We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 96–216 of 216. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

1951 is missed again.

Comment on this

If we take the total of the gross agricultural output for the whole country, excluding turf—I have always been interested in the figure excluding turf which I could never really feel was part of our agricultural produce whatever else it was—we find for 1926-27, the figure was 97; for 1938-39, 100; for 1947, 91; and for 1954, 114.

I am not saying by any means that these are figures about which we should throw our hats in the air, but they are figures about which we need not hang our heads in shame. Let us examine them a little more closely, because the fact is that for many years in Ireland there was a very large volume of under employment on the land particularly in the West of Ireland where we had large families leaving their small holding. There might be three or four grown boys and all of them remained as agricultural workers on the land. Unfortunately a great many of them have left the land, not to seek industrial employment in their immediate neighbourhood but very often to emigrate. It has meant that there are less people working on the land and that has had this interesting result, and it is worth noting—I have tried to get made out an index of employment of the gross output per individual male engaged in agriculture in Ireland. In 1926-27 you get a volume of 86 as compared with a base year 1938-39 of 100; in 1947, 98, and in 1954, 139.

Comment on this

The introduction of machinery is the answer to it.

Comment on this

There seems to be a passion whenever you produce any ray of sunlight or consolation to persuade ourselves that we are not the most abandoned race in Europe; it seems to madden Deputy Walsh and he always has some explanation to show that it it not half as good as we think it is.

Comment on this

Is it not terribly foolish to be using these figures——

Comment on this

It is no harm to tell the Deputy about them.

Comment on this

——without giving reasons for them?

Comment on this

It is no harm to tell the Deputy about them and that is all I am trying to do. I do not want to preach the doctrine of complacency at all, but I want to try and get this whole picture into some kind of rational perspective. Are the farmers of this country better or worse off than they were? Is not that an important question?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

I conceive the only purpose for which a Minister for Agriculture exists is to ensure that, over a long term, the farmers of this country will be better off than they were. For that purpose, I like to recall not only the annual increase in the volume of their total production, but I like to look at how now do they stand, because it could appear that farmers were doing very well and yet transpire that what they were in fact doing was living on their capital. I would like to look at the end of the period to which I refer to the condition of the farmer's stocks. Has he run them down or has he built them up? If he has run them down that mitigates substantially the satisfactory nature of the picture that the first statistics appeared to reveal; but if, in addition to that increase to which I have referred, it transpires that at the same time his stocks have greatly grown, then I think we have reason to say that things are not so bad as some people seem to think.

The total number of cattle in this country in 1939 was 4,057,000. By June, 1948, there was a slight decline to 3,935,000. How many cattle are there to-day? 4,483,000. That means the farmers of this country own 400,000 more cattle to-day than they did in 1939 and they own 500,000 more than they did in June, 1948. What are 500,000 cattle more worth at an average? It is a substantial sum of money, and it is owned by the farmers of this country —£20,000,000. You would not put it in a child's hand. Let us pause a moment.

Comment on this

They are not all at £40 each.

Comment on this

This is what puzzles me: the moment I demonstrate that the farmers of this country have £20,000,000 more the whole Fianna Fáil Party are objecting and are quite indignant about it. I would expect all the members of the Fianna Fáil Party to say that is good news——

Comment on this

How does this expert arrive at this figure?

Comment on this

Half a million cattle more. What are they worth? Let us not get vexed about it. Let us go £5,000,000 either way. If you look at sheep, in 1939 the farmers of this country had a stock of 3,047,000 sheep. By 1948 the stock of sheep had fallen to 2,057,000. They now have 3,268,000. They have 1,250,000 more sheep than they had in 1948. In 1948 they had 457,000 pigs. To-day they have 798,000 pigs. Let us not over-estimate the effect of these figures; but surely they are relevant for the purpose of considering how Ireland stands?

Fianna Fáil appear to me to spend their time vacillating between two courses when they refer to the land project. One is to say that they started it and the other is to say that it is "not so hot" in any case.

Comment on this

No, it is not.

Comment on this

There is not need to get cross.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny there was land reclamation in the country——

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy will let me speak after listening to 47 speeches. I think it was Deputy Davern who was saying with pious forbearance that he did not wish to say anything inimical or obstructive about the land rehabilitation project but he felt he had a duty to say that there was a lot of land being reclaimed under that scheme, that mountains of money were being spent on it and that it would never be worth sixpence.

Comment on this

And it is true.

Comment on this

Wait a moment. Then Deputy Neil Blaney gets up and he says in reference to the land project that it is important to remember that this work was put in hand by Fianna Fáil——

Comment on this

You can have it either way. I do not give a fiddle-de-dee. All I am concerned about is this: no matter who started it, there will be 1,000,000 acres reclaimed or in the process of reclamation at the end of this year.

Comment on this

Yes, since 1936.

Comment on this

I do not give a fiddle-de-dee. There will be 1,000,000 acres of new land in a country whose entire national resources consist of something between 10,000,000 and 12,000,000 acres of land. Does not that suggest that we are a little better off than we were ten years ago?

Comment on this

What will the 1,000,000 acres have cost?

Comment on this

Are they not there?

Comment on this

What will they cost?

