We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 1–202 of 385. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In discussing this Estimate I was referring to the figures in the Statistical Survey and to the appalling situation which is disclosed from the point of view of unemployment, education, our health and social services generally, our agriculture and industry. However, probably the most disturbing feature, even more disturbing than any of those, and God knows they are bad enough, is the point referred to by Deputy Costello, the Leader of the Opposition. That was the general feeling amongst reasonable people who are prepared to accept the evidence of their own eyes and ears that there is a very precipitate loss of faith by the people generally in their politicians and in the effectiveness of parliamentary democracy.

In regard to emigration, unemployment, health, education, and so on, it is possible that we have not yet gone beyond the point of no return and that something may be done to create prosperity and a just social order. Our people were always politically conscious and very jealous of their political rights, in relation to the last general election when with the formation of the Government at that time there were Deputies who were pledged not to sit in this House.

The continuous drop in the polls in recent elections in respect of all political Parties—no Party is exonerated—is probably the most disturbing feature of all in a gloomy litany of unfortunate facts which we must admit here. That our people should be beginning to lose faith in parliamentary democracy is one of the most frightening developments of our history but in the light of the people's experience I find it difficult to blame them. I do blame them, of course, because if they hand up their right to form or displace Governments they merely surrender to the incompetence and inefficiency of the politicians. In that way it is a retrograde decision on the people's part, but at the same time it is difficult to place the entire blame on them. It is easy to attribute that development to a long list of promises made and broken by political leaders over the years. I think it is certainly due to some extent to the fact that on one side they have heard: "Lower taxes, better prices and better times for all"; while on the other side they have heard: "We will get your husbands back to work" and slogans of that kind which were ill-conceived, ill-considered and designed primarily and solely as vote-catching media.

To some extent the people's present attitude is due to that but I think that more than anything else it is due to the fact that our political leaders have failed the public in respect of every single one of their promises, with, perhaps, the exception of slum clearance. They have created in the public mind the certainty that they are not able for the jobs they set themselves. If it was the solution of Partition, Partition remains stronger than it ever was. I would have thought that those who vehemently and with deep emotion favoured the ending of Partition by any reasonable means would have seen that the fundamental changes in our economic policy which I have suggested and which the Tánaiste, Deputy Lemass, suggested only two years ago were first necessary. I would have thought they would have seen that radical changes were required as regards State investment in manufacturing industries, even at the price that would demand, that is the interference with the rights of the business minority, wealthy or otherwise, which seems to dominate the activities of the Government and its predecessors, even at the expense of hurting these people in their pockets for the sake of our own nation, our unemployed and potential emigrants, I thought they would recognise the need for the radical changes which the Taoiseach referred to in 1930 when he said that if we did not get prosperity within the system he would go outside it. Surely the case has been made for the Taoiseach to go outside the system which has been tried with such diligence and dedication by people who believed in the private enterprise system——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy advocating radical changes which require legislation?

Comment on this

Changes in Government policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Changes that would require legislation?

Comment on this

No, Sir, a change in the attitude to the use of capital investment. If the Government had increased the allocation of capital for capital development in the Budget it would have been possible to do it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Without alteration in the legislation?

Comment on this

I do not think it would necessarily have meant a change in the legislation. However, I am talking on broad general principles and saying that if this Government could not see its way to do this on behalf of our own people then they should do it for the solution of the problem in which they have always been first to declare their genuine interest. I think it can be said of the Taoiseach that he has always insisted on his genuine anxiety—I am sure it is genuine—to see the end of Partition. They should have realised that one of the prerequisite conditions for the union of wills which the Taoiseach has spoken of, the ending of Partition by agreement, is the establishment of prosperity down here, first of all, a prosperous society and then a levelling-out of differences in relation to our social status. All these things are needed before there can be an end to Partition by the union of wills which we all wish to see. This could only mean the establishment of a welfare State here in order that the Protestant Unionist, the Catholic Nationalist or the Catholic Unionist would be agreeable to join with us knowing that he would not suffer in consequence as he would now most certainly suffer if he were to join with us certainly, in respect of social services, health services, educational services, old age pensions and other such amenities.

It surprises me that, even if it was not for the much better reasons, such as for the sake of our own people— reasons which appeal to me—but even for the reasons that would help to end Partition and make a real, tangible move towards ending Partition, the Taoiseach has not decided to make the changes needed in our economy, to create the full employment without which, of course, I think it is unrealistic to suggest that we could have a proper welfare State established.

We have failed without doubt. These people will not become second-class citizens or members of a second-class society from the social point of view. Our people have seen the political leaders promise that they could and would end Partition. The leaders have failed to do it even though they have had 35 years now to do it. We have also failed to realise another cherished objective of our political leaders, the revival of the Irish language. That is conceded apparently in the setting up of a commission——

Comment on this

I have the greatest respect for Deputy Ó Briain. I feel he is one of the few genuinely interested in the revival movement but I do not think anybody would try to hold that the attempts of successive Governments to establish the language as the spoken language of the people have not failed. We have failed in that object also and we have now set up a commission. It is as clear as could be to me—I do not know all the members of that commission—that because of its constitution it will not examine the case, the possibility of the language revival, or any new moves that should be taken to revive it, if it is possible to revive it, because they are persons whose minds are already made up. They are persons who are closely associated with the older approach to the language movement. They are not fresh minds or new minds, and will not bring any new or fresh approaches to the consideration of the whole problem.

We have failed to create prosperity in our primary industry, agriculture. There has been very little development in it, and very little expansion of it, considering mechanisation and the advance of mechanisation over the last 100 years. Mechanisation has not been used to the extent that it should have been used. Agriculture has not been used as a source of raw materials for our industries, and the products of agriculture and of fisheries have not been processed to the full extent as food. We have not developed agriculture to anything like the extent that it is capable of being developed.

We have made no attempt to find alternative markets to the very difficult and highly competitive British market. We have made little or no attempt to try to rationalise a marketing system for the farmer. We have made little or no attempt to help him in the establishment of co-operatives from which he could buy the raw materials of his industry, his seed, farm machinery and equipment. Like the rest of the consumers he is at the mercy of the rings, cartels and monopolies which put up the price of the raw materials of his industry, the machinery and implements which he uses. These rings, cartels, and monopolies make it very difficult for him to produce a competitively priced commodity. On the other side, the farmer is at the mercy of a chaotic marketing system and little or no attempt has been made to find new outlets for his products.

I suggested in the past that a number of newly developed colonial societies might have a sympathy towards us and, with modern methods of food preparation, deep freezing, packing and tinning, we would have gone much further and fared better by initiating trade with these new countries.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not anxious to interrupt the Deputy but surely that is a matter for the Department of Agriculture? One may not go over every Department on the Taoiseach's Estimate. The Taoiseach is responsible for major aspects of Government policy.

Comment on this

In relation to agriculture, it is clear that no policy has been devised by the Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I should like the Deputy to keep to major aspects and not to details.

Comment on this

No policy has been devised for the dynamic development of agriculture. We have failed in that regard also. It is clear that industry has not been developed to the extent that would absorb the young people who will be looking for employment, and also persons unemployed at present. I have already outlined the reason for that failure. It is the failure of private business, private enterprise, to create jobs. Our dependence on the private individual, our belief that prosperity can be achieved as a byproduct of the private individual's pursuit of wealth, has not been justified.

We have failed in regard to the development of another very important industry, the fishing industry. We are now told by the Minister for Lands that we shall need to develop deep water and middle distance fishing fleets.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely the Deputy is travelling over the administration of all Departments, and is trying to bring the fault, if there is one, home to the Taoiseach? These matters should be raised on the respective Votes when they come up.

Comment on this

In dealing with these things in a very general way I think the Taoiseach has responsibility for Government policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He has not responsibility for the administration of the various Government Departments. He is responsible for major aspects of Government policy. He is responsible to this House for that.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach asked us this morning to apply ourselves to a study of the Irish Statistical Survey which covered all aspects of Government, including the ones I have mentioned, and two I now propose to mention, unemployment and emigration. I think there will be no doubt at all that in relation to unemployment and emigration no solutions whatever have been found for these serious problems. I think that that is the source of the great dissatisfaction, demoralisation and bewilderment which exist.

I think Deputy Costello is quite right. He says there is a state of indifference to politicians, political Parties and parliamentary democracy. I think it is worse than that. The situation has developed into one of contempt for politicians, political Parties and parliamentary democracy. That is largely due to the fact that our political leaders over 35 years have made these wild promises to end Partition, to revive the language, to establish a prosperous agricultural industry, to end unemployment and emigration, and have achieved none of these things. I do not know why the Taoiseach should still think that he can, with any authority, come in here to lecture us on the best ways of solving our problems, or on the likely ways of solving our problems.

As a young man he failed. Certainly, certain achievements were made in the 30's and I am prepared, and always have been on all occasions, to say that advances were made in social legislation, health services, house building and the establishment of industries, but the Taoiseach cannot continue to free-wheel on the goodwill created in the country, by those few prosperous years, for the rest of his life. Without any doubt I think that a case has been made showing that the present Government has no solution whatsoever for the serious problems of Government. Even the Taoiseach must know now in his heart that he cannot offer any solution for these problems. As is pointed out in the survey, there is a crisis in our very existence as a nation. At the present rate of emigration the nation could cease to exist as an entity in about 30 to 40 years. Does the Taoiseach not think it is time that he handed over the wearisome burden of office to his younger, more active colleagues? He has them in his own Government. He surely cannot have so much contempt for them that he does not think they are capable of taking over government and initiating new, virile and dynamic policies. It is true to say that he was in at the birth of our nation, but is it now his ambition to be in at its death?

Comment on this

I have listened to Deputy Dr. Browne with great interest. While he has been speaking, I have been trying to fathom what is in his mind. I have come to the conclusion that it is a good job we have not many more Deputies in the House with the same outlook, because I can only describe it as the outlook of a man completely without hope. I would suggest and recommend to the Deputy that he should spend a little time in the library and, right from the beginning of the re-establishment of this nation 35 years ago, examine everything—the Budgets, the legislation, the different documents that will show him what type of industries we had— and to follow it up year by year.

Comment on this

Is it the type the Deputy brought back from America?

Comment on this

What type?

Comment on this

That is what I should like to know.

