Committee on Finance. - Vote 47—Lands (Resumed).
Contributions 128–291 of 291. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
There is no doubt that Michael Davitt did a great deal for the tenant farmers of this country but I think it will be conceded that Cut Quinlan and the farmers of Sander's Fort, Woodford and Ballycohey put paid to landlordism in this country. I hope we have seen the last of it.
We have vast ranches in Tipperary and there is one of 800 acres the owner of which is in South Africa. I am quite sure I could give a guarantee to the Minister that he is not fighting against the Mau Mau, but I do not care whether he is with them or against them, where 800 acres of land are giving employment to only three or four people, I think it is our duty to focus attention on that, and to divide that land and put into it young, virile men who would give to the State the production necessary for our economy.
I hold that no man, or very few men in this country, can possibly farm 800 acres of land and, as I said during the Minister's absence, every small holding that goes up for sale now is usually gobbled up by adjoining large land-holders. The small man is unable to get money in the bank to finance him and the danger is that we are going to have all these smallholdings taken over by the moneyed people. Money is an evil when it means lessening the holdings in this country and lessening production. I feel if this process continues the Minister must cry "half." This Minister, or some Minister, must at some stage say there must be a limit to the number of acres any man may own. There is very little employment on these ranches and that is responsible for lopsided economy to a very appreciable extent. You have no employment, no production, but you have bullocks roaming around, and many of our young people emigrating. That must stop, and the way to stop it is to acquire the large ranches, put the people on them, and then we will have a happy and contented country.
Comment on this
I shall confine my remarks to a reference to one matter only and I shall not detain the House very long. It concerns the administration of Sections 27 and 28, I think, of the 1950 Land Act, dealing with the acquisition of land that comes on the market for cash. I think the criticisms that were offered when the Bill was going through the House have proved correct because the Land Commission has not, so far as I know, gone into the auctions generally to acquire land. Reasons for that were given by some of the speakers on the other side this evening. They suggested that "puffing" and such other malpractices would prevent acquisition of land at the market price.
The Minister, when he was piloting that Bill through the Dáil, laid emphasis on the fact that the market price should be paid for these smallholdings that come on the market from time to time. I do not think there is any necessity to question that, particularly in respect of those smallholdings in the West of Ireland. Here is a matter of which I want the Minister to take a note. I have drawn attention to the fact that holdings were available in my constituency and that these holdings would be useful to relieve congestion. Criticism has been made by people in the Leinster counties of what they call undue migration to the detriment of local aspirants for land. If holdings become available in the congested districts and are not acquired by the Land Commission, then one must say that Deputies in Leinster counties would have some ground at least for their criticism. Here is the explanation that was given to me for the failure of the Land Commission to acquire a holding very recently when it was brought to the attention of the local Land Commission office—there was no congestion in the immediate vicinity of the holdings and therefore the provision of these sections of the 1950 Act did not apply.
I think in view of what the Minister said on the 1950 Act, that explanation is a rather lame excuse for the Land Commission to get out of its obligation to apply the provisions of the Act for the relief of congestion. If there is no congestion in the immediate vicinity of the holding, would it not be desirable to acquire that holding and to migrate somebody into it rather than send him further away? Other speakers have said that what is happening in respect of these holdings which the Land Commission failed to acquire, is that people with more money than they require, people whose means of livelihood is not exclusively or mainly agricultural, acquire these holdings as investments, possibly for the grazing of stock. I think that the Minister ought to see to it that, whatever about going into the public auction, where it is known or brought to the notice of the Land Commission that a holding is available by private treaty, that holding should be acquired. I do not think that the price will be "puffed" to a figure which would put it beyond the range of the Land Commission's finances.
I do not have to say any more about it because the Minister himself must have come across a good many cases of it in his own constituency. In view of the case he made for those sections of the 1950 Act, I certainly think the Minister should insist that these holdings be acquired when they are on the market and available for acquisition by private treaty. They will contribute something to the relief of congestion. Accordingly, I ask the Minister to direct the Land Commission to interpret the existence of congestion somewhat differently and not to qualify it by insisting that the congestion must be in the immediate vicinity of the holding.
Comment on this
I want to say at the outset that I am very pleased by the interest shown by Deputies generally during this debate in the Land Commission and their work. A good many useful suggestions were put forward. Criticism, on the whole, was good and constructive; there was less wandering, if I might use the expression, from the beaten path this time than I have noticed for several years back.
One of the principal sources of complaint was that the Land Commission were slow about the acquisition of land and that the value of the land bonds which the commission pay for land has fallen. The questions of roads and the selection of migrants were also raised. I must admit that the questions raised about the Land Commission being slow in the acquisition and distribution of land were true. However, it is unfair for members of the House to criticise the Land Commission for that, because the law this House has passed has set statutory shackles on the feet of the commissioners; the laws this House has passed since 1923 prescribe certain delays, so that the owners of land, if they happen to be absent from the country, or if they happen to be unaware that the Land Commission are proceeding, will have due notice, so that fair play will be given to the persons from whom land is being taken.
