C.I.E. Report and Accounts, 1959-60: Motion.
Contributions 130–282 of 282. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We know the Deputy is trying to filibuster this debate because he does not want the Deputies to speak on it.
Comment on this
There is no question of that. I have not been speaking half as long as either Deputy McGilligan or Deputy Michael Murphy.
Comment on this
No, Sir. Before Deputy Dillon graced us with his presence I reminded the House it was the Coalition Government in 1956 who set up the Commission——
Comment on this
One point to which I did not refer was that raised by Deputy Michael Murphy, as to what the charges for road transport would be as against the rail charges. A short time ago the Board of C.I.E. announced reductions in the weekly charges for provincial buses, bringing these in line with rail charges and in certain circumstances very much under the rail charges. I had intended to refer to certain other matters dealt with by Deputy M.P. Murphy, but perhaps I have said enough.
Comment on this
I regret very much the attitude taken up by Deputy O'Malley. While he seemed to throw the onus for making this a political issue on Fine Gael it is extraordinary that no member even mentioned politics until he stood up. I was glad when the Taoiseach came in because he seemed to have a curbing effect on Deputy O'Malley who was not so free with the balderdash afterwards. The Taoiseach is a sensible man, a business man, who knows very well that the sort of speech made by Deputy O'Malley is no help to him or to his Party or to the House.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley even tackled me on what he thought I would say although I had not opened my mouth until now. He said my speech would naturally be reported in the Clare Champion; possibly it will, and Deputy O'Malley should know by now that I shall come back here after the next election without any trouble.
Comment on this
I feel that speaking about the West Clare line now is more or less a matter of discussing what should have been done by way of closing the stable door before the horse was stolen. It is a pity that representatives of the House and of the people concerned did not have the opportunity that is afforded here today of putting their views forward. If they had there might not have been— indeed, there would not have been—as much dissatisfaction as there is at present in the areas concerned because of the closing of that line. Undoubtedly, there is a lot of truth in the statement—I have proof of it—that the representatives of the people, or the public bodies, in Clare at any rate, were not allowed an interview by the Board of C.I.E. The answer given was that the C.I.E. Board would see a deputation but only on the question of roads and there would be no mention of retaining the line. That was hard on the people of Clare because there is a history and tradition attached to that line and even though the line has gone I believe that tradition will live on.
The people are very disappointed because if C.I.E. are making the profits they claim and reducing their debts, as stated here to-day, the £10,000 gained by closing the West Clare railway would not mean much. It is also hard on the people of Clare to have to continue to pay their contribution towards the subsidy of £1,000,000 to keep other railways open while their own line is closed. Further, it is very hard for the overburdened rate-paying community of Clare—and overburdened it is at present—to be asked to make and maintain the roads of Clare for the extra traffic now being put on them. There is no doubt that it will mean extra cost because when asked for an estimate the county engineer, I think, spoke about £200,000 or £300,000. He also made it perfectly clear to C.I.E. that the road from Ennis to Ennistymon was a death-trap. There are 48 bends on that road, one more dangerous than another. Already, even before the extra traffic, there are four crosses on the road marking places where fatal accidents occurred. Every day we see appeals for safety on the roads, but how can that be achieved now? On one Sunday alone 1,900 cars passed along the road from Ennis to Lahinch. From that, one can judge what conditions will be like with the extra traffic.
I am expressing what I believe the people feel in West Clare. We shall still have to pay our contribution towards the £1,000,000 subsidy and we believe that it would be only just and fair that the West Clare line should be allowed to remain until the end of the term—that is two years more. If by then the line was not showing a profit or was not being run as well as any other line in the State, by all means close it down. I could guarantee no voice or finger would be raised against it. But, I suppose as I said already, it is a case of talking about locking the stable door when the horse is gone.
Comment on this
I shall intervene briefly. I can assure Deputies that I shall not encroach unduly on the time available to them, but I think it is desirable to try to get this discussion back to some realistic basis. The Government decided to give the Dáil an opportunity of discussing on this motion the policy and administration of C.I.E. in a comprehensive way. We had hoped that the Dáil would welcome and avail of that opportunity. The amendment which was moved, however, by the Fine Gael Party and the speech delivered in support of that amendment by Deputy McGilligan seemed to me to make it clear that, so far as they were concerned, they have decided to decline that opportunity. Instead of getting a constructive debate on transport policy, we have had what I can only describe as a nagging amendment supported by a nagging speech on a matter of a comparatively trivial nature.
Comment on this
I think I am entitled to assume from the terms of the trivial amendment moved by the Fine Gael Party, and the speech delivered in support of it by Deputy McGilligan, that, in fact, the Fine Gael Party, the principal Opposition Party in the House, have no serious complaint to make about transport policy as it is now being administered and have, indeed, no objection to the closing of branch lines so long as local politicians are given adequate opportunity of blowing off steam on deputations to the C.I.E. Board.
Comment on this
Allow me to say that I am prepared to defend to the utmost the right of any politician to blow off steam.
Comment on this
I do not want to force the Fine Gael Party into some policy announcement based upon irritation, but am I entitled to assume from the amendment they have proposed that the only point of complaint they have to make regarding the administration of C.I.E. is the failure of the Board to receive a deputation from local politicians before closing a branch line?
