We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by the Minister for Finance.

Contributions 194–413 of 413. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Could you impress that on the Parliamentary Secretary, Sir?

Comment on this

It would be relevant to the Vote on Account if the 1939 Act had not given the 48-hour week to the worker, if it had not given him holidays with pay and controls with relation to overtime and night work. I think it is most relevant.

Comment on this

Do not forget the standstill for the workers.

Comment on this

You would not give them employment.

Comment on this

I would employ more than you with your tennis raquet and your golf clubs on the road to Cavan.

Comment on this

This is the third time that Deputy Lynch has interjected a remark about a standstill order. What about the standstill order? You tell me.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not at this stage.

Comment on this

The point is that there never was a standstill order. There was a certain position at the time due to the circumstances at the time and the then Taoiseach had to go on the radio to contradict the misrepresentations made by a former Leader of the Coalition.

Comment on this

Are the same circumstances operating now?

Comment on this

I know that these social achievements of the Fianna Fáil Government are unpalatable to the Fine Gael Party, the attitude of which will continue to be, with the exception of Deputy Lynch, against the working people of this country. Deputy Lynch has said that the workers vote for him. I know the people who have voted for Fine Gael but the laws of order would not allow me to express myself on them.

Wet time insurance, the charter of the building worker, was introduced for the first time by Fianna Fáil. The present Government is examining the position with regard to wet-time insurance generally. I came across a case recently in which a man with his family would have been better off if he had drawn unemployment assistance rather than wet time.

Comment on this

One case? I could give you 400.

Comment on this

We are the Party who have brought all these injustices before the people. We do not think we have cured all the ills but we have placed them before the Irish people and told the people that we want to remove them. We do not say that everything in the garden is rosy. I have not yet come to 1948. I am now at 1947 and only that Deputy Barrett reminded me I would have forgotten to mention that in 1947 our Government set up the Department of Social Welfare.

Comment on this

I did not remind him of any such thing.

Comment on this

I was looking at the Deputy and I was reminded that in 1947 we set up that Department. I need not now go into the necessity for it but we were dissatisfied with the delays and the faulty administration which obtained up to that time. The first task given to the Department was to prepare a comprehensive scheme of social welfare but we went out of office in February, 1948, without bringing in that scheme. We had to wait until 1952 to bring it in.

Deputy Norton, who was then Leader of the Labour Party, became Minister for Social Welfare in the Coalition Government in 1948. In public statements, he said he would bring in the Social Welfare Bill before the summer. He genuinely believed that he would. I believe that he believed that and so did the Irish people. He meant it in his heart but he was in a Coalition Government. For three more years, Deputy Norton as Minister for Social Welfare repeated that promise and covered up his Fine Gael colleagues in the Coalition Government to the best of his ability and acted in what he deemed to be an honourable manner. The Social Welfare Bill did not appear. It was held up by the Fine Gael majority in the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

On a point of order, has what the Parliamentary Secretary is now saying anything to do with the Vote on Account for 1963?

Comment on this

It has everything to do with it.

Comment on this

He has not made it clear to me.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Parliamentary Secretary is dealing with Government expenditure, he is in order.

Comment on this

He is not. He is dealing with the Social Welfare Bill of the inter-Party Government in 1948.

Comment on this

I hope you will remember that, Sir, when I am speaking.

Comment on this

Vote No. 50, Social Insurance, and Vote No. 51, Social Assistance total £28 million and it would be a sorry look-out if I could not refer to an item costing the taxpayers £28 million.

Comment on this

So long as that holds for the rest of the debate, it is all right.

Comment on this

I shall not dwell on this but I shall just recall what Deputy Jim Larkin said on 28th April, 1952, describing the position:

We knew that Fine Gael utilised every opportunity that came not only in the open light of day but in the dark of night.

That was often quoted by Deputy Norton subsequently. That was the reason—and let the public know it— why the Labour Party were not allowed to bring in the Social Welfare Bill. What was the contribution to the old age pensioners and the widows in those years, 1948 to 1951? The total increase was 2/6.

Comment on this

Question.

Comment on this

All right.

Comment on this

As my memory serves me——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot have debate in this fashion.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary said it was 2/6. They got an increase of 7/6 and the means test ceiling was increased from £99 to £104 in 1948.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seeks on every occasion to bandy words with the Parliamentary Secretary. The debate cannot be carried on in this fashion. The Deputy will get an opportunity of making his own speech in an orderly fashion. This is disorder.

Comment on this

I am very pleased with you because I hope you will think of this when I am speaking.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair always thinks of it when anyone is speaking.

Comment on this

The figure of 2/6 which I gave for old age pensions and widows' pensions in the three years of the Coalition Government is correct.

Comment on this

No, it is not correct. The means test ceiling went up from £99 to £104.

Comment on this

When we took over.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

When we took over in 1951, we immediately increased the rates of old age and blind pensions, and we eased the means test very considerably.

Comment on this

The means test remained as it was.

Comment on this

In 1952, this long awaited Social Welfare Act became law.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

We will skip those years with those references. Deputy Lynch might enlighten me because he was here from 1954 to 1957. What was the sum total of the increases in social welfare benefits in that period given by the Fine Gael Party who had control of the purse strings and the key Ministries and used their influence and voting power to overwhelm their Labour colleagues? I want to get it on the record. What was the sum total of the social welfare increases in that period, 1954 to 1957?

Comment on this

You tell me now. You seem to have it there.

Comment on this

I have—2/6d.

Comment on this

What did you give from 1957 to 1962?

Comment on this

In every single year since 1957, we have given an increase and some new improvement in the social welfare services.

Comment on this

That is lovely, is it not?

Comment on this

We have increased old age pensions by 8/6d., I think.

Comment on this

Could you be sure?

Comment on this

I am certain. We eased the means test for old age pensioners and beneficiaries of unemployment assistance.

Comment on this

Of course, having taken away the subsidies on bread, butter, tea and flour, you had to do something.

Comment on this

The Deputy's Party were back in office subsequently and did nothing.

Comment on this

We were not back since 1957. You removed the subsidies in 1957.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary might be allowed to make his speech. The Deputy will get an opportunity of making his in an orderly way afterwards.

Comment on this

In reply to Deputy Lynch who asks what did we do since 1957, we increased the widows' pension by 8/6d. A widow with two children got an increase of 14/6d. Are those figures correct? Before that, nothing was paid to a woman with more than two children. Now, as we know, all dependent children, are counted and the widow with six children is now entitled to a non-contributory pension of 71/- as compared with 36/6 in 1957.

Comment on this

How many of those widows are there?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

That represents an increase of 34/6d. a week. In unemployment assistance, there is an increase of 24/6d. and, as in the case of the widow, all dependent children are now included. A man with a wife and six children in rural Ireland now gets 74/6 a week. What did he get in 1957? He got 28/-. In urban areas, a man with a wife and six children gets £4 2s. 6d. What did he get in 1957? He got 38/-. There is a 50 per cent. increase in children's allowances. Recently we introduced the contributory scheme for old age pensions. There is now no means test. It is not necessary to retire from work in order to qualify, and the basic rate is 40/-a week. A man gets 30/- extra in respect of his wife, irrespective of whether or not she is under 70 or over 70. He gets £2 and an extra 30/- for his wife.

All existing rates of benefit have been increased since January last, even though they had already been increased in last year's Budget. The increase amounts to about 5/- a week, and there is a substantially greater increase for dependent children. As a result of all these increases and social welfare payments, contributory and non-contributory, given in last year's Budget, I calculate that recipients will benefit in a full year to the extent of no less than £3,780,000. That was the figure given by the Minister for Finance. The net result of all that is that this Government added to the expenditure on social welfare in 1962 a sum 50 per cent higher than the total amount added during the whole period of the two Coalition Governments, dominated by the Fine Gael Party.

