We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Government White Paper on Incomes and Output: Motion.

Contributions 163–363 of 363. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Costello must be allowed to proceed.

Comment on this

Would you ask the Minister for Justice has he partaken too much at the bar that he cannot stop?

Comment on this

Do not be rude. You do not have to be that guttersnipeish.

Comment on this

As to whether the economists were right or wrong, I said I did not know. However, we took their advice, knowing that the result would be that we would be out of office. The Labour Party made their contribution to the national well-being in the carrying out of that policy. Be it said to their credit, they did it in the interests of the country. They got howlings and roarings from the Fianna Fáil Party. Now the Taoiseach proceeds to repeat that to-night. As I said, we did not know whether they were right or wrong, but one economist has said recently they were wrong. I read it as that anyway.

In the December issue of The Irish Banking Review, there is an article on the Irish economy by a very distinguished economist called Dr. Alfred Kuehn. He was until recently a research officer with the Economic Research Institute in Dublin. At page 30, he gives an account of the economic difficulties we were in at the time— rising output, imports exceeded by far the amount necessary for current production, leading to an increase in stocks. He goes on to say:

The balance of payments predicament would have probably been less severe in the following year, because production would have risen further to meet demand and stock building would have levelled off. But, as this apparently had not been anticipated by policy makers the emergency brakes of import levies were applied; the measures effectively reduced imports in the following years; but they were also instrumental in bringing on recession.

That is the view and the advice we got. You can take your choice.

Comment on this

You must take responsibility for it.

Comment on this

I took full responsibility, knowing I was going out of office as a result. But I learned a lesson I have never forgotten and which I press upon the Deputies here considering this matter. When you get advice from economists, they give you the best advice they can. They give you expert advice, excellent advice. They give you advice got as a result of their research, labour and study, and they give it to you sincerely. But you must recollect that when they do that, they give it coldly and calmly, and I am not disparaging them by saying they give it inhumanly. It is not their business to say what human suffering is going to result in consequence of their opinions and economic principles. I learned that lesson and I hope the Deputies considering this will learn that lesson. Their economic theories may be excellent and they may be acting according to their lights in giving you excellent advice, but you have to remember—as a result of experience I emphasise it—that if that advice results in human suffering and unemployment, it is no answer to the people who have to leave or see their children leave to say you are following economic principles. That will not mean anything to them. There will be produced, as there has been in England, a result far worse than if these economic principles had not been promulgated and acted upon.

Mr. Haughey rose.

Comment on this

May I ask—I am not protesting, Sir—I assume you heard the Minister's suggestion that he had arranged with the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to allow Deputy Costello speak? Are we to take it this is the way in which speakers are called, so far as the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is concerned?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Ceann Comhairle and the Leas-Cheann Comhairle on their own responsibility call Deputies. It is at their discretion. Six Deputies have spoken already. Four Opposition Deputies have spoken and two Government Deputies. The Chair is endeavouring to interlard them as fairly as possible.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it not a fact that the Minister for Justice has said in the last ten minutes that he discussed the next speaker with the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and that the name of Deputy J. A. Costello was to be selected on the ground that he was an ex-Taoiseach?

Comment on this

No. What I said was that if the Leas-Cheann Comhairle proposed to call the ex-Taoiseach in preference to me, I would have no objection.

Comment on this

You discussed it with the Leas-Cheann Comhairle?

Comment on this

In reference to me, not in relation to any other Deputy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

An ex-Taoiseach, as between two Deputies, is entitled to preference. Deputy J. A. Costello got preference. Six Deputies have spoken—four Opposition Deputies and two Government Deputies. Surely that is not giving any unfair preference to the Government side?

Comment on this

May I direct attention to the fact that the speaker before Deputy Costello was the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this

I am asking you to appreciate that fact. You are forgetting about us. The Labour Party had only one speaker out of six.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Labour Party got their speaker. Six Deputies have spoken—four from the Opposition and two from the Government Benches.

Comment on this

May I ask in what order of preference does the Ceann Comhairle arrange things? As a new member, I am confused.

Comment on this

I am addressing my remarks to the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am endeavouring to distribute the debate as evenly as possible.

Comment on this

You are not doing it.

Comment on this

Did you not rule, Sir, at Question Time last week that an amendment would be moved after the motion? Did you not concede that point today to Deputy Dunne when you allowed him to move his amendment?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I acted according to the order made by the House.

Comment on this

There was no order made by the House in respect of Deputy Dunne and myself.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

A motion was moved.

Comment on this

On a point of order, there is a motion in the name of the Labour Party and only one Labour Deputy has been allowed to speak.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

How many does the Deputy want?

Comment on this

We want our speaker in now, Deputy Mullen.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister for Justice——

Comment on this
Charles J. Haughey Minister for Justice (Mr. Haughey) Fianna Fáil

I should like to make it clear at the outset that this White Paper is the Government's White Paper and we are not seeking to hide behind any economists or official advice of any sort. If this debate has done nothing else but procedure for the House the admission that Deputy Costello when Taoiseach accepted advice offered to him without knowing whether it was good or bad and proceeded to act on it then it will be historically very interesting.

In publishing this White Paper the Government has done no more than its simple duty. In a democracy like ours the Government is charged with the defence of the economy exactly in the same way as it is charged with the defence of the national territory. In pursuance of that responsibility, it must keep a constant watch on developments. It must continually analyse the statistics and be in a position to identify trends. It should always be able to anticipate dangers before they arise and seal off any trouble spots. It must always endeavour to have the initiative and its policies so framed that it controls developments rather than be dictated to by them. To my mind, that is the difference between good and bad government in the economic field.

A good Government are on top of the situation, ahead of events. They should never allow economic difficulties to progress to the point where they no longer have the freedom to follow their own policies for the betterment of the community but are rather forced by the exigencies of the situation to adopt one expedient after another. That is the principle and that is the issue in this debate. That is the difference between us and the Opposition. We believe that the Government must direct and guide the economy in the way they want it to go. We have a comprehensive programme for economic development and in order to be able to put that programme into effect, we must have the economic initiative. We must be in control of events and not be controlled by them. That is why this White Paper has been issued.

Here we have a clear case of the emergence of a dangerous trend which, if it were allowed to develop, could have the effect of wrecking all our efforts to date. In 1962, weekly earnings outstripped output per worker and if that trend were allowed to continue without check, we would undoubtedly be precipitated into an inflationary spiral. The White Paper analyses that situation. There is no question of apportioning blame or criticising anybody. It is a calm, dispassionate analysis of the position. Its analysis of the trends and its basic conclusion that in 1962 wages and salaries outstripped and ran ahead of productivity cannot be challenged by anybody. I think nobody in this debate so far has attempted to challenge that fundamental conclusion of the White Paper.

