An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958— an Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958— Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–143 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
Last night, before the Adjournment, I was about to refer to a book written by Professor Hogan and published in 1945. That book was introduced in this debate as an argument for the abolition of P.R. Before I deal with that I should like to refer to another matter which arises at this stage. The Taoiseach's main argument, having made a very feeble case, was: "Let the people decide." All right. Let the people decide. I spoke for one hour last night. This morning I read the three morning papers which were conveying to the people what I said. The Irish Times gave me about eight square inches, the Irish Independent gave me seven and the Irish Press gave me one and a quarter square inches.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Sherwin resume his seat? The manner in which the metropolitan Press deals with Deputy Sherwin's speech is no concern of this House and is not relevant to the matter before the House.
Comment on this
This is a House of Parliament and what I say is intended for the people.
Comment on this
The Deputy will proceed to discuss what is before the House and not what the Press of Dublin does in regard to his statement.
Comment on this
The opinions of the people are certainly before the House because it is on the opinions of the people that this Bill will be decided, not by this House. This is only a preliminary to the referendum. It is the opinion of the people that counts. I am trying to get to those people. I will not proceed with that but I maintain that the people are the State, not this House, and I am trying to reach the people. I am not able to do so. I am, in a limited way, but that is my point, that the people will not be able to judge fairly if somebody tries to crowd me out.
Comment on this
This House has no control over the metropolitan Press. What they publish and do not publish is their concern.
Comment on this
All right. I will accept that but, if the Press injures liberty, they have as much right to be dealt with by this House as any illegal association. If I were not depending on the Press, I would not be here and thanks to the Evening Mail I am here.
I was about to quote last night, before the Adjournment, Professor Hogan's book which I have here and which I read before Deputy O'Malley, perhaps, read it. I have gone through the whole book. Professor Hogan dealt with the whole subject fairly, as things should be dealt with by the Press and by this House. He summed up all that is good in P.R. and all that is good in the straight vote system and he struck a happy medium. He said that perhaps a modified form of P.R. would be the best but he was against the abolition of P.R. That was not said in this House and, if a one-sided view is to be put before the people, the people cannot decide. That justifies, not only a free Press, but an Independent in this House.
I quote now from a book entitled Election and Representation by Professor James Hogan, Professor of History, published in 1945:—
"It is probable that, for example, in Ireland an outright return to the majority system would enable the present Government Party not merely to survive to a ripe old age but to go on governing even after it had declined into a state of dotage. In these hypothetical circumstances, and indeed under present circumstances, there is much to be said for having in Parliament at least a few Independents, who, because they have minds of their own and are free to speak them, can become the medium for expressing unpalatable but salutary truths and opinions. However bitter in the mouth for the Party leaders, and however unpopular with large sections of the electorate, such plain speaking is essential to the elasticity of thought which is an indispensable condition of an alert, fearless, and freely developing public opinion. With but a very limited measure of P.R., Parliament will continue to be accessible to the brilliant individualist, whereas a complete return to the majority system would be bound to turn it into a preserve for Party men only."
The whole book deals with that subject, giving both sides. My point is that both Parties in this House are concerned with putting only one side. I am not wanted here. The people are to be confused. The Press is to be gagged.
We are told all about the countries that have the straight vote system but not of the small countries, of which we are one, which have the P.R. system. The 1916 Proclamation says that we will cherish all the children equally. The Constitution says that all Parties are guaranteed the right of association without prejudice to their political views. If, under this Bill, some small Party is to be kept out of this House, how can they have the right of assembly without prejudice when what is proposed here is prejudiced?
The Taoiseach, speaking on the 1st February, 1933, as reported in the Irish Press said: “If we get power we shall give free and equal rights to all citizens.” That is what the Taoiseach said when he was looking for power. I repeat it: “If we get power we shall give free and equal rights to all citizens.” Surely this proposal justifies the Northern junta? One of our main arguments has been that the minority in the North were not getting their due representation. Surely we cannot now have any face before those people in the future. We have surrendered our cause because our main argument was the disfranchisement in the North of a large section of the people.
As I said yesterday, it is now quite possible that a large number of the citizens here, as evidenced by recent by-elections, will not vote at all. It is now evident that only about half the people voted in recent by-elections. It may be the case that by the abolition of P.R. a Government might be returned by 20 per cent. of the electorate. The votes of the other 30 per cent. would be divided between the other two Parties and so a Government would be in office that would have the support of only 20 per cent. of the people.
