We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Adjournment Debate—Government Policy.

Contributions 92–207 of 207. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The sale of boats.

Comment on this

The purchasing and the sale of boats. The really exciting thing is that the consumption of fish in Ireland has gone up amazingly. Our rate of consumption on the home market was incredibly low and, through much better marketing and better handling, there is now an infinitely better home market for our fishermen than there ever was before, and exports have also gone up.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy accept that the number engaged in forestry and fishing has gone down, according to the appendix to the statistics?

Comment on this

I shall accept that if the Deputy has the official figures before him, which I have not, but the important thing is whether those industries, and they are industries, are being put on a firmer basis. You can always employ men on an uneconomic level but that is not the way to deal with an economic problem. You have got to get the business running economically before you expand and take on additional labour. That is what is being done and has been done to some extent here.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Deputy's policy would be to throw the workers out of work to build up the industry?

Comment on this

No, no. I do not think even Deputy O.J. Flanagan, in his wildest dreams, would expect me to suggest such a thing, but I was dealing with an interjection from my left which was on a different point altogether. I am in favour of giving increased employment, just in case Deputy O.J. Flanagan does not know that, but the increased employment must be on productive work and must be done economically. I am delighted we have got that point over though it is in a different context.

I do not want anything I have said to be regarded as evidence of complacency because there are no grounds for complacency whatsoever. We shall be facing grave problems in the future and our whole marketing of agricultural produce in other lands is tangled up with the economic framework of Europe generally. Here again we have taken a positive stand, and I think a valuable one. We have been criticised for not going in with the Six or with the Outer Seven——

Comment on this

We are at sixes and sevens.

Comment on this

In actual fact, there does now appear to be a growing realisation that neither the Six nor Seven can make any progress on their own, and that consequently the Six and Seven must come together rapidly. That is what the Government have always advocated. They have always struggled very hard to prevent that division arising in Europe, and are now trying to bridge the gap and bring the parties together under the aegis of O.E.E.C. When that has been negotiated, and I think it is only a matter of when—not if—we can look forward to an increased market potential in Europe generally, but it is quite impossible in the present state of uncertainty to plan with any confidence on the European market or any market, especially for agricultural produce, other than the British market.

Here again the Government have acted with decision and have initiated high level trade talks in London which are at present being continued, at intervals admittedly, but the results of which are being carefully investigated on each side of the Irish Sea. That, to my mind, is a very healthy trend. It shows that the Government are fully prepared to negotiate, as they have been asked to do, with the country which is by far our best customer.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is a bit of a change from the time when people over there were shouting that the British market was gone forever, and thank God.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Flanagan must not interrupt.

Comment on this

A lot of things have changed, including Deputy Oliver Flanagan.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It was the Deputy's Party who said that. All belonging to it said it: "The British market is gone forever."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Flanagan must cease interrupting. The Deputy can make his speech later.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy Flanagan is feeling better now. The point is that a definite step has been taken to reach a new trade agreement with Great Britain. I think it will be found that, when that has been achieved, the Government will proceed as rapidly as possible to bring the other countries together and have a proper European trade agreement brought into operation. That may be exciting. At the same time, it may be dangerous. But the Government are fully prepared to negotiate and to act whenever they can.

I cannot see any signs of any complacency anywhere in the Government. I can see plenty of signs of active and constructive work. All around us are the signs that that work is bearing fruit. The fact that conditions are improving does not mean that we have not got to work very hard. We shall certainly continue to work very hard. The preaching of pessimism and disaster is something which is of very little political advantage to anyone. It is certainly very bad for the country. I do not expect the Opposition to hand out bouquets just for the fun of it. To keep on shouting that the country is in a crisis, that emigration is mounting, that unemployment is increasing when the facts clearly show the reverse——

Comment on this

What about the balance of payments?

Comment on this

——is nonsense. Take the balance of payments position. This Government will not get panicked into taking action with regard to the balance of payments because they have the foresight and the confidence to see that no crisis is in fact impending. They know the situation will right itself. How right they have been proved in that in recent months when the balance of payments position has taken a marked turn for the better. It would have been much more like the Opposition to panic, but this Government do not panic. They keep resolutely on their course, and have been proved right in doing so.

There are criticisms which can quite properly be made and I hope that, for the benefit of the Government, they will be made, but those criticisms must be constructive and they must be based on facts. If they are based on imagination, they will not be of very much help, either from the point of view of the Party which makes them or from the point of view of the country. By all means, let us have criticism, but let it be constructive, and positive, and based on facts.

Comment on this

I was interested in what Deputy Booth had to say. I think everybody will admit, especially the members of the Government, that they have quite a difficult task. I do not think the picture Deputy Booth painted in the last half an hour is the right picture. I think he has good reason for saying that the Government should not be complacent about the situation.

I intervene principally because of two questions addressed to the Taoiseach recently in relation to employment figures. Mark you, I think the Taoiseach has transmitted some of his optimism about the figures for employment to people such as Deputy Booth, who honestly believe that employment is rising when the contrary is the case. It was suggested to the Taoiseach last week that the contrary is the case. He became very indignant at the suggestion and he said he would produce figures to show that employment was rising in 1959 as compared with 1958 or 1957.

It may be true to say that the trend in emigration has turned the other way, but there is still emigration. All of us will admit that emigration has decreased but that decrease is due to the fact that we have practically reached saturation point where emigration is concerned. I do not think Deputy Booth could quarrel with me on that. There may be other factors, but the main factor contributing to the decrease is that we have reached saturation point.

