Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (resumed).
Contributions 195–404 of 404. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The supposition was that we were pulling in different directions. That was Deputy de Valera's analysis some time ago. Deputy MacEntee yesterday, when he moved to refer this Estimate back, was rather facetious in his approach, but he did suggest that some statements made by some of my colleagues did not appear to agree with the statements I was making or with general Government policy. According to Deputy MacEntee, and some of the other Opposition Deputies, the supposition was that Fine Gael said one thing, Labour said something else, and Clann na Talmhan something different. He gave an example. He selected three Fine Gael members—Deputy John O'Donovan, Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, Deputy General MacEoin, Minister for Defence, and some other Fine Gael Minister.
Comment on this
Three members of the Fine Gael Party were selected. Labour were supposed to be pulling against Fine Gael and Fine Gael against Clann na Talmhan: and the only evidence of that that could be adduced from Deputy MacEntee yesterday, and from his leader to-day, was that the Minister for Local Government, said something somewhere and the Minister for Health said something else.
Comment on this
No reference was given which would enable us to identify the speeches. We were not told where they were made or what was said. That is the sole evidence produced during the course of this extremely hysterical debate, so far as the Opposition is concerned, during these last two days. That is the only proof offered of the so-called pulling and pushing on the part of the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
What has really exasperated the Opposition, and made Deputy de Valera so hysterical yesterday that he thumped the table and said he detested this Government— thereby, of course, detesting the Irish people who elected them—what has disappointed him was that we came in here as a Government, all united: Fine Gael, Labour and Clann na Talmhan all united, all agreed, pooling all our resources in the last eight months and all our knowledge and bending all our energies and our goodwill to meet the situation.
Comment on this
Our steps have been approved. The steps we have taken have proved to be the right steps. The Leader of the Opposition and his colleagues pretend that they will help us. In what mood are they going to the country? Will they give us the help we require in this national emergency? Or is it, as I believe it to be, a mere pretence?
Comment on this
Is it a mere pretence that they will help us in this emergency and help to convince the people that these steps have to be taken? Have we not had experience in the last six months, when we asked the people to save, and pointed out that it was their duty to save, of underground suggestions: "Do not save. You are giving it to this Government that we detest."
Comment on this
The next few days will show whether the Government will get from the Opposition real, genuine, sincere help in the national emergency that confronts this country at the moment. Irrespective of whether it is a Coalition or any other form of Government that is in office, faced with this situation, we know now at the end of this two-day debate that the steps we have taken would have been the steps taken by Deputy de Valera if he had been in my place.
Comment on this
We took this decision. Now this Government is not supposed to be able to take unpopular decisions. We took this decision, and we took it unanimously and without the slightest disagreement on the part of any person in the Government. We took it at a time when we are facing a by-election in Cork.
Comment on this
We could have waited a little longer and not brought in these measures just now. But we preferred to do the courageous thing, the thing that Deputy de Valera, who detests this Government, said we could not do.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach should not be hysterical, thumping the table.
Comment on this
We have once and for all given the lie to Deputy de Valera that this Government cannot take unpopular decisions and have not got the courage to take unpopular decisions.
Comment on this
We will test the bona fides of Deputy de Valera, who, in spite of the fact that he detests this Government, says that he is going to help in this national emergency. What has been said in Cork? We know what has been said. We know the rumours that have been put around, some of which were reiterated here to-day by Deputy Childers. That is where the matter will be tested, and we will be see then whether or not we will get practical support from the present Opposition.
Comment on this
We will test the support. Deputy de Valera this afternoon proceeded to give his views on this Government. He repeated what he has said before—it would be a disaster if a Coalition was formed. He said that before the first Coalition was formed.
Comment on this
He repeated that to-day. We were in power on the first occasion for three years, whether by trickery or anything else. We were elected by a big majority of the Irish people at the last general election in spite of the fact that all the force of the personality of Deputy de Valera was thrown into the campaign and appeals were made to him: "For God's sake, do not retire."