Comment on this
At any rate, so far as the record will show, there will be nothing to indicate that the Fine Gael Party has any policy regarding the closing of branch lines other than that which the C.I.E. Board are now implementing.
Comment on this
If there were a policy to be advocated by that Party surely it would have been the subject of their amendment. On the question of whether or not the Board should have received a deputation, while that may be the subject of some local irritation, it is surely of very minor significance in relation to the broad issues of transport policy embodied in the Act of 1958 and the manner in which the C.I.E. Board are now administering that policy.
Comment on this
I am not aware that the Board refused to receive a deputation. In fact, I know the Board did not refuse provided they were confined to discussing——
Comment on this
Provided they did not discuss their methods in relation to the closing of the railways.
Comment on this
——the practical and important issue of the future transport arrangements in these areas.
Comment on this
Let me put this question to the Deputies opposite: if the Board had met the deputation, as they might well have done, and if they had given these local political representatives——
Comment on this
——an opportunity of making in public the protests which they felt they wanted to make on behalf of their constituents, an opportunity of going through this exercise of blowing off steam, would that have ended the agitation about the closing of these branch lines?
Comment on this
Do not all of us know that this was just a peg on which all this agitation is being hung and, if that peg were not there, another would have been found.
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy should allow the Taoiseach to speak without interruption. He himself was allowed to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
Personally, I do not think there is the slightest obligation on me to defend the C.I.E. Board for not receiving a deputation without limitation as to the matters to be discussed. However, if they had received such a deputation, would that have been an end of the matter?
Comment on this
Of course, it would not have been an end of the matter because the important issue is not whether the Board were right in deciding to limit the deputations to discussing future transport arrangements in the areas, but the effect of their decision to close these lines on the economic development of the areas concerned.
Comment on this
Why did the Opposition not put that down in their amendment to this motion? Why did the Opposition spokesman not deal with that aspect of it?
Comment on this
The Opposition have that opportunity now. We put down the motion to give the Opposition that opportunity. But, instead of that, we get a niggling speech from the principal speaker for the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
So far as I am concerned, I would expect the Board to receive local deputations when they propose to close a branch line. The Board have agreed to receive deputations upon the important aspect of that question, and I left this House under no illusion whatsover as to what the policy of the Board would be. I said on 29th May, 1958——
Comment on this
Let me quote:
It is certainly contemplated that C.I.E. will in the future eliminate from the rail service any branch or stations which are uneconomic and where there is no prospect that they will become economic. When they have decided to close a branch line or station, the question of alternative transport facilities in that area arises.
Comment on this
Let me deal with this, as I regard it, important question as to whether the closing of the West Cork branch line is prejudicial to the economic development of the area; whether it is true, as Deputy Murphy suggested, that the railway is essential to the economic prospects of the area; or whether its economic development depends in the slightest degree on the preservation of the railway. Since the C.I.E. Board announced their intention to close the West Cork railway there have been three announcements of intention to establish important new industries in the West Cork area and, at the moment, there are proposals for four additional important industries in that area.
Comment on this
Does that not demonstrate beyond question that the existence of the railway is in no way essential to industrial expansion in West Cork and that its ending has not restricted industrial expansion there? It is not a coincidence that this industrial development of the West Cork area really began only after a decision to close the railway line was announced by the C.I.E. Board.
Comment on this
It is not quite the coincidence the Opposition want to represent. To my knowledge, it is true that in the past efforts to induce industrialists into that area were hampered because of an impression which industrialists had that, if they established industries in the area, they would be pressurised by the Government to use a form of transport there unsuitable to their business. The industrial development that is now taking place in West Cork is unprecedented in the history of that area. Is that not true?
Comment on this
Does that one fact not give the lie to the suggestion that the railway line is essential to the area in order to open up new industries there? Industry is now flowing into that area. One reason it is doing so is because there is now clearly complete freedom for those who engage in industry there to use whatever form of transport is best suited to the type of business they undertake.
Comment on this
Let us consider agriculture. I do not propose to go into details with regard to agricultural development possibilities in the West Cork area because at the moment a comprehensive survey is being carried out there by the Agricultural Institute and it is on the outcome of that survey that decisions will be taken as to the best development possibilities in West Cork so far as agriculture is concerned. It is a fact that there are six agricultural co-operative societies in West Cork. They are the biggest operators of road transport in the area.
Comment on this
Because I know them so much better than the Taoiseach does. I put the travelling creameries there.
Comment on this
It has been suggested that the economic development of the area depends on the existence of the railway. I have clearly shown that manufacturing industries have only begun to flow into that area since it was announced that the railway line would be closed. The announcement of the closing of the railway was followed by a number of new proposals for industry in that area.
Comment on this
So far as agriculture is concerned, the six agricultural societies have always relied upon road transport and have not used the C.I.E. system, either rail or road, and I shall give the Deputies some statistics.
Comment on this
What are the other economic possibilities of the West Cork area, apart from industry and agriculture? They are afforestation, fishery development and tourist development. They are the other main economic possibilities in that area. As far as afforestation is concerned, State afforestation activity in the area is expanding rapidly and 1,800 acres will be planted in West Cork this year. That is four times the acreage planted in 1956, the last year in which the Deputies opposite were in control of the Government.
