We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1961 — Second Stage.

Contributions 160–331 of 331. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 1961
Enacted

No. 6 of 1961 ›

There have been a number of times when Fine Gael voted against the Government for no apparent reason and this was one of them. In this case, we have been forced by the decision of the High Court to revise the constituencies purely on a mathematical basis. Deputy Kyne was trying to make suggestions in regard to territorial revisions but of course territory is something which does not come under consideration at all, in view of the High Court decision. It is just a mathematical calculation and once the Government have decided as to the correct ratio between population and Deputies, there can be very little room for manoeuvre of any sort. In a particular case, as the Minister explained, the Government decided to adopt as the basis a ratio of 20,000 of the population to each Deputy. Once that is settled one has to start, I suppose, with the city and divide it into units of 20,000 and then work away out along the country and see what happens.

The Minister would possibly be the first to admit that some of the results of this mathematical basis of division are extraordinary when one sees them on a map, but unfortunately the population is not equally spread over the country and sometimes you must draw boundaries in a very odd way to keep the constituency in the right ratio of population to representation. When it is accepted, as it had to be accepted, that there must be virtually no variation in the ratio between the population and the number of Deputies over the whole country, there can be no question of gerrymandering.

It was very disappointing that right from the start the Leader of the Opposition has hurled this accusation across the House. He did it not in any malicious fashion, judging by his expression. He did it out of sheer lightheartedness; he had a broad smile on his face as he described how wicked we were in having introduced this Bill. If he were really serious, I think he might at least have appeared to be serious. Actually, he took the whole thing in a most lighthearted way. Since it appears that he was not serious in his accusation, I think he should not have made it at all but so many people are so obviously ignorant of what gerrymandering means that I should like to get this on record.

If one wished to gerrymander a constituency, one would have to devise a scheme whereby, in some constituencies favourable to one's own Party, it would need only a population of, say, 10,000 to return one Deputy, whereas in other constituencies where the supporters of one's own Party were fewer, it would need a very much greater number. Where in all constituencies the ratio is uniform, it does not make, and cannot make, any difference to the final result whether the constituencies are divided in this, that or the other way.

Suppose that in a certain area of South Tipperary Fianna Fáil support is rather weak and suppose there was a revision whereby certain Fine Gael votes were taken out of that area and put into another constituency. That would not affect the final result in the number of Deputies returned to this House because the Fine Gael votes which had been transferred from one constituency to another would be just as valid in the constituency to which they were transferred. Under the proportional system, they must achieve their result.

Deputy Kyne, in particular, appeared to think that if you drew a line which was not approved by him, you were obviously gerrymandering. We all know that certain revisions might be more suitable to one's personal wishes than others but that does not involve gerrymandering. The only way in which you can gerrymander a constituency is by altering the ratio between population and representation. Once that is uniform, the result must be fair. That is the beginning and end of it and I trust we shall have no more fanciful suggestions that Fianna Fáil have done anything in the slightest degree improper or anything that even remotely could possibly be to their own advantage.

Comment on this

What were they all doing in the Custom House for the past month?

Comment on this

I do not know. The curious thing is that it was not until today that I heard about this rally at the Custom House.

Comment on this

They must be trying to freeze out the Deputy.

Comment on this

I doubt it. I know I am a bit awkward at times but I keep my ears and eyes open and if there was a tremendous rally of my own Party in a certain direction, I should almost certainly hear something about it. But I never did. I am forced to conclude—not for the first time—that the imagination of certain members of the Opposition very often runs away with them. We have had cases like that before and undoubtedly we shall have them again. Certainly, I heard nothing of this amazing rally of Fianna Fáil Deputies around the map in the Custom House but if somebody can tell me more about it—not in this House because I think that would be wasting the time of the House—tell me who were there and what happened——

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Loughman.

Comment on this

The Deputy is outside the circle.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Booth should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

There is no circle so far as I know, even though my constituency was completely revised. The only point at issue here is whether revision suits certain Deputies or does not. That is something which unfortunately is entirely irrelevant. The only really relevant point is: is this a fair and proper division of the country, accepting the unfortunate decision of the High Court that there must be no variation between the ratio of population and the number of Deputies? The only criticism one could make is that in certain cases the proportion is 200 or 300 or perhaps 400 over the average and in certain other cases that it is 200, 300 or 400 under the average. You can hardly get closer than that without drawing lines down the middle of a street or having a boundary which could not possibly be justified.

I am absolutely satisfied that there has been no consideration of Party advantage and even with the worst will in the world, there could be no Party advantage, once the judgement of the High Court is accepted and once the ratio is uniform throughout the country. There can be no gerrymandering in those circumstances. I am absolutely satisfied that there has not been any and I hope we have heard the last of it because once this charge is thrown across the House, it causes quite an unnecessary spirit of bitterness to arise, something which Deputy Cosgrave referred to when speaking recently and when he mentioned the unnecessary tension that can arise in a debate such as this. Let us remember, and I should like to join with him in this, that this bitterness and tension are unnecessary. Let us have done with them and discuss the Bill on its merits.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Having listened to Deputy Booth tonight and having listened to him on 19th November, 1959, I scarcely recognise him as one and the same person. I should like to remind him now of remarks I made on that occasion on the unconstitutional Electoral Bill then before the House, remarks which he described as "sudden and unsubstantiated accusations". I had taken my seat here seven days previously. I said then that the Taoiseach was wrong when he stated this House is the final judge of what is practicable. It is not. The court can determine whether or not this Bill is a practicable distribution of the influence of the Irish people and, even if the Taoiseach marshals all his majority behind him on this Bill, there is another place in which it can be subsequently tested and destroyed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy give the reference?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Column 435 of Volume 177 of the Official Report. Almost at the very beginning of this prolonged and costly controversy over practically two years, I asked the Minister to have the Bill thoroughly revised so as to avoid the necessity of going to the Supreme Court. The Minister, his colleagues in the Government and his supporters in the Party refused to amend the Bill, except in one small instance when, after an attack of conscience, they gave one seat to Dublin. Dublin, of course, should have got five seats. That one seat was given to balance off a certain Fianna Fáil seat given down the country.

Later at column 1071 of the same volume, I said:

It is certainly an ironical situation that it is the Government whose Party introduced the present Constitution who are flouting it and we have to stand up and appeal to them to have respect for the Constitution which they introduced. As I have said, if it is not done in this House, there are still two other places in which it can and will be done, if necessary.

I was supported by several other members of the Fine Gael Party, here and in the other House. We told the Minister and the Government that the Bill was as unconstitutional as any Bill could be. Deputy Booth, amongst other Fianna Fáil supporters of the measure, told us we were being unreasonable.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy quote that?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

There were cries from the opposite side of the House.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Deputy has alleged I made a certain statement. I should like him to give the reference.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair did not hear the Deputy give any quotation and I cannot, therefore, ask him to give the reference.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Deputy Booth is, of course, a pastmaster in the art of trying to put speakers off their stroke, but it takes more than Deputy Booth to put me off my stroke. In 1959 I said quite bluntly that the Bill was as unconstitutional as it could be. My statement was greeted with jeers from the other side of the House. From Deputy Corry, it was: "That poor baby over there." From Deputy Browne, it was: "He is young yet." From Deputy Seán Flanagan, it was: "He is only a newcomer." It seems now that out of the mouth of the babe and political suckling words of wisdom came forth.

Remember, it is not the Fine Gael Party and it is not the High Court which upset the 1959 Bill. It is the Constitution. Fianna Fáil love to denigrate the courts. They love to attack the whole legal system on which our fundamental liberties depend. They love to drag it down into the mud. They traipsed the highways and byways of Leitrim ridiculing our Judiciary. But it was not the judge and it was not Fine Gael; it was the Constitution itself which damned them and the Bill of 1959 and it was the Constitution which makes this Bill now so necessary.

It is a fundamental law of democracy that all votes shall have equal value. It is a simple rule of democracy—it bores Deputy Booth—that every man will go to the polling booth knowing that his vote will have equal influence in the selection of a Government. That is the essence of the democratic system in which we believe.

Comment on this

Does the Bill not do that?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

This Bill does it because the Constitution has compelled the Government to do it. Costly and prolonged efforts had to be made to make the Minister for Local Government respect the obligations of the Constitution. The Constitution provides that every vote shall have equal value. In a democracy, it is one man—one vote and to every man an equal vote.

Comment on this

The Deputy supports the Bill then?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

The 1959 Bill gave threequarters of a vote to the Dublin voter and one-and-a-quarter votes to voters in some of the rural constituencies in which Fianna Fáil had a traditional majority. Deputy Loughman hopes that what he says here will not be heard by Dublin. But it will be heard by Dublin, just as the words of Deputy Corry have been and will be heard by Dublin. So long as there is any freedom of speech here, attacks made on Dublin by Deputies opposite will be shouted from every street corner and from the rooftops in this city.

In 1959, when there was an amendment tabled to give to Dublin a small modicum of justice, Deputy Corry said: "I am asking this House to wipe out the first amendment, to get rid of Dublin". He went on to say: "I am asking all the country boys to marshal themselves together and to do the job. Then we shall have no difficulty". Perhaps it was a difficulty that Deputy Ryan was elected in July, 1959, with a majority in a constituency in which Fianna Fáil had had an overwhelming majority at the general election two years previously. If I happen to be that difficulty, then I am proud that seven days after I took my seat here, I told this House and the Minister for Local Government that the 1959 Bill was as unconstitutional a piece of legislation as ever came before this House.

What were the reasons put forward here and elsewhere to justify the 1959 Bill? We were told that Deputies had a colossal amount of work to do, running hither and thither, over here and over there, writing letters, receiving thousands of people, and doing, if I may say so, a great deal of work which the Constitution does not contemplate, which the Constitution does not even allow, and which no true democracy would sanction. It was said here that there were certain rights to which the people were entitled but which would be denied them, unless they went grovelling with their hats in their hands to their T.D.s.

Comment on this

Nobody said that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

That was the implication behind the overwhelming argument made.

Comment on this

It was not.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It was argued that people could not obtain their rights unless they got their T.D.s to go and see Ministers down in their confessionals in Leinster House or into their offices scattered all over the city. Rights were not obtainable in this country unless you went to secretaries of political Parties; rights were not obtainable unless you went and prostituted your political belief.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy make that statement to the Leader of his own Party and see what he will say to him?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to speak without these interruptions.