Yesterday the Taoiseach replied to a question tabled by Deputy Desmond. I have not got the actual question but the reply is reported in today's Irish Times:“The Taoiseach told Mr. Desmond that in the nine months ended September 30th the number of insurance stamps sold amounted to 18,616,500 compared with 18,271,200 in the nine months ended September 30th, 1958. The increase over 1958 was 345,300 which represented an average increase of 8,854 insured workers a week throughout the nine months compared with the corresponding period in the previous year.” I am sure every Deputy believed that was the correct picture, but I know the Taoiseach knows it is not the correct picture. I do not say the Taoiseach was dishonest, but the Taoiseach should have mentioned other factors.

It is true to say that the number of insurance stamps sold in the particular period was 8,854 more than in the same period in 1958, but surely the Taoiseach remembers that he gave permission to his Minister for Social Welfare in October of last year to introduce what was described as the Social Welfare (Amendment) Bill, 1958. That raised the insurability of certain persons from a maximum of £600 to £800, and that meant an increase in the number of insured workers. On that occasion, those of us who spoke in the debate asked the Minister, or his Parliamentary Secretary, what new number of insured workers would be brought in. In column 913 of volume 171 of the Official Report the Parliamentary Secretary replied, and said:—

We estimate that the number of persons who will come in as a result of this Bill will be about 18,000——

What has the Taoiseach to say now about this increase of 8,854? We have got 18,000 new entrants.

Comment on this

No, no. The figure was all wrong.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary's figure?

Comment on this

That figure of 18,000 ignored the fact that all manual workers were insured, anyway.

Comment on this

But that was the figure given from the Government benches.

Comment on this

Let me quote what the Parliamentary Secretary said on that occasion:—

We estimate that the number of persons who will come in as a result of this Bill will be about 18,000——

Here is an important point for the Taoiseach in view of what he has just said—

and of them at least one-half will be State employees.

That does not suggest to me that at least half of these would be manual workers.

Comment on this

There are no stamps bought for State employees.

Comment on this

No stamps bought for State employees?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

And the Parliamentary Secretary, when he referred to 18,000, said that at least half of them would be State employees and that 9,000 State employees would, under the new Bill, be deemed to be insured.

Comment on this

No stamps are purchased for them.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot follow that argument. It seems to me that the figure which the Taoiseach boasts of is now reduced to a minus figure of 10,000. I must confess that I cannot understand the Taoiseach's line of argument in this debate. I suppose I must accept his word when he says that no stamps are bought for these people. What sort of transaction is carried on between the Department of Finance and the Department of Social Welfare, I have not been aware of, and I am not aware of it tonight. In any case, it needs a good deal of explaining.

Apart from figures which many people in this House seem to ridicule, there is not much evidence that there has been an increase in employment. Deputy Booth admits, and all of us know, that so far as employment in the rural areas is concerned, it is steadily decreasing. There is a reason for that in respect of agriculture. Agriculture has become so mechanised, and has been for the past ten or 15 years, that the tendency is to lay off men. These men have either to seek employment in the towns or cities or emigrate.

I frankly cannot see—I use the word "see" deliberately; I am not depending on figures now—any increase in employment to the extent the Taoiseach suggests there has been in industry. For instance, I saw in a reply which the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce gave here today to a question about the number of new factories which have been established in recent years, that four new factories were established in Wexford. I shall not say that I am the best Deputy in the country, but I have a fair knowledge of my own constituency and I do not know of any four factories started in Wexford. I honestly have no idea whether small additions have been made to existing factories in Wexford, whether it is a new type of processing in an existing factory, or whether some small factory has been started and carried on in a backyard. I do not know anything about the four factories in Wexford which the Minister for Industry and Commerce talks about.

A Deputy from Waterford said it was suggested in that reply that there were seven new factories in Waterford county. He does not know of seven new factories. The whole total comes to about a few hundred. Of course, if we were to believe the Irish Press, there are about 25 new factories every Sunday. No reference is made to any factories being closed. I have read reports of the speech of the Taoiseach in Limerick last week when he talked about pessimism, about banshee wailing and hand-wringing. We heard the same from Deputy Booth. Will some one tell me who wailed and wrung their hands more often and more loudly than the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, the Sunday Press, the Evening Press and the Irish Press in the three years from 1948 to 1951 and in the period from 1954 to 1957? No one minds criticism and, of course, the Press have a special privilege to criticise as strongly as they can, but if the Government say there is an attempt by the Opposition Parties to undermine confidence in the Government, I say the criticism could have been stronger during the periods I have mentioned especially in view of the fact that there were three newspapers behind that criticism.

Deputy Booth is a relatively new member of the House and he criticises the Opposition for the questions they ask as if he had no idea what it meant to be in Opposition. Deputy Booth and his colleagues asked the same questions and made the same criticisms. The Taoiseach told us it was the duty of an Opposition to criticise. He said that was a right of the Opposition and that he reserved the right to criticise and not make suggestions. The record of that can easily be found. I well remember Deputy Lemass, as he then was, saying it was the duty of the Opposition to criticise and of the Government to produce results, if they could.

In reply to Deputy Flanagan, Deputy Booth said that the Government wanted to provide work but that it had to be productive and economic work. I disagree with him thoroughly, in view of our circumstances. I appreciate that efforts are being made, and I am sure they are being made at the present time by the Government and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to provide employment, but the fact is that we will not get it this year to fill all our demands. I feel that we will not get it in the next three, four, five, six or seven years. We shall not have established in this country factories that will be productive and economical and therefore I believe it is our bounden duty, and the bounden duty of the Government, to provide work —just work, without any qualification.