Comment on this
Employment in afforestation in West Cork increased ten-fold in the past decade. It is now clear that forestry activity will become of major economic importance in that area. There is a great area of land there eminently suitable for afforestation purposes, more suitable for afforestation than for any other purpose. Land is being acquired as rapidly as possible by the Department of Lands for the purpose of a still further extension in afforestation activity there.
Comment on this
I shall confine myself to politicians and to anybody outside the House who wants to put himself in that category.
As far as fishery development is concerned, Deputies are aware that Castletownbere is to be developed as a major fishery harbour. That will take some years to complete.
Comment on this
The Board of Works in the matter of a few weeks will be inviting tenders for the initial boring operations which have to precede detailed planning.
Tourist activity in the West Cork area can expand enormously and will, I am convinced, expand out of all recognition to anything known previously as soon as the new Cork Airport, which the Government are providing, comes into operation. That is necessitating a very considerable extension of hotel accommodation there, and in order to facilitate tourist development very considerable activities in the improvement of the inland fisheries in the area are going on or are planned.
Looking at the whole picture, I think I can say without fear of contradiction by anybody who wants to base his statements on fact that the economic prospects of West Cork are brighter now than ever they were in its history. They are certainly far brighter now than they were before the decision to close the railway line was taken.
Comment on this
I think it is true to say—and I doubt very much if any Deputy, even Deputy Murphy, will have the hardihood to contradict me —that this agitation about the railway line is completely political in its origin.
Comment on this
Let me say this. Since the Board of C.I.E. announced their decision to close the railway line not one co-operative society, not one industrial undertaking, not one important merchant in the whole West Cork area has undertaken to give one ton of additional business to the C.I.E. concern if the railway line is kept open.
Comment on this
Let me give the Deputy some figures as to what extent this C.I.E. service is of importance to the co-operative societies, the industries and the merchants of West Cork. Of the total shipments of produce out of the West Cork area by the six co-operative societies operating there, three per cent. went by C.I.E. road or rail services.
Comment on this
Of the total outward shipments of the industrial concerns in the area, six per cent. were carried by C.I.E.; and of the total outward shipments of the 34 principal merchants in the whole area, only five per cent. went by the C.I.E. system. Is it not preposterous to suggest that these marginal activities by all the commercial and industrial undertakings in the area require the retention of an unprofitable railway system?
Comment on this
I shall, if the Deputy gives me time. I know that manufacturing and inventing grievances is a stock-in-trade of some West Cork politicians, but they rarely have had less material to work on than they have in this instance.
Comment on this
The railways, far from being essential to the area's development, have been an impediment to it. They generated a sort of Maginot Line mentality, which had to be cured before the economic potentialities of the area could be fully developed. Now the development of West Cork will proceed. It is happening in industry—in regard to agriculture the survey will show the lines on which to proceed—and it is happening in afforestation, tourism and fishery in a manner which will be realistic and which certainly will not require the retention for reasons of sentiment of a system of transport unsuitable to the economy of the area.
Similar conditions prevail as far as West Clare is concerned. I think every Deputy knows that the industrial development of Clare is proceeding at an unprecedented rate, at a rate I would not have dared to forecast even three or four years ago. I share with Deputy Murphy the sentimental feeling he has about the West Clare railway, the line we used to sing and make jokes about in our youth. But we cannot base our policy in this matter on sentiment. I had the same sentimental feeling about sailing ships, but we are not going to develop our merchant marine with sailing ships just because of some sentimental regard for them.
If this country is to increase employment, stop emigration and raise the living standards of its people, we must strive in every sector of our activities for the greatest efficiency attainable. We cannot build here a progressive nation and a modern State and at the same time cling on to systems, methods and organisations which have outlived their utility. That, at any rate, is the policy of the Government in that regard; and, as far as I am concerned, I am prepared to preach it in West Cork or anywhere else and justify it with practical results there and elsewhere.
I have only one further point to make before Deputy O'Sullivan "breaks the tapes" again. It has been suggested that the roads of these areas will be given an amount of additional traffic which they are unsuitable to bear. The figures given earlier to-day by the Minister for Transport and Power go a long way towards demolishing that contention. It is, however, the policy of the Government to assist local authorities to maintain the roads in their areas in a state suitable for the traffic using them. If we get from these areas realistic proposals for the bringing of roads up to that standard, they will be very carefully considered. But it is not helpful, either to the consideration of the problem or to the interests of these areas, to have fantastic estimates of costs prepared on a propagandist basis and publicised in the Press.
Comment on this
I have no doubt whatever that in Cork and Clare the local authority officials decided to put down as necessary, in consequence of the closing of the railway lines, every road work they wanted to have done in that area, whether the closing of the railway had any bearing on it or not.
Comment on this
I do not know if I can say very much about the Tramore line. It was of very little economic importance. In so far as the experiences of other areas is a guide— the Minister for Transport and Power mentioned the Bundoran line—I am quite certain the tourist potentialities of Tramore can be far better developed by a flexible and economic system of road transport than by railways. We have closed many a railway and branch line since this State was established. We closed the line from Galway to Clifden; we eliminated railways in Donegal altogether; and we closed the line from Dundalk to Greenore and numerous other ones. There never was a line closed without public agitation of this sort about it, but there never was a serious complaint about the inadequacy of the substitute services once the line was closed.