Comment on this

That is not a speech. It is only blathering.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

The functions in which Deputies can usefully engage on behalf of their constituents are, of course, very many but the deliberate and sustained effort by some politicians to pretend that everything they are asked to do can be obtained so long as it is asked of them has demoralised this country and has brought the people to the belief that their rights are not obtainable unless they go begging for them from T.D.s.

If there are—as there appear to be —many Deputies who find it inconvenient or who find it most onerous that people should come to them seeking advice or looking for assistance, then they ought not be members of this House. I have no doubt that there will be many who will stand up here or elsewhere to accuse me of being unwilling to do the necessary work which a Deputy ought to do. That is not so. I want to underline what I believe is a very dangerous trend in Irish public life and that is the corrupting influence which certain politicians are inflicting on the country by pretending that rights are obtainable only through them.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not relevant to the Bill before the House.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It is insofar as the functions of Deputies are related to it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see how the achievements of Deputies can be relevantly debated on this Bill.

Comment on this

One of the reasons the constituencies are manipulated is to permit Deputies to work better.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Certainly this aspect of the matter was discussed at very great length under the 1959 Bill. It may well be that some of these things are not the substantial considerations. That, indeed, is my argument. It is because I say they are not the substantial considerations that it is necessary to emphasise there is a considerable amount of pretence and make-believe by some public representatives who pretend that it is well nigh humanly impossible to do what they have to do and a great deal of it might be better not done at all.

There is a very easy way of providing for our people a system which will give them advice and assistance without having to submit themselves to the indignity of going along and promising political support to a member of this House. Other countries have a system of citizens' advice bureaux many of which are run on a voluntary basis. I believe it might help to uplift our people and kill the notion that a right is not obtainable unless you go to a politician if we had the system of citizens' advice bureaux.

In the final analysis, of course, you cannot limit the rights of Deputies in relation to almost anything which they are called upon to do. If you limit the right of a Deputy in this House or of a Senator in the other House, you are limiting the rights of the people themselves. I am not arguing that there should be any limitations on the rights or, indeed, any curb put on the duties of Deputies, but I would respectfully suggest that it is time the members of this House made it quite clear that natural rights and statutory rights are obtainable in this country without the necessity of going along with hat in hand to promise political support to a member of one Party or another.

Deputy Booth made his usual quota of erroneous statements. Not the least of them was his remark that the decision of the learned judge of the High Court was that the constituencies should be measured on a purely mathematical calculation. Deputy Booth told us that the decision of the judge was that the constituencies, according to the Constitution, had to be revised according to a purely mathematical calculation. I have not a copy of the judgement in my hand but I am prepared to challenge any member to quote from the decision of the learned judge any remark which can even be interpreted as possibly meaning that the only consideration had to be a purely mathematical calculation.

The learned judge prefaced his remarks by saying, not once, indeed, but on a number of occasions throughout the judgement, that he could not consider a revision of the constituencies on a purely mathematical calculation. Indeed, if you did we might have more vulgar fractions in the House than we have at the moment. The Constitution makes it quite clear that the ratio between the number of members in any constituency and the population of that constituency shall, as far as practicable, be the same throughout the country.

That is what this Bill seeks to do. I am prepared to credit the Minister with that purpose but what is the whole history of this Bill and what is the history of all that has led up to it? We had in the early part of 1959 an attempt to change our electoral laws, to abolish the system of proportional representation which gives fair representation to all sections of the community. The Government also sought to set up a tribunal which would not be subject to the criticism of this House, which tribunal was to arrange the constituencies.

We in Fine Gael opposed that measure and the people of Ireland supported us; they condemned that effort to change the electoral laws. Fianna Fáil having again been defeated, tried another method to perpetuate themselves in power. They tried to implement an Act which was illegal according to the law as it stands. They were defeated there because the courts obliged them to respect their own Constitution. Again I emphasise that it was not the decision of one man. It was the Constitution which declared the Bill of 1959 to be unconstitutional. Unless Fianna Fáil try to make anything of the fact that there was only one High Court Judge who condemned the Act of 1959, I am saying here— as I said elsewhere—that the only reason the Government did not bring the decision of the learned High Court Judge before the Supreme Court for revision was because they were absolutely certain that the Act had not got the chance of a snowball in hell of being upheld by the Supreme Court.

Having been defeated in the proportional representation referendum and having been defeated in the High Court on the illegal Act of 1959, they were not going to risk a third defeat by getting another whack against themselves in the Supreme Court. That brings us then to the necessity for another illegal Bill—this one.

We are now in the peculiar situation that no matter what the Minister tries to do, no matter what the Government try to do and no matter what the Houses of the Oireachtas try to do, we are still committing a legal mortal sin, if I may put it that way. No matter what we do now, we cannot comply with the provisions of the Constitution which require that the constituencies be revised from time to time in periods of not fewer than 12 years. That cannot now be done because we are more than 12 years from 1947. The responsibility for this sorry mess, the blame for the manner in which we are ignoring our Constitution, lies upon the Minister personally, upon the Taoiseach who leaves him in his office and upon all member of the Government and of their Party who have been accessories before and after this fact.

We find ourselves now in another quandary, the quandary as to whether or not we should await the results of the census which was taken last Sunday. Whether we want to argue on this or not, the fact remains that the census is already taken, even though the results of it may not be known. If you post a letter, you have posted it, even though it has not been received.

All this legal mess, all this disrespect for the institutions of this State, all this contempt for the constitutional provisions, is a natural flow from the real contempt in which Fianna Fáil hold the institutions and the system of law.

It may be all very well and very funny and very good music-hall to jeer at lawyers. I am prepared to accept all the cracks which can be thrown at lawyers but I do submit quite seriously to this House that when you do not respect your institutions and when you treat lightly very fundamental constitutional and legal obligations, you are undermining the very foundations of the State and of democracy itself and you do not know where the rot will end.

There is another criticism of this Bill, that is, that it is directed at the next general election and thus far only. Any Government, whether it be Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour or inter-Party, who seek to control the destinies of this State by just looking to their own narrow view of a general election are playing very foolishly, very foolishly for themselves, in the first instance, because, when you try to work out things for yourself politically you are not always successful and certainly not successful in the long run. It is also very foolish because it is perhaps damaging the whole institution of our parliamentary system when a Government play around in that way.

Deputy Booth and others have endeavoured to refute the charge of gerrymandering by pointing out that as the constituencies are now being made equal and as the ratio between members and population is so far as is practicable the same throughout the country, there is no room for gerrymandering. Of course, that is quite wrong. Fianna Fáil have at the moment the largest majority any Government have had in the history of this State. It is the first and the last time they will have it. The fact is that they have it at the moment and, therefore, they need be concerned with one thing only—not with keeping out their opponents because their opponents are now so much weaker than they—but they have only to try to preserve the seat of each individual Fianna Fáil Deputy and no more. That gives them an everlasting majority if they are successful but, of course, they will be far from successful.

If anybody wants to look at the new constituencies map, he will find that the counties which have had their borders overrun are areas in which there is a marginal Fianna Fáil seat which they are endeavouring to preserve by stretching out so as to have a larger area around the parish of the particular Deputy. It is as simple as all that. There is no other explanation for many of the incongruous changes which have taken place in constituency boundaries.

If one needed any more sure evidence of whether or not it was personal interest which was being kept in mind, one could go to County Donegal where we find that the border, instead of being moved eastwards, as would appear to be the reasonable and most practical thing to do, has been turned on its axis so as to give a much larger area of influence adjacent to the Minister's residence. The Minister would probably be prepared to admit that elsewhere, but, of course, he will deny it very flatly in this House and get most annoyed with Deputy Ryan and others for suggesting it. But, from looking at the map itself the manner in which the axis has been so extraordinarily changed is obvious. It may, of course, be just a coincidence, in which case I apologise to the Minister, but it is seldom that there are political coincidences that are so exceedingly convenient.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy suggest a different line?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

A different line was suggested in another place.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

If the Deputy is interested, I have four maps on which I would be glad to demonstrate to him a more rational way in which it could have been done.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not charge him for that, I hope.

Comment on this

Deputy Ryan was one of the persons responsible for all this.

Comment on this

If he asks Deputy Ryan as a constituent, he will not charge him.

Comment on this

I am sure he will not charge him in any case.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Deputy Davern has spoken. He says that Deputy Ryan is responsible for all this.

Comment on this

One of the persons, I said.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Is Deputy Ryan not a mighty man, that made the Fianna Fáil Party respect their own Constitution? Is he not simply fantastic?

Comment on this

Deputy Ryan always thought so.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Not all the power of Deputy Ryan could have changed the Bill of 1959, if it had not been unconstitutional, and the Deputy knows that. The law as regards the arrangement of constituencies was fixed as far back as 1922 under the first Constitution of this State and accepted by the Fianna Fáil Party and again by the people of Ireland in 1937. Deputy Ryan was not heard of in 1922 when the law was fixed providing one man, one vote, and to every man an equal vote. That is when it was determined—as far back as that —and that is the fundamental basis, I believe—maybe I am wrong—the fundamental reason why so many people sacrificed so much in this country. It was in order that the principle of "one man, one vote and to every man an equal vote" might be the principle on which Irish political life would revolve.

In the last century, we had the forty shilling freeholder. We had for a long time, until we could get rid of it, the property vote. We had the educational vote which gave extra political power to people who had received what might be called upper education. We had rotten boroughs which gave privileged power to a small section of the community. We got rid of all those inequalities. We got rid of the property vote; we got rid of the educational vote; we got rid of the rotten boroughs. It was sought to reintroduce them in 1959. It was sought to introduce a system by which extra political power would be given to a person if he were lucky enough to reside on the western seaboard or lucky enough to reside anywhere but in Dublin. But, because so many generations had fought for the principle of equality and of fair play and because we enshrined it in our Constitution in 1922 and because Fianna Fáil accepted the principle in 1937, the 1959 Act was upset. Deputy Ryan is not responsible for it at all, but it is good for the people of Ireland that there are Deputies here —and they appear to be only on this side of the House—who insist upon respect for the Constitution and who insist upon fair play, no more and no less, for all sections of the community.

