Committee on Finance. - Greyhound Industry Bill, 1955—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 184–387 of 387. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 14 of 1955 ›
If the Minister states he is accepting the amendment, I can sit down, because I think it is a very fair amendment:—
"An authorised officer shall submit to the board a report in writing concerning such investigations which may have been made by him under sub-sections (1) and (2) of this section within one week from the completion of such investigations, and shall furnish a copy of such report to all persons concerned."
That is a very reasonable request. As I have already stated here, I moved another amendment on behalf of the Irish Coursing Club because they were not satisfied to give complete jurisdiction to any particular board and they were trying to eliminate any prejudices that any member of the board might have. I respectfully suggest to the Minister that this amendment is very fair and I do not see what objection anybody here could have to it. Legislation by good wishes is no use. It has to be made an Act to be in any way operative outside. It is no use saying: "I would not at any time allow this occur." The second part says:
"Any person concerned——"
Comment on this
Indeed he does, several times. That is what he was put up to do. The decent man has not the faintest notion what he is talking about. All he is doing is reading the notes Deputy MacEntee passes to him.
Comment on this
I have to deny that statement because I have been here and I have been listening to this discussion for quite a long time——
Comment on this
——and, as I have already stated, I wanted to be helpful to the Minister in this matter. I had hoped the Minister would accept the amendment we suggested here. Nobody has asked me to do anything here, good, bad or indifferent and I do only what I like to do myself. I am interested in this Bill. People I am associated with for a long number of years would like to see this amendment go through. I do not like to see anybody getting complete control. There should be an appeal from that type of control in case an injustice might be done to the individual——
Comment on this
On a point of order. How can the question of appeal arise on the amendment at present under discussion?
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle is in the Chair and he will rule on the point of order, if the Deputy will shut up.
Comment on this
The amendment is in fact designed to provide that the authorised officer will furnish his report in writing—that is the first step in the appeal procedure—secondly, that he will furnish a copy of the report to the persons indicted in it, and thirdly, that the person indicted has reserved the right to be heard. It is an appeal procedure.
Comment on this
I will accept that ruling from you, Sir. In ordinary common law, if a man is charged in the courts, at least he gets a copy of the charge. He knows what he will be charged with and his solicitor and all concerned will know that and will try to defend that man. This amendment is a very simple amendment. It is merely trying to protect the rights of the individual. I will not fall into the trap I have fallen into previously of using the word "appeal". I am convinced that this amendment is just and I cannot understand why the Minister cannot accept it. The Minister will not always be there. Ministers and Government will change as time goes on and I am sure in years to come the Minister would like to have an Act he put through this House regarded as impartial and just and as protecting the individual.
Comment on this
The Deputy is speaking in very general terms. He should be more precise, and should get back to the amendment.
Comment on this
It would be a great pleasure to go back again to the amendment. I was just trying to strengthen my argument. We are asking one simple thing in this amendment—that an authorised officer shall submit to the board his report in writing concerning such investigations which have been made by him under sub-sections——
Comment on this
I do not see anything wrong with the amendment and I cannot understand why the Minister cannot accept it. The amendments will make the Bill a very good Bill and that is what we all want this Greyhound Industry Bill to be, when it is passed by the House. We all have our own point of view on this, and I feel very strongly that protection should be given and that the amendment should be accepted.
Comment on this
There is one point in connection with paragraph (c) of this amendment that I thought the Minister would refer to, that is, the question of privilege. I do not think he replied to Deputy O'Malley's submission in that connection and I would like to know what view he takes of it.
Comment on this
I take it that (c) was submitted in anticipation of the suggestion that the report should be a written one.
Comment on this
I cannot doubt that the stipendiary steward, giving a report to his employer or controlling authority, ought to have some qualified privilege at least under the ordinary law of slander and libel.
Comment on this
I am not a lawyer— the Minister for Agriculture is a lawyer—so I am not quite certain what is implied by the suggestion that the stipendiary steward should have what is known as qualified privilege. I suppose that qualified privilege would not cover a report where the courts would find that there was malice.
Comment on this
Precisely. The importance of this amendment is that it does give an aggrieved person who has reason to believe that the report of this authorised person was vitiated by malice the right to know what has been said against him and, if he has been wrongfully accused, then to proceed by the ordinary civil courts against the person who has slandered him or libelled him, as the case may be. That is what we are getting at.
The Minister will appreciate that, perhaps, this paragraph (c) operates also in one way to protect the authorised officer, because a person who has been found guilty on sound evidence and, perhaps, a person whom the authorised officer has reported to the board on sound evidence, as being guilty of a malpractice, will not proceed in the courts but will accept without further ado the finding of the officer when it comes to his hands. We are, I think, getting into a more or less absurd position, first of all, that an officer of this board may, wittingly or unwittingly, wilfully or innocently, ruin a man in his reputation and in his livelihood, and the person who will be so affected will not know what has been said against him. I cannot conceive that that is a reasonable way of proceeding, that it is a just way of proceeding and that it will help this board to be cleared up or the industry to be put upon a sound basis.
All we are asking in paragraph (a) is that the person who is involved in a finding, in an adverse finding particularly, of an authorised officer should know the terms of that report and, if he thinks well of it, should have the right to be heard by the board before the board takes action. I submit that it is really only an innocent person who would avail of that procedure. If the person is guilty, he will accept the finding of the board and will try to avoid the publicity which might necessarily attach to the proceedings if he went before the board. Certainly, there is one thing a guilty person will not do, and that is, bring the matter into the public courts.
I cannot see why the Minister is so adamant in refusing even to consider what is involved in this amendment. He has, I am afraid, reverted to the stubborn and obstinate refusal to participate in the debate which characterised the proceedings in this House on this Bill before July last. I would beg the Minister not to do that. Earlier to-day and on the last occasion on which we were debating the Bill, he has shown that he is prepared to participate in the deliberations of the House. I would ask him on this occasion, despite everything that has happened, to approach this amendment objectively.
