We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 10—General (Resumed).

Contributions 134–297 of 297. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

There might not be so much "hear, hear," when I am finished with these boys. Deputy MacBride chose the words "action of the Government in ensuring." Is the Deputy now maintaining that it was the action of the Government, in view of the fact that the Minister for Finance admits that it is something over which he has no direct control?

Is Deputy MacBride still of opinion that the Minister for Finance went down to the bankers, held a gun to their heads and said: "You are not to follow the bank rate in Britain," so that Deputy MacBride could say: "Good man, Mr. Sweetman; that is the right policy"? What has happened to the Minister since? What is the reason for the change? If action was taken then, why is it not taken now? Perhaps Deputy MacBride will enlighten us later on. Perhaps he maintains the Minister should have ensured by some Government action that the rate of interest would have remained as it was and not again have followed the British bank rate.

Comment on this

Did it follow the recent increase in Britain?

Comment on this

From what we see in the public Press, it appears that the bank rate in this country is about to increase again.

Comment on this

Of course it is.

Comment on this

I have quoted Deputy MacBride and no doubt he appears very willing to enlarge on his outlook on this matter. I have this question to put. I could give quotations from the Minister for Education, Deputy MacBride, Deputy Costello, Junior, and the Tánaiste whom I have quoted previously. Surely, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, the time has come for the younger members, at least, of the Coalition group to wake up to the fact that they are being codded? No doubt some of them entered political life with ideas, but I am afraid they have been disillusioned on that side of the House, and disillusioned by their elders, particularly by the Minister for Agriculture.

Replying to the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon made that famous statement of his to the House on the 1st December, 1953. He was criticising the interest rate, which was not as high as that paid on this Government's last loan. The present Minister for Agriculture said:—

"Why did we ever go to the country to seek a loan at 5 per cent.? The most abandoned banana republic in South America could raise money at less than that..."

Am I, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, a member of an abandoned banana republic? If I were a member of an abandoned banana republic on the 1st December, 1953, what, in the name of goodness, kind of republic am I a member of now?

Comment on this

One without any bananas—no bananas.

Comment on this

I would say one of sour grapes.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary got enough sour grapes in Leix-Offaly to last him for a long while. The Minister for Agriculture was not satisfied with his quotation, because evidently he remembered what he had said back in 1952. He always seems to pick December for making fantastic statements. "If winter comes can spring be far behind"? Speaking in this House on the 4th December, 1952, he said:—

"I can assure Deputy Dr. Browne that the day of borrowing at 5 per cent. has gone, and gone for ever."

Comment on this
A Deputy

And so is Deputy Dr. Browne.

Comment on this

How now, Dr. Browne, and how now, Deputy O'Leary; it is "gone for ever"? Or had Deputy MacEntee's appalling Budget created all this hedging? Remember, the date was the 4th December, 1952, long after the damage had been done by the appalling Deputy MacEntee. However, remember, the Minister for Agriculture was in good company. He had the Minister for Education, Deputy Mulcahy. Deputy Mulcahy was good. He waxed eloquent. "The latest blow," he said, "that the Minister has struck at our economy is the launching of a £20,000,000 loan at 5 per cent."

Comment on this

We got the £20,000,000.

Comment on this

You spent £24,000,000.

Comment on this

What did the present Government get? They got "sweet Fanny Adams," to borrow an expression used by Deputy Lemass on a previous occasion here. But the Taoiseach entered into the controversy. There was no controversy in the eyes of the Coalition speakers—no, no, they went all over the country and there is no doubt about it, they fooled the unfortunate gullible people. I think some people believed Deputy Briscoe was getting a cut out of the Government interest rates.

Deputy Costello, the present Taoiseach, betook himself to Athy, and is quoted in the Leinster Leader of 8th May, 1954. This was just before we got the hammer and he said: “An instance of the kind of Government that Fine Gael will not have is the high rate of interest paid for their borrowing by the present Government. There will certainly be a change of policy here”. Of course he was right —but the change was in the wrong direction. As I said, and it impressed me deeply, my description of the Government is this: if the Government would give us the red light, the people of the country would halt. If they would give us the green light, we would know to go ahead. But we are in a valley of indecision. They cannot make up their minds for a year before they go forward. So it is the amber Government—“Forever Amber.” That was banned and this Government will be banned too. The Minister for External Affairs, speaking in this House on the 6th May, 1955, said: “We said when the loan was floated at 5 per cent. that it was bad financial policy and bad economic policy”. Does the Parliamentary Secretary, whom I see nodding his head, now agree?

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

Yet the Coalition floated a £20,000,000 issue at 98½ on the interest rate of 5 per cent. What has the Parliamentary Secretary to say about that? They are very quite now. The Minister for Social Welfare decided to take a little interest in this matter too and according to the Enniscorthy Echo the Minister for Social Welfare made an extraordinary statement when he said: “The difficulty seems to be that the money is not available”. The Labour Party did not seem to be very troubled about that at all; the Minister for Social Welfare said that the money should be made available by the Government and under its control the Government should have power to create and control credit.

Then in Letterkenny the Taoiseach, according to the Irish Times, said on the 26th April, 1954, that he was opposed to large loans at an artificially high rate of interest and he favoured rather private capital investment. As I have stated, the Tánaiste was concerned in this question too. On May 5th, 1955, when they were basking in the reflected glory of what they had done on the banking institute in this country and visualising Mr. Sweetman driving down in a State car to the court of the Bank of Ireland—where he announced to the various banking interests that the time had come when something had to be done by Government action about high artificial rates of interest—As had something to say. As reported in Volume 150 of the Dáil Debates at column 879 on May 5th, 1955, the Tánaiste expressed himself in this way:—

"The Government because of its stability; because the people know its policy; because the people know it can be trusted, is able to borrow money at a lower rate of interest than that at which the Fianna Fáil Government was able to borrow it in 1952 and 1953."

That was the Tánaiste's idea and at least he was consistent. In Volume 130, exactly 20 volumes earlier, we have him saying——

Comment on this

You must have the whole library there.

Comment on this

As reported in Volume 130, column 218, of the 21st March, 1952, we had the Tánaiste speaking. There was some interruption from Deputy Major de Valera and Deputy Seán Collins had something to add.

The Tánaiste then asked Deputy Major de Valera:—

"Is the Deputy suggesting that we can only get loans provided somebody pays 5 per cent. on them?"

Deputy Major de Valera replied:—

"I am serious. Where is the money to come from ultimately? You cannot just go on printing bank notes. We would like to hear the Deputy on the financing of such things."

Deputy Norton, as he then was, said:—

"I am afraid that Deputy Major de Valera has shown a rather shallow approach to this whole problem of agriculture. I do not propose to waste any more time on him."

The Tánaiste then went on to give a dissertation. He was speaking on the Estimate for Finance and he went on to speak about agriculture. You might as well have Deputy Briscoe talking about agriculture as the Tánaiste.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This does not arise on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I am referring to what the Tánaiste said on this occasion and I am trying to impress on the House what his attitude was.

The Tánaiste then said as reported in the same volume at column 219:—

"If the small farmer has not got money he can procure it by borrowing. Clearly he can only borrow from the State and the State should and could raise the money and lend that money to the farmer. It can go further and lend that money to the farmer at a nominal rate of interest."

Has the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government anything to say about that? The Tánaiste further said:—

"Other countries have done the same thing and if they can do it why cannot we? The State can do anything it wishes. It can borrow money at a certain rate of interest and lend it to the farmer at a lower rate of interest and repay the difference out of State funds. There is nothing, however, to prevent the State creating money for the purpose of lending it to the farmer and when the farmer repays the money the State creation of the money is cancelled."

I can assure the Tánaiste that when the honest Irish farmer gets his hands on the Labour Party they will not have much more talk. There will be a repetition of what happened in Leix-Offaly.

