Committee on Finance. - Vote 38—Local Government (Resumed).
Contributions 183–386 of 386. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I heard many theses from the Parliamentary Secretary which were not very edifying. The great expert and Government discovery should leave me alone and remember his position in this House. It is not playing the jack-in-the-box he should be.
Comment on this
Let the Deputy keep quiet, too. I was developing the point that, in housing, there are six extra officials and there is no speed up in the sanction of grants and there is no speed up in the inspections. I should like to know from the Minister the justification for the increase in his staff. We would like him to relate it to the desire of the Minister for Finance to cut his staff. In how far is this related to recruitment for the Civil Service? Have we the same intake year after year in the Department of Local Government as we had before? Is there any further slowing down in collaboration with the Department of Finance in the recruitment every year? These are matters that needed answering.
Deputy Desmond dealt with the period 1948 to 1951. We are sick and tired of hearing that. The man who set housing going in this country now occupies the most exalted position in the State. He was Minister for Local Government here, and before his advent as Minister for Local Government, from before the Great War, there was not a rural house built in this country.
Comment on this
That is the truth. There was not one rural house built before the time of Seán T. Ó Ceallaigh.
Comment on this
There was not one rural house built in the country before the advent of Seán T. Ó Ceallaigh as Minister for Local Government. From that to the period in 1940, when the war stopped it, the country was dotted with houses, and they are a memorial for all time to his work. Anyone who succeeded him was only carrying out the programme he initiated and laid down. It was interrupted during the war when material could not be got. This thing of lauding the period from 1948 to 1951 as a period of local government is all moonshine.
Deputy Smith has been criticised here by the same democratic Deputy, Deputy Desmond, about the means test in the housing grants. What happened the first supplementary grant when there was no means test? I will speak for my own constituency, which I know, and will bet a shilling to a button that the same happened in Cork. The wealthy landlord, the wealthy possessor of a big farm, got into his limousine and went into the county council with his solicitor, and before the poor man had time to turn round he had his application in, and in one four months the £50,000 was used up for these gents. Some of them boasted openly in the fairs of Westmeath "I gave my son that to get a car," or "someone else belonging to me went to the South of France on a holiday." That is the liberty, equality and fraternity, we got from labour. But when we came in we made it applicable to the poor man, to the man with the small wage or on £20 valuation, to the man who needed it. In that way we made it stretch and did not let it be burned up in a few months by people to whom it was only pin money and who did not need it.
Comment on this
It is nothing to Deputy Rooney, but I cannot help stating the truth. Then we come to the road grants. Deputy Smith has dealt with this whole matter in very much detail. I do not know of anything that gives more employment than road work, and here this year this Government takes from the Minister for Local Government £500,000—five weeks' work for 10,000 men at the time they will most need it, around the winter months. There is nothing facing them this winter as a result of that but unemployment in every county. There are no factories in many of the rural areas, and they look to road work as a means of existence.
Deputy Smith in the last period of the Fianna Fáil Government committed our Government to the principle that every yield from the Road Fund would go into the roads. That is done away with now, and we hear discussed the relative merits of county roads and main roads. In my own county, which is not nearly the biggest county, but a small county which does not justify a separate constituency, there are 900 miles of county road to be made. At the present rate of wages and grants, it will take 90 years to make them, because all we make is ten or 12 miles of road a year. We are told about the £200,000 increase, but, as has been pointed out by other speakers, that will be absorbed by wages.
We contend that the child going to school in County Westmeath, and its parents going to Mass are entitled to as good roads as children and parents in Dublin or any other city. The child in Dublin walks out to go to school and steps on a cement or tarmacadam road, but the child in Westmeath steps into a puddle of water six months of the year. Surely he is entitled to the same amenities as the other child. If ever there was justification for the amortisation of a fund, that fund should be the Road Fund. It should be pinned down to the increased yield from motor taxation, and, goodness knows, the people who pay in taxation on petrol and tyres and parts, taxation which does not go into the Road Fund and which is a big portion of revenue, are entitled at least to get the amount of the Road Fund back to give them as good roads as they have in the towns and cities. There was nothing in the Government programme to say that they were going to take away from the Road Fund. We pointed out to the people, and they did not believe it, that they would raid the Road Fund. They raided the Road Fund before.
Comment on this
Of course it is true. The Deputy ought to know the value of words. The Road Fund was raided to the tune of £500,000.
Comment on this
One of the Deputies in the course of this debate referred to the appointment of rate collectors and rent collectors. I have nothing to say to the system of appointment, but I do say that there should be a salary basis and not a percentage basis, irrespective of the number of houses— salaries, say, with increments and pensionable rights. I think that there is provision for that, but it should be emphasised and enforced.
In regard to purchase schemes for houses, I think we have gone far enough as far as rural cottages are concerned. I am very glad that the people in the Custom House have not got a scheme, and I hope they do not get one, for the recent houses for the time being. There are a great number of people without proper housing in my county, and we have sold a lot of cottages under the purchase schemes, running into a couple of thousand. Those cottages are being sold with the consent of the council. A nominal sum passes, but we know, though we cannot prove it in a court of law, that instead of a nominal sum of £50 or £60, £300 or £400 has been passing into the hands of these people.
I know one case where the individual went to live in a condemned house after selling the purchased cottage. If purchase goes on too rapidly, and more than overtakes the replacement of houses, you will have the same problem all over again. As far as the five, six or seven schemes in County Westmeath are concerned, I hope there will never be a purchase scheme for the next 50 years, because, if there is, we will have no houses for the genuine labouring man. There is more trafficking in these houses than we would like and that trafficking will increase.
Much has been said about the relative merits of main and county roads, though possibly it is not very pertinent to this debate to develop that matter now, owing to the cut in the Road Fund. Last year, I was in a small European Country, Denmark, and I noticed outside the towns there a path for cyclists and pedestrians. Mark you, that is very desirable. On the main road out by Chapelizod, there is a tramline and I think that could make the beginning of such a venture here. It is used at the moment by campers and I think it could be developed into a cycle track. That would make for greater safety on our roads. Anyone using a motor car knows that one of the main causes of accidents is a cyclist, particularly at night without a red light, coming out suddenly before a car when another car is approaching. Very often accidents occur in those circumstances. Now this might possibly be a long-term policy project. Possibly it may never be completed. But it would be very desirable if we had such a path developed for cyclists and pedestrians. It would help to reduce the number of casualties on our roads.
There is another matter I should like to raise in connection with main roads. We did an excellent job of work on the road from Kilbeggan half way to Tyrrellspass. I do not know why that scheme should be abandoned with one half of the road left unfinished. Traffic is increasing on that road. It carries all the heavy traffic from the West. I do not believe we have yet reached peak-point at all, so far as traffic is concerned. Our roads will need to be made wider and wider to carry this increasing traffic. I do not believe in the present policy of taking over a piece of land and not using it. I do not believe it should be given back to the farmer. I think that piece of land should be planted. It is dangerous to regiment the motorist on too narrow lines, either where the road is dead straight or where it twists. There should be some break in the landscape because, if there is not, the safety of other road users is imperilled. Where there is a break, because trees have been planted, or for some other reason, the psychological reaction will make for greater road safety. The planting of trees in such areas should be encouraged by the Department of Local Government.
In the course of this debate, we intervened, perhaps wrongly, and we were accused of talking about standstill Orders in wages. What we want in this country is a standstill Order on prices. If we had that our wage problem would solve itself very quickly. In conclusion, there is one thing which stands to the credit of Deputy Smith, the Minister's predecessor; that is his fight for the roads in rural Ireland and his application of the full yield of the Road Fund to the country roads in general. This House should unite in the coming year to ensure that the fund which is collected from all the people using the roads, whether they be farmers using farm machinery, motorists or autocyclists, should be devoted to making our roads at least as good as roads elsewhere in Europe.
Comment on this
On the debate for the Estimate for the Department of Local Government, much can be said and much useful criticism can be offered to the Minister, irrespective of who he may be. I want to refer first of all to Deputy Kennedy's concluding remarks wherein he complimented the ex-Minister for Local Government, Deputy Smith, on his approach to the road problem. Many Deputies have already raised this matter, but I think it bears repetition. Indeed, the more we repeat it, the better it will be for the country: the Minister and his Department should turn their eyes more to the county road problem and forget about major improvements on the trunk roads.
I do not know if the Minister has been in Cork City or county of late, but I want to instance a case now where, last year, an improvement was effected in a dangerous turn. That was on the road between Fermoy and Cork City. A good job was done. Everyone who travelled the road thought it was a good job, a bit too good perhaps when they came out off the by-roads, having travelled over pot-holes and so forth. Having improved that corner last year, they started this year to undo a lot of the good work they did last year by taking in another three-quarters of an acre of arable land to give a little better vision on that corner. Deputies should bring such extravagant "goings-on" to the notice of the Minister for Local Government.