It is no pleasure to be talking here like this this evening. We all know that, if it were not for the issues involved, if we were to allow this Bill to go through, the business would collapse because there is no other business to go before the House, and we are all just as anxious to get away and have time to ourselves as the Minister is, but we are here tied to this post of duty and we are trying to get the Minister to consider the ordinary rights of the citizen under the Constitution. That is what is involved in Deputy O'Malley's amendment. I hope that the Minister, who was so concerned on other occasions about the constitutional rights of the citizen in regard to education and health, will consider them even in relation to the greyhound industry.
Comment on this
I have nothing to add to what I have already said while Deputy MacEntee was at his tea.
Comment on this
We will have to consider another amendment on Report Stage to see if we cannot get this into the Bill by a side-wind.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23 (f):—
Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(4) All investigations under this section shall be carried out in accordance with regulations made by the Minister.
If the Minister had agreed to the amendments put down by me under Section 44 this amendment would possibly not be necessary. Will the Minister intimate his views?
Comment on this
It seems a little odd that the Minister should be asked to reply to this amendment that was set down on the Paper the day before yesterday without Deputy O'Malley taking any measures to seek to justify it. However, I would suggest to Deputy O'Malley that it is hardly appropriate to ask the Minister for Agriculture to make regulations to control the methods by which the stipendiary steward should conduct investigations on the spot of irregularities that he suspects. What regulations does the Deputy think one should make, that he could wear a green Fedora hat, carry a red flag? It seems to me manifest that the conduct of such an inquiry as it would be the duty of a stipendiary steward to make is one of the things which obviously the Minister cannot make regulations to control.
Comment on this
Yes, he can. Surely the Minister could provide by regulation that a person suspected by an authorised officer of an offence should be told by the authorised officer what the offence was. Is that not one thing that the Minister might do by regulation? Might he not require him to put that allegation in writing? Is that not something the Minister could prescribe by regulation?
Comment on this
I do, that "all investigations under this section shall be carried out in accordance with regulations made by the Minister." The Minister has asked Deputy O'Malley what he would prescribe by regulation and the first thing is that the person suspected should be told the offence of which he is suspected.
Comment on this
He would be a very useful stipendiary steward if he went round to every shyster on the course and said: "Do not change a dog to-day. I am watching."
Comment on this
The Minister is not going to get off as easily as all that. There is this provision in the section:
"(4) a person who—
(a) obstructs or impedes the exercise of any power conferred by this section."
What does that mean? Surely before a person can be guilty of an offence under paragraph (a) of sub-section (4) the authorised officer would have to inform that person what he was undertaking. Surely the person likely to be mainly concerned in the offence under paragraph (a) of sub-section (4) would be the person suspected of the action which was being investigated. Therefore, is there anything so absurd in asking that the authorised officer will inform the person suspected of an offence at a race meeting which he is proposing to investigate what the offence is? I think there is a little more than that in it.
Sub-section (3) says:
"For the purposes of an investigation under this section, an authorised officer may—
(b) give such directions and require such facilities as he may reasonably consider necessary (including directions and facilities as to the examination of greyhounds and the detention under specified control for any purpose of greyhounds or of documents relating thereto)."
Does the Minister wish the House to believe that, after an authorised officer approaches the owner of a greyhound which has won a race in circumstances which the authorised officer regards as suspicious and proposes to detain the dog for examination, the owner concerned will not know that he is under suspicion of having committed an offence, and is there anything unreasonable in asking the authorised officer to tell the owner concerned what is the offence which he is suspected of having committed? The Minister cannot really laugh this thing off.
The authorised officer must at least disclose his suspicions to the person concerned. The next thing is that the authorised officer ought to be obliged to put his suspicion and his allegation in writing for the protection of the individual whose conduct he is going to investigate. A matter which the Minister might prescribe by regulation is what is proposed in regard to the preceding amendment to sub-section (3) (a) with, if the Minister likes, some slight modification. I gather that the Minister took exception to the suggestion that a copy of the report should be furnished to all persons concerned.
Comment on this
I gather he took particular exception to that. As you say, Sir, the House has disposed of amendment No. 23 (a) which, of course, covers sub-section (3), paragraph (a), in the form in which it is on the Order Paper. I am going to suggest that the Minister might make a regulation accepting in part the principle indicated in paragraph (3) (a) and say that the authorised officer should submit a report to the board in writing. Then, if he likes, he may also make regulations that the board, having considered the report, will communicate the terms of that report to any person who may be subject to a disqualification order under Section 45. He could then proceed further, if he wished, to give effect to paragraph 3 (b) and paragraph 3 (c) of the previous amendment.
The Minister has asked what sort of regulations we think he might prescribe. I shall not specify the precise nature of the regulations, but that is the type and kind of regulation the Minister might make under amendment No. 23 (f), the proposed new sub-section. I think the purpose of that amendment really was that, if the Minister rejected in toto, as he virtually has, amendment No. 23 (e), he might be prepared, having heard the arguments here, to consider making regulations which would take cognisance of the point of view we have expressed on these benches and would endeavour to extend to the person who might be seriously involved the sort of protection against injustice we are anxious to concede to him. Indeed, that was the purpose of the amendment.
When Deputy O'Malley put down amendment No. 23, it was felt, though we thought it a very good amendment and one based on a sound principle, that the Minister might see objections to it which were not apparent to us and, rather than let this go altogether against the subject involved, we said: "Then, if the Minister will not take our recommendations, perhaps he will at least concede that there is a reasonable basis for our amendment and will take power himself to regulate the proceedings under Section 44."