I believe there is still quite an amount of work to be done in housing. A reply which I got from the Minister for Local Government today was to the effect that there are still 177 cottages needed in Wexford, but the Minister has so directed his housing policy that the Wexford County Council will build in each of the next three or four years only 40 cottages. That means that some of those 177 people who the Minister admits need cottages, will not have a cottage for another five years. That is a small example, but it is an example of work that could be done and should be done. I do not know why the Government are going slow on the housing question. There is a motion before the House at present in relation to the Local Authorities (Works) Act. Suffice it for me to say that I think it was a tragedy that scheme was stopped by the Fianna Fáil Government.

I wonder what was really in the mind of the Taoiseach when, in his usual spectacular way, about six months ago, he sent letters to the chairmen of the local authorities all over the country, and gave the impression, whether he meant to or not, that they were to send up all the schemes they could which would give employment—and I do not think he said productive employment. So far as the Government were concerned the sky was the limit. I know the local body in my home town, Wexford Corporation, sent up a scheme which would cost about £½ million. There are some simple people and there would be some Fianna Fáil people on that corporation who would be simple people —politically, I mean—and I think they have an idea in their minds that there will be sanction for a scheme for the improvement of the harbour in Wexford at a cost of about £½ million. Tipperary, Mayo, Limerick and Cork and the other local authorities have sent millions of pounds' worth of schemes to the Department or the Board of Works. I do not know which.

When the Taoiseach is replying, I should like him to say what is to happen to these schemes. As yet, I do not know of any scheme that has been approved. I was very suspicious, and I am still very suspicious, of that invitation to those people to send up all these schemes because I remember that in the Department of Local Government, in the Board of Works and in the Fisheries Branch, there are, at the present time, and have been for the past ten, 20 and 30 years, schemes filed away which could be put into operation if the objective of the Taoiseach is to provide employment.

Again, let me stress that I believe we should be able to afford, as Deputy Blowick said, an expenditure of anything up to £10 million per year in the giving of employment. Some people may be critical and say: "We do not want relief," and may try to persuade the workers that it is only relief work and work given for charity, but it is an investment of £10 million to keep people in this country so that when this productive work about which we all speak gets going, we shall have these workers to engage in it.

The Taoiseach is anxious and so is every member of this House to see that factories are established, whether in the Shannon free trade zone. Wexford, Mayo, Dublin or Cork. We are all anxious to see factories established but we know how slow a process it is. We know the protracted negotiations that must, of necessity, go on between Departmental officials and Germans, Belgians and Americans. Sometimes it takes three years to establish a factory. A man with 38/- a week on the dole cannot wait so long. The rural worker, who is employed for nine months of the year as an agricultural labourer, cannot afford to be living on £3 1s. per week for his wife and family for the other three months in the hope that these factories will be established. There is plenty of work to be done. There is plenty of productive work to be done in factories.

What are the detail difficulties about extending the forestry programme? We have stepped up our forestry programme spectacularly over the past ten years: whether it can be stepped up any more or not, we do not know, and we do not know whether it would be a good investment to pump more money into it.

We cannot be particularly proud about the roads we have in the country. Many local authorities boast about the condition of their roads and say that they have now reached saturation point, as far as the expenditure of money is concerned. Many roads are not in good condition, in view of the increased car and lorry population. It seems that we shall have to pay more and more attention to the roads. Therefore, an expenditure of another £2,000,000 or £3,000,000 on the roads would, in my opinion, be justified, not alone to keep money in this country but also to provide adequate highways for the traffic that will travel on these roads in a relatively short period. Whether it is on land, drainage, or road work, I think the expenditure of money is justified.

I cast no aspersion on the 62,000 who are unemployed at the present time. If there are instances where 10, 20 or 30 men want to go into some business or factory, employers have difficulty in getting the right type of worker. I do not necessarily mean the man who will work as against the man who will not work. Amongst those 62,000 there is a big proportion of men who are used to rural work only. Many of them are not suitable for factory work. They cannot adapt themselves too easily to the operation of a machine or the making of different articles but we will be left in a position in a short time, if we do not do something about the matter, in which 20,000 of the 62,000 will be forced to emigrate, and we shall never have any skilled operatives in the country or workers who can be trained.

I make no apology for repeating that the expenditure of £10,000,000 to keep workers in the country will pay off in the long run. The Government propose to spend substantial amounts in the near future in making grants to the hotel industry. I have no objection to that. They have poured out, I suppose. some millions of pounds to the hotel industry over the past two years. I have no objection to it. That will not pay off for another few years and maybe for three, five, seven or ten years, but still we thought we were justified and are justified at the present time in throwing money into the hotel business to promote the tourist industry and we will not get a return possibly for another seven or ten years when we hope this country will attract more tourists.

Similarly, the Taoiseach has—shall I say—gambled as far as the transatlantic air service is concerned. I expressed doubts in this House as to whether or not it would be a success and I do not want to comment further on that. He admits himself that it is now in the growing pains stage. He says it is more than an experiment. It is going to be a success. Still we have to give it a chance. Still he is prepared—I do not object to his doing it —to pour millions of pounds into the development of a project that will not show a return for five, six or seven years.

It is much more worthwhile to expend money on the employment of people in our own country or on giving them the means to live in their own country so that, when we do want them, they will be available. I would ask the Taoiseach, when he is replying, to refer to the reply he gave to Deputy Desmond yesterday and to relate it to the statement made by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare when he spoke on a Social Welfare Bill on 25th November, 1958.