In his first Budget the Minister for Finance used a famous cliché about "increased productivity." I would like somebody on the Government side of the House to tell us exactly what they mean by "increased productivity." Let us take the specific case of the dairy farmer. The Minister for Agriculture has urged the dairy farmer to go in for increased productivity. He used again the old catch cry of "One more cow, one more sow, one more acre under the plough", but there were never fewer cows, sows or acres under the plough than there are at present. At the same time as the Minister for Agriculture was urging the dairy farmer to increase productivity he tells him that the has priced himself out of the export market and out of chocolate crumb. In spite of what Major General Costello says to-day, and while the Minister for Agriculture is urging the dairy farmer to increase production, we find in the Estimate for his Department that he has reduced by £1,000 the provision for subsidising creamery butter, should that be necessary.

The Government have failed miserably; they do not know whether they are coming or going. Fortunately, the public have at last woken up to that fact—at least, the people they misled in the last election. Undoubtedly, the Government have not given any indication of what they are going to do in connection with the question of State expenditure. The Minister for Finance does give four lines to it. After two years the Minister for Finance now wakes up to the fact that he might set up a type of commission to investigate the whole administration of the Civil Service. Last night, Deputy Finlay used some figures, which he corrected later—it is very easy to make a mistake in these figures and I am not referring to that—in which he attempted to point out that the Government had 3,000 fewer civil servants.

In actual fact, the figures are that, in 1947, there were 31,179 civil servants in this country. Then the Coalition took office, and at the end of the Coalition period, we had 33,975. These figures are taken from a reply given to a parliamentary question and they are in the Dáil Debates. In 1948, the figure was 32,171; in 1949, 33,472; in 1950, 33,975. In regard to 1952, we were back again at the time. The first available figures for the 1st January, 1954, were given by the present Minister in reply to a question by Deputy Jack Lynch, and they showed that, on that date, there were 33,657 civil servants at a cost of £14,000,000. Therefore, from January, 1939, to January, 1952, the number of civil servants in this State has, in fact, increased by 9,800.

I tried to obtain from the Central Statistics Office to-day the figures as on the 1st January, 1955, and on the 1st January, 1956, but they were not available. However, they are available to anyone who will go through the Book of Estimates and add up, as I have done, the numbers in every Government Department, established and unestablished, and he will arrive at an approximate figure. In fact, he will arrive at the actual figures, if his addition is careful. I have arrived at the figure that there were approximately 294 established civil servants in 1955 more than there were in 1954, and approximately 250 unestablished civil servants. This would mean, in fact, that, in one year, the Coalition Government have increased the Civil Service by some 500, and the Estimates for 1956-57 show a provision for nearly another 300 in excess of that figure again. So that there is no question about it that the Government is not serious in its efforts to reduce expenditure at the top.

Comment on this

I wonder would the Deputy say do these figures include people like postmen, forestry workers, Gardaí and soldiers, or is it exclusive of those?

Comment on this

The source of my information, as I say, is that I have gone for several hours through as much information as I could possibly get in regard to established and unestablished officers of the State.

Comment on this

Would it include foresters, for instance?

Comment on this

There is quite a big number in the Department of Lands, but actually it is rather noticeable that there is not a very substantial increase in the Department of Lands so far as the number of workers is concerned. In fact, it would be a matter for congratulation if the number of workers in the Department of Lands had increased, but, unfortunately, that is not the position.

One could speak at length on this question of Government expenditure and one could go through the Estimates and point out the various things which possibly could be reduced. I think it is a most serious problem to confront any Government at the present time, and so serious is it that I would like to quote from the Irish Independent. It is not usual for anyone on this side of the House to quote the Irish Independent but I suppose the devil quotes Scripture for his own purpose.

In Volume 150, column 999, Deputy Seán Flanagan is reported as having said:—

"On the 2nd October, 1954, in a leading article headed ‘Two Major Problems', the editor said: ‘What we feel bound to stress is that the great majority of those who returned the present Government to power were mainly influenced by the assurance of strong measures to cope with both the cost of living and the alarmingly high rate of State expenditure.'"

Certainly that is a departure from some of the previous leading articles in the same newspaper and, if I might say so, they were very constructive remarks by the editor at that time.

On the 12th May, 1955, just a year ago, in Volume 150, column 1411, the Taoiseach is reported as having stated:—

"It is on those principles we intend to continue operating. That is clearly stated here in our policy. We will eliminate extravagance. So far as possible we will cut public expenditure and by a suitable production policy, and not just mere talk about production, we will bring about a situation whereby the national income will be increased and the real wealth of the country will be increased. We hope we will be able to reduce taxation and yet get a better revenue yield; and that better revenue yield will help us to reduce taxation still further and, at the same time, give to our people those benefits we wish to confer on them."

That is a most contradictory statement in so far as it is completely at loggerheads with the recent Budget statement and the first Budget statement of the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy give us his own mind now.

Comment on this

We then had the Taoiseach on the cost of government and he also got back to his pet point of the effect of high interest rates on borrowing by local authorities.

The Taoiseach got back to that again a column later when he said:—

"Was it by chance that when the Minister for Finance floated his loan last autumn at a lower rate of interest than that which obtained when the former Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, floated his loan, that that loan was fully subscribed? The response to that loan showed that the country had confidence in the Minister for Finance and in his policy. It showed also the determination of this Government to reorientate downwards the cost of Government borrowing. It underlined the distinction between the policy of the Government and the policy of the last Government.

"The last Government acted on the policy of dearer money. We demonstrated by a reduction in the rate of interest on that loan, which has proved so successful and which has gone to a premium since, that this country was creditworthy and could get better terms from the public and the people did give their savings to this Government at a lower rate of interest than they were prepared to give it to the last Government. That was an outstanding tribute, from the people who lent their savings, to the present Minister for Finance and to his policy.

"That policy of keeping down prices, keeping down both the cost of government and the cost of living, was also emphasised when we took the decision, in conjunction with the banks, not to increase the bank rate here this year. It was emphasised that we would deal with these matters by reference to our economy— we weighed and tested them by that and by nothing else."

The Government, indeed, ought to be ashamed of themselves. We, on this side of the House, have consistently agreed that it is outside sources which govern the rate of interest to a very large extent. However, in the final analysis, it is the man in the street who proves or disproves the fact that a loan is not successful. The greater proportion of a public loan, outside of the banks, the insurance companies, the other big bodies, is subscribed by the smaller man, the man who subscribes £500 and upwards. The failure of the loan to succeed, as the Leader of the Opposition said, was a very regrettable occurrence from the point of view of the future economy of the State, but when it did fail, and fail in such a fashion, it was time that the Government should have resigned and not wait for Leix-Offaly to give them a decision also. They had a political and a financial verdict of the people of the country.

I could speak on Government expenses all day. I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is present. I was hoping to have got in for Vote No. 9 for his Department.

Comment on this

It is a pity you did not.

Comment on this

It discloses a very important feature. If this is any criterion——

Comment on this

Have a go at it now.

Comment on this

If this particular item is any criterion of Government expenditure it is no wonder how the spending and the control of money generally by Government Departments is carried out. In Volume 166 Deputy Blaney put down a question——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not discuss that.

Comment on this

The Deputy proposes to give an example of Government expenditure and to quote one particular instance.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputies were allowed to give small examples like that, we could go on for ever. The Deputy admits that he failed to raise the matter on the proper Estimate so he cannot be allowed to raise it now.

Comment on this

We had a building of 375 sq. feet erected——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy is allowed to raise that question, others will seek to discuss similar matters.

Comment on this

This is very ungrateful of the very people who asked to have this thing done.

Comment on this

A couple of rooms cost as much as a drawing room of Buckingham Palace.

Comment on this

It was built to facilitate the Opposition.

Comment on this

We put it up for tender and did it cheaper ourselves.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Malley is to get back to the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

You want something else out at the front gate now.

Comment on this

There are some points which I would like to bring to the notice of the Minister and which are non-contentious. One of them is the tobacco tax. Would it be possible to give vouchers for tobacco to the old age pensioners? It would not cost very much. The loss of revenue from the old age pensioners would be negligible. Would the Parliamentary Secretary bring that matter to the notice of the Minister?

Comment on this

I have not a clue about it, but I will look into it.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary may not have a clue about it, but a lot of old age pensioners will not have an ounce of clue or any other sort of plug out of it. Five pence an ounce to them is a very heavy impost.

