Committee on Finance. - Vote 45—Transport and Power.
Contributions 1–201 of 372. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:
That a sum not exceeding £2,643,010 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1962, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Transport and Power, including certain Services administered by that Office, and for payment of a Grant-in-Aid.
The Estimate of £3,964,510 for 1961-62 shows a net increase of £317,840 compared with £3,646,670 granted in 1960-61.
The principal increases in 1961-62 are in the provisions for Salaries, £28,000 (Subhead A); C.I.E.—Redundancy Compensation £116,000 (Subhead D.2); Harbours £119,000 (Subhead E); Construction, Dublin Airport £20,000 (Subhead F.3); Shannon Free Airport Development Co. £80,000 (Subhead G.4); International Organisations £21,000 (Subhead J) and Rural Electrification £71,000 (Subhead L). Increases on other subheads amount to £40,000, bringing the total of increases to £496,000.
The principal decreases in 1961-62 are in the provisions for Acquisition of Land £22,000 (Subhead F.1); Construction—Shannon Airport £52,000 (Subhead F.2) and Technical Assistance £10,000 (Subhead K). Decreases on other subheads amount to £2,700. To these must be added an increase of £92,000 in the Appropriations-in-Aid subhead which is equivalent to a decrease in the net grant. This brings the total of decreases to £178,000.
The net increase in the Estimate for 1961-62 compared with 1960-61 is therefore £317,840 as I have already stated. The increase in the salary provision is mainly due to increases in the number of technical officers employed in air traffic control and on radio work, and to provision for the staff of Cork Airport. The increase in C.I.E. redundancy compensation is caused by a greater degree of reorganisation within C.I.E. than was envisaged originally. The increase in harbour grants is due to the fact that the bulk of the grants payable on the construction of two new tenders for Cobh will fall due in the current year and also to provision for a major improvement scheme for Galway harbour.
The increase for construction at Dublin airport arises from the need for additional passenger handling facilities consequent on the phenomenal growth of traffic at that airport. The increase in the grant-in-aid to Shannon Free Airport Development Company arises from an increase expected in the amount of grants which will be paid to industrialists establishing new factories at Shannon airport. The increase in the amount for International Organisations is mainly due to increased contributions for weather ships and air navigation aids operated on an international basis. The contributions are proportionate to our share of transatlantic air traffic and the inauguration of an Irish transatlantic service has increased our proportion of the cost.
The decreases in the provisions for Acquisition of Land and Construction at Shannon Airport are due to the completion of the acquisition of land required for airport construction and improvement and to the virtual completion of the new runway and terminal buildings at Shannon airport. The reduction in the provision for technical assistance arises from a reduction in the amount for a major project which it is expected will be completed this year. This project is financed from the American Counterpart Fund and a corresponding reduction is shown in the Appropriations-in-Aid.
A substantial increase is provided for in the Appropriations-in-Aid from landing fees at Shannon airport, due to an expected increase in the number of landings. The balance of the increase is due to an increase in the cash surplus on the operation of Dublin airport.
Before reviewing operations during the past year and dealing with plans for the future I wish to draw the attention of Deputies to the notes on the functions and activities of my Department circulated in advance of this debate. Many duties are performed, which are non-controversial and consequently are seldom the subject of public discussion. Nevertheless, these functions are valuable to the community and although not generally known represent a very considerable proportion of the work performed by the Department.
The House had only very recently an extended debate on the report and accounts of C.I.E. for the year ended 31/3/60. In the particular circumstances it was perhaps unavoidable that a disproportionately large part of the debate was devoted to the question of the closing of branch lines but I did review for the Dáil the substantial progress made by C.I.E. towards the target of self-sufficiency by 31/3/64 set before the Board by the Transport Act, 1958.
Preliminary figures for the year, which are subject to further check and audit, indicate that the loss of £709,000 in 1959/60 has been reduced to £250,000 in 1960/61. In 1957/58 the losses were £2.3 million. This reduction is due mainly to further substantial increases in business during the year, total receipts having been increased by £1 m. approximately and railway receipts alone by £500,000. There is now some reasonable prospect that the Board will have reached solvency before 31/3/64.
The rapid progress of the Board towards solvency will release part of the present annual fixed grant from the wasteful and unremunerative function of meeting revenue losses and thus enable the Board to devote more funds to the positive goals of improving services and efficiency so as to develop the long term earning capacity of the undertaking.
Making use of its freedom of commercial action, new business is steadily and continuously being secured and this is the most effective test of the standard of service offered by the Board. A heartening feature of the Board's financial recovery is the fact that the railway carried more tonnage during the year ended 31st March, 1961, than ever in the Board's history, highlighting the Board's determination to make the railways pay.
Revenue from package deals and special deals for carriage of livestock continues to increase, and the Board's targets were more than achieved. Up to February, 1961 package deals concluded by the Board brought in some £600,000 of new business. One of the more gratifying aspects of the package deal drive is the fact that C.I.E. are succeeding in convincing transport users that it is in their interests to employ professional transport hauliers rather than to purchase vehicles for their own use.
Much of the increased business is due to the Board's flexible and imaginative approach to the task of selling transport. I have mentioned the obvious example of the package deal but there were innovations on the passenger side also. About 92,000 passengers were carried on educational tours during the 1960 season, compared with 21,000 in the previous year. Another innovation, the rail rambler ticket, introduced in 1960, earned £8,600.
Mystery trains, successfully revived in 1959, carried 25,000 passengers in the 1960 season; traffic on day tours by coach and bus increased by 17,000 or 11 per cent. Bookings on the Board's extended coach tours increased from 7,800 in 1959 to 9,100 in 1960. Bookings for the current year so far are appreciably better than last year. A particularly satisfactory feature of the extended coach tours was the increase of 100 per cent in bookings for the month of October, 1960. The fact that the weather during the 1960 summer was by no means dry indicates that even better results would have been achieved if fine weather had prevailed.
Season ticket users of C.I.E. provincial bus services are now paying less for their weekly tickets as a result of the new system of charging which came into effect in December, 1960. The Board then decided to bring bus charges more closely in line with corresponding rail fares. Juveniles' and school children's tickets are now almost 50 per cent. cheaper than heretofore. The age limit for school children has been raised from 15 to 16 years and rates have been reduced to as low as one-third the adult rate. A new age category has also been introduced for students and apprentices. From 16 to 18 years old the rates have been cut from three-quarters to half adult fare, and from the 19 to 21 age group the cost is now two-thirds instead of three-quarters the adult charge.
Enough has already been said about the closure of uneconomic branch lines. I will confine myself to repeating that the Board do not plan to close any further branch lines during the statutory reorganisation period. In the Board's experience the substitute road services are giving satisfaction to its customers. Complaints have been few and the Board have taken steps to ensure as far as it can in each case that the cause for complaint will not recur.
The Board have set ambitious but practicable targets for the improvement of services. Long term plans include a major review of rolling stock, plant, equipment and buildings over the entire system; plans are being prepared to bring these up to the highest international standards. In the case of rail services, all main line trains will be brought up to the standard of named trains; carriages will be modernised and new, up-to-date carriages will be introduced; station facilities will also be improved. The Board's target on the locomotion side is full dieselisation as early as possible. As far as rail freight is concerned there is a continuous drive to improve handling facilities and new, up-to-date equipment is being provided.
The Board's road services also are to be improved. Better standards of heating and comfort are being provided for bus passengers. The question of additional bus shelters is being examined. Twenty-five per cent. of the single deck fleet will be renewed over the next two years. Old and obsolete vehicles in the road freight fleet are being replaced.
C.I.E. have undertaken a major review and reorganisation of the management structure at all levels and have set an example to industrialists by the internal use of work study in all its forms and cover a great area of administration and operation. Area and district managers have been appointed with delegated authority to act with speed and flexibility in selling and rendering service to the public, and also in dealing with any complaints about local services. The Board confidently expect that the new organisation will add further vigour to the drive for better services to the customer and more business for the Board.
A sum of £35,000 has been allocated from the U.S. grant Counterpart Reserve Fund towards the cost of the establishment by C.I.E. of a development and research unit in connection with special technical freight transport problems including the use of containers, flats and pallets to form the basis of better road/rail co-ordination.
A sum of £9,800 has already been paid to C.I.E. for the purchase of elevators, portable conveyors and pallet trucks in pursuance of this research and development and it is expected that the balance of the grant will be required over the coming year.
As far as the Board's employees are concerned, intensive training schemes to improve techniques at all levels have been launched and the scheme of joint consultation has facilitated full co-operation between employees and management.
One last word of warning about C.I.E. No Minister for Finance faced with tremendous demands for seven figure increases in educational and social services will want to subsidise C.I.E. It will take the same kind of continuous dedicated effort by management and staff working closely and enthusiastically together to maintain C.I.E. as solvent a company as can for instance be found in a modern highly developed export industry facing cut throat competition. Let everyone dispel the idea that there will ever be an easy period for C.I.E. when either to management or staff the prospects appear easy and cash returns are rolling in without tremendous effort.
The number of coach tours operated by foreign operators continues to increase. The number of passengers carried on such tours in 1960 was about 13,600 compared with 7,500 in 1959. These tours are now admitted freely; the only conditions which are applied are (1) that they must be confined to persons normally resident outside the State who have made advance reservations and (2) that the duration of each tour within the State must be not less than 4 days. It is noteworthy that notwithstanding the substantial numbers of passengers carried on such tours the numbers carried by C.I.E. on its own coach tours have also increased substantially.
