We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–153 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

When we adjourned we were discussing the impact of the Budget on agriculture. I was asking the Minister for Finance why he made provision for £150,000 to convert a proportion of the wheat crop into animal feed. As I understand him, he gave me two separate reasons: (1) because we had too much wheat and (2) because the 30,000 tons of wheat he proposed to convert into animal feed were bad.

Comment on this

I do not think he said "bad". It is inferior.

Comment on this

He said it is bad wheat.

Comment on this

It would be bad wheat to carry over.

Comment on this

He said "bad" wheat.

Comment on this

I think that what happened is that this is wheat which the millers do not want to mill. They made the case very strongly to me—and I saw their point—that they should not be asked to mill sprouted wheat. I pressed the view on them that they should, but I said I recognised that if any undue proportion of sprouted wheat was pressed into the grist it would put an unreasonable handicap on them. I said: "We are quite prepared to see that you get a sufficiency of grade A wheat——"

Comment on this

Imported.

Comment on this

——imported, if needs be —to enable you to carry any quantity of sprouted wheat you may have to incorporate into the grist.

Comment on this

You gave them a guarantee that they would get 50 per cent. imported——

Comment on this

No. They got 50 per cent. from September until about October. Then we sent for them again because at that time we did not know what the wheat crop would be like as it came in. The general undertaking was: "Whatever it is like, we will see that you get enough Grade A. wheat." When the crop was in and we knew the position we sent for the millers and said: "It is not reasonable to look for 50 per cent. with this crop. Try 66?rds." I said to them: "I hope you will be able to raise it to 70 but we are going to lean backwards in implementing our undertaking to you that you will have a fair deal inasmuch as you did your duty in taking in the crop."

Some of the millers—I think quite bona fide—made the case that they could not mill sprouted wheat. We suggested: “You can. Try it with 66?rds.” Some millers said: “That is quite impossible.” However, by experience, they discovered that it was not impossible. Then the point was made to me: “That will leave us with a carry over of 20,000 or 30,000 tons.” I said: “It may be even larger but there is no difficulty about filtering that into the grist next year”.

Comment on this

The carry-over is 80,000.

Comment on this

The crop turned out to be much larger than we anticipated.

The astonishing position is that I am now told that we produced too much wheat. Yet you will find plenty of warriors sitting on these benches who will tell me that the inter-Party Government destroyed wheat in this country. Now you hear your own Minister saying we produced too much.

Comment on this

No. There would not have been enough wheat if the crop had been harvested safely. There will be a much bigger harvest this year.

Comment on this

Exactly. There will be a much bigger harvest this year.

Comment on this

And will it be harvested properly?

Comment on this

It depends on the weather.

Comment on this

We have too much wheat. One of the defences for appropriating £150,000 in this year is that there is no place to put the wheat. I assure the Minister that he is mistaken. There is store. It is quite possible to carry forward that wheat and filter it into the incoming wheat next year with such proportion of Manitobas as may be requisite to produce baker's flour.

I warn the Minister that he is walking straight into a very awkward situation if he once concedes that wheat which has sprouted is unfit for conversion into flour. He does not realise the land-mine on which he is putting his foot. The Minister thinks that by "sprouted wheat" millers mean wheat with visible sprouts upon it. But they do not mean that at all, if you ask a miller's technician. If you once concede to millers——

Comment on this

The wheat we are talking about now is not sprouting.

Comment on this

What is wrong with it?

Comment on this

It is wheat which is millable but of a very low grade. It will not keep—at least, we are so advised.

Comment on this

Do not believe a word of it. They tried to sell me that cup of tea and I just laughed at them. It is nonsense. I assure the Minister there was not a barrel of wheat taken into storage and dried from the last harvest that will not keep for an ample time to permit of its being incorporated into suitable grist.

Comment on this

There is a new crop coming in——

Comment on this

——which will be a very large crop, according to the acreage, and there must be accommodation made for that crop. We cannot leave that out.

Comment on this

No, but I do ask the House to face this interesting fact: how many members of the Fianna Fáil Party believe that one of the results of the inter-Party Government policy was that we had too much wheat, that we had so large a crop of wheat in hands and growing——

Comment on this

We only had too much wheat because we had to use 50 per cent. imported wheat.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that that is not true.