Mr. M.J. O'Higgins rose.

Comment on this

Before Deputy O'Higgins starts, I want to direct attention to the fact that at least two members of the Fianna Fáil Party, three members of the Fine Gael Party, one member of the Labour Party and one member of the Clann na Talmhan Party spoke and although a number of other Deputies offered, they were persistently ignored by each member who sat in the Chair from 6 o'clock. I am speaking on behalf of the other people in this House. I think it is a disgraceful performance on the part of the various officers in the Chair. The people in this House were elected to have an equal voice when they are called in this Chamber. It is contempt of the public.

Comment on this

It is only fair to the Chair to say that I offered myself on six occasions. I have been here since the debate commenced. I have not seen any Independent member or members offer himself other than the members of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I did not refer to Deputy O'Higgins personally and I hope he will accept that.

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy O'Higgins will accept the fact that I have been sitting here all the time.

Comment on this
Patrick W. Palmer Acting Chairman (Mr. Palmer) Fine Gael

The Deputy will be called on, irrespective of whether I am in the Chair or not.

Comment on this

I do not care so long as some member from this part of the House is called on.

Comment on this
Frank Sherwin Mr. Sherwin

There are two of us.

Comment on this

Deputy Booth made an appeal that criticism of the Government in this discussion should be based on facts. I hope to criticise the Government and I hope to back every word of criticism I say with facts which I have before me.

I want to start by asserting it is a fact that this Government have failed disastrously all along the line. I want to assert that this Government have failed in dealing with the problem of the cost of living. I assert that this Government have failed in dealing with the problem of unemployment. I assert that they have failed in dealing with the problem of emigration. I assert that they have failed on the question of the balance of payments. I assert that they have failed in dealing with the problem of illegal activities in the State. I assert that they have failed in dealing with the question of health services and the preservation of harmonious relations between the Government, on the one hand, and the medical profession, on the other. I assert that they have failed in dealing with the agricultural industry. I assert that they have failed in their external affairs policy and have failed even in their effort to abolish P.R. and make the future safe for Fianna Fáil.

I think that even Deputy Booth will acknowledge that, prior to and during the last general election, all the artillery of the Fianna Fáil Party was turned on the previous Government and all their criticism levelled against that Government, principally on the question of employment and unemployment. I have here, and I intend giving, fact No. 1 from a pamphlet entitled "Facts for Voters" produced by the Fianna Fáil Party prior to the last general election on the occasion of a by-election in Cork city. I do not know if Deputy Booth will agree with me. Will the Deputy accept that what is stated in this at least was presented to the public by the Fianna Fáil Party as facts?

The first fact I want to refer to is that in that by-election which preceded the general election by a few months, the Fianna Fáil standard bearer had this to say of the Fianna Fáil policy which Fianna Fáil were presenting to the people and which they asserted they wanted to give the people an opportunity of accepting at a general election:—

Emigration has reached frightening proportions. Soaring prices are robbing the wage packet of its value. Rates have increased enormously. In Fianna Fáil we have set a state of full employment as our goal. We believe it can be achieved. We are working out the details of a dynamic programme of investment which, in an expanding economy, will bring the nation to that goal.

That was before the general election campaign started. Fianna Fáil were laying the fuse which they wanted to ignite at the right time. They had produced their proposal for full employment—the Lemass plan for 100,000 jobs in five years. We were told in the by-election in Cork city that Fianna Fáil were eagerly awaiting the opportunity of putting that proposal before the people.

In the same pamphlet, we read: "Fianna Fáil plans the end of emigration." It continues:

In contrast to the attitude of the present Coalition, Fianna Fáil has been preparing its plans for the day when the Party will again take up the reins of Government. The Fianna Fáil plan proposes an increase over five years in the number of new jobs by 100,000. This would result in full employment and the end of abnormal emigration.

We were told Fianna Fáil had a dynamic plan which they wanted to put into operation and that they were awaiting the opportunity to do so.

Then we come along to the period of the general election. Everyone knows that there were difficult days for the people of this country and that there were difficult days politically for the then Government in the year 1956. All of us know the measures which that Government were courageous enough to take in order to meet a crisis situation which had developed, not through any fault of the Government. Because of those measures, there was a dislocation in trade. There was an increase in the unemployment figures.

What sympathy did the Government get at that time from the then Deputy Lemass, deputy-Leader of the Opposition? What sympathy did the then Government get from people like Deputy Booth who were contesting the election on behalf of Fianna Fáil? Was there as much as one Fianna Fáil Deputy now in the House who stood by the Government in those days and appealed to the people to keep up their hearts and their confidence?

There was one voice crying out to the people in those days. He did it from the Government Benches and from the Opposition Benches. It was the voice of Deputy J.A. Costello telling the people that there was no need to despair. He put before the people in October, 1956, a programme for production which the Fianna Fáil Party are proud now to enhance and endorse. He told the people that a temporary period of upset and dislocation had to be faced, if we were to preserve the national solvency. What support did he get then from the Fianna Fáil benches? How many Fianna Fáil Deputies did we hear talking about gloom and despair?

Did we hear Deputy Lemass in those days asking the people to forget this talk of gloom, despair and despondency, to have confidence in the country and in its future? I believe many Fianna Fáil Deputies are confusing the people's confidence in the country and the people's lack of confidence in the Government. They are two different and distinct things.

