We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 5—General (Resumed).

Contributions 132–283 of 283. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

I have here a little docket which was circulating during the election campaign. It came into my hands from a widow, with one child, who came to me seven or eight days ago. She was not one of the lucky ones who get the increase to make up for the increased cost of bread and butter, or an increase in respect of her child. She admitted that she had voted for Fianna Fáil, as she was entitled to do, but she drew particular attention to what was at the bottom of the card asking for her support for the two candidates in her constituency: "Keep this card; you may need our help." She does need it now. She needs the help of the Fianna Fáil Deputies in Cork to oppose the increased burden on her for bread and butter for herself and her one son. She wants fair play and Fianna Fáil said they would give it.

A short time ago, the same members—they thought they were right— decided by their votes to oppose giving an increase to road workers in Cork County. What is the position now? Are we still to be told that the people are in the same position, that they have no reason to complain? Fianna Fáil cannot have it every way. While we are prepared to accept that the ultimate hope of Fianna Fáil, by their policy, is to give prosperity to the country, we consider they are going about it the wrong way.

Comment on this

Follow the Moscow line.

Comment on this

Whether Deputy O'Malley ever travelled to Moscow or New York is immaterial to me.

Comment on this

Deputies MacEntee and Boland did.

Comment on this

I am more interested in the future of our people than in past history. I am not worried whether the Minister or Deputy O'Malley may get hot under the collar.

Comment on this

I will not take any of the Deputy's insinuations.

Comment on this

I asked a simple question and I owe the Minister no apology. I apologised to the Chair, and I have no more interest in the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy should shut up, so.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Malley is repeatedly interrupting, notwithstanding the cautions I have given him. I shall not repeat my warning.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce said last week, when speaking in this important debate, they were sorry for some of the hardships already imposed, and perhaps more that are to come. That means that the people are still unaware of what may be in store for them. The Government could not expect co-operation from an Opposition when such an important factor as a reduction in the cost of living is not put into operation but when, instead, a vicious increase in the vitally important items of food, such as bread and butter, is placed on the shoulders of the people. I do not mind what concessions they may wish to give to the man with the £1,300 motor car; I do not mind whether or not they thought it wise to remove the levies on television sets— that is their business—but I do not agree with the removal of the food subsidies coupled with the suggestions to the trade union movement that it should not look for an increase.

In conclusion, I want to draw attention to the statement made by the Minister for Lands on Tuesday, January 29th, 1957, as published in the Irish Press. Deputy Childers, as he then was, speaking at a Fianna Fáil cumann meeting in Wicklow said—I would like to add this quotation because I know we shall not get it from Deputy O'Malley:—

"It was not popular to tell the people that if they looked for as near an English standard of living as they could get, more and more of their wages would be spent on imported materials and more and more goods must be exported or more and more barley and wheat produced at home to pay for them."

What was wrong with that? What is wrong with trying to build up a better economy to give the people a higher standard of living? Of course the Government Party complains about emigration, and one of the problems in connection with emigration, whether we like it or not, is the question of the standard of living. Is there anything wrong in suggesting that people here should get a nearer approach to the higher standard of living in operation in other countries? Is there anything wrong in suggesting that in order to achieve that, greater production should be the aim?

Comment on this

We all agree with that.

Comment on this

I am asking the Minister——

Comment on this

Is that not what the Minister for Lands pointed out there?

Comment on this

No, he did not; he simply stated——

Comment on this

Go on.

Comment on this

I will go on when it suits the Chair. I am not a Fianna Fáil back bencher. The Minister for Lands said it was not popular to tell the people that if they looked for a standard of living as near to the English standard as they could get, more and more of their wages would have to be sent abroad to enable them to enjoy some of the comforts and luxuries that exist elsewhere unless——

Comment on this

Go on.

Comment on this

——we can have increased productivity in this country. As I said before, exports have increased and this is shown principally by the big increase in the volume of cattle exported this year. The adverse trade balance is coming into line and that was the policy of the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this

That was the policy that put them where they are.

Comment on this

I do not mind the ignorance of the fellow over there. That was a situation which was satisfactory.

Comment on this

I shall ignore the reference to a Deputy in the terms "the fellow over there." I shall not even ask that it be withdrawn.

Comment on this

Coming to the final point, in regard to the balancing of the Budget, on what basis do we balance the Budget? If a man who has a wife and family wants to balance his budget at the end of the financial year, he counts his cash and his bills, but does he take into consideration what capital assets he has in the way of stocks? We were told that we had an adverse balance at the end of the last financial year; we were told by Fianna Fáil that the country was near bankruptcy, but if we combine the assets at that time with the returns that were not brought into account by the end of the financial year, but had, of necessity, through being store cattle, to be brought into the new account, we see much of the hypocrisy of balancing the Budget. It is in itself just a cute way used by people outside the House, certain sections of whom have been telling us for years back: "Hope for little because you will get little. Do not expect too much because much must be reserved for those who have much."

