We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Greyhound Industry Bill, 1955—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 212–442 of 442. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Greyhound Industry Bill 1955
Lapsed

No. 14 of 1955 ›

That is not so.

Comment on this

——that the tracks are unilluminated so that the bookmakers cannot see and that the patrons and bookmakers may, therefore, become involved in disgusting brawls——

Comment on this

The Minister is twisting what was said.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

——in contradistinction to the dignified calm and decorum of the Curragh, which the Deputy had in mind. That is what is wrong with Deputy MacEntee.

Comment on this

What is wrong with the section?

Comment on this

He thinks the common people who frequent greyhound racing tracks cannot be expected to attain to the standard with which he is familiar on the Curragh.

Comment on this

Odi profanum vulgus et arceo.

Nemo me impune lacessit.

Comment on this

I think these people are the same kind of people that most of us in this House are, no better and no worse. I do not think it is a pretty sight to see Deputy MacEntee purporting to look down his nose, metaphorically speaking, in contempt at the illiterate habitués of the greyhound racing track.

Comment on this

That is misrepresentation.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy would be ashamed to hear his colleague's observations repeated. But they were made and they are on the record; and these are the grounds on which Deputy MacEntee seeks to condemn the machinery section which his Party thought appropriate to the Curragh. What other reasons did he provide? What other reasons did he advance as to why the machinery section appropriate to the Curragh is not appropriate to Harold's Cross, to Shelbourne Park, to Limerick or to Cork? Because on the Curragh there is literacy—even Latin, such as Deputy O'Malley has favoured us with in his Horatian interjection. But at Shelbourne Park, there is nothing but illiteracy, gloom and brawl. Now, perhaps Deputy O'Malley would favour us with his apprehension in regard to the illiteracy and brawling which is likely to manifest itself if the machinery section——

Comment on this

In due course I will give the House the benefit of my observations.

Comment on this

——of the Fianna Fáil Act of 1945 is applied in 1956 to the greyhound racing business at Shelbourne Park——

Comment on this

There is no comparison between greyhound racing and horse racing.

Comment on this

——at Harold's Cross, at Limerick and at Cork.

Comment on this

Forget the Stygian gloom.

Comment on this

I advert only to what Deputy MacEntee had to say and I note, with satisfaction, that some of his colleagues are already getting uncomfortable in finding themselves constrained to defend his disedifying animadversions.

Comment on this

Sir, we have listened——

Comment on this

He would not let Deputy O'Malley in. He would sooner try to cover that flank himself.

Comment on this

——to the meanderings of a disordered imagination. I did not use the phrase "Stygian gloom". Neither did I say that the bookmakers are illiterate. But I do know the difference—apparently the Minister does not—between a horse and a greyhound.

Comment on this

One has a jockey and the other has not.

Comment on this

And that is the Deputy's conception of agriculture——

Comment on this

I know the conditions which prevail at a race meeting held in the daylight——

Comment on this

——the difference between a horse and a dog.

Comment on this

——with a comparatively long interval between each race and the conditions which prevail in another type of race meeting which is held very often in the evening in artificial light. Apparently the Minister, who is in charge of this Bill, does not know the difference between these two types of function. The Minister, with that sort of snobbish superiority, held up his hands when we were discussing Section 32 and proclaimed to Heaven that, thank God, he was not like other men, that he was not one of the hoi polloi who go to greyhound race meetings. He confessed that he knew nothing about the sport and that the last occasion—and I assume the only occasion—upon which he was on a greyhound racetrack was in 1932.

The Minister, completely ignorant of the conditions which obtain on greyhound racetracks, instead of addressing himself when he rises to the serious arguments that have been advanced on this side of the House, emulates the type of lower schoolboy at a neophyte's debating society by a speech such as we have just listened to. While the Minister may find matter for gibing and jeering at in this section and in this debate, this section is a matter of serious import to those who are bound under penalty to comply with its provisions. That is why we have tried to inform the Minister, so that he will appreciate that a section which might be workable and practicable in the Racing Act will not be workable in the conditions which will obtain in those enclosures to which Section 33 is supposed to apply.

I did not say anything about Stygian gloom. I said that these events were often held in the evening after sunset in artificial light. I suppose O'Connell Street is one of the most brightly illuminated thoroughfares, not only in the City of Dublin but in any city of Europe. Let any person walk down O'Connell Street to-night and he will see bright spots of dazzling light on the pavement, but between these he will see dark patches of shadow.

Comment on this

Very like this debate.

Comment on this

A bookmaker at a dogtrack has to operate in conditions very like those——

Comment on this

The lights do not go out, anyway.

Comment on this

——and he has to operate very quickly. As Deputy O'Malley told the House and tried to explain to the Minister, there are six races, and sometimes seven, in the evening at these tracks, and the interval between the end of each race and the start of the next is about ten minutes. It may be a little longer. In that period a bookmaker, standing up with people around him, has not merely to enter the bets, not merely to pay out to those who have made winning bets, but he also has to make a very rapid calculation.

I was saying—and I am certain— that the general body of the fraternity would not deny that the standard of literacy among some of these men is not very high. Up to this, it did not have to be very high. If they could read and write, they could enter bets in terms with which they were familiar, but it becomes quite a different matter when they have to levy, assess or compute a percentage upon those bets. That requires a great deal of mental agility and a degree of ability that is not easily found.

Comment on this

They have a clerk for that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

How is that reasoned argument on behalf of the bookmakers dealt with by the Minister for Agriculture, the Minister who has the responsibility for this Bill which is imposing these disabilities upon the bookmakers? He gets up here and he alleges that I said that all of the bookmakers were illiterate persons. Sir, the Rules of Order bar me from characterising the Minister's statements accurately and precisely but those who heard me speak and heard the Minister speak afterwards might very well wonder if the Minister knows the difference between right and wrong, between truth and falsehood and whether falsity does not more often characterise his speech than veracity.

There is no blame, in the circumstances in which many of our people have grown up to manhood over the last 30 or 40 years, attaching to the man who has not had the benefit of public school education like the Minister, whose parents have not been so well-endowed that they were able to send him to a university. There is no blame whatever attaching to a person who, because of his boyhood circumstances, finds he is not as well-equipped to deal with clerical transactions as more fortunate and better-circumstanced persons might be. Indeed, when a person so handicapped creates an independent position for himself, uses his talents to the best of his ability to provide for himself and his family, he is entitled to the highest degree of consideration. When I said that the standard of literacy amongst some of these men is not of the highest——

Comment on this

We will have a commission on it.

Comment on this

——I did that, not scoffing at them, not jeering at them, but pleading for them, asking the Minister to take that particular disability into consideration and not to impose upon them responsibilities which they might find it very difficult to discharge. The Minister cannot ride away from his responsibilities under Section 33.

The Minister approves of the section. I trust that he did. I trust that he read the section before he put it to the House. Some of us are wondering whether he read the Bill at all in view of the attitude he has taken. If he did, and if he approved it, all I can say then is that it is doubtful whether the Minister knows the difference between a horse and a greyhound, and between a racecourse and a greyhound track. The conditions that exist on a greyhound track are as different from those which exist in a racecourse as the difference between a horse and a greyhound. The Minister has, on several occasions, when questioned as to the suitability of some of the provisions of this Bill, harked back to the Racing Act and said "This section is taken from the Racing Act." What a confession coming from the Minister that is in charge of our primary industry. Is it any wonder, in the light of that confession, that our cattle prices are tumbling?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely we cannot have that on this section.

Comment on this

And that our agricultural industry is stagnant. We are debating the incompetency of a Minister who is not able to conceive a section for himself and who has to go and take second-hand goods out of the Racing Act. The Minister is yawning.

Comment on this

Would you blame him?

