Adjournment Debate: Government Policy.
Contributions 109–228 of 228. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
A debate of this sort offers an opportunity for a general review. I do not consider it should necessarily be used for the purpose of arraigning the Government on what they have or have not done as the people will have an adequate opportunity later of expressing their views on the record of the Government. Nevertheless, the House is entitled to question various aspects of Government policy and entitled to information on what decisions have been taken and how these decisions have operated.
The great problem have facing the future of this country is the provision of additional employment and the production of goods, agricultural and industrial, which can be exported at a profit. Looking at any set of figures or statistics, it seems that there is a continuous drop in the numbers employed on the land. Whether the number of persons leaving the land varies between one year and another, the general tendency has continued uninterruptedly. Certain short periods show a bigger exodus than others but, over the period, whether the figures are taken from the statistics published last year prior to the Budget or from the Statistical Abstract, it is evident that there is a continuous exodus from rural areas. That has often been referred to by people who have written and talked on this subject. It is accompanied by emigration from urban areas.
It seems to me that this problem has never been properly appreciated or understood in so far as general plans or programmes are concerned. Repeatedly, views have been expressed about the provision of employment and the establishment of industry to absorb those who leave employment on the land. It seems, from the various efforts that have been made, that so far the additional employment provided in industry has not nearly kept pace with the combined numbers of those who leave employment on the land and those who reach adult status each year.
I have always taken the view that the claims made by the present Government when in Opposition that they could provide full employment would not be justified in practice and certainly were not warranted on past experience. Some time within the past couple of years I listened to an address by a well-known economist in this country. He expressed the view that this country could enjoy its present or even a higher standard of living, both those directly employed in agriculture and those employed elsewhere, and still have 200,000 fewer people in agriculture than are employed at present. That talk was given about two years ago. When studied in that way the figure sounds somewhat startling.
If we look back at the various figures that have been published over the years for the numbers leaving rural occupations or occupations as farm workers or family help on farms, it is seen that that figure is likely to be attained in quite a measurable distance of time depending on the rate of exodus which could be acheived in 15 or 20 years. The serious fact which seems to emerge from that is that, once an exodus of that sort is attained. It will have cumulative effects.
From time to time many people refer to the rate of emigration or migration, as the case may be, from areas on the western seaboard and in the more congested areas. Looking recently at figures for agricultural employment in other provinces, I notice the tendency is not confined to these areas and the common to other parts of the country though the emphasis is heavier in the congested areas. It seems to me that the efforts to provide additional employment have so far not measured up to the requirements or the needs of the community as a whole.
In particular, I want to deal for a moment with efforts in recent years to attract industry to certain specific areas. We are all familiar with the efforts to attract industries to the free zone at Shannon. Considerable effort has been made to provide facilities and to attract industries to that area. It seems, from what has happened, that so far the effort has not met with the success expected.
I want to repeat a view I expressed here previously. The facilities and encouragement provided for the Shannon zone should be provided not for Shannon but for Limerick or Ennis. With the exception of limited industrial projects where goods are exported through the airport or where the raw materials can readily be imported by air, it seems that there is no merit, per se, in undertaking such a project at Shannon. The obvious places for that development are the city of Limerick or the town of Ennis where natural facilities exist. A ready pool is available for employment in Limerick and in Ennis. If there is a slack in employment at a place like Shannon, the people concerned come either from Limerick or Ennis. Very few live at Shannon Airport. The encouragement provides, the facilities offered could be more effectively provided either in Limerick or Ennis without having to provide additional ancillary facilities or services required at Shannon and that are already available in these other places.
There is one aspect of this matter to which I wish to refer. It is not confined to this project but generally to the encouragement which has been afforded to new industries. Many of these industries have developed under strong State stimuli. They have been encouraged and facilitated in many ways by the remission of tax on export, by generous facilities in the form of loans and by the assistance which is available, through the Industrial Credit Company, and so on. That is all undoubtedly to the good and has succeeded in establishing or encouraging the establishment of industries which would otherwise not have been started.
The tax remissions and reliefs provided in 1956, and since expanded, undoubtedly operated as probably the greatest incentive ever given for industrial export but I notice in a few remarks on occasions—the most recent one was the speech of the Chairman of Seafield Fabrics, Ltd., Mr. Declan Dwyer—a note of anxiety and even of criticism of the facilities afforded to new industrialists. Comparison is made with the expansion programmes and costs which Seafield Fabrics and other existing industrialists have undertaken.
This speech was reported in the Press on the 13th December. At the 14th ordinary general meeting of the company held on Monday, 12th December, Mr. Dwyer said:
I would mention in passing that the total capital cost of these developments in both companies will be in excess of £270,000, not one penny of which was received in the form of a Government grant, which these days is so much in evidence for foreigners starting industries here.
The chief deterrent to the further expansion of the bulk of Irish industries (excluding the new "spoonfed" class which is bolstered by Government grants and tax-free concessions) is the abnormally high level of direct taxation.
I mention that for the reason that on another occasion somewhat similar remarks were made and I want the Government and the appropriate Departments to ensure that no facilities will be denied to existing industrialists which are being offered to those about to commerce new enterprises. Quite recently, I had a similar complaint from a firm alleging different treatment from that afforded to an established firm in a similar line of business, although in actual fact the firm which communicated with me had been established for some considerable time before the other one which was competing with them. I suppose it is inevitable that some conflict may arise from time to time but I think that we ought not, on the one hand, provide incentives and encouragement and, on the other, operate in such a manner as not to facilitate to the maximum extent existing industrial undertakings.
I have been struck by the very considerable evidence not only of people leaving the land but by the fact that, despite the efforts made, there are now substantially fewer people employed than in 1956. These figures have already been quoted and I do not propose to labour the point but it is significant that, in the figures of the Budget which were published at the time, about 50,000 fewer people were employed then than four years previously. If we take into account the very large numbers emigrating and that over the past three to four years I suppose no fewer than 150,000, on a fairly conservative estimate, have left this country, we can realise the magnitude of the problem that has to be overcome.
I do not believe it does anything to help this problem either to exaggerate it or, on the other hand, minimise it such as the Minister for Transport and Power was doing a short time ago. The fact that in certain quarters, in individual industrial or commercial undertakings or other undertakings, there may be a spirit of optimism or that certain sections of the community are now better off than they were, does not justify the claim made that very many of the people find it just as difficult as ever to live and that many of them, because of that, are forced to find employment elsewhere. Certain sections of the community undoubtedly have had their position improved. In that regard, it seems to me that the State companies should set a headline.
Up to recently the Government claimed there had been very little rise in the cost of living. The recent consumer price index refutes that claim but, even prior to the publication of that, it is, I think, generally known that the E.S.B. recently granted a wage increase of 12½ per cent. That is a fairly substantial increase. If it was made on the basis of the change in the cost of essentials and in the falling value of money, it indicates the views of the conciliation machinery or the E.S.B. wage tribunal of the changes that have taken place.
But it does pose the question of the standards State bodies establish and how these standard will impact on the rest of the community. An increase of 12½ per cent. must have an effect on the price of electricity. Whether the the price is that which the domestic consumer has to pay or whether it is felt by the agricultural community or industrialists, it will have an effect either on the cost of living or on the cost of production. While it is conceded and recognised that, as the cost of living rises, the E.S.B. employees are entitled, just as any other section, to an increase in their wages or emoluments, these other factors in a State undertaking must be recognised and adequate allowance made for them. Only in the accounts which were published recently and in the statement made by the Chairman of the E.S.B. was reference made to the increased costs which had to be met by the E.S.B. and as a result the charges were increased from October. Is it a fact that this recent increase will be passed on to the public in the future or was it budgeted for in the additional charges which were already imposed last October?
Reference has been made during this debate, and during the discussion yesterday, to State bodies. I might as well refer to the matter now as later. There is an impression that State bodies do not give sufficient information to the public and that Ministers in the House do not give sufficient information when queried on the activities of these undertakings. The growth of State-sponsored bodies and State companies has increased greatly since the war and the tendency is for their number to increase. This development undoubtedly makes it important to see exactly what the position is vis-a-vis the statutory authority for these undertakings and the information which is furnished here to the Dáil and which is made available to the public.