Comment on this

A brilliant discourse

Comment on this

Listening to the long speech made by Deputy Desmond one would despair of this country's future. I think one of the reasons why the Coalition Government was defeated in the last election was that the people believed the country had reached the stage when a little reality should enter into political life. To use a hackneyed expression they were about fed up with people playing to the gallery and with the unreal approaches being made, and with a good deal of the fiddling with our whole economy. They simply said: "Give us something real for a change. We want a Government that will take action," or in other words, "let honesty prevail".

I listened attentively to Deputy Desmond for the last hour and I challenge anybody in the House to point out where he made a single constructive suggestion at a time when this country is undergoing the greatest crisis it has ever experienced. That type of speech, which largely consists of criticism of the other fellow and nothing else, might be all very well——

Comment on this

Last year.

Comment on this

——at a time when the country was overflowing with milk and honey——

Comment on this

This time 12 months.

Comment on this

——but at a time when the people have handed over this country to the strongest Government that was ever elected for the sole purpose of taking the action necessary to put the country into a proper condition——

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

If Deputy Desmond had paused for one moment and reflected on the state of the country at the time it was handed over to a strong Fianna Fáil Government, it would, of course, have completely spoiled the background of all he was trying to say.

I do not propose to be led by him to follow the same line, repeating promises made and not kept by members of this House or Governments or Parties. It should suffice for me to remind the Labour Deputies that they as a Party were the one section who definitely promised, by word and advertisement, written and spoken, that they stood for the reduction of the cost of living by means of subsidies, prior to their coming into office in the Coalition Government on the last occasion. Why should people who so utterly dishonoured their pledge to the people on that occasion, take up the time of the House for an hour to-day alleging that Fianna Fáil have dishonoured promises to the people on this occasion?

I do not want to go on quoting everything said by Labour Deputies here over a number of years. I do not think it gets us anywhere when one Deputy quotes what another has said and points out how he dishonoured his pledge. The policy of the Labour Deputies is to criticise the people on this side of the House. If it is constructive criticism it may be useful, but if it is criticism just of the type in which Deputy Desmond has indulged for the last hour, it leads only to complete frustration in the minds of the people, who over the last two and a half years have lost completely their confidence in the public representatives of this country.

When these subsidies were introduced first, what was the attitude of the Labour Party? What was their attitude towards the subsidies, about which so many crocodile tears have been shed here within the last week? I take the Leader of that Party, Deputy Norton, and quote what he said on the introduction of subsidies on the first occasion. It is given in Volume 108, column 435, of the Official Report, dated 15th October, 1947:—

"The highlight of the documents put before us is, I take it, the subsidies to reduce the prices of tea, bread and butter."

This was the first introduction of the subsidies, about which we hear so much now. He continued:—

"I think these are sham reductions."

These are the sham reductions we are now crying about. He continued:—

"I do not think they make any perceptible contribution to relieving the plight of the ordinary working people to-day and they make a less perceptible contribution in the circumstances in which they are offered. ... The Government, in this emergency Budget, this crisis Budget, this Budget to relieve the small man of his difficulties, will give him 3/10½ a week in the form of reduction in the prices of tea, sugar and bread and will take back 4/1 if he consumes a pint of beer per day and smokes a packet of cigarettes each day."

Those are the people who have made it plain to everybody that they come in here merely to criticise what the other fellow does, irrespective of whether it is right or not. I do not like to interrupt any Deputy, but I found it difficult to restrain myself when I listened to the hour-and-a-quarter dirge from Deputy Desmond in regard to the subsidies.

I do not think we shall convince the people that we are in earnest about anything, if one Government starts quoting what another did. If we on this side of the House in our Budget produce the best possible results, the Labour Deputies and the others opposite seem to regard it as their function to criticise it.

Deputy Desmond referred to my speech on the Budget last year. I would make the same speech to-day. I said then that, if the Budget held out hopes of an expanding economy, to relieve unemployment and provide a better future, I would say it was a good Budget, irrespective of what hardships it might mean. I say the same thing about the Budget to-day. After 35 years of native Government, what have we to show to the rest of the world? An alarming decline in population, as revealed by the last Census, the greatest unemployment problem of any country in the world to-day, complete dwindling of our external assets—

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this

——absolutely no hope for the future——

Comment on this

Read this morning's Irish Press.