The Parliamentary Secretary has received representations from the taxi drivers of Dublin. It is not for me to make representations on behalf of that body but, generally speaking, the hackney men throughout the State are in a very bad way and would it not be possible to give them a basic allowance per month? They are in a frightful situation—and the Parliamentary Secretary knows it well—since the drive yourself cars came into operation. They are fighting for their existence and many of them have gone out of business. The Minister should consider giving them a basic allowance of 100 gallons per month and anything in excess of that could be paid for at the full rate of duty. I raise these few matters in the hope that the Minister will give them consideration particularly in view of the fact that the loss of revenue to the State will be very small indeed.

Generally speaking, the Book of Estimates shows that there is an increase under the majority of the headings. There is an increase in nearly every single item. I think I have quoted sufficiently to show that the Government will now have to revise its policy. Someone could have interrupted there, as people are so fond of interrupting, and asked: "What would you have done?" It is not for us to answer that question. The people over there are the Government and it is for them to say what should be done. It was very clearly stated by both Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Lemass that no further increases in taxation would take place after 1953.

Comment on this

It lay lightly on the land at that time.

Comment on this

One of the solutions put forward by the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Defence to remedy the dire straits in which we found ourselves was private enterprise. The Tánaiste, speaking in this House, as reported in Volume 130, column 212, said:—

"One has only got to look at the import figures in order to realise the enormous quantities of imports which are still coming into this country... Many of the defects, from the standpoint of not having these commodities produced at home, have been due to a pathetic reliance on what is called private enterprise to produce these commodities. We can see clearly now, having given the experiment a trial for 30 years, that private enterprise will not go into the manufacture of these commodities unless it is assured of dividends from the start. That is not possible except in rare instances. The State will have to find other and more efficacious methods of establishing industries to manufacture the goods which are imported unless, of course, we are perfectly satisfied to sit down here for another 30 years and see what the volume of these goods will be 30 years hence."

"Unless the State is prepared to come in and use its powers up to the limit to assist in the establishment of industries at home... we will be talking of industrial development here for the next generation."

That was the Tánaiste's and Minister for Industry and Commerce's idea of private enterprise on 21st March, 1952. In May, 1954, he and the Labour Party criticised private enterprise and gave promises of what they would do; and the first point on the Labour Party programme was the nationalisation, if you please, of the flour milling industry, so very dear to Deputy O'Leary's heart.

Comment on this

And the Avoca mines.

Comment on this

One of the first questions I put down in this House was to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce if it was his intention to nationalise the flour milling industry. I got one single word by way of reply: "No". Speaking here again in March, 1952, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Norton, said at column 214:—

"Cement is a commodity that obviously ought to be nationalised. Cement should be made available to our people without their having to pay the ransom they are paying in the form of dividends to-day. Why should not flour milling be nationalised? Why should the milling of flour to produce bread for our people be a source of substantial remuneration to those who lend money to the flour milling industry? I would nationalise flour milling to-morrow if I had my way."

Comment on this

So would I.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste has his way now as Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

Time enough yet.

Comment on this

Who has his way over there? No one seems to know who actually is what. In my opinion there was one very significant occurrence in relation to the Budget. The Minister for Finance referred very briefly in his Budget statement to increased social benefits. Is it correct that the Minister for Finance refused to announce here the increase in social service benefits as Fine Gael Minister for Finance and left it to be announced next day to the people by a Labour Minister?

Comment on this

Left it to the Minister concerned.

Comment on this

Left the announcement, awaited eagerly by the people, to be made by Deputy Corish, Minister for Social Welfare. Is it a fact that at this long drawn out Cabinet meeting the Minister for Finance threw up his hands and was going to pitch the whole lot to hell, so to speak?

Comment on this

Or to Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Is it true that a compromise had to be arrived at? Is it true that the Minister for Finance said the Labour Party would no longer hold the gun to his head and, if they did not like it, they could lump it and that it was his opinion that they should go to the electorate and declare a general election and, if they had any conscience, they would? Are not these things true? Was not the Taoiseach in favour of a general election as well? Were not the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance in favour of holding a general election on the night Leix-Offaly was declared?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Suppose the Deputy comes now to the Financial Motion.

Comment on this

I would like to quote.

Comment on this

What was that the Deputy said about quotations generally when he started?

Comment on this

It is by repetition I am trying to drive it home. I am not allowed to repeat, but I would remind the Parliamentary Secretary:—

"That's the wise thrush; he sings each song twice over,

Lest you should think he never could recapture,

The first fine careless rapture."

At column 268 of Volume 131, 23rd April, 1952, the present Minister for Finance, then Deputy Sweetman, said:—

"What has outraged the country is the cynical disregard by Fianna Fáil for their election promises—the cynical disregard by them of the statements and the speeches which they made in this House prior to the last general election and during the three years of the inter-Party Government's régime. They are now in the position of having been hoisted with their own petard. They campaigned around the country during the whole of last May and they got their canvassers in every town, village and rural area to say that, if Fianna Fáil were the Government, there would be a reduction in the cost of living. The leaders were careful not to say too much in that respect from the public platforms."

Then the Minister for Finance stated, and I throw these words back at him:—

"If the members of the Government, and the Taoiseach himself, are sincere and honest in saying that they believe the people will stand behind them in this Budget there is a way in which they can test that belief without very much delay."

I would like to say that the Labour Party are very worthy representatives outside.

Comment on this

There is never more than one of them in the House.

Comment on this

The shadow Minister for Finance, Deputy O'Leary. Deputy James Larkin makes very eloquent speeches and gets reported quite appreciably in the national papers, but he makes very few speeches of any consequence in this House. He made a rather important one when he addressed the Dublin Regional Council of the Labour Party on 10th February of this year. He said, speaking about the Party he supports:—

"The inter-Party Government will soon be two years in office, but it has not yet put forward any major proposal for basic changes in economic or financial policy."

Then Deputy Larkin, who goes through the Lobby to support this Government, went on to say:—

"The urgent need for action is clear to all, particularly in view of the banks' decision to increase the bank rate, the crisis in the building trade as a result of financial conditions, and continuing difficulty in securing adequate financial facilities for much needed industrial and agricultural employment. The workers' living standards are being imperilled."

That was Deputy Larkin's attitude outside the House, but here it is very noteworthy that he is silent in his support of the Government.

The other matter I want to refer to is that in the Estimates for Local Government there is, in spite of the avowed intention of all sections supporting the Coalition Government to speed the housing drive, a sum of £25,000 less for the provision of new and reconstructed houses. It is no answer to say that in certain specific areas the housing position is nearing a solution. There is £25,000 less in the Estimate for that Department. This is very ominous, and never for a great number of years were there so many unemployed in the building industry as there are at the present time. We had the Tánaiste—I have no doubt as to his sincerity—going to the United States of America to seek industry for this country.

Comment on this

To raise the wind.

Comment on this

Or to attract industrialists to come here. I have no doubt whatever that he considered what he was doing was in the interests of the nation and a matter which should occupy his attention. But while he was away looking for new industries the greatest industry in this country, giving the most employment, was collapsing. That is the building industry. A very great percentage of the skilled tradesmen have departed for Britain and elsewhere, and will be lost to us for ever, due to the Government's policy, or lack of policy, and their indecision with particular respect to the question of granting financial assistance to the Dublin and Cork Corporations.

That figure of £25,000 which mainly goes towards the reconstruction and grants for new houses by private individuals might be acceptable to a certain extent, perhaps, but when we come to the huge item of assistance for housing authorities in the solution of housing of the working classes there is nearly £1,000,000 cut by the Minister for Local Government and by this Government. I beg your pardon, the actual figure in the cut in the grants to local authorities is £100,000. It is a decrease of £99,995 for the year 1956-57.

Comment on this

Has any grant been refused?

Comment on this

Dublin Corporation

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe, no doubt, will be well able to see to the affairs of the Dublin Corporation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe failed to discuss that matter before and I suggest that Deputy O'Malley should not try.

Comment on this

Deputy Donegan asked what he deemed to be a most pertinent question: have any loans been refused?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is administration pure and simple.

Comment on this

I submit that it is financial policy of the Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

By repeating "financial policy" at intervals does not make a speech relevant. If, as the Deputy says, grants are not being paid that is pure administration and cannot be tagged on or in any way related to the Budget.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I should like to ask the Chair to rule on this. Legislation is apparently part of Government policy, and if the Government has refrained from introducing legislation to make such payments legal——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is not going to rule on a hypothesis for anybody.

