An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1958—Tairiscint (atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1958—Motion (resumed).
Contributions 134–273 of 273. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1958 ›
I wanted to mention that we had a decision from the Seanad and this motion proposes that we should disregard that decision.
Comment on this
The decision of the Seanad is not referred to in the motion. This is a motion to put into operation a provision of the Constitution.
Comment on this
On a point of order, surely the whole kernel of this discussion is that the Government want to ride roughshod over the decision of the Seanad?
Comment on this
I am putting it as a point of order to the Chair that there is a motion down here, arising out of the decision of the Seanad and, as a matter of order——
Comment on this
No. There is a difference between the matter the Seanad decided on and the decision of the Seanad.
Comment on this
I should be only too happy if, for the guidance of the House, you would define the difference between the decision of the Seanad and what the Seanad decided.
Comment on this
The matter which the Seanad decided on is quite a different matter from the decision of the Seanad—as the decision of the Seanad.
Comment on this
Would it not be in order to discuss the necessity for the introduction of this motion?
Comment on this
I did not ask that. I asked would it be in order to discuss the necessity for the introduction of this motion. The necessity was the defeat of the Bill by the Seanad.
Comment on this
The motion before the House is a motion by the Taoiseach to put into operation a provision of the Constitution. That is the matter before the House and the decision of the Seanad does not arise on that, as the decision of the Seanad.
Comment on this
They are the words of the Constitution. The Deputy does not want to discuss the Constitution?
Comment on this
Again, on a point of order, surely this motion not only concerns, may I put it, what the Seanad decided, but also discusses an amendment of the Constitution. Surely the Deputy is in order in discussing the Constitution.
Comment on this
I understood from the Chair's remark that the Deputy was being—perhaps "reprimanded" would be too strong a word —but being advised not to discuss the Constitution.
Comment on this
Exactly. That is what I am trying to keep him within and Deputy O'Higgins knows it, I think.
Comment on this
I know what is under discussion, but, in case I am wrong in any particular, I look to the Chair for guidance.
Comment on this
It is surprising that the Taoiseach spoke so briefly when he came to the House with this motion. Unfortunately, although this matter has been fully discussed and debated, the Taoiseach never took the Opposition to task in this House on this issue. He came in here and introduced the Bill many months ago and hardly said anything in favour of it or anything that could be debated with him. He merely stood up, spoke a few words, sat down, and then went out. Similarly, when replying to the Second Reading debate, he said very little. He came in on this occasion with the motion in order to steamroll it through with the majority he has. Again, he said very little—a couple of dozen words.
Comment on this
I do not consider that it is a lesson and most people in the country do not consider that it is a lesson. The point I want to make is that the Taoiseach when he comes in here can be taken to task, and any points or arguments he has to put up can be debated, but he ran out of the House every time and was not seen in the House until the end of the debate.
Comment on this
The point I want to make is that if the Taoiseach thinks he has a case for this, why does he not come in here and listen to the debate? Why did he not go up to the Seanad and listen to the debate there? Because he does not want to hear any arguments. He sees the advantage for the Fianna Fáil Party and he is determined to take that advantage, if he possibly can.
I feel that this is such an important issue that we should have got a comprehensive statement from the Taoiseach when he was introducing this motion. It is very unusual to have a measure come back to the Dáil from the Seanad and then put to this House in order to have it steamrolled through by a majority. The Taoiseach seems to have plenty to say when he goes down the country to the Party conventions, but, of course, he cannot be taken to task at these conventions. He has avoided taking part in the debate here. In fact, it is remarkable that the majority of the Government front benchers, apart from coming into the House and going out of it again, have kept away from the Bill and left it to the Opposition to have the matter fully discussed and debated.
I mentioned already that in Britain over a million people voted for the Liberals in the last election but did not get one seat. We could have the situation here where a large number of people would support a particular Party or policy and yet fail to get representation in the Dáil. The Manchester Guardian in a leading article this morning, which is quoted in the Irish Independent to-day, says:
It is hard to believe that any other electoral system could have done more to establish Irish politics on a firm constitutional basis.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it in order for a succession of Fine Gael Deputies to come in here with the same brief and cuttings from the Manchester Guardian?
Comment on this
It is only a game— that is a new attitude to politics.
Comment on this
That is a new outlook on proportional representation.
Comment on this
I should like to take this opportunity of welcoming Deputy Vivion de Valera to the House. This is the second time I have seen him since the change of Government in 1957.
Comment on this
I have been giving a quotation from the Manchester Guardian and I have a different point to make on it from that made by other Deputies. This article, which supported the retention of proportional representation in Ireland, continued:—
Some modification of the electoral system may be required. Must this involve the overthrow of P.R.? Might not the object be achieved by substituting three member constituencies for those which at present return five or more members—or, perhaps better, by institution of one-seat constituencies using the alternative vote?
That is the system which we have at present in by-elections. We get a very fair result from the by-elections under the alternative vote system. The man who wrote this article considers it a very fair system and he is a man who is outside this country completely.
Comment on this
The Manchester Guardian had a very interesting article on proportional representation on Saturday.
Comment on this
That must have appeared in yesterday's issue and it was quoted today by the Irish Independent.
Comment on this
The article goes on:—
The pity is that, by forcing the electorate to choose between the present method and one as different and as uncongenial to many Irishmen as that used in Britain, Mr. de Valera has barred the middle road. Ireland will eventually be the loser if its parliamentarians are forced, as in Britain, into one of two Party strait jackets.
I want to point out that under the changed system of election, there would be only one large straitjacket here for 20 years, much to the disadvantage of the community at large. The rights of the citizens would obviously disappear when they would not have proper representation in Parliament and you might have a situation where the majority of the people outside the Dáil would decide to set up a Parliament outside Leinster House.
We have seen such a situation in another country where our good friend Castro and his revolutionaries decided to do away with the minority government, a government representing a minority of the citizens of that country. There was a revolution there by the majority of the people led by Fidel Castro. There were many abuses in that country. The system of the spoils of office operated there and then we had the revolution and all that followed it.
Similarly, we have seen the situation in Britain when there was a swing to one side or the other. We have seen policies completely reversed, much to the discomfort and loss of the people affected. We had on one occasion the nationalisation of the steel industry when one government got into office and immediately another government got in, it was denationalised. We have Conservatism on one occasion and Socialism on another. Those are the drastic changes which can come about under the two-Party system as opposed to the system of election under proportional representation.
We could also have a situation in which industries would be nationalised and private enterprise invaded and that policy reversed subsequently by a new Government. We could have a great deal of economic disturbance. We could have drastic changes of policy. During the 40 years since our own Government was established, we have not been subjected to these misfortunes, chiefly because our system of election prevented any drastic changes, particularly changes which might impose great hardship on one or other section of the community. We had a strong Cosgrave Government under proportional representation—a Government which functioned despite the very grave difficulties which faced them during those years. It was followed by a strong Fianna Fáil Government for approximately 16 years. We had then two inter-Party Governments. On the average, the inter-Party Governments had a longer life than the average Fianna Fáil Government. The fact is that under the proportional representation system the people have an opportunity of electing whatever Government they like. The proposed new system will not afford them the same opportunity.
In these days, one is justified in asking why the voters' attention is being diverted to electoral changes rather than directed to the very grave economic problems facing the country. It is obvious the Fianna Fáil Party have no intention of doing anything about the problems which exist. They want to take the people's minds away from them. If they succeed in getting the new system of election through, they do not care what happens to the people in general. At the moment we have a Government with a working majority of 20. Would the Fianna Fáil Government be any better off with a majority of 80 under the proposed system? Surely the Fianna Fáil Party cannot argue that it is impossible to implement an effective economic policy with a majority of 20?
Comment on this
I am working on the division lists. There is very little case to be made for taking away from the people the system which has operated so well up to this. There is no indication that the new system will be a suitable system. Our people are very patient. They are very fairminded. If they find an injustice has been done to them it is not likely they will show the same kind of patience as we see elsewhere.
This is a selfish move on the part of Fianna Fáil. The Taoiseach has talked about a multiplicity of Parties. There are only three political Parties in the House with a membership of more than four. Surely the Taoiseach cannot contend that it is harmful for divergent political opinions to be represented here, when there are only three political Parties with a membership of more than four. Obviously, he is thinking of the danger of a break-up in his own Party in which, when he is gone, one might have the Lemass group, the Aiken group, the MacEntee group and the Ryan group. That is the multiplicity of Parties against which the Taoiseach wishes to provide. This legislation is for the purpose of cementing his Party and keeping them together, whether they like it or not. He knows very well that they would not have stood together in the past, were it not for his unifying influence. Now that he has decided to leave active politics, he brings in this system, irrespective of whether or not it is good for the people, in order to maintain the Fianna Fáil Party as a unified political organisation.
It is very difficult to reconcile the Taoiseach's attitude today with his action in the past. We remember the praises he sang of our present system of election in 1937. It is the system which elected Fianna Fáil to government in eight general elections over 16 years. It is the system which sent Fianna Fáil back at every election. It was kind to him then, even though, in more recent times, it may have been unkind to him. It would, of course, be unkind to him again, if the people were given the opportunity at another general election. It is intended, however, to change the system of voting before the next general election. It is a clever move because it means that it will no longer be possible to put Fianna Fáil out, but it would have been possible to put them out had the present system been maintained.
The new system will render the votes of many people ineffective because, if they do not vote for Fianna Fáil, they may as well stay at home. They will be wasting their time just like the man I mentioned earlier who has been voting Liberal for 25 years and never yet had a Liberal representative in the House of Commons. It is unfair to create a situation wherein the opportunity a man gets of expressing his opinion on a ballot paper is rendered ineffective. A vote will be of very little use to him unless he is a supporter of Fianna Fáil because that is the Party the system favours.