Comment on this
In spite of every effort that was made, nobody can assert that this Government—Coalition or inter-Party Government or anything you like to call it—was returned to office by anything other than the votes of the Irish people and on the mandate of the Irish people, freely given in the democratic general election of 1954. If ever any Government came into office with a mandate from the people it was this Government. I went around the country, up and down the country, asking the people to vote for Fine Gael but stating clearly and specifically that, even if Fine Gael were to get a majority in that general election, I would invites my colleagues in the Labour Party, in Clann na Talmhan and in Clanna na Poblachta, to form a Coaliation, or an inter-Party Government with me, even if we in Fine Gael had an overall majority. It was, therefore, perfectly clear that there would emerge from that general election——
Comment on this
——an inter-Party Government, if Fianna Fáil did not succeed in securing a majority. I assert here, and it cannot be denied, that we have a mandate from the people to do the work of the nation, the work we are doing, and we will give an account of our stewardship at the end of our team, whenever it will be.
Comment on this
And when we do go to the country, I think we will be able to tell a better story and show a better record than Fianna Fáil had after 20 years in office. We have this in common: we represent all sections of the community and the only object we have in Government to-day is to do the best we can for all the Irish people and for all sections of the Irish people.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I sat through the whole of Deputy de Valera's speech. Not once was he interrupted. Deputy de Valera is now sitting as Leader of the Opposition, responsible for the people behind him, and he has made no effort whatever——
Comment on this
There are two Deputies who are interrupting constantly. I am warning them that I will use the powers I have to deal with them if they persist.
Comment on this
Another charge that the leader of the opposition levelled at us, and at me in particular, to-day was that this Government got into office at the last general election by false pretences. That is a charge which he is found of making, never giving any authority to support the proposition. He said that I said something in 1952. I did not catch what he referred to in the course of his speech. During the entire period, when I was leader of the Opposition, I dealt with the Policy of the then Government in detail. I criticised it in a manner in which I thought was constructive. Having given constructive criticism, I gave my own positive proposals every time. I did that during the course of the general election.
All my speeches are on record. They are on the records of this House. They are on the files of the newspapers, because, for practically every speech I made, when in opposition, I gave a script to the newspapers so that nobody could thereafter misrepresent what I had said. I assert that, while in Government, during the first inter-Party Government period, and in Opposition from 1951 to 1954, I followed a consistent line of principle and policy and, as head of this present inter-Party Government, that same line of policy has been complied with in principle and in every detail.
In respect of the sterling assets to which Deputy de Valera referred to-day, the principles upon which our schemes of productive capital expenditure and prudent repatriation of external assets were founded were stated again and again by me in public from 1948 to 1951, and were put on the records of this House between 1951 and 1954. Those principles guide the decisions which we now have to make.
As the Minister for Finance said to-day in reply on the Fifth Stage of the Imposition of Duties (Confirmation of Order) Bill, our policy is a flexible policy. The principles have been strictly adhered to in every single respect. Deputy de Valera made a suggestion that my colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, had, if I took Deputy de Valera down correctly, stated that our external assets were of no use. He rhetorically cried—and, again I say, hysterically—could we not get an end to this nonsense of saying that our sterling assets were of no value. Who said that? None of my colleagues either in the Government or behind me.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan said nothing of the sort. In any event, I am dealing with a specific allegation of the Opposition to-day. You will not get away from that. I have seen the script of the speech of the Minister for Agriculture. He stated nothing of the sort. What are we doing to-day? Why are we asking the country to suffer these sacrifices? Why are we imposing these levies? Deputy Aiken endeavoured by means of an interruption to suggest we were trying to collect more taxes.
Comment on this
Is it in order to say that another Deputy made a statement which he knew was untrue?
Comment on this
If Deputy Morrissey does not know the difference between Great Britain and Canada, I am not responsible for the fact.