Comment on this

100,000 tons of Canadian wheat imported on "tick" and not paid for yet.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

Here is the position. The first explanation is that we have too much wheat and nowhere to put it. I want to warn the Minister for Industry and Commerce against this and here is the reason I think it is so deplorable that there is only an acting Minister for Agriculture——

Comment on this

That will be remedied to-night.

Comment on this

——the millers will come and say that sprouted wheat is not fit for conversion into flour. The next step will be that the millers will explain to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that sprouted wheat does not mean wheat with the sprout on it. They will explain that the maltose content of wheat rises above a certain level before it makes a sprout and that therefore wheat with a maltose content above a certain basic figure is technically sprouted wheat and must therefore be rejected under the same decision as has apparently been taken this year.

I want to say most emphatically there is no wheat in storage in this country at the present moment, dry, from last year's crop which is unfit for conversion into flour. I am not saying that by guessing: I am saying it from certain knowledge, and I am warning the House to watch its step in regard to this matter. If it is ever conceded that the contention is true on this occasion, it will be widely expanded. I ask the House to note this astonishing fact, that for the first time since the State was established, according to the present Government, we have too much wheat——

Comment on this

No, we have not.

Comment on this

Too much imported wheat.

Comment on this

Too large a carryover.

Comment on this

And it is not paid for.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry must restrain himself.

Comment on this

It is because an exceptional amount of wheat had to be imported.

Comment on this

You are backing up the millers now.

Comment on this

As Deputy Allen ought to know—and I believe does know, because he is a cute operator beaming over there for the last 25 years——

Comment on this

Longer.

Comment on this

——we got the present crop used, and should get it all used——

Comment on this

Then why did you permit so much foreign wheat to be brought in?

Comment on this

——by the skilful use of sufficient quantities of imported wheat. Has the present Minister for Industry and Commerce reduced the grist?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

If the Minister changed the grist——

Comment on this

Is that not the point? If imported wheat had to be brought in, that explains the carry-over.

Comment on this

Yes, but has the Minister thought it expedient to reduce the grist?

Comment on this

I am told that the quality of last year's Irish crop was not good enough. I consider the present grist to be the proper grist.

Comment on this

I disagree with him entirely.

Comment on this

Now, we know.

Comment on this

I disagree.

Comment on this

Well, you see, he is the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

And I disagree with the Deputy also.

Comment on this

I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce is right in that it would be foolish to press for a higher percentage than 66?. He might go to 70, but I would not press it. I think he would be wrong to force them to use grist higher than 70/30 in this year, but there is no reason whatever for converting the carry-over into animal feed. That ought to be filtered into the grist next year and the full economic price recovered for it. It is wrong to charge up to the taxpayers of this country £150,000 for the purpose of enabling that stuff to be converted into feed. If that principle is once admitted, it will be brought up against the Minister year after year by men who quite honestly believe that they ought to be allowed to have 50 per cent. Manitoba and 50 per cent. native wheat in any grist.

I think they are wrong, but they honestly believe that, and it is their desire to turn out a first-class product that makes them press that view. If it is conceded that 30,000 tons of last year's crop are fit only for conversion into animal food, that contention will be expanded, and it is wrong and foolish.

I had occasion to query the Minister for Finance who, I notice, with great discretion, has not come back——

Comment on this

I share your hope that he will not be long.

Comment on this

I do not blame you. One more salvo from Deputy Allen and Deputy Corry and the position of the Minister will be untenable.

Comment on this

I have a more material reason than that.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance has been out now for an hour and a quarter, having tea, and when he was going out, I was expressing some surprise at the method he employed for informing us that the present Government was going to put on butter not only the 5d. consequent on the withdrawal of the subsidy but something between 1d. and 2d. in additional levy. He said: "I stated that in my Budget speech," and I queried that. I did not have his Budget speech before me when I was speaking and I said that I did not think any Deputy in the Minister's own Party understood that. He said that he had stated it most explicitly, but here is what he said, and I quote from Volume 161, No. 8, column 947:—

"As from to-morrow, 9th May, payment of subsidy to reduce the price of butter to the consumer will cease."

That is quite clear: that is the 5d. a lb.

"Control over wholesale and retail prices of butter will be removed. The price to creameries for butter will, however, be supported by the Butter Marketing Committee at a level sufficient to continue the existing price position for milk supplied to creameries and to meet the cost of cold-storing butter for winter requirements. The appropriate subsidy paid on butter not yet sold to consumers will be recovered, as far as possible, by a levy on existing stocks. On that account, it may be expected that the retail price of butter will shortly reflect the withdrawal of the subsidy."