Comment on this

Are they being utilised to the best advantage?

Comment on this

I would like to think that, without lining their ditches with Civic Guards or employing ten fields of inspectors, the farmers will use that land to the best advantage——

Comment on this

We are off.

Comment on this

I am not asking the House to believe by any means that these figures are, as I say, appropriate material for complacency, but I think we ought to have regard to them when we are reviewing the whole question of the Irish countryside.

I sometimes get tired listening to ferocious comparisons being made between our farmers and the farmers of certain continental countries, and the comparisons are usually made to the disadvantage of our farmers. I am prepared to concede at once that a successful agricultural industry is founded on hard work and I think that probably applies, too, to any other form of worthwhile human effort; but I do not see why, in a modern society, where everyone aspires to the 40-hour week, the minimum trade union rate of wages and every other sort of protection for the rights of man that the only section of the community to be excluded from these benevolent dispensations should be the farmers on the land. I think they ought to work and work hard, but I think they have the same right as any other section of the community to say: "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy."

I should like now to read a short objective survey made, not by a citizen of this country, but by a citizen of Great Britain who travelled abroad. This appeared in the Farmer and Stockbreeder of the 10th and 11th April. Ceux sont les gens qui travaillent.

It was not to Belgium that he went. He went to Denmark, and I would like some of the critics of our farmers, who compare us so unfavourably and who compare our performance so unfavourably with that of the Danes, to ponder on this: "Half of the 200,000 farms in Denmark are less than 25 acres. The typical Danish smallholder's farm would be about 15 acres". I wonder what Deputy McQuillan would do if he were a member of Parliament in Denmark?

Comment on this

I would wait until the Land Commission Estimate comes up.

Comment on this

He would keep about seven milking cows; fatten some 20 pigs a year; and keep a flock of 200 hens. "The holding is too small for a tractor; the number of cows too few to justify the full economic use of a milking machine, although he often has one; the area under each crop too restricted to allow much mechanical work. But he has one advantage— that he does most of the work himself and he does not think of it in terms of hourly rates or overtime. The hours of work are long, perhaps 70 hours a week. There is no paid labour and only in exceptional cases can be holding support an adult son."

Comment on this

They did not go to England.

Comment on this

I do not know where they go.

Comment on this

They stay there in their own country.

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that for our own farmers?

Comment on this

Nobody suggested anything.

Comment on this

I think of my neighbours who go to Strandhill for a fortnight in the summer and who think it no crime to go to a football match on Sunday. They think it no disgrace to claim a little leisure time. And, then, I think of the Emperor Hadrian, to whom the following reflection is attributed—I invite Deputies to dwell upon it: "I doubt," said Hadrian, "if all the philosophy in the world can succeed in suppressing slavery. It will at most change the name.""I can well imagine," said the Emperor Hadrian, "forms of servitude worse than our own because there exist lands where they transform men into stupid, complacent machines, who believe themselves free just when they are most subjugated or where, to the exclusion of leisure and pleasures essential to man, they develop a passion for work so violent as the passion for war amongst barbarous races.""To such bondage of the human mind and imagination I prefer," said Hadrian, "even our form of slavery."

Comment on this

He must have been a poet.

Comment on this

Nobody will charge our people living on the land with that form of slavery. And, so long as I am Minister for Agriculture, I do not ask our people to emulate the example of those who conceive it noble to develop a passion for work as violent as the passion for war amongst barbarous races, because, to such bondage of the human mind and imagination, I would prefer the Roman form of slavery.

Comment on this

The Minister is driving them in that direction very quickly. Cut the price, and the Minister has them then.

Comment on this

At least the Deputy subscribes to the views and sentiments I have expressed.

Comment on this

We are all agreed they should go to football matches. There is no disagreement on that.

Comment on this

I invite the Deputy to study it. I think we have a way of life here that may not produce the same return in cash, but probably produces a better return in the combination of reward and a decent life. That is what I want for our people.

When I listen to debates here, I often wonder do people ever fully appreciate the breadth and scope of the work of the Department of Agriculture. I have tried to emphasise it by the publication of this explanatory memorandum. It is well known to Deputies, such as Deputy Walsh, who had the experience of presiding over that Department. The work is very wide, and I do not know whether Deputy Walsh sympathises with me in the dilemma which seems to me to harass every Minister who presided or presides over that Department since the State was founded.

The Minister spends one half of his time exhorting people to do things for themselves. He spends the other half of his time repelling accusations that he wishes to set himself up as a universal dictator, supervising everybody and everything he does. I am sure Deputy Walsh will agree with me that, from the viewpoint of most Ministers for Agriculture, the most welcome guest is the man who comes in and asks: "Am I free to organise this and am I assured that, if I set this in motion, the Department of Agriculture will not intervene at all?" Such visitors are rare: 90 per cent. of those who call want to know what the Department is going to do about something. In certain areas of activity, however, where the intervention of the Department is absolutely indispensable, a Minister who seeks to do his duty as best he can is not infrequently largely occupied in repelling the charge that he wants to establish a dictatorship or that he wishes to upset the whole social system upon which a Christian community is founded.