Comment on this

I do not know what Deputy McQuillan is talking about. Perhaps he would be a little more lucid? The Deputy is fond of interjecting something that means nothing—just a loud, empty voice. Perhaps Deputy McQuillan would join with Deputy Dr. Browne and see what has been created? I believe they would then come to the conclusion that great success has followed our efforts in the last 35 years, and particularly in the last 30 years. I do not understand this idea of saying everything has ended and that we are here now presiding over the end of this nation. I hope there is a little bit of pride amongst the vast bulk of the Deputies of this House and that they see that further great advances can be made, nationally as well as economically.

I do not know whether it is appreciated that the standard of living of our people has improved out of all hopes and expectations of those who saw the beginning of our State, with this part of the country anyway under its own Government. I have a clear recollection of the standard of living of the people in my own native city. I am happy to say that the standard of living of all of our people has improved. Even those who previously were unemployed, but who were desscribed as destitute, have benefited— not as much as we should like to see, but at least they have been raised considerably from the level in which we found them.

Talking of social services, look through the records and see, as each year followed each year, the development of social services. I do not know whether Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy McQuillan remember the workhouses that existed in this country. Have they now completely forgotten that such existed because they have not experienced it in their adult lives in the sense of seeing it? I am very happy to belong to the Party which is the present Government of the country because I am satisfied that genuine and honest efforts are being made, and will continue to be made, to make further advances in every sphere of activity here.

I rose particularly to refer to some remark made by Deputy Costello. During the course of his contribution to the debate, he singled me out and paid me a distinct honour. He said it was I, Deputy Briscoe, who had wrecked the housing policy of the Coalition Government. These were the words he used—that I had wrecked the housing policy by what I had said in the House, by what I had said in the corporation and by what I had said outside both these places. Does anybody believe that I, as a member of the Opposition, a back bencher, could have wrecked the housing policy of the Coalition Government, if they had a policy at all? What happened? When Deputy Costello's speech will appear in the verbatim report, it will contain the charge also that I had brought about in the corporation such restrictions in connection with the building of houses under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Acts that building had stopped. What were the facts?

During 1956 and 1957, local authorities, and in particular the one of which I am a member, the Dublin Corporation, were faced with a situation where we had a building programme which meant acquisition, clearance and development of sites, seeking tenders for schemes of two and, maybe, up to four- or five-roomed houses, submitting schemes to the Local Government Department for sanction and then asking tenders from contractors for the building of the houses. We went along those lines but we came to the point where, as far as ordinary contracts for housing schemes were concerned, in connection with housing schemes actually in the course of construction we had no money. We could not get money. I remember the matter was brought to a head when we sought a public loan. All Dublin Corporation public loans were always underwritten and guaranteed by the Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Candidly, I do not see how all this ties up with the Taoiseach's Estimate.

Comment on this

I am answering what was said by Deputy Costello. I want to show categorically that, if there was a wrecking of the housing policy under the Coalition, it was wrecked by themselves.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely that should be raised on the Vote for Local Government?

Comment on this

The Deputy would not come in and speak on the Vote for Local Government.

Comment on this

I do not know whether you were here when Deputy Costello was speaking, Sir. I took the precaution of going up to the office in this House and I read the proof of Deputy Costello's speech. It is in this regard he made his reference to me. As from to-morrow, when the verbatim report is circulated, there will be a statement by Deputy Costello on the records of this House that it was I, Deputy Briscoe, who had brought in new restrictions attaching to Small Dwelling (Acquisition) Acts loans. I want to say that these restrictions were brought in by order of the Coalition Government. In the financing of small dwellings, at one stage we owed £800,000 to the people who were building these houses for borrowers. We had not got that money. The Government then made available £1,000,000 which enabled us meet our obligations to the extent of £800,000, but we were only then enabled to allow a further £200,000 worth of houses to be built—some 100 houses.

What were the restrictions laid down by the Coalition Government? I am sorry Deputy O'Donnell is not here. I am sorry Deputy Sweetman is not here. They were the members of the Government then. They received deputation after deputation from representatives of the Dublin Corporation. I was one of the members of the deputations. When we were asking and giving facts about these things, they withdrew the right of the corporation to give money for loans for private houses if the applicants did not qualify for a supplementary grant. The matter was so serious that I took the best advice I could at the time from colleagues of my own as to what could and should be done in order to stop the rot that was setting in.

The failure of the Coalition Government in the question of housing in Dublin City was well recognised by the ordinary citizen of the city. The Minister for Local Government yesterday, in answer to a question by Deputy O'Donnell, gave the actual figures of moneys withheld by the Local Loans Fund from the other local authorities.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have given the Deputy a certain latitude——

Comment on this

This Government has restored complete confidence——

Comment on this

You are building all the houses now.

Comment on this

In the next few years we shall, thank goodness, have built all the houses that are needed. We shall continue to build houses as they are needed to meet obsolescence or even further natural growth of the population.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should now come to the Taoiseach's Estimate.

Comment on this

I do not know to what extent the Taoiseach's Estimate is or is not responsible for the policy of restoring the availability——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is Local Government administration.

Comment on this

The Government has restored the availability of finance to enable local authorities to do their job properly and to the extent to which it is needed to be done by them. I listened to the speech made to-day by Deputy Dr. Browne. Other Deputies have also spoken.

Comment on this

Very few other Deputies.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. Browne spoke as if there were no confidence in this Government. There was the suggestion that people were becoming contemptuous or negligent of their responsibilities as citizens with regard even to the election of members of this House. There was the suggestion that there is grave disappointment.

Comment on this

There is despair.

Comment on this

There is no despair now.

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this

There is no despair now. There is a re-awakening of hope in the people. The people are not so stupid as to accept what Deputy Dr. Browne suggests, namely, that you can accomplish in any year or in the lifetime of any Government all your aims and ambitions and that you can have everybody satisfied and everybody happy.

Comment on this

You want about 40 years.

Comment on this

We would want about 500 years if Deputy McQuillan's Party were ever to come along.

Comment on this

At the rate at which you are going, nobody will be left in the country.

Comment on this

The census of population will show that the population of this country has not fallen to any extent. It is true that, as a result of emigration in every year of all the years about which we have been talking, the population of the country has been kept static.

Comment on this

It is lower than ever this year. The Taoiseach has the statistics before him.

Comment on this

As a result of what? Since when?

Comment on this

Ask the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I am asking the Deputy to get up and substantiate what he is saying.

Comment on this

I shall, when I speak.

Comment on this

The Deputy should know now the extent to which the population of the City of Dublin will listen to his advice. The Deputy had an experience for the first time in his life of participating in an election in Dublin City. He has learned that probably he will be more successful in the constituency to which he belongs.

Comment on this

I shall be back here again, too.

Comment on this

I did not say the Deputy would not. What I said was that the Deputy has learned by experience that the citizens of Dublin are not prepared to swallow him.

Comment on this

They did not swallow much from Fianna Fáil in the last by-election.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy McQuillan must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

I am trying to help Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this

Or to encourage him.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not realise that the people of the Twenty-Six Counties have now put into Government a Party with an absolute majority?

Comment on this

All the worse for the country.

Comment on this

All the worse for the Deputies opposite. It will be much worse for the Deputies opposite the longer we stay in office. I believe that, at the end of the period of office of this Government, a few Parties will be forgotten about and that there will be others much smaller even than when they came into this House this time.

Why do some people not accept decisions? The people of the country have stated clearly: "We have had enough of Coalitions. We have had two experiences of them. We have now restored single Party Government. Single Party Government is now being given an opportunity of trying to do, within the resources at its disposal, the best it can for the people of this nation." When the end of the period of office of this Government is reached, and when another election is held, it will be for the people to judge whether or not further progress has been made.

I am quite satisfied, and I say it without any reservations, that since the re-election of Fianna Fáil as a Government public confidence has been restored; hope is in the minds and hearts of the people; progress is being made every day, at what pace one cannot say exactly, but certainly, as year will follow year of the period of office of Fianna Fáil, the creation of new industries will follow and increased employment will follow; I hope a fall in the emigration figures will follow.

I am not prepared to follow the lines of thought of Deputy Dr. Browne and to say that everything is ended and that this country is finished. I do not know if people study problems that arise in other countries. Some of the wealthiest nations in the world with most progressive people, with the most up-to-date methods of production in every industrial commodity, and so on, have ups and downs. They have seasonal periods of unemployment. Numbers of their citizens undergo unemployment. We are doing the best we can for those of our people who are at the very lowest level and we hope, as time goes on, to do more.

Deputy Dr. Browne talked against private enterprise. It reminded me of the first few months of office of the first Coalition Government. What did we have then? We had definite expressions of hostility and objection to the development of the tourist trade. We had expressions of opinion to the effect that these foreigners should not be allowed to come in here to take the bread and butter off the table of our people. We had the destruction of our trans-Atlantic air service because it was said that this was a prestige project and that the only people who would be able to use it would be millionaires from other lands. Our trans-Atlantic air service was destroyed and our equipment sold.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy please come to the Vote?

Comment on this

Tell us what Gladstone said years ago.

Comment on this

I am not saying what Gladstone said but I am saying what the Deputy and his colleagues said.

Comment on this

What did we say?

Comment on this

You would not allow tourists. You would not allow private enterprise to have profits from the creation of industry. You have now learned that tourism is a good thing for the country. I think Deputy Lynch will agree with me on that.

Comment on this

I do not agree that the Coalition Government tried to do away with tourism.

Comment on this

Read the speeches of Deputy Dillon and Deputy Norton.

Comment on this

Quote.

Comment on this

I say that they said it. We have now reached the stage where we accept the incentive of profit for private enterprise and we no longer say that the entrepreneur should be put in gaol. I should like to point out to Deputy Dr. Browne and to Deputy McQuillan that we have a Constitution which is the basis of our laws and which recognises the rights of private property.

Deputy Dr. Browne said that the only possibility of this country saving its people and securing unity between North and South was that we should become a welfare state. I do not think the Deputies on the opposite benches will subscribe to that. I think the question of Partition will ultimately be solved. I believe that if, in the North, they became an absolute welfare State, it would be one of the reasons why they would want to come down here and join with us where there is a real recognition of individual liberty and freedom.

The real reason I rose to speak was because of the references made to me by Deputy J.A. Costello. If it was correct that, instead of wrecking the policy of the Coalition Government, I had wrecked the Coalition Government itself I would be far better satisfied. That is what I believe was in the mind of Deputy Costello when he spoke.

Comment on this

Enthusiasm is no substitute for facts and still less for a lack of policy. Listening to some of the speeches here to-day one would be pardoned for labouring under the impression that some people think that talk in a particular manner or fashion can provide the remedy for some of the problems which affect the country. I believe that there is no quick or easy solution for many of the problems which confront the country. Some of these problems are peculiar to this country; others have similarities with problems elsewhere.