Comment on this
A Deputy said that another Deputy made a statement which he knows to be false. Is that statement withdrawn?
Comment on this
If I have no option as between withdrawing the remark and withdrawing from the House—I want to listen to the Taoiseach; he is most amusing——
Comment on this
Will the Chair be good enough to let me say that if I have no option as between withdrawing the remark and withdrawing from the House and being unable to listen to the Taoiseach, I withdraw the statement but I will make it outside the House. The Chair cannot compel me to withdraw.
Comment on this
I have interrupted only once but there is a Deputy who has interrupted 40 times in the past half an hour and has not been reproved.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey will withdraw the remark that I am not giving equal justice in the House. He will withdraw the suggestion that I am not giving equal justice to both sides.
Comment on this
We are doing here to-day what we believe to be essential to conserve our sterling holdings. That has secured at least lip service from the Opposition and the unanimous approval of this House. If Deputy de Valera will read the final paragraph of the peroration of the Minister for Agriculture, he will see that the charge he made to-day against the Minister for Agricultural is entirely without foundation.
Deputy Childers spoke a short time ago about broken promises, and the Leader of the Opposition, yesterday, and on this Estimate this afternoon spoke about a demoralising campaign throughout the country. I suppose that the 1954 General Election campaign was the demoralising campaign to which he referred. I have put on the records of this House the statements I made throughout the length and breadth of this country on the question of promises. I will read one more, and I will continue to read them.
Comment on this
Is it proper for Deputy MacEntee to come in here to pick up where Deputy Killilea left off?
Comment on this
The leader of the Opposition referred distinctly to me; Deputy Childers referred distinctly to me in the context of promises and false pretences. I want to recall to the Deputies of this House. It will go the records of this House. It will go again on the records of this House. I was asked by the Irish Times a series of questions during the general election for the purpose of putting me into a hole of corner. I invite the Irish Times to produce them again and print them again. I rejoice in the answers I gave at that time because nobody can accuse me of promising what I believe to be incapable of fulfilment— of giving irresponsible promises. The answers to the questionaire that I got from the Irish Times were printed in that newspaper on the 13th May, 1954. The first two questions I was asked were:
"If returned to the Government, do you propose, in the coming year, to reduce the cost of living by increasing food subsidies?
If returned to Government, do you propose, in the coming year, to retain taxation as it is at present on beer and spirits, motoring and cigarettes?"
I then proceeded to say a few introductory words before coming to the following sentence:—
"I do not therefore, propose to repeat the action of our opponents in 1951, when they made specific promises which they subsequently broke. They failed to keep their specific promises to maintain subsidies and not to restore certain taxes. I am prepared to make only one promise—to provide good Government to the best of my ability."
Comment on this
I invite the Irish Times to re-publish that. I would have the greatest pleasure in repeating the whole lot of it, but I have a very short space of time at my disposal. I will give the Deputy, if he is curious enough and has never seen it, a copy of this if he wants it.
I want to make one further quotation from the speech that I made following the speech at Ringsend opening the campaign. I made almost the same speech at Ballyshannon. This speech was in the possession of the Irish Press and was given to the Irish Press and the Leader of the Opposition before it was made. I said, on the 24th April, 1954:—
"We do not intend to stifle our future endeavour by promises, hotly secured in the midst of an election campaign. We will enter into no such competition and it should be appreciated that anyone who holds out to you rosy prospects of the expenditure on benefits is offering to spend your money for you. We will make no such promises, which would dishonour you as much as they would dishonour us. We do not believe that the Irish people are to be brought, but we will promise earnest service, the endeavour, so far as we may, to see that only the best talent is employed in Government, and the determination to be untiring and undistracted in the search for economic amelioration and social peace."