I am happy to be able to report some significant improvements in the cross-Channel passenger services. I must take this opportunity to acknowledge the quick response made by Sir Reginald Wilson, the new Midland Chairman, to the representations made to him.
An additional platform is at present being constructed at Holyhead. This will greatly facilitate passenger movements by the more expeditious handling of extra and relief trains, many of which, up to the present, have had to remain outside the station pending the clearance of other trains and this will also speed up clearance of ships. The customs examination centre at Holyhead has been extended to permit of a faster flow of passengers through customs.
British Railways have reduced the maximum number of passengers to be carried on the larger mail boats. Accommodation is usually fully booked at peak periods only but as additional sailings are being provided for these periods there will be no overall loss in carrying capacity. Additional sailings will as usual be provided during the summer season but as compared with 1960 there will be ten extra sailings, viz. seven inwards and three outwards. These include certain completely new sailings with special train connections.
Heretofore on sailings inwards for which sailing tickets were required control was exercised at Holyhead and passengers without sailing tickets were held up there. British Railways now propose to exercise this control when passengers are joining the connecting train for Holyhead and persons without sailing tickets will not be allowed to join the train. This will prevent outshipments at Holyhead. The foregoing improvements should go a long way towards eliminating complaints about uncomfortable travelling arrangements. Having acknowledged the improvements already effected and promised this summer, I should say that we await further improvement. Better refreshment service, more personal care for passengers, greater punctuality of trains, alterations to ships sailing and the replacement of the Princess Maud are some of the matters still for consideration.
At Dún Laoghaire, the route which after Dover-Calais is the busiest sea route from Britain, improvement works were carried out by the Board of Works at a cost of some £140,000. The boat pier has now been provided with a modern double-deck structure with improved facilities for passengers, more customs examination space, a track for passengers' cars and arrangements for crane installations so that the carriage of increased numbers of vehicles could be effected speedily.
British Railways are providing for the summer season on the Dún Laoghaire-Holyhead service additional capacity for 428 cars inwards and 464 cars outwards and on the Rosslare-Fishguard services additional capacity for 1,000 cars each way. This additional capacity, together with that to be provided for 2,000 cars each way by the British and Irish Steampacket Co., will mean an increase in capacity by 50 per cent. over the summer period this year as compared with last year. I hope that the response to this increase in capacity will go far towards establishing the need for and the profitability of placing a proper car ferry on a cross-Channel route. I do not need to stress the importance of this kind of tourism—it has been estimated that each tourist's car entering this country represents, on average, £60 tourist expenditure.
The Tribunal of Inquiry into cross-channel freight rates, which reported in May, 1959, suggested that a committee representative of shippers as a whole should be formed under official auspices to consider problems of cross-channel transport, particularly in connection with freight rates to co-ordinate information on these problems and to discuss them with the Irish and British Traffic Conference or with individual undertakings. In pursuance of this suggestion I had pleasure in launching the National Shippers Committee in May, 1960, with a widely representative membership. The Secretariat is provided for this Committee by the Federation of Irish Industries.
The Committee have been active in pursuing their objects since its inception. They had the unhappy experience of being presented in their first year of operation with an increase in cross-channel freight rates, which came into force in November, 1960. It was particularly disappointing to find that the method of introducing this increase differed nothing from that used prior to the formation of the National Shippers Committee. The Conference announced the increase less than one month from the date on which it was due to come into operation and no effort was made to discuss the proposal with the National Shippers Committee before the public announcement.
There is no statutory authority vested in me or in the Government to control international freight rates nor in the nature of the trade could such unilateral control be effectively exercised. Moreover, without access to the books and accounts of the companies on both sides of the Irish sea it would not be possible to determine whether any particular increase was justified or necessary. It does seem, however, in view of the importance of the trade to the country's economy and indeed if only as a matter of sensible public relations on the part of the companies, that they should discuss their proposals frankly with the National Shippers Committee, which represents the users, in order to explain the necessity for any increases and perhaps to modify or alter them in the light of the representations made by the Committee.
Apart from the activities on a broad front of the National Shippers Committee, Córas Tráchtála offer a very useful advisory service on shipping practice which is becoming more and more widely used by shippers and I'm told that in many cases their advice has meant savings in shipping freights and faster delivery. Many firms tend to let this important subject be handled as routine at lower levels and thus best and cheapest services may not be secured.
Under the aegis of Córas Tráchtála a number of importing and exporting services have established Shipping Services Ltd., as a co-operative organisation to handle customs clearance, forwarding and transhipment for Irish imports and exports through Liverpool. The participating firms have secured substantial decreases in the cost of these services and far greater efficiency in the handling and despatch of their business. I would strongly advise firms to whom these services are relevant and who may not yet have considered them to explore the possibilities.
A solution to the ban on container and ferry services to the port of Dublin has not yet been found. Negotiations between the parties concerned are being conducted under the aegis of the Labour Court and I can only hope that a satisfactory settlement may be reached. In the meantime Deputies will be glad to know that the ferry service between Greenore and Preston, which is operated privately and for which containers and road transport are provided at this side by C.I.E., is doing a substantial business. The possibility of ferry services at some other east cost ports has also been mooted.
There were no spectacular developments in the world shipping situation during the past year. The general slump in freight rates, which set-in in 1957 following the end of the Suez crisis, continued but some hopeful signs of better times ahead were noticeable. According to the tramp freight index of the British Chamber of Shipping the average monthly index rate of 74.2 points for 1960 showed a slight gain over that for 1959, compared with the lowest point of 62.7 points in April 1958; the market remained remarkably steady throughout the year and there was no tendency for freights to fall back. (These index figures relate to a base of 100 at 1952).
There is a good chance that there will be a slow intermittent recovery in freight rates at the end of a cyclical depression, the pattern of which has been repetitive in the industry. A significant factor is that the laid-up tonnage figure for the world which reached a peak of 9 million gross tons in 1959 had fallen to about 3 million gross tons by June, 1961, reflecting the fact that more ships are securing employment, combined with a continuing flow of old ships to the scrap yards. After noting the less favourable position in regard to tanker operation it is probable that the dry cargo market will reach a state of equilibrium before the tanker market, but the existence of laid-up tanker tonnage, some of which can be used for grain or other bulk cargo, tends to hold down dry cargo also.
It is gratifying to record, against this background, that Irish Shipping Ltd. kept all their vessels employed throughout the year and that in all the circumstances their trading results are likely to be satisfactory. Last year the company showed an operating surplus of £152,000 and a commercial loss of £543,000 after allowing for repairs costing £57,000 and full depreciation amounting to £695,000. For the year ending 30th April, 1961, Irish Shipping Ltd. expect an operating surplus, after allowing for the cost of repairs, but before charging depreciation, of about £238,000.
The company's fleet consists at present of fifteen dry cargo ships, of which ten are deep-sea, and three tankers, of which two are deep-sea. The aggregate dead-weight tonnage of this fleet is 148,000, of which 108,000 tons represent dry cargo tonnage. To replace three uneconomic vessels of a total dead-weight tonnage of approximately 26,400 tons, which were due for replacement and were sold during 1959-60, the company ordered two conventional deep-sea dry cargo vessels of 14,700 tons dead-weight each. One of these vessels was delivered in May, 1961, and the second vessel, which is being built in the Verolme Cork Dockyard, is due for delivery early in 1962.
The company have recently placed an order for a 15,000 ton bulk carrier with the Verolme United Shipyards, Rotterdam, as it is becoming clear that an efficient shipping company must be able to cater for the growing development of specialised bulk carriage for certain traffics, such as ore and even grain. These three vessels are of the most modern design and are expected to make a net profit plus depreciation even with present depressed freight rates.
I should perhaps define current shipbuilding policy as at present determined and agreed by the Board. The ideal time to build new ships is when new building and laid-up shipping are declining, when scrapping is necessary and when there is evidence that freight rates are on the upgrade. Even under the present conditions a number of vessels are earning profits and the company is not overburdened with out of date ships whose costs are out of line with present competitive conditions.
It is the practice of Irish Shipping Ltd., when ordering a new vessel, to seek competitive tenders from leading shipyards and the company have invariably invited tenders from any Irish yard which might be interested, including the Belfast yard of Harland and Wolff Ltd. It is expected that the Verolme Cork Dockyard will, with its modern layout and prefabrication techniques, be in a position to compete with the best foreign yards and that the vessel at present being built there for Irish Shipping Ltd. will herald a new era for Irish shipbuilding.
In their relatively short life so far of twenty years the company have succeeded in establishing a substantial fleet of modern ships, which, when the two ships on order are delivered, will amount to 138,000 tons dead-weight of dry cargo tonnage and nearly 40,000 tons of tanker tonnage. The present fleet represents a capital investment of the order of £13.7 millions, to which the State has contributed about £8.4 millions. That this investment has been a fruitful one is clear when we consider that (1) we have now a first-class fleet capable of diversified operation with vessels varying from the largest deep-sea freighters to small coasters—this fleet is one of the largest purely cargo fleets in these islands and we are now well on the way towards the target of 200,000 tons of dry-cargo tonnage which, it is estimated, would be sufficient to meet our essential needs in a future national emergency; (2) over the years Irish Shipping Ltd. have, by their earnings abroad, contributed substantially to our balance of payments; in 1960 the company's net contribution, on current account, amounted to £1,685,000; (3) the company have paid a total of about £2,750,000 income tax; (4) direct employment is given by the Company to about 800 men ashore and afloat; and (5) the repair, overhaul, bunkering and provisioning of the company's vessels are carried out in the State to the greatest extent practicable and the building of large vessels for the company at home has now commenced also. May I again comment on the fine reputation carried by the company throughout the world.