Notwithstanding the effort to achieve equality, there is still a bias against Dublin and in favour of the western seaboard. It is not as obvious or as atrocious a bias as there was in the 1959 Act. However, if anyone goes down the schedule of ratios which the Minister so kindly circulated, he will find that the minus sign is before the western seaboard constituencies, in the main, and that in front of all the Dublin constituencies there is a plus sign. It may be just a coincidence again, but I wonder how large would the minus be and how fantastic would the plus be, if this Bill were to be framed upon the census taken last Sunday.

The Minister and the Government know well that this Bill would have to be changed even more and whether we like it or not, the probability is that over the next 12 years, Dublin will continue to expand. I most certainly hope that other areas of the country do not suffer any further drop in their population. I am as anxious for that as anybody else. We have more than enough to cope with in Dublin at the moment. The probability is, however, that my hope and the hopes of others will not be completely realised and that by the end of the 12 year period, Dublin will again be grossly under-represented compared with other parts of the country.

In the decision on the 1959 Bill, there was a general welcome by many Deputies because the Bill made very few changes as against the 1947 position. I believe that one reason for that is that once you get into a groove, be it a political or any other one, you do not want to be disturbed. Very few people like changing house and very few people like changing their beds. They prefer to stay as they are and hope for the best. That was a natural reaction and that was one of the reasons why the 1959 Bill was not more roundly attacked.

The constitutional provision is there because of the need to change constituencies. It is reasonable to expect that our population will move over a 12-year period, whether it be into the cities, out of the cities or otherwise. We may have large towns building up. There are hopes in regard to the Shannon estuary; we do not know, over the next 12 years, what proportion of the population may become resident around the Shannon development area. That is the kind of thing the constitutional provision is there to cater for, that when there are changes in the population, extra seats or fewer seats will be awarded as the circumstances require.

The condemnation of the 1959 Bill was not solely dependent upon its failure to respect a provision requiring equality. It was also because it had failed to make the changes necessary by reason of the movements in population. A movement of population is not a movement which is confined to any 12 year period. The movement in population which the Constitution requires us to respect is a movement at any time. We had the peculiar situation in which the population of Kerry, Donegal and Mayo had dropped considerably since 1922 and yet these areas had not lost one Deputy, whilst areas like Dublin and Cork city had received only about one-third of the extra representation to which they were entitled.

Whether we live in Dublin or in Cork, in Ballyfermot or Ballydehob, makes no difference. There is one golden rule which we all ought to respect, that all Irishmen are equal, that no Irishman has a right to any greater power than another and no Irishman should be made suffer any lesser power than his fellowman, unless it be economic. That is the simple rule enshrined in the Constitution, and it is the Constitution and the Constitution alone which condemned the Bill of 1959.

This Bill shows a regard not, if I may say so, for the judgment of the High Court—that is only a passing incident in our constitutional history— but for the constitutional provisions which were there long before Deputy Ryan was even thought of and long before even the Minister was in a position to gerrymander or, shall we say revise, the constituencies. It is the constitutional decision that the Irish people have made twice in their history, in 1922 and in 1937——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has said these things very many times. Repetition is not in order and the Deputy should come to the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It is only because of the necessity to underline these things that I have repeated myself. I apologise if I am doing so, but I am pointing out that the 1959 Bill was upset because of the decision of our people in 1922 and in 1937 and not because of any decision of any legal institutions in recent times. Deputy Booth referred to the unfortunate decision of the High Court. Is it not a sad day indeed when a member of this House says that a court makes an unfortunate decision when it obliges the Oireachtas to respect the Constitution? Let this be said here, as some people were only too glad to emphasise elsewhere: it was the Houses of the Oireachtas that were on trial in the High Court. There were 41 of us in this House who went into the lobbies and voted against the 1959 Bill, but unfortunately it is the Houses of the Oireachtas which passed that Bill. It shows a very serious dereliction of duty when a court can find the Act deserving of condemnation on each and every ground on which the plaintiff sought to have it declared unconstitutional. It shows that many members of this House either have never read the Constitution or, if they have read it, do not respect it.

In order to preserve the fundamental rights of all citizens, from the humblest to the most powerful, in order to make us all equal, whether we come from Ballyfermot or Ballydehob, the Bill of 1959 was declared unconstitutional and this Bill has been brought in. This one, of course, gerrymanders within the law. A great deal can be done within the law. The members of the Fianna Fáil Party ought to try it some time, instead of always trying to go outside the law. That is what this Bill tries to do but we say to the Fianna Fáil Party now: "Take this Bill. Go to the country on this Bill and we will beat you on it. The people defeated your efforts to change the electoral laws in 1959. As a member of our democratic structure defeated your effort to gerrymander in 1959, so will the people in 1961 reject the Fianna Fáil Party, and send them here with a minority equal to the majority they got by accident, or by default, in 1957."

They know that day is coming. They cannot postpone it with a Bill like this. They can try to soften the blow. They are a bruised and beaten Party and I do not blame them for wanting to soften the blow but they need not worry, the blows will ultimately get home. This Bill, although far from being what a fair Bill should be, is constitutional, and it certainly will not protect them from the wrath of the Irish people as soon as they give us a chance.

Comment on this

The Deputy who has just spoken is a great believer in the theory of one man one vote, and that all votes are equal. That is fair enough, provided the circumstances and the background are the same, but if a voter in the west of Ireland has greater difficulty in getting representation here through his Deputy, in contracting his Deputy to put his views before him, or in causing his views to be made known in Dáil Èireann, than the city voter, if you make each vote equal it does not, in the long run, achieve what you may have in mind.

In other words, if you follow that theory to its logical conclusion the same set of circumstances must be operating for the vote in Dublin as for the vote in Donegal or Kerry. I contend that it is more difficult for any group of people in Donegal or Kerry to have their views represented here, because they must travel to meet their Deputies, or their Deputies must travel to meet them. In that way an arrangement by which one vote in Dublin equals one vote in Donegal does not give fair representation. We have heard several speakers here today advocate that the matter should be put to the people by way of a referendum to obviate the difficulties which have cropped up on this occasion.

Comment on this

How many votes would the Deputy give to Donegal?

Comment on this

With regard to the revision of constituencies, Fine Gael want to have it their own way on every occasion. They opposed the proposal in the referendum to set up one-seat constituencies because they alleged that Fianna Fáil wanted to ensure a permanent overall majority at that time. During that debate it was pointed out that as a result of the revision of the constituencies in 1959, the Bill would operate to provide a large number of three-seat constituencies, and it was the belief of Deputies opposite that that was done because Fianna Fáil thought that in most three-seat constituencies they would have a majority.

We have now got away from that number. In the Bill we have a lesser number of three-seat constituencies, yet Fine Gael and the Opposition shout "gerrymandering". It sounds most illogical to me to try to put forward the same argument, whether one-seat, three-seat or four-seat constituencies have a preponderance in the Bill. The Minister can rest assured that no matter what type of division or rearrangement he attempted, it would be criticised, and criticised severely as this Bill has been criticised, especially by Fine Gael.

The previous speaker referred to the Minister's own constituency and the previous Minister for Local Government, Deputy O'Donnell, said that in his opinion there was gerrymandering in Donegal. That is not so. The Derry Sentinel referred to this Bill when it was circulated. They would be expected to, and I think they did, take an objective view of the Bill. A very fine article appeared in that paper pointing out that in their opinion the only result in Donegal would be that the Independents in Donegal would lose representation. They went on to say that the Bill was not of Fianna Fáil choosing but that no matter what lines were drawn in Donegal it would not affect the situation at all and that any other line drawn would have the same effect as this line will have.

Deputy O'Donnell suggested a line he had in mind. That line would not produce a result in the next election different from the result this line will produce. Everyone of us here, given a map, would, I presume, draw different lines to conform with that Article of the Constitution which indicates the population per Deputy. When a Minister is confronted with the building up of three-seat constituencies where the population at the moment does not warrant it, he must, if the population is 50,000, keep going until he gets 60,000. What determines where the line will be is where he arrives at the figure of 60,000 people.

The same will happen when he is trying to build up or maintain four-seat or five-seat constituencies. If county boundaries have to be ignored, as they have, I do not see why the Opposition should blame the Minister who is tied by considerations of mathematical accuracy. If you are trying to plan with a certain figure in mind, you must cross everything. If it is a local authority boundary for county council purposes you must cross it or you must cross county boundaries and Dáil constituency boundaries. That has been done.

To conform to the decision of the High Court, it was imperative that numbers rather than any other consideration should be the guiding principle. No matter what rearrangement takes place you will have changes in representation. No matter what Deputy or Minister produces a rearranged programme, some members will lose parts of their constituencies. For that reason, those who are affected beneficially like it and those who are adversely affected do not like it.

It is unfortunate that the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Dillon, set the tone of this debate by crying "Gerrymandering". It is a hateful word in the history of this country. It is unfortunate and unwarranted and it should not have been used.

Comment on this

I oppose this Bill on the ground that there has been a considerable amount of gerrymandering. We were promised the Bill two weeks before it saw the light of day. We have not heard any excuse for the delay. We know that every Fianna Fáil councillor in every constituency was consulted in connection with the drawing of the line.

Comment on this

That is absolutely untrue.

Comment on this

We all know it. It was all you were doing—fighting down the corridors.

Comment on this

I was not consulted.

Comment on this

There is no other excuse for the delay in producing the Bill. The draftsman did his job. He probably conformed to the requirements of the Constitution. When he had his job done, apparently the Fianna Fáil Party found it necessary to fiddle with figures to suit themselves. We have a few obvious cases where the boundary lines of constituencies have been altered to a considerable extent. There is no reason for it except to bring advantage to the Fianna Fáil Party.

If the Bill had been left as originally drafted, instead of presenting us with what we have now, there would be less for us to complain about. When this type of activity becomes obvious, it is up to us to make known to everybody that the Fianna Fáil Party are interested in preventing the people, so far as possible, from getting them out of office when the people try to get them out.

