Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).
Contributions 140–305 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
At what price? Why did you not do it when you took office in 1933, if you were so fond of rural electrification and of electrifying the country? Why did you wait until 1940 when the war was at its height and the costs of development were so very much greater?
Comment on this
Was it not a fact that you people had to be educated to think that these things were not white elephants? Is that not really what happened? When you were educated, then it was a bit too late. You were a bit long in the tooth and it cost more to do it.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy quote from some of the speeches made from that side of the House when we introduced rural electrification? I shall quote them on the next day.
Comment on this
Our only objection is that it is costing too much. If you had followed in the steps of the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government and developed it throughout the country we would today have it much cheaper than it is. But, simply because it was initiated——
Comment on this
The people who put us into office indicated that they did not want us to follow in the footsteps of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government. They were fed up with them.
Comment on this
Because it was a white elephant. There is the answer. But when you saw the wisdom of the policy of the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government you were very glad to come around to their way of thinking. The Minister is an honest man and he has let the cat out of the bag.
Comment on this
The people said: "Do not touch that: we are suspicious of it." It was amusing when Deputy Davern tried to tell me something about what the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government did.
Comment on this
He said they reduced the old age pension from 10/- to 9/-. I was at school at the time. If the old age pension was 10/- in the days of the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government I know it was only 10/- in 1948, after the war.
Comment on this
Do you remember that? It was 10/- and you got an extra 2/6 from the Relieving Officer if you could prove you were a pauper.
Comment on this
I do not mind the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary having a go at me, backed by Deputy Davern.
Comment on this
If Deputy Davern says Cumann na nGaedheal in 1932 were able to give 10/- to the old age pensioner I would point out that in 1948 Fianna Fáil were still giving them 10/- only, plus the 2/6d. the Relieving Officer gave them if they were in poverty.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister enjoys his lunch. We have heard a lot about industrial employment in the State. Let us have a look at the State generally. What are our main industries? The big industries are the Sugar Company, the E.S.B., Guinness's, the Oil Refinery, the Sweepstakes.
Comment on this
Apart from agriculture, these five concerns are the biggest in the country. Can Fianna Fáil take credit for the introduction of any one of the five big ones?
Comment on this
No, we cannot take credit for them, but I think we can justifiably prove we saved them from ruin and put them on the road to success.
Comment on this
The Sugar Company —you did everything to blow it up. You saved the E.S.B. from ruin when, in fact, it was necessary to have guards to protect it in the old days. Remember what you said about the Sweepstakes. Do not forget that. Remember what you once said about Guinness's. You said it was foreign capital that should be banished out of this State.
Comment on this
I think Cumann na nGaedheal in 1932 did their damnedest to get Guinness's to leave this country to prevent Fianna Fáil from coming into power.
Comment on this
At the time some local papers and some daily papers published that Guinness's were likely to go—that they would go—if we came into power.
Comment on this
On a point of order. If the Parliamentary Secretary will interrupt me and give quotations, why does he not say where he got that quotation?
Comment on this
In 1955, the number engaged in manufacturing in this country was 191,000. This is 1961 and how many are engaged? The total is 190,000. I am quoting now from Table 16 of the statistics issued by the Taoiseach's Department the other day.
Comment on this
I am. I am quoting from page 27, Table 16, of Economic Statistics. If the Parliamentary Secretary will take them and have a look at them, he will find that what I say is correct. Deputy Davern said that we were all mechanised now and he gave that as the reason that men are no longer working in the fields.
Comment on this
I have given the figures for industry. Would you like to hear the figures for agriculture? In 1956, the number in agricultural employment was 1,163,000; five years afterwards, in 1961, the number is 1,112,000, a drop of approximately 51,000. Deputy Davern tells us that 51,000 people have lost their employment because now we have tractors and machinery.
Comment on this
They do not want to hear me making a speech and they do not want to make speeches themselves. Between the Minister, the Parliamentary Secretary and their henchman behind them, I have not got a moment's peace since I got on my feet.