The provision of £240,000 for grants for harbour improvement works covers works in progress, or expected to commence shortly. The principal current improvement schemes are those for Drogheda and Galway, for which grants totalling £175,000 and £340,000, respectively, have been authorised and which it is expected will get under way during the year. This head also covers provision for the construction of two new passenger liner tenders, by Liffey Dockyard Ltd. to the order of the Cork Harbour Commissioners, of which the State is meeting half the cost.
The provision in 1959/60 was for a total expenditure on harbours of £120,648, but expenditure in the period reached only £105,000, because certain works, contrary to expectations, did not commence within the year. In addition to the grants for harbour improvement works from the Vote for Transport and Power, there is also provision in the Estimates for non-voted capital services, comprising a total of £83,000 for works at Dublin, Cork and Limerick, for which grants from the National Development Fund were approved. By now all of our commercial harbours have since 1945 either received a generous measure of State assistance towards essential improvement works or have applications under consideration.
I should make it quite clear that the grant of State assistance for a harbour is an exceptional measure. If proposed improvement works are of a productive nature, which they certainly should be, it is for the harbour authority in the first place to raise the necessary funds by borrowing, with the assistance of the local authorities or other local interests who stand to benefit from the improvements. State assistance must be reserved for essential and productive schemes, the full cost of which cannot be met locally.
Generation of electricity in the year ended 31st March, 1960 at 2,094 million units was 10.4 per cent. greater than in the previous year. In the year just ended the rate of increase in demand was about the same. Industrial consumption was 566 million units in the year ended 31st March, 1960, or an increase of 19 per cent. while domestic consumption was 703 million units or an increase of 5 per cent. The rate of expansion for industrial consumption at 19 per cent. in the year ended 31st March, 1960, was inflated somewhat by the incidence of one large new consumer (the oil refinery) but provisional information for the year ended 31st March, 1961, shows that industrial demand continued to be buoyant showing an increase of approximately 11.9 per cent. which is higher than the rate of increase in domestic demand at some 8.3 per cent.
I understand that the provisional results for the year ended 31st March, 1961, show a reasonable surplus and this is welcome news after deficiencies in the three preceding years. The improvement is due almost entirely to saving on fuel costs made possible by the phenomenal increase in output from hydroelectric stations in what was an abnormally wet year; the recent increases in rates did not significantly affect receipts in the year 1960/61.
An important consideration for the E.S.B. is that their operating results may fluctuate up and down by as much as £500,000 in any one year according to weather and the Board must therefore keep reserves to meet losses in bad years and to defer as long as possible unavoidable increases in rates. It may be expected therefore that the Board will use this surplus to help make good the inroads made on their reserves by the losses of the past three years.
When I spoke on this occasion last year, I mentioned that the new generation programme which had been approved was based on an estimated annual rate of increase in demand of 7 per cent. The annual rate of increase has now been running at about 10 per cent. for the past two years and it has, therefore, become necessary to accelerate the commissioning of new generating plant.
As Deputies are aware, the Board's charges, for both rural and urban supply had to be increased last year to correct a mounting deficit on the Board's overall revenue account. As the Board's accounts show, the loss on rural areas was reaching very substantial proportions. The Board is bound by statute to adjust its charges so that its revenue will be sufficient to meet expenditure and it was, therefore, imperative to increase charges. The increases were very moderate and were the minimum necessary to enable the Board to comply with their statutory obligation to keep the undertaking solvent.
Electricity here is a relatively very cheap commodity. Wages, salaries, construction costs, the cost of other fuels and the cost of food and agricultural produce have all increased far more than the cost of electricity which has increased by only 36 per cent. since before the war.
As far as rural areas are concerned the effect of the recent increase in charges is to add between 3d. and 4d. a week to the total bill for the typical farm consumer.
There is, however, an offset to this increase by the reduction from 80 to 60 in the number of units charged at the higher price. Any rural consumer using between 80 and 360 units per two months is, therefore, saving 1s. 2d. per period on the unit charges previously applicable. The charge has been made that rural consumers, when canvassed for supply, were assured that the fixed charge component of the Board's tariff would never be increased. No responsible official of the E.S.B. was ever authorised to give such an assurance and though I have gone exhaustively into the matter I have found no evidence that any such official ever did. In any case every contract for supply of current signed by every applicant makes it clear that the level of the whole may be raised at the Board's discretion.
The rural electrification scheme as originally planned will be completed in 1962 at a cost of between £31 and £32 million. At that stage, some 280,000 rural premises or 75 per cent. of the premises in the areas developed under the programme will have been connected. The remaining 25 per cent. remain unconnected mainly because they are so situated that the charge for making supply available to them after taking account of subsidy would be higher than the occupiers are prepared to pay. In addition, there are a number of isolated areas the connection of which would be so uneconomic as to be completely impossible under the present programme. The E.S.B., of course, go back over areas which have already been developed and people who refused to take supply initially have another opportunity of being connected at comparatively moderate rates of charge, though somewhat higher than if they had taken the supply when the areas were being developed initially. The whole position regarding the development of rural electrification on the completion of the present programme is one which is at present under examination.
Last year was not a very favourable one for Bord na Móna. Owing to the bad weather during the harvesting season, output of sod and milled peat at about 1½ million tons, was more than 25 per cent. below target and the Board expect therefore to show a loss for the year, after paying interest and depreciation, of the order of £100,000 approximately as compared with a profit of £35,000 in 1959/60. In order to avoid the adverse effects of a wet year in the future, arrangements have now been made to maintain a stock-pile of milled peat which will be fed in years of good production.
The new briquette factory at Derrin-lough was in operation for most of the year and brought the Board's total briquette output to about 120,000 tons. A second new briquette factory at Croghan with an output of 100,000 tons commenced testing just before Easter. This should meet the growing demand for this very new and attractive fuel, but the possibilities of further expansion must await the result of marketing experience. Exports of peat moss litter, and peat for ad-mixture with coal for coke production, as well as peat for mixing with foundry sand have been maintained. Deputies will have an early opportunity of considering the affairs of Bord na Móna in more detail as it will be necessary in the near future to introduce a Bill to authorise increased capital expenditure on turf development.
Coal imports were approximately the same in 1960 as in 1959 being 1,660,000 as against 1,600,000 tons. Great Britain, imports from which were almost 1,200,000 tons, recovered her position in the Irish market to the extent of about 300,000 tons, mainly at the expense of the United States, whose exports to this country fell from 462,000 tons to 184,000 tons. Imports from Germany—126,000 tons and Poland—134,000 tons were about the same as last year.
Home production of semi-bituminous coal in the Arigna Area has been running at about the same rate as last year when it was between 65,000 and 70,000 tons. Efforts to achieve greater utilisation of Arigna coal are proceeding and, under a technical assistance scheme, expert consultants have been appointed to carry out investigations directed to the possibilities of increased use of this coal for generation of electricity. Their report is expected in the current year. In this matter my Department is operating in conjunction with the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Anthracite production has shown a rise in 1960. At approximately 185,000 tons, it was 30,000 tons higher than the average for some years previous. About 10,000 tons were exported during the year. This compares with exports of approximately 1,000 tons in 1959. Certain grades of anthracite must be imported, of course, but imports in 1960 were about 55,000 tons or about 5,000 tons below the figure for the previous year.
The mines generally were able to dispose of their output although stocks at the end of 1960 were over 8,000 tons higher than at the end of 1959. Some dissatisfaction has been expressed with the sizing of certain grades of Irish anthracite and the mines and the merchants, under the stimulus of my Department, are co-operating in an endeavour to eliminate any cause for complaint.
I would like to refer to the scheme for promoting fuel efficiency in industry which is operated by my Department. Under the scheme grants are made available towards the cost of efficiency surveys of heating and power plant installations carried out by expert consultants. The maximum amount of this grant in any case is one third the cost of the survey.
Quite striking savings have been achieved by a number of firms who acted on the recommendations of consultants employed under the scheme. The response to the scheme has however been somewhat disappointing. I have recently arranged to have the scheme republished and I hope to see a greater response in the future.
I should also like to mention the very commendable efforts being made by commercial interests to popularise native fuels for domestic heating using high efficiency installations. It is gratifying to see such an enlightened awareness of the importance of fuel efficiency and it is greatly to be hoped that this attitude will become widespread.
At Shannon airport the new main runway which was brought into operation during 1960 is 10,000 feet in length and has ensured the use of the airport by fully loaded jet aircraft on flights to and from North America. Major extensions to the terminal building have been completed. These extensions provide improved and increased accommodation for passengers and public. Extension of the aircraft parking area is necessary to enable jet aircraft to be brought close to the terminal building and the work is proceeding. The new freight terminal building which is required to provide for the increasing terminal traffic during the winter will, it is hoped, be completed by October, 1961.
Whilst the number of aircraft landings at the airport—8,300 during 1960—showed a decrease of 11 per cent. on the 1959 figure the total number of passengers handled increased by 2 per cent. to 416,300. This represented one-fifth of all the air travellers on the North Atlantic route. The airport's total freight traffic at 18,163 metric tons was down by 11 per cent. as compared with 1959 but mail increased by 7 per cent. The drop in freight was due to decreases in transit traffic. The North Atlantic freight traffic through Shannon at 17,904 metric tons amounted, however, to one-third of all the air cargo over the North Atlantic. There was a substantial increase in terminal traffic. The number of terminal passengers—62,705 embarked and 58,132 disembarked—increased by 26 per cent. over 1959 while the amount of terminal freight—904 tons embarked and 901 tons disembarked—increased by 29 per cent. For the first five months of 1961 the terminal passenger traffic increased by 49 per cent. over the corresponding 1960 period.