I do not think we shall ever see another Coalition Government in this country. That is my personal opinion. Equally, I do not think we will ever see a Fine Gael Government. My reason for spending so much time on these social welfare benefits given by my Government to the workers and the less well-off members of our community is to bring out into the open the Fine Gael position. They have now an opportunity on this Vote on Account of saying in public here what they stand for. They have now an opportunity of criticising, of saying what they think we should do, of telling us what they think we should cut.

The whole kernel of this Vote on Account is the total shown on the right-hand column of the statement of the net added expenditure on Public Services for the year 1963-64. It is misleading, and politically dishonest, to suggest that the figure of £167 million is criminal, unprecedented and wrong. The only regret I have is that the figure does not approach the £200 million mark for capital services. I hope that the day is not too far distant when the economy of this country will be in a position to finance further capital expenditure by the State on the progressive schemes I enumerated at the outset. I am only too sorry that the Minister for Agriculture is not getting £80 million instead of £8,816,000.

Comment on this

He will probably promise it the next time.

Comment on this

I am only sorry that education is not getting more than £12 million, but I get some consolation in the fact that it has increased since 1957 by £3 million. I am sorry we cannot give secondary education more than £3,745,000, but I get some consolation in the fact that it has gone up by £2 million since 1957. I am sorry too that vocational education, about which Deputy Treacy has often spoken here, is not getting more than £2,255,000, although there is £1 million more being given now as compared with the amount provided by our predecessors. I am sorry all this expenditure on education, agriculture, housing and social welfare is not higher. I make no apology to the Fine Gael Party that the figure stands where it does. They should appreciate the difference with regard to the expenditure of the money. They should realise what it means to the farmers.

We have heard the Leader of the Opposition and the former Minister for Finance speaking; not only have they said it but it has been stated in the papers by their minions, in speeches prepared for them, that this unprecedented amount of £167 million in the Estimates for the coming financial year will be a crippling burden and should never have been allowed to reach this level. I only hope that the economic position of the country will allow us to vote more for housing and more for schools. Never in the history of this State has more money been spent on schools than has been spent last year and this year by this Government. There are hovels of schools. There are hovels under this Government but we are out to eradicate them to the best of our ability. Are Fine Gael against this £2 million vote for schools? Is Deputy Barrett against it? If he is, he cannot have it both ways. We shall have a vote on it. He cannot, on the one hand, say these Estimates should not amount to £167 million and, on the other hand, when I explain to him the different headings, advocate that money should be spent on various services. However, if he disagrees, he has an opportunity of showing his disagreement to the public.

Too long have Fine Gael run with the hare and the hounds. I am very glad that the mild dawn of promise has arrived for my friends on my left. That is why, when a Fine Gael speaker addresses us here, he should tell us, beyond yea or nay, whether he is against these increases. Let him tell us whether he wants a reduction in the Estimate of the Minister for Lands, who is here beside me. The Estimate for Lands, when we took over power, was £1,900,000. Do the members of the Fine Gael Party want us to knock off this amount which the Minister for Lands is now asking this House to vote in the coming financial year? When he took on this responsible position, including Forestry, the expenditure was £1,600,000. This year, we are asking for another £2 million on top of that for Forestry.

That is the only purpose of this Vote on Account, that the Government will put their case and that the Opposition will be, as it is their duty to be, constructively critical. It is certainly not their duty or responsibility to attempt, as they have done over the past two weeks, to mislead the Irish people. Of course the tempo will increase for the next few weeks. With the by-election looming up, all this political misrepresentation has been planned.

I think I have put my views reasonably. I have given no false figures. I have made no outlandish claims and, with due respect to Deputy Barrett, any figures I have quoted I have quoted from the official documents of this House. It is time the Fine Gael Party realised that it is in their interest and the country's interest that they should consider their position and the role which they have played here in Opposition. They will then appreciate that instead of their being looked on as the main Opposition, the eyes of our opponents turn elsewhere.

Comment on this

Having listened to the Parliamentary Secretary give us a dissertation at great length on the ancient history of this country and trace the various enactments back to the commencement of the State, I do not intend to follow that line of debate. I merely wish to avail of this opportunity to make a brief appraisal of the work of the Government, to review their policy and indicate the attitude of my Party in that regard.

It has been said that the amount of money being voted this year is a record figure of £167 million, and that is so. It has been said, and rightly so, that it is a formidable sum. We are not so much concerned about the actual figure itself. It is understandable that it should increase, having regard to increased costs, the cost of capital services and other services. Rather are we concerned about how it will be spent and what effect it will have on the economy. Our Party is concerned to know what effect the expenditure of this formidable amount of money will have in creating employment opportunities and giving our people a better standard of living; what effect it will have in increasing social welfare benefits and bringing much needed relief to the aged, the sick, the infirm and the unemployed. If it has a worthwhile effect in this regard we say it is money well spent and our only regret, like that of the Parliamentary Secretary, is that there is not a greater amount of money for public services on this occasion.

In regard to this huge expenditure, we have had forebodings and indications from the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance as to how it will be met this year. We are naturally concerned as to how this money is to be found. There have been indications that the Budget may contain a sales tax provision of some sort. There has been an attempt recently to place a pay pause on wages and salaries and we are afraid that by reason of the manner in which the Government have set about finding this expenditure, the situation in the economy may well worsen rather than improve.

There have been increases in many important categories—agricultural grants, Local Government, Education, Lands, Fisheries, Health, and so on. In relation to agricultural grants, it is gratifying to know that there will be an increase in expenditure of £221,000. It is gratifying as a whole to see more money being spent on agriculture. However, as the Leader of my Party queried today, we wonder, having regard to all these helps, aids and stimulants to the agricultural community, if they are bringing the reward which we should expect.

We have not been getting the increase in productivity from agricultural land that one would desire. Despite statements here by Government spokesmen that theirs is the Party and the Government which best serves the needs of the agricultural community, we have evidence of great unrest amongst certain sections of the agricultural community today, particularly, the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association, in relation to the price of milk, to which the Taoiseach referred, and the general situation in local authorities as regards the impost of rates. It is true that the Government have come to the rescue of farmers in this regard and have set aside a considerable amount of money to bring about a rebate in rates.

We desire very much that agricultural produce should increase. We should like very much to see more people employed in agricultural production in this country. We deplore the fact that so much machinery must be brought in here to work our land and that so many people have been disemployed in agriculture in this country. You do have that drift from the land, to which the Minister should have regard, and which is very undesirable.

It was rather ironic to hear the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance tell this House about the great things his Party had done for the welfare of the workers of this country. He traced the whole code of social legislation and the Industrial Acts and tried to infer that the Labour Party, as such, was a misnomer and that anything that had been done for the workers of this country had been done by the Fianna Fáil Party. I believe, fundamentally, that were it not for the Labour Party and the trade union movement spear-heading all these ideas, no Government in this country would have brought about these reliefs. It was the trade union movement and the Labour movement which really agitated for shorter working hours, better conditions, decent wages and better social welfare benefits. It was only by dint of pressure and pressure on the public conscience of this country that any Government acquiesced under the circumstances.

It was ironical, too, inasmuch as the Minister for Lands is in the House at present, that the Parliamentary Secretary should talk in this strain when, quite recently, the Labour Party sponsored a Bill in this House to give a new charter to agricultural workers. We sought to abolish the Agricultural Wages Board and to give these workers the right to go to the Labour Court to lay down decent wages, conditions, holiday payments, and so on. The Minister for Agriculture opposed that motion. We had the spectacle of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael going into the lobby only a few weeks ago to vote against that measure to improve the status of the lowest paid, hardest-working and most exploited element in our society.