The Taoiseach says he dislikes coalitions and that is the reason he has decided to bring in this new system. If we examine the record of the two coalition Governments, we find he is jealous of the achievements of those two coalition Governments. In 1948, the first coalition Government was confronted with a position of utter stagnancy. The situation was not a happy one; we had to float a loan of £10,000,000 to pay the Fianna Fáil debts which had accumulated over a period of 16 years.
Comment on this
They do not want to hear about the £10,000,000 apparently. They had hoped that it was forgotten but it has not been, so when it comes to talking about coalitions, it must be remembered that the coalition had to float a loan of £10,000,000 to pay the debts left by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
£10,000,000 is small when compared with the external assets which were squandered.
Comment on this
The country lost as a result of the first coalition.
Comment on this
Did the Minister for Industry and Commerce lose his £100,000,000? What happened to that?
Comment on this
This is developing into an argument and Deputy Rooney is the only Deputy in possession.
Comment on this
Those are mainly the points I wanted to make against this proposal. It has already been widely debated, but we have not heard from the other side of the House, any arguments that would convince the people that this proposal is for the good of the nation. If the nation could be convinced that the new system would give more bread, more work or better conditions for our people, and more houses, possibly Fianna Fáil would be justified in asking the people to support it, but the Fianna Fáil Party cannot tell them that it will give more work, more security or a place at home instead of a berth on the emigrant ship. Those are the arguments the people want to hear, that the new voting system will give them an improved standard of living with better pay, better conditions and more security.
That is the attitude the Fianna Fáil Party should adopt and that is what the people want to hear. If Fianna Fáil could say all that to the people, they would get their support. If they could show the people in what way a change in the voting system will improve their standard of living or make things easier for the ordinary men and women in this country, the people would be far more interested in those better conditions than in a change in their system of voting.
Every effort is being made by the Fianna Fáil Party to take from the people the system which they have been operating successfully for so long. Unfortunately, the people have only a month left now in which to decide to hold on to the system which has been so fair to them and under which only three Taosigh, Mr. Cosgrave, Deputy de Valera and Deputy Costello, functioned here as leaders of three different Governments. It is fair to say that the system has been satisfactory so far as the ordinary electors are concerned and efforts to change it do not appear to be justified.
Comment on this
In introducing this motion and thereby disregarding, out-of-hand, the considered judgment and decision of Seanad Éireann, the Taoiseach has, in effect, made a laughing stock of the Houses of the Oireachtas as presently constituted, and has gone a long way towards impairing the good name this country has enjoyed abroad amongst the democratic countries, for fair play, justice and honesty in its Parliamentary activities.
The whole history and background leading up to this motion must appear almost unbelievable to a stranger. We are seeking now, through this motion, to put to the people, at this most inopportune time, the question as to whether the electoral system which has been operating here since the foundation of the State should or should not be changed. We need go back only to the last general election to pinpoint how unreal this suggestion is. Quite candidly, I was concerned actively in the last general election and as a candidate, I did not hear the remotest hint from any of the Fianna Fáil candidates in my constituency, or in any other constituency, that the system of election under which we were then seeking election was wrong or unsuitable for this country.
Every Deputy sitting in the House now, every Deputy for or against the proposal, was elected under the P.R. system. There are many of us who, perhaps, would not be here if some other system of election had been in operation, and that applies to people on all sides of the House. Something which must strike us immediately is that of all the very many problems, and of all the very many points put before the people for their decision in the 1957 general election, not one tittle was there regarding the merits or the demerits of the P.R. system of election. We discussed the food subsidies; we discussed unemployment; we argued about emigration; each Party put forward their policy on Partition and on the revival of the Irish language; we discussed whether, and to what extent, we needed new school accommodation, further housing accommodation; and, to a large extent, we concentrated our energies and our powers of arguments on the merits of one-Party government versus multi-Party government.
All those issues were debated up and down the country at every crossroads, outside every church gate, in every hall that was hired to hold an election meeting. We had that whole wide field of discussion but none of the candidates who were then contesting the election, and are now on the Government side of the House, suggested to the people that the time was opportune for a change in the method of election. That was not an issue before the people at all and the people operated the election system as they found it, the only system they have ever known, when returning the Government Party to this House.
At the end of last year, like a bolt out of the blue, the Taoiseach announced at the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis that it was his considered view that the system of election which had returned him to office, less than two years previously, was a bad system; that the system which had returned his Party to power for 16 out of 20 years was a bad system, and that it needed changing. Nobody had suggested it up to that, but, of course, by the mysterious powers of mysticism and hypnotism the Taoiseach apparently wields over the members of his Party, straight away you had a thousand voices reechoing the master's voice: "P.R. is bad; we must rid ourselves of it." Straight away you had Deputies up and down the country convening their closest Party assistants and carrying out a process of conditioning the people for this referendum.
The question was obviously so important, taking precedence over all our other various problems that we had discussed during the last general election campaign, that it now transpired all the things which all of us argued about during that campaign were unimportant in the light of the major brainwave the Taoiseach got, prior to the Fianna Fáil Árd-Fheis. Immediately the political Parties and the people of the country were asked to concentrate all their thoughts and all their energies on this alleged major problem. For a while, we were to forget that we still had a very serious unemployment problem, and probably that was one of the reasons for the introduction of the proposal.
We were to forget, in particular, that the Government were elected largely on the promises they made to end the unemployment problem. They had paraded up and down the country with the slogan: "Elect Fianna Fáil and end your unemployment problem" and "Wives, get your husbands back to work." That problem was now to be brushed aside. We were to forget our housing problems and our school problems; we were to forget the economic problems that beset the nation; and we were to concentrate all our energies on considering whether or not the system of election, which had received the approval of all Parties in this House down through the years, was a correct one, and whether or not it should be dispensed with. That was so important that the Dáil had to be re-convened during a time when, in the normal way, it would be in recess for the Christmas period. It was reconvened and we had a long and full discussion here on the merits and demerits of the Bill, on its introduction and on its passage through the various Stages.
It was alleged then, of course, by the speakers on behalf of the Government Party that it was being talked out here for the sake of obstruction because the people on this side of the House did not wish it to go to the people. I do not believe that the Government spokesmen were serious in that argument, but, nevertheless, it was put forward. I think the people of the country appreciate the service that was rendered to them by the Opposition Parties in discussing this matter at such length, endeavouring to bring to bear on the subject all possible arguments, and in endeavouring to have the public enlightened before the referendum was held. At any rate, after a very full discussion here, the Bill went through because the Government Party, being a majority Party in this House, had the necessary majority, and the majority ruled. It then went to the Seanad and I think any unbiassed person will agree that the debate on the issue in the Seanad was first-class.
I think the prestige of the Seanad went up very much, in the estimation of the thinking people of this country, because of the manner in which they dealt with this Bill. When I say "dealt with", I am not speaking of the decision they ultimately made. I am speaking of the contributions, the valid and cogent arguments brought to bear on the subject by spokesmen on both sides of the Seanad. I think nobody can accuse the Seanad of not having dealt conscientiously with the Bill. Eventually, the Bill was rejected by the Seanad and I personally feel that it is regrettable that, in spite of the decision of the Seanad, the Taoiseach has seen fit—particularly at this time when he is contemplating retiring from public life after a very long career—to disregard completely the wishes of the Seanad and foist the issue on an electorate that really does not want it.
It must be the experience of all of us that the people are saying: "Why must we have all this hub-bub; why is so much time being wasted on an issue such as this when we have so many other problems confronting us?" The Taoiseach may have miscalculated the feelings of the people. He may have mistimed it in introducing the Bill originally, but I do feel he got a wonderful opportunity of a way out, without loss of face to anybody, on the Bill being rejected in the Seanad. I think he certainly would not have lost face and would have gone up in the estimation of the people, if he had then said: "Very well; the time appears to be inopportune for a decision on this matter by the people. I shall accept public opinion as voiced in the Seanad, where I could not get a majority, and I shall postpone this Bill, pending the further investigation of this matter in a cooler atmosphere, in a non-political atmosphere, by some commission or other." I personally regret that the Taoiseach did not avail of the golden opportunity which then presented itself to him.
Be that as it may, we now find ourselves faced with the whole political hurly-burly being brought to bear on a decision affecting the Constitution. To my mind any change in the Constitution of a State is a very, very important matter. I feel that any change, irrespective of what it is or by whom it is proposed, so long as it is a change in the Constitution of a State, should be debated and argued and voted on in the calmest possible atmosphere. Such changes as appear desirable but which do not appear to be urgent—where it matters not whether you take them this year or the year after—should be time so as to coincide as much as possible with a period where you have comparative political quiet and general calm in the country. It is highly undesirable that such changes should be forced on the people when very many other problems of a very grave nature are besetting them.
It is unfortunate that on this occasion the people who had the power to do so should have seen fit to ask the people to consider a constitutional change of this magnitude, a change in the system by which the members are elected to this Parliament. As I say, if other major problems were absent, the time might be opportune to ask them to consider and give their judgment on such a question but the people are not concerned with that at the moment. As we are aware, on both sides of the House, the problem confronting the ordinary man at present is one of getting a job, and of keeping it, and of raising a family on the wages paid to him. The problem besetting ordinary families is the fact that jobs cannot be found for sons and daughters and that when they come of age almost automatically they must emigrate to find employment. The problem besetting those left at home is the low standard of living for the large mass of the people.
Comment on this
I do not propose to develop them and I am just mentioning them in passing. With problems such as those existing and foremost in the minds of the people, without attributing any reasons for the existence of these problems, I am simply suggesting that this appears to me to be a time which is most inopportune to ask the people to decide a purely constitutional issue which, to my mind, should be debated and decided in the calmest possible atmosphere, away from political dissension of any description. Of course, to make confusion more confounded, we add to these problems by deciding to hold a referendum at the same time as the Presidential election. Whoever decided that has, first of all, done a disservice to the office of President. He has, or they have, done a grave disservice to that office and a disservice to the people by expecting them to give their decision on a constitutional issue at a time when they are being cajoled and bludgeoned on purely political issues by political Parties.