Looking at what has been accomplished elsewhere there is no indication that policies or programmes have been implemented rapidly to solve similar economic difficulties or to provide remedies for them. In no country in the world has a plan been adopted which provided for an absolute remedy for some of the problems comparable with those that exist here. We should endeavour to ascertain from facts and information at our disposal what is wrong with the policies that have been adopted, or the lack of policies or programmes in certain respects, and what changes are necessary or desirable in our national economic policy.

Much talk has been devoted to what has been called the twin problems of emigration and unemployment. Repeated references have been made to the statistics published in the recent statistical survey for 1957. Looking at some of the figures there certain interesting facts emerge. Table 23 on page 41 gives details of the census of population. Subsequent paragraphs refer to changes in the population during inter-censal periods. One of the significant and interesting conclusions made as a result of these figures is that the drop in population was less in the first decade of the State, between 1926 and 1936, than in the course of subsequent censuses.

On page 43 reference is made to the fact that the average yearly net emigration was higher between 1951 and 1956 than during any comparable period shown in the table and that the rate of net emigration per thousand of the average population increased steadily in each inter-censal period since the period 1926-36 when it stood at 5.6 per thousand. Subsequently, in the decade 1936-46 it was 6.3 per thousand of the population and in the period 1946-48 it was 8.2 per thousand. The censuses subsequently were more frequent and between the years 1951-56 the rate of emigration per thousand was 13.4. I mention these figures because I believe that whatever deductions can be drawn from them are not easily ascertainable by reading them. Experts, either economists or others qualified to evaluate returns impartially, should be requested to examine the significance of these returns and endeavour to ascribe, if it is possible to do so, the reasons for the variation over the last 36 years.

During the periods I have mentioned, with one exception, there has been a continuous decline in our population. The exception was for the census taken for the period 1946 to 1951. It may be that the rise, which was a comparatively small one of 6,000 persons, was due to the fact that that period coincided with the years immediately after the war when a number of people were obliged because of the war to remain in Britain and were unable to return home—there may be some explanation of that sort—but the significant fact is that the rate of emigration per thousand was lower for the first census period 1926 to 1936, which embraces a period in which we had the first Fianna Fáil Government, and that the figures for subsequent periods, alternating between Fianna Fáil and the inter-Party, show a decline more or less comparable for each period.

I do not believe that any real progress can be made by tearing down or trying to tear down what is already being built up. On the other hand we should endeavour to discover from the published facts which are available in great detail in a variety of official publications, and where possible and necessary, make changes which are desirable and which will operate to improve the national economy.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

In discussing this Estimate it is not possible to consider in detail, but rather in general, aspects of Government policy or general economic policy as the case may be. The returns which are published for agriculture during the past year indicate a reasonably satisfactory result but that result can only be maintained if measures are taken to provide a basis for further expansion.

Reference has been made here on a number of occasions recently to the need for speeding up the measures for the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. I believe we have not realised sufficiently the urgency of that problem. Just four years ago the scheme was initiated. It commenced after the signing of the Grant Counterpart Agreement with the United States and compared with Britain, which is the principal market for livestock, we are many years behind. They have had over 20 years experience of intensive measures. I should like to hear from the Government what steps will be taken to speed up and to expand that service. When the scheme was initiated four years ago, the sum of money provided initially was probably sufficient to start it and additional sums have been provided since. However, in view of the declared policy that by 1960 many areas in Britain and a number of ports of entry will be cleared of tuberculosis and that animals not free from the disease will be refused entry into those areas, it behoves all of us in this country and the Government, as the responsible authority, to expedite, and do whatever is necessary financially to expedite, the expansion of that scheme.

The other matter concerning agriculture which I wish to mention is the Agricultural Institute. Just over four years ago I negotiated and signed the basic agreement with the United States ambassador for the use of the Grant Counterpart Fund. Although discussion had been proceeding for some years prior to the negotiation of that agreement, a great deal of talk and criticism flared up from a variety of interests, some of them vested interests, concerning the establishment of the institute. I refer to that for the reason that some of the most vocal critics of the delays, of the lack of progress and the failure to implement policies or programmes, are those who themselves by their action refuse to allow that institute to be established. Nobody presents reasonable criticism or even unreasonable criticism over a certain period but ultimately decisions must be taken and, although it is now just over four years since that agreement was signed, the institute is not yet established. Because of the criticism and objections made by a variety of interests the legislation to establish it was delayed. It was initially introduced in our time and the present Government has continued it and the Act is now law.

I notice that the necessary steps are being taken to establish the institute. I think it true to say in this matter that, whatever other criticism may be levelled at either or both Governments, the delay was not due to Government inactivity or lack of effort, planning, co-operation, or goodwill on behalf of any of the responsible authorities in the various Government Departments. But the delay in this case has extended already over a period of four or five or six years and now, with its establishment imminent, it will take another year or two before any worth-while results can be expected from the institute. It is a good thing, however, that the controversy has ended and that the institute is on the point of coming into existence. People who utilise the freedom which those without responsibility can use for the purpose of criticism, for the purpose of objecting to proposals which are made, should ponder the consequences of using that right without measuring fully the responsibility which should attach to it.

In the case of industrial development, the past year has seen little expansion apart from some increase in output. I believe it is now generally recognised that the weapon of protection as a means of developing industry has been exploited nearly to the full and that, in fact, in some cases, protection alone, while providing assistance for an individual industry or even for a group of industries, may create problems elsewhere. Quite recently an example of that sort occurred where a duty was placed on certain cotton goods. That duty has raised the price of a variety of articles of cotton to the trade generally, for the purpose of providing protection for an individual factory or one or two factories, as the case may be. I mention that because I believe that real progress in the future will have to be on different lines and that the highly competitive conditions which exist at present whether or not the Free Trade Area comes into existence —and that is extremely doubtful— make it imperative that efficiency, technical skill and knowledge should form the basis on which our industrial fabric should be framed.

There is general agreement in the House on the desirability of securing foreign investment and foreign technicians who have knowledge and experience. I do not believe we shall see any great contribution from foreign investment here and I think we shall have to rely, as in the past, to a very considerable extent on our own resources. We have had some notable examples of foreign technicians providing the know-how, technical skill and experience either in collaboration with Irish technicians or alone, and even in recent times we have had such examples in the case of the oil refinery and of those who have come to develop the mineral resources at Avoca, but on many occasions when we speak of the need for new industries we overlook our responsibility for maintaining existing ones and in some cases overlook the burdens placed on these industries either by the general level of taxation or by taxation in specific cases.

I want to refer to one matter discussed here on a few occasions recently. That is the decision to continue and, by reason of the Government's alteration of a decision, to maintain the duty on newsprint. That duty affects an industry that gives a great deal of employment directly and indirectly. It was originally imposed as a temporary measure to deal with the balance of payments problem but it was never intended to remain. It has recently been made permanent. That adds a burden to all industries in the country coming within the ambit of the duty, especially newspapers and periodicals using newsprint. That industry gives a great deal of direct employment and the indirect employment is probably even greater. It is a duty maintained at a time when encouragement and assistance are being offered to external investors to invest here. We are maintaining at this time a penal tax on an existing established industry.

Not merely is it a burden directly but the newsprint industry here has to compete with a very powerful industry of a similar nature in Britain that is enabled to flood this country with a variety of periodicals and newspapers and it has available far greater resources, a far larger reading population and, in consequence, is in a position to throw on to this market the surplus left over when it has satisfied its home needs. I therefore believe this is a special case in which a decision should be taken. I pressed the Minister concerned, the Minister for Finance, on it and he said it was not possible to revoke it this year, at any rate, because of the revenue factor involved. I understand the total amount involved is about £100,000 and, at the rate at which revenue was running this year, it is obvious that sum would not seriously affect the revenue return, while the advantages which would be derived from revoking the duty would be considerable.

Another industry which is sometimes referred to as offering great possibilities for expansion, and for which in this year's Budget a small sum of money was set aside for publicising it, is the distilling industry. That industry, in the main, provides male employment and draws its resources from home-grown materials. It has a great tradition behind it but it has to compete with one of the most financed competitors in the world, the Scotch distiller. I believe that the measures taken, both by this Government and the previous Government, are entirely inadequate to extend whiskey sales in the dollar market. I believe that not merely should further steps be taken but that the whole question of the level of taxation on that industry should be re-examined.

In seeking to encourage external investment here we have recently amended the Control of Manufactures Acts. I do not think anyone is entirely happy about the method in which that was done. In fact, it is questionable whether in some respects the whole atmosphere surrounding that discussion has not made the position worse, even if the actual statutory and legal position is somewhat better. No restrictions of any sort should be placed on the entry of foreign capital into this country. We have had extensive experience by different Governments of the comparative lack of success of our efforts in that sphere and I believe that the primary success of our industrial development will depend on our own exertions and our own capital. Whatever about the acquisition of technical knowledge or skill, in the main we shall have to rely on our own capital here. If we are to attract external investment no legislative provisions of any sort should be allowed to interfere, or even to give the suggestion that there is here what are regarded as bureaucratic and State restrictions which are so strongly resented, particularly in the United States and Canada.

The most pressing problem for a great number of people is the high and rising cost of living. The abolition last year of the food subsidies caused a very serious increase in the cost of bread, flour and butter. Over the last 12 months while there was an eight point increase, I think, in the consumer price index, the cost of food alone increased by 13 points. The cost of bread increased by approximately 50 per cent., flour by over 70 per cent. and butter by a considerable sum.

Subsequent to those increases transport charges have pressed heavily on users of the public transport system and, in addition, health charges have been increased, pressing on in most cases the same section of the people. While all are affected by increased prices charged for food, a great many of those who have been obliged to bear increased transport charges in the way of bus fares, have also been obliged to meet the increase in health charges because they are the people who come within that category. It is, therefore, important that no action of the Government should make that situation worse.

Recently we enacted a measure dealing with the purchase of tea. I do not want to go into the detailed administration of individual Departments, but this is a matter of general public interest. That measure confines the purchase of tea to a company set up under statute. I have read a letter which that company has sent to a tea trader who is not a member of it, informing him that if they are to provide services—and they are the only company authorised to import tea—they will charge 5 per cent. for those services. This man is not in a very large way of business but he said it would mean £18 a week additional in his case. That charge, of course, he will have to recover from the purchaser who is, in effect, the consumer.