There was a Party in power in Spain representing only a minority of the people when Franco declared civil war. What justification will you have if the majority of the people decide to defy you as they may very well do? What will you do if they tell you that you have the support of only 20 per cent. or 30 per cent. of the electorate and that you have not the authority of the law? Even de Gaulle set up a system under which, if a person did not get a majority, there would be a second election in order to give people time to consider the position and withdraw. A Government elected in that way would be able to claim that there was a substantial number of the people behind them. If 50 per cent. of the people do not vote, you will have a Government elected by 20 per cent. of them. How then will you deal with Sinn Féin if they say that you have not the authority of the law and that they will defy you?
I say that this proposal is dangerous in a country divided as we are. The only section of the Constitution that has anything democratic about it at all is that which states that P.R. should be the system of election. It gives a person the right to stand for election to this House. Look at the other sections dealing with elections. Take the one dealing with the election of the President. A man has to get the support of 20 Members of the Oireachtas before he can stand. That means that two Parties can decide on their own who is to be President and there can be no election. That has happened already. The late Alfie Byrne, who was Lord Mayor of this city for 10 years, went forward and got the support of a number of Deputies but because he could not get the support of 20 he could not stand. Only a representative of the Government or of the Opposition could get the required 20 and therefore the Presidency is the property of two groups. I have a right to stand for President if I want to. When the Press referred to me this morning it looked as if I were talking about myself. I want the Press to know that I may talk for myself but I do not work for myself.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy before that he ought to confine himself to the Bill. He is travelling very wide of it.
Comment on this
Something was said about O'Connell. He justified himself because he was fond of asserting himself.
Comment on this
I do not understand that but if the Deputy will confine himself to the terms of the Bill that is wide enough.
Comment on this
We now deal with the right to vote. When you are 21 you can vote and when you are 18 you cannot vote but if there were war to-morrow it would be the fellows of 18 who would be doing the fighting. The majority of the I.R.A. were under 21. They could not vote but they fought.
Comment on this
It is all part and parcel of what is not in the Bill. The one section of the Constitution that gives people an opportunity and gives them certain rights is to be deleted.
Comment on this
I shall try to avoid that, Sir. I am told that when all power rests in the hands of a few it encourages corruption. I know that in politics there is a good deal of corruption. I have experience, not of corrupting, but of corruption. I am a member of the corporation and I know all the corruption that goes on there. Only last year, in a nice way, I was offered a trip to America.
Comment on this
If the Deputy persists in that line of argument, I shall have to ask him to resume his seat and discontinue his contribution.
Comment on this
One of the main arguments for the Bill is that it will give stability. We all know that there is bargaining in a Coalition Government. But even in one Party there is bargaining. Even in one Party there must be bargaining behind the scenes. It may be done quietly in that case and more openly in a Coalition Government. I am quite certain that the Taoiseach can assert his authority in his own Party but I am not so sure that, when someone else takes over the honour, he will be able to assert his authority without bargaining. I know there must have been some bargaining in the Government when one Minister retired and his son came in in his place.
Comment on this
The Deputy must resume his seat. He is travelling very wide of the Bill and he has deliberately ignored my instructions.
Comment on this
I shall not offend again. I want to put the case that there can be bargaining among one Party. Deputies will have read of the bargaining that goes on in England. The Labour Party there differed on the question of the atom bomb and on the question of the death penalty and there was practically strife amongst the Party. In any case, I believe that there is a section of the Constitution which can lead to the differences which existed in the Coalition period.
There is a section in the Constitution which makes everyone aware of a danger and which causes distrust. It is the clause under which the Taoiseach can go to the Park and ask the President to dissolve the Dáil. Let us say there are two or three Parties and all the Parties have a policy which they say is for the good of the people— there is not a great deal of difference between the policies of the Parties— and if they agree to adopt something that is the pet policy of a Party at least it will be something that a large section of the people want. At the same time, as was proved, there is a certain awareness, a certain distrust. Each Party would like to be the Government Party but, all the time they are deciding on policy, they are worrying about how they will stand in the next election. There is a certain distrust and the fear that the Party holding the office of Taoiseach may rush to the Park when it suits them.
