Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 119–274 of 274. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am not saying the Deputy is trying to skate around this at all, but I am at a loss to know how it is related to the Government's general policy on expenditure. If he can tell me that, I shall be quite satisfied.
Comment on this
What I was about to say on the Government's policy on expenditure is that while we must look after our less fortunate brothers and sisters, we must also be very careful that we do not hinder the normal expansion of both agriculture and business by expenditure, not necessarily on charity but any form of activity, which is in its nature unproductive, because, by the very action of taking money from productive expenditure, we are, to some extent, impeding the trade and industry and agriculture of the country. I would ask the Minister for about the third or fourth time to look into that very carefully and do what he can for industry in that respect.
We have an extra cost of £17 millions for Government this year and some of those millions could have been saved by a wiser expenditure policy. We know there have been increases in wages and that they have had to come about and the Government are faced with that, but there have been also a number of white elephant schemes which have not been productive and which we can ill afford. I should like to see the Government prepared to spend where necessary but not to be spendthrift in carrying out their duty. We face the future with a certain amount of trepidation because we are not being, and have not been, informed by the Government to the extent we have a right to expect but we are facing it confidently none-the-less, because we feel that the Irish people will be able to rise to whatever the future may demand.
Comment on this
I find it rather difficult to speak on this Vote on Account because it appears to be permissible to speak only in general terms. A Deputy to whom I mentioned this said that one was quite free to range over the entire field of Government, but judging from what I have heard up to this and from the interventions of the Chair, it is obvious that there is not a free range and that one may only take a bite here and there and, even then, not spend too long chewing it. Of course, Deputies on the opposite benches took the bite wherever, and only wherever, it was sweet for them.
Speaking within the terms permissible of the situation which has led up to the present Book of Estimates, and speaking of the economy generally, I believe that we are dealing with a very ill patient and before any treatment could be effective, a radical operation to remove the cancerous growth which started about 1932 would first be necessary. Many people feel this operation is overdue and since the Taoiseach made his notorious attack on the N.F.A. last week, many feel he is anxious to throw in the sponge. He feels that 24 years of mismanagement is making the situation quite impossible for him, especially when he realises how unprepared we are for the testing time ahead.
I want to get to one point quickly, lest it should escape me. Deputy Leneghan, the Independent Deputy speaking with the Fianna Fáil tongue, said that we had banished the landlords and the crowbar brigade. If they have been banished in his part of the country, I say emphatically they are still with us in County Dublin because I witnessed an agent of the Government carrying out two evictions in the past week which were completely unnecessary and which would never have occurred if Fianna Fáil had not failed to allow Dublin County Council to build sufficient houses.
Comment on this
I assume that it is necessary to provide money for housing. I am sorry if I have outstepped the limits.
Comment on this
The Deputy may have an opportunity of speaking of that subject on the Estimates but this debate is on general Government policy on expenditure. The Deputy may discuss administration in detail on an Estimate.
Comment on this
I felt it was a very important point to mention that we still have the brigade with us, and, as Deputy Leneghan was permitted——
Comment on this
The overall picture which Deputies opposite tried to paint was one of prosperity generally, one of a buoyant economy. Deputy Booth quoted at length from the bank bible, various bank bibles, in fact, but he forgot to quote any part of the speech of the Governor of the Bank of Ireland that might be against him. I should like, if I may, to quote a third paragraph from the same report:
It is a matter of public concern that earnings in the agricultural sector which show little or no rise from the levels of eight years ago should continue to lag behind those in other sectors of the economy. The farmers have had to contend with a difficult harvest. They now face problems arising from the altering pattern of the traditional British market such as affects the butter trade. It has many times been observed that an increase in agricultural incomes through expanding exports would give a major impetus to the general prosperity of the community.
We look at this evening's Evening Mail and we see: “Prices Jump Angers City Housewives.” We see many indications that the people are dissatisfied with the policy of this Government. The farmers are on the march and these sensible people are not on the march without serious cause. I was sorry to hear Deputy Tully, and I think Deputy Corish, condemning the farming community——
Comment on this
Will the Deputy wait just a moment?—condemning the farmers because they are now resenting the fact that their incomes are not keeping pace with those of the rest of the community. They have a perfect right to show that resentment. Nobody shows it more or oftener than trade union members. I am not objecting to trade union members looking for their rights but how can they hope that farmers will ever be in a position to pay their workmen what they should be paid if their incomes are not adequate? I believe farm workers, skilled and unskilled, should be paid at the same rates as in any other industry. They cannot get it if the farmers are not in a position to give it to them.