Comment on this

The Minister must have been somnolent when this Bill was put into his hands, and when he said to his advisers, "What does this section mean?" and he was told, "It is all right, Minister. It is taken out of the Racing Act." That is an Act which was passed by this House years ago, but Rip Van Winkle has been sleeping all that time and thinks that circumstances in the year 1956 are just as they were in the year in which the Racing Act was passed. He seems to think that the provisions of that Act, which were acceptable to the House then, can be taken and applied, without the changing of a comma, to quite a different sport. I say that the fact that the Minister has lifted this section out of another Act does not add to its merits and does not make it any more acceptable to the House. It merely condemns the Minister out of his own mouth with the sloth, indolence, and incompetence which he has applied to this Bill as he has applied these qualities to the agricultural industry of this country.

Comment on this

I find all this rather amusing, especially the remarks of Deputy MacEntee regarding the abilities of a bookmaker's clerk. Did Deputy MacEntee ever notice the agility of a bookmaker's clerk and is he aware of the fact that a bookmaker's clerk can make a calculation much more rapidly than Deputy MacEntee can? Is he aware that these calculations resolve themselves into simple matters of addition and subtraction? This is parliamentary codology, based on Section 32 of this Bill, which Deputy MacEntee insists on bringing forward for no other purpose than that of deliberate obstruction. Does he not know that after the first few nights of these calculations every bookmaker's clerk in Dublin and in the provinces will know automatically what is the sum payable on every single bet? Does he not know that the thing is completely mechanical? Is it not true that every bookmaker in Dublin will rise to this and is it not his business to see that there is no Stygian gloom about the piece of paper on which his clerk makes his calculations? If there was, should he not produce a flash-lamp and dissipate that gloom?

Bookmakers' clerks are the most agile-minded people in this country, and Deputy MacEntee knows that as well as everybody else if he has gone to the dogs as often as, speaking metaphorically, he has been going to the dogs here for the last 20 years. This is parliamentary codology and obstruction based on the merits of this section which is part of the machinery of Government. There is no Party who subscribed more to that machinery of Government than Fianna Fáil when, all through 20 years of office, they applied that machinery of Government to putting a man in the wrong when he was in the wrong.

Comment on this

Twenty years.

Comment on this

I am not good at figures.

Comment on this

The latter remark of Deputy Donegan would give one seriously to think. A Deputy here says that he is not good at addition and subtraction. How then could we expect an ordinary bookmaker's clerk to be more efficient than he is?

Deputy Corry rose.

Comment on this
Patrick W. Palmer Acting-Chairman (Mr. Palmer) Fine Gael

Deputy O'Malley will resume his seat. Deputy Corry is in possession.

Comment on this

The trouble seems to be that Ministers, since they were appointed here the last time, seem to have set up a little college of their own. They wake up and have ideas and their whole trouble seems to be to find out how little they can do for the pay they are getting. That is what is wrong with the Minister over there. The Minister took the whole of the section out of the previous Racing Act, not knowing and not caring about the difference between horse racing and dog racing.

I make one suggestion to the Minister. I do not know whether the Minister considers that the ordinary bookmakers' clerk has got the same education that he got, but I will give him a little docket and let him try to make it up. Let him take this:—Untamed at 15 to eight; Quarto at five to one—

Comment on this

Is this in order?

Comment on this

Royal Star did not go at all; Royal Sauce, no place betting; Swanland Boy, won at six to four; Entente Cordial, no place betting; Cockrullah, one to two; All My Eye, four to six; Dilettante, eight to one. There are ten horses for the Minister.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I would ask the Deputy to deal with the section.

Comment on this

I am giving an example of the particular job the unfortunate bookmaker is supposed to do.

Comment on this

Under this section.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

That does not matter. The Deputy may not give details. He should deal in a general way with the section.

Comment on this

I am putting that up as an example of what the Minister expects the bookmakers to do in a quarter of an hour.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

There is nothing about that in the section.

Comment on this

Yes, there is, Sir.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

No.

Comment on this

The bookmaker has to enter in the prescribed manner particulars of all the course bets, retain the records, make up the sum and charge the levy under this section. I am telling you what he has to do. Forty-five bob each way cross doubles, 1/2, and a 120 each way trebles, 1/2. The Minister can make that up at his ease and then he can see the kind of job he has given the bookmaker to do. Is the Minister serious? Did he even read the Bill before he brought it in here? Those are ten horses picked out of to-day's racing returns and those are the bets. The last was only 8/1. Make up 2½ per cent. on that. How much will he be charged before he leaves the race-track or the dog-track? In the dog-track you usually have seven races. That would be 21 cross doubles and 66 trebles. The Minister can "have a go" at that.

I suggest when he finishes on that job, to make up for his laziness, he take a stroll between Dungarvan and Clonmel. There he will find a little monument to a greyhound called Master McGrath, which won the Waterloo Cup three times. That dog did more for dog racing and agriculture than the Minister did in all his life.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I would ask the Deputy to come to the section.

Comment on this

I am dealing particularly with that section. I am giving the Minister ten races and I am asking him to make it up. He expects that the bookmaker must do it or else be fined £100 under this section. Let the Minister do it. He has got £2,500 a year. That is more than the bookmakers ever got out of the game. Let the Minister make it up and give us the result. My trouble with this Minister, and with all the Ministers over there lately, is that they are so damn lazy. The Minister admitted that he took this section out of the Bill for horse racing. In horse racing there is a half an hour between each race, which gives them some chance to make up bets.

Comment on this

There is not in evening racing.

Comment on this

In evening racing the poor devil is in an even worse position. Dog racing is on at night time. The longest period between any two races is a quarter of an hour. Will the Minister undertake to make up that ticket or any ticket like it in a quarter of an hour, and make it up in regard to the particular levy, be it 3½ per cent. or 4 per cent., that has to be put on it? Unfortunately, we of the agricultural community have been brought into such straits by the Minister lately that we have to fall back on the dogs and the horses. Now, after following the pig with one levy, he is following up the greyhounds with another levy. It is not fair. No human being could make up a levy like that, and dockets like that occur every night in the dog track.

I suggest that Deputy Tony Barry would take the Minister up to Shelbourne Park for a couple of nights and let him see how the game is going. He would learn there that this section does not suit the business. That section should be changed completely, unless the Opposition or the chief Party in the Coalition want to make jobs for all the briefless lawyers, who could go down to the Police Court and defend the bookmakers.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I would ask the Deputy to restrain himself. There is nothing about briefless barristers in this clause. The Deputy should confine himself to the section.

Comment on this

The bookmaker is taken to the courts for not complying with this section. He may be fined £100 and, if he appeals, he gives a job to some of those boys. That is the job that the Minister has given to the unfortunate bookmaker under this section. The section was brought in to cover horse racing, where you have only one race every half-hour, and it was not brought in to cover dog racing. The Minister was so damn lazy that, instead of having a section prepared for this Bill, he brought in this one and threw it in like that. That is what has happened. I suggest that the Minister should take it out, take it home and sleep on it. Let some Deputy over there take him to the dogs for a couple of nights and let him have a look for himself. If he does, he will not come in here and make such an idiot of himself by putting forward the like of that.

Comment on this

Listening to the different speeches from the Opposition, it is very hard to know what they are getting at. I go to the dogs regularly because I have a track in my own town and I know the position. I want to see the greyhound industry put on a proper, sound basis.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

That is the principal thing behind the Bill. These amendments and so on are only so much balderdash.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

They are talking about horse racing and about the dogs. You would imagine that, just because the dogs run at night, they were running in the dark and that the bookmakers cannot make up the bets. They are paid here for an English race immediately after the race. There is no delay at all.

Comment on this

A dog race?

Comment on this

A horse race.

Comment on this

There is a bit of difference.