Comment on this
I advise the House to reject this amendment, on the ground that I believe it is the duty of the stipendiary steward to look out for malpractices, such as the painting of a dog, the substitution of a dog, the drugging of a dog, or any other malpractice associated with greyhound or horse racing and that, far from imposing upon him a duty to notify in writing a suspected delinquent, I would advise him to come upon such a delinquent like a thief in the night.
Comment on this
His duty is to watch and survey and take every precaution he can to ensure that any potential offender against the rules of racing is unaware of the fact that he is overlooked; and, the more he can come upon him unaware, the better he will discharge his duty as a stipendiary steward. No honest man has any reason to apprehend surveillance. No honest man but will welcome the close attention of any honorary or stipendiary steward and it seems to me quite divorced from reality seriously to suggest that a steward, in the discharge of his duty, should have upon him a preliminary duty of notifying in writing any suspected delinquent that such suspected delinquent is under observation.
Comment on this
Or that he is under investigation. If the man is in process of painting a dog, I hope he will get caught. If he is in process of substituting a dog, I hope he will get caught. If he is in process of drugging a dog, I hope the stipendiary steward will come upon him unawares, and that he will get caught. I have not the slightest desire to see any of these classes of person notified by word of mouth or in writing that they are going to get caught. I hope they will get caught. I hope they will be convicted. I hope they will be warned off every decent racetrack and out of every coursing club in the country. The test is: no honest man eschews surveillance. The only person who is afraid is the rogue and I do not propose to put any duty upon the stewards of the club or of the board to accommodate the rogue or to facilitate any roguery he has in contemplation.
Comment on this
The Minister is living in a dreamland. Would the Minister devote his attention to his own section, Section 44? If a man is suspected of doping a dog, how will the suspicion arise? What will be the occasion of it? When the dog has won, or lost a race then, at that moment, the dog should be impounded and will be impounded. The Minister has been talking about facilitating rogues. The moment the dog is impounded, the rogue will know that he is being investigated. But is he not entitled to know——
Comment on this
——and he will be storming heaven that the rest will not find out. Now, if he has painted a dog, does he require to be told in writing that he is being investigated for painting a dog?
Comment on this
There is no question of protecting any wrongdoer. But the Gardaí cannot question a man without giving him the usual caution. Is the Minister, barrister and all as he is, not aware of that? Is that protecting the wrongdoer, or is it protecting the innocent citizen against unjustifiable persecution? Now, which is it? All we are asking is that, if a person is suspected by an authorised officer, he will be told at the point of suspicion that of which he is suspected, and that with which he will be charged. Remember, he will not be able to destroy the evidence, because, under Section 44, the authorised officer has power to detain the dog under specified control until the investigation is completed and until the dog has had a veterinary examination. All that is involved here is that, at the moment, the suspect should be told that of which he is suspected.
We had the Minister getting up here and endeavouring to becloud the issue by talking about rogues and evildoers and tricksters and spivs and all the rest of them. The Minister has a tremendous vocabulary. He used to use it from these benches. All we want to do is to protect the innocent person against an irresponsible investigation, because an authorised officer may act irresponsibly. He may act malevolently. Does the Minister deny that he may act malevolently? All we want to do is to ensure that he will act in good faith. One of the ways in which one can ensure that is by compelling him to state to the person concerned of what malpractices that person is suspected. That is all that is involved here. All that we are asking is that the Minister for Agriculture should, by regulation, ensure that an innocent party is not prejudiced. When the smoke-room conversation on the other side has terminated, I will proceed.
Comment on this
I am supposed to address you, Sir, in order that my words may reach the Minister. If the Minister is not prepared to listen to me, then I cannot see very much point in wasting the time of the House until the Minister is prepared to give attention and full consideration to what I am saying.
Comment on this
Now that I have secured the attention of the Minister, I cannot conceive the reluctance of the Minister to give any consideration to his obligations as a member of the Government to ensure that the powers which he confers on this board are not being wrongfully used and that at least he will prescribe some procedure which will give some protection to the person who may own, train or be in some other way interested in a greyhound against a malicious accusation that he is guilty of some sort of wrong-doing in respect of greyhound racing or coursing. That is what we are asking the Minister to do by amendment No. 23.
Comment on this
I think it might be possible to bring Deputy MacEntee and the Minister together on the matter. I think that in a way we may possibly be talking about different things. It is recommended in the report that wide powers should be given to investigating officers for the purpose of putting down abuses. I think that recommendation is a very wise one, but, unfortunately, as the Bill is drafted, a great deal of power is being left in the hands of the body in respect of which the aforesaid report had an awful lot of derogatory statements to make. I am personally satisfied enough that the only way you can successfully make an investigation rapidly and on the spot is by doing it. You either do it or you do not.
Because of the feeling we have of the bad faith which might motivate the investigating officer notice should be served on the person that whatever steps had to be taken by the investigating officers have been taken and as soon as possible the person involved given an accurate idea of what he was being accused of. This whole thing goes to the root of the opposition that this Party has had to this whole Bill all along. That is to say, while carrying out the recommendations of the committee to the effect that wide powers should be given for investigation and so forth, we think they are being given to the wrong people. For that reason, we are afraid that the same bad faith which was proved on the part of the particular body time after time in investigations of this kind might arise, even after the passing of this Bill.
It is to that sort of thing we object, and, because of that, we feel that the Minister should certainly reserve to himself the right to make regulations, if he thought it advisable ever to make regulations, and not come down and pounce on the person on the spot which is the only possible way you would be able to put down abuses of a certain kind. It is after that has been done that we want to protect the individual against bad faith or the abuse, without bad faith, of the powers of a very wide nature we are giving to the investigating officer under the terms of this Bill.
I would even go so far as to say that it would be possible to incorporate all of the matters we are anxious to look after in the interest of the individual by adopting this sub-section. Instead of saying that all investigations under the section shall be carried out in accordance with the regulations made by the Minister, the Minister should have power to lay down regulations governing the procedure to be adopted by an investigating officer and leave it at that. That would not mean that a regulation should be made that he would have to go along——
Comment on this
I was extending the customary courtesy to Deputy Flanagan and suggesting that he put his idea down in the form of an amendment.