Do not let any Deputy mislead this House into believing that these farmers are on the march simply because of the growing burden of rates. It merely indicates that the last straw is breaking the camel's back. The position that agriculture finds itself in today is due to a number of causes. The Minister for Transport and Power numbered among these causes the fact that we had insufficient industry. I cannot agree more. We have insufficient industry but whom is he blaming for that? I place the blame where it should be placed, on the Government. I know from personal experience they are deliberately keeping industry out of this country. We offer certain inducements on paper; we write a brochure; but when people come here to establish an industry, they are as good as told that if they do not go to a part of the country to which they do not want to go, they may get out.
Comment on this
I have personal experience of a good industrialist recently proposing to set up an industry outside the city where there is a great deal of unemployment, that is, in Ballyfermot. The first problem these people came up against was that they could not get services in Ballyfermot.
Comment on this
There are no services. They could not get sewerage services for industry. The people who were proposing to come in here were interviewed. They guaranteed to give employment to 550 people. They were told they would get no grant for various reasons. The first thing they were asked to do was to prove that they could not start this industry in a remote part of the counry. They refused to do that because they knew the pool of labour was not available and they had to close down a similar industry elsewhere because of the lack of a pool of labour.
When eventually I had this matter raised again, we went through the whole field once more. These people guaranteed to come in here and start an industry. They asked for a promise that after two years, having exported all their products—£1,000,000 worth a year and having employed for two years 550 people and shown firm orders for a third year's trading—they would get a grant in advance. They were told by the body concerned that that was an impossibility, that the body concerned could not covenant on that basis. They would consider the matter again and let these people know within a week. Six weeks have passed since then and no communication has been received by these people.
That is the type of thing to which I refer when I say this Government have deliberately put industry out of this country. The only conclusion we can come to in regard to this industry is that there is a vested interest some where else working against us. These people would come in and prove by investing their own money that they can do as they say. However, they have been deplorably treated. I am personally aware of this, but there are many other industries that have gone out of the country for the same reason. Their managers refuse to move to remote parts of the country because the pool of labour they require is not there. They are badly received; they are obstructed from the word "go".
There are three or four bodies dealing with this subject: there is the Industrial Development Authority; there is An Foras Tionscal; there is the export body; and then there are the various Departments dealing with licences. Altogether it is rather a nightmare for people to come in here, especially if they do not speak the language too well, to find their way around and get industries established. There are far too many difficulties in their way.
We have failed to provide a home consumption market and we have failed absolutely through the fault of the Government in their efforts to establish industry. We have also failed to find a profitable export market for our agricultural produce. If agriculture today is getting support which the Taoiseach says is much more than it should be, it is due entirely to the failure of the Government to find a profitable market for this agricultural produce. We have reached the stage when it is a waste of time sending out advisors to assist the farmers to an increase in production. The fact is that every extra unit produced is sold at a lower price. If we question that, we are told they are looking for markets. "Looking for markets" really means making inquiries.
The Governments of other countries who are concerned with the same export problem tackle it in a different way, in the way it should be tackled by us and tackled vigorously. I would urge the Government, even at this late stage and while we can still do it without being restricted by the rules of the European Economic Community, to go into debt, if necessary, to buy our way into the wholesale markets of these export countries. It appears to be the only way to get in satisfactorily. We will not get in merely by inquiring and looking for markets. It is an investment which should long since have been made. We failed hopelessly to find a market, especially for dairy products. There is no opportunity for this country, if we are unable to dispose profitably of dairy products. The supports are high and they are high because we have concentrated all the time on the cheapest possible product through which milk can be disposed of, that is, butter. We have never made a serious effort but the opportunities are there, if we seriously look for them.
I want to say a few words about the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. We know that much more money is required for Posts and Telegraphs. I feel that the whole policy there is wrong. It is wrong because we are concentrating all this money in Posts and Telegraphs at the present time upon existing services, whilst at the same time, we are refusing a limited service to the people down the country. We talk about the backwardness of the farming community. Could they be otherwise? They cannot get a telephone. I think this money would be much better spent if we endeavoured to give these people the limited services essential to their ordinary everyday business. They may only need to get out twice or three times a day but that can be very important. These people can be saved having to travel a considerable distance, and being away from their work for a considerable time. They have been refused that service.
With regard to health, I think it has been demonstrated quite clearly that the enormous burden of rates, as a result of the health charges, could be transferred and borne much more equitably under a system of insurance. The health services at the moment are being dealt with by a Select Committee and we are all hopeful that a change may be brought about. The people generally are quite right to seek to have the health services transferred, as they are completely right in seeking to have main road upkeep transferred, to the Central Fund and away from the rates. The position at the present time in County Dublin at any rate is that all roads should be main roads. They were classified about 28 years ago. The whole pattern of traffic has changed but we still have no change in road classification.
The Minister for Transport and Power referred to the fact that there was an increase in the income per head of the population engaged in agriculture. That would nearly have to come about because there is such a decline through emigration in that sector of the community that we would be almost bound to have an increase per head of the population. I think I have covered all that occurs to me at the moment but I am sure there is quite a lot I have left out.