That is the situation and it behoves those of us who are charged with doing so—because of the responsibility we accept when we enter public life—to make our case, even in this undesirable atmosphere. I was particularly struck during the passage of this Bill through this House and through the Seanad, up to the time of its rejection by that House, that there was unaminity on one point by all sides. It was unanimously accepted, and was not disputed, that the proposed new electoral system would be the means of ensuring that small Parties could not be represented in this House. Nobody seriously tried to refute the allegation that the smaller Parties in this House at the moment would disappear in the first election after the change, if the referendum is carried.
The case was made by the Government Party that that is a desirable thing. It is regarded as undesirable to have an independent Labour Party in this House. It is, apparently, regarded as undesirable to have a Farmers' Party here, the Clann na Talmhan Party. It is desirable, apparently to ensure that the Sinn Féin Party, who have an abstentionist policy, cannot succeed in carrying their case so far as saying: "At least we elected a man to the House and we will pursue our policy by indicating that we shall not go there."
I do not want to develop the argument which I made on the Second Stage of this Bill as to what effect that will have, particularly in relation to the people who hold extreme views, as expressed in incidents over the past few years. At any rate, the Government tune appears to be that small Parties are undesirable. We had the Taoiseach saying here, and I am quite sure he has repeated it, that small Parties were undesirable because they went out at election times and made promises which they did not intend to fulfil because they knew that on their own they could not form a Government. I think it ill-behoves any Fianna Fáil spokesman to upbraid any of the smaller Parties regarding their conduct in relation to promises made during election campaigns. If I wished to do so—but I do not wish to delay the House—I could produce a sheaf of pamphlets issued by the Fianna Fáil Party during the last general election outlining their promises, which, of course, they did not implement. It would perhaps, be particularly embarrassing for Deputy Galvin and Deputy Healy were I to produce the election literature published in our constituency in the city of Cork. I have done so previously and, with the help of God, I shall do so again in the future but in a debate of this nature I do not wish to quote them again.
It is quite clear, and the people sitting opposite know it as well as I do, that it is not a valid argument for any member of the Government Party to say that small Parties are undesirable because they make promises. That is not a valid argument. There may be other arguments why a person could hold the view that small Parties are undesirable and while I do not hold that view it is one which I am prepared to argue and also to respect. My answer is that if small Parties are undesirable surely the proper way to have that decided is by the people at each general election.
The people should not be asked to decide once and for all, as they appear to be invited to do now, whether it is desirable that smaller Parties should have representation in this House in relation to the support they get at any general election. The people should not be asked to commit themselves irretrievably to that situation, but should be allowed at each general election to decide whom they want to elect. If sufficient people see fit and proper at any general election to elect 12, 14, 16 or 20 Deputies of the Labour Party, they are entitled to do so. The Parties opposing them at that election can bring all the arguments they wish to bear on the matter and can advise the people against electing them, but surely it is fundamental to democracy that the people should be allowed to do so, if they wish.
We are being charged by speakers on the opposite side with stringing this debate out. They say: "Why not let the people decide?" Not alone am I prepared to allow the people to decide in the referendum but I am prepared to allow them to decide at each general election, under the P.R. system, whether it is desirable to have a two-party parliament or a parliament in which there are one or two major Parties and other Parties representing interests who have the support of the electors.
It is quite clear that the question of a one-Party government or a multi-Party government can be put before the people at each general election. In 1951, in 1954 and in 1957, the people were clearly asked to decide between a one-Party government represented by the Fianna Fáil Party or a multi-Party government represented by the other people who had associated with one another during the first inter-Party Government in 1948. The issue was quite clear in 1951, 1954 and 1957. On two out of those three occasions, the people decided they wanted a one-Party Government, in 1951 and in 1957. In those years, the people opted for a one-Party Government and they were entitled to get it. In 1954, the other of these three occasions, the people decided for a multi-Party Government and they got it. I do not see where that contravenes any democratic thought or practice. The people were entitled and allowed to decide on this issue in 1951, 1954, and 1957 and they should be allowed to decide also in 1960, 1970 or 1975.
It is claimed that under the proposed system of election, we will get more stable government, more responsible government, by having on one side of the House the major Government Party and one other large Party in opposition. I think it was the Tánaiste who advocated that the small Parties, the sectional interests or, as I think he called them, the pressure groups should, if they wanted their voice heard, join one or other of the major Parties, state their point of view there and endeavour to have their sectional point of view carried into the general policy of the major Party.
That is all right in theory but purely farm interests would not be quite at home with purely industrial interests. Labour interests would not regard as satisfactory a situation in which their ideals and aspirations would be discussed within a Party and carried only in so far as they could carry the strength of that Party internally. The place for the advocacy of the policy of these varied groups is here in Dáil Éireann. It would be a completely retrograde step that the facilities to discuss and advocate their policy in this House, which are now available to the Labour Party and to other Parties who endeavour to represent certain interests, should be taken away from them and that there should be substituted for this Chamber some back room in a political hall where they would endeavour to convince internally the Party bosses as to the merits of their case. I do not think any self-respecting section of our community, sectional interest, small Parties, pressure groups or whatever you like to call them, would accept or could be expected to accept that situation.
We are told that the new system will give us a better type of candidate. I doubt that. If you implement the straight vote system, the British or Stormont system, it is inevitable that the Fianna Fáil Party, for instance, being the Party with the major support in this country, would have a certain number of safe seats, approximately 30, and, similarly, the Fine Gael Party would have perhaps 20 safe seats. That could lead to wholesale abuse. In the filling of those seats, you would have open to you the abuse in relation to what could be regarded as a political reward for services rendered or services to be rendered by an individual to a political Party. It is no use closing our eyes to that. That could happen.
A safe Fianna Fáil seat could be given as a reward perhaps to a man who had rendered signal service to the country in the past, but who is now incapable of being a truly active representative on behalf of his constituents. It would be a human and understandable temptation for a political Party to say: "We shall give this safe seat to this poor fellow at the end of his days as a reward for what he has done." I do not think that the people of that constituency should be visited with such a disadvantage. Nor do I think that they would feel themselves that they were adequately represented; they would feel it was a complete abuse of the electoral system.
You can also have the situation where there is no such agreement, where the seat will not be regarded as an endowment to some man at the end of his days. You can understand the pulling, dragging and skull-duggery there will be within that political Party, which has in fact the power to grant a seat in this House to an individual. It could easily happen that 50 or more delegates of that Party would have the granting of a seat here to a particular individual. So long as that candidate was produced at the election, the people supporting the major Party would have no option but to put him in. The only other course open to them would be to vote contrary to their consciences and political thought. I do not think any of us would wish to see such a state of affairs existing here. I am sure many Fianna Fáil Deputies who have spoken on this matter up and down the country spoke with their tongues in their cheeks.
Speaking against the present electoral system, Deputy Booth made the point that where, for instance a Fine Gael candidate was elected on the votes of a Labour candidate on the third or fourth count, he was a peculiar type of candidate. He could not be three-quarters Fine Gael and a quarter Labour. Under the proposed allegedly straight system a Fianna Fáil candidate who gets the highest number of votes in a constituency contested also by Fine Gael, Labour, Farmers and Clann na Poblachta is elected, even though he gets only a minority of the total votes cast. He would then have to be some kind of a piebald Deputy, worse than Deputy Booth's man who is three-quarters Fine Gael and a quarter Labour. This man would have to be one-third Fianna Fáil and one-sixth each Fine Gael, Labour, Farmers and Clann na Poblachta because he would be the only representative the entire electorate in that constituency would have. I do not think anybody is competent to speak for all shades of political thought in any constituency.
You could have the situation of a Fine Gael candidate being elected as the sole representative in his constituency. He has to speak on behalf of those supporting Fianna Fáil, Labour and the Farmers. It is too much to expect that the Fianna Fáil constituent should be able to go along to a Fine Gael Deputy and endeavour to get him to put down a question in the House which would embarrass a Fine Gael Minister. Does anybody in his same senses think that would happen? Does anybody think that I could go along to Deputy Healy in Cork—I am taking Deputy Healy because as the sitting Deputy he represents me as one of his constituents—
Comment on this
Could anybody expect Deputy Healy to pursue a Labour or trade union matter raised by me which would embarrass his Minister? I do not think so. I do not think Deputy Healy would be dishonest in refusing to do that for me. The whole situation would probably be an embarrassment to him. The situation where you have three, four or five Deputies from the one constituency representing various interests but, by and large, representing the whole constituency and anxious to meet the wishes of the people generally and to press forward the welfare and advancement of the constituency as a whole, is a much more desirable situation.
I must say that the Taoiseach has not explained, to my satisfaction at any rate, the reason for the change of mind that has come over him over the years. He has not explained why he is now saying to the country and why he has now apparently convinced his own Party, outwardly at any event, that P.R. is bad, when he was saying in 1937 that the system we had we knew, that the people knew it and that it had worked well. At the time of the passing of the 1937 Constitution he expressed the opinion that the P.R. system gave fair representation and that it succeeded better than any other system we knew or had read about. Those were very straight and strong words. He has not explained to this House or to the people what happened since that time—outside of the fact that he was put out of government in 1948 and 1954—to make that P.R. system, which returned him to office on so many occasions, such an undesirable thing now. If he does not make that case strongly and quickly, he can look to his laurels when it comes to the referendum. My personal opinion is that in this issue the Taoiseach has bitten off more than he can chew, probably at the behest of some of the colleagues he is leaving behind him to carry on in a Fianna Fáil Government. First of all, they underestimated the intelligence of the people. They underestimated the energy of the Opposition and, all in all, I think they have made a major blunder which they will pay for on the day of the referendum. I am thoroughly convinced that with the Opposition Parties putting the case before the electorate and with thinking people generally being so convinced of the merits of the case being made by Opposition speakers, there is no doubt that, irrespective of the confusion that may be created by having the Presidential Election on the same day as the referendum, this will ultimately turn out to be a boomerang for the Fianna Fáil Party. Instead of being a blessing, it will be a boomerang for them; and for very many days to come they will regret their decision to force this on the people.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach's proposal that the Bill be deemed to have been passed has been challenged by the Leader of the Opposition. Deputy Costello's amendment is reasonable and should be accepted by the Government. It asks that further consideration be given to the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill which is aimed at the proportional representation system, a system which has operated here for so many years.