That promise has been fulfilled by me and my colleagues in the spirit and in the letter. When it is said that I secured votes by false pretences, I invite any impartial man to read those speeches which, fortunately for me, are on record. Remember that I was tuanted by the Irish Press and by Deputy Lemass, for failing to make any promises. I am now in the happy position of being able to say to the Deputies opposite that I never made an irresponsible speech during the entire campaign in that general election.
What did Deputy de Valera do in 1951, in order to snatch office from us? He had promised, during the course of the 1951 election, to put back the food subsidies, to maintain the food subsidies.
Comment on this
In that election? I should like to be confronted with any statement of mine.
Comment on this
Let me give the history of the food subsidies. The Fianna Fáil Government introduced them in 1947. In the election of 1951 they promised to maintain them.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is there to be any effort made to allow the Taoiseach to speak without interruption?
Comment on this
The Chair has made repeated efforts to prevent interruptions which are coming from both sides of the House.
Comment on this
Naturally interruptions of the Taoiseach come from the Opposition, but there are interjections from the Government side of the House also.
Comment on this
If no interruption comes from this side of the House, will you take steps when interruptions come from the opposite side of the House, because that is what includes the interruptions from this side?
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying the Chair is not carrying out its duties properly? By the manner in which the Minister puts his question, it appears to be a charge against the Chair. The Chair is trying to maintain order in so far as it is possible to do so.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it not useful for Deputies to be asked to withdraw charges made against the Chair?
Comment on this
The question of withdrawl does not arise in the opinion of the Chair. The Taoiseach.
Comment on this
These subsidies were introduced in 1947. They promised to "maintain" them, in the General Election of 1951, when they were seeking the votes of those five gentleman, who subsequently got their walking papers from the electorate in the last general election, in order to put them into office. They promised to maintain the food subsidies. They went back on that promise in 1952, and in Deputy MacEntee's Budget they slashed them.
Comment on this
They slashed them. Deputy MacEntee said they were not going to increase the taxes on beer and spirits. They promised that.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach must be allowed to make his statement without interruption in accordance with Standing Orders. Every Deputy is entitled to make his speech without interruption. Now, the Opposition or any other Deputy seeking to interrupt the Taoiseach will have to bear the full brunt of Standing Orders.
Comment on this
I ask any fair-minded person—and, mind you, there were many fair-minded persons who voted in the last general election for us —is Deputy of de Valera or any member of that Party, entitled to say that we got in by false pretences. They got into office, and they reduced the subsidies in 1952. Deputy Lemass and Deputy MacEntee promised they would not take the food subsidies off, that the taxes on beer and spirits——
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Taoiseach has alleged—I am sorry, Sir. I want to raise a point of order.
Comment on this
Yes, Sir. The Taoiseach has asceribed to me a statement which I never made, in relation to food subsidies.
Comment on this
I said "bear and spirits." I said you promised that you would not put on the taxes on beer and spirits but that you did put them on in 1952. In Rathmines Town Hall that promise was made, in relation to beer and spirits. I am occupying the time of the House perhaps unduly on this, but I think it is in the public interest to deal with these charges, these false charges, which are repeated in the Hitler fashion—get the lie going and you never can catch up on it. Deputy de Valera is repeating what is untrue when he says I made any promises—except the promises I made to give good government. That has been given and will be given.
What really exasperated the Leader of the Opposition yesterday and to-day was the fact that he saw the position slipping away from him for ever. He spent nearly two hours to-day in justifying his past. That is his attitude all the time; he is always anxious to demonstrate to the people how wrong they were when they were disobedient to his will.
We are not here by false pretences, but by the votes of the people. He hates this Government, when it is a Government elected by the people. He hates this Government, elected by the majority of the people. He is going back to those days that, perhaps, we should not refer to here, but which perhaps it is necessary to recall to younger people who did not know the conditions which existed 20 years ago. not to talk of 30 years ago.
Comment on this
This is a clear contrast between the treatment the Taoiseach is getting and the treatment the Leader of the Opposition got for two hours, without a single interruption.