I was asked to-day, and several other days, too, why did I not warn the people of the trend in cattle prices? The answer is perfectly simple —because I was not able to do so. But in so far as prudence would allow, I think I did give the people who were concerned a warning when, speaking in Dáil Éireann on 26th May last, in Volume 151, at column 223, I spoke of the prices then ruling in the Dublin cattle market at the time, and said that they were:

"...going £9 a cwt. in the Dublin market a couple of weeks ago. I am not at all so sure that this is a realistic price. In fact, I think that price has gone so high as almost to cause us concern."

The plain truth is that nothing that I or anybody else could say would dis-made farmers both here and in Great Britain from buying store cattle last year on the basis of the prices they got last May for fat cattle. I sympathise with them, because many of them did lose money this spring because they confidently expected, and nothing would persuade them that it would not come to pass, that when February and March came the same dramatic upswing would take place this year as took place last year. Most objective observers knew full well that it would not take place, but none the less there were many men so obsessed with the validity of their own judgment that they were resolved to try, and they lost money.

It was no part of my duty or my right to overrule their judgment Every man has a right to make his own judgment in matters of that kind. But I do not think that the strictures which I passed upon the Irish Press were unduly severe. Remember, I never suggested that many of the big farmers of 200 or 300 or 400 or 500 acres, or the sophisticated and experienced operators in the fat stock market, were going to be impressed by what they read in the Irish Press; but what I was concerned about was that where you had a small farmer in the West of Ireland with a few store cattle and he read in the Irish Press, beginning on the 2nd February: “Cattle Prices Down: English Demand Slackening Off: Cattle Down by 16/6 per cwt.” and all this in flare headings—“Cattle are down by 8/- to 10/- a cwt.: Many Remain Unsold.” February 8th—“Cattle Boom Over — Childers: February 9th: Price——”

Comment on this

I was using the term in its normal sense. It is over. The Minister said so himself.

Comment on this

It is the presentation of this matter in that newspaper with which I find fault.

Comment on this

Did the Independent publish that?

Comment on this

I have no fault to find with any newspaper that conceives it to be its duty to record the news as they saw it, but my objection was to a series of flare headings, day after day, inserted by people who ought to know what the repercussion of that would be down in the West of Ireland and other areas in the country where small farmers had some cattle and were naturally nervy, and who, if they feel that the bottom is going to fall out, will rush into the market and the first offer they get they will take.

Comment on this

Who bought them? Who was buying them? There was no demand for cattle at the time.

Comment on this

Let us not go into that. We heard Deputy Crowe saying here a couple of nights ago—he is a plainspoken and shrewd man—that he knew a few people who sold their cattle and sold them cheap. I do not think my strictures were unduly severe. If my strictures had been so grossly unjust as subsequent speakers described them as being I cannot imagine that they would have been referred to with such passion by the speakers on the Fianna Fáil Benches, for they would have felt that my strictures would have condemned themselves. All I am asking for is for a sense of responsibility.

Nobody wants to ask a newspaper to publish something that is not true, but I do ask them, if they are dealing with matters relating to the markets, particularly in which our small farmers trade, to use a due sense of proportion and responsibility, and present things objectively and with all proper reservations. But if there is an oscillation in the fat stock market in Dublin do not plaster it all across on top of a daily paper, "The bottom has fallen out of cattle prices", the only result of which will be that you will make certain small people to whom the loss of £10, £15 or £20 is a cruel blow, lose their money, to the advantage of less scrupulous neighbours who are only too glad to take advantage of any temporary panic into which they may be thrown.

Comment on this

You do not know what you are talking about.

Comment on this

I do put it to the House that in a matter of that kind my responsibility to protect the farmers ends with the small farmer. The large, well-to-do, sophisticated, experienced farmer does not require any advice from me or the Irish Press or anybody else as to market conditions, but it is the small farmer, who is going to a fair, perhaps, twice a year, and who is quite disproportionately conditioned by publicity of that kind, who may suffer, and suffer acutely, if some sense of responsibility is not shown. In so far as the Irish Press offended in this matter the sum of my endeavour is to ask them not so to offend again, but to retain some sense of responsibility when dealing with such matters in the columns of their newspaper.

Comment on this

And make you the editor.

Comment on this

Well, I am sure that the Fianna Fáil Party has wished me many ills, but I never thought that Deputy Allen would sink to that.

Comment on this

Could the Minister tell the farmers how to sell the 100,000 cattle they have on hands now?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Allen should cease interrupting. He has already spoken at length.

Comment on this

He is looking for it.

Comment on this

I see here in the speeches of Deputy Childers and certain others a kind of implied suggestion, an implication, perhaps no more than that——

Comment on this

I asked the Minister a question but did not get an answer to it.

Comment on this

——that I had some distaste for the National Farmers' Association, or that I do not give it its due status, or welcome its emergence. I am obliged in those circumstances to remind the House of the chronology of events. I think I am right in saying that the National Farmers' Association was established at a meeting which took place on the 6th January, 1955. I think I am entitled to remind the House that at Robinstown Macra na Feirme Club on October 12th, 1954, I spoke as Minister for Agriculture and, having dealt with certain matters, I went on to say:

"There is one other matter I want to say a word on to-night, about which I have thought for a long time but which until to-day I was not sufficiently sure about to speak on in public. I think the time has come when Macra na Feirme should use all the influence of which it is possessed to permit the establishment in this country of a national farmers' union to which all farmers, whatever their political affiliations, may belong. I strongly advise you to insist that the national executive shall consist of men and women who are not members of Oireachtas Éireann. You will remember that I am myself, as my father and grandfather before me, a politician and a member of Parliament and, therefore, when I advise you to exclude those actively engaged in politics from the executive of a National Farmers' Union, I do not thereby mean to belittle politicians."