In one form or another, State bodies are established by the State, either by statute or the provision of capital, and those employed in them, like all of us, are public servants. The fact that these organisations have been established under statute and that statutory authority defines their responsibility, does not mean that those organisations can adopt a somewhat authoritarian attitude to the public or that they can ignore the public or the Dáil. I would say that, in the majority of cases, the staffs of these companies are most courteous and helpful whenever their services are sought, but there are other occasions when they are not and these occasions often create the attitude of the public towards the manner in which these bodies deal with public queries or where public questions or interests are concerned. No one experts, nor would they be justified in expecting, that the day-to-day questions of administration of these bodies should be open to query in the Dáil, but undoubtedly important decisions should not only be made public but the reasons for them should also be given.
This question was considered some years ago in Britain and when we were in Government we considered the matter without, I admit, getting a satisfactory arrangement under which the various matters could be brought under review. There is provision in most of these statutes for discussions when the annual reports are presented to the Dáil and an opportunity is afforded to members to discuss particular problems. In a way, that affords an opportunity for the matter to be brought before the Dáil and to enable public attention to be focussed on it but from experience over the years that rarely happens. With very rare exceptions, an occasion of that sort is afforded when legislation is introduced which increases the capital or provides additional capital or finance for capital development or when, as in the case of C.I.E., a Transport Bill comes before the House. It does, however, seem from what has been said here, and at very many meetings and gatherings throughout the country, that there is dissatisfaction with the manner in which decisions are taken and the complete refusal to discuss the terms of these decisions except on the basis of predetermined lines laid down by the company. This applies particularly in the case of C.I.E. where branch lines are concerned, but in other matters other State companies should also afford the public the fullest information in, I believe, their own interests.
Comment on this
The closing of branch lines by C.I.E. has already been ruled on by the Ceann Comhairle. It does not seem to be a matter for the Adjournment Debate.
Comment on this
I refer to it only in passing. It seems from the experience of those who have interested themselves in these matters that, in the interests of the company concerned, the best policy, the soundest policy and the policy that will secure maximum public support, is to give the public and the House the fullest possible information. Much of the criticism would have been avoided if the people knew the reasons behind the decisions of these undertakings, which as I have mentioned, set a headline in many ways and in this particular instance could do likewise if they offered an explanation and information on the occasion of particular decisions or actions. I feel the Government and the Taoiseach should have another look at the question which was considered some years ago and, in the light of the information furnished by various State bodies, reexamine the question. As there is an ever-growing tendency for the number of these bodies to increase, with so many ramifications in so many spheres of economic, social and national activity, it is vital that the public interest should be so understood and recognised that public confidence in whatever action is taken would be readily forthcoming.
Another question to which I wish to refer has reference to the effort to provide and develop the industrial potential and the tourist industry. While great efforts have been made and are being made to establish new industries, the effort made so far as tourism is concerned seems to be inadequate and is not achieving the desired results. Is the publicity campaign which is being undertaken directed into the right channels or has it achieved the aims and objectives outlined when that programme was initiated? I do not want to re-tread old ground or reexamine the background which has prevented Bord Fáilte from getting support and which has militated against its effectiveness. Most of that is now water under the bridge, but certainly the past difficulties of that body have prevented it from playing the part which it might play in the industrial expansion.
It is well recognised that the accommodation available is not sufficient and that on many occasions we have lost large conferences because we could not provide adequate accommodation on a particular occasion or at a particular period. I have been struck by the growth in tourist trade income for this country compared with other European countries.
In the annual report of O.E.E.C. a study was made over a period of the three years, from 1955 to 1958, of the increased income which resulted from tourism in a number of European countries. The figures showed that Austria increased its income by 103 per cent., West Germany by 64 per cent., Italy by 48 per cent., France by 12 per cent., Britain by 25 per cent. and Ireland by 12 per cent. It is true that there was one country, Switzerland, which had an increase of 5 per cent. but I presume that was so because of the already highly developed state of the tourist business in that country. Our percentage increase was substantially lower than any other country engaged in developing the tourist business.
Quite recently the Irish Banking Review commented on the fact that State allocation for the development of tourism, a most important contributor to the economy of the country, was only £3.55 million out of a total of £53.4 million for the period 1960 to 1964. I deplore that for the reason that tourism expenditure or the scope which expenditure on tourism enjoys, offers the greatest return for a comparatively low outlay. If anything like the same effort were devoted to developing tourist facilities as is employed in other spheres—it is true that additional facilities have been provided in the way of hotel and bedroom accommodation—the scope for expenditure, and the benefits that would follow from it, would be felt by almost all areas in the country. The benefits would be dispersed throughout our cities, towns and rural areas.
One of the matters complained of here has been that of transport. This matter was referred to again this week in the course of a discussion in the House of Lords. Reference was made to the unsatisfactory nature of the sea transport arrangements, particularly at the peak periods of travel, either at holiday periods or at the Christmas and Easter rush periods. I believe that the Minister for Transport and Power, in conjunction with any other Minister interested in the matter, should convene a conference of all interested parties, and, if necessary, responsible British as well as Irish interests. I notice that the has had some such discussion.
Unfortunately, in the past any discussions taking place have never produced the desired results because when there was a peak period of travel the same or similar problems arose again. While I agree that an effort was made, when these problems arose, to remedy them or to obviate the same mistakes later, past experience justifies the belief that up to the present the travel facilities are nothing like adequate. It is of some significance that this matter was the subject of comment in the recent debate in the British House of Lords.
It does seem to me that it would be better to provide encouragement for the development of tourist facilities rather than to develop some of the undertakings to which I have referred already. In the tourist business we have available not only potential travellers from Britain; no doubt the majority of those are our own people returning for holidays but we have untapped opportunities where the United States is concerned. It is quite significant that although there was growth in the number of United States visitors to the Continent and Western Europe, the increase in the number coming to this country was not commensurate.
I believe that we should now capitalise on the fact that the new President of the United States is of Irish extraction. It is surprising how many people in America have never heard of this country and are not familiar with it. Undoubtedly the election of a new President will focus attention in America on his background and we should capitalise on that to the fullest possible extent.
Another point to which I wish to refer is the recent decision to increase the interest charged on Small Dwellings (Acquisition Acts) Loans. It seems a rather extraordinary decision at a time when interest rates are falling to increase these charges. It comes at a time also when there is a drop in local authority housing and employment in building houses because of the fact that in many cases the schemes planned have been completed. The prospect of maintaining employment in the building industry depends to a considerable extent on the Small Dwellings Acts schemes. These have always been good schemes from every point of view in so far as they encourage people to build houses for themselves and encourage groups to come together for the purpose of providing housing schemes. They have been characterised by individual and group initiative as the case may be. There is no justification for the decision to increase interest rates, especially when the tendency everywhere is for interest rates to fall. I believe there is need for an explanation of this decision and, if possible, a change in if it is not to affect detrimentally employment in the building industry at a time when the opportunities of employment in local authority housing schemes are greatly restricted.
These schemes and the Small Dwellings Act schemes have in the past proved not only satisfactory but have inculcated a spirit of initiative and self-help in providing accommodation for many people who otherwise would be forced to look for local authority houses, for which they would be ineligible, or who could not otherwise provide themselves with accommodation and who had not sufficient funds available to purchase houses or to build them out of their own resources.
The Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act loans facilitated a group in the community, particularly the white collar section, who were not catered for under other schemes and who depended on these loans to provide for their needs. I believe, therefore, that it is a bad decision and one which should be altered before damage is done to the employment prospects as well as the prospects of providing accommodation for this section of the community who endeavour by their own exertions to assist themselves.
Comment on this
I do not think there is much point in trying to convince the present Government of the seriousness of the situation, at least in the rural areas. If they believe their statements, it is quite clear they have their eyes completely closed to a very dangerous situation in the rural areas. It would appear from their speeches— and I believe them—that the large centres of population are not feeling the pinch as badly as others but is there any use in adding my voice to the many others to try to convince this Government that the situation of the farming community is pretty desperate? The Taoiseach is not a farmer but, if he analyses the statistics furnished by his own office each month and each year, he will realise that there is a pretty serious situation existing for all farmers but especially for those who are trying to eke out a living on holdings of 30 acres and less. I am taking farms of 30 acres and less, in a rough and ready way, because they are the smallest range of holdings, from which, naturally, the income is smallest.