Comment on this
There is a lot of blackguardism on that side of the House. They do not want to allow the first man in the country to speak in his own Parliament. It is a common blackguardism.
Comment on this
The principal speaker of the Opposition referred to these matters yesterday afternoon, and a more deplorable utterance I certainly never listened to. It was really comical. The Deputy, I know, likes to play the role of a political playboy. He rejoices in it sometimes, and he was in his political playboy mood yesterday afternoon.
Comment on this
He complained that I had not given an exposé of the economic conditions and financial affairs of the country during the past 12 months and said that I had brought in emigration as a red herring. Then he proceeded to say that my colleagues in the Fine Gael Party were apparently not in agreement with me, or something to that effect. That was all playboyism. Does Deputy MacEntee remember the 20 years, or nearly 20 years, during which his leader, Deputy de Valera, was Taoiseach, when his method of introducing the Estimate for the Department of the Taoiseach was to get up and move the formal resolution for £20,000, or whatever it was, and sit down and say that he would answer any questions? There was never any expose by him. When I because Taoiseach I did introduce the practice of giving information to Deputies and giving them some material on which they could discuss Government policy during the 12 months. I kept up that practice all the time I was Taoiseach and every year since I came back to office I have done it.
This year I made it clear in what I said that, because we had had so many discussions of an economic character, and because the facts and figures had been given as recently as yesterday, I would not go over the ground again; but I did deal with a matter that I thought was very relevant, the matter of emigration. If I had wanted to draw red herrings across the discussion, do you think I would deliberately, have brought the subject of emigration into this debate? I threw it into the arena of this debate, deliberately threw it in, and I got a very poor response, I must say. I invited attack upon myself and my colleagues, but I have nothing to reply to in the debate.
Deputy MacEntee then proceeded to say that, because I had not given an exposé I prevented him from reviewing Government policy. In answer to Deputy MacEntee yesterday, I said that this discussion on my Estimate was free for all, that Deputies were entitled, even though I dealt with only two or three topics in my introductory speech, to deal with all or any matter of Government policy, that there was nothing to stop them doing that. I do say this, and I say it not merely about Deputy MacEntee, but about every Opposition Deputy who has spoken in this debate, that another characteristic feature of this debate on my Estimate is that, whereas there was much hysterical denunciation of the Government in all moods and tenses, there was practically no discussion at all of any aspect of Government policy or any exposé of any errors of the Government in matters of policy. There was no real criticism of Government policy at all. The Leader of the Opposition detests this Government. Not a single one of the Deputies opposite, from Deputy de Valera down, selected aspects of Government policy and said, “That is wrong; you should not have done this; you should have done that; this could be our policy.” There was nothing but destructive denunciation in the speeches that we had to-day or yesterday.
Comment on this
If Deputy MacEntee says it does not exist, why did not he say so? Why did he not show where it does not exist?
Comment on this
He forgot to say it. He could have save it. He could at least, have said said that we have no policy. That is why he made such a jejune speech yesterday evening. Deputy MacEntee loves, as I say, to play the role of political playboy likes another role, the role of pseudo-statesman. He is comical when he is playing the role of political playboy; he is very dangerous indeed when he is acting the part of pseudo-statesman, I have in all seriousness to speak to-night to the dangerous utterances that he made within the last few days, and I have to do so in all the greater seriousness because of the remarks made by the Deputy childers a very short time ago. Deputy Childers spoke about rumours that this Government were going to nationalise the banks.