These delays were deliberately installed in the Land Acts as passed through this House. The Land Commission cannot evade these statutory periods of a month in this case, or three months in that case, laid down by the various Acts so as to ensure that injustices will not be done. It must be remembered that the Land Commission have sweeping powers; they have the power to dispossess a man of his property. Surely nobody will deny that that is a sweeping power. It must also be remembered that, from the decision to acquire land or to resume it, there is no appeal; the moment the lay commissioners decide that the land of Mr. X is to become the property of the Land Commission, there is no appeal to any other court. The only appeal may lie on a question of law. For that reason, the House, in its wisdom or unwisdom, decided to make sure that the process by which the Land Commission deprives a man of his land shall be slow, steady and careful. Therefore, when a Deputy attacks the Land Commission for delays in taking up land, he is only revealing his own ignorance of the laws with which he should be acquainted.
I was proud, when presenting this Estimate, to be able to give the House a very good account of the Land Commission's activities this year. In the year gone by, over 700 holdings were rearranged. As many holdings were rearranged this year and last year as were rearranged in the three preceding years. Some Deputies seem to think that progress is slowing down in this respect. That is not so. We have increased our activities from that point of view by 50 per cent. over the past five years. We must remember that we are dealing with human beings —that it is not with land entirely we are dealing.
We are dealing here with men and women, their livelihoods, their whole future in many cases. Accordingly, a certain amount of care must be taken in the case of rearrangements. As I have said many times previously, a rearrangement scheme is not a Land Commission scheme. It is a scheme of the tenants themselves because, until the last of the tenants has agreed to the scheme and has signed a consent form for the inspector, nothing can be done.
Deputies from the congested counties will know of cases where an inspector spent the whole of the winter going out to a townland or to a group of townlands. He might have a rearrangement scheme completed, except for one crank who, at the last moment, will refuse to agree, although he may have given the inspector the impression that he was agreeable. In such cases, the inspector's whole winter's work goes for naught. I ask Deputies to remember that rearrangement work is different from any other kind of work the Land Commission handle.
A rearrangement scheme, as I have said, is not the Land Commission's scheme; it is not the inspector's scheme. It is the scheme that the people who are being rearranged agree to. If they do not agree—and very often one tenant smashes up the whole scheme—the Land Commission may not proceed further. On previous occasions, it was suggested that the commission were advised to deal drastically with the type of tenant who smashes up such a scheme. The justice of such a proceeding has to be taken into account. Sometimes the crank refuses to agree for the purpose of mere obstruction; sometimes he is a crank only because he is a crank. I do not know whether the sledge-hammer of a Government Department should be brought down on top of such a man.
Occasionally, it is possible to rearrange the rest of the tenants and leave the crank there. In other cases, however, that man may own seven, eight or ten acres of land scattered throughout the townland or throughout the parish in bits and pieces. Of course, the inspector has strict instructions not to allow any tenant to put the gun to his head in order to try to get a better slice of land in the village than he is entitled to.
Comment on this
On that point, if a man who is in a position, that he can hold up a scheme, sells his holding of seven or eight acres and then tries to get a farm, what would the Minister's attitude be?
Comment on this
The man I am talking about might have only seven or eight acres altogether in bits and pieces.
Comment on this
I have known of a case where a farmer, who was offered a farm out of the place, but who would not please his neighbours to get out, tried to sell his holding of seven or eight acres later. Would the Minister allow that to happen?
Comment on this
Not in most cases. It is a very hard matter to decide, because no two cases are exactly alike. As I have said, taking into account that over 700 holdings have been successfully rearranged this year, I think the Land Commission has achieved a great deal. It is a sign that the outdoor inspectors of the Land Commission in the congested areas are doing their work well. Sometimes we get criticisms from Deputies who have no experience of the difficulties that arise. That makes it appear as if the Land Commission, like every other Department, is a useful butt to have a kick at in the Dáil because it cannot reply. Occasionally Deputies indulge in that type of criticism; I regard it as a waste of time and when I suspect that is behind what is being said, I will not reply to it.
Various Deputies asked for certain figures. The area acquired was 30,473 acres. The area allotted was 35,596. The number of holdings vested, that is the number of holdings in which the Land Commission handed over ownership to the tenant, was 7,704. There were 1,031 holdings enlarged and the enlargement of those holdings used up 11,858 acres. There were 763 tenants who gave partial exchanges and received for the lands they gave 16,182 acres. In regard to other allotments, 204 allottees received an area of 7,556 acres. The total number of people who benefited from rearrangement, exchanges and enlargement was 1,918 and 35,596 acres were used up in the process.
That is a vast amount of land to go through. Some Deputies seem to regard the Land Commission more in the nature of a factory or a mill so that if you get sufficient men to throw enough land into the mill and set the wheels turning, suitable and adequate holdings with the tenants nicely installed will flow out on a conveyor belt. That is the impression some Deputies give me, that they have not gone to the trouble of finding out exactly what the work of the Land Commission is. If they spent only a few days with the Land Commission inspector in the course of his work, went in company with him, but not interfere in his work, they would see what the Land Commission inspector had to put up with.
Comment on this
In case Deputies think I want them to go around to resume the practice, which I hope is dead, of going around along with the inspector dividing land——
Comment on this
I was listening to the Minister's statement as to the number of acres being divided, apportioned and so on, and I wonder, before the Minister concludes, would he indicate the number of acres apportioned in County Limerick?
Comment on this
I cannot allow every Deputy to stand up and make a second speech in respect of his county.