Comment on this

Legislation is there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is not going to rule on hypothesis.

Comment on this

This is not hypothesis.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Malley on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy O'Sullivan, took a little advice from his leaders at times the position of the country might be better.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary might not be so discourteous or unmannerly.

Comment on this

I would seek better advice than yours if I were looking for it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Order!

Comment on this

The question I would like to raise is the position regarding the increase in cigarettes and petrol, which has been passed over very quietly by speakers on the Government side of this House. Do they forget that beer is costing the public more since they came into office, that cigarettes have previously been increased and that, in fact, this is the second increase to the man in the street?

Comment on this

What about wages?

Comment on this

We will come to that in a second. We are dealing with tobacco and beer now.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to get you off prices. She is a great authority on them.

Comment on this

I want to keep him on prices.

Comment on this

Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll would not get me off anything.

Comment on this

How right you are.

Comment on this

Deputy Larkin, in Volume 130——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

By way of indication to the Deputy as to the attitude of the Chair: the Deputy is making extensive quotations. A Deputy's speech is his own contribution to the debate, and not a series of quotations.

Comment on this

Am I to take it, Sir, with respect that I am not entitled to quote at length?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I did not say that, but the Deputy has quoted three or four times since I came into the Chair.

Comment on this

Where, Sir, with respect, is the line of demarcation?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That lies with me. We will not have a series of quotations with nothing more.

Comment on this

It is very uncomfortable material for the Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy means that as a suggestion that the Chair is favouring the Government, he will withdraw it immediately and unreservedly.

Comment on this

I will withdraw it unreservedly, and I will withdraw from the House, in disgust.

Comment on this

I am afraid that I will probably be considerably duller than Deputy O'Malley. On the Budget proper, there is not very much that I wish to say. It was obvious that the increases in social welfare benefits, the increases in wages and salaries of State employees, were bound to lead to an increase in taxation. Likewise, it was inevitable in the present situation that the general administration costs should rise and accordingly the Government were faced with the task of raising additional revenue. The Budget is a tough Budget, a tough Budget inasmuch as it had to provide for the additional moneys to meet the increases in wages, and to meet the increases in social welfare benefits. But although it was a tough Budget, the method of raising revenue, I think, was probably the most equitable one that could be found. Naturally, it is never popular for a Government to have to increase taxation.

There continues to appear in the Budget, or rather in the Estimates, a number of anomalies, anomalies which have persisted for a very long time. Possibly the most striking one is the continuance of a very high rate of expenditure on roads. When I say a high rate of expenditure on roads, I mean a high rate of expenditure on roads in comparison with other types of productive investment. We spend approximately £10,500,000 on our roads, as compared with £1,500,000 on forestry. I think that that probably arises from a long-standing misconception that road work provides additional employment. We should have realised by now that the amount of additional employment provided by road work is negligible. The labour content in road work is small and it is a pity that there is not a better assessment of the labour contents of different public works.

I have, I think, on a number of occasions asked the Taoiseach to seek to have a comparative analysis made of the labour contents which exist in the different types of public works undertaken by the Government. An analysis of that kind would be useful to have. It would enable the Government and this House to examine the capital expenditure programme of the Government in relation to employment and to the return on expenditure.

Probably the most welcome thing contained in the Budget statement was the announcement by the Minister for Finance that he proposed to have a careful examination made of the efficiency and the cost of Government administration. I hope that this announcement was not merely a pro forma announcement, but that it is an indication that the Minister for Finance and the Government intend seriously to examine the whole position of Government administration in the country. I have no quarrel with the number of civil servants that are employed by the State. They probably are necessary. I am far from happy, however, as to the efficiency of the Civil Service machine generally. I think that the time is long past when we should have had a thorough examination of the administrative machine of Government. The Civil Service machine, I think, is defective in many ways. The system of recruitment, the system of promotion within the Civil Service, the system of responsibility in the Civil Service, while possibly necessary in some respects, leads to a great deal of inefficiency. I hope that the Minister for Finance in carrying out his examination of the administrative machinery of Government will examine it from that point of view as well as from the point of view of economy.

I cannot help feeling that one of the serious dangers, one of the serious problems, that face democratic Government in this State is the continued unchecked growth of bureaucracy. Apart from the fact that this unchecked growth of bureaucracy is in itself damaging to the democratic concept of Government, it also leads to a very considerable degree of inertia. Before it is possible to get anything done, a proposal has to pass from one Civil Servant to another, from one file to another, and considerable delays occur—delays that lead to inefficiency on the one hand and that are also fairly costly from the point of view of public administration. I hope the indication given by the Minister for Finance is a serious one and that he intends to tackle this question energetically, with the energy of which he is quite capable and that he will not allow any other considerations to delay or to make him relent in his decision to carry out this overhaul of the Civil Service machine.

Turning to the Budget statement generally, in so far as it relates to the economic position of the country, there is nothing new in the Budget statement. Due to the lack of a definite economic policy on the part of both the Government and Fianna Fáil it is not surprising that the Budget statement should not contain anything very new or positive. It was largely a repetition of many of the usual tags that emanate from the Department of Finance. Members of the Opposition have criticised members of both the Labour Party and Clann na Poblachta for supporting the present Government. The reason, as far as I am concerned and as far as Clann na Poblachta is concerned, is a simple one. We are not in agreement with everything the Government does, and possibly we have been criticising it more for the things it does not do, but we regard this Government as being a much better Government than Fianna Fáil would have been in similar circumstances. It is quite a simple attitude which I think is easily understandable.

I have no doubt that had there been a Fianna Fáil Government in office and had Deputy MacEntee been the Minister for Finance he would have attacked the food subsidies and intensified his pursuit of a deflation policy. We had experience of that before. Furthermore, as far as the Opposition is concerned, it is very hard to detect from their speeches what is their real policy because they speak with two completely different voices. However, I am not going to go into long quotations but I think anyone who has read the speeches of the different members of the Front Bench of Fianna Fáil in the last year or so will realise that there is a wide chasm which apparently exists amongst the leaders of the Party in regard to economic policy.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

Before passing from that aspect I should like to refer briefly to the employment position. In the midst of the atmosphere in regard to the economic position of the country generally, there has been a tendency to overlook what, to my mind, is the most important indication of the economic position and that is the employment and the unemment position in the country. Indeed, many of the speakers from the Fianna Fáil Benches have, both inside and outside this House, painted a completely untrue picture of the position in regard to unemployment. The position was that in May, 1953, we had 81,000 unemployed in the State. We have 63,000 unemployed this year. That is far too high a figure but I think it is well that these figures should be appreciated.

Comment on this

How many were there last year?

Comment on this

We had 62,000, but when Fianna Fáil was in power in 1953 we had 81,000. When the inter-Party Government was in office in 1951 we had brought that figure down to 54,000.

Comment on this

How many were there in 1949?

Comment on this

In 1951, when the inter-Party Government were in office, it went down to 54,000, but by the time the Minister for Finance in the Fianna Fáil Government pursued his deflationary policy in 1953 it had gone up to 81,000. I think it is well that these figures should be remembered. Unfortunately, some members of this House are seeking to mislead the people in regard to these actual figures.

Comment on this

You are doing your best to do it.

Comment on this

I do not know if Deputy Derrig is challenging the accuracy of the figures but, if so, he can look them up himself.

The difficulty I find in discussing the Budget statement and the economic policy generally in this House is that both the Government and the Opposition seem to lack a definite economic programme or a definite economic policy. In addition, there is a lack of an objective appraisal of the causes for the balance of payments difficulties. Very largely, we have been going on very false premises. The first fault I have to find is that the adverse balance of trade situation which we are experiencing is nothing new. We have always had an adverse balance of trade except in exceptional circumstances. The balance of trade position from our point of view is structurally adverse.