That is not an isolated case, but I mention it because it is a glaring example of the way in which money is being wasted on these major road improvements. Rural Deputies know what people have to contend with living along the by-roads adjacent to our main roads. The Minister has given an earnest of his intention to put more money into the by-roads, but I am not at all satisfied that that lead is being followed from a financial point of view. The only way in which effect can be given to these proposals is by directing the money into the by-roads rather than into the county roads.
The Local Authorities (Works) Act was an excellent Act. I believe—I mentioned this on the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture—that there should be more cohesion between the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Local Government in relation to the Local Authorities (Works) Act. If the Department of Local Government directed more of its attention and more of its funds to the implementation of that Act, the rehabilitation project, which we all believe is good for the country, could more easily be carried out. The problem is that there are many rivers which could be drained under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. If they were drained, the adjoining lands could then he reclaimed under the land rehabilitation project; but the rivers are not being drained at the moment because the Department of Local Government will not sanction the schemes. This Act brought relief beyond measure to small farmers, but much more effective use could be made of it, if my proposal were accepted.
I join with my colleague, Deputy Desmond, in appealing to the Minister and his Department to speed up the sanction of tenders, and so forth, for housing schemes and sanitary schemes. It is rather annoying for members of local authorities to have to ask at different meetings of the local authority if there is any account of a particular scheme and to be told month after month that it is pigeonholed in the Custom House in Dublin. Members of local authorities in this House should appeal to the Minister and his Department to expedite the sending out of sanction for those schemes.
We had experience recently in Cork County Council in regard to the arbitration awards for land taken for the purpose of building houses and cottages. It took long enough to get the arbitrator to sit on these awards, but, when he had done so, it was nearly another 12 months before we got the decision of the arbitrator. I do not know whether or not the Minister is directly concerned in this, but I think it is his business and the business of his Department to make the results of these arbitration courts known at least within a reasonable time of the sitting of the court. People whose land has been taken from them feel that, if they had withheld their rates, they would be told very soon that the rates were overdue and that they had to pay. If we, on the other hand, demand something from them, then let us give back something to them with the same promptness we demand ourselves.
With regard to roads, I do not know if this comes within the ambit of this debate, but I feel that a certain Sunday newspaper should be congratulated on its appeal for a road safety programme. I think that all of us in public life should add our voices in asking for a little more care on the roads. That little bit of care and caution, which we can all give so easily, might be the means of saving many lives.
I do not intend to go into this Estimate in any detail, but I have mentioned two or three points which, I believe, deserve the attention of the Minister and his Department. The only thing I would say in conclusion is that we should get a little more speed up in that Department. The suggestion that county councils could do a lot of work also deserves to be considered by the Minister. The practice of sending up proposals from local authorities to the Custom House and having them come back again for information can only be described by any reasonable person as a delaying action. Much of that work could be done by the local authorities themselves and I would appeal to the Minister to examine that possibility. It would also be an effort at decentralisation. It would help in speeding up the work and it would probably keep many people out of the city and, much as we may like the city, I think many of them would be better off in the country.
Comment on this
It is rather strange that the mover of the motion to refer back this Estimate is not the ex-Minister for Local Government. To my mind, the ruination of local government in this country was brought about by the Fianna Fáil Government when they introduced the County Management Act and put it into force in 1942.
Comment on this
That was the ruination of local authorities, because all their powers were taken away from them. That was the cause of the increase in the rates.
Comment on this
I never voted for the County Management Act. The Labour Party never did that. Deputy Kennedy attacked the Labour Party here. I thought his contribution was very poor, from an ex-Parliamentary Secretary. He said the Labour Party did not want direct labour. He gave all the praise for the housing drive to the President and former Minister for Local Government, Mr. Seán T. Ó Ceallaigh. In 1948, when the first inter-Party Government was set up, for the first time in the history of this country, a Labour man, with experience of local authorities in his native County Cork, started a housing drive by direct labour throughout the Twenty-Six Counties; and more houses were built during that time than for the 16 years of Fianna Fáil rule.
This Estimate is the most important one for members of local authorities. There is a good number of members of local authorities in the Dáil, but I find that members of local authorities here speak with two minds. They criticise the Minister for Local Government and his Department in the House, but they adopt a different attitude in their respective local authorities. I always believe that the more money we put up in the local authority, the more grants we get from the Central Fund; but that is not the policy of the members of Fianna Fáil on Wexford County Council. We find that to-day they do not want houses, they do not want roads, they do not want anything done. They tell us the rates are too high and we cannot afford it. Deputy Kennedy spoke of 70,000 small farmers in Westmeath——
Comment on this
7,000—but he does not want the local authority to build houses for these people. I always understand that local authorities build houses for the working class, and the small farmers can get grants and loans and build their own houses. I do not know why he brought in that.
There is no use saying at present that there are sufficient houses in the country. That is not so, in either the city or the rural areas. Every member of a local authority knows that when a house goes up in a rural or urban area, there are 50 or 60 applicants for it, agricultural labourers and so on. Then we are told that the housing drive is coming to an end. The person who says that is not in touch with the people——
Comment on this
——because there is a demand for houses and there always will be. If you could get direct labour schemes going, instead of trying to play with contractors, houses could be built cheaper, because, naturally, the contractor is looking for a big profit——
Comment on this
We are told that the rates have gone up. We know that, but why have they gone up? Because we had to honour the award to employees of local authorities and because we had to meet the provisions of the Health Act. That is why the rates have gone up. These are the things that the people in the Fianna Fáil Benches are evading.
I have been a member of a local authority for over 20 years and I have seen Governments change and chairmen and Parties change. I find that one section of a council does not want anything done when "Dev" is not in power. They are all for slowing up. I can criticise the Custom House as much as any other Deputy for delays in sanctioning proposals. I know of schemes that have been held up for months. Anyone who is a member of a local authority knows that we have difficulties and they will know that the delay in building some houses is because there is not title to go in on the land. I defy any Deputy in the Fianna Fáil Party to deny that. There are many cases where people have not taken out title and where the county council cannot go in until they get title.
Although we have our freedom, we have not got the authority to acquire derelict sites which may belong to some landlord in Britain. These people look for their pound of flesh before they give up their derelict sites. There was a mistake made many years ago when ground landlordism should have been got rid of. In Enniscorthy alone we had to pay £200 for derelict sites.
Comment on this
The right time to deal with it is when the Minister for Local Government is here. If the ground landlords had been put out, instead of dealing with the land annuities, a good job would have been done for this country.
Comment on this
Deputy Kennedy and the Deputy from Donegal spoke about the wages of our road workers. The place to talk about that is in the local authority itself. It is the local authorities that deal with the wages of the road workers and the quarry workers. Yesterday evening, in my own area, notice was given to the employees of two quarries. I went to the county engineer and he told me that it was the first he had heard of it. I want the Minister to take up that matter immediately and to find out what is behind all that. The county engineer knew nothing about it but the men are still under notice. I want to know what is happening.
Comment on this
I was through Enniscorthy to-day but the hedges were so high I could not even see the quarries.
Comment on this
I saw the Minister passing but he passed me very quickly. I believe that the purchase scheme for the cottages is a very good scheme. Every man should have a chance to purchase his own house because it gives him an interest in his house. The cheapest houses in this country were built by the British for 8d. a week. They are still standing throughout the country.
Comment on this
The houses were built. There is no use in saying that Seán T. Ó Ceallaigh built them all. We know the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party with regard to the day's pay.
Comment on this
Deputy MacEntee would not sanction 2d. a day for the Tipperary workers. We had a Fianna Fáil Government for 16 years and their Minister for Local Government did nothing but build roads for C.I.E. It is only since the change of Government that the county roads, about which Deputy Kennedy was crying, had more money spent on them. All down through the years it was a question of money for the road from Dublin to Waterford and that from Cork to Dublin. The Government were making roads for C.I.E. Everyone welcomed the change. I think that the country roads should be made passable for the man who is walking and the man on a bicycle. The person in a motor car does not mind a bad road. He has got tyres for getting over it.
Comment on this
The man in the motor car gets over the bad roads better than the man with the bad boots or the young child who has to walk four miles to school. I do not want to see the Road Fund raided but I want to see the money going back into the roads. We are all paying taxes for our motor cars and we want to see our roads properly maintained. Deputy Kennedy mentioned several times during the Minister's absence that he had raided the Road Fund. I suppose the Deputy did so in the belief that if he said it often enough people would believe him.
Comment on this
I am also glad to see that the pension scheme for road workers has been amended. That action was long overdue. That was a bad Act and we are now trying to improve on it for the sake of the road men. That amendment in the Act is welcome to every worker under a local authority.