The evidence of this dangerous trend is clear and incontrovertible and if this Government were to sit back, with what, to my mind, would be criminal negligence, and allow inflation to develop unchecked then they would be unworthy of their trust. It was the duty of the Government to give a clear warning of what was happening.

It should not be necessary for me to outline to the House the results of inflation. They are well known both inside and outside the House but in view of some of the remarks which have been made, particularly by Deputy J.A. Costello, I feel I should point this out, that in an inflationary spiral and when wages start chasing goods in such spiral, the people who are hardest hit are people on salaries and wages and fixed incomes, the people to whom Deputy Costello has referred. Businessmen and other sections of the community are very often able to cushion themselves against the worst effects of inflation but inevitably the people who are hardest hit and who can do least to protect themselves in inflationary circumstances are those who get their livelihood by means of salaries or wages or fixed incomes of some sort.

Comment on this

Do nothing but wages and salaries chase goods?

Comment on this

Yes, of course they do. All incomes chase goods in an inflationary spiral.

Comment on this

There is the heart of your fault.

Comment on this

But that does not defeat my argument. The point I am making is that in inflation, other sections of the community are very often able to cushion themselves against the worst effects of it, but the people who can rarely catch up and who are hardest hit are people on wages and salaries and fixed incomes. In a situation of this sort, it is the duty of the Government to speak out in unequivocal fashion, to point out clearly what is happening, and give the public the fullest possible information and, if possible, to point to the remedy.

It seems to me that the Government have the duty to act in this way in the interests of the community as a whole but especially in the interests of those people who I have said will be hardest hit if inflation is allowed to develop unchecked, those who rely on salaries and wages for their livelihood. In this Government, all our policies are directed towards procuring a continuing expansion of the economy so that out of the increased pool of production, we can make available to our people better living standards, better housing, better health services, better social services and better amenities for the community generally. That is the only sound policy to pursue. It is only out of the pool provided by increased production that we can derive these benefits to which I refer.

It is possible by certain tricks and financial juggling to mortgage the future and secure temporary benefits or advantages that are not justified by increased national income. But that —and I think most Deputies will agree with this—is only storing up trouble for the future. The only safe way to conduct our affairs is to share out to all sections of the community the benefits of increased production when they have occurred but not before. That is, in fact, what happened during the years 1958, 1959 and 1960. Over that period of three years, salary and wage-earners secured substantial increases in remuneration but they were covered by increased productivity.

Comment on this

The judges' salaries?

Comment on this

Forget about the judges. The Deputy might be up before them one of these days.

Comment on this

It would not be the first time.

Comment on this

That may be the trouble.

Comment on this

But you will fix it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

I want to emphasise that during these three years substantial increases in remuneration were procured by practically all sections of the community without any objection whatever or without any criticism of any sort by any member of this Government because we wholeheartedly approved of that process. We should have liked to have seen it continue indefinitely. We believe that when increased production justifies it, the proper thing to do is to make the benefits of that increase available in one form or other to wage earners, salary earners and others.

Comment on this

Why not do that with the hardship cases as well?

Comment on this

We do that in every Budget. If there are any hardship cases at present, then the White Paper will not prevent those being cured.

Comment on this

Why do you not prevent them? That is what you are there for?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

Our approach to this matter is governed in this way: we know there are times when increased salaries, wages and incomes are good business, good sound economics—when they are justified by increased productivity. The increased purchasing power generated by these increases stimulates further economic advance and, as I say, that is what happened during the years 1958, 1959 and 1960. Substantial increases in remuneration were secured which were justified by the increase in the national pool. We also know, however, that there are times when the workings of the free enterprise economy can result in wages and salaries outstripping productivity and in those circumstances it is necessary, unless you are to get into trouble, to have restraint until such time as productivity catches up again. That is exactly what we are looking for in this White Paper and nothing more. The present Labour Party cannot have regard to the national interest in this matter.

Comment on this
Deputies

Why?

Comment on this

They are in a political straitjacket. They think that politically it is necessary for them to react violently once the very question of salaries or wages is mentioned at all.

Comment on this

We are working in conjunction with the Congress.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Please allow the Minister to proceed.

Comment on this

They feel they must react in this way once the subject is mentioned at all. They cannot have a calm, dispassionate approach to the subject on its merits. I think they are doing themselves less than justice.

Comment on this

One seat in the city of Dublin. You are not entitled to talk for the working people at all.

Comment on this

We transformed Dublin.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Deputies must stop interrupting the Minister.

Comment on this

Tell that to the Deputies over there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am addressing my remarks to the House.

Comment on this

Stop that gentleman behind the Minister from interrupting.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am making my remarks to the House.

Comment on this

I am afraid we cannot expect any really constructive approach from the present Labour Party to this serious problem to which the Government are directing attention. That is a pity because I think——

Comment on this

Could you not show the same regard for the workers as you showed for the judges? The workers got only about 12/- a week but the Minister gave the judges £16 a week.

Comment on this

I never heard the Deputy say anything when I was giving it.

Comment on this

We all objected. We voted against it.

Comment on this

We did.

Comment on this

As I said, it is a pity the Labour Party take this approach and I would appeal to them even at this late stage to change their tactics.

Comment on this

To become "yesmen".

Comment on this

To become responsible and not to grasp at this as a stick to beat the Government. The people with whom they should be concerned are the wage and salary earners.

Comment on this

They are the people who are hit in this White Paper.

Comment on this

You would do your reputation a lot of good if you approached this on its merits because it would show that you had a real grasp of our economic situation and a positive approach to our problems and not the destructive, automatic mechanical reaction. When——

Comment on this

When did the Minister set himself up as a lecturer?

Comment on this

The fact is that we are the Labour Party.

Comment on this

When I feel the necessity to point out the error of your ways, I have to do so and I am sorry if it disturbs or annoys you.

Comment on this

It does not disturb us; it amazes us.

Comment on this

If it does not disturb you, then keep calm.

Comment on this

The White Paper has you properly disturbed.

Comment on this

I want to say that I am quite confident that we are going to get the support and co-operation of the people in this appeal which we have made to them to close the gap because I know there has been a great feeling of pride among the ordinary men in the street in our economic achievements in recent times. They have seen the dramatic advances that have taken place. They are aware of the tributes that have been paid to this country by impartial international experts and leading foreign economic and financial journals. These achievements have given our people a new feeling of confidence and they do not want under any circumstances to have anything happen which would endanger the progress which has been achieved so far. When this Government, who have been responsible for the Irish economic miracle, come to the people and say——

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is the miracle of 70,000 unemployed.