We are all well aware of the discussion in this House when this proposal was brought in here out of the blue, unexpectedly, without any recommendation from anybody except the Taoiseach. It seemed to me and to everybody on this side of the House that the Taoiseach evidently saw an opportunity of doing something for Fianna Fáil before he left that Party. The proposal he put before the House at that time was the abolition of P.R. The system of P.R. was first recommended in 1912 by the then President of Sinn Féin, Arthur Griffith. He described that system as most suitable for the Irish people. After the fight for freedom, when the first Government was formed, P.R. was put into the Constitution by Arthur Griffith and those associated with him in the first Government of this State. P.R. was the system of election considered most suitable.
After a number of years, the Taoiseach and his Party decided to come into this Dáil and not to disregard it, as Sinn Féin did at that time and as Sinn Féin are doing today. He came into this House in 1927. He was elected under that system and I think he was re-elected once or twice afterwards. In 1937, the Taoiseach decided that a new Constitution for this country was needed. He put a Constitution before the people and in doing so he described P.R. as the fairest method of election. That method of election has continued right up to the present time.
It is rather strange, after 37 years of trial, that P.R. has suddenly been declared a bad system for the Irish people. It has been declared a bad system because it is a system which gives the various sections of the people the right to express, through the ballot box, their views on Government policy. That Government policy will come under trial at least once in every five years, but, for various reasons, it has come under trial much oftener.
It is rather strange that the Taoiseach should ignore the views of those people who have given very sound reasons as to why P.R. should not be abolished. We are well aware that Fianna Fáil have an over-all majority in this House. The proposal had to go through because of that majority. We know the arguments that were made for and against. I think they made interesting reading to the people of the country.
We know all the arguments for and against the measure, as made in the Seanad. The debate there, too, was very interesting. It gave our people to understand that in our Seanad we have people of independent thought, people who are prepared to give a lead, and to give of their talents and their judgment in relation to what is best in the national interest. Having done that and the Bill having been rejected in the Seanad, it has come before this House again. As I have already said, the proposal which comes from the Taoiseach is that the Bill should be passed. To that proposal there is an amendment by Deputy J.A. Costello that the Bill be deferred for further consideration. That is a reasonable request. It is hard to understand the hurry in trying to push the measure through. It will go through, no doubt, but we on the Opposition benches feel that whether or not we are delaying the House, we are fulfilling a duty to the people who sent us here by debating the matter fully.
After 40 years of trial, the P.R. system of election is now being challenged. It will be for the people to decide. Under the present system we can have in any three-seat constituency, a Fianna Fáil T.D., a Fine Gael T.D. and perhaps a Labour or an Independent T.D. In that way, you have the largest Party, the second largest Party and the third, each represented. I do not know what line or argument one could put forward as to why that should not be so. We are told that the different sections of the people should always come together in the national interest. It can truly be said that when the fight for freedom took place in 1916, Pádraig Pearse, Tom Clarke and all the others associated with them did not ask any one section of the people to join the fight for freedom in which they laid down their lives.
I think, too, a grave mistake is being made if we introduce the proposed system which will represent a policy controlled by one Party. We cannot hope to have unity, particularly in elements—Labour, for instance. Is no weapon to be left in their hands except the strike weapon? Is the Parliamentary Question, which is considered the Constitutional way of putting one's point of view before the people, to be disregarded as it will be disregarded if Labour does not get representation in this House?
Another matter, too, which has of late been recognised is that the farmers are a very important section of our people who play a major part in the economic life of the country. Does the proposed new system mean that if they want to come into this Parliament, they must go to a political club, take out a membership card and hope to get selected by the Party at election time and then come forward to represent the farmers? If the farmers of Ireland and the working people of Ireland decide they want to send forward a candidate from among their own people, affiliated to their own union, whether he be a representative of the farmers or of the working people, they are entitled to say that he is the man they want to put forward at the election.
Under the proposal now before the House, it is intended, instead of having the multiple-seat constituency with the transferable vote, to have a single-seat constituency with a non-transferable vote. That means that in, say, a four-seat constituency—I represent such a constituency—if Fianna Fáil can get in respect of each of these four seats 40 per cent. of the votes, then they get all the seats. On the other hand, if Fine Gael get 35 per cent. and Labour 25 per cent., they get no representation. There you have clearly a picture where 40 per cent. of the voters in an election decide that their candidate represents that constituency and the 60 per cent. who have not decided to give them their No. 1 vote get no representation. To my mind, that is a very undemocratic system. It is a very grave situation and can result in disaster.
If an attempt is made to keep down people who may have grievances or to get them to yield to a political power, no matter how great, the people will rebel against it.
The British were here for 700 years and at the end of that time the people decided to get the freedom of the country and control of State institutions. It is those parliamentary institutions, which were bought so dearly and at such great sacrifice in 1916 to 1921 that are now being threatened.
In the last revision of constituencies, in 1947, Fianna Fáil decided that there should be nine five-seat constituencies, 22 three-seat constituencies and nine four-seat constituencies. In 1947, having been in power for years, Fianna Fáil felt fairly safe but wanted to make themselves safer. In 1947, they gave the people an opportunity to decide that 51 per cent of the votes would entitle a Party to a majority of seats. They felt that they would get 51 per cent of the votes in most of the three-seat constituencies, which would give them two out of every three seats. It had worked pretty well for them in the past, but it did not work so well from 1947, for, in 1948, the Parties who formed the inter-Party Government gained substantially in some of the three-seat constituencies and those Parties, who had been 16 years in the wilderness, so to speak, felt it was time to come together, find out how far they could agree on a common policy and put it into operation. We know how well they succeeded for three years. We know, and the farmers know, that the prices of cattle soared from year to year because the Minister for Agriculture of the inter-Party Government, Deputy Dillon, decided that civil servants would not go to England to seek a market for our cattle but that he himself would go.
Comment on this
All the other Ministers of State, also, did very valuable work for the economy of the country in their three years of office. In a three-seat constituency, a Party which gets 51 per cent of the votes will get two seats and another Party will get one seat. That is a fair test. Under the proposal now before the people, the single seat constituency with the non-transferable vote, the Fianna Fáil Party will have to get only 40 per cent of the votes to get that seat. With 40 per cent of the votes, they can win the four seats in Limerick. There is no reason why any Party should claim the sole right to represent the people in any constituency. I have mentioned Limerick because I have tried to judge the effects of this proposal there. I have a good idea as to how the constituencies will be divided. Limerick city comprises residential areas, working class areas and business areas. There is no clear-cut division between working class and residential areas. In each part of the city, there are residential areas and working class schemes. It is obvious that it would be very difficult for any Party which is not highly organised and prepared to spend a great deal of money to succeed in that area.
We know that appeals have been sent out already for a huge amount of money. The Fine Gael Party have not got that money. As everybody in political life knows, we have to spend a certain amount of money at every election. We have not got the big money that will swing an election. I do not think it is right or fair or just that any Party should try to swing an election. The people should be given a fair system of government and all sections should be afforded an opportunity of representation in Parliament. That is the only way to preserve democracy. We should be doing a very bad day's work, whether in government or in opposition, if we did not protest against anything that would be undemocratic.
Can any Deputy imagine a situation in which there would be, say, 100 Government Deputies and 20 or 30 Deputies in opposition? In that situation, the only function the Opposition could perform would be to obstruct. Can it be expected that people would enter the Dáil as an Opposition to a Government so entrenched in power and would spend weeks studying legislation and considering social problems, in the knowledge that they were completely ineffective? It is like a dog barking up a tree at a cat. That is the only comparison I can make of the situation.
The people have many ways of judging what they should do in this coming referendum but I fear that some of them rely more on personalities than on political argument or common sense. Many people have been asking what all this is about and what is the necessity for the change. No matter what appears in the newspapers or spoken off political platforms it is no use. People are very disturbed to-day. They are disturbed because there is a revolutionary change in industry, a revolution in machinery which has made many people redundant. Unemployment has now hit many homes. That is a tragic happening and has led to comment from the Bishop of Cork, Most Rev. Dr. Lucey, who has no interest in politics but who has an interest in the people. The fact that young people have to leave their homes and seek a living in foreign lands is, perhaps, not the worst of our tragedies.
Comment on this
I accept your ruling, Sir. The Bill has been sent back to this House by the Seanad which rejected it by a two to one majority.
Comment on this
If we take away the eleven people put into the Seanad by the Taoiseach, the 30 people who voted against the Bill and the 19 people who voted for it, it is nearly a two-thirds majority. I am not going to dwell on that matter other than to say that there was a two to one majority against the proposed change in the Seanad. I am sorry if, in saying that, I am offending somebody on the opposite benches but I am sometimes very offended myself when I hear people talk on that side of the House. However, I never interrupt and I think we would be doing a service to the Ceann Comhairle and to the House if we could bear with others.
I should like to draw the attention of the House to the published opinion of six professors representing the two Dublin Universities in the Seanad. They have issued a manifesto in which they state that in their opinion the people should hold on to proportional representation. We all agree that the universities are places of learning where professional people, teachers, doctors and lawyers—receive the education necessary to qualify them for their professions. The minds of those people are not clouded by any political issues. They are elected by the graduates of the Universities who know them and their work and I think that their opinion is well worth considering. When we get men such as these coming forward and giving a considered opinion we should hesitate and ask ourselves whether it would be wise to rush such a measure as this before the people.