Figures issued by the Central Statistics Office reveal that in the three quarters of last year the income from cattle exported was £22.1 million. This year there is a slight improvement; the figure is £23.5 million. In 1958, for the first three quarters, January to September, inclusive, the income from exported cattle was £32.5 million. In 1957, the year in which Fianna Fáil took over from the Inter-Party Government, live cattle alone brought in £37.5 million. These figures show that from 1957 to 1958 there was a drop of £5,000,000 or, in other words, that the farmers got £5,000,000 less for their cattle. In 1959 there was a drop of £15.4 million on the 1957 figure and in 1960 a drop of £14,000,000 on the 1957 figure.
I listened to the Minister for Transport speak here today. He told us that he thinks the agricultural industry is in good shape and in good from and is getting adequate assistance from the Government. One of the boasts he made was that the fact that farmers had borrowed £19,000,000 from the banks was a good sign. It comes as news to me that any group of persons who are in debt is in a better position than they would be if they had their own capital and did not need to borrow.
I challenge the Minister for Transport and Power to disprove that when the Inter-Party Government was in office, from 1954 to 1957, the amount of borrowing by farmers was negligible, the reason being that they had their own capital to finance their own projects but, as a result of the rise in the cost of living and the disastrous fall in income that I have indicated, the farmers have been badly hit. The Taoiseach is a businessman. Will he tell me what industry in any country, even in the United States of America, could withstand the blow inflicted by a loss of £15½ million in one year, £14,000,000 in another year and £5,000,000 in another year, with no prospect of improvement in the situation?
The present Government took office in the month of March, 1957, on a shoal of false promises. The Taoiseach made the statements that Deputy Dillon read out today. We all read them at the time and some of us were soft enough to believe that the present Taoiseach and the then Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party, who is now the President, made those statements in good faith.
Comment on this
When two men who have held responsible positions in the country for 16 years or more go on a public platform at the time of an election and make a solemn statement to the electors that they know will be published in the Press and read in every household, one cannot help believing it.
Comment on this
I did not believe it. Why should I support Fianna Fáil? We had kept the cost of living down by food subsidies and Deputy Murphy supported us in that. Fianna Fáil said that some of the propaganda used against them was that they were going to do certain things and the present Taoiseach and the Leader of the Party at that time, Mr. de Valera, said: "No. That is all wrong. We will not do away with the food subsidies." Even if they did not do away with the food subsidies, the position was no better than it would have been if the Inter-Party Government had been left in. They got there on false promises which they must have known they would not live up to. It is difficult to see how the work of any man laid on a foundation of such falsity could have success. That is the principal reason why the present Government has not had any success in the handling of the country for the last four years. It was not enough to make promises before the election but at the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis following the general election of 1957 the Taoiseach promised an expenditure within the next five years of £220,000,000. What has become of that £220,000,000?
Comment on this
Either the Taoiseach never made the promise or never intended to carry it out. Which is it? I do not want to recall the promise of 100,000 new jobs. That was fantastic. Anybody soft enough to believe that, deserved a Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
No, I did not believe that, I said did not believe that they were going to remove the food subsidies. I genuinely believed that they were not going to do that. I did not believe the promise of 100,000 new jobs.
Comment on this
Very few believed that. The average Fianna Fáil supporter said: "The poor things want to get back to power at all costs and must say something." That was the attitude about that. Most people thought that the food subsidies would not be touched and that the cost of living in food, bread and butter in particular, would remain unchanged.
Several things have happened since that. The most notable is the complete lack of employment in rural areas. The Minister for Transport and Power can tell us that the unemployment register is down by 20,000. The wonder is that it is not down by a greater figure because people have fled from the country. All those who want to make use of their time and to make a living have had to fly from the country. The Local Authorities (Works) Act, under which useful and productive employment was given, was completely cut out by the Fianna Fáil Government.
The Government tells us that migration of whole families which has been brought to their notice is not a fact. Would the Taoiseach ask the Garda Síochána or the enumerators of the census how many houses that held families in the past five or ten years are now shut up? I notice a whole table given of holdings of farmers. I know from my experience in the Land Commission that these tables can be misleading. Many people hold two or three small holdings and these are described as homesteads but they are really three detached parts of the one homestead.
If the Minister wants to get a real picture of what is happening in the country, I am giving him at least two pointers on how to do it. First, he can get the list of homesteads at present occupied and another list of the homesteads which have been vacated in the past 10 years. This will reveal a wholesale clearance is going on under our eyes. There is only one way to meet that situation. The Government must find markets for what the farmer is producing and cannot sell and, secondly, they must bring employment into the rural areas.
The cost of running the country this year is roughly £177 million. Less than £3 million of that is spent on direct employment and then we wonder why people are leaving the country. The reason is obvious: we are taxing the people for every grandiose scheme under the sun but sufficient attention is not being given to employment by the Special Employment Schemes Office, the Board of Works, the Forestry Section, the Land Commission, Bord na Móna and so on. The only sensible thing for people to do in these circumstances is to fly from under this heavy tombstone of taxation placed on them by this Government. The minor employment schemes and rural improvement schemes which used to give employment in the winter months are being reduced. The Minister for Transport and Power is taking credit for expansion in forestry. We need not take any credit for that because any credit that is due goes to the inter-party Government who first put forestry on its feet.
Would the Taoiseach tell us what plans Fianna Fáil have for increasing agricultural production and, if they have any plans for increasing agricultural production, what plans they have for the marketing of it once it is produced? The farmers have increased their production of cattle, pigs, butter and everything else, but it is left on their hands.
On the subject of the production of butter, it is peculiar that we have the Government asking for harder work and increased production while yesterday I was on a deputation representing 700 small farmers who were trying to establish a creamery and who had the proposal rejected. We went to Foras Tionscal who always gave grants for the establishment of industries provided these industries would not have a damaging effect on existing industries.
These small farmers, trying to help themselves, put up £6,000 capital for this project. They were seeking a grant of £3,500 towards the erection of the creamery and the reason their proposal was turned down was that the Government feel there is too much butter being produced.
If a foreigner wants £250,000 to establish a factory at Shannon, in Cork or in the city of Dublin, it is given without any demur but when 700 farmers who cannot sell their produce and who see no other course open to them, seek to establish this industry to increase their incomes and give a certain amount of employment, they are turned down, notwithstanding the fact that a Bill to help the marketing of butter passed all Stages in the House last night. The Minister for Transport and Power said that no Party has or could have plan to stop emigration. I do not think anybody has ever made the claim that he could stop it completely.
Comment on this
If we look at a table in the agricultural statistics, issued about a month or six weeks ago, we shall find that in 1934 there were 579,409 males engaged in occupations on the land; in 1954 the number was 421,309, a drop of 158,000 approximately. That means, if you look at it in another way, that one out of every seven males working on the land in 1934 was gone by 1954. Until the new census appears we shall not know what the drop is for the last six years but I take it it will be in proportion or that the number will be even greater than that shown in the Table in respect of 1934 to 1954.
The policy of this Government seems to aim at the elimination of small holdings; anyhow that is what is happening. If that is Government policy the Government should come out in the open and say so. Many people are trying to remain in holdings on a very reduced standard of living in the hope that some day the tables will be turned and things will begin to brighten up; instead of that they are getting darker day by day. The wise ones—and I call then wise—have gone while the going is good; whole families, father, mother and children, have moved over to England. The net result of Government policy is the extermination— there is no other word for it — of farmers of under 30 acres.
The Government have been done two things to bring that about; they have increased the cost of living and they have—and this is the most charitable expression I can use—failed to find a market for what the small farmer has to sell. The small farmer depends particularly on a few cattle, sheep and lambs, pigs, eggs and turkeys. The market for all these has vanished.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Moher think the farmers are fools? They went into production and produced enormous numbers of turkeys last year and the year before and when they had them, the Government could not find a market for them.
The Minister for Transport and Power told us about all the radio sets they were selling in Pakistan and India and the merchandise we were sending to the far ends of the world but what I want to know is why scrap the principal industry that is already established with the necessary capital and machinery—because every single holding is a potential factory? Why scrap that and let it die? Should that not be the first thing to get our attention? We are supposed to have 380,000 holdings or farms in the country and each one is staffed with at least the necessary skill, equipment and livestock. Why not take that and see that it, in any case, was in a good healthy condition? Why not find a market for the output of those farms instead of going to Pakistan to find a market for radio parts—which may be admirable in itself? Why scrap the main industry we have?