Comment on this

What is the White Paper for if we are living in a miracle?

Comment on this

When the Government come to the people and say that this line of action is necessary to protect what has been achieved——

Comment on this

This is a death certificate.

Comment on this

——then I think the Irish people will accept that. They know what has been achieved and they do not want it to be jeopardised. I do not mind going to my friends who are trade unionists or salary or wage earners and explaining to them what is involved in this White Paper. I know they will understand because I can make a straightforward case and I can show that what we are looking for is reasonable. The people know we are doing well at present, far better than they hoped for five, six or seven years ago.

Comment on this

Some of you are doing well.

Comment on this

They know that what has been achieved has been achieved and made possible only on the basis of good planning and sound policies and they will understand that we are a country in course of economic development and that we must plan and act as such. To seek a level of wages or salaries which is not justified by productivity is like writing a cheque which you know is not going to be met and when the implications of what is in the White Paper are fully understood, I know that we are going to get the support and the co-operation of all concerned.

Comment on this

Do you want the chance to try that out?

Comment on this

The Deputy will be able to talk later on.

Comment on this

You tried to prevent that happening in 1957.

Comment on this

I do not think it is necessary for Government spokesmen to-day to be too hypothetical or to ask people to draw on their imaginations to visualise what happens as a result of incompetent policies. Nineteen hundred and fifty-six is not so long ago and people remember only too well when the economic policy of Deputy Dillon, Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Corish brought this country to its knees. We had then the grim reality of what can happen when economic policies are put into operation which the former Taoiseach admits he did not understand or know what they involved.

Comment on this

He did not say that.

Comment on this

He said that he got advice and he did not know whether it was good or bad.

Comment on this

He said he did not know whether it was right or wrong.

Comment on this

Take your pick.

Comment on this

Do you know whether your advice is right or wrong?

Comment on this

Is it any wonder that the appalling catastrophe of 1956 came when we had a Taoiseach who was prepared to act in that fashion? The people will remember only too well the atmosphere of that time, the unemployment and emigration, and the atmosphere of defeat and apathy. They recognise in this attack on this Government's successful economic policies the same irresponsible approach to our——

Comment on this

With 300,000 people fled from the country.

Comment on this

They went in the Deputy's time.

Comment on this

300,000 Irish emigrants in England.

Comment on this

They are coming back now.

Comment on this

You started that.

Comment on this

The Dublin Corporation's housing problem has become acute again because the emigrants are coming back. Deputy Mullen knows that.

Comment on this

There were no vacant houses when I came in.

Comment on this

You are aware of the fact that contractors are advertising all over England for workers to come back, and they are coming back.

Comment on this

300,000 is not bad.

Comment on this

Nobody wants to go back to the situation of 1956.

Comment on this

In 1956-57, you wrecked our economy.

Comment on this

What about 1922-23?

Comment on this

We were not there.

Comment on this

Your two fathers would not agree on that.

Comment on this

The Minister's father did his best to prevent us.

Comment on this

My father, Lord rest him, is not here. Leave him out of it. Deal with me.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is entitled to speak. Deputies continue to interrupt the Chair. It has come to that. They will not even hear the Chair. I am asking Deputies on all sides to refrain from interrupting the Minister.

Comment on this

Let him stop his silly speech.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not for me to say whether his speech is silly or not. The Minister is entitled to make his speech without interruption. That is all I am concerned with. Deputies cannot make any case for interruptions.

Comment on this

The Minister should sit down when the Chair is speaking.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not be talking to the Chair when he is sitting down.

Comment on this

May I point out that, as a matter of decorum, it is usual when the Chair rises, for every Deputy to sit down?

Comment on this

I also pointed out to the Deputy that he should not be talking to the Chair when he is sitting down.

Comment on this

When the Minister is in this House longer, he will know——

Comment on this

Do not lecture me. I do not need any lectures.

Comment on this

The Minister needs quite a lot of lectures and he will get them.

Comment on this

It is quite clear the Opposition do not care what happens. Exactly as they did in 1956, they are prepared to let inflation develop and do nothing about it. That is the meaning of their attack on this White Paper and on the Government's plea for restraint. If by means of this debate or otherwise they could succeed in defeating the Government in its objectives as set out in this White Paper then they would succeed in doing again what they did in 1956. We must at least admit they are consistent in their perverseness.

They are living in a fool's paradise if they think that the people do not recognise the success of this Government's policies and the achievements that have been brought about since 1957. Does not everybody know that there are more jobs now, that they are more secure and that substantial increases in wages and salaries generally have been procured in the last few years? If we are asking for a certain amount of restraint at this stage it is because we think it is better to have our people in jobs and ask them to have restraint than to have no jobs to put them into as was the case in 1956.

This Government's policy has been clearly indicated. We have pointed out that in one form or another free trade is coming and we have made plans to keep the economy moving forward and to strengthen it to meet the competition we know is inevitable. The White Paper pinpoints certain features of the economy which during 1962 gave cause for disquiet. They have been mentioned already: a slight fall in our exports, a balance of payments deficit, a slight falling off in the rate of economic growth and of course the fact that wages and salaries have outstripped output per worker.

In these circumstances, it is entirely justifiable for us to ask for a certain amount of restraint at this stage. There is no question of hardship to anybody, no question of reducing anybody's income as Deputy John A. Costello tried to suggest. We have at the present time a sound, expanding economy and we want to keep it that way. There is danger that we could run into difficulties if at this stage we were to over-reach ourselves. All the Government is asking is that the existing economy be protected. There is nothing negative in what we are doing. We are seeking co-operation in our efforts to protect the economy. I want to emphasise that it is an expanding economy and that what we want to protect is the very process of expansion itself. If we are asking for restraint at this stage it is only so that our ultimate objectives of full employment and a doubled standard of living will be made all the more certain of realisation.

Comment on this

I notice the Minister for Justice referring to the Government's White Paper as their own. I find that it is its own confusion and I propose to explain exactly what I mean by that. Before doing that, I want to say that this White Paper is a deliberate attempt to woo the large farming community and the industrial employers. It is very significant that in the White Paper, there is no reference to them and no urging on them as to what they should do.

Comment on this

Profits—does the Deputy not see it there?