Comment on this
Deputy Derrig urged the Land Commission to minimise the losses on resale. I can assure the Deputy that that question is constantly under review. In fact it is one of the headaches of the Department. To give an example, in 1951, the loss on resale was 33 per cent. while in 1955 it was down to 22 per cent. of the aggregate purchase prices. The same Deputy raised the question of the effect of rising costs on the output level of improvement works. Labourers' wages and building materials have gone up and are still climbing. The question was put also of the rateable valuation of the 43 holdings purchased under Section 27 of the 1950 Act. The rateable valuation of these holdings is £709. The approximate purchase price was over £40,000.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I asked the Minister a question as to the apportionment of land in County Limerick and he has not so far answered.
Comment on this
That is not a point of order, and the Deputy has interrupted the Minister several times.
Comment on this
I cannot allow Deputies to stand up and ask questions unless the Minister gives way. The Minister must not be questioned by every Deputy in respect of each county. He is concluding the debate.
Comment on this
Deputy Derrig asked about the area on hands and in the machine. The area on hands at 31st March, 1956, was approximately 100,000 acres, a large part of which is bog or poor land which the Land Commission found difficulty in allotting. Acquisition proceedings are at present in progress in respect of a total area of 54,025 acres and detailed reports on a further area of 5,403 acres are under consideration with a view to initiating proceedings. During the year 1955-56, 49,374 acres were inspected and valued and 20,836 acres were gazetted for acquisition and resumption. In all, up to 31st March, 1956, 1,201,000 acres have been finally acquired and resumed and, of this area, 1,098,000 acres have been allotted. The number of turbary allotments was 1,007, covering an aggregate area of nearly 1,800 acres. Some Deputies pressed for closer cooperation between the Land Commission and the Department of Agriculture. There is no need to press for that. There is constant and close contact between the two Departments and some of the legislation passed by this House obliges the commission to consult the Department of Agriculture on certain occasions. Deputy Palmer and Deputy Flynn raised the question as to the number of migrants from Kerry in the past three years. In 1953-54 the number was 11; in 1954-55 it was eight; in 1955-56, it was nine. The details of the land allotted is: 1953-54, 205 acres; 1954-55, 908 acres, 1955-56, 2,061 acres.
Deputy Beegan and other Deputies raised the question of the deterioration in the value of land bonds. To some Deputies who spoke about the temporary drop in the value of land bonds in the stock market, I would point out that it was the inter-Party Government and myself, as Minister for Lands during the period of 1948-1951, that introduced the principle of market value for acquired land. I remember that there was some very peculiar criticism, when we look back over the years, in regard to this matter. While we heard plenty of noise from the benches opposite when the price of land bonds dropped, very little credit was given to the Minister for Finance or myself as Minister for Lands when the land bonds which were issued at par rose above par. They are below par at the present time and I can assure Deputies that this is a matter which I will take up with the Government at the earliest opportunity. The Minister for Finance fixes the interest rate on land bonds each year and he does that in consultation with the officials in the Department of Finance so as to ensure that the issuing of land bonds for the coming year will not mean that those whose land is being acquired by, the Land Commission will be at a loss. But fluctuations in the stock market, just as in any other market, are entirely beyond the control even of the Minister for Finance and his officials. This year, the value of the bonds has dropped, giving rise to the complaints made by the Deputies. I want to assure the House that, if this continues, I will not feel happy. It would not be right if we were paying land bonds to a man whose land we had taken and for whose land the Appeal Tribunal judge had fixed a particular price and when we were paying the land bonds, they were considerably below the market value—in other words, that he was not getting what he was entitled to.
Deputy Tully, of Meath, asked for details regarding sums paid in respect of preview expenses. The fees paid in the year 1955-56 varied from 12/- to £5 6s. 1d., giving a total of £255 paid in respect of these preview expenses, and 64 prospective migrants were involved.
He raised the question of remnants of estates. He raised it by way of parliamentary question in the Dáil some time ago, but on that occasion the time at our disposal did not permit me to give him a full explanation. As far as I remember, there are about 700 small portions of estates, some of them let, some of them remnants of bog, but all of them just scraps. A fairly considerable number of estates are allotted each year, and as fresh farms or estates are being allotted, the number of remnants changes. The Land Commission must hold onto each remnant until some fine day the inspector finds some man who will accept it and will fit in with Land Commission policy and Government policy in regard to the allotment of land.
Comment on this
Migrants will not take it, but you will always have a local man who will take it.
Comment on this
In some cases where there are remnants, we would be glad to know a way in which we can get shut of them. There is a good deal of criticism of the Land Commission in regard to the way estates are allotted. I do not think that in the whole history of land division work by the Congested Districts Board, the Land Commission or the Estates Commissioners in days gone by, any estate was ever divided that pleased everybody. As a matter of fact, if it came to a time when somebody did by any chance stand up in this House and praise the Land Commission or the Minister for Lands——
Comment on this
——I would fall over backwards. What happens is that, when land is taken over by the State, people in the country being very land-minded and I do not blame them become very anxious to get some of that land. The Land Commission inspector is paid and is qualified to divide that land according to Land Commission policy—or Government policy, I should say—and to give it to those best entitled to it, number one, and those who he thinks will make the best use of it. For every one who gets land there are always bound to be at least ten disappointed people. These have their hearts set on getting land, and they are very disappointed and bitter because they cannot see why the neighbour should have got it when they did not get it. That is very natural. I quite understand it, but it is one of the things that make the work of a Land Commission inspector very difficult.