I met many deputations, whatever C.I.E. may do, with regard to the closing of a railway line which required the positive consent of the Government and in no single case, going around the traders and councillors who made up the deputations, could I get an affirmative answer to the only question that mattered: "If the line is kept open. can you get more traffic for it?" I never got an affirmative answer to that question and it is the only one that counted.
I submit to Deputies that the idea that we should hang on to things that have outlived their utility just because of a dislike for change or for reasons of sentiment is out of keeping with the spirit of modern Ireland. We are going ahead to build up a progressive State, well equipped and organised in every arm to secure the maximum economic development and the maximum benefit for its people from that development. We can do that only if we are prepared to take decisions such as the decision which is obviously justified in the case of West Cork and which has been shown to be right by the improvement that immediately followed it.
Comment on this
It is obvious from the temper in which the Taoiseach has spoken that he has a very bad case. It is surprising, if his case is so good in his own mind, that he refused until to-day to discuss this problem with anyone. I want to say to him that he was particularly unfair to Deputy Wycherley who, over the past three months, has defended any approach to the Taoiseach on this matter.
Comment on this
I have already made it clear that we are giving the whole of Government Time for this debate. If it does not conclude to-day, I cannot now say when it can be resumed.
Comment on this
At the outset, I want to protest against the personal attack made by the Taoiseach on the officials of Cork County Council. If such an attack were made on officials of the Taoiseach's Department, he would be the first to jump to his feet and say that any criticism should be levelled at the responsible Minister. There was an attack on a report submitted by Cork County Council in relation to the estimated consequences on the finances of Cork County Council, if the closing of the line were proceeded with.
In case the Taoiseach does not know, I want to remind him that the Fianna Fáil members of Cork County Council proposed a resolution congratulating the Cork county engineer and his officials on the compilation of the report. A resolution was unanimously passed by the 46 members of the council approving the report which the Taoiseach to-day condemns.
Comment on this
Anyone would congratulate a local official who tries to get more money for his own county.
Comment on this
The basis on which it was tendered was not discoveries in regard to Leitrim, Cavan, Monaghan, Sligo and Donegal county councils. The information we secured was that in Donegal the Minister for Local Government made a special road grant as a result of the closing of the railway and consequently it was completely divorced from the question of sub-standard roads being brought up to standard. It was entirely devoted to compensating the area for the impact of the closure of the railways. The grant made available by the Minister was £375,000, payable at £75,000 per annum over five years. The total road mileage in that county is 598.
Deputy Corry put down a question asking what would be payable to Cork County Council, if the West Cork lines were closed, and the Minister said no grant was available. The road mileage in Donegal is 598 and in Cork it is 106,000. This report was not prepared in the offices of Cork County Council as propaganda in support of a case. We know what was provided in Donegal. Let us take the case of Sligo where not one mile of railway line was closed. Sligo was compensated for the additional traffic on the roads en route to and from Donegal. Sligo received £45,000 per annum for five years, a total of £225,000. Surely we must put all this expenditure against the estimated losses we are told about.
May I say I completely agree with the Taoiseach in one statement, and in one statement only. The statement to which I refer was made by the Taoiseach on 27th November, 1957, as reported at column 1050, Volume 164, of the Official Report. He said:
There is another aspect of this financial problem that I should, perhaps, deal with now.
He went on to deal with it and said:
There is, I know, a popular belief that the financial difficulties of C.I.E. are due mainly or entirely to the continued operation of branch lines.
He went on:
All the information available to me would make it quite clear that the elimination of branch line operations would not make any appreciable difference to C.I.E's financial problem.
That is a statement of the Taoiseach's with which I would agree, but anyone listening to-day would have thought the entire solution of the transport problems of this country was to close down branch lines. The complaint we have in relation to current happenings in transport is concentrated in the amendment tabled by the members of this Party because of the fact that they gave support to a Bill passed through this House on the word of the Taoiseach who, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, assured the House that a period of two months' notice would be given, prior to the closing of a line, so that interested parties might make representations. In fact, the Taoiseach went further. In the Taoiseach's words:
In cases of decisions to close down a branch railway line, the Bill says two months' notice must be given. I do not think we need to write in there that during these two months the board will have to hear the deputation from the local council of the town losing the railway service or meet the representations of the trade unions who may have a point of view. Of course, they will do it. Indeed, the whole purpose of the requirement to give two month's notice was to provide a statutory period during which these inevitable representations could be entertained.
It is clear that at that time the Taoiseach only visualised the closing of branch lines since he refers to "the town". There are 100,000 people involved in the West Cork line who do not regard it as a branch line. There are 120,000 tons of merchandise, despite anything the Taoiseach may say, being transferred to the roads. It was only yesterday that a Road Traffic Bill was introduced to deal with the already existing problems on the roads.
If the Taoiseach knew the local conditions, he would be in complete agreement with the county engineer in relation to the inadequacy of the roads to carry the additional traffic visualised as a result of the closing of the line. I often have to go off the main road in my frequent journeys out of Cork city because I cannot make time or travel with safety with the present volume of commercial traffic on the road. Deputy MacCarthy will agree with me when I say that at the moment the problem is so serious that by-pass roads are being planned to by-pass two towns in that area. What will be the effect of all this work on the local rates and on the Exchequer?