Comment on this

Let us have regard to the people who make profits, the people who work and work very hard and get very little pay for it. They are the people who make profits.

Comment on this

I would refer the Deputy to Page 8.

Comment on this

This White Paper is full of confusion. As is often said in Dublin, somebody has got mixed up in the jerseys and that is exactly what has happened in this case. We have had the Minister for Transport and Power going around pontificating, talking down to the workers, telling them what they should do and what they should not do. It is perfectly obvious he had a sneak preview of this White Paper. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions found it necessary to hold and emergency meeting on the Saturday following its issue which, incidentally, I protest as a Deputy was in the hands of the Press before it was in the hands of members of this House. I personally did not get it until after the Press got it.

Comment on this

Was it not in the hands of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions?

Comment on this

The Irish Congress of Trade Unions, after reading it verbatim in the morning editions of the newspapers, were placed in the position of convening an emergency meeting. Their objection to the text of the White Paper resulted in the Taoiseach deciding to climb down and make a hurried statement. He did an unprecedented thing in making an announcement on a Sunday. There was a certain amount of watering down taking place, once the reaction set in. Then we had the Minister for Finance making a statement and last night we had the Minister for Industry and Commerce. All these were frantically seeking to take the Government out of the morass they had got themselves into. That is a clear indication to me that there was no thinking on the part of the Government—collective thinking anyhow— before they issued this White Paper.

I was interested to hear Deputy J.A. Costello indicating his experiences at the hands of the economists, and I was intrigued to observe that he said that the same set of economists were the people acting in an advisory way to the present Government.

Last Wednesday during Question Time, Deputy McQuillan made some supplementaries and the Taoiseach then indicated that since 1957 we have had good government. If we have had six years of good government, what is the meaning for this White Paper? Why is it there? What is its purpose——

Comment on this

Quote from it, will you?

Comment on this

——if we have had six years of good government? There is one objection I want to make to the White Paper, that is, the putting of public enterprise into second place. I regard that as a tremendous slap in the face to the people who control and work public enterprises. I also deplore the fact that while doing that, the Government are leaving people who promote private industries, over whom we have no real control, to go to town. The Minister for Justice, the Taoiseach and the Minister for Industry and Commerce can all use the expression "restraint". Indeed this afternoon the Taoiseach went a good distance in saying what he thought about the actions at times of the Federated Union of Employers, but very often in matters such as this, you will get people saying: "I will have to say this much but you can go ahead and do what you like afterwards."

What I object to most of all is the biassed nature of this White Paper, the use of State employees and the indication to anybody who has any sort of control over them that they should tread very carefully and indeed should not start anything lest they set a headline. In other words, the 100,000 State employees can be safely described as guinea pigs. It would be much better if instead of adopting this attitude, the Government applied their minds to serious planning. They should have serious regard to the reports coming out now and then about the possibility of certain industries going to the wall as a result of lowering tariffs on the one hand and inducing foreigners to set up industries here on the other. The Government would be better occupied serving the nation better, if instead of inducing foreigners to come in to operate and exploit in some cases, we operated these industries ourselves and expanded this idea of State operation.

It has already been mentioned that there had been no talk about a ninth round before the issue of this White Paper. What is the position now? The ordinary man in the street who is a member of a trade union has every right to think again about what has been said to him at meetings of his trade union by way of advice, not to be seeking a further increase in wages. He will think, and quite rightly so; "Perhaps I was entitled to a ninth round. It appears very like that when we get this warning note from the Government. What has happened to my trade union that they are not pushing and looking for this ninth round?" This whole thing can create tremendous difficulties for us all.

In addition to that, we have the situation where you have people who have not yet had the eighth round. There is a certain amount of clearing up to be done. In some cases, they are semi-State concerns. Are we to take it that what is to happen now is that the eighth round will not be cleared up? Many of these things could be avoided very well had there been consultation with the organised workers and employers before the White Paper was issued. It is very wrong to suggest that the Irish Congress of Trade Unions was looking for concurrence, but there should have been consultation with both sides. Had that step been taken, we would be in a much healthier position now. Instead, we have the present speculation on the part of many people about who is right and who is wrong.

That is where the Government have failed. They made a tremendous mistake in not adverting to the good offices that were previously there by way of organised labour and organised employers. One might say, as has been said, that no one side or section of the people deserve to be consulted, that the nation must be consulted in matters of this kind. The White Paper deliberately points at a section, and now we must take everybody into consideration and say that when a stand has been taken, it is about time for it to be adhered to. This House is repeatedly disregarded. I am worried about people talking about democracy. The Minister for Justice talked about the democratic way. The democratic way for what? It is about time the Government made up their mind with regard to matters of national importance that the first place in which they should make pronouncements is this House, and not at meetings of the Federated Union of Employers or even at trade union meetings. This is either the Parliament or it is not. It is very difficult to know, the way things are going now, when we are left wondering as to what power even the Government have got over some people they put in charge.

Many Deputies have found it necessary to raise questions in relation to different Departments. Very often they have not been raised in this House because the Ceann Comhairle has said that they are not matters that can be raised in this House, that they are for the chairman of this, that or the other. So much for the manner in which democracy is operated in this House. I was glad to hear somebody from the Government benches at least talking about democracy, but I would like them to dwell on it and to realise that when members of no matter what Party come into this House, they expect to obtain information.

I would like to know what is going to be the position of the Labour Court in this matter. We have had a tremendous amount of speculation about the Labour Court, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce made a speech last night about it. He indicated he was thinking of making changes. Many other people have the same idea. Indeed, on the workers' side and on the employers' side, it has been agreed that there is room for improvement in the modus operandi of the Labour Court.

What about the confidence of the workers in the Labour Court as a result of this White Paper? I am a trade union official and can speak with a certain amount of knowledge on this matter. Frequently, a trade union official advises workers to avail of the machinery of the Labour Court. In the face of this White Paper, the travelling will be very hard because there is a direction contained in it and it does not take a man of great intelligence to know where the direction is. Is that not a shocking state of affairs when the Government are talking in terms of greater production and the interests of the nation?

The sequence of events is rather interesting, to say the least of it. I remember the first time we made our application for entry into the Common Market. Government representatives made a statement indicating the state of our country and explaining that it would take some time to prepare for the removal of the tariff walls. Shortly after that, these representatives made another statement indicating that we were ready to go in and to take our full responsibilities. The next thing was the announcement that we were an underdeveloped country. Then we have this White Paper. Surely that is not going to create a good picture outside.