I know there is no Deputy from a rural constituency coming in here who does not get complaints—I get them myself—and tales are carried, all kinds of stories, about the people who got it, that they should not have got it. Every time I hold an inquest on the division of an estate, I have had to admit that the inspector was right. Some people, judging from what appears on the surface, might disagree with them, but let us get down to full details, let us get the papers and the circumstances of the various applicants, and you will find your information was lacking. That has been my experience both as Deputy and as Minister.
Comment on this
I hope it is, but I want to say this: the law of this House says that the acquisition of land and the allotment of it is a matter for the commissioners and the inspectors, but I want to make this clear that the Deputies are the law makers, and if a Deputy knows of any case in which the law has been violated or outraged, it is not only his right but his duty to raise it and to bring details of it either publicly here in the Dáil or privately. It is not only a Deputy's privilege, but, I submit, his duty, if he finds or thinks that the allotment of land or the acquisition of land has been carried out in violation of the law of this House, to draw attention to it, and I would be very glad to know it.
Comment on this
I should be very pleased to submit to the Minister's office the action of a certain Land Commission official in County Limerick who is actively engaged in propaganda and organising for a particular Party in that area.
Comment on this
I should be very surprised to hear it, because Land Commission inspectors have their jobs and they are very anxious to hold them. I want also to add this warning to any Land Commission inspectors and both indoor and outdoor members of the Land Commission staff, that they are playing with fire, if they touch politics. They are supposed to give a fair crack of the whip to every person they meet, regardless of politics, religion, or anything else, and I would have absolutely no hesitation in recommending to the Government their dismissal overnight, if I thought they were guilty of any kind of discrimination connected with politics, religion or anything else. There are very clear-cut instructions laid down, and everyone is fully aware of the penalties attached.
Deputy Maguire is very wroth with me because I do not prophesy at least a year in advance the number of holdings that will be dealt with, the number of migrants who will get holdings, the number of times we will make rearrangements, in a particular year. I want to say again, as I said before on a previous occasion in this House, that I cannot prophesy what will happen. As I said at the outset and as every rural Deputy should know, rearrangement schemes, and the allotment of lands depend to a large extent on the response of the tenants, and very often one man will upset a whole scheme, so that any attempt at an estimate will be only a guess. A Minister should not indulge in guesswork or conjecture in this House.
Deputy Seán Flanagan is very interested in the Nally estate in County Mayo. That estate will be divided just as soon as the inspector can reach it.
The question of roads was touched on by many Deputies. I put it to the Deputies that the Land Commission makes a good road. I think it was Deputy Fanning, of Tipperary, who described it as throwing a handful of gravel on the top of the road.
Comment on this
That is a fact. So far as we are concerned, we would not take over the roads because the roads were never made.
Comment on this
It is the Land Commission that makes the roads and the local authority that maintains them. My experience in the Midlands and the West of Ireland, Kerry, and practically every county, is that the Land Commission makes a good sound road for the purpose of providing an accommodation road to an allotment or into a bog. While this House votes money to the Land Commission under sub-head I of the Estimate under debate at the present time to make roads, the Land Commission does not ask or has not got from the House money to repair those roads.
Comment on this
I have known roads in Tipperary which came before the council and we refused to take them over because they were not made properly at all.
Comment on this
The Land Commission does not make a public road. It makes an accommodation road 12 or 13 feet wide.
Comment on this
I agree about the width, but the matter I am complaining about is the condition of the roads, which is so bad that we cannot take them over.
Comment on this
The roads the Land Commission make are in most cases quite good enough for the county council to take over if only the county council would take them over in the condition in which they are when the Land Commission finishes them.
Comment on this
If Deputies would not interrupt me we would get through more quickly. Deputies will have another chance. As I said, the Land Commission makes a good wide road and leaves it in good condition. What happens then is that in practically every instance the tenants go in and they use that road; they bring in lorries to take out beet, lorries to bring in turf, tractors and threshing machines. The road is grand for a while but, with that traffic passing over it, it first becomes potholed and then falls into disrepair. Then people come along and say: "The Land Commission made that road five or ten years ago and look at it now."
Comment on this
Deputy Fanning may not interrupt. Deputy Fanning had his opportunity. The Minister is now concluding.
Comment on this
I will answer any questions when I have finished, if I can. The Land Commission make good roads. If Deputies will look at sub-head I they will see that there is no money there for the repair of roads. I submit that there is provision to keep these roads in repair and that is under the Special Employment Schemes Office, either by way of minor employment scheme or rural improvement scheme. That is the proper machinery. Surely a body set up to relieve congestion and settle the land question must make roads to suit their particular activities. Are we to have four road authorities? Will we have C.I.E., the county council of the particular county, the Special Employment Schemes Office and the Land Commission? There would be desperate overlapping there and a criminal waste of public money and public officials' time. The Land Commission make good roads and those roads should be kept in repair by the county council or through the Special Employment Schemes Office. Those are the two bodies which are equipped financially to keep such roads in repair.