Clann na Poblachta tried to assert their authority and they acted like opportunists. They thought the time was ripe to bring down the Government and that they would be able to become the Government. That was largely based on the feeling that if they did something which would force the Taoiseach to go to the President they would succeed. This clause in the Constitution had a lot to do with this distrust and this lack of cohesion during the lifetime of the Coalition Governmnt. Let us suppose that the power was not there. Let us suppose that a Government must last for five years. Each Party would then say: "Nobody can pull a fast one. Let us work hard and then in the last two months of the five years we may try to pull off something." But for the best part of the five years they will work hard.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach's main argument was that a Coalition Government cannot work and he pointed out exactly what I have pointed out. He says that one Party only can give stability. If the people must have elections more often than they should, what great harm is that? At least the people will be the deciding factor all the time, whereas the people are not the deciding factor at this moment. It could well be said that the Government does not represent the people so it is not a lot of harm for a Party to go to the people every time they seem to differ and say to them: "Now what do you want?" I do not see much harm in that. It is better to do that than that we should have people going around with guns in their hands.
The well-known writer, Mr. De Vere White, referred to the danger of nepotism in politics. That has a bearing on this question. He said that when all power rested with the few all honours would go to the few. That is a danger. I am not one to refer to men and to the fact that their sons hold office. I would probably like my son to be in the Dáil but that is not the point. It can be overdone. O'Connell had eight of his family in Parliament. I am not saying that he was himself responsible for that. There were plenty of his followers who thought he would like that.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce said one of the Parties here was surplus and that they had no justification for their existence. He said that the Labour Party were the natural Opposition. That is right; I shall accept that. However, according to Professor Hogan if there had been a straight vote in 1932 there would not have been one Labour man returned to this House, and he was a man who went into the matter in detail. But what does the Tánaiste mean? He wants to blot out the Labour Party. That is what would happen. Perhaps one or two might get back. The question of a surplus Party cuts two ways and we shall not forget that.
Admittedly on appearances, the Opposition now is a surplus Party but Fianna Fáil might be a surplus Party in a few years' time, especially if P.R. were maintained. That is the real reason for this Bill. After all, when the Taoiseach passes from the scene— I hope he will live for a very long time —the Party will miss his influence. Then they cannot say that they will do any better than the Opposition. It will be a question of who will have the leadership or who will decide which Party will become the surplus Party.
I could speak for two weeks from the voluminous notes, most of which I have memorised and which I have studied carefully for 30 or 40 years. I could argue with any man but, with all respect, I do not accept that this is the best means of making one's case. Another member can get up after me and perhaps misrepresent me, or even tell a fib, and I shall not be able to question it. If I do, the Ceann Comhairle will tell me to sit down or to leave the House. I consider that the best kind of debate would be that which Lincoln had with Douglas on the question of the Union of the States. On that occasion both men stood up, man to man, each answering the other, until finally the audience knew all the facts for themselves. That is the kind of debate I would like and I am confident that I would hold my own in it. If the Taoiseach thinks a little more stability is required, I would appeal to him not to take such a violent course as to abolish P.R. As one fair-minded Deputy said: "There is a happy medium." It must be remembered that while this proposal might give stability, it might also give tyranny. Just as in the case of General de Gaulle, who has given dictatorial powers to the President, the Taoiseach may be careful, but when de Gaulle goes, a bully may come in his place and bullying is always answered in the same way. That is why I suggest a happy medium. Do not deny other people their rights; do not say: "Only we shall represent the people", but rather let everyone, according to his ability, participate in public representation. This Bill denies that right; this Bill says: "Let the Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Parties alone survive. We shall put insurmountable obstacles in the way of any others." It declares, as did King Louis of France: "I am the State." But you are not; the people are.
Comment on this
I am rather amazed at the length of time taken to discuss P.R. here, particularly by the Fine Gael Party which always claims to be anxious about the will of the people. We have spent a fortnight now trying to prevent the people expressing their will in this matter. Let us be clear about that. This Bill, if passed by the Dáil cannot become law. It goes by referendum to the people and the people will decide whether the present system of P.R. is to be continued or whether we are to have a change. It is the people and nobody else who will decide, and all this holdup is because certain people here do not want the issue to go to the people.