Comment on this
In addition to the £14 million which I have mentioned, plus extra postal, E.S.B., telephone and transport charges, what have they got in additional capital investment?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary will probably get an opportunity of making his own speech.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary does not want to speak. For capital investment, they have got £18 million in Prize Bonds. They boast about their National Loan and Deputy Davern says that we were never better off than we are now. The people of Donegal will be delighted when Deputy Brennan, Deputy Cunningham and Deputy Breslin go back and tell them that they are so prosperous. So prosperous that what? That we are giving the old age pensioners an extra threepence a day, the price of a stamp. They are getting eighteenpence a week—we will forget about the seventh day.
We are told that this is now a wealthy State, a prosperous State, the best run State in Europe and that we are able to give them an extra eighteen-pence a week. That is a little too much. We take a penny off for every ounce of tobacco they smoke and for every 20 cigarettes they smoke. That is the Fianna Fáil idea of being liberal in the most prosperous State in Europe. Deputy Davern gave us advice as to what we should do when we go to the country. He said that we should not criticise the Government, that that is sabotaging the State. He said that we would get more votes if we told the people that we are getting on well instead of going around with our hair hanging down in our eyes like a banshee. We told them the truth in Sligo-Leitrim and did you see what happened?
Comment on this
You penalised them for telling you what they thought of you. Income tax is also being reduced. That is a great thing. I remember the Parliamentary Secretary and myself and some others some time ago making a case to the Minister for a very poor section of the community, the fishermen, that they should not be required to pay income tax.
Comment on this
I call them poor because I think that is what they are. I will be glad to tell them that Deputy Brennan does not think they are poor.
Comment on this
There is not the slightest doubt about that, but they are still poor and now, for the first time in history, P.A.Y.E. is extracting money out of their pockets.
Comment on this
They will get a refund in the lacuna period, but they are being put to the trouble of doing without it until they get that refund. In 90 per cent. of the cases, these fishermen earn their livelihood outside the territorial waters of this State. If a foreigner comes in here and sets up within the territorial limits of the State, he can export wherever he likes and he pays no income tax, corporation profits tax or sur-tax, but an unfortunate fisherman, if he goes outside the territorial waters of the State and brings his catch back here to be processed, has to pay income tax.
Comment on this
No, but the fishermen are throwing the whole thing up. Some of the fishermen from Killybegs are clearing out. P.A.Y.E. has seen to that. We could make a case to the Minister for Finance to give these poor unfortunate fishermen the same privileges as we are giving to the foreigner.
Comment on this
Would you give them an undertaking that if a Fine Gael Government come back, the tax will be rebated?
Comment on this
When Fine Gael want to enunciate their policy, they will do it through their leader. Remember this, if they give a promise, they will keep it. It will not be like the promises of the new President and the present Taoiseach when they said that they would not abolish the food subsidies. When we want to enunciate our policy, it will be enunciated in a proper manner by the leader of the Party and if we give a promise, that promise will be kept.
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy Loughman got smacked because of his intervention on the Electoral Bill and to-day he has got another spokesman from Tipperary. When Deputy Loughman and Deputy Davern go back to the Golden Vale they will say to the farmers: "Look, gentlemen, you must have been asleep. Will you waken up? We are living in the most prosperous State in Europe." That is what Deputy Davern thinks. I wonder what the farmers of the Golden Vale will think?
Comment on this
They will not hear that down there. Deputy Davern says one thing up here and another thing down there.
Comment on this
Unless Deputy Davern ceases to interrupt I shall have to ask him to leave the House.
Comment on this
The policy of Fianna Fáil is to hit the people, and hit them hard. Then they rub them very smoothly believing they will forget the blow.
Comment on this
That is used for many things as some Deputies seem to know. They blistered the people for four years to the tune of £14,000,000 additional direct taxation. Now they come along and say they will give the people some small concessions by way of increased dole, additional social welfare benefits, and they believe the people will forget all about the blister of the £9,000,000 put on their shoulders when the food subsidies were removed. They will tell the people that cattle prices are good now as a result of the T. B. eradication scheme. I wonder will they tell the people what Deputy Dillon told the House this morning; in 1950 Deputy Dillon told Mr. Carrigan, the head of the investigating party visiting Europe, that we were then tackling tuberculosis eradication in our cattle industry.
