We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 1–161 of 297. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The discussion of the Vote on Account can be properly described as a general stocktaking and review of the conduct of the Government during the past year. This is also an occasion for Deputies on this side of the House to remind the Taoiseach and the Ministers of the Government of the responsibility they have, not only to the House but to the country. We have now reached the stage at which this Government have lost all sense of responsibility so far as the people are concerned. We take this opportunity to remind the Government of the various pledges and undertakings which they gave to the people at the last general election, and the undertakings they gave to the House since the general election.

The economy of the country today is in a serious state of decay and no matter what the Minister for Finance or the Government may attempt to convey to us, the people of the country have no respect for, or belief, or confidence in economists or statistics and figures of any kind. No amount of statistics supplied by the Government, and no expressions of opinion from the economists, can convince me that we are enjoying the wave of prosperity which is alleged to be prevailing by Fianna Fáil Ministers from the Taoiseach down. I have no evidence that a wave of prosperity is passing over the country at the moment, and I doubt if the people have either. Every section of the community seems to be labouring under the greatest difficulties, to be working under a wave of depression. They are attempting to live on meagre and limited incomes, despite a soaring cost of living.

I should like to hear from the Minister his excuses for the present unemployment position. No amount of statistics can convince me that we have not an extraordinarily high number of unemployed persons here and that that number is not increasing week after week. We saw over the week-end that some hundreds of workers in the textile and clothing industry have gone on short time. There are fewer agricultural workers on the land. There are fewer employed in business houses and behind the counters of the shops.

Over the past 12 months, not to speak of the past five years, record numbers have been emigrating. No positive steps have been taken by the Government to check the flowing tide of emigration of our young people. These young people have been denied the right to live in their own country by this Government, who promised them employment and undertook to provide it. There has not been a single sneeze from the Fianna Fáil Party in regard to the stemming of emigration and the provision of employment. Immediately young girls leave school, they embark on the emigrant ship and are exposed to the grave moral dangers of life in England. The hospitals, hotels and factories of England are crammed with young Irish girls, forced to leave this country through lack of employment and because so little is held out for them at home by their own Government.

A grave problem is also presented by the number of fathers of families who are torn away from their families and, because of the bad management of those in office, forced to seek a livelihood in the land which was once the traditional enemy of the Party in office to-day. They are compelled to work in the coalmines, the industries and other concerns in Great Britain. That is a far cry from the promises made by the Government when at one stage they promised to bring back all the emigrants. The traffic was to come to a standstill in all the provincial towns because of the huge numbers going home for lunch from all the factories and employment schemes to be provided by Fianna Fáil.

This country is a good country for a small section of the community. It is a good country for the rich and for those who have pull. It is a good country for those who have influence, but it is a bad country and holds no future for the unfortunate poor, who appear to be increasing in numbers. It is a queer country for those unfortunates who cannot provide for themselves. I should like the Minister to tell us what happened to the Fianna Fáil plan for the provision of 100,000 jobs in five years. They have been six years in office now since the Taoiseach made that statement when he was enjoying the hospitality of his colleagues in Clery's Ballroom. Not alone would this House like to know, but those who were expecting some of the 100,000 jobs would like to know what happened that scheme.

Will the Minister be honest enough to tell us that they never had a scheme for the provision of 100,000 jobs? It was a scheme for the provision of 100,000 votes for Fianna Fáil, if they could get them. A very good vote-catcher was this promise of 100,000 jobs. Parties have made promises and men in public life have given undertakings but that this was the most barefaced, the most cajolling promise ever made to the electorate—to have the hardness of neck to stand up and say: "If you put us back, we will provide 100,000 jobs and there will be no such thing as an unemployed man or woman in this country".

Ireland has made application for membership of the EEC. During the past year, the negotiations in Brussels have broken down and Britain's application for membership has been unsuccessful. Despite the fact that Britain's application has been rejected, we find the Taoiseach hopeful that Ireland's application will be accepted. Will any responsible Minister stand up and say that Ireland's application is likely to be successful when Britain's has been turned down? Assuming for one moment that we are admitted to the Common Market, what preparations have we made in this country for such entry? Is it not true to say that in Britain for the past ten years, or thereabouts, there are experts and there are engineers and a Department of State separately set up to plan and to make provision for the repercussions of the Common Market? Statistics have been taken there as to what products are to be stepped up and what industries are likely to be affected.

What alternative employment is to be provided for workers in industries whose product will seriously be curtailed by our entry into the EEC? In this country, all we had was plenty of loud, foolish talk but not a single step to plan for the future.

Comment on this

That is not true. That is misrepresentation.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

What plans were made in this country in the event of Ireland's admission to the EEC? Deputy Carter may know some of those plans——

Comment on this

So does the Deputy.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——but they have not been disclosed in this House. I did not hear them.

The Taoiseach has been questioned by the leader of Fine Gael, by the Labour Party and by others as to the thousands of workers who will become redundant in industry and in other spheres of activity, in the event of Ireland's entry into the Common Market. Where will they go? Some people in Fianna Fáil seem to think they have been planning for that. Has it been done by the same planning engineers as planned the scheme of the 100,000 jobs because, if so, neither the country nor this House can have confidence in the planners of such a bogus, false and misleading scheme as that of the 100,000 jobs.

It has been declared that, if we enter into the EEC, at least 150,000 workers in this country will lose their employment. That was made very clear here by Deputy McGilligan last week. On top of the number of people already unemployed here, we shall have a further 150,000 unemployed. It is only reasonable that we on this side of the House should ask the Government to what will they put those 150,000 workers. The Taoiseach may say, in effect: "Well, that does not worry us a whole lot now because Britain has not been accepted." Therefore, when Britain has not been accepted, we shall not be accepted and the question of planning of the future does not arise and we need not worry about 150,000 persons losing their employment.

There was a very interesting article in yesterday's Evening Herald. It contained a forecast by the head of the French ready-to-wear industry which he gave at a press conference in London. This leading French businessman states, as reported in the Evening Herald:

We feel that the Common Market was a battle between politicians but politics will change and we feel sincerely that not later than next year England will be in the Common Market. To get England in, we feel that concessions will be made.

France has been responsible for torpedoeing Britain's application, according to authoritative sources in this country, in Britain and elsewhere. We feel that the attitude of France has been the result of the action of one man only and, as this leading businessman said "politics change". We feel an effort will be made, even by France, at a later stage to encourage Britain into the Common Market.

My view, for what it is worth, is that the Common Market cannot work or will not work or can never be successful without Britain. Therefore, if it is to survive and if it is to work, Britain must be a member. Whilst we play our part and whilst we are likely to play our part in the world in which we live today, there is only one choice to be made and the choice is between the free world of the free people in the free nations or the complete and entire rule of Communism.