Comment on this

That is the position in which we find ourselves. I shall not go round all the various speeches, but I shall take that of the leader of the Opposition and refer to one statement he made, which every Deputy knows was received very cynically by the country. He said: "We handed you over a clean slate." His speech was less critical than most of those made from the same side of the House. He at least made an attempt to be realistic and he did not deal with trivial, petty matters for the purpose of criticism of his opponent. He said: "We handed you over a clean slate."

Comment on this

That is proved in this morning's Irish Press.

Comment on this

He handed over 80,000 unemployed.

Comment on this

You had 87,000 in March, 1952.

Comment on this

He handed over a crisis such as this country has not experienced since it first got native Government 35 years ago. He handed over a Budget which failed to balance to the tune of £8,000,000, and no one on that side of the House has even attempted to explain where the £8,000,000 could be found.

All who spoke seriously—I do not think Deputy Desmond spoke seriously, as he did not agree with the idea of a balanced Budget—and every member of the Fine Gael Front Bench, including the former Taoiseach himself, agreed with the principle of a balanced Budget. They are now at one with those of us who say our economy must be built on a strong foundation and that such a strong foundation can spring only from the principle of a balanced Budget.

Let us come together and decide that, once and for all, however hurtful it may be to anyone at the moment, we shall make one serious attempt to put the country on its feet, to expand the economy, to create employment, to build up the nation to what it should be and what it was intended to be when people gave their lives for it. Let us not come in with petty political bickering, to spend days and weeks talking about petty things in which above all things the Labour Party should not indulge because if we are to develop this country, if employment is to be increased, if our economy is to be expanded, if our standard of living is to be maintained and improved, it will not be done by throwing out sops to the people one after another. It can be done only by honest endeavour, by getting the people to realise that by their work alone can a nation be built.

I remember a very biassed, pro-British, series of textbooks and most members of the House remember it too, the Cunningham and MacArthur Oxford series, which people were compelled to use as textbooks at one time. One of these texts dealt with the industrial development of England. In the very opening page it said that not in a country's resources alone can greatness be achieved for a nation; it is only in the ability of its manpower to exploit those resources that greatness can be achieved. However biassed the series may have been, nobody could refute the good, sound logic of that statement of fact.

We are teaching our people to believe that prosperity can be gained in some peculiar manner without extra work, endeavour or attempt on their part. Are we to go on, one year after another, telling them that we can increase social services, that we can give them doles and sops just to please them, for political purposes alone, without making any serious attempt really to develop the resources of the nation and give the people a chance to do what I believe they should and can do—to endeavour by their own skill and strength and work to put the country on its feet and create the prosperous State, which we are entitled to have equally with any of the other small States such as Denmark, Belgium, or Luxembourg?

I do not think that anybody on the other side of the House would disagree with one single word of what I say but when a Budget like this is introduced they see an opportunity and it is very difficult to let it pass. But, remember the people have become very, very intelligent and they resent people who overplay their hand when an opportunity presents itself. I would advise the Opposition not to overplay their hand on this occasion. We must let an air of reality permeate the House and I say, in all earnestness, that this is the first really non-political Budget that we have had in this country for a long time. The people opposite who talked so much about a national Government when they saw that Coalitions were discredited and forsaken by the people should realise that if a national Government were in power here to-day all that they could do is exactly what Fianna Fáil have done on this occasion. They have done what is honest, wise and prudent in the best interests of the future outlook, progress and development of this little nation.

Somebody had to start some time. We could not go on as we were. The people realised that and expected a severe Budget on this occasion. There is no doabt about that. They realised that we could not go on increasing social services, making available further easy payments which could be procured without work or endeavour, physical or mental, on their part. While our social services leave much to be desired, they are already far in advance of our national income.

Comment on this

The Deputy would like to have it both ways.

Comment on this

No. I want no ambiguity about what I am saying. What I say is unequivocal, that our social services leave much to be desired but, as they stand to-day and as they are costing the country, they are far in advance of our ability to pay for them. Let us begin at the beginning and lift up the standard of the people first and social services will more easily follow because nothing succeeds like success. Let us not put the cart before the horse. I have heard people crying about the price of the loaf. What does it matter to a housewife whether a loaf is 1/– or 9d. if her husband is unemployed? What does it matter whether a loaf is 10d. or 1/6 if there is not a penny in the house to buy bread? What is to be done with the almost 100,000 unemployed that have been in this country over the past few years? Are they to be told that money can be brought out of the clouds?

Comment on this

You found it for the master bakers.