A number of things could be mentioned on this Estimate. This is my thirteenth time to speak on it so that my contribution has now almost become a hardy annual. There are many things wrong in local government. Every member of a local authority knows that but one has to be a member of a local authority to know what is wrong. A person who is not a member of a local authority knows nothing about the problems with which these bodies are faced.
The housing needs are still there, no matter what anybody says about them. Houses are needed in the rural areas, in the villages and towns and in the City of Dublin itself. Money spent on building houses is money well spent. Our local authorities are becoming the biggest landlords in most towns because now they own the most houses. However, we should try to build cheaper houses.
I advocated, on several occasions, that we should leave out the bathroom in certain schemes and then we could sell the houses at a cheaper rate. The bathrooms are running up the cost of building houses. There are thousands of people living in slums who have not got lavatories or a water supply. They would be glad to get a house with toilets and water and forget about the bathroom. We have been told that it costs £150 to put a bathroom in a house. This amounts to a considerable figure when the housing scheme is finished and that is the cause of the high rent of certain houses. I believe that the rent of houses for agricultural labourers and forestry workers has come to its peak to-day at 6/- out of small wages.
Another problem that has to be dealt with is that of electric light which we all want to see provided in the rural areas. I do not know whether the Minister for Local Government can do anything in this matter but the two months' bill for electricity is a heavy one. Six shillings a week for a cottage is also a large sum out of £4 a week and any further expense would be a hardship on these people. Perhaps some other system could be adopted in order to lessen this hardship.
No one will grumble, I am sure, no matter how much money is spent on housing and roads. The ratepayers in my own area do not mind paying rates, but they do object to having bad roads to travel over in view of the high rates they pay. It is time that more attention was paid by the officials in the Custom House to the schemes which are submitted to them so that those schemes will not be delayed. Of course there is a certain amount of capital to be made out of that. There are certain people making capital out of the delays, but delays have always been there no matter what Government was in power. The same officials are there, and it is the Minister's duty to see that, when housing schemes and other improvement schemes are sent up to the Department, the local authorities will get the authority to proceed with the work as quickly as possible. We must give credit to the last inter-Party Government for having brought our tradesmen back to this country to build houses for our people. When they went out of power in 1951 and when Fianna Fáil came back they put the brake on housing and the men had to go away again. Delays occurred in relation to schemes in my own area. I might say that sometimes there were deliberate. Probably an official was told: "Take your time." Now that is good tactically, of course, for the Opposition.
We must do our utmost to see that housing is provided for the people, to see that schools are erected and good roads constructed. We will not be here in another 50 years. Many Deputies have passed away since this House was formed. The same thing goes on day in and day out; the same speeches are being made here year after year. I want to see progress. Above all I want to see housing for the people. That must come first, because you will have no country unless you have housing and we have not sufficient decent housing accommodation in the city or in the country.
Take the case of Dublin. In spite of all the talk we hear about houses being built for this man and the other man, it is very difficult to get a house here and they are badly needed. There are houses needed also in the rural areas to keep the agricultural workers at home. There are many men working in England who had to leave home because they could not get a house and had no prospects of geting married. If they had a house in which to settle down many of those men would be at home to-day working on farms. I appeal to the Minister to give every assistance to local authorities in connection with housing schemes and other schemes which are essential to the well-being of the nation.
Comment on this
It is not for the purpose of prolonging this discussion that I take part in the debate on this Estimate but to try to get some information for constituents of mine who are aggrieved by the present state of affairs. I have in my hand a letter from one of my constituents who built a house under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. He contracted with the building society for £2,000. The papers were signed and were in order and even the mortgage was executed with the Sligo Corporation at a rate of 5 per cent. He was quite agreeable to that. This man was earning a certain wage and he built what he could afford. Although the mortgage has been executed and all the deeds are in order, he now finds himself faced with a demand from the corporation for 5¾ per cent. I would like an assurance from the Minister that this man will get the house, to which I think he is justly entitled, at the rate for which he contracted.
Comment on this
If that rate was set out in the mortgage and was a condition of the mortgage, he can only be charged at that rate.
Comment on this
That is the case. The information I have here is that the rate of 5 per cent. was set out in the mortgage and contracted for and all the deeds have been executed.
Comment on this
The corporation, I understand, are depending on some section of the Act that allows the local authority to charge a half per cent.——
Comment on this
——over the rate at which the money has been borrowed. But this man had the mortgage executed before that came into force and I would like an assurance from the Minister that that man will get his house at the rate he contracted for.
Comment on this
The facts are as stated. I know all about this man and he would not tell me a lie about it. I feel he has a grievance because it would mean an extra burden of £10 a year on him, or £350 over a period of 35 years, which I think is very unfair.
Comment on this
Provided a proper mortgage was executed and there was no variation clause, then I think he should consult his solicitor if he is being pressed for the higher rate.
Comment on this
I will convey that information to him and I am glad to have it. I would like if the Minister would deal with the different corporations on this question because there are other people involved as well. They may not have gone as far as this man and had the mortgage executed, but they signified their intention to the building society of building a house. I was listening to Deputy Smith here tonight stating that when he was Minister any man who had in writing signified in any way his intention to build a house was granted the old rate of interest. I would like the Minister, when he is replying to the debate, to make it clear to those people that he will give them the same facilities as were given by his predecessor.
It is not a small matter for a man to build his own house. For a man who puts £2,000 into a house, a rate of ½ per cent. means an additional £350 over the years. Very often he finds great difficulty in getting people to go surety for him. I will leave that point but I am glad to have the assurance of the Minister that such a man is quite safe.
There is one other point I want to bring to the notice of the Minister. In rural areas, houses are reconstructed and new houses built on very low valuations. I know of a man with a valuation of £13 on his land and a valuation of 15/- on his old house. The total valuation was £13 15s. He built a four-roomed bungalow-type house and he now finds himself saddled with a valuation of £4 10s. on the house.
Comment on this
The point I want to make is that the country people do not understand. They regard one Minister the same as another. They believe there is collective responsibility between the two Ministers. It is the Minister for Local Government who deals with houses.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not discuss on the Local Government Estimate a matter which pertains to the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I agree, but this excessive valuation is going to kill housing in the country. I hope the Chair will not think I am endeavouring to get in my say in this matter. I want only to point out that this excessive valuation will kill housing.
Comment on this
Something ought to be done. If the man in question had been told that this excessive valuation would materialise, he would not build the house. A farmer with 24 acres and a valuation of £13 cannot bear a valuation of £4 10s. on a small house, having regard to the rates at the present time. They are practically £2 in the £1 and that means a rate of £9 on the house. For that reason, I think the Government should do something about the matter. I am sorry for bringing in this point. I know it is a matter for the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Not on this scheme. I never came across a case where there was a rise from 15/- to £4 10s.
Comment on this
This is my first experience and if something is not done about it, it will kill reconstruction and building. If I had to build a house and was told I was going to be rated so highly, I would not build the house.
I must say that we were very disappointed when the Minister, in introducing his Estimate, gave no indication of his intention to reduce the rates. The rates, as the Minister knows, have gone very high in practically every county in the western areas. Some of them are over £2 in the £1.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister to do something about it. I want him to fulfil the promises that were made.
Comment on this
By the Minister's colleagues, the Minister for Defence who spoke at Sligo town on the 30th March, 1954, and said that Fine Gael stood for a reduction in taxation. The Fine Gael Party stood for a reduction in local rates. Fine Gael, if returned to power, would take steps to see that the Central Fund would undertake responsibility for all future expenditure and for some of the existing expenditure which was at present being met by the local rates. The undertaking that the Central Fund would meet further expenditure has not been honoured in any way.
Comment on this
It was £16,000. I was listening to the debate on the Budget and I think the Minister for Finance and his Parliamentary Secretary berated this side of the House for attempting to stop the Government from getting money. How much extra has the Minister for Local Government got out of this Budget?
Comment on this
One of the arguments used to get the Budget passed was that money was needed by the different Departments. Now we find that there is not one shilling in the Minister's Department for the reduction of the rates although the promise was given that the Government would vote money out of the Central Fund for the relief of rates. It is needed because the rates at the present time have gone too high.
Deputy Desmond spoke about road workers' wages and told us what they did in Cork, but what was done in Cork was not done in other counties where there are Fine Gael majorities. All the road workers were granted increases, but no money was made available to implement the increases and we now find that the road workers are idle.
Comment on this
I do not want to make political capital out of this but never since I came into public life have I seen so many looking for work. The road workers' wages were increased and nothing was put in to meet that increase.
Comment on this
No, but we are talking to the boss of the council chamber. I was listening to the news at 1.30 on the radio and I was delighted to hear the Minister talking about libraries.
Comment on this
I might compliment the people of Sligo on the magnificent library they have got there.
Comment on this
The Minister complimented the libraries and the county council on the work they were doing. I should like if he would furnish a copy of that speech to the representatives on Sligo County Council and stop them cutting down the estimate by £1,500.