We had, too, the evidence of the attempted pay pause which the Government introduced quite recently. Fortunately, it did not have the desired effect. The workers of this country were quite shocked, and appalled even, that the Government should have the audacity to impose such a restriction on the right to negotiate with their employer or trade union or that there should be the suggestion of a pay pause. Not only were the workers shocked by that proposal but the country as a whole was deeply shocked by it.

Up to Christmas of last year, the Taoiseach and Government spokesmen indicated clearly in public statements inside and outside this House that the economy of this country was in a very sound condition; that we had a viable economy; that there was nothing to worry about unduly; that we were going full steam ahead into the Common Market; that we would be in the Common Market very soon and that we had nothing to fear at all from outside competition. Indeed, the confidence of the Government was such that the Taoiseach was inferring that we might even go it alone into the Common Market, if necessary.

It was rather a shock to us all, then, to find within a few weeks that we should have this complete change about. The gloomy picture was painted of a fall in production and a disequilibrium in our balance of payments. An attempt was made by the Government to introduce panic measures, the first of them being the pay pause and indications now that a sales tax will be imposed in this country.

A sales tax, if it is true, may well have very bad effects. If it is to be a tax imposed on so-called luxury goods, it will mean that the average housewife in this country will be denied those things which are regarded as essential in these modern times to eliminate drudgery in the home. It may, too, have an effect on employment inasmuch as, if sales fall, it is bound to have an effect on production and certainly on any goods manufactured or assembled in this country. It is bound to have an adverse effect on and to upset the employment position in this country, which is very bad at present.

Speaking of unemployment, we have heard of the Government's Programme for Economic Expansion. The Government, despite any pretence on their part, will have to admit that their plans in that regard have proved an abject failure. The increase in productivity which they set out to achieve may have been achieved, and a little over and above that, but that four per cent. increase in production is nothing like the increase in production which is desirable in order to create full employment. We need an increase in production much in excess of four per cent. to give us the full employment which is so desirable in our country.

We have at present upwards of 60,000 unemployed. It is true to say that nearly 300,000 people have emigrated in the past six years. At a time when the Government are crying out for increased productivity, it is indeed farcical to talk about it when, on the evidence before us, we find that our most cherished assets, our young people, are denied the opportunity to work in their own land. What a colossal increase in productivity we should have if we put the 60,000 people at present unemployed in this country to productive work. Is it outside the bounds of possibility for a Christian Government to find ways, means and measures to put these people to work? What a wonderful economy we should have, what a prosperous one, if we had devised ways and means as we should have done to employ in productive work in the country the 300,000 people forced to emigrate in the past six years?

The Government talk of productivity as if the worker who is fortunate enough to have a job in this country could bring about greater productivity of his own volition. The facts are that the worker on his own is not capable of increasing production, that unless he gets the tools, the machines and the equipment, he cannot do it. Therefore, the attitude of the Government in reflecting like this on the Irish worker was wholly unjustified and unfair. It was done in the clear open light of day, without any regard whatsoever to a check on profits and prices. Prices have increased considerably, and the Government have not availed of the machinery which is there to control them. Indeed they have permitted profits to rise unbridled.

It is my firm opinion that the Government have leant over backwards on the side of the opulent, the wealthy and privileged in this country. There was evidence of that fact when they conceded only 2/6 a week to the old age pensioners, while, at the same time, giving upwards of £12 to the judiciary. It is evident from the point of view that they gave a rebate in rates on agricultural land while ignoring other sections of the community on whom rates are as heavy a burden. That is not to say that I begrudge the agricultural community what they got, but I do say it is unfair that one section of the community should be chosen for such a concession.

In relation to the Estimate for Industry and Commerce, I notice that there is a figure of £250,000 as an increase for equipping industry under the re-equipment scheme. That is very desirable. It is of the utmost importance that industry should be guided, advised and helped to re-equip itself to meet the free trade circumstances which are looming up, for despite the fact that we have not as yet got into the Common Market, it is evident that free trade is in the offing. Nevertheless, I am concerned that the expenditure of this money for industrial expansion in this country needs some looking into.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but discussion on particular Estimates is not regular on the Vote on Account. It is the general policy. The Deputy will find an opportunity of dealing with the matter he is now endeavouring to deal with when the Estimate for that Department is being debated. If the Deputy were to be allowed to proceed on those lines, we could take every Estimate individually.

Comment on this

I have no intention of delving——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I would sooner he did not deal with it at all because it would then become difficult, if not impossible, to restrain Deputies from dealing with the Departments of Defence, Local Government, Agriculture and so on.

Comment on this

It is a pity the Ceann Comhairle was not here when the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance was speaking because he covered the whole ramification of Government down through the years.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He did not cover any particular Estimate.

Comment on this

Every Estimate since the beginning of time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He referred only to outlay on the Estimates. The Deputy is trying to deal with administration and the policy of the various Departments.

Comment on this

I do not wish to comment any further on this matter except to say that I am concerned with redundancy in industry and that it is desirable when we spend money on industry that we should ensure the highest labour content is involved. I wish to submit that the £250,000 in this Estimate for the re-equipment of industry should not be spent on experimenting with new ideas, new machinery, new equipment, which would only have the effect of displacing labour.

I know as a positive fact that much money allocated in this way has been utilised for the re-equipment of industry in the belief that it would achieve greater production, but that the employers concerned were satisfied with the same productivity and there was created as a result of the expenditure of this money much unemployment in the firms. I think money spent like that, while it may seem economical and wise to the Government, is socially wrong. The primary purpose of spending money for industrial progress is to endeavour that industry should give the highest possible employment and that this employment should be as permanent as possible. It is to be deplored that any money spent in assisting industrialists should be used to achieve a situation where unemployment obtains.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy and I seem to differ about what a short reference is.

Comment on this

I do not want to go through the various headings, lest I might outstep my rights. You will understand, Sir, that as a new Deputy, I am not as yet acquainted with the——

Comment on this

The Deputy is not doing badly at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

General Government policy.

Comment on this

Since we have the Minister for Lands in the House, I should like to refer to the Estimate for his Department.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is what I took exception to in relation to Industry and Commerce. The Deputy will probably endeavour to refer to Agriculture, Local Government and so on.

Comment on this

I really want to praise the Minister——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is just as disorderly.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making a great case if he can get away with it.

Comment on this

I hope the increase in the Estimate there will give more employment and I hope the Minister will see fit to acquire more land and, above all else, where he knows there is redundancy in afforestation, that he will consider paying a little more for mountain land. I understand the price at the moment is not very attractive and much more land is required if we are to maintain the present employment under this heading. I would ask the Minister to consider an increase in that regard.

The ideal which the Government had of providing 100,000 new jobs has not yet been realised. We have not seen the achievement of the 20,000 new jobs a year which they set out to attain. Indeed, unemployment is now in excess of what it was at this time last year. I want to see that dynamic programme which the Government had devised on paper put into operation and implemented in practice, if that is possible. I believe the Government are pursuing the wrong policies in many regards. The 20,000 jobs a year have not been achieved; we have not seen the dynamic programme to which they referred; and we have not seen any capacity for hard work on the part of the Government, never mind on the part of the workers of the country.

Comment on this

What about the 92,000 who were unemployed when the inter-Party Government were in power? Is there not a great difference between the two figures?

Comment on this

There were 140,000 unemployed in the Deputy's time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Treacy should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

A consummation devoutly to be wished.

Comment on this

As a result of the breakdown of the Common Market talks and the situation that has arisen since, the policy of the Government of continuing to reduce tariffs is causing some anxiety. They are continuing a policy of reducing tariffs in the belief that in the long run we will get into the Common Market or some such organisation, possibly EFTA, but there are no indications as to when that will happen. In the meantime, the industrialists are in the position that tariffs will be lowered without any of the gains or advantages which would normally accrue to us if we had gained access to the Common Market or some similar organisation. That is a worrying situation. I wonder if it is a wise policy.