I admit that the farmers who have the land for it and are employing it to grow wheat and barley on a big scale are getting a fairly good return because they have fixed prices but the small farmer gets no assistance and no help from the Government. I know that Deputy Moher is thinking that they are getting a subsidy on fertilisers and relief of rates but while these things are a certain help, that is not the way to tackle the problem.
The farmer works the whole year round and the principal part of his job is to find a market for what he has produced. That is where the Government fell down on the job. We heard the details about the flight from the land in every country, but there was no reference to the flight from the land in England because actually the number on the land has increased.
Comment on this
Since 1938, the number has increased. England learned the lesson and poured money into the development of agriculture. I put this to any Deputy as a challenge: when Fianna Fáil took over from us in 1957, agriculture was never in a better or healthier condition.
Comment on this
We were pushed out as many a good Government were pushed out, by fraud—a nasty word but I cannot find another for it. The farmers were never as well off as when we went out in 1957.
Comment on this
The proof of that is that the people had so much money in 1955 and 1956 that they were purchasing wholesale with the result that we had to put a tariff on certain goods coming into the country. Where was that money coming from? Scarcely from people who were borrowing money from the bank. It was scarcely the £19,000,000 the Minister for Transports and Power spoke about that upset the balance of trade so much that the Government had to put on tariffs to stop them from buying.
Comment on this
You could not get a loan during the Deputy's term of office.
Comment on this
I would say to those Deputies opposite who are interrupting: let them wait until they go to the country and when they do, they will get a wallop that they will not forget for many a long day.
Comment on this
The sooner they go, the better, but God help any Government that have to take over the mess they have created. It will be beyond the power of any Government to bring back the 60,000 or 80,000 families that have emigrated. It would take a lot to convince them now, scattered as they are through the towns and cities of England, that they should come back when they had to go with their caps in their fists to their former enemy to beg for a living after 40 years of self-government.
If it is the policy of Fianna Fáil to exterminate the small farmer and if it is best, in their opinion, for the country, in the long run, let them come out in the open and say they are doing it, but let them not be like the Minister for Transport and Power, rubbing salt into the wound and trying to cover it over with oil when, due to the high cost of living and the failure to find markets for their products, the people have been forced out of the land. Let them come out in the open and say what the Government intend to do about it. Let them take a chance and perhaps it will pay off. Let them forget the false promises on which they got in in 1957. We will forget them if the Government now come out in the open and turn over to the truth and say exactly where they stand.
In case any Deputy might think that I am opposed to industrial development, let me say I am not. The one fault I have to find with it is that it is not going fast or far enough, at least in the west. We have got a bad deal from the Government in the west in spite of An Foras Tionscal and the Undeveloped Areas Act. But no amount of industry the Government could establish could undo the damage that is already done. The two things most needed are to find markets for the produce on our hands and provide a great deal more employment which is so badly needed. There is plenty of productive work to be done in the rural areas and the men who could do it are going away. If the Taoiseach looks over his figures again, he will find in the £177,000,000 it costs to run the country, less than £3,000,000 is spent on direct employment of working men and perhaps there he will find the reason for the large scale emigration.
Comment on this
I welcome a debate such as this because it can be a check on the Government and a check on the Opposition. It gives the backbenchers an opportunity to review the position over the past year. I believe it is our responsibility to try to make suggestions to the Government about how we might try to remedy the ills of the particular sections of people for whom we speak.
I understand that in this debate it is permissible to debate general Government policy and, in particular, the policy implemented by the different Departments of State. I shall take the Minister for Local Government first. Speakers here have referred to unemployment. I admit that Ministers, other than the Minister for Local Government, have a certain responsibility where the provision of employment is concerned. It is only natural, however, that those of us who are members of local authorities should be particularly interested as far as the provision of employment is concerned in the policy of the Minister for Local Government.
Some months ago, we received a lengthy circular letter from the Minister. The genesis of that communication was that the Minister was cutting down on a number of labourers' cottages being built. Admittedly, there was no specific statement to that effect in the circular, but that was the clear implication. It was more or less pointed out that, when an application was received for a labourer's cottage, it was the duty of the county council to inspect the home of the applicant and, if it was found unfit for human habitation, an estimate should be made of the cost of putting the house into a condition which would render it fit for habitation. It appears to me there is a deliberate "go slow" policy on the part of the Minister for Local Government where building is concerned. We are exhorted to give more employment but, when the opportunity of providing employment arises, we are advised to adopt a different policy.
Twelve months ago, I raised the question here of building houses for small farmers. The Minister was enthuasiastic in his approval of that idea. He pointed out, as the record will show, that there is an income limitation and a valuation limitation where the building of houses by local authorities is concerned. I do not suppose my views carry much weight. Certainly nothing has ever been done along the lines I suggested.
Comment on this
It is not up to the county council. It is the responsibility of the Minister to give a direction in the matter. I firmly believe the Minister for Local Government agrees with my suggestion, but we want a direction to build houses for small farmers up to a certain valuation, without loss of subsidy, grant or anything else to which we may be entitled.
Comment on this
I am pleased to hear that. I believe there is a "go slow." policy. We sent up a scheme for 145 cottages. After a delay of roughly six months we were informed the plans were not acceptable. We submitted further plans and, after some months delay, some cottages were sanctioned and others were not. At the end of the financial year, instead of having built 145 cottages, we had built only 48. If North Tipperary send up plans for 150 cottages, South Tipperary plans for another 150, Laois and Offaly likewise, right down through the 27 local authorities, and if it is assumed that each cottage costs £1,000, and the Minister reduces the number by more than 50 per cent., that represents a saving of £100,000 per year over all the local authorities. There is an aphorism in my part of the country that, if you want to hold a man on the land, the safest way to keep him is to take £1 off him every week. At the end of four years give him back 5/- out of that £1, and he will thank you. He will forget that you are responsible for depriving him of the other 15/-.
We hear a lot of complaints about unemployment, with consequent requests for the employment of workmen. Several Deputies have spoken about tourism but no one suggested that people coming into the country each year, who are described as tourists, should have their names and places of birth noted. The Minister for Transport and Power referred to the 50,000 fewer unemployed in the country. What was the reason for it? It was because whole families emigrated en masse during the past few years. If the places of birth of the supposed tourists coming in here each year were noted, I can guarantee that more than 90 per cent. of them would be found to be persons returning to visit their fathers and mothers or other relatives.
The Minister for Transport and Power insisted on repeating that there were fewer unemployed in the country. I accept his figures and I have explained the reason. Why would an able-bodied young man or woman stay here and try to exist on a pittance of 38/- a week? Why would they not be taking ships for Liverpool, Glasgow and elsewhere in Britain? If you compare the 1956 census figures with the, figures for the present time, it will be found that there are four times fewer able-bodied young men and women in the country capable of taking up employment.
I want to sound a note of warning. We are facing a very dangerous situation in this country in the not so distant future. If the flight from our shores of all our able-bodies young men and women continues at its present rate, in a few years we will have a nation of very old people with very few young people. That is the rock upon which we will perish.
If I may turn to agriculture for a moment and deal specifically with the operations of the sugar factories, I can point to an indication of our population trend. People will say, of course, that our people as a whole are not consuming as much sugar as they were years ago. I say that is a fallacy. The real reason is that the population is getting smaller and smaller and the consumption of sugar as well as of everything else is growing less and less. As the population dwindles, and we produce more, the less we have to sell at home to the detriment of our small farmers.
That is a tragedy because when this country was in dire straits it was the small farmers who served the nation best. I refer the House particularly to their efforts during the last war. In many parts of Lower Ormonde, long before the Thurles Beet factory was established, the small farmers were carting their beet to the Grand Canal stores for shipment to the Carlow factory. It was not a very popular occupation in those days to grow or harvest beet. In fact, in many parts of Lower Ormonde, it was looked upon as a disgrace. Yet these small farmers put their beet into common horsecarts and took them miles to the Grand Canal depot where sometimes they had to wait for very long periods because the barges were held up by storms or high water or various other conditions over which the canal company had no control.