I have definite views on what the membership of this House would be, if there were straight voting. My views are very different from those which have been expressed here. You have the example of Deputy Sherwin who was elected in a by-election by a straight vote of the people as against all political Parties, and he got in here. That is one example of straight voting. As one almost 30 years here now— which is a fairly long spell—I can go back and examine what has happened. I went into a one-in-five constituency, and, by good hard work, I succeeded in making that a two-in-five constituency the next year. When I came very near getting it a three-in-five constituency the territory I had cultivated and brought into good heart was taken from me and handed over to other Deputies, and a rural area that had been tacked on to a city constituency was given me instead. A countryman in that area came to me later and said that he had written to his local T.D. about a heifer loan and that he had got a letter back saying that his T.D. had seen the Minister and that he would hear all about his Dáil loan next week. I had to hold my new area for ten more years and when I had brought that into some kind of shape. I was told it would hold two after my work. I was duly given a second and I brought him over the sticks. That was the second round.
Comment on this
Then after a further ten years, they had another look at the territory they had taken from me and said: "The place we took from Deputy Corry has gone into fenland and mud again", so it was handed back to me and I had to get to work and recultivate it. When I had done that, I was told that we should have two seats there and I brought in two, and that is the situation now, thank God. When a person has been carrying ballast for any Party on his back for a long number of years, it is about time he got a clean sheet. I say that any Deputy who does his job in this House and does his job for his people here and outside, no matter what Party he belongs to, will not be put out, either in a straight vote or a crooked one. He is in no danger.
I believe P.R. should have gone 20 years ago. The only two people who agreed on that, it seems, were Deputy Dillon and myself, but Deputy Dillon spent two hours yesterday attacking the abolition of P.R. Let us see what happened. In this House on November 12, 1947, Deputy Dillon said:—
"P.R. is, in fact, as we all know in our hearts, the child of the brains of all the cranks in creation. So far as this country is concerned, it was tried out on the dog. I doubt if any other sane democratic country in the world has put it into operation in regard to its Parliament.... It was foisted upon us by a collection of half-lunatics who believed that they had something lovely that would work on paper like a jig-saw puzzle, but like all these crank ideas in operation, it has resulted here in an election in 1931, an election in 1932, an election in 1938, an election in 1939, an election in 1943, and an election in 1944."
That is the view of a man who spent two hours last night telling us that P.R. should not be abolished. Is there any sense or reason in this House, or is it just a place for this kind of moonshine where a playboy may come in and spend two hours telling us the evils that would follow the abolition of P.R.? He said:—
"If you are going to have P.R., it is perfectly obvious that you should have five- or seven-seat constituencies. Personally, I think P.R. is a fraud and a cod and it ought to be abolished."
That was Deputy Dillon's view, as expressed here on 12th November, 1947. Has he the brains of a little wren? He said then:—
"I believe in the single member constituency, with the transferable vote, so that the man who gets the support of the largest number of people living in the constituency will represent the constituency."
That was Deputy Dillon's view as expressed in this House.
He went back to a period which I do not think any decent man in this country wants to remember, a period which many people would like to forget. James Dillon came into this House as leader of one of these Parties which he is afraid now will be abolished. He was the leader of the Centre Party in this House. He succeeded in collecting a number of others and brought them in here. After six months, all that was left of that Party was the late ex-Deputy Kent, sitting there alone, representing the farmers of this country, and James and Company had sold out.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon had sold out and was sitting there as a shadow Minister. Deputy Dillon comes here and talks about the freedom of speech that would not be allowed him but for the Blueshirts who supported him, helped him and assisted him, but the unfortunate man who remained true to the Party in whose interest he was elected, ex-Deputy Kent, saw the same Blueshirt brigade pulled around from farmyard to farmyard——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I take it we will all be entitled to refer to this period when we speak? It will be a very interesting debate.
Comment on this
Would it not be desirable if nobody talked about the Blueshirts or such matters here?
Comment on this
The Minister for Defence and the Minister for External Affairs started it. Surely we will be entitled to refer to the Blueshirts, too?
Comment on this
So will I when I rise in a few moments, and I will tell the Minister the number of Blueshirts he has commissioned in the Army.