The Government must be aware that if free nations are to flourish and to survive, the only hope for the world is a completely united effort between a completely united Europe linked in close co-operation with the United States of America forming a bloc known as the free world bloc against Communism. We should play our part and we must play our part to bring about, in so far as we possibly can, a United Europe. It is our place to use all the influence we have abroad to see to it that an effort will be made to have both Britain and Ireland members of the EEC and that, in addition, when the EEC is formally established, there will be the closest possible link between the United States of America and the united Europe. When we reach that stage, there will be little fear of war, of world discontent or of any trouble because a united Europe, with the United States of America, will definitely be the most powerful force in the world.

All of us desire to see the day when we shall have that world force in order to ensure against war and, furthermore, to plan for a future and for a greater measure of prosperity in a united Europe. If this leading French businessman is correct in his forecast, and I have a feeling that his forecast may be very accurate, what planning have we done here in this country to prepare for entry next year into the EEC? The Government have been silent on this matter.

I put it to the Taoiseach and to the Minister for Finance that we have lagged well behind Denmark in making arrangements for entry into the Common Market; that our Ministers were snoring while the Danish Government were actively planning for entry into the Common Market. I should like to hear from the Taoiseach whether he has brought together under the leadership of the Minister for Industry and Commerce the leading industrialists in this country, the trade unions, and all sections of the community, including the farmers' organisations, to discuss the seriousness of the Common Market. When I hear Fianna Fáil speakers down the country talking about the Common Market at crossroads, one would imagine they were talking about Ballinasloe fair. Very few of us realise the seriousness of the problem, the manner in which it must be met, and the necessity of planning in preparation for it, and the manner in which we must be prepared to face the growing pains of the early years of the EEC.

I want to accuse this Government. I want to charge them with neglect of duty. I want to say they have not faced up vigorously to their responsibilities, that they have not kept the country, this House, or the people properly informed of the implications involved, that they have not got down to consulting with all organisations concerning the urgency and importance of preliminary preparations. There has been no positive or definite planning for the 150,000 workers who will lose their employment overnight on the entry of Ireland into the EEC.

However, the Common Market problem faded into pale insignificance in recent weeks in comparison with the problem posed by the Government in their White Paper Closing the Gap. Where was the White Paper asking the people to live within their means, to tighten their belts, to watch their spending and not to look for increases in pay when the judges' salaries were being increased, although some of them were already earning £30 a day? The man with £30 a day was not asked to tighten his belt; he was not asked to cut down his spending or to live within his means. The White Paper was addressed to the workers, the wage earners, the farmers and business people, all of whom have very limited incomes.

The White Paper was an unnecessary document. If Fine Gael were in office, there would have been no need for a White Paper of that kind. This was a typical piece of Fianna Fáil planning. I should like to hear from the Taoiseach, because he has been dodging the answering of this question, whether he studied the White Paper before it was sent to members of the Dáil and the Press. If he did study it, why did he not immediately say: "Before we release this to the country, we had better consult with the trade unions and the people?" The first duty of the Government before issuing that White Paper should have been to call a conference and to have present at that conference representatives of the farming organisations and the trade unions. The Government should then have told that conference: "This is what we are faced with. Have you any suggestions as to how we can meet the economic difficulties lying ahead?"

Fianna Fáil did not do that. They used the firm hand again. After paying themselves and their friends and after being responsible for increasing taxation to an unprecedented figure, they asked the poor to live within their means and made a threat of a wage freeze. What are the implications of the White Paper? Why does it ask people not to seek increases in pay? It is a pity it was not addressed to the select few who received large salary increases eight months ago. Here we have a White Paper asking the people not to seek wage increases, to be patriotic, to work harder, to spend more time working and get less money for it.

If that White Paper had been sent to Grangegorman, one could understand a certain response from that quarter but why, in Ireland, in 1963, is a pay pause asked for by the same Government as recklessly increased the prices of bread, flour and butter, recklessly increased the cost of living, did away with the Prices Advisory Body and allowed everyone in a position to do so to charge what they liked for their goods without any public inquiry into increasing costs?

During the time of the inter-Party Government, a public inquiry was conducted by the Prices Advisory Body before any increase was allowed in the prices of essential commodities. That is not the case now. Instead we see the Government asking the community generally to be patriotic while they themselves can spend what they like in wild extravagance and squandermania.

I should like to hear from the Taoiseach whether it is a fact that when that White Paper was issued, many thousands of applications by Government employees for increases in pay were under consideration. I should like to know that because I feel that this House is entitled to a statement. What is the position regarding the 10,000 members of the National Teachers' Organisation who propose to press their claim for better salaries and better conditions with the utmost vigour and determination? Does the White Paper cut across the rights of these 10,000 national teachers who are looking for what they are entitled to, a decent and proper standard of living? Before the White Paper was issued, did the Minister for Education agree that the 10,000 national teachers were to be betrayed in this manner and that an effort was to be made to sabotage their right to look for what they are entitled to? In replying to the debate to-night, it is the duty of the Taoiseach or of the Minister for Finance to inform the House what the attitude was, is and will be towards these national teachers.

Is it not a fact that 5,000 members of the Gárda Síochána now say that despite the White Paper, they are going ahead with their claim for an increase in pay and better conditions? Who can deny that the Gárda are entitled to a substantial increase in pay? I want to place on record that a Government from this side of the House would and certainly will sympathetically consider the case of the Gárda Síochána and of other State officials for increases in pay to which it is felt they are rightly entitled in order to ensure a proper standard of living.

I should like to be informed as to the position of other sections of the community such as civil servants. The association representing the civil servants recently issued a statement which was published in the Evening Herald of Friday, 15th February, 1963, under the heading “Protest by Civil Servants.”:

An attempt to single out State employees for discriminatory treatment in the matter of pay adjustments would be resisted by every means at their disposal, says a statement on behalf of the civil servants general staff side on behalf of 25,000 civil servants who are looking for the rights to which they are entitled. The statement followed a special meeting of the civil servants which considered the Government's White Paper on incomes and output.

Here we see that the civil servants' association speaking on behalf of 25,000 organised workers have protested against the terms of the White Paper. We feel sure that they will continue to seek what they are entitled to and that men will be found in the House sufficiently courageous to stand up and see that the rights of those people are safeguarded and maintained, because they are seeking only what they are rightly entitled to.