I believe that any measure that affects a commodity so vital to the community, because this country is a very great consumer of tea—we consume in the region of between 22,000,000 and 24,000,000 lb. of tea per annum and I need not stress or elaborate on the importance of tea as a beverage in every household in the land—and anything that involves an increase in the price of that commodity because of a State decision, or the decision of a Government Department, is a matter that requires urgently to be re-examined.

The news in the last few days shows a a grave international situation because of events in the Middle East. Much of the unrest is of long-standing, aggravated by attempts to employ artificial remedies where an entirely different approach was, and is, essential. World events may have serious repercussions on this country. What is happening elsewhere is not passing unnoticed here and is influencing the minds of many people. So far as this country is concerned our interests and the interests of a great many, if not all, small countries lie in the preservation and maintenance of peace which is vital to our very existence. Many of the problems which exist in the world have their origin in mistaken policies adopted in the past. The area at present affected has been for a great number of years a source of potential trouble. We can only hope that the authority of the United Nations and the influence and power of the Free World will be such that world peace will be maintained.

As far as this country is concerned, the only remaining political problem is the solution of Partition. While differences arise on the method of achieving that aim, all Parties in the House and all sections outside are agreed on the aim of a united Ireland. Therefore, it is vital that care should be taken to ensure that national policy must be decided by Dáil Éireann and the Government responsible to the Dáil. Whatever decisions and actions are carried out must be based on the views of the majority of the people. While there is general agreement on the aim of ending Partition and of a united Ireland, differences have arisen in the past, and even exist at present, on how that aim may be realised. Public representatives in all Parties and those who have responsibility for guiding public opinion have in existing circumstances, and particularly in the light of the international situation, a heavy responsibility to see that public opinion is moulded and influenced in the right direction. It is not sufficient to say that nothing has been done about the Partition problem or that, because Partition still exists, the very existence of it entitles any group in the community to take whatever action they think is appropriate.

Frequently, too much attention has been paid to publicity and not enough to the requirements of a practical policy. Publicity may be useful or it may not. Where it wins sympathy and understanding for our objectives, it is beneficial but if it shows us in the contrary light, it is not helpful. Therefore, it is essential that we should realise that the solution of Partition, in common with a number of other problems, depends on our own exertions and on our own efforts. What has already been achieved here—the winning of freedom for the State established here—was, in the main, due to our own exertions and to the exertions of those who have gone before. With the exception of the very generous and welcome help extended by the United States and by our people in other countries, in the main, that success was due to our own efforts. Therefore, it is obvious from experience of our own history that the solution of the problem of Partition depends in the main of the people in both parts of the country.

We must seek to ensure that national policy is so directed that all sections are attracted to the idea and to the ideal of a united Ireland, that where necessary we should review existing policies or actions, continue those likely to lead to progress and reject those that have been found to lead nowhere or which fail to achieve what was expected from them. It is vital that no support should be given to any irregular force, no matter for what purpose. Anyone who, by the expression of opinion—and particularly those in public positions whose views carry weight—encourages these activities should ponder the consequences of his action.

Unfortunately, many of the mistakes made in the Middle East and in dealing with problems, including our own, are traceable to mistakes in British foreign policy over a long period. To proceed on the basis that conditions in the world to-day are the same as in the days of Palmerston is a contributory factor to many of the difficult problems existing in so many places. To-day, however, the dominant role in international affairs is played, not by Britain, but by the United States on the one hand and Russia on the other. The United States has repeatedly given evidence of a capacity for world leadership and it has not the colonial record that has been such a difficult legacy in the case of British foreign policy. We look with confidence tempered with anxiety, at the heavy responsibility which the Government and people of the United States have to bear, recognising that great sacrifices will have to be made to preserve the liberties of the Free World. What has been achieved by our own people can be extended, provided we show the same unity of purpose and the same determination to solve this problem as was shown in securing the establishment of an independent State for this part of the country.

The only other matter I should like to refer to is to ask the Taoiseach if he has any information on what progress has been made concerning the Lane pictures. Have there been any recent developments? One gathers the impression that not the same public interest is focussed on this matter as was the case some time ago. I should be glad to hear if any recent developments have taken place.

Comment on this

I was disappointed at the contribution of Deputy J.A. Costello this morning in so far as he went back again to the quite unfounded accusations that the members of the Party now forming the Government had, at the last election, held out promises of starting policies which would have immediate beneficial results on unemployment and emigration. The Taoiseach set the example, which was followed by all those of us who took part in that election. He made it perfectly clear that there was no easy solution for unemployment and emigration though these were two of the major problems facing the country. There was no magic touch-stone or magic formula whereby everything which was wrong would suddenly become right. Even if there were such, I cannot believe it would be healthy. The fact remains that, during that election and ever since, we made it perfectly clear that the only remedy is through the hard, unremitting labour not just of the Government but of every member of the public.

Reference was made by Deputy Dr. Browne to a loss of confidence in parliamentary institutions. I do wish that people in public life would not make such irresponsible statements. The only people who are constantly stressing this loss of confidence in parliamentary institutions is the small number of newspaper editors who have a rather over-developed imagination and also defeated politicians who feel that their defeat of their lack of success at a by-election is because the public have lost confidence in parliamentary institutions. It is not a fact. There is no reason to say that the poll at elections is steadily getting less and less. I grant that the poll at the last by-election was very low. There are numerous reasons for a low poll on that occasion but certainly it cannot be said that there was a loss of confidence in parliamentary institutions.

The very great majority of the people believe in parliamentary democracy. It is wickedly irresponsible of persons in public life to tell people that they have lost confidence in such institutions. Those of us in public life have a tremendous responsibility because the average member of the public is so easily led. If you tell the public that they have lost confidence, they will lose confidence simply because you have more or less told them to do so. I do not believe there is any spontaneous loss of confidence amongst the people at all and I should like to go on record to that effect.

Deputy Dr. Browne and also, I think, Deputy J.A. Costello referred to a general spirit of gloom and a lack of self-confidence in the country. Certainly, that was the case when this Government took office. It is never easy to find a remedy for a loss of morale. As I said on another debate, it is easy to start a slump but it is a shockingly hard job to stop it.

Comment on this

And it is particularly difficult for the creators to provide the solution.

Comment on this

The real trouble was that the creators of the slump decided they could take no further action. They dissolved the House and, therefore, they did not get a chance to find a solution or certainly to restore confidence. Having created a drastic trade recession, with mounting unemployment, they just walked out knowing that they had no solution.

Self-confidence is returning, though slowly. Once again, we find that business men are planning ahead with confidence. They are planning for export. They are planning for increased production. It is a very slow job.

I would be the first to admit that this is no time for complacency—and the Taoiseach has never given any indication that he thinks otherwise. At the same time, this is not a time for creating alarm and despondency. People who do so in this House or outside it are doing a very bad day's work for the country. Nobody on this side of the House is complacent for a moment about unemployment, emigration or anything else. We are trying to work steadily towards a known objective.

I appreciate that it is difficult for members of the present Opposition to speak on this Estimate with any great conviction. It must be disheartening for them as an Opposition, though I hope it is not disheartening for them in their private lives, to find that conditions are showing at least a tendency to improve. It is much easier for an Opposition if things are getting worse and worse. Where, however, the situation shows very definite signs of improvement, it makes it more difficult to offer either constructive or destructive criticism. For that reason, I was very glad to hear much of what Deputy Cosgrave said. I think he was making a very good effort to offer constructive and helpful criticism in some of the statements he made.

This improvement, such as it is, is due mainly to an increased atmosphere of political and economic stability in the country. The main trouble in the past, during the Coalition period, was that there was no stability. Nobody outside and possibly nobody even inside the political Parties concerned ever knew what the Coalition Government would do next. It was always the toss of a coin as to who would hold the whip hand at any moment.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know what he will do next?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I certainly do and that is to try to explain to this House, for the benefit of those who have not yet appreciated it, that what we are trying to do is to increase the confidence of people in themselves; to leave it to the private individual and to private enterprise to increase production both on the agricultural and industrial fronts and to increase employment, thereby striking one blow at least against emigration.

It would be so nice if we could just say: "These problems come under headings A, B, C and D, and it is as easy as all that." I think that Deputy T. Lynch knows in his heart and soul that there is not an easy way out. It is a matter of hard slogging at a consistent policy.

Comment on this

Then Deputy MacEntee was wrong when he said, while he was in Opposition, that it is the duty of the Government to formulate a programme whereby emigration can be stopped.

Comment on this

I imagine it is more than possible that the Minister for Health will speak on this Estimate and doubtless he will answer for himself. It is never easy for a back bencher to answer for a Minister as I am sure Deputy Lindsay well knows.

Mention has been made of Partition. I do wish that that word could be banished forever from the language. Deputy Cosgrave did mention the word but I was glad that he coupled with it the question of unity. The whole problem should be viewed purely as a matter of unity and disunity. I am convinced that if the Border went tonight, and if all British troops disappeared from Northern Ireland overnight, we would not be one inch nearer unity than we are to-day. What we must do is to unite people who are at present disunited. That is a difficult job in view of past and recent history. To get a spirit of unity in the country we need to have stability again, we need respect for the law and respect for the Oireachtas. Those are essential. There has been a very regrettable outburst of lawlessness in the country with which the previous Government found itself unable to deal.

Comment on this

Oh, no. The Deputy is inviting a lot of trouble now.

Comment on this

I am not afraid of inviting trouble. I am merely stating facts.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Booth should be allowed to make his speech. Other Deputies will get ample opportunity of making their speeches.

Comment on this

We have been forced to take very strong action and such resolute action was not taken by our predecessors. I am all in favour of letting the law take its course. All my training would lead me towards that but when an illegal organisation sets itself up in armed opposition to the State and to the courts, and does not recognise the Oireachtas or the courts set up by law, and is prepared to intimidate the judiciary and juries, it is impossible to deal with such a situation in the normal way.

Nobody could be more anxious than I that anyone accused of an offence should have a fair trial. But when I know that the accused is a member of an illegal organisation or that there is reason to suspect that he is and that that organisation is prepared to intimidate the jury set up to try this accused man so that he will get a fraudulent acquittal, then the ordinary court system breaks down and becomes of no use whatever.

The only alternative is to make sure that anyone who is reasonably suspected of illegal activities would be put out of the way until such time as he is prepared to give an undertaking that he would comply with the law of the land. It is most regrettable that this should have to happen but we have tried to grapple with this problem. We have tried to establish law and order in the land again, not, I regret to say, with complete success. Anyone in public life must take a fair responsibility for what is taking place and we must all act together to ensure that no encouragement is given to these young men to take action which they know is wrong and ill-advised.