Comment on this
I am still an Independent, in spite of the fact that I voted for the Government. As I said before, I merely voted for a Government. I am not subject to Government criticism but I have no intention of recklessly criticising the Government. It is the privilege of Parties here to say things and much of what they say is really phoney. I suppose it is all part of the game. If you are out of power, you demand all sorts of things from those in power. I have a lot of experience on Dublin Corporation. You get the like of what I am talking about where people always want things done which will involve expenditure. When the burden of the rates gets heavy, they go into the rate-payers' lobby. You always get that kind of thing.
I will do my criticising, too. There is an increase of £17 million in this Book of Estimates. We must accept the fact that half of that increase is due to increases in wages. Therefore, that is no fault of the Government. If you are going to criticise the Government at all on account of the increase of £17 million, you must have that amount and ask what the other half is for. Fair enough, they said the other half is required for extra subsidies and grants for farmers and because of the rise in prices. To some extent, that is true, but what we want to ask is whether the Government are spending that money wisely. I have my own opinions and I want to express them.
First of all, I should like to deal with the Common Market. I shall go back to a few other things later on. Up to now, I have held the opinion that the Government are correct in subsidising and encouraging the industrial revival here, even though to some extent it may crash on entering the Common Market. It is not certain yet that we shall enter the Common Market because it is not certain that Britain is entering. Before the election, I expressed the opinion here that we should lobby with those in Britain who wanted to keep out of the Common Market because I believe that if Britain kept out, it would be in our best interests. Whether we like it or not, we depend upon Britain to a large extent. If Britain could keep out and if we could capitalise on Britain, we would do as well as we did in the past. The devil one knows is better than the devil one does not know.
If Britain goes in, we have no choice—it amounts to that. We are just acting in a clever manner. We are entering the Common Market because Britain is doing so and if Britain withdraws, we will withdraw. So as not to be caught on the wrong foot, we are going in at the same time as she is. If we go in, whether we like it or not, a great many of our industries will fold up. It is generally accepted that, agriculturally, we will improve, but our industries will fold up. I believe that entering the Common Market will mean that there will be no further investments in industries here.
Comment on this
If industries are in danger of folding up, would people not want to be crazy to invest in them?
Comment on this
If there is to be a free market as between this country and every country in the Six, will we survive the competition that is likely to arise?
Comment on this
There are a few industries. I am generalising. Sweets are much cheaper in Britain. I know that you can buy a quarter of sweets for a "tanner" in Britain. The same sweets cost one shilling here. That is a case in point. In many instances, our industries will fold up in the event of the Common Market coming into operation, but at the same time, there will not be any immediate effect. The effect is going to be spread over a long period, but I am satisfied that many industries will go and that will discourage any future investment in industry.
It does not follow that that will create poverty here because I suppose our redundant workers will emigrate to Britain or Germany, so that we shall survive. That will not be the Government's fault; it will not be anybody's fault. It we do not enter the Common Market we shall not be able to export anything so we shall face failure anyhow. We have to take a risk, a calculated risk. Even so far as any commitments with NATO are concerned, we will have to take a calculated risk and, if a thing is worthwhile, it is worthwhile taking a risk. If we were afraid to take a risk about NATO and were kept out of the Common Market as a result and pauperised ourselves, that would be no great attraction. I am just expressing an opinion on this matter. I am no expert, but I have intuition and I read, like anybody else.
I am not impressed by the size of the sum allocated for social welfare in the Estimates. If the people who are on social assistance do not get 5/-a head, it will be worthless to them. When the amount of the Supplementary Estimates is taken out of the amount of the Estimates here, there will not be very much left and if it is the Minister's intention to keep social benefits within the ambit of the amount left in the Estimate, he is not going to give very much. I shall be very disappointed if that is the case.
Within the past few months, a large number of Dublin tenants have been informed that their rates are going up 2/- a week. If people on social assistance are to get only 2/- increase, that will be swallowed up by the increased rents and there will be nothing left to meet the other increases. I will be disappointed if there is less than 5/- all round for those on social benefits. I am not going to vote for the Government on one issue and vote against them on another. It is at least a Government and I am satisfied that it would be foolish to have a change for some time, so I shall vote against them only on certain issues. If I thought the people who are on social benefits were to get only a miserable amount, I would not vote for the Government.
The Government have accepted the principle that everyone is to get an increase and for that reason they are to introduce a Bill to increase judges' salaries. I want to ensure that these other unfortunate people living on fixed pensions and on social benefits will get an increase. I will not be satisfied with a "bob" or two.