The decline in passenger and freight transit traffic at the airport during the year has been counter-balanced to a great extent by increases in terminal traffic, i.e. in traffic originating and finishing there. An important element in the increasing terminal traffic at the airport is the development of the new industrial estate which is already providing about 70 tons of air freight a month. The availability of this new and increasing cargo should prove most attractive to airlines operating through the airport.
Eight foreign airlines are operating scheduled jet airplane services through Shannon airport. Present information indicates that with the introduction of jets on the transatlantic passenger services the airlines will schedule more passenger flights to land at Shannon this summer than they did in 1960. It is also encouraging to see that there is a recovery in the downward trend of landings by scheduled cargo aircraft at the airport. At this stage an estimate of total non-scheduled landings cannot be made but these are beginning to form quite a considerable proportion of the traffic at the airport—almost 40 per cent. in 1960. In the months of December 1960, and May, 1961 for example, a total of 103 and 147 jet planes landed at Shannon.
The increase in overall passenger traffic at the airport is reflected in an increase in the turnover of the sales and catering service. Turnover in the half-year ended 31st January, 1961, the latest period for which figures are available, amounted to £743,349, an increase of 7 per cent. on the turnover during the corresponding period of the previous year. This is a satisfactory development after the decline in trading which occurred in 1959 as a result of decreased activity at Shannon airport. This service necessarily depends on the level of traffic particularly passenger traffic at the airport.
The total capital expenditure on Shannon airport amounted to £4,615,000 on 31st March, 1961. For the financial year ended 31st March, 1961, total revenue at the airport was £728,472 and expenditure was £579,958. The operation of the airport in that year yielded a surplus of £148,514. This figure, however, makes no allowance for pension liability nor for depreciation and interest on capital which amounted to £456,000 for the year. Although air travel is now a normal feature of modern life airports all over Europe lose money. I am glad to say that the operating revenue at Shannon is considerably more than the operating cost while at Dublin both items are virtually even. But additional revenue is required to pay interest and depreciation. The receipts as a percentage of total costs are favourable when compared with other European airports.
In my view it should be the aim to operate all airports without any loss whatever. Unfortunately, there is a factor present here which does not apply to other types of transport in that an increase in landing charges to balance expenditure would distort the cost structure of fares charged by both our own and foreign air operators. Until the other countries cease imposing an unnecessary tax on national and municipal budgets in order to maintain their airports though the total may be small, I cannot enforce a "pay as you go" system at our airports.
Activities at Dublin airport continue to expand. During the year 1960, there were record totals of 15,200 aircraft landings, 818,800 passengers and 14,400 tons of freight handled, representing increases of 24 per cent., 27 per cent. and 39 per cent. respectively over the 1959 figures. Since June, 1960, when I last spoke on this matter, new sceduled services have commenced to operate into the airport. B.K.S. Air Transport Limited, in conjunction with Aer Lingus, operate a passenger service between Dublin and Belfast; Airlines (Jersey) Limited operate from Exeter to Dublin and Air Safaris Limited have recently introduced a service from Bournemouth.
Perhaps the major development during the year in this respect was the introduction in April, 1960, of the Liverpool-Dublin vehicle air ferry service, which carried over 1,500 cars and other small vehicles during the season. The service, which was suspended for the winter season, has been recently re-introduced. There is still a great untapped potential for carrying vehicles by air which can be of considerable benefit to the tourist industry. One essential to profitability is, however, that the service should be provided over the shortest possible route and I am hoping, therefore, for a favourable outcome to negotiations which I am having with the British Minister of Aviation on the provision of more suitable terminals on the British side. Other routes have already been approved and in the meantime the B.K.S. Liverpool-Dublin service will continue.
Extensions of the main runway and of a subsidiary runway to provide for the full economic use of the Aer Lingus Viscount 808 aircraft and to permit of the Limited jet operations which Aer Lingus are carrying out between Shannon and Dublin, have been completed. The new hangar for jet aircraft was put into use in December, 1960. The continuing increase of traffic at Dublin airport has necessitated additional aircraft parking space and the work is nearing completion. Traffic developments have also necessitated the provision of extra passenger and public accommodation and a new "finger" building or pier as an extension to the main terminal building is under construction. Progress has been delayed owing to the calling off of cement supplies during the industrial dispute. Nevertheless, it is expected to be available for the greater part of this year's busy season. Other projects include offices for administration and staff catering, flight victualling and cabin services and a new peat fuel boiler unit.
Owing to the steady and considerable increase in traffic at Dublin airport in recent years, it has become necessary to provide for further developments. A co-ordinated overall plan of development for the foreseeable future is at present being formulated.
The total capital expenditure on Dublin airport up to 31st March, 1961, amounted to £2,417,619. In the year ended 31st March, 1961, total revenue at the airport was £340,000 and expenditure amounted to £343,867. The operation of the airport, therefore, showed an operating deficit of £3,867 in that year. This figure makes no allowance for pension liability nor for depreciation and interest on capital which amounted to £229,000 for the year.
Construction of the new Cork airport, which commenced last year, is progressing steadily. Due to the 70 per cent. above normal rainfall from October 1960 and during the early part of this year progress was inevitably retarded but advantage has since been taken of the improved weather conditions to press ahead with the work as quickly as possible.
It was intended that flying operations would commence at the airport on 1st September, 1961, but owing to the industrial dispute affecting cement supplies, it will not now be possible to start operating until 16th October, 1961. Aer Lingus will operate scheduled services from Cork to Dublin, London, Bristol, Cardiff and Paris. Cambrian Airways, a British independent airline, will operate in conjunction with Aer Lingus on the services to London, Bristol and Cardiff. Services to Cork by other British independent airlines from Derby, Leeds, Manchester, Newcastle, Jersey and Exeter are also envisaged.
Total capital expenditure at the airport up to 31st March, 1961 amounted to £457,483.
In order to meet the future financial requirements of the air companies, a Bill has passed the Second Stage in the Dáil to increase the authorised share capital of Aer Rianta from £10 million to £13 million and to make provision for the issue by the Exchequer to Aer Rianta of repayable advances up to a maximum amount of £1 million. The total amount of issued share capital of Aer Rianta at present is £9,975,541 as against the figure of £10 million authorised under the Air Navigation and Transport (No. 2) Act, 1959.
I would like in referring to the progress of the air companies to mention that Aer Lingus has just completed a quarter of a century's operations. The directors and management of the air companies are to be congratulated on the successful expansion of activities in Britain, Europe and North America, based on sound economic principles and wise guidance since 1936. In the year ended 31st March, 1960, Aer Lingus made an operating surplus of £170,148 and in the six months ended 30th September, 1960, the operating surplus was £210,000. The financial accounts of the company for the year ended 31st March, 1961, are not yet available but I understand from the company that the airline will show a surplus of about £180,000 for that year. The company's total passenger traffic increased by 25 per cent. from 567,000 in the year ended 31st March, 1960, to 712,000 in the year ended 31st March, 1961. Freight traffic increased by 39 per cent. to 10,875,000 kilos (10,680 tons) and mail by 4 per cent. to 1,650,000 kilos (1,630 tons). Aer Lingus recently inaugurated a new service on the route Dublin-Jersey-Rennes. The company's frequencies of services on many of its existing routes are being increased. In the first five months of 1961, passenger traffic increased by 28 per cent. over the 1960 period.
The present operational strength of the Aer Lingus fleet consists of 7 sixty-five seater Viscount 808, 7 forty-seater Friendship F.27 and 5 thirty-two seater DC 3 aircraft. The passenger and freight traffic have increased in the first four months of this year by 24 per cent. and 44 per cent. respectively, over the 1960 period.
Aerlínte financial results for the twelve months ended 31st March, 1960, showed that there was an operating loss of £589,080 for the year, compared with an operating loss of £788,599 for the eleven months ended 31st March, 1959. The accounts for the six months ended 30th September, 1960, showed an operating surplus of £143,000 compared with a deficit of £286,000 in the same period of 1959. The provisional accounts for the year 1960/61 show a probable deficit of the order of £80,000.
The Aerlínte transatlantic service was inaugurated in April, 1958, with the leasing of Super Constellations from Seaboard and World Airlines Incorporated. This arrangement was terminated in December, 1960, when the company introduced its own Boeing Jet service, each plane carrying a maximum of 137 passengers. In the year ended 31st March, 1961, the company carried 35,176 passengers representing an increase of 51 per cent. on the previous year. Freight carried increased by 210 per cent. to 347 tons and mail by 9 per cent. to 48 tons. In the first five complete months of operation of the jets, January to May of this year, a passenger increase of 78 per cent.—11,645 as against 6,547—was recorded over the corresponding five months of the year 1960, when piston-engined aircraft were used.
As Deputies are probably aware, there has been much publicity in regard to the failure of the world's airlines to reach agreement on the levels of rates for transatlantic air freight. With the increased capacity now available and the introduction of new specially designed all-freight aircraft, the way is clear for a considerable reduction in the freight rates previously charged, particularly for the larger consignments. Agreement has now been reached on new rates and subject to the approval of Governments, they will come into effect on 1st October, 1961. Quite substantial reductions are to be introduced, especially for large consignments. The rates are at present being examined in my Department.