Comment on this

Will you tell them that money can be produced out of a hat? Where is the good in talking nonsense? Deputy O'Sullivan and every other Deputy realise as well as or better than I do that an honest approach has to be made, that we cannot go on forever telling the people that they can have things without paying for them, that they can have wealth and a higher standard of living without working, without an extra effort, without increased production. The most elementary economist in the world knows that the position in which we were fiddling—I use the word deliberately—would land us eventually in complete ruin. Now that a serious attempt has been made, however hurtful it may be, I do not blame the Opposition for trying to exploit it but I say: "Do not overplay your hand." We did not make any promises in the election.

Comment on this

Oh.

Comment on this

Nor did the people accept us as having made any promises. The one thing with which the people became completely disgusted was this business of giving a little sop here and a little sop there, increasing some little social service, putting a halfpenny on something to pay a little extra. They have come to realise that the expanding economy for which this country is crying out could not derive from such action.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil were past masters at that, starting from free beef.

Comment on this

The people have come to realise that prosperity is not brought about as a result of the sops that they have been taught to expect from weak Governments and any position in which we find ourselves to-day is the result of weak government.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! That is the truest thing the Deputy ever said.

Comment on this

I suppose that no country, with the single exception of France, ever experienced such weak government as this country did during the two terms of office of the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil were strong for 16 years.

Comment on this

And we came back stronger.

Comment on this

We did a job for 16 years of which we can be justly proud.

Comment on this

You left agriculture in the mire.

Comment on this

You had to come back to our policy anyhow.

Comment on this

The Opposition had to be converted to wheat.

Comment on this

How do you like the present price—the present increase?

Comment on this

Deputy Egan was talking all over North Offaly about the increased price he would give to wheat.

Comment on this

I did not say anything about an increased price.

Comment on this

Then all the people around Edenderry who told me were wrong.

Comment on this

The wheat and the milk will get you.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Sweetman not remember what he promised in Rhode about turf development? There was no reporter present. He would have been more careful if there had been.

Comment on this

The Deputy was there listening to me. He is better than a reporter.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Brennan is in possession. These interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

The people in this House need not get too worried about the situation. We will take what we think is the proper action to develop this country, in a really genuine and sincere manner. We have the important problem before us of increasing production, of giving employment to our people, of stemming the tide of emigration and getting the people to realise there is no easy road to national progress. I do not think that all the patter which has issued from the other side of the House in relation to this Budget will ever again lead the people to believe there is any easy road to better times—as the Labour Party pamphlet put it before the 1954 election: "Better times and lower taxes." This is the type of thing which creates a sense of unreality in the minds of the people.

For the first time in years, we have had a Budget which is not in any way designed or framed to meet political exigencies. It is the first non-political Budget we have had since 1952. It is the first really serious attempt that has been made to take cognisance of the serious situation in which we live and if any man who has spoken attempted to explain where we can get £8,000,000 to balance the Budget, then he would have made a really serious contribution to the debate.

Deputy Desmond believes in going on in the old humdrum manner and that nobody need make any effort at all. That was the only inference I could draw from Deputy Desmond's speech, although I do give the Deputy the credit of being threatened with intelligence. Earlier, I quoted Deputy Norton's condemnation of subsidies on the first occasion they were brought in here. Now it is the worst thing in the world to remove them, the people have become so accustomed to them.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton related that to the taxes imposed in the same Supplementary Budget.

Comment on this

I do not care; the position is exactly the same. If it was bad to put them on then, it cannot be bad to take them off. One cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

You are trying to have it all the one way.

Comment on this

If there was one thing demonstrated in the political life of this country during the past few years it was that the people have got disgusted with this playing to the gallery. The former Minister for Defence——

Comment on this

The Deputy has got a hard neck.

Comment on this

——was an adept at trying to please everyone all the time. I could quote a few examples of that.

Comment on this

Trot them out.

Comment on this

I would love to hear them.

Comment on this

I am talking about the former Minister for Defence. The former Minister for Finance became realistic when he became Minister. Before he became Minister, he had the panacea for all our evils, just like the Labour people. When he found himself faced with hard facts, he had to warn the people that they could not go on spending as they were spending. People, he said, could not expect to get easy money every day for doing nothing. The former Minister for Defence could go to a by-election meeting in Limerick and tell the people that he was bringing a Bill that would please everybody.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy producing it now?

Comment on this

He did not produce it anyway. It was part of the old game of attempting to please everyone. It was absolutely playing to the gallery and led us into the economic crisis in which we find ourselves to-day. The former Taoiseach comes along to say: "We handed you over a clean slate"—with 80,000 unemployed, a deficit of £8,000,000, and the greatest record of emigration the country has ever experienced.

Comment on this

Nonsense!

Comment on this

No wonder the people decided to put back a strong Fianna Fáil Government. However cynical the Opposition may be, it will not deter us from going forward with the knowledge that this Budget lays the foundation for an expanding economy, more employment and a better standard of living, together with what naturally must flow from that result, a curbing of the tide of emigration.