I think I am entitled to say that the exhortation delivered by the Minister at Robinstown on October 12th, 1954, made some contribution to the development which ensued on the 6th January, 1955. I am happy to read in the speech of the recently elected chairman of the National Farmers' Association, Dr. J.N. Greene, 28th April, 1956, that he has it to tell that "friendly and helpful relations have been established with the Department of Agriculture. This had been a matter of policy and they regarded an association with the Department as complementary to each other and not as opposing forces."

I think it is right to inform the House, lest there be any misapprehension about the matter, that frequent consultation takes place between my Department and the various sub-committees of the National Farmers' Association and that the President, Dr. Greene, knows he has a standing invitation to come and see me personally on any matter which he considers to be of sufficient substance to justify discussion at that level. That there should be any closer contact between the association and the Department, I consider to be impossible. It is very necessary that the association should maintain its independence while at the same time feeling certain its view will always be welcomed and that whenever in the judgment of its chairman for the time being it is necessary to discuss a matter at ministerial level he will always feel that he has full access to the Minister's room to raise any matter or discussion which he cares to name.

Again, I do not want to suggest for a moment that there is any reason for complacency but our instructors are often compared unfavourably with those of elsewhere. I think at present they are not adequate but they do not compare as unfavourably as some of the wholly illusory comparisons that were made would suggest. A common comparison is to take the position in Holland and say there are so many instructors per 100 farmers there and then compare the position here but carefully restricting the comparison to the number of agricultural graduates who work as county instructors or parish agents or horticultural instructors with the number of instructors of all kinds available in Holland. It is only on closer inquiry that one discovers that a very large number of the advisers in Holland are not university graduates at all. Those making the comparison choose to ignore or overlook the 112 parish agents in the congested areas which we have here who closely resemble the agricultural advisory services which obtain in Holland. Having made clear that the comparison between our circumstances and those of European countries is not as bad as some would suggest, I want to make it quite clear that the ideal at which I aim is to ensure that in every three parishes of the 800, approximately, rural parishes in Ireland we should have one satisfactory parish agent whose job it would be to bring within the reach of the farmers in that area all the information they require and who would serve as a means of informing the Minister for Agriculture of anything they lack.

I do not care to attribute base motives to my neighbours. When Deputy Moher is talking, sometimes I find myself believing that this is a perfectly honest straightforward man —and the next minute I find myself beginning to say: "This is the shrewdest operator I have ever heard talking."

Comment on this

That is hardly fair.

Comment on this

He gave a most emphatic description of how his soul rose up when he received a certain circular I sent out to the county committee of agriculture. He pictured how he rushed to his venerable typewriter —a man stalwart and resolute albeit poor—and, with the inadequate equipment he had, his ancient typewriter, tapped away in the public service, dashing off the letter to all and sundry. You saw the picture of Paul Revere riding at night, sounding the tocsin, calling to those who felt with him to rally to the flag. He hastened to add that he just sent it to them: "This is what I got. What do you think about it?" That was very moving but if you are having a fiesta or something you can always cast Deputy Moher for the part of Paul Revere— the wide hat and the cloak. That is a very moving story. I think it is true that in some of these envelopes Deputy Moher inserted a little note to say: "Anything you can do——"

Comment on this

I can do better.

Comment on this

No. "Anything you can do to stop this, stop it."

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

I should like Deputy Moher to examine his conscience about that.

Comment on this

I have a clear conscience on the whole thing.

Comment on this

I am sure you have, but it all depends on the particular instrument with which one burnishes the conscience. I am sure Deputy Walsh will agree with me that, in so far as the functions of the Department are concerned, no Minister has ever sought to control his technical staff provided he is satisfied they are doing their job and getting the stuff over to the farmers. He does not give a fiddle-de-dee how they do it. In fact, technical men would not take it. I think Deputy Walsh would agree that if he or I asked the officers of the Department of Agriculture to propagate that which they knew to be wrong they would not do it—and we would not ask them to do so because we know the answer we would get.

All this talk about control is pure cod. However, I am so anxious to get the thing done that I do not care who does it. If any organisation such as Muintir na Tíre, Macra na Feirme or the National Farmers' Association want to avail of the parish plan and do not want direct contact with the Department of Agriculture and go to the county committee and tell them to do it, I shall be delighted. However, whenever a group of bona fide farmers in parishes seek that service and cannot get it from the committee of agriculture, I will supply it.

Comment on this

Why not go to them first and ask them to do this thing?

Comment on this

I have asked all the branches who have applied to me to go first to the county committee.

Comment on this

Are you not competing against the county committees of agriculture with the limited number of graduates you have?