The Shannon Free Airport Development Co. Ltd., which was incorporated in 1959, continues its activities to promote the increased use of Shannon airport for passenger and freight traffic and for tourist, commercial and industrial purposes. The company works in close harmony in industrial matters with the Industrial Development Authority and, in tourist development matters, with Bord Fáilte Éireann.
The company's main sources of finance are provided under the authority of the Shannon Free Airport Development Company Limited Act, 1959. The Act authorises the Minister for Finance to subscribe for shares in the company up to an aggregate limit of £1,500,000. The Act also authorises the provision by way of Grant-in-Aid voted annually of sums which in the aggregate shall not exceed £500,000.
The capital is being used by the company for the construction of factory buildings and dwellings. The income from these activities is used to supplement the company's grant income. The non-repayable grants are used by the company in meeting its running expenses and providing financial assistance to new industrial undertakings at the airport. Capital issues to the company up to 31st March, 1961, amounted to £1,168,000 and payments by way of grant-in-aid to £367,500.
I am happy to say that encouraging progress has been made with the development of the industrial estate. Sixteen factory bays and a special factory for a piano manufacturer have been completed and on the basis of the continuation of the present promotional programme, the company envisages building in the current financial year a further ten factory bays and ancillary buildings and a scheme of one hundred dwellings for workers will also be undertaken. These dwellings are in addition to ten houses which have been constructed and a scheme of 137 flats which are at present under construction and which will be completed during the current year. Employment in May was 724 and it is estimated that by next March this figure will have reached about 1,250. The following are among the commodities being manufactured at the airport: radios, floor maintenance machinery, knitted jersey fabrics and fully fashioned garments, wire gauze, precision threaded fasteners and miniature capacitors and pianos.
Apart from the direct incentives to manufacture which are available at Shannon, such as factory premises for rent, taxation relief, grants for machinery and training, and relatively low labour costs, firms have been attracted by the availability of air transport from their factory doors to any part of the world. They are primarily export industries and do not intend to compete in the home market with other Irish manufacturers. Factories providing goods of high value in relation to volume, where speed of delivery is an important element, are in a position to deliver goods by air to any part of the world within a few days. Freight traffic has been constantly increasing and it is estimated that by 1965 over 5 million kilogrammes of air freight will be generated annually by the factory operations now established or planned at Shannon.
The company has leased factories as quickly as they can be built and, given the resources necessary, proposes to maintain a continuous programme of factory building up to the limit of demand. To enable the company to continue its work of attracting industries to the airport, legislation is before the House to provide additional finance when the present statutory limits have been reached.
I attach great importance to the introduction of modern methods in industry in Ireland and to the desirability of employing the best technical assistance to study problems of productivity, rationalisation and the use to the best advantage of labour. These problems have been the subject of wide international study and I am glad to say that the State-sponsored bodies under my control are fully alive to the need for employing modern methods of work study and organisation in their structures.
In all cases, industrial consultants have been engaged to examine existing systems and to recommend improvements. Officers of the companies have been sent abroad on courses in management to keep in touch with the latest trends. Each company has a special division, including work study teams specially trained for the purpose. These divisions are actively engaged in a constant review of existing procedures so as to ensure that the most up-to-date systems are adopted. Training courses for staff employed in the organisations are an important part of these arrangements. I may say that training courses for certain grades of staff are also becoming a feature of my own Department. The results have proved to be advantageous and are a clear proof of the profit to be gained from applying the latest techniques of work study to the problems that arise in every industry.
In the case of the transport and power industries forward planning is essential to expansion and economy. We must endeavour to be ready in good time to meet the growing demands of tourism and industry and not allow ourselves to be overtaken by events and committed willy-nilly to wasteful and inadequate temporary expedients. Both in relation to the activities of the Department and those of the State bodies for which I am responsible I have repeatedly stressed the importance of this forward-look approach. The development of our airports is kept under continual review so as to ensure that the ever-growing air traffic will not find us unprepared. The airlines watch traffic developments with the need in mind for timely replacement and additions for their fleets. SFAD Co. are pushing ahead with the development of the World's First Air Industrial Estate which involves planning over the next five years. C.I.E. have embarked on a comprehensive programme of improvements which look forward to bigger business created by better service. The need for long term planning and co-ordination by E.S.B. and Bord na Móna is obvious to all. Irish Shipping Ltd. has a long term programme for the expansion of the fleet to the approved target of 200,000 tons.
It is not enough to plan ahead. Both now and in the future the State-sponsored bodies must aim at the maximum of efficiency in their operation and to this end it is essential that advantage be taken of new modern techniques of management and production. I can tell the Dáil that in the introduction of new methods and techniques the State-sponsored bodies are in the front rank and will, so far as I am concerned, remain there. Only by those methods can they play their full rôle in the development of our economy. Increased productivity is also the only means by which a rising standard of remuneration for their staffs can be guaranteed.
Comment on this
We have just heard the Minister introduce his Estimate for possibly the last time under a Fianna Fáil Government for a good while, we hope. The Minister is the first Minister for Transport and Power, which was a branch of the Department of Industry and Commerce prior to this. Therefore it might be no harm to review the activities of Fianna Fáil in so far as transport and power are concerned since they came into office.
The Minister's Department deals with three branches of transport and power. It deals with transport by land, transport by sea and transport by air. So far as power is concerned, it deals with power by electricity and power from mineral sources, but I think it is agreed on all sides that transport and power now are developed from one main source and that is from electricity. The others are merely subsidiaries. It might be no harm if I opened up my remarks on the debate with electricity.
I was delighted to hear a Fianna Fáil Minister pay such tribute to the E.S.B. and to the magnificent work that is being done by it. I am not in the least surprised when I see some Fianna Fáil Deputies hang their heads. I am afraid that Deputy MacCarthy is the only one of the senior members present who remembers the description by the present Tánaiste of the E.S.B. —the whole Shannon Scheme. It was described by him as a white elephant. Away back in 1927 when we had pioneers in this country—thank God we have one still on the front benches of Fine Gael in the person of Deputy McGilligan—who set out to develop electricity in this country. They were the pioneers. I am referring to politicians so far as Deputy McGilligan is concerned, but we had the technicians too. One is still with us— Dr. Tommy McLoughlin. They were the real pioneers of electricity in this country. As a result of their initiative they were able to turn out, through the development of the Shannon Scheme, electricity at roughly .3d. per unit.
We thought in those early stages— I did not; I was too young to think of it but my predecessors on these benches did—that we would continue the initiative displayed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in the development of electricity. I wonder do Deputies remember what the Shannon Scheme was described as? I am very glad to see the present Lord Mayor of Limerick here when I know what was done for what I might describe as the magnificent city of Limerick by those pioneers, Deputy McGilligan and Dr. Tommy McLoughlin in the development of electricity in this country.
When I think of what the present Government thought of the magnificent work done by those pioneers it annoys me. We all know what white elephants are but suppose we had accepted their advice?
Comment on this
The Deputy may and some day I hope he will initiate me into a knowledge of them. Suppose we had adopted the advice of Fianna Fáil and shut our eyes to the development of electricity; unfortunately in 1932 the people of this country did adopt the advice of Fianna Fáil and what has happened? In 1927 we were able to turn out electricity at .3d. per unit but, as a result of the advice of Fianna Fáil to the E.S.B., electricity today costs us 1d. per unit. If we had developed the rivers and the various other schemes then advocated by the old Cumann na nGaedheal Party and adopted by the technicians of the E.S.B., we would now be able to turn out electricity at .3d. and we would have no necessity for the protests of the Deputies from West Donegal, West Cork, West Mayo and the various other constituencies along the western seaboard against what the Minister described as "something over which he has no function"—the increase to consumers under rural electrification.
It amuses me to hear the Minister say today: "bodies under my control" and he includes in them the E.S.B. I asked a question last week to know the number of households cut off by the E.S.B. in the Rosses of West Donegal within the past six months and the reasons for it. I was told by the Ceann Comhairle that he refused to submit the question to the Minister for the simple reason that he had no control over the day-to-day activities of the E.S.B.
Comment on this
No, that is where the Deputy makes a mistake. The reason was emigration but the Ceann Comhairle refused to submit the question as the Minister was not responsible for the day-to-day affairs of what he now describes as "bodies under my control."
Comment on this
Which you refused to put back. You would not have rural electrification in this country if it were not for the inter-Party Government. It is Deputies like Deputy O'Malley from cities such as Limerick who have left rural Ireland as it is today. Take rural electrification. We initiated the E.S.B. in 1927. Unfortunately the Cumann na nGaedheal Government went out of office in 1932. From 1932 to 1948 we never heard of rural electrification and then, in 1948 for the first time, an inter-Party Government decided that every house in Ireland was entitled to electricity and they did their best to provide that social amenity for every house. We were doing very well; we had reached the stage where 23 out of 26 counties had reached a position in which they could say that rural electrification was available for every house. Back came Fianna Fáil and what has happened? Deputy Breslin and Deputy Brennan, the present Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, are going round the country protesting against the charges now being made for rural electricity, all imposed by the body which the Minister takes credit for—"bodies under his control". Yet when we ask a question here, he holds up his hands in holy horror and says: "I have nothing to do with that body."
Can he answer that question for the people of the country because I am going to pose it and so are my colleagues here at every meeting during the coming general election? I want to know why a body under his control has left 120 people in west Donegal without rural electricity? Some, of course, have gone for reasons over which he has no control. However, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Taoiseach have. The other day in my own area the Minister for the Gaeltacht opened a new Irish college and we had there the pessimistic statement of the local parish priest that in ten years' time all we shall have left in the area will be 20 old people.