Comment on this
I am giving an example of what did happen to one of those small Parties who came into this House, whose leaders deserted them and whose sole representative here found himself down the country with a team of men——
Comment on this
The Deputy will pass on to the Bill before the House and leave that section of Irish history out of it.
Comment on this
May I refer to the statement made here last night by Deputy Dillon about the mobs led by Deputies? Am I allowed to allude to the mob who burned the house of Deputy Paddy Murphy—those peaceful, blue-shirted citizens?
Comment on this
The Deputy is allowed to allude to something that is relevant to this Bill, and only that.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the statement made here last night by Deputy Dillon that he had to march up O'Connell Street in Limerick and nothing would have got him up that street alive "but the ranks of blue-shirted men on either side of me, protecting me from the consistent, sustained and malevolent attacks of Fianna Fáil mobs, and led by Fianna Fáil Deputies."
As I said, this is a matter which none of us wishes to remember. None of us wishes to remember a period in which a bunch of Irishmen endeavoured to sell out this nation to John Bull.
Comment on this
No one wants to remember that. They do not like to think about it and I do not wish to remember it, as I am sure others do not. Deputy Dillon was allowed last night, and I heard him here, to express his views and to blow himself into a heat, cool down again, blow up again into steam and cool down again for nearly two hours on his hatred of this House doing now what he appealed to it to do in 1947. Deputy Dillon alluded to the benefit this nation got from a Coalition Government and from the coming together of all these teams. I well remember a couple of questions I asked after the ball was over. On 23rd April, 1952, I asked the Minister for Finance: "If he will state (1) the total amount payable and paid in interest and sinking fund in the financial year 1947-48 and (2) the total amount payable in interest and sinking fund in the financial year 1952-53."
Now, Sir, it must be remembered that from 1923 to 1948, we had 25 years of this Parliament. Cumann na nGaedheal were there for a number of years and Fianna Fáil for a number of years. After those 25 years, the total amount payable in interest and sinking fund was £4,224,000.
Comment on this
Neither the financial position of the State nor the alleged bad administration of Governments arises on this Bill.
Comment on this
We were told last night of the benefits that fell to agriculture and industry and every other activity during three years of Coalition government.
Comment on this
I cannot allow the Deputy to proceed on that basis. If I did Deputies could traverse the administration of all Governments since this State was established. I shall not allow that.
Comment on this
Surely if one Deputy was allowed to point out here the benefits, as he said, the country got from a Coalition Government——
Comment on this
I do not want to discuss the administration of Governments; I want to discuss the results of their administration.
Comment on this
No, Sir. All I am concerned with is the fact that £4,000,000 per annum was paid in interest and sinking fund in 1948 and there was a sum of £10,500,000 when the boys ran.
Comment on this
Surely that is a matter of Government policy and the administration of Government policy.
Comment on this
The Deputy will pass from the administration of Governments and deal with what is in the Bill.
Comment on this
Very good, Sir. Let us take what we have seen happening under these Governments and what we have seen happening under the present system of P.R. representation. We have five or six different Parties in the House now. I was amazed to hear Deputy Blowick admit that if there were an election to-morrow morning over 100 Fianna Fáil Deputies would be elected and only 27 Opposition Deputies. It is the most amazing thing I ever heard, that a Government Party that must have made a lot of enemies in their time would win all the seats in all the constituencies except 27. That is a most amazing and surprising admission. I do not see that condition of affairs coming at all.
I do not see any danger of it. I do not care what political team comes down to my area. I will kick them out. That applies not only to me but to any Deputy who is doing his job for his constituency.
This business of political Parties has burst and the sooner that is realised the better. In future, people will elect the man who will work for them, who will look after their interests and who will not be afraid to speak on their behalf. That is the type of man who will be elected in the future to this House, whether he is from Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, the Labour Party or any other Party.
What I object to in regard to the small Parties is what happens. Ever since I came into this House, I have seen how many sold out. You had, after the second-last election, a picture drawn by a Deputy of what happened outside a Deputy's house the night before the Taoiseach was elected. The leaders of one Party were outside knocking at the door of his house. They wanted him to vote a certain way and that vote was going to decide which of the two Parties would be in office. How low does a thing like that bring political life or the public institutions of the State. Here you had two leaders of a Party knocking at the door, walking into a Deputy's house and asking how much did he want for his vote the following day. He would be made a Minister. That is what happened.