On the other hand, it is very hard to beat the old dog off his track. It is well known that Fianna Fáil were responsible in the past for drafting the heads—and they are still available in Government offices—of legislation, which they would have presented in this House had they got the chance, to bring about a permanent wage freeze and wage control. That has been pointed out here by others on this side of the House and it was never denied by any Fianna Fáil speaker or Minister. They did make an effort to freeze and control wages before. That is on record, as well as the heads of the Bill they were bringing into this House, if it were not for the fact that they were beaten in a general election immediately afterwards and never had the strength or courage to come forward later with their Bill until this White Paper arrived as the thin edge of the wedge to control the wages of wage earners throughout the country.

I wonder if the Government have as yet seen the foolishness of their ways in this regard and whether at this late stage they have proposals to set up a permanent national committee to determine the allocation of national income and to advise the Government on wages. It is all very well and fine to consult with trade unions, farmers and others, but the primary responsibility is on the Government and it is our job in Opposition to discharge the duty of an Opposition. I clearly remember when the Taoiseach was in Opposition and when he was criticising the policy of the inter-Party Government, he was asked if he could make a constructive suggestion. "Ah," he said, "it is our job to oppose and you are being paid as a Government to put the constructive proposals into operation." Now the boot is on the other foot and he is being paid to put the constructive proposals to this House and to tell the House what the future is regarding output, incomes and wages.

I should like to know if there is any truth in the report published this week in a national newspaper to the effect that the Government are likely to appoint a national body to fix wages and if the Government have such a proposal under consideration, whether it will be a body of economists who have no responsibility whatever to the people or whether it will be amply representative of the trade union movement. Any effort to control or restrict wages is bound to meet with the toughest possible opposition from organised labour, unless organised labour have a say in the moulding of whatever Government policy is likely to be introduced in this regard.

Again, it is strange that the Government should concentrate on restricting people's incomes when they could have rendered a more valuable service over the past three years and particularly over the past 12 months. They could have reduced the cost of living but they failed miserably to do so. Not alone did they fail miserably to reduce the cost of living but they made no attempt to reduce it. They devoted all their energies towards making it very difficult for the wage earner and the poor to exist.

Has the price of practically everything not been increased? Is it not a strange time even to consider restricting or freezing wages when there is no attempt to control the cost of living? It is no harm to remind the House that during the time of the inter-Party Government, bread and flour were reduced and either 7d. or 8d. per lb. was taken off butter. The moment Fianna Fáil got a chance they put back that 8d. per lb. on butter and they did not even give the dairy farmer the increase for his milk which they promised faithfully to give.

I should like to hear what is the policy of the Government in relation to the cost of living. Have they any policy in that regard or are they going to sit there like a group of schoolboys and allow the cost of living to go even higher than it has gone already? The tendency is for prices to rise and rise. They have proposals to keep down incomes but no proposals that I have seen or heard to keep down the cost of living. Every Deputy and, more important still, the people outside would like to hear what will be done about the cost of living. Does the Minister for Finance realise that there are tens of thousands of homes today where butter is never used? In an agricultural country, people cannot afford to buy butter.

Comment on this

Why are the sales of butter going up?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

At the same time, we are paying the British housewife to buy our butter and to eat it. There are many homes in Ireland today where there are ex-T.B. patients, disabled persons, old age pensioners, widows, orphans, people who are blind or sick and others in the very low income group whom nobody seems to care about and to whom butter is a luxury because they cannot afford it. The sales of jam and margarine have gone up considerably.

Comment on this

So have butter sales.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

In the case of the real poor, margarine and jam are used as a substitute for butter. In relation to flour, there is a similar experience. The price of flour was allowed to go up. The price of bread is prohibitive today, prohibitive for old age pensioners, for widows and the poor, people with whom we on this side of the House are primarily concerned.

Comment on this

You are now, when in Opposition.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

When we took the 8d. a lb. off butter——

Comment on this

You never did that.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Sevenpence or eightpence.

Comment on this

You never took anything off it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Would somebody give the Minister a pinch and wake him up?

Comment on this

You never took a penny off it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Does everybody not know the inter-Party Government reduced the price of butter per lb.?

Comment on this

You did not. That is just a make-up.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister says it is a make-up but the housewife does not mind what kind of make-up it is if she gets butter at a reduced price as she did.

Comment on this

She did not.

Comment on this

You imported some yellow stuff from New Zealand.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

When I hear the Minister for Finance brazenly say in a loud and determined voice, but, nevertheless, with a smile on his face——

Comment on this

Who is brazen in this case?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——that the inter-Party Government did not reduce the price of butter——

Comment on this

No, they did not.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

What did they do?

Comment on this

They did no good of any kind.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister is like the woman who could never see anything wrong with her son who had two left feet and could never go right. Surely the Minister will give the inter-Party Government credit for doing something? Did they do anything right?

Comment on this

Not that I remember.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Did they do anything right that the Minister does not remember? I put it to the Minister and the House that the inter-Party Government provided a better standard of living for our people and a lower cost of living. Everybody knows that is true. I only wish the Minister for Finance would stand up in my constituency and say we did not reduce the price of butter.

Comment on this

Yes. I shall say that anywhere I go.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If the Minister does, they will say he is not all there, that he has no memory and that he is not a responsible Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong in that. You did not do it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Can the Minister say what happened?

Comment on this

The Deputy is not talking to a Fine Gael club now.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister says we did not reduce the price of butter. I say we did reduce the price of butter by at least 7d. a lb. The moment the change of Government came Fianna Fáil put back that 7d. a lb. on butter. If Fianna Fáil were not back in office today, the Irish people would be getting butter at 7d. or 8d. a lb. less than they are paying for it now. However, if they were foolish, that is their own responsibility. As I have often said before, if they sow nettles, they cannot expect roses to grow. They sowed nettles and the nettles grew and stung.

Comment on this

How did you reduce it?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

At least the Parliamentary Secretary admits now the price of butter was reduced.

Comment on this

No. I am admitting no such thing.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I suggest the Parliamentary Secretary should go into conference with the Minister for Finance because at least the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach admits we did reduce the price of butter. He has given us that much credit.

Comment on this

I did not. I should like to get the history of this alleged reduction. Would the Deputy tell us a little about it? When did it happen? We do not remember it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister for Finance and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach are now in office and are being paid to look up the records, statistics, days and dates. The general public know, and it is well known in this House, that the price of butter was reduced. Everybody in Ireland knows that except the Minister for Finance, who knows nothing whatever about it. Further than that, he does not know of any single item of good the previous Government did but he thinks they might have done something good that he does not remember. That is the record of the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

They did one good thing. They went out of office when the people wanted them to. That was a very good thing.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Parliamentary Secretary should know that in the previous general election, Fianna Fáil went out of office when the people wanted them to.

