Committee on Finance. - Motion by the Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 1–107 of 183. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Last night I was dealing with the situation as this Government found it when they took over office and I gave some instances of what that position was. I dealt with the position under which the county councils were given authority to anticipate road grants that would come into operation during this year. I also dealt with the complete ending of housing grants under the instructions of the Minister for Finance and I wound up by giving the appalling condition of affairs under which a Minister for Health was unable to reply to three letters sent to him by a local authority in Cork, during an epidemic of polio, seeking sanction for 20 extra beds in the Orthopaedic Hospital. The reason given was that because of financial stringency, the letters could not be replied to. The condition of that Government last December was that they had not sufficient money in the Department of Health to pay 50 per cent. of the cost of a number of beds.
We are also aware that it was practically impossible for any local authority to get from the Government the grants due to them under the housing scheme and the grants due to private individuals under the same scheme. Close on £500,000 was due to Cork County Council under those heads when that Government went out of office. You had the further position of the dead weight of loans. When the inter-Party Government first took over in 1948, the amount to be paid in principal and in interest on borrowed money was £4,500,000 per year. On the day they left office that had increased to £10,000,000 per year; when they left office a second time it had reached the appalling sum of £17,000,000 per year —a dead weight load that had to be paid by taxation before the people had one halfpenny to put anywhere.
In dealing with this Vote on Account there are some items which were alluded to by the Minister for Finance yesterday. They are put down here as agricultural subsidies. How they come to be subsidies on agriculture is more than my intelligence can appreciate. One of them is for a sum of £200,000 subsidy on superphosphate. That is a subsidy which should appear on the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce, and not on the Vote for Agriculture. It is a sum of money which is being paid to artificial manure manufacturers to enable them to compete with the prices at which farmers can get superphosphate imported here. Therefore, that sum should be transferred from the backs of the farmers who are credited with it and put instead into the Department of Industry and Commerce.
There is a sum of £520,000 for farm buildings. I might suggest that 50 per cent. of that sum would also be properly applicable to the Department of Industry and Commerce Vote. It is directly due to the neglect of the Department of Industry and Commerce that we have a condition of affairs in which three-quarters of a sheet steel mill is lying idle, with the result that sheet steel has to be imported. I suggest that 50 per cent. of that subsidy is to cover the difference between what we have to pay Britain for sheet steel and the cost at which it could be manufactured here. A sum of £250,000 was voted by the Dáil in 1953 presumably for the purpose of finishing that sheet steel mill. I do not know what became of that £250,000 when the gentlemen opposite took office. We have been placed in a position to-day in which no other country can supply sheet steel, under a cartel, and we have to pay the British whatever they ask for sheet steel.
I also suggest that the greater portion of the sum for ground limestone subsidies should be transferred to the Department of Industry and Commerce Vote for C.I.E. The greater portion of the American Counterpart Fund for this purpose did not go into the pockets of the farmers but into the pockets of the incompetent, inefficient C.I.E. establishment. I have given instances of this before and I give them again now as I find them. The owners of ground limestone plants, even though they had their own transport to carry the ground limestone into the farmers' fields and spread it there, still had to pay 7½ per cent. of their takings to C.I.E. That is a scandalous conversion of the money that was meant for the assistance of the agricultural community and I see no justification whatever for it. Let us hope that a different attitude will be adopted by the Department of Agriculture this year in relation to the £448,000 that is being voted, and that it will go directly in subsidy for transport, without having to pay commission to C.I.E. "as the old man of the sea" in this instance.
A lot of play was made yesterday in connection with the Government's attitude towards wheat, barley and milk. In approaching that matter, I have a very divided mind. For some 20 odd years, an organisation, of which I have the honour to be a member, carried out all the negotiations on the price of wheat and feeding barley with whatever Minister was in office. A change was made some three years ago and a few gentlemen with hyphenated names took over the job. I ask members to place themselves in the position of a Minister who meets such a body to negotiate prices. That body, according to themselves, this year, demanded a price of 38/- per barrel for feeding barley. Was the Minister to tell those people: "Look, run away and reconsider that and come back here and ask for 48/- per barrel, instead of 38/-"? Was he to tell them that or was he to say they were looking for too much? What was the position? I leave it to any Deputy to judge for himself. If a farmer at a fair was asking £40 for an animal, would a buyer come along and say: "I am going to give you £45"?
Comment on this
The conduct of the negotiators is not a matter for criticism in this House. The conduct of the Government and their policy in respect of expenditure of money are the subject matters of the debate.
Comment on this
The Deputy may not proceed to discuss the body which discussed the price of wheat with the Government. He may discuss what the Government did on the matter.
Comment on this
They were the people who suggested to the Government that there should be last year's price for wheat.
Comment on this
I do not agree either with the price fixed for feeding barley or the price fixed for wheat, or with the method by which the job is being done in either case; but, disagreeing with all those, then where am I to turn? What line is left for me in relation to these matters? A former Minister for Agriculture here, dealing with wheat, said at column 2050 of Volume 106 of the Official Debates:—
"We had the enthralling, stimulating and surprising experience of eating bread made out of Irish wheat. Before you eat it you have to hold it out in your hand, squeeze the water out of it, then tease it out and make up your mind whether it was a handful of boot polish or a handful of bread. If it was boot polish you put it on your boots or shoes, and if it was bread you tried to masticate it, if you were fit."
That is the Minister whom those people would put in charge of agriculture and, unfortunately, I have to judge between the two.
Comment on this
There is one other statement I would like to read at column 2042 of the same Volume:—
"Some day I am convinced that peat will go up the spout after the beet and the wheat. God speed the day."
Comment on this
I must remind the Deputy that it is the policy of the present Government that is under discussion and not the policy of the previous Government.
Comment on this
Those are the circumstances in which we have to approach this matter. I note that in 1946——
Comment on this
——this Dáil brought in an Act dealing with industrial research and standards. From 1946 to 1958, the gentlemen in this institute have been receiving each year a pretty considerable amount of public money from the taxpayer.
Comment on this
I cannot see the relevancy that has to the Vote on Account at present before the House.
Comment on this
These gentlemen had a particular job to do. It was their task to find out whether a palatable loaf could be made out of all-Irish wheat. The first result was in the shape of an experiment carried out in the Curragh during the last 12 months and that proved a palatable loaf of good bread could be made out of all-Irish wheat, despite what the ex-Minister for Agriculture said to the contrary.
Had the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Institute on Industrial Research and Standards worked as they should have worked for the 12 years they have been in existence, surely it would not be beyond their intelligence to have trained the millers and the bakers into producing an all-Irish loaf, a loaf which would solve the problem with which we are now faced. Instead of that, we had the spectacle of wheat being sold for animal feeding, while, at the same time, foreign wheat was imported to the tune of £3,250,000. There should have been no necessity whatsoever for the importation of that foreign wheat, had the institute and the Department of Industry and Commerce done their job and educated the millers and the bakers. It was their bounden duty to do that.
In relation to the manner in which the job is being done, I must register a most emphatic protest. From 1940 to 1947, we had compulsory wheat growing. There were farmers who, appreciating their duty to the nation, grew far more wheat than they were compelled to grow by law. They were the vast majority of the ordinary small tillage farmers. The Government succeeded some five years after a half-crown bonus was given on wheat in paying every man on the quantity he delivered to the mills. There should be no difficulty to-day in implementing the same principle. The quantity delivered to the mills in 1956 was 400,000 tons and there should be no difficulty in instructing the millers to instruct each farmer to grow the same tonnage of wheat as he delivered in 1946, plus 50 per cent. Let the gentlemen whom the present Minister had to threaten that he would break down their walls and drive in tractors to compel them to produce wheat continue to ruin their good land. They refused to grow wheat then because they said it would ruin their land.
I can see no justification for throwing overboard the decent hardworking farmers, and thrown overboard they have been. The section of the community who refused to till in those years were making money out of ranching and the sale of bullocks. It paid them because the price of store cattle went up; they sold the fat cattle and they bought no more. They put in the plough and the tractor, tore up the land and grew wheat. The activities of that section of the community have left the country with a surplus of wheat.