Mark those words: "On that account, it may be expected that the retail price of creamery butter will shortly reflect the withdrawal of the subsidy."

Is there a Deputy who would interpret that as meaning that the price of butter will go up by 7d. a lb.? In the paragraph dealing with this arrangement, the Minister ends with the words: "On that account it may be expected that the retail price of butter will shortly reflect the withdrawal of the subsidy". Does that not amount to saying, to any man who was listening, to a declaration that the Minister is in fact taking steps which will result in the price of butter going up by the amount of the subsidy, to wit, 5d. a lb.? It is only when the butter starts being delivered from the creameries to the shops that it transpires that not only has the subsidy been removed, but the production allowance and the cold-storage allowance have been added to the price and the price control removed, with the result that there is an additional impost of 2d. per lb., though the Minister for Finance now says that he thinks 1½d. would be enough.

We are all conscious of what that means to the consumer, but was there a single member of the Fianna Fáil Party who knew that that additional impost was to be put on butter at the expense of the consumer?

Comment on this

It was announced in the Budget.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Allen know, cross his heart and hope to die, when that speech was made in this House, that there was 7d. a lb. going on butter, or did he think it was 5d.?

Comment on this

I knew it would be more than 5d.

Comment on this

Did the Minister for Finance have time to refer back to what he said on the Budget in regard to butter? I want to ask the Minister for Finance, now that he is here, does he think the paragraph in which he announced this did fairly inform the House of his intention, not only to withdraw the subsidy, but to add something between 1d. and 2d. to the charge to be levied on the consumer?

Comment on this

Why is the Deputy repeating that? Why does he want to repeat that? Did he not go over all that before?

Comment on this

Since that was asked, I got a copy of the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

Why is the Deputy allowed to repeat his speech like that?

Comment on this

I am not repeating.

Comment on this

Of course, you are.

Comment on this

The Deputy went over all that before.

Comment on this

I had not got a copy of the Minister's speech then and I am asking the Minister now if he thinks it was fair to say:—

"The appropriate subsidy paid on butter not yet sold to consumers will be recovered, as far as possible, by a levy on existing stocks. On that account, it may be expected that the retail price of creamery butter will shortly reflect the withdrawal of the subsidy?"

Was that not a suggestion that the impact of the Minister's proposals would simply be that prices would go up by the amount of the subsidy?

Comment on this

As I said before, I made an hour's speech. If I had to weigh every word, as the Deputy wants, I would have taken months to prepare the speech. Everything was included in the subsidy.

Comment on this

I would have thought the subsidy was generally deemed to be the 5d. subsidy.

Comment on this

That may be the Deputy's opinion but the subsidy was there, paid by the Government.

Comment on this

That is perfectly clear. That is the Minister's version. The House has heard my version. Which does the House think was the disingenuous way of approaching them, to communicate that information to them? Certainly, no newspaper in Ireland, no member of Dáil Eireann, no consumer in Ireland knew until the butter started being delivered that the price was going up by 6½d. or 7d. a lb. All believed, when the Minister sat down, that this referred to 5d. But, what I am concerned about is this— there is nothing in the Minister's speech about what is going to happen, now that all subsidisation of the milk and butter industry is withdrawn and all control removed. There is nothing in the Minister's speech as to what is to become of the surplus.

Comment on this

Wait now. What is the point? What could I gain, seeing that the butter was going up the next day, by concealing it?

Comment on this

Had you not divisions to face?

Comment on this

Divisions?

Comment on this

Did you not get Independents to vote for you in that division?

Comment on this

And we will get them again.

Comment on this

I think it is important that the facts should be stated and what I am anxious about it what the repercussions of these proposals will be on the industry. We know now that the price of butter——

Comment on this

You knew it the day afterwards.

Comment on this

——is going to be in the order of 4/3d or 4/4d. I reckon that that will result in reduced consumption of butter on the domestic market. There is a clear undertaking here that whatever surplus over and above the domestic market there may be will be exported by the Butter Marketing Committee.

Comment on this

Yes. I heard that before. I heard it all before from the Deputy. I heard it an hour ago.

Comment on this

Heretofore, the Treasury recouped the Butter Marketing Committee for any losses they made on that transaction.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

What is the Minister's intention in the coming year?

Comment on this

What is the Deputy's intention in repeating the speech?