Those are the conditions under which a Government can be elected under the P.R. system. There is no danger for small Parties under the straight vote system. Let us take the Labour Deputy as an example. No man can tell me that, if one-third of South Cork were carved out to-morrow, Deputy Desmond would not get a seat. He would, in spite of anything. No one can tell me that Deputy McAuliffe would not be elected.
Comment on this
I know the Deputy does his work, and any Deputy who works will be elected. It is the fellow who will not look after his constituents who will get in once or twice but never afterwards.
Comment on this
No. This is the third or fourth time that I have had Deputy Moher as a colleague. He does his job.
Comment on this
What will happen to the team which travelled round in a motor-car from booth to booth on polling day from an early hour to tell the fellow at the gate: "So-and-So is all right. We want two seats; vote for the weak man"? I have been round to them all and I know what happens. What will become of them? What I speak of happens in every constituency where two men are going forward.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Sullivan should keep quiet. I think he would be well advised to take the tip. How many times have we seen the results of what I refer to? If you get two out of three in enough constituencies, you will be on this side of the House and the other fellow will be on the other side.
Comment on this
What will happen under the P.R. system? I saw where William Kent, God rest his soul, was sixth and the seventh was elected. A man belonging to a political Party votes one and two for the two members of his own Party and to show what he thinks of the rest he gives his No. 3 vote to the fellow he hates most. Is that not what happens?
Comment on this
Some 1,300 votes went from the farmers' candidate in East Cork to a lady down in Cobh.
Comment on this
He understands that all right. Deputy Sweetman will be here, whether there is P.R. or not.
Comment on this
Fine Gael, Labour or any Party can come down to whatever spot I pick out myself and I will get them out. That is a fair offer. I promise another thing. If I can judge what will happen in future under this Bill, knowing the Deputy, but not knowing what will happen in his constituency, I think I can prophesy that his Party, will come back in sufficient numbers to establish a Government. If there is a lazy fellow now, who does not bother about his constituents, he will be found out and he will get the road. Make no doubt about that. However, that is only one side of the picture.
There is another aspect to it. Of what are those who oppose this Bill so afraid? Why are they afraid to face the people? This Bill is for the purpose of affording the people an opportunity of deciding under what kind of system they will elect their representatives. Are those who oppose it so much afraid of the people that they do not want the people to be consulted? Is that what is wrong? All this Bill will do is ask the people to choose between P.R. and the straight vote. There are Deputies here who described P.R. as a fraud and a cod, something introduced here by lunatics. So afraid are those Deputies of facing the people that one of them spent two hours here last night condemning this Bill, a Bill which proposes to wipe out the fraud and the cod. This Bill will not wipe out big Parties. In my opinion, it will have the opposite effect to what a great many speakers here think it will have.
Comment on this
Any Deputy who has looked after his constituents properly will have no trouble in being re-elected, irrespective of what political badge he wears.
Comment on this
If a Deputy falls asleep after he is elected and only wakes up when the next general election comes round he will deserve anything he gets. Under P.R., he gets a second lease of life; he will not gets a second lease under this Bill. The dodgers, the sleepyheads and the lazy representatives will get the road.
Comment on this
There is where the change will be. I cannot understand why these people are so excited. Very few of them must be doing their job properly. Deputy Dillon made a lot of noise here last night. I know Deputy Dillon does not bother about his constituents from the time he is elected to the time he has to go back to them again, and that is the reason why he made all the noise here last night.
Comment on this
Did Deputy O'Sullivan read what Deputy Dillon said about P.R.? Did he hear him last night? What does he think of him now?
Comment on this
A Deputy comes in here and spends two hours defending something in which he does not believe and in which he has no faith. He described it as a fraud and a cod. If he thinks it is his duty now to come in here and defend what he described as a fraud and a cod in 1947, then I think we would be the better for his absence.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon said P.R. was introduced by half lunatics. He said it was tried out on the dog. He said no country in the world would have it but ourselves. I will send that speech over to Deputy O'Sullivan, if he wishes to see it.
Comment on this
Read it then, and see if it is possible to justify a Deputy occupying two hours of the time of this House defending what he called a fraud here. How can he defend it? It is no wonder some people are afraid as to the respect that will be shown for the institutions of this State.
