Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 14—General (Resumed).
Contributions 158–347 of 347. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
In a case such as that, the Minister will assess the entire profits under Schedule D.
Comment on this
"... in such cases shall be assessed under Schedule D by reference to actual profits."
Comment on this
I am getting at this, that whereas he got away on a notional basis, as the Minister says——
Comment on this
——on his farm profits and as any genuine farmer will still continue to get away, under this Budget the profits which he makes on his farm will be added to the profits which he makes on his business and he will be assessed on the entire amount under Schedule D. I only hope that I am wrong.
Comment on this
If the Minister is going to argue, of course, I cannot say very much. I feel for those unfortunate farmers who for the first time are nailed for income tax.
Comment on this
I am not saying it at all. What I am saying is that they have to pay under Schedule D, whereas the big farmers are getting away.
Comment on this
I want to point out that they must pay under Schedule D, which is the important thing. Perhaps the Minister does not see my point.
Comment on this
I see the Deputy's point —that they are all making fortunes from farming. That is what the Deputy is saying.
Comment on this
A small farmer who makes £300 out of his farm, and who also has a business on which he makes £300 more is now to be assessed under Schedule D on the £600, whereas the big farmer who makes £600 on his farm without any business will be in the same position as he is today and will be merely assessed on his poor law valuation.
Comment on this
That means that a professional man like the Deputy would have his profits lashed up and that the ordinary farmer will not have to pay.
Comment on this
The trouble is, and Deputy Corry knows it, that the publican who has a small farm must pay income tax now under Schedule D on his gross assets.
Comment on this
£300 on the farm and £300 on the public house. He is making £600 a year and he is now to pay under Schedule D on £600 while ranchers like Deputy Corry, who make £600 or £6,000, will not pay income tax on it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy submits an amendment putting in the ranchers, I will see what I can do about them.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry might resume his seat and Deputy O'Donnell might cease inviting these interruptions.
Comment on this
The trouble is I never know when he is sitting or standing. He is there now getting bothered when I explain that he, as a big farmer with no business, will still be assessed for income tax purposes on his PLV, whereas his neighbour over in West Cork who has a public house and a farm will be assessed under Schedule D on his entire profits. I know the Deputy, when he is in his constituency next February or March, will find the farmers coming in and saying: "I have received a demand for income tax on the produce of my farm. Why should I have to pay it when I make only £300 on my farm and £300 on my public house—why should I have to pay on £600 net profit while you, Deputy Corry, who have no public house, have to pay only on your PLV".
Comment on this
When Deputy M. J. O'Higgins sat down after making his speech, not one member in the Fianna Fáil benches offered to speak.
Comment on this
You are blowing off steam and afraid of your lives you would have to go to the country.
Comment on this
I shall make way for the Deputy very shortly. He can be getting his notes ready. I shall send him scuttling to the Library to look up a few things.
Comment on this
We do not want interruptions—we want speeches. The Deputy is a very good friend of mine and I am sure he pays his taxes cheerfully, but his neighbour down in Cork who cannot make £6,000 on his farm, who can only make £300 on his farm and £300 on his public house, will pay through the nose, and a lot more than Deputy Corry. There is one crowd I am very glad to see included under this tax and that is the dancehall proprietors. I am very glad indeed they will not escape. I remember a time when there was a 10 per cent tax on dancing and when a certain amount of revenue—something in the region of £150,000—was realised. That was wiped out by the present Government. Why I do not know. There is no more thriving industry in this country than the dancehalls.
Comment on this
I heard Fianna Fáil Senator McGlinchey say that a good dancehall in Letterkenny was as good as two industries in the town.