We have got to try to live as Irishmen and live together. It is a matter of great pride to me, as a member of this Party, that the two leading members of our Government are both people who are acceptable in the North. Anyone who goes there knows that the Taoiseach is welcome in Belfast at any time and that the Tánaiste has been invited there and is welcome there. You only have to ask any member of the Government of Stormount as to whether they would prefer a visit from anyone in the present Opposition to have it made quite clear that he is persona non grata.

Comment on this

That is most interesting.

Comment on this

That is probably because it has been clearly established that, while Unionists disagree radically with the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste on many points, they appreciate that they are men of principle, men with whom they can talk whether they agree with them or not. I would advise members of the Fine Gael Party to go North and ask whether any of their ex-Ministers would be welcome to go to Belfast and speak at a public meeting. They will find that they are not. I refer to that because it is only men of principle and probity who can contribute anything to this question of disunity.

We have been able, not to do anything very startling, but we have been able to make steady progress. We have been able, with the co-operation of the Provisional United Trade Union Organisation and the Federated Union of Employers, to achieve some stability in wages. We have been able to create conditions in which industry and agriculture have been able to increase productivity. I am far from satisfied on the question of the establishment of new industries but here I must admit that it is a slow job. You cannot establish a factory or a new business in less than two or three years. We are making steady progress. That is what is needed and not starting booms and slumps.

Deputy Cosgrave made a reference to the international situation. Here again I feel that the Government deserves great credit for its prompt answer to the appeal of the United Nations Secretary. I have long felt that we should take a more active part in international affairs and in the working activities of the United Nations. So far as I know this was the first occasion that a request came to an Irish Government from U.N.O. When we were asked to send observers to the Lebanon they were sent there at once.

Those officers in the Defence Forces are probably now in a certain amount of danger but, knowing them as I do, and I know some of them, I am perfectly convinced that they will behave in an exemplary manner no matter what conditions may arise. I hope everybody will join in expressing our concern for them with our confidence that, whatever they are called on to do, they will do it as Irish soldiers should.

We are trying, as a Party and a Government, not to be too introspective. That would be very unhealthy. We are trying to deal with our local, internal problems but we are trying also to make some contribution to the world in which we live. For that reason we have nothing to be ashamed of. We can take a certain amount of pride in our achievements. At the same time there is still no reason for relaxing our efforts or for any complacency. I would hope that the speakers from the Opposition would contribute in the national interest towards the restoration of public confidence by refraining from criticism unless they honestly feel they must criticise. I do not want to limit them in their criticism but I would warn them against spreading unnecessary alarm and despondency which would have a bad effect on national development generally.

The Government has been trying, with some success, to grapple with the problems with which it has been faced and given co-operation and more time —not an indefinite time, of course, but some more time—the progress which has already begun to show itself will continue and as progress continues the rate of progress will increase.

Comment on this

I usually make up my mind that, no matter what is said in this House, I shall not be led astray by the previous speakers, but I usually fall by the wayside. Deputy Booth said he hoped the members of the Opposition when speaking would not say anything that would bring about a cloud of despondency amongst the people. Deputy Booth need not have said that to the members of this Opposition, because whatever we could be accused of or whatever our faults and failings, we never ran down the country for the sake of political advantage. I remember Deputy Seán Lemass's pawnbroker sign when we issued a loan and I remember the former Minister for Finance, now the Minister for Health, advising people not to subscribe to a national loan. Only last year we had another former Minister for Finance, Deputy Aiken, now the Minister for External Affairs, saying that nobody would put a bob into the country. Notwithstanding all these remarks Messrs. Arthur Guinness and Son, Limited, invested £500,000 in Bord na Móna as if to stuff it down their throats that there was hope for the country.

Partition is often used as a smoke-screen especially when the Government wants to draw people's attention away from economic problems. We have gone into the slough of the main in regard to Partition. One of the main reasons for that is the intolerance of some of our people and the intolerance of our fellow countrymen in Northern Ireland. Deputy Booth was saying here that it was wonderful that the two leading members of the Government were welcomed in Belfast. I agree with the Deputy that it is a wonderful thing but when the man whose seat I have the honour to hold in Waterford, John Redmond, went to Belfast he was called a traitor.

I want to ask the Taoiseach if the way the year has passed has been satisfactory? The attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party to this Dáil, the manner in which they have attended to their parliamentary business, the way Ministers avoid answering questions here, the truculent and impertinent manner in which Ministers introduce their Estimates here—is that good? Is it good that the leader of the Irish Government spoke here this morning when introducing the Vote for his Department with only four members of his Cabinet and 15 members of his Party sitting behind him, while the Opposition gave him the compliment of having 23 members present? Does that show that the people in this great 78 member Party are taking their parliamentary duties seriously. They have run away from them in the past few weeks. Members just came in, sat down for a minute and ran out again. I had the experience of being a teller in a division and the Government members all charged in and asked: "What are we voting for?" or "Which way are we voting?" They did not know what business was on in the House or what was the intention of the Government.

Was it good when the Minister for External Affairs introduced his Vote here in the most truculent and impudent manner? Not one of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party that were selected by the Taoiseach to go to Strasbourg, to represent us abroad, spoke on the Vote for External Affairs. They had nothing to contribute and only two of the people who have been sent to Strasbourg at the expense of the Irish taxpayer, namely, Deputy Sir Anthony Esmonde and Deputy Declan Costello, showed any interest in that subject. Those who represent us aboard should be able to give an account of themselves when the Vote for the Department of External Affairs is before the House.

As far as the policy of the Department of External Affairs is concerned, the Minister when introducing that Vote mentioned nothing about policy, what our policy was or where we were going. To-day he answered a question and said he intervened with a friendly Power to look after any of our people who might be in Iraq. I asked him what was the friendly Power and he said he could not tell me. I suspect the friendly Power is Great Britain and——

Comment on this

Supposing we ask somebody to do something for us, we cannot say anything until he says "Yes".

Comment on this

He could have said to whom he had made the representations.

Comment on this

That may not be advisable either. If I asked somebody to do something and I tell beforehand that I am asking him——

Comment on this

He might be in doubt as to where he stood.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

Men of principle who have been welcomed by the Unionists of Belfast should not have any bother.

Comment on this

Tying up the whole position in relation to Belfast, and so on, let me say that I come from a port city. We looked out on the world on the Macha when she went to the south of France to bring back the body of W.B. Yeats. When she came to the British fortress of Gibraltar flying the Irish tricolour she received a thunderous salute of guns from the British squadron there. That was as it should be. Recently it was not an army squadron that went to Bantry Bay, but a training squadron of the British Navy.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on this Estimate.

Comment on this

I thought I could raise it here.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Minister for External Affairs.

Comment on this

The Minister for External Affairs will not talk. This is our only chance.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would be irrelevant on this Estimate.

Comment on this

I shall ask the Taoiseach only one question: Does he consider that the action of the Minister for External Affairs did anything to improve our position as far as Partition is concerned? Somebody said in this House to-day that the people were not fools. The people are fools; and they have been fooled by the Fianna Fáil Party time and again. They were fooled with the green bill at the beginning saying Fianna Fáil would cure unemployment and bring back the emigrants. We had Deputy Booth saying to-day that they wanted time, but they did not want time last year when they were to "get cracking". The slogan was: "Vote Fianna Fáil; Put Your Husbands Back to Work". It was just like that. Deputy Lemass has his £100,000,000 plan and 100,000 jobs.

Comment on this

He did not say it would be done at once.

Comment on this

We should send over the present Minister for Industry and Commerce and get him to take the part that is being taken by Jimmy O'Dea because he would be a right leprechaun with the crock of gold. Fianna Fáil was supposed to "get cracking" and to do wonders. Instead they introduced a few smokescreens for the usual Chamber of Commerce dinners all over the country. Everybody listened to the wonders that were to happen. European Free Trade was one of the forms of dope given out-and dope it was, because anybody who examined it thoroughly could see that we could never have anything to do with it because of our hot-house industries and because we give imperial preference to British products coming here in return for imperial preference for our cattle. They do not like the word "imperial" in this House.

Comment on this

They do now.

Comment on this

Yes, when they are being paid for it. Another smoke-screen was the Shannon free port. Instead of following fairies and will-o'-the-wisps, I think we should look to the ports that are working and doing something, the ports that are paying. The Fianna Fáil policy was to centralise everything in the port of Dublin. I have the figures. I am not coming in here as Deputy Briscoe did, holding his thumbs——

Comment on this

As far as Irish shipping is concerned the policy of the Department of Industry and Commerce was to build 10,000 ton ships. I want to say that a stop should be put to that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be a matter for the Estimate for Industry and Commerce rather than for this debate.

Comment on this

I have referred to this so much on the Estimate without effect that I should like to draw the attention of the Taoiseach to it because I do not think he would allow it to go on.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On this Estimate Deputies are confined to broad questions of policy.

Comment on this

It was the policy of that Department to build big ships and leave the little ports out of it. All Irish ports are little ports; Dublin is the only one that can handle these ships.

When the Taoiseach went to form his Government he showed straight away how short of mettle he was in the 78 men that he had. He was not able to select a team out of 78. He had to go outside and I am not saying that to the detriment of the fine man who is dead whom the Taoiseach brought in. I gave him a civic reception when I was Fine Gael Mayor of Waterford even though he was a Fianna Fáil Minister. I do not want any slap back about that. Then, when the Taoiseach found himself without any Minister for Agriculture, he brought in a confessed failure as Minister for Agriculture and I think that was part of the Government's policy——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Ministers may not be criticised on this Vote.

Comment on this

In his statement this morning the Taoiseach referred to the enormous importance of producing tuberculin tested cattle so that all our cattle would be tuberculin tested. I find we have only 58 accredited herds in the whole country. I shall repeat that: we have only 58 accredited tuberculin-tested herds in the whole Country. That is the result of "getting cracking," after 12 months, at a time when we have only a couple of years more to make our cattle T.B. free and when there is a £55,000,000 industry at state. I have the names and addresses of the people who own accredited herds and the name of the Minister for Agriculture is not amongst them. God knows if there was ever a crusade that was a success in this country. One crusade that was supposed to be a success was that of Father Mathew and he achieved success by taking the pledge himself and saying: "Here goes: in the name of God". The Minister should do that himself.

Comment on this

Take the pledge or get an attested herd?

Comment on this

Both. Does the Taoiseach approve of the conduct of his Deputies in this House when, even during the Taoiseach's own statement here this morning we, in the Opposition, had many more people in the House than his Party could muster? While he was making his statement one of his Deputies was reading a newspaper, holding it right out——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This matter is not relevant to the Estimate.