Surely it should not be beyond the intelligence of the Department of Agriculture to find a remedy, without penalising the ordinary farmer who grew wheat in the ordinary way? A man growing 500 or 600 acres of wheat can afford to grow it at a profit of £2 per acre; but take the case of the ordinary farmer who has five or ten acres out of 40 under wheat. If he has £20 profit out of ten acres, what does he live on? Those are the circumstances in regard to which I would examine this matter and deal with it. I consider that the manner in which this problem has been dealt with is wrong and I have no hesitation in stating that.
I cannot yet understand the wide difference in treatment of the agricultural community and the industrialists. A while ago, I referred to the £200,000 given for the production of superphosphate. Those gentlemen are also entitled to walk in to the Prices Advisory Body and say: "We are working at a loss and we are going to raise our prices," and under the legislation in this country to-day, there is no alternative but to give them that increase.
The position of the agricultural community is far different. I note here that a sum of £200,000 is being given as a Grant-in-Aid for industrial development this year. That has been given, I take it, under the Act of 1956. Under that Act, industrial firms are entitled to come in here, put up a factory for the export of manufactured goods and receive up to 75 per cent. as a grant for the erection of that factory and the machinery in it. If a foreign industrialist comes into this country, claims that grant and gets it, nobody in this House dare question who got it, how they got it and how much they got.
The administration of all that is vested in some bunch of people outside. We have no power. Within the last month, I put a question down here asking the amount that has been given out under this Act to non-nationals and the amount given to Irish industrialists. The Minister told me he had no power to reply to that question. This £400,000 is being given out blindfold to a body of men appointed outside who apparently can do what they like with it. They can tell Mike: "You are entitled to it," but they can tell Mikey: "You will get nothing."
If we examine the case of one of these industrialists who comes in here and gets a grant of £300,000 or £400,000 towards starting an industry for export, we probably find he exports anything from £20,000 to £50,000 worth of goods per year. That is one side of the picture. On the opposite side, you have an industry in this country that is exporting goods to the value of £75,000,000. In order to get that £75,000,000 you have to pay roughly a subsidy of £2,250,000. I think it is money well spent. But when I look over there and see what they gave me, what am I to do?
I take up Volume 106, column 2048, and here is what I find there:—
"We are subsidising butter production to the tune of £2,000,000 per annum. How long will that go on? Do we expect butter to get dearer in the markets of the world? Do we expect the time in the early future when the price of milk will become so adjusted that it will be possible to suspend this subsidy or do we intend to continue producing milk for conversion into butter in creameries at an annual cost to the taxpayer of £2,000,000 per annum? I want it to go on record most emphatically that I think such a policy is sheer insanity and is purely pursued for the purpose of maintaining the prestige of incompetents in the office of the Minister for Agriculture."
This is a statement made by Deputy James Dillon. Now where am I to go? This man told me he will give me a "bob" a gallon for five years.
Comment on this
Penal servitude for five years is a lot worse than six months' imprisonment. That is the judgment I make on this. We would be well advised to bring this matter before the Prices Advisory Body. I have examined this as closely as I could without going into the 980 pages of lines contained in the Report of the Milk Costings Commission and I find that the labour hours per cow are practically the same as the labour hours per ton of beet. In 1948, the price of beet was £4 8s. 0d. per ton——
Comment on this
The Deputy is going into a matter that is more relevant to the Estimate for Agriculture. What is generally discussed on the Vote on Account is the general overall policy of the Government.
Comment on this
I am referring to the milk costings published a few days ago and on which apparently the Minister has acted.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy not see that it is more relevant to the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture?
Comment on this
We have not. The gentleman who dwelt so long on the foolishness of giving any subsidy and who flooded us out here with his statements about the extra number of cows in the country and the extra millions of gallons of milk, put into this Estimate last year only £666,000 for the butter subsidy——
Comment on this
That is the amount that was in it after the Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance revised the Estimate in June.
Comment on this
Again I must suggest to the Deputy that all this would be more relevant to the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. We cannot go into the items of every Estimate on the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
I am going into an item of over £1,000,000 allocated this year as a subsidy on butter.
Comment on this
Surely I am entitled to say on the Vote on Account that this Estimate is wrong and should be revised?
Comment on this
The general principle followed in discussing the Vote on Account has always been to discuss the general policy of the Government, not details of any particular Estimate.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the general policy of the Government and a statement made by the Minister when he introduced the Estimate yesterday.
Comment on this
Yes, Sir. He said that the amount for subsidisation of butter for export was up by £734,000 and I am dealing with that. I am suggesting that, taking it on the only heading of costings that we know—and I have given, as near as I could, the labour hours in both cases and that is the factor that increases or reduces costings—the price of beet went up by £1 12s. 0d. per ton and that surely the price of milk should have gone up by a corresponding amount per cow.
Comment on this
——by trotting around this Lobby, would consider the matter, I think the least the farmers could expect from him now would be his silence.
Comment on this
I maintain that policy is foolish. We have reached a crisis so far as the cattle industry is concerned. In the next couple of years through the bovine tuberculosis scheme we shall have to get rid of all our milch cows suffering from tuberculosis. I take it that will mean roughly 40 per cent. of the milch cows. When that is done we shall be faced with the question as to whether it is worth while to replace them and the policy of any Government will be very seriously considered by the farmer when he sells or gets rid of a tuberculous beast and has to replace it at a cost of £70 or £80 for a springing heifer. If these cows are not replaced the £45,000,000 brought in last year by our cattle exports will fall by 50 per cent. If that happens there will be very little to boost industry and less to pay the £17,000,000 to the civil servants.
This is one of the greatest steps in my opinion that has been taken up to date here. The farmers are entitled on costings to an increase and instead they are getting a reduction. I can only give my own reaction and that is that if I am to pay a subsidy or portion of a subsidy because we have too much butter I shall take care that we will not have too much butter. It is only a few years since another Minister for Agriculture had to bring Brian Boru's butter in here and we know how the people took that. We do not want the reintroduction of Brian Boru's butter now. The nation depends for its economic existence on the dairying industry and the number of cows in the country, because we have not yet invented a machine to give us a bullock without having a cow. Therefore, the whole cattle trade depends on whether the southern farmer keeps dairy stock or not. He will have to reduce or he will reduce his dairy herd. He is a fool if, under the circumstances, he does not reduce it to such an extent that he can lay down the law on the price of butter. There is a remedy for everything. If over-production means a cut in price, there is a remedy.
As an example in the opposite direction, I shall cite another great industry which is being kept going here by the agricultural community, namely, the beet industry. Instead of a cut for over-production, there is a bonus for every extra ton of beet produced. There was a bonus this year of 5/- a ton for those who could produce a certain quantity and 2/6 a ton for a smaller quantity. In some areas such as that which Deputy Hughes represents they were lucky enough to get the 5/-. Farmers in other areas got only the 2/6. That is the opposite policy to the policy at present being put into operation with regard to wheat, barley and milk. I do not think the policy in regard to these commodities can work out.
In connection with beet we had the advantage of having the price based on costings carried out in 1948. Costings were taken of some 400 farms. The amazing difference between that and the famous milk costings which took five or six years to produce is just the difference between people doing a job themselves and allowing it to get into the hands of civil servants. In the case of beet we carried out the costings. Farmers are paid on the cost of production each year and the cost of production of an acre of beet has gone up by about £19 since 1948. It should not be too difficult to discover the increase in the cost per gallon of milk in the same period, taking the labour content in each case.
I think the action is wrong but, as I said before, no man who has to face the alternative can face it. No man can face the alternative suggested by another Minister who told us that he would not give any subsidy on butter and that the production of milk for conversion into butter in this country is sheer insanity. That is the statement I read out here by the former Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon.
I have been rather disappointed by the position in regard to civil servants. When the emergency ceased there were some 4,500 surplus civil servants who had been employed under the rationing system in Ballsbridge and elsewhere. They were taken into the permanent staff then but recruiting for the Civil Service did not stop despite the fact that there were 4,500 surplus civil servants. Therefore, there are still 4,500 surplus civil servants. I alluded to the dead weight debt of £17,000,000. Another £17,000,000 has to be added to that for civil servants. That is £34,000,000 that the people must find before they find anything for the ordinary public services.
