not saying that some sort of restriction of credit would not be necessary if applied wisely and with proper discrimination. We are not saying that the situation is not inevitable in the circumstances but we do know that the Minister for Agriculture is pessimistic and that the Minister for Finance has not acknowledged the help he has got, in regard to reducing imports, from the banks.

The Minister has not faced the one difficulty which no Government has entirely succeeded in facing, namely, that the farmers in this country fear that if they increase production their prices will go down. In spite of the number of cash inducements to farmers, in spite of the number of guaranteed prices that have existed, the farmers of this country still have that fear. They have it primarily because of the rapid changes of policy that take place when the Coalition Government get in with their prejudice against the Fianna Fáil system of cash guarantees. That shows itself in changes in the system and as a result farmers have never yet had the confidence to go ahead in the way in which we would like them to and in which we would hope they would do. The Minister has not yet faced that challenge.

Another challenge he has not faced is that there is not half enough capital invested in agriculture, that capital is not available to small farmers, taken large and wide. The whole capital structure of farming is utterly inadequate and that demands a policy of long term development. Nobody has succeeded in dealing with that entirely but the Minister now has an opportunity to command aid for this particular work which he possibly never could command before, due to the fact that we have got to export more produce, due to the fact that the Minister for Agriculture is in a position to demand of his colleagues far greater assistance to help him in his problem. He is even in the position at the present time to ask the rest of the community, if necessary, to make sacrifices in order that there may be a sufficient injection of capital into agriculture and in order that all these difficulties, many of which have been with us for a long time, may be overcome. The Minister is in an ideal position at the present time. He is in that position because of the difficulties we face and because the public, who might in other circumstances think that measures adopted to expand production were extravagant, ill-advised or perhaps speculative, would be inclined to support a Minister for Agriculture who had some new ideas in view of the seriousness of the country's economic position. So far as we can see, he has not faced that challenge.

There is another challenge he has not faced, one which is very much easier for him than ever it was before. The level of agricultural teaching is disgracefully low in this country. The problem is made easier for the Minister because of the National Farmers' Association and Macra na Feirme which have published an important document admitting that is the case. They have published a statement saying there are three things required to bring about increased farm production — to give farmers more confidence, greater use of capital and greater educational facilities. They even go so far as to say the third is the most important of all, so that the Minister's problem is in some ways easier because an organisation outside politics, a new national organisation, has made declarations upon the matter. The Minister's task is easier than it was before, when, if he thought of new ideas or proposed new policies, he would run the risk that, if no national farmers' organisation had pronounced upon these proposals, they would be criticised from the other side of the House merely for making debating points or because members of the House thought they were wrong.

The Minister now has this work done for him and the Opposition, if forming the Government, would be in exactly the same position. That gives the Minister a great opportunity. I think one of the curious things about this debate is that the Minister did not mention the National Farmers' Association in the course of his address. It is not the first time that an effort has been made to start a non-political farmers' association, avoiding the difficulty of having to support the interests of the big farmer as against the small farmer, avoiding the difficulty of having to disengage from political controversy. The fact is that the National Farmers' Association has a number of ways of advising the Minister. Its membership is constantly increasing and the level of its pronouncements is certainly far above that of any other association I have seen for many a long year. Yet the Minister has made no comment upon it.

I would like to ask whether the Minister rather regrets the growth of the National Farmers' Association or what is his view about it and why, as this organisation is growing rapidly throughout the country, he took no advantage of its existence to modify his general attitude to agricultural problems and their solution.

The Minister has the opportunity of criticising the National Farmers' Association for any of those defects either in organisation or extent or scope of their activities. He has equally the opportunity of doing what has been impossible up to now for many reasons, social and historical, of beginning to invite a neutral farmers' association to take a far greater part in the day-to-day and week-to-week administration of agricultural policy and of using that organisation and the advantages that may spring from it to decentralise the work of the Ministry and to ask for consultation at every level on every problem so as to give farmers a sense of their own responsibility as a vocational organisation.

The Minister has that opportunity, as would anyone who was Minister for Agriculture this year and has the opportunity of guiding the work of this Department, because it is quite obvious from a study of the figures of the growth of the National Farmers' Association that its major growth took place in the lifetime of the present Government. They had barely got going when our Government was defeated and the Minister has now an ideal opportunity of speaking about the vocational organisation of farmers in this country and of giving a lead to the country upon it, and of saying how far the Minister must be responsible for promoting and administering policy and how far he thinks he can give the farmers for the first time in the history of this country a far greater and more immediate part in carrying out farming policy and in making proposals for changes, and in bringing the main lines of policy from Merrion Street down to the very smallest parish so that they can be discussed by farmers sitting round the fireside or in halls, so that they may feel they have a far more intimate part in what Merrion Street does and thinks than they have had before. It is a great surprise to me as I said that there has been neither criticism nor praise nor any comment from the Minister.

In regard to the question of capital, as the Minister knows, the debt on the amount invested in land in the form of external capital is about £1 per acre. There has never been any great change in regard to that. The banks have become essentially savings institutions and farmers are quite naturally determined, I think, to regard their deposits as savings for their families. Since the inception of the State there has been no change in the form of credit advanced by the banks. No effort was made by any Government, as yet, to organise credit facilities for farmers. The present Minister has simply said that he has every evidence that farmers did not want credit and he has left it at that. As the Minister very well knows, if agricultural production is to expand something will have to be done, not only about encouraging farmers to use more credit but to provide them with the necessary facilities.

The Minister has not faced the problem. It is a problem that affects farming and which has affected it for many years. Since the end of the war, with a full employment world in Great Britain, the demand for labour has been so tremendous and the wages offered so high that the economy of the small farm area has been largely dictated by the tremendous attractions of emigration and it is difficult to expect the small farmers in the small farm areas to undergo the risk of changing something like their present system of production and engaging in more capital expense when in fact, however modest their profits may be, they have increased, simply by there being fewer and fewer people each year on the land, and so long as agricultural prices continue to rise the people in the small farm areas have an automatic increase in income per head.