It seems to us that the Government staked their all on the hope of geting into the Common Market under the umbrella of Mr. Macmillan, and now that General de Gaulle has put paid to that hope, they seem to be at sixes and sevens as to where to turn or what to do. They seem to have no policy, and they are trying to rearrange their programme as best they can, but they should soon be in a position to give an indication to the country as to what the future will be. It is not good enough to continue to reduce tariffs as if we had some hope of getting into such an organisation and allow that to happen indefinitely. That will have the effect of creating unemployment and redundancy in many industries of which I have personal knowledge.

The Government have the reports of the Committee on Industrial Organisation which clearly stated that there would be serious redundancy in very many of the industries they had surveyed. They stated that there would be redundancy in the cotton, linen and rayon industry, in the boot and shoe industry, and serious redundancy in the car assembly industry and some other industries. That is the pattern, and that is why I lay such emphasis on the desirability of attaining something worthwhile with the money sought in the Book of Estimates.

The Labour Party aspires to the idea that a redundancy pay fund should be available for people who are disemployed. That is nothing new. Many progressive countries have a system under which the workers are compensated when laid off in industry. It seems only right, equitable and just, that when a man has given the best years of his life to industry, he should not be discarded and thrown on the unemployed scrap heap without as much as a "thank you". We hope that provision will be made for that kind of redundancy pay fund which will adequately compensate those people for their loss of employment and give them an opportunity of looking around for alternative work or starting out, perhaps, on their own. I was hoping to have an opportunity of going through some of the items in the Book of Estimates.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has not lost his opportunity. He will have it on the Estimates when we come to them.

Comment on this

Very good. While the sum is up on the sum for last year, we are not at all surprised at that. We believe that if the people demand a service and if a service is being supplied, it must be paid for. There is nothing in this Book of Estimates that we could fall out about and our only regret is that the amount of money being sought is not more.

We express the hope that the expenditure involved will bring about the kind of Ireland to which we aspire: an Ireland of happy homes with men, women and children shielded from the terrible spectre of unemployment and emigration, an Ireland where men are afforded an opportunity of working at home in their own towns, if possible; where they are afforded an opportunity of marrying, founding a family and rearing them at least in frugal comfort, an Ireland in which they have a decent educational system which will give every family, however poor, an opportunity of attaining to the greatest heights in education, cultural and spiritual pursuits, an Ireland where there will be decent social welfare benefits.

The people on the front bench of the Fianna Fáil Party may pride themselves on the increases they gave under the social welfare heading in recent years, but when we compare our social code with that of our fellow-Irishmen across the Border, it pales into utter insignificance. We desire in Estimates of this kind that there will be a good health service for our people. In that regard, we would hope we would not have an odious means test applied under which a person's family life and his privacy are pried into in order to determine whether or not he should get free hospitalisation, as is the position today.

That, as I say, is the Ireland to which we aspire. I do not believe these Estimates are sufficient to give us that Ireland, and I believe that many of the increases in the Book of Estimates this year will be offset by the method by which the Government now propose to finance the Budget. I believe the forecast is that we will have a hair-shirt Budget. I also believe that a sales tax will interfere with the standard of living of our people.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy want?

Comment on this

I believe that a sales tax will have the effect of reducing the standard of living of our people.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We may not discuss taxation on this.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir. We believe that our people are entitled to the best in life. Some people, including some of those in this House, think that because a worker has a motor car or a television set or a washing machine——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Taxation on any goods is not relevant on this.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Tax expenditure, not tax collection, may be discussed.

Comment on this

On the general policy, I was saying that there is a feeling in this House, on certain sides of it, that the workers are too well off, that they are too well paid in the first instance, that they are not producing enough and that they should work harder. When I say that they are too well off, I mean that if they have a motor car, they are looked at with suspicion. If they have a television set, it is resented by certain elements of society. We believe that our people are entitled to the best that life can offer.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We believe that all the things, including the so-called luxury goods, will now probably come under the axe of a sales tax and thereby have an adverse effect on the standard of life of our people and possibly have repercussions on their employment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy may not in that very clever way discuss taxes by a sidewind of that kind. I have given the Deputy a good deal of latitude but my rulings in future will be more rigid.

Comment on this

Very good, a Cheann Comhairle. I propose to conclude, so I will ease your mind in that regard. I am only concerned to say that I would love someone to indicate to me whether in this formidable amount for Public Service this year, there is any hope for the young people, especially those who are coming out of school for whom, to my mind, there are no opportunities available. There does not seem to be—certainly in my constituency, for which I can speak with authority—any opportunity for young people of 15, 16, and 17 years of age, however well educated they may be. There seem to be no jobs available for them.

I appreciate that the Government are anxious to increase the industrial arm and are spending quite a colossal amount of money in that regard but it does not have the desired effect. We are not creating the employment opportunities for our young people. It is my experience that those males who enter employment in a particular industry as long as it survives remain there, but the amount of recruitment in after years is very limited indeed. The amount of recruitment of juvenile labour since the middle thirties is very slight indeed. There does not seem to be, then, an opening or an opportunity for our young people to gain any foothold in any kind of secure or remunerative employment. All that is available is the blind-alley job, the underpaid job or that job where they are taken in and employed for a number of years and then laid off without any hope of being retained.

Some kind of indication should be given as to what we propose to do for the 5,000 or 6,000 who are coming out of school every year, to provide jobs for them. My experience in my constituency is that in the main the bulk of these people, the flower of our youth, the brains of our country, the people who should be making the Ireland of tomorrow, whom we are educating at a great cost and whose parents are making great sacrifices to rear and train them as good Christian men and women, are being discarded by this Government as products of no consequence and sent out to the four winds of the world.

Comment on this

What would be the Labour policy?

Comment on this

We would see to it that it was not so much wealth that counted in this country but welfare. We would see to it that it was not so much profits that counted as people, and we would regard as the first essential, the most cherished asset in this country, our people, our children. We would see to it that in so far as it was humanly possible, our children, whom we reared at great cost, would be provided with a job at home. It is significant to note that every progressive country in Europe ravaged by a great war has found full employment for its people, and a high standard of life, and this country of ours has not. Be it said that despite the aspersions cast on Fine Gael and the Labour Party in this debate and the aspersions cast on the Coalition Government effort, we have heard nothing in this debate but great disillusionment and great frustration, particularly from Fianna Fáil spokesmen.

Comment on this

Line up with the Tories.

Comment on this

I am no Tory.

Comment on this

Line up with them.

Comment on this

Never. I have heard aspersions cast and the only solution to the whole situation was a reference to 1957. We had the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance going back to 1908 and tracing the whole social welfare code and the various enactments down to this time and talking about the past. I am not concerned about the past. I am very definitely concerned about the future, and I am asking as one who has obligations to speak for the young people of this country, what is to be done for them. Are we to pursue a policy of being satisfied to rear them, educate them and then send them into emigration? That is the policy we deplore. We say again that as far as we are concerned, our most cherished assets are not the land or the capital of this country but its people, and we would see that those people are given a right to a job in this country and to the best that the State can provide, a high standard of life in keeping with the countries of Europe. When, as I have said, every country in Europe is progressing to a very high standard of life, to full employment and to a state when it is able to draw on labour from other countries, we have this country of ours virtually crawling on its belly.

We have made very little progress in the last 15 or 20 years and the main fault must lie with the Party now in power. They are the Party who are in Government in this country. They have had full control of the affairs of the country. They have been in office now since 1957 unhindered in the pursuit of a policy which is not bringing more security, more prosperity or more happiness to the Irish people and in that regard I feel that they have utterly failed.