Comment on this

I do not see any difficulty in my town as far as delay or hardship is concerned. The bookmakers' clerks are good educated men. The majority of them are solicitors' clerks and they do this work in their spare time. It is a reflection on these men for Deputy MacEntee and other speakers to say that they cannot make up the bets they have got. They have the right to know if there will be any improvement in an industry which is an important one for them, for the small farmers and the workers who keep dogs. The interests of these people are not being served by the holding up of this Bill. If the Opposition want to serve these people they should let the Bill go through. After all, I think it is a good thing for bookmakers to have horse racing and dog racing by night. In that way, they have the double event. All this shedding of crocodile tears by Deputy MacEntee and others of the Fianna Fáil Party is so much balderdash.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy agree with the levy on bookmakers?

Comment on this

They are trying to sabotage the interests of all these people. Deputy O'Malley is very worried about the bookmakers. I am sure he is. The bookmakers are all right. I am not here to defend them because they are well protected. They will not make any mistakes when they are paying out. I do not see them giving away any "fivers" too much. There is no need to worry about these people at all. This Bill should be let through in the interests of the industry. The people outside want this Bill to go through. That is why I support it.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary said the people want this Bill. Our anxiety has been to make this a good Bill. That is why we put down those amendments. It is much better to make it a good Bill, if possible, rather than have another Government coming in with an amending Bill as will be necessary if this scrap goes through On the section, the board may make regulations for securing the payment of levies and generally for carrying the provisions of this chapter, in relation to levies, into effect. We have put down an amendment to that.

Comment on this

You have not.

Comment on this

We have an amendment down to Section 33.

Comment on this

You have not. We have now reached the stage where the Deputy does not know what he is talking about. There is no amendment to Section 33.

Comment on this

I am dealing with Section 33.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

When I took the Chair the House was dealing with Section 33, not Section 32.

Comment on this

What then is the Minister talking about?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

There is no amendment to Section 33.

Comment on this

The section deals with the collection of levies and the imposition of levies.

Comment on this

It does not.

Comment on this

It deals with the method by which these levies are to be collected. The regulations have been prescribed under which the bookmakers are responsible for the collection of these levies. The bookmakers are expected to keep records of every bet they take. Not merely are they to keep records of these transactions, but they are obliged to have these records inspected, to submit records of these transactions to the board.

Comment on this

Not under Section 33.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know what is in the section.

Comment on this

The Minister must not have read the Bill.

Comment on this

Sure he only took it out of your Bill.

Comment on this

Out of the Racing Board Bill. Under the section, the bookmaker is obliged to submit his records to the board for inspection. He must submit records of all his betting transactions, whether they deal with greyhound racing or horse racing. I presume these records are contained in one book, in one ledger or whatever it may be. The board may demand that this book be submitted to them. They have the right, according to this section, to examine transactions that have no relation to greyhound racing. That in itself is sufficient reason for the deletion of this section. Under it, you are empowering the board to inspect a type of transaction which they are not legitimately entitled to inspect. The members of the board which the Minister has designed are the ex-members of the Standing Committee of the Irish Coursing Club. They are the people the Minister will appoint to control the industry, the people who, for 25 years, have been in control of it and who have made it a complete failure.

Comment on this

What about the Fianna Fáil members?

Comment on this

They have been a complete failure. Deputy Barry, who has just left the House, was one of the people who sat in judgment and signed a report. Is he not aware that every section in this Bill is contrary to the wishes of the people who made the report? We are told this Bill will make the greyhound industry better than it was in the past and one that is capable of being built up and expanded in the way in which it should be.

Comment on this

As I said earlier, before I had to give way to Deputy Corry, it was very amusing to hear an educated man like Deputy Donegan state that he was not competent to subtract, divide or multiply to a certain extent. How then, in the name of goodness, can he attack Deputy MacEntee for suggesting that the rate of literacy, comparatively speaking, is not very high among a certain section of the greyhound fraternity? Obviously Deputy Donegan was brought in here for his nuisance value, just as Deputy Coogan is thrown into these debates to interrupt the Opposition. While, in the Minister's eyes, Deputy Donegan may appear to be a very efficient Deputy, I am afraid his logic has not been very impressive to-day.

I do not want to embarrass Deputy Donegan when I state that the ordinary runner or clerk employed by a bookmaker is as wide as a gate. How many Deputies could calculate 2½ per cent. of 13/4? Even the Minister would not answer that very quickly. I do not think Deputy MacEntee was far away from the mark when he suggested that, comparatively speaking, the rate of literacy in certain sections of the greyhound fraternity was not, due to no fault of their own, very high.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Would the Deputy comeback to the Greyhound Racing Bill?

Comment on this

He will keep away from it.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy O'Leary does not realise we are dealing with a very serious matter which, as the Taoiseach said this morning, vitally concerns a very important branch of the agricultural community— the small farmers—a statement which, of course, some of us took with a grain of salt. Deputy Lemass once remarked that he conceded that the most intelligent man on the Government Benches was Deputy O'Leary. We all subscribe to that view.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Would Deputy O'Leary be interested to know that his Party had a most relevant motion down to-day under the names of Deputy James Larkin and Deputy Mrs. O'Carroll on a section appertaining to the section under discussion, but for some obscure reason that was withdrawn, and all day long—and I have been in the House since 10.30 this morning—I have been wasting my sweetness on the desert air——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I would remind the Deputy we are dealing with Section 33.

Comment on this

Section 33 is before the House and it is to that section I am alluding.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy is referring back to other sections.

Comment on this

I am referring to Section 33 which deals with the onus which is being placed on bookmakers and their assistants, to use a favourite expression of the Minister for Agriculture, to become prostitutes of the Revenue Commissioners in the Stygian gloom, perhaps. The Minister may as well face the position that there will not be any levy collected by the new greyhound board because the bookmakers have no intention of acting as tax collectors. It will not be worked.

Comment on this

They will not go on strike again.

Comment on this

They are not inspired by political motives like Deputy O'Leary's colleagues when they threw themselves down on O'Connell Bridge and outside Leinster House.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Would the Deputy please come to the section?

Comment on this

This is not a political action. The Bookmakers' Association, as we all know from the deputations we have had to both sides of the House, are non-political in their outlook. They have not the slightest intention of subscribing one fluke to the Greyhound Board if this levy is imposed. They will just quit betting on the tracks. There will be no more bookmakers at Shelbourne Park, Harold's Cross, Limerick or Cork, which are the four main places concerned.

Comment on this

What about Wexford?

Comment on this

Your track in Wexford is not licensed at all.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Would the Deputy please address the Chair?

Comment on this

I am sorry. I was pointing out the effect of Section 33.

Comment on this

There will be no bookmakers according to the Deputy.

Comment on this

There will be no bookmakers, according to me and according to Deputies on the Government side of the House, at the four tracks I have mentioned. Perhaps they will bet at the flapper tracks but that is no concern of this House. We are speaking about licensed tracks under this Bill. The Minister has chosen in his wisdom to refer to the Racing Board Act of 1945. I wonder has the Minister read the speech he made when that Act was introduced here, because very many of the sections were criticised by him. He told us in very polite terms what we should do with certain sections but we did not carry out his suggestions. They are now part of the legislation of this State. I want to point out— and I draw to your attention the fact that the Labour Party has one sole representative sitting on those benches —that if Section 32 is brought in along with Section 33 then the unemployment position among the greyhound fraternity will be very serious indeed. Before there was any question of a levy the bookmakers' assistants' representatives made representations to the greyhound advisory committee that if the totalisator was brought in the consequences would be very serious for them due to the unemployment of their members. They made representations to that committee to recommend in their findings that their members, if they lost their jobs, should get priority when the totalisator was brought into the tracks. There was no mention of the levy at that time. Now a levy is envisaged of 2½ per cent. in the first year and 1¼ per cent. thereafter.

Comment on this

Who pays the levy? Is it not the punter?