With this continuous development it is extraordinarily difficult to make any proposals which can be reasonably acceptable for increased production based on changes in fundamental methods and techniques because it is only human for a farmer to keep his investment low when, in fact, by diminution of the numbers of people living on it and by rising prices, higher profit levels can be consistently maintained. The Minister has not dealt with this fundamental problem nor has he adverted to it and yet it is the biggest issue we face — that there is a growing economic integration with Great Britain that could not be foreseen by either the Cumann na nGaedheal Party nor the Fianna Fáil Party when the State was established, an integration which is being effected by the full employment world in Great Britain and by the very high wages and salaries offered to the people. No one objects to a certain amount of emigration — it is natural to our people — but when, as I have stated, it became essential to start what I might describe as intensified modern farm methods in the small farm areas, the alternative solution offers a tremendously contrasted way of life which is difficult to change. In other words, every little bit of extra capital invested may increase production by 10 or 20 per cent., but the knowledge required is twice that and there is, again, five times as much worry for the farmer. That is the problem we are faced with and, as I have said, we have heard nothing from the Minister about it.

The Minister must be aware that the consolidation of holdings in all the western areas is proceeding apace. The work of the Land Commission is negligible compared with the falling in of holdings and the enlargement of holdings in the West. I suppose the most serious statement in the Population Commission Report, which no doubt the Minister has read, has been the sad fact that any increase of production that has taken place in this country in the last years has been on farms from 50 to 150 acres and the Population Commission Report announces an actual reduction in the output per acre of the smaller farm. As the smaller farms amount to one-half to two-thirds of the land of this country, that is a really serious problem which ought to be faced manfully and which ought to be the subject as far as possible of non-political discussion here because it may be the death of this nation if it continues. As Deputies have already said on both sides of the House, the small farmers have not the capital to engage in modern methods, have not the organisation as yet to co-operate with their neighbours in sharing modern machinery and they live far away from the main centres of propaganda and instruction and, apparently, the problem is a very serious one which is in no way being faced.

Part of the reason for all this is the fact that we have been discussing in this House, largely, since 1947, matters that have no concern with production. Thanks to the Coalition policy and propaganda during three general elections, most of the discussion and the debate, both during by-elections, general elections and in this House, has been on non-productive matters. We are always discussing the retail prices, the cost of living. People have become obsessed with price levels instead of considering costs of production and greater output. We have set the very worst example that can be set in this House by this long conflict, for which the Coalition Parties are entirely responsible, on retail prices, the cost of living, how much people have to pay for bread to-morrow, for tobacco the next day and stout the next day. It is all, it is true, a snare and delusion. We are seeing the last and the end of it at the present time but, nevertheless, it has prevented any kind of fundamental attitude to production being typical of this House.

It is interesting that the National Farmers' Association has put improvement in education first in their programme and it is interesting that in their report on the institute they have even suggested that there must be some education on national objectives in regard to agriculture. They have suggested a form of education that you could find in the earlier days of the Catholic organised co-operatives of Belgium or in the Danish high schools. It is clearly indicated in the agricultural institute report that it is necessary that the younger people be taught something about the importance of fertility, of unlocking the fertility in the soil, the importance of seeing that every parish produces as much as it can and every family produces as much as it can and that there is a contribution in that way to the nation as a whole. That has been recommended by the National Farmers' Association and it has passed almost without notice. It is probably one of the most remarkable recommendations by any farmers' body in the last 30 years. In the light of the fact, as I have said, that production has been diminishing in the small farms, it is of very great significance.

The whole problem is even more fundamental than that. The world of technology has not yet come to rural Ireland. The world of science and technology has not yet come to the younger people. We have the poorest form of education in Northern Europe. There is no country where there is less teaching of science, either rural or otherwise, than there is in this country. Educational experts are well aware of the fact that if a child leaves school at 14 years of age, unless he is a very special genius, he has not yet acquired the knowledge even of his own language to understand what technology means, to be able to choose between a technological career and a career not connected with science either rural or otherwise or to be able to feel that he can translate into words what productivity means. It is recognised all over the world that the school-leaving age is far too low if that be the objective.

Since the war and with the advent of the Butler Act in Great Britain and with improvements in education elsewhere, we have fallen very far behind in our standards in regard to scientific instruction applied to farming or anything else. When we speak of these things, no one disagrees. No matter to whom you talk, everyone agrees that education has fallen behind; everyone agrees that there is a tremendous absence of scientific thought amongst the younger people in the rural districts; everyone agrees that something must be done about it but, so far, no action has taken place.

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy consider that the parish plan would have done something to remedy that position?

Comment on this

It is a contribution.

Comment on this

Nobody more than he did all in his power to frustrate it.

Comment on this

We are not talking about the administration of the parish plan.

Comment on this

When I get up I will give you my views on the parish plan.

Comment on this

It has been found in practically every country engaged in agriculture that, in addition to local advisers, there has to be a far greater degree of teaching, both practical and theoretical, for farmers' sons and, indeed, for their daughters in many cases. Our level of teaching has fallen very far behind that of other countries.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy ever attended one of the short courses at Athenry?

Comment on this

I have attended one of the short courses. It is the number of pupils that attend them that is important. Of course, the Minister is not referring to that. Will the Minister let me develop my speech? I have not said that there is not a system of teaching here available. The difficulty is that there are not one-tenth the number of pupils, one-tenth the number of teachers and there has not yet entered into this country the spirit of agricultural technology. The scientific scene does not yet exist in the small rural community, not in the sense that it exists among our competitors in Europe. It exists there. We should not be ashamed of talking about it.

Other countries have had to fight for more education. Education has improved in other countries not always as a result of people all over the country suddenly passing resolutions. It has frequently been the result of leadership in one particular sphere of activity or another. In some cases in Europe it has been the Church of the majority faith of this country that has taken a very large part in actually stimulating rural science education. In some cases it has been the Lutheran Church but, whatever the influence has been, someone has to give the lead. Improvement does not generally come by thousands of people all over the country passing resolutions demanding more education. There generally has to be some form of leadership before something is done.

I wanted to speak about it here tonight because I have taken the opportunity of making a very considerable study of this, both in the way the system works here and in other countries, and I feel perfectly certain that it lies at the root of many of our difficulties. We need about 500,000 scientists, managers, chemists, soil experts, agricultural engineers, putting it dramatically, in this country in order to administer agriculture properly.

Comment on this

Half a million?

Comment on this

The Minister knows if I am exaggerating, as he himself does, in order to give an instance of the tremendous deficiencies that exist. One can make comparisons in regard to all these matters. As I have said, the National Farmers' Association have made some very interesting statements and have proposed a number of changes.