I suggest that £17,000,000 is too heavy a burden for producers to bear. I had hoped for a substantial reduction in that figure. I expected to hear from the Minister for Finance in his speech introducing the Vote on Account some reference to the guarantee that he gave that that sum and that burden would be reduced. Those on the other side of the House who said "Hear, hear!" are unfortunately in the position that their Minister for Finance reduced nothing in that line, despite the fact that he knew what the situation was, despite the fact that he was a member of a Government that sanctioned the establishment of these 4,500 temporary staff and allowed recruiting each year for the Civil Service.
Comment on this
The Minister who left this country in such a condition that the local authority's cheque was dishonoured——
Comment on this
Sir, I do not mind what charges Deputy Corry makes against me. They are only amusing. But I object to his saying that the cheques of Kildare County Council were dishonoured. They were not.
Comment on this
Let the people judge. You offered money for a little job before and you ran from it. I would suggest that, in the present financial condition of the country, that £17,000,000 must be reduced to £10,000,000. It could be done; £10,000,000 a year would be sufficient for a small country like this to pay for civil servants.
Comment on this
Send them to Whitegate to me and I shall get jobs for them. There is a very simple way out. You need not sack any of them. I would like the Minister to tell us, when he is concluding, the number recruited into the Civil Service in the last 12 months.
Comment on this
I would advise the Deputy to keep his tongue in his cheek for a little while longer.
Comment on this
If I were in Deputy Sweetman's boots, having given instructions to the county managers to the effect that not one penny was to be pent on housing, I would keep outside that door. It is not the first time I said that to Deputy Sweetman.
Comment on this
We know that several letters were sent from the county councils to the Department of Local Government looking for grants that were not forthcoming.
Comment on this
As I said, I do not think that an industry that has given us some £75,000,000 a year in exports is an industry to which we should refuse £2,250,000 in subsidy. I challenge the amount that is to be spent here in grants by the Industrial Development Authority and the amount which that money is to bring in in exports as against the £75,000,000 provided by the agricultural community in the export of stock. I am prepared to accept from the Minister the same proportion in subsidy to the farmers as those industrialists are getting. Under the Constitution of this State, equal rights are guaranteed for all citizens, and the agricultural community are entitled to the same rights as any tuppence-halfpenny industrialist who comes in here to cash in on us, as they are doing under the famous Act that was brought in here by Deputy Sweetman. We will get an opportunity in this House to deal with the amount given in those grants and who gets it. I hope we will have an opportunity of bringing this development authority under the control of this House and then we will have some funny stories.
I have covered the ground as fairly as I can and as I said, where is the alternative? On the one hand, you have the people who left this country bankrupt and, on the other hand, those who are endeavouring to bring it back to a reasonable state as regards finance. You have a choice between the man who says: "You got £660,000 last year; I will give you £1,400,000 this year," and the man who said: "I will withdraw the subsidy and give you a ‘bob' a gallon." You have a choice between this Party and the Party whose Minister for Agriculture said he would not be found dead in a field of wheat and who said he "would drown us in eggs.... Do we intend to produce milk for conversion into butter at an annual cost to the taxpayer of £2,000,000 per annum? I want to go on record as saying most emphatically that such a policy is sheer insanity." The only alternative we have is the man who guaranteed a "bob" a gallon for milk for five years.
I have given what, in my opinion, is the alternative in regard to wheat, in regard to milk and in regard to barley. The Government that found it a good policy to reduce the price of feeding barley from 48/- to 40/- in order that they might rake in in taxation from the unfortunate pig feeder the sum given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce as £1,096,000, must face their responsibility. On top of that I want, on behalf of the farming community, to repudiate in the strongest possible terms, those people who attempted to negotiate a price without authority. Who went in and demanded an uneconomic price for feeding barley and who proposed this outrageous price for wheat?
Comment on this
Yesterday afternoon the Minister for Defence in the course of his introductory remarks rather plaintively complained that it would appear to him that the approach to the matters arising on this Vote on Account by the Opposition was not sufficiently objective. Last year, on 20th March, when this Government was formed, I stated that we, who had gone into opposition, would tend to be a constructive Opposition and that we would not indulge merely in recriminanations and bickerings. I drew attention to the fact that we had every reason to know the kind of task and problems that would confront the Government who were then setting out upon their task. I said that we would, so far as it was possible, give them assistance, but that we were not going to lie low in the Opposition Benches; that we would give constructive opposition, but at the same time would be a vigorous and a vigilant Opposition.
The circumstances confronting us to-day, after 12 months of the present Government, call for that vigorous Opposition. I would have been prepared to give at least some measure of sympathy to the Government in the tasks which confronted them and with the full knowledge of the difficulties that must confront any Government in present circumstances governing the affairs of this State. I think we are entitled to take strong exception to the oblique references of the Minister for Defence and his colleagues and to the express references made by one of his colleagues during the past week-end to the conditions that they found when they came into Government—what they are pleased to refer to as the "Coalition mess."
If they wish for our co-operation, if they wish for some sympathy in the difficulties that confront them, at least they should extend to us not sympathy or generosity, which we do no expect, but some measure of appreciation of the difficulties which faced the Government and which they had to tackle in the very difficult year of 1956 and the beginning of 1957. I shall have occasion here this afternoon to compare the conditions which we, as a Government, faced during that critical period with the conditions that subsisted since this Government took office just 12 months ago.
We have now to examine the record of the Government over the past 12 months. I do not say that everything they did was wrong or that they have done nothing or achieved nothing, but, very largely, what they have achieved has been the result of carrying out the readymade policy which we handed to them when we left office 12 months ago. While some good has been achieved, nevertheless, critical, and I believe, impartial examination will demonstrate that the present Government has done nothing and certainly has not done sufficient to justify the shift-over of power which was effected as a result of the last general election.
Let me just very quickly and very inadequately recall the conditions that we had to face in the year 1956 and the beginning of 1957 and the conditions in which we had a general election last year. Have Deputies forgotten the dumping of Argentine cattle, causing the depression of cattle prices which occurred in 1956? Cattle prices fell and all our export prices collapsed also. Import prices rose at the same time. We had the world boom bringing up freight rates and import prices in practically every commodity.
We had in this country an unexampled and unprecedented expansion of bank credits which led to another round of wage and salary increases and consequent increases of taxation. We had the position where credit was scarce and where it was practically impossible to get the necessary capital to carry on the capital expenditure of the Government and bring to fruition its capital scheme. We had the credit squeeze by the banks but, above all, we had the problem of the balance of payments. The problem of disequilibrium on external account is one that has afflicted the country from time to time for some years past but in 1956 that problem became one of major importance.
A huge deficit, something like £94,000,000 threatened to repeat itself in 1956 and rigorous measures were necessary to ward off what might have been a serious and permanent injury to our country. We had to take measures to deal with that situation and we took the necessary measures. We were very glad to see that, as the months went by, those measures were effective. In 1956 the trade deficit was reduced by something like £20.6 million and in 1957 by a further £21.9 million with the result that the balance of payments deficit was only £14.4 million. In 1957 the figures indicate that there was a surplus and, as Deputy Sweetman pointed out yesterday, there was obviously going to be a surplus. We had brought that balance of payments into equilibrium at the time we left office in March of last year.
That was a serious position with very serious economic reactions on the country, causing very serious unemployment. All these matters were something over which we had no control but in addition to the difficulty of getting capital, on top of the bank squeeze, the restriction in business and economic activities and the necessity to take steps to correct the deficit in our balance of payments account, there came, towards the end of the year, the Suez crisis causing a further disruption just at the very moment when it appeared that we had—in fact, we had as it subsequently transpired—gripped the situation, and solved the problem. We had hopes then of ending unemployment and there was a clear cut and definite written-down policy for production which I announced in October, 1956, to deal with the situation in the future after these adverse economic conditions had been corrected.
We were then faced with another economic crisis entirely apart from anything over which we had any control. Everybody knows, although our political opponents very conveniently forget, when criticising us in this House and outside it, that the Suez crisis caused a further deplorable and almost disastrous effect on business and unemployment in this country. It was in those conditions, and following upon the result of those conditions, that we had to face the electorate in March of last year.
The various promises that were made by Ministers and their political supporters during the general election have been adverted to in the course of this debate. Doubtless it will be a long time before they hear the end of those promises. For my part, I do not intend to dwell upon them to-day. I say, just in passing, that both the present Taoiseach and the present Tánaiste, in particular, made statements in the course of the general election campaign which, to say the least of it, were imprudent and which certainly will be acutely embarrassing for both of them for many years to come.