If we want to get a picture of the multiple-seat constituency as against the single seat constituency we have only to look at the situation in Northern Ireland. In Northern Ireland there are 52 seats to which members are elected by the single non-transferable vote. In the last election the position was so favourable to the Government Party that 22 members were returned unopposed. There was no use opposing them. In the other seats there was opposition but with practically no effect. I think there are about 12 members in opposition in the Northern Parliament. They are in the position of barking up a tree. It does not matter what they say. The Party with the power and the money is going to rule and that is the Party that is ruling in Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
It is a wonder then that they do not have proportional representation in the North. I believe that if you had three or four-seat constituencies in Northern Ireland with the transferable vote you would have much larger representation for minorities. That is something that should be suggested by those who have the interest of the smaller Parties at heart.
The Taoiseach was very fond of talking about Fermanagh, Tyrone and Derry and of pointing out how they had been gerrymandered. Now he has suddenly stopped talking about them. Why, after all his condemnation of the Unionist Party for their gerrymandering of these seats, has he given up talking about it for the last 12 months? There is a good reason; he now wants to gerrymander the seats in the Twenty Six Counties.
Under the new system it is doubtful if candidates will be selected by their own areas. A number of them will be selected by the Party bosses. They will probably live here in Dublin. They will be men of vision, if you like—big men in the economic life of the country. They will not be bothered going down the country to talk to the farmer, the labourer and the shopkeeper. They will stay in Dublin. When they have something to say, we shall hear them on the radio. The system which sends up the plain man to parliament is a good system and I cannot see any reason why we should drop the system which has served us so well for so long and which has given such very fair results.
The Taoiseach has given us some calculations and I shall use his own figures. He has quoted them several times: 40 per cent for one Party, 35 per cent for another Party, and 25 per cent for a third Party. That does not, of course, give fair representation. There is, too, the danger that the Government elected under such a system may at some stage decide that local authorities are getting too troublesome. Local authorities are elected under proportional representation. Members of local authorities may at times be troublesome. They have to listen to people's grievances. There may be nothing in these grievances, but they must make representations to whatever Minister is involved. In a way that is a safety valve because it at least provides the people with a means of airing their grievances.
The Taoiseach says now that P.R. is a bad system. If a strong Government are returned under the proposed new system, they will be strong in office. Likewise, they will be strong in the local authorities. It is doubtful if one will get the type of candidate one would like to see offering for local authorities. It is doubtful if the businessmen or the big farmer will bother has head coming along to Dáil Eireann. He may not like to come in under a political banner. He will be debarred from coming in as an Independent. That is one of the dangers I see in this proposed new system.
One of the things which brought me into public life was the appalling housing conditions in Limerick city. As a member of the Corporation, I felt I could help the manager and the officials to solve the problem. After 15 years in the Corporation, I feel I have achieved something worth-while. But most people do not look at things in that way. That is why I think this measure carries in it very grave dangers. In the local authority now, you meet the different representatives and there is to a certain extent a harmonising of interests. It will be a major tragedy if the Government, having got this measure through, decide to apply the same system to local authorities. In Northern Ireland, there is a definite cleavage between the Unionists and the Nationalists. At times, it reaches extremes. One reads in the Press of a Nationalist ex-soldier who fought right through the war looking for a house and a Unionist supporter, who never spent a day in the Army, gets the house. That happens, and it is to be deplored, but, if it happens in Northern Ireland between the Nationalists and the Unionists, there is every reason to suppose that it will happen in the Twenty-Six Counties under the new system.
Too much stress has been laid on multiplicity of Parties. We have not a multiplicity of Parties at the moment. We have Fianna Fáil with 78 seats; Fine Gael with 40 seats; Labour with 12; and Farmers with 4. That represents four Parties. There are a number of Independents. I cannot understand how anyone can argue that P.R. leads to a multiplicity of Parties. The two major Parties have in turn held office. Fianna Fáil policy has been tested; Fine Gael policy has been tested. Inter-Party Government has been tested. The present system of election should be allowed to continue. We come here to work for those who send us here. If the people are not satisfied with the Government, they have a constitutional right to change. Let us not have here a Government with a huge majority whipped, as it will be whipped, to serve the Party first and the people in a secondary capacity.
The issues are extremely grave. It is all very right and proper to have personalities in a Presidential election. It is tragic to introduce personalities into a proposed change in the electoral system. The Government would be wise to accept the amendment in the name of Deputy Costello. We should put the issue to the country as a separate issue. As we are to have a Presidential election, let us have a Presidential election and let it be a Presidential election, and let the people vote 1, 2, 3 as they like, but then let us have a general election. Let the then Government state that they want this referendum, that they want the electoral system changed and let the Deputies elected at the general election be the people who will decide for and against the referendum. In the last general election, the people were not told about the proposed change. They were entitled to be told. That is the only safe and democratic way in which one can get a decision. If that were done by the various Parties which were elected, nobody would be dissatisfied. In the coming referendum, the people are asked to vote "Yes" or "No" and they have not got it into their heads yet whether it should be "yes" or "No". At a circus a clown comes out to keep the children quiet and he says: "Yes and no; yes and no" and suddenly he says: "No and yes." At the moment the people are confused and we will not get what is called a genuine reflection of what is in their minds.
Another matter I should like to refer to is that it is strange that after all we said against the British we are now adopting the British system of election, the single seat with the non-transferable vote. We are more or less condemning the system which Arthur Griffith, Michael Collins and all those associated with the early days of our parliamentary life and even the Taoiseach himself in 1937, praised and said was far fairer. Now we suddenly say we want the British system. Let us judge the British system by what is happening in Northern Ireland. If we do that, we shall get the truth. Let us not learn by trial and error.
There is no reason, to my mind, why the Government should not pay heed to the many interested people who have spoken on this very important matter. I feel that what will happen if this referendum is passed is that an organised Party will be geared up and will control the whole country. I feel that is what will happen, but only for a time. The Government would be foolish if they do not say to the Opposition that they are prepared to sit down and talk it over. That is what should be done, if we are as democratic as we are supposed to be.
I have spoken at great length and I did not intend to speak at all, but I do not speak very often and I felt that I should give my views to the best of my ability in the interests of the people I represent. It is not from any anxiety to stay in public life that I make the remarks I have made. I feel that our great men of 1916 and 1921, although they are now in different camps, have taken different sides, and have gone before the country in various ways and put policies before the people should not in the end see our people leaving the country, and emigration and unemployment figures soaring. That is a tragedy. It is a tragedy that after rearing young people and spending money to educate them, they should be given as a gift to other countries. Their services are paid for as we know, but their services are a benefit to the countries to which they emigrate. That is where I see the tragedy. With mechanisation of farms——
Comment on this
I do not wish to say anything further but, in conclusion, may I say to the Taoiseach and the Government Party that they should seriously consider the amendment tabled by Deputy J.A. Costello to refer back this Bill for further consideration?
Comment on this
I am one of those Deputies who sat rather frequently and patiently on these benches during the discussion on this measure for several months past. There are a number of others like me who did not intervene. We were anxious to hear from the Opposition what exactly was the case they had to make as to why they were afraid to let the people decide an issue such as this. I have heard different speakers, but I cannot say I have heard different speeches. I have heard the same speech from different Deputies, day in and day out, all that time, but I did not hear, in any of those speeches, anyone make a case other than that which would be made by frightened people.
Fine Gael are frightened—not to-day or yesterday but for a long time—of the Irish people. When the Labour Party joined the Coalition, they became frightened as well and so did all the other Parties that formed the Coalition. The result of it all is, of course, that they have lost confidence in the Irish people. They tell us every day in their speeches that the Irish people are not capable of judging— that they are not capable of deciding this issue. A moment ago, Deputy Carew said: "Why not have a general election and let the people make up their minds?" This is a general election. The people are asked to come to the booths, not to decide on candidates, but to decide a simple issue, whether or not they are prepared to change the system whereby Dáil representatives are elected at the moment. I can form only one conclusion as a result of all the speeches I have heard, that is—and it is not anything new to me—that Fine Gael are completely out of touch with the people of rural Ireland. They have not the slightest idea of the amount of intelligence which the people in rural Ireland have and, of course, the intelligence which people in cities and large towns have. They seem to have no confidence in those people or in their intelligence. I am quite a long time in this House and I have always had one belief, and one lesson driven home to me, and that is that on the edge of a bog in rural Ireland you will find an intelligent individual, a person who can discuss politics with you as intelligently as most of the Deputies on the opposite side of this House who have been speaking against this motion.
I heard Deputy Carew a moment ago speak about Fianna Fáil coming into this House. I also heard a lot of talk during the debate about dictatorship. I am one of those who came into this House 32 years ago. Why did I come in? I came in because the then Government were putting through a Flogging Bill. That was worse than any dictatorship in this country, and we had a number of issues such as that being put across by Fine Gael because they wanted to have a dictatorship. We all remember that there was one Party in this country—and the people of the country know it—that could put a foot down on behalf of dictatorship. That was the Blueshirt Movement and that is why Fine Gael are frightened ever since.
If Fine Gael, the largest Party on the Opposition side, want to build themselves up and again occupy the Government benches let them put a policy before the people that suits the people. Let them not talk above the people's heads. Let them be sensible in what they say. All down through the years they have carried on with the old type of propaganda that they used when they were in complete control in the early stages, when they had very little opposition. We had talk of small Parties disappearing and, during my time in the House, I have seen a lot of Parties disappear. I have seen the Labour Party, as have many young Deputies who came into the House a few years ago, as a strong Party. They joined Fine Gael in Government with, I think, about 21 members but they did not return in the next election with 21 members. They ought to waken up and realise the reason for that. The people they represent are not the type of people who are prepared to tie themselves on to Fine Gael, because Fine Gael policy has always been most destructive and never helpful, as far as I can remember.