Comment on this
To encourage the eradication of tuberculosis Deputy Dillon had various schemes—the double byre scheme and all the rest of them.
Comment on this
I am glad Deputy Davern is leaving the House because the things I am going to say now might provoke him. Deputy Cunningham asks had we the money. Of course we had the money and we began tuberculosis eradication but, from the day the inter-Party Government went out of office until they returned in 1954, nothing was done about the eradication of tuberculosis. In later years Fianna Fáil took up where the inter-Party Government left off and it is only now we are reaching the stage where our cattle——
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is not helpful. The House should allow Deputy O'Donnell to proceed without interruption.
Comment on this
We had one aspirant for the post of Minister for Agriculture from Deputy Moher's constituency but he got a kick in the pants from the Taoiseach. Deputy Corry told us he was going to be Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
Whenever they had to select a Minister for Agriculture they generally went north. The Minister has told us—it is a great consolation to the poor unfortunates in Donegal and in the West of Ireland— that he will introduce legislation to ease the means test in relation to unemployment assistance. What does he mean by that? Does he mean the present test is too difficult? He does. I am glad Deputy Cunningham agrees that he does. In other words, the investigating officers have been carrying out the instructions of the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Kennedy, and examining into the means of old age pensioners, the unfortunate recipients of unemployment assistance, widows' and orphans' pensions and so forth. The investigating officers have been going around the country——
Comment on this
The Deputy was a Minister himself and he knows perfectly well that revision is due periodically.
Comment on this
Might I point out that the administration of the Act would relevantly arise on the Estimate? It is not relevant on this.
Comment on this
I quite agree, but the Minister has referred to it. He said the Minister for Social Welfare will introduce legislation to ease the means test for social welfare recipients.
Comment on this
Of course it is a good thing, but why should it be necessary? The Deputy sees the idea. It is the old, old policy of Fianna Fáil: keep tricking these unfortunate people; reduce their unemployment assistance, increase their means, reduce their widows and orphans' pensions and old age pensions accordingly. But, when it is coming near election time, introduce a Bill to ease the position. It is the old Fianna Fáil carrot dangled in front of these unfortunate people on the eve of an election and at a time when Fianna Fáil know there is no possibility of having such a Bill passed through this House before the election.
We hear about the efforts being made by the Government to give employment in rural Ireland. One of the biggest employers in my constituency was Gaeltarra Éireann. They never gave less employment than they are giving today. I remember the Parliamentary Secretary speaking a few months ago in a place called Kilcar. He told the people there that they had not got enough hand weavers and he said: "We will train more weavers down in Gweedore and we will have plenty of employment here for hand weavers." I have no objection to any man from any part of my county procuring employment, but here was the build-up for a crowd of enraged unemployed weavers, led by the local curate. We had the Parliamentary Secretary saying that this was a change-over, changing from one class of loom to another and that, on that change, unheard of unemployment would follow. We have been waiting ever since. There is no more employment. Indeed, there is less employment. But there is an election coming off and the Parliamentary Secretary will go down there again and tell the people: "Hold on. We will give you more employment in a short time."
Comment on this
I will be there all right to remind the Parliamentary Secretary of what he said in Kilcar a few months ago. Do not worry about that. That is one of the methods by which Fianna Fáil are providing more employment.
We hear a good deal about the housing drive. Last night Deputy Sweetman pointed out that there is less money for building this year than there was in 1956. By means of a question yesterday, we elicited from the Minister for Industry and Commerce the fact that there was no shortage of tradesmen in the building industry. At the same time, we are told that we are trying to bring them back and the reason there is no progress in the building trade is that all the tradesmen have gone out of the State. The Minister for Industry and Commerce said he had no evidence of a shortage in the building trade of genuine tradesmen.
Comment on this
What is the use of putting them in the Irish papers when they are not seen in England?
Comment on this
We have heard what happened the Land Reclamation Scheme. Just have a look at the amount which is now being spent on that scheme. It is interesting reading for this prosperous State in which we are living. Of course the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is the man who sabotaged the Local Authorities (Works) Act which was one of the most useful schemes we ever had. He is the man who must take full responsibility for sabotaging it.