Comment on this

They went out to return stronger than ever, as we have always done.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Yes. Of course, Fianna Fáil were returned stronger than ever because they promised 100,000 jobs that have not materialised yet.

Comment on this

They will come.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If we all live long enough, please God, they will come all right. In 1932, there was to have been full employment; emigrants were to return from America to employment at home. Ireland was to be a land flowing with milk and honey in 1932. In 1942, it was still coming. In 1962, prosperity was just around the corner but had not reached us yet. In the case of Fianna Fáil, prosperity is always coming but it never seems to come. It is a case of jam yesterday; jam tomorrow; but never jam today.

Comment on this

There is good Irish butter.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil may attempt to fool the people. It must be admitted that there is no Party in any country in the world that has been so successful at fooling the people as Fianna Fáil have been. I have a queer feeling that that is at an end and that at the next general election we will see a new Government who will make an effort to provide employment, reduce the cost of living, give our people the standard of living they so richly deserve and better treatment than they are getting at the present time. In relation to the cost of living, Fianna Fáil have no policy.

Comment on this

I do not like to interrupt the Deputy but would he mind answering a question on that? Could he explain why the cost of living during the last three years of Coalition Government went up by 11 points?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If the Parliamentary Secretary is quoting from statistics——

Comment on this

From facts. That is accepted.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——and Fianna Fáil propaganda, may I say that the cost of living was much lower during the term of office of the inter-Party Government than it is to-day?

Comment on this

That is not my question. I asked why did it go up by eleven points during the last three years of Coalition Government.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The cost of flour, bread and the essentials of life was much cheaper during the term of office of the inter-Party Government. Nobody knows that better than the Parliamentary Secretary.

Before I was interrupted, I was coming to a very important point. Now that the Minister for Finance is rather vocal, we should like to hear what he has to say in relation to the proposal he has in mind for a purchase tax. The Book of Estimates this year in so far as the taxpayer is concerned is a record breaker. Beer, spirits, petrol and the essentials of life cannot bear any further taxation. We all know that these commodities cannot be any dearer.

Comment on this

The price of petrol came down last week.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Now that all the channels of taxation are exhausted, the Minister for Finance suggests a purchase tax. If the Minister for Finance introduces a purchase tax next month, such purchase tax would be equivalent to a reduction in the people's incomes. A purchase tax has the same effect as a reduction in the people's incomes. There is no difference. I hope and trust that the trade union movement, the farmers' organisations that we admire and cherish and are glad to have, the housewives and every section of the community will rally together, sink their differences of the past and resist such a purchase tax. I want to say for the record that if Fine Gael were in office, there would be no purchase tax; there would be no purchase tax contemplated; there would be no purchase tax threatened; there would never be a purchase tax put into operation.

Here we have Fianna Fáil coming in the backdoor with this method of cutting down people's incomes. They do not want to cut salaries. That would be too barefaced. They do not want to take so much per week from each wage earner, from the guard, the teacher, the civil servant, the road-worker, the forestry worker, the businessman. Instead of a reduction in income, there is to be a purchase tax.

A purchase tax must be and should be resisted. A purchase tax did not succeed in any country in which it was introduced and is bound to fail in this country. I hope trade unions and everyone concerned will rally the moment such a tax is introduced and defeat the motives behind it. The intention is drastically to cut down the incomes of our people.

The country cannot afford any new taxes. At one time, the Taoiseach—I do not know whether it was the present Taoiseach or the former Taoiseach who is now President—said that taxation had reached its limit. The Minister for Finance must now realise that taxation has reached its limit long since and that if any new taxation is imposed that will affect the distilling, brewing and textile industries, it will mean more unemployment. In the case of the brewing industry, it will mean that most of the small breweries will close down. The textile industry, which is in a very delicate situation at the moment, cannot afford one penny of additional taxation. Rather than be subjected to additional taxation, the distilling, brewing and textile industries and the motor trade need encouragement and incentive. They need a tonic to revive them, to enable them to increase their production, to put more on the market, to provide more work, to take on more hands, to increase their output for the home market and the export market, rather than being killed by increased taxation imposed by an irresponsible Government who do not see any further than their noses.

What is wanted is encouragement. Something should be given to industry, rather than taxing it out of existence. There are many speakers in the House who feel that the Government are endeavouring, so far as possible, to tax industry out of existence. Was it not the last inter-Party Government, through Deputy Sweetman, who gave certain tax concessions to industrialists to come here and establish industries and to help in the revival of Irish industry? Would it not be better if the Government concentrated on giving industry a tonic to revive it rather than putting a halter of increased taxes around its neck so that it must cut down on expenses and reduce employment? In that regard the Government have fallen very far short of discharging their responsibilities.

I am a believer in industry, I believe in the establishment and encouragement of industry. Industry is a great medium through which employment can be given. I believe our industrialists have played a noble part in providing work and producing good articles. I believe our industries produce articles which are as good as can be produced in any industry in the world, having regard to the limited conditions in which they must work. The time has come when an effort should be made to encourage, help and assist them in every possible way.

I should like to hear from the Minister what he has done about his promise and undertaking to reduce the number of civil servants. We have in this country as good a Civil Service as there is in any country in the world. I am sure that is agreed all round, but having regard to our dwindling population, to our very limited resources and to the paying capacity of our taxpayers, is there any justification for vastly increasing the number of our civil servants? No one has any objection to such an increase if it can be justified, but why promise to reduce the number and then increase it? Does it not show deceit and dishonesty on the part of the Party who say on a platform on a fair day, at street corners and church gates, that their policy is to reduce the number of civil servants and come then into Leinster House and vastly increase it? If that is not the essence of dishonesty and hypocrisy, I do not know what it is.

When the Book of Estimates reveals a bill for the highest taxation on record, we must bear in mind that as well as having to meet that bill, the taxpayers now have to meet a record-breaking increase in the rates of the local authorities. I remember when the Minister was Minister for Health, and in this House, from the very seat in which he is sitting this evening, I heard him say that the Health Act could mean 2/- in the £ on the rates. That is on record. Instead of being 2/- in the £ on the rates, it is now 6/-, 7/- and 8/- in the £, and yet fewer people are getting health services. Despite the record-breaking cost of the health services, there never was such a limited number of people getting health services; there never were such bad health services; there never were such poor, bankrupt, broken-down, helpless, health services as there are today; and yet the health services never cost the ratepayers so much.

What will be done about relieving the local authorities in that regard? If the Minister said to me: "What would you do about it if you were in office", I would be very happy to reply. If a Fine Gael Government were in office, the health charges would immediately come off the rates, and the rates in every county in Ireland would be reduced by at least 5/- in the £. A reduction of 5/- in the £ on the rates would be very welcome to the small farmers, to the mountain farmers, and to the farmer who lost his sheep in the snow, the farmer who was surrounded by snow for the greater part of the winter and whose Government did nothing whatever to relieve his plight during a disastrous and tragic winter.