It is only in times of war, in times when we are unable to obtain supplies we require, that we have a favourable balance of trade. That does not in any way minimise or retract from the very real problem which faces our economy but I think it is necessary that we should realise that the adverse balance of trade which exists, and has existed for the last few years, is not new. It has always existed in our economy. What are the causes for the present balance of trade difficulties? The main cause I feel is that there has been a complete lack of objective analysis or appraisal of the various factors that have led to the increase in the adverse balance of trade.

I think there are roughly four causes. There is, firstly, the fall in agricultural production, and a fall in agricultural exports as a result. I am far from satisfied that the tentative explanation put forward by the Department of Agriculture is the correct one. Only in the course of the next few months will it be possible to assess whether the fall in agricultural exports has been balanced by an increase in the holding of cattle in the country.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy read the trade returns?

Comment on this

I wish I could be as certain as Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy read the statistics given by the Statistics Branch?

Comment on this

I have read all the statistics and they would indicate that there is a higher cattle population in the country than ever before. I am not quite certain to what extent these statistics represent the actual position in the country. We will have to wait a few months before coming to a definite conclusion that the fall in cattle exports has been offset by an increase in the cattle population. That is a matter which will come to light in the course of the next few months. The fall in agricultural exports and the fall in agricultural production generally is a separate problem. The problem undoubtedly requires to be dealt with, and dealt with objectively—much more objectively than we have ever attempted to deal with it.

That is only one of the factors. The second factor which contributes to the increase in the adverse balance of trade arises from the increase in wages, social benefits and other earnings. This is a factor which very few of us have cared to face but it is essential to face it. Any increase in wages, social welfare benefits and earnings, will inevitably lead to an increase in consumption and to an increase in the adverse balance of trade under present circumstances. Take the simple example. If you give an increase of 5/- a week in wages or social welfare benefits, at least 50 per cent. of that increase will be spent on goods that will have to be imported. In many cases, particularly if the increase is given to the lower income groups, it means an additional packet of cigarettes in the week, for which the tobacco has to be imported, or it means an additional pair of nylon stockings or some clothing or some material that has to be imported.

I think you can take it as axiomatic that, certainly as far as the first 10/- increase in wages is concerned, 50 per cent. of it is spent on the purchase of commodities that have to be imported; and to that extent, therefore, any increase in wages, any increase in profits or any increase in social welfare benefits, does affect the balance of payments position. That is one of the equations we have to face. As far as I am concerned, I do not think it matters very much, provided the Government and the Parliament have a definite economic programme and plan to deal with the situation which results from that increase in the adverse balance of payments position.

The third factor which contributes to the increase in the adverse balance of payments position arises from increased industrial employment. While I think there certainly has not been an increase in agricultural employment —there probably has been a marked decrease in the course of the last year —there has continued to be an increase in industrial employment. Again, the higher the number of people employed is, the more they will spend and the greater proportion of the money they will spend will inevitably be spent on commodities that have been imported. Therefore, you have to face the situation that the more people you employ, the higher will be your rate of imports. That is inevitable. The higher the wages, the higher the import rate will be. Those are two inevitable factors and two inevitable rules of our economy. I think we are inclined to ignore those rules in considering the general economy of the country. They are not new rules; they are rules which have been there ever since the State was founded and they will continue to be there until we are capable of increasing our own production to a much higher rate than we have been able to increase it so far.

The fourth factor which has led to the present situation is the unsatisfactory terms of trading. It is true that terms of trading have not been particularly unsatisfactory in the course of the last year, but they are endemically unfavourable to us originally, by reason of dual prices and various political reasons of that kind.

I feel that it would be useful to the House and to the country generally if a proper analysis and appraisal of these four factors were made, so that we could relate them to the exact increase in the adverse balance of trade position. Obviously, in that situation, there are two alternative remedies that can be followed. You can either cut down consumption, or you can increase production. If you want to cut down consumption, you can do it quite easily by reducing wages, reducing the standard of living of the people, and creating unemployment. The higher the unemployment figures, the better it is from that point of view. If you maintain unemployment at a sufficiently high rate, then the overflow of unemployment will emigrate and will cease to be a liability on your economy. That is one way of dealing with it. It is the way of dealing with it which, I think, has been pursued so far by the Central Bank and, I feel, by the Fianna Fáil Party, in the course of its last few years in office. You can in that way achieve a beautiful balance sheet, but it is the type of balance sheet and the type of policy which, I think, has laid the foundations for the growth and development of Communism in Europe in the earlier part of the century. I doubt if any responsible person will, on analysis, advocate the pursuance of that policy.

The other alternative is to increase production. Here, again, I think that most of our Parties have been somewhat unrealistic in dealing with this question. We all agree that production has to be increased and we all talk about the necessity for increasing production but beyond that we do not seem to be prepared to pursue any active policy in regard to it. I would like to give full credit to the Minister for Industry and Commerce for the attempt that he has been making, and which I hope will be successful, to bring about the creation of new industries here. In that connection, also, I think it is necessary to point out that there has been quite a substantial increase of industrial production in the country and in industrial exports. From that point of view, the industrial development aspect of our economy has been reasonably satisfactory. The rate of progress has been too low but at least it has been progressive.

The outstanding side of our economy is the agricultural side. There seems to have been no progress and, in fact, there seems to have been retrogression. What are the requirements for increased production? It seems to me that there are two requirements as far as agriculture is concerned—in the first place, increased investment in agriculture and, in the second place, better technical services and better land utilisation. That is where I am inclined to criticise the policy of the Government, particularly in regard to the question of investment. If investment is essential in order to ensure increased production, surely investment in agriculture should be encouraged, and not discouraged by imposing credit restrictions or increasing rates of interest.

Here, again, let me say that I am quite satisfied that the policy of the present Government has been a much more liberal policy in regard to the credit squeeze than the policy which would have been pursued by the Fianna Fáil Government if it had been in office. But I feel it is hardly logical to talk about the urgency of increased production if, at the same time, you are to pursue a credit restriction policy, if you are to pursue a credit squeeze at the same time.

Here, again, I want to give full marks and full praise to the Minister for Finance for the action which he took which resulted in the banks not increasing the bank rate on the first occasion on which it was increased recently. I am sorry he was unable to maintain that line in regard to the second increase in the bank rate which took place in England.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will tell us why?

Comment on this

I do not know. I am not in the Government. I assume that the banks put on a considerable amount of pressure and used a lot of arguments which may have had some weight or may not have had some weight. Not knowing the arguments they used, I am not in a position to express a view on that. I would have been much more satisfied had the bank rate not been raised. As Deputy MacEntee has thought fit to interrupt me on that issue, I can say that I have no doubt whatever that had he been in office, the bank rate would have been raised twice, judging from the attacks he made on the Minister for Finance when he took action to prevent the banks raising the bank rates.

Comment on this

I said that the Minister's gesture was a temporary one and a futile one.

Comment on this

The Deputy went much further. He made a full-blooded defence of the banks and said that it was outrageous to use any pressure on the banks to prevent them from raising the bank rate. Does the Deputy wish me to turn up his speech, because I read it very carefully?

Comment on this

Quote it. What I am really interested in is why the Minister surrendered instead of taking the advice of the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Minister did not consult the Deputy. He may have had reasons of his own. I do not know what reasons were advanced to him. From the point of view of the national economy, of our own development and of increased production, it would have been much better if the bank rate had not been increased. Whether the Minister was left in a position where he had discretion to increase it or not I do not know.

If production is to be increased we must be able to secure a higher rate of investment in agriculture. We can only do that if there is a sufficiently liberal credit policy pursued by the Government and by the banks. I do not know whether the Minister for Finance remembers the very constructive speech made by the Taoiseach on this matter at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis in February, 1953. Dealing with this very question of increased agricultural production, the Taoiseach, in the course of his speech, said: "The big factor in increasing agricultural production in Ireland is the utilisation and creation of improved capital facilities with steady interest rates." That is a perfectly sound statement.