Comment on this
I will make the speech again at the chapel gate and I will make it fairly often. In fact, I am thinking of having a record made of it. I am going to remind the Parliamentary Secretary that he is the man who sabotaged this scheme, who left us with flooded lands around Gweedore, Glenties and other places, land that could have been reclaimed if he had not sabotaged the Act and had left money for this work.
Comment on this
"Bogged in it"— there is the cat out of the bag. Does the Deputy say it was money badly spent?
Comment on this
The matter is not relevant on the Budget. The Deputy will have a suitable opportunity to discuss it.
Comment on this
I hear the Government talking about tourism and what they are doing to attract tourists. They are doing one good thing to make certain that tourists will not come back, particularly those who are seeking some night life—that is, since they started to close the public houses——
Comment on this
I certainly would not argue with you, Sir, but it arises under the heading of tourism.
Comment on this
We have unfortunately a very wet climate and we have no control over the elements but there is something we could do to attract tourists, that is, to reduce the price of the bottle of whiskey by £1, take the duty of £1 off the bottle of whiskey and a similar amount off the lb. of tobacco and off cigarettes.
Comment on this
No, Sir. I maintain that we should be able to attract tourists for 12 months. How is it that the Isle of Man, which is in close proximity to us, has built up such a magnificent tourist industry, or the Channel Islands lying between France and Britain? They have their own customs duties and people go there because they know that certain commodities are much cheaper than they are on the mainland. If we reduced the price of whiskey by £1 per bottle, we would still collect the same amount of revenue.
Comment on this
Are you not trying to encourage them to come in? I am talking about the middle-class people of Britain, the factory worker who has a limited amount to spend.
Comment on this
I have no experience of "Red Biddy" but I have experience of drinking "Mary Anne", and it is a reasonably good beer. If we reduced these prices, we would attract people. I know the answer Fianna Fáil will give me—that it would encourage smuggling and that is something to be dreaded. I maintain there is no crime whatever in smuggling, provided it is not against the laws of your own State. There is no crime in smuggling a bottle of whiskey out of this country or having it smuggled out, as we do with our sweep tickets. Do we not have them——
Comment on this
I am giving them advice on how they could build up the tourist industry. If they do not want to take the advice——
Comment on this
No, but with the revenue from cheap whiskey. The Deputy knows all about it. He dealt in cheap whiskey, or cheap wines. I do not propose to hold up the House any longer——
Comment on this
Well, it was not ploughed. There are very few of them left. If I had the time, I would have but I will have time in the next four months.
Comment on this
I am somewhat nervous about rising here to-day. It has been Donegal's day with a vengeance. As Deputy Moher said, the contributions have covered a wide field. I was rather saddened to hear the Parliamentary Secretary refer to Messrs. Guinness. It is an organisation which has been 200 years in the country and is one of our greatest traditional industries and I doubt if any sane man would ever decry or deride it.
Comment on this
No, but the Parliamentary Secretary did make a remark that it was said by Cumann na nGaedheal——
Comment on this
It was said that when we came into office they would leave the country. That was about 1932.
Comment on this
This morning, Deputy Dillon made a rather exhaustive and analytical speech covering our economic activities. He was quite objective and took credit for certain things the inter-Party Government had done just as the present Government take credit for some things they have done. If we were all a little more tolerant, we should recognise the value of contributions of this kind. That schoolboy attitude of "whatever you can do, I can do better" should not obtain here.
It is all traceable, I suppose, to the fact that this House was founded during a civil war and many of the bitternesses still exist. At least we have grown up sufficiently to leave them behind and to try to get to realities because the whole conception of territorial freedom has changed in the past 40 years and our problem to-day is our economic survival. If we are objective in this, we should at least be tolerant enough to recognise the value of contributions successive Governments are making. It is a good thing there has been a continuity of policy by Governments in recent years. It is something we should be proud of.
The Taoiseach this morning took Deputy Dillon to task for some things he said, but I think there was a misunderstanding. Deputy Dillon this morning dealt with the tables of economic statistics and covered the whole field of economic activity and did not deal so much with the Budget specifically. The Taoiseach, since he became Taoiseach, has been most fair in his contributions here and I was sorry to see him rather irritated this morning, but I suppose that is Irish politics.