Deputy Lindsay mentioned the reclaiming of bogland at Ballycroy. That was tried out on a small area of ten holdings containing about 20 acres each. They were fenced, drained and cultivated. They were handed over to nine migrants and one landless man. At the moment in Glenamoy on the site of the grass-meal experiment the Department of Agriculture is carrying out very detailed and far-reaching experiments on approximately 500 acres of blanket bog. When these are completed, coupled with the experience that will be gained from Gowla Bog, it may be possible—I hope the experiments will be successful—to do something on a big scale with such areas. That may be possible when we know where we are going and what type of treatment will give the best results.
The Beckett estate has been on hands for six years. The position is that the mansion and 21 acres of land were sold to the Mayo County Board of Health for a sanatorium; 197 acres are held by the Forestry Division; approximately one acre went for three building sites; 50 acres went to a Swedish industrialist as a site for a factory. The total allotted is 269 acres and the balance on hands is 145 acres. In view of all that has been done there already I think it will readily be admitted that the Land Commission have not been sleeping on that particular job and I think I am not being over-optimistic when I say that the allotment of the remainder of that estate will probably take place next winter or spring.
Deputy Corry comes along then with this road of his. This letter, he told us, and it has gone into the debate now like my £700 promise——
Comment on this
——was dated 16th June of this year; I think he stated that the letter was dated 16th June of this year.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not get away with that. The Deputy stated distinctly, and made a great joke of it here for a crowded gallery at the time, that it was dated 16th of this month, and to-day is only the 12th. He has since looked at the heading of the letter.
Comment on this
If the Minister will pardon me, the letter was dated 16th May and it arrived at the county council office this morning. When was it posted?
Comment on this
The Deputy said it was dated 16th June. The Land Commission is now making an offer of £300 and I hope the Deputy will accept it. I think it is a good offer. Let me say, for the Deputy's information, that special permission had to be sought from the Minister for Finance to get this because as I said earlier, the Land Commission does not ask for money for the repair of roads constructed by the Land Commission. They do not do that as a rule. Personally, I am opposed to it because we would have too many road repairing authorities if that were the case.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned putting gravel on top of the sod. My trouble is that they took the sod and forgot the gravel. The Minister can call that a grand road, if he likes. I do not.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry also mentioned the Kilworth estate and the Curragh. There are two State properties in County Kildare, Ballyfair and Kingscommon. Ballyfair consists of 150 acres and Kilworth 825 acres. I am not too sure of the quality of Kilworth. A ghastly experiment was carried out in this country some years ago of taking people from fairly poor holdings and placing them on the worst bog in Ireland. That was done to 11 tenants. Then it was discovered and stopped. Unless Kilworth is fairly good quality land my recommendation to the Land Commission will be not to touch it. There is another branch which would be very glad to get it, and that is Forestry.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry has been here since 1927 and it is only now that he has discovered Kilworth and Kingscommon, Ballyfair and the Curragh and the Remount Farm at Lusk. He has only discovered those after 30 years. For the Deputy's information, these five places rolled into one would only form a very small portion of the annual acquisition activities of the Land Commission. We took over 30,000 acres this year. These five farms would comprise only 2,500 acres all told and that would be only one fifteenth of our total acquisition. They would be useful if they were good, and I will look into them. But I would like Deputy Corry to let me know why it is—he had a Minister of his own Party here for 19 years—he never heard about the State Property Act until now. It is only when he finds himself in Opposition, when he cannot do a whole lot of harm except talk, and finds me here with the responsibility of Minister, that he hands this into my lap. He had four Ministers of his own Party—Deputy Derrig and Deputy Moylan, a Cork man and a neighbour of his own, and a couple of other good Deputies of his own Party Ministers for Land. He could have got them to do what I got our Government to do—pass the State Property Act—to take over these farms and properties and to give powers to the Board of Works to sell coastguard stations and a lot of other buildings and properties which had outlived their usefulness.
Comment on this
Did the Minister come in here and listen to the Minister for Finance telling the reasons why the State Lands Act was brought in here and at whose bidding it was brought in?
Comment on this
Deputy Fanning raised the question of the one-mile limit. Up to 1948 the limit was two miles, or two and a half miles.
Comment on this
I cut it down deliberately and I told the House on more than one occasion why I did that. The reason was that I found that in most counties in the West and in some of the Midland counties the owners of smallholdings, who had got additions at a considerable distance from the parent holdings, found such additions a great cause of trouble. The father of the present owner of the holding was very glad to get an additional five, six or ten acres, even two miles away. But in the meantime his son, who was going to school at the time, has grown up and when he becomes a young man he finds he has to spend a considerable portion of every day of the year on his bicycle or perhaps on horseback going from the home farm to the addition, bringing water to cattle or bringing fodder, and so on.
The result was that the younger generation were getting very discontented and I deliberately cut down that two-mile limit to one mile. I believe I did the right thing. Deputy Derrig was three years Minister after I was and he did not alter it, and I think he was wise in not altering it. I did that in good faith and I still hold I was right in doing so.
Comment on this
On that point, I think it is the most foolish statement a Minister ever made. A man can easily go to his land on a main road instead of crossing fields.