If you take, for example, the Netherlands, the Department of Agriculture there, to cater for 5,500,000 acres of arable land, spend £20,000,000 a year. This includes forestry and the operation of the Department in general. They spend £1,000,000 a year on research in a country where there are 5,500,000 acres of arable land as compared with our 11,000,000 acres. They spend £2,000,000 on education compared with the figure here which I got by adding up a number of sub-heads and which I think is a full figure— £412,000. Here there are one-tenth of the facilities required. There is gross overcrowding in a number of buildings where the education of the young people takes place. Here there are far too few pupils, far too few opportunities for travelling abroad to learn other ways and compare them with those here.

In Holland, the University in Weningen has 1,000 students on a five-year course. There are also a number of other courses in Holland. There is a general agricultural course which in its first winter — courses are held during the winter — takes 144 hours. The schools are spread among regions or districts. There are 7,000 students attending 436 courses, compared with the 4,500 people who take night classes here or rural science classes in the vocational schools. There are elementary school day courses in Holland taken after primary school education is over. There are 206 of these schools with 18,000 pupils in a State where they farm 5,500,000 acres of arable land, not 11,000,000 acres. They are organised by official bodies in some cases and by Church organisations in others, with State aid. These schools operate during the day and for the first year the pupil works for two-and-a-half days a week or 560 hours a year in order that he can help his father on the farm at home. In the second, third and fourth years he attends these courses for from 400 to 500 hours a year. One of the interesting things is that in the first two years of what is a four-year course most of the teaching consists of Dutch, arithmetic, natural history and geography. In other words, the intelligent Dutch people know perfectly well that if they want to understand agriculture properly they must first of all learn their own language.

Nobody can doubt that should also be the case here. Proof of it lies in what has been the experience in Great Britain and elsewhere abroad. In Great Britain, in spite of that country's long independent history, and of the 1945 Education Act, for a number of years 10 per cent. of those liable for military draft have been illiterate, 25 per cent. have been unable to write anything except the most simple message.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy. I have sympathy with the argument he is following but I think I should direct his attention to the fact that I am not responsible for education below the level of the adolescent. That branch of education was specifically removed from the Department of Agriculture by legislation of this Parliament. The Department of Agriculture used to be responsible for agricultural technical education but in 1924, I think, by special Act of this Parliament, all that was transferred to the Department of Education, which are now responsible for it and the Department of Agriculture has no say in the matter of education at all below the level of the standard of education given in Warrenstown and Ballyhaise.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think the Deputy is concentrating on elementary education. He is indicating, I think, that a good elementary education is necessary for those intending to study agriculture later.

Comment on this

I was trying to deal with the whole question of the teaching of agriculture in this country. The school courses in Holland to which I was referring go beyond the ordinary primary courses of education. A great deal of Dutch is taught in them and so are zoology, plant breeding, natural history and geography. Farm courses include practical demonstrations, visits, films and every conceivable type of group work for the very young people and the headmasters of these schools teach five days a week and on the remaining two days they frequently visit the pupils' farms and help the Government in advisory work. The whole school teaching in Holland is based on the fact that in general the teaching is done in the winter and in the summer the teachers do advisory work and assist with the practical work on pilot farms and so forth.

Comment on this

The rural science teacher in our vocational schools here is very often the headmaster and he fulfils a similar role.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the fabric of this education in this country.

Comment on this

I cannot comment on that because it is not my responsibility as I said earlier. That is an approach that might well be made to the Minister for Education.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy might leave the foundation and get on to the first storey of the agricultural education system.

Comment on this

These remarks might be addressed to the Minister for Education, who would be able to answer them.

Comment on this

I should think the Minister for Agriculture would have a good deal of responsibility for these matters. In this particular matter I am going far beyond the immediate field of political controversy because this is a problem that is not properly faced up to. The Minister now has an opportunity no other Minister had of getting something done about this deficiency. I mentioned these elementary school courses and will go on to a description of the winter schools which operate from October to April and which have 4,000 students. The pupils work for 120 hours per course and even in these schools a good deal of Dutch and mathematics are taught, so it is thought that some sort of training in the language of one's country is necessary if the pupil is to absorb the main subject. In all countries of Northern Europe it is considered that the pupil must have a far greater level of general knowledge as well as the specialised theoretical knowledge. Of course there are constant changes taking place in these countries. For instance, there has been an increase in the teaching of agricultural engineering and in the use of machines. The facilities in this respect in Holland are lavish.

We on this side of the House have been avoiding embarrassing the Minister in regard to the constitution of the agricultural institute. We want to continue to do so in the hope that he will soon be able to make a decision about it. I do not think that I need embarrass the Minister further about it but I am not at all sure that we have not wasted a lot of time talking about an agricultural institute in Dublin. What we need is a lot more farm centre buildings and centres of education throughout the country. I am not at all sure if the whole of the American money should not be spent in this way in the truly rural districts. I am beginning to feel, having made these comprehensive studies, that that is more on the lines on which we should be going and that at least some of the money that is involved should be spent in that way.

Comment on this

Surely the parish agent is the answer to that?

Comment on this

In my view he is not nearly sufficient.

Comment on this

He is a good beginning.

Comment on this

He is a good beginning all right. There is another question I want to ask the Minister and I want to enter into a highly contentious field. I have been examining the —Dutch Advisory Report and in the most recent Report of the Dutch Agricultural Education Authority they state that it would take so long to get teachers trained with degrees that they have given up the agricultural degree and they have appointed assistants who have a secondary agricultural education and they say this course has proved worth while. They say that if those assistants are given a course, not only in the work they have to do, but in teaching and in public relations and in the sociological end of it, and, at the same time, a course in special subjects, it is worth while. Many of these assistants, in their spare time, continue their training until finally they have a higher educational standing.

Comment on this

We have had 120 of them for the last 50 years.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister whether he has finally-made up his mind about this matter.

Comment on this

We have had 120 instructors without degrees for the last 50 years.

Comment on this

The present policy is to have an agricultural science degree.

Comment on this

Is it not odd that the Deputy is struck with what he finds in Holland but he does not advert to the fact that we showed Holland what to do?

Comment on this

That is why I want to ask the Minister what his general policy is.