Fine Gael would immediately deal with the finances of the health services, and would introduce a scheme of better health services, services for all, with free choice of doctor which does not obtain to-day, and that reduction of 5/- in the £ on the rates——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of the health services does not relevantly arise on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I agree, but I was endeavouring to point out the reduction Fine Gael would bring about for the ratepayers and taxpayers, if we were in a position to do so. It is only right that we should demonstrate to this House and to the country the comparison between the wise economic policy of Fine Gael, and the wild, extravagant and spend-thrift policy of Fianna Fáil. It is only right that we should tell the people how we would bring about a substantial reduction in rates by making all charges for main roads a national charge.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot have a discussion on the rates on the Vote on Account. We are dealing with Government spending.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Government spending in relation to roads in a general way, and particularly in relation to housing, is not being tackled by the Government as it should be. The same applies to the various schemes in relation to drainage and afforestation which could be implemented, both of which would be quite capable of employing many thousands who are now unemployed. I put it to the House that the Government are not spending the taxpayers' money with prudence, wisdom and caution. That is why I charge them with irresponsibility, with insanity and with a high degree of neglect. As the custodians of the taxpayers' money, they are failing to spend it wisely and as it should be spent.

I should like to hear from the Taoiseach or the Minister what Government policy, as reflected in this Book of Estimates, has in store for the farmer. I represent a good farming constituency. It has a first-class tillage tradition and a tradition of honesty, hard work and straightforwardness. Is it not a fact that people are flying out of our farms to-day? There is no Fianna Fáil Deputy in the House at the moment from west of the Shannon. If you travel through parts of Galway, Mayo and Roscommon you will find galvanised iron nailed up against windows, doors barred and the land in a state of desolation. There is no one to be seen because they have emigrated. The small farmer has been put completely out of business.

Take the dairy farmer, the tillage farmer and the livestock farmer. Is there any hope that the position for them next year will be any better than it was last year? Last year, from my own knowledge, was the worst for the majority of the people on the land since the Famine days. I have known farmers who, when last year's harvest was over, still had to pay for the seeds and manures that went into the ground last spring. I have known farmers who were the victims of an injustice by the millers and others, who took their produce unjustly and did not pay for it. The Government stood by and allowed that state of affairs to exist.

What encouragement is there for any young farmer's son to remain on the land? Is the tendency not to get off the land as quickly as possible, to fly from the country to the cities, towns and abroad? This is simply because in this country we have no agricultural policy. The Minister for Agriculture has no contact whatever with either policy or realities. This Government do not know the conditions under which the farmers are living today. Our farmers are short of credit. All our land is short of livestock. Our farmers are not getting sufficient for wheat, oats, beet or barley. When they produce both barley and wheat, there is no market for them and they have to beg those responsible to take the barley and wheat, as I saw them begging last year.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These are items which would relevantly arise on the Estimates, but not on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I should like to hear in a general way what proposals the Government have to aid the farmers. Is it proposed to give every farmer immediately a loan of £1,000, interest-free? If it is not, it is Fine Gael policy. If we were in office today, every farmer would immediately get a loan of £1,000 interest-free, to carry out any schemes.

Comment on this

They certainly would want it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I agree with Deputy Lalor—they certainly would.

Comment on this

They would, if you were in power.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am quoting from "Fine Gael Policy—A Change For The Better", by James Dillon. I always carry it around with me. I quote: "We shall provide interest-free loans to farmers ... Sums ranging up to £1,000 will be made available for schemes of increased production planned in conjunction with the advisory services." If a Fine Gael Government were in power, every farmer in Ireland could have a loan of £1,000, interest-free.

Comment on this

And no extra taxation?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

No. I want to repeat that: no, a thousand times no. That can be done. Not alone can it be done, but it will be done and will be amply demonstrated in this House by the next Government. Deputy Dillon is the man who will provide it. It is the one way in which you can increase production. There is no use asking farmers to work harder. They cannot work any harder. They have themselves slaved to death. There is no use asking them to increase production. The only way is to give them the money to do it. We have in Ireland farmers as good as those in Denmark, New Zealand, Australia or Britain. But our farmers never got a chance. How could they get a chance? We had the Economic War. We will not go into it.

Comment on this

You had better not.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The history of it is not too good.

Comment on this

Not from your side.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Many a prosperous farmer died in the workhouse as a result of Fianna Fáil conduct in the Economic War.

Comment on this

And your conduct, too.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Economic War opened the gates of every workhouse in Ireland for the intake of small farmers. The Irish farmers must be the best in the world to take the treatment they got over the years. There were the ten fields of inspectors that the Minister for Agriculture was to bring down on them. He said: "The old cods. I will make them work." We have a fair memory, and the farmers have not a bad memory, either. If the livestock breeder or tillage farmer got half a chance, if he were encouraged with the capital to enable him to go ahead, he would have a better record than the Danish farmer. I am hopeful that the day will come when the Irish farmer will be given a chance to display his real ability on the land—a chance he has not got under Fianna Fáil. I see in this morning's paper the heading "Hope For More Exports: British Market's Value." That heading is in today's Irish Independent. Our farmers are the backbone of the country. If you have a prosperous agriculture, the community is prosperous. If you have a bankrupt, poor agricultural community, all is lost—and that is what we have today.

In connection with this "Hope For More Exports", the Minister for Finance stated a moment ago he did not like any references to the Economic War. I should not imagine the Minister would like to hear any references to the Economic War. Those were the days when he was shouting "The British market is gone and gone forever, thank God." We now see the very men who condemned the British market arriving, even as recently as the day before yesterday, in London to see if they can get anything. They wanted to talk to the British Government about the serious plight in which they now find themselves, in the hope that they would be able to get a market for Irish produce.

We must bear this in mind. Last week and the week before, the Danes were in London negotiating with the British Government to see what they could get for their farmers. The minute the reports appeared in the papers that representatives of the Danish Government were in London bargaining, the Minister for External Affairs and the Taoiseach got in touch with Mr. Macmillan to know if he would meet them to see if they would be able to get anything that would be left after the Danes had got the best of it.

The Danes are always able to wipe the eyes of the Irish because the Danes have the key in their hands to the British Ministry of Agriculture and to 10 Downing Street. Our present representatives are the men who always condemned and wrecked the British market, who denigrated it and despised it until the day before yesterday when they dropped over to see if the Danes had left anything. Why did the Government not go to England before the Danes? Why did the Taoiseach and his Government of "Yes"-men—as we can describe them because none of them must have spoken for the farmer—not arrange with Mr. Macmillan to enter into negotiations long ago?