Comment on this

It is not the bookmaker. It is you and I and the ordinary man in the street who pays the levy, but where else in the world would a bookmaker be asked to act as a tax collector on behalf of the State? Then we get the usual cliché which has been thrown back at us since the Second Reading of the Bill was moved on the 14th December last year: "It is like the Racing Board Act of 1945." There is no comparison between horse racing and greyhound racing. If you go out to Shelbourne Park the first race may be at 8.30, the next race at 8.37, with intervals of seven or ten minutes between each race. What chance has the ordinary bookmaker's clerk of computing the proper amount of the tax? As I remarked previously, the life will be frightened out of these unfortunate clerks waiting for the officials of the new board, with their famous stumps of pencil, to come around to try to justify their existence by prosecuting some unfortunate clerk to a bookmaker. It is about time the Minister made himself aware of the position. It is about time that the Minister and his colleagues would cease misrepresenting the attitude of this Party on this very important subject. There is no question of delaying tactics. There is no question of obstruction on the part of those on this side of the House.

Comment on this

No, not at all.

Comment on this

No, that is correct and let Deputy Crotty be honest and support us on this side of the House when we ask the Minister to give due deliberation to the section on which the whole future of the greyhound industry hinges. Festina lente.

Comment on this

What has that to do with the levy?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Section 33 is under discussion.

Comment on this

I would like to tell Deputy Donegan the levy is not under discussion. I have not the Bill before me but I have a photographic memory. Section 33, I think, deals with the method of collection.

Comment on this

I would like to see that album with the photographs in it.

Comment on this

Later. To get back to the point. There are no delaying tactics on the part of this side of the House. As the former Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Walsh, Deputy MacEntee, Deputy Briscoe and my other colleagues have pointed out, we are fully aware of the importance of the greyhound industry to this country. But we are conscious——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I would like to remind the Deputy that this is not a Second Reading of the Bill. This is Section 33 on the Committee Stage. The Deputy is dealing with various matters that do not come within the ambit of that section.

Comment on this

I submit I am entitled to the same latitude which was afforded to Deputy O'Leary when he generalised on the whole position of the greyhound industry. Once again at 9 o'clock, and we have been here since 10.30 this morning trying to hammer a little sense into the Minister, I repeat that we, on this side of the House, are willing to have an all-Party meeting on the controversial sections in order to take them out of what has unfortunately been introduced by speakers on the Government side, namely, political acrimony. If the Minister likes to look back on the debates he will see that, in relation to certain sections of the Bill—I admit he was in better humour then than he is now: it was not one of Stygian gloom—he was prepared to let them go to a free vote of the House. Why the sudden change? It is quite obvious that he knows now that the entire Labour Party will vote against certain sections.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This section has reference to regulations for the payment of levies on course bets.

Comment on this

Yes, the collection of levies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The only thing I want to say is—it may not be important, but it is relevant—that the Deputy is not dealing with the section.

Comment on this

With all due respect, I was qualifying a statement before the acting-Chairman left the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The qualification seems to be a good deal longer than the statement.

Comment on this

The Labour Party had certain amendments down dealing specifically with Section 33, the section which is now before the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no amendment at all to Section 33.

Comment on this

Dealing with Section 33 itself and the collection of the levy by the bookmakers——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have told the Deputy there is no amendment at all to the section.

Comment on this

I beg the Chair's pardon. We are talking about Section 33.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is what I want the Deputy to appreciate.

Comment on this

I was pointing out to the House that the Labour Party had certain amendments down——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

To Section 33?

Comment on this

I want to make a little progress.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I would like to help the Deputy to make a little progress. That is the reason I am asking him to confine himself to Section 33. He is referring to amendments to Section 33. There are no amendments to that section.

Comment on this

I bow to the Chair's ruling on that point. We are so keenly interested in this Bill and there are so many controversial issues, including this Section 33, that I would ask the Minister again in relation to every section, from Section 33 onwards, to go back to his orginal intention and allow a free vote if he is not prepared to have an all-Party meeting on these controversial sections. What could be fairer? It is scurrilous to suggest that the Fianna Fáil Party is obstructing the Bill.

Comment on this

This Section 33 is one of a number of sections in Chapter II of this Bill, The side heading reads: "Regulations for payment of levies on course bets." This is one of five sections dealing with levies. I suggest, with all due respect to the Chair, that these sections are all interwoven.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Section 32 has already been decided on by the Dáil and the discussion on it may not be reopened now.

Comment on this

No, but a reference back——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will please listen to me. He has asked me to make a statement. Section 33 is before the Dáil for discussion, and nothing else.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling. Section 33 provides for the making of regulations in relation to the payment of levies and generally in relation to the carrying out of the provisions of this chapter in so far as levies are concerned.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is the Deputy entitled to read the section of the Bill?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not reading. He can refresh his memory.

Comment on this

I just want to refresh my memory on this. For the benefit of those on the other side of the House who have not yet read the section I will refer to certain points in it. Sub-section (a) requires bookmakers, who are liable to pay levies, to enter, in the prescribed manner and at the prescribed time, particulars of all course bets in the prescribed record. In the prescribed manner, in the prescribed time and in the prescribed records; it is quite obvious that this sub-section must have reference to some other section or sub-section in this series of sections. Bookmakers have to enter in the prescribed manner the prescribed particulars and they must do it in the prescribed time.

Who will prescribe all these things? It is not the Minister. It must be the board. The board will prescribe and we have no doubt at all but that the board will prescribe that bookmakers will do all these things in Section 33 at the time the bets are made or at the time the bets are being paid. There is no doubt about that.

Under sub-section (ii) they will retain the records for the prescribed time. Now prescribed there again means prescribed by the board, we take it. Whether the period is long or short—it may be for years—they will have to retain these records.

Under sub-section (iii) they will have to send, on the request of the board, the records to the board for their inspection. The bookmakers will have a lot of things to do—the small little bookmakers that we talked about on the previous section, the men with scarcely any property in this world. They may have their bags and their board and their box and a small amount of money, but they have no property. Nevertheless they will have to do all the things that are set out in this section.

They will have to furnish copies of the record to the board at such time or times as may be prescribed. It will not do just once; under sub-section (iii) they will have to send the records to the board for inspection and under this sub-section they will have to furnish copies of the records as often as the board may demand or as often as may be prescribed by the board.

Under sub-section (b) the board may make regulations for the supply, use and supervision of levy paid betting sheets and the making of refunds in respect of unused or partly unused such sheets. I suppose they will have to furnish these to the board too.

Sub-section (c) deals with entering into arrangements by the board with and taking security from bookmakers desiring to pay levies on the basis of returns furnished by them. Under this sub-section they must give security to the board, these little bookmakers about whom we were talking a short time ago.

Sub-section (d) deals with the granting to bookmakers by the board of remissions or refunds (as the case may require) of a levy in cases in which the whole or any part of the contingent liability of a bookmaker in respect of a course bet made, laid or otherwise entered into by him is shown to the satisfaction of the board to have been transferred to another bookmaker by means of a fresh bet made, laid or otherwise entered into by the first-mentioned bookmaker with the second-mentioned bookmaker.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is the Deputy entitled to read a complete section for the purpose of delaying matters?

Comment on this

Can the Deputy not hear me? This means that the board can give back portion of the levy which they have taken in the wrong if the bookmaker has laid off the particular bet. Deputy Donegan will understand that. The small bookmakers have many things to do under this section. These small bookmakers went in and pleaded before the advisory committee, of which that respected member of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Barry, was a member, before any legislation came before this House that they should be treated fairly and that the advisory committee should advise the Minister for Agriculture to deal fairly with them in this Bill. Instead, it is quite obvious that if they were going to be levied on bets under the previous section, they have to make all kinds of returns to the board under this section.

Comment on this

They have to do that at present.