This is just one of a series of efforts by Fianna Fáil to prevent the people from having the voting strength and the power to put them out any time they wish to do so. A few years ago they wanted single-seat constituencies in the hope of abolishing all other political Parties in this House so far as they could. They failed in that, thanks to the people. However, it took the people to do it because Fianna Fáil steam-rolled the Bill through this House and said that the country would have it, whether or not the people liked it. However, the people had to be consulted and the people rejected it.

Fianna Fáil came to us with the 1959 Electoral (Amendment) Bill which again was unfair to the average elector. That Bill was found to be unconstitutional. Now we are faced with this Bill. On each occasion on which Fianna Fáil were compelled to bring in an Electoral (Amendment) Bill which would give equal strength to any vote whether cast in Cork, Kerry or Donegal, they tried to take a mean advantage and to organise the system in a manner to bring advantage to themselves and disadvantage to electors in certain areas.

This Bill was intended and designed I am sure to give equal voting strength and fair play to all citizens. Now we see some rearrangements in some constituencies which make it obvious that Fianna Fáil have reorganised the figures, having consulted their cumainn and local representatives. Take for instance, the County Dublin constituency which has been increased from three to five seats. Obviously, the reason for the increase is to ensure that the Minister for Defence will be elected at the coming election. At any time, he could be beaten two to one by Deputy P. J. Burke. His seat in County Dublin was, therefore, very much in danger.

The Minister for Defence stood for election on three occasions and was elected only on the last occasion when one of the outgoing Deputies did not contest the election again. The 1959 Electoral (Amendment) Bill left all the city vote inside the city boundary. When it became obvious that the Minister for Defence would be in danger at the next general election, Fianna Fáil decided to take approximately 10,000 votes from inside the city out into County Dublin. I refer to the area of Ballyfermot where the Minister was resident for a long time and where he personally campaigned actively. Therefore, he took that area out from the city and brought it into the county constituency.

Another situation is that Deputy Cosgrave was taken out of his constituency and is now living in my constituency. Deputy Cosgrave, who represents Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown, now finds himself residing outside a constituency which he has represented for so long. There are approximately 8,000 electors who will not have the opportunity of supporting him in the next general election. Instead, they will have to vote for a candidate in the Dublin county constituency. As I have said, under the Electoral Act of 1947 he lost a large slice of his constituency in the south and west. On this occasion he loses it on the south and east which leaves him completely cut off and without the opportunity of seeking support among his neighbours whom he has represented since 1944.

Reference has been made to the constituency of Waterford and to that of Tipperary. It seemed very obvious that the constituency of Waterford should have been left with four seats instead of the arrangement whereby nearly 30 miles of the Waterford area is taken into South Tipperary. This Bill ignores the census which took place on Sunday last. When constituencies are being revised, attention must be given to the last census figures. If Fianna Fáil had gone about this business straight and fair in 1959 we should have had the constituencies reorganised and rearranged by now. Instead of that, they spent a year trying to take the proportional representation system away from the people and giving them a single-seat system instead.

In 1959, 12 years had elapsed since the previous revision and the constituencies, by law, should have been revised by 1959. It was Fianna Fáil's duty to do that. When it came to the 1959 revision, instead of bringing in a plan of reorganisation under the proportional representation system, they brought in a new system which they tried to put over on the people. They failed in that effort. Now the opportunity to rearrange the constituencies has passed and we are here in 1961, 14 years after the 1947 revision, arguing about the lines to be drawn in the various areas for the new constituencies. I consider that we should have waited a few months for the census figures of last Sunday to be made out so that the revision of the constituencies could take place on those figures.

I am satisfied that Dublin city and county would be entitled to at least one more seat if the new figures were known. We all know that the population of Dublin city is increasing at the rate of 15 souls per day—something like 100 per week. That increase is due mainly to people coming into the city; we must take it that a large proportion of those 15 souls come into the city from some part of the country. Those people are entitled to equal representation, no matter what part of the country they may have come from. When the census figures for Dublin city and county become known we shall surely find we have not given to either area its proper representation; we shall find that both Dublin city and council will be under-represented in the Dáil in relation to the new figures.

I was impressed by some of the arguments put up by previous speakers. Deputy Norton made a very good point regarding the taking into his constituency of parts of two other counties. I agree with him that that arrangement was not justified. Deputy Faulkner referred to the fact that the town of Ardee was being taken out of Louth and put into Monaghan. He seemed to repeat the case he made in the High Court which brought defeat to the result that he wanted. He said that Louth was the finest example of prosperity brought about by Fianna Fáil in any county. I know his constituency as well as he does and I know there was mass unemployment in Dundalk when the railway works were closed down there.

Comment on this

What about when the Deputy's Party closed down Inchicore?

Comment on this

One would think from Deputy Faulkner's speech that he did not live in his constituency, that he did not read the Drogheda Independent or the Dundalk paper which published large reports of unemployment in both those towns. He need not set up Louth as an example. If there is any credit for prosperity in those towns, it is due entirely to the enterprising businessmen of those towns who were engaged in the export industry. Thanks to the Sweetman plan of tax remission——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The relevance of those remarks escapes me.

Comment on this

It was relevant for Deputy Faulkner.

Comment on this

The point I am making is that they have taken Ardee out of Louth and put it into Monaghan, and that anything Deputy Faulkner has said does not provide justification for that action. I consider there is no justification for it. We have heard some rural Deputies speak about the representation in Dublin city and county. I would again remind them that the people in Dublin city have come from all over Ireland and when the people of Dublin city and county speak, it is with the voice of the whole country, all gathered in one community. I forecast a situation in the future where it will be necessary in each 12-year period to have the position of the constituencies rearranged in accordance with the census figures so that we shall be acting in accordance with population trends. We may have a greater number of people leaving the rural areas for the towns and cities. Their vote must follow them. That is the benefit of a revision of the constituencies.

It would be unfair to the people of the country for the Minister to ask the House to accept the Bill in its present form. Obviously, it is designed to give an advantage to the Fianna Fáil Party and to prevent the people who want to remove the Government from doing so. I suggest that, even at this late stage, the Minister should set up an all-Party committee of the House and go into this arrangement of the constituencies again. I think he could be sure of being met fairly by every Deputy, whether of his own Party or of the other political Parties. There are a few examples of revision in this Bill crying out for remedy and crying out for fair play and justice to the people concerned, who are being taken out of constituencies and put into others to which they do not rightly belong. Instead of waiting for amendments to come along, the Minister should set up such an all-Party committee.

Some of the speakers opposite tried to tell us that the 1959 Bill was an agreed measure. It was opposed by the Opposition at that time. If the Government consider that an agreed measure would be best, then an all-Party committee would be the remedy. The Minister should let us know if he would be prepared to accept such a committee.

Comment on this

The Opposition to this Bill can be summed up in a few words: "Suspicion haunts the guilty mind." There is no doubt if the Fine Gael Party had the drafting of this Bill, they would gerrymander. Knowing their own faults so well and knowing they are always prepared to take advantage of any fault in any Bill, any referendum or anything else, they are attributing to Fianna Fáil something that is untrue. They cannot have it both ways. When they opposed the single-seat constituency, they gave as their reason that they wanted rural Ireland to have greater representation. They were afraid that Dublin and Cork might get greater representation. Today we hear a completely different story. They want more representation for Dublin city. Deputy Rooney let the cat out of the bag. It is not the first time the cat escaped from Deputy Rooney. It is another indication of how little discipline there is in the Fine Gael Party. A year and a half ago, the Fine Gael Party agreed to what is known as the 1959 Bill.

Comment on this

They voted against it.

Comment on this

You were delighted when you saw the final text of it because some of you were afraid of your lives there might be changes detrimental to your future interests.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence did not like it.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Rooney is now very uneasy at the thought of Deputy Cosgrave hovering around his area. No wonder he would be uneasy. I should be very worried myself if a young and intelligent Deputy like Deputy Cosgrave were in my Party——

Comment on this

There is no danger of having a young and intelligent Deputy in your Party.

Comment on this

Deputy Rooney gave no other reasons for opposing the Bill than that there was a danger of losing his own political identity. We have heard the word "gerrymander". As Deputy Cunningham said it is a word that should not be used here to any appreciable extent. Fine Gael are attributing to their fellow Irishmen in the South the system responsible for Partition. The people who use that word ought to be ashamed of themselves and should stop using it. There is no gerrymandering in this Bill.

Comment on this

Of course, there is.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister has no personal animosity against me. Deputy Sweetman has been studying form, apparently, and he knows Gortnahoe is gone. If there were a few more Gortnahoes in Ireland, Fine Gael would never be heard of again. They would scuttle out of the country as quickly as they scuttled out of government in 1957.

Comment on this

The Deputy may be scuttled out after the election.

Comment on this

That could happen. It would be the will of the people.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy reluctantly agreed, the same as Deputy Loughman.

Comment on this

If the people decide, I shall be happy. Deputy Sweetman will have to travel faster, too. He was very near losing his seat the last time. I was never as near as that and I hope I shall not be in the future.

Comment on this

He was not making promises.

Comment on this

It is because we do not make promises that we get the people's confidence. That is why we are here with such a majority, and the next Dáil will show a greater majority for Fianna Fáil. Deputy Rooney will be looking around for dual purpose hens and feeding them with tomatoes. I would advise him to do that rather than criticise a Bill about which he knows little. The Minister has no personal animosity against me, but, as Deputy Sweetman says, it is quite on the cards that I will be the victim of the rearrangement of townlands.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy knows why? Because the Deputy happens to have as a colleague the assistant Whip of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

There are no pets in this Party. Ability counts here. When I look at some of the members of the Coalition Governments, I would say it is not ability that counted in their case. The lawyers were here up to a few minutes ago. There were four out of eight. They were responsible for all this rearrangement of the constituencies but now they are trying to hide behind poor Senator O'Donovan. Deputy Ryan is trying to claim all the credit. I wonder was the matter brought before the High Court with the authority of the Fine Gael Party?

Comment on this

To uphold the Constitution.

Comment on this

It would be about time you thought of doing it.

Comment on this

We did it at a time that you did not.

Comment on this

I wonder did they——

Comment on this

I know.

Comment on this

I wonder did the Fine Gael Party condone the action of Senator O'Donovan, Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Ryan?

Comment on this

We always uphold the Constitution.