Comment on this
I did not hear the Leas-Cheann Comhairle's remark. An additional five per cent is being added to the corporation profits tax but it is being made retrospective to January, 1962. The Minister knows that all companies produce a balance sheet annually. They pay dividends, distribute profits, retaining certain profits for improvement of their machinery and their business. Where are they now to find the money to pay the arrears of corporation tax ? I know one firm in this city, a very big firm, that finds itself "in the red" to the extent of £30,000 which it must draw from the bank to pay the arrears.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry will pay 2½ per cent more from now on, on Irish socks or English socks. I would advise him to buy his socks in Cork and not to come to Dublin looking for them. It is a poor state of affairs when you find a Deputy leaving his own city and tramping the streets of Dublin looking for a pair of Irish socks. I am certain the shopkeepers of Cobh or of Cork could produce Irish socks and, if necessary, handknit Irish socks, and yet the Deputy comes here, to what is known as the dirty city, trying to get a pair of clean socks. He will pay 2½ per cent on those socks from now on and not only that but the farm-labourer who works for him will pay 2½ per cent on his socks, provided he has them.
Comment on this
He will pay 2½ per cent also on his cap, 2½ per cent on his vest and on his shirt and on his suit and on every item of food he eats, and on every little entertainment he gets in the public house, picture house, or dance-hall. He will pay 2½ per cent for the absolute necessity of having a haircut and ultimately somebody will have to pay an extra 2½ per cent for his coffin.
I do not wish to sound ridiculous or absurd but the clergy give a service. There is no doubt that it is a very good and genuine personal service. Will there be a retail tax on church collections ?
Comment on this
We are discussing this without knowing the exceptions. I am sure the Minister never anticipated putting a tax on church gate collections——
Comment on this
I shall say nothing about that except that it will be a very acute person who will escape the Minister this time. If we knew these exceptions, there would be no necessity to mention them here, but if we do not mention them and if they are overlooked, possibly they will come within the terms of the provision.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
Another aspect of this matter which worries me is the impact of this retail tax on food supplies and other items supplied to hospitals and other local authority institutions. I do not think we can classify purveyors of food supplies to hospitals as wholesalers ; they must be described, I fear, as retailers and therefore on all supplies to hospitals and other local authority institutions, there will be a 2½ per cent retail tax. That is a very considerable sum which will have to be borne proportionately by taxpayers and ratepayers. Has the Minister worked out what will be the impact on the rates from November 1st next ? It will be very heavy. This will hit particularly the ratepayers who, in my opinion, are already taxed to capacity and who will find great difficulty in providing further funds to meet the 2½ per cent increase.
I wonder what the position will be in regard to fish landed in our harbours. Will there be a 2½ per cent tax on the sale of fish? Of course, it does mean that fish sold over the counter will be subject to the 2½ per cent but I am thinking of the retailer who sells his fish across the water.
Comment on this
I am very glad to know that as otherwise it would be serious from our point of view on the western seaboard. Of course, the fishmonger will have to pay 2½ per cent and he will pass that on to the fish consumers. I do not think that will encourage the greater consumption of fish to which the Minister and Parliamentary Secretary referred. That is serious.
This Budget will hit more people and hit them next November in unexpected places. Perhaps the Minister would define what he means by "a very small shopkeeper". He says that in the case of such a person, there will be a nominal tax of 10/- per £100 where the retail turnover is £100 per month. Who has heard of a shopkeeper with a turnover of £100 per month ? I do not know how we could have such a person. Who is the "very small shopkeeper" referred to by the Minister in his speech? It would be very interesting to know.
I refer to page 51 of the Minister's speech where he says:
There will be relief, by way of reduced rates of tax, for persons in a small way of business. In fact, very small businesses will have to pay only a nominal charge. The intention is to charge only a flat 5/-for the first £50 of monthly turnover and 3d. in the £ for the next £50 of monthly turnover, which would mean that a shop with sales of £100 a month would pay only 17/6d. tax a month.
Has the Minister in mind what limit a small shopkeeper could go to pay on his turnover ?
Comment on this
Every shopkeeper, big or small, would pay 5/- for the first £50, 3d. in the £ for the next £50 and 6d. in the £ on the remainder.