Comment on this
I thought the Deputy said the estimate was too high. Now he is trying to say it is too low.
Comment on this
I do not want the Minister saying one thing and in the next breath saying another. I want to point out that they could save in other ways if they wanted. I do not know how. The delay in dealing with schemes was mentioned by some Deputies. I thought no one was treated as we were until I heard Deputy Desmond talk about the way the Department and the local councils were playing ball with these schemes. In Sligo we set up a rural water scheme nearly two years ago and it is as far away from being completed to-day as then. I wish something could be done to speed up these schemes. If the schemes are to be given, let the Minister give them and if not, let him turn them down. We should not keep the people waiting years and years for these schemes.
Comment on this
It is going on a long time and the Minister ought to do something to speed it up. As Deputy Desmond, I think, said, this business of playing ball between the council and the Department with the people looking on is not a fair way of dealing with the matter, to say the least of it.
There is very little else I want to say, except that we are disappointed with the Minister for allowing the Road Fund to be raided to this extent, because, with the increase in wages, half the amount of work will not be done on the roads this year that was done last year. I think the Minister is well aware of that fact and he should have made a stand there. When the increase in taxation on motor cars went through this House some years ago, as Deputy Smith pointed out to-day, a demand was made on him that all that money would be used for roads and he on his part gave that guarantee, but he promptly said he could not give that guarantee for his successor or any other Government.
The Minister should have insisted that the money collected for that purpose, and some of the money collected from the present petrol tax should be reserved for the upkeep of the roads. I am not going to embarrass the Minister in any way, but I want to tell him quite plainly there is a great amount of unemployment among road workers. The Minister can see that for himself. Some of them are working half-time. In some cases, I have come across gangs of men and, where there used to be ten or 12, there are now only two, and when you speak to the county surveyor about it, the answer you get is: "We have not got the money." The Minister should deal with that situation, and go back to the Government or to the Minister for Finance, and at least get back that £500,000 that has been taken from him.
I am glad to have the assurance of the Minister that this man who had contracted for his house will get the grant at the old rate——
Comment on this
If he gave me wrong facts, I cannot help it, but I am giving them to the Minister as I got them.
Comment on this
I should like to associate myself with what Deputy Gilbride has said about family men who obtain loans under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts. The Minister, I think, is aware of the situation in my constituency; he has quite a sheaf of correspondence on the matter pointing out the difficulties with which these people — generally young married couples—have to contend as a result of the change in the rate of interest. If these people felt and had reason to believe they had contracted at an ascertained and definite rate of interest, then I think, if there is red tape to be cut in this matter, the Minister would be justified in cutting it. He would be only doing justice to these unfortunate people who now through no fault of their own find themselves in difficulties, which to them are very grave difficulties, and which will repeat themselves each year in which these people have to meet the demands on their capital sums.
Last year, quite a number of people on all sides of the House indicated to the Minister their disquiet about what appeared to them to be a waste of funds on the main roads. When the Budget was being introduced here a fortnight ago, the Minister for Agriculture mentioned, in passing, that he, for one, did not at all agree with the expenditure on main roads as it is being carried out at the moment. I should like to tell the Minister, who was not in the House at the time, that there was a chorus of "Hear, hear!" from these benches in which we are sitting. Since last year, I do not think there has been any diminution whatever in expenditure on public roads. It is agreed that a certain amount of expenditure is necessary, but on any main road on which I have to travel, I think you will find evidence of colossal——
Comment on this
It is not down on the roads on which I travel, or if it is down by £200,000, judging by the expenditure that is going on now, it could be down by £300,000 if county councils prudently conducted their business of the construction and repair of main roads.
Comment on this
During the course of the debate, reference has been made to the type of house being provided for the working classes. Deputy Lynch, of Cork, last week said he felt that the houses that were being provided in Cork City were not an ideal type of house. I entirely agree with that attitude and I have been trying to impress on the Minister and his Department for a long time that the type of house which tenants in Cork want—and I know the minds of many of them on the matter—is the terrace type of house. I have been in, and I have been shown, bedrooms in working-class dwellings in Cork where you could comfortably fit two double-beds and a single bed. I do not believe that is the type of room which the working-class fathers and mothers want. Such rooms are difficult to heat, difficult to furnish and, above all, the construction of houses of this nature is so expensive that the economic rent is the type of rent which the working-class family finds hard to pay.
You find also in Cork that development costs of working-class schemes are large because we ourselves believe that the roads which are provided are too wide, that footpaths are too wide, and I would ask the Minister seriously to lend ear to those who speak the minds of the tenants. I feel that the Minister's advisers in this matter are out of touch with the tenants and out of touch with the type of house which is necessary. It may be true to say— I think it is true to say—that, architecturally and otherwise, they are ideal houses, but when we in Cork find ourselves faced with the position that we have 3,000 families still to house, we feel there is a condition of emergency appertaining in Cork which could best be met if we were satisfied to build the terrace type of house which would give comfortable, cosy and healthy conditions to those families who at the moment are living in tenements or slums.
I should also like to draw the Minister's attention to the signs which are on the main roads. Some uniformity should be reached among county councils and I think the Minister should take steps to lay down certain regulations under which roads could be posted with danger signs and signs of that nature, because you do find, driving from one county to another, there are different standards of danger. In one county, coming to quite a gradual bend, you will see a warning "Dangerous Corner" while, in the next county, when you are coming to a really dangerous corner, there will be no danger sign whatever.
I think there might be an extension of the Town Planning Acts to prevent hotels and licensed premises and others from putting up notices such as "Stop," which looks like danger signs and which engender in the minds of motorists a disregard for all notices that appear on the roads.
There is one thing in particular to which I should like to refer the Minister. In Cork City, there have been gravely disturbing rumours regarding larcenies from direct labour building schemes in the city and allegations that workmen engaged on direct labour schemes, while being paid by the corporation, actually left their work and went to help in the construction of other private buildings which were not part of the corporation scheme. Whether these rumours are correct or not, I do not know. I have been told by men who were working on the scheme and who are still working on the scheme that there is truth in these rumours.
When the Cork Corporation approached the situation, they asked their officials to make some inquiries and investigations into the matter, and we were surprised to find that the attitude of our officials appeared to be that it was in the hands of the Garda authorities and that, therefore, the officials of the Cork Corporation should not make any investigation into the allegations that quite a substantial portion of their property was the subject of larceny. The Cork Corporation set up a sub-committee to go into this matter and we found ourselves at one stage in the position that the city manager informed the corporation that he would not allow any of his officials to give any information to that sub-committee. He changed his mind at a subsequent stage. I am gravely disturbed, inasmuch as I feel that the allegations which are widespread in Cork were not investigated at the time they should have been investigated.
I am glad to know that the Minister has an interest in this matter and I would ask him to have it investigated as fully as possible, so that, at some stage, the people of Cork will be told whether there is any truth in these allegations or not, because I and other members of Cork Corporation and other public representatives in Cork are disquited by the attitude of laissez-faire which was adopted by our officials towards these very disturbing rumours in the city.
Comment on this
There are just a few matters arising from the Estimate to which I should like to refer. One is the question of the raiding of the Road Fund. That matter has been adverted to by other Deputies, but it could not be stressed too often. From the pronouncements by the Minister when he became Minister for Local Government, one would have expected that there would be a vacancy in the Cabinet early this year when a decision was made to raid the Road Fund. This House would have some respect for the present occupant of that Ministry had he resigned the Ministry when the Road Fund was raided. The seriousness of that matter is not appreciated by the House. It is no excuse to say that the Road Fund has increased this year over last year and had increased last year over the previous year. We are well aware of that. We are also aware of the fact that there are many thousands of miles of road, on which the people who pay the Road Fund must travel, that are unsuitable for any type of traffic, apart altogether from motor traffic.
Five hundred thousand pounds is a considerable sum of money. Each year for a number of years past the Dáil has been called upon to provide out of borrowed moneys sufficient to keep a certain number of men employed in a slack period of the year. Notwithstanding all that, the Minister for Local Government allowed £500,000 to be filched or stolen or taken from the Road Fund by the Minister for Finance. For what purpose will the Minister for Finance use that money? The Minister for Local Government did not explain that to the House.
Comment on this
I do not think so. He said it was to pay extra salaries for civil servants, I think.
Comment on this
I think that is what we heard. This is the first time we heard that it is for capital investment. That £500,000 would give 100,000 workers a week's employment at the current rate of road workers' wages or would give 2,000 men work for a whole year. I wonder are the Labour Party satisfied——
Comment on this
At the rate at which Wexford are paying, it would give them employment for a longer period.