Comment on this
Other Deputies may, if they wish, try to put me off by gibing at me, but I believe our duty is to come here and see if we can improve conditions for the people we represent. I remember at the time of the tillage regulations, when people could be brought into court and convicted for not reaching their quota, there was not a single prosecution in Lower Ormonde. Now the people who kept the beet factories going during that time find that their acreage is substantially reduced, even though they are supplying a factory less than 40 miles away. Last year, their acreage was substantially reduced and although some growers were granted an increase this year, it was not granted to portion of my area.
I want to pay a tribute to the managing director of the Irish Sugar Company. While I reserve the right to criticise the company, I think Major-General Costello is the right man for the job. It is not his fault that the subsidy given to all farmers previously has been withdrawn and is now confined to those living a certain distance from the factory. The Minister should point out to those concerned with the company that the farmers affected are those who helped to build up the industry. Now that it is a flourishing industry, they are being denied the subsidy. I hope the Taoiseach will make representations to the Minister for Agriculture in this regard.
Barley growers are not getting a just price for malting barley. The barley and wheat growers in my area are being badly treated. I have a newspaper cutting here which tells me that one barrel of barley will make eight proof gallons of whiskey. The excise duty on that is £70. A fair average crop of barley is 16 barrels per acre. Therefore, the Government get £1,054 per acre for barley. Admittedly, a small increase in the barely price was given. But take the price of barely 10 or 12 years ago and compare it with the price of intoxicating liquor at that time. Take the case of the pint of stout. I sold barley at £4 per barrel at a time when the print of stout was 10d. Now I sell barley at 37/- a barrel and the price of stout in Dublin is 1/6d. and down the country 1/4d. or 1/3d. Who gets the difference? I agree that barely made £4 4s. 0d. per barrel in one particular year but, in the years following, those manufacturing stout paid the same dividends. This year, we got, at a rough estimate, 37/- per barrel, and the firms concerned paid 33? per cent. dividend at the expenses of the small tillage farmers.
For the past couple of months, Questions have been put down by other members of the House with regard to the importation of oats. I want it to go on the records of the House that I agree 100 per cent. with the Minister for Agriculture in refusing to allow the importation of feeding oats. I can understand that, possibly, the Minister will have to allow the importation of oats for seed purposes. There is a section of people in this country, whom, I am proud to say, I do not represent, who, when buying, whether oats for horses of food for themselves, do not buy one iota of Irish manufacture.
We have reached a poor stage in this House when there is a demand from this or the other side of the House for the importation of farm oats to feed Irish racehorses. Why Irish oats are not considered good enough is hard for me at least to understand, when we consider our Irish land, our Irish limestone, our good soil, good grass and good hay. We have been able to build up Irish horses to that point of perfection where they are taking prizes all over the world and people pay £10,000, £20,000 or £30,000 for horses reared on Irish Limestone grass of hay.
I was speaking to a trainer not so long ago and he told me that he put all his horses through the Curragh racing stables on Irish oats and would not use important oats. The Minister will want to stand firm or he will be "shot down" by people who will say the Irish farmer is not growing the amount of oats he used to grow some years ago. I do not blame the Irish farmer. He was growing oats for a long number of years and could get no one to buy his crop, with the result that today many have gone out of the production of oats.
I will be fair to the Minister. It is quite possible that pressure will be put on him to remove the embargo on the importation of foreign oats. I will also say that he will be fair and straight about it. If he could get from these people who are pressing him to remove that embargo, a guarantee to a certain group of Irish farmers that if they grow a substantial amount of good oats—and there is a big difference in the growing of oats between good, bad and indifferent—they will get a guaranteed price. If that were done, the Minister could say to those people: "Yes, gentlemen, we will have Irish oats suitable for feeding Irish horses."
I thoroughly agree with the Minister on the stand he has taken on the question of the importation of foreign oats. My only request to the Minister is that he will take the same stand with regard to the price of malting barley, leaving wheat out of it completely, and that he will take the same stand with regard to the areas with which the Sugar Company are concerned.
The people who live far away from Thurles, Mallow or Tuam will not have the haulage of their beet subsidised by the Sugar Company. It seems that there is a small group in the Thurles area who never grew beet before and are now growing it on a large scale. We are the people who helped in a small way to build up that factory and we are being cut away completely from it. I want to point out that beet plays a large part in our agricultural drive. Lest some paper might say I criticised the factories in am, Mallow, Thurles or Carlow for criticism's sake, I want to pay tribute to those factories. Beet is one of our main industries in North Tipperary.
We have been in a bad way in North Tipperary for the past three or four years in regard to river drainage. In the Cloughjordan, Lorrha and Carrigahorig areas, we had to seek the help of the Minister concerned with drainage. In my time, Governments have changed. One went out and another replaced it. When the Government which replaced the previous Government came into office, they completely cut off the Toney county councils used to get for river drainage.
Comment on this
I understand the Taoiseach gets in at 4 o'clock. I should like Deputy Tierney, to give some little time to others. I am sorry to have to say it but. I do so because of the position.
Comment on this
I want 10 minutes if I can get it. I want to tell the Taoiseach about the unemployed in Dublin. Independents spoke once today. There are nine of us.
Comment on this
I may give someone 10 minutes. So long as I am relevant, I may continue to speak even until 4 o'clock. Therefore, you will have to take me easy.
Comment on this
Deputy W. Murphy is under a wrong impression. We are not on roads at all. I am dealing with rivers.
Comment on this
Deputy W. Murphy is only wasting time when he interrupts him. Let him continue.
Comment on this
I was pointing out the position that existed when the previous Government went out and this Government came in. At that time, a small amount of money was spent on the Carrigahorig River in North Tipperary. I think the then Minister made it clear that if any county council in Ireland spent any portion of money on a river or group of rivers and wanted to continue with the work, he would sanction the amount of money they wanted to spend. The Carrigahorig River is flanked by, roughly, 5,000, 6,000, or 7,000 acres of good fertile land which our old people can remember was used extensively for tillage. Today, one would need hip boots to walk that land; top boots would not do. Our council have spent a certain amount of money. We employed our engineers to make a survey and we employed other people to take the levels.
The Minister has refused to allow our council to spend any money on the drainage of the Carrigahorig River. I want him to realise the injustice to the people in that area. It affects farmers as far north almost as Portumna in County Galway whose land is now flooded year after year, due to neglect. Possibly a lot of the blame can be laid on the farmers concerned and a lot of it on the council concerned, inasmuch as we promised that we would get the work done and assumed we would be enabled to get it done. Just as we were about to get the work done, the Act was put into abeyance. I believe I could perhaps finish now.
Comment on this
It is only a few years since I was elected to this House. The picture of those elected before me has been one of Deputies fighting and arguing on behalf of the poorer sections of our people. I must do my share and the prospect is that those who come after me will have to continue with the work. I must admit that there has been a small improvement in the case of old age pensioners. Some people boast that our old age pensioners are now drawing 28/6d. a week. I assume that the majority of them will draw more than that when the new Bill is eracted.
Comment on this
I was shocked at something in this House yesterday. A Deputy asked a question of the Minister for Justice about the amount of money a Garda was getting for minding a dog and what it was costing to feed the dog per week. The Minister replied that the Garda was receiving 15/- per week for leading out the dog and that it was costing £1 per week to feed it. I trust that none of the old people will think I am comparing them with the dog. However, can anybody explain how we can feed an old man or an old woman on 28/6d. a week when, on the Minister's admission, it costs £1 a week to feed a dog? Is that not a good case for a vast increase for our old age pensioners?
Comment on this
We should be satisfied with 37/- if we could get anyone to buy them. Does Deputy O'Malley know of anybody?
Comment on this
With the increased money which I assume the Government will receive as a result of the introduction of the P.A.Y.E. system— because a vast number of people will now pay income tax who have not hitherto done so, some of them very unjustly—I trust they will see their way to meet some of the points I have raised. Having regard to the vast amount of money at the disposal of the Government, I assume that, in their generosity, they will give credit to the people on whose behalf I speak this evening.
Comment on this
I will have to abbreviate what I wanted to say but had I the opportunity, I could speak for at least half an hour. I represent a Dublin constituency. There are quite a large number of unemployed in Dublin city —approximately 15,000. There would be a much greater number unemployed but that the Minister for Social Welfare and his assistance adopt a sort of Gestapo practice of disallowing unemployment assistance on the ground that they are not genuinely seeking employment. As everyone knows, there is no employment for manual workers in Dublin city. There may be work for some technicians, tradesmen or girls, but, for manual workers, there is no employment.