Comment on this
The Minister does not make that clear. Now he says that it is 5/- on the first £50, 3d. in the £ on the next £50. Does he go on at 3d. in the £ ?
Comment on this
I thought it was 2½ per cent on the entire retail sales. The Minister now tells me that on the first £50 there is a flat rate of 5/- and it is 3d. in the £ on the next £50. What it really boils down to is that on the first £100 of retail sales, you pay 5/3d.
Comment on this
Then it is 17/6d. on the first £100 and 2½ per cent after that. The Minister says:
In fact, very small businesses will have to pay only a nominal charge.
Is there any business with a turnover of only £100 ?
Comment on this
You should see them when they apply for the old age pension. They have very small profits then.
Comment on this
The Minister tells us that there are business people with a turnover of only £100 a month. Suppose we say that they make a profit of five per cent. On that it means that for running a business they are making £5 a month and for making that amount we are now going to charge them 17/6d. If I am wrong, I hope the Minister will correct me.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say that a person with a small business is making more than five per cent ?
Comment on this
It is no wonder that the Minister seems to be getting his information from the Department of Social Welfare. Now we see the source of his information. God help the unfortunate people who are depending on that Department.
Comment on this
I am a Deputy who never invites interruption in this House but I am continually interrupted. The principal interrupter, Deputy Corry, has gone. I told him I would send him running to the Library to look up his facts.
Comment on this
I was dealing with the Budget when I was so rudely interrupted. I would like the Minister to define what he means by a small business. I know he has told us that it is a business with a turnover of £100 a month, making a profit of 20 per cent. I hope that every member of the Fianna Fáil Party will read the Budget carefully and be able to explain to the people of rural Ireland why they are putting 1½d. on the 1b of tea, one shilling on the pair of shoes, a penny on the 1b of butter, a penny on whiskey and a penny on cigarettes. To make up for that the recipient of the old age pension is to get 2/6 a week.
Take the case of the shopkeeper who is selling what we in the country call heavy goods such as meal, lard and feeding stuffs. Such goods are very expensive and the profit on them is very small. For every £100 worth of these goods, there may be only one per cent of profit. Yet a retail tax of 2½ per cent is to be taken from that trader. Surely the retailer must add that to the farmer's bill and therefore put up the cost of feeding stuffs throughout the country?
Comment on this
I intend to deal with this Budget mainly from the point of view of its effect on the recipient of social welfare. I think it will not be a very long or difficult task to show that the net result is that this year, once again, the Budget provides for a further improvement in the position relative to the cost of living of every recipient of social welfare, both under assistance schemes and insurance schemes. The year 1963 marks another step in the continuous progress in that regard that has been taking place under this Government. This Budget is yet one more instance of the already well established fact that one of the many differences between Fianna Fáil and the alternative Government is that even in the most difficult circumstances we have always given practical evidence of our concern for those people who find themselves dependent on the schemes administered by the Department of Social Welfare while the Opposition record in that respect is one of almost completely ignoring the duty of a Government.
Last year, I showed, and other speakers on the Government benches showed, beyond any shadow of doubt, that the increases given by the present Fianna Fáil Government in regard to every social welfare service more than compensated for the increases in the cost of living. I showed that that was so, no matter what date was given as the starting point for these comparisons. I showed that that was so, even allowing for the backlog that accumulated due to the years of neglect by the two Coalition Governments we have had. I demonstrated clearly at the time of the Budget last year that we were making gradual progress— I admit, slow progress but continuous progress—towards the objective the Taoiseach mentioned here today of raising social welfare payments to a level that could be regarded as satisfactory.
Comment on this
Therefore, in order to establish that this process is continued in the present Budget, it is only necessary for me to compare the position subsequent to and consequent on this Budget with the position with regard to the different social welfare services that existed immediately after the 1962 Budget.