Comment on this
Whatever the Taoiseach may contend, I maintain that an additional 120,000 tons of merchandise is not an inconsiderable amount. Does he contemplate the problem that will be created in relation to beet?
The Minister for Transport and Power was quite wrong this morning —Deputy Corry can contradict him more effectively than I can—when he talked about the diversion of beet haulage from rail to road. The railways were carrying the beet to Mallow. The additional beet was delivered by road. If we had time, we could bring forward plenty of reasons for that. There was the refusal of C.I.E. throughout the years to provide loading banks. There was the serious abuse by the management of C.I.E. in refusing to consider representations by beet grower's and farmers' organisations for facilities to load beet above floor level. Is it any wonder the farmers went over to road transport when that occurred?
Farmers had to bribe C.I.E. workers to prevent them from turning off the lights at a railway station. If they were not given a hand-out, there was a danger the farmers would be left in the dark, with half the load of beet. In face of such abuses, how can the Taoiseach be so critical of the action of agriculturists in their business?
Comment on this
He referred to the co-operative societies of West Cork in critical terms because they did not give business to C.I.E.
Comment on this
How could C.I.E. provide the farmers with travelling creameries, or would they do it if they were asked? Would C.I.E., in his opinion, provide the service the cooperative societies are providing for their members to-day? Not at all.
Comment on this
No. Is he satisfied C.I.E. ever met the claims put forward by business people and by societies for the provision of suitable facilities?
Comment on this
Is this extra 120,000 tons of merchandise on the road of very little importance? If the Taoiseach had all these arguments, why, up to to-day, did he refuse to receive any deputation or not insist that the chairman of C.I.E. be more courteous in his attitude to deputations?
I want to decry the suggestion that we are blowing off steam and that our attitude is purely political. The Taoiseach's Party have been most loyal in ensuring that attention was directed at the head, the chairman, of C.I.E. and kept away from the Taoiseach and the Minister for Transport and Power. Only when the chairman of C.I.E. was insulting in the terms of his replies to the public bodies of the South was it directed to the heads of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Transport and Power to see if they could exercise any influence over that individual to ensure he would meet the people who wanted to discuss the matter with him.
We were strengthened in that by the views the Taoiseach placed on record when the Act was going through the House. We accepted the Taoiseach's word. His confidence had a profound effect on agreement of this Party and on the passage of the Bill when he assured us there was no reason to write in the provisions. It was not what the Taoiseach said in introducing the Second Reading that was important but what he said in reply to points made by Deputy Cosgrave and others. They were right. We were mistaken in accepting the Taoiseach's word at that time. We should have written them specifically into the Act. This is a lesson dearly bought.
We are convinced that the people who have legitimate reasons for protest against the action of C.I.E. should have been received by the Board of C.I.E. If the Board had good arguments to advance and good proof that the losses would continue and that the situation could not improve in that area, we, on the other hand, had the answer in the glowing descriptions to-day by the Taoiseach of factories sprouting in West Cork. If that is true, what is the purpose of introducing this Bill to close a branch line where there is no hope of improvement of traffic in backward parts of the country? If the future is as glowing as the Taoiseach tried to paint it to-day, surely C.I.E. could hope for an improvement in the volume of traffic on that line? If that area is to sprout factories, if there is to be a diminution of emigration from that area, if wealth is to flow there from tourism and other sources, surely we could expect a considerable improvement in the volume of traffic in the Cork to Bantry railway?
The Taoiseach is disposing of his own arguments when he says the branch line must go because there is no future for the area it now serves. He is absolutely contradicting himself to-day in advancing these two points of view.
Comment on this
I said not one industrialist was prepared to say: "I will give an additional ton of traffic to C.I.E."
Comment on this
I am talking about industries that are there now. Those coming in the future have not been asked.
Comment on this
Have they not? I was one of a group who brought a German industrialist to Bandon. When taking him into the local hotel, a train passed by. We were saying it was as if it had been staged. He asked to see the amenities of the railway station. We are still battling to get that industry to Bandon. On the last occasion he visited us his first remark was: "Oh, since I was here with you last, you lost your railway."
Comment on this
Perhaps. We are disturbed because of the impact on potential industries in that area. The first comment made on the closure of the line was by Mr. Boland who, more than any living man, is responsible for bringing industry to West Cork. He regarded the action of C.I.E. as a stab in the back to the efforts to improve that area.
Enough material was provided by the Minister for Transport and Power to enable any Deputy to speak on this subject for at least an hour. The Minister referred to the period given to put the finances in order. He did not refer to the period of five years, only three of which have elapsed. He wanted to steer away from the fact that he was applying the guillotine two years short of the period C.I.E. were given to put their house in order.
During the past couple of months, various resolutions were passed asking for an extension of the trial time. We feel other branch lines such as those mentioned by Deputy M.P. Murphy are paying less than the line from Cork to Bantry but are not being closed at the moment. We are not advocating that they should be closed but we feel that to select the West Cork line out of all these is extremely unfair. If given an extension of time, if C.I.E. meet the people and discuss the various means of improving business on the line we believe they will be met.