Coupled with the need for increased credit facilities for the farming community is the question of improved land utilisation and improved technical facilities. If I may do so, though it may not be strictly within the confines of this particular debate, I would like to express my regret at the tremendous delays which have occurred in reaching any finality in regard to the proposed agricultural institute. I think it was as far back as 1949 or 1950 that I was able to secure the consent of the American authorities to the utilisation of the Grant Counterpart Fund for this purpose. Now this money has been available ever since 1950. We are now in the year 1956 and, beyond many controversies and many paper plans, we are still no nearer to the achievement of this institute, so essential if we are to secure an increase in agricultural production. I do not blame the Government or the Minister for that. If the Government is to blame, it is only partially to blame for it. Undoubtedly, many other interests have succeeded in confusing the issues and delaying the actual formation of this institute.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not discuss the institute in detail on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

It was by way of an aside. In dealing with the question of increased agricultural production, there are two essential requirements: firstly, added investment in agriculture and, secondly, added technical facilities. It seems to me that in regard to both of these we are making very little headway. The policy of the Government in regard to credit facilities, particularly for agriculture, has not been sufficiently progressive. While I blame the Government to a certain extent for that situation, I realise that the direct responsibility really rests with our banking system and that it is nearly impossible under modern conditions to influence and direct the economy of a country so long as credit and banking remain the prerogative of a small monopoly responsible to no one. That is the position of our present banking system.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is a small, noncompetitive monopoly responsible to no one and with, apparently, a very slight sense of national responsibility. Looking at the figures of the commercial banking returns for the December quarter, 1955, one finds that our so-called Irish banks invest in Irish Government investments only £17,000,000 whereas they invest in British Government investments £115,000,000. I merely mention that to indicate the measure of national responsibility which this small, noncompetitive monopoly displays.

Again, may I refer to the views put forward by the Taoiseach in the same speech at the Fine Gael Árd Fheis? I refer to it because I think it reflects the true position and I hope that, by referring to it, that may possibly remind the Government that there is an important task to be fulfilled in this field. Dealing with the banking system the Taoiseach said:—

"At the present time it is purely a monopoly although it has the appearance of being a private enterprise system. It reacts entirely in its policy to the policy from time to time pursued in Britain, a policy which is dictated by the British Government for British purposes related entirely to the conditions in Great Britain."

Further on, the Taoiseach went on to say:—

"The British Government induced the British banks to raise the bank rate and withdraw credits for the purpose of creating unemployment and discouraging production over a wide field of British industry in order to divert both capital and men to armaments and to their heavy industries. The Irish banks applied the same policy here, where conditions are quite different, where there is no rearmament and very little heavy industry. A system such as this cannot continue. Irish banking institutions can only flourish on Irish prosperity. At any rate they cannot continue to be used to take the savings of the Irish people to bolster up an outside economy, however vital the prosperity of that economy is to our external trade."

I think the time has come when the Government should seriously consider either extending the powers and functions of the Central Bank so as to enable it to issue credit and govern the credit policies of the commercial banks or take control by starting a commercial bank or by acquiring one of the existing commercial banks. There is nothing new or revolutionary in that. I think we are probably the only country in Europe which has not got a central bank which issues credit or which, at least, governs the credit facilities of the other banks. Our banking here is a most fantastic anomaly, an anomaly of an Irish banking system which invests mainly outside the country. It is completely noncompetitive and wasteful. In most towns in the country we have up to four or five banks, all of them imposing a policy of restriction in regard to credit. If the Government are not prepared on their own initiative to take these steps may I suggest that the time has come, and, indeed, is long past, when it would be desirable for them to set up a new banking commission to review the functions of our banking system in regard to credits?

In that connection I should like to draw the attention of the House to a report which was prepared by a number of American experts, businessmen and economists, at the request of the Government through the E.C.A. I do so, not because it says anything new, but merely because, being a report prepared by foreign experts, it may carry possibly more weight than my views with the House or with the Government. I am quoting from the Appraisal of Ireland's Industrial Potential which was prepared at the request of the Government in 1952. It says on page 20:—

"There is a similarly close linkage with the British financial system. Ireland's currency is directly tied to Great Britain's. Although the basic treaty with Britain provided that a separate and independent control over currency and banking should accompany the status of political independence, a banking commission appointed by Ireland's Minister of Finance in 1926 advised that the Irish currency be tied to the pound sterling with 100 per cent. reserve coverage and this arrangement adheres to the present day.

"This 1926 commission further considered the establishment of a Central Bank and decided that it was not feasible to do so at that time. When Ireland's Central Bank was constituted in 1942, it followed the established precedent of investing its Legal Tender Note Fund primarily in British Exchequer bills, with the rest of the 100 per cent. coverage provided by gold bullion, British legal tender currency and sterling balances on deposit in Great Britain or Northern Ireland.

"The manner in which legal tender notes in Ireland have been covered by investment of external assets is indicated in Table 21.

"The fact that the Central Bank has made no use of its statutory power to invest its legal tender reserves in Irish Government securities has handicapped the development of an active domestic capital market in Ireland which is one of the country's primary needs. The emphasis on complete liquidity that has led the Central Bank to invest so heavily in British Exchequer Bills at interest rates of a little over 1 per cent. as against long-term British Government securities with, perhaps, a 2 per cent. higher yield has represented an annual revenue loss to Ireland of, perhaps, £500,000.

"The commercial banking system of Ireland, as well, has shown a similar tendency to operate in a fashion that channels Irish deposit funds into the British capital market rather than retaining them in Ireland for domestic use, although this may reflect the choice of individual investors rather than bank initiative."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Might I interrupt the Deputy? I feel that in discussing the banking system the debate has been unduly widened, and that it should be raised on a separate motion rather than on this Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

Yes. It really arose as an extension of the discussion of credit policy and of the question of credit restriction, which, I think, has been discussed already in the course of the debate; but I appreciate that to go into it in greater detail would widen the debate too much.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

I regard these matters as vital, as, if we are agreed that the essential requirement is increased production, we must automatically take the steps necessary to increase production, namely, we must ensure a high rate of investment in our own agricultural and industrial potentials. I think, too, that possibly the Government and the Minister for Finance would be well advised to pay more attention to the view of international economists and international bodies that have been dealing with economic questions in Europe. It has been urged by them in recent times, recent months particularly, that the existence of deflationary pressures should not be allowed to reduce the rate of investment in agriculture and in industry. The same tendency on the part of different banking systems shows itself in different countries—the tendency to restrict credit, to impose a credit squeeze. The general view is that a credit squeeze, if it affects the rate of investment, is damaging to the economy; and in addition to that—and I think this is a very important thing to bear in mind—it is generally accepted by all responsible economists and by all responsible international economic bodies that credit restriction or credit squeeze will primarily affect the rate of investment rather than the rate of consumption.

There has been a great deal of discussion in the course of the last two years on these questions, and the unanimous conclusion reached by the O.E.E.C. and by the Economic Commission of the Council of Europe, as a result of fairly detailed study of that particular problem, is that credit restriction will primarily affect the rate of investment to a much higher degree than it will affect the rate of consumption, and therefore, by imposing credit restriction or credit squeeze you are really preventing investment, and not affecting very much the rate of consumption. Therefore, when it is a question of dealing with consumption, particularly consumption which results from imports, the best protective measures to adopt are direct measures against the imports, such as import levies or purchase tax.

What it seems to me we lack mainly —and this applies to both sides of the House and to the country as a whole— is a concrete economic programme. Ever since the State has been set up our economy has drifted under the influence of different economic theories and political considerations, but there has been no consecutive economic development programme followed. There have been partial programmes initiated, but there has been no overall consecutive economic programme pursued.

Our economy faces a great many serious problems, the structural defect in our balance of trade, the highly-abnormal and endemic rates of unemployment and emigration. These are huge problems that can only be dealt with if there is a constructive and definite economic programme planned over a period of years. Surely it should be possible at this stage to get a sufficient measure of agreement in this House to set up a national economic council, which would be charged with the task of formulating a ten year programme, a ten year programme which would not be deflected by political considerations. Such a programme would require to plan the annual rate of investment which was required for agriculture and the annual rate of investment required for industry. It should have definite targets to achieve in regard to both employment and production and also to secure a phased increase in national income.

Unless that is done, unless we can secure acceptance by all Parties in this House of a concrete, definite, economic programme over a period of, say, ten years, we shall continue to drift from year to year and to adjust our policies merely in the light of political considerations or in the light of temporary emergencies, as we have been doing for the last seven or eight years. I think the time has come when we should grow up and we should do as other countries—should agree on at least certain definite objectives. I think the trouble is that very often we do not even realise the extent of the problems we have to face, or if we do realise it, we tend to run away from them, or pretend we have illusory remedies for them.