Comment on this
I am not afraid of that issue, either. I suppose that when the case comes to be argued, it could be argued that the judges are entitled to it as well as everybody else, and the T.D.s, too. There are a few human beings among them, too. They are not all millionaires. Some of the millionaire T.D.s are against increases for T.D.s because of the effect of public opinion, but there are some, like Murphy, who had to run away to America because he was starving here. I am only pointing out that if the principle is accepted that there should be a general wage increase, there is no reason why it should not be extended to the Taoiseach and the Ministers because, in my opinion, they are the worst paid people in the State for the full time job they have to do. The rest of us can come and go, can attend to our businesses and make a few "bob" on the side, but the Ministers have to give their whole time to the job. I see no reason why they should be pilloried because certain dogs in the manger outside have to have a crack at the politicians. I will say that no matter what Government are in power.
I believe that the Government should be criticised but I also believe that they are often unfairly criticised. It is all a part of the game. I will fight for certain types of principles but I am not going to be irresponsible in this House. I have plenty of savvy, whether others think it or not.
Comment on this
Earlier today, when this debate was in progress, we had what is becoming a rare thing in this House, a speech from the Fianna Fáil benches. The person who spoke was the Minister for Transport and Power who said many things in the short time he was speaking but he delivered himself of this pearl, and we are accustomed to this particular Minister casting his pearls in this House, that, in his judgment, having travelled throughout the country and met the ordinary people of the country, like Deputy Leneghan from Mayo, there was now a far better spirit in the country, that the people were more confident with regard to the future. Listening to that, I wondered whether my ears were deceiving me. Then it occurred to me that the Minister's peregrinations throughout the country must have been in very confined and secluded areas. He seems not to have been aware that in the past three or four weeks in every part of Ireland, there is at least a definite section of our people who have been endeavouring to make it known to Government Ministers and to all and sundry that they are not pleased with the present situation and that they are not confident with regard to the future.
Ten days ago in my constituency—I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands has had a similar experience—some 3,000 farmers marched through the county town. They included the old and young, the rich farmer and the small farmer, the Catholic farmer and the Protestant farmer.
Comment on this
They were marching, carrying banners and posters, in order to emphasise that, so far as they and the industry they represented were concerned, they saw in the present situation no hope and that they had little confidence for the future. Is that just to be wiped off the slate as if it did not occur? Have we in this House so lost touch with the people that we shrug off the fact that in the last six weeks 100,000 farmers in the west, east, north and south have marched to demonstrate the fact that they have a particular concern in relation to what is happening to the agricultural industry?
The Minister for Transport and Power does not even recognise that fact. According to him, farmers do not count. He says there is a far better spirit in the country and a feeling of confidence among our people. As long as we have Ministers who, in circumstances such as the present, talk the puerile nonsense we have heard from the Minister for Transport and Power, in my view the only solution is a quick general election to get that Government out. It is bad enough, God knows, that a section of our people should be driven in 1962 into marching through the county towns whenever a county council is meeting to strike a rate—and the situation that brings that about must be a serious situation—but if that situation is met by absurd Ministerial complacency, then a very serious problem faces this country.
When I say "Ministerial complacency" I am being kind. We had from the Taoiseach the other day not complacency but a type of aggressiveness that used to be popular at one time in certain countries in Europe. The Taoiseach came out to attack the farmers. The National Farmers' Association were sneered at by him from his sheltered position in this House——
Comment on this
——as some group of malcontents. The National Farmers' Association were irresponsible and they were doing wrong, and no matter what is done for the farmers, no matter how deeply we asked the general taxpayer to dig into his pocket, we will get nothing in the way of thanks from the farmers—that is the Taoiseach speaking at Column 1203, Volume 193 of the Official Report. That was an effort by the Taoiseach to create, not immediately but perhaps some time in the future, a certain political advantage out of the present situation in the country. He was anxious to try to turn town against country. He was anxious to create, if he could, in this Dáil and outside it a section of people who would divide themselves into pro-farmer and pro-town. Doing that he hoped that he might, if this situation developed, in some way stake a future for his Party in the days that lie ahead.
That is bad. Throughout the years in this House we have had our difficulties, our problems, our differences, our disputes. We have had changes in Government, difficult decisions have had to be made by different Governments. But we have always maintained, at least so far as the major Parties are concerned, a concern for a broad national outlook. We have never permitted the situation to arise here in which politics are to be dictated by sectional interests, by a group representative merely of one particular section of the people. It would be a very serious thing if Deputy Lemass as Taoiseach—he is a city man, a man whose horizon seems to be limited by the boundaries of Dublin city—set out to try to turn the legitimate protest of Irish farmers into a movement in which our people were to be divided into pro-town and pro-farmer. I hope that good sense will take the place of the kind of exhibitionism we saw last Thursday and that the Taoiseach and his Ministerial colleagues will appreciate the fact that farmers are driven into these protest marches because they feel, rightly or wrongly, that they have a grievance. They have a sense that they are being wronged and they feel that some measure of recognition of their complaints should be countenanced by the Government.