I want to emphasise that, in the opinion of the Labour Party, there is no such thing as a crisis in existence in this country at the moment. It is wrong for anybody to talk in terms of a crisis. The situation at the moment can well be overcome with reasoned thinking. The words "climbing down" or "change of attitude" are not popular but I do believe that if the Government had the doing of it all over again, they would go about things in a different way. I was interested and intrigued by what the Taoiseach said to-day in relation to the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. In no uncertain way, he explained the confidence he had in the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. At the same time, the Taoiseach and the other members of the Government have forgotten the part the Irish Congress of Trade Unions has been playing for many years in helping the Government to overcome problems. It may not be known to every member of the House but it surely is well known to the Ministers of the Government that most of the time of the officials of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions is spent in working on various committees set up by the Government.

With that in mind, surely the attitude adopted towards those people was a wrong attitude? I hope it is not too late but perhaps somebody will set about reconciling the position because the talks that were proceeding between employers and trade union representatives have been put aside. They have been wrecked by this hasty action. Perhaps on reflection, the Government will be big enough to realise the mistake they made in that regard and will invite the Congress and the Federated Union of Employers to come together to discuss this problem.

I have already expressed the view that it should not be said that there is a crisis. There are many good reasons why that should not be said. The last increase in salaries secured by the civil servants was taken care of by the money that came in from the pay-as-you-earn system of income tax. The Budget and the Supplementary Budget also helped. That is my understanding of what I have read. Our bank deposits are up. It should also be borne in mind that it is not so long since the Government planned for a two per cent. increase and secured a five per cent. increase in industrial output. The Government shouted with glee about that. Still, we have this White Paper. I should like to know if this White Paper is a prelude to a rough Budget. Are the Government preparing the people for a rough Budget? Are they attempting to produce conditions in which the people will say, in the event of a rough Budget: "Things are not so bad as they might have been"?

In connection with this White Paper and its advocacy, we should not forget that many firms have boasted that they have absorbed the eighth round of wage increases. With regard to the suggestion of a wage pause, taking the average weekly earnings of agricultural workers, county council workers, forestry workers, and some people in the distributive trades, who are getting £6 to £8 a week, does anybody suggest that these people are well paid and should stand-easy and, whether it be the eighth, ninth, 10th or 11th round, should forget it in the interests of Ireland? We all know that there are thousands of such persons, excluding females. I am talking about men. Anybody can check that what I am saying is correct. Yet the suggestion is made that these people should mark time and look for nothing more.

Is there anybody in this House, particularly any member of the Government, who will have the impudence to suggest that such rates of pay can be regarded as fair, proper, reasonable and sufficient for a man or woman to live in frugal comfort?

There are others working in factories and workshops who consider themselves fortunate that they are getting £9 or £10 a week. Does any member of the Government suggest that £9 or £10 a week is enough for one to live on? Can any member of the Government produce a formula to show how people can live and rear a family in proper surroundings on £9 or £10 a week?

There is another group of workers who are described as highly-skilled and they are in the £11 and £12 a week income bracket. They are the minority of workers. Yet, we have a situation where, in a subtle way, we are told to stand still in the matter of wages.

I hold that to afford a more acceptable way of life, there is need for a better distribution of wealth. If one has regard to what is advocated in the White Paper, we will not get that. The Minister for Justice has said that weekly earnings have significantly outstripped production. What about the person with £6, £8, £9, and £10 a week? Are they to become jokes for everybody? What of unorganised labour? What of the people who have no trade union to represent them and who are earning low rates of pay? Are they to continue to be exploited? Are the employers, under this White Paper, to say to them: "There it is. Do not start another round. You are not being fair to the country"?

Having regard to all the statements made on this matter, I would like the Minister for Transport and Power to state the number of industrial and manual workers in the State services who are earning as much as £12 and £14 a week. If he makes a study of it, he will find that such people are largely in the minority. Earlier today the Taoiseach made reference to a speech made by Mr. John Conroy, President of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union and Treasurer of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. He was referring to one of Mr. Conroy's many speeches and his advocating of conferences between employers and labour. Why did Mr. Conroy, in the past couple of weeks, find it necessary to make such a speech? The answer is obvious. It is because the Government have failed to bring about that which is most desirable.

Seeing that the Taoiseach has such a penchant for reading the speeches of Mr. Conroy and people like him, I wonder if he would have regard to the speech made by Mr. Conroy in which he said that the industrial worker should have at least £10 a week. Will the Government address themselves to that and issue another White Paper to the effect that that should be done? We heard the Taoiseach say that the employers and workers in other countries expect to get guidance from their Governments. What guidance has been got from this Government in relation to wages and conditions? I would say none.

I should also like to remind this House that we are not attempting to create discord in this House or outside it. But there is one thing sure. Prior to the last election, the Labour Party, in their submission to the people, indicated that they believed that if Fianna Fáil were returned to power there would be a wage pause. They have gone very close to it in this White Paper. You can call it what you like but that is what is contained in paragraph 21 of the White Paper.

I feel I should avail of this occasion to remind the Government that it was Selwyn Lloyd of England who first introduced the pay pause. You know where Selwyn Lloyd has gone— he is no longer a Minister. Macmillan was his partner and you know what is happening to Macmillan. Even the Sunday Times has predicted that he is on his way out. I think that Fianna Fáil are on their way out. If they are sincere about this matter, the least they could have done, the proper thing to have done, was to attack prices.

I have already said that we very often find employers inviting wage applications. We often find trade union officials trying to advise workers as to what is going to happen in relation to increases in wages because of the merry-go-round. Could we have it from the Government now that there will be a serious attack on prices and that rising prices will be fought as tenaciously as increases of wages will be resisted by employers? Can we have an assurance from this Government that any standstill will produce better services for social welfare beneficiaries or an extension of the scope of the Health Acts? I doubt it very much.

It is significant that the idea of a wage pause should occur in 1963, 50 years after 1913, a year in which the workers will be celebrating proudly the progress made since 1913. It is significant that restraint is being advocated in such a year. If we are to gain the confidence of the workers, whether organised or unorganised, incentives will have to be produced for them, incentives that will make them realise that there is concern for them in this House. It would be a real advance if we had an easement of rates, an attack on prices and an improvement in our health services.