Comment on this
I wonder are the Labour Deputies satified. Two thousand men, rural labourers, who have no employment at the moment, could be put into employment, if that sum were devoted to the purpose. It is unfortunately true, as was pointed out here already, that, in the past 20 years, there have not been as many men in rural areas seeking employment in the month of May as there are this year. That £500,000 would have given employment to 2,000 men. That is a considerable number. It would have given them full employment at £5 a week for the whole year.
Comment on this
£4 17s. 6d. is the rate in Wexford.
Comment on this
The Labour Party can still remain in Government; the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government can still sit beside his Minister and not a blush comes to his cheek or to the cheek of any of his colleagues. Deputy Tully, who is concerned to increase wages, is not a bit concerned about maintaining the pool of money that belongs to the road workers of this country. Rural workers, who have no other employmen, if they got six months' work or three months' work, would remain in benefit. Even at this late stage, the Minister should do something about this matter. I would ask the Minister's colleagues of the Labour Party, on whom this Government depends for a majority, to exert themselves and to see that those 2,000 rural workers who could have got full employment for a whole year out of this £500,000 will not have to emigrate, along with all the others.
Comment on this
Repetition does not add anything to the argument. The Deputy has said that three or four times.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to advert to the fact that the payment of reconstruction and housing grants is very much in arrear and there is a whole chorus of complaints on that score. The sooner the Minister checks up on that, the better. Grants that have been outstanding for the past 12 or 18 months should be paid. In some cases, people tell you that they have reported that the house is completed, that there has been no final inspection and that the grant has not been paid. That is a fault in administration, whether it is deliberate or otherwise, in the Department. If there is a necessity for a new Housing Act, it is the Minister's neglect that he has not introduced the Bill. It is two or three months since the Minister told us that he proposed to introduce the Bill in a fortnight's time. The people are held up and merchants, many of whom gave building materials on credit, are held up. We hope the Minister will speed up the payments of these housing grants.
In this year's Estimate the contributions towards housing loan charges of local authorities amount to £1,665,000 and there is £2,250,000 for housing grants—a decrease of £25,000. We just wonder if that decrease is justified or if this £2,250,000 will pay the housing grants that are outstanding—the housing grants that have been stalled and stalled for many months now—in addition to the ones current in the present year. I take that matter very seriously and the Minister should take it more seriously than his Department have been taking it for some time past. If an announcement were made that funds were exhausted and that no money was there—which was generally felt in the country—it would be all right but a large number of people are not satisfied about the delay.
I come now to the administration of local authorities. I heard an estimate made some time ago that local authorities, taking an ordinary county council, maintain from five to 12 extra persons on their staff because everything must be referred to the Department of Local Government and there is endless correspondence. The average item that needs the sanction of the Minister involves correspondence at least 12 times on the average before sanction is obtained. If an ordinary local authority has to maintain a minimum of six extra persons on the staff how many extra persons must be maintained on the Minister's staff in order to deal with the endless correspondence that goes on with all local authorities all over the country?
I respectfully suggest to the Minister that there is nothing in any Act that I know of in this country that compels him to demand in respect of every single small item with which a local authority must deal that it must go up for his authority and sanction. It is time an end were brought to a lot of that. Last year, the Minister took steps to bring an end to one matter, that is, the sanction formerly required for the acquisition of plots for single cottages. There are many other activities and many engineering activities in that branch of the Minister's Department so far as local authorities are concerned that could be brought to an end.
In 1956, with local authority administrators, secretaries, accountants and a staff of officials of a very high standard—of just as high a standard as the officials who work in any of the Government Departments—surely they should be able to deal with local administration, aided by a local authority. The local authorities and staffs should not be treated as minors. It is all right for the Minister and the Government to call policy. It would be all right if a local authority were told on the first day of every financial year that a loan of £X would be provided in that year in respect of a certain number of houses and that they could work to the best advantage on that amount. Similarly in respect of sanitary and other services: they could be told that they would get a certain amount by way of grant in a particular year. That would be the Minister's policy and, while we might disagree with it, he would be entitled to call policy.
All the red tape and a lot of the unnecessary correspondence to and fro between local authorities and the Minister's Department should come to an end. It would save tens of thousands of pounds and the time of many hundreds of staff. When they are looking for economies, which are overdue, in the public administration, that is one fruitful source for economy.
I want to protest in the strongest possible manner against the attitude of some of the Minister's officers with regard to local authorities. Last year, the county council of which I am a member, had a scheme for the improvement of roads. With the Minister's sanction, they raised a loan for the improvement of roads. On the advice of their own engineers, the county council decided that certain widths of road were sufficient—that, with such a large number of badly surfaced miles of roads, they would be quite satisfied if certain roads were improved and steam-rolled to a certain width. Over the heads of the local authority and everybody else, the Minister's officers came down and forced the local engineers to agree to their widths of roads.
Comment on this
Probably the same thing will happen this year. The council had raised their own money by way of loan. While nobody could say that the Local Government engineers were wrong in insisting on 16-feet or 18-feet roads, that would be all right for some years to come. The council felt that they had a very serious grievance in the matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy should direct his complaints to the Minister. The Minister is responsible to this House.
Comment on this
It is the Minister whom we blame. He and nobody else must take the responsibility. I am sure, too, that' he would take the blame, if there is any blame in the matter. These things should not happen, because the local engineers and the members of the local authority, who were all drawn from rural areas, were absolutely unanimous——
Comment on this
Was last year a departure from precedent? Can the Deputy answer that simple question?
Comment on this
They had a letter from the Minister's Department last year saying that, subject to such and such a condition, the Minister approved in principle. In the end, we found we had ten miles less of roads reconstructed because of the fact that there was no single mile in the county on which we could put the narrow width of road. We were prepared to spend the money over a larger amount of road in the belief that by putting in a bottom and a good centre the road could be widened in the future. The Minister should give liberty to local authorities in such a matter, if their engineers and the members of the council are satisfied that there is nothing wrong with it. You can take it for certain that members of local authorities are as meticulous and as careful about spending the public money as the Minister could ever be. They are on the spot and they carry the responsibility. They raised this money out of their own pockets and those of their neighbours. The Minister should have far more confidence in the local authority than appears to be the case.
I hope that, in the economy drive, the Minister will remember that one direction in which there could be economy would be less correspondence and that local authorities should be given more liberty to make their own decisions on many minor matters in respect of which there is no reason in the world why the Minister's Department should enter at all. Local authorities are sufficiently grown up now to be well able to administer the local authority funds, without having to seek sanction for every single thing that crops up.
More flexibility in local administration is overdue. Either that must come or local authorities should be done away with altogether, because we are getting to the stage when there is scarcely justification for them because their viewpoints count for very little at all in the present local government machinery. Where the principal officer of a local authority is concerned, he is like Mohammed's coffin, suspended in mid-air, between the Department of Local Government and the council. It is the council who pay him, though he is not responsible to them; but that is another day's work and I suppose it will provoke discussion for years to come.
Those are some of the weaknesses in local administration and they become more apparent as the years go on. When Deputy Gilbride was talking about the high rates and suggested to the Minister that he might do something about them, he was told that the council could strike what rate they liked. It is a fairly well-known fact that there are limits to which the council can go in that respect. Their chief officer or manager may decide that a rate is adequate or that it is not. I suppose there is something to be said for that. Recently, there were increases given to local authority officials. There were no two ways about these increases. The councils were told that if they did not give the full amount the managers' association had decided, that was that. The Minister's Department wrote to the local authorities pointing out where they got off. One local authority with which I had a connection, while they conceded the full amount to the lower paid officers, thought they would put a maximum on the amount they would pay the higher officials. The result was that the lower paid officers were not paid the increases, though the councils granted them the full amounts. They were told by the Minister where to get off.
Last year, councils thought they were getting back a lot of their democratic powers. I do not know where they came back. Several members on this side expressed the view, and we have seen it proved within the last month, that no powers were given back by last year's amendment of the Management Act.
Comment on this
I am not discussing the legislation, but pointing out that the claims made for that legislation——
Comment on this
The Minister has no power to deal with the results of legislation passed by the House.
Comment on this
I have said the Deputy may not discuss legislation passed by the House. It has already been approved.
Comment on this
I do not want to disobey your ruling, but I would like you to further clarify whether an Act——
Comment on this
Any Act passed by this House is an Act of the House and discussion on it may not be reopened. Would the Deputy please resume his seat? What may be discussed on the Estimate is administration, not legislation.
Comment on this
I have ruled that the Deputy is endeavouring to discuss the results of the recent County Management Act.
Comment on this
If the Deputy persists any further in this discussion, the Chair will have to take the appropriate action.
Comment on this
I will get away from it and on to something else. I should like to know from the Minister a few points about road grants. I should like to know if councils will be notified promptly if their plans for road reconstruction, which they forward to the Department, have been approved, or if there will be any hold-ups in that regard. I should like to know if local authorities will be notified early if the Department will sanction their applications to raise loans to supplement road grants, so that the engineers can go on with the preparation of material? It is important at this time of year, when the weather is good, that there should be no delay in the forwarding of such approval, because materials to be used next October and November could be prepared now. I hope these matters will get the Minister's attention in the very near future.