I admit I am tempted to go back a good deal further so as to show once again the contrast between the neglect of social welfare by the Coalition and the continuous development both in regard to the scope of social welfare and the level of payments under Fianna Fáil. But, beyond reminding the Opposition that the increases given by Fianna Fáil—for instance in the case of non-contributory old age pensions—since the War now total 15/-as against the total of 5/- granted by the two Coalition Governments and beyond reminding them that all new schemes introduced since the beginning of this Dáil to function here were introduced by Fianna Fáil and that practically all increases in every other social welfare scheme, apart from non-contributory old age pensions, were given by Fianna Fáil—beyond reminding the Opposition once again of that— I shall resist the temptation to go into any further details.
I said that all I had to do, then, was to establish that the position of social welfare recipients following on this Budget is better than the position which existed following on the last Budget. The cost of living figure for February, 1962, which was the latest figure available at the time of the 1962 Budget and on which the arguments of that time were based, was 154. The latest figure available now is the figure for February, 1963, which was 160—an increase of 3.9 per cent. The turnover tax, the only feature of this Budget that will affect the costs of the receipients of social welfare, is 2.5 per cent.
Comment on this
So that, even if all the income from social welfare payments were affected by this turnover tax— which of course will not be the fact— the total increase necessary then to get back to the position that was established by the Budget of 1962 would be 6.4 per cent. But, of course, the turnover tax will not fall on all expenditure.
I think the Budget statement shows that the tax will fall on approximately 75 per cent of total personal expenditure. Therefore, if that proportion were to apply to an equal extent to social welfare recipients as well as to other classes of the community, the total increase that would be necessary to restore social welfare payments to the position that existed after the last Budget would be 5.8 per cent. As I say, that is only if we assume that all the items will carry the 2½ per cent equally. I do not think it is necessarily true that that is likely to happen.
Retailers will have to try to get back this 2½ per cent, which they will have to pay on their turnover, in the most efficient way in which it can be got. I think that, generally speaking, they will have sufficient intelligence to see that people who are existing at or near subsistence level are already spending as much of their income on these types of items as they can and that therefore an attempt to recover this tax by increasing the prices of necessaries is not likely to be very effective. I feel that the intelligent retailer will make every effort to avoid increases in commodities that are necessaries and will put them, instead, on the type of item that is purchased mainly by better-off people.
Therefore, while for the purpose of comparing the position of social welfare recipients now with what it was after the last Budget, I shall take the figure of 5.8 per cent as the deterioration in their position due to the cumulative effect of the increase in the cost of living and this turnover tax, I am quite certain that in actual fact there will not be that much deterioration in their condition. I propose now, in order to show up some of the nonsense which the Opposition have been talking, to take a brief look at each of the social welfare schemes so as to compare the position as established by this Budget with that which existed after the last Budget.
The increases proposed are 2/6d. per week in the personal rate and the adult dependant's rate for all the assistance schemes. As the Minister said in his statement, this increase is applied also to the Infectious Diseases Allowances and to the Disabled Persons (Maintenance) Allowances. Apparently, Opposition Deputies did not study the Minister's statement and were not aware of this but the Taoiseach mentioned here today that provision is also made for increases in the contribution schemes which—while the details are not yet worked out—we believe should be approximately double those for the assistance schemes. That is for the contributory schemes.
Comment on this
The workers will pay some of it, of course; the employers will pay their share of it and the general taxpayers will pay the rest, but it is as a result of the provisions of this Budget that this extra amount will be made available. That is the mechanics of making it available, and all the money eventually comes from the people's pockets.
In addition to these increases in the assistance and insurance schemes there are also the increases in children's allowances which were mentioned in the Budget statement. These will be equivalent approximately to an increase of 2/3 per week for the family who have one child, 3/3 for a family of three children, 4/3 for a family with four children, and so on. I propose to examine briefly the effect on each of these social welfare schemes of these increased rates in conjunction with the increases in the cost of living since the Budget of last year and in conjunction with the maximum possible effect of the proposed turnover tax, which maximum effect I do not actually expect to materialise.