About a year or so ago, I asked the Taoiseach what schemes he had in mind for such workers and he gave me a rigmarole about schemes of economic merit and suggested that we should pile up the proposals. He then went on to say that something big was to turn up at the North Wall which would absorb a lot of manual workers. I have heard nothing about that since.
I want to protest against the practice of the Department of Social Welfare in disallowing unemployment assistance on the ground that they are not genuinely seeking employment. I am sure that most of the people who are unemployed are "browned off" going round getting "No" for an answer. I think it should suffice that they sign and accept work from the labour exchange when it is offered. If they refuse to take work, then there are some grounds for saying they did not want it and for the Department refusing to allow any assistance. Most people who want workers now seek them from the labour exchange. You cannot go direct to the Corporation for a job. The workers are sent from the labour exchange but to tell people that because they are not genuinely looking for what does not exist, labouring work, and that they are not entitled to any money, is a shame.
That is one of the ways the Government have of telling us of the limited number, whatever it may be, drawing assistance and officially passed as unemployed. There are actually thousands who have been disallowed assistance in one way or another. For instance, if they are earning a little by selling newspapers, they are disallowed. They may not sign up any more, although it is only a hand to mouth affair.
Apart from that, the Taoiseach now tells us that there is a need for only 50,000 more jobs. That is, of course, because they have all gone away. They are not going to stay here to have the Gestapo down on them by the Department of Social Welfare. They are not going to stay here for this miserable amount of assistance. I think it a shame that those people should be driven to England because a large number of our people in England are actually living a life of misery. It must be remembered that the wages there are not much better than what we pay here. The sum of £9 per week is approximately a worker's wage. Unless a worker labours on the weekends and does overtime, he would not be able to live at all.
What is the position of the fathers of families who are compelled to go to England to work? They work until 8 and 9 o'clock at night. They go from bed to work. They might have a few beers on a Friday. I was in England for a fortnight during the summer. It was not enough but I went among the people. I did bed and breakfast in about half a dozen little satellite towns around London. I visited working class people in Camden Town and Hammersmith. I visited their homes because I had a long list of people I knew formerly. I went into the pubs. with them, although I do not drink. Unlike those people who go to a hotel and act the T.D., I acted the plain guy I am.
Comment on this
Not on holidays. What I want to impress on the House is that those people go from bed to work. They have only a few beers on a Friday. It is a terrible thing to see married people driven to that kind of existence. Then, of course, there are the temptations as a result of being away from home. The House knows what I mean. I think it is disgraceful that married men have to emigrate. I know the way they live. They eke out a miserable existence. They live on £3 per week. The Taoiseach may flatter himself that there are only 50,000 more jobs required. If everyone were to do as the Taoiseach does, they could brag, too.
These workers have responsibilities. They have to maintain their families. The crowd at the top say that things are rosy. We have created an artificial prosperity in circumstances where the population is smaller and where a large number of our people are forced to live in England. We are told by the Minister for Transport and Power that the people here are doing all right but how are they living? There are 4,500 people who are unable to pay their rent every year.
Most of the people here are living from hand to mouth. They buy things on the H.P. and from the point of view of food values they are no better off now than their forbears were who ate potatoes and salt. It is disgraceful that people should be permitted to buy on H.P. It means that people are handing out more than half their income on purchasing junk goods. A great deal of it is produced for home consumption. Before the stuff is half paid for, they have to buy again. If the goods were not junk, the people would not be so much involved.
I would ask the Taoiseach to do something about the junk toys and goods coming into the country from outside. Kids are being robbed. They have to pay 1/- for a small toy which is a big amount to them. If you blew on one of these alleged gelatine toys, you would dinge it. I would ask the Taoiseach to do something about all these junk toys.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Government about the setting up of so many State boards and denying members the right to ask questions about these boards. I do not object to statutory bodies; they may mean efficiency and I am all for efficiency but I hold that we should have the right to question them because injustices are being done by some statutory bodies. I quoted one case of an old age pensioner who used 9d. worth of electricity and had to pay 13/9d. for a meter fee. I argued that with the Minister for Transport and Power and he tried to palm me off by saying that they were to put in saving boxes. What are the savings boxes for? To save 13/9 meter fee? That is not an answer and, for the Minister's information, the E.S.B. has decided not to go ahead with the savings box idea. A sum of 13/9d. is charged for a meter and 9d. for electricity but we are not supposed to ask questions. I have no objection to efficiency but we should have the right to ask questions.
Comment on this
Christmas comes but once a year but when it comes it brings Deputy Dillon's annual outpouring of gloom and depression. I gather that his view is that the country is in such a deplorable condition that it could be said to be a broken-down horse.
Comment on this
The Deputy stressed his pessimistic views very strongly to-day. He believes the country is like a broken-down horse and there is nothing left to do with it except to hand it over to be killed off inhumanely, by putting in another Fine Gael Government. What a depressing Christmas message to the Irish people! I am not going to suggest that the picture of the national situation is all in bright colours but certainly it is not composed of all the blacks and greys with which Deputy Dillon painted it.
I am going to indicate to the House —and I hope to send members away to their Christmas festivities encouraged—some of the bright patches here and there, in a picture which is not inconsiderably brighter as compared with this time last year. I hope Deputies opposite like to get good news, because I am going to give them some whether they like it or not. In this year, 1960, the indications are that the national income will be £20 million higher than last year, that is an increase of four per cent. In other words, the country in this year will have achieved an increase in the national income as compared with last year at double the rate we attempted to forecast as being possible when we prepared the Programme for Economic Expansion. If we can keep that up, and I see no reason why we should not, we shall reduce by one-half the time required to double the national income, which was the objective aimed at when the programme was being framed.
The value of the country's production, the total output of wealth by effort expended in agriculture and industry, this year is also likely to show an increase of four per cent. and to be the highest ever recorded in the history of Ireland. Deputies need not start cheering yet; there is better news than that. Last year Deputy Dillon was very depressed about the prospect of a deficit emerging from the country's international payments and he spent a long time in his pre-Christmas speech expressing his deep anxiety about the country's future because of that anticipated deficit. He will be glad to know—or will he?—that this year all indications are that the country's international payments will be well and truly balanced with the possibility of a small surplus. The deficit on visible trade is this year running at about £9 million below last year and all the indications are that a surplus will emerge on the invisible items. That balance on international payments was achieved notwithstanding the fact that there was a slight but inevitable increase in imports due mainly to increased purchases of materials for industry which are both evidence and a consequence of our country's industrial expansion.
The exports of Irish products in this year have reached the highest total ever recorded. They were no less than 17 per cent. in value above those of last year. What are the Deputies opposite looking so gloomy about? This is good news. Exports in this year to the 12 months ended November last are no less than £20 million in value over the highest ever previously recorded which was in 1958.
Comment on this
I shall deal with that. The outstanding features are the rise in the shipment abroad of manufactured products and also increased exports of live cattle. Exports are running at no less than 33? per cent. —one third—above the average level achieved in the three years, 1954 to 1956. The volume of industrial production and the number of workers employed in manufacturing industry are also the highest ever recorded in this country. Will some Deputy opposite even smile?
Comment on this
We have not yet got statistics for the total agricultural output in 1960. I anticipate that some increase will be shown. It is true that national production and income figures for agriculture can be misleading in many ways. Agricultural incomes could be rising in Wexford and falling in Donegal. Agricultural conditions could be better in the milk-producing counties than in the store cattle counties and these are factors which we must take into account when determining agricultural policy. We realise very well that conditions in recent years have particularly affected small farmers in the western areas dependent on store cattle and sheep and that their position requires consideration by the Government. We are fully aware of that problem and we are giving constant attention to ways and means of helping those affected by it. My expectations that the overall figures for agricultural output this year will show an increase over last year are based on these facts.
We know that milk output is up very considerably and that farmers are now receiving a higher price for milk delivered to creameries than they obtained last year. We know that the number of cattle, sheep and pigs was found to be higher at the June enumeration than last year. Cattle exports have increased by 35,000 head and the value of these exports increased by £2,500,000, while at the same time the value of our processed meat exports increased by £2 million, an increase of £4½ million in that sector.
The acreage under tillage increased by 15,000 acres, but we are all aware that harvest conditions prevented that increased acreage being expressed in higher yields. A further significant fact is that the number of agricultural tractors in use on the farms this year rose by nine per cent. over last year, from 39,300 to 42,900.