Comment on this

That is a paraphrase of my statement.

Comment on this

I repeat what I said last year—Deputy Desmond did me the honour of quoting me—that honesty will prevail and again to-day I say that we have a really honest Budget, a Budget which faces up to the facts as we found them. It is a Budget which is imposed because of the record of the past two and a half years.

Comment on this

Bosh!

Comment on this

It is imposed by the economic crisis in which we find ourselves to-day. It is an honest Budget and I conclude by saying again that honesty will prevail.

Comment on this

Give the people a chance.

Comment on this

No, give the Government a chance.

Comment on this

We do not want any quarter from the Opposition and we do not expect it.

Comment on this

I believe this is the sixth day of this debate. I notice Deputy J. Brennan is leaving the House, but I hope he will not go for a moment. It will do him all the good in the world to listen to me. I have never heard such a flow of frothy nonsense as his speech. The backbenchers of the Fianna Fáil Party who are compelled to speak here have not one word to say about what the results of this Budget will be for the people throughout the country. Here is what this Budget means: the 10-stone bag of flour gone up from £2 to £3 12s. 6d., an increase of £1 2s. 6d. the loaf of bread gone from 9d. to 1/1, an increase of 4d.; the lb. of butter gone from 3/9 to 4/4, an increase of 7d.; cigarettes increased in price from 2/10 a packet of 20 to 3/–, an increase of 2d. a packet; and an increase of 6d. per gallon on petrol. How about what Deputy Killilea used to refer to as the poor man's pint? That has gone up by one penny.

In the light of these facts, how can the speeches made by Fianna Fáil Deputies be anything other than nonsense of the worst type? They tell us they had to put the country on its feet. Instead, they have put the workers of this country on their backs, where they will remain until this Government goes out. We heard Deputy J. Brennan say: "We did not make any promises." Has he not got a "neck" for anything? In a speech in Waterford on 28th February, a few days before the election, what did the Tánaiste say? I presume he was speaking for Deputy J. Brennan, for the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Beegan, and presumably for Deputy Killilea. He said: "The present leaders are threatening the country with all sorts of unpleasant things if Fianna Fáil become the Government, such as compulsory tillage, wage controls, cuts in Civil Service salaries, higher food prices and a lot more besides. The Fianna Fáil Government do not intend to do any of these things because we do not believe in them. How more definite can we make our denials of those stupid allegations?"

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,

Comment on this

How, after that statement by the Tánaiste on the eve of the election, can Deputy J. Brennan stand up and say: "We made no promises?" Surely if the Tánaiste made that statement on the eve of the election, he cannot now justify the increase in the prices of all these commodities. This Budget has become known throughout the country as Ryan's Blister. That is what this Budget is called and, mind you, no man can put on a more severe blister than can a doctor. He certainly succeeded this time. Remember he is a great man for the blisters; remember that while he was in charge of Agriculture in days gone by, he put on more blisters than that.

Comment on this

We are prepared to discuss the economic war at any time.

Comment on this

Of course, Deputies who stand up now and attempt to defend this Budget do not approach the real issues. They cannot approach them. I think it was Deputy Gallagher who spoke about how the newspapers received it. Does he know what the local papers wrote about it? He said that the papers regarded it as a great Budget, a Budget that would put the country on its feet. I have here a quotation from the Sunday Press of May 12th, a brazen one, I may say. It quotes Professor Joseph Johnston, a Senior Fellow of Dublin University, as saying it was right to do away with the food subsidies. Not alone that, but another gentleman quoted, Dr. Louis Smith, said also it was right to do away with the subsidies. Last came Joe McGrath. He said it was right to do away with the subsidies. What about the man down the country? I happen to have here a copy of a well-known paper in the West of Ireland— the Tuam Herald for May 18th. It says that the unemployed are facing starvation. Here is what the Tuam Herald has to say on the Budget:—

"‘There is nothing but starvation facing the unemployed in this town unless something is done,' declared Mr. Mio Campbell at Tuam Trades Council meeting on Monday night, when he condemned the increases in the price of bread and butter resulting from the withdrawal of the subsidies under the Budget."

He was referring to the town of Tuam.

Comment on this

I did not know there were any unemployed in Tuam after what Deputy Donnellan did for them.

Comment on this

The report goes on to say that Mr. Campbell condemned the increases in the prices of butter and bread. He forecast starvation and nothing else.

Comment on this

A Coalition spokesman.

Comment on this

It was what Joe McGrath said that the Sunday Press quoted.

Comment on this

What did Joe Blowick say?