Why did the Minister for Justice or any other Minister attempt to lecture the workers? I ask that having regard to the behaviour of the Minister for Justice and the Minister for Transport and Power towards workers generally. That is an attitude they cannot be too proud of. Our form about these things is that everybody is a worker. We have been obliged to listen to sneers being thrown at defenceless workers, at people who have not got the right to strike and who cannot defend themselves. I would like to know, as a trade union official, from the Minister for Justice, what exactly are the jobs he refers to when he said that everybody knows there are more jobs and more security now than before. I wonder if the Minister for Justice has had regard to the CIO reports and to the operations of CIE in laying off workers. I would appeal to the Government to display a little more confidence in organisations such as Aer Lingus, CIE, the ESB and Bord na Móna. Good work has been done by all those industries and organisations right from the top to the bottom on behalf of the nation.

Comment on this

This White Paper is entitled "Closing the Gap". The first essential in any discussion with regard to it is, I think, that someone, preferably the Taoiseach, or one of his Ministers, should endeavour to close the gap between the terms of the White Paper and the terms of Ministerial utterances since the White Paper was issued. The paragraphs in this White Paper which have occasioned most comment in this debate are paragraphs 20 and 21. Paragraph 21 sets out the particular recommendations of the Government with regard to the problem which the White Paper says, in paragraph 20, exists. The first part of the paragraph reads as follows:

As a more immediate matter, the Government are convinced that it is necessary to avoid the damage to the national economy which would occur if further wage and salary or other income increases, whether in the public or the private sector, took place before national production had risen sufficiently. General restraint is essential ....

It is quite clear, I think, that anyone reading those words when this White Paper was first published was entitled to come to the conclusion that the Government were in fact not merely advocating but were determined to implement a wage freeze and not merely a pay pause. They were determined to implement a wage freeze. They set out in the White Paper that the Government are convinced that it is necessary to avoid the damage to the national economy which would occur if further wage and salary, or other income increases, were made whether in the private or the public sector.

In paragraph 21, it is stated:

In the light of the considerations set out in this White Paper, the Government deem it necessary that Departments and State-sponsored organisations should not accede for the present to any claims for increases in wages and salaries, or for changes in conditions of work having the same effect, which would arouse expectations of similar increases in other employments.

The very last sentence indicates that, even if awards are made as a result of arbitration proceedings, the Government, if necessary, will see to it that those awards are not implemented. Anyone reading that was legitimately entitled to come to the conclusion that what the Government intended to do was to clamp down on any increases in wages and salaries. We are entitled to know at this stage of the debate whether that is still the Government intention. Is that what they mean? Are they serious about it?

Comment on this

There is no mention of a standstill or a freeze in that document, and the Deputy knows that as well as I do.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary should not quibble.

Comment on this

Read the document.

Comment on this

I have read the document, and read it very carefully, and if the Parliamentary Secretary is anxious to give the views of the Government in this matter, I shall be very glad to hear him answer the question.

Comment on this

I shall do that when the Deputy sits down.

Comment on this

He can answer it now for my benefit.

Comment on this

When the Deputy sits down, I will explain it fully.

Comment on this

To my mind, at any rate, it is quite clear the Government, as a minimum, intended a pay pause. I think they intended going further, and having a wage freeze. Perhaps I am wrong in that, but will the Parliamentary Secretary agree with me that the clear implication in that White Paper is that there was to be a pause on wages?

Comment on this

The past President of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions does not think so.

Comment on this

Time will tell.

Comment on this

And I do not think so.

Comment on this

All I want to know is what the Government think. Was this intended to be a pay pause, or was it not? The Parliamentary Secretary says he does not think so.

Comment on this

I am quoting the Past President of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions.

Comment on this

The difficulty is this White Paper has not been published by the Congress of Irish Trade Unions. It has not been published by any of the Opposition Parties here. It has been published by the Government and I am trying to find out what the Government mean by it. Do they intend a wage freeze? Do they intend a pay pause? Or is it all nonsense, and they are not serious about it at all?

Comment on this

It is merely a statement of facts.

Comment on this

Young Lochinvar has come out of the west. Despite what appears to me to be the very categoric and specific terms of paragraph 20 and 21 of the White Paper, as soon as resentment and criticism were aroused when the document was published, the Taoiseach decided they had better say something about it. Now, as I read the Taoiseach's speech published in the daily papers of 11th February, he says, in effect, that they did not mean that at all; there is no question of a pay pause; there is no question of a wage freeze.

Comment on this

And there is no question of a wage freeze in that document.

Comment on this

Then what is it for?

Comment on this

Surely the Parliamentary Secretary is being hypocritical.

Comment on this

Let us start from the ground up. This document is entitled Closing the Gap. It sets out what the Government said was the problem. Having devoted 18 or 19 paragraphs to stating the problem, they then come to their decisions on it. This is what they say in paragraph 20, and I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will have got it off by heart by the time I have finished:

As a more immediate matter, the Government are convinced that it is necessary to avoid the damage to the national economy which would occur if further wage and salary or other income increases, whether in the public or private sector, took place before national production had risen sufficiently.

Does that imply that there will be no increases?

Comment on this

No, no.

Comment on this

As far as the Government are concerned, in the public and private sectors, there are to be no further increases. If it does not mean that, what does it mean? It says the Government are convinced of a particular thing which we now hear they have no intention of trying to implement. I assume that if the Government think they are convinced that a particular course of action is the proper course to be taken they will proceed to take that course of action.

In paragraph 21, they go on:

In the light of the considerations set out in this White Paper, the Government deem it necessary that Departments and State-sponsored organisations should not accede——

What does that mean?

Comment on this

Is that not plain King's English?

Comment on this

They say "should not accede".

Comment on this

Read the next few words.

Comment on this

"For the present——"

Comment on this

That is it.

Comment on this

"——to any claims for increases in wages and salaries." In this paragraph earlier, it is stated: "The Government deem it necessary——"

Comment on this

Read the last sentence.

Comment on this

"——that Departments and State-sponsored organisations should not accede——

Comment on this

Read the last sentence.

Comment on this

What I am asking the Parliamentary Secretary and the Government is whether I am right in my interpretation——

Comment on this

Read it on.

Comment on this

That is what it says. Is that what it means?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy read the last sentence?

Comment on this

Certainly. The last sentence is a very dangerous one.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

You had better keep whistling.

Comment on this

"In the light of the considerations set out in this White Paper, the Government deem it necessary that Departments and State-sponsored organisations should not accede for the present to any claims for increases in wages and salaries, or for changes in conditions of work having the same effect, which would arouse expectations of similar increases in other employments——"

Comment on this

The last sentence in the paragraph.