Comment on this

It seems to me that if it is Fianna Fáil policy to ignore——

Comment on this

It is all right; he was reading the Irish Press.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is not a matter for discussion on this Vote.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil Deputies take little or not interest in the business of the House. I think that is a matter for the Taoiseach who cannot be here all the time. The other day we had the Minister for Agriculture asleep at times, reading the paper at other times and then he would not reply.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should make an effort to get back to the Estimate. Much of this is irrelevant.

Comment on this

Carry on with your lecture.

Comment on this

I wish you would carry on——

Comment on this

I am too disgusted, listening. Redmondites.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

I am proud to be a Redmondite. I was never with the emergency men, never with anybody that seized the farmers' beasts. Coming back to the Estimate——

Comment on this

Hurrah!

Comment on this

The Deputies opposite always manage to make me do this. They have great fun but I shall let you have blow for blow any time but you have not the pluck to get up——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy addressing the Chair?

Comment on this

I am addressing these gentlemen through the Chair. I do not think it was good that during the passage of the Cereals Bill last week Deputies from the greatest wheat growing counties in the country, Fianna Fáil Deputies, did not think it worth their while to contribute anything to the debate on behalf of their constituents. They had nothings to say, whether they thought the policy was right or wrong. The only one who did get up to speak was a man whose conduct I do not admire in this House but at least he had the courage to say what he thought, and that was Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

Yet he voted for it.

Comment on this

I am talking of the grain growing counties, Kilkenny, Kildare, Wexford, Tipperary, Cork and Meath. The representatives from these counties were silent.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We certainly cannot have a repeat of that debate on this Estimate.

Comment on this

We grow it; we do no talk about it.

Comment on this

It was mentioned that there was a resurgence in industrial activity. I wish I knew where it was. So far as I know there is no resurgence in industrial activity, but the removal of the food subsidises has caused the cost of living to rise, has caused rates to rise, has imposed burdens on small shopkeepers, small farmers and ratepayers in small towns, as well as on big farmers. Business is in a shocking state down the country. I let Dublin speak for itself. Trade is falling off, the population is going down and costs have risen, thanks to the deliberate action of this Government in removing the food subsidises. The impact of the Government's policy in removing these subsidises has been shattering for the past two years and still goes on.

Last Monday night I was at a meeting of Waterford Corporation when we had to bring in a supplementary estimate to meet a rise in wages for our employees necessitated by the removal of the subsidises and the rise in the cost of living. That means we will start next year with a deficit. Deputy Dr. Browne said he thought the Taoiseach should hand over to his younger and more active colleagues. I do not think Deputy Dr. Browne is right at all. I do not think very much of the Taoiseach as a leader, but he has nobody to hand over to. That is the trouble; he is stuck.

Comment on this

Any chance we could win the Deputy over?

Comment on this

You come over this way.

Comment on this

Any kind of a small man could be a big man over there.

Comment on this

That is why I am appealing to the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Coalition were accused of slowing down the housing programme in Dublin, but what has happened during the past 12 months? Were more houses built in Dublin? They have had a year to "get cracking", and I should like to point out to the Taoiseach that they have done nothing, even though we are told the demand for houses exists. The Minister for Local Government has told us that the money does not matter, but the houses are not being built.

In 1957, a sum of £250,000 was voted in the Budget to be used in the improvement of marketing, to explore and find markets and to promote the sale of our goods abroad. I asked the question how much of that money had been spent, and I was told that only £80 or £90 of it had been spent, proving after some 15 months, that nothing had been done.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce went to London where he made speeches about selling our products in London, and spoke about new boards and new organisations to be set up for the promotion of sales of our products in England. The Minister apparently forgot that he was the man who had kicked the teeth out of the London tea merchants in Mincing Lane, two or three months before that. He was asking them to buy our products after he had told them that they dare not come in here to sell tea. Dealing with Government policy——

Comment on this

Dealing with what?

Comment on this

Here we go again.

Comment on this

We ought to find out what is Government policy, but the only time we can get any glimmering on it is when we pick up the newspapers and read the speeches of Ministers at dinners and other functions. The Taoiseach opened something down in Lahinch last Sunday, and he came out with the gospel that tourism was one of our greatest economic propositions, ranking with the cattle trade.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I had my poll broken because I tried to say that the cattle trade was necessary to this country.

Comment on this

That was high treason.

Comment on this

I, and all who ever stood with me were hounded and blackguarded everywhere we went. Bills were brought into this House to proscribe it, but now we have got it in the gospel of the leader of this Government that the cattle trade is all right—it is the business.

Deputy Briscoe said that we were trying to wreck the tourist industry. I do not want to say anything about it but, in the name of heaven, what kind of organisation had we looking after the tourist industry up to the time the inter-Party Government got into office? Termonfeckin, Ardmore and Tramore were all beautiful tourist promotions and the less said about them the better, because the taxpayers had to pay and pay heavily for them. The first time I ever got any idea about it was at a meeting of the General Council of County Councils, at a time when people were starting to come in here, when a man got up there and said: "We do not want people coming in here eating our steaks and giving us nothing but paper." This economist is now a member of the Government.

It was great fun interruption me here this evening. But I am clothed in the armour which Fianna Fáil supplied to me. I was brought up in the hard school of the storm of Fianna Fáil interruptions by all their henchmen. We have effected one improvement in the House. The Taoiseach made his statement this morning. As I said twice before, there was a very big attendance of the Opposition. It would be interesting for Deputies to look at the Dáil Debates of the 26th July, 1956 and see how Deputy John Costello, when he was Taoiseach, made his statement. His statement was punctuated, sentence by sentence, by the savage interruptions of a whole horde of interrupters over here. The present Taoiseach sat there at the time and smiled benevolently through the whole performance. I hope the example shown by the Opposition will be a lesson to the Fianna Fáil Party when they are in Opposition, and I hope that will be soon again.

I did not avoid talking about emigration. In regard to unemployment, I said in passing that Fianna Fáil could always fool the unemployed and always did. Unemployment is the Government's responsibility. The leaders of the Government, members of the Government and the Government's newspaper said they could cure unemployment and cure it quickly. All they wanted was an opportunity to "get cracking" and they could do something about it—this wonderful something. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, said he had a solution. He should have gone and boiled his head in it. Where is the solution? Where are all the promises made to the unfortunate people? When the Taoiseach wants to address a lot of Irish people now, he goes to London. Maybe he is not received as well there as he should be. We should stop this nonsense about foreigners and about these hated people over in England when we have the leaders of the Government going over there and saying we want to be friends with them. We read that in the papers, but when it comes to Bantry or something else, we find there is another side.

If the people are to have respect for this Parliament, Deputies, and particularly members of the Government Party, should have respect for it. They should use their parliamentary privileges, attend to their office, and take part in the business of this House. It is not sufficient to be elected, just to get letters and be a messenger boy for your constituents. You are there to represent them and the Irish nation. It is a great honour to do so. The members of the Fianna Fáil Party should take on themselves the responsibility for Government, attend to this House and attend to their business.

Comment on this

I do not intend to delay the House very long. I listened very carefully this morning to Deputy Costello, who led off for the Opposition after the Taoiseach's opening remarks. In the course of Deputy Costello's contribution, he pointed out how perturbed he and other people were at the air of apathy and cynicism that has now become apparent throughout the country in regard to political life. He expressed himself as being rather perturbed last year at the attitude of young people and older people towards this political institution. He went on to say that the air of apathy apparent last year has hardenced since, and has been shown in the manner in which the people have failed to cast their votes on a number of occasions. In addition, he pointed out that, outside this House, the public were beginning to say: "What is the use, they are all the same?" I hope I am not doing him an injustice when I give that as my interpretation of his remarks here to-day.

I should like to suggest that we here must be in a position to set the example if the public outside are to hold the little respect they have left for this House. It is our duty in this House and it is the duty of the Government to ensure that, when matters are discussed and problems raised in this House, the answers given are truthful and factual. At the moment, one of the greatest safeguards the public has against bureaucracy and a form of dictatorship that may be apparent in various Departments is the privilege of extracting from Ministers during Question Time the true facts of the various issues that may be raised.

If Deputies have brought to their notice matters which are of importance and if those Deputies raise questions or problems in this House on behalf of the public, surely the public are entitled to hear the truth to the questions asked? That is why I preface my remarks on this matter by pointing out that Deputy Costello, as Leader of the Opposition, is himself perturbed, and indeed so are many of the public, irrespective of what political Party they may support, at the fact that they are now beginning to believe it is an impossibility to extract in Leinster House, in the course of political debate, what is a fact or what is the truth.

One would imagine that the present Taoiseach, who has, throughout the country, a name for integrity, would be the first to ensure that, no matter who was hurt or where the blame lay, no matter what close friend of his might be hurt in the process of extracting the truth, the truth would be of more importance than the welfare of any member of his Party, be he Deputy or Minister.

I had occasion here very recently to cross swords with the Taoiseach on a matter which I do not propose to reopen on this Estimate except to refer to the actual questions I put to the Taoiseach himself in connection with a matter that was the responsibility of another Minister. Deputies in this House and the public will recall that there was quite a dispute in this House recently between the then acting Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and myself.

Comment on this
Liam Cunningham Acting-Chairman (Mr. Cunningham) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not raise a matter of administration, dealing with another Minister, on the Taoiseach's Estimate.

Comment on this

I have pointed out that I do not intend to refer to it in order to make a case now——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy should get away from specific matters dealing with other Departments.

Comment on this

If the Acting-Chairman will allow me, the case I am making is directly in connection with the Taoiseach's own Department. I asked the Taoiseach a question in this House on the 24th June last. I asked him if he was prepared to set up a committee to inquire into the accuracy or otherwise of statements made in the Dáil on the 17th June in the course of supplementary questions relating to the recent appointment of sub-postmaster in Ballyfermot Upper post office.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is responsible for that matter. The Taoiseach is not. Therefore, the Deputy may not develop or pursue it.

Comment on this

The Acting-Chairman is being badly advised.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I am making a ruling on what the Deputy is saying. I will not allow him to pursue it.

Comment on this

I have referred to the remarks of Deputy J.A. Costello and others in connection with the example that should be set by Deputies and by the Government to the effect that the truth should be respected in this House. I now state quite bluntly that the present Taoiseach has stood over falsehoods in this House and I have the evidence to prove it. I ask him to set up a Committee of this House to examine into the accuracy or otherwise of my remarks.