If the people have, as I believe they have, confidence in the future of the country and in the ability of the country to overcome any handicaps which now beset us, that confidence is due in great measure to the work of Deputy J.A. Costello in appealing to the country and to the youth of the country to show that confidence, whether he was in Government or in Opposition. I believe the people have that confidence in the country but they have not confidence in the Government. They have shown that at by-election after by-election. In the two years and nine months this Government have been in office, in two out of three by-elections in the capital city, Fianna Fáil have suffered reverses.

The point I wanted to make was that, having prepared the ground, having the opportunity presented to them because of the difficulties faced by the inter-Party Government, Fianna Fáil took full advantage of it during the general election. Every one of us remember how every dead wall in the country was plastered with Fianna Fáil posters saying: "Beat the crisis. Let us get cracking. Wives, get your husbands out to work. Unemployment is the test of Government policy." In that atmosphere, we had the Taoiseach putting himself on record in a few speeches of which I propose to remind him.

I take it that Deputy Booth will accept it that these are facts. These are the words of his Taoiseach as reported in the Irish Press of 23rd February, 1957, speaking in his own constituency of Dublin South (Central). That report states:—

He said that the rise in unemployment during the past few months was indisputable evidence that things are wrong with the country. The policy of any Government should be judged by its effect on employment. If it is putting more people into work, it is all right. If it is putting them out of work, it is wrong. Fianna Fáil has never refused to accept that test.

I should like to pause there and ask the Taoiseach to ponder on the bit of wriggling being done in relation to unemployment figures today. The report continues:—

Its main economic aim was to bring about conditions in which Irish men and Irish women can get a livelihood through work in Ireland. Full employment must be the objective of any worthwhile programme.

Again, speaking in Drogheda, as reported in the Irish Press of 16th February, 1957, he had this to say:

The measure of the worsening of the national situation is the increase in unemployment. That is the real test of the soundness of the policy of any Government. Unless the policy of the Government is successful in putting people to work, of giving a chance of getting work to all who are dependent on it for their livelihood, it is not good enough. The aim of any worthwhile policy must be full employment.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy comment on the figures I gave?

Comment on this

I do not know that I remember the figures Deputy Booth gave but I propose to comment on figures given by the Taoiseach's Department on 11th of last month. The general Fianna Fáil pamphlet for use all over the country, produced for the general election with a photograph of their former leader on the front page, had this as one of its main headings: "All energies devoted to one aim: full employment. The whole energies of the Fianna Fáil Government will be devoted to the realisation of the objective of full employment. This can be achieved only through a rapid and substantial increase of national resources and it is to this end that Fianna Fáil will apply its economic policy." At the foot of the page there is this in bold, black letters: "Unemployment can be cured". On the next page, again in bold black letters: "Action can start now. Over 90,000 people are now out of work. The Coalition says it can do nothing for them now. Fianna Fáil believes that work must be provided at once."

That was the Fianna Fáil propaganda during the general election campaign. I do not think anyone can doubt that they were saying fairly and squarely to the people: "As far as this election is concerned, the big issue is the issue of employment and unemployment and we are coming before you as a Party offering full employment in Ireland. We are coming before you as a Party offering to create 100,000 new jobs inside five years, if you put us into Government with a sufficient majority to stay there for five years." Was that not the gist of the message conveyed by Fianna Fáil through the mouth of the Taoiseach to the electorate at the last election? Let them now examine their consciences. Let them now tell about the 100,000 new jobs they were going to create if they were given a sufficient majority to stay in office for a period of five years?

Comment on this

We have not been in five years yet.

Comment on this

At the rate you are going, I do not think you will be in for five years. However, the idea was something in the region of 15,000 to 25,000 new jobs a year. Lest Deputy Booth should think I am in any way misrepresenting the facts or misinterpreting the message which Fianna Fáil wanted to give the electorate at the last general election, may I remind him that when the Minister for Defence was even more of a greenhorn in the Fianna Fáil Parliamentary Party than he is today, he gave his interpretation of the results of the general election and he told us across the floor of the House why Fianna Fáil were put into office. If Deputy Booth cares to consult the Dáil Debates of the 15th May, 1957, he will see that at columns 1283 and 1284, he had this to say:

In my opinion, and in the opinion of any fair-minded person who even now goes back and looks over the speeches made in the election campaign, it is beyond all doubt that we were put in here as a Government to take the necessary steps to remedy the situation of mass unemployment and emigration brought about by the previous Government.

Again, in column 1288 of the Dáil Debates of the same day, the Minister for Defence said:

The people who have been affected by that unemployment and resulting emigration have put their faith in Fianna Fáil to remedy this situation, in the full knowledge that there would probably be a period of comparative austerity before progress towards remedying the situation became apparent.

Fianna Fáil have now been there for more than half of a full period in office and on the 11th of last month a question was put down by Deputy Lynch to the Taoiseach. The information given to Deputy Lynch in reply to that question, regarding persons in insurable employment over the years 1956 to 1959, showed that as between 1956 and 1959 there were 40,000 fewer people in employment than before Fianna Fáil became the Government. Remember, this is the Government which is supported by Deputy Booth who pledged themselves in all their speeches and propaganda during the general election that they were the Party who would give full employment; they were the Party who were to end emigration and cure unemployment; they were the Party who were to create 100,000 new jobs.

We find that, half way through their period of office, their best boast so far as employment is concerned, is that they have succeeded in pushing out of employment 40,000 people who were in employment before the present Fianna Fáil Government came into office. Is that anything to be proud of? Will Deputy Booth deny that is a fact?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

These are figures from the Taoiseach's own Department.

Comment on this

That is a distortion and a misrepresentation of the figures I gave.

Comment on this

I shall read out the question and the answer.