Deputy Davern this afternoon was quite pleasant but he did say things that would not bear investigation. The booklet issued under the title Economic Statistics is rather revealing. I must admit I have not studied it. It is most interesting, if a person had time to sit down and digest it and realise its mathematical value. Deputy Davern contradicted Deputy O'Donnell when he was speaking. In Table 16 of the booklet it is shown in black and white that the estimated number of persons who work in the main branches of nonagricultural economic activity was only 699,000 in 1960 as against 692,000 in 1959, 692,000 in 1958, 703,000 in 1957 and a still higher figure in 1956 and 1955. It is hard to reconcile these figures with some of the statements made this morning by the Taoiseach but these are the Government's statistics and these are the facts that one can deduce from this Table, if it is of any value at all.
Table 7 shows the number of males engaged in farm work. The number on 1st June, 1960, was 413,000 as against 420,000 in 1959. The number increases as one goes back and decreases as one comes forward. I know that that is a trend in every country in Europe today. Whatever the cause, it is not entirely economic. There is that drift from the land all over Western Europe and it is quite common in our own country.
The day is fast approaching when there will be no such thing in this country as an agricultural labourer. The traditional agricultural labourer who lived in the rural cottage within 20 miles of Cork city is fast disappearing. He will not work on the land as long as he can get work anywhere else. In other words, he will not work on the land until economic necessity drives him to do so. I do not know whether it is because of the drudgery of the work on the land or the isolation of living on the land or what it is, but it is a fact.
We all realise and appeciate that for any Minister for Finance the balancing of the Budget is one of the major problems he has to face in any year. Everybody must have sympathy with the Minister in trying to present a balanced Budget in this country at any time, but especially in these difficult years. We are all very pleased that the Budget was introduced in favourable circumstances this year, that exports show an increase of 17 per cent and imports an increase of 14 per cent. The activity behind these increases, whether in imports or exports, must have given rise to a good deal of economic activity and must have created economic security for many families and workers in the State. That is all to the good and nobody will deride or criticise that development.
Revenue has been very buoyant. The buoyancy of the revenue has made matters rather easy for the Minister in the present year. Nevertheless, we have to face the fact that the Budget is an all-time record as far as revenue is concerned and an all-time record as far as expenditure is concerned. In recent years, the tendency has been all the time for revenue to chase expenditure. How long that will last, I do not know. We seem never to be able to cushion ourselves against any emergency that may arise in these unpredictable times. If we are going to emerge into a free trade world, where will we find ourselves? We cannot rely on tariffs or price supports of any kind.
The reliefs given in the Budget will be welcomed. Nobody is so small-minded as not to admit that these reliefs will bring about a certain amount of satisfaction but they are small. We are glad that even a small effort is being made in the decrease in the standard rate of income tax and the 6d. decrease in the P.A.Y.E. scheme.
The reliefs given to agriculture and the subsidisation of the transport of lime will be welcomed by the farming community. It is a pity that these reliefs were not in operation during the spring when lime was being used on the land. The Government who now bring in that relief must be criticised and blamed for having reduced the subsidy on the transport of lime in former years. If Deputy Dillon took credit for the introduction of the lime scheme, he is also within his rights in criticising, as he did this morning, the action of the Government in cutting the subsidy on the transport of lime. It brought results that we did not like. It decreased the utilisation of lime on farms during the present year.
The Minister has taken a bold step in regard to death duties. I should like the Minister to tell me, when replying, if it means that there is no death duty on estates under £5,000 and that in the case of an estate of £10,000, it means that the first £5,000 is free of death duty. Does it mean that death duty will begin on £5,000? I should like clarification on that point. The reduction of one per cent. in the case of larger estates will be very valuable to the holders of medium-sized farms and other property. In the past, people had an extraordinary fear of death duties and left estates unadministered, thus creating difficulty. They were afraid to go to a solicitor and arrange for the estate to be administered because of the excessive charge which they feared would be levied on the property before transfer.