Comment on this
If the Minister puts down an amendment reserving to himself the power to make regulations, then, I think, we will allow this to go through, because we can hold the Minister for Agriculture—not the present Minister, as he will not be long enough in office to enable us to do so—responsible to the House, if he fails to make regulations to protect the subject. That is all we are concerned to do. In view of that, I think we can allow it to go.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:—
In sub-section (1), page 21, line 49, before "may" to insert "and having heard any person affected or having afforded such person an opportunity of being heard."
The Minister does not need me to enlarge on this as we have been over all the ground before in the previous sections. It simply reiterates our views that a person who is accused of a certain matter, or infringement of the regulations in the sections of this Act should have an opportunity of being heard by the board before he is disqualified.
I feel no doubt at all that the Minister will accept this very reasonable amendment. Some time ago, the Minister referred to reports by stipendiary stewards, and it was pointed out then that, when a stipendiary steward sends in his report to the stewards, if it is anticipated or considered possible that a trainer, a jockey or some such person will be warned off, the stewards send for all those interested parties. They send for other trainers, or other jockeys who may have taken part in the race, or any others who may have been involved in any indiscretion which may have arisen. In other words, this amendment simply asks that, before anyone is warned off or before the sentence is carried out, or before the stewards come to a decision to carry out a sentence of disqualification, the party involved shall be given an opportunity of defending himself in the same way as the judge says to the prisoner: "Has the prisoner anything to say before I pass sentence on him?"
Comment on this
If the Deputy has in mind that where, after an investigation, the board decides to take action, then, before it takes action, it shall notify the individual against whom it proposes to take action, and give him reasonable time in which to make his representations to the board, I will accept that. But, as drafted, if there is any investigation, even if the board decides that no action is called for, they will be under an obligation to give everybody a hearing. I think what we should do is, that if there is what we will call a prima facie case against a person, the board would notify him and ask him if he has anything to say and give him a reasonable period in which to make his representations and forbear to take any action until that opportunity was afforded him.
Comment on this
I think that would cover the point. My amendment was not perfectly clear. Will the Minister put down an amendment on Report?
Comment on this
This gives very wide powers of entry and inspection.
"An authorised officer may ... at all reasonable times enter on and inspect any greyhound racetrack,"—
we are not objecting to that—
"authorised coursing ground or place used for the public sale of greyhounds"—
there is objection to that—
"or the training of greyhounds for reward and may there require any person to give him any information which he may reasonably consider necessary for the purposes of the administration of this Act."
I do not think we could take any exception to giving an authorised officer power of entry and inspection on a greyhound racetrack or coursing ground, but it is quite a different matter to give him power of entry into a sale yard at any time. Of course, the section says "at all reasonable times" and possibly I am overstating it when I say "at any time". "... and there require any person to give him any information which he may reasonably consider necessary for the purposes of the administration of this Act." It then goes on to say that a person who
"(a) obstructs or impedes the exercise of any power conferred by this section,
(b) fails or refuses to give an authorised officer any information within his knowledge which the officer requires under this section, or
(c) in giving any such information, gives information which, to his knowledge, is false or misleading in any material particular,
shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding £20."
After all, a Garda cannot enter ordinary premises, unless he has a search warrant. Again, I am putting the point——
Comment on this
On the whole, I do not think these powers are excessive. I am not trying to score off the Deputy at all, but inasmuch as the Deputy did not put down an amendment, I think he probably agreed with that view. I have not a closed mind on this and if the Deputy feels there is any qualification of these powers that is really urgently necessary, I will most sympathetically and carefully consider any proposal he has to make, but I would ask the Deputy to dwell on the fact that in respect of every power the authorised person is required to act reasonably and at reasonable times and for the reasonable purposes of the enforcement of the statute.
Comment on this
These tactics of the Minister endeavouring to fob off on Deputies in opposition his responsibilities and obligations are not good enough.
Comment on this
And what is the proposal? A Garda officer could not enter a sales yard. He could not enter a premises where greyhounds are kept without a search warrant——
Comment on this
That is the ordinary law of the land and the Garda, at least, comes in uniform. A Garda is trained in investigation, but here we have an authorised officer, a private individual, who might possibly fake his credentials and authority, and he is entitled to enter the premises of a person carrying on his ordinary occupation.
Comment on this
Certainly, he might. It might be some person who was not a genuine authorised officer. What we are doing is giving power of entry to a person who does not carry his authority on the surface as a Garda will—a Garda is in uniform nine times out of ten when he tries to enter a premises and he is armed with a search warrant and he has to be. He has to apply for this search warrant in due form, but under Section 46 the Minister proposes to allow any Tom, Dick or Harry appointed as an authorised officer by the greyhound industry board to enter at will.
I know, of course, there is the apparent safeguard of the phrase "at all reasonable times". I suppose that means that he will not enter your premises at 3 o'clock in the morning, but he may do it at 7.30 in the evening, particularly if you happen to be training greyhounds, or at any time between that and midnight. The Minister asks: why did I not put down an amendment? Because the section on the face of it is so bad that, unless the Minister indicated here, having heard the arguments, that he proposed drastically to amend it, there would be no purpose in putting down an amendment. What we did intend to do was to vote against the section because, as I have already said, it gives to an official of this board—which carries no responsibility to this House or to the people of this country except such as may precariously attach to the Minister—the right to enter the premises of a private citizen who is trying to earn his livelihood by carrying on a legitimate business.