After all, I wonder do we here sometimes forget our beginnings? It is true to say, although apparently it is not said often enough, that this country is primarily an agricultural country. There are people who, apparently, would like that not to be so. The plain fact is that it is so. The plain fact is that the Lord Himself, in his providence and wisdom, so created this country that our main source of wealth is the land we own, the soil we possess and the industry which flourished in that land and on that soil. It surely must be a matter of concern that pretty well every farmer throughout Ireland at present, whether he is a small farmer or a big farmer, an old farmer or a young farmer, whatever his creed or outlook, is complaining about the state of his industry. That surely should lead to some concern amongst the members of the Government but apparently it does not.
On Thursday, the Taoiseach said that farmers were in effect being spoon fed at the expense of the taxpayer, that subsidies of one kind or another were being doled out to them and all the rest of it and that they were a pampered, petted section of the community. I wonder do Fianna Fáil Deputies share that view with the Taoiseach? He went on to say in effect, that in the last decade, farmers have done well and that in the first half of the decade, their incomes increased out of proportion to the increase accorded to workers in industry and that what is happening is merely the making up of lee-way by industry. Is that view shared? I should like to assert so far as the midlands are concerned, if Deputy Leneghan will permit me to speak about that part of the country——
Comment on this
It is not merely a question of the average farmer in the midlands having had in the past five years a proportionate increase in his income. The fact is that in the past five years, each year his income has gone down steadily. The average farmer in the midlands, and I think it is true throughout the country, finds since 1956 the price of everything he has to sell is substantially less, while the cost of everything he has to buy has advanced. If the Taoiseach is correct in saying that in the first half of the last decade, when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture, farmers experienced a substantial increase in their income, it is equally true to say that in the past five years during which Deputy Smith has been Minister for Agriculture, an effort has been made to take back from the farmer what he got in the first half.
I would express the hope, in any event, that the Government will take stock of the present situation. After all, we are told that we are about to enter —some day, somehow, some time—the Common Market. It is difficult to know what is the view of the Fianna Fáil establishment on the Common Market nowadays. We find different speeches being made by different Ministers. It is hard to know precisely what they see in that Market, whether it is a challenge or whether it is going to lead to a situation in which all our difficulties and problems will be solved. We never know now whether "Mr. Europe" on the Fianna Fáil front bench is the Minister for Lands or not, but whatever problems are in store for the country in relation to the Common Market, it is right that we should have some stocktaking ourselves. Mark you, if the Common Market is to be an unlimited market, let us not forget that for the past 40 years, we have had available to us an unlimited market with free passage of men and money and material.
Comment on this
We have had eggs. It has been available to us but it was not prized and was not appreciated.
Comment on this
At one time, the Fianna Fáil Government could not see beyond their noses because they were willing to give loud huzzas and hoorahs—when Deputy Leneghan wore a blue shirt—and——
Comment on this
Your colleague, Deputy Leneghan. They have learned since but I wonder if they have learned very much because what has happened the market which used to be ridiculed by the Fianna Fáil Government and which for us was unlimited? We have gradually priced ourselves out of it in relation to practically everything we sell and were it not for the sneered at bullock we would not be doing very much trade with Britain at the moment. We should not fool ourselves into thinking that our existence is going to be in any way easier, if we add to the 80 millions, living on the island of Great Britain, some 200 millions, or whatever the number is, living in Western Europe. If we could at the moment supply the British market with all the goods they require, we would have no need to be concerned about a Common Market in Europe, but we have not been able to do it and therefore we must examine the reason why.
I noticed in the past 12 months that much attention, and rightly so, was paid, particularly prior to the last general election, by the Government to preparing industry for the Common Market. That was very right and very proper, but I wonder what care and what attention have been devoted to preparing our major industry for that market? Surely in the past 12 months the penny might have dropped or somebody might have told the Minister for Agriculture that some effort might be made to organise agriculture to make it aware of the problems that might arise from the Common Market and prepare the way for agriculture in that Market? Possibly somebody may have said that to the Minister for Agriculture. Possibly the Minister for Agriculture may have been preparing blueprints of one kind or another, but so far as the Irish farmer is concerned, he does not know what has happened. All he knows is that every week he has fewer pennies in his pocket to jingle and that every year the toll and tax upon him is greater and that he is driven this year into marching in protest with his friends and colleagues in each county.
That is poor preparation for the Common Market and seems to indicate in relation to agriculture, as indeed in relation to many other things, that there is little evidence that the Government have any settled policy or clear programme to follow. The Government introduced the Vote on Account last week and asked this House to give them, on account, a sum of money to fill a bill of £148 million. I have listened to speeches made on behalf of the Government in relation to that large bill and genereally speaking, I think it is fair to say that, having announced the figure, Government Ministers, from the Taoiseach down, said: "So what?" and challenged anybody who even raised his eyebrow at the size of this Bill by suggesting: "Well, do you think we could do anything about it?"
It was only five years ago—not a very long time in the life of a parliament, not to mind a country—that the Budget figure was £109 million.