Comment on this

Joe Blowick is able to give the right answer.

Comment on this

It is what the workers said I am interested in. Mr. Campbell continued:—

"It is the duty of this council to bring up this matter of the hardships imposed on the working classes by this Budget that has been brought in. There is 4d. extra for the loaf and 5d. for the lb. of butter. It is bad enough on the working man, but what about the unemployed? There is nothing facing them but starvation."

The poor man thought there was an increase of only 5d. on the lb. of butter—he forgot about the 2d. extra for storage. He said the Budget was unbearable for the working classes. Just imagine that—it was unbearable for them.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this

What is the point of order?

Comment on this

What has the opinion of a member of a trades council reported in this Herald, as Deputy Donnellan says, to do with the proceedings in this House on the Budget?

Comment on this

What about the question of starvation?

Comment on this

I have already been told to restrain myself and to cease quoting.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have to be asked again.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not make another speech at this stage.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle told me that I was not allowed to quote indiscriminately from every newspaper in the State.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not debate the Ceann Comhairle's ruling at this stage. Deputy Donnellan is in possession and he is in order in quoting the newspaper from which he is quoting.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Malley was quoting tripe.

Comment on this

The Giles cartoon.

Comment on this

Mr. Campbell continued:—

"...it was unbearable for them as union officials to have to listen to these men who were unemployed and did not know what to do.

All they can do is look to somebody for the fare to England."

Comment on this

There was no use looking in February and March.

Comment on this

Mr. Campbell went on:—

"... and this Budget will get rid of all the young boys and girls in this country at a very fast pace."

Comment on this

You got rid of 48,000.

Comment on this

They will all be gone, if they can get the fare. That is the position in Deputy Killilea's and my constituency in north Galway. That is the real situation and then you have Deputies like Deputies Brennan and Gallagher saying they have put the country on its feet and that this is an honest Budget. What about the hunger marchers I saw last night? Shortly they will be on their feet.

Comment on this

The organised hunger marchers.

Comment on this

You will have more going on hunger strike.

Comment on this

There are 20,000 less since you went.

Comment on this

Many more will be compelled to go on hunger strike. I know at least 300 families in Tuam who will starve on account of this Budget, and, if you think that is wrong, you can ask Deputy Killilea and he will tell you. It is no laughing matter at all for the Fianna Fáil people. There will be a day of reckoning.

Comment on this

And Galway will win the All-Ireland, and they all starving.

Comment on this

We breed them good, boy.

Comment on this

And there are 300 starving in Tuam.

Comment on this

You will not kill the Galways fellows as easily as that.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil's attitude in trying to defend this Budget is to say they have been only two months in office but if they do as much damage in the next two months as they did in the past two months, what will be done at all? Their attitude is: Hit me now with a child in my arms. They do not realise that there are people starving in the country. I think it was in the Sunday Press last Sunday that the Tánaiste said nobody would sabotage this country as they were a strong Government. Why should the worker look for an increase in wages? He should not do it and he would sabotage this country if he did.

I say the workers of this country must look for an increase in wages and they must get an increase in wages; otherwise they will starve. I know there are quite a lot of people in the Fianna Fáil Party who do not mind whether they do or not. All they care about is being on the Government side of the House. I remember the Tánaiste sitting in the Front Bench and when asked what suggestions they had to offer, he told the inter-Party Government it was their job.

Comment on this

You did not do the job.

Comment on this

We are saying it is for you to do the job, if you are able.

Comment on this

You drove all the men out of the country.

Comment on this

If they can get their fare to England, they will leave the town of Tuam.

Comment on this

And Galway is going to America.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Was the Deputy not the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance in the previous Government?

Comment on this

Listen——

Comment on this
Major de Valera

This is what you get from an ex-Parliamentary Secretary. This is what Deputy Sweetman had for his Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that his standard is higher?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is higher than that.

Comment on this

You did not even get a Parliamentary Secretaryship.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is the National Parliament and not the crossroads. Deputies must allow the Deputy in possession to make his speech.

Comment on this

They will say they had to do this thing; that they had to put the tax on the bread and butter. I think they were only a few days in office when they remitted certain levies imposed by the inter-Party Government which were bringing in less than £5,000,000 a year. These were levies imposed upon certain luxury articles such as television sets and certain types of motor cars and imports of that description that the people could well do without. The big industrialists had got their grip and the attempt was made to tax the necessaries of life for the starving sections of our people.

Comment on this

It is not correct to say that we put a tax on butter or bread. We did not. That was suggested by Deputy Donnellan.

Comment on this

Two and two do not make five.