I remember how vocal the Minister used to be about the rights of citizens. When we were putting through the Health Act which the Minister's Government are now operating, I remember how very vocal the Minister was about the rights of citizens. I recall how vocal he was when we were putting through an Education Bill. If the Almighty had given me the rhetorical powers the Minister has, the roof would be lifted off this Assembly. I know that Deputy Dillon, by his eloquence, would shake the walls of this chamber if we brought in a provision like this. We do not put down an amendment to this section because the section is so radically bad that, unless the Minister indicates that he proposes to amend it in such a way that it will ensure that, before a servant of this board tries to enter the premises of any private individual, he will arm himself with a search warrant similar to that necessary for a Garda, we will vote against the section. That is the way in which this section should be amended. I hope the Minister will be able to give serious consideration to an amendment to the section on the lines we have suggested.
Comment on this
Under Section 38, which has already been adopted by the Dáil, the board is charged with responsibility for the supervision of public sales of greyhounds, and there are laid upon the board a number of duties to ensure that such sales are properly conducted. That section was adopted by this House after protracted discussion. The means of giving effect to that section are set out in Section 46, which we are now considering. Under the section, an authorised official, and only an authorised official—who shall, as already explained to the House, correspond very closely to a stipendiary steward of the Racing Board—shall have, at all reasonable times, a right of entry to a place where public auctions of dogs are being conducted. That is the purpose of this section.
I meant that section to give him that power; I meant the authorised official, and only the authorised official—not a person carrying forged credentials, or any Tom, Dick or Harry, or any irresponsible person but an authorised official—to have that power. I meant to give him that right, at all reasonable times, to enter a greyhound racing track. I meant to give to an authorised official of the board the right, at all reasonable times, to enter on a place kept for the training of greyhounds for reward. I think he ought to have that power. Further I meant to ask the House to clothe an authorised official with the right, at all reasonable times, to require a person on any of the premises to which I have referred to give him any information that he may reasonably consider necessary for the administration of the Act.
There is nothing in this section which I consider excessive. As I have already told Deputies, I have not tried at any stage of our deliberations on this Bill to assume an adamantine or dictatorial attitude. If there is something in the section which causes any grave misgivings to any Deputy, I shall be glad to try and remove these misgivings. The customary courtesy of this House, certainly in the case of a Bill which has been under discussion for ten months, is that Deputies who have reservations about something in the Bill and who are interested in it would put down amendments indicating what they would like to have done.
If I find the words used in any such amendment ineffective to serve the purpose the particular Deputy had in mind, I will give him a draft of what I think is a better amendment. If that fails, I will listen to his argument. I may then say that I cannot do exactly what the Deputy wants but that I will go a certain distance with him, and will put down an amendment between now and Report Stage. However, I do not think there is anything in this section which gives rise to a reasonable misgiving. That, of course, is only my opinion. If there is, I invite the Deputy so concerned to put down an amendment and, if I cannot meet him, I shall endeavour to go very close to it.
Comment on this
I think the Minister is making too much play about the period of time this Bill has been before the House. We have come to this section on Committee Stage for the first time and therefore are having our first opportunity of discussing the section on its merits.
Comment on this
I observe that. Deputy MacEntee said he thought this section was so bad that there was no point in putting down amendments to it. I think that is a reasonable point of view. Sub-section (2) of this section refers to a person who obstructs or impedes the exercise of any power conferred by the section. Who is to decide whether a person is obstructing or impeding the exercise of the powers conferred by the section?
Comment on this
I think Deputy MacEntee is worried about it, because it is not clear that the authorised officer of the board is not alone the person who has that right.
Comment on this
The authorised officer is apparently the only person who has the authority to give evidence on a point of obstructing or impeding.
Comment on this
If the Deputy were defending a client in the District Court would he ever allow the State to get away with that proposition?
Comment on this
I think that is the point that worries Deputy MacEntee. The only person who can say whether he has been impeded or obstructed is the authorised officer.
Comment on this
If that is the anxiety, I do not think there is any amendment to the section necessary to allay that apprehension. I do not think there is, but, if you think there is, then put down an amendment.
Comment on this
I know that Deputy MacEntee is worried about the power of "ante" under this section and feels it is excessive. Definitely, the Minister does not.
Comment on this
He intended that that power should be given. The only thing we can do on that is to oppose. We feel it should not have been given and the Minister feels it should.
Comment on this
I should like to put a point to the Minister, I am doubtful about the constitutionality of this —I suppose the Dáil had better adjourn until this private conversation is concluded.
Comment on this
Every time Deputy MacEntee goes and has tea he comes back here like a red-tailed bee.
Comment on this
I must protest against the display of ill-manners by the Minister here this evening. Whether we talk sense or nonsense, we are sent here as representatives of the people and, for good or for ill, the Minister is bound to listen to us.
Comment on this
The Minister may take it either way. I am certain the Minister is unhappy. The shallow acceptance of the proposals in this Bill betrays an utter lack of responsibility on his part and a complete disregard of his obligations to the citizens. I am sure the Minister is unhappy. He has seen what the effects of these provisions are. For the first time, they have been brought to his notice. I am perfectly certain the Minister is disturbed in his own mind because the Minister has liberal antecedents. I do not think he was ever in the Blue Shirts.
Comment on this
I am coming to a point, now. The Minister has always professed to be concerned with the constitutional rights of the citizens. Deputy A. Barry has left the House with the report of the advisory committee tied to his tail. He signed it. The Minister set up the committee. But the committee certainly did not recommend to the Minister the powers which the Minister is seeking to confer upon officers, appointees, employees, of the board which he proposes to set up under the Act.
I was saying that, in this House on previous occasions, the Minister made a parade of his regard for the constitutional rights of the citizen. What does Article 40 of the Constitution provide? It provides that the dwelling of every citizen is inviolable. Let us see now what is involved in Section 46. The ménage of a private house may be used for the purpose of housing greyhounds. The trainer may kennel his dogs in buildings which are inseparable from his own private house, the place where he lives, his dwelling.