I do not intend to base my criticism of Government policy, or lack of it, or of the results of their operations in the administration of this State in the past 12 months, on those broken promises. I would recall to Deputies the epitaph by an anonymous rhymer on Lloyd George after one of his famous election campaigns—a rhyme that has found its way into the leading books of comic rhymes and comic verses and which is peculiarly appropriate to the promises referred to here which were made particularly by the present Taoiseach and the present Tánaiste in the course of the last general election. It runs:—
"Count not his broken pledges as a crime.
He meant them, how he meant them,
At the time."
The promises were very useful at that time and they may have secured votes. The number of votes secured by them was small, in my view, in comparison with a very much more effective campaign carried on during the years, particularly the last years, when we were in office and right throughout the length and breadth of the country during the general election. I did not object to that campaign merely because it was both unjust and uncharitable but because in practically every respect it was untrue. The real reason why I objected, and why my colleagues objected, to that campaign and to the disruptive tactics that were pursued from this side of the House against our efforts to deal with the national dangers in 1956, and in the beginning of 1957, was not merely that it gave us difficulty but because it had very serious repercussions in the national life of the country. It was very largely responsible for that mood of disillusionment and cynicism with political institutions that was so rife in the last few years. It threatened the very basis of our political democracy. Their propaganda, during those years when we were in office, was designed not in the interests of the national affairs of the country but solely to put us out of office and secure office for themselves.
Over those years, the really effective propaganda which has put them where they are now was the propaganda against the inter-Party system of government, "Coalitions" as they called it—co-operation between Parties in government—and the call to the country for a strong Government, a Government with an overall majority, that would be able to tackle the difficult problems and deal with them effectively in such a way as a weak Coalition could not. They have their strong Government now and we see the results. Throughout the country, the Taoiseach gave expression to his obsession against inter-Party government. His colleagues gave vent to the same views—all designed to put them back into office and all designed to secure what they did, in fact, secure in the most favourable circumstances possible for them—an overall majority in this House.
That campaign succeeded because it came to its full effect in circumstances most favourable to them because of the conditions facing the Government at that time. The words "strong Government" became a blessed formula to a number of disillusioned people, to a number of people suffering from unemployment, to a number of business people whose business was affected by international affairs and the economic circumstances of the country. "A strong Government" became a blessed formula by which every economic and financial ill that afflicted the country was to be cured.
It will be my duty now to examine whether this strong Government, with its overall majority in this House, has made any impression upon the problems that face them and which they were called upon to solve in circumstances very much different from those which faced their predecessors. We endeavoured, in the course of the election campaign, very unsuccessfully to counter the argument of "A strong Government". We endeavoured to draw the attention of the electorate to the fact that a Government that had such a record in the country—a Government that brought about the various economic crises with which we were afflicted and a Government with its record of disaster—were not the Government to be entrusted in difficult times with the handling of the affairs of this State.
The people decided generally to support them—and they decided to do so because they were of the view, which was brought about by the propaganda of Fianna Fáil, that all the problems and all the evils afflicting the country were due, not, as they were, in fact, to conditions of economic forces and financial considerations over which we had no control, but to the existence of an inter-Party Government. Because of the difficulties at the time, very many people—in fact, a sufficient number of people—voted because they wanted a strong Government to make the difference between a Government incapable of forming a Government and a Government with a clear majority.
It is our task to examine what the Government, having got that clear majority, have done with it. But, in the background, helping along this propaganda, were not merely the promises that were made but the £100,000,000 plan of Deputy Lemass which was to provide full employment for the people. He, as Deputy Sweetman pointed out yesterday, kept probing at that, kept harping at it, disseminating suggestions about it, but, all the time, there were the suggestions, inferences, or innuendoes that it was not the official policy of Fianna Fáil. They gave themselves that let out, that bolt-hole. But, all the time, it was put over that Deputy Lemass had a £100,000,000 plan for the solution of the problem of unemployment and for the attainment of full employment. It can be readily imagined now, even in retrospect, how people suffering from the fearful terror of unemployment and from the actual experience of unemployment, must have grasped at that ideal and that figment of the imagination of Deputy Lemass, as he then was.
The other people, those ordinary conservative people who shrank at the notion of £100,000,000 and whose talk has so frequently been about native Government expenditure, those people, Tory in their outlook, did not like the £100,000,000 plan, but they took refuge in the innate conservatism of the present Taoiseach, then Deputy de Valera, and his colleague, Deputy MacEntee, who had been the most Tory Minister for Finance this country ever had occupying this office.
At all events, they came into office. We took the view that we had gone through a sea of trouble in the year 1956 and the beginning of 1957, though we had that situation then in such a position that we hoped to build upon it in such a way as to increase the prosperity of the agricultural industry, and of all sections of our people. We also hoped to increase employment by means of the incentives we gave to the export trade and the policy I had outlined then. It looked as if we had some chance, as if we had some light in the darkness. Knowing, however, that the darkness still subsisted, we wished the present Government well in their task.
Now we are entitled to ask what the Government has done in the last 12 months to increase the national wealth and the income of the people, to give additional employment, to stem emigration and control, as far as it can be controlled by Government action, the increase in the cost of living. What are the results? I suppose the most dramatic action of the present Government was their abolition of the food subsidies in the Budget of last year. The people who voted for them and for a "strong Government" clearly had the view that it was only a strong Government which would be able, which would have not merely the courage but the ability, to do what was done by the present Government in the Budget of last year, to abolish the food subsidies. They did abolish them.
I would remark here in parenthesis that these food subsidies, having been abolished to the tune of £9,000,000, can never be restored by any Government that succeeds them. That fact had better be faced by all sections of the people. They took away a certain amount of the food subsidies by the Budget of 1952 and, just as they failed and failed miserably to give the benefit of that painful operation to the people in general, the food subsidies were swallowed and the economy of the country got no benefit whatever from them by the Budget of 1952.
The same fate has overcome the saving that was effected, or appeared to have been effected, or that it was claimed would be effected, by the present Minister for Finance by the abolition of the food subsidies. Nine million pounds were the cost, according to the Minister for Finance in his Budget speech last year, of the food subsidies to the taxpayer. These were abolished in full. There was no tinkering about it; they were a "strong Government". There was no question that it was to be given in little pieces to the people, so that they would bear the burden over a number of years. It was all taken at once and in the first year of office—following, as I said, in my Budget speech, the Machiavellian principle. It was all taken away, £9,000,000. There was £1,500,000 of it in last year which had to be provided out of the saving, for compensatory payments in the way of social benefits. That was estimated at £2,500,000 in a full year, as necessary because of the increases in the cost of living that would be bound to ensue from the abolition of the food subsidies.
Taking £2,500,000 from £9,000,000 leaves £6,500,000. This Book of Estimates which was presented to us the other day ought to have been down by at least £6,500,000. We find that the Book of Estimates is down only by an apparent sum of £1.7 million odd. When the other payments are taken into account that were detailed by Deputy Sweetman yesterday, they show that the result of these transactions and manoeuvrings is that the £9,000,000 saved by the abolition of the food subsidies is again swallowed up. In fact, when analysed, the Book of Estimates shows that expenditure on Supply Services and Capital Services this year is up by some £300,000 instead of being down in amount. That is the achievement by this dramatic stroke of the "strong Government" as its first act—to take £9,000,000 in ease of the taxpayer as the unfortunate taxpayer thought, but it is swallowed up and now where has it gone? Instead of having a decrease of £6,500,000 at least on the face of the Book of Estimates this year, the figure has gone up and the public expenditure is shown to be increased by £300,000.
I take the view and have taken it very strongly—some economists differ— that very many of the difficulties confronting us then and which may confront the present Government now are traceable to the disruption of the economy caused by the Budget of 1952. The food subsidies were taken away at that time. It seems to be the pet theory of economists that food subsidies are unjustifiable and they produce arguments to that effect with great cogency and force. All we know, however, is the result to this country of abolishing the food subsidies. We know what happened in 1952; we know what happened in 1957, when the food subsidies were abolished. What benefit has the taxpayer got? What benefit has accrued to the economy by promoting the expansion of industry due to the decrease in taxation which is so urgently required if business is to be activated and industrial expansion to be achieved? We had nothing, as far as I can see, but bad results from the taking away of these food subsidies.