I wish to deny the Taoiseach's allegation that this debate is purely to blow off steam and is politically inspired. He and the Minister must know that the I.N.T.O. is not a political body. They were one of the bodies that met to protest. They went further than any politician and said they would actually boycott in relation to the transport of school children to Dublin. The Minister smiles at that. The Minister smiles at the resolution passed by the Irish National Teachers Organisation. I just mention it and I would not have mentioned it at all, were it not that the Taoiseach said that politicians were the only people consulted about the closing of the branch line. The Minister described the period of five years which C.I.E. got as being a reasonable period. We allege that the period of three years which West Cork got was an unreasonable period.
Comment on this
The Deputy is arguing on the basis that there is something sacrosanct about rail service. I do not regard the rail service in a rural area as sacrosanct in any sense whatever.
Comment on this
If the Minister does not, why did he and the Board not receive the people from the area and give them proof? If they had a case, why were these replies from the Chairman of C.I.E. in such insulting terms to the Cork County Council? Why was there this stern consistent refusal to receive a deputation from any of the interested parties? The Cork County Council loses £1,700 per annum rates on the buildings that are now being eliminated from rating, even though C.I.E. are still paying for some buildings that have been closed for 15 years. It is a matter of concern. That is a loss of revenue to the Cork County Council. We are all anxious in face of the grants to Donegal and elsewhere. There will be a very heavy imposition on the rates in Cork County in order to build up the roads.
Comment on this
Before the Minister came in, I gave the figure of £375,000 as provided in relation to Donegal where there is less than half the mileage of main roads affected that there is in Cork. The Minister may think that he has passed off to the shoulders of the ratepayers some expenses falling on C.I.E. up to now. It will be a long day before he hears the end of that. I want to allege that when he talks about the estimated losses on this line, there are a number of questions which this deputation wanted to put to the Minister and to the Board of C.I.E.
We want to know whether the estimated loss of £56,000 on the line included the erection of a new roof over Bandon railway station; we want to know whether the estimated loss of £56,000 included painting of all the bridges a bright blue. There were no objections from the aesthetic point of view as to the colour selected. A deep black might have been a more appropriate colour than the bright blue colour which C.I.E. used in the painting of all their buildings. The bridges were painted within the past 12 months. For what purpose? I know that in the E.S.B. office at Bandon, C.I.E. paid in a cheque of £15 for the installation of electric wires over the railway bridge to protect the C.I.E. workers painting the bridge within the past 12 months. That is included in the £56,000 loss. There are hundreds of interesting queries that the people in that area have to put to C.I.E.
Comment on this
It was based on the optimistic hopes in relation to future traffic that could be got that they built a new roof over Bandon railway station and painted all the buildings bright blue, whilst at the same time they had decided to close the whole line.
Comment on this
These are some of the things that could have been discussed if, during past months, the Minister or the Board of C.I.E. had met the interested parties. Then possibly it would have been understood more clearly whether or not there was a case for the closing of the line. The Minister used some very exaggerated terms this morning. He talked about an astonishing improvement in so short a time in the affairs of C.I.E. Are we to take it that that improvement has now ended? Are we to expect that that improvement will continue?
I want to refer to the compensation payable to those who will not be absorbed in other sections of C.I.E. The trade unions involved are satisfied with the level of compensation their members will receive. Last week, we asked the Minister to give us an idea as to how many employees would be displaced from employment on the West Cork line. We were told that there would be 210 and that half of the permanent staff of 185—I do not know how you can divide 185 by 2— were to be assigned to other duties and the remainder would be compensated.
When I questioned the Minister as to whether the amount of compensation would be lesser or greater than the estimated losses on the line, the Minister was of the opinion that it would not exceed the loss. Then he went on to say that it would diminish as the years went on. In that respect, I want to inform the Minister, in case he does not know it, that at least two of the men received £2 per week compensation for the rest of their lives. They capitalised the sum of £1 per week for the sum of £600, so that the capital involved, according to the insurance company, in the compensation of these men who lose their employment, is approximately £1,200 per annum. Is the Minister questioning this?
Comment on this
I will answer the Deputy in my reply. He has made so many wild statements that my reply will be disappointing to him. I could not follow him.
Comment on this
The Minister can take my assurance that an insurance company has valued at £600 compensation in respect of these men in return for the capitalising of a sum of £1 per week.
Apart from their compensation, there is the question of their employment. The Minister for Industry and Commerce interjected a remark last week that the factories would absorb the men who are being displaced from employment with C.I.E. We understood that the development of new industries was intended to offset emigration and absorb some of the 15,000 coming on the market every year. If some of these are to be absorbed into other undertakings it means the emigration of a similar number of workers. There was never any intention that the moneys expended by the State in the creation of these new means of employment were intended to absorb those already in employment in other State undertakings.
The Minister made an extraordinary statement this morning. He talked about a new wind blowing through Coras Iompair Éireann and went on to say that "there has been a remarkable improvement in the morale of the employees, who are now conscious of being members of what is becoming an efficient and successful undertaking and who feel that their efforts are worthwhile to themselves and to the community." It would have been as well, under present circumstances, if that statement had been omitted from the Minister's script. The Minister went on to pay a wonderful tribute to the chairman of C.I.E. The Ceann Comhairle indicated that it was not permissible to discuss the person of the chairman but the remarkable tribute paid by the Minister to the chairman of C.I.E. invites some little comment.