We should recall the speeches made when the present Constitution was before this House. The speeches made at that time were exactly the same type of speeches as those made to-day. The Opposition were afraid to let the Constitution go before the people and have them decide whether they wanted to change it and adopt the new one. They told the people that Fianna Fáil would be dictators if that Constitution were allowed to pass but what has happened since? The very people who said that we were establishing a dictatorship swallowed the Constitution afterwards, and went all over the world making speeches that we had the best Constitution in the world.
Why are the speakers on the opposite side afraid to let the people decide this issue? Somebody said a moment ago that the Seanad held up the Bill and then threw it back, but the Seanad has never had the experience of facing the electorate in this country and, to my mind, the Seanad should have been terribly slow to reject this Bill.
Comment on this
Somebody referred to the Seanad a moment ago but I do not think the effect the Seanad had on this issue has been taken very seriously throughout the country. As I said before, some of the Fine Gael speakers should tell us why they are not prepared to let the people decide this issue for themselves. When this debate started a long time ago I formed the conclusion that there were a number of Deputies on the opposite side who felt very shaky about their own position in their constituencies. Having made inquiries I have now come to the conclusion that, whether it is a question of P.R. or anything else, their position is still shaky. When discussing this matter I think that Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy O'Higgins can really shake hands to the Dáil, in so far as P.R. or the single-member constituency are concerned, and say goodbye now.
I intervened in the debate only with the intention of asking those people across the House to tell us the reason why they are afraid to let the people decide this issue. Do they think the people are so grossly ignorant that they are incapable of making a proper decision? If not, for what other reason have they opposed this? Is it for the sake of politics?
Comment on this
I shall have other points to dwell on but, before going further, I have to draw particular attention to the contribution of Deputy Killilea. We all understand that Deputy Killilea came in to vote against the Flogging Bill but we remember afterwards when he voted for another. He came in to vote for the Constitution in 1937. He followed the Taoiseach in voting for a new British King to represent us. I am afraid that in discussing what is before the House red herrings are being drawn across the issue by Deputy Killilea, which tend to deceive the people in a more extraordinary manner than anything else that can be said here. I submit that it is late in the day to discuss the Flogging Bill.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, Deputy Killilea has drawn particular attention to the fact that small Parties, like the Labour Party, lost support by voting for and supporting an inter-Party Government. Of course, Deputy Killilea conveniently forgets that the Labour Party unfortunately also lost some of the seats they had here when they supported the other large Party, Fianna Fáil. We know that the history of this small State is such that any small Party is always handicapped by supporting any of the two large Parties, and we suffered more in the Labour Party by having supported Fianna Fáil—even under proportional representation—between 1932 and 1948 than we ever did in any instance since 1948 onwards.
Comment on this
Apparently Deputy Killilea is terribly worried that a small Party like the Labour Party should have lost votes during the last ten years, but he has proudly boasted that he is a member of this House for 32 years, and he never worried in 1933, in 1938 nor in 1943 when his Party, led by the Taoiseach, jumped the country under P.R., even though they held a majority, and demanded another quick election at the expense of the Labour Party. It is a bit late in the day to tell us they are mourning the fate of small Parties.
Comment on this
I shall face the people at any time. I should like to know why the back benchers of Fianna Fáil who are like myself, a back bencher of the Labour Party, are not going out and speaking at the church gates on this issue? In a general election, or a local election, they do so but now they are depending on a little, small black book to give the answers to questions they may be asked.
Comment on this
And they have decided in relation to the forthcoming referendum that the wisest course for them to take to try to get the support of the people in rural Ireland is by not addressing them in that way.
Comment on this
They are depending on some of their Ministers. I intend to draw particular attention to some of the statements made by Ministers on behalf of the back benchers of Fianna Fáil. Unfortunately during the past three weeks, circumstances placed me in the position of not being able to attend here, but at least I was able, through the Dáil debates, to study the statements of some of the members here. What struck me forcibly was the approach of four members and I must say that the approach of each and every one of them, as against the other three out of the four, was so amazing and contradictory that I think it is essential to draw attention to it.
The first one could be termed as putting up the case of the Prussian junta. The second, from the way he put forward his point of view, would remind one of a professor of philosophy, theology, and economic science, all wrapped up in one. The third, to me at any rate, would undoubtedly make an excellent public relations officer for a government and of course the fourth would be what is termed down the country a general handyman, the man who does all the little jobs the boss does not want to do himself. I did not think that I would have to add another to the four. The members of the Government Party, and particularly the Taoiseach who is responsible for this motion, have made it perfectly clear that the coalition of Parties is a deadly thing. The coming together of various Parties to form a Government, whether we call it inter-Party or coalition, is ruination for the country. When the Taoiseach says that every one of his Party will say it
The extraordinary thing in relation to the views of these four members I have mentioned is that apparently there is the most extraordinary combination of different individual views to the formation of a coalition within one Party ever heard of from speakers of different Parties in opposition. In relation to the Fianna Fáil view that P.R. has failed, apparently their view is that a coalition of individuals is all right when the individuals are in one Party. They may differ completely, as they have in the views expressed here, but the fact that they are under one roof, in the one Party, means they are then part of a homogeneous mass. Let us examine the views expressed by these members whom I have mentioned.
First of all, there is the Minister for External Affairs, or, as an old man down the country termed him lately, with no disrespect intended, the "Minister for Everything." In the case which the Minister made in favour of abolishing P.R. as a system of election to this Assembly, he made it perfectly clear throughout that what he wants is a system whereby there will be two Parties and only two in this Chamber. That would be grand for this country, of course, and everything would look lovely then. He wants no more than two Parties. It is a good job that Deputy Killilea did not draw attention to the fact that in 1927, apparently when he came in, Fianna Fáil were not the second Party——
Comment on this
They were not the second Party in the Chamber. There was the Labour Party and there were other small Parties as well. But the Minister for External Affairs says: "Nothing doing. There can be only two Parties," if he can have his way— a Government Party and an Opposition. Why then did the Fianna Fáil Party not realise in 1927 the utter necessity for coming in as part of one main Opposition Party? I say they were right to come in independent of any other Party but I believe that other Parties have the same right of being independent of what may be termed the main Opposition Party. The Minister for External Affairs knows, and I am sure Deputy Killilea knows it too, coming from a rural area, just as I do, that no matter what system there is, no Government will ever prevent people in rural Ireland from returning members of small Parties. Perhaps they will be returned in smaller numbers but they will be here, even if there are only one or two of them instead of half a dozen, or three or four instead of a dozen. One thing which the Minister for External Affairs will never succeed in doing is having just one Party facing him and his Party across the House.
He is worried about another point and, in fairness, his colleague, the Minister for Education, seems to be worried about it, too. Over the years, we did not dare to expect an answer from the Minister for External Affairs in matters relating to his Party, but he insists on getting an answer, as he stated in the Dáil Debates, from the Labour Party. He is not here now but perhaps his colleague, or the Chief Whip of the Party, may convey to him my answer regarding what the Labour Party will do in connection with a motion passed by our annual conference a few years ago. I shall give the answer and I have no hesitation in doing so. The Labour Party as a democratic Party have always accepted the decisions of our Party conference. Unless any decision arrived at by the annual conference is altered by a further annual conference of the full Party, we are bound to accept decisions already passed. I hope the Minister will be told that. As a democratic Party, we, as the small Parliamentary group of the Labour Party, never go contrary to decisions of the conference, and please God, we never shall.
The second member I mentioned, and who drifted off at a tangent to the Minister for External Affairs, was none other than Deputy de Valera. His point was, and it is very interesting, that a Government are, or should be, elected by the popular vote. I am entitled to ask what really is the popular vote. Let us look at the rural areas with which we are all conversant. In Tipperary, there could be one member elected in the constituency which Deputy Loughman now represents. If one member, should it be a Labour man, be elected with only 25 per cent. of the votes, would that be popular?
Comment on this
I am sorry to have to use the words but it seems to me extraordinary political ignorance for a Deputy to say it could not happen.
Comment on this
I have proof it could happen. Under the proposed system in an area embracing a population of between 20,000 and 30,000 of a population, which includes children under 21, the number of people entitled to vote will vary between 8,000 and 10,000.
Comment on this
Take it as a maximum of 10,000 people. If there are three or four candidates, 2,500 people voting for one candidate—and it is important to remember that the Minister for Lands said recently down in Mallow that while only one candidate can be elected, any number of candidates can stand——
Comment on this
I am minding nothing. I shall quote where it suits and give the Deputy his answer. If there are four candidates standing in a constituency with a maximum voting register of 10,000, if one candidate can get 2,500 votes, although the other three between them can get 7,500, they cannot beat him. Now is Deputy Loughman satisfied? Would he say the people in his constituency would be satisfied if a Labour Deputy was elected on a quarter of the vote ? Would he say that would be a popular vote? I say it would be anything but popular to see three-quarters of the people of that constituency disfranchised and one quarter of the population enjoying the benefit of having their candidate elected for a period of five years.
Deputy Major de Valera again concentrated on what he termed the two blocs. In this he is on the same ground as the Minister for External Affairs: "We want a Government and one main opposition Party," and we are told that is going to give the benefits for which the people are longing. Let me skip No. 3 and come to No. 4. No. 4 was the view expressed by Deputy Corry. I know Deputy Corry as well as anyone and I regard him personally as a friend of mine. I am proud to say he is a Corkman like myself. However, I am sorry that Deputy Corry apparently is as bewildered in relation to the operation of P.R. as——
Comment on this
As Deputy Loughman is Deputy Corry told us here that to his own personal knowledge a man walked into this Assembly having being elected by one vote. That could happen, of course, but in the case Deputy Corry mentioned the man who walked in was in an area where there were six candidates. According to Deputy Corry's story, one elector, in his wisdom or otherwise, marked his paper right down to No. 6 and decided to give this man No. 6. Yet Deputy Corry tried to convince everyone here, as Deputy Loughman probably would, that the No. 6 vote got him into this chamber. It is an absolute impossibility that the last number could give him one vote over another candidate because——
Comment on this
Anything to get out of a hole helps. Apparently this man, struggling to get that No. 6 vote, was running neck and neck with some other man and one vote would decide it. But if the No. 6 was marked for this man surely a higher number, being nearer to No. 1, must have been marked on a paper for the other candidate? What happened him? Deputy Corry forgot. I do not blame him for not going to the church gates speaking about P.R.