Comment on this

You have not said that. You cannot ride two horses. You either did or did not and if you did, why pretend for over a year that you were accepting the 1959 Bill?

Comment on this

We voted against it.

Comment on this

It shows the country quite clearly what they can expect from the Fine Gael Party in the future, as in the past. Deputy Sweetman is a past master at interrupting.

Comment on this

Who?

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy acknowledges it.

Comment on this

The Minister has nothing personal against me.

Comment on this

He might.

Comment on this

I am quite sure he has not and I have the greatest sympathy with him in trying to adhere to——

Comment on this

The Constitution.

Comment on this

——what would be an unanswerable case in the courts if the Fine Gael Party were officially or unofficially to bring it before the High Court again. Perhaps here or there you will find certain Deputies who will gain. I cannot say that, but I can say that there was no other method open to him in Tipperary South except what he did. It is unfortunate for me but I cannot grumble. It is about time that the Fine Gael Party now said whether or not they were responsible for bringing the High Court action. It often strikes me that people are trying to ride two horses. That is what the Fine Gael Party are trying to do now. You are ashamed to say you did——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is constantly using the second person. He should use the third person.

Comment on this

I am so fond of Deputy Sweetman, you will forgive me, Sir.

Comment on this

You should be very concerned about the third person in South Tipperary.

Comment on this

We have the old Coalition again. Look at the way Deputy Corish will stand up for them when they are on their own tails again.

Comment on this

He is a constitution-alist too.

Comment on this

Although Deputy Corish pretends there will never be a Coalition again, and his instructions are there will not be, still when he sees that they are getting it hot and are asked a straight question, he has to draw a red herring across the track. He can make his mind easy; the third person will be elected.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Davern is the one who will not be.

Comment on this

The Deputy might be right. He will not shed any tears and I am sure Deputy Sweetman will not.

Comment on this

I should be very disappointed if I had not the Deputy to interrupt now and again.

Comment on this

You will have to make up your minds on which side you are now. It is about time you did.

Comment on this

The Chair is not supposed to be on any side.

Comment on this

It is about time the Fine Gael Party did make up their minds and apologised to the people for the enormous taxation and cost they have again put on them. It is reminiscent of the Sinn Féin Funds. This is not the first time that the Fine Gael Party were responsible for extra taxation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not seem to be relevant to this measure.

Comment on this

It does not seem to be true either but you would not mind that.

Comment on this

The legal luminaries have been the curse of this country and when they formed the first Coalition they were the greatest curse since Cromwell. It is about time they answered that question.

Comment on this

Which one?

Comment on this

It is about time they got off the fence and stated whether the action in the High Court was of their making——

Comment on this

What was wrong with the action in the High Court?

Comment on this

——or whether it is their secret methods again; whether they do not agree with what their colleagues did. If that inconsistency is there the Fine Gael Party are damned for ever.

Comment on this

The majority has no right to do wrong.

Comment on this

In regard to my constituency of Cork City I feel that the Minister, for various reasons, has undoubtedly made a very bad job of it. Whatever may happen to Deputy Davern or Deputy Sweetman as a result of the introduction of this Bill, I feel it is not the Deputy that matters. You can always find another Deputy and possibly a better one. The thing that matters is the electorate. The person to be thought of is the citizen and the spirit and the letter of the Constitution was that the citizen should be given the best possible representation. That is the attitude of mind which the Minister should adopt when he is approaching a Bill of this nature. He should give to rural constituencies rural Deputies; he should give to urban constituencies, in so far as he can, urban Deputies.

We find in regard to Cork City that he has taken from the present constituency approximately 9,999 votes in the Blackrock area. In passing, I think that the original explanatory memorandum issued in regard to this Bill is misleading inasmuch as it indicated that the electoral division of Blackrock is being returned to the Cork county constituency. I may be wrong but I can never remember an occasion when the electoral division of Blackrock was in the county. If it was then, it was an amazing anomaly, because the electoral division comes to Victoria Street, which is about one to one and a half minutes walk from the City Hall. It also comes to High Street which is three minutes walk from the City Hall. Certainly 99 per cent. of the people who reside in the electoral division of Blackrock work in the city and regard themselves as city folk.

The city bus services serve every portion of that division. It is in every way, except for the purpose of local government, a part, if not the most important part, of the city. The Minister has taken that away and given it to the new constituency of Mid-Cork and by way of consolation prize he has given Cork city the division of Rathcooney which is purely rural. Rathcooney runs to a distance of eight or nine miles from the City Hall and it has always been looked upon as an electoral division which is obviously rural and it should continue to be rural. I appeal to the Minister to have second thoughts about recasting these constituencies. I know he has difficulties but he is not doing the best possible job in this Bill. He is not giving Cork city the proper type of representation. If he asks Deputies of his own party I think he will find that is true.

There may be reasons why constituencies have been recast and for the manner in which it is being done but none of them is valid from the point of view of giving the best possible representation. It may be purely a coincidence that if this Bill goes through the two Opposition Deputies for Cork City will both find themselves outside their own constituencies while the three Fianna Fáil representatives will find themselves inside their constituencies. It may also be a coinsidence that Deputy Manley, who sits next to me here, representing South Cork will find himself in Cork city. This is a ridiculous situation and it should not be allowed to go on to the Statute Book. I ask the Minister now to reinvestigate the matter and try to give more appropriate representation to the residents of Blackrock division.

Comment on this

Four years ago the present Fianna Fáil Government were elected and since then their record in relation to electoral laws has been unique. They began in 1958, when they should have been attending to their economic business, trying to find out how they could carve up the country so as to ensure they would be retained in office when an outraged electorate got an opportunity of voting them out. When they should have been attending to Government business, they were trapesing up and down the country trying to abolish proportional representation and we lost—probably forever—the differential of 10 per cent. that we had on our pigs and bacon exports to the Danes because the Government were asleep in regard to that side of our business. They were too busy trying to ensure that with the abolition of P.R. they would find themselves secure. The people defeated them on that issue notwithstanding that they had the bait of having their leader as Presidential candidate at that time. He very nearly went the same way as a result of the outrage the people felt at the attempt to change the system of voting for purely Party purposes.

The Fianna Fáil Party made a second effort in the Electoral Act of 1959 and their own rules—they were the people who introduced the present Constitution—when the referee blew the whistle, proved them to be fouling. Now they are upset and annoyed because they are not allowed to override the rules they themselves laid down, not allowed to set at nought the Constitution and the principles they themselves put in writing. It is the same old story of Fianna Fáil—every condition, every rule, every Act is perfectly all right so long as it suits Fianna Fáil but, the moment it does not suit them, it goes out the window and they try to get away with something else and make it suit themselves. We have seen that over the years. Now they are whining and crying because they were caught out.

Here, they come along with a third effort. Deputy Davern takes great exception to the use of the word "gerrymandering." What is its origin? It was called gerrymandering because the shape of the constituency was in the form of a most peculiar shape of bird. If one were to consider only personalities—but it is not a question only of personalities, as Deputy Barrett said— I should be delighted to have an addition to County Kildare but if you look at that on the map and if you then take up the pamphlet issued by the All-party Committee on Partition some years ago and see what they gave as the typical example of gerry-mandering—the bird—you will find exactly the same shape as we now have in Westmeath, Meath and Kildare. We even have the bill coming right down in exactly the same way. Yet Deputy Davern objects to the use of the word "gerrymandering." Of course, it was done.

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare has left the House but we know why that bit of Westmeath was cut off. It was because he did not like one of the Labour county councillors in that area because he was becoming too strong. That was deliberately cut off and they also deliberately cut the tail off Deputy Fagan's constituency just on one side of his house. They did the same on the other side to Senator Sheridan and Deputy Giles' house is to be the last house in the constituency.

Comment on this

They took me out.

Comment on this

All of us get our strength naturally enough from the areas around us and they deliberately left his as the last house and took him into my county. I am glad to have him. They did it deliberately, cut it down the middle.

Travelling from that up to Donegal we find that the old divisions of east and west were changed into north-east and south-west deliberately, to suit the Minister for Local Government on the one hand and to get Deputy Sheldon out on the other. Deputy Cunningham was honest enough to admit that was the purpose and that would be the result of the Bill in Donegal—to get rid of Deputy Sheldon. A few cats have been let out of bags in this debate.

We all know why Louth was dealt with as it has been. Deputy Faulkner had to come in and put a brave face on it but it was necessary, when pieces were being taken off Louth, to come right down into the county, to cut out its whole middle, so to speak, right down to within five miles of Deputy Faulkner's own house. Why? Because Fianna Fáil are in danger of having only one seat there after the next election and it had to be made certain that that seat would be left for the Minister for External Affairs in case Deputy Faulkner might beat him otherwise.

Deputy Davern does not yet seem to have realised that it was because Deputy Loughman is assistant Whip of the Fianna Fáil Party that a "skelp" had to be taken out of Waterford and built on to Clonmel to try to bolster up Deputy Loughman. Wherever you look, you will see that this Bill has been deliberately framed for the benefit of Ministers, Parliamentary Secretaries and Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party where there was any danger for them. Pontoon and Straide were taken from North Mayo and put with the South for the benefit of the Minister for Lands. Ballaghaderreen was brought in from Roscommon to South Mayo because it was the old living place of Deputy Séan Flanagan. In Sligo-Leitrim, because we beat Fianna Fáil there the other day, the whole heart had been torn out of Leitrim. You can go up and down the country and see the same thing wherever you go. It makes no difference so far as a Party may be concerned because, if the votes are taken out of one area they are in another, but it does make a difference for individuals. It is in order to protect certain individuals in Fianna Fáil that this Bill has been designed in this way.

Deputy Barrett spoke about what is being done in Cork city. I do not know whether it is because Deputy MacCarthy felt himself in danger in Cork that they took the Blackrock area out of the city and put it into mid-Cork. It is an entirely unnatural revision to take a suburban area out of a city constituency and to take a rural area which has no real roots in the city, or its suburbs, and put it into the city constituency. That is what is being done in Cork city. Three years ago, Fianna Fáil tried to keep themselves in office by the abolition of P. R. The people beat them. Last year they had a Bill, with a similar aim. The courts beat them there by making them keep their own rules. This year they are trying once again to gerrymander but in the next general election it is the people who will beat them, and beat them hollow.