Comment on this

It is quite plain, as I said before, that the object is to wipe out those bookmakers because they could not do all that is laid down under Section 33. It is clear that the Minister knows this. I say this much: it was just pure, cussed laziness on the part of someone—and that someone must be the Minister—that this section was lifted out of the horse racing Bill. Any rural Deputy sitting behind the Minister could have told him that it could not be operated in regard to dog tracks even if it is workable in regard to horse racing. The Minister suggested on a couple of occasions during the day that we were obstructing the passage of this Bill——

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

——but we are as concerned, as the Minister himself would be, to have this Bill enacted and made law. This is going on since last December. It is the second major Bill dealing with lotteries and betting to come to this House since it assembled last October. I am surprised that the Minister is not anxious to get agreement from this side of the House, and have an agreed Bill which could be quickly passed. Instead, the time of Dáil Éireann was taken up because of the crooked attitude adopted by the Minister. If any measure ever came before this House that should be non-controversial it is this Bill——

Comment on this

But you are making it political.

Comment on this

There is no question of politics in it but the Minister wanted to make political capital out of it in some way because he has——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Deputy please deal with the section?

Comment on this

——stubbornly adhered to his own ideas and has no use for the views other than his own. Section 33 is the one which I am pointing out is unworkable. Even at this late stage, after all the time that has been wasted——

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

——by the Minister because of his attitude on this Bill, may I suggest he should withdraw the Bill and have it redrafted so that we will have a Bill that can be approved and which will get through this House in 48 hours? Only last Thursday, we had the Minister for Industry and Commerce appealing to the Opposition to come to him if they had any particular viewpoint to express on any piece of legislation and he would use his good offices——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Clearly, the Deputy is not dealing with the section, and he knows that.

Comment on this

I am trying to keep as close as I can to it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not endeavouring to keep as close to it as he can. The Deputy is making general statements and is not dealing in any specific way with the section. If he does not deal with the section, I will have to ask him to resume his seat.

Comment on this

I had got down as far as sub-section (2) of this section which says:—

"If any person—

(a) contravenes a regulation under this section, or

(b) makes, in any record kept in pursuance of any regulation under this section, any false entry with regard to a course bet, that person shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding one hundred pounds."

In all the legislation that has passed through the House over the years a fine of £100 was very seldom provided. The usual fines ranged from £5 to £10, £15 or £20 and it was probably during the emergency that this House suggested that any person might be fined £100. Now, if a small bookmaker makes a mistake, or his clerk makes a wrong record, which is discovered afterwards, that poor man may be fined £100. There is not much encouragement for a bookmaker to go to a dog track any more.

There is one redeeming feature if you like and that is in sub-section (3) which provides:—

"Regulations for the purpose of this section shall require the consent of the Minister."

Either the Minister will consent or object to the regulations made by the board. When regulations are once made everything set out in this section can be operated and if proof were needed we can see that bookmaking on greyhound racetracks under that section will be an impossibility for ever more. There is no doubt about it; bookmaking must come to an end. The situation was bad enough under the previous section, but this section makes it so difficult that no bookmaker could continue to operate.

Comment on this

Wait and see.

Comment on this

This is a section dealing with the collection of the money by the bookmakers and in my opinion we are being rather hard on this section of the community in making it a penal offence if bookmakers do not collect the money required under the Bill. Some two hours ago I dealt with the tax; now we are dealing with the collection of tax by the bookmakers and with the penalty that can be imposed for not collecting it. A number of these people are not equipped to do this job, or not as well equipped as they might be. For one thing they have to deal with the ordinary tax; now they have to deal with the special tax. I feel there should be some other method of raising the money without being too hard on a section of the people who, in my estimation, are not able to bear it.

Comment on this

Poor fellows.

Comment on this

That is right; a number of them are poor fellows. I feel the Minister's advisers should be in a position to advise him on this particular Section 33. Indeed, if I might say so, it is followed up by Sections 34 and 35 which prescribe what penalty can be put on a bookmaker if he does not conform to the regulations.

While I am personally anxious to see that this Bill should go through this House and that it should be a good Bill, I am also anxious about the individual bookmakers who are to suffer under the legislation that we are passing here. We cannot be just with the whole community unless we are just with the individual. We are dealing with individuals here, a group of them. Surely it is not beyond the resources of the Department of Agriculture and the numerous advisers of the Minister to bring in legislation here which will give the board enough money to carry on the work that this Bill requires of it without penalising a section of the community that is overtaxed already. That section of the community is the bookmakers. Not alone are we taxing them but we are compelling them to toe the line and, if they do not do that, they are to be fined £100. I would say that that is an injustice. I would say that they are thoroughly unsuited to have an obligation of that kind put upon them. I feel that this House, and the Minister and his advisers should be in a position to have some other means of getting the money than by doing it in this way.

Not alone have the bookmakers to do this, but they also have to deal with competition from the totalisator and, for that reason, I must speak against what I feel is an injustice to this section of the community. I feel that this regulation will be responsible for a lot of unemployment and it is a pity, when this Parliament introduces legislation of this kind, that the framers of such legislation could not introduce it in a way that would not penalise a section of the community for the benefit of another section. I feel that Section 33 is an injustice to the people I am defending and they are the bookmaking community.

Comment on this

We have spent a long time on this section and I do not propose to inflict myself on the House for any length of time. I have merely risen to ask the Minister will he not give some consideration to the arguments by which we have been attempting to demonstrate that this section will be unworkable? Whether it will be workable or not, it will impose a great deal of expenditure on small people who can ill afford to defray the cost of complying with this section. If the Minister would assure us that he would, on the Report Stage, bring in an amendment to reimburse the bookmakers for the expenses which they will incur in collecting the levy on behalf of the board, he would go a long way indeed to meet us. I am sorry the Minister is not here. I do not know whether the Parliamentary Secretary will be in a position to answer for him.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Crotty Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Crotty) Fine Gael

I will.

Comment on this

I would feel happier about the section, and the effect of it, if I thought the board would reimburse the bookmakers for the expenses they will incur in complying with the requirements of this section.

There is another point to which I would like the Minister to attend also. The penalty which is prescribed under sub-section (2) of the section is a very heavy one. As Deputy Allen has pointed out to the members on the opposite benches who have taken the trouble to listen to the debate it amounts to no less than £100. I hesitate to believe that Deputies responsible for this legislation have noted that fact.

Comment on this

That is a maximum.

Comment on this

You know what happens with revenue penalties. The maximum penalty is the one that is imposed. When I was Minister for Finance from 1932 to 1949 I had, on many occasions, to deal with the cases of bookmakers who had been guilty of an offence similar to that which is created by this section. Many representations were made to me on their behalf. Inevitably, I found that the maximum penalty, in that case £100, had been imposed and I had no power to mitigate it, even though it was quite clear to me that the unfortunate devils who had been guilty of the offence had forfeited their sole means of livelihood. I know the difference between those who follow the occupation of bookmaker and those who attend the greyhound racing tracks. The majority of the latter are all small men who can ill afford to go to race meetings. They have been caught up in this game and they are there because of circumstances.

I do not want to condone any breach of the regulations of which they might be guilty, but I do want to feel that this section is enforceable and that it will not impose an obligation on people which they cannot fulfil. Therefore, I fear that many people are going to be caught out under sub-section (1) of this section. I feel that there will be many people who, unwittingly, will have made false entries in their records. The difficulty in their case will be to prove to the satisfaction of the court that these entries have been made unwittingly and without any intention to deceive.

The penalty which is provided for under sub-section (2), the penalty of £100, is a heavy one. As the section stands at the moment, there is no power to mitigate that penalty. I have two suggestions to make to the Minister. One is that the maximum penalty should be reduced to, say, £50. The other is that the Minister himself should take power to mitigate the penalty which the court may impose in any case when the Minister, in his own good judgment, feels it to be excessive—excessive in relation to the resources of the man upon whom it is imposed.

These are the three suggestions which I would submit for the Minister's consideration. As I have said, if he can see his way to accept them, a great deal of our dislike of this section will be removed and a great deal of the objections which we find in it will be overcome. The first suggestion, if I may repeat it, since the Minister was not present when I made it, was: would he introduce on the Report Stage some provision which would compel the board—I think I had better use the word "compel"—to reimburse the bookmakers for any expenses which they may legitimately incur in collecting the levy? I know that that might not be very easy to draft, but it would be possible, say, that the Minister might say that the bookmakers would be entitled to retain some fraction of the levy, say, one fifth, to re-inburse them for the expenses which they would incur. That has two merits. It will enable these people to carry on, I think, without undue hardship.