We have heard a good deal about people understanding P.R. Now, there was an old woman in my constituency who had no reason to have any great love for me. The boys got at her three weeks before the election to show her how to vote. They warned her, and warned her, and warned her. They were at the door of the polling booth the day she voted and, as she was coming out, one of them caught her by the arm and said: "I hope you did it right.""Oh," she said, "I only gave that Corry one vote and I gave Barry five." That is what happens. Anyone who goes to see the count has a fairly good idea of the kind of voting that goes on. For example, poor Bill Broderick got 1,000 over the quota, and, on the redistribution system, I got those 1,000 No. 2's, and we were both in opposite camps.
Comment on this
That is how Deputy O'Sullivan succeeded is coming in here. He had a couple of "fooleens" in North Cork. I ask the Deputy not to interrupt me. I do not want to say things that may hurt him.
Comment on this
We have seen what has happened. I am not at all surprised at the people who tried to foment a Fascist revolution here being afraid to have the will of the people consulted now. I am trying to be reasonable in my approach, but it is very difficult to remain reasonable, in the light of what we had to listen to here last night. I have endeavoured to approach this matter in the light of present-day circumstances. I firmly believe that there would be very little change in this House after a general election held on the straight vote system to-morrow except that a certain number of passengers, who are not paying their fares, would disappear.
I have examined the matter thoroughly. I could spend hours explaining where second preferences went and where third preferences went and all that kind of tripe. I do not believe in it.
Consider the relief it will be to the ordinary representative here. If a Deputy is looking after something in his constituency he will not have two other Deputies putting in their noses and saying: "I shall look after it with you." If a Deputy gets a job done for his constituency, such as having a grant made available, an industry established, or something else, he will not have a political organisation coming along three weeks or a month afterwards and thanking some other fellow for getting it. That is what is happening at present under P.R. That will not happen. The Deputy will have his own constituency and it will be his job to look after it. If he does not look after it while he is a member of Parliament, he will not have the chance of looking after it again because, if he does not do his job right, he will get the boot at the next election. He will not survive a second election if he does not do his job. That is the way I regard this matter and I have a fair idea of it.
Above everything else, I do not like Coalitions. The present system leads too much to Coalitions, leads too much to conglomeration and to the kind of picture that, unfortunately, was drawn in this House a while ago of leaders of a Party knocking at the door of a Deputy's house asking: "How much do you want for your vote? We shall make you Minister for Health if you will vote for our man."
Comment on this
The Deputy is not quoting. If he were quoting he would be required to give the reference.
Comment on this
I am giving examples of what happens under this maxium-gatherum and the price paid. There were seven or eight votes there belonging to the unfortunate farmers of this country. The price was, one a Minister and another a Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
Nobody is talking about anybody's entitlement. I consider that I am entitled to be Taoiseach or——
Comment on this
What one is entitled to is a matter of opinion, but if I walked in with five votes, or even two votes, and those votes were to decide which two men were to sit on one side or the other here, I know the price I would ask and the price I would get.
Comment on this
There is no use talking tripe of that description. It has been done and we have had that disgraceful picture drawn in this House of what did happen under that system. Let us be logical and look facts in the face. I do not grudge any group of Parties coming in here and forming a Government. I do not care. I think it is bad to have one Party too long in Government. It is the worst thing that could happen in any country.
Against that, you have the other picture that I drew here, the picture of a country being governed fairly, safely and everything being looked after, where, after 25 years of Government, you were paying £4,000,000 a year interest and principal on debt and a maximum-gatherum crowed came in and put it up to £10,000,000 in three years.
Comment on this
These are the things that count with the people—the results of P.R., what it does and how it works out in the final analysis, where every man has his price and, if you refuse to pay, you have the Taoiseach running to the Park. On the day you refuse to pay the price demanded by any one of the little splinters, the Taoiseach will have to run to the Park. I saw Deputy Oliver Flanagan there having to talk for a day and a half so that the Taoiseach would get an opportunity of going, to the Park, that he would not be kicked out here before he would go. We all saw that. As soon as they found that one of the splinters was gone, that one of the sticks propping up the menagerie was gone, there was immediate consultation with Deputies who were sick to know if they would be able to come. Failing that, an unfortunate Deputy in those benches was condemned to speak for a whole day, and half a day.