In 1952 they were justified on the grounds that at that time there was no possibility or reasonable prospect of an increase in agricultural production. That was the basis on which the Budget of 1952 was framed. We now know what expansion of agricultural production has taken place since that year, in spite of everything that may be said against the unfortunate farmers. Because there was to be no expansion of agricultural production, everything had to be increased in taxation by the Budget of 1952; foodstuffs had to be increased and the result was that there was no easement of the taxpayers' burden as a result of it. I cannot see at the present time how there is to be any easement of the taxpayers' burden as the result of the abolition of the £9,000,000 in the food subsidies—or, at its best, from the point of view of the Minister for Finance, £6,500,000.
There are the first fruits of this "strong Government". In so far as there was anything of a new character in the Budget of last year, there was that proposal of abolishing the food subsidies, which had certainly given promise of some easement of taxation and expansion of business. There was the development of the policy we had initiated of giving incentives to export. There was the provision for £250,000 for agricultural marketing improvement. I have dealt with the effect of the abolition of the food subsidies.
The effect of the export tax remission was merely to develop the policy that we had initiated and as regards the £250,000 provided for the development and improvement of agricultural marketing, there has not been one penny piece of that £250,000 spent for the purpose of improving agricultural marketing. All that has been done is to set up some sort of advisory body to advise the Minister how he is to spend that money that has not yet been spent and apparently will never be spent. The farming community is in a state of ferment. Whatever views people may hold about the desirability of reconciling the interests of farming, the national interest and the interests of the taxpayers and the dwellers in towns and cities, the way that the farmers have been treated here is no way to treat the principal industry, on which the whole State is founded.
The milk producers are up in arms to the point where they are making statements—which I feel sure the farmers will repudiate when they calm down and look upon it not merely from the point of view of their own interests but the interests of the nation as a whole—that they will boycott the bovine tuberculosis eradication scheme and, like Samson, pull down the pillars of the temple, destroying themselves and everybody else. While we sympathise with the milk producers and fully appreciate their importance and vital necessity in the national economy, no body of decent farmers would stand over the resolution which appears to have been fathered by the erstwhile friends of Fianna Fáil.
Various speakers have referred to the effect on the farmers' income of the price of wheat, the price of milk and barley and the reduction in their incomes through the levy. I do not intend to go over that ground, because I am not competent to do so, but may I remark two things in passing? One is that if the financial stringency of the country was such that it required the imposition of this levy on the milk producers, at least this strong Government, with its clear majority, with its penchant for plans, should have had some plan of an alternative character rather than the imposition of the levy to export cheap butter to the British for the utilisation of surplus milk. Surely there is some plan by which that milk could be disposed of rather than disposing of it to the British market at cheap prices. Has the Minister and his advisers ever considered the desirability of, if not the necessity for, developing the cheese industry in this country? It is a matter that I had views about when I was in office, views perhaps that I was not fully entitled to hold because it was a matter on which I had no very great knowledge. It was brought to my attention by an expert from Denmark that, after the war, the Danes, who had no knowledge of the technique of cheese-making, no experience in that technique, had built up a vast export trade in cheese. I had hoped, if we had not been interrupted in the course of the development of our constructive policy for agriculture, that that matter might have been considered.
I understand that years ago there might have been some very great difficulty in manufacturing the various ranges of cheese that are developed on the Continent, in Switzerland, in France, Holland and Denmark. Now, however, the scientific advances in research have been such that the bacteriological considerations affecting cheese are now pretty well established and well known. In any event, whether or not that was merely a bee in my bonnet, I think it devolves on the Minister for Agriculture to find some alternative plan rather than the one he has adopted for the easement of the milk producing industry.
I would then ask, for the second remark on the subject of agriculture, if it is indicative of a strong Government that, when matters vitally affecting the agricultural industry are being dealt with by conferences, by those taking part in the Free Trade Area arrangements in Europe, the Minister sent to those conferences is the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture is left safely at home? We all know that one of the stumbling blocks in connection with the establishment of the Free Trade Area, and the conditions under which it will be set up, is the question of how agriculture is to be dealt with. That is a matter of the most vital importance to this country.
It is a matter, as everybody agrees, of the utmost importance to us, how we are to be affected by the establishment of this Free Trade Area. Are we to be left out in the cold? Are we to be left out on the edge of the Atlantic Ocean to impoverish ourselves still further, or are we to take part in it and see that we get conditions which will enable us to make use of that Free Trade Area and, above all, to see that our interests, as a primarily agricultural country, are safeguarded and that the benefits which the first inter-Party Government got for the farmers in the Trade Agreement of 1948, and which Fianna Fáil never got, are not frittered away? Are we going to see to it that the manoeuvrings which take place in these international gatherings, when every nation is out for its own selfish interests, will not be such as to leave us out in the cold?
The Minister for Industry and Commerce is looking after industry primarily, but agriculture is one of the stumbling blocks there and one of the matters in which we are vitally concerned, and yet the Minister for Agriculture is left at home. I suppose it would be imprudent to say what many people do say, that he should not be in the Government at all; but certainly when he is in the Government, at least he should be looking after the interests of agriculture at international conferences which may vitally and very markedly affect the agricultural community for many years to come.
I suppose perhaps it might be too trivial a matter, where very wider interests are involved, to draw attention to the position of the Government's policy on television, to indicate that in that matter, while one Minister says one thing, another Minister says another. Nobody knows where this strong Government stands in connection with a vital matter of that kind, but I do take the view, and I think my colleagues take the view, that the expenditure of moneys very urgently required for much more important purposes are being spent upon the so-called Irish transatlantic air service.
Does anybody doubt that the moneys, to whatever extent they are being spent in that futile performance, merely, I suggest, to pander to an obsession of the Tánaiste, would have been very much better used giving tax reliefs to Irish industrialists in order to get further into the export market and particularly into the market in America, or in improving agricultural credit facilities, or in much needed expansion of educational services? This strong Government has gone back on its tracks and has set up a transatlantic air service that not 5 per cent. of the people outside Fianna Fáil or their most devoted adherents want, and which will not be of any advantage to this country. Even if it were of advantage, there are such things as priorities and certainly the transatlantic air service is a long way down on the priority list as compared with those matters which are urgently required for development. The aim would seem to be to have this air service used by the Irish who are going to America as emigrants, rather than have them go by boat.
We are entitled to ask is it a mark of strong Government to throw away the levies on luxury articles as one of their first acts after they were appointed last year? If they had left those taxes on luxuries in operation, there would have been, I suggest, sufficient, and perhaps more than sufficent, money available to finance the export of butter and to save the farmers from the imposition of a levy of a penny a gallon on the price of milk. That is a matter that is deserving of the severest criticism. Those import levies were put upon these articles by us, admittedly, as a temporary expedient, and were to come off as soon as national conditions permitted. Some of those import levies were made permanent levies of a revenue-producing character, but some of them were taken off the luxury articles. The proceeds of those levies would have enabled the Minister for Agriculture at least to have stayed off the imposition of the levy on the milk producing sections of the farming community.
It is a new thing in Irish politics to have farming organisations passing votes of censure on Fianna Fáil. It shows, at least, whatever the views may be about these farming organisations, that the present Government have lost their confidence. We took the view that it was desirable in the national interest, not merely in the interests of the farming or agricultural community, that there should be the closest possible co-operation between representatives of the farmers and the Government at the very inception of policy. As part of that policy, we took the view, and still have the view, that these farming organisations should keep outside politics. They are desirable to have there, so that there can be a definite connection with policy, when it is being formulated by any Government and any Minister for Agriculture, affecting the representatives of the farmers, but they should keep outside politics. It is deplorable, therefore, that the Minister for Finance saw fit to make the very disreputable remarks which he made in a speech at Enniscorthy last week.
Comment on this
I think the Minister took the most undesirable method of expressing it. I gather he agrees with me that they should keep outside politics.
Comment on this
That would be a simple thing to say simply and courteously, but why drag it in and say that Fine Gael were mixed up with them?
Comment on this
That is how I ended up —that I hoped they would not join Fine Gael, as the rest of them did.
Comment on this
It was the kind of thing the Minister for Finance, on reflection, ought never to have done.