Comment on this

I am only asking a question. I can find no provision left in the Estimates, after the Minister's speech, to meet the charge that may come in course of payment if there are exports of surplus butter by the Butter Marketing Committee and where is that going to be provided?

Comment on this

The Estimates were printed.

Comment on this

But, after the Minister's speech and his announcement of his intention to withdraw all subsidies here mentioned, it does not seem to me to leave anything in these Estimates to provide for the contingency of the Butter Marketing Committee having to export surplus butter. Who is going to pay for the export of surplus butter, if a surplus transpires? I reckon that it will cost about £10 a cwt. to export butter.

Comment on this

How much did it cost last year?

Comment on this

Any that we exported last year cost about £7.

Comment on this

How much butter was exported?

Comment on this

It is in the accounts.

Comment on this

One million or half a million?

Comment on this

Last year, no—nothing like it. We only started exporting butter about January and only the exports for January-March came into that account and in this year, prior to the Budget, in the month of April, the Minister had to export certain butter which will probably be paid for out of the Vote on Account. It is quite simple. The Minister can simply say to me now that for any butter the Butter Marketing Committee have to export the loss will be met by the Exchequer.

Comment on this

Of course, yes. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

He said that in the Budget statement.

Comment on this

Any Deputy could ask that simple question.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say what provision is being made in the Estimates for the charge?

Comment on this

There is enough left to pay for anything that is likely to arise before 31st March.

Comment on this

The Minister has not made an estimate. If there is any Supplementary Estimate required to support the export of butter, it will be forthcoming?

Comment on this

It will have to be brought in.

Comment on this

That is a very important step.

Comment on this

That was said on the Budget statement in answer to questions by the Deputy.

Comment on this

Not at all. These are two interesting facts that we have extracted: first, that we have too much wheat; and, secondly, that not 5d. a lb. but between 6½d. and 7d. is going on the price of butter, but for the reassurance of the industry, the Minister undertakes to subsidise the export of any surplus that may arise at the price level at present obtaining on the domestic market.

I want to revert for a moment to the speech of the Minister for Defence. He wound up by saying: "We did not know the ravages wrought by the previous Government." I think I am entitled to ask, what are these ravages? The total agricultural production of this country increased by over 32 per cent. from 1947 to 1955.

Comment on this

By how much did it decline from 1954?

Comment on this

What I am concerned about is——

Comment on this

Answer that.

Comment on this

——the situation obtaining at the latest date for which we can get the total gross agricultural production, which is the year 1955. The figure for 1956 has not yet been published by the Central Statistic Office. I have no doubt that it will show a further improvement on what we already know. It represents an increase of 32 per cent. in the gross production of the agricultural industry in this country, provided you take into account the changes in the numbers of stock on the land. I have read out for the House the highest figures over recorded in the history of this country for exports of cattle from Ireland in January, February and March of this year, with the trend, so far as we have the figures, appearing to be in the right direction for the months of April and May as well. We have more cattle on the land of Ireland at the present time than we ever had before in the history of the country.

Comment on this

Question?

Comment on this

I merely give the figures as published by the Central Statistics Office. According to those figures, more cattle were reared in 1955 than we ever had, and more sheep, I believe, than we ever had before in our history. We have twice as many pigs as we had in 1947 and the numbers are going up.

Comment on this

After ten years of famine war.

Comment on this

I am not casting any reflections on anyone. All I am saying to the Minister for Defence is that if these are evidence of ravage, then ravage has a meaning which I never attributed to it before. We had the biggest wheat crop in terms of yield last year than we ever had and we got as much beet from 340,000 acres last year as we got from 620,000 acres in 1948.

Comment on this

Yes, without any manure.

Comment on this

I am not talking in terms of abbis or anything else, but I am asking: is it evidence of ravage that we got more wheat than we ever got in any harvest before and from one-half the acreage of land? Nothing approaching that quantity was produced in Ireland before. We grew more barley in Ireland last year than at any time since it was first introduced into the country. Is that evidence of ravage? On 1st April this year, we had 1,300,000 acres of land rehabilitated, or in the process of rehabilitation, under the land rehabilitation process.

Comment on this

At what price?

Comment on this

Well, now, Deputy Allen thinks all that is wrong.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Allen object to that expenditure?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

Oh!

Comment on this

That is fair; I shall accept it. Everybody is entitled to his own view. I am for it, but I can understand Deputy Allen's view.