Under this section, the Minister is taking power, despite the declaration of the Constitution, to empower an officer of this board to enter the yard, say, attached to a dwelling in which, on one occasion or another, a public sale of greyhounds has taken place, or the yard or the garden or the outhouses in which greyhounds are kennelled under the jurisdiction of their trainer. It is a nice point for the courts to decide whether these premises are separate. In most cases, they will not be structurally separate and in most cases will be used for other purposes than kennelling greyhounds. However, they are part of the greyhound trainer's establishment and, despite the provisions of Article 40, despite the solemn proclamation that the dwelling of the citizen is inviolable, the Minister proposes to give the employee, the minion, of this greyhound industry board the right to enter without warrant, without, in fact, any authority beyond the pass or the badge which the person seeking entry may carry in his pocket. He can go in there without disclosing to the owner of the premises the purposes for which he seeks entry. There is not even that protection afforded to the citizen—not even the protection of compelling the authorised officer to inform the person into whose dwelling he proposes to force himself of the purpose for which entry is being sought.
That is what the Minister proposes in Section 46 of this Bill. I doubt if the Minister has really considered the matter. As I have said, this thing has been served up to him on a platter; it is put before the House and, while we are debating it, the Minister endeavours by gibes and sneers to create the impression that our opposition is not founded upon the fact that this Bill is one of the most oppressive measures ever introduced into this House and one of the most ill-conceived.
This is a Bill which flouts, in almost every particular, the findings of the advisory committee, which the Minister himself set up. He will not find in the report of the advisory committee any suggestion that such drastic and unqualified powers as are proposed should be given to any person in relation to the premises under private ownership. I think the Minister ought, even at this late hour, mend his hand in regard to that and try and give us some sort of guarantee that these powers will not be unnecessarily used and that, above all, the person whose premises it is sought to trespass upon will be told for what reason the visit is being paid.
Comment on this
The Deputy has repeatedly made the offensive and impudent suggestion that I do not carefully consider proposals which I bring before Dáil Eireann. I desire to place it on record that I regard Deputy MacEntee's suggestion to this end, as impudent and offensive. The Deputy has just had another cup of tea and returns inspired with his refreshment to say that this section confers on an authorised officer the right to break into a man's dwelling.
Comment on this
The Deputy did. The Deputy said it gave him a right to break into a man's dwelling. There is no power in this section to enter any man's dwelling unless it can be proved that he is training greyhounds in the parlour—and I do not know how any man could train greyhounds in a parlour—or if it can be proved he is conducting public auctions of greyhounds in the bedroom.
Comment on this
Unless he is using his dwelling for one of these purposes, there is no power in an authorised officer to enter his dwelling, any more than there is in any citizen of the State. There is a power set out in this section to give an authorised officer the right to enter any place where public auctions of greyhounds are habitually held, where greyhounds are trained or raced. I meant to put those powers there. The Deputy was too lazy for the last ten months to put down any amendment to curtail those powers. He is now maintaining a studious policy of obstruction with his eye upon the clock. He is conducting that policy at the instigation of whom I do not know but I hope to find out, for it is at the instigation of somebody interested in greyhounds and that cannot be said of Deputy MacEntee until this Bill came to pass. At the instigation of somebody he has maintained what he described himself recently as bitter opposition, for the best part of ten months. It does not dismay me but it is important to get it on the records of this House that all the claptrap we have heard to-day, including the profound contribution from Deputy Burke of North Dublin——
Comment on this
——is all designed for obstruction. That does not alter the fact, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, although I experience some pangs of conscience in appearing to repeat myself, that if there is any reservation in the minds of any Deputy about Section 46 and if in the last ten months, having put down amendments to Section 45 and to Section 47, if by some extraordinary aberration he did not notice that there was a Section 46 in the Bill, he is welcome so far as I am concerned, and subject to your authority, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, to put down an amendment now. If we can meet it without irremediably weakening the Bill between this and the Report Stage, I shall be happy to do so.
Comment on this
One would think from the Minister's repeated remarks that this measure had been before the House for ten months. In actual fact it was not before the House on more than 15 working days of the House——
Comment on this
——spread over ten months. What does the Minister mean by stating that the Opposition is adopting obstructionist tactics?
Comment on this
I resent that. I could be much better occupied, if it were not for the fact that I am deeply interested in the various sections of the Bill. On the point raised by the Minister as to why we did not put down amendments on certain sections, he might be interested to know that it was conveyed to me recently that it was doubtful if any more amendments would be allowed. If the members were to put down all the amendments which from time to time we have discussed and agreed they were reasonable, we would be here for the next two years. But, of course, we are aware that the Government will not be there for the next two years.
Comment on this
What is all this talk about, the sarcastic reference by the Minister as to whether we believe the sale of greyhounds could take place in bedrooms or in kitchens? Does the Minister recall where Tulyar was sold or Vimy bought? It was at the dead of night in this city and although I asked for details of the auctions——
Comment on this
Now the Minister is giving the power of entry and inspection to authorised officers to come along with more powers than the Gestapo had under Hitler. Do not have any doubt about that. The people who are oppressed by these sections will rise up. However, the Coalition Government have got so cocky that they have come to the conclusion that they will just ride roughshod over the populace because they know that, once they go, they will never be seen again.
Comment on this
As I have said on a previous occasion:—
"That's the wise thrush
He sings each song twice over
Lest you should think he never could recapture
The first fine careless rapture."
I repeat it now for Deputy O'Leary's benefit.
Comment on this
I and my colleagues want to show the people of this country the tactics adopted by the Minister and we challenge the Minister that he may not have any interest in this Bill but there are vested interests, and very big backers of the Fine Gael Party, particularly, who are interested in this Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister was heard to say that I had some form of private interest. I have no interest but to protect the private citizen. If I were to characterise the Minister's statement by the word which would properly describe him, I would be asked to leave the Chamber.