Comment on this
One of the greatest hopes aroused throughout the country by the coming into office of this strong Government with a clear majority was that, by virtue of the wonderful plan of £100,000,000 drawn up by An Tánaiste, or by virtue of the plans Fianna Fáil said they had, the unemployment problem would at last be solved. Other speakers have dealt with that aspect of the Government's inaction, failure and blunders during last year. I will content myself with referring to the City of Dublin.
Despite the fact that last year the unemployment figures in February were staggering, if you like, as a result of the ferocious economic blizzard that hit the country in 1956, as was admitted by the Taoiseach last week during the debate on the Supplementary Estimate for Agriculture and which was still further aggravated by the Suez crisis, in spite of the fact that the February figures for unemployment were aggravated by those conditions, all that the Government have been able to achieve in the past 12 months, with those conditions gone and with very much more favourable conditions existing, is a reduction of 2,500 in the unemployed in the City of Dublin. At the same time—and I think it has been admitted—something like 57,000 people emigrated during the past 12 months. That is certainly not anything that can be put to the credit of this strong Government.
There was some talk yesterday about the increase in the cost of living, about whether the cost of living is increasing or not, or whether it has decreased by one point between August of last year and November of last year. The position is that, in 1956, between February and November of that year, the consumer price index figure rose from 132 to 134. In that bad year, it rose by only two points. Between the same dates in 1957, February and November, it rose from 135 to 142, that is, by seven points. That is the result of strong Government.
There has been an expansion of banking credit according to the documents that we have available, an expansion of something like £7,000,000. It would have been thought that if the banks, all of whom have raised their dividends, had increased their credit by £7,000,000, the net result of the injection of some of that money into business and industry would have made itself felt, either in the prosperity of business or in increased employment. Everybody knows the straitened conditions in which business is carried on at the moment and everybody knows the position of unemployment. The fact of the matter is that most of that £7,000,000 was secured by the Government and though, on the face of it, there appears to have been an increase of £7,000,000 in bank credit, very little of it was given to business, industry or agriculture.
In the months from June to November, the number of State-aided new houses declined from 5,291 in the year 1956 to 3,241 in the year 1957, while, in November of last year, the number was less than half that in November of the previous year. The volume of industrial production in the second and third quarters of the year 1957 was less than that in the corresponding periods in the previous year, during which the economic blizzard was in full force.
The Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance pin their faith upon having equilibrium in our balance of payments. I hope they continue to do so and, if necessary, I hope they will have the courage to take the steps we had to take in order to achieve that equilibrium; but may I point out the result, and I hope it is only a temporary setback, in January of this year during which this strong Government was in office? The January figures for our external trade show some disquieting features. Cattle exports are considerably reduced as compared with the same period in the previous year. Over £3,000,000 of our exports of last year were due to the export of butter. Are we to rely upon balancing our international payments on the export of butter that we cannot sell here?
In the year that is just ending, international commodity prices have been falling. They are down by a significant percentage, by about 11 per cent., from the beginning of 1957 to the present time as compared with the previous year; so that, with import prices tapering off at least, if not actually coming down, and with import prices now possibly lower than last year, we ought to have had some better results economically and we certainly ought to have had some reduction in the cost of living. If those trends in international commodity prices continue and if import prices continue to come down, even Fianna Fáil will not be able to prevent a reduction in the cost of living.
I have given some, not by any means all, of the criticisms that can be made of the fruits of this strong Government's policy over the past 12 months. I could go on in greater detail into this, but my purpose here is not so much to criticise the Government. That is necessary; it is part of our duty and part of the democratic process that we should criticise when criticism is required; but what is really required and what is really essential is that there should emerge from our discussion here some sort of hope and some sort of policy for the future. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance seem to count it a virtue when they say that they are determined to balance our Budget: "We are determined to balance our Budget; we are determined to produce equilibrium and balance in our international payments." That is not the beginning and the end of all economic and financial policy. That, of itself, may be very virtuous economically and financially, but it will not produce employment and it will not stimulate business.
We have had, necessarily, in the past few years a very considerable amount of restriction; but we had a very considerable amount of it unnecessarily between 1952 and 1954, as a result of the Budget in 1952. It is about time that a little bit of expansion was tried. What is the good of having a balanced Budget and having your international balance of trade in complete equilibrium, if you have mounting unemployment, increased emigration, falling business and a depressed agricultural community? There must be something wrong and it is about time that the Minister for Finance and his colleagues in the Government proceeded to mould their economic and financial policy towards expansion and development rather than restriction.
It will be admitted by all economists that a very small and temporary disequilibrium in our balance of payments may be necessary in certain conditions in order to achieve the necessary stimulant to expansion in business, industry and agriculture and that such a slight disequilibrium is a small price to pay for achieving that object. It had been our policy, when the international balance of our external trade was achieved, to build upon that solid foundation, and it was the view of the then Minister for Finance that the way to achieve some measure of prosperity was, having achieved that sound basis, by means of the greatest possible permissible amount of capital expenditure on productive enterprises to achieve the expansion so urgently necessary. We were not given the opportunity of putting that policy into operation. It is about time the Minister did it.
There is a limit to what can be done by Government in the way of capital expenditure, but nevertheless I am convinced of the necessity for having that capital expenditure on productive enterprises at the highest possible level. It seems to be the catch-cry that Government expenditure is too high. The level of Government expenditure is the mark of economic sanctity. That is what makes you a good conservative in the eyes of certain sections of the community. Even Deputy Haughey paid lip-service to that doctrine yesterday, though he carefully added that he did not regard the keeping down of Government expenditure as some kind of magic and sacrosanct in itself. While we must keep in existing circumstances the capital expenditure of the Government at the highest possible level, provided that expenditure is on productive purposes, at the same time, there is a most urgent necessity to create conditions in which the private sector of the economy may give its full—or perhaps I should say, less ambitiously, its fuller—contribution to the desired economic development of the country in existing circumstances.
It is about time all controls were taken off the private sector of the community. It is of the utmost importance that that private sector, private business and private enterprise, should have sufficient capital to enable it to expand. That capital can be acquired only by decreased taxation. It can be acquired only by increasing the purchasing power of the money in the hands of the ordinary people. You cannot get that increase in capital and expansion in business, unless there is a reduction in taxation. You cannot get that increase in business activity which can give its full and essential contribution to the ending of unemployment and emigration and the development of the country, unless we can get foreign capital in here. We have been preaching that doctrine for years, the doctrine of the necessity for getting foreign capital in here.
We did apparently convert the Minister for Industry and Commerce to our point of view some years ago. You will not get any foreign capital here so long as you present to American or English industrialists, who may be tempted to come over here, three or four statutes of a complicated character which are frightening them off and which the most expert lawyer in the Bar Library will not try to interpret. We have been prevented, to an extent that God only knows, from getting capital to our advantage here in building up our undeveloped resources, our industry and agriculture. God only knows the amount of capital we have lost because of the Control of Manufactures Act.
Speak to any American industrialist and tell him "Do not mind them. You can get over it. There are devices of which any lawyer of a few years' standing will tell you to enable you get over those Acts. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has full power to give you a licence." He will wave you aside and say: "Government control. We will not adopt fraudulent devices. We are coming in on our own merits, on our own money and in our own way." Until that is stopped we shall not get into the country sufficient foreign capital to make any indentation on our problems. Until we get foreign capital here we shall all the time be starved of capital and be in the position that we cannot finance worth-while schemes that are at hand to be done, even by private enterprise, if only the necessary funds were available.
Lower taxation, availability of capital, restriction of control and, as soon as possible, the reduction of the bank rate. What is the justification of the continuance of the bank rate now? Why should we have to pay 7 per cent. because the British appear to be in trouble? It would seem that the efficacy of the raising of the British bank rate for the purposes they have in mind has been practically admitted to be of little avail. The bank rate should be reduced at the earliest possible moment.
It does not devolve on us as an Opposition to put forward at this stage, clear, definite, detailed points of policy. The present Government took office under conditions far different from those that I outlined, and very shortly indicated, which we had to face. They faced the condition when they came into office that the balance of payments had been rectified, that they had a basis upon which they could have built very solidly and very soundly for industrial and agricultural expansion. They had a policy ready-made and tailored to the conditions then existing, which we handed on to them and which they took and put into operation in part.