Comment on this

Half of it was wasted.

Comment on this

We rehabilitated that land; we had photographs of it in this Lobby and out at the R.D.S.; and it has been seen by people all over the country who are still applying in numbers far greater than the existing staff is able to cater for. I do not think that is evidence of ravage. It is work I am proud to have done.

Comment on this

Half of it was wasted.

Comment on this

I do not think that is evidence of ravage.

Comment on this

£500 an acre was spent on some of it.

Comment on this

I think it is evidence that we have something in this country on which money was well spent. We have provided £100,000 with which we built or reconstructed over the past eight years. We have carried rural electrification into almost every area in rural Ireland. Let us look at the record. I am looking at what we got for our money and which I am not sorry to have got. I think it represented good value for all that was spent. We have also built sufficient hospitals to accommodate every person who requires hospital accommodation at present. We have provided sanatoria which are adequate for every human creature who may require sanatorium treatment within 48 hours of his medical adviser prescribing it for him. We have carried the telephone service to every rural post office in Ireland so that there is no farmer in rural Ireland who has not got that amenity within his reach. Mind you, it has cost us £100,000,000 to provide the houses. It has cost us £12,000,000 to provide the telephone development and £34,000,000 to carry electricity to rural Ireland. We have spent £7,000,000 on bogs and as much more on purchasing a fleet of ships to sail the seas.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say who "we" are?

Comment on this

The successive Governments of Ireland.

Comment on this

The people of Ireland?

Comment on this

Yes. They spent it. I do not know that we have any reason to regret any of that expenditure. When we begin counting up our assets, I think we should remember that we have all that property now. We should remember that this country is that much better off that we have it. We also have the extra stocks on the land and extra fertility which we have been putting into the land in the shape of lime and fertilisers that we had not got some years ago.

Let us suspend for a moment the eternal wailing and moaning with which Fianna Fáil seek to justify their present policy. I know that economists can say with conviction that we are in a state of acute crisis. I would like to ask Deputies this question: is there any country in the world in which a man can have a better life than in Ireland? There are a lot of people in this country who believe that living in America is like living in the Saturday Evening Post, but it is not. It is only a very small minority of people in America who live a la Saturday Evening Post. Most of our people do not labour under such obvious illusions about Great Britain, but a lot of our people believe that to live in America is to live in comparably better conditions than those which obtain here. I do not think that is true. I think conditions are different. Some prefer them but a great many of us prefer what this country has to offer.

Could we not stop wailing and moaning and denigrating this country before the world? Is it not time for our people to show to the rest of the world that other countries are quite welcome to what they want but that we have what we want here and intend to keep it? I am sick listening to people bawling and moaning about emigration. There is no living creature who has to leave this country as an emigrant from want, certainly in rural Ireland. So far as I know, all the people who are going abroad from rural Ireland are going from good employment, but they are going because they believe they can earn more, in terms of money, in Great Britain or America, and that they can live in a freer and less supervised land, and that appears to attract them. They may be wrong. Those of us who elect to live here presumably think they are.

We have got to ask ourselves the question: If they choose to go has anyone a right to stop them? I do not think anybody has that right. I think the most sacred liberty our people have, and must retain, is to go where their hearts listeth. So long as this is a free country some of our people will choose to test their fortunes in the wide world and others will elect to stay at home.

I do not believe there is any human creature in rural Ireland who is constrained by want to emigrate from this country. I believe there are hundreds who elect to go because they would rather earn £20 a week in London, Birmingham or Manchester than £6 or £7 a week in their own town. I am not at all sure that, when all the bills are paid, they are very much better off on the high wages they get in England. However, they think they are. They are entitled to live their lives the way they want to live them, not the way I think it is good for them to live them. This House should never have the power to abridge that freedom. Once that freedom is taken from our people, they are no better than slaves in prison camps.

I believe that at the present moment this country is one of the best countries in the world to live in. I believe we should be proud of it. I think we have to face the fact, however—and the sooner we do it, the better for everybody—that we will never be rich in this country. If we fix our eyes on the far horizon of material wealth, such as is displayed in Great Britain and the United States of America, we are chasing chimeras. So far as this country is concerned, we are primarily an agricultural economy whose material resources consist of 12,000,000 acres of arable land and the people who live on it. That will never provide in terms of money and goods the same standard of living as is available in great industrial economies such as Germany, Great Britain and the United States of America. If we make up our minds to that and adjust ourselves to the fact, I believe it is possible to get for our people in this country a better living than is obtainable in any other country in the world. If we make it our heart's desire to emulate in Ireland what they have in Birmingham, Pittsburgh and the Ruhr, we will never know peace and contentment in Ireland.