Comment on this

This Bill has been introduced in rather peculiar circumstances. It has been introduced in consequence of a decision of Mr. Justice Budd. It is astonishing that the Government, in the dilemma in which they found themselves, did not have recourse to some alternative means of rectifying the position that arose as a result of the decision of the High Court. It was open to them to appeal to the Supreme Court. I do not presume to have any knowledge of the law, but I thought the decision of Mr. Justice Budd a rather challenging one: he asked that the matter should go to the Supreme Court. That was never done. He must have had serious grounds and it is rather surprising that the Government did not there and then appeal to the Supreme Court. I wonder had they some foreknowledge that the decision would be upheld in the Supreme Court?

If the 1959 Bill is unconstitutional, is it not pertinent to ask whether the various Dála set up here in recent years were legally constituted? I believe that if all the Bills which revised the constituencies had been brought before the court they would have been found to be just as unconstitutional as the 1959 Bill. I wonder did the Government go about righting the wrong done in the right way? There was nothing to stop them amending the Constitution. That would have been the most practicable way of dealing with the situation. This measure pinpoints the necessity and importance of the Constitution where electoral Bills are concerned. I think the position should have been remedied in 1960 or in 1961, instead of leaving it to some later date.

Is it not obvious from this tabular statement issued by the Minister's Department that there are 17 constituencies with 66 Deputies, who individually represent, on an average, fewer than 20,000 people. In 21 constituencies, there are 78 Deputies representing individually, on an average, over 20,000 people. There is still a disproportion, no matter what this Bill purports to do in regard to the ratio of representation. Again, electoral divisions framed on the old poor law and dispensary areas are obsolete. There is grave need for a new approach. It was suggested very sensibly this evening that a joint committee should be set up to examine into this question of electoral divisions and to bring them up to date.

There is one particularly regrettable feature in the chopping up of some counties. We cannot complain on that score in Cork, but some counties have been ruthlessly chopped in order to get the necessary proportion. The county is the administrative unit, so far as local authority goes. There is invariably a certain rivalry between counties. There is a certain clannishness in counties, to the extent very often that people in one county will not vote for someone from a neighbouring county or another county. That is a grave danger in this Bill. I would much prefer to cut down representation and leave the county as the unit. I would regard that as more practicable in the long run.

There is another regrettable feature. There is an increase of four Deputies in Dublin city and county. We appreciate the population of this area is 705,007 or practically 25 per cent of the population of the Twenty-Six Counties. It is much easier for a Deputy in Dublin to represent 30,000 people than it is for a Deputy in Connemara to represent 10,000 people. No matter what the Constitution says, I do not thinks we are approaching this problem in a practical way. It should be possible for a Deputy adequately to represent 30,000 constituents in an urban area like Dublin. There would then be no need to give these extra seats to Dublin. I would be the last to try to cause any rift between Dublin Deputies and rural Deputies. The Dublin Deputy has, however, many advantages. He can do his day's work and then come in here. The rural Deputy must stay away from his home and business for two or three days at a time. There should be some compensation for these rural Deputies as against those who are centrally situated.

I have very radical views about representation. I believe there is over-representation here. When the Act of Union was passed in 1800, the representation given in the British House of Commons was 100 and the population then was double, if not treble, what it is in the Twenty-Six Counties today. I believe we are being over-generous with Dublin. I do not want to cause ill-feeling but we must be realistic and must appreciate the inconvenience rural Deputies have to face as against those centrally situated in their urban constituencies.

Deputy Barrett referred to the changes made in Cork city constituency. As in the case of the counties which have been chopped up, geographical considerations were entirely disregarded. Nobody could condone the change made in Cork city where a purely urban area was taken out of Cork city and put into a rural constituency. It may serve the members in that constituency but it is not the practical and sensible way of dealing with it because the people in that area have nothing at all in common with the people in the rural constituency of mid-Cork.

Deputy Barrett mentioned that the buses run to all parts of the Blackrock area. So also did the old electric trams in Cork. Deputy MacCarthy or any of the Cork city Deputies will readily admit that. It was most incongruous and most anomalous that should be done. Rathcooney is a purely rural area which, as Deputy Barrett said, is eight or nine miles from the centre of the city of Cork. That is being brought into the city constituency. At least the Minister should make some effort to make an alteration in that in order to bring about some kind of harmony between the type of representative and the needs of the people who elect that representative. There is nothing at all in common between the Blackrock area—it was purely a city area at all times and has been from time immemorial—and Rathcooney which is a purely rural area. I think that is entirely incongruous.

Another reason why it is rather tragic to chop some of the counties— I sympathise with those who have been divided—concerns the health administration which is now a very important activity in every county. It is very awkward for the people who are brought from an outside county into another county. In so far as local affairs are concerned, they will go to their own local authorities, but in so far as national affairs are concerned, they will have to go to a man outside their county altogether. It is a bit awkward for them.

These are the only remarks I wish to make. I am making them from a national point of view and not for any personal reason whatever. Like Deputy Barrett, I agree that it is not the Deputy who matters but the people. They should be given the fairest representation. That should be the motive. I do not know why the Minister in some cases made the changes he made. I do not know what motivated him to make these changes. We cannot interpret the Minister's mind in that respect. At all events, the decision in Cork city is rather peculiar. I think it could very easily be remedied. There are certain other areas on the outskirts which could go into the constituency of mid-Cork and thus leave Blackrock where it has been from time immemorial.

Comment on this

It was suggested by a number of speakers that an all-Party committee should be set up to deal with this very contentious matter. Whilst it would be over-optimistic to expect that an all-Party committee would agree 100 per cent. in a matter such as this, I feel that that suggestion merits at least some attention. In passing, I might add that if other matters were referred to all-Party committees, irrespective of their nature, more progress would be made in this House.

Coming from County Louth, I should like to assure the Minister that, whilst I sympathise with his position to a certain extent, the people in County Louth area affected, an area which will be put into County Monaghan, are very resentful of the intentions of this Bill. Various opinions were expressed by both Fianna Fáil supporters and Fine Gael supporters. They all resent being put into a separate county, being detached from their existing native county of Louth and put into Monaghan.

Earlier this evening, Deputy Faulkner pointed out that County Louth was a constituency which had enjoyed all down the years since the foundation of this State its own natural boundaries. Admittedly, there were years ago two constituencies in that small county, North and South Louth, but, as a county, its boundaries were always respected. I think it is a very retrograde step for the Minister at this stage to tamper with our boundaries.

I should like to comment in that respect that the decision of the High Court judge in the recent court case did not suggest in any shape or form, as far as I can recall, that boundaries as such should be tampered with. Certain suggestions were made by Mr. Justice Budd. I do not think he mentioned or even encouraged that county boundaries as such should be touched. Then, again, we have the anomalous position facing us, if this Bill is passed, that people, in one area in my county anyhow, will be voting for a man in the Dáil election who possibly may not be a County Louth man. As Deputy Manley said, when the local government elections take place they will have to vote for one of their local men. I think it is fraught with great danger in so far as there will be much confusion. More serious still is the danger that most people may not vote in future elections to the same extent when they discover that they will not have the chance to vote for a county man. They will be expected to vote for a man who is not one of their own.

This Bill intends to cut off the whole town of Ardee which is a very prosperous and up and coming town. In addition to that, a large slice of a rural area is also due to be put into County Monaghan. I think it is a very retrograde step.

One point puzzles me very much. Last Sunday night a census was taken. I cannot understand why the Government are not prepared to await the result of that census. The allocation of population to Deputies is being based in this Bill on the census taken in 1956. When the result of the present census is known it will undoubtedly disclose that the population of this country has diminished, if not considerably, at least to a fair extent. We will be faced with the unusual position of allocating 20,000 people to a T.D. in 1961 and that position will obtain for the next 12 years, because as we know, the revision of constituencies must take place within at least 12 years.

We are going to pass a Bill on a census which is five years out of date. That is all the more surprising when we remember that a new census is being compiled. I cannot see why we cannot afford to wait a few months until we get the new population figures. If we had those figures, it might mean that we would not have to interfere with county boundaries now. It might result in a reduced number of Deputies but that might not be a bad idea, either. I think the Government would be well advised to await the result of the current census which should be out in a few months time.

The pattern all down the years has been to allocate approximately 20,000 people to one T. D. As Deputy Manley suggests, would it not be better and more equitable to move up the scale a bit and concentrate on hovering around the 30,000 mark? Again, that might mean that slices of one county would not necessarily have to be put into another county to make up the difference in that county. These points merit consideration by the Government.

Many references were made by Deputies to the court decision given recently in respect of Senator O'Donovan's action. Either the court decision was right or it was wrong. There is no via media. If the Government think that the court decision was wrong, why are they not appealing against it? If they do not appeal against it, it is to be presumed that they are in agreement with the decision that the Electoral Act of 1959 was repugnant to the Constitution and that, therefore, Senator O'Donovan was quite right in making known that fact. The Government cannot have it both ways. They should either appeal against the court decision or state honestly and categorically that they accept the court's decision, that they acknowledge their mistake and that they will abide by the court decision.

As Deputy Sweetman pointed out, the people, in 1958, rejected the attempt by the Government to foist single member constituencies on the country. They rejected it in no uncertain terms. Again, the court defeated the Government recently. I am confident that, irrespective of the Government's measure now, the people will rally around the Fine Gael Party. Speaking personally for County Louth, I have every confidence and every hope that they will turn once more to the Fine Gael Deputies.

Comment on this

This is an ordinary piece of gerrymandering which, unfortunately, we have to discuss in the sort of academic atmosphere of the Constitution. It is, clearly, the third effort of a gerrymandering type to retain power for a Party that is on the way out. That was recognised in most places when the action which ended against the Government, or against the Attorney General, was being discussed. Everywhere that action was discussed during its progress say, at the inconveniently-placed bus stops in O'Connell Street or in the public-houses, whether open under the old licensing law or under the new, or wherever teachers, Army men, civil servants or guards gathered together to discuss their own peculiar depressions, the ordinary comment made about Senator O'Donovan's case was that it was a great effort on the part of the Government for a shocking piece of gerrymandering and they were caught out and were exposed completely, as they deserved to be.