He stressed particularly that he was infusing C.I.E. with something of his own adventurous spirit. Well, of course, Captain Morgan had an adventurous spirit. The Luftwaffe had an adventurous spirit. History has to record a number of people with adventurous spirits but they have not got very much to commend themselves to the present generation for what they achieved. I can assure the Minister that if he were to discuss these actions of the Board of C.I.E. in the area I represent, there would not be much appreciation of the spirit of adventure.
Comment on this
The workers engaged on those lines can modernise in Britain and elsewhere with the compensation we shall be paying them for the next 25 years. We claim that if the Board met the interested parties they would convince the Board that it would cost more to close this line than to keep it open. The Minister will hear a lot more on the Estimate of what it will cost the ratepayers to provide roads to carry the additional traffic which the Minister thinks will have such little effect.
In another part of the Minister's introductory speech he said:
There is, in any case, no good reason why the relatively limited number of persons in a few areas who enjoyed subsidised fares under these conditions should expect to retain them indefinitely at the expense of the rest of the community.
This argument, of course, could be carried into any Department of State. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs could come in here and say that it was costing more than 3d. to deliver letters in various parts of the country and that he should be relieved of the obligation. The argument could be extended to a ridiculous degree.
In relation to the gradual shift which the Minister mentions in regard to the transport of beet from rail to road haulage, he says that C.I.E. will carry beet by road on the same terms as it was carried by rail. There is no advertence to the impact on transport with regard to the maintenance of roads and the traffic problems that will be created. There is no alternative to the transport of this beet through Cork City to get to Mallow. The traffic problem that will result on Patrick's Bridge, Cork, will be nobody's business. The Minister interjected that there was a possibility that some of this traffic might be diverted to Mallow by Brian Boru Street. I know every inch of those roads and I know what it is like to try to get a bus to transport children to school. C.I.E. have reported to me that the roads were incapable of carrying C.I.E. vehicles. Then the Minister for Transport alleges that these same roads are capable of carrying the very heavy beet haulage from the West Cork area to the factory at Mallow.
These are some of the arguments we advance as to why this is a wrong action on the part of the Minister, the Taoiseach and C.I.E.—carrying out their original intention of closing these lines and, in the interim provided by law, not giving the interested parties an opportunity of discussing with C.I.E. the situation presented by the closure. It is for that reason we feel this opportunity should be availed of to protest as vigorously as possible.
If the Minister and the Board insist on the closure at the end of March they should at least leave the lines there. If they do persist with this dictatorial decision, and are not prepared to change their minds, they should not remove the lines, but should leave them there, as they left them in Donegal and elsewhere. However, a new practice has arisen of ripping up the lines with the desire, I suppose, of showing a dramatic increase in exports this year. The ripping up of lines and exporting them is a very poor contribution to the balance of payments.
We suggest that they should give the 100,000 people affected at least the two years remaining before the expiration of the five-year period, presented to the House at the time the Transport Act was passed. During that period remaining C.I.E. should do as they have not done before, consult the local business and agricultural interests about ways and means of securing additional traffic. Sufficient attention should be given to the submissions of the Cork County Council in relation to the impact on the rates as the result of the transport of goods on the roads of Cork county, if the Minister persists in his intention of closing these lines.
Comment on this
The last speaker revealed a deplorable state of bungling within C.I.E. He told us that the roof of Bandon Station was replaced last year and that an elaborate job of painting was carried out at a time when C.I.E. must have known the line was going to be closed. They had got the power to do it; I am sure they had taken the decision to close the line, yet they proceeded with a most elaborate expenditure on a line which was to be scrapped. If that is the case, and if that expenditure is added to the working costs for that year, it is very hard to know whether it is due to bungling or merely deceiving the people as to the true state of affairs in regard to the working on that railway.
The principal reason for my speaking on this debate is to refer to the closing of the Claremorris-Ballinrobe branch line. C.I.E. met a deputation in regard to that a line on two occasions. They were gracious enough to meet us and while they would not allow a discussion on the actual closing of the branch line they discussed ways and means of getting alternative traffic. As a result of a second deputation, they agreed to run a trial bus for three months. They did that and the bus has since been taken off due, I understand, to uneconomic running. While the lifting of the line was a very serious blow to the people in a huge area in West Mayo, I must say they did not treat us as discourteously as is alleged in the case of the West Cork railway.
I want to be as brief as possible and not to delay the House because some of the speeches have been very long and some of them, including that of the Taoiseach, were anything but to the point. Ballinrobe is one of the biggest cattle centres in the West of Ireland. It is the only town in an area of very good arable land, with the result that the cattle and sheep fairs there, particularly in winter time, are the biggest in the west of Ireland from Cork to Donegal. When the line was being closed, C.I.E. promised that they would provide adequate alternative service for the fairs.
On 6th of this month, the joint honorary secretaries of the Ballinrobe Town Development Committee wrote to the chairman of C.I.E. as follows:
Dear sir,
Your attention has, no doubt, been drawn to Press reports regarding the poor services provided by your company at the December and January fairs in Ballinrobe.