Comment on this

Is it in order for a Deputy to declare that the Taoiseach has stood over falsehoods in this House? If it is not, I would ask the Chair to request the Deputy to withdraw the statement.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy certainly should withdraw that statement.

Comment on this

I am sick and tired of withdrawing statements and of being asked to withdraw the truth.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy should withdraw the statement he has just made that the Taoiseach has stood over untrue statements in this House.

Comment on this

To my knowledge, whether or not it was through a lack of knowledge of the facts on the Taoiseach's part, in so far as the evidence is at my disposal, the Taoiseach is in the position that he has stood over untrue statements made by the then acting Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy may not explain away his statement. He made a statement which he should not have made.

Comment on this

I repeat that the Taoiseach stood over a false statement in this House which was made by the then acting Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy ought to withdraw that statement or else leave the House.

Comment on this

I am asking that a committee be set up to examine, or otherwise, into this matter. I am sick and tired of being asked to withdraw the truth. That is what I want to see proved here. The former Taoiseach has mentioned——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy will discontinue his speech and resume his seat. Otherwise he must leave the House.

Comment on this

I cannot withdraw the truth.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I order the Deputy to resume his seat immediately.

Comment on this

This has been a rather interesting debate—interesting because of the lack of contribution to it from Deputies on the Government Benches with the exception of the Taoiseach himself who, in his own inimitable style, sought to create an atmosphere wherein things were not too bad but that we must not be complacent.

The only other item of interest that we have had from the Government Benches has been the rather startling revelation by Deputy Booth that the Taoiseach and the Minister for Industry and Commerce—the head and the deputy-head of this Government— would be welcomed at any time by the Unionists of Belfast in their city. He added the rather significant rider that if any ex-Ministers sought to go to Belfast they would not be so welcomed.

It is rather strange that, on a subject so very dear to the Taoiseach, particularly abroad and notably in his contributions during his period in opposition—the subject of Partition— reference to it was missing from his speech to-day. It is wonderful to hear about this union of heart and spirit of which Deputy Booth told us to-day. It was wonderful to hear that these two people, the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste, would be welcomed in Belfast because they are recognised by the Unionists of Belfast, no doubt by Unionist standards, as men of principle. That was the only contribution we had to-day from the Fianna Fáil Benches apart from the rather facilely inept statement by the Taoiseach himself.

As has been pointed out by the Taoiseach and the Leader of the Opposition this debate provides an opportunity whereby a survey of Government policy can be made. I do not believe for one moment that the Government have any policy except the policy of hoping that something may happen through world circumstances of which they can boast, or, on the other hand, that world circumstances may be such that their circumstances will leave them with an excuse and an alibi for the fact that they failed to do any better.

"Things began to look right in 1957" said the Taoiseach to-day. If one kept trying to examine the various ways in which things came right, with the obvious implication of the Taoiseach that it is as a result of his presidency of the Government, one would find himself in that mental condition adumbrated by Goldsmith when he talked about the horizon—that however far you follow it it will still be further away.

The Taoiseach uses the expression: "Again we are on the right road." If the right road is to be understood as the road to the North Wall, to Dún Laoghaire, or to Shannon Airport then we are most certainly on the right road. I was hoping to-day that I would hear, as I was sure all northwestern and southern Deputies coming from the coast and congested areas, hoped to hear from the Taoiseach, something of the Government's plans in that regard and something whereby the lot of the people in those areas might be improved. Remarkable as it may seem, the Taoiseach's speech does not contain one reference to the resettlement on the land which he mentioned as Leader of the Opposition in 1956. It does not contain one single reference to the revival or survival of the national language which formed a considerable part of his speech as Leader of the Opposition in 1956.

To-day the Taoiseach did not make a case that he, and those supporting him now in the Government, made no promises to the people in the General Election of 1957. He carefully avoided it. It was left to Deputy Booth to say that such an allegation was quite unfounded. I do not know whether Deputy Booth is innocent or naïve or whether, in the remarkably short time he is in this House, he has got into the channels of brazen effrontery so characteristic of the Fianna Fáil Party.

One would have liked to have heard from the Taoiseach an explanation as to why the promises he made and the promises which were made on his behalf by his spokesmen and candidates, successful or unsuccessful, have not been carried out. Quite obviously the Taoiseach, as well as the other members of his Party, has arrived definitely at the point where public morality is to have a standard laid down as follows—promises are permissible to gain Government authority and, having gained it, performance is of no consequence.

How can one blame, as Deputy Booth seeks to blame, the Leader of the Opposition for speaking about cynicism, disillusionment and indifference among our people when those particular mental attributes must surely follow from conduct such as that pursued by the Fianna Fáil Party prior to the last general election, during the campaign and since? We are rebuked in very gentle language by Deputy Booth for trying, as he says, to destroy the national morale by reason of speeches such as those made by the Leader of the Opposition in reference to cynicism, disillusionment and indifference. Deputy Booth was not here prior to the General Election of 1957, but he could not fail to be aware of the conduct of the then. Opposition in this House during the tenure of the last Government whereby every act and every word on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party was directed towards destroying national morale, towards shaking public confidence and making it clear to the people that, in doing that, they were doing them a national service. The only service they did to the people was to gain their confidence to some extent and to get into power themselves.

In Volume 195 of the Dáil Debates, column 1903, the Taoiseach, then the Leader of the Opposition, is reported as having said this in relation to the then Government:—

"The doctrines they taught were quite the opposite and they got into power, in my opinion, by false pretences and it was false pretences that were the very beginning of original sin. It was false pretences that tempted poor Mother Eve at the start.

Mr. O'Leary: Captain Cowan and Dr. Browne.

Mr. de Valera: False promises— these were the basis and are the basis of the present Government. They have now had to play the part of the reformed rake in regard to these matters. Every single promise that they made on prices and all the rest of it—I could go through a long litany of them—bank restrictions, bank rates, etc.—they have proved false to and unable to carry out."

Then he adds, significantly I thought, words which must have been brought home to him in no very uncertain manner since he took office the last time:—

"How can people in the country rally around a Government of that sort? I do not think they can."

The Taoiseach in the course of the last general election campaign—and I do not think it can be said too often— made a specific promise to the people that the cost of living would be kept down in so far as the retention of food subsidies would keep it down. This promise was made obviously as a result of prior deliberation and consultation by the Deputy Leader of the Government, then Deputy Lemass. At Water-ford on the same night he said in relation to our charges that food subsidies would be removed on the accession of Fianna Fáil to power: "How definite must our denials of these stupid allegations be?" They did it and we have now, as the Leader of the Opposition said, had a full year in which to examine the effects of that.

I have been waiting anxiously and so, I am sure, has every Deputy not alone on the Opposition Benches but on the Government Benches, for some sort of plan or programme for the people of the congested areas of the northern, western and southern coasts. Permit me again to recall the famous promise of the successful candidate, now Deputy Doherty, speaking to the people on food subsidies when he said: "You can trust Mr. de Valera to do the right thing." The people of my constituency who are paying increased prices for flour, bread and butter, with nothing by way of compensation in their income, must now be amused and possibly hurt at Deputy Doherty's conception of the Taoiseach's doing the right thing. Absolutely nothing has been done in relation to the northern, western and southern coasts. Nothing was planned that was not in operation before. It is true that my successor, the Minister for the Gaeltacht, has engaged on some sort of business about pigs under the title of "Sceim na Muc" which is no great addition to the economy of the country. All of this was being effectively done——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy may not discuss the details for which another Minister is responsible.

Comment on this

I am not discussing details. I am discussing Government policy and surely "Sceim na Muc" is Government policy.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It is one of the many schemes operated under the Minister for the Gaeltacht.

Comment on this

One would expect the Chair not to be partial.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Will the Deputy resume his seat? The Chair has ruled that the details for which the Minister for the Gaeltacht is responsible may not be discussed on the Taoiseach's Estimate.

Comment on this

The Chair has also said that Sceim na Muc is one of the many schemes——

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Deputy may not criticise any statement made by the Chair.

Comment on this

Standards of criticism vary and the tests by which they are judged have an extraordinary sliding scale. Is there any improvement outlined in the Taoiseach's speech to-day attributable to any single aspect of what might be Government policy? I do not think so. On the introduction of the Estimate last year the Taoiseach, at column 821, Volume 163 of the Official Debates of the 4th July, 1957, said:—

"We hope the measures that will be taken will continue to have that result. There can be nothing spectacular about the results in the present year ..."

At no time to-day did we hear from him anything about the measures that he prophesied would be taken or the results they would continue to have. To-day's speech was nothing more than what the Minister for Health, then Deputy MacEntee, said in relation to Deputy Costello's speech two years ago when he used the words "stratagem", "sleight of hand" and other such words calculated to show disapproval.

This speech of the Taoiseach contained nothing by way of planning for the future. It contained no specific suggestion to deal with either unemployment or emigration. The Leader of the Opposition has already outlined what was described by the Tánaiste as the acid test whereby a Government should be judged and that acid test was how it dealt with the question of unemployment. It is true the unemployment figures are 1,700 fewer than last year. I do not think Deputies coming from country constituencies, particularly coastal constituencies, can shut their eyes to the fact that that 1,700 has been more than accounted for by emigration. On the occasion of the Budget of 1957, repeated this year with all its ferocity I prophesied that, in relation to my own constituency at any rate, all that it would mean would be that one more member of a family would have to emigrate or migrate and sooner than was anticipated. Speaking in that strain I challenge my colleagues in the Fianna Fáil Party to join in this debate and contradict me when I say that more people than ever before have either migrated or emigrated from the constituency of North Mayo to England, Scotland, America or other parts.

Deputy Booth said that the previous Government had entirely failed to deal with lawlessness on the part of illegal organisations. He knows perfectly well that is not true but he goes further and says that the action taken by the Government which he supports was taken because juries would be intimidated and judges would be thwarted. It is open to any Government, on the information they have, to take such measures as they deem fit, but speaking of the Government to which I had the honour to belong, I want to say we gave the courts a fair trial and they were working well. There was no indication of interference with justices or juries. The difference is the difference of method, but the difference implied in the Fianna Fáil method is that they would not allow the courts to operate, or allow juries to be intimidated, without having one solitary experience of that happening.

Credit is claimed on each side of the House from time to time for various things. Speaking as a country Deputy and recalling the times when calves were sold at 2/6 and 5/- each, while dropped-calves are now making between £20 and £30, one can get a true picture of the situation by looking at page 171 of the 1958 year book issued by the National Farmers' Association. That page is entitled: "At a glance; useful information for farmers.""Grants for erection of dwelling houses". They were there even before the State was founded and the principle of grants for dwelling houses was continued under the first Government, continued under Fianna Fáil, and continued by the inter-Party Government with greater vigour from 1948 to 1951, so that nobody can take any great credit for that. "Grants for reconstruction, improvement, or repair of dwelling houses"—the same remarks are applicable.