I was glad in that connection to find a measure of agreement, at least, between the Minister for Agriculture and Deputy Lemass. The Minister for Agriculture is in favour of a five-year agricultural plan. Deputy Lemass is in favour of a five-year economic plan generally. At least, we have reached a stage where there is agreement as to the need for a plan. May I say that I think five years is far too short a period? Might I appeal to the Minister for Agriculture, who is here in the House and to Deputy Lemass, to extend their planning ideas into a much longer period than five years? I hope they will both persevere in the formulation of plans, but instead of having two or three different plans, I would rather see an economic council charged with the formulation of a plan. I feel that, to a certain extent, formulation of a plan of this kind is more a task for economists than for politicians. Politicians no doubt are necessary. It is necessary no doubt to consult them in regard to formulation of a plan of this kind, but it is essentially a task for economists.

In conclusion, I want to say one or two words in regard to savings. Again, in regard to savings, every succeeding Minister for Finance comes to the House and talks of the importance of savings but very little has been done. Again, I think there are some changes in the economic position of the world which are not taken into account. Naturally, with the extension of social welfare, the urge to save is reduced. You cannot get the same rate of savings as you got before. In addition to that, I think that our system of taxation does not lead to savings. On the contrary, it leads rather to the dissipation of savings and if savings are to be seriously encouraged, it would be necessary to alter the existing system of taxation radically.

It would be necessary to substitute, I think, more of a purchase tax, to tax purchases rather than to tax income. In that way you can provide an incentive to savings, but it is useless to keep on decrying the lack of savings, without facing these particular problems— without realising, in the first place, that the incentive to save which used to exist prior to the coming into effect of the welfare State has now ceased to operate, and that it is necessary to replace that incentive by a new incentive. The new incentive, I think, can be secured by altering the system of taxation. However, that is a much larger problem which I cannot possibly discuss now.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy indicate the main lines of the changes that he would suggest?

Comment on this

I do not think so on this discussion. I think it is worth thinking about. It is worth realising that the normal incentive to save which existed up to ten or 15 years ago has ceased to exist.

Comment on this

That is commonplace but we want a constructive suggestion.

Comment on this

I have been making one, if the Deputy would listen. I have been suggesting that one of the methods of replacing incentives to savings which used to exist would be to gradually transfer taxation to purchases rather than to income. In that way you would create a new incentive to savings which is lacking now, particularly in the situation where your money is continually depreciating. In connection with that, I wish Deputies of the House and newspaper writers and economists would remember this. We talk of this inflationary situation. First of all, we continually misuse the word "inflation" We use it on the one hand to describe a situation in which prices are going up in relation to the availability of goods, and, secondly, to describe a situation in which our balance of payments position is getting more difficult. The simple definition of inflation is that you have too much money chasing too few goods. That is the definition of the state of our economy at the present time. I am afraid I have been rather long and rather diffuse, but I felt I would just like to give these few views on our economic policy.

Comment on this

Many speakers have given their views on this Budget and a number of Fianna Fáil Deputies have given their definitions of it. I agree with the Minister's definition that this is a realistic Budget. I think it is also a courageous Budget. I think, in fact, that it is a Budget on which there has been very little disagreement in this House. I do not think that the Fianna Fáil approach to this discussion has been effective. In so far as criticism was concerned I think that the Fianna Fáil Party believe that in the Budget proposals which the Minister has put to the House he has approached the problems which confront this country in both a realistic and a courageous manner.

The Minister in his Budget statement pointed out the problems which confront the country and I think he summarised the dangerous tendencies which have become apparent in this country under five headings: that the balance of trade deteriorated; that savings dropped, despite the fact that there was an increase in money income; that consumption was outrunning production; that it was becoming difficult to raise adequate capital for national and local development and, finally, that there had been a fall in the deposits in commercial banks. The Minister made it clear that some of these tendencies which we are now facing had only become apparent in the last quarter of last year. He had already introduced certain proposals to deal with the unbalance of payments when he introduced the import levies some time ago, and the hire-purchase restrictions. In an effort to deal with the drop in savings he also introduced his proposals regarding the issue of new saving certificates, and the fourth measure, if it could be so described, to deal with the situation is the implement which presents itself to the hand of every Minister for Finance, and that is his annual Budget.

Deputy MacBride referred towards the close of his remarks, I think it was in reply to Deputy MacEntee, to the desirability of taxing expenditure rather than income. I think that Deputy MacEntee will agree that the Minister in this Budget has taxed controllable expenditure rather than income. During the course of this debate there have been, naturally enough, certain comparisons between the present Budget proposals and the Budget introduced by Deputy MacEntee in 1952. I may have a few remarks to make on that later, but for the moment I want to assert that, in fact, the Fianna Fáil Party are hard put to criticise the present Budget proposals or to disagree with the steps which the Minister has taken.

Deputy O'Malley when speaking this afternoon made the claim that it was not for Fianna Fáil to say what they would do; that the present Government was there and it was the responsibility of the Government. I do not disagree with that and I think the Government have faced up to their responsibilities in a cool, collected and courageous way. There have been no panic-stricken measures or anything of that nature, but I want to remind Fianna Fáil Deputies in particular that their deputy leader, Deputy Lemass, went on record only a couple of months ago as giving his views and, I presume, the views of Fianna Fáil on what the Budget proposals should be. He spoke in Mallow and was reported in the Irish Press on Wednesday, 14th March last under the heading, “Lemass Analyses National Economy”. In a sub-head in that report we are told that: “Our general aim will be to discourage consumption of non-essential goods which have to be imported”. I do not think there is any disagreement with regard to that.

I think the Fianna Fáil Party will accept that the proposals which the Minister has introduced in the Budget, the earlier proposals which he introduced by way of import levies, and even the hire purchase restrictions were aimed at securing that objective. What I find interesting is to compare that speech which Deputy Lemass made in March last with the Budget statement of the Minister. I think any Deputy reading Deputy Lemass's speech would have preferred that Deputy Lemass should have made this speech reported in the Irish Press of March 14th last, as his contribution to this Budget debate. I think Deputies would find in that speech the reason why we are claiming here that there is very little that Fianna Fáil could find to say against the present Budget proposals.

Deputy Lemass, and I am quoting from the speech to which I have referred, said that it would be necessary to lighten some existing taxes and raise others. He went on to say: "The taxes to be raised would be those which are bound to reduce the consumption of non-essential imported goods and the taxes to be lightened are those which are found to be restrictive in production." I think it will be agreed by the Deputies opposite that the two main imposts in the present Budget are fully designed to reduce consumption of non-essential imported goods and to that extent, in any event, I take it that Deputy Lemass will agree with the Budget proposals. I do not know whether Deputy MacEntee has stepped down in the ranks of the financial hierarchy of the Fianna Fáil Party and now differs from Deputy Lemass or not, but I assume that Deputy MacEntee with his experience, and his grasp of financial matters, will also agree with these proposals in the Budget.

Comment on this

I am waiting to hear which of the taxes were reduced.

Comment on this

I am talking about the taxes which were imposed and the objective which can be attained by these taxes. I will deal with Deputy MacEntee's point in a minute. Deputy Lemass went on, in his speech, to deal with economy and the necessity for cutting down expenditure and said: "The case for cutting down expenditure must be decided on the same basis. It must be clear that the disadvantages to the nation will not outweigh the saving."

I would like to refer Deputies to what the Minister had to say in his Budget statement in column 28 of the Dáil Debates of the 8th May. The Minister made it quite clear in his Budget statement that he was approaching the matter in the light of examining anything that had to be cut down. At column 29 he refers to a statement he made on the Vote on Account and says:—

"I made a comment that it would be shortsighted to seek a way out of our present difficulties by cutting down such investments as will yield early returns in terms of increased output of saleable goods."

Again, we find Deputy Lemass, before he found himself in the position of chief spokesman of the Fianna Fáil Party against this Budget, expressing the same idea as was expressed by the Minister in his Budget statement; and I think it was a very sound idea as expressed by Deputy Lemass; and again, I believe that is one of the reasons why Fianna Fáil find it difficult to criticise this Budget.