Despite the promises and guarantees of your company when a deputation from this committee, accompanied by local T.D.s, visited Dublin in December, 1959, the following was our experience at the January fair in Ballinrobe—the position at the December fair was not much better.
(a) Livestock were not cleared until 8.30 p.m.
(b) Only six lorries and matadors and one single lorry were assigned to Ballinrobe for this fair.
(c) Many farmers were left standing with their stock for hours at the station in icy cold conditions due to a shortage of pens.
(d) Livestock after enduring arctic conditions in pens all day did not, we learn reliably, leave Claremorris until the 9 p.m. special that night. What must have been their condition when they reached their destination next day?
(e) Buyers attending the fair for years told us they would never again attend the fair.
In view of the seriousness of the above, we would welcome a report from your Company and a statement as to the action you propose to take with regard to future fairs in Ballinrobe. Copies of this letter are being circulated to local Dáil representatives.
Sincerely yours,
(Signed) Messrs. Staunton and Jennings,
Joint Hon. Secretaries.
That letter reveals a shocking state of affairs. It is a matter about which the Minister should consult with C.I.E.
The Taoiseach came out with a flourish of trumpets about the sudden sprouting of factories throughout West Cork, due to the closing of the West Cork line—a thing that I do not believe. I understand that for years efforts have been made to have even one small industry established in the town of Ballinrobe, so far without success. The Taoiseach suggested that factories had sprouted all over West Cork since the closing of the West Cork line was talked about. The Ballinrobe line has been closed for 12 months and no factory has materialised there as yet.
The Minister might interest himself in asking C.I.E. to provide a better service so that the fairs, which are the last thing left to Ballinrobe, will not be killed. He might also interest himself, and get his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to interest himself, in getting an industry into Ballinrobe.
The Taoiseach provided me with a certain amount of amusement when he attributed the development of forestry in West Cork to the closing of the railway. I should like the Minister for Lands to elaborate on that and to tell me how.
Comment on this
What the Taoiseach said was that the closing of the railway line did not prevent the progress of forestry in West Cork, which is a different thing altogether.
Comment on this
He said that later. He quoted forestry as one of the things that were flourishing because of the closing of the line.
Comment on this
I will. The planting that the Taoiseach was boasting about was carried out on land that I gave to the present Minister when we left office in 1957, and not on anything that has been acquired since.
Comment on this
Why is it that C.I.E. do not show in their accounts the returns on the sale of scrap? They scrapped the line from Claremorris to Ballinrobe. The Department of Local Government are giving a grant of £12,500 for each of the next four years. In addition, it will cost the ratepayers £37,500 in each of the next four years to put that 11 miles of road into fit condition to bear the traffic that will be diverted to it from the railway line. C.I.E. have no right or authority to claim one penny accruing from the sale of scrap of the railway line. The least they might do for the ratepayers is to devote the value of this scrap to the improvement of the roads that have to bear the increased traffic arising from the closing of the line.
I have the greatest admiration for C.I.E. and I am very proud of the improvements they have carried out in recent years. It is regrettable that they closed these branch lines. I maintain that they have no legal right to the cash they get for the scrap of the lines. It was not they who put down the line. It was not this generation that put it down. The ratepayers, who have to bear the burden of the increased traffic on the roads, should not be saddled with the burden simply because C.I.E. want to operate without showing a loss, if not showing a profit, in any year. They should devote the proceeds of the sale of the scrap of the lines to improving the roads that will have to carry the extra traffic.
Comment on this
I hope someone from Dublin will have a say because Dublin is held up to ransom by the country, do not forget.
Comment on this
I had intended to speak at length on this motion and the amendment, but, in view of all the ground that has been covered in regard to the West Cork railway, I shall confine myself simply to the question of that very small section of railway line from Waterford city to Tramore. That section is scarcely eight miles in length and I am reliably informed that the annual loss is estimated at £2,800, although we have never received that information officially from C.I.E. That would appear to be a very small figure.
In the course of his speech the Taoiseach taunted the Fine Gael Party that the only peg on which they could hold the Government up to criticism was the fact that deputations had not been received by C.I.E. That is an important fact in relation to Tramore railway. It is honestly believed in the area that if the C.I.E. management agreed to consult with the local people of Tramore and Waterford city, a compromise could be achieved whereby C.I.E. would be enabled to run the Waterford-Tramore line without loss and possibly with a profit.
The Minister for Transport and Power has said that railway lines in rural areas are not sacred. I suggest, equally, that road traffic in rural areas is not sacred. The system that is most economical and most efficient is the proper system. There is nothing to indicate that the Tramore-Waterford section of railway line could not be made economic, provided the views of the local people were acceded to. That is all that Waterford city and Tramore ask. The Chamber of Commerce, the Waterford Corporation, the Town Council of Tramore and various other organised bodies representing all shades of political opinion, all creeds and all interests in the town of Tramore and the city of Waterford, appealed to C.I.E. to meet them in fair conference to discuss how best this problem could be solved. The only answer that they got from C.I.E. was that the only conference that they would consider was, not on the question of the railway, but any alternative system that might be proposed.