The second one is that it will, perhaps, enable the board to enforce more strictly the regulations, because they will have the assurance that the people who have to comply with paragraph A, sub-section (1) are not doing it gratuitously for the board, but that they are being recouped for the expenses to which they may be put.

The second suggestion I make is that the amount of the penalty provided in sub-section (2) might be reduced to £50; and the third one is that the Minister should take some powers to mitigate a penalty in any case in which he is convinced that the penalty, even for a deliberate offence, is excessive in relation to the resources of the bookmaker upon whom it is imposed.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had made these suggestions at the beginning instead of the end, we might have got somewhere. I will begin at the last of the Minister's three suggestions, that is the suggestion in regard to powers of mitigation. I think that such powers are generally vested in the Minister for Justice in respect of all such offences.

Comment on this

I doubt that. I would be glad if the Minister would look that up.

Comment on this

I have no hesitation in saying that, if there is not such a general power, I will have no objection to such a power being created in this Act. But one has to bear in mind that the general principle ought to be that the fixing of a maximum penalty should be left to the discretion of the appropriate court which tries the offence. There is available to the judiciary discretion to give the defendant the benefit of the Probation of Offenders Act, if he believes it was a relatively insignificant offence, or to fine him 10/- or £1, or even 1/- if he thinks it is no more than a technical offence, and generally to use his discretion in matters of that kind.

I think it is a sound principle to say that the power of mitigation is a power that the Minister should rarely use once the matter is before the courts, bearing in mind that the defendant always has the right to appeal to the Superior Court from a decision that he feels unduly harsh. There is always an appeal from the District Court to the Circuit Court in any criminal prosecution for a statutory offence or a Common Law offence. But I will certainly examine that suggestion.

In regard to the amount of the fine, if the Deputy felt strongly that the maximum of £100 was excessive, I would not hesitate, if the Deputy pressed that view, to reduce it to £50. There is no desire to quibble with anybody. The desire is to provide that, where a person flagrantly seeks to defraud the board by making a contribution which is not what he is obliged to contribute in comparison with all his colleagues in the bookmaking profession, he shall be suitably penalised. If the Deputy presses that strongly, I am prepared to reduce it.

In regard to the third proposal, that the board should pay the cost of collection, I do not think that is a reasonable proposal for the reason that the only place that the board can get the revenue to do that is from the proceeds of the levy. We have given the undertaking that, if the bookmakers consider that 1¼ per cent. should be the maximum levy paid, we will so provide. If you provide a higher levy, you simply provide the extra revenue from which all such concessions could be made. The whole object of the scheme is to secure for the board sufficient revenue to enable it to do the work it has to do. Anxious as I am to meet the Deputy in any reasonable proposal, I am sorry that that is a proposal on which I cannot meet him.

In regard to the desirability of providing a third recourse for a defendant, after he has appeared before the courts in the first instance and exercised his right of appeal, and the ability of the Minister to remit, if that power is not vested in the Minister for Justice under his general powers, I will certainly seek to incorporate it in this Bill or to give to myself or the appropriate Minister the power the Deputy suggests.

Comment on this

I do not wish to delay or to debate this matter any further except to say I am glad the Minister is prepared to meet us in some respects. I would very much like that the penalty should be reduced from £100 to £50. I am glad to accept the Minister's assurance that he will verify that, in fact, the Minister for Justice has general power to mitigate a monetary penalty, and if he should find that that is not the case in relation to this particular penalty, that he will bring in an amendment to ensure that the power of mitigation can be exercised.

Comment on this

Subject to the reservation: unless I find that that is violating some fundamental principle of the law.

Comment on this

We do not want the Minister to do that. I agree with the Minister that this mitigation of penalty should be exercised only on the rarest occasions, but I have particularly in mind the fact that very small people may find themselves in difficulties by reason of that. That is really all I am concerned about.

The other point I wanted to make— the Minister might see his way to meet me—was that the board might recoup or reimburse the bookmakers for the expenses incurred by them in collecting the levy. I do not think we have really threshed out the merits of that suggestion. I think it could be done very simply and I do not think it would be impossible to achieve; neither do I think it would place an impossible burden on the funds of the board. However, as I have said, we have not yet had a chance to make the case for it in any great detail. What I propose to do is to vote formally against the section when it is put to the House, because I think the section will be found to be impracticable, and to reserve the right to bring in an amendment on Report Stage which would enable us to discuss, perhaps on a more suitable occasion, the practicability of recouping the bookmakers for any expense they may incur under this section.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 22:—

In sub-section (1), line 41, before "bookmaking" to insert "greyhound".

I move this on behalf of Deputy Walsh. I do not know whether the Minister has considered this amendment. I think it is of fundamental importance. The section, as it stands, reads:—

"An authorised officer of the board may (subject to the production by him if so required of his appointment) at any time enter any premises in which the business of bookmaking is carried on and there search for, inspect and take copies of or extracts from any documents there found relating or believed by such authorised officer to relate to course bets entered into by the person engaged in the said business and may require any person found in such premises to produce all documents in such premises relating to such course bets."

The point there is that a very wide power is given to the authorised officer of the board to enter any premises in which the business of bookmaking is carried on. I have a fundamental objection to the section. We desire in this amendment to limit these powers of entry to those businesses in which greyhound racing only is carried on. I do not anticipate that the Minister will have much difficulty in accepting the amendment. We may, perhaps, have some discussion then on the section.

Comment on this

The difficulty here is that the levy attaches to course bets only, the bets made on a greyhound racing track, but the records relevant to such betting transactions may well be kept in the office of a bookmaker who would be engaged in other transactions, and thither the officer of the board must have recourse in order to inspect those records of course bets. The officers of the board have the power to enter only bookmakers' premises, because it might well mean that a bookmaker who did no office betting in regard to the transaction of his business on tracks would bring back to his place of business his records. You could not say his permanent office was a greyhound bookmaking premises because it would not be a greyhound bookmaking premises. It would be a bookmaking premises, but, in fact, a premises in which he carries on no greyhound bookmaking business. It would, however, be a premises where he could ordinarily keep the records of his greyhound track transactions. Thither the officers of the board would have to have the right to repair to inspect those records. Really, I feel sure the Deputy does not imagine that any abuse might herein lie. The officers of the board are statutorily confined to bookmakers' premises, to which they will be required to repair for no other purpose than to inspect records of greyhound track bookmaking transactions.

Comment on this

I think the Minister has made a point but it is not a point in support of the section as it stands.

Comment on this

Might we deal with the amendment at the moment?

Comment on this

It is not a point in support of the section as it appears in the Bill. The Minister's case is—and I agree there is substance in it—that a person may not actually carry on the business of greyhound bookmaking in his office, that he may confine his activities to the track. I do not want to commit myself at the moment. I concede that in the case of such a person the board might feel they should have power to examine his records and, for that purpose, have to enter premises occupied by him, even though these premises were not occupied by him for the purpose of carrying on the business of bookmaking on greyhound racing. They might be occupied by him for carrying on a general business of a bookmaker. As I say, there is substance in that point, but, if so, it seems to me that the phraseology of the section lends a different principle to it. I am not addressing myself to the merits of that principle. I suggest that the Minister might word the section in this way: "To enter any premises in which the business of bookmaking is carried on by any person who"—I am just trying to phrase it—"holds a licence or a permit from the board." I am trying to find a form of words——

Comment on this

Might I interrupt the Deputy? What he is trying to do is to confine the entry of the officer to the office of the bookmaker who has at least got a track licence, but one of the difficulties which might well arise is that the officer of the board might have a legitimate reason to believe that a bookmaker not licensed to bet on greyhound tracks had in fact been betting on greyhound tracks. It would therefore be necessary to enter his premises for the purpose of searching for and requiring production of his records to establish that fact. It might arise that the officer of the board would have a duty to inspect the records of a licensed bookmaker who held no licence from the board to bet on a greyhound track. It is for that reason we seek to retain the power for an authorised officer of the Greyhound Control Board to enter any bookmaker's premises in search of evidence that he has been transacting betting business on a greyhound track. It is a power that I imagine would be very rarely used. Could we dispose of the amendment first?