Comment on this
Deputy MacEntee spoke about the kiss of death to the Irish pound. He spoke about the kiss of death to the Irish pound on the 20th March, 1956, reported at column 810 of the Dáil Debates of that day. That would have been all right, or would perhaps have done little or no damage were it not for the fact that he repeated it on Wednesday last, and that repetition of his reference to the devaluation of the pound is reported in the Dáil Debates of the 18th July, 1956, at column 1137 and 1138. He goes on to say that, if certain things are done——
Comment on this
"——will be devalued vis-á-vis sterling.” I want to assert here that those utterances are highly dangerous and, in fact, the reason I mention it to-night is that it has been reported to me that the fact that Deputy Macentee repeated that statement the other day has caused great uneasiness in this city. It is almost treason to the nation for Deputy MacEntee——
Comment on this
Deputy MacEntee knows and ought to know perfectly well that there is not even a remote possibility of such devaluation, that there is full and complete cover of the Irish pound in sterling holdings. Because of the damage that has been done by this pseudo-statesman——
Comment on this
——repeating his innuendo—he was playing the role, of the statesman when he said it, but the damage was there, the poison was in his utterances—I have to make this categorical statement to-night——
Comment on this
I have been told that because of Deputy MacEntee's statement last week deposits have left this country. I want that to be known here so that the seriousness of this thing may be made known. Such a thing should not be mentioned, should never be mentioned, of out Irish financial system. What Deputy Childers mentioned to-night about the nationalisation of the banks ought not to be mentioned in the context in which he mentioned it to-night, because of the danger to our financial system, particularly in the critical conditions that exist at the present time.
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I ask if the Taoiseach will be allowed to conclude his address without interruptions?
Comment on this
I am afraid, A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that I will have to shout them down but I, will do my best. I will discuss this matter in a manner leaving no doubt. Not merely will this Government not take the step contemplated by Deputy MacEntee—
Comment on this
I will withdraw from the House rather than withdraw that charge. The Taoiseach well knows that I did not contemplate that but I have forced the Government at last to take action to prevent it.
Comment on this
I assure the Dáil and the country that my Government and myself would surrender office rather than do so, and that, for myself, I would never become a member of any Government which did it or proposed to do it. I hope the former Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, out of regard for the national interest, will put some curb on his desire to get political advantage out of national difficulties. I address the same remarks of Deputy Childers in relation to his observations here to-night. It may be that Deputy Childers made this suggestion about nationalising the banks in some particular context. However, lest that suggestion might do damage unless I deny it, I want to say that this Government has no such intention. It is very regrettable that I should have to deal with matters of this kind.
I stated in Cork that I had no objection to my political opponents taking advantage of the difficulties we were in, but I asked the people of Cork to remember that our difficulties were the nation's difficulties. That is what I should be doing to-night—trying to get the people to understand that these are the nation's difficulties——
Comment on this
——instead of meeting a barrage of interruptions from that gang over there who alleged and contended they were going to help us and the nation in the nation's difficulties. That is why I have little belief or faith in——
Comment on this
The House might allow the Taoiseach to conclude his statement without these interruptions.
Comment on this
May I withdraw the word "gang"? It slipped out in the heat caused by the barrage of hysterical interruptions from the Opposition Benches. I regret I was misled into the use of that word and I apologise to the Deputies opposite for it.
It has been the object of all the speakers on the opposite benches, from the Leader of the Opposition down, to try to suggest that the conditions with which we are faced to-day in this country are similar to and traceable back to the conditions in 1947. Of course, there is not parity or similarity whatever between the conditions existing how and those existing in 1947 or 1952. In 1947, the Budget was brought in not for the purpose of dealing with any balance of payments difficulties whatever——
Comment on this
There were no balance of payments difficulties at that time. Deputy de Valera yesterday traced the history of our present difficulties to 1947 to try to justify his past. In 1947, there were no balance of payments difficulties. Quite the contrary. There was difficulty about the rising cost of living, and subsidies were introduced. May I point out—and the reference can be had if it is wanted— that that 1947 Budget budgeted for a substantial surplus?
Comment on this
I am glad to know you agree with that statement, because that was our challenge to the 1952 Budget.
Comment on this
I am glad Deputy MacEntee agrees that the 1947 Budget which imposed those penal taxes budgeted for a substantial surplus.