Comment on this
Five years later, it is plus £50 million, if we take into consideration the food subsidies.
Comment on this
They have increased the cost of Government at the rate of £10 million a year. That means that if they are in office, and if Deputy Leneghan does not get a cold in the head, we will read a Book of Estimates close on £200 million in five years' time. No doubt, a Government Minister defending that situation will again say: "So what."
I should like to know where this country is going. It costs close on £150 million, according to this Book of Estimates, to provide necessary services in the coming year. Five years ago, when Fianna Fáil came into office, the present Minister for Finance said, as he had to say, of course, after their election promises, that taxation was too high—£109 million was far too much to take in taxation from the people. Deputies who were here then will remember the said he was going to do something about it.
Comment on this
He certainly did—he put it up by another £41 million. He said he was going to prune the Civil Service.
Comment on this
He said that the cost of the Civil Service was to be cut. There was to be a new scheme for organisation and method—bright boys were to be brought into every Government Department; there was to be a removal of red tape and green tape and the number of hands in the Civil Service was to be substantially reduced. They were brave words five years ago when the Minister for Finance was concerned with the problem of finding £109 million with which to run the country. We can remember the Minister announcing his schemes for the pruning of the Civil Service. He did his first effective pruning by removing the subsidies on bread, butter and flour and putting up the price of these essential commodities. He saved £7 million by doing that.
Comment on this
I remember my sympathy for the Minister when he said the figures were there, that they were ready for him and that he had to find the money due to the fault of his predecessors. But he asked us to watch next year when, after pruning the Civil Service, we would see some result. Well, he has had many years since and we see the results now —plus £50,000, £10 million each year. Not bad going for a Minister representing a Party that declared five years ago that this country was being bled white because taxation ran at the level of £109 million. Mind you, in the course of those five years £7 million disappeared somewhere. People in Mayo, in the south, in the north and in the east, have had to pay more for bread, butter and flour in order to give more money to the Minister for Finance. I wonder where that money has gone.
Comment on this
I remember the concern of the Minister five years ago over the cost of Government and I remember the present Taoiseach issuing a very solemn warning, worth recalling now, when he referred to the problem facing the Government and all the money they had to find. He said taxation pressed too lightly upon the land and indicated five years ago to the Irish farmers: "Look, be careful, because we are going to have to tax you."
Comment on this
On a point of order, Deputy O'Higgins has purported to quote the Taoiseach. Would he please give the reference?
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Taoiseach never made those remarks. Either Deputy O'Higgins will withdraw them——
Comment on this
Deputies should bear that in mind when we find that because farmers have apparently had the impertinence, in the minds of the Fianna Fáil Party, to express their concern, they are attacked by the Taoiseach who suggests that the leader of their organisation is irresponsible, the Taoiseach who says that no matter how deeply the Government ask the taxpayer to dig into his pocket, you will get no thanks from the farmer. Does that indicate that we are to face in the future a new threat from this Government, headed by the Taoiseach, to impose fresh taxation upon the farmers?
Comment on this
I am very glad to hear that and I accept that, if it does happen, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands will resign from the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
Nota bene! The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands will not answer a hypothetical question.
Comment on this
How does the Deputy reason that out? He does not reason. I want to know how he reasons it out.
Comment on this
It is making the Minister uncomfortable anyhow. The Minister's reactions are the most interesting thing in this.
Comment on this
It is patently true that at least one person feels himself better off now than he did 12 months ago when he was a Fine Gael county councillor and he is obviously going to take great care that he will remain in this House so that he need not fear meeting the people of Mayo.
Comment on this
We, on this side of the House, are concerned, and that concern we have endeavoured to express, and will continue to express. There is at the moment a definite inflationary spiral in existence.
Comment on this
In the past three years, there has been put into circulation a very marked increase in purchasing power. That makes the Government's task of raising money at the moment, perhaps, somewhat easier. It is easy to raise money when everything is going up, when incomes are expanding for almost everybody in the State, except the farmer; in those circumstances, it is comparatively easy to apply a short-term solution to budgetary problems. But that is merely stacking away trouble for somebody else some other day, and this inflationary spiral we are facing at the moment will have to be paid for some day somehow. We are concerned as to how it has come about. I do not think there are many people outside this House who have any doubt as to the cause of it. The cause of it, I assert, has been weak Government in the past three or four years—a Government incapable of making up their minds. That goes in relation to certain——
Comment on this
——trade union efforts, and there is no doubt about it, unofficial strikes and other efforts directed against trade unionism.
Comment on this
This is the Government who summoned this House in high drama last August, and then showed the white flag and ran for shelter, the Government who do not know their own mind, the Government who have been incapable of making up their mind in the past three years.