Comment on this

I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

On the section, it seems to me that, having disposed of the amendment, the fundamental objection remains and I think that my point of view is strengthened by what the Minister has just said in respect of the amendment. I think it is unprecedented that we should authorise the officer of a statutory board to enter the premises of any individual who has no association in this case with the activity which the statutory board has been set up to control and administer. I think the Minister will find that this section, if it is challenged in the courts, will be held to be repugnant to the Constitution. Why should an officer of the Greyhound Industry Board be authorised to enter the business premises of a bookmaker who has no licence or permit from the board to operate on a greyhound racing track at all? It is carrying the right of search far beyond what has ever been contemplated.

Comment on this

I think the case made by the Deputy in respect of that part of this section has a good deal of force and I would like to look at it again, that is, regarding the entry of premises where the person is not a registered greyhound bookmaker. In the meantime perhaps the Deputy would think about an amendment and put it down on the Report Stage to remedy the defect which he sees. I shall examine the section again and put forward an amendment in the same sense.

Comment on this

I am prepared to allow the section to go through on the undertaking that it will be recommitted on the Report Stage. I am very unhappy about giving any officer of this board the right to enter premises of another person. It seems to me the board ought to be content with the powers which would be conferred on it by Section 35. They ought to be wide enough. It is not that I want to protect any person who is guilty of an offence under it. I want to preserve the ordinary privacy of a person's business premises.

I want to safeguard from extenuation, to put it that way, so far as I possibly can, the constitutional rights of the individual in this country. That is why I am prepared, in order that we might make some progress, to allow the section to go through if the Minister will undertake that we shall have the right to recommit and discuss it. I would ask the Minister to consider very carefully the terms of Section 34. I am perfectly certain if he were on this side of the House, and I were to bring in a proposal of that sort, he would resist it very strongly and criticise it very cogently.

Comment on this

I shall look at it again.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:—

In sub-section (1), line 3, to delete "authorised coursing meeting" and substitute "at any authorised coursing meeting or in the precincts thereof".

This is a drafting amendment on the same lines as Nos. 28, 29 and 30.

Comment on this

I cannot see any objection to it. I think the officer will be quite entitled, where he suspects a bookmaker of not fulfilling the conditions of his permit, to ask him to produce the documents for inspection.

Comment on this

Perhaps we could have some explanation from the Minister as to what exactly he has in mind here? May I read the section and perhaps I shall be able, as I go along, to point out my difficulty in regard to it? The section reads:—

"(1) The board may, after consultation with the club, make regulations providing for—

(a) prohibiting persons from performing specified functions, or specified classes of functions, at authorised coursing meetings save under and in accordance with permits granted by the board at its discretion,

(b) the making by the board of charges in respect of the grant, retention or renewal of permits."

I do not see any objection to (b). With regard to (c), the attachment of conditions to permits, I do not know whether there is any limitation or restriction as to the character of the conditions which may be attached to permits. The next sub-section (d) deals with the suspension and revocation of such permits. Sub-section (e) prohibits persons performing specified classes of functions at authorised coursing meetings from having any beneficial interest in bookmaking at such meetings or in the ownership of greyhounds participating in events forming items at such meetings: there is no objection whatsoever to that. Sub-section (f), the refusal of entries for events forming items at authorised coursing meetings in the case of greyhounds in respect of which disqualification orders under Section 45 of this Act are in force; there is no objection to that.

The only paragraph on which I would like to have some information from the Minister is that in relation to the prohibiting of persons from performing specified functions, or specified classes of functions, at authorised coursing meetings save under and in accordance with permits granted by the board at its discretion. I assume that means only persons licensed to act as starters and judges could act at these meetings, or does it apply to any other class of persons? One can understand that the starters and judges must be licensed and authorised by the board but then, again, there are other people who will be engaged, like kennel men and so forth; there are cloak-room attendants. The question is as to whether or not the power given under (a) is too wide, particularly as these regulations will not be subject to the consent of the Minister.

Comment on this

This arises out of a recommendation in paragraph 143 at page 59 of the advisory committee's report. It is designed to provide that the control board may prescribe the qualifications necessary on the part of all officials connected with coursing and racing and grant suitable candidates for these posts licences which will render them eligible for appointment. It is anticipated that this procedure would apply to stipendiary or supervising stewards employed either by the executive committee of the Irish Coursing Club or the board itself, as well as to managers, graders, judges, timekeepers, hare drivers and stewards connected with coursing events.

I cannot imagine that the board, which I would hope to be acting in the closest co-operation with the executive committee of the Irish Coursing Club, would try to attach conditions to the employment of relatively minor personnel, such as cloakroom attendants and so forth. I would suggest to the Deputy that the underlying theme of all this legislation is that, subject to certain essential safeguards, we would give this board power to supervise the day-to-day finances of the greyhound racing and coursing industry through the Irish Coursing Club. We should not seek unnecessarily to regulate their every act. I must proceed on the assumption that, in regard to matters of this kind, the board will proceed with reasonable prudence and stipulate that there shall be qualifications for certain types of officials at a coursing meeting where it is appropriate that such qualifications should be stipulated, such as in the case of a stipendiary steward, a starter, or something of that kind. I think I must proceed on the assumption that a responsible board, on which the Irish Coursing Club itself will be adequately represented, will not make or prescribe vexatious qualifications for simple servants who should not really have any specific qualifications stipulated for them at all. I think, however it is both appropriate and suitable that the board should have the power to insist on certain minimum qualifications for a stipendiary steward, a starter, a hare driver or a timekeeper. I do not think we need apprehend that any abuses will ensue from the giving of such a general power.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

I would like to draw the Minister's attention to a discussion we had earlier to day with regard to an ad hoc court of appeal in relation to bookmakers. Does the Minister not think that there is a necessity under this section to have some body to which people could make appeals? This goes further than merely engaging a person who is qualified. I can quite visualise a particular body saying they will not engage so-and-so. If a person is found qualified and is subsequently either suspended or dismissed, surely that person will have a grievance. There might be some doubt as to the merits of the decision and, from that point of view, the aggrieved person should have some body to whom he can make an appeal. I do not think we can legislate here to give a body, such as the board which will be set up here, all power over the lives and the limbs of their employees with no appeal on the part of the employees.

I am sure the Minister will agree that something must be done to remedy that position. If he likes, another ad hoc body can be set up. After all, there could very easily be a suggestion that a particular individual should not occupy a certain position because his third cousin owns a dog which is racing on that particular track on that particular day. That might be a very good way of getting rid of an individual. Would the Minister not consider this point between this and the Report Stage? Asking him to consider something is not, I am sure, unreasonable.

Comment on this

I shall consider anything. I shall consider that but, truth to tell, I do not think this is a case in which an appeal is necessary.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not realise that what I have suggested could arise?

Comment on this

Under Section 36?

Comment on this

Sub-section (a) gives the board the right after consultation with the club to make regulations providing for prohibiting persons from performing specified functions and so on, and the granting of certain permits——

Comment on this

Look at sub-section (a):—

"prohibiting persons from performing specified functions, or specified classes of functions, at authorised coursing meetings save under and in accordance with permits granted by the board at its discretion."

Comment on this

Again, suppose I qualify under one of these regulations and I am given a permit, under sub-section (d) there is a regulation which would enable the board to suspend or revoke such a permit.

Comment on this

I see the point the Deputy makes and I am prepared to examine that.

Comment on this

Does the Minister see the point I am making?