Let me come to the third person who put up such an extraordinary performance to justify the abolition of our present system and the introduction of the straight vote system. When I hear it termed the straight vote system it reminds me of the Mallow Road, the most crooked road in the country. Deputy Booth was not to be outdone by any of his colleagues and he is one unit in the homogeneous mass. In fairness to Deputy Booth— what I did not do in relation to the other speakers—I think it is essential that I should quote what he said. He is speaking of the importance or otherwise of public opinion.
At column 1620, volume 174 of the Dáil Debates of the 5th May, 1959 Deputy Booth is reported as saying:
"We do not say that it was in deference to public opinion that we took this action because the average member of the public has far too many things on his mind for him to worry about the niceties of an electoral system."
That in itself is rather interesting because many members of the Government Party have been telling us for the last six months that it is in response to the demands of the people that this opportunity is being given to them. Last summer the Taoiseach started the ball rolling by telling us that the people were clamouring for it. He went so far as to say that in his journeyings around the country in 1948 after the election, everywhere he went the people were beseeching him to have P.R. wiped out. Yet Deputy Booth makes it perfectly clear that it is not being done in deference to public opinion but because the Party, led by the Taoiseach, have decided, irrespective of whether it may suit public opinion or not, to try to put this case across.
Speaking at column 1626 of the same volume Deputy Booth makes a most extraordinary statement:—
The powerlessness of the present Opposition in Northern Ireland—
—I would say the six north eastern counties. I am not trying to "pull a fast one" on him, but that is how we understand the position—
is purely because there are not sufficient voters to give them more power. That is the beginning and the end of it.
So that is the position? We have been fooling ourselves all the time? If Deputy Booth says that is the beginning and the end of it, is it not time that the Minister for External Affairs changed his line of approach? Over the weekend the Minister was guest at a celebration which brought together a number of the men of other years and at which tribute was paid to the part they played in obtaining our freedom. At that celebration the Minister stated that one Unionist vote in the Six Counties was equivalent to two, and sometimes three, Nationalist votes. Is the Minister right? Deputy Booth says he is not.
Comment on this
Deputy Loughman is becoming so uneasy that he should leave. Deputy Booth is not being misquoted. I have never dishonoured my principles by misquoting anyone. If Deputy Loughman wants to study the remarks, I have given the reference. If he can show where I am out one single word, let him come in here and I shall apologise to himself and to Deputy Booth. But I am not misquoting. It is important to understand that we shall have to change our views completely and realise that the position in the Six Counties is nothing like we thought it was. I supported the views expressed by the Taoiseach every time he condemned the system in those counties which, under the straight vote, gave to a minority far less representation than that to which they were entitled. But now Deputy Booth apparently says that the Taoiseach and all of us are wrong.
Let us go a little further. At Column 1628 in the same Volume, Deputy Booth is reported as saying:—
There are some people who think they are doing a great day's work for Ireland when they twist the facts in relation to Northern Ireland.
The more he goes on, the more complicated it becomes. Apparently, we have all been twisting the facts. Apparently, the people who are advising the electors in the Twenty-Six Counties to go over to the new system are telling them, through their mouthpiece, Deputy Booth, that their ideas are old-fashioned and that they will have to become more liberal-minded in regard to the system of election in the Six Counties.
But Deputy Booth goes further than that. At Column 1630 he is reported as saying:
It is difficult to find out what he (Deputy Dillon) is defending, and I do not know how you could "undebauch" a system...
Deputy Booth has friends for once. During the week-end the Taoiseach himself rode in with Deputy Booth. The Taoiseach may not agree with him in relation to what he said about the Six Counties, but at least in regard to the debauched system, he does agree. I am quoting from the Cork Examiner of Monday, 11th May. The Taoiseach speaking about P.R. after 1937 said:—
"It was not long until everyone in the country saw very clearly what the consequences of the so-called P.R. system would be."
The Taoiseach makes it clear that it was after 1937 he considered it was the "so-called" P.R. system. Deputy Booth said it was debauched and that you could not undebauch it. Perhaps somebody would tell us now, if the system of P.R. mentioned by the Taoiseach is debauched, as apparently Deputy Booth says it is, who debauched it?
Up to 1932, under the P.R. system, there were a few nine-member constituencies and there were seven-member and five-member constituencies. In 1937 that was changed. Some of the large constituencies were altered. But, apparently, even that alteration did not give the desired effect—an increased representation for the Fianna Fáil Party in Government. Therefore, Deputy Booth's debauched system was further debauched by Fianna Fáil. For whose benefit? Again, the number of constituencies with five members was slashed and the number of constituencies with three members was extended wherever possible for the benefit of the Government. Now that it is admitted that the system is debauched, did anyone else interfere with it other than the Fianna Fáil Government?
There is one thing with which Deputy Booth cannot charge the inter-Party Government, and that is the debauching of P.R; because from 1948 to 1951 and from 1954 to 1957 they did nothing to interfere with the P.R. system. I have never been one to go out of my way to speak in favour of Fine Gael no more than Fianna Fáil. The Cumann na nGaedheal Government found it difficult to operate under P.R. in 1927. The most important point is that, at least, even though they may have seen it was going against them, they were still honest enough to the people they represented, and to the country as a whole, not to interfere with the system of P.R. in that period. It was left to the Taoiseach from 1932 onwards to make a system of election into what he now terms a so-called "P.R. system".
Comment on this
I have quoted Deputy Booth and Deputy Booth can go and check it in the Dáil Library if he so wishes.
Comment on this
I am sorry for having to repeat it but, to prove that I am not misquoting, Deputy Booth says here he agrees with Deputy Dillon. He was amazed to find that there was some little point on which he could agree with Deputy Dillon. He mentioned here that a debauched system could not be undebauched, any more than a scrambled egg could be unscrambled.
Comment on this
I have a few more nice statements here which were made by Deputy Booth. As reported in Column 1640 in the same volume of the Official Report, Deputy Booth states: "We do not consider for a moment and never did consider that we would have to wait for public opinion to advise us in this matter." There we have it again. On the one hand the Taoiseach tells us that the proposed change is being made at the behest of people clamouring for it everywhere he went and now Deputy Booth says quite clearly, as I have quoted, that they did not have to wait for anyone, that they had decided themselves.
Then we hear about Coalition Parties and the different views expressed by different Parties. What a wonderful set of circumstances must have arisen to bring together such various views under the one roof in one political Party. I am sorry to have to waste so much time in quoting but I will make clear why I find it so essential to do so. Deputy Booth finishes by saying, as reported at Column 1641: "We have allowed the Opposition to talk almost endlessly on this subject." It is kind of him. I wonder is it because we have P.R. or is it in the hope of securing the so-called straight vote that, at this point, Deputy Booth has allowed us to talk almost endlessly? That is wonderful.
A line of approach similar to that was heard of in other countries where people were looking forward to the day when a minority counted for nothing, a minority view, expressed in the country represented by so-called Government. Deputy Booth took exception to references by Deputy Dillon. He thought Deputy Dillon was extra hard. However, I think it ill became Deputy Booth to go so far as to suggest that Independents were voting for the retention of P.R. solely because it was for their own protection. He gave credit to two Independents who supported the Government. I always understood that an Independent has a right to vote with any Party or any Government or Opposition he so wishes. I would never suggest that Independents who would vote against my principles or my opinions would do so for an ulterior motive in relation to their personal welfare. It is unfair to the members concerned and it ill becomes the member who used those words.
Comment on this
I judge, too. It is extraordinary that an important member of Fianna Fáil went so far as to state that this measure, a measure to try to secure the abolition of P.R. and the introduction of what I term "the narrow road system," was supported by the Unionist Party in the Dáil and Seanad. That is interesting.
Comment on this
I did not say the Deputy did but it is on the records that a responsible member of Fianna Fáil stated that. If that is true then undoubtedly, whether it is a coalition or a friendly alignment—I do not know which we may call it—there is an alignment between the outlook on the Taoiseach's introduction of this measure here, supported by Deputy Booth and by members of Fianna Fáil, and the policy in operation in the Six Counties where Deputy Booth made it clear that the Opposition cannot do any better because, as he stated, of the number of votes they had, and that is that.
The Minister for Defence said, and I agree with him wholeheartedly, that one Unionist vote in the Six Counties is equal to two, and at times three, Nationalist votes.
Comment on this
In relation to Deputy Booth's interjection, it is quite easy to give figures to suit any particular occasion. I heard an interjection by a member of the Fianna Fáil Party for whom I have great respect. He stated a while ago, when Deputy Carew was speaking, that even if P.R. were in operation in the Six Counties, the position would be the same. What an extraordinary suggestion—the suggestion that there would be no difference. We know there would be a difference. We have no hesitation in saying that there would have to be a difference in representation. I recall to the mind of Deputy Booth and others that in elections there in the recent past, where the Opposition was divided—Nationalists and members of Sinn Féin or the Labour Party—the Opposition combined had a much greater vote than one Unionist candidate but, because there was no transfer of votes, the candidate representing the Unionist Party under the so-called "straight vote" system was able to sit smugly as a member of Stormont and say: "Although the others outvoted me, I got in because they could not transfer their votes." That is the position for which, admittedly, not only Deputy Booth but other Deputies who have spoken are anxious.