Comment on this

Read out the figures given today by the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I shall read out some figures given by the Taoiseach, in reply to Deputy Lynch's question.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy trying to prove?

Comment on this

I am trying to prove that Fianna Fáil are a disastrous failure, so far as employment is concerned. On the 11th November, 1959, this question was addressed to the Taoiseach by Deputy T. Lynch. I am quoting from Column 885 of Volume 177 of the Dáil Debates:

Mr. T. Lynch asked the Taoiseach if he will state the total number of persons in whole-time employment in the State in each of the years 1956, 1957, 1958 and to the nearest available date in 1959.

The Taoiseach says I am distorting the figures. This was the reply given by the Parliamentary Secretary:

Donnchadh Ó Briain: It is not possible to ascertain the total number of persons in whole-time employment in the State at any specific date. Particulars of the numbers of persons in insurable employment are, however, available in the form of estimates based on insurance stamps sold, or issued to employer depositors. Thus the average number of stamps sold per week in a year provides an estimate of the average number of persons in insurable employment throughout that year.

For the years ended 31st March from 1956 to 1959 the estimates of the weekly average number of persons in insurable employment were as follows:—

Year ended | 31st March

1956 | 501,400

1957 | 485,900

1958 | 464,700

1959 | 460,200

A comparatively simple sum in arithmetic will show the Taoiseach that the gap as between 1956 and 1959 is a figure of 40,000 odd. Does the Taoiseach still question the figure?

Comment on this

My answer is that it was in 1956, in the last nine months of the Coalition that 50,000 people lost their jobs, and that explains the number.

Comment on this

That is precisely the statement the Taoiseach made in Limerick and, as he is prepared to take that statement as a test of his accuracy in this matter, let us deal with it. The Taoiseach says that for nine months, six months in 1956 and three, I think, in 1957, when the inter-Party Government were in office, the numbers in employment fell by 50,000 in these months. I think I am summarising the Taoiseach fairly. Will the Taoiseach just look at his figures? On the figures he has given, even as between the 31st March, 1956, and the 31st March, 1957, the reduction was 15,500 whereas the figure of 50,000——

Comment on this

In respect of the last disastrous nine months of the Coalition.

Comment on this

Anywhere in the four years given, show me a drop of 50,000.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants the figures, I shall produce them.

Comment on this

Where is it?

Comment on this

I shall speak tomorrow. In that nine months, judging by insurance stamps sold, the drop was 50,000.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is quite mistaken.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach already intervened——

Comment on this

I am intervening only to state the facts.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach already intervened to try to gloss over a figure given in a recent debate which was put up to him by Deputy Corish. The Taoiseach might at least do the House the courtesy of agreeing that they have some knowledge of procedure and some intelligence. The Taoiseach gives us figures for insurance stamps sold. He has not adverted to the fact, in his interjections here this evening, that the ceiling for insurance stamps was raised from £600 to £800 and that, according to his own Parliamentary Secretary in introducing the Bill which provided for that, there were 18,000 people being brought in. These were not 18,000 new people going into employment; they were 18,000 already in employment who will now be covered in this respect.

Comment on this

Most of whom were in employment for which stamps are not purchased. No stamps are purchased for civil servants.

Comment on this

There are.

Comment on this

There are. I challenge the Taoiseach on that and I shall apologise if I am wrong. I made some inquiries and, according to the information I have, stamps are purchased for civil servants, people in State employment, and the Taoiseach might check that and deal with it tomorrow.

Comment on this

Manual workers, no matter what they earn, were always insurable. We are talking about salaried workers, not manual workers.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach will find there are stamps sold.

Comment on this

I think the Taoiseach will agree that at least there are widows' and orphans' stamps sold.

Comment on this

I am talking about unemployment insurance stamps.

Comment on this

I should like the Taoiseach to check the tots of the figures given yesterday and see if they relate only to unemployment insurance stamps. However, I want to continue giving Deputy Booth some facts. Those are the facts in relation to unemployment figures as announced to this House by the Taoiseach's Department, that there were 40,000 fewer people in employment on the 31st March, 1959, than on the 31st March, 1956. Remember that that is only on a par with information which his predecessor gave me in reply to a Parliamentary Question I asked on the 12th March, 1958. On that occasion I asked the then Taoiseach to state the average number of persons in industrial and agricultural employment in the years 1956 and 1957. The information given—admittedly the figures were estimated—showed, as between 1956 and 1957, there had been a drop of 24,000 in the figures for industrial and agricultural employment.

I asked a similar question yesterday. I want to say that I take very grave exception to the manner in which the question was answered. I asked a question exactly similar in every respect, bar one, to the one I asked on the 12th March, 1958, the only difference being that in the question on the 12th March, 1958, I had to relate the question to the years 1956-57 whereas in the question yesterday I asked for similar information to cover the years 1958 and 1959 to date. While in March, 1958, the Taoiseach's Department were able to give an estimate of those engaged in industrial and agricultural employment, I was informed yesterday by the Parliamentary Secretary, answering for the Taoiseach, that those figures could not be given as far as industry was concerned and that he could only give me figures for those engaged in transportable goods industries. I should like to ask the Taoiseach why he is not able to give the figures in 1959 which he was able to give in 1958.

Comment on this

What figures? The Deputy has not made himself very clear.

Comment on this

I have 25 minutes to make myself clear.

Comment on this

The Deputy referred to two types of industrial employment. I do not know the difference between them.