I believe that our policy of establishing stability and developing our resources was yielding an ever-growing result. I saw around me in my own town and in other towns of Ireland a standard of living being enjoyed by the small farmers of Ireland that certainly my father never hoped to see. I rejoice that the people in one short lifetime were tenants at will in mud cabins, the most of which were roofed in thatch, and came to the market towns in their bare feet, while their children are now living in security on their own land, not infrequently driving a car and many of them a tractor, wearing clothes and enjoying a standard of living comparable with that enjoyed by any rural community in the world. I heard conditions here compared with those in Denmark. I rejoice that our people value correctly freedom, the right to leisure and the right to labour hard, in truer proportions than many Continental peoples seem to do.

I wholeheartedly agree that the whole future of this country depends on increased production for export and that the maintenance of the kind of standard of living for our people that I want, and which I believe they can enjoy, ultimately depends on our capacity to get from the land the maximum of which it is capable of yielding. The whole purpose of the policy of our Government was to bring within the reach of the farmers of this country the means to get from the land of Ireland the best living it was capable of yielding for themselves, their wives and their families, in the certain knowledge that, if they did that, it would be the wisest thing they could do for the nation as a whole.

I apprehend that the departure embarked upon by the present Fianna Fáil Government is throwing all that stability away by inviting sections of our people to bear wholly disproportionate sacrifices for a purely economic theory which has no intrinsic value except as a means of achieving the balance of payments that we all desire, and putting the whole programme we had in mind in jeopardy. I am afraid of the consequences of that. Let us be clear on this. On the heads of Fianna Fáil be it. I do not think the people knew what Fianna Fáil intended to do. I think Fianna Fáil is entitled to say, "You told them and they did not believe you." I agree that is true —I admit that. I do not think they wanted to believe it. I do not think they could persuade themselves that any Party professing to be a national Party in this country could do to our people what Fianna Fáil are doing in this Budget. They were wrong. Their most treasured right in the sphere of politics is their right to do wrong in politics, but it is a right which could be purchased at a terrible price if our people elected to exercise it.

I think in this Budget they are only paying the first small instalment in the debt they contracted by electing Fianna Fáil with a clear majority in this Parliament. They have got the majority; they have got the assurance that no attempt by anybody to set that authority aside, except by the will of this Oireachtas, will receive support from any responsible Deputy. I think they are using their authority like madmen and I deplore the catastrophe it will bring upon our people.

Comment on this

I wonder where the boys found the neck. There is no doubt but that they have neck. On the last three attempts they made to get a loan, they were refused. That was the total of their credit. Last night, I heard a lot about the wisdom of the prize bonds scheme. The total amount of credit that Deputy J. A. Costello, Deputy Sweetman, Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy Dillon and the whole bunch of them together could get from the Irish people on the prize bonds was £200,000; but, as soon as they were going, the people came in and subscribed up to £5,000,000. There is their total credit for you. If the people of this country knew what those creatures had done, they would take them out and hang them and, in my opinion, hanging would be too good for them——

Comment on this

Would you be the hangman?

Comment on this

I would not mind the hanging, so long as they did not cut our throats——

Comment on this

There is "Jamesie" again.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not refer to a member of the House in that manner.

Comment on this

Deputy James Dillon. When that crowd were leaving office in 1952 I asked the then Minister for Finance a question. I asked him if he would state the total amount payable and paid in interest and sinking funds in the financial years 1947-48 and 1952-53. The answer was that there was payable in 1947-48 for interest £3,095,000 a year and for sinking fund £1,128,000. On the day of the election there was payable for interest £7,300,000 and for sinking fund £2,725,000, a total of £10,080,000 a year or over £6,000,000 a year of an increased dead-weight debt to be paid by the people of this country because the boys were in office for three years.

To-day I asked a question of the Minister for Finance because I was curious about the present position. Here is the answer: payable for interest, £10,188,964 and for sinking fund, £5,219,529, a total of £15,408,493. It was £4,000,000 for interest and sinking fund on the day the Irish people had the misfortune to throw that mixum-gatherum gang into office. They have to pay now for their foolishness a sum of £15,000,000 a year, a dead-weight debt that must be paid before there is a penny for anything else. Eleven million pounds a year those heroes have cost this nation, to be found by taxation out of the poor man's pint and the poor man's bread and butter.