There was a good deal of discussion here this morning about emigration. We all regret emigration. It is traditional with us. The Taoiseach on various occasions and in various places has given three main reasons for emigration. The first was economic and the second social; I forget how he termed the third cause. I asked the Taoiseach a question as to whether he thinks there is any practical way of providing us with yearly statistics as to the number who leave the country for the first time. That information would be very valuable but we have to wait for a census in order to get the exact figures.
May I be permitted to quote figures I read in the Cork Examiner some time ago? We are given from Great Britain itself statistics of immigration from various countries into Great Britain and these immigration figures for the Republic of Ireland are given as 64,494 for the year 1959 as against 58,316 for the previous year. Northern Ireland is not included in those figures. If these figures are correct, they are startling but what is more startling is that we have no machinery in this country for assessing the figures as it should be our duty to do. That information should be available. I do not know why we should wait to get the information from London with regard to these matters.
There is another feature which I have observed and of which I am sure other Deputies are aware. It is the over-competition with old traditional businesses of various kinds. It is very much in evidence in Cork where old-established firms have been changing hands in recent years. They have been forced out of business by the over-competition and extensive advertising by new firms with salesmen out on the road every day. That is one of the drawbacks from which we are suffering and one of the causes of whatever stagnation there is in our economy. I do not know how that can be remedied but it is very obviously there.
To give one case, there was in Midleton in Co. Cork a very old-established firm of millers. This business was run by a very decent family. These mills have been closed down in two places in East Cork and the traditional owners of the mills went into the Cork Milling Company. Now this concern has been taken over by Messrs. Rank and the whole activity transferred to Limerick. East Cork is the greatest grain-growing area in the country and it is inconceivable that this milling activity should leave East Cork and be transferred to Limerick. However, we must remember that those people in control are people from outside this country and that this centralisation is seemingly in the interests of economy.
If that is the case, it has done more harm than good because it has taken away a traditional industry from a locality to which it was almost indigenous and transferred it to an area where there is very little grain grown at all. I do not know how that can be remedied but there should be some safeguard for these old-established concerns that served us well in generations gone by, that gave employment and provided stability for the working classes in these areas.
I do not intend to go into these various figures because I have not studied them sufficiently to be able to adduce conclusions. However, I think everybody is pleased with whatever advance has been made. Anybody who has the interest of the country at heart will appreciate the advances made in recent years. As I said a while ago, the availability of credit in recent years, the advance of £20 million to farmers and the vast millions of pounds that have gone into hire purchase, all have created activity. As long as that activity is productive, such expenditure is justifiable. As long as it brings about the results we want, we must all admit it is eventually for the good of our people.
Comment on this
From what we could gather from the Taoiseach's speech, one would think this was the first Fianna Fáil Budget. It is about the twenty-third or twenty-fourth Budget that has been brought into this House by Fianna Fáil. Let us examine what the Taoiseach said today in respect of the sudden upsurge in the economy, this dynamic expansion. This is only a rehash of the high-sounding phrases we hear in this House every time a Budget is introduced. That is something for the headlines in the Irish Press. They will go to town on that. There are enough amadáns in the country to swallow it.
Comment on this
It is very strange that any time there was an upsurge from Fianna Fáil in this House, it came immediately after a change of Government. In regard to any results they had to show the momentum had been gathering before they got into office and they collected the kudos. The fact that they are shaken out of their lethargy by the coming into power of an inter-Party Government goes to show that there is a need of change, and that change will come because the people realise the need for it.
The Taoiseach went as far today as to cast a reflection on the previous Taoiseach by suggesting that the dead hand was in the Government and that there was no progress while he was in power. That is what we could gather from the trend of his speech. It is only natural the Taoiseach should try to put his stock up before the coming election. One of the greatest assets of the performers of the Front Bench—I was going to describe it as a circus—is their jugglers. They can juggle figures remarkably well, whereas the figures issued by the Central Statistics Office contradict everything they have said. These figures may not have the blessing of the Fianna Fáil Government because they have no say in them. The figures quoted by the Fianna Fáil side are like the high-flown statements we have had from them designed for the Irish Press and for the amadáns around the country who swallow them. I challenge the Taoiseach or any of his back benchers to go across to Birmingham or Coventry and make some of the foolish statements they made here to-day. We know the reception they would get. We know the reception they got before, without opening their mouths.