Comment on this

"——in conditions of work having the same effect." Not alone are there to be no increases in salaries or wages but there are to be no changes in conditions which might have the incidental effect of increasing wages. Nothing is to be permitted which would arouse expectations of similar increases in other employments. The paragraph continues:

They trust that there will be a full appreciation of the fact that the Government should not in respect of persons whose remunerations is provided directly or indirectly from public funds, or whose employment arises in the provision under statutory authority of public services, follow a course they are convinced would be contrary to the national interest.

Comment on this

Next sentence, please.

Comment on this

As far as civil servants or any other people who might be generally deemed to be State employees are concerned, there are to be no increases in wages. The paragraph then says that it is not envisaged——

Comment on this

Go on. Read it.

Comment on this

Permit me to make my speech in my own way. The Parliamentary Secretary will just have to listen. It says "it is not envisaged". That is merely for the moment.

Comment on this

That is not in it at all.

Comment on this

For the moment the Government are thinking that conciliation and arbitration proceedings should be put in suspension. Rather do they think that findings in other sectors should be suspended also, and listen to this: "...and, if necessary, not applied until this can be done without damage to the national economic interest".

Comment on this

That is the thing.

Comment on this

In other words, the Government are saying that as far as State employees are concerned, there are to be no increases and that as far as others are concerned, they want general restraint as far as arbitration awards are concerned. Arbitration awards are to be put into cold storage and no increases are to take place. But then the Taoiseach spoke and was reported in the public Press on 11th February last. According to this report, he said that the White Paper did not envisage or forecast any action to enforce a standstill in wages. On the contrary, the Taoiseach said, the Government's desire was that there would be a steady continuing rise in real wages, in salaries and living standards generally, in line with rising national output. He said the White Paper reflects the Government's decision that another general round of wage increases, in advance of an expansion of national output, having regard to the revival of national economic progress, rising prices and rising unemployment which it would cause, would not be initiated by the Government or statutory organisations financed out of State funds.

That, to my mind, was looking at the White Paper with half an eye. There is no question of the White Paper simply saying: "Wage increases will not be initiated by the Government or by statutory organisations financed out of public funds." But it does say, and presumably intends, that there will be for the moment a wage freeze as far as certain sectors, at least, are concerned.

Comment on this

The White Paper clearly states, however, that conciliation and arbitration will continue to operate, though regard must be had to the effect of particular awards on other sectors of the public service and on the national interest generally.

Comment on this

In the White Paper, the Taoiseach omits the last sentence which the Parliamentary Secretary invited me to read into the White Paper—that if necessary, arbitration awards will not be applied. That is the sting in that last sentence.

Comment on this

They will stand.

Comment on this
Mr. Barry

Where will they stand?

Comment on this

Stand still.

Comment on this

Stand to be paid.

Comment on this

They will stand still.

Comment on this

Do not be silly.

Comment on this

Are we to take it that the Taoiseach, his higher Ministers, his Parliamentary Secretaries and his backbenchers all stand over the White Paper or do they all stand over his statement of earlier this month, or would they prefer to move on to as late as yesterday and accept the interpretation put on it by the Minister for Transport and Power who is reported in the public Press as giving his gloss to the thing:

The whole spirit of the Closing the Gap White Paper was to encourage this up-to-date approach to the seeking of better living standards. The Government asked only for an intelligent examination of the national yearly profit by voluntary negotiation between employers and workers.

Apparently the Minister for Transport and Power stopped reading the White Paper before he came to paragraphs 20 and 21. If he did, I should be glad if the Parliamentary Secretary would call his attention to those two paragraphs. I do not think the Government should be left in any doubt about the feeling of the people. This is an unwanted Government. There have been criticism of the Fine Gael Party and of Fine Gael leadership on the grounds that they have not been fully critical of the Government. Those criticisms of the Fine Gael Party are touched off because of the impatience of the people who want to get rid of the present Government. They want to see every Deputy in every Party in this House doing what he can to get rid of this Government, and quickly.

The Taoiseach had the gall to-day to talk about irresponsibility associated with the Fine Gael Party. He and his Party can thank their lucky stars that they had inside this House a responsible Opposition who were prepared to play their part properly as a responsible Opposition in a parliamentary democracy and who did not accept as a definition of a responsible Opposition the type of advice given in the editorial columns of a daily newspaper recently, which seemed to imply that even if the Government were doing what we believed they should do, we should prod them and prick them and criticise them. We have not done that. We did not do it because we believed this Government had come around to a correct point of view and had dissociated themselves from their old isolationist policy in the past. While they were negotiating as the Government of this country on behalf of the people of this country, we were prepared to act as we felt a responsible Opposition should act, but do not let the Government feel that is a shield for them to get away with it. As far as we are concerned, we regard this motion as a vote of no confidence in the Government. We are inviting the Government to go to the country and to give the country an opportunity of passing judgment on their actions as a Government since they were last elected.

Comment on this

Hot air.

Comment on this

Before the Parliamentary Secretary succeeded in getting into this House, the Fianna Fáil Party campaigned up and down the country with the slogan "Let's Get Cracking." You are cracking now and the Parliamentary Secretary knows it. The Taoiseach spoke of people whistling in the dark to keep up their courage. All he has to do now is to look over his shoulder and he will see a prime chorus of whistlers behind him.

The Taoiseach to-day made an effort to suggest that we in the Fine Gael Party, because of our criticism of the Government with regard to the White Paper and the failure of their policies which led to the issue of it, were in some way adopting an attitude antagonistic to the interests of the farming community. I think back— and my political memory is somewhat longer than that of the Parliamentary Secretary—to the utterances of Fianna Fáil Ministers! I think it was the Taoiseach himself who spoke of featherbed conditions for the farmers in this country. I think it was the present Tánaiste, as Minister for Finance in a Fianna Fáil Government, who stated that taxation rested lightly on the land. I think it was the same Minister for Agriculture they have now who spoke of lining the ditches and hedges of the farmers' fields with inspectors and Civic Guards——

Comment on this

This is the gramophone record.

Comment on this

——to see that the policy recommended be carried out. These are the people who, through the Taoiseach, endeavour to suggest that the Fine Gael Party are in some way antagonistic to the interests of the farmers. I do not think the Taoiseach is doing a good day's work—certainly not for the country and not even for his own Party—if he endeavours to use this White Paper and the situation being created by it to create a division between the farming community and the industrial workers. That is not good business, coming from the head of any Irish Government. The Leader of my Party, Deputy Dillon, has very rightly pointed out we are too small a country to endeavour to create two nations of any kind, whether it is by political partition or by creating classes of rich and poor or sectional divisions between industrial workers and the farming community.