Comment on this
I know the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is slightly blind. With the greatest respect, I did not mean that. I should have said that the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is possibly deaf at times when statements are made outside this House. Inside the House his hearing may be perfect. Be that as it may, I heard that statement, and the Leas-Cheann Comhairle heard it, in an area where cheap electricity should be made available for the people by the Minister for Transport and Power.
The next matter with which I wish to deal is C.I.E. I was but a young qualified professional man when C.I.E. was established by Fianna Fáil. I remember the old Dublin South-Eastern Railway, the Great Southern Railways and the Great Northern Railway. I also recall the days of the Lough Swilly Railway and the other County Donegal railways. When Fianna Fáil came into office they told the House, the country and myself, through the medium of the newspapers, how a national subsidised body such as C.I.E. would run the transport of the country efficiently and cheaply and that in future there would be no need to subsidise small lines like the Lough Swilly Railway.
At that time we were prepared to accept the arguments offered by the present Taoiseach who was then Minister for Industry and Commerce. But what did we find? After about four years there began an automatic closing-down of these railways. Before I came into politics I remember, as a solicitor, being instructed by the people in the Rosses, in Gweedore and in other areas in West Donegal to oppose at an inquiry the closing down of the Lough Swilly Railway Company. All I had to go on were the instructions of my clients, the poor people of Gweedore and the Rosses and the other places up there. They instructed me, and senior counsel through me, to oppose the closing of these railways and the present Taoiseach, through C.I.E., put the case before the tribunal that, before the lines were closed, the main roads and the county roads would be put into such a condition that they would be able to carry all the traffic which might be diverted from the railways.
We argued against that. We said it could not be done. We said also that the freight rates would be increased. That was the case put to the tribunal by my senior counsel, Mr. Seán MacBride. That railway was closed down 21 years ago and in the mean-time every penny we could afford to divert from the Road Fund was put into the main roads instead of going towards the improvement of the county roads. I remember some years ago a deputation led by Senator Louis Walsh and including the Deputies for the county, going to the present Taoiseach and making a case for the retention of the railway line between Glenties and Stranorlar. We were told by the very efficient officials of the Department of Industry and Commerce, over which the present Taoiseach then presided, that the road between Glenties and Stranorlar would be able to carry all the traffic which would be diverted to it from the railway line.
What do we find now? All the moneys diverted from the Road Fund are being put into a road carrying the traffic which the railway line could carry much more efficiently and much more cheaply. I shall not refer to the Tramore and the Waterford line. Deputy MacCarthy knows all about that and perhaps he would be able to tell me that advantages have been taken of the Road Fund grants but is he satisfied with what the Minister for Transport and Power is doing in that area? Is it any substitute for the railway line which was there and which is no more? That is all I shall say as far as C.I.E. is concerned.
Comment on this
I have the greatest respect for him. Let us take Shannon airport. Supposing you had not the Shannon scheme where were you today? Supposing Paddy McGilligan and Tommy McLoughlin and their colleagues of the day had not developed the power of the Shannon where would Shannon airport be today?
Comment on this
Developed by whom? By the people who called it a white elephant? You would be burning turf somewhere down in Birr. I have nothing but respect for the general manager of Aer Lingus, for the former manager of Bord na Móna and for the general manager of C.I.E., but where would they be were it not for the foresight of Deputy McGilligan in developing the Shannon for hydro-electric purposes? Were it not for that Shannon airport would at the moment be an undeveloped area. I say that with nothing in my mind, even on the eve of a general election, but respect for the men who have now developed Shannon Airport.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy agree that the people who developed the Shannon scheme are people who deserved the greatest credit? What about the people who called the Shannon scheme a white elephant? The Minister for Transport and Power now takes credit for the development of the harbours.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan will tell the Deputy. I am speaking only of the people who made it possible for Shannon airport to be developed.
Comment on this
I know what the Deputy is getting at. He is Mayor of Limerick on the eve of a general election and I know he wants to be elected again. I do not want to express any opinion on that. However, when he talks about the development of the harbours there is something in which he may be interested. Did he hear the Minister for Transport and Power today say a word about Limerick harbour?
Comment on this
Go up along the whole west coast of Ireland and where is there one solitary harbour grant mentioned in the Minister's speech to-day? He talks about the transfer to the container service between Greenore and the Six Counties. I am very glad to see that the Minister is interested in the Six Counties.
Comment on this
I hope he continues to move closer. I can remember the time when he thought that there were no harbours anywhere but on the east coast.
Comment on this
The Minister tells us that grants were given. The western harbours have not received grants.
Comment on this
Not one of them received a shilling under Fianna Fáil. Galway did not get a shilling.
Comment on this
Deputies should allow Deputy O'Donnell to make his speech. There are far too many interruptions.
Comment on this
Of course it was. Deputy O'Malley should move north and north west and get to know what is happening. I know that he used to go there in his early days like the rest of us but of late years he has lost touch. I am dealing only on very general ground with the Minister's speech and I will leave it to my colleagues to deal with it further, particularly Deputy McGilligan, to whom I will pay a tribute for the various schemes initiated by him in the time of the old Cumann na nGaedheal Government.
Comment on this
At the outset I would like to pay a compliment to the excellent introductory speech which the Minister has made on his Estimate. It is comprehensive and enlightening and Deputy O'Donnell, for one, has not gone to any great trouble to read it or he would not make some of the allegations he has made. Before dealing with some of the points referred to by Deputy O'Donnell I should like to draw the Minister's attention to one matter which I hope he will deal with in the course of his reply.
A great injustice is being done at the present time. It has nothing to do with the day-to-day administration of C.I.E. but I think a responsibility rests on the Minister to investigate the matter and put it right. Briefly, I refer to the appalling state of C.I.E. pensioners. I am not going into detail and I do not think it would be in order to do so or to go into the inadequacy of the pension generally but it is only fair to say that when pensioners reach the age of 70 years and become eligible for the £2 a week old age pension, these pensioners who have all been in insurable employment have the pensions paid to them by C.I.E. cut to a certain extent. I think that if a pensioner has £X or shillings a week and gets the £2 old age pension he is entitled to get that £2 plus X.
Comment on this
We shall hear what the Government's view is. Personally, I am not interested in whether the Government agrees or disagrees with me. I am telling the Government what should be done. We cannot be muzzled because we disagree or agree with the Government.
Comment on this
When we see that an injustice is being done it is our duty to bring it to the attention of the Government. I have already written to the Chairman of C.I.E. on the matter. It is not only the pensioners in Limerick that are concerned; it also concerns those in Dublin, Galway and everywhere else. The people who get £2 a week when they reach the age of 70 are entitled to it and it is no skin off the nose of C.I.E. whether they get it or not. There is no reason why C.I.E. should cut their pensions when they get that £2. I shall leave it at that. No doubt the Minister will have some explanation of it.
We heard Deputy O'Donnell refer to the Shannon scheme and bring up the hardy annual that Fianna Fáil classified it as a white elephant. It would be well worthwhile for Deputies on the Opposition benches who wish to perpetuate this suggestion to look up the records on the matter. One of the best speeches made at that time, in 1926 or 1927, was made by the former Taoiseach, now President de Valera. There was no question that we opposed the Shannon scheme but the Fianna Fáil Party at the time were opposed to the location of the Shannon scheme at Ardnacrusha. As President de Valera pointed out, the Fianna Fáil Party were in full agreement in principle with the absolute necessity for electricity for our industrial development and for the advancement of agriculture but he stated categorically that the Fianna Fáil Party were advised by their experts, and, after considering the matter themselves, were of the opinion that the best possible location for hydro-electric power in this country would be the Liffey. All that is a long time ago and time has proved the attitude then to have been the correct one.
Initially the Liffey would have been the correct location. It matters not the slightest now. Suffice to say that, so far as I am concerned, I agree with Deputy O'Donnell that the people who initiated those projects deserve the everlasting thanks of the people and the State. I do not think anyone would try to deprecate the Shannon scheme or the initiation of hydro-electric schemes in this country. It is as well that we should clear up the matter once and for all; Fianna Fáil were never opposed to the introduction of hydro-electric schemes in this country. The only argument was simply one of location. Deputy O'Donnell suggested, if my hearing is correct, that in 1927 electricity was being sold at .3d. per unit.
Comment on this
No. He said experts said it could be produced at .3d. and it was. That is what the experts said.
Comment on this
I understood Deputy O'Donnell to say that the price of electricity in 1927 was .3d. per unit.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan interrupts and says that what Deputy O'Donnell said was that the experts said electricity could be produced at .3d., and it was. Where is the difference? Electricity in 1927 was .3d. per unit.
Comment on this
I accept that. Deputy O'Donnell then went on to say that electricity is 1d. per unit today. Was that the figure he gave?
Comment on this
And he castigated this Government for being in the main the principal contributory factor in that increase from .3d., or 33? per cent. to 100 per cent. Surely all costs have gone up substantially. Labour charges have increased. Wages, thank God, have risen substantially. The price of fuel has increased. So have many other things. I cannot see how that line of argument can be sustained. However, Deputy O'Donnell did not pursue the argument about rural electrification very far. In actual fact, the increase on the rural consumers is due to the action of the last Coalition Government, in which Government Deputy Norton was Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Norton, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, with the agreement of the last Coalition Government, removed the subsidy on rural electrification. Deputy McGilligan asked: "Did you put it back?" We did put it back actually.
Comment on this
And it is being paid by the rural consumer. You restored a subsidy and it is being paid by the rural consumer.
Comment on this
First of all, a statement is made bluntly in the belief that people will swallow it. It is stated we did not restore the subsidy, that we never put it back. Now the admission is, yes, we did put it back.