Comment on this

I did not draw the distinction. It is the Taoiseach himself who drew it in the reply to the question yesterday. Perhaps if the Taoiseach would endeavour to make it his habit to read the questions put down to him and to read the answers given on his behalf, he might be able to follow things a little bit more clearly. My complaint is this. On the 12th March last year I asked a question and I got an answer. On the 9th December this year I asked a similar question but I was told I could not get an answer.

Comment on this

What answer was the Deputy looking for?

Comment on this

I was looking for the numbers of people engaged in industrial and agricultural employment in this country for the years 1956, 1957, 1958 and 1959 to date. Will the Taoiseach undertake to give those figures tomorrow?

Comment on this

For industrial employment there is no problem.

Comment on this

What the Taoiseach told me yesterday was this:

Current statistics of the number of persons engaged in industry and agriculture are available only from the Quarterly Inquiry into industries producing transportable goods covered by the Census of Industrial Production and from the annual Agricultural Statistics Enumeration respectively. These figures relate to all persons engaged in the activities concerned and not merely to employees only. I propose, with the permission of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle...

He then issued a tabular statement. That answer given yesterday was entirely different from an answer given to a similar question on the 12th March, 1958. I would ask the Taoiseach to look into it.

I doubt if it is necessary, even to satisfy Deputy Booth's appetite for facts, to emphasise by further quotation from Fianna Fáil election propaganda that the issue they were making in the last general election was the question of unemployment and, allied to that, the question of emigration and also the cost of living.

Comment on this

Not the cost of living.

Comment on this

The Deputy thinks that the cost of living was not in issue in the election? Let me quote from the election address of the Minister for Health:

To the electors of Dublin SouthEast. On March 5th you will have the chance to elect a Government. We trust that it will be a better Government than you have had since 1954. In living memory trade has never been so bad, unemployment so rife and the necessities of life so dear.

It winds up:

If you do your part in this election to put a Fianna Fáil Government in office, we believe you can look forward with confidence to a revival of industry, an increase in employment and greater security for all.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The Deputy might have said "hear, hear!" on the 5th March, 1957, but I doubt if he would find many people in his cumann to say "hear, hear!" today. The facts are that the complaint was that the necessities of life were never so dear. We have in the general election pamphlet, issued on behalf of Deputy Booth and other Fianna Fáil Deputies, a whole page devoted to telling the people how dear everything was. They were told that they paid more for tea, beer, whiskey, tobacco, cigarettes, coal, turf and a host of other commodities. Was that not putting the cost of living in issue in the general election?

Comment on this

The Deputy said that we pledged ourselves to reduce the cost of living.

Comment on this

I said the Deputy and his Party put it in issue in the general election.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy said that.

Comment on this

I shall undertake not to revise the script of what I said if the Deputy will do the same. Then we shall see who is right. Fianna Fáil put in issue in the general election the question of unemployment, emigration, and the cost of living.

I have already dealt with the Fianna Fáil history as far as unemployment is concerned. Having got back to office with an overall majority—as big a majority as any Government had since the State was established—having got from the people the power to put into operation any policy they wished, to implement, if they wanted to implement, their proposals for full employment and their plan to give the people of this country 100,000 new jobs— with all that power and no one to stop them, what have they done, apart from wasting the time of this House for nine months discussing the Fianna Fáil proposal to abolish P.R. and make the future safe for Fianna Fáil? Apart from that, what have they done in their two and a half years of office? They have pushed 40,000 people who were in jobs before they came into office out of their jobs.

Comment on this

That is incorrect. There are 17,000 more people working today than when the Coalition were in office.

Comment on this

That is not correct.

Comment on this

If the Minister does not accept the figures published by the Taoiseach's Department, I cannot help him.

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not understand the figures given by the Taoiseach today, I cannot help him.

Comment on this

Then they were faced with a by-election in Dublin, North Central. In the by-election we did not hear much of the 100,000 new jobs but we did hear, nine months after they got into office, that the Government had a policy for more work and that plans were being prepared. This is what they said: "Next year the plans being prepared by the present Government will come to fruition and a great improvement may then be expected in the unemployment situation. Even now the unemployment figure is several thousands less than at this time last year." In November, 1957, when they were faced with this by-election Fianna Fáil did not quite concede defeat but they did concede that there would be some postponement of the 100,000 new jobs that were to be created. Instead of being created in 1957 it was now going to be the next year.

Then they had a by-election in South Galway and I had to search their literature very carefully to find out what they would say about the question of unemployment. Now they had left 1957 and they were in 1958. In 1957 it was to be next year. In 1958 it was only at the very back page of their election literature that they made any reference to the drive for more jobs. The Minister for Lands may now wish to overlook the fact that the general election literature prepared for him and his colleagues said that there were over 90,000 people out of work, that the Government in office could do nothing for these people and that Fianna Fáil believed that work could be provided at once. In the South Galway by-election there was only very little reference to the strive for jobs when it was said: "The intensive drive of the Fianna Fáil Government is getting results."

One of the results claimed was that the number out of work was fewer by several thousands than at the same time the previous year. Notice how clever that is. They say that the number of people out of work was fewer but there is no reference to the number of people in work. This was in May 1958 and, according to the figures given by the Taoiseach's Department on the 11th of last month, there were approximately 36,000 people fewer in work in the year ended 31st March 1958 than in the year 31st March 1956. Deputy Booth, with his appetite for facts, can stand over the statement that the number of people out of work was fewer by several thousands but it would never strike him to ask about the number of people in work. To him the statement that there are fewer people out of work means that there are more people in employment. The fact is that it does not and on that occasion it meant there were 36,000 fewer people in employment when that by-election was held than there were in the year 1956. I am sick and tired of hearing Fianna Fáil Deputies—the Minister for Lands was at it here a few minutes ago—painting the year 1956 as the black year in this country.