Comment on this

I want to get the stuff to the farmers as soon as possible. If the county committees provide it, that is well and good.

Comment on this

You asked them to do this?

Comment on this

Yes. I have told every applicant who came to me in Cork to go to the Cork County Committee and see if the committee will give them a parish agent who will be personally responsible to the county committee of agriculture for his three parishes, and who will be charged with the responsibility of bringing to people in those three parishes——

Comment on this

The county committees of agriculture have refused to do that.

Comment on this

Not that I know of.

Comment on this

Let the Minister ask them.

Comment on this

That is what they are being asked to do now. It is not for me to ask them. I have no right to go to any county committee and ask them to charge the rates. I never did it. If county committees of agriculture come to me with their schemes and ask me to approve of them, unless they are completely at variance with the general policy of the Department, my answer is in the affirmative. It is for the county committees of agriculture to take the initiative, and not for the Minister for Agriculture. Any person who wants something in Cork should go to the county committee of agriculture and if they do not supply it, I will endeavour to do so. As long as I am Minister for Agriculture, we are going to keep up the fight to get access for the small farmer, and ultimately for all farmers, to a parish agent, who will be charged with personal responsibility for the development of agriculture along the right lines in the area of which he is in charge. That is an indispensable part of a truly progressive policy.

I do not think we ought to close our eyes to the fact that we have short courses operating in Athenry Agricultural College which are second to none. I have this strange difficulty. It costs £6 for a two-weeks' course all-found and it is very difficult to get fellows to take it up. It costs more than that to feed them, never mind providing the college with staff to teach and demonstrate. I find it very hard to get the courses filled. I approached Macra na Feirme, as I think my predecessor did, and offered to let them fill the courses with their own nominees.

Comment on this

Has the particular time of the session anything to do with it?

Comment on this

We vary the time. We had them at all sorts of times. Even when fellows attended a course, finished it and asked for another course, we tried to arrange it for a fortnight. The odd thing is that it is hard to get the courses filled. I believe that, if we had parish agents more widely scattered, we could encourage our fellows to go to courses of that kind. It is not always so easy to do it.

I wonder do Deputies entirely forget that in every technical school in Ireland there is a teacher of rural science? As far as I know, in every one of those schools there is a first-class qualified teacher of rural science. His difficulty is that he cannot get pupils.

Comment on this

Four thousand five hundred in all.

Comment on this

I know. Here is Macra na Feirme. Here is the National Farmers' Association and surely to God one of their first jobs should be to overwhelm the teachers of rural science in every technical school in Ireland with applicants for a course. The facilities, I think, are there. You observe that I now have to speak with a certain note of doubt in my voice because for some strange reason, back in the 1930's or some time, instruction of that kind was taken away from the Department of Agriculture and is now vested in the Department of Education. I intend to try to get some closer liaison between the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Education in respect of agricultural education in the technical schools. But, if Macra na Feirme, the National Farmers' Association, Muintir na Tíre or anybody else wants a job to which they can put their hands in the morning without consulting anybody, let them organise young lads in their own districts and ask for a course in elementary agriculture in the local technical school. The elementary agriculture is not all that elementary. It is an excellent course for any young fellow working on his father's farm, or who intends getting married and setting up a house of his own.

I wonder whether any Deputy has been out at Ballsbridge? Certain people suggested to me that we should try to do something to suggest to people how an Irish farm kitchen in rural Ireland could be improved from the point of view of amenities. I said there is nobody in my Department qualified to tell a woman how to run her kitchen, but that if the Irish Countrywomen's Association would like to undertake the business, I would facilitate them and undertake the costs within reasonable limits. I would let them set up what they in their experience, would consider a typical Irish country kitchen, having regard to the modern facilities which have become available with the introduction of rural electricity and such other facilities as are now available.

There will be certain differences of opinion as to whether the rural kitchen they set up is too elaborate or not sufficiently so, but I am sure that the Irish Countrywomen's Association would say that this is their first year and will invite criticism and suggestions for amendment. Where the Department of Agriculture gets the co-operation of a voluntary body of that kind, that is the right approach. I think voluntary bodies can do these things better than the Department of Agriculture and better than the most conscientious bureaucrat or civil servant. The fact that they are prepared to do it voluntarily and man it voluntarily is in itself something of real value.

Deputy Hughes referred to the desirability of meeting the views expressed by certain growers of wheat concerning giving them a 1 lb. escalator rather than a 3 lb. escalator which they are at present enjoying. That is easier said than done, but I agree that something ought to be done. I know there is a great desire on the part of many people who grow grain to have an escalator arrangement for moisture content. As far as I can see, the administrative difficulty of doing that is virtually insurmountable. The present position is that if wheat is under 23 per cent., you get paid the basic price, and in a normal year 90 per cent. of the deliveries agreed upon between the farmers and the millers comes within that category. It is only when you get up to 24 per cent., 25 per cent., 26 per cent., 27 per cent. or 28 per cent. that you begin to make very heavy penalty reductions. It is only in these high levels that it is necessary to have oven tests made of samples.