When the Minister is replying, I should like him to give an indication of what is the future general policy of his Department in the matter of water supply schemes. I think the amount of the grant was changed some time ago. We do not know what the amount of these grants are now, because it is a matter for the Minister to determine from time to time. The proportion of the grant in relation to the cost of these schemes would seem to be small. Water supply and other sanitary schemes are absolutely necessary in many areas which are still without water or sewerage and I suggest that the Minister give increased grants for this very necessary purpose.
While on that subject, I should like to refer to the provision of grants for bridge-building. Wexford County Council recently signed a contract for the largest amount provided for any bridge built in this country this century. They are dissatisfied with the amount of the grant. They have recently asked the Minister to reconsider it, and are awaiting the decision. We can see no reason why our neighbouring County Councils of Cork and Waterford, who propose building a somewhat similar sized bridge that will cost no more money, and possibly somewhat less, were offered a grant of 15 per cent. more than Wexford. We think that is unfair, and the only reason it is claimed that Wexford was not entitled to it is that for Cork and Waterford it is going to cost ½d. or 1d. in the £, but it is approaching 8d. or 9d. on the rates in Wexford. I think we should have got a bigger grant from the Road Fund than Cork and Waterford. Some consideration should be given to the amount the local ratepayers will have to pay. Wexford Corporation are a very poor body. Their revenues are very small and their rates very high, but they have offered to contribute 1s. in the £, which, in my opinion, is beyond their resources.
I am speaking now about the grant towards the new Wexford bridge. The Minister was down there this morning and saw the need for it.
Comment on this
I know that you were there often, and I am glad that you got safely across that bridge.
Comment on this
No, much the same. What I was pointing out was this: you have offered a much larger grant to Cork and Waterford for Youghal bridge than to Wexford County Council for their bridge. We think it is unfair that, while the bridge at Youghal is only to cost the ratepayers of Cork and Waterford something like a halfpenny or a penny in the £, the Wexford ratepayer will pay 8d. or 10d., and Wexford Corporation are being mulcted in 1/-in the £.
Comment on this
I understand all the details of it all right, but, however, I am claiming, just as all Wexford people will claim, fair play, and that is all. The road this bridge is on is the shortest road from Rosslare to Dublin —about ten miles shorter than any other road; and while the claim of the Local Government Department is that it is not a trunk road like the Youghal road, it is just as much a trunk road. It is a main road, designated as such for the past 30 years. I hope that the Minister will give favourable consideration to the application of Wexford County Council for an increase, and at least bring the grant up to what was offered to Cork and Waterford, where the charges will be one-sixth or one-tenth of what they will be on the ratepayers of Wexford. Wexford town, in paying 1/- in the £, which they are unable to do, are trying to help the county council to finance the building of this bridge because it happens to be in Wexford town. Waterford and Cork Corporations have got off very cheaply.
Comment on this
Ten years ago, we asked for a grant for the bridge when it would cost us about a quarter of what it will cost us now, but the Minister offered Cork and Waterford, in order to bribe them or cajole or coax them——
Comment on this
It was the Minister, anyway. The sins of his predecessor are on the Minister's head now, whatever they may be, and he has good deeds and bad deeds. I give him credit for both. The Minister must accept the whole lot of them, and when the Minister leaves office, someone else will accept the evil he did and the good he did. I have not a bit of doubt about that. I hope there will be someone found to take on his mantle and even all of the evil deeds he does while he may be Minister. However, subsequent to that, the Minister offered Cork and Waterford a 75 per cent. grant from the Road Fund. There is no question about that. Wexford County Council for the last four or five years have been asking the Minister to reconsider the matter and to give the same grant as given to Cork and Waterford.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, four years ago we were told to wait until we had received a firm contract. The firm contract is now signed and, for better or worse, we have to go on, and we are going on with it, and we only plead now across the floor of the House——
Comment on this
They are working at the moment, anyhow, and we are pleading for fair play across the floor of the House, and we hope the Minister, with his big, generous heart, will give us that fair play.
Comment on this
Since the debate on this Estimate opened, we have had quite an interesting selection of views from people on both sides of the House. Some of them are, in my opinion, quite sensible views with which I would be very much inclined to agree. Some of them are mostly the feather-brained kind which are trotted out for no apparent reason, and some have got such muddled views that it is very hard to be sure on what side of the fence they should come down. I was very interested in Deputy Allen's views on the County Management Act.
Comment on this
The Chair ruled him out of order, but I wonder on which side of the fence he would come down on.
Comment on this
As far as employment and the raid on the Road Fund, as it has been described by my colleagues opposite, are concerned, I feel that the proof of the pudding is in the eating. Deputy Joseph Brennan was inclined to take the view that I should have led a deputation somewhere or other several weeks ago on this point, because of my position in a trade union. I feel that the time to lead that deputation is when the money which has already been granted is expended and people are being laid off. For that reason, I would suggest to this House and to the Minister that something should be done now, not by me, but by the Department of Local Government, to see to it that the money which has been given to local authorities for the purpose of carrying out works on roads is expended, first of all, for the purpose of getting the job done, and, secondly, and very important, in giving employment to people who normally are employed as county council workers.
I must register a very strong protest against the practice which has grown up over the past few years, and seems to be encouraged now by county council officials, as well as by the Department of Local Government, of doing as much work as possible by machinery. We are told that, as a result of wage increases, some councils claimed that there will be less work done and less employment. I suggest that as a result of the excess use of machinery on jobs which could be much better done by hand, there is unemployment, and there will be growing unemployment, unless something is done to stop it. I am not trying to do what some people did a few hundred years ago in seeking to stop the march of progress. I do not want to stop, or see stopped, the use of machinery, if it is for the good of all concerned, but surely nobody can suggest that it is for the good of all concerned, if a bulldozer costing £15 per day is used to do a job which could be equally well done, in perhaps a little longer time, by ten men who would not cost more than £7 or £8 per day.
The Department of Local Government must examine its conscience; and I suggest that examination should take place immediately because in certain counties unemployment is growing, for one reason or another. It is growing in some counties because so much machinery is being used, hired machinery in some cases, to do work which could be done better by hand. There are occasions admittedly on which this machinery more than pays for itself. I do not want to stop the march of progress but I do not want to see some get-rich-quick merchant buying machinery and getting contracts from the county council, and in some cases no contract at all, at an excessive fee while the men who should be doing the work are forced to line up at the local labour exchange or emigrate. If the money which is granted is properly expended, there will be no need for anybody to talk of the necessity for giving extra money because of wage increases.
It is not wage increases which are causing unemployment. It is the excessive use of machinery. We know that over the past few years there has been a tremendous improvement in the type of machinery used for road making. We have no objection to the use of such machinery if it is doing a job which cannot be done equally well by manual labour. Surely it is going a bit too far when we find whole areas in which men are being left off in order that some machine can be brought in, a machine sometimes bought by a local authority as an experiment and, if the experiment proves unsatisfactory, is promptly hung around the necks of the ratepayers. At other times the machinery is borrowed or hired. I know the Minister is a reasonable man and I appeal to him now to examine into this matter; he will find that what I am saying is perfectly true. If, later on in the year, I find, as the Jeremiahs across the way are predicting, that there is unemployment because there is not enough money available, then I will take whatever action is necessary.
On the question of wage increase, we were very glad this year to be able to avail of the Labour Court on behalf of road workers. It is regrettable that one or two local authorities, after agreeing to have the case investigated by the Labour Court and after having attended there, sought then to intimidate the road workers by notifying them that, if the wage increases which the Labour Court had recommended were paid, there would be less employment and suggesting to them that they should take a smaller amount. I protest strongly against that action. A Government sponsored Labour Court was set up and surely the least we can expect from local authorities is that they would respect that court.
There is another matter which arises in relation to employment and the Minister should take cognisance of it. At this time of year, certain officials of local authorities seem to go a little bit mad because they cease to recognise the normal working hours. They expect men to start work at eight o'clock in the morning and continue working so long as there is light.
Comment on this
From this time of the year on until the surface dressing operations are finished. One finds this craze in very many counties, a craze on the part of officials who do not themselves have to have their noses to the grindstone for 15, 16 or 17 hours per day. I suggest these people are breaking the law and the Minister should put an end to this practice forthwith.
Comment on this
They are paid time and a quarter, which is the minimum rate.
Comment on this
The practice has grown up during the years and it is very widespread now. It has become worse over the last few years. I would like to see it stopped and stopped quickly. The trade union I represent could stop it. We could stop it at grave inconvenience and loss of wages to the men concerned. I suggest the Minister should be able to stop it without any loss to anyone.