Comment on this

It was the most disastrous year in our history.

Comment on this

There we are again.

Comment on this

The year Fianna Fáil were put into office.

Comment on this

Let that kind of thing go on the record because, according to the figures now being published by the Department of the Taoiseach, it was the peak year for employment in the past six years. There were more people in employment in 1956 than there were in any of the six years from 1954 to date. That is described as a black year.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy admit that 50,000 people lost their jobs in the last nine months of that year?

Comment on this

Where are the figures to support the assertion that 50,000 lost their jobs?

Comment on this

They are to be had.

Comment on this

They are not to be had.

Comment on this

They can be got by Parliamentary Question.

Comment on this

I shall now quote from the speech of the Taoiseach at Limerick and I am sorry he did not wait to hear it. The speech is reported in the newspapers of 6th of this month. I have the papers here, if Deputy Booth does not believe I have the facts in my own notes.

Comment on this

I am sure you have the papers.

Comment on this

Let us, first of all, comment on the fact that, in keeping with the phraseology of their Dublin North (Central) by-election speeches, of the plan being postponed until "next year", as recently as 5th or 6th of the present month, the Taoiseach states in Limerick that next year could mark a great leap forward on the path to increased national prosperity. Again, we are going over to next year. Remember, this was the job that was to be tackled at once. Fianna Fáil were to beat the crisis. Fianna Fáil were to be allowed to get cracking. Fianna Fáil told the people that "action could start now." Fianna Fáil told the people that there was no reason for any delay, that the Coalition were all wrong in saying they could not do anything then. Fianna Fáil said that something must be done at once. Now we find that it is postponed from 1957 to 1958; it is postponed from 1958 to 1959 and, in December, 1959, the Taoiseach again says "next year".

Comment on this

No, we are doing all right now.

Comment on this

You are doing all right but you are not putting more people into work.

Comment on this

There are 17,000 more people at work. That is not to be sneezed at.

Comment on this

It is certainly not to be sneezed at if it is not there.

Comment on this

I should be only too happy if the Taoiseach would stand over the figures issued by his Department, which show that there are 30,000 fewer people in employment.

Comment on this

There are 17,000 more people in employment.

Comment on this

They are all in England.

Comment on this

They are not, and you know it.

Comment on this

They must be in the Minister's Department.

Comment on this

If you take your own figure for insurable employment, the figures are there for you to see.

Comment on this

What about the increase in the numbers as a result of the 15,000 new jobs per annum estimated by the Taoiseach as being required?

Comment on this

There are 18,000 civil servants who do not use stamps at all.

Comment on this

May I go on, if the Minister has no objection? I propose to quote words which may not be palatable to him. The Taoiseach is reported as saying at Limerick:

Mr. Dillon may believe that what he asserted was a statistical fact, that the number of people in employment is 40,000 less than three years ago and said this proved the failure of the Government policy.

Then the Taoiseach asks: "What are the facts?" and he sets out what he, presumably, claims are four facts. I want to controvert each of the four. The first fact, following the Taoiseach's rhetorical question, is:

The three years of which Mr. Dillon spoke include the last months of the Coalition Government, the last half of 1956 and the first quarter of 1957——

I shall give him that fact. He goes on:

during which this country experienced a slump of unprecedented severity in production and employment. During the nine months' period when the Coalition were in control the numbers in employment fell by around 50,000.

If the Minister for Lands will look at his volume of the Dáil Debates for 11th November, 1959, not a month ago, he will see that that simply is not so, if the figures given by the Department of the Taoiseach in reply to a Parliamentary Question are correct, because the decrease as between 31st March, 1956, and 31st March, 1957, according to those figures, was 15,500. Even making due allowance for the Taoiseach's exaggeration, that is a very far cry from 50,000. The Taoiseach went on:

That rapid decline in production and employment was arrested before the end of 1957.

That was the Taoiseach's second fact. I want to ask him, if that is so, how is it that there was a further decrease in employment between 31st March, 1957, and 31st March, 1958, according to his own figures, of 21,200—an additional decrease of 21,200 persons, who were put out of employment under a Fianna Fáil Government in the year when the Taoiseach talks about the decline in production and employment being arrested? He says then:

In 1958 the long process of recovery was begun.

Then he says:

In this year, 1959, the recovery has been much more rapid.

Again I invite the Minister for Lands to look at the figures as between 31st March, 1958, and 31st March, 1959. Employment, according to that reply, decreased by a further 4,500 persons. These are another 4,500 persons who were in jobs and who have been put out of jobs under a Fianna Fáil Government. So that the gap between 31st March, 1956, and 31st March, 1959. as at 31st March, 1959, had lengthened out to 41,200 people—41,200 fewer people in insurable employment than there were before Fianna Fáil became Government. However, I imagine that even Deputy Booth has now had his fill of facts about unemployment.

Comment on this

No; I am waiting for them.

Comment on this

It might be as well to turn for a moment to the question of the cost of living. I asked a Question yesterday to find out what increases had taken place in commodities included in the calculation of the cost-of-living index figure as between March, 1957, and the latest convenient date. According to the answer given to me by the Department of the Taoiseach yesterday, there were 197 items included in the calculation for the cost-of-living index figure and, of those 197 items, 149 have increased in price since Fianna Fáil took office; there have been decreases in only 42 cases and in six cases there was no change.

I move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this