Comment on this
We know the history of Fianna Fáil in relation to trade unionism—we know all about it. I am perfectly prepared to deal with that at any time. We know all about the standstill on wages. We know all about the efforts made in the past——
Comment on this
At one time, but certainly not in the past three years. Where has the courage gone? I want to assert that the eighth and ninth round of wage increases, now deplored by the Taoiseach and by the Minister for Finance——
Comment on this
Everybody on these benches certainly agrees with the Deputy as far as decent wages are concerned. What we are concerned about is what is happening now. We are concerned about the fact that a spiral has been started. In one of the evening papers today, there is a bannerline "Prices jump angers housewives".
Comment on this
It is the Evening Mail, 13th March. We are concerned with what will happen now if the increase in wages that has taken place is to be offset by a further increase in the cost of living. If that happens, then the situation for the ordinary people will be very much worse. It is both very easy and very simple to tide oneself over a temporary problem by saying wages will be adjusted all over the country. That is what this Government have done, but they have not had regard to any financial policy, any fixed programme. They have not had any consideration as to what the future is likely to be. In 12 months' time certainly, if we take into consideration recent experience, the cost of living will be up another ten points. We will then have to face the tenth round of increases.
Comment on this
That will have to be paid. Then we will have the old process of wages chasing prices all over again.
Comment on this
So far as corrective measures are concerned, the harvest was reaped by the present Government.
Comment on this
The situation is as I have suggested, and the troublesome and worrying thing about it is that the Government apparently do not give a damn about the future. So long as they can maintain their present position in this House and get men from Mayo and a few other fellows behind them in the Division Lobby, it is all right, but someone else will have to clean up the mess, some other day, some other time.
Comment on this
I want to say that there is one section of the community which cannot just suffer on. When speaking here the other day, the Taoiseach threw a sneer across the floor of the House at the Fine Gael Party with regard to a Fine Gael motion designed, he said, further to increase the cost of government and the cost of the other services in the country. It is true that there is a motion on the Order Paper, put down by Fine Gael, asking the House to express the opinion that, in view of the steep rise in the cost of living and the difficulties created thereby for all pensioners, the whole question of pensions should be reviewed as a matter of urgency.
Comment on this
There will be plenty of tears. Despite the smiles of the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands, there are pensioners in this country—
Comment on this
—who are in the situation that they are the eggs that are being broken to make the Fianna Fáil omelette.
Comment on this
I should like to suggest to the Minister and to the smiling Parliamentary Secretary that they should have a little bit of Christian charity in their make-up and have regard to the fact that, despite the laughter of the Parliamentary Secretary, there are unfortunate State pensioners—people who have left the Civil Service, people who have left the postal service, people who have left the local government service, former teachers, former Gardaí, former Army men— who are existing on small pensions which at one time might have been thought to be adequate when the cost of living was some 20 points lower than it is now, but who are now feeling the pinch, while Fianna Fáil allows living costs to soar, to the amusement of the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
We, on this side of the House, are concerned about that section of the community because they cannot suffer on. The rest of the community—and even the hard-pressed farmers who have had to go through worse times under Fianna Fáil in the past—will be able, in one way or another, to struggle through, but there are many pensioners who will not, and who will be driven in despair into absolute abject poverty. We make no apology for the fact that, as the main Opposition Party, we have tabled a motion drawing the attention of the House to that problem and to that section of the community. It will be debated in due course, despite the sneers of the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Despite the sneers of the Taoiseach and the smiles of the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary——
Comment on this
That is the ordinary Fine Gael practice—tell lies and get away with it. The Deputy goes away from it now.
Comment on this
This debate is availed of each year for the purpose of discussing, and endeavouring to find out, the current policy of the Government. We are availing of the debate for that purpose. This year, the debate takes place some six months after a general election, and at a time when concern is being expressed by many sections of the community in relation to what the Government are doing. That concern is moulded by the fact that there is little evidence nowadays of any clear Government policy. I have already referred to the protests about the rates.
It is well to remind the House that only eight months ago, on the eve of the general election, the country had tremendous evidence of the concern on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party with regard to the rates and everything else. At that time, prior to the general election, the Taoiseach was a busy man going around, with the Minister for Finance occasionally accompanying him, talking about how concerned the Government were about the level of local taxation. Finally, on the eve of the general election the ratepayers throughout the country were exhilarated to see that the Taoiseach had sent to a committee of experts the whole question of rating and the incidence of local taxation. Was that an election gimmick? Is it not rather interesting that we never heard anything more about it? It is now forgotten, and the rates are taking their place, as they always have, as just one of the white man's burdens, but is it playing fair with the people——
Comment on this
——that prior to the general election the ratepayers should have been codded into believing that Fianna Fáil, at last, would devise some new form of taxation which would wipe out the rates and reduce the burden on the people throughout the country? But that is gone as is much else of what was said on behalf of the Government in the general election. Speeches were made and promises were held forth. They all disappeared, and today we do not know what the Government are doing. We do not know what their policy is. We do not know whether we are going into NATO with the Minister for Lands and the Parliamentary Secretary, or whether we are staying out with the Minister for External Affairs. We do not know whether the Common Market is a challenge, or whether there is an era of prosperity for us. We do not know what the policy of the Government is, because the Government themselves do not know it. They are now in the position that they are a caretaker Government, dependent on the good wishes of Deputy Leneghan and Deputy Sherwin. They are marking time until such time as vacancies in this House have to be filled, and the very moment vacancies fall to be filled, this caretaker Government will disappear——
Comment on this
——because a general election must be held and the moment it is held, this Government and all they stand for will go.