What the growers wanted, having got the norm fixed at 23 per cent. moisture content, is a bonus in respect of every 1 per cent. moisture content below that. I sympathise with that approach, but the fact is that the norm was originally set very high and 23 per cent. moisture content, as a norm, is very high. But, in addition to that, there would be a great many administrative difficulties and costs which would make it utterly impossible. What the growers feel is that it would throw back on them the right to dry their own grain and be remunerated accordingly.

The administrative difficulties of doing the thing in the way suggested make it next to impossible to do. When the old wheat system was first set up, there was a certain number of people in the business called the grain dealers. They are still there and there are no new ones created since 1939. I said to the farmers' representatives that if they believed there was any jam in this business of drying grain and selling it to the miller dry, let them form co-operative societies of grain growers, to handle the growers' grain, and I would give them a grain dealers' licence, and, if there was any jam in it, they could have it. As at present advised, that approach is as far as I can go. It goes a certain way to ensure that if there is jam there, those accessible to it have the device of constituting themselves a co-operative for the purpose of taking the jam.

Deputy Colbert is a Deputy who, I am obliged to say, prima facie made a very valuable contribution to the debate because he seemed to talk moderately and reasonably, and what he was saying seemed to me to contain a very great deal of horse sense. He threw very special emphasis on the advantage of silage. I agree with him entirely and I would like to inform him that the Department has just completed a new leaflet on silage of which copies are available on application by post to anyone who will write and ask for them. I think the leaflet expresses all the views that Deputy Colbert expressed and they are designed to make it possible for any farmer, including the smallest, to make silage on the lines mentioned by Deputy Colbert Colbert. I agree with Deputy Colbert that grass growing and in the shape of hay and in silage is the keystone of economic creamery production in this country and I hope the parish agents operating at present in West Limerick will be able to do a great deal to enable the farmers of West Limerick to achieve the right level of grass husbandry to meet the objectives that we mentioned.

I listened with great interest to the speech made by Deputy Donegan and I want to thank him for his contribution to the debate which dealt very largely with the problem of barley and other grain crops. I must say that as I sat listening to-day to Deputy Neil Blaney from Donegal who happened to speak on very much the same topic, I got the impression that every phrase that Deputy Blaney uttered was designed to increase, if possible, the difficulties of a Minister for Agriculture in disposing of the grain crop. I would recommend to Deputy Blaney to read Deputy Donegan's speech because there he will find a speech, dealing with exactly the same problem, every phrase and sentence of which is designed to help the Minister to deal with the grain crop. That is the difference.

I welcome and value the contribution made by Deputy Donegan and I hope I do not embarrass Deputy Colbert by saying that I welcome and value such contribution as he made. I do not complain in the least if a Deputy deems it his duty to be critical if he goes on to say: "And here is the way to put it right." But when people like Deputy Blaney intervene it is a different matter. I knew well what he was up to because I know every hair on his head. He was trying to kick up a row. He would love to have it to say that he had a row with me, but I am too old a hand for that. It is a disgraceful and futile misuse of this House for a Deputy to conduct himself like that. However, I suppose in 20 years' time he will have more sense and less voice and that it will be better for himself and for the country. I once told Deputy Blaney that he stood in grave danger of damning his soul through hatred which is one of the Seven Deadly Sins. He does not hurt anybody else by hating someone. The only person an individual ever hurts by hating someone else is himself. Hate corrodes the hater; it never hurts the object hated. I just want to show Deputy Colbert, before I depart, this new leaflet on silage. I think its exterior gives promise of its most excellent content.

Comment on this
Michael Colbert Mr. Colbert

What is the title?

Comment on this

Just "Silage". It is devoted entirely to silage. I shall deem it a privilege if I may have the pleasure of sending the Deputy a copy.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Autograph it.

Comment on this

I dare not do that. That would surely destroy the Deputy. I want to deal with another facet of this debate. I think it was Deputy Moher who mentioned it. I have no complaint if the Deputy was critical. He was interested in the Landrace pig and the desirability of reviewing the position. I do not know if Deputy Moher read what has recently occurred in the Isle of Man. In the Isle of Man it has suddenly been discovered that the pig population is riddled with atrophic rhinitis and this has turned up in the relatively few bacon factories in the island. The consequence is that there was clamped down on the Isle of Man the following morning an absolute prohibition against the export of live pigs from the Isle of Man to Great Britain. We are perfectly free to export live pigs. It may not at this moment be a very valuable market but the fact is that it is there and can be a very important stabiliser to our pig market.

My problem is this and it is only this. I have not the slightest desire to control, compel or coerce anybody. So far as everyone knows, I am a devotee of the Shorthorn breed. I am certain that in our conditions, compared fairly with other breeds, it will match and beat most of them, if you take all the facets into consideration. But I have never sought to compel people to keep Shorthorn. I have never sought to coerce people who want to keep Friesians, Jerseys, Ayrshires or any other breed they like. Nevertheless I have always felt free to say in public what I thought was the best breed. I have never sought to interfere with those who preferred the Aberdeen-Angus or the Hereford. In fact I have been able to provide facilities which my predecessor had not time to provide for the transporting of Jersey cattle from Jersey. There is now a quarantine station in Jersey. We cannot do it in respect of Guernsey cows because Guernsey Island has not the facilities.

Comment on this

Before the Minister concludes will he say, in respect of Landrace pigs, has there been a veterinary investigation here?