Comment on this

I want to extend both services but Deputy Moher is determined that I will not and that he will obstruct me in every way he can.

Comment on this

Deputy Moher is dealing with the question of who should administer the parish plan.

Comment on this

I am trying to get on with the job.

Comment on this

That is the question — who should administer it?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Childers should be allowed to proceed.

Comment on this

No matter where I look I find that these educational services are far more extensive than they are here. Is it not obvious from the stagnation of agriculture that a great deal more will have to be done in that direction particularly because our land is not as uniform as that of Holland? Our problems are greater and require a greater knowledge of agricultural matters generally than is the case in certain parts of Europe where you have a certain dull uniformity over huge areas. The problem is greater here than there.

I also find that so far as research grants are concerned we are far behind other countries. In Holland £1,000,000 a year is made available for agricultural research. I do not see how the Minister can be refused if he puts up the case to the Minister for Finance that more money is needed for research. That is the amount of money that is available in Holland for 5,500,000 arable acres as compared with our 11,000,000.

In their report on the agricultural institute the National Farmers' Association adverted to all these things. I agree that so far as the level of education is concerned, it can only develop slowly. I believe that the suggestions made by the National Farmers' Association and Macra na Feirme are well worthy of consideration. They do not advocate the abolition of the county committees of agriculture but they advocate that they should become corporate bodies with a greater number of co-options from farmers in the area and that they should be modified to suit the needs of the present day; modified so as to get the kind of people on to them who will take a great personal interest in the month to month working of the parish agent and see that the agent does group work in the different parishes.

I do not know whether the Minister is cynical and thinks that the National Farmers' Association have over-estimated their capability to be able to do this, but I would like to ask the Minister whether he has considered the paragraphs in the commission's report in regard to that matter. In Holland the work of the advisers and their assistants is largely assisted by co-operative advisory associations.

Comment on this

I thought that in Holland they were almost entirely State controlled.

Comment on this

They are State controlled but these advisers work largely with a variety of co-operative advisory associations. They meet these people everywhere and work with them collectively so that there is a far greater volume of group work done and there is a far greater number of pilot farms in Holland such as the one we are now running in Kildare. The amount of group and co-operative work done to the advice of these people is far greater than it is here. I am suggesting that the representations made by the National Farmers' Association in regard to the modification of county committees of agriculture in order to enable them to take a greater part in the work of the parish agents seem to me to be of great importance. I feel very strongly that we are not going to make much progress until, in some way or other, the farmers can feel that they are really part of the Department of Agriculture.

Now I know it is very easy to say something like that. It is far easier to say it than it is to put it into operation. The Minister has, at least, two national farmers' organisations with which to discuss the matter and he at least knows that there has been very little success so far in increasing production, particularly in the small farming areas; and he must know that one of the reasons for that is the feeling of the remoteness of the Department, the fact that it is administered by a political Minister, and the fact that his policy may change from time to time. I feel that we shall never progress until farmers feel that the Department is something that they are almost running themselves, even though there has to be some ministerial policy due to our relations with countries abroad with which we trade and due to the amount of moneys spent collectively by the Government on agriculture and due to the fact that, if money is spent for the farmers, there must be a sense of responsibility in the spending of it and somebody must be held responsible. But, within that limitation, I feel this is an essential contribution to the improvement of our agricultural life. As I have said, the modification of the county committees of agriculture is at least a small beginning and the farmers can now feel they are taking a real part in the work of the advisers.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy mind saying what the modification is of which he speaks?

Comment on this

A number of alternative ones have been made.

Comment on this

They have a right to co-operate.

Comment on this

But the idea is there should be some statutory obligation on them to co-operate in a certain type of farming organisation.

Comment on this

I think they are cooperating with persons interested in agriculture.

Comment on this

But there is no statutory obligation to do anything — there is an option — and a great many of them do not do anything. There are entirely human reasons for that, of which the Minister is well aware. There is nothing disgraceful in it. As the Minister would know if he read the minutes of the county committees, because of natural tradition they are really administrative bodies. They pass votes authorising this person to do this thing and another person to do something else. They do not, for example, hold fortnightly meetings to discuss what is being done in the area, what lags in the way of improvements in agricultural production, because there is no broad survey of the deficiencies in the several areas. I do not mean mentioning the names of farmers, but there is no sort of competitive work undertaken by the committees because the advisers are not given a broad picture of the target to be achieved in relation to any particular area. They are not given particular problems to solve and, because the committees do not live in that spirit, they have not yet played the part they should play in improving agricultural production both from the standpoint of propaganda and the standpoint of social relations in so far as the farming community is concerned.

I am sure the Minister will agree with that. I think it is a matter that requires consideration. I hope I have said sufficient to suggest that this whole question of education requires consideration. I would like now to deal in more detail with the question of the market for beef in Great Britain. I think it is a pity that the Minister indulged in this criticism of the Irish Press because I think the problem is a serious one. I think the farmers need some kind of lead from the Minister, if he can give it to them, in regard to the marketing of cattle.

As the Minister knows the bulk of the chilled beef has been coming into Great Britain between August and December. At the same time peak production in home-produced beef in Great Britain also takes place, plus very big sales from here to Great Britain at the same time. That is a problem our farmers have to face. As the Minister knows, there have been all sorts of exhortations to people not to buy their cattle at the peak price period but rather to buy their cattle earlier, try to get them improved earlier and sold earlier. That is a very difficult thing to do and it is not always even possible to do it. In any event, I think the farmers, instead of being told they should not pay attention to the Irish Press headings, need more advice on the marketing of beef in general. The farmers, for example, are very worried about the entrance of Argentine beef on the British market at 1/7 per lb. There have been statements made by various agricultural economists in Great Britain pointing out that the average exports to Great Britain have been 63,000 tons from 1951 to 1953 as compared with 355,000 tons pre-war. These economists seem to take the view that, although there may be some increase in frozen beef exports from the Argentine, they will never reach the pre-war level because of the growth of population there and permanent changes in the Argentine economy.