Comment on this
In the name of Providence, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, what is this except impudent disorder?
Comment on this
No, it is not. I am not going to allow the Minister to get away with that. The Minister has said we have been obstructing. The Minister has not given us one reasonable concession in relation to this Bill. If it is obstruction, what else is there on the parliamentary programme except this Bill?
Comment on this
Neither was the Minister's allegation that we were obstructing Section 46. We have been debating the section in a reasonable way and, instead of getting up and answering our criticisms on the section, the Minister gets up and hurls the charge against us that we are obstructing. Obstructing what? Where is the business that has brought this House together?
Comment on this
The section before the House at the moment is Section 46 and Deputy MacEntee should address himself to it.
Comment on this
I agree with you, Sir, but it is very difficult. If Section 46 is the business before the House where was the relevancy in the Minister's dastardly allegation that I had some private interest in obstructing this Bill? I am not obstructing the Bill. I am criticising the Bill, but the Minister cannot stand criticism.
Comment on this
The Minister, with the arrogance which characterises his whole attitude, in public at any rate, thinks that, because he brings a Bill in here, we are to accept it on our bended knees and thank him for it. That is not our job. Our job is to examine it, to criticise it, and to try if we can to induce the Minister to give ear to our criticism and weight to what we are saying and to the suggestions which have been made by his advisory committee. The Minister mentioned that I went out. I went out to get a copy of the Constitution. I went out at six o'clock, four and a half hours ago, in order to facilitate the Minister and to try and keep him in good humour——
Comment on this
It seems to be just as relevant to the section under discussion as the fact that I had a cup of tea at 6 o'clock in the evening. The Minister has been holding that against me for the last three hours and a half. I am sorry he did not have his cup of tea because he might have been in better humour——
Comment on this
I went out to get a copy of the Constitution. Article 40 guarantees that the dwelling-house of every citizen is inviolate. When I put it to the Minister that it might be a nice point of law to decide whether the dwelling-house of a greyhound trainer, whether the outhouses in which he kennelled the dogs he was training, was not part of his dwelling-house, the Minister got up and said "Oh, we are not suggesting that the trainer will train his dogs in his bedroom." Nobody suggested that. The Minister might have imagined that is where the greyhounds are trained. Performing fleas might be trained in some of the bedrooms we hear about.
Everybody knows where greyhounds are trained. The people who train them very often are agricultural labourers and others, and it would be very difficult, as I said, to differentiate between a building which would be properly an appurtenance to a dwelling-house and a building which would be used solely for the purposes of training greyhounds. Greyhounds are not trained in bedrooms, but they have to be kennelled somewhere and where they are kennelled is part of the trainer's establishment. Where they are kennelled might be very difficult to distinguish as a separate building distinct from the trainer's dwelling. It might be all part of the same premises. The Minister apparently does not know that.
He has been harping here about the Racing Board. He has professed on more than one occasion to know nothing about greyhound racing and yet he comes in here and legislates for conditions of which he has no knowledge, of which he is proud to parade his ignorance. We do not live on the same lofty plain as the Minister. We are not philosophic Liberals on this side of the House. We happen to be just down-to-earth, common citizens who know how the ordinary people of this country make a living, including the type of person whom you must often find training greyhounds. He does not belong to the aristocracy with which the Minister associates. He is just an ordinary plain Tom, Dick or Harry, a fellow who probably might, in a misguided moment, vote for the Minister—but he is not likely to vote for him at the next general election.
In any event, because we know the conditions under which these people carry on, we are saying to the Minister what in fact he is giving, in one case at least, the authorised officer of this Greyhound Industry Board the right to do is to enter what may be the dwelling of a private citizen, and if that private citizen happens to be a man in humble circumstances, trying to eke out a livelihood by training greyhounds, he has the same right of protection as the friends of the Minister who might have their dwellings in much more opulent circumstances. I think it is really an abuse of the procedure of the House to have the Minister come up here and, when he is faced with solid arguments against the section, to get up and treat them with the derision and scorn with which he treated them here this evening.
I was hoping that, after this failure which attended his efforts to steamroll this Bill through the House during the summer session, the Minister would come here and be prepared to listen to our arguments in an objective way. We are not suggesting that he would concede everything we would say, but at least what we have been saying has been well grounded and has been advanced here because there are sections in this Bill which, in our opinion, are repugnant to the Constitution and which, whether they are repugnant to the letter of the Constitution or not, are at least repugnant to all standards and criteria of fair play and justice.
These are the things which we tried to deal with on other sections. Having said that, the Minister can get his Section 46 if he likes, but there are some other stages of this Bill yet to be faced and, unless the Minister between now and the Report Stage brings in an amendment which will at least meet the point of view of the Opposition, he is not going to get very much further with this Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23 (h):—
In sub-section (1), line 31, before "by" to insert "having heard any person affected, or having afforded such person an opportunity of being heard".
The adoption of the amendment would mean that sub-section (1) of Section 47 would read as follows:—
"The board, with the consent of the club, or the club, with the consent of the board, having heard any person affected, or having afforded such person an opportunity of being heard, may ..."
Comment on this
I will accept that or draftsman's words, that is to say, if the Deputy will withdraw the amendment, I will introduce something on Report Stage to reproduce what he has in mind.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23 (i):—
In sub-section (1), line 33, after "following" to insert "for a period not exceeding three years".
I put down what I consider a reasonable period. If there were not a limit on the period a person could be warned off for life. An exclusion order could be made against him in respect of any greyhound track, coursing meeting or sales. I would suggest that the Minister should insert a period, be it three years or five years. There should be some limit. It would be very harsh that a person could be warned off for life for one misdemeanour. There are degrees of seriousness of offences. In the law courts the sentence may be life, ten years or three years or any period. I suggest to the Minister that he should put down some limit.