There was a great fuss in 1962 in relation to certain talks on Ireland's admission into the EEC. We were told in this House that the Danes were not as far advanced in negotiations as we. Deputy Dillon will deal with that later. Now we find that back they came from London yesterday, having got nothing.

Comment on this

And you are glad of it. You are delighted.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

No, we are sorry, very sorry. The only thing we can say is that Mr. Sandys is coming over on a holiday.

Comment on this

You can send him a telegram.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

We in Fine Gael realise the value of the British market. In 1948 we got more out of Britain than Fianna Fáil ever got.

Comment on this

What did you get?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The 1948 Trade Agreement. It linked the price of Irish livestock to that which the British farmer was getting.

Comment on this

It was there before 1948. That was there from 1938.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The 1948 Trade Agreement put millions and millions into the pockets of the Irish farmers. It was the best agreement ever entered into with Britain on behalf of this country.

Comment on this

What was in it?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

We got more out of Britain than ever Fianna Fáil were capable of getting. Why? Because Fine Gael always had the good Ambassadors, the men who knew how to negotiate and the men who knew how to get the best possible bargain out of the British. Could you blame the British? Mr. Macmillan and Mr. Sandys and Mr. Soames are by no means foolish men. They know that the men coming to talk to them on behalf of the Irish farmers are the men who crippled and denigrated the British market. They know they are the very men who decried and hated the British market. They know that these very men are now trying to steal in through the back door to see if they can get for the Irish farmer anything the Danes have left.

It was terribly stupid not to go over and negotiate long ago and particularly before the Danes. I see the report in today's paper of what I may describe as a statement of silence by the Taoiseach when he came home. If they had got anything from the British for the Irish farmer or for the Irish economy the Taoiseach would hardly be down the steps of the plane before he would have a press conference to announce it. But always, when they lose anything, we have this silence. The last time they came back with less than they had; they lost concessions for Ireland. When they arrived back last night, there was not a single word and there was no statement. The simple fact is that they got nothing from Britain. But if Fine Gael had been there, something would have been got and could be got and can be got and will be got from the British.

Comment on this

In exchange for the Six Counties.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

When the Taoiseach was going over on behalf of the Irish Government, in the hope of getting more exports—Ireland being an agricultural country and the Danes having been over there bargaining on agriculture—why did the Taoiseach not take the Minister for Agriculture with him? Is it not strange that our representatives went over to ask for increased agricultural quotas, better markets and better conditions, and that those representatives were the Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs and that the Minister for Agriculture was left at home?

No explanation has been given to the Irish farmers as to why they were not represented. The Irish cattle trade must look upon all this with suspicion as must the tillage farmer and the dairy farmer. The talks went on between Mr. Macmillan and Mr. Sandys and the Minister for External Affairs and the Taoiseach and our Minister for Agriculture was not present.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see how this is relevant to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It is very relevant——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would be relevant on the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture but the debate on the Vote on Account does not consist of agriculture, per se.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I could not discuss on the debate on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture negotiations with the British Government on foreign policy talks, British market values, and the steps relating to entire Government policy which were discussed in Britain yesterday between the Ministers concerned.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are discussing general Government expenditure. How the absence of the Minister for Agriculture at any discussions arises, I cannot see.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

We desire to have a prosperous agricultural community. We desire to spend the money in the Book of Estimates in a proper fashion. I fail to see how we can have a prosperous agricultural community if we bargain with Britain in the absence of our Minister for Agriculture. It cannot possibly be done. The only conclusion I can come to is that the Government are ashamed to send the Minister for Agriculture because he would be no match for Mr. Soames.

I presume that Government policy was discussed in London over the weekend. The only statement issued about it had relation to the intended visit of Mr. Sandys. We welcome him. The sorry part of all this is that there is not a better relationship between this country and Britain. I want to say that the more British Ministers who come here on public or private visits, the better. Let them see what we have, what we can give them. We have the best livestock for the British market; we have good farmers and we have as good a country as there is in the world today if only it were worked properly. When Mr. Sandys comes over, he will have something to see and that is why visits of that kind should be more frequent.

I should like to see the Queen of England coming to Ireland. I should like to see President de Valera going to England and being royally received in London. We are too small and narrow-minded here and we will never get anywhere if we continue to be narrow-minded. Those days are gone. There is a new generation now and the lead was given in that matter when Deputy Dockrell brought the Lord Mayor of London over here and when he himself was royally received in London.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps the Deputy would come to the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I will, but I want to show the necessity for closer ties of friendship between the two countries. Economically, we are sunk without Britain and it is our duty to bring about closer friendship between the two countries and to end the bitterness that prevailed some generations ago. Thank Providence, that is now forgotten and we can start off anew.

I want to make reference to the plight of the dairy farmer. At last the Government have seen the wisdom of meeting representatives of the dairy farmers. There is no section of the community who works harder. They are entitled to more for their milk and they should get it. It is the duty of this Government to give it to them.

I also want to make reference to the growing practice of the Government in recklessly and ruthlessly increasing the valuation of property in order to get in more money.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That may not be discussed on the Vote on Account, which deals with Government expenditure.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I think the increasing of valuations in that way is unjust and unfair.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will get an opportunity of dealing with that on the various Estimates.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I want to take this opportunity of protesting against it. Everybody knows that there is no section of the community who work harder than the dairy farmers and they get very little recompense from the Government for their efforts. I am glad to see that an effort is being made to meet the organisations of those farmers. All small farmers should make an effort to organise themselves to get their rights and to get what they are entitled to.

Comment on this

Echoes of 1950.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Does Deputy Moher think they should not organise?

Comment on this

One of the organisations was founded in 1950.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

May I ask Deputy Moher if he thinks the small farmers should not organise and fight for their rights?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of organisation does not arise.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

On the question of small farmers fighting for their rights from the Government, I want to quote his Lordship, Most Reverend Dr. Lucey, Bishop of Cork. He said that he could not keep silent while injustice was being done, and he advised small farmers to organise on their own before it was too late. He said: "Not long ago we had a reference by a responsible Minister to the sickening whine of the small farmers. These farmers do not whine themselves but I would rather that they spoke out like the fearless people they are. Instead of that, they keep silent and go away."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These are matters for the Estimate for Agriculture and not for the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is an observation directed by the Bishop of Cork to the Government.

Comment on this

The Deputy feels he is a coadjutor.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Does Deputy Moher say his own bishop is wrong?