Comment on this
It was not introduced until May, 1952. Deputies will remember that, after the change of Government in 1951, we ha Deputy MacEntee, the then Minister for Finacne, talking about the balance of payments—woe and despair, critical times, and so on. He started here——
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I repeat a submission I made to the Ceann Comhairle when he was in the Chair? I sat during the whole of Deputy de Valer's speech and he was not interrupted once. Since the Taoiseach has started, there has been a deliberate campaign of interruptions to prevent him from speaking—a deliberate campaign by several Deputies. I ask you, Sir, as the guardian of order in this House, to see that the Taoiseach is heard with the courtesy with which Deputy de Valera was heard.
Comment on this
The Chair has repeatedly asked Deputies to allow the Taoiseach to conclude without interruption.
Comment on this
In 1951, when Deputy MacEntee was Minister for Finacne, he came into this House—I think it was some time in July—and cried havoc, woe, misery and the balance of payments. He did not take any action whatever to correct the balance of payments until May of the following year when, on wrong assumptions, he introduced his infamous Budget of that year.
Comment on this
They had not courage in 1951, in spite of all their talk. They had intended an autumn Budget but shirked it. It was not until May, 1952, that they brought in their infamous Budget dealing with the balance of payments. At that time, the whole trend had reversed itself, as we pointed out and demonstrated in speech after speech and article after article in periodicals. The inter-Party Government on the other hand, took action the minute we saw the trend going against us. We took action in December last when, rightly or wrongly, whichever point of view you take, we acquiesced in the raising of bank interest rates.
I spoke to the Cork Chamber of Commerce in January last. In March, we put on the special levies for the first time. In May, the Minister for Finance introduced his Budget. Now, for the fourth time, we are taking the necessarry steps.
Comment on this
Deputy MacEntee, crying woe and havoc in relation to the critical condition of the country, issued a White Paper in September, 1951, showing how the trend was going against the country, but he took no action until May, 1952, and, at that time when he introduced his Budget, the trend had gone entirely in favour of our balance of international payments. That Budget of 1952 was introduced in a year in which there was a £10,000,000 increase of the external reserves of the banking system. Is that the condition that exists to-day when, in a period of 18 months, the Irish banking system has lost something like £50,000,000 of net external reserves? Is that not an entirely different condition?
Comment on this
Owing to the drying up of the inward flow of capital caused by the new financial policy of the British Government and an unprecedented spurt in consumer spending; the financing of the balance of payments deficits has fallen completely on the banking system——
Comment on this
——creating a situation in which limitations on expansion, which in other circumstances we might have enhoued, became the unenviable duty of the Government. In 1952, Deputy MacEntee, Minister for Finance as he then was, based, as appears from the infamous White Paper of 1951, his whole principles, and his utterances of woe and misery, on the opinion that here would be no expansion in the agricultural industry. We said the cause of the imbalance at that time was the stockpiling created by the war in Korea and that, inevitably, the running down of those stocks would tend to correct the imbalance, we also said that agricultural exports would rise—as they rose dramatically —and turn the tide of the balance of payments in our favour.
The Leader of the Opposition tries to suggest that the conditions in 1947 and 1952 were the same as those which exist now—again trying to justify his past. The Leader of the Opposition spent a considerable time in telling us, item after item, of the hopes he had held. When he had concluded his speech I asked some of my colleagues whether I was mistaken or whether he had just given us a list of all his failures down through the years.