Comment on this
There may be an answer to it. Possibly the work that is being done could not be done in the winter or in wet weather. That may be the answer. I do not know.
Comment on this
The work that is being done can only be done in fine weather but, if in former years, this work could be done at a much slower rate over a few months, and without this excessive overtime, surely with up-to-date machinery the work could be done equally well inside the summer period without any hardship on anybody. I might add that, except on very rare occasions, the men concerned do not want to work overtime, much as they need a fatter pay packet, because it means they are out of work as soon as the job is finished.
I would like the Minister to examine this system, which has grown up in many counties, of using contract material in preference to direct labour. The excuse is given that the former is cheaper. While that may be true in some cases, in most cases the difference is very slight and I suggest there is no reason at all why county councils should not be able to get the work done just as cheaply if the machinery is of the proper type. Men should not be left unemployed so that some contractor may reap a very rich harvest. There is no use giving a big employment grant if the result is that the workman gets even less than he was receiving ten years ago. Despite the increased grants, there is a smaller volume of employment. I suggest that matter should receive immediate attention of the Minister.
A few months ago somebody said that direct labour on housing had not proved a success. I know that 30 years ago the county councils decided they would carry out road works by direct labour. That has never been altered but, in defiance of that, officials are attempting in some places to have the work done by contract.
Many of us were wondering what was happening in relation to the housing grants and we were glad to hear the Minister's announcement of the introduction of a new Bill inside the next fortnight. I am sure that when that Bill is introduced those who have been building in the interim period will be catered for and no losses will be incurred.
Comment on this
In some counties there is trouble in relation to the erection of labourers' cottages. In one or two counties, the position has been that only a few contractors are prepared to tender for these houses for some time past. In some cases, the work is very badly done. Possibly we can blame the engineers and say that they should see that the work is properly carried out; but, when the choice is so small it is very hard to know whom to blame. Definitely the ratepayers and the people who will live in the houses suffer. The greatest encouragement should be given to any council that is anxious to carry out building by direct labour.
Another problem which is affecting a number of counties, and which is affecting my own in a very big way, is the question of cottage repairs. I do not know what has happened over the years but I do know that, at the present time, it is almost impossible for any local authority to find easily the amount of money required to keep in repair the cottages they have. There is a legal obligation on them to keep these houses in repair. It looks as if they will not be able to keep them in repair in some cases and what is going to happen then I do not know. There will have to be some system devised by which money can be made available to local authorities to have their cottages repaired so that they can be purchased by the tenants. It would not be reasonable to ask a tenant to take over a cottage in a bad state of repair. If these cottages could be handed over when they are in good repair, the scheme would work out in a much better way.
There is another point I should like to bring to the notice of the Minister. When making a vesting Order would it be possible, instead of setting out a fixed rent which cannot be altered until a new vesting Order is made, for the Minister, instead of saying the rent is now so much and that it will be reduced by 50 per cent. to lay down a regulation that the existing rent can be reduced by 50 per cent.? That would simplify the matter considerably because at the moment some local authorities are very badly tied up and people cannot purchase their houses because of this legal bar.
One other matter that deserves consideration is that in some cases the records of county councils seem to have gone astray. In my constituency we have a case of two cottages built together under the one roof but according to the records one was built in 1897 and the other in 1908. It would have been physically impossible to build these houses eleven years apart. However, the result of that is that one of the tenants has bought out his cottage on ten years purchase and the other man has had to buy out his under 15 years purchase. All that is due to a clerical error and the county council officials have not got the power to alter the vesting Order. They have to carry out the regulations as they are laid down. I would ask that, in a case of this kind, something should be done to set the matter right.
We have heard the question discussed, over the past couple of days, as to whether money ought or ought not to be spent on county roads or on main roads. I think there seems to be little doubt in the minds of Deputies that the proper way to spend the money is on the county roads and that the accent should be taken off the main roads. I suppose I travel more through this country than any one else in this House. That may be a tall order but it is true and I, for one, am satisfied that the present standard of our main roads is so high that it requires very little alteration. There is still a tremendous number of county roads in a deplorable condition. Even if we were to suspend the expenditure of money on main roads and spend the whole lot on the county roads, I think it would be advisable.
We have a problem in County Meath where the county council decided to deal with the matter of these county and byroads in a particular way and it did not work out so well. We have, in County Meath, a number of boreens and lanes. These lanes and boreens serve quite a number of houses. It was decided by the county council, in order to make proper roads of them, to declare them as county roads and then repair them. This was done but the county council found that it was responsible for the maintenance of them and they also found that the Department was unwilling to assist in any way. Some of the critics of the scheme suggested that something should have been done long before that. It was all right to say that was the way to do it but the idea was that the job should have been done many years ago. Since many of the main roads have now been brought up to a very reasonable state of repair, perhaps all these lanes and boreens could now be converted into county roads. At some time or other we must reach the end of the work on the main roads and I suggest to the Minister that the Department should find some means of helping councils who give an indication of their willingness to help themselves by drawing up such a scheme. I think that the Department should make available some type of grant to such councils.
Even in County Meath, a sum of £30,000 represents a very sizable figure. To carry out a full programme, five times that amount will have to be found and councils are not too anxious to embark on such programmes. The Minister might put aside a certain sum that could be spent to help councils anxious to help themselves in this matter.
There was a complaint about the delay in having houses inspected. This is a matter which is true of one county as well as of another. In some cases we are told that the appointed officer had too much work on hand or that he had been ill for some time. I do not think this is a matter that ought to be passed over lightly. It surely is a bit thick when you find that houses, reported for inspection two years ago, have not yet been inspected. I think we can go back to the two years before that and find that the same thing happened then. The same thing also happened in the previous two years. The inspectors in many cases are not living close enough to their areas and for some reason, apparently, some of them do not want to carry out their job. I think that this is something about which the Department ought to take some action. Houses, whether for construction or reconstruction, should not be allowed to lie for years without being inspected. If everybody carried out the regulations and decided to wait until the inspector had reported the scheme as O.K., many of the houses would not have been touched yet. I think this is a deplorable state of affairs in view of the fact that very many of the people need the money so badly. In many cases people do not qualify for grants simply because somebody who is paid to do a job is not doing it.
There are very many matters which can come under discussion in this Estimate but there is one which, I think, should be referred to, and I did not hear it referred to earlier. It is the question of the Local Authorities (Works) Act grants. I think that those grants should also be raised to the amounts at which they stood four or five years ago. Very useful work has been carried out under those grants. As a matter of fact, since the arterial drainage schemes are in operation, the Local Authorities (Works) Act grants can be far more effectively used than they could be when the drainage was directed into already waterlogged and overloaded rivers. I suggest that this is something which the Department should examine, and I suggest that the grant should be increased.
I also suggest that the work should be notified much earlier than at present. At present the system seems to be that the road grants are expended during summer and autumn and the drainage grants during the winter. Would it not be more sensible if the order were reversed and the drainage grants expended in a period when people can work on drainage without undue hardship, and leave the road grants to be expended during the winter period?
There is one other matter which I would like to bring to the notice of the Minister—the question of approval of grants. I have been informed by a number of county managers this year that, while they have been notified of the amount of the grants, they still have not got approval for the spending of any of them. I do not know whether that is correct or not but it is rather peculiar that it should arise in more places than one. I think if the Department agrees to grants being expended, and have approved the works on which they are to be expended, it is surely reasonable that authority to spend should be given to the local authority concerned so that the work can be put in hand if the men are available and the work can be done. One problem on which I would like the Minister to give me a decision—I do not know if it would be possible for him to do so-is this. Out of the entire allocation which is given to county councils and local authorities generally from the Road Fund, would the Minister be able to say how much is spent on labour?
Comment on this
It is very difficult, reading the items of the Estimate, to know exactly what is relevant. There have been a few brushes between speakers and the Chair already this evening. I take it that legislation is out, but it also seems to me that a good deal of the discussion is about topics which are almost exclusively the province of the local authority. Reading the information given to us in the Book of Estimates it does seem to me that we are discussing things about which there is the minimum of information or a complete absence of information in the details supplied in the Book of Estimates.
Take for instance all the references that have been made to roads. One would have to search this Estimate to get any information about road expenditure. Another criticism I have of the form in which the Estimate is presented to us is that, in the beginning of the book, we are supplied with items under the summary of capital services; and in the part of it that deals with local government, the sums mentioned are exactly the same as those mentioned under the relevant headings in the Estimate itself. The question I would like to have answered is whether the sums mentioned under the capital heading are additional to the sums mentioned in the Estimate itself?