I think the Minister should give some advice on that matter because there has been considerable perturbation in agricultural circles in relation to the wild prophecies made as to the extent to which Argentine beef will flood the market. That will obviously affect prices at certain times of the year and, if the Argentine continues to send towards the end of the year and we continue to have very heavy sales at the end of the grass period, we will be faced with a formidable difficulty if cattle are exported on the hoof, not through any co-operative marketing operation but through the prices paid to individual farmers. If that continues we shall be faced with a permanent and difficult problem. Equally, if a great deal of finished British beef also appears on the market at the same time, the problem will be made even more difficult still. I think the Minister should give his views on that.

I am myself an incurable optimist in regard to the future of agriculture. I refuse to listen to the many Jeremiahs who hold that we can never advance for this reason or that reason. I have noted the fact that the British are consuming 250,000 tons less beef than they were consuming pre-war and they are not yet, in fact, very high consumers of beef. The consumption in Ibs. per head for the year 1954 was 43 in the United Kingdom; 37 in West Germany; 82 in Canada; 89 in the U.S.A.; 108 in New Zealand; 119 in Australia; and we have the truly fantastic figure of 185 in the Argentine. Perhaps some slight reduction in Argentine consumption at home may help to contribute towards exports to Great Britain. But the figure for home consumption in the Argentine is, as I have said, a fantastic one and, even allowing for an increase of beef from the Argentine, I do not know at what figure one could put that increase; at present it is 63,000 tons for the last three years. If it reached another 30,000 or 40,000 tons and if New Zealand managed to add another 15,000 tons, there is still an enormous opportunity for us, as the Minister knows, provided our cattle are the right kind and the right weight and provided we study the British market.

Again, I think that in face of our present problems the Minister will have to do far more market research into the whole question of the cattle trade here. I made a tremendous effort myself to find out what the situation is, to find out whether there has been any research into the future possible trend of the British market, to find out whether the small lean joint habit is likely to last, whether it will be a permanent feature because of the smaller British family, because of the children living away from their parents and because of higher incomes, to find out what the proportion of the large joint required for catering purposes is as compared with the small joint and to get some kind of market trend and some kind of idea as to where we are going. I have made an effort to find out whether the policy of breeding and the use of bulls here really conforms with the future market trend of Great Britain, whether the farmers, who are out of touch with the market and have not got the figures and who do not know anything about what the market trend will be in detail, are able to get the advice as to how they can act in face of present circumstances.

I am a firm believer in market research. I had enough experience in the advertising world to know how unpleasant and hard-boiled and materialistic it sounds, but it has become an essential feature of modern commercial life and some effort should be made to measure the situation in Great Britain at the present time. I was at Cambridge recently and there I inquired into the work of progeny testing on cattle, and the success achieved in proving the hereditary factor in the conversion rate of young cattle when fed on equal quantities of food. I would like to ask the Minister whether he could not persuade the Minister for Finance that we could be one of the leaders in the world in that, even as a small country, whether, if our principal job is selling cattle on the hoof to Great Britain, if it is going to be one of our major forms of production, he could persuade the Minister for Finance to let us be one of the leaders in that, one of the initiators.

Comment on this

In what?

Comment on this

In doing progeny testing for cattle for conversion to beef. I understand from what I learned in Great Britain that this will be a permanent feature, that it is accepted exactly as in the case of pigs. It is going to be accepted within ten years from now that a bull will no longer be judged in the way it was judged before, by pedigree, and so on, but on conversion tests of the rate at which the cow produces lean meat in a given, time fed with equal quantities of food. That has been accepted in America and in Great Britain, and there is going to be a rapid development of that kind of progeny testing. It offers the Minister the opportunity of accepting another of those headaches which come in the course of considering modern production methods. We should take a leading part and do the job really well, carry out the tests ourselves and perhaps produce more cattle for breeding ourselves on this new basis. We should set a headline to the world in this regard and I am quite certain from what I have learned that it is one of the coming features of beef breeding. We should consider doing it for ourselves and not rely on other people to do it for us.

I note that the Minister recommended an increase in the cow population and made proposals therefor. I suppose he is aware that it involves a considerable amount of working capital in terms of feeding and housing to hold over cattle, fertilising grass to make more feeding stuffs, and so on. It rather made me wonder whether the Minister had any particular reason in not speaking on this particular occasion on the general breeding policy in the dairying area. The Minister has not yet been able to change his view about the policy. I have been studying reports on the whole question of the dual-purpose animal and I think the Minister knows a number of changes have taken place in spite of what used to be regarded as official departmental opinion on the matter. The Friesian has reared its head in a very big way in the dairying areas and I find if one brings back from Great Britain a market report on the price paid for a year-and-a-half or a two-year-old bullock of various breeds and types, it does not seem to conform any longer to what would be the opinion on the matter in the dairying areas and the difficulty that the Minister would have in changing his policy in regard to what is the perfect dual-purpose animal is the old difficulty of migration up to the Midland areas. I imagine it is a problem that should be examined in great detail and that there should be market research in regard to it. It is quite certain, from talks I have had unofficially through the dairying areas I happened to be in in the course of by-elections, that the official policy is dying on its feet and yet there has been no announcement by the Minister as to any change that may take place in the future.

Comment on this

I am sorry but I do not quite follow what the Deputy is referring to. Does the Deputy suggest that the accepted dual-purpose animal is no longer the Shorthorn? There are 80 per cent. dual purpose Shorthorn cows in the country.

Comment on this

I know, but the Minister knows very well that there are now Friesians with good beef content and they are gradually sweeping through the dairying areas. There is no official comment on the matter and no official encouragement.

Comment on this

Not to give the Deputy a short answer, I knew that Friesian addicts, having denied the possibility of there being beef and meat in the one hide, so long as that referred to the Shorthorn, are now loudly claiming that in respect of the Friesian and saying that they are dual-purpose cows. I do not complain; I simply think that Shorthorns are better dual-purpose cows but I freely concede that another man may honestly believe that Friesians are better.

Comment on this

The Minister may have to risk his head being severed by taking some decision in this connection.

Comment on this

My decision would be in favour of the dual-purpose Shorthorn but I do not think the Minister for Agriculture has a duty to coerce.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting coercion but there are a great many facts that have not been told to the people in regard to comparative tests that have been taken in regard to various breeds that have been allowed to have exactly the same food, and the Shorthorns have been beaten hollow by the Friesians.

Comment on this

I really do not know if the Deputy has any knowledge that I have not got——

Comment on this

Perhaps I will leave it to Deputy Moher who, I think, has more knowledge than I have on this question.