Comment on this
He got back by the same methods. I mentioned that and the Leas-Cheann Comhairle thought I was talking about Fianna Fáil, but I was talking about Big Bill Thompson.
Comment on this
I am glad to see that in the Book of Estimates there is an increase of £3,000,000 in the amount for agriculture. If we look back to 1953 we see that the over-all estimate for that year was £13,000,000. Five years ago, it was £17,000,000 and last year it was £36,000,000. That alone shows we are not forgetting agriculture.
Last year the Taoiseach, realising that the rates position was getting beyond farmers, set up a committee. He set up a committee of experts to examine the whole rates position. As we all know, it usually takes quite a long time for such a committee to issue its findings. We are hoping for the report in this case in the not too distant future and we trust the committee may be able to suggest a solution to the problem. The Departments of Local Government and Finance have examined the matter and would now like an outside opinion. We have realised that that trouble exists. We have set up another committee to examine the plight of small farmers and the findings of that committee are expected shortly.
In the past five years there has been a subsidy in respect of fat cattle slaughtered in England. If that subsidy had not been forthcoming two years ago, what would have been the position in the spring of that year? Take a man who bought four cattle, subject to passing the 14-day test, three of which passed the test, the fourth failing it. The man was fined £14 for the beast that failed. Such cases were widespread. It was out of that that the fat cattle subsidy had to come to guarantee a support price for the reactor cattle, the cattle that would not pass the 14-day test. Very little credit is given for that.
Now that most of the store cattle going to England are passing the 14-day test, it is admitted that one can travel the country and find fewer reactors than the number of fingers on your hand, so to speak. That subsidy was needed for the intervening time as, otherwise, the farmer with reactor cattle would suffer very severely.
We have given good support to pigs. If we can maintain the quality, breeding and selection we shall be able to command a fair percentage of the English market. The Munster Institute has been set up for the progeny testing of pigs. There are some results coming from it and we hope to get our place on the English market. Our main competitors there are the Danes who have been in the trade for a very long time. We cannot expect, overnight, the results we should like to see achieved. I am convinced that, in time, we shall achieve the best results.
It may be said that the prospects for pigs are not too secure at present. I have never known it to happen in competition with foreigners that if we produce really top quality produce the market is not there. We are beginning to see that already from our Grade A Special which is selling very well on the English market. Hotel people in particular are buying that bacon which is a few shillings a ton cheaper than the Danish product. When more of that Grade A Special is available we shall find our place on the English market and be able to compete successfully with foreigners.
I should like the Department of Agriculture to sponsor a television programme. It is one of the best ways of putting their policy and ideas before the farmers. As time goes by, there will be a wider audience for programmes on Telefís Éireann. Very good work has geen done on sound broadcasting and a regular television programme on agriculture, sponsored by the Department, would bear excellent results.
The Agricultural Institute has been established only a short time and already we are getting some very good results from it. A surprising piece of information which it has given us is that the yield per acre for grain crops on small farms is lower than it is on large farms. One would imagine it would be the other way round as the smaller man would be able to give more attention to his crop. However, with machinery and fertilisers, the larger man can achieve a higher yield.
We have been rather generous about the subsidy for artificial fertilisers and that is helping to secure higher yields. According to the figures supplied by the Agricultural Institute, the increase per acre is quite noticeable over the past eight years.
I hope the Department of Agriculture will sponsor winter farming schools to an even greater degree. That is a service which is much needed by our farming community. It provides advice on farm management. A great deal of information which the Agricultural Institute is assembling percolates to the farming community but, definitely, it is necessary that farmers should have more advice available to them.
I notice with pleasure that there is an increase of £.3 million to the tourist industry, bringing the amount for the coming year up to £1,000,000. In my view, it gives the best return for money invested—a return of over £40,000,000. It is well that we see the possibilities and are developing that industry. I live near the main road to the West of Ireland and in the Summer it is difficult to get across the road because of the flow of traffic to and from the West. There is a greater circulation of money. The visitors have to be fed and that represents an invisible market for agricultural produce. In that way, we are capitalising some of our natural resources. We have always been noted as a friendly people and are very friendly to visitors. The people who have come here have always been impressed by our friendliness and have returned. We have encouraged this industry by grants to hotels because visitors must have some place to stay.