In any event, whether they are additional or merely explanatory of the method by which the money is to be found, I think that they should appear under the Estimate itself where the two separate statements may be seen at the one glance. It does seem to me that the items in the capital summary are not additional but that it is just an indication to us that the sums are to be raised by way of borrowing. I do note that the entire of the sum to be provided for works under the Local Authorities (Works) Act is to be borrowed. Whether that is good financial policy or not is questionable. We do know that the expenditure on this service is very closely allied to the expenditure out of the Road Fund itself, and a great part of the work undertaken under the Local Authorities (Works) Act is immediately ancillary to the reconstruction or improvement of either county or main roads—in any event roads which are financed out of the Road Fund.
One may not, as has been clearly demonstrated by the Chair, refer to legislation, but I take it I will be permitted to advert to the effect of a particular piece of legislation to which references were made in passing by a number of Deputies. I refer to the effect of the Managerial Acts on the exercise by the Minister of his functions——
Comment on this
Administration may be discussed but the merits or demerits of an Act may not be discussed on an Estimate.
Comment on this
I recognise that I have to keep within the limits set out by the Chair, but what I want to refer to specifically is the obligation which rests upon the Minister in regard to the exercise of his ministerial functions. That obligation is now heightened by the fact that a very larger number of the duties formerly carried out by elected authority are now, in fact, within the executive category, and that the council is only aware of what the executive authority does by way of question and answer, such as we have in this House.
I had occasion last year to refer to what I looked upon as a very grave dereliction of duty on the part of a local authority. When I referred to it the Minister came back with his usual defence: "Did that not happen before I came in? Was it not a Minister of your own Government who was mainly responsible in the matter?" That sort of attitude is not good enough for a Minister. If there is an evil to be remedied, if there is a dereliction of duty to be corrected, surely a Minister, having squelched the complainant here in the Dáil, is not entitled to wash his hands of responsibility in the matter. No matter who the persons are who comprise the Government or Opposition, the Minister responsible should see that the public duty is carried out.
I spoke in great detail last year on a matter about which I had cause to complain and which lasted for ten years. In my opinion—and I hope I will not tempt Deputy O'Leary into any irrelevant and unpermissible remarks about the managerial system —it would not have happened in pre-managerial days; I will concede that much to him. However, it had to do with the provision of a water supply scheme in a Gaeltacht area. The law, I understand, is clear enough, particularly for those upon whom the duty rests of carrying it out—the county legal advisers, the county councils and the county officials generally, who should be experts in the Acts which they have to administer. It does seem and it did seem extraordinary that any set of officials should so misconstrue— and I have to be charitable and conclude that it was an innocent misconstruction—the Acts of Parliament that a very urgently needed water scheme was completely muffed and muffed over a period of about ten years.
If the Minister were here—I am sorry he is not—I would have expected to get the glib interruption: "You yourselves were there when it happened." I am conceding that to him straight away but, when the matter came to my notice, as a representative of the area I took all the action I could to ensure that finality was reached in this matter. The Minister recapitulated the history of the case for the benefit of the county manager, pointed out again in his final letter the legal objections which the scheme contained in the view of the departmental advisers and, because of the local authority's insistence on the legal soundness of the scheme, gave his sanction with the addendum that the local authority would itself be responsible for any consequences if in fact it was not as legally sound as he said it was.
Having got this official intimation from the Minister, the local authority then dropped the scheme like a hot spud which convinced me and must have convinced the Minister and the Minister's advisers that they were doubtful about the soundness of this scheme at any time. A well-known firm of engineering consultants was then consulted and they were sent off on a wild goose chase to find water about five or six miles away over undulating granite country. They discovered a supply of water in a place that was already being tapped for another community. The report of the consultants was duly presented and it expressed doubt as to whether the supply would be adequate for the existing needs plus the new ones proposed. In any event it indicated that the cost of the scheme would now be £43,000 as against the original £16,000 and, of course, the local authority, the elected authority in this case, felt themselves compelled to drop the scheme.
I do not wish to go back over the whole ground this year, as I did it last year, but it is relevant and pertinent this year again because the subject of wells is now a matter of current local administration and, therefore, proper to be referred to on this Estimate. I want to ask the Minister—it does not matter from which side of the House or from which Party he is drawn— what does he regard as his obligation, having given his sanction? What does he now regard as his obligation when he finds that his sanction is nugatory or when he finds, as happened in this case, that he was being asked by a local authority, with its tongue in its cheek, to give sanction to a scheme that they apparently knew was not sustainable or water-tight against possible objectors?
When I refer to the managerial effect in this regard, I am not referring to the Act itself. What I want the Minister to take cognisance of is the fact that there is a greater obligation on him in respect of this function of sanction of his in respect of proposals which are submitted by the executive authority. I understand the word "reserve" in relation to functions indicates the category of functions exercised by the elected authority. I do not know exactly what the others are referred to as unless they are managerial functions. However, where the function is a managerial one and where it has to do with an important public project such as the one to which I am referring, the Minister is not entitled to sit on his hunkers when he finds that his sanction is ineffective.
It is bad enough to have the ending of the scheme plus the additional cost of the exploration work carried out by an important body of consultants but, to try to compensate the community to be served for the disappointment, the futile search for drinking water in solid granite that has been tapped in other years without result is now being undertaken again. I will put a question to the Minister here. It seems to me if one asks for information across the floor of the House from the Department of Agriculture as to what goes on in any particular council one cannot get it, even in regard to the expenditure of grants that the Department themselves have given to a local authority. I put a question to the Department about the knowledge gained through the sinking of pumps in granite in search of water 20 or 25 years ago. The Department told me they had no information on the subject.
Comment on this
I feel sure the Wexford County Council would be able, even after 25 years, to dig up information on what was at that time a sort of pioneer scheme. I am certainly satisfied the Galway County Council could do it, but apparently the Department cannot.
Comment on this
That is the Minister's attitude always. Does he want to shed all responsibility as Minister for Local Government? There are certain items set out in this Book of Estimates for which the Minister, as far as the public are concerned, is responsible to Dáil Éireann.
Comment on this
I think it ridiculous to take up the time of this House by asking here questions to which the replies could be given by the local authority down in Galway.
Comment on this
I want to tell the Minister across the floor of the House that I put to him a question about the allocation of road grants made by him to the Galway County Council. In reply, he referred me to the county council for information. I applied to the county council for the information but did not get it.
Comment on this
If the Minister would let me make my statement of the facts and not try to bawl me off by these intelligent suggestions we would both get on much more quickly. I assure him I am not speaking here to-night for the purpose of having my voice heard or because I think I might get some publicity in the morning. Last year when I raised the same matter I did not get any publicity. I myself gave the account to the people who were really concerned. In case the Minister did not hear my remarks here this evening——
Comment on this
I want the Minister to bear in mind what I have said in relation to the exercise of his function of sanction. That sanction was a great safeguard in pre-managerial days. I have not been a member of a local body since the advent of the managerial system but I was a member in pre-managerial days. When Deputy O'Leary refers here to the managerial system I should like to tell him we had just as many serious reservations about it as he had.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen, who is a very experienced local administrator, complained, and rightly so, of the contact between the Department and the managerial offices in every county on matters of detail. I understand that complaints can be made against the local administration of practically every one of the 27 councils in the country. It does seem to me that, having regard to the fact that the phone is so much in use since the managerial system came in and that, to our own knowledge, it is availed of to such an extent both in the Department and in the council offices, it is ridiculous that a matter such as I have mentioned should have been allowed to continue for ten years without somebody having been able to expose the snag and bring the tomfoolery to an end. The people are being fooled by the spectacle of elaborate machinery being sunk into 900 ft. of granite on the edge of the sea in an attempt to get fresh water. However, there is more cynicism than optimism in the minds of the people.
Comment on this
I am not going to advertise or criticise any firm of consultants here in Dáil Éireann. The Minister has spoken a good deal, more outside than inside the House, on the question of the main roads or, as he called them once in my hearing, the autobahns for the plutocrats. He may have been putting his little bit of political snobbery standing on its apex, but we forgive him for doing that in a by-election.
As far as the congested districts and the Gaeltacht areas are concerned, the Gaeltacht Office under the administration of Deputy Jack Lynch laid the foundations of this scheme for the development of all the roads in the Gaeltacht areas, and when I personally made representations that a beginning should be made on the county roads in these areas and work on these roads out to the main approaches to those tourist areas, I was told that all the authorities—Local Government Department road advisers and county council engineers—had, as a result of long examination, decided that the main approaches should first be improved and that at the end of three years the county roads which I had in mind would follow automatically. That policy is in fact being carried out and I do not think the Minister can claim the entire credit for it. In so far as he adheres to that policy I give him all credit, but I should like to point out that he did not initiate it.
On the question of criticism of the amount of money being spent on main roads, is it not a fact that the standard of the work is in fact imposed from above? When it comes to improving the main roads with the help of Government grant, plus the local income from the rates, are the proposals not subject to the approval of the Minister's road engineering advisers? I move to report progress.