Comment on this
The question was also raised that local congestion should get first preference. Most Deputies spoke as if the Land Commission brought migrants into farms they were going to divide with some kind of fiendish delight; that they were going to deprive the local congests of land. That is not the case. The Land Commission has very strict instructions to satisfy the local congests before any land is considered for migrants.
Comment on this
That is not being done and the Minister knows it quite well.
Comment on this
I will prove to the Minister that it is not.
Comment on this
Probably where the Deputy and the Land Commission would fall out is that the Deputy might not agree with the choice of applicant; the Land Commission having certain knowledge perhaps not available to the Deputy and myself, say that they will not give land to John or Pat but will give it to Michael. The law of this House says that that is what will happen. It says very clearly that the Minister will have no function whatever in arranging acquisition, resumption or allotment of land or fixing the annuity.
Comment on this
I suggest the Minister should change the inspectors and he will then get a lot more satisfaction.
Comment on this
We have held inquests time and time again. Before I became Minister I thought I had a dozen or more than a dozen such cases where it appeared that the wrong persons had got land but I had to admit after having held my own little private inquiry that the Land Commission inspectors were right and that I had got only half the story from those tenants who had brought it to my notice. That is the truth.
Several Deputies have mentioned the matter of purchase of land on the open market under Section 27 of the 1950 Act. They seemed to be under a misapprehension concerning it. Land bought under this section cannot be used for enlargements. If they look at sub-section (1) of Section 27 they will see:—
"Where—
(a) any interest in land is offered for sale, and
(b) the interest carries the right to vacant possession of the land and,
(c) the Land Commission require the land for provision of new holdings for migrants or to facilitate new arrangement of lands held in rundale or intermixed plots, the Land Commission may purchase such interest for cash."
That section of the 1950 Act allows the Land Commission to buy land in the open market but it allows them to buy it only for two purposes: for migrants or to facilitate the rearrangement of land held in rundale or intermixed plots. In case Deputies might not appreciate that aspect——
Comment on this
An explanation was given to me during the last fortnight that migrants might not be brought into it unless it is to relieve what is called local congestion. I do not know what this explanation means. Perhaps the Minister could explain it now?
Comment on this
The section lays down clearly that the Land Commission may use it for migrants, a migrant being a person who surrenders his own holding in exchange. The Land Commission can purchase it for this purpose or for the purpose of helping in rearrangement.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say quite positively here to-night that they need not be congests in the immediate vicinity of the holding offered for sale?
Comment on this
They can be 20 miles away from it. We can buy it and if necessary divide it up into one, two, three or more holdings for migrants. That is what the 1950 Act says.
There has been a lot of talk about 1,000 acres and 500 acres. Would the Deputies who know of these farms let me know of them? The Land Commission want to know where these huge ranches are. The Land Commission are now finding it difficult to acquire land, and if Deputies between now and the months of August and September would send me in lists of these farms, which (1) comprise a huge acreage of good land, and (2) are not being properly worked, I would be delighted to hear of them and I will give Deputies my word of honour that I will have them examined.
Comment on this
Some months ago I gave a big list of farms, such as the Minister mentions, at Athlacca, Limerick, and the Minister informed me, in reply to a question, that the Land Commission were not prepared to acquire them at all.
Comment on this
I gave the Minister several lists and I did not get even a civil answer from the Land Commission.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Hara mentioned the Dickens estate. This estate is composed of 396 holdings, all small, and the majority in rundale. If 50 per cent. of the tenants could be got to migrate it would not be possible even then to provide economic holdings for the remainder. That gives Deputies some idea of the problem there. It is engaging the attention of the Land Commission. If 50 per cent. of the tenants would migrate it would not be considered an insuperable task.
Comment on this
I gave a dozen names to the Department myself and when the inspector came out they changed their minds.
Comment on this
You cannot do it without the consent of the tenants. I would be only too happy to deal with it as soon as possible, if the tenants would co-operate. The tenants there all have small scattered holdings. They made good use of the assistance available to them under the various Housing Acts. They are mostly migratory workers, and perhaps they are afraid of embarking on new holdings. If these words of mine reach the Press and catch their eye, I would assure them that, if they choose to migrate, they will never regret it. They would be much better off. We will get holdings for them within their own county or, at least, within their own province, and we will not let them "invade" Deputy Tully's county unless they wish to do so. I want to assure them that they will not be making any mistake if they take their courage in both hands and accept the holdings that the Land Commission offer them. There is more migration within the congested counties than there is to Meath——
Comment on this
Deputy O'Hara mentioned one man who got land on three different occasions. I shall look into that because it does seem a bit queer. Deputy Jack Flynn complains that Kerry is neglected. He and Deputy Maguire are the only two Deputies who left the Fianna Fáil Party and came back again——
Comment on this
All right, but is it not equally unfair of them to say that the whole work of the Land Commission is devoted to Mayo? The figures will show that there is a fair amount of Land Commission activity in practically every county.
Comment on this
I say this for Deputy Flynn's benefit: more work could, and should, have been done in the past in Donegal, Sligo, Leitrim, Mayo, Galway, Clare and Kerry. If most of the Land Commission work is going on to-day in these counties it is only just and right. If more work had been done in them in the past there would not be so much for me to do now. I think I have good news for Deputies on all sides of the House when I tell them that the unvested holdings requiring rearrangement at the moment amount to approximately 9,000 and the unvested holdings that are so small that they are entitled to additions amount to about another 9,000. In view of these figures the end of the Land Commission work may be in sight.