Comment on this

I gave the information last year but it was passed over without comment.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Childers accept Deputy Moher's views on that subject?

Comment on this

No, but I do accept market reports on various classes of bullocks. Furthermore, I have investigated this matter in Great Britain and I do accept the results of the experimental tests which were accepted by the British Department of Agriculture on the profits made on year-and-a-half-old bullocks fed on various grades of food — A, B and C — over certain periods. I will not go further than that into the matter. The Minister can study the reports himself. It would seem to me that a great many people in the country are not acquainted with what I would call the new climate in regard to this matter.

In connection with his proposal for stabilising the price of pigs, first of all, the Minister apparently does not favour the formation of any pig marketing board for this purpose. He does not consider at this stage of our development, when there is no longer any of the political conflict that beset us before, when we were necessarily responsible for the economic war which we fought on our own basis, that it would be a good thing if the farmers could run the organisation to stabilise the prices of pigs. Does the Minister think that imprudent? Is it always to be——

Comment on this

I would prefer that the farmers would cure all their pigs, but that is not the fact.

Comment on this

There has been a proposal made by a responsible organisation for a pigs marketing board to stabilise the prices of pigs. This body would be able to spread knowledge throughout the country by means of more propaganda through co-operatives, to advise farmers through local committees of the organisation so as to achieve a higher proportion of grade A pigs. I would like to ask the Minister whether it is considered that——

Comment on this

Is it the proposal that it would be representative of curers, farmers and consumers?

Comment on this

And a member of the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

That would be four.

Comment on this

That was the proposal. I do not think the consumers were proposed for representation and perhaps that is rather natural under the circumstances.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy would agree they would have to be considered.

Comment on this

They would have to be considered. I would like to ask the Minister also whether, in studying the whole question of pig marketing, he accepts that the present method of collecting the pigs does not involve such high costs that before any profit can be made on a bacon pig not only the question of progeny testing and the question of stabilising prices and encouraging farmers to produce a suitable type pig would have to be inquired into but also the method of collection. Pigs are being collected in Mayo and brought to Cork; pigs are collected in Cork and brought to Mayo. Has the Minister made any inquiry as to what the extra costs of producing bacon pigs here are compared with Denmark and Holland, because, as I understand it — I have not got the figures with me — the total extra cost of collection in the case of the system of pig collection we have here makes the difference enormous? I would like to ask the Minister to be quite frank with the House in saying if, with the plans he has announced, he thinks that pigs can be produced on barley meal imported on to the farms. Does the Minister really think he can encourage small farmers to go into the business permanently with a view to producing grade A bacon pigs? Could it be done through co-operatives or would the overheads of co-operatives swallow up the profits? Does the Minister think the work can be done properly and that the work of grain growing and grain handling can be done on a purely co-operative basis?

Comment on this

I think the idea is that the small famrer should grow the grain himself.

Comment on this

The farmers cannot grow the grain.

Comment on this

Because there is a tradition against it. The people in East Cork grow barley for the farmers of West Cork, who buy it.

Comment on this

And so I want to show them how to grow it for themselves.

Comment on this

The same thing happens in my constituency.

Comment on this

You canont grow barley in bogs.

Comment on this

You can grow barley where you can grow oats.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think that the only alternative is to reduce the profit of the handling of grain almost to nil? Does he think that through some farm organisation there would be more help in this direction, that there would have to be more help because it hardly exists at the moment; that farmers' co-operatives will have to be offered facilities for grain-drying and so on?

Comment on this

That is something the National Farmers' Association could be doing.

Comment on this

And I was imploring them this very day to do it.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister was engaged in that matter because I have worked out the extra cost of producing grade A bacon pigs here compared with other countries and there is still a very long way to go before we can even begin to be competitive.

I would like to close by asking the Minister if he has reconsidered the question of the high prices of fertilisers in this country? As the Minister knows, the figures have been published for competitive prices of all sorts of fertilisers in many countries abroad and, in the case for example of phosphates, the price here is extremely high. In fact, in about November, 1955, the price of phosphates here was the third highest in Europe. I would like to ask the Minister if there is any way out of that difficulty and whether he is examining the problem? The figures that have been produced by some farm organisation showing the profits that can be made by the application of phosphates in various countries show a very diminished profit figure in the case of Ireland.

It is clear that sufficient quantities of phosphates are not used because the price is so high and in view of that it seems strange that we should have such a prejudice in regard to subsidising fertilisers. That prejudice arose partly because there may have been some difficulty in administering the subsidy but when we consider the expenditure of £25,000,000 a year on capital services and that only some £6,000,000 are devoted to agriculture we realise that this is something for which not only the present Minister but former Ministers must take responsibility and something which I think underlies the whole background of our problem. We have not yet been able to reverse these figures and I think if we had been able to do so the money for housing and all the other non-productive expenditures would have been found very quickly.

Both Governments have continued that position, but in relation to this huge capital programme why is the present Minister still prejudiced against the application of heavy subsidies to fertilisers? I think it is essential for the development of the industry. The Minister apparently believes that a subsidy could not be made available without the danger of its being absorbed in higher profits——

Comment on this

I do not believe in subsidising the industry.

Comment on this

I think that is a very serious statement by the Minister because the British Government does subsidise fertilisers as the Minister knows.

Comment on this

They do.

Comment on this

I think there are other countries where fertilisers are subsidised and where apparently racketeering does take place in prices merged at various points. It seems to me to be mere prejudice. We spend enormous sums of money on every kind of capital work such as arterial drainage, which is very valuable and very necessary, but, if there is a lack of capital, I honestly think if we are going to spend capital it would be better spent on fertilisers than on arterial drainage if the money is not available for both.

I would like to ask the Minister does he consider whether most of the suggestions he has made depend ultimately on enormous increases in the amount of grass and feeding stuff available in this country? The quicker turnover of cattle which is essential if we are to expand production can only come from that. The sending of cattle of nine and ten cwt. to England at the age of two years on a far bigger scale, if that is to be the future trend, can only come from that. It seems absolutely essential to consider in the light of present circumstances, particularly in view of the present change in market trends, the old question of fertiliser price margins. I cannot see any justification in spending £8,000,000 a year in subsidising bread at the present time, at this stage of our history, at this stage of our inflation, if we cannot afford subsidies for fertilisers.