Notwithstanding that, Deputies have rolled into this House this evening to talk about this in terms of principle. Deputy Faulkner said that the 1959 Act which was repealed by the High Court as being unconstitutional was an agreed measure. It was nothing of the sort. I interrupted to say that there was a division. He parried that by saying: "Yes; some small points were divided on on Committee Stage." There was a division on the Fifth Stage, the last Stage of the Bill. It was after I personally had made an intervention to indicate a point of view that the measure was in many respects unconstitutional.

On the Fifth Stage, there were about six speakers. On that occasion, one only supported the Minister, and he was Deputy Booth. Others had views that were more consonant with the views I expressed than with the views expressed by Deputy Booth and the Minister on behalf of the Government. In the end, there was a vote for or against the measure and it did not leave this House as an agreed piece of legislation. It was not so. It was objected to at the beginning. There was an effort made to see could some betterment be made in it on Committee Stage and when that failed the Party I belong to, joined by the Labour Party, Deputy McQuillan and Deputy Sherwin, all voted against the measure as a whole without paying any attention to the details of it.

On that particular occasion, as I say, I indicated various points of view and I will come back to these at a later stage. I want to get rid of one misconception that appears to prevail through the House, that is, that the Electoral Act of 1959 was drafted with a view to giving the rural areas better representation. The phrase that was used continually throughout that debate—and I used it myself— was that the Minister expressed the attitude that he should approach the revision of the constituencies with a rural bias. He denied that.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give the reference?

Comment on this

I am going to give the reference—column 235 of the Dáil Debates of 19th November, 1959. He said:

There is one argument that has been used here or rather—should I say?—misused. It was stated several times by many Deputies that I said that there was a rural bias in this Bill but what I said in my speech on Second Reading was that there may appear to be a rural bias so far as the provisions of the Bill were concerned. If viewed in a purely statistical light "there may appear to be" as distinct from "there is". I just want to correct that misuse...

So far as the Minister is concerned, he put himself on record here as disclaiming any effort to approach this question with a rural bias and I hope we will hear less of that when the new measure comes to be discussed in the election that will be, I hope, held on the amending measure before us tonight.

I personally want to go back on the Minister's phrase. I think he did say that he thought there should be a rural bias in dividing out the constituencies but I know that when he was in the witness box on oath, he denied that he said that. I want to put in contrast the phrase he did use here in Dáil Éireann and the phrase he used before a court when we were not permitted to bring in the Dáil Debates to show what he had said when speaking on this measure. Whether there was rural bias or not in the Minister's approach rural bias is not allowed under the Constitution, and that is what the judge declared.

Comments have been made here as to the new piece of legislation about hurling bricks at county boundaries, how it fragments boundaries, how you have pieces of one county shoved on to another and pieces of another county tacked on to the bottom of another, and so on. There is a great deal of clamour in regard to political life that the county boundaries are there, that they govern local authority business, that local authority business and public business of the Parliamentary type often run together and that it would be very convenient that the county boundaries should not be broken when one comes to deal with the National Assembly. These are all great points of view—rural bias, keeping the county boundaries as they are, not fragmenting counties, not breaking up counties, not having people in one county area put into another one. They are all great views but they were not made a prominent matter when the Constitution was being passed and they are not in the Constitution. The people who lament now the fact that these standards cannot be used must look back on their own past and blame themselves for not being viligant enough to see that these standards were embodied in the great Constitution of 1937. It was plainly recognised that the county boundary was not a standard in the Constitution. The standard was, as I described it on the Fifth Stage of the 1959 Bill a purely statistical one to be found in Article 16 which was under investigation by the courts in the recent action.

Those who appeared for the Attorney General used every method of obstruction that court procedure allows in order to prevent the true picture being put before the judge who determined this matter in the courts. One of the matters it was sought to bring in before the judge was the Third Amendment of the Constitution which was deemed to have been passed by both Houses and then failed to get the required vote at the plebiscite. It involved a constitutional amendment, in fact, involved several, and one of them was this:

As soon as may be after the receipt of the request from the President the Commission shall proceed to determine or to revise the boundaries of the constituencies on a fair and equitable basis having due regard to geographical features and established administrative and territorial divisions and, subject to these considerations, in such manner that the population of each constituency, as ascertained at the last preceding census, shall, so far as it is practicable, be the same throughout the country.

This was an amendment to the Constitution. Article 16 simply says:

The ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency, and the population of each constituency... shall, so far as it is practicable, be the same throughout the country.

In the amendment which was defeated on referendum, there was an attempt to bring in a constitutional provision that when determining constituencies, the Commission should look at geographical features, established administrative and territorial divisions. Their general direction was to divide on a fair and equitable basis and, all those things being considered, then to come to the final matter which is in the Constitution, to divide in such a way that the population of each constituency, as ascertained at the last preceding census would, so far as practicable, be the same throughout the country. It was recognised when the referendum matter was being considered that these words were not in Article 16, that it was sought to put them in. Then the futile argument was made in court that it had to be assumed that these words were there and the judge was not allowed to have this brought to his notice through legal procedure.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I would be slow to impute this to the Deputy but it does seem to me that he is implying that the ordinary procedure adopted by the court in relation to the matter he is now discussing constituted obstruction of the judge. The judge gave a ruling in this matter and I take it it was a good ruling.

Comment on this

The judge was obstructed.

Comment on this

The judge made the decision.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I take it Deputy McGilligan is entitled to refer to the court procedure.

Comment on this

I am referring not merely to court procedure; I am referring to misuse of court procedure by those who appeared for the Attorney General.

Comment on this

I think it is wrong— and Deputy McGilligan should know this much better than I do—that the procedure adopted in court over which a learned judge presided should be described in this House as a misuse of the procedure of the court. That should not be allowed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Surely the Chair should not be asked to give a ruling on that question, whether the procedure was correct or incorrect.

Comment on this

Those who appeared for the Attorney General could have allowed this matter to come before the court. Why did they not allow it?

Comment on this

That is a different matter from what the Deputy has just raised.

Comment on this

Why would they not allow it? For the same reason as the Minister is objecting in this House: they wanted to hide it. There was obstruction in court as there is obstruction here.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan is having a slap at the Judiciary, just as he did previously in this House on a similar matter.

Comment on this

If there be any suspicion that I am having a slap, open or sub rosa, at the judge, I want to disclaim that. I am having a slap, and I mean to have a slap, at those who appeared for the Attorney General, advised by him on their procedure. They would not allow this matter to be brought into court.

Comment on this

Was it not the judge who decided, in the last analysis, whether it should be brought into court or not?

Comment on this

He decided it should not.

Comment on this

Why blame the Attorney General?

Comment on this

I am blaming the Attorney General because he would not let that be brought before the court. I am bringing it before the public now. I am entitled to speak of it now.

Comment on this

It was ruled out of order by the judge.

Comment on this

And I am bringing it into order here because it was ruled out of order by the judge.

Comment on this

So the judge was wrong?

Comment on this

I say the Attorney General was wrong. The procedure was there to be availed of and the Attorney General took refuge behind it. I want to explain what happened.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

May I point out to Deputy McGilligan that we are getting away from the Bill?

Comment on this

I am trying to keep to the Bill.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is now arguing the whole court case again.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not seem to be relevant.

Comment on this

The constitutional case was argued on Article 16 of the Constitution which, as I said on the Fifth Reading on 19th November, 1959, contained only one standard, a statistical one, that the constituencies were fixed so that there should be not less than one member for each 30,000 of the population and not more than one member for each 20,000; secondly, that the ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency, and the population of each constituency, as ascertained at the last preceding census should, so far as practicable, be the same throughout the country.

In this House it has been asked: why should we break up county boundaries? The answer is that the Constitution does not say they should be observed. I am arguing that that must have been known to the Minister's advisers because at an earlier stage they had tried to amend the Constitution and referred to territorial and established administrative divisions, geographical features, and all the rest. There is much worse than that in this piece of legislation which was deemed to have passed both Houses. There is anxiety here that nobody should criticise the judges, that judges should have a free hand to decide constitutional questions. What did this propose:

No Court shall entertain any question as to whether the Commission shall have been properly constituted or any question as to whether the determination or revision of boundaries of constituencies set out in the report has been properly carried out.

Comment on this

What personage was going to preside over that Commission?

Comment on this

A judge. Because there was one judge there, you could not go to court to raise the question as to whether the determination or revision of boundaries had been properly carried out. That certainly was a great effort to stop the courts from looking in on what this Commission did. Again, successfully, the advisers of the Attorney General kept that from the knowledge of Mr. Justice Budd when he was trying the recent case.

Comment on this

The judge ruled it out of order and well the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

The judge was bound by court procedure on an objection taken by a party.

Comment on this

Having considered it.

Comment on this

The objection was taken by a party but objection cannot be taken by that party here. I want to raise the point that the objection was taken.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not blame the Attorney General for something the judge ruled in court.

Comment on this

The judge ruled because the Attorney General asked him to do so.

Comment on this

It was because he probably thought it was correct that he so ruled.

Comment on this

The judge ruled it out when he was asked to rule it out.

Comment on this

Even though it may be wrong?

Comment on this

In the witness box, the Minister was asked if there was a map in his Department which was prepared in the time of his predecessor, and whether that map was extant. He said there was a map and that it was extant, and then he immediately claimed privilege for it. He did not want to have it known in the court how civil servants acted under different Ministers. The divisions of the constituencies were produced entirely from the gerrymandering proposals in the present Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy is codding no one.

Comment on this

I wonder why the map was not produced. I want to ask another question. It is still extant, I believe. Why can it not be produced now? We are out of the court atmosphere. The case in court is over. There are no more legal controversies over this matter. Supposing there is a question of referring this Bill to the Supreme Court, as can be done—if An tUachtarán thinks it proper, the Bill we are discussing now can be referred to the Supreme Court—will the Attorney General's advisers go to the Supreme Court under the shadow of privilege? Will they bring the map in which apparently Deputy Loughman was asked to make some changes with which—in his own phrase—he reluctantly agreed?

Comment on this

There must be a terrible number of maps around.

Comment on this

There is one missing.