Comment on this

Arising out of the remarks made by the Deputy who has just spoken, it would be no harm to mention at this stage that one of the boasts of the Government Party is that they have attracted many foreign industrialists to the country. The reason of course is plain. Foreign industrialists find here the cheap labour they cannot find in any other country, and it must be borne in mind that if you have cheap labour, you still have in the minds of the people providing that cheap labour the anxiety to emigrate. That was referred to by no less a person than the Taoiseach when he spoke in Galway two years ago. Talking about steps to be taken to combat emigration, he indicated that one of the most important factors was to reduce the gap between earnings in Britain and earnings here so that the people of this country would not be encouraged to emigrate by the prospect of obtaining greater earnings.

The last speaker who spoke on behalf of the Government was the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance. I have seldom heard a less realistic or a more pessimistic speech. The norm or standard of success for Governments, judging by the Parliamentary Secretary's remarks, is how much they can spend in any year. The Parliamentary Secretary exulted that they were spending more this year than they ever spent before and he apologised to the country that they had not spent more. We were spending £167 million and so many thousands and he was terribly sorry that we were not spending £200 million. He apologised for everything except the fact that the present Government had not honoured their promise to employ 100,000 people. He spoke of capital expenditure of £100 million but if the norm or standard of success for Governments of the country is how much we spend, let us at least know what it is being spent on.

The Parliamentary Secretary lamented the fact—he had to lament it because it is under his nose in his own constituency—that enough was not spent on the housing of the working classes. He indicated that this was not the fault of the Government but of Limerick Corporation. To me, it appears an amazing coincidence in respect of Dublin, Cork and Limerick Corporations, three bodies which are most sincerely anxious to house the deserving working classes, that since a Fianna Fáil Government went back into power by some extraordinary unexplained process——

Comment on this

It was not extraordinary and you know that.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins can make a speech later, if he wishes.

Comment on this

I will; I will speak next.

Comment on this

I was speaking about Limerick, Cork and Dublin Corporations and Deputy Collins might do me and the House the courtesy of shutting up.

Comment on this

I am sorry.

Comment on this

It is an extraordinary coincidence that the three main public bodies in the country which are sincerely anxious to house the working classes housed less since the year Fianna Fáil went back into office. How it happened I do not know.

Comment on this

I will answer that.

Comment on this

Speaking as a member of Cork Corporation—and there is at least one other member of the House who is a member of Cork Corporation and if he were here, he could not deny what I am saying—I say that Cork Corporation is anxious to house the working classes but the number housed dropped by 100 per cent. since this Government took office. The Government will lend money through State or semi-State bodies for the building of hotels but it will not give money for houses for many pregnant young married women. They are going on the basis that the sacrament of marriage does not matter.

Comment on this

I thought you were an honest man.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Barrett should be allowed to speak without interruption. That privilege is allowed to every Deputy.

Comment on this

It is misleading to look at the Estimates alone for an indication of increased public expenditure. Deputy Collins who has been so voluble knows as well as I do that not only the Estimates will be used to raid the pocket of every wage earner. Deputy Collins, as a member of a public body, knows as well as I do that increased rates will mean an increased raid on the pocket of every ratepayer in the country.

Comment on this

Because they are going to get extra benefits.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want to make a speech?

Comment on this

I am sorry.

Comment on this

Cork County Council, for the first time in their lives, will require over five million pounds from the ratepayers of that county. If the estimate which is before the council is passed, it will mean a 4/2 increase in the rates. Cork city will have an increase of 3/3 if the estimate as it is put before the corporation is passed.

One might ask: what is one going to do about it? What is one to do about the increased demand we find in the Estimates for the Public Services? What is the member of Cork County Council or Cork Corporation to do regarding the local demands? It is only with fear and hopelessness that you can address yourself to a problem of that nature. For many years, one has been saying: "This cannot go on; we must live within our means," but these words do not seem to mean anything any more to anybody. Nevertheless, these things are said only because they are facts. It is a fact that this cannot go on and it is a fact that we are living beyond our means.

This country, in my opinion, seems to be suffering from that most dangerous disease known as delusion of grandeur. Any medical man will tell you that this is the most dangerous condition in which any person can find himself and, in my opinion, it is the most dangerous situation in which any country can find itself. We are in this situation and I defy any member on the Government benches to deny it. Only the best will do us. We are a poor country, a country which is progressively becoming depopulated, almost an underdeveloped country, but only the best will do us. I remember standing down in St. Stephen's Hospital in Cork with an international delegation—architects, engineers, doctors, everything mixed up. One of them looked at one of the corridors and said: "I never saw so wide a corridor in any hospital in the world in all my life." He thought it a most magnificent piece of extravagance.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael attitude to social expenditure.

Comment on this

I do not care who did it. Even if we did it, it is still continuing and that does not stop me from decrying the fact that there is not any indication of the present Government stopping it.

Comment on this

Poor mouth.

Comment on this

Anybody who travels from Dublin to Cork or further south will see the folly of our expenditure on public roads. Since 1954, I have seen it year after year.

Comment on this

What will the Labour Party say to that?

Comment on this

I am not interested in what the Labour Party say about it. I am suggesting to the House—and if Deputy Collins is capable of hearing what is being said, I am suggesting it to him—that that is not a form of expenditure in which we should engage. We are a small country——

Comment on this

And a great one.

Comment on this

The difference in the journey between Cork and Dublin in terms of minutes, quarter hours or half hours means nothing. No matter what you do to the main roads, it would not mean more than twenty minutes between Cork and Dublin. I insist that it is the most unnecessary form of expenditure any government can engage in.

I think Deputy Corry will agree with me on this, however reluctant he may be. This is a further scandal to which I am referring. I do not know that I am remaining sufficiently general or not but regarding the regional hospital in Cork, the health authority said no, we did not want a regional hospital. I have a shrewd suspicion, and I know that Deputy Corry has a shrewd suspicion, that the Minister for Health is determined to spend £2 million on that institution, if necessary, over the dead body of the Cork Health Authority.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is becoming rather particular.

Comment on this

I was afraid of that, Sir. Hospitals with wide corridors and roads with four lanes of traffic might be highly desirable but I, as a private citizen, might think it desirable to paper my house with the most expensive wallpaper. However, I, as a private citizen, would cut my cloth according to my measure. It is unreasonable to suggest to those on the Government benches that they should do what the ordinary responsible citizen and householder would do, that is, cut their cloth according to their measure and not come in here and suggest that the ordinary norm and standard of success of the Government is how much they can spend in any given year.

I suggest that the proper question is to ask how much can a Government save in any year, how much can they save on roads and hospitals and how much can they spend on the necessary social service of housing the working classes. If I am becoming particular in this matter, Sir, I think you were presiding here when the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance went into the question of housing in Limerick and dealt with the eradication of the slums. In 1956-57, when the inter-Party Government were in office, 491 houses were built in Cork city by Cork Corporation. In 1957-58 the number was 381. Since then, the number has gone down and down until last year only 228 houses were built.

If there is to be expenditure, let it be expenditure on services that are necessary, not on services which are providing unnecessary main roads, not on hospitals which are unnecessary.

On the question of unnecessary expenditure, I should like to protest against the vulgarity that is being introduced into our tourist trade. Year after year we are becoming less and less Irish and more and more commonplace. We are reducing this country, to which tourists used to come to see how the native Irish lived, to the common basis of any country in Europe.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be a matter for the Estimate rather than for the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I am trying to keep my argument as general as possible. There is no man I know who worked more selflessly to bring this country into the Common Market than the Taoiseach but the Government seem to have failed signally in their responsibility to the people in that regard. The upshot of the whole thing seems to be that the Government gambled on our becoming a member of the Common Market. Every Minister went down the country addressing meetings, speaking at junior chambers of commerce meetings and, in some cases, senior chambers of commerce meetings in terms of what was to happen when we entered the Common Market. Nobody ever spoke of what would happen if we did not. Nobody seems to have thought of what would happen if we did not.