Comment on this
We restarted the subsidy for the current year. We did not restore the subsidy that had not been paid by the Coalition Government.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the subsidy which was removed by Deputy Norton when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
It was pointed out in a debate in this House by Deputy Lemass, who was in Opposition at the time, that the result of removing the subsidy would be to increase the cost of electricity to rural consumers, and Deputy Lemass was proved right.
Comment on this
In the annual report for 1956-57 published by the chairman and directors of the Electricity Supply Board, and signed by the chairman, they attribute the increase in the cost of electricity to rural consumers to the direct result—there is no other reason given—of the action taken by the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the Coalition Government, Deputy Norton.
Comment on this
I have given the reference. It is in the report which was placed on the Table of this House. It is available in the Library. It is the report of the directors and chairman of the Electricity Supply Board for the year 1956/57 and they attribute the increase in the price to the action taken by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Norton. Deputy Lindsay can get the report and can castigate me later, if he so wishes. That report attributes the increase in the cost to rural consumers to the direct action of the Minister for Industry and Commerce of the day. Deputy Norton, in removing the rural subsidy.
Comment on this
No. 1, he did not, and, No. 2, if he did, you did not make any attempt to put it back.
Comment on this
No. 1, he did not. I shall quote from Volume 171 of the Official Report, Columns 508 and 509. The House was debating the Electricity Supply (Amendment) Bill, 1957. It was the Second Stage. I hope Deputy McGilligan will listen carefully and not contradict me. I have accepted his challenge to quote. At Column 509 the Minister stated:
The object of Section 3 is to reintroduce a Government subsidy of 50 per cent. for rural electrification as from 1st April, 1958.
I repeat "the object ... is to reintroduce a Government subsidy of 50 per cent. for rural electrification."
Comment on this
It is quite obvious Deputy McGilligan will not listen to the full explanation. I shall continue the quotation:
The object of Section 3 is to reintroduce a Government subsidy of 50 per cent. for rural electrification as from 1st April, 1958.
That is one point fixed.
Such a subsidy was payable from the commencement of the rural electrification scheme in 1946 until 1955 when the subsidy was withdrawn. It was then argued that the board had reached a position in which, from their own resources, they could provide all the finance required for future development. The financial expectations of 1955 have not, however, been realised. In the year ended 31st March, 1955, the board had a gross surplus of £928,659 including a surplus of £44,130 on rural revenue account.
The next surplus fell to £50,184 in the year ended 31st March, 1957, the deficit on rural revenue account being £491,645.
We have the position, therefore, that before the action taken by the Coalition Minister for Industry and Commerce the rural revenue account showed a surplus of £44,000 on 31st March, 1955. Then, on 31st March, 1957, as a result of the deliberate action of the Minister for Industry and Commerce of the day, on the rural revenue account the deficit was £491,645.
However, Deputy Lemass covered every aspect of the scheme and he continued:
While other causes, notably a reducing rate of increase in demand for electricity generally and the charges arising from the bringing into operation of new generating stations in the last few years, have operated to reduce the board's annual surplus, the fact is that the demands of rural electrification have meant the difference between a modest surplus and a loss on the Board's electricity net revenue account. The average return on capital represented by fixed charges is falling heavily with the connection of new rural areas and the annual deficit on rural account when the scheme is completed would, in the absence of a subsidy, be well over £1,000,000. The board have been increasingly perturbed by the growing deficits on rural electrification.
Need I deal with that any further?
Comment on this
Wait now. You were to give us a quotation from the Chairman of the E.S.B. You have not given it.
Comment on this
I referred the House to the Report of the Electricity Supply Board for the year 1956-1957, signed by the chairman and the directors. In that they point out in no uncertain manner that the increase in the cost and this appalling deficit of £500,000 was attributable to the then Attorney General's colleague, Deputy Norton, as Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
It would be far better to let me alone and not to draw me. The Minister in his reply can deal far more competently with this matter.
Comment on this
The innuendo in the interruption by Deputy McGilligan is that, in fact, the Electricity Supply Board was not worried in those years about the cut in the subsidy.
Comment on this
It does not mean anything. It is of no account whatever. They have given me the facts.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley is in possession. Other Deputies will get an opportunity of making their own speeches.
Comment on this
I have already pointed out, and Deputy McGilligan has been listening to me, that the then Minister on 6th November, 1958, gave his reason for re-introducing the subsidy when he uses the words: "The board have been increasingly perturbed by the growing deficits on rural electrification."
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to think that I can memorise these reports which I study so assiduously. I thank the Minister. The reference now, for Deputy McGilligan's benefit, is page 10 of the 1960 Report. So, Deputy Lindsay will have to go back to the Library and bring that one up with him.
Comment on this
In the 1956/57 Report the matter is also dealt with. Deputy O'Donnell said that in 1948 in 23 out of the Twenty-Six Counties the rural electrification requirements had been satisfied.
Comment on this
He said that in 1948 in 23 out of the Twenty-Six Counties the rural electrification requirements had been satisfied.
Comment on this
Whether he did or he did not, I wrote it down here. I have not shorthand but I wrote it down to the best of my ability. I accept Deputy O'Sullivan's statement that he did not say it. I withdraw my suggestion that he did.
Comment on this
Which, of course, was entirely incorrect. As everybody knows, rural electrification was started by the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, in 23 out of the Twenty-Six Counties the rural electrification requirements are not even satisfied today. I do not know what Deputy O'Donnell is speaking about. Deputy O'Donnell started off on C.I.E. and he castigated the Minister. He spent quite a lot of time in the Rosses, in his own area, in Gweedore. It seemed we were on the eve of a general election. It was very interesting news to me personally.
Comment on this
Having dealt with C.I.E. and parochial matters, he then went on to deal with harbours. Deputy O'Donnell invited interruptions and when I asked him to deal with the transatlantic service or air services generally he evaded the issue by asking me where the reference was made by the Minister in his introductory speech to any harbour in the western part of the country. I have already said that over £500,000 had been given to us in Limerick for harbour development, for which we were very grateful. A very substantial grant has been given to us for the purchase of the new dredger which is working very effectively. The "Dún Aengus" is operating in Galway. If one looks at page 18 of the Minister's speech one can see that £340,000 has been earmarked for Galway——
Comment on this
——and £175,000 for Drogheda. The Minister goes into far more detail. Deputy O'Donnell, obviously, did not listen to the Minister or read his speech. It is quite all right to criticise Fianna Fáil for saying that the Shannon Scheme was a white elephant.
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy was not here in time and the rules of procedure would not allow me to repeat myself. He will see it all in the Official Report. I know that air navigation is a very sore point——
Comment on this
——with the Fine Gael Party. We will come to the Irish taxpayer in a second. It would be unfair for me to isolate the Fine Gael Party. Equally responsible for these sins of omission or commission at the time are the Labour Party, such Independents as supported the Government, the Clann na Poblachta Party at the time, Clann na Talmhan—all of them were in it together. There is no point in rehashing in this present atmosphere all these old sins. They sold the transatlantic planes. All right. When they were in a week they came to that decision. We know what happened. We know what the frightful consequences were and how far it delayed us getting back into the international field in such a highly competitive transport project.
We are on the eve of an election and I want to ask two questions of Deputy McGilligan, the former, very able Minister for Industry and Commerce. No doubt, when he is replying he will answer those questions and not be as evasive as he apparently thinks I am. If it should happen and naturally—I suppose I am rather biased—I must add "God forbid" that Fine Gael were returned to office and we took up our papers and saw "Fine Gael to Form New Government" and in brackets "With the aid of Labour, Independents, etc., who are not participating", the question I should like to ask is this: Will this new Fine Gael Government decide to sell our transatlantic fleet of jets? That is the first question for which we will award two marks——
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I think my question is rather rhetorical in view of Deputy Lindsay's interruption. The Minister has very lucidly given figures here for the administration of Dublin and Shannon airports. He has given details of the accounts of Aer Rianta and full information in regard to the very substantial trading profits of Aer Lingus. When Deputy Lindsay so glibly interrupts with what the cost is to the Irish taxpayer, how many million marks, as he says, it is going to cost, I should like to remind him and other Deputies that that type of interruption and that type of mentality does not appeal to the people. As a result of these air services we are giving employment in Dublin and Cork and, indeed, all over the country in tourist offices, in hotels and, bringing it to the final analysis, to the agricultural community who provide the produce for these hotels and for the tourists. This is a very large industry——
Comment on this
If we are to be constructive, Sir, Deputy Lindsay should allow me pursue my line of thought. The position is that there are many thousands of families in this country earning their livelihood as a result of the progress made by this country in the international field of air transport. Now that we are on the eve of an election, I want to know, particularly for my own area of Limerick city, what the Fine Gael attitude is. Shannon Airport is the biggest employer in that area. Clare benefits to a very large extent also, probably even to a larger extent than we do. We are thankful for these crumbs which have fallen to us from this airport.
Comment on this
There is this consistent mentality of Fine Gael of echoing their leader's viewpoint. Do they not have minds of their own? We know Deputy Dillon's outlook with regard to civil aviation. We know he does not approve of the transatlantic air service. At least, I admire him for his consistency. At least, if he disagrees with it, he is sticking to that. But we are going to hear a masterpiece, from Deputy McGilligan, the former Minister for Industry and Commerce. As I said, in certain respects he was a very efficient one. I am not trying to be rude or insulting in any way. But I say there is a responsibility on a Party which is going to go before the people of telling them what they are going to do in certain respects. If I were over there I could talk about the food subsidies. Why did you not throw that one in?