In conclusion I just want to dwell on the other side of the picture. I spoke, in the course, of my remarks in opening this debate, of the necessity for not looking too much on the dark side of things, for remembering the achievements of the past. Those of us who were alive in Dublin prior to the Treaty wil remember the conditions in Ireland from 1910 onwards. I remember them here in Dublin, where I have lived all my life, and in the country, where I travelled as a young barrister. I can see the changes. If anybody lived in the City of Dublin when I was a boy they would remember that scarcely a boy or girl had a boot or stocking to their feet, I remember a phrase that was used by my mother in reference to the amount of clothing that the poor pelple wore in this city, that they had not enough on them to dust a fiddle. I would ask Deputy McQuillan to remember that, when he whinges and whines in this House about our present conditions. Remember what has been achieved, the houses that have been built—
Comment on this
You can take, if you like, the credit for anything that was done but I am saying we were all in on it for the last 35 years. Every single Party in this House was in on it. Whatever has been done, we can all take part of the blame or the credit, whichever you like, but I do say that something has been achieved. I have lived to see, and I thank God I have lived to see dramatic changes in the conditions of life and the standard of living of our people.
As the Minister for Agriculture said to-day, we have had to take these corrective measures, but they are only palliative measures, only transitory measures, and the sooner they go the better we will be pleased. Any such measures to correct the balance of payments, whether taken by us or by any other Government, are, as I said, only palliatives. We cannot get a proper balance of trade until we get a greater volume of exports, until we get more production, to use a phrase of which, as Deputy de Valera said, everybody was tired. Until we get the support of farmers and industrialists and an increase in the exports of goods, cattle and everything else, we cannot make progress and we will be only stopping holes and keeping out leaks here and there.
Those are the fundamental things that must be done, but let us survey what has been done. We have on the credit side the successful efforts of my friend, the Tánaiste, in getting the oil refinery in Cork. Look at what that will mean to this country in capital flowing in, in all the goods and services and all the subsidiary services it will bring in.
Comment on this
That was started by deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
It used to be said by Deputy MacEntee that bringing in capital into this country was a liability, but it is one of the ways in which, ultimately, you can hep to correct your balance of payments deficits and I take it that is what we all want to achieve. That is what we have been trying to do. In addition to the oil refinery we have had the mineral development in Advoca, in Allihies, West Cork, and other places. The output of our cattle last year was the highest ever recorded. The stocks of live stock, cattle, sheep and lambs were the highest we have ever had.
There has been a grealy increased output in pigs and as I think the Minister for Agriculture said to-day, practically a record crop of barley is expected. By the end of this year we hope there will be 1,000,000 acres of Irish land rehabilitated or in the course of rehabilitation under the land project. We have made dramatic strides in forestry and we have fixed our target in forestry. We have fixed our target in housing, and we have more boats than ever before in the hands of Irish fishermen, all of which are being operated at a profit.
Are those not things to be proud of? I do not care who is responsible for them, but I say we are entitled to meet our difficulties without, as Deputy Childers said to-night, beating our breasts and indulging in self-pity. We have no need of self-pity. We shall meet our difficulties, expected or unexpected, as they come, without whinging, whining or self-pity. If we get co-operation from the Opposition, from the country and from the farmers in particular, and if the Opposition will ask their supporters to co-operate in the savings campaign, then we shall be able to carry out our programme of capital expenditure and there will be some hope for this country.
Comment on this
May I inquire if the Taoiseach can give me the information I sought in relation to agriculture?
Comment on this
There is another matter on which I should like to hear something. There are rumours that the Report of the Central Bank has been some time in the hands of the Government. Will it be published soon?
Comment on this
Does Deputy de Valera want an answer to his question or are we to listen to this stuff from Deputy Briscoe? Where does the Lord Mayor get his information? Has he got spies out?
Comment on this
In relation to the second question asked by the Leader of the Opposition, he is aware that what occurs in respect of the Report of the Central Bank is that it is delivered to the Minister for Finance, that it is then handed over to the Stationery Office, that it is between the Stationery Office and the Central Bank that the printing arrangements are made, that it is the Central Bank that checks the proofs as they come from the Stationery Office and that it does not come back to the Government through the Department or the Minister for Finance until the final proofs have been checked by the Central Bank and the printing completed. The completed prints have not yet come back to me.