There are other favourable figures which Deputies may be pleased to hear. There is first of all the very significant jump in electricity consumption; the significant recovery to which Deputy Corish referred of activities in the building and construction trades and there is—and I would personally attach considerable importance to this —the absorption of a general wage increase with much less effect upon the overall price level than might reasonably have been expected. We know that these facts do not tell the whole story. There are other features of the national situation which are not so cheerful, but no account of the national circumstances is accurate which does not give full weight to them. Deputy Corish in his reasonable speech attempted to do that but Deputy Dillon just ignored them.
Comment on this
The Government, like Deputies who have spoken here, constantly have in mind the position in regard to unemployment and emigration.
I have never in the past declined to accept that developments in regard to these two national problems can be taken as indicative of the success of the policy of the Government. I do not deny that it took longer than we hoped to arrest the downward movement in the national economy which began in the final year of the previous Government. That was not checked until 1958. The year 1957 was the year in which we regarded ourselves as fighting a rearguard action against that inherited slump; 1958 was the year in which we were planning for recovery, the year in which the decline in the national economy was stopped with the first signs of recovery towards its end; 1959 was the year in which national recovery began. The upsurge was not sufficient to be really noticeable until about the middle of last year.
Employment, calculated on the average weekly number of people in employment, is now increasing at the rate of 9,000 a year.
Comment on this
In this year, employment has on an average for each week been 18,000 higher than 1958 and 9,000 higher than in 1959. While that is satisfactory enough, this country needs to at least double that rate of expansion to wipe out the backlog of unemployment and remove the economic cause of continuing emigration.
That is the result which the Government are trying to bring about.
Deputy Corish spoke about the unsatisfactory situation that there is for a worker when his tenure of employment is uncertain, when he has not got continuous employment week in and week out throughout the year. As the Minister for Transport and Power indicated, all the evidence from the available statistics is that the higher employment levels now achieved represent in the main the taking up of the slack in our employment situation, longer spells of employment, with fewer breaks for the existing labour force. A better ratio has been established between the weekly average of persons at work and the total number of insured workers.
That is one explanation of the fact that the percentage increase in output in manufacturing industry is so much greater than the increase in the total number employed. I think it is reasonable now to expect that that position will tend to change and that henceforth an expansion of production will be reflected more directly in higher employment.
Comment on this
That does not explain the situation in the rural areas to which I specifically referred.
Comment on this
I appreciate that but I am speaking only in general terms now and not with reference to particular sections. One other fact is that approximately half the increase in employment is attributable to manufacturing industry and about half to other circumstances. It is interesting to note that our experience in that regard supports a theory which I put forward in a speech in 1955, which many Deputies opposite have since misquoted but which very few seem ever to have read.
Deputy Dillon suggested that that speech, made in 1955, two years before the general election took place and four years before it was expected to take place, was intended to be an election manifesto or programme published on the occasion of the election and designed to mislead the electorate. That is a complete falsehood. The proposals I then put forward were clearly described by me as presented for comment and criticism and not as a final programme and I invited co-operation from all sections in completing them. Deputy Dillon also ignored the fact that in the following year, again three years before the election was expected, I made another speech to the same audience and which was publicised in the same way in which I said that the rapid and extensive deterioration of conditions since 1955 had rendered out of date some of the plans which were publicised then.
I therefore refute the suggestion he made that anybody could have been misled or that these speeches did any more at the time they were made than to convey to the public that Fianna Fáil were making full employment the objective of their economic policy and were trying to work out ways and means of bringing it about.
I think it would be useful now, briefly to carry out, in relation to the circumstances of to-day, the type of calculation I attempted then. Full employment is the objective of the Government's economic policy.
Comment on this
It seems clear from the examination of date now available that the number of new jobs necessary to bring about full employment should be greatly reduced from the figure I put forward in 1955. First of all, we must get a definition of full employment. Sir William Beveridge in his book "Full Employment in a Free Society" described full employment as a condition in which no more than three per cent. of the wage-earning labour force was unemployed on the average over the year. On December 10, the latest date for which figures are available, the number of persons with unemployment insurance benefit claims current plus the number of persons without means with unemployment assistance claims current was 34,000 5.7 per cent. of the insured labour force. The average for the full year, as Deputies should appreciate, would be less than that.
It seems that if we could create about 20,000 new jobs to cover the residue of the unemployment situation carried over from the past and so develop the national economy that it would expand at a rate which would create 15,000 or 16,000 new jobs per year, we would have a situation that could be fairly described as full employment and one which would mean the end of emigration due to non-availability of employment. Deputy Corish rightly pointed out that the situation is not, and could not be, as clear-cut as that. With employment here increasing at that rate, or any rate, some numbers of Irish workers will be attracted home from England and some number of farmers and their sons will offer themselves as wage earners. There is always a question whether the employment register provides an accurate picture of the extent of our unemployment problem. Everybody knows that young people after they leave school do not normally come on to the unemployment register until they have had one spell of employment and to that extent the register may underestimate our problem.
On the other hand, there is this remarkable fact which I will mention and from which Deputies can make their own deduction: on the date of the census of 1951 the number of people in the country who described themselves as being on that date "farm workers unemployed" was less than one—third of the number who on that date were receiving unemployment assistance as unemployed farm workers.
It is against that background of information, that analysis of the dimensations of the unemployment problem of this country, that I ask the Dáil to consider the calculation that I have made that the country must double its present rate of expansions to solve its unemployment and emigration problems completely. I think we can do it. I do not say that it can be done next month or even next year, but I contend that it is not beyond the capacity of the country to achieve that result.
The argument that I was trying to establish in 1955 was that, big as the unemployment problem appeared to be then, the resources of the county were sufficient, if properly utilised, to bring about a full employment situation in time.
Between 1956, when the previous Government was in office, and this year, we have changed from a situation in which employment fell by 20,000 on weekly average to one in which employment is increasing by 9,000 on weekly average in each year.
Comment on this
The reason for that was the action of the Minister for Social Welfare in bringing in more people.
Comment on this
That is not the entire explanation. The point I am making is that, although it is not nearly enough, what has been that a is an encouragement to believe that a higher expansion rate is realisable.
I want to put these propositions to the Dáil: If the present rate of expansion of output in manufacturing industry can be maintained and if employment in manufacturing industry can henceforth be expected to increase in closer relationship with the rate of increase of output and if it continues to be correct that employment in other sectors will expand at about the same rate as employment in manufacturing industry, we will be very near realising that target of full employment in a very few years. Those are three "ifs," but I suggest to the Dáil that they do not altogether represent unrealistic assumptions.
In next year, the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells me, 70 new industrial concerns will come into production. These are projects promoted by private enterprise, the plans for which have been completed and all the necessary facilities and grants arranged. That represents two new factories every fortnight on the average over the year and the employment potential of these industries will rise to 7,000, an average of 100 for each factory.
If we assume that there will be also next year a continuing growth of employment amongst existing industrial concerns, then, on the basis of the other assumptions which I have mentioned, we could be coming to within sight of our target.
Deputies have discussed here the problem of emigration. As we know, and as I think I have made very clear, this is not a problem that the Government is anxious to conceal. We want to get it out in the open so that people can take a long, careful and objective look at it and all the factors that are operating to sustain it. We have no completely reliable statistics about the volume of emigration. There are 10,000,000 journeys in or out of this country every year and, in the circumstances, Deputies will understand that the Statistics Office is reluctant to commit itself to any final figures regarding the volume of emigration when it is clear that a one per cent. error in calculating the number of the journeys in or out would bring about a more than 100 per cent. error in the residual figure representing the net balance of passenger movement outward. The only information we have regarding the volume of emigration comes from these figures, that is, the net outward balance of movements by people by sea or by air. The number of journeys by sea or by air represents only about one-half of the journeys in or out of the State, the other one-half being across the Border.
These figures such as they are suggest that in the 12 months ended 30th September of this year, emigration was less than in any year since 1954 except the year 1959. It is still very much too heavy. I do not want to appear to be complacent because the level of emigration which is shown by these calculations seems to be somewhat lower than it was some years earlier. Indeed, I have prefaced my remarks by pointing at once to the unreliability of the statistics available to us but I put them forward to refute the suggestions which underlay the speeches of Deputy Dillon and some other Deputies that this is a phenomenon which has grown up and developed now or has become more serious now than it was previously.