I suppose it would be best to start at the one social welfare scheme which any of the Opposition Deputies have the nerve to mention, the only one in which they have any record so far, even though their record in regard to that is so miserable compared with Fianna Fáil's, that is, the non-contributory old age pension scheme. At present the rate is 32/6 on which there is an increase of 2/6, which is an increase of 8 per cent. Therefore in that scheme the net position of the pensioner after this Budget is better than that after the last Budget and, as I said, it was demonstrated clearly that at the time of the last Budget the increases that have taken place in the cost of living from any date one chose to take had been more than compensated for.
With regard to the non-contributory widows' pension scheme for a widow with no child the increase proposed is 2/6d., from 31/- to 33/6d., which is again an increase of approximately 8 per cent. If the widow has one child the effect of the increase in the widows' pension scheme plus the increase in the children's allowance scheme will be to give her a total increase of 4/9d. on the present rate of 41/-, which is an increase of 11.6 per cent. If she has two children, there being no extra increase for the second child, her percentage increase is 8.7 per cent. If she has four children the increase is 6/9d. and that amounts to 9.1 per cent on her present income from the non-contributory widows' pension scheme. Therefore in that scheme also there is a net improvement in the position of the recipients.
The other assistance scheme is that for unemployment assistance. The rates here are different for rural and urban recipients. I am taking the figures for urban receipients ; of course, the rural figures are less and the increases given are the same so that the percentage in the case of rural people will be higher. Here again the increase for a single man is 2/6d. on the present rate of 24/-, an increase of 10.4 per cent. If he is married the increase is 5/-, which is an increase of 12 per cent. If he has one child the increase, taken in conjunction with the increase in children's allowances, is 7/3d., which is an increase of 13.8 per cent. If he has two children the increase is 11 per cent; if he has four children the increase is 9/3d., an increase of 10.8 per cent. There again the increases given more than compensate for the maximum possible effect that can be attributed to the increases in the cost of living and the effect of the proposed new turnover tax.
On the contributory side the position is the same. As regards the contributory old age pension scheme the exact figures have not been decided upon but it is assumed that they will be approximately double those of the assistance side; that will be 5/- for the personal rate and the same or something similar in the adult dependant rate. In any of the contributory schemes the percentage increase in payment would be at least double the maximum deterioration in the purchasing power that could be ascribed to the combined effect of the cost of living increase and the effect of the turnover tax.
Obviously then the position is that each recipient of social welfare in any shape or form, whether married or single, with or without children, has his or her position improved as a result of this Budget. Last year I pointed out that as a result of the provisions of the Budget an additional amount of £4.2 million was being made available for the receipients of social welfare. The amount by which they will benefit from the proposals being made in this Budget is at least £5.64 million. That is taking into account the full effect on the contributory schemes of the workers' contributions and the employers' contributions and also taking into account the increases in children's allowances, and that is in a full financial year.
Of the total of £3.5 million which it is proposed to collect by way of this turnover tax, the Minister's statement showed that £1.9 million is needed for the increases in the different social welfare services in this financial year but in addition to that, of course, the increases that were granted last year operated only for portion of the year and they were financed by the taxes imposed in last year's Budget only for that portion of a full year. This year those increases have to be paid for the full year and the money to pay for them is being provided in this Budget. The difference between the cost to the State of these increases for a full financial year and for that period over which they operated last year is £1.032 million. Taking that extra provision which has to be made for the increases that were granted last year in conjunction with the provision that is being made for this year for these new increases, there is almost £3 million of this £3.5 million, which is being raised this year by means of the turnover tax, required for social welfare increases.
This Budget is an honest one. It is framed to provide the necessary money to meet the expenditure incurred in operating all the services that the Oireachtas has deemed it fit to provide. I have shown that not alone has it maintained the position of social welfare recipients but that another improvement has been made in the real level of social welfare payments. There have been no specific and concrete suggestions as to where economies could have been made. The only thing approaching such a suggestion I have heard was