Comment on this

Yes; therefore there must be some form of appeal.

Comment on this

And the Minister must examine that.

Comment on this

I will.

Comment on this

That is all right.

Comment on this

But I want to be perfectly honest with the Deputy. I am not saying I shall introduce an amendment.

Comment on this

If the Minister says he is prepared to examine it, I took it he was prepared to introduce an amendment but, however, I take it there will be nothing to prevent my bringing in an amendment?

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

Before that section is put I would like to say that my point is somewhat different from that of Deputy Briscoe, and perhaps my approach to the problem would be different also. I think that the power given in paragraph (a) of sub-section (1) is much too wide. I think that there should be some clear statment as to the classes of persons to which it will apply. I mean we should not, in a matter of this sort, hand over to private individuals the power of prohibiting persons from doing certain work. That is what it amounts to. Let me be quite clear about this and I am not challenging the necessity for the——

Comment on this

Could we not do a deal on the managers, graders, judges, timekeepers, hare drivers, stewards and stipendiary stewards?

Comment on this

Yes, if the Minister were to introduce an amendment setting out the classes of persons which the board may prohibit from performing certain functions at coursing meetings, that would go a long way to meet the case.

Comment on this

I will do a deal then on the basis of managers, graders, judges, timekeejers, hare drivers and stewards. Now the report put in "etc." but we will leave it out.

Comment on this

The list of persons whom the Minister has specified would go a long way to meet me. There is only one other thing, and again it comes back to my objection to the section. Sub-section (2) creates an offence. It states:—

"If in relation to an authorised coursing meeting, there is a contravention of any regulation under this section, the person holding the meeting shall be guilty of an offence, and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding £50."

I think the Minister should look into that sub-section again. There should be some provision made—the person holding a coursing meeting might be deceived. A person might come along with a permit, perhaps even a forged permit for all one knows, and the person holding the coursing meeting might, in good faith, allow him to function. I think there should be some further consideration given to sub-section (2). Personally, I would also like that these regulations should be made with the consent of the Minister. That is a great safeguard. We cannot have bureaucracy proliferating all over the place and we cannot give bureaucrats almost absolute power of control but that is what is to happen under this Bill and under this section as it stands.

I should like to see the Minister—it will not always be the present Minister for Agriculture—I should like the responsible Minister mentioned in this Bill to have responsibility pinned on him in some way for the actions of the board under this section, and it can, of course, be pinned on him if the regulations are made with his consent. The Minister says he is quite convinced that the board will not act in an unreasonable way. Lots of us have made mistakes of judgment in matters of that sort which we have bitterly regretted later. I do not think we should proceed in a matter of this kind on the assumption that the board would always act in good faith if the board is to be allowed to go its own sweet way. That is why I think it would be a great safeguard for everybody concerned if the Minister were to introduce an amendment on the Report Stage stating that these regulations must be made with his consent. I am sure his consent will not be needed except on perhaps one or two occasions, the first being when the board is making the regulations governing the classes of persons which the Minister himself has detailed to us and perhaps on another subsequent or rare occasion when these regulations may have to be modified. I should like to ask the Minister to consider the point which I have made.

Comment on this

I shall consider the point.

Comment on this

On this section I want to add that some members of the standing committee of the Irish Coursing Club feel there should be an appeal if any individual among those referred to here by the Minister were penalised. It was suggested to me that in a case of that kind the Minister might consider, say, the District Court. Members of the Irish Coursing Club have mentioned this to me. If the Minister gave that permission in that section I think it would be fair to all concerned because I feel, as Deputy MacEntee rightly said, that mistakes could easily be made. We are all human and prejudices exist and even the standing committee of the Irish Coursing Club pointed that out at that time. They felt it was only right that some court of appeal should be left open.

It may be all right to say that the board will consist of exceptionally decent men—I am sure it will—but nevertheless a board may err and I believe the individuals to whom the Minister referred should have some protection and some method of appeal. The case may arise where a particular track owner, manager or steward may have at one time or other annoyed some members of the future board or of the board that will be appointed when this Bill becomes law and that member may be anxious to get his own back by using his influence, but if he knows this individual has the right to appeal to an impartial court he will be very slow to do anything that should not be done.

I feel that it will call for good operation of the regulations if it is known that every individual has the right of appeal to an impartial court. I do not want to make it impossible for the board to operate but if the board feels that any man, holding a responsible job, has the right to appeal to an impartial court, let it be a District Court or some other court, whichever the Minister may cite as the court of appeal, I think it will make for impartiality.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to be a little more precise in regard to the suggestion which I made to him which was that, generally, the board could only make regulations with the consent of the Minister. I should not like to allow this section to pass without getting, if I could, an undertaking from the Minister that, on the Report Stage, he would bring in an amendment to provide for this concession. I put it to the Minister that it will not impose any undue obligation on him and we would regard it as a great protection.

The right of appeal from a decision of the board to suspend or revoke a permit is a more difficult matter. We want to have this board, as far as possible, an autonomous body, able to act on its own responsibility.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The unfortunate thing is that there is a feeling in some minds and among some sections of the community that favouritism has influenced the actions of the board in respect of certain undertakings.

Comment on this

The board has not been constituted yet.

Comment on this

We all have a feeling that certain persons will be on that board and, unfortunately, these gentlemen are associated in many minds with certain, shall I say, restrictive practices, in the past. That is why Deputy P.J. Burke is so concerned about paragraph (d) which gives the board the right to suspend and revoke permits. It is also the reason which actuated Deputy Briscoe in raising this matter.

I can see that the board, for the proper control of those who are licensed to act at coursing meetings, should have the power to suspend and revoke permits. It would be impossible for them to see that these coursing meetings were properly conducted if they had not that power, but, unfortunately, as I have said, the atmosphere which has been created around the past activities of members of the club has caused a degree of suspicion which makes people rather anxious to ensure that these powers of suspension and revocation will be exercised impartially and effectively. I do not know how the Minister could fully meet me on this point but perhaps he would consider it.

The point with which I am really concerned is that the Minister should provide that the regulations be made only with his consent. I hope that the Minister can give me a specific and definite assurance that he will, on the Report Stage, bring in an amendment to cover that and, so far as I am concerned, I would readily accept Section 36.

Comment on this

I will meet the Deputy by specifying the categories of cases.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to go a little further.

Comment on this

I would meet the Deputy by naming the categories of cases. I will look at the problem raised in paragraph (d) as to whether it is practicable to provide for an appeal, but I do not want to set up tribunals all over the place to deal with every trivial little matter. I would ask the Deputy not to press the suggestion with regard to the control of the Minister. If we did that, we would bring back to within the province of the Minister for Agriculture the whole supervision of this business. I do not want to invest the Minister for Agriculture with the obligation of supervising coursing in this country. We have got to set up a control board in which we will have confidence. Do not, in the excess of your zeal for safety, create a situation in which, in the last analysis, Dáil Éireann is to run the coursing business. Our aim ought to be to set up a competent control board which will supervise the whole thing. Once you insert the provision that anything must have the approval of the Minister anyone can ask a parliamentary question and you bring back the whole thing on to the floor of Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

Can the individual appeal to the Minister?

Comment on this

I shall examine the position with regard to a special tribunal for appeal.

Comment on this

What happens if a particular case is submitted?

Comment on this

I shall examine the question of providing a way of appeal.

Comment on this

Even if, in the last analysis, it will be to the Minister?

Comment on this

No. It would have to be an independent tribunal of some sort. I shall examine the possibility of doing that. I would ask the Deputy not to press me on the other matter because that would bring the whole greyhound industry back on the floor of Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

Our reason for pressing this is because of the past history of the people responsible for the issue of those permits. The board will be a continuation of the old standing committee of the Irish Coursing Club and we have, in the report of the advisory committee which dealt with the Irish Coursing Club, the statement that there were many cases of fraud connected with greyhound coursing over the last number of years.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy report progress and leave well enough alone?

Comment on this