Comment on this
There is a responsibility on the main Opposition Party who are seeking a mandate from the people. We are told they are putting up sufficient candidates to form a Government. I suppose it is a good thing to be ambitious.
Comment on this
There is a responsibility on them to tell the people of the country, first, are the transatlantic planes to be sold? They are, are they not?
Comment on this
That is a very simple question. Do you or do you not intend, if you form a Government, to sell these planes? Do you intend again to stab in the back civil aviation in Ireland? Do you intend to bring to an end—and it must be the tendency in your minds, judging from some of the questions I see from leading members of your Party in regard to Shannon Airport looking for ammunition for this fusillade about to be launched by Deputy McGilligan— these developments and to close down the industrial zone in Shannon?
Comment on this
In 1948, when it was suggested in my constituency that the transatlantic air service would never see the light of day if a Coalition Government headed by Fine Gael got in, one of their leaders stated at a meeting in my area: "How often must these stupid allegations be denied?"
Comment on this
Please do not attempt to addle the Ceann Comhairle. No sooner were they back in 1948 than these foolish allegations, which they would not bother to deny, were thrown overboard and at the first Cabinet meeting it was decided that the planes would be sold and the Lockheed factory in Shannon scrapped. When we got back we had to start from scratch again. It has caused me a great deal of anxiety since. These are possibly very embarrassing questions. I am glad the Press have taken very careful note——
Comment on this
——that on the debate for the Estimate for Transport and Power the youthful and active Deputy from Limerick put these questions to the former Minister for Industry and Commerce and in his reply the Minister for Industry and Commerce asked Deputy McGilligan at the end of his speech would he not answer Deputy O'Malley—this is what I prophesy—and the Deputy concluded without dealing with the matters in question.
Comment on this
It is grossly unfair to attribute fairy tales to me. I am searching for information as to the state of mind of the biggest Opposition Party in this House. We are now discussing the Estimate for Transport and Power. I want to know what their policy is. It is true for the Taoiseach when he castigated Fine Gael for having no policy on transport and power. All we hear from Fine Gael in this House is: "You did so-and-so on such-and-such a date.""You said so-and-so on such-and-such a date." Then there is that unfortunate trick of taking remarks out of their context. The position is that this responsibility will have to be faced once and for all. The country will not put up with them any longer. There is a nation on the march and they will not be impeded by the obstructionist tactics of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
I am not dealing with generalities. I am dealing with civil aviation which I respectfully submit is highly relevant.
Comment on this
The Minister dealt comprehensively with the position at Shannon airport and gave us full information with regard to the Shannon Free Airport Development Company Limited. There is one thing that would want to be cleared up in the minds of quite a few people; indeed, there are people who should appreciate the position better, including leading industrialists who are not very clear with regard to these facilities at Shannon Airport.
It has been explained that the raison d'être of the industrial estate in Shannon Airport is to find compensatory employment, so to speak, because of the anticipated falling off both in revenue and in employment due to the advent of jet aircraft. It was the considered opinion of the experts of the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Transport and Power that a substantial amount of revenue and employment would be lost due to the over-flying of the airport by jets. In order to preserve the economy of the entire area, including Clare and Limerick, the economy of both of which depends very much on the prosperity and the wealth of Shannon Airport, it was decided that this new project would be brought to fruition as soon as possible, that is, the idea of an industrial estate.
There is one point that should be brought home to the minds of industrialists and the public generally. When the Industrial Development Authority, which has a representative on the board of the Shannon Free Airport Development Company Limited, examines applications for loans or grants, the sine qua non is, as the Minister recently stated, that air freight be utilised in the main for the export of the finished goods. It is true that the Shannon Free Airport Development Company has growing pains the same as any other major organisation. Certain raw materials have had to be imported by ship which is quite understandable but that could be twisted around to suit the mentality of those opposed to the whole concept of this industrial port.
Then again it was necessary in some cases to export certain of the finished products of two of the factories by ship and, as will be seen from a statement by the management concerned, with the variation in the charges for air transport cargo they are very happy to say they are now in a position economically to export all their finished products from the factory. This is a tremendous development at Shannon in the industrial zone and I would genuinely appeal to all members of the House to co-operate in not making, or attempting to make it, at any time a political cockshot.
Comment on this
I have not made the allegation that such is the case. I have appealed to all sides of the House not to treat it politically no matter who is in power because it means so much to the young people of this country.
Comment on this
That kind of clap-trap will not cut any ice with anyone. Look at the gleeful way Deputy McGilligan smirks as he gets his tongue around the figure of 50,000 gone.
Comment on this
There was never any emigration under the Coalition Government in their periods of office?
Comment on this
There was never any emigration in this country from 1948 to 1951 and from 1954 to March, 1957? No one left the country?
Comment on this
With all due respect, I am dealing with the development of the industrial zone in Shannon and if I were allowed to develop my line of argument I would point out it is a deterrent to emigration.
Comment on this
The Deputy has plenty of food for thought but I hope Deputy McGilligan is using his pencil to give me the answers to my questions. Another point is that there is no question of another area of the country losing. On the question of employment I would appeal to all members of the House to co-operate in any way they can, particularly those who go on delegations abroad, using their influence to propagate the advantages of Shannon. There are young people there learning trades. There are people of all political persuasions. They do not ask your politics when you apply there.
Most of the time the position in Shannon is that the number of industries vetted annually is on the increase. There is often a suggestion that people who come with proposals to set up in Shannon have the decisions held up for a considerable time. We know perfectly well that "chancers" have come to this country. They are here now. There are probably proposals before the Industrial Development Company by these "chancers." And some "chancers" got money in the past. That is the risk we have to take and that is the reason the Industrial Development Company and the Shannon Free Airport Development Company must be careful in their inquiries and careful in arriving at a decision, as to whether an industry will be set up in the area with their approval.
Therefore, Sir, the main point I stress is this, that other areas in Wexford, Galway or Drogheda are not suffering if a new industry is starting in Shannon. It is primarily for the encouragement of air freight, and that position should be put up to people who may have any doubts about it. The Minister in his recent speech at the Rippen factory in Shannon referred to the position, and the primary duty that has developed concerning air freight. No other county or city in the country can be at a loss if an industry goes to Shannon.
A question the Minister might be good enough to answer when he is replying is: There have been certain changes in the Shannon-Dublin daily plane services. They are at an hour which is completely unsuitable for people who want to travel from Limerick to Dublin and back. It may be that there are good reasons for this; it may be that it is necessary to facilitate the transatlantic travellers but the time is completely unacceptable for the people in the south.
The Minister did not give us any information—perhaps he is not in a position to do so—as to what is the anticipated programme of Aerlínte with regard to the purchase of future aircraft. I know they have ordered planes for a time ahead but the Minister did not refer to it and, with the substantial increase in freight and the number of passengers, I think that we will have to make substantial purchases of new aircraft in the very near future. It is not for an ordinary layman like me to attempt to tell the very efficient board of directors of Aerlínte their business but it is of interest to hear what is envisaged.
Another point that the Minister might give consideration to is this: he did deal in his speech with the landing of Irish planes in different areas in Britain. I wonder if it would be possible for the Minister for Transport and Power to propagate among the international users of airlines the idea of seeing in Shannon airport a terminal point for a transatlantic flight— in other words that all the transatlantic aircraft should have Shannon as their permanent landing point and then ferry the passengers to London, Paris, Rome and other airports by smaller jets or maybe piston aircraft.
The obvious answer is: "why ask someone to land at Shannon and delay a considerable time?" Well now the position as everyone knows is that the conditions at London airport are completely untenable. The congestion is appalling. The plans which have been made for future development, we read in an article in the Sunday Times three or four weeks ago, are now out of date and it is not possible to extend the facilities in Gatwick. The position in the London area is that they are faced with a serious crisis which is insoluble for a period of at least ten years. It would be a good deal for this country if it were feasible to point out (a) that we have the facilities in Shannon Airport and (b) that the landing charges —one of the big bones of contention is the increase in passenger rates on transatlantic aircraft—are reasonable. We are one of the most economical airports in the world from the point of view of landing charges. That is a bait which we could hold out.
We could point out that we have the facilities and capacity to handle these aircraft, reasonable landing charges, accommodation in the area for overnight passengers and adequate facilities to ferry the passengers to parts of Britain and parts of Europe. I think that the suggestion is worthy of consideration because in the next two years London will have to be closed to a very high percentage of the traffic which would in the ordinary course of events be catered for there. I see a tremendous opportunity for this country if we try to sell this idea to the other airlines. Perhaps there are other reasons or perhaps the British have other ideas, that they are not going to have landings in Shannon but I do not think that they will have any option because it will be a very long time before adequate airports are available in Britain to serve this need.
Comment on this
I was rather surprised on Saturday morning to find in my post a rather bulky document from the Department of Transport and Power setting out the many functions of that office because in the course of statements made by the Minister in the Dáil I, and a number of other Deputies, had assumed that this individual had little or no function. The House will recall that on a number of occasions when I addressed Parliamentary Questions to the Minister for Transport and Power the Chair disallowed these Questions on the ground that the Minister had no functions in the matters to which the Questions referred. The Questions related to matters dealt with by C.I.E., the E.S.B. and other State-sponsored bodies. Now we find in the Minister's memorandum a statement setting out the functions of his office. That suggests that the Minister had responsibility for the matters involved in my Question and that the Chair erred in disallowing those Questions. Possibly, as I alleged in the Dáil previously, there is connivance between the Chair and the Minister.