The Suez crisis had ended. They had not to meet the conditions when they went for a loan that we had to meet. The day after it opened the British bank rate was increased and any chance we had of getting capital was practically destroyed. World conditions were different, more money was available and there was less international tension. Those conditions, under which they have operated in the last 12 months, were far more beneficial to economic expansion than the conditions which faced the inter-Party Government in the 15 or 18 months before they left office.
The only results of 12 months of this so-called strong Government—that has its clear majority, that can do anything, that can snap its fingers at the Opposition, that has had ample leisure during the last 12 months and ample freedom from parliamentary work to devise a sufficiently effective and forward policy—are something very little short of chaos in the agricultural industry, little hope for the ending of unemployment, scant hope for the reduction of taxation and no hope for the ending of emigration.
Comment on this
With your permission, Sir, I want at this stage to lodge a protest on behalf of the Independent Deputies. This debate has been on now for nearly nine hours. In that period, nine Deputies, representative of the Parties in the House, have spoken. I have been present here for something like six hours of that period and I have offered myself on a number of occasions to the Chair to speak. I think it is a most undesirable line of approach that all the back benchers of the various political Parties are getting preference now over the Independents. It is a very bad way to treat Independent Deputies, who may have views that are not in agreement either with the Government or the Opposition. I want to express that view on behalf of Independent Deputies.
Comment on this
I would point out that the Chair at all times endeavours to call speakers from the different Parties in the House and to afford an opportunity for the expression of different viewpoints. While I have sympathy with Deputy McQuillan's point of view, I would point out that, since the debate on the Vote on Account commenced, the following speakers have been heard from the various Parties: four Fianna Fáil, three Fine Gael, one Labour and one Clann na Talmhan.
In addition to taking into consideration the number who have spoken for each Party, the Chair must also take cognisance of the time factor, and in this instance, the time occupied by the various speakers has been: Fianna Fáil, 2 hours, 19 minutes; and all others, 6 hours, 5 minutes. The Deputy will be called as soon as possible, as the Chair is always prepared to give Independents every possible assistance.
Comment on this
I wonder would it be possible to get a series of long playing records here so that Deputies on both sides could record to-day what they will say for the next five years?
Comment on this
First of all, I want to deal with the charges that have been made by the Opposition that during the course of the general election the Fianna Fáil Party made all sorts of specious promises suggesting there were no difficulties that could not be immediately overcome and promising the people of this country that all the problems left to them by the Opposition when they were in office, could be solved in a moment of time.
We have already had the experience of Coalition election promises, of the promises made in 1954 to reduce prices, to reduce taxation, to build up agricultural production and industrial production. We had a welter of these promises in 1954, none of which materialised and all of which were broken in fact. As a Party with long experience of dealing with Coalition propaganda, we were quite determined that in the general election we would speak our minds honestly to the people of this country.
I have been going through all the speeches made in the general election by those Deputies who are now Ministers and I find their realistic and plain speeches were something of which we can be proud. I have been through all the speeches since the 21st February and I can find in no single utterance by any Minister a suggestion that these problems could be solved or that work would be found for hundreds of thousands of people overnight.
Most of the Ministers in almost every speech pointed out the difficulties that had to be met. They pointed out that any policy for bringing about greater production and employment must of necessity be of a long term character. The only promises made of an immediate character were that, as far as possible, we would put into operation housing grants and provide money for roads, the issues of which had been rapidly declining in the latter months of 1956. Over and over again it was stressed that it would take time and would require to a greater extent than ever before the effort of the people themselves to overcome the difficulties.
Many of the problems related to marketing; many to getting costs down; many related to exporting more goods at lower cost, overcoming difficulties that would arise when the world boom ended and to overcoming difficulties that had arisen because of increases in taxation that had made costs too high in many spheres of economic life.
The Taoiseach himself—and he needs no commendation or praise from me because he is beyond that—was extraordinarily scrupulous in all his speeches. He was scrupulous in pointing out that it would not be easy to overcome the work of the Coalition Government, of people who did not know their own mind, people who had dissension among themselves. Right from the beginning to the end of the election campaign he stressed the difficulties that had to be faced and said that we must have faith, that just as we had overcome the difficulties of 1952, just as we had met the problems left us by the Coalition Government of 1951, if we got the whole people behind us we could eventually triumph again.
I should like to quote from many of these speeches. I do not think it necessary to record them all merely for the sake of repetition but as I went through the election, from one week to another, I found that, if anything, the warnings of the difficulties became more insistent towards the end than at the beginning. Every effort was made to persuade the people that it would take a very considerable time to provide all the solutions to the many problems that faced us. I then examined official Party political statements, many hundred thousand copies of which were circulated and in which the whole of the promises made by Fianna Fáil of a specific character were listed. I found that so far as those plans were concerned a great many of them have already been put into operation. Where we made a specific statement of what we would try to do immediately, we have been able to carry out promises we made of an immediate direct character. We did restart many forms of Government activity the grants for which had dried up. We did decide to make an examination of agricultural credit with all its complicated problems and that is now being done. We did decide to step up the anti-tuberculosis bovine campaign and that is being done. We did decide to put into operation the plans for promoting an agricultural institute and that is now being effected.
We did decide to go on with the promotion of turf burning power schemes. We did restrict food imports as far as possible, in order that we could produce the maximum for ourselves. We did take every step to cut down expenditure and to introduce economies wherever possible in Government administration. We did invoke further legislation in the Finance Act by reducing taxation on Irish company dividends. We did step up the remissions on taxation on the profits of exported goods; we did modify the import levies, abolish many of them, and stabilise some of them in the form of permanent revenue duties.
Plans for expanding forestry plantation are in preparation and are likely to be announced in the course of the discussion on the Estimate. Tariffs to give further employment in industry have been imposed in considerable numbers. Encouragement to foreign investment has been given by changes in the Control of Manufactures Act and the issue of a new Act to deal with that question. We did get the Small Dwellings Acts loans and the grants going again and we paid the many people to whom money was owed at the time we reached office. We have ensured as far as possible that capital should be available for productive purposes.
Those were specific promises which we made in the general Fianna Fáil Party statement. Those promises have already been fulfilled as far as possible in the light of the Budget situation we had to face when we took office. There was nothing more in the official Party programme than the items I have mentioned; there was no further specific promises made guaranteeing to do certain things other than those I have mentioned and in every case those promises have been fulfilled or else in certain cases the problems are under very active consideration.
It is not easy to fulfil all of them. We found a Budget deficit, a position in which it was extraordinarily difficult to raise money for any purpose. We found a position in which previous loans issued for State capital purposes had not been filled; we found ourselves in the middle of a crisis in which there was a large number of unemployed. In the light of the circumstances we found we did not break any specific promise made in the general Party statement issued in thousands and thousands of copies all over the country and upon which we stood.
Apart from that, we made it perfectly clear that the rest was a long term job and that it would take time to deal with it. I want to make it quite clear so that nobody can have any doubt in regard to the present problems we have to face here. The easy work of increasing production and stimulating employment has been completed; most of the projects were devised by Fianna Fáil. Naturally one always begins in the life of a new State with the easy things. There are very few things we can do of a dramatic kind such as we did in our earlier period of office. All the easy tasks have been completed and all those Fianna Fáil projects are still in operation—such as protection for new industries, grants for new industries, grants for industries in western areas, the first Fianna Fáil land reclamation grant, the first soil analysis, encouragement of tillage, encouragement of housing, rural electrification, building of new power stations burning turf. All those plans to assist the country to increase employment and production or the great majority of them were devised by Fianna Fáil and are still in operation.
The easy work of that kind as I have said has been done in a large measure. There may be other dramatic proposals that will come before the people from time to time; there may be other and dramatic successes, but we rely largely now on work which requires not only the assistance of the Government but the initiative of the people. We have to keep our costs down if we are going to export. We have to encourage people to believe that this is a country with a stable economy into which investments will flow. We have to meet the many changes in world conditions that will come upon us now that, at least for a period, the world boom is over.