Comment on this

He is not my bishop.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

He is a fellow Corkman. I never heard of one Corkman letting down another before. Surely Deputy Moher will not let down the Bishop of Cork in this? Was he wrong in what he said?

Comment on this

He will be flattered by being quoted by you.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Every word he utters contains commonsense and intelligence. That is more than can be said for members of this Government.

I really feel that this country is heading for a year of great economic unrest and when I say "economic unrest," I mean unrest in industry, unrest in the trade unions and unrest among the farming community. We are facing a very serious strike in transport to which I do not intend to refer, but Government responsibility is very serious in this matter.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I thought the Deputy said he did not intend to refer to this matter, which does not arise.

Comment on this

He was not going to refer to it except to blame the Government.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Who is responsible? Of course you are responsible.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question may not be discussed on the Vote on Account. It is not a matter for discussion.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I want to inform the House that when Deputy Costello was Taoiseach, he worked all day on a Christmas Day to prevent a bank strike and he did prevent it. Now no Minister has lifted a finger to prevent the country from being paralysed by a transport strike. I want to draw a comparison between them and Deputy Costello who worked all day Christmas Day without his Christmas dinner. There is no sign of any Fianna Fáil Minister losing five minutes. Anyway, they will not have to walk. They will travel at the expense of the poor taxpayer who will be out with his hand up looking for a lift.

Comment on this

You will not have to walk.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

What do you mean?

Comment on this

You will not be walking.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I have to travel at my own expense.

Comment on this

You travel at the expense of the State.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Not at all. If I want to travel around my constituency from Mountmellick to Portlaoise, who will pay me? Will you?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I can get a bus this week but next week I will not be able to get anything.

Comment on this

Get the old bike.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

There will be a great many like me, a great many saying the sooner we have a change of Government, the better. I do not propose to dwell any further on this Vote on Account.

Comment on this

You have done fairly well.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is a compliment from the Minister.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

At least he agrees with what I say. He has shown his appreciation.

Comment on this

It took a long time anyway.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I want to wind up on the note that the sooner the Fianna Fáil Party pluck up a bit of courage and get out, the better for the country and for everybody in it. We in Fine Gael are ready for a general election in 24 hours—at very short notice—and while Deputy Lalor keeps me on hands he is all right. He is a decent fellow and while he is decent, he is all right.

Comment on this

We have three out of five.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I will look after you. I will always have a couple of thousand left over that you can get.

Comment on this

Wait and see.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The time has now come when Fianna Fáil should allow the people to test their policy. They have failed miserably in every step they have taken and blundered in every attempt they have made. They are no possible asset to the country and they have inflicted untold hardships on every section of the community, farmers, civil servants, business people and all. All sections today are clamouring for a general election and when the time comes for one, the people will show their appreciation of the men who have been serious in their efforts to help them. I direct my remarks to the Labour Party. The Labour Party have a duty to put Fianna Fáil out and we have a duty to co-operate with any Party who help to put them out. Is that not very clear? I will take any kind of Government who are against Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

As long as you get free transport.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

There are good men in the Labour Party today, as good as there are in Ireland, and the worst of them is better than Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

How does this arise on the Vote on Account? It has no relation to it whatsoever.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

An alternative Government certainly arises on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is confined to general Government expenditure.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

All those in Opposition, Labour and Fine Gael, should unite on the first principle that in the interest of the people, we need a change of Government.

Comment on this

And have a Coalition again.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

We can settle all our differences after that but the first essential is a change of Government. I am prepared to help, to co-operate with and support any Party who will co-operate with Fine Gael in putting Fianna Fáil out and replacing them in the morning. I would welcome their help and support and if they want help, I will give them all the help and influence I possibly can. A change of Government is desirable and necessary. Fianna Fáil are a Party of very old men with a very old policy. The time has come for a change and the sooner the change comes, the better for all sections of the community.

Comment on this

It has been two hours now.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I was not speaking for two hours.

Comment on this

You were.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. J. Brennan) Fianna Fáil

There is a word in the English dictionary, "balderdash". It is not a very nice one but it is the only word adequate to describe what we have listened to for the past hour and a half.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister says it was two hours.

Comment on this

It was four o'clock when you started.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I will give you the five minutes.

Comment on this

Public representatives at some stage or other in life become mature. They either resort to gimmicks to keep themselves in public life or they take increased responsibility seriously. It is a matter of which course one chooses, but we in Fianna Fáil have invariably chosen what we regard as the responsible course in all our time in public life. You have only to look back on our record over the years to appreciate that fact. If we went out of government temporarily—and we did—we always came back stronger than before and those accidents do not happen without reason. They are based on very sound reasons and the reason, in my view, is the fact that we have been honest with the people at all times.

We are considering the Vote on Account for 1963-64 and to a great extent the debate has not differed much from what one would hear in many county councils throughout the country at this time when the local rate is being discussed. I must say that the Labour people took a constructive line and welcomed the amount but Fine Gael speakers invariably started by condemning the huge amount proposed in the Book of Estimates and having done so, having condemned and pretended to be appalled at this huge vote they proceeded in their speeches to advocate more expenditure in every possible sector of the community.

The same thing happens in parish pump politics, in county councils throughout the country where local councillors advocate more expenditure right through the year for every little service for which the local authority is responsible but when it comes to striking the rate, they try to shelve responsibility and say it is an unbearable burden, intolerable and must be reduced. Fine Gael resorted to the old tactics of saying it was entirely the fault of Fianna Fáil. The public in this country are not fools any more than in any other country in the world. For many years they have listened in this House to speeches such as Deputy Flanagan has repeated and which have made very little impression upon them.

Once again, we have just heard from Deputy Flanagan the miracle of Fine Gael, the miracle which only happens when they are not in office. We have just been told butter will be reduced in price, farmers will be paid more for their milk, bread will be cheaper. A better price will be paid for wheat; every farmer will get £1,000; taxation will be reduced; the guards, the teachers and civil servants will get more and taxation will be reduced. Outside of Grangegorman, there is not a solitary citizen who will take that statement otherwise than with a grain of salt and it is not necessary to dwell on that statement for one moment.

We have faced up to our responsibilities fairly and squarely. At the start of our term of office, we announced our programme in the form of a White Paper known as the Programme for Economic Expansion. We decided when that programme was issued, we would hide nothing from the public, that our method would be exposed and open to them, that the progress made would be charted along the line, that we would annually review the progress and publish a statement accordingly.