As far as we can see in the West this Budget offers very little to the small farmers. The mentality behind the Budget is the mentality of the ranch country the Minister comes from and represents. The large farmers will get any of the subsidies that are going. I wonder how many small farmers from the West would use a ton of fertiliser and get, say, a reduction of 5/-? It would not pay his bus fare into town to order it. So far as I can see, the Minister is catering merely for the ranchers of his own county, plus a few more areas like Deputy Davern's area.
Deputy Sweetman talked about the blisters on the people. There is no denying the fact that the increase in the rates throughout the country can be pinpointed to Government policy. The Minister may ask me why. I shall tell him. The increase in the cost of living brought about by the famous Budget which was to put the country on its feet, at a time when Fianna Fáil were promising to do a great deal, is still having repercussions on the rates throughout the country. At every county council meeting there is a demand for an increase in salary from every type of person. That was caused by Fianna Fáil policy and nothing else You cannot blame any man for asking for an increase to meet the cost of living.
What is the alternative? It is the mail boat, or suffer on while Fianna Fáil policy is being put through. It is the squeeze for the small man. We were told that one of the first things Fianna Fáil would reduce was the number of civil servants. Will the Minister kindly tell us, when he is winding up this debate, how many extra civil servants have been put on the pay list, which he will have to meet, in the past year and a half or so? How many more are earmarked to go on it? Of course that statement was all right for the Irish Press and for the amadán down the country to swallow, and he swallowed it. The policy of Fianna Fáil is more at the top, and to the devil with the small man.
I said that this Budget is mainly an election Budget for certain sections of the community. We would like to see moneys allocated for the purpose of the re-introduction of the Local Authorities (Works) Act. We hear about the promises that have been made to encourage the small farmers, but there is hardly a meeting throughout the country at which a resolution is not passed demanding the re-introduction of the Local Authorities (Works) Act, which was dubbed as "slush money" by Fianna Fáil. It is very strange now that the Fianna Fáil members of local bodies are proposing the re-introduction of that Act at every other meeting, the Act which was introduced by the infamous—as we heard them called —Coalition Government. Just because it suited the small farmers, and did not suit the big farmers of the ranching county to which the Minister belongs, it had to be wiped out. Wonderful work was carried out under that Act. I was surprised that even in the statement of the Taoiseach, that was one matter on which he did not propose to help the small farmers.
It is rather amazing to see that this year quite a sizeable amount of the moneys allocated for forestry were not spent. I do not know what Deputies will have to say to the unemployed who live on the fringes of the forests. What can they say to the people when they ask why employment was not given, even though they demanded it, and when they ask why the money was not spent? Perhaps my colleague Deputy Geoghegan will be able to give them some good reasons when he goes home.
Comment on this
That is what I want to get from the Deputy. I want the Deputy to tell us why that money allocated for forestry was not spent, while the fathers of families had to take the mail boat. If he is prepared to tell the truth now, he will stand up and say whether or not that is a fact, just for the records of the House. I should like the Deputy to go to West Galway and tell that to the people. The Deputy has nothing to say? The hasp has been on many a door on the fringe of those forests throughout Galway County. The people can be seen any day at the nearest station with their bags——
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot make a speech because he knows what I am saying is a fact. I am trying to give him a little grist for his mill, and when I go to his area I shall ask him questions as to why the moneys allocated for forestry were not spent, when the fathers of families had to take the mail boat.
Comment on this
We will shortly have a "go" on that question and I shall ask the Deputy to account for his stewardship in that regard. The Deputy might also tell us why the bus charges have increased. I hear a lot of growling, and he knows many of the people on the route I have in mind. Perhaps he might tell the ratepayers of Galway why there is a demand for an increase in the salaries or wages, as the case may be, of the workers. Those few points will be of interest to the people in the West. Possibly the Deputy will be the one to explain them when the call comes. So far as the West is concerned, this Budget offers nothing to the small man. It is a big man's Budget, and it was framed by the Minister for his own purposes in the coming general election.