Deputy Lemass, later in this speech, referred to food subsidies. I propose to dwell on the topic of food subsidies for a while but, for the moment, I just want to let Deputy MacEntee and other Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party know what Deputy Lemass had to say with regard to the question of food subsidies, within the framework of a speech dealing with his views on what Budget proposals should aim at. He said:—

"Fianna Fáil has given a great deal of consideration to the possibility of introducing changes in administrative methods to secure a full return of work from public officials. Food subsidies must be accepted as likely to remain a permanent feature in the Estimates unless a very steep fall in the cost of living should take place, and that is not very likely, to put it mildly."

The Minister, in his Budget statement, made it quite clear that, as far as this Government were concerned, even a difficult budgetary situation was not going to be used as an excuse for further interfering with or reducing the food subsidies.

Deputy Lemass, in March last, when he was speaking in Mallow, had come to the point of view that food subsidies must be accepted as likely to remain a permanent feature in the Estimates. I think the House will welcome that expression of opinion from Deputy Lemass. It is not so very long ago since, in the atmosphere of Deputy MacEntee's 1952 Budget, Fianna Fáil Deputies, including Deputy Lemass, were expressing a somewhat different view with regard to food subsidies. I have a quotation here from a speech made by Deputy Lemass in this House on the 3rd April, 1952. which is reported in the Dáil Reports of that date at columns 1299-1300. Deputy Lemass then said:—

"I do not know if Deputies have ever considered these food subsidies to be a permanent arrangement. They were certainly never introduced—"

Comment on this

Is it in order for the Deputy to make a speech based on Press quotations?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is quite in order so long as the quotations are not unduly long.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been a quarter of an hour.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the Deputy is trying to blame this Budget on Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this

I do not know whether or not these quotations are embarrassing to Deputy Davern. They were not intended to.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy we are very proud of them.

Comment on this

I am simply expressing a certain measure of agreement with a speech that Deputy Lemass made recently, which I believe was a very sensible speech, a very sound one and which, to my mind, shows a large measure of agreement between the proposals which Deputy Lemass would have put into effect and the proposals put into effect by the present Minister for Finance. But there are certain points of difference.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy angling for an invitation?

Comment on this

I am leaving Deputy MacEntee out of it for the moment, but I dare say we will manage to get to the 1952 Budget before we finish. I was referring to Deputy Lemass's view, as expressed in March last, with regard to food subsidies, when he said:—

"This must be accepted as likely to remain a permanent feature in the Estimates unless a very steep fall in the cost of living should take place, and that is not very likely, to put it mildly."

I hope that Deputy Lemass's views will be accepted by the Fianna Fáil Party and I hope that the Fianna Fáil Party have now reached the conclusion that they were wrong to interfere with the food subsidies and that, as far as their future policy is concerned, it is not going to be based on removing the remaining food subsidies or reducing them. I hope that Deputy Lemass speaks for the Fianna Fáil Party in expressing that view.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell us why he did not restore them?

Comment on this

That is not very difficult. However, if Deputy Davern does not like to hear the views expressed by Deputy Lemass, he might prefer to listen to Deputy Childers.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy that they are always most palatable.

Comment on this

If Deputy Lemass's views, which I have just quoted, are palatable, I wonder will Deputy Childers' views, as expressed in this House in March, 1952, be quite as palatable? On the 10th March, 1952, at column 2313, speaking on the Vote on Account, Deputy Childers also referred to this question of subsidies. He threw out a suggestion. He said:—

"Subsidies work out at 2/- per head of the population per week. I feel it is absolutely true to say that there are large groups in the community not in need of children's allowances or of subsidies. I simply mention this as a fact which the House should study and examine in considering our whole economic problem."

Deputy MacEntee had something to say about food subsidies in April, 1952, when he made clear the then Government's decision that they were satisfied that incomes generally had advanced more than the cost of living and that, as essential foodstuffs were no longer scarce, there was now no economic or social justification for a policy of subsidising food for everyone.

I take it that the Fianna Fáil Party have not got over that and that they agree with the view expressed by Deputy Lemass in Mallow when he was speaking there last March. I hope so. The present Minister has made it clear that, as far as this Government is concerned, notwithstanding the difficulties which they found themselves facing in drawing this Budget, they were not going to interfere with subsidies.

I just want to refer to one other matter which, I think, may be of interest in Deputy Lemass's analysis of the national economy in his statement of what the Budget proposals should aim at. He said:—

"There is another principle which should determine the form of the Budget and that is that the number of taxes should be kept as low as possible and reliance should be placed on a few substantial taxes for the great block of revenue, i.e., income and inheritance taxes."

There I see one of the sharp disagreements between Deputy Lemass's outline of what the Budget should be and the Budget as introduced by the present Minister.

Deputy Lemass's view was that the Government should keep the number of separate taxes as low as possible, that reliance should be placed on a few substantial taxes and one of the substantial taxes suggested by the Deputy was income-tax. I think the Minister was quite right to avoid any further increase in income-tax. I think that the present situation is one where, in looking for increased preduction, it would have been extremely unwise to increase income-tax.

Comment on this

Is the workers' insurance contribution not a tax increase?

Comment on this

Is that not what Deputy MacEntee wants?

Comment on this

Answer the question.

Comment on this

I take it that Deputy MacEntee agrees with his deputy Leader's views as expressed in Mallow when he suggested that we should work out a few taxes and go in heavy on those taxes and that one of those taxes should be income-tax.

Comment on this

Answer the question.

Comment on this

The increase has not been put on the income-tax.

Comment on this

There is another 5d. out of the workers' pay packet.

Comment on this

Is it not a good investment?

Comment on this

I do not know whether Deputy MacEntee intends that interjection to be taken seriously or not. Is it Deputy MacEntee's view that you can give things for nothing, that the Government can just shell out?

Comment on this

That was never my view. That used to be your view.

Comment on this

What was the point of Deputy MacEntee's interjection? The fact of the matter is that the deputy Leader of Fianna Fáil has stated, in his outline statement, that one of the taxes on which reliance should be placed is income-tax. I am saying that I am glad that, in his Budget proposals, the Minister avoided any increase in income-tax.

Comment on this

The Deputy is reading the Irish Press anyway. It will have a good effect on him.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass, when he spoke after the Minister for Finance on the 8th May, said that there was an increase of £8,000,000 approximately to be found out of ordinary revenue. At column 46 of the Debates of the 8th May he referred to waste and extravagance. He said:—

"This leaves £8,000,000 to be accounted for. What happened to it? Where has it gone? In waste and extravagance."

Later on he says:—

"There has been no expansion in the public services worth talking about £8,000,000 has gone in waste."

Deputy Davern apparently still follows his Leader. I want to put this question to people like Deputy Davern. Do they believe that it is waste and extravagance to pay decent wages and decent salaries to State employees and do they quarrel with the increases that have been given? Are they not aware that in that figure of £8,000,000, to which Deputy Lemass referred as having gone in waste and extravagance, there is a sum of £2,500,000 representing pay increases to State employees? It is not simply to civil servants alone.

Comment on this

We have converted you too.

Comment on this

Will you take on a new job now and try to convert Deputy Lemass? Deputy Lemass referred to £8,000,000 as being gone in waste and extravagance. That £8,000,000 is made up of a number of different items. One of them is a sum of approximately £2,500,000 for pay increases to civil servants and other employees of the State. There is about £1,250,000 to pay for the health services. Is this waste and extravagance or part of the waste and extravagance referred to by Deputy Lemass? Does Deputy Davern agree with him there? Does he consider that £1,250,000, which makes up part of that £8,000,000, as waste and extravagance?

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass worked wonders when he got Deputy O'Higgins to read the Irish Press.

Comment on this

There is £340,000 in that £8,000,000 for relief of rates on agricultural land. I wonder would Deputy Davern go around Tipperary North Riding or Tipperary South Riding, I never know which is which, and tell the farmers there that that £340,000 is waste and extravagance because it is going for the relief of rates on agricultural land?

Comment on this

Who introduced that item at first?

Comment on this

I am not saying who introduced it.

Comment on this