Comment on this

When Deputy Blowick was Minister for Lands, all the poor forestry workers in Tipperary were on the breadline.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy tell us that bread and butter have not gone up in price at all?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Donnellan.

Comment on this

I would ask the Government to reconsider the Budget and withdraw it. They ought to realise they have done wrong and that they have put the poorer sections of our community in the position that, if they can get the price of a ticket, they will emigrate. There is no greater example of that than the town of Tuam at the moment. How can any Minister of any Government say that the people were too well off last year? They were not. The worker was barely able to make ends meet last year.

Comment on this

There were 90,000 unemployed. That is as much as the Deputy was able to do.

Comment on this

You left ghost towns after you.

Comment on this

What is to happen this year with the increase in the price of flour, butter, tobacco, cigarettes and all these other commodities which are necessaries of life?

Comment on this

What about tea?

Comment on this

That interruption did not come from Tuam.

Comment on this

I know it did not; it would be far from either myself or my colleague from Tuam to interrupt. I would ask the Government to with-draw this Budget; or otherwise there will definitely be trouble in this country. Let Fianna Fáil think what they like with their big majority. The people of this country, the workers and the producers, are not going to be hounded down in that despicable way. They must get an opportunity to live. I appeal to the Government to reconsider this Budget. The extra 1/– for the old age pension or for children's allowances is only fun—they cannot be serious in giving it. Surely that is only pulling the wool over the eyes of the people, trying to pretend that they are compensating them for the money being taken from them. They are doing no such thing.

I believe that, instead of putting the country on its feet, you are putting the country and its people on their backs. You will have more unemployment in this country or there will be more emigration. The only hope for the country is a withdrawal of this Budget and a reconsideration of the hardship it will impose. You could put back the levies which the inter-Party Government had imposed on luxuries and unnecessary articles and get the money required in that way rather than by taking it from the section of the community which is least able to give it, and which will not give it.

Comment on this

Donnellan's dilemma.

Comment on this

O'Malley's muddle.

Comment on this

This debate has been going on for a number of days and nearly every aspect of it has been covered or spoken to in one way or another. I should like to make a few comments upon the proposals and to ask the Government just exactly what they mean by different statements. We had a statement from Deputy Brennan to-day that this was an honest Budget, that it was necessary and that the previous Administration had done, or omitted to do, something which created this position. Is it not rather significant that the Minister for Finance, who introduced the Budget and made the Budget statement, did not make any such charge or make any such comment? It is left to the back benchers of the Party who now form the Government to make these charges, as if they were well founded, when everybody knows that what caused the change of Government was an effort and a determination by the previous Government to bring in an honest statement by imposing the levies necessary to correct the balance of payments problem that had arisen.

If that Government had not imposed these levies at that time, it is true to say that we would not have so much unemployment. If the previous Government had not to restrict expenditure upon various matters, there would not be so much unemployment, but they considered it necessary then. They did the work so well that when a change of Government did take place, the balance of payments problem had been rectified and to-day our balance of payments for the first time is in balance. I am perfectly satisfied that the Minister, when he was introducing this Budget, was quite clear that it was going to be a very great hardship. In the course of his speech, he declared that there was a sacrifice that the people would have to accept and, if they did not accept it, there would be certain consequences. He had no doubt whatever in his mind that a sacrifice would be asked of the people.

How history repeats itself. In 1932, 1933, 1934, 1935, 1936, 1937, and 1938, the people of this country were being asked to accept sacrifices. I do not intend to go into them, but everybody knows what they were, and that strong Government then imposed these sacrifices. They got their supporters all over the country to believe that these sacrifices were necessary in the interests of the country, when it was well known that no such sacrifices were necessary, and that it was just the antics of a Government imposing hardships of a very grave nature upon the people who, unfortunately, had given them their support at that time.

I challenge any Fianna Fáil Deputy, in the House or outside the House, to say that he welcomes this Budget, that he is satisfied that it was a grand thing to do. No; what he will say, and what he is saying, and getting all the supporters he can to say, is that the Government had to do it, that there was no alternative. The Government speakers here ask what was the alternative and they expect us to put up the alternative. The former Taoiseach in his speech, the reading of which I commend to the backbenchers of Fianna Fáil and to the Government —I am not going to quote from it— showed how the Budget could be balanced and how the difficulties could have been got over, without taking away the food subsidies and imposing the taxes that have been imposed. There are many methods of getting taxation from the people, if they are able to bear it; if they are not able to bear it, then the only alternative is to reduce expenditure.