The next heading is: "Grants for Farm Buildings." Fianna Fáil were in power here from 1932 to 1948, an uninterrupted period, but they never thought of grants for farm buildings because these were started by the first inter-Party Government. The Taoiseach, who tells us to-day, and tells us truly, after years of bitter experience, great inconvenience and great national expense, that agriculture is the primary industry of the country, guided our destinies for 16 uninterrupted years. Agriculture is important to-day but during the whole of that period it was never important enough to have put into execution a plan for grants for land reclamation which was started by the first inter-Party Government in 1949. Neither did they think of the land project fertiliser scheme started by the inter-Party Government in 1950——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely that is agricultural administration?

Comment on this

This was Government policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Major Government policy may be discussed on the Taoiseach's Estimate but not departmental administration and this, surely, is departmental administration.

Comment on this

I submit, with respect, that schemes of the magnitude of grants for the installation of water supplies, fertiliser schemes, the T.B. eradication scheme, the accredited herd scheme, the soil advisory service, the contagious abortion scheme, and the parasitic diseases——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If we are to go into the administration of all Departments of State on the Taoiseach's Estimate there is no point in discussing the administration of the Departments individually at all. The only points that may be discussed are major aspects of Government policy, not administration of Departments.

Comment on this

I was about to submit that the covering of such a vast field by the first inter-Party Government and the utter neglect of it by the other Government over the previous 16 years is a matter of comment in relation to major Government policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a matter for comment in relation to a major aspect of Government policy. If we were to adopt that course we would discuss all Departments of State on the Taoiseach's Estimate.

Comment on this

Agriculture had always been the cornerstone of Fine Gael policy. We always recognised that the ultimate prosperity of all our people in every walk of life depended in the last analysis on those who lived and worked on the land whether in big or small farms.

I should like to know from the Taoiseach, when replying, what are his plans for the people of the small holdings, the people he has blistered—in conjunction with his Government, of course—with the continuing effects of the 1952 Budget and the sorry present effects of the 1957 Budget? I see my colleague from North Mayo smiling. He must have sold a lot of suitcases this year to emigrants who had to go away to earn a living——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the personal activities of any Deputy should not be referred to in the House.

Comment on this

Seeing that they can be related to promise and performance——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The personal business of any Deputy should not be referred to in the House.

Comment on this

I am sorry. I really should not refer to it, because there is not any business, really.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is only aggravating the offence by making remarks of that kind.

Comment on this

I want to know from the Taoiseach what he proposes to do regarding the provision of employment, provision of fishing facilities and amenities for those who live on the coast; what he proposes to do to alleviate the hardships caused to the people of whom I speak. People on fixed wage or salary scales have had their incomes stepped up a little in relation to the demands made on them, but the people for whom I speak have not had their income stepped up in any way. Even if cattle prices have increased they have so few cattle and the profit resulting from that increase is so negligible that it would not, and could not offset the hardships imposed by the removal of subsidies and increased taxation generally.

If there is no answer to that I am afraid we must accept as Fianna Fáil policy that their economy is the economy of the good land only, the economy of the economic holder, and that the sooner the hillsides, the valleys, the peninsulas and coastal villages are wiped out the better they will like it. We, on this side of the House, are prepared at all times to make constructive contributions but, when you find a situation whereby honest effort and honest endeavour, such as were displayed by the last Government in times of economic difficulty—now acknowledged by the Taoiseach and Tánaiste to be such times—and when you are faced with the vilest of campaigns, the strongest stalk will bend and probably break when struck by persistent blasts. That is what happened in this country in the latter days of 1956 and the beginning of 1957.

There was propaganda calculated to destroy national morale, calculated to turn men's minds away from honest endeavour, and to draw up the alluring horizon of "get cracking", of more employment, and the stemming of emigration. The people were led to believe by the present Taoiseach and the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the cost of living would be kept within the limits of their capacity to pay. How can people be blamed if they are now to indulge in a period of disillusionment, cynicism and indifference when they find that when the objective, power, has been secured performance is of no consequence?

Democratic institutions in this and any other country must inevitably pay the penalty essentially resulting from such conduct. The Fianna Fáil Party will go down in the history of this country as the Party who made the best contribution—but which we hope will be foiled by the people—towards the destruction of the faith of the people, not alone in their country, but in those making honest endeavours to guide them along the road to national prosperity and national survival.

Comment on this

I was rather surprised at the Taoiseach's rather short, curtailed account of the working of his Department and of the Government in general during the last 12 months. He glossed over a lot of very important things very cursorily, and did not bother to go into detail. He did not seem to worry a lot about what are still our three major problems: emigration, the loss of our boys and girls; next in importance the huge figure of unemployment and last, but by no means least, the cost of living. These were not dealt with. Instead, the Taoiseach stressed that last year was a year of recovery. The only comment I wish to make on that is that the Taoiseach must be completely out of touch with the people of this country if he says last year was a year of recovery. Every single person to whom I speak, whether an ordinary working man, a small farmer, a shopkeeper or a businessman, says they have never had a more embarrassing or tighter year since the economic war. If that is the Taoiseach's idea of a year of recovery then we can only pray that we will not have many more such years of recovery.

Nothing has been done to try to stem emigration. It is all very fine to talk here and try to score politically over one's political opponents, but I wish to put forward a suggestion that might possibly help, if not altogether stop, the outflow of people from this country, and I want to give my reasons for making the suggestion. In the last 12 months it has not been the youth alone who emigrated. Whole families have gone. Whole families have locked the doors of, perhaps, brand new dwelling houses and cleared off to England, to the United States or to Canada, but mostly to England.

I hold that what is wrong is that the Government is not spending enough on employment. It is not for pleasure that people emigrate; it is to make a living. They are forced to emigrate when they cannot make a living at home and I do not know any of them who are going for pleasure. Some people go for holidays and come back again, but those who go for holidays are very, very few. On the cover of the Book of Estimates there is a sum of £110,002,220. I have just concluded examining various Votes under which money is provided for employment, and I find out of the total of £110,000,000 odd, a comparatively small sum, some £3,500,000. I think the Taoiseach should turn his attention to that and increase the amount of money spent on employment and on the ordinary working man.

We find that under Vote 10 there is roughly about £700,000 spent on rural improvement schemes and minor employment schemes which do very good work, even if they provide only part-time employment during the winter. In another Vote, £405,000 is provided for arterial drainage and, again, I believe there should be much more money spent on that. About £3,000,000 is provided for housing through the Department of Local Government, and I think it would not be unfair to say that, of that £3,000,000, only approximately a quarter is spent on labour. It is only fair to say that three-quarters of it is spent on materials and the figure left for employment is then about £750,000. The Land Commission spends £150,000 on employment, but forestry tops the list with about £1,500,000, and employs approximately 5,000 people. If the Taoiseach wants to seek a solution to emigration—and when I was a member of the Government that is what the then Government directed its attention to—he should try to give more employment at home because, if people could get employment at home, they would not emigrate.

There is no use beating around the bush, talking about emigration and the evil it is, until we get down to trying to stop it. What is wrong with government here is that it is costing £110,000,000 to run the country, on the face of the Book of Estimates, and only £3,500,000 is spent on employment. In the case of forestry, materials are mixed in with that figure, so that not even all that amount is being spent. Why then grumble about the youngsters leaving the country? It is quite evident that private employment cannot absorb them. The only way to check it is to try to give them employment at home. We have the most underdeveloped country in Western Europe to-day. If there is any money to be spent, we should spend it in giving them useful employment.

I shall not go into the details. I was very keen on forestry myself. Every single member of the Governments of which I was a member was very keen on forestry and pushed it ahead to the position it is in to-day. I was sorry to note that the number employed in forestry has dropped. I suppose the number dropped had to go across the water to get a living. We are spending a huge amount of money on various items but very little is being spent to provide employment for our young people at home. Then we tear our hair and shed tears over the fact that our youth are going. Private employment has absorbed as much as it can, but it is not enough. More money should be spent by the Government, especially in the rural areas where emigration is at its worst.

The cost of living has been spoken about so often—particularly when one remembers the promises made by Fianna Fáil before the last election— that I am loath to go over the same ground again. The present Government Party has the backing of a powerful propaganda sheet, the Irish Press. It is not a daily paper; it is a propaganda sheet for the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Are we discussing the policy of the Irish Press or the Irish Press as a whole?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies should confine themselves to the Taoiseach's Estimate.

Comment on this

All right, but we cannot overlook the facts of how they got back into power 15 or 16 months ago. I think we are justified in examining the means by which they got into power. Those means were, firstly, making promises they had no notion of fulfilling and, secondly, their backing by the Irish Press. I did not come in to attack the Irish Press. When we were in power and Deputy Dillon initiated the land rehabilitation project, side by side with the announcement of that was a series of gloomy disasters about floods and earthquakes in Japan in order to undermine the good of Deputy Dillon's programme.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The policy of any organ of the Press is not under discussion and does not arise relevantly.

Comment on this

Very good. However, I put it to the Chair that surely an instrument that had such a profound effect in undermining a Government in power and which, through false promises, put an Opposition back in power should be——

Comment on this

Is the Deputy entitled to attack the Irish Press in this House?

Comment on this

If an instrument such as the Irish Press is used by the Taoiseach to further his policy, I think you can talk about such an instrument.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I know nothing about the policy of any organ of the Press in the country, but I do know that the policy of any organ of the Press of the country does not fall relevantly for discussion on this Estimate.

Comment on this

Even when——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Blowick may say a particular organ of the Press is backing a particular Party, which may be the Government Party or not. That is a matter on which I cannot decide. But the Deputy should confine himself to what is in the Book of Estimates on the major policy of the Government.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Very good, I shall deal with the promises made. Several Deputies here to-day deprecated the fact that Government institutions are coming into disrepute. That is not due to the people outside taking a lackadaisical view of Government institutions, but it is due to our conduct here. Candidates going forward at general election time should not bid for votes with a bid they know they cannot honour, with a cheque that will bounce. A promise that cannot be fulfilled is a cheque that will bounce. The Government Party got into power on such false promises. One of them was the proposal of the present Minister for Industry and Commerce to find 20,000 new jobs for the boys and girls coming out of school each year. The cost was to be £100,000,000.

Comment on this