Comment on this

I should like to see the original Bill to find out what hacking was done by the Party. We are ostensibly debating the Second Reading of this matter but there were many steps before that. There was the introduction of this piece of legislation. There was then a map produced, and that map was apparently brought to the notice of the Party. That map was hacked about and today the result is that we have got the present divisions.

I should like to find out, and I am sure the Supreme Court would like to find out, what were the original divisions. How were these constituencies arranged after Mr. Justice Budd had made the declaration of what he thought was the line that might be followed. How was the map rearranged? What is the difference between that map as originally presented and the map we have now to consider? I suppose if there is any appeal to the Supreme Court in regard to this question, the Minister's advisers will follow the usual procedure and say: "We claim privilege for anything that has happened departmentally."

Comment on this

We will wait and see.

Comment on this

I have a lot of experience and it has taught me that if there is any refuge into which the Minister can crawl, he will avail himself of it. Surely it would be more bona fide if the step taken was that the Government would go forward to the Supreme Court and ask for a decision from that Court that this piece of legislation is constitutional. They should go with clean hands and the greatest degree of good faith, and that would entail the maps being produced from the Department. The changes made by the Party could then be seen.

That is the background of the action taken before Mr. Justice Budd. I asked that the judgment should be circulated to Deputies in order that they could follow the new proposal, and that advertence could be had to what the judge had said. Although there are copies in the Library apparently, they are not much read. I have heard more mistakes made in the interpretation of that judgment in the past couple of hours than I would have thought possible in connection with something clearly written and clearly spoken.

For instance, it was suggested that the judge laid down that there should not be a wider divergence than 1,000. He made no such comment. If he had, then this piece of legislation would fall. In these legislative proposals, there is a minus sign in front of Clare which is below the average of 833, and there are various pluses of 700, which means there is a divergence between the highest and the lowest of the order of 1,500 of population. If 1,000 were laid down—with which I do not agree—then of course those proposals would fall.

The present proposals have to be looked at from three angles. As I say, it is rather ridiculous to be discussing what I call an obvious attempt at gerrymandering in a sort of academic way as it was by busmen or civil servants or other people who discussed the old legislation, but we can discuss what happened in the courts to make our minds clear. That was a despairing effort by the Government to arrange the constituencies in a particular way. Whatever the Government have done, they have been caught out, exposed and condemned for it.

Let me get back again to an academic atmosphere with regard to the present proposals. Three points can be raised on the present Bill. The Constitution provides that the Oireachtas shall revise the constituencies at least once in 12 years. We have not done that and it is not possible to do it now. We just cannot meet that Article of the Constitution. There has been a flagrant breach of that Article and the only excuse that can be made is that it is not possible to do it. Of course one could go on and ask why certain precautions were not taken before a certain date in November, 1959. We know from the mouth of the Taoiseach that in some way he got advice that so long as they produced this piece of legislation in this House before that particular date towards the end of November, everything was in order. I do not think they adhered very closely to that, and as an opinion, I do not think they believed in it very much.

At a later stage the question was raised whether the legislation would be passed in time. The Taoiseach again said that he was not so much alarmed that he would bulldoze legislation through the House but, at the same time, it was speeded up, and resort was had in the Seanad to a particular provision in the Constitution which allows the President to sign a Bill earlier than the fifth day after it is presented to him. That procedure was used in order to get legislation passed before the date—I think it was 29th November, 1959. Here we are now in April, 1961, and we have not revised the constituencies.

That is a point which could be raised: "The Oireachtas shall revise the constituencies once in every 12 years." That has not been done and there is no way of getting over it unless the advice given to the Government to bring in a piece of legislation before a date in November, 1959, can be relied upon, which they did. We now have a new piece of legislation dated 1961 and yet staring us in the eyes is the obligation to revise the constituencies at least once in every 12 years.

The second point is that the ratio between the number of members to be elected for any constituency and the population has to be the same throughout the country and that ratio is to be determined on the basis of the constituency population as ascertained at the last preceding census. A census was taken on Sunday last, 9th April. The obligation is to have the ratio determined between the number of members to be elected and the population as ascertained at that census. The English phrase is: "as ascertained" and I am instructed that the Irish phrase says "taken"—"the census that has been taken". I do not care which phrase is used. There is quite a well-known legal standard to guide this matter.

Say, at an election, the polling day is 12th June. Say there are islands off the coast and constituencies where boxes are delayed in transit. Suppose there is a riot in any part of a constituency and the poll has to be put off in a certain area for a number of days. If there is a long drawn-out count and if the count is not finished until 19th June, the person elected was elected as from the 12th. The legal standard in all this is that once the poll is taken the result is in fact ascertained on the day of the poll. It may not be disclosed until later but it is ascertained on the day the poll is taken. That is shown by every possible clause in the Electoral Act of 1923 or the subsidiary ones.

Say a fatality occurs and the person who has been nominated dies before the morning of the day the poll is to be taken. The election is then off in that constituency. If he dies ten minutes after the poll is opened the poll continues. If he happened to get a number of votes he would be returned to whatever would be his position on the poll and a by-election would be declared at once. The standard all the time is the day of the poll.

The standard with regard to the census is the day it is taken. Whether or not it will apply to the Constitution, I cannot say, but, on the ordinary law, the census was ascertained last Sunday. Yet we intend to go along, neglecting that—in fact, turning our backs entirely on it.

When this matter was raised on the 7th of March of this year, when the first Stage of the Bill was being looked for, Deputy Norton asked some questions. I quote from column 16 of the Official Report of 7th March, 1961, Volume 187, No. 1. The relevant extract is as follows:

Comment on this

Could the Minister say if there is any intention to get this Bill through this House, and perhaps through the Seanad, within a particular period?

The Taoiseach: No.

Mr. Norton: How long will we get to consider the Committee Stage of the Bill? Is there any desire on the part of the Government to pass the Bill before the taking of the new census——

The Taoiseach: No.

Mr. Norton: ——or can the House deal with the Bill in the ordinary course, regardless of the new census?

The Taoiseach: You can forget the census.

Mr. Dillon: It might be convenient to clarify one matter. Deputy Norton has referred to the Constitution with reference to the census. I gather from the Taoiseach's reply that he is quite satisfied that even though the new Bill has been introduced and is under discussion here at the time the census is being taken, it will create no constitutional problem. That is the Taoiseach's opinion. Does he propose to take the precaution of clearing this matter with the Supreme Court in the event of our consideration of the Bill extending beyond the date on which the census is taken?

The Taoiseach: The final figures from the census will not be available until next year and clearly we must have an Electoral Act before that.

It is not the most precise way of relating the Constitution to the legislation. At Column 18, the Taoiseach would up the series of questions by saying: "If I thought there was any danger of that, I would postpone the census." He has not postponed the census. It has been taken. I suggest, from a reading of cases in connection with electoral law, that the critical date on which the census is taken is ordinarily not the day on which the results are issued to the public.

I should imagine it will be accepted in this House by people who have any realism in them that the population of this country has suffered a serious decline since the last census. The electoral Act that has been repudiated was based on a population short of 2,900,000— about 12,000 short of that. The Registrar General reports the statistics with regard to births and deaths. The statistical information, meagre and all as it is, with regard to emigration clearly indicates a very serious decline in the population. I have had estimates proposed to me and argued about which put the population below the 2,800,000 mark. In other words, a decline will be shown in the census returns of between 90,000 and 100,000 people.

On the basis of the constitutional provisions of not more than one seat for 20,000 of the population, that would mean that the total membership of the Dáil should not be more than 140 Deputies. Yet, it is proposed to go along with a piece of legislation which gives us 144 Deputies, divided among certain constituencies. I have not travelled the country and therefore I am not personally aware of the full position but it is quite clear that if there is a decline of a significant type in the total population it will be found to have hit hardest the western seaboard counties. Donegal, Galway, Clare and Kerry will certainly be found to have lost many thousands of population and a loss of those thousands will require a further adjustment in the electoral provisions before us.

It is apparently proposed that we can forget about the census and that if there were any danger the Taoiseach would postpone it. I suppose he got the advice on which he relied in connection with the Act disowned by the courts. The point is the ratio. The ratio must as far as practicable be the same throughout the country. Here is where, naturally, Deputies are in difficulties. Nobody can shift around townlands to make new constituencies. One has to have the information. One can gather it from the statistical material available but it is a work of some magnitude to investigate these points. The officials of the Department are quite aware of all these matters.

Mr. Justice Budd said that on examining the situation,—he did not say, the most critical examination—it was quite clear the electoral divisions of the country were built up, as far as districts outside the urban areas are concerned, on townlands. He took the population outside the urban areas and said that in his calculation there were so many townlands and the average population to a townland was about 60 people. If that is what one has to play around with, if you can move areas around on the electoral map and throw in divisions of 60 or 100 or 250 people it is certainly possible to get much nearer the same ratio in one area of the county and another than is in the legislation before us. I hope nobody will attempt to do anything except maybe correct outrageous things that have been done and glaring errors.

This House should get information that has been sought on all hands. We want to know the position on the map prepared in Deputy O'Donnell's time as Minister for Local Government. We want to see what changes were made in that by the first map produced with the 1959 Electoral Act and what is the appearance of the first map produced by the Department in connection with the present Electoral Bill.

This matter was discussed to a slight degree on the 23rd March of this year when the question was raised as to when the Electoral Bill was likely to come to our hands. The Taoiseach said, as reported at Column 1179 of the Official Report of Thursday, 23rd March, 1961, Volume 187, No. 9:

Mr. Norton: Could the Taoiseach say more about when we are likely to get the Electoral Bill?

The Taoiseach: It will be available before the weekend.

Mr. Corish: This weekend?

Mr. MacEntee: Is the Deputy apprehensive?

Mr. Norton: Is that a guess?

The Taoiseach: No. The position is that the proofs are being checked and they require a great deal of checking.

Mr. Norton: There must be a nice amount of multilation done——

I want to see what manipulation was done. I would direct my attention to a place such as County Dublin where I know that all the area of Ballyfermot has been taken from the City and handed over to the county. It is suggested that that is because the present Minister for Defence will be in a parlous condition at the next election if left with his own constituency. I do not suppose he had anything to do with it; it must have been Santa. I should like to see the map so as to ascertain how the original map was cut down and mutilated to what it is now. I move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this