Comment on this
The Deputy might explain another thing—why the average life of a Fianna Fáil Government was less than the average life of an inter-Party Government. What section forced Mr. de Valera to go so repeatedly to the Park?
Comment on this
That is one of the evils of P.R. I remember being here one time and my legs were worn from galloping up that stairs. I remember the first time I came over here I saw a poor Deputy flying out of Buswell's Hotel, with his coat thrown on his arm and one half of his face shaved and the other half lathered. He was running across here to vote.
Comment on this
You have the position under this system that it takes two elections to give the people an opportunity of deciding whether they will get rid of a certain crowed or not. They decided on the second round. That is why we had general elections in 1932 and 1933 and in 1943 and 1944. Deputy Dillon told the truth on that. Fancy being in here as a member of a Party, as we were for a couple of years, depending on the Ceann Comhairle's casting vote. The first time we came in here we thought we had hunted them until John Jinks disappeared.
Comment on this
The Deputy is only a baby in this thing. How long ago is it since there was a vote of no confidence in the then Government and one member of a Party disappeared in order to give the Taoiseach, or the President as he was then, a chance of running to the country? That was in June, 1927, after a general election and we had another election in September, 1927. John Jinks saved the day that time. You had those things happening all along the line. Two men sitting up there could decide who was to be Taoiseach. They could belong to whatever Party they liked to call themselves. We have seen a lot of these Parties coming and going here.
Then you have the wretched spectacle of the purchase and the purchase price. As soon as that is over you have the retainer which must be paid to each Party in the shape of policy to enable the Government to continue. That is what has happened. You have poor Deputy Corish saying that they could have relieved unemployment were it not that he could not get agreement with the rest of them. That was because each Party had its retainer to get and had to get it. Those are the things that are happening under the present system.
I am a firm believer in a man having charge of his constituency and looking after it. If he does not look after it, let him go back to the people and they will deal with him. How many people have we seen coming in here for one or two terms and then going out for ever? You have those changes happening in every constituency. You have often seen that happening with small Parties who go to the people and say: "Here is our programme. Everything you want in the world is there. The Garden of Eden is there only for you to come into it." They are elected. They come in here, as Deputy Dillon came in here, and they sit down as leader of a Party and then, after three months, negotiations take place, the price is paid, and they are over there. The poor innocent man whom they succeeded in taking away had to sit down alone as a sole representative left of a Party of eight. That was poor Deputy Bill Kent, God rest his soul. He was the only man who was not for sale, who had no purchase price. We know what they did then. I personally had to go down 18 miles and bring my men with me to do that man's threshing.
Comment on this
The Deputy should make an effort to come to the Bill. The threshing of corn does not come into it.
Comment on this
I am very much on the Bill, Sir. I am pointing out what happens to members of small Parties who do not follows their leader. I do not wish to go further into it. I have put up my reasons for supporting the Bill. I am prepared to support, at any time, the judgment of the people. Let the people judge. They are good judges. I have survived 14 general elections and that is a pretty good record. I did it because, instead of being a slavish member of a Party, I have put my constituents first. Any Deputy who does that need not be afraid. Either with single member constituencies or any other system of election such Deputies will come back here.
Comment on this
Listening here for the past few weeks to the debate on this proposed change in the Constitution I wondered what is behind the Bill before the House. Knowing the inner workings of the Fianna Fáil Party, I wonder what is the real reason for the Bill. There are two lines of thought I could turn to on the matter. The first is that when Fianna Fáil appealed to the people in the last election they asked for a majority strong enough to carry out a programme which they laid before the people. That programme was one of more work, less emigration, better prices for the farmer and an increase in old age pensions. That programme eventually led the people to decide that, on those promises, Fianna Fáil were entitled to a bigger majority in this House.
Having got that the majority and having been almost two years in office, nothing was done about that programme which they laid before the people and now we have this Constitution Bill. That makes me wonder whether this Bill was brought in to try to take the minds of the people off the serious issues facing the country at the present time. Listening to the various speakers from the Government benches—and I must say there were very few speakers from those benches—I was struck by the fact that they confined their remarks to the following of leaders of various Parties. I have been following this debate very closely for the past three weeks and I was not surprised that, as I have said, very few Fianna Fáil Deputies offered themselves. The few who did offer themselves have been chosen members who were told by the Chief: "Get in there and make a contribution to this debate."