Deputy Dillon was very unwise to make his suggestion that the reduced number of registered unemployed is attributable solely to the higher rate of emigration. He should have thought, if he gave it thought at all, that that would immediately invite comparison with 1956, in which the number of people returned as having emigrated was 11 per cent. higher than in this year but the number of registered unemployed was nearly double.
Comment on this
I am not prepared to commit myself to a figure because it is quite obvious that no figure that I could give would be one that the Statistics Office would be prepared to stand over. I will concede at once that the level is far too high, that the figure has remained at far too high a level since the end of the War. I contest the argument that it is heavier now than it was in 1956 or 1955. The available information, such as it is, suggests otherwise.
Comment on this
Those are the figures for the number of persons who registered for employment for the first time in Great Britain, published yesterday.
Comment on this
I suggest that the non-availability of employment, while it is certainly the most important cause of emigration, is only one cause. Deputy Corish mentioned cases where to his knowledge workers, because of dissatisfaction with their conditions of employment or other reasons, left a job to emigrate. There is not a Deputy who does not know of people who have left employment in this country for the purpose of emigrating. My personal post contains letters every week from former employees of the E.S.B. or C.I.E. who quit their employment here and went to England and want to come back and get their old employment restored to them.
We all know that there are other factors operating than the non-availability of employment, important though that is and, as I have said, probably the most important factor. The social, psychological and other factors which are clearly there require to be brought out and studied.
Emigration has been a feature of Irish life for over 200 years. The idea that it is something that started, say, with the Famine and continued only because of the conditions resulting from the Famine is disputed by the Commission on Emigration which the Coalition Government in 1948 set up, which showed that even before the Famine emigration averaged some 27,000 a year. It is clear that a situation which has continued for such a long period must have its effect upon the outlook of the people as a whole and have created amongst them a feeling of inevitability which has to be eradicated, not merely by the development of economic policy but also by an educational process which can perhaps be best undertaken by people who are not directly associated with Government at all. In so far as the availability of employment is concerned I am prepared to agree that that is a sphere in which Government policy predominates. Through the expansion of industry, through the development of our fisheries, forestry and tourism——
Comment on this
——we can hope to bring about a situation in which that cause will be removed simultaneously with measures which will increase the productivity of agriculture, which will create the possibility of bringing livelihoods earned in farming sufficiently close to urban standards, together with the other attractions of farming life, to stop the movement of people out of agriculture.
I have said previously that, in my view, agriculture is in a period of transition. I do not want to develop that point now but it may be that many people occupied in agriculture have not yet understood that important changes are taking place.
Comment on this
A higher farm income must mean increasing the output per farm acre. How that is to be done is the key question of agricultural policy. It may be that the increased use of lime and fertilisers is the answer. Certainly the policy of the Government is based upon the belief that it is a large part of the answer. It is for that reason we have been increasing very generously the subsidies designed to reduce the price of fertilisers to farmers and to bring about an expansion of their use. It may be that changing the pattern of agricultural production is another part of the answer.
Store cattle are our main agricultural product and, as Deputy Blowick said, it is the product which is of vital significance to the small farmers in the West of Ireland who, notwithstanding the dimensions of their holdings, are endeavouring to procure a livelihood by a pastoral type of farming to which those holdings are not altogether suited. What are the prospects regarding the store cattle trade? It is difficult to be dogmatic in this regard, but all the indications are that the prospects are good. In so far as the world situation is concerned, a deficiency in beef production is likely to persist for some years. In regard to Britain, we see that the average per capita consumption of beef per year is still 10 lbs. below the pre-war level, but that it is coming up to the pre-war level. It is expected that within the next year it will come closer to it than is was previously and consequently a steady demand for store cattle by British farmers is to be expected.
This would not be the occasion for a detailed discussion upon agricultural policy, but certainly Deputy Blowick, when speaking here today, did not seem to know what is happening when he talked about the Government coming in to help farmers with their marketing problem. Does he not realise the Dáil spent the whole day yesterday discussing proposals for the improvement of marketing arrangements for milk products based upon the recommendations of the Marketing Committee we set up? He has been told that proposals for new marketing arrangements in relation to pigs and bacon will come before the House in the next session again based upon proposals of that Committee, modified as they have been to some extent by subsequent discussion with the parties directly concerned.
Comment on this
In so far as there is a problem in marketing—nobody denies there is—what the Government did was to call in the representatives of several sections of agriculture, put them on this committee, and say to them: "try to solve this problem and we will act upon your recommendations unless it seems to us there is a good reason which we can publicly defend for not doing to," and only in one important respect did we find ourselves unable to accept their recommendations. The decisions which were taken by the Government upon the report of that committee were published to the Dáil and to the country in a White Paper which Deputy Blowick does not appear to have read.
Comment on this
The pillars on which all forms of production rest are three: availability of markets, availability of capital, and technical competence in efficient methods of production. As far as marketing is concerned, we took the course which I have described. I am not going to suggest that there is action open to us which can solve the current international problems in respect of agricultural products. Everybody knows that great industrial States are, for political and other reasons, subsidising their agriculture to an extent that countries like this could not attempt and that, as a result of these subsidisation arrangements and the restrictions on trade to which they give rise, agricultural products are passing in international commerce at prices which are well below their economic cost of production.
I believe the world must come back to sanity in that regard soon and indeed all the efforts of Irish Ministers at international conferences where trade matters are discussed are directed towards bringing world attention to that problem and having some remedial action taken in regard to it. That was done only this week by the Minister for Industry and Commerce at the conference in Paris which set up the new Organisation for Economic Development in Europe.
In regard to capital, I think it is true to say that Irish farmers never had access to so much capital and credit as they have at the present time because of the changed policies of the banks in that regard. To the extent that they have not got it, we have introduced here this week a Bill which will be designed considerably to extend the resources and the powers of the Agricultural Credit Corporation to make good any deficiency in existing facilities in so far as we can.
Irish farmers are, in the main, highly competent but they require information and advice regarding new processes, new seeds, new fertilisers, new methods of production which are becoming available to them. It is the aim of the Government, through the organisations which have been set up for that purpose, to extend the advisory services available to farmers. We recognise that at the present time there are practical problems arising mainly out of the availability of the personnel trained and competent to give that advice——
Comment on this
——which prevent our extending the services as rapidly as we would like. I think no Deputy who has heard me will accuse me of exaggerating the magnitude of our achievement in the economic field. I assert that achievement there has been. We recognise that we have not done much more yet than made a good beginning. I do say, however, that we have made a good beginning and it is now clear that the lines of policy on which we have decided and along which we are now proceeding are capable of bringing about the improvement in the national economy that we desire. In so far as changing circumstances may necessitate a modification of any of these policies, we are prepared to make these modifications, but the basic soundness of the policies we are following has been demonstrated by the results achieved to date.
In view of the highly—political note that has been introduced into this debate, I cannot conclude without contrasting the situation as it now exists with that which existed in 1956.
Whether this is our last year of office or not, I do not know yet. The election is not due to be held until 20th April, 1962.
Comment on this
Need I assure Deputies opposite that it will be my natural anxiety to make sure that the date will be the one most advantageous to them?
Comment on this
Contrasting the situation that exists now with that in 1956, we find that in 1956 the national income fell. It was the one year since the war in which the national income showed a decline, notwithstanding the inflationary pressures then in operation. In that year, total national production fell. It was the one year since the war in which total production fell substantially and in which the drastic decline in employment then recorded was experienced by the country. In that year not merely were income and production and employment falling, but there was throughout the whole country an atmosphere of despair and despondency.
Comment on this
One thing that every objective commentator on Irish conditions is saying now is that despondency is gone, and confidence restored and that the people believe our rate of progress is evidence of our capacity to go ahead and that lines of policy have been settled which will ensure that the rate will be accelerated.
May I say that it is quite obvious in any further development of national thinking on this matter people are going to get very little assistance from Deputy Dillon, judging by his speech here to-day? There was an indication of a very rational approach in the speech of Deputy Corish. I would advise Deputy Dillon to study Deputy Corish's speech and learn how a Party Leader should behave.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Taoiseach if his attention has been directed to the figures published by the British Board of Trade?
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?