Those are the facts. Will any Deputy over there contradict them? Only one of them. I noticed that Deputy M. J. O'Higgins, during his speech last night, showed great fondness for quotations. But he stopped at March, 1956. Apparently there was a blank in the ammunition bag between March, 1956 and March, 1957. I have no delusions whatever. I told the people no lies. I told the people that the only reason that gang were going was because they could not get, beg borrow or steal, one bob more to keep them there. That was proved by the way the prize bonds were received. People in this country would not subscribe to them, would not give them a bob for anything.

Look at the tale they are leaving after them. I will give it as closely as I can. I should like to quote from the Official Report of May 7th last. During his statement on that day, the Minister for Local Government said:—

"There was, however, another factor contributing to the decline in activity as shown in the figures for 1st April last and that was the hold up, for financial reasons, of the commencement of new works between last summer and the spring of this year. That has had the effect, not so much of considerably reducing the number of dwellings completed in 1956-57, as of diminishing those in progress and those ready to be undertaken now. This in turn will probably have the effect of reducing the number of dwellings which we may expect to have completed in the present financial year."

Later the Minister said:—

"Since assuming office, I have recommended the issue of £1,340,000 to liquidate the obligations of local authorities outside the Cities of Dublin and Cork, to banks, to contractors and to persons awaiting payment of approved grants and advances for private housing."

And those gentlemen informed us yesterday that they left a clean sheet behind them. That is only one of the little tales they left after them. We know what happened as a result: private individuals owed money to the contractors who built the houses, the contractors owed it to the builders providers, the builders providers owed to the banks, and no credit was available. That was the mess those bucks left after them. There was in addition to that, a sum of £2,000,000 due on sanitary services.

Later in his speech on the Estimate, the Minister for Local Government said:—

"The outstanding liabilities of the Road Fund at 31st March, 1957, in respect of road maintenance and improvement grants and other liabilities, amounted to £4,212,000."

Be adding them up, boys, if you want to know why we had to withdraw the subsidies from bread and butter. These are all part of the little tale left behind. The Minister later said:—

"Payments in respect of the existing liabilities of the Road Fund to road authorities will be the first charge. These amount to approximately £2,600,000."

Of course the local authorities had to go in and borrow in the ratepayers' names and pay 5½ per cent. interest for the money. This is only some of the tale left behind; I am dealing with only one Department. The Minister's predecessor walked out of office leaving over £6,000,000 due to contractors, to private individuals and to local authorities. It is no wonder the incoming Minister did not know where he stood until the bills came in.

I have another little docket here. I heard Deputy Dillon speak about wheat. I wonder is this little docket, dated October 5th, 1956, yet paid: "Negotiations are at present on the point of completion for the purchase by the Éire Government of 100,000 tons of Canadian wheat"—on three months' tick.

Comment on this

Where does that quotation come from?

Comment on this

That was from the Corn Exchange News of the 4th October, 1956.

Comment on this

That is the chaff.

Comment on this

Well, it has won a general election and two bye-elections. I should like to hear the Minister for Finance, when he is concluding, say whether the £3,500,000 has yet been paid to the Canadian Government for that wheat.

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

I suggest the Minister should find out. He might have to put another penny on the pint for it.

Comment on this

Jaffa oranges.

Comment on this

It should be the Minister's business to find out.

Comment on this

I could not pay it.

Comment on this

That was three months' "tick", to bring over the Canadian wheat. The Deputy over there looks pretty well for a hungry fellow.

Comment on this

I got it in time—which you did not.

Comment on this

Those are the bills which the Minister has to pay. It is no wonder he said he would wait a while until they were all in. Has he found out that one and, if he has not, I might suggest a few more to him. I might suggest he inquire of the Indian Bank how much is due for the tea which was ordered there last October. I am creditably informed that there is £2,000,000 due to the Indian Bank for tea. I want to know if that has been paid. Those are the items which go to make up the reason why we have to come in here to clean up the mess and put extra taxation on the unfortunate people of this country. It is just as well to be clear about it. I hope there is somebody taking all that down, who can add them up in a minute.

Comment on this

He never knew it until the Deputy told him.

Comment on this