When I give these figures I think it is only fair to say that, in the past, certain congested townlands and estates were vested without any rearrangement. This was done in the past, how long ago I do not know. I know that these places have been vested and that that fact has had the effect of putting them far back in the priority list. These cases will have to be dealt with some day and I know that the Land Commission has no intention of by-passing them altogether.
Deputies raised the question of land being held on hands for a long time. I know that land is sometimes kept a long time on hands but I want to ask Deputies if they want to have the Land Commission so stocked with outdoor inspectors that when possession is taken of a farm these men are waiting on the ditch to pounce in and divide it. I want to make it clear that there is no great hardship being done to the tenants who would get these lands because the small tenants get first preference in the grazing and in the use of these lands.
Comment on this
There is no hardship on the land. Deputy Moylan advocated the setting up of 60, or 80, or 100 acre holdings. He thinks that the Land Commission is not aiding agricultural production. I cannot agree with that. Anybody who travels through Meath or Kildare knows that the production of land which has been divided in these counties must have been doubled, if not trebled. Unfortunately we have no means of measuring agricultural production except through the volume or value of our agricultural exports. However, our standard of living has increased to such an extent that most of the increase in our agricultural production is being consumed by our own people at home.
Several Deputies paid tribute to the manner in which subdivision is being dealt with at the present time. It is being dealt with very rapidly and I am glad of that fact. Deputy Kennedy raised some question of a father and son who got land in the Adamson estate. I will look into that question and see if there is any substance in it. Land is not so plentiful that we could afford to divide it in that way or to divide it into farms of 60, 80 or 100 acres although that is what I myself would like to do.
Comment on this
You gave a farm of 170 acres to three brothers who came up to Meath from County Kerry.
Comment on this
I did, when they gave up 300 acres of land in the Dingle Peninsula that we needed very badly for the relief of congestion down there.
A number of Deputies raised the point here about migrants and the eyes nearly dropped out of their heads when they described how a migrant could buy a holding of land situated beside him. What is this country coming to? If these men have struggled for generations on poor holdings in the West of Ireland and if they saved what they earned, over and above their requirements, and if they have enough to buy a second holding of land, what is wrong with that? I wish we had more of that type of men in the country. I think it was Deputy Rooney who said some of the migrants from the West were not using their land properly. I do not know a single one of them that is doing that. The duty is imposed on the Land Commission to ensure that when they select migrants or other allottees for land they must be satisfied that they are the people most likely to work it to the best advantage. That duty imposes a pretty strict obligation on the Land Commission to see that they do not give land to the duds.
Comment on this
What if they buy a farm of land right after they come up?
Comment on this
Let us say that John Murphy is a migrant. It is not just to give him a gift at the expense of the State that the Land Commission give him his holding. It is because they want the holding that he leaves behind him that he is migrated. We want that holding to relieve congestion in the area that he is leaving. It does not matter if he has won the sweepstake prize of £50,000; it is the holding that he leaves behind him that is wanted. By all the talk there has been here it would look as if Deputies would seek to divert the Land Commission from the work this House meant it to do, which is to settle the land question on a national scale, into a kind of Santa Claus giving out parcels of land. That is not the position at all. Every migrant who gets a holding gives up another valuable holding in exchange for it to the Land Commission in order to relieve congestion in the townland he leaves. A man who does not do that will not be allowed to become a migrant.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been trying to shackle the Land Commission in this House. I have no notion of following the line that he laid down or of replying to the wild trash that he comes in here and talks on every occasion.
Comment on this
The whole question of congestion is one for which every Irish Government is responsible. That congestion was created in a very quick time in the past with a terrific amount of bloodshed. There is now no method of undoing it except by adopting the same totalitarian methods that were used to create it.
Comment on this
Why did the Minister not preach when he was a private Deputy what he is preaching now? At that time, the Minister could not move half fast enough.
Comment on this
If the Deputy can point out any inconsistency or any line of policy that I advocated when I was a Deputy that I am not following now, I would be glad to hear it. If the Deputy goes down to the Library, studies what I have said and finds any inconsistency or finds that I asked Deputy Moylan or Deputy Derrig, when they were here as Ministers, to do something that I am not prepared to do now myself, I would be glad to hear it.
Comment on this
Several Deputies asked what is the amount of land still available. That is a question that cannot be answered, for the reason, as I have said on previous occasions in this House, that a farm of land that is available now might not be available in a year's time; land that is being well worked now and which the Land Commission cannot touch may become available in a year's time. The truth of the matter is that the pool of available land, as we call it, fluctuates with such rapidity that any attempt at a figure would be a mere guess, and would probably be misleading rather than anything else.
It was suggested that the Old I.R.A. should get preference. Deputy Tully of Meath mentioned that. Such is the case. The Old I.R.A. do get preference.
Comment on this
What preference do they get? They get no preference in Meath. Indeed they do not.
Comment on this
Do you want inspectors to go around the area and give them undue preference? They are given first consideration. The inspectors' instructions are to that effect and they follow them out.
Comment on this
Are they likely to get a farm when land is being divided?