Comment on this

We kept a constant and vigilant watch in all the factories because we know that somebody has brought in at least one half-breed Landrace boar; we have actually prosecuted in this case and are now in the process of having the animal castrated. What vexes me about it is that you will get people to stand up in public and suggest that it is some desire to frustrate people that induces me to enforce regulations against the importation of Landrace pigs. The only reason I enforce regulations against the importation of Landrace pigs is that wherever they have come in they have been followed by atrophic rhinitis.

Comment on this

They were not imported to the Isle of Man.

Comment on this

Yes, they were.

Comment on this

My information is that they were not.

Comment on this

I assure the Deputy they were and the appearance of atrophic rhinitis is coincidental with that Mark my words. I should say, probably, the discovery of atrophic rhinitis is identical with the introduction of the Landrace pig but I must say that certain Swedish authorities have resented this reflection. They have conducted inquiries both in Great Britain and I think, recently, in the Isle of Man and the tenor of their inquiry is to establish that this disease was endemic both in Great Britain and the Isle of Man before the Landrace ever came in but that nobody had noticed it. The Department of Agriculture in Great Britain repudiate that idea completely and say that they knew the condition well and had been constantly vigilant to protect themselves against it but that it came in upon them through the extraordinary fact that this disease factor can be suppressed in the carrier and you can have a carrier pig that does not appear to have any symptom about its snout at all but whose progeny will manifest the defect. It is even suggested that a carrier pig can have progeny which itself shows no evidence of the disease but the progeny of the progeny will turn up with atrophic rhinitis. That has been suggested, but it is certain that a boar or sow showing no symptom itself can affect all its progeny.

Comment on this

Is the Minister perfectly certain that there were importations of the Landrace to the Isle of Man?

Comment on this

I am virtually certain there were importations from Jersey or from Scotland—not directly. I do not know whether they came directly or not but I am virtually certain. There are, certainly, Landrace pigs there now and there are two schools of thought, one which says the disease was endemic there before and the other which says it was not.

Comment on this

Is the statement true that we have thousands of Landrace pigs?

Comment on this

No; that is a gross exaggeration but I do not doubt that some half-bred Landrace-Large Irish White sows may have come across the Border because, the Deputy understands, they keep a very close watch but you cannot watch every part of the Border. The Border is not that effectively watched on either side any night.

That is my sole concern, then, this question of disease. If that element were eliminated, I would not mind a fiddle-de-dee but that element is present. I am bound to add that I would be strongly opposed on grounds of policy to the introduction of any of what are called the forest breeds of pig from Great Britain, like the Tamworth and these coloured pigs which are naturally indigenous to forest country. We have in this country, fortuitously, it is true, but none the less truly, a pure breed of pigs, to wit, the Large Irish White. Nothing but considerations of the gravest significance should induce us to depart from that but I would certainly be prepared to consider the Landrace on its merits but for this disease factor.

I would like to say this: The case is made that all you have to do is to bring in the Landrace and all your troubles are over. I checked up on that and it is not true. The Landrace, like any other pig, can produce various results which are largely dependent on the environment in which they are reared and the feeding methods employed. I found at one factory in Denmark that the grade A percentage over the previous year of pigs going in there—and they were all Danish Landrace—was 55 at one factory. At another factory it was stated to be 75. The explanation given for the wide difference was that in one area there was better feeding and management practice than in the other.

If I could get every breeder of pigs in this country to pursue nothing but the best feeding and management practices and if we could have five or six years battering away at the pig progeny testing we would be well on the road—well on the road—to getting the type of pig that would be equal to the best the Continent is in a position to produce. I think that would be our best method of procedure and, as at present advised, it is along those lines I intend to travel.

I have tried to cover the points raised by most of the Deputies who have spoken in this debate but before I finish I want to talk on one other matter, that is a matter which was referred to in the course of this debate by Deputy Childers. He said that he did not wish to embarrass me by referring to the institute. That does not embarrass me in the least because there is nothing to conceal. There is a very odd story. When I came back to office this time I understood that substantial agreement had been reached between the Government and University College, Cork, and University College, Dublin, on the desirability of establishing an institute to meet National and Trinity College, Dublin, in principle at least, but I discovered, to my amazement, later, that Cork had changed its mind, that they wanted to set up a faculty of agriculture in Cork and they repudiated their previous decision. I discovered that the President of University College seemed to have changed his mind, which anyone, I suppose, has a right to do. An entirely new situation had then arisen.

I want to make it clear what I believe to be the ideal but we have to remember that in matters of this kind it is not always possible to attain to the ideal. I have no doubt what I think is the ideal. I would like to set up a full-scale agricultural university in this country into which we would concentrate all the best we have so as to make it the rival of the finest institution of its kind on the Continent of Europe and I believe it would do it.

What we have to remember is that in this country we do not accept in matters of education the fact that you can separate into water-tight compartments matters material from matters spiritual and I accept that proposition. Then there is another breed of proposition put forward by a certain type of university professor, that is, that you cannot study agricultural science without contact with the humanities. A great deal of that is cod. Ask an engineering student in University College, Dublin, or a medical student, what humanities he comes in contact with and see the answer you will get. But, when you come down to the question of sociology and philosophy, I think you do run a danger if you seek to set up an institution dealing with agricultural science divorced from all contact with the fundamental truths on which life is founded.