When the previous Government attempted to reduce expenditure, is it not true that there was not a Deputy then on this side of the House who did not hold the Government up to ridicule and scorn? Was it not a pity that the Opposition did not support the Government at that time in doing what was necessary? It is true that the leader of the Opposition and the Minister for Health did say that they would not vote against the proposals. They had only one comment to make upon them, that is, that, in their opinion, they would not be sufficient and that we would have to put on more. Yet, they were so efficient that, in nine months, the balance of payments problem which they set out to rectify was rectified. That is the proof of their success.

As I said at the beginning, that brought about a certain amount of unemployment. We now hear Fianna Fáil talk about 90,000 unemployed and a strong Government. They forget that in 1940 the total number of unemployed in this country was 147,000. That was at a time when our Defence Forces were at their highest peak with over 50,000 in the Regular Army. There were also the countless people who joined the British Army or got work in Britain under the permit system.

After a great number of years of strong Government, we took office in 1948. Unemployment was then at a high level. The net result of the inter-Party Government's operations between 1948 and 1951 was a reduction in unemployment to the lowest level for years. A rather more significant thing happened. Because of the increase in the marriage rate, by 1952 there were over 47,000 more children on the school registers and the number has been increasing since then, notwithstanding all the talk about a dwindling population.

Is there even one member of the Fianna Fáil Party who went into the Party room the day after the Budget and said to the Minister for Finance: "I am delighted with your Budget?" I know well that no member of that Party did that. I know that they came out here to whistle going by the graveyard. They had to try to defend it and I do not blame them. Deputy Gallagher said the Opposition are playing politics. We would have a lot to learn before we could ever play politics as the Party now in Government can and have played them. I do not know that it would be of any advantage to us, at the same time, because our reputation for honesty in public life would not improve. We have that reputation and we have always had it.

When a Deputy gets up behind the Minister and says here in my presence that the sops and the throwing of money to the people for not working are responsible for putting the country in its present condition, I heartily agree with him. I was referring to all that Fianna Fáil did in that respect— whether it was free beef or anything else or whether it was like the famous occasion when the present Minister for External Affairs, speaking at Athlone, said there was any amount of food in the country and that it would be a great blessing if every ship were sunk going to and coming from the country, that we would have more and more to eat, and that, instead of having to tighten our belts, we should have to loosen them.

One farmer, working hard at cleaning a drain and up to his knee in mud was addressed by one of those boys going along the road who said across the ditch to him: "Hard work, John.""How are you doing?" asks John. "I am going in for the free beef." John said: "You are lucky to get it that way. Just look at how hard I have to work for it." The man on the roadside replied: "Ah, by the time you walk in for it and walk back again it is hardly worth it." Then John said: "Indeed, it is a mean Government that does not post it out to you."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is getting away from the Budget.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan asserted here in my presence that the reason for this Budget was the sops thrown by the inter-Party Government —the "weak Government" according to him. I am countering that statement by pointing out that if his argument is correct it must come back to his own door and to the door of his Party but not to our door. Fianna Fáil has the great technique of being able to charge their opponents with their own sins and almost convict them —and sometimes succeed in convicting them.

I put it candidly to the Government that the harshness in this Budget is unnecessary. The matter could have been adjusted in an easier way. They could have taken steps to ease the burden, somewhat. Let me be quite clear about this. I am anxious that, as we are doing this, it will get a chance to succeed but it will not succeed if there is another round of increases in wages. Therefore, along with the Government, I appeal to all concerned to give this Budget a chance. It will be a sacrifice and a hardship but whatever chance it has rests with the people in doing the best they can. They voted for this Government and put them into office knowing that they would do this and, as the Minister has asked them to accept the sacrifice, I think they should do so. I do not know whether or not they will accept my advice but, if they do not, this Budget will be a colossal failure.

I submit that if the inter-Party groups were in office to-day and brought in a Budget anything like the present Budget then, no matter what the circumstances, there would be a howl from the Fianna Fáil Deputies. We should be torn asunder and politics would be played in a ghastly way. We should get no opportunity of defending ourselves and, no matter how much we might point to the circumstances that required in our opinion such a Budget, or one nearly as bad, our explanations would not be accepted. They would say—and rightly so—"It does not matter what the circumstances may be: this is what you are doing. These are the hardships you are imposing." The net result would be that the inter-Party Government would be torn asunder with a broadside of political propaganda the like of which we have never heard.

The harsh effects of the present Budget will be felt daily more and more. I know that no member of the Fianna Fáil Party is satisfied that it will not impose very grave hardship. The defence is that this Budget is necessary. The former Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, proved conclusively that it is not essential and that there are other alternatives.

Comment on this

What about the gap of £11,000,000 which the Coalition Government left behind?

Comment on this

What are £11,000,000 compared with £100,000,000?

Comment on this

It is a pity some of the Deputies opposite did not remain out of the House for another while and let me finish my speech.

Comment on this