We are now in the situation that we are not in the Common Market, we are not in EFTA, we are not in anything; we do not know where we are going and we do not know how we got where we are. It might be true to say that the Government are the victims of circumstances. That is not the business of anybody on this side of the House.

Comment on this

Why is it not?

Comment on this

When in 1957 the inter-Party Government found themselves the victims of circumstances, when an economic blizzard was striking Europe, nobody over at this side of the House worried about that. They told us that we were the people responsible for government and that it was our baby. The people on that side of the House are now the Government. They have failed the country signally. We are not in the Common Market; we are not in EFTA; we have arrived nowhere. It is their responsibility now to explain how we have arrived at this position and it is the responsibility of the Government on an occasion such as this to tell us whither we are bound and how we are to get there.

It is all very well for the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance to go back to 1908. The country wants something more than vague vapourings about 1908. The country wants to know about 1963, 1964, 1965 and what is to face our children. For that reason, I want to protest more strongly against the type of speech made here to-night by the Parliamentary Secretary. We want reality here; we do not want time-wasting adjectives with an occasional verb.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Collins must allow Deputy Barrett to make his speech.

Comment on this

I am glad that Deputy Collins realises what I am getting at.

Comment on this

I thought you were an honest man until now.

Comment on this

That is typical of the remarks we hear from the benches over there. So long as we compliment the Ministers and agree with what they have done, everything is all right but immediately we disagree with the Parliamentary Secretary, with what the Government proposes to do, immediately we criticise the Government for failing to carry out their promises, then one ceases to be an honest man. We are here to criticise the Government and we will continue to criticise the Government. It is my pleasure to criticise a Government who have failed so signally to deal with the problems I have mentioned, who have left us in the position that we are not members of the Common Market, that we are not members of EFTA, that we do not know where we are going and that we do not know how we are to get there. That is something the Government should answer before this debate concludes. I challenge them to do so.

I doubt if Deputy Collins can satisfy us on that matter or if any member of the Government can do so. I believe that the whole approach by the Government to the problems of our time was shown by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance when he exulted that they had spent more money than ever before, when he apologised that they had not spent more, when he intimated that next year they would spend much more, no matter where they got the money. You cannot spend unless you get the money and the people are tired of giving the money to the Government. The Government have investigated every crevice of every pocket of every wage-earner in the country. They have gone far enough. The stage has been reached at which the people will not stand it any more and I believe the Government will be told to get out and to stay out.

Comment on this

Before Deputy Barrett leaves——

Comment on this

I will leave before the Deputy starts.

Comment on this

——I should like to assure him that the Government have no intention of running out. Judging by the antics of the Opposition Party we will be in office for our full term. The Opposition will take good care to give us no opportunity to move out. I can assure Deputy Barrett, further, that when we do move out, we will not leave the load of sorrow Deputy Barrett found in Cork. in 1957, and the broken homes of building contractors who had to clear out, because the State welshed on their grants and had nothing with which to pay them.

Deputy Barrett's complaint now in regard to the number employed is that we brought in foreign industrialists to employ them. I have gone as closely as I could into this Vote on Account. I have heard some criticism of the Minister for Lands here. If there is anything for which to condemn him, I will condemn him. During the long time I have been in this House, the Land Commission has been regarded as an institution in which if a scheme was started, your grandson might reap the benefit. However, I gave the Minister for Lands a job to do, namely, to rescue from misery seven families and the Minister did it in three days. My only regret about the Estimate for the Department of Lands is that more money is not being provided to rescue more families from the congested holdings on which they have to eke out an existence at present.

We should have a little more patriotism. If people who are in safe positions in this country, instead of buying a British article, were to buy an Irish article, they would create employment for Irish people in their own country. In that way they would be doing something for the country. Unfortunately, that aspect of patriotism has disappeared, particularly in this rotten city of Dublin.

I have here an advertisement published by a Dublin businessman. His greatest boast is that 65 per cent of the goods he sells, as estimated by his company's auditors, is Irish manufactured, which means that the people of Dublin are buying the other 35 per cent of foreign clothing, foreign shoes, boots and so on.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would seem to be a matter for the Estimate and not for the Vote on Account, which deals with policy in relation to Government expenditure.

Comment on this

I am dealing here with Government expenditure and the remedy for it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is talking about Irish industries.

Comment on this

My friend Deputy Treacy complained about luxury taxes. I say there are 2½ million imported foreign goods which could bear a 40 per cent. luxury tax and it is the only way to help to create employment for our people and compel these snobs to buy Irish.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of taxation does not arise on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

There were complaints from Deputy Treacy also about unemployment. We had a Labour Minister for Industry and Commerce up to 1957. There was a State industry in the town of Cobh—Irish Steel Limited—where there was employment for 600 men on the day that Deputy Norton took over as Minister for Industry and Commerce and when he left office in 1957, there were 300 odd employed in that industry. That is the employment the Labour Minister for Industry and Commerce provided in my constituency. He cannot deny it. Today, that industry is giving employment to close on 1,000 men. Since 1957, there has been that change in regard to employment generally right through my constituency. I may not be believed; people may take the view that I am biased. I shall quote an opinion of a man who is honoured by every class in the community and by every Party here for the employment he is giving in rural Ireland. I have here a letter I received from General Costello within the past fortnight indicating the position as he finds it in my constituency. It is as follows:

It has from enquiries been clear to us that the labour required for the operation of a processing plant is not available in this area in addition to the labour demand that will arise on the land for the production of the intensive crops required. It is quite apparent from our inquiries that the necessary labour cannot be got. Not only is there no significant unemployment in the area but a considerable number of workers are being transported daily into the area from places a considerable distance away.

He goes further and says:

A large number of Mallow workers have to live in Cork city and to be drawn from Cork city.

That is the condition of affairs in my constituency. In those circumstances, we hear a wail about unemployment.

On Thursday morning last, I had to leave this House to attend a conference in Mallow of the organisers of four new processing plants, two in Kerry, one in East Cork and one in West Cork, that would give employment to a minimum of another 1,000 people in the factories and at least 3,000 or 4,000 on the land, which is just the type of employment we need. Those are the things that are required and any Deputy worth his salt would go down to his constituency and find employment for his constituents, as I have done, instead of moaning here about unemployment. If he does that, he will have no need for moaning here.

The more we look into this question of employment, the more we see the line and the steps the Government took. It is only a couple of months ago that £5 million was provided for that particular side of the industry. That is providing more employment in rural Ireland and keeping more of our people on the land. That is the kind of employment we want for them. That is the kind of employment to which they are entitled. You will not get that employment by coming in here and moaning about unemployment, any more than you will improve conditions for our dairy farmers by statements like the outrageous statement made here by Deputy Donegan a fortnight ago. No responsible Deputy would make such an outrageous statement. As a farmer, and a representative of a rural constituency, I object to slanderous statements being made by the Deputy.

Listen to what the Deputy said on 5th February, 1963, at column 1054 of the Official Report:

What I am going to say now is not a popular thing. I have said it before and I am going to repeat it. From two-thirds to three-quarters of the milk being delivered to creameries here is unfit for manufacture into cheese and the higher priced milk products because it is too dirty.

That is a statement by the shadow Minister for Agriculture. I do not know what Deputy T. O'Donnell thinks about it.

Comment on this

Read the next sentence.

Comment on this

"At the same time, the dumped world produce so far as milk products are concerned is butter."

Comment on this

Finish the paragraph.

Comment on this

I will.

If you leave out the consumption of liquid milk here, which is very small, 95 per cent of our milk production, on which rests the whole basis of our agricultural economy, goes into butter. These are the figures on which we propose to dismantle our tariffs for eventual entry into the Common Market.

The milk goes into butter, Deputy Donegan says, because it is too dirty to go into cheese or the higher priced milk products. That statement is, of course, in keeping with other statements I have heard from those benches from time to time.