Comment on this
Does not the Deputy think it a better thing to provide, as is provided in sub-section (2), that the board may revoke? If we put in three years or, indeed, any period, it may work hardship on people in respect of whom no one would contemplate a protracted suspension. My feeling is that the Deputy's amendment, instead of making the section more favourable to minor delinquents, might in fact have the effect of making it more harsh and, if you mention three years, that that would come to be the sort of minimum.
Comment on this
Is it that the Deputy feels that, no matter what the offence is, there ought to be an absolute prohibition on life suspension?
Comment on this
This amendment was put down two days ago. The Minister very kindly indicated an hour ago on another amendment that he appreciated what I had in mind. I am quite satisfied that he does so in respect of this amendment. I agree that an offence could be of such a nature as to merit life suspension but I submit that there should be a limit in respect of other offences. I would suggest that the Minister should examine the matter between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
How will I prescribe a limit if the Deputy has agreed with me that circumstances might conceivably arise in which the board ought to warn off a trainer or an owner or somebody for life? If we put in an absolute limit, we preclude the board from ever doing that in any circumstances. I think the section is better as it stands but, if the Deputy chooses to put an amendment down again, I will have it further examined but I suggest to the Deputy that he would consider the point I am making to him, that is, that, in fact, the section as it stands is, if anything less rigid and severe than it would be if we accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I would point out to the Minister that under the Bill, after five years, there might be an entirely new board, with the exception of the chairman and that there is the possibility that every year or every second year, by popular vote of the Irish Coursing Club, someone on the board could be deposed or put off and then a case might come up for revision. The Minister says that the board has the power to revoke such an exclusion order. Agreed. The exclusion order might come up for review when the nucleus of the board might be entirely different. It is most unlikely that the board will warn off anyone for life because, in my submission, a matter of such a serious nature as to merit that course would warrant State interference prior to that. The Minister will appreciate my point. If a crime were committed, it is not the board that would hold an inquiry. The State would take action. Take a case of a man defrauding the public in bets or a man winning a race with a substituted dog. That is not the sort of thing that the board is set up to deal with. It is to deal with suspected cases. If there were a case of robbery and fraud that came before the notice of the State the Guards would intervene very quickly and would not wait for the club or board to hold an inquiry.
Comment on this
I am bound to say that I do not think we ought to put a limit on the period of suspension.
Comment on this
Put down something and I will consider it, but I am not binding myself now to accept it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23 (j):—
In sub-section (3), line 39, before "revoke" to insert "and with the consent of the board".
The Minister will notice that I did not suggest the insertion of the words in sub-section (2). Sub-sections (2) and (3) are similarly worded:—
"(2) The board may, after consultation with the club, revoke any exclusion order made by the board.
"(3) The club may, after consultation with the board, revoke any exclusion order made by the club."
I do not want to give the power to the club——
Comment on this
Would you let me, just for reasons of draftsmanship, put in an amendment to give effect to that, if the Deputy will withdraw it?
Comment on this
I should like to direct the attention of the House, for the record, to the fact that in the last three minutes I have met the Opposition in respect of three amendments.
Comment on this
Comparatively trivial but we are grateful. We are grateful for the generosity which the Minister parades before the Dáil.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:—
Before sub-section (2), to insert the following new sub-section:—
(2) Where regulations under sub-section (1) of this section fix, in relation to a greyhound racetrack or part thereof, maximum charges in respect of bookmakers carrying on their business which are more than five times the maximum charges fixed in relation to the track or part, by the regulations (or by other regulations for the time being in force) in respect of persons who are not such bookmakers, the regulations shall require the consent of the Minister.
This amendment is designed to enable me to satisfy myself that the board will not prescribe admission charges for bookmakers higher than five times the admission charges for the ordinary public unless it is fully necessary. If the board does not take any action under Section 48 of the Bill, which gives it the power to fix charges, the entry charge for bookmakers to every track is a matter of negotiation and arrangement between bookmakers and the track management because under Section 48 the board "may by regulations" do certain things. If it does not make regulations then the status quo, whatever it is, continues to operate but if the board decides, in respect of any track, to regulate the entrance fee for bookmakers they cannot fix an entrance fee for bookmakers in excess of five times the fee charged to the public for entrance on the course without express sanction from the Minister for Agriculture.
If this amendment is adopted these alternatives are available in respect of charges to be made to bookmakers hereafter: (1) the board may declare itself disinterested, in which event bookmakers and course management can make any arrangement which is mutually acceptable; (2) the board may declare itself interested and say to the track management: "You may not charge more than five times the admission charge levied on the public in respect of a bookmaker." In either of these two contingencies the Minister does not come in at all, but supposing there is a country track, a rural track or a track anywhere where, in the judgment of the board, it is fair and equitable that, in all the circumstances, the track management should be allowed to charge the bookmakers more than five times the charge levied on the public, they may authorise a charge in excess of five times the basic admission charge. However, such an order has no effect until it has been submitted to the Minister for Agriculture and approved by him.
To the best of my knowledge and belief, that is the most equitable way of disposing of this difficult question of bookmakers' entrance fees while at the same time ensuring that you may not place upon small tracks an impossible burden by precluding them from charging more than five times the basic charge. I understand in respect of certain tracks bookmakers would prefer that the board would disinterest themselves altogether and allow the local bookmakers' association and the race track management to make an equitable arrangement suitable to both, but the inclusion of this amendment provides, I think, against every possible contingency and for that reason I recommend it to the Dáil.
Comment on this
I understand amendment No. 25 will not be moved. It has been retabled as No. 25 (a).
Comment on this
These three amendments, Nos. 24, 25 (a) and 28 (a) are to be taken together, and No. 30 also, by agreement, because amendment No. 30 also limits maximum charges for admission to coursing meetings. It is a ministerial amendment.