There are many members of the Fianna Fáil Party whom I know personally who hold certain views. As I said at the start, we in rural Ireland have something in common, completely divorced from our own political viewpoints, but I have nothing in common with the views expressed by Deputy Booth in relation to the importance of switching from the electoral system we have now. I come from an area where we know and understand that the views expressed by some people are very similar to those of Deputy Booth. They never formed a part of the true sentiments of the rural Ireland that we know. If it were for nothing else but for that alone, may God grant that no system of election will be imposed on the people of rural Ireland which would introduce into the Parliament of this country the new-found, new-styled Laberalism that is so prelevant among some of the members of the Fianna Fáil back benchers at present.
Having drawn attention to the views expressed by these four members, I should like now to draw attention to a point made by many members of the Opposition. Many members of the Opposition, during the course of the debate, stated that under the present electoral system not alone had the elector the right to vote for the Party of his choice but where there were two candidates from one Party, he could vote for one or the other.
I have tried to draw particular attention to certain points in relation to four Government speakers. In the four constituencies represented by the Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Major de Valera, Deputy Booth and Deputy Corry, the Fianna Fáil voter was lucky to have an alternative. In each of those constituencies there were two Fianna Fáil candidates. At least, the voters in those areas who believed in the Fianna Fáil policy were not coerced by circumstances to vote for one Party candidate only. They had a choice of two.
I feel it incumbent on me, also, to draw attention to some of the remarks made by the Taoiseach over the week-end. The Taoiseach is the person primarily responsible for the introduction of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. I quote from the Cork Examiner of Monday, 11th May, a report of a convention:
Mr. de Valera said that in 1948 Parties with conflicting policies formed a Coalition Government. All of the Parties concerned had told their supporters they would not join a coalition and they deceived their supporters.
I am not interested in past history but I challenge the Taoiseach, Deputy Loughman or any other member of Fianna Fáil to show where in any discussion during the winter of 1947 and the month of January, 1948, prior to the formation of the Government, there was ever a word of coalition or inter-Party, at any stage.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach said that they deceived their supporters because they said they would have no hand in coalition government. We know that it was after the election in 1948 that the first suggestion ever emanated in relation to coalition and we also know that, up to to-day, the Taoiseach regrets as one of the biggest mistakes in his life the fact that he misjudged the situation when he believed that, in spite of the ill-treatment given to the Labour Party, they could not form part of an inter-Party Government.
Later, in the same speech, the Taoiseach is reported as saying:
The only way a Party could secure itself in office was by giving good service to the community, by having a good policy and showing that it was attainable by having good performers and good administrators.
So, it was essential, even under the straight vote system, to have good performers and good administrators. We know that is correct. We know that what is keeping the junta in Stormont in their present position is that they have good supporters, good administrators and good actors. That is why we are opposed to it here.
The further we can keep away from a system that is a curse to six counties in our little country, the more chance we have of bringing every section of the community, at least in the Twenty-Six Counties, into a position where each section will listen attentively to the views of all other sections. That is not the case now. The Taoiseach says that it is essential to have good performers and good administrators. Apparently, the Party that can produce the good performers and the good administrators will come out on top but the only way in which they can come out on top, of course, is under the straight vote system!
Deputy Loughman mentioned the impossibility of a candidate securing election with a total poll of 2,500 out of 10,000. For his benefit and for the benefit of the House, I intend to quote from the same issue of the Cork Examiner a report of a statement of the Minister for Lands in Mallow, County Cork:
At the polling booth the elector would have one vote to cast for one candidate. Any number of candidates could be nominated.
That was kind, of course. That is the key to the whole plot. You can vote for only one candidate but the more candidates that are nominated the better chance "our man" has. The Minister did not say that but we all know that is the meaning. The greatest chance there is of the Government coming back with a huge majority is by dividing and conquering, by encouraging the farmers to put up their candidate, the Fine Gael Party to put up their candidate, to make sure that the Labour Party will put up a candidate and that Sinn Féin, if they did not wipe them out, would put up a candidate. The more candidates that are nominated, the greater the chance the "good performer" has of coming back and making sure that he is a good administrator.
I shall quote what I consider to be the gem of all these statements, in view of the fact that the Taoiseach has been telling us all the time that it is not for the benefit of Fianna Fáil they are introducing this measure. That has been asserted by many Fianna Fáil speakers but, naturally, the statement of the Taoiseach must carry more weight. While the Taoiseach says that it is not for the benefit of the Party, the Minister for the Gaeltacht, Deputy Moran, is repored as follows, again in the Cork Examiner of 11th May, speaking in Nenagh at a convention:
"Mr. M. Moráin, Minister for the Gaeltacht, said it is quite apparent now that if Fianna Fáil had had the straight vote system under which a strong Fianna Fáil Government would have been elected in 1932 the economic war would never have dragged on the length it did,"
and so forth. I am not interested in the economic war but the point is that, while the Taoiseach says that it is not for the benefit of Fianna Fáil they are introducing the Bill, the Minister for the Gaeltacht says: "What an awful pity it is that we had not it in 1932. What a powerful Government we then would have." If they had it in 1932, they would have had it ever since. It is natural for them to expect that if they can get it through, they will be in the same position as Lord Brookeborough and the Stormont Government are in. Is that for the benefit of the country? Fianna Fáil may believe that it is. Should this Bill go through, history may prove the reverse to be the case.
Deputy Loughman rightly drew particular attention to the position in relation to six constituencies surrounding his own constituency. He went so far as to say that the candidate with the highest number of first preference votes was elected. That may be. I do not know anything about those constituencies. In answer to him, I am entitled to give actual figures. There is no question of going into detail. I will give the finalised figures in a constituency with which I am directly concerned. It happened under P.R. and it is only under P.R. that it could happen.
In the election campaign, there were Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Farmer and Labour candidates. Each Party contested that election and asked the electorate for their votes. The Farmer candidate, who got 4,700 votes, was eliminated after the first count. Now, watch the result. Of those 4,700 votes, approximately 49 per cent of the people who had cast their first preferences for the Farmer candidate cast their second preference for Fine Gael; in other words, they were saying that if they could not get their No. 1 candidate elected, the Fine Gael man was their second choice.
That Fine Gael Deputy is in the House to-day. Again, of those 4,700 votes, 38 per cent of the people who cast them said that they wanted the Farmer but if they could not get him, they wanted Fianna Fáil. We have that Fianna Fáil Deputy in the House to-day. Of those 4,700 votes, 7½ per cent of the people casting them said that if they could not get the Farmer in, they wanted the Labour man and they got the Labour candidate. So that out of the 4,700 persons who voted for that Farmer candidate, 95 per cent, while not succeeding in electing their No. 1 man, did succeed in electing their No. 2 and so nobody can say that South Cork is not represented in Dáil Éireann. That could happen only under proportional representation.
What would happen under the so-called straight vote system? There you would have those 4,700 voters divided into two constituencies. Many of them would be the fathers and mothers of families and would thus be representing the opinions of probably 20,000 people. They will be in the position of having to put an X before the candidate of whichever Party they prefer. They can do no more and the result would be that they would have no representative for their 4,700 votes.
That is the position the Taoiseach and the Fianna Fáil Party wish to impose on the people. They are telling us that they are leaving it to the free choice of the people. I think it is amusing to hear that being said and then to see the front benchers and every Deputy on the Government side going to their conventions and saying everything possible against proportional representation and not one word in favour of it. It does seem strange when they say here that they are leaving the choice to the people.
They ought to be sincere at least and tell the people that there are two sides to the story. Why should they depend on the Opposition in Leinster House, comprised of different political Parties and the Independents, to go to the public and say that they are condemning proportional representation but "here are the facts in favour of it"? That is of vital importance to the people. If they want to decide it on a fair basis, let them come out in the open and give a fair résumé of both sides of the argument.
There is another aspect of this problem that does not seem to have been touched on at all. Despite what Government may be in power, with the introduction of the straight vote system and with the result of the referendum known to the Government and its being known how the people voted for and against the change in every constituency in the Twenty-Six Counties, it will be utterly impossible to divide these constituencies into fair divisions. Any Party having the desire of abolishing proportional representation and knowing the way the people voted on the issue will be bound to divide the constituencies in their own favour.
I believe that the really true picture of what this change will mean cannot possibly be seen for ten or 15 years. The Minister for Lands did mention that the next ten years will be very important in the life of the country. Of course that is so. We know that the electors of the Twenty-Six Counties are very independent-minded. I give them credit for that. They may vote for Labour, or Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael at one election and they may be the bitterest enemies of any one of those Parties at the next. They are entitled to do that, but, in the years to come, should this change be put into operation, after the period of trial is over, they may see their error, but it will then be too late.
In ten years' time, should the change be successful, the position in rural Ireland will be static. The supporters of Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and Labour will hold to their own Parties. However, we do know that any swing which affects the Parties comes, not from the rural areas, but from the industrial areas. Dublin and County Dublin must play a large part in any election result. Cork city, Limerick, Waterford and Galway and any other area that is likely to become more industrialised will play a greater part in any swing of votes from one Party to another.
Here in Dublin you could have an electorate of 10,000 people and a Government candidate who is fairly strong with a good, solid vote behind him. It could also happen that the Opposition candidate might be equally strong or pretty near to it. Along with them, there could be a candidate from one of the smaller Parties. In such an industrial area we can easily see what would be the position of these 10,000 voters with a strong Government candidate, an equally strong Opposition candidate and a fairly strong second choice.
In the rural areas, that cannot happen and what may be the result? No member of this Government, or the Taoiseach, can prevent the formation of another Party in the Twenty-Six Counties. They cannot prevent such a Party from using a most patriotic name. They cannot prevent such a Party from taking up a policy which may be considered far more advantageous for the electorate in the industrial areas than the policy put forward by the Government or the Opposition.
Cuireadh an díospóireacht ar ath-ló.