I made inquiries into this. I went out to Mitchelstown, which is in my constituency, and I asked them how much of the milk coming in there was put on one side because it was too dirty to manufacture into cheese. They said: "You might get one per cent off and on, but that is all". I went to Rathduff, another cheese factory newly established, and I got the same reply there. If the farmers are dirty and if the farmers' wives are dirty, then it must be in county Louth that they are dirty. That was the most disgraceful statement I have ever heard in this House, and the biggest insult ever hurled here at our agricultural community.

That is the kind of statement made here by certain irresponsible Deputies. That is the kind of statement which causes a good deal of unrest amongst the rural community. It is, of course, in keeping with the policy of the gentleman who stood up there and offered the farmers 1/- a gallon for milk for five years. What hope could we have of increased employment on the land under the policy laid down by the present Leader of the Opposition? Listen to his opinion of the beet factories. I am not at all surprised that he apparently did not bother interfering whilst another member of his Cabinet, Deputy Norton, was getting a levy of £16 a ton imposed on our sugar. Here is what he said at column 2041 of Volume 106 of the Official Report:

There remains beet—the blessings of beet! Some day, and in the not far distant time, our people will have to ask themselves whether it is in the best interests of the community as a whole to continue the production of sugar from beet in this country at an annual cost to the community of £3,000,000 sterling. That is what it costs in normal times to keep the beet industry going in this country. If, instead of growing beet and converting it into sugar, we import refined sugar into this country there will be £3,000,000 sterling more for the national exchequer and that £3,000,000 can be used to increase children's allowances in every home in Ireland from 2/6 per child to 5/-per child, and the land vacated by that crop can be used for the production of profitable agricultural produce which will help to finance essential imports and to enrich the farmers who live upon the land.

Comment on this

Why not go back to the Flood? Does the Fianna Fáil Party not like to go back?

Comment on this

I will go back to 1922, if the Deputy likes.

Comment on this

Go on. The Deputy will bring blushes to his colleagues' cheeks.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Deputy Corry should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

I am giving facts, statements from the Official Report of this House. It is no wonder the Deputy who made that statement did not know, when he was in a position of responsibility in later years, that there was a levy being put on our sugar and did not even know that it was in contravention of a trade agreement. The taxpayers of this country have paid over £1 million in levy last year and ever since that levy was imposed, for six years at least.

Comment on this

For six years after the Deputy's Party returned to office.

Comment on this

For six years after that levy was imposed. If the Deputy has any doubt about it, I will quote again from the Leader of the Opposition. Here is what he said at column 1411 of the Official Report of 12th July, 1960:

I want to raise a specific matter which affects the problems of beet farmers who are supplying beet to the sugar factories, and also other products which are produced from Irish sugar, which is raw material produced in this country. In 1948, we negotiated a trade agreement, Article V of which reads as follows:

The Government of the United Kingdom undertake that where goods, the growth, produce or manufacture of Ireland, are dutiable at preferential rates of duty, they will not vary the existing preferential treatment of these goods in such a way as to put any class of goods the growth, produce or manufacture of Ireland at a disadvantage in relation to goods of that class from other sources enjoying preferential treatment.

Now, that is a pretty comprehensive Article and yet with that Article in existence, I understand that goods containing Irish sugar are being subjected to a very formidable levy, the proceeds of which are devoted to the subsidisation of goods of similar quality containing sugar derived from Crown Colonies of the British Crown. I am told, I think, by some of the Minister's colleagues, that when Deputy Norton was Minister for Industry and commerce, this matter arose and that he did not consider it desirable to press the interpretation of Article V which would give us the right to claim exemption from that levy.

I do not know what the position is in regard to that. I have no recollection of hearing the matter discussed when I was a member of the inter-Party Government, although it could have happened and passed out of my memory but I do not remember it and I have not discussed the matter with Deputy Norton. Whatever attitude was taken up, I should like to be told now because frankly I confess that as I see it now, it appears that that Article is wide enough and comprehensive enough to cover the present procedure under which I believe that goods which are the growth, produce or manufacture of Ireland are being put at a disadvantage in relation to goods of that class from other sources enjoying preferential treatment.

That was the statement made by Deputy Dillon in this House on 12th July, 1960. What amount of revenue and what amount of production have been lost to this country in the six years since that inequitable agreement was made?

Comment on this

Why do you not change it instead of blowing your top here? Say it to the Minister.

Comment on this

You made it.

Comment on this

You change it.

Comment on this

The evil that Deputies do and the evil that buckshee Ministers do lives after them. That is our misfortune in this country.

Comment on this

We are still endeavouring to get clear of the mess you made six years ago and it was only this year we were able to bring in the Coast Protection Bill. Down in my constituency within the past three months, farmers have been refused contracts in respect of over 250 acres of beet. Out in a portion of Deputy O'Sullivan's constituency, there are 500 acres of beet short, due to the working out of that iniquitous agreement. That is the position due to the fact——

Comment on this

Deputy Corry is just being vulgar. Is that in order?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I did not catch Deputy Corry's statement.

Comment on this

I hope you will not catch it tomorrow when it will be repeated.

Comment on this

That is the second time.

Comment on this

Who made the agreement? Who is responsible for that money having to be paid? Who was responsible for the loss of employment to the worker in the field, to the worker in the factory and——

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I am dealing with the amount of unemployment that was caused by that one step alone on the part of the inter-Party Government, the amount of misery that was caused by it. I am not asking too much in asking that even at this late hour some definite steps should be taken to have the matter straightened out. I should like to see the job finished so that our farmers can go into full production.

Dealing further with agricultural topics and the position of our agricultural community in general, I think I remember Deputy Dillon here complaining last year about the price of wheat. It has been a very sore topic. If a man has not some faith in what he is saying, he should not say it. How can a man responsible for making such statements as Deputy Dillon made in the House look in the face any farmer growing wheat. I wish to quote from Col. 2050, Vol. 106, of the Official Report of 18th June, 1947, where Deputy Dillon said:

...for the first time since the emergency, we had the enthralling, stimulating and surprising experience of eating bread made out of Irish wheat. Before you ate it you had to hold it out in your hands, squeeze water out of it, then tease it out and make up your mind whether it was a handful of boot polish or a handful of bread. If it was boot polish you put it on your boots or shoes and if it was bread you tried to masticate it if you were fit.

That was the opinion of Deputy Dillon, the Leader of the Opposition, as to the kind of wheat produced by Irish farmers. Let us examine the agricultural policy from the shilling a gallon for milk to the attitude of the new budding Minister for Agriculture who tells us that 75 per cent of the milk is too dirty to be made into cheese. Let us examine the policy on those lines. Let us remember the batch of Ministers who went over to Britain and came back with a £76 per ton levy on our sugar but did not know anything about it until we challenged them here years later. What can you expect from a team like that? So much for that.

I shall now suggest to the Government that in line with the reduction in tariff duties in preparation for entry to the Common Market, they should remember that the agricultural community have so far got no round of increases. My friends on my left are looking for the ninth round, but the poor agricultural community have not even got one—and let me tell you that there is nobody in that community who does not work. All we are asking is that we be brought into line with our fellow-farmers in Great Britain and Northern Ireland with whom we shall be competing. In fact, I would go a step further and ask the Government to take a bigger step in the derating of agricultural land in this year's Budget.

When I heard Deputy Barrett talking about the cheap labour that is to be had, I could not help thinking of the lot of employment we have succeeded in getting for the Deputy's constituency at Rushbrooke where each worker is earning anything from £12 to £25 a week. That is the general run for the workers at Rushbrooke Dockyard. The minimum wage at Irish Steel is £9 10s. a week and there are very few on that minimum wage. Most of them are earning from £14 to £20. Those are the conditions under which extra men have been placed in employment in my constituency since 1957. The 200 men whom Deputy Norton got rid of from that industry in a very short period of three years are back in employment and 400 more with them. There are now 1,000 at work there at decent wages.