Comment on this
The Deputy also mentioned that direct labour should be employed where possible. The trouble is that we are short-handed, particularly in the Deputy's constituency both in the case of direct labour and contracts. Contractors sometimes find difficulty in getting sufficient labour.
Comment on this
I will make ten units available for the Minister tomorrow if he wants them.
Comment on this
I would be glad to know of it. Deputy Palmer, Deputy Brennan and Deputy Esmonde mentioned that the letters from the Land Commission should be more explicit. They object to the acknowledgment they get that their letter has reached the Department. I do not know what is wrong about that. It is only courtesy that an acknowledgment would go out to whoever sends a letter to the Department. I will have that question examined. If Deputies do not like the little folder they get, I will have the matter examined and see if I can send out one more embellished, with the Land Commission coat of arms on the top, if they want that.
Comment on this
Complaints are also made that from time to time the Land Commission does not reply. I did not get replies myself when I was a Deputy; I want to assure Deputies that I do not get replies now that I am a Minister and perhaps I should say why. The majority of letters coming from Deputies, Senators and members of local authorities are letters recommending some constituent of theirs for an allotment of land on a particular estate. All these representations from Deputies go on the particular file and the inspector who investigates the congestion in the area looks into every one of them. I want to assure the House of that. Once again, it may be a year or two or three years before the particular farm is divided. What does a Deputy who writes in and says: "I recommend Pat Burke of such a place for an allotment on X estate when it is being divided" want the Land Commission to do? Does he want the Land Commission to write back a letter to, say, Deputy Corry, Deputy Fanning or Deputy Collins saying: "Yes, we will give Pat Burke land when the estate is being divided, but we will not be dividing it for three years. We will give him an allotment whether he is dead or alive on that date"? Deputies who write in get back a letter saying that the representations on behalf of So-and-So have been received. That is as far as the Land Commission could go
I should again remind Deputies that this House has set up the Land Commission as a court and, having done that, they say, "We have set up the Land Commission; no T.D. or even the Minister, will be able to use influence with them and woe betide anybody who tries to use influence with them for this that or the other." Having done that and having put them on that pedestal, they start making a cockshot of them from the day they put them up. That is all wrong. If we have the Land Commission as a court they are entitled to the respect that their status gives them. They are entitled to that respect the same as any of the other courts—the District Court, the Circuit Court, the High Court and the Supreme Court. They are a court, just as the Revenue Commissioners are a court and just like many other bodies that have judicial status in the State. Deputies should give that court the respect that is due to it.
It does not encourage Land Commission inspectors or the commissioners to find that, having been given a responsible job of work to do by this House, we sit down here for two or three days each year, when the Estimate is being debated, and on many other days put down parliamentary questions, abuse them and say they are doing this and that and the other, that they are partial and open to political pull, religious pull and God knows what. That is not a decent way to carry on. We will get much better results from them if we treat them in the way they should be treated.
Comment on this
When the Deputy has a cast iron case, this is the place in which to thresh it out and if he knows something has gone wrong, that either the Land Commission or some of their servants have violated either the policy of the Government or the law that this House makes, it is the duty of that particular Deputy to thresh it out here in full, if he decides that that is the best course and, if not, it is his duty to bring it to the notice of the Minister.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister a question? Leaving out the personalities that the Minister seems to be inclined to bring in, does the Minister consider, in view of the charge laid upon the Land Commission to solve congestion, that there should be a limit or a ceiling imposed on the amount of land left in the hands of any individual in this country?
Comment on this
Has the Minister a policy? I have a policy and I stated it in this house. Has the Minister a policy?
Comment on this
I will answer no question of the Deputy's because it is a waste of time and would be demeaning—except the questions he puts down in the ordinary way as parliamentary questions. I will give him any information on them that it is in my power to give.
Comment on this
I will put a parliamentary question to the Minister but I would like to know, does he believe that a man with 300 acres in a congested county should be allowed to buy a migrant's holding within four miles of the particular holding that he has?
Comment on this
May I ask a question? The Minister referred to the making of roads. He said that they made fairly good roads but that people are using lorries, tractors and everything else on those roads. When he was dividing land did he think that the people would travel on bicycles or saddle horses? Are they not going to increase production?
Comment on this
If they are to increase tillage and production they must use lorries and other heavy vehicles.
Comment on this
What I said was that the Land Commission, when they divide land or develop bog, make good roads but I made it perfectly clear that, the Land Commission having done so and having handed them over to the tenants, it is the duty of the tenants and the public representatives to keep the roads in repair. The House is not giving me money for the repair of roads in this Vote. When we have not the money to do it, how do Deputies expect me to do it? Even if the House gave the money, it would be bad policy to have a fourth road authority in this country to repair roads.
Comment on this
Deputy Fanning has already asked his question. He cannot carry on the debate in this fashion any further.
Comment on this
The Minister ought to resign having regard to the fact that he has not the confidence of the Government. There was no member of Fine Gael — the largest Party in the Coalition—present.
Comment on this
If the Deputy was not in the House, I should like to remind him that it is not customary for a Minister to send for Deputies so that they may hear him.
Comment on this
I am now putting the question. Deputies had ample time to say whatever they wanted to say. Deputy Brennan will resume his seat.
Comment on this
I was patient during the Minister's speech. Now I want to put a few pertinent questions.