I would have been very happy to see an institute which was a true, complete, sovereign, independent and absolutely autonomous agricultural university providing for every aspect of agricultural science and into which would be invited one of the great Orders of the Catholic Church to provide such a course of philosophy and sociology as might be requisite and for which we might turn to the Protestant Church in Ireland to make corresponding provision in the spheres of philosophy and sociology for those students who were of the Protestant Faith. I want to warn Deputies that even to discuss these matters is liable to bring a hive of bees around your hair. Some of the people that buzz, you would think, would be more at home——

Comment on this

Should the Minister not wait until he brings in the legislation?

Comment on this

Do not tempt me to make a tart reply. That is the kind of interjection I would expect from Deputy Blaney. Deputy Childers asked a question. I am answering it. Is that not what I am here for? What is the point of his asking me a question if I do not answer it, or if you put your finger to your nose and say: "Yah, why do you answer him?"

Comment on this

Why did not you wait until you introduced legislation?

Comment on this

I did not introduce legislation.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister why he did not wait until he introduced legislation rather than arguing the pros and cons of the matter now?

Comment on this

Because Deputy Childers asked me a question which he had a right to ask and because I am answering that question.

Comment on this

All right. Go on.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy satisfied?

Comment on this

I am.

Comment on this

Then, that is the position. I think the idea I have in mind is the right one, but I am not at all sure I will get there because the vested interests are now massing in every direction. Galway wants a faculty of agriculture; Cork wants a faculty of agriculture; Dublin wants to retain the faculty of agriculture; Trinity are now seeking it. If we have an institute of agriculture, we must have five faculties, according to those people, when we have not the personnel adequately to staff one good one. The National Farmers' Association and Macra na Feirme want us to set up a most elaborate organisation for the distribution of grants. There is to be a liaison with the county committees of agriculture and there is to be transferred from the Department of Agriculture to some august body most of the functions of the Department of Agriculture, including all the advisory services. So long as I am Minister for Agriculture, the responsibility for the advisory services will not be transferred from the Department over which I preside. I do not know whether Deputy Walsh is prepared to resume office for the purpose of delivering these services over to somebody else. I am not. So long as I am here, they will not be transferred and anybody interested in that had better note it.

Comment on this

It will not be long now, James.

Comment on this

That is a pious wish bursting out, but piety associated with the Deputy is not convincing.

Comment on this

The farmers in Laois-Offaly are praying now.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Will the Minister say a little bit more? Is he trying to compromise? How far has he gone?

Comment on this

I would like to meet a number of interested parties when embarking on something of this nature and I think that is the right way to proceed. It is extremely touchy and all sorts of people are touchy about it. I cannot get people to see what seems to me to be as plain as a pikestaff, that I regard it as an essential element that such an institute should have, in every respect, without qualification of any sort, all the independence and autonomy of a university. I must have said that 40 times in public in the most substantial language and yet you will find an imbecile trotting up and saying: "Ah, but you want to control the institute." It is like talking to a mirror or a lunatic who does not understand a word. You can say: "There is no legislative device the mind of man can conceive that I will not employ to ensure the autonomy of the institute," and, in the end, an imbecile will say: "Ah, but you want to control the institute." All you can do is shake them warmly by the hand.

Comment on this

You are aware, of course, that the Cork University people did not change their minds in this matter.

Comment on this

I am aware from the records that, if they changed their mind from the position they originally took up, they did so under duress.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Who is Deputy Barry's informant?

Comment on this

I think I have covered the ground opened in this debate to the best of my ability. I do not think I need deal specifically with everything every Deputy said over and above the survey I have tried to make of the speeches made. They will be carefully studied in the Department of Agriculture and the suggestions offered examined carefully, with a view to determining how they can be availed of to improve the services.

I think I should end by reaffirming that it is not within the power of the Minister for Agriculture, however well intentioned, to increase the output, to increase the numbers of cattle, sheep or pigs, nor can he increase the gallonage of milk. The only people who can do that are the farmers on the land. It is my duty to bring within their reach all the facilities requisite to do these things, if the farmers are prepared to do them. I freely concede that my own reputation rests on the ability or will of the Irish farmers to do just that, given the opportunity and the facilities required. If I am wrong, other methods are appropriate, and these have been outlined on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party by Deputy Smith in one of his frank and revealing speeches. His method was to tell the farmers that if they did not do the job there were plenty of inspectors supplied with plenty of money and machinery to burst open their gates and break down their ditches.

Comment on this

Laois-Offaly gave you the answer to all that.

Comment on this

I may be right and I may be wrong. As long as I am Minister, we shall trust the farmer to do the job, and I think, on the statistical material I have submitted to the House, we can assume that we may, with a reasonable measure of confidence, look forward to the farmers of this country resolving the fundamental economic problems of our community by expanding production and providing the wherewithal to purchase the essential imports we must have, if an appropriate standard of living is to be provided for all our people.

Comment on this

It is better than going past a graveyard.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 60
·
Níl 72
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?