Comment on this

Practically everything has been said on this Estimate, but I would like to compliment the Minister on his great grasp of every detail that is in the interests of agriculture. Take the limestone subsidy. Much has been said about the good effects achieved by the use of lime on the farm and the farmers have been helped considerably by this limestone scheme. Quite a lot has been said from the opposite benches of the extra expense involved because of certain monopolies by companies in the transport of ground limestone. It is a wonder that they did not rectify that matter. They claim to have started it. If they did, why did they not start it on a proper footing? If they did not start it, they had a chance some two or three years ago of straightening the matter out and there would be no need for them to spend one and a half hours here criticising the set up and trying to lay the blame on the inter-Parties.

Certainly, the good effects of the scheme are to be seen all over the country in the wonderfully green fields in the very early spring, continuing into the late autumn and early winter. There is almost an all the year round production of the best natural food, good grass.

Most people are reluctant to mention wheat. I think the Government took a very good line in changing the set-up in regard to wheat. It will be admitted that wheat growing has a very low employment content in comparison with the growing of other grains that give all the year round employment. Take, for example, Kilkenny, the ex-Minister for Agriculture's constituency. Kilkenny grows approximately 46,000 acres of wheat, which costs the country very nearly £500,000 in subsidy. As against that, County Cavan grows only 1,000 acres of wheat but the growing of other crops there has a higher employment content. In Kilkenny there are only 12,500 male workers on the land and in Cavan, where there is very little wheat grown, there are 18,000 male workers on the land. In addition, the two counties are similar in size but Kilkenny has a valuation 20 per cent. higher than Cavan. Therefore, there is a good deal to be said for the type of farming carried on in Cavan, having regard to the employment content in the production of corn consumed on the farm and the production of cattle, pigs and other live stock for which there is an export market.

There is no export market for wheat. There could be a famine in the midst of plenty if there were over-production of wheat for which there is no export market.

Comment on this

There is export to the people who eat it.

Comment on this

Did not I point out that the export is from the constituencies where wheat is grown? That is the unfortunate part.

Comment on this

You are not taking the mills into account.

Comment on this

I am taking the overall picture. The best authorities in this country, some of them supporters of the Deputy's Party, have said that it is more important to keep the people at home than to have a higher standard of living. That is not merely my opinion. It is the opinion of people not very far from the Deputy's constituency, whose opinion is very highly valued. I would again compliment the Minister and his staff on the wonderful success they have made of agriculture.

Comment on this

I have been here all day and at this stage I am not in a fit condition to initiate a debate. For part of the time, the House sounded more like a political windmill than a debating chamber. I do not know how the Minister survived all the nauseating bouquets that have been flung from the opposite side of the House since the beginning of the debate.

I would not start off on the note which I intend to take were it not for the fact that I have been baited and taunted by the Minister across the House as the would-be assassin of the parish plan in Cork County. That charge having been placed on my head, the House is entitled to some explanation of my position in relation to the parish plan as a member of the Cork County Committee of Agriculture.

I want to go back, first of all, to the copy of the departmental notice which was issued by the Department of Agriculture to the C.A.O. in Cork. I want to repudiate any implication or insinuation that I was responsible for any of the opposition which the parish plan met in the Cork County Committee of Agriculture. I went to the Cork County Committee of Agriculture meeting and gave my views on the parish plan and I hope, before I am finished, to give a résumé of the statement which I made there.

The first intimation that the Cork County Committee of Agriculture got of the introduction of a parish agent in that part of Cork County represented by the two parishes of Kilworth and Ballynoe and Conna, was when the copy of a circular which was sent to the C.A.O. in Cork was circulated to the members of the county committee. There was no prior consultation and no prior information was given. There was merely the simple statement that this agent had arrived in the two parishes concerned and had taken up work there. That was the first intimation that we in the county committee of agriculture, the body that has a statutory responsibility for the provision of an advisory service in the county, not from the Minister and his Department.

I will tell the House what I did when I got that circular. I thought it was an innovation. I thought that organised farming interests in the county had a right to know. I typed five carbon copies of the circular. I sent one to the county representative of the M.P.A. in the area, another to the representative of Macra na Feirme, another to the secretary of the Mitchelstown society, another to the secretary of the Castlelyons Co-operative Creamery and another to the county secretary of the creamery suppliers. I thought that as an elected representative in the county I was entitled to pass that information on to the organised farmers of my constituency. That was the part I played.

The Minister is inclined to imply that I am opposed to the extension of advisory services in that county. That is not the case. Ever since I became associated with the county committee of agriculture, I have advocated the introduction of further advisory services where requests had been made for those services. I tried to initiate an advisory service with the local co-operative society. That disposes of the charge that I am opposed to advisory services in the county, but the big question that arises is the control of advisory services in the county and I expressed my view of what I thought of a further incursion by the State in the matter of the control of the advisory services. I know also that as far as the agricultural advisers under county committees of agriculture are concerned they are indirectly controlled by the Department of Agriculture, because a county committee of agriculture may do only what the Minister permits them to do.

Comment on this

They need not do what the Minister wants them to do which is a very much more important thing.

Comment on this

The advisory services controlled by the county committees of agriculture are, to some extent, controlled by the Department of Agriculture. In fact they are so controlled to a very large extent. It was stated in the circular that the intention was to supplement rather than supplant the existing services. At the same time, there was the usual cute, ambiguous paragraph inserted at the bottom asking the C.A.O. to make such adjustments in the services as would accommodate the parish agent. I assumed that was because the Department or the Minister did not want duplication of the services in that area and that it was a polite and a veiled invitation to the committee to withdraw any advisory services they had in the area.

How then can you argue that the service was not supplanting an existing service? That is the question I pose here. Any opposition I expressed in the Cork County Committee of Agriculture to this parish agent was not to the parish agent himself or what he proposed to do but to the system by which he was controlled. I was in good company on that particular occasion because it was the very day on which one section of the dairy farmers were parading here in Dublin protesting against the delay in producing the Milk Costings Commission's Report by another group of civil servants.