Comment on this

What did you do when the fellows were knocked off the railways?

Comment on this

In the area under my jurisdiction, I take very good care nobody is knocked off. If others looked after their bit of territory as I looked after mine, there would be no need to worry.

Comment on this

Brian Boru was not in it—the new king of Ireland.

Comment on this

If I had blamed the farmers' wives of this country for dirty milk, I would hang my head.

Comment on this

Who is doing the blaming now?

Comment on this

This budding Minister for Agriculture said 75 per cent of the farmers were producing milk too dirty to be processed. If there was any shame in him, he would run off and drown himself in it.

Comment on this

There is not. We are getting the statement but not the reason for it.

Comment on this

The reason for it?

Comment on this

I did not give the farmers' wives——

Comment on this

I have given the statement and I have given the proof that such does not exist, as far as my constituency is concerned. I am calling on Deputy T. O'Donnell to say whether all the farmers' wives in County Limerick are dirty milkers, too.

A number of comments have been made about housing. I am prepared freely to admit that it took the Minister for Local Government nearly three years to get the civil servants in charge of housing in this country——

Comment on this

Is it proper for the Deputy to charge the Civil Service?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He is making general charges. These charges have been made throughout the debate and were ruled to be perfectly in order.

Comment on this

What I am saying is that it took the Minister three years to get out of the heads of the civil servants the instructions they got from Deputy Sweetman. That is what I am saying, and I stand over it. I can now say this much: the man who wants to build a private house in Cork county today need only have £80 of his own money.

Comment on this

Good man.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Sullivan knows that. He knows the regulations made under the development grant and loan schemes in regard to housing in my area.

Comment on this

I do, and I know a lot more, too, of what the Deputy says to the Housing Authority in Cork about the Minister and his Department. Of course he will not say it here.

Comment on this

Hot under the collar.

Comment on this

When it is not going on record, what he says about the Minister and his colleagues in the Government is entirely different.

Comment on this

I shall put something on record now. When the Deputy was still in the sucking bottle days, I was saying it here.

Comment on this

That was when the Deputy was playing with the buttons in the RIC barracks. We still have that now.

Comment on this

I am surprised at the Deputy.

Comment on this

That is what you will get.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Sullivan must make way for the Deputy in possession.

Comment on this

The Deputy made a remark and——

Comment on this

I would ask that Deputy O'Sullivan be forced to withdraw that statement.

Comment on this

The last time, Deputy Corry withdrew at the instigation of his own Party in the Cork County Council chamber.

Comment on this

The Deputy has just passed a certain remark.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Collins please resume his seat?

Comment on this

We could have the imputation here that a man's father ran away from the Fenians.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Collins persists, I shall have to ask him to leave the House. Deputy Corry is not being allowed to make his speech. Deputy O'Sullivan should cease his interruptions.

Comment on this

I shall, Sir—when the personalities cease.

Comment on this

I can assure Deputy O'Sullivan that whenever my father's record comes to be written, it will be as good as that of his father.

Comment on this

Get on with the Vote on Account. This is the greatest lot of nonsense one could hear. I am not saying who is to blame. There should be an end to this kind of maudlin stuff.

Comment on this

The speed or the slowness of housebuilding in any area is 90 per cent the responsibility of the local authority in charge of the area. I can stand over that statement. There are times when the speed of housing in any particular district is slowed up and stopped. In some cases, that is due perhaps to the tardiness of the elected representives but in many cases, it is caused by the manager in charge. I have had experience of that. Anybody who reads last Tuesday's Cork Examiner can see an example of it.

Two things which we require in this country are, first, employment for our people and secondly, that when a man leaves his work in the evening, he will have a decent home to go into. We should proceed along those lines and it is the one thing on which I agree with Deputy Barrett. I seriously suggest to the Government that the Road Fund Money at present being squandered on roads should be diverted to housing. I think that that would be a good and a wise step. Only last Saturday, I attended a meeting in a village in my constituency. The proposal there concerned a sum of from £65,000 to £70,000 in respect of by-passing a village.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be for the Estimate for the Department of Local Government. It does not arise on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I know that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy knows it, there is no point in proceeding with it.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that a change be made in this Estimate as regards roads and that the money be channelled into housing. I think it is a wise and a good suggestion.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no Estimate before the House.

Comment on this

I do not wish to take up much more of the time of the House. I have examined the Estimate as closely as I could. With regard to rates on agricultural land and, as a matter of fact, rates in general, the Government should take a further step to lighten the burden in that respect. We have an increase of 4/2 in the £ to face next Friday on the consideration of our estimate. That absolutely wipes out the increased grants we got last year—and farming prices have not improved. The position of the farmer as regards prices today is just as it was seven or eight years ago. He has not got another round of increases. He certainly deserves some direct relief, particularly in his rates. In order to deal with the competitive market, we shall have to place our farmers in line with the farmers in Britain and the farmers in Northern Ireland, neither group of whom pay any rates on agricultural land.

As regards Deputy Barry's remarks and, I think, the remarks of Deputy Treacy on the position of the Common Market, I should like to say that our application for the Common Market stands where it stood at the start.

Comment on this

Tell that to the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

The only trouble is that General de Gaulle was not prepared to allow into the Common Market, not Britain on her own but all her step-daughters and grand-daughters and every other country that she had collected or forced into subjection during the past 400 years in with her. If all those came into the Common Market, then the position of the Irish farmer entering the Common Market would be far worse than our present position, instead of improving it. De Gaulle is therefore fighting our fight. Firms subsidised by the State should at least be compelled to purchase Irish products, particularly food. I suggest that someone should go through the books of Irish Shipping Limited for the past 12 months. It is strange that money supplied by this State would be used for the purchase of New Zealand butter and North of Ireland sausages. If anybody here has any doubt about it, I shall produce the proof of what I am saying. If we are to find employment for our people, if we are to work out employment for them, we must at least hope for sufficient patriotism here amongst our own people to buy Irish first.

Comment on this

As we have now left what Deputy Corish described as "Children's Hour," I suggest we should not mention Deputy Corry's remarks until later. It must be said that we have reached a stage where, since this Government came into office —not at the last election but at the previous one — somewhere between 250,000 and 300,000 people have emigrated. At the same time, we have an unemployment figure something less than the worst we recorded. However, taken in conjunction with the——

Comment on this

Thirty thousand less.

Comment on this

Do not exaggerate. We are prepared to accept the accurate figures.

Comment on this

We have over 60,000 unemployed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Donegan has only a few moments. He might be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

Even if he is only talking nonsense, let him talk.

Comment on this

In conjunction with the 300,000 who have emigrated, one must—if a true comparison is to be drawn—take a figure of over 60,000 unemployed into account. If one is to take below the line expenditure as well as above the line expenditure, it will hit somewhere above the £235 million mark. The national debt is around £500 million. At the same time, we have a trade deficit of £100 million. What saved us from a balance of payment crisis?

Comment on this

Good government.

Comment on this

A combination of things saved us. The tide was running with the Government. They were going with the stream. They had these advantages. A flow of money was coming into this country in different ways. First, you had emigrants' remittances. Next, there was the purchase of land by foreigners. On Tuesday, we tried to get this recorded but we were not given the facility. Nobody knows how much land is purchased here by foreigners. We tried to get a register kept but we did not succeed.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy an estimate?

Comment on this

When I feel like giving it, I shall give it. At the same time, in Dublin city, you had a flood of semi-public buildings—offices, the new university, Liberty Hall, the P.J. Carroll building, several insurance buildings, the Intercontinental Hotel. All that is activity which will not recur again.

Comment on this