One of the odd things about this White Paper, when we consider the problem it is intended to deal with, is the fact that nowhere in it, as far as I could see, is there any mention at all of the desirability of savings to endeavour to remedy the situation which has come about. Do the Government believe in savings? Do they believe in doing anything to further savings? I am not an expert on economics, but surely it is true to say that in a situation of the sort facing the Government, where you have an imbalance of payments, one of the weapons to be used should be to foster as best we can savings amongst our people? Why is there no mention in that White Paper about savings? Why is the only remedy that seems appropriate to the Government the remedy of the wage freeze? Is it because the traditional and historical Fianna Fáil panacea for all ills is a wage freeze?

This White Paper was issued in the month of February. The Taoiseach replying to the Adjournment Debate in December, 1962, addressed himself to this House only two months ago. Surely the problems suggested in the White Paper existed then? Perhaps I might read paragraph 1 of the White Paper:

The purpose of this White Paper is to draw attention to the economic dangers caused by the gap between incomes and productivity (i.e. output per head) which has developed over the past year or so....

It is not something that happened to-day or yesterday, but something that developed over the past year or so. Look again at paragraph 12:

The reason for concern at present is that, as indicated in earlier paragraphs, most of the features described were present in 1962....

The White Paper says that this is something that has been developing for the past few years. It was certainly there in 1962. Two months ago, the Taoiseach addressed himself to this House. What did he say? I turn to columns 1469 and 1470 of the Dáil Debates for 13th December, 1962:

Deputy Dillon expressed concern about the adverse trade balance. He talked about the gap that exists between the value of our visible imports and the value of our invisible exports. It is true that the over-all picture at the end of this year, when it will be possible to determine it in February or March next year, will probably show some deficit on our external payments but, in so far as that deficit has not involved as the Deputy found out, any diminution of our external reserves, it is not a matter of great concern.

December, 1962, it is not a matter for great concern: February, 1963, Closing the Gap, standstill, wage freeze——

Comment on this

Two different matters.

Comment on this

That is the gap he is talking about.

Comment on this

They are two different matters.

Comment on this

At columns 1471 and 1472 of the Dáil Debates of 13th December, the Taoiseach is reported as saying:

In many trades, as Deputy Sherwin pointed out, and in many industrial occupations requiring particular skills there is a scarcity of workers. In many areas of the country full employment has been realised and, indeed, there are directions in which or economic progress is being retarded at this time by labour shortages. That is our real problem and it is the problem to which I would prefer to see Deputies directing their attention rather than trying to disparage the reality of our achievement so far.

Comment on this

And we want to preserve that. That is why this White Paper was published.

Comment on this

Why were we not told about the closing of the gap then?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary should read Paragraph 12.

Comment on this

I have read it.

Comment on this

Read it again.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach was so carried away by his own enthusiasm and by what had been achieved by Fianna Fáil Government up to December, 1962 that he looked a little into the future to see what was necessary and at Column 1472 of the Dáil Debates of 13th December he said:

In relation to this problem of employment and unemployment at this time, the main matters that are giving the Government concern are these two. First to meet the housing needs of those whom we want to attract back from England to employment here and to meet the housing needs arising from industrial expansion in particular towns....

In December, 1962, two months ago, the Taoiseach was talking about attracting back workers from England. Are they likely to be attracted by the wage freeze policy the Government now suggest in this White Paper should be operated?

I have mentioned that the White Paper does not at all refer to the question of savings. I have mentioned the particular line which the Taoiseach pursued here two months ago when my reading of his speech, and I think a fair interpretation for anyone to take out of his speech of 13th December last, was that everything in the garden was lovely, everything was rosy, that we were going ahead and going to get the workers back and the big problem was to build houses for them. So much did that speech of the Taoiseach impress the editorial writer of one of the principal provincial papers in the country, The Kerryman that they came out with the heading “Never So Good”. They had this to say:

In the course of his reply to the debate on his motion that the Dáil adjourn until January, 22, An Taoiseach is reported as saying that in many industrial occupations there was a scarcity of workers and in many areas full employment had been realised. Indeed there were directions, he said, in which our economic progress was being retarded by labour shortage.

If that statement were published anonymously, few, we venture to say, would take it as referring to this country, or for that matter to any country in these islands, Macmillan could not say it, Brookeborough could not say it; Lemass has said it.

The queues at the Labour Exchanges in Britain, especially in the north, are growing longer; there is a large and hard core of unemployment in the Six Counties for years; as for the position in this country, believe it or not, you have read Mr. Lemass's statement. Mr. Macmillan and Lord Brookeborough have every reason to be envious of Mr. Lemass, or so it would seem they should.

To their credit, if such it be, Mr. Lemass and his Ministers never fail to have the good word. Nothing downs them. They have never been behindhand in making things seem very much better than they are. They are born optimists, likeable fellows until one gets bored with hearing the success story too often.

The attitude of the Government is that this country is flying. If anybody does not understand that modern way of saying so, it means that it is prosperous and steadily getting more prosperous.

That is the impression that the Taoiseach succeded in creating in the last month of last year. There was no question then of a wage freeze or a pay pause, no suggestion that any awards made by arbitration would be put in cold storage and not applied on the orders of the Government. Is it suggested now by the Taoiseach and by his Ministers that they have no responsibility for bringing about the situation with which this White Paper and its recommendations are intended to deal? Are their memories so short and do they think that the public memory is so short that we are likely to forget that, following the 1957 election, the Fianna Fáil Government deliberately increased the cost of living when they slashed and abolished food subsidies?

I put down a question which was answered today by the Taoiseach and it is just as well to remind him and the Parliamentary Secretary of it. I tried to find out what increases had taken place between mid-February, 1957, and mid-November, 1962. I was told that 3½ lbs. of household flour had increased in price from—these are average increases—1/0¾ to 2/-; the 2-lb loaf of bread from 9d. to 1/4; Irish creamery butter from 3/8¼ to 4/6½; sugar from 7d. to 8¼d. Clothing had increased in the period by 7.6 per cent; cigarettes by 25.9 per cent; tobacco by 24.7 per cent; bus fares by 27.8 per cent; rail fares by 23.5 per cent; rent inclusive of rates, 23.8 per cent. We also had increases in things like whiskey, stout, beer, postal and telephone charges, electricity charges and even motor insurance. All these items have been increased in price by the Government and every time there is an increase imposed by the Government, it makes the value of money less and when that happens, it is perfectly natural that people endeavour to compensate themselves for the lesser value of money by applying for wage increases.

Comment on this