The Cork County Committee of Agriculture faced the situation that day where the gallery overflowed into the committee chamber and every organised branch of farming in the county, through their spokesman, protested against the control of the parish agent directly by the Department of Agriculture. We have, as Deputy Childers has been saying, thanks be to God, reached the stage in this country when we have organised groups of farmers who, we must admit, speak for the farmers throughout the country. I have accepted that situation and I am sincerely glad to see such a development in every county throughout the country. So also should any Minister for Agriculture, because now the Minister for Agriculture is in the happy position that he can consult with the body representative of the farmers on any proposal he wishes to introduce.

As I was saying, a rather peculiar situation developed at that meeting in Cork. We heard first the spokesman of the National Farmers' Association who submitted a memorandum which expressed the considered views of the county executive of that association. There was concurrence from a spokesman on behalf of Macra na Feirme and finally from a representative of Muintir na Tíre, Professor Lyons. Professor Lyons came into the meeting also. I believe he is a member of the national executive of Muintir na Tíre and I believe that, in co-operation with the Very Rev. Canon Hayes, he was the author of the parish plan. He quoted extensively and first of all repudiated the suggestion that he at any time, as spokesman of Muintir na Tíre, advocated the control of the parish agent directly by the Department of Agriculture. He quoted from pamphlets and memoranda which he had written over a number of years.

I am in no difficulty whatever. I know the propaganda of Fine Gael in East Cork has been going full blast to try to represent me as a person who is opposed to giving advice to farmers in the constituency. I had from one very prominent farmer in the area a rather abusive letter charging me with trying to deprive the farmers in two East Cork parishes of the advice of a parish agent. I sat down and rattled off six sheets of foolscap and attached a note saying I was enclosing what amounted to an open letter and inviting him to publish it in any newspaper he wanted or to read it at any guild meeting of Muintir na Tíre in his area.

Comment on this

Might he add, when he read the six pages: "He doth protest too much?"

Comment on this

The six pages dealt with State control generally and with the sterility which is being associated with State control in this country. I have a strong objection to the extension of that control to the advisory services and I will try, in as few words as I can, to give the reasons for my objections. I do not object to the parish plan. My objections are not based on the fact that the services have been introduced by Deputy James Dillon, the Fine Gael Minister for Agriculture, because I defended that same Minister at a public debate.

Comment on this

God forgive you.

Comment on this

These antagonisms and opposition to State control are as old as the Department of Agriculture itself. One of the things that we have lacked in this country is that no Government or no Minister has ever made a gesture that could be regarded or interpreted as an act of faith in the farmers or as an act of faith in organised farming in this country. The attitude always was that nothing could be done as effectively as it could be done by a Government Department.

One of the questions I wish to pose is this: does the parish plan envisage the ultimate elimination of the county committees of agriculture? Is this the first move in the totalitarian control of the bureaucratic set-up in Merrion Street? Those are the questions I pose to the present Minister for Agriculture.

If you take from the county committees of agriculture the control of the advisory services you deprive them of the purpose of their existence. It all adds up to one thing — that the county committees, with all their faults and whatever few virtues they have, must disappear if the control of the advisory services is to be completely centred in the Department of Agriculture here in Dublin. Is not that a logical conclusion?

Another objection I have is this — everyone here is conversant with Muintir na Tíre and its foundation. Everyone is conversant with its composition. Everyone knows that it would be a complete misnomer to say that Muintir na Tíre is an agricultural organisation. It is no such thing. It is a rural organisation and Muintir na Tíre is the sponsoring body as far as the parish plan is concerned. In other words, the sponsoring body of the parish plan is a rural organisation but it is not an agricultural organisation. There is a very distinct difference. As a local representative I have, on many occasions, visited guilds of Muintir na Tíre and I have just jotted down what we might regard as a cross section of the composition of the local guild.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Has the Minister for Agriculture any responsibility for Muintir na Tíre?

Comment on this

Yes, Sir, in as far as they are sponsors of the parish plan. Come on, give us the cross section.

Comment on this

You were poking me and prodding me all day as the assassin of the parish plan. Now let me defend myself.

Comment on this

Give us the cross section.

Comment on this

I will give you the brains trust and then the ballast. You have the local parish priest, unless he is too senile, and then he is usually represented by the local curate as chairman. You have the dispensary doctor and the local solicitor, the Civic Guard sergeant, the local grave digger, the water curator, the sewerage caretaker and the local maternity nurse. They are the people who constitute the brains trust of any normal guild of Muintir na Tíre with a few old doddering farmers thrown in to nod.

Comment on this

That is a deliberate lie. I am the chairman of the county committee of agriculture and I am also the chairman of the guild of Muintir na Tíre.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy cannot use the expression "a deliberate lie". He must withdraw that expression.

Comment on this

I withdraw.

Comment on this

Nobody can deny that they are a fair cross section of the brains trust of the local guild.

Comment on this

I trust that Professor Lyons will read that statement with approbation.

Comment on this

The Minister looked for it. That is the sponsoring body of the parish plan while side by side with them you could have the local N.P.A. committee, the local Macra na Feirme committee, the local co-operative society committee and the creamery milk producers' committee. Am I not making a fair case that while Muintir na Tíre might represent a cross section of the rural community it does not represent organised farming and agriculture as we know it?

Comment on this

It represents all the people and not a cross section.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Deputy Giles. I would listen to him until I would burst a pressure gauge. This is not any new fight. This row over the intrusions of the Civil Service and over the spreading Colossus here in Merrion Street is as old as the Department of Agriculture itself. Let us go back to before the Minister's time. Let us go back to Horace Plunket.

Comment on this

With whom, I hope, you do not compare me.

Comment on this

I make no comparisons at all.

Comment on this

I am much obliged.

Comment on this

Horace Plunket founded what I might describe as the first independent agricultural organisation. He did that within the last 50 or 60 years. It was the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society. He was, under Balfour, the first organiser of the Department of Agriculture or, as it was then, the Board of Agriculture. The Irish Agricultural Organisation Society was his first foundation and when he was invited to develop the Department of Agriculture he left the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society and he left in his place, as general secretary, a very able man, R.A. Anderson. With him, to the Department of Agriculture, went Mr. Gill, another one of his earliest co-workers in the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society.

When he left the Department of Agriculture and returned to his original foundation, the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society, a body which had done so much for Irish agriculture with so little, one of the things which he recorded was the amazing thing that while he was director of the Department of Agriculture he could not believe the incursions that body had made on his original foundation, the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society.

Comment on this