I might add that during the election conflict at the end of 1956, during the by-elections of that period and even during the general election, there were no general signs of the end of a world boom. There were some economists who predicted that the mounting employment in America, mounting exports and mounting production may have reached their maximum figure but there were no facts upon which we could rely which would suggest that within a year of gaining office we would begin to face a new series of difficult conditions which would affect not only this country but every country in Europe. None of us knows how long the recession in the United States will continue. It may be only of short duration but, nevertheless, there has been a change in the economic climate which will be as big a change as that which took place after the second world war had ended. And, just as everything was only to easy for us from 1947 until 1955, just as during that period it was only too easy to postpone all the major problems relating to marketing, investment and production, so now we find that we are facing immediate difficulties, immediate challenges to our initiative, immediate challenges to our capacities to compete on more difficult terms in respect of nearly every export that we have.
We also face the position that the period of easy money that was obtainable during most of the last ten years, obtainable from the sale of our foreign savings, obtainable by our being able to incur foreign liabilities against those savings, has ended. We in Fianna Fáil were not responsible for this. During our brief period of office from 1951 to 1954 we did our best to stay the loss of our savings. Many of us at that time made speeches, which were laughed at by the Opposition, pointing out that it was essential to maintain these reserves for the time when the post-war boom would end so that there would be savings available both for investment and for meeting trade recessions when they came. The fact remains that during the whole of those six years every effort made by Fianna Fáil to warn the people of this country that they must preserve their reserves for productive investment was laughed at by the Coalition Parties. Now we face a position when a great deal of productive investment has got to be effected through our own savings or else through the money that we can encourage to come from abroad to help us to start factories for our export trade.
During that period, because it was so easy to spend saved-up money, the people, encouraged by the Coalition, got the impression that they could vote themselves a higher standard of living, that wages and salaries could go up without prices going up in their turn, that wages and salaries could go up without our having to face permanent increases in costs that are inevitable in the case of an island community with extra freight costs and with all the additional difficulties that affect both the Twenty-Six Counties and the Six Counties in varying degree. We now have to face all those problems and overcome them.
It would be far more profitable to talk about methods of encouraging both employers and workers to establish incentive bonus schemes in factories from which both employers and workers could benefit in order to keep down costs, in order to stimulate industrial exports, in order that a great many factories that have not yet had an opportunity to export can do so than to try to charge Fianna Fáil with making promises at elections.
If we could have members of the Opposition telling us and informing us as to the degree to which the present Minister for Industry and Commerce has failed, if they think he has failed, in stimulating that kind of talk among industrialists, the Opposition will be doing immense service. They would find it difficult because, ever since the election, all those of us who have any experience of business have been going around the country encouraging people to think of incentive bonus schemes, methods of increasing productivity and reducing costs in order to get into markets where we have no access at the moment, in order to maintain markets that we have in the event of reducing prices.
That is the kind of task we have to face and, as I have said, it is not dramatic talk that will get us anywhere; it is not talking about broken promises in an election; it is not making grandiose phrases about not paying too much attention to the balance of payments that will get us anywhere. It is the hard work of exploring new markets and of encouraging the people to explore markets themselves. The reorganisation effected by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in CÓras Tráchtála Teoranta, the explorations being made by that body, are all far more important to the people than anything in relation to the recent arrangements for wheat. These are the fundamental problems that we have to deal with—collaboration between employers and workers who will have the courage to face increases of production without the fear of workers becoming redundant, which is now affecting many groups of workers and employers alike, who in many cases are afraid to take the steps necessary for fear that, instead of production increasing and exports increasing, the workers will simply be fewer in number. These are the difficulties we have to face.
In connection with agriculture, we have an agricultural marketing committee which is investigating the immense problems that affect our agricultural exports, problems in the case of almost every product where there is competition on a foreign market, problems of regularity of supply, of standard packing and grading, problems of advertising, the difficulties of overcoming the freight costs which our competitors do not have to meet in a great number of instances.
There are many heartening signs of progress. Many new types of exports have been initiated in the last 12 months in our industries. We have had agriculturists who proceeded on their own with new exports. For instance, the plans that have been announced in Wexford for the export of fruit juice is one small example of the kind of progress that we have to make in a great many different directions. There is another example of the kind of progress we can make. There was a firm which succeeded in 1956 in exporting feed oats to the West Indies in terms of hundreds of tons and found that this year the farmers grew too few oats to enable them to achieve the supply they require in order to continue that trade.
There are, for example, opportunities for the export of fishery products which are a perfect illustration of the problem which affects this country. It is not a dramatic problem but one which requires continued investigation and hard work and effort by everyone concerned. It is only a very tiny section of our trade; it is the export of what are known in this country as Dublin Bay prawns to the U.S. where there is a very ready market available but they all have to be of one particular size and have to be caught in the right kind of waters. The catches have to be very rapidly deep frozen and the trade contacts have to be made with the U.S. of an acceptable character. These are difficult marketing problems that are a challenge to us and that have to be overcome if we are to swell our exports and, as a result, give the kind of employment which will help to do something to ease the problems of unemployment and emigration.
There has been a kind of despondency which has settled over the people of this country from the beginning of 1956, and which I hope is passing away, because of the impression that has been created that we seem to be isolated in regard to this difficulty of high emigration and high unemployment. It is a challenge to us to realise that the people of the Six Counties, with overwhelmingly greater advantages in many respects, have exactly the same kind of problems as we have. Anybody who has read the Ibec Report on economic conditions in the Six Counties will find that in many instances they could substitute the Twenty-Six Counties for the Six Counties and then appreciate that the problems here are the same, the difficulty of bringing capital into an island community, the high freight rate costs across the Channel, the small home market. All those difficulties affect the whole of the 32 counties. They are the challenges to our island community.
It is no good trying to deceive the people by trying to make it appear there is an easy solution or that Fianna Fáil ever promised that they could solve the problems with ease. All these problems must be overcome by hard work and by Government action in the form of finance, in the form of marketing assistance, but they must be overcome. I believe that with time we can overcome them. One of the most heartening things one can see is the number of people engaged in economic activities of practically every kind covering almost every commodity from bacon to aluminium wire, to fruit juice, to seed oats, to almost every type of activity in every industrial field, who have succeeded in overcoming these difficulties, who are able to compete abroad with other countries and who are able to increase their exports.
The job of this Government is to give the greatest possible aid to expand the numbers of persons engaged in those successful enterprises. If we could have a debate based on those technical and marketing problems and have suggestions made to enable us to get over our difficulties we would be doing more for the people of this country than by making a blind accusation against the Government that we made wild promises during the election when in fact every one of us, so far as we could do so, warned the people that it would be a long uphill task.
The Government in the Budget of 1957 took several steps to aid the export of our produce and to encourage foreign investment. Since then in every single month successive steps have been taken in that direction. The marketing of our agricultural produce abroad is the greatest single problem we face. The Agricultural Committee is working on that and, as I have said, we may have to make changes which at the moment seem not feasible in order to ensure growing agricultural exports. There are many steps that may have to be taken of a kind we have not taken before. Consideration will have to be given to their practicability.
For example, in the increase of certain agricultural exports it is so necessary to guarantee the supply of the right product at the right price, graded and packed in the right way, that preference may have to be given to the export market even at the expense of the home market in order to ensure that an export can be set going and that it can be regularly supplied. It would be a wonderful thing if, instead of wrangling over the price of cigarettes, the price of tobacco and the price of drink, we had been wrangling over the far more serious problems of trying to provide such an expansion of exports in a seller's market that we would form a marketing organisation that would ensure that when competition came the machinery would then be in existence to enable those exports to continue, that there would be if necessary a saved-up levy fund available during the time when prices were high to save the difficulties the Exchequer now meets in paying subsidies on exports.
We never had that climate of opinion in this country. The Coalition were too much determined to keep people thinking how they could vote themselves a higher standard of living now, how they could get cheaper drink and cheaper tobacco, while all the serious issues of building up economic strength to face competition were postponed and postponed and postponed. During our brief three years of office with a very uncertain majority the most we were able to do was to stabilise the financial position and leave this country in a better position financially to face the prospects of meeting greater competition later on.
I do not intend to deal with all the issues in this Vote on Account. I merely want to try to bring the debate back to reality, to the realisation that this country has to develop in a very short period of time many of the elaborate marketing systems that have been in operation in other small countries for a generation or more. It is simply a question of whether the people wish to have that form of organisation, whether they are prepared to make changes in habits and methods of a very drastic kind in order that we can export many of these products. That is the real problem that faces us and let us get down to it now and stop talking nonsense about what the Government were supposed to have promised during the general election.