It was particularly stressed in that programme that as much of the public expenditure as possible would be channelled into productive employment and increased production generally. Those are the lines on which we are going and I defy any Deputy listening to me here to take that Book of Estimates of £167 million and say that that is not the predominant motive which actuated every Department's Estimate in the entire book. The taxpayer is being asked to come to the aid of agriculture to the extent of £36 million, which is more than £8 million above last year's Estimate, and we have just heard a Deputy insinuate that nothing is being done for agriculture. I should like to see a greater figure for agriculture. I am a rural Deputy and I particularly welcome the Government's plan for the small farmers about which most of the Deputies on the Opposition side of the House who have spoken so far know very little. The small holding west of the Shannon is the holding that has down through the years supported a family at a very low standard of living which the younger people of to-day are not prepared to tolerate.

I come from a constituency where emigration has been known in the days when emigration was more akin to starvation and nobody in this House can tell me anything about it. I have seen emigration in days when destitution drove the people to find a living somewhere. In the townland where I was born and reared, I saw over 40 people emigrate between 1924 and 1926. It was not to England they went then because there was no employment to be found in it. They went to America and most of them never returned. To-day, however, with the greatest facility, a person can get an air ticket or a rail ticket and be in England the next day. Invariably, they will find better pay than they are getting at home in any job we are likely to offer them. There is no denying that. I do not think there is a person in any occupation in this country who could not point out that from a monetary point of view, his services would be better rewarded if he went to work in England, whether he is a professional man, a tradesman, an artisan of any kind or even a labourer.

That is not everything. There is much more to offer here than mere monetary gain. It must be remembered that while many of those who emigrate are already leaving employment here, we do not deny that there is a percentage, much too big a percentage, who have to go for economic reasons and that is the percentage with which we are concerned. There are factories in the country where there is good employment. There are factories in my county from which people have emigrated to find employment in England or in America. However, there are also people who have to go due to economic conditions.

I was present at an official luncheon on one occasion in my county at which his Lordship, Most Reverend Dr. McNeely, spoke. He seldom speaks and when he does he speaks wisely. He said in regard to emigration that if we could reach the position—and he believed that everybody concerned was doing everything possible to reach that position—where we could offer work to those who wanted to go, then at least we could not be blamed for letting them go.

That is the answer. Nobody wants to stop emigration compulsorily. Let there be free movement but if we could reach the position where we could say: "If you wish to stay there is a job for you," then the finger of responsibility does not point at the Government. Unfortunately, that stage has not been reached yet and the economic situation is not entirely responsible for it either. It is only part of the cause. Social reasons may tend as much towards driving them out as any other reasons.

To work towards finding more employment, creating better employment and the expansion of the economy generally is the only solution but that solution will not come overnight. Let us see are we moving in that direction. The people outside who take an interest in the affairs of this House are not fools. They are quite well able to judge whether the efforts being made are genuine, whether they have been effective and what their ultimate outcome will be.

In the Programme for Economic Expansion as enunciated by this Government, there are laid down two sound principles which are being followed. The end is to expand our economy and create the necessary opportunities which must ultimately absorb the surplus labour from the land. What are these efforts? Under every single heading that is calculated or designed to improve our economy, there is greater activity, more money is being given annually and in general, the economy is being expanded as planned. That programme aimed at an average annual increase of two per cent. in real national income and those are the standards by which we must be guided. That target has been exceeded and a rate of four per cent. has been achieved.

We have given more money to afforestation. I remember the time when the Opposition preached that afforestation would solve all our problems overnight. The figure for afforestation has reached the highest ever recorded and the activity under afforestation is the highest ever achieved and is still going apace. In fact, in my constituency, the complaints I am getting now are that we are taking over too much land for afforestation, that it should be left for the farmers.

We have put more money into tourism. I remember when the Coalition suggested a tax on tourists. I remember when it was said that they were coming in to spend paper money and to take away our food.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Who said that?

Comment on this

Mr. MacBride, who was then a member of the House and an integral part of the Coalition Government. We do not hear any word of that now. Tourism is now regarded and accepted as the second biggest industry we have. We are giving it every possible encouragement. I did not hear a single complaint about it in the course of this debate.

In regard to fisheries, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands has made it possible, by a training scheme, for every decent fisherman who so desires to equip himself to go to sea with the necessary knowledge and, by paying down a very low percentage of the cost, to go with one of the best equipped boats that there can be, to the fishing grounds, so as to increase our catching power and to expand the industry. We have set up processing stations and ice-plants to offset glut and to stabilise the price of fish generally.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

We did all that.

Comment on this

The former Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Flanagan, must be aware that during his entire period in that office, during which he was responsible for fisheries, not one herring was exported from this country, not one attempt was made to find markets for fish. I do not want to go into the other shortcomings. The more he did, the better I would like it but there is a terrible lot of cod— if I may quote the Leader of the Opposition, and I am not punning— talked from the other side of the House about fishing. We are going about the development of fisheries in accordance with the best advice we can get and we are putting into it all the moneys necessary to expand the industry. The important factor is that it should give employment to a large and expanding number of people and contribute to our balance of payments because every fish taken out of the sea is real production and a contribution to the national wealth. We have a long way to go and we are moving rapidly towards expansion of the industry.

I have already referred to agriculture. Apart from our new plan for the small farms, which I particularly welcome and advocate, we are asking the taxpayers to support agriculture to the extent of £36½ million. No Deputy and nobody outside this House can accuse this Government of not making a genuine effort towards the expansion of our economy in every possible direction.

There was discussion here about the White Paper Closing the Gap. That White Paper was misrepresented by the previous speaker. He called it a pay pause and a signal to tighten your belt. He knows as well as I do that it is neither of these things, that it is a very intelligent document, well regarded by the responsible people throughout the country, particularly the small farmers about whom I am talking, particularly by the people who have to stand by and watch others getting increases which they cannot get. If that White Paper points out, as it does in the simplest language, that the Government should not be pressed for increases until the expansion of the economy justifies them, I think it is a very sane type of thing and I guarantee that no sensible Government who will ever be in power are likely to regard it as anything but a very sane document.

We have all sections of the community to consider, not merely one section. There was a great deal of talk about equality and not asking one section to carry the burden more than another. That is exactly what Closing the Gap means—absolute equality for all sections; that no one section should be allowed to pass another until it is justified by an increase in national wealth or production, an increase which, fortunately, we are getting.

If there was some slowing down in progress last year, that does not necessarily mean that we had sunk back to the position in which we were in 1957. Remember, if exports last year showed a decline, they were £21 million more than they were prior to 1951—a very marked increase. Remember, there was an increase in real national income last year also. But we are taking the easing off as a necessary warning and we issued that White Paper Closing the Gap as a very sane, logical document which explains in the simplest terms what is good government and good national housekeeping and I think even all sections of organised labour agree with the principles contained in that White Paper.

Comment on this

Congress did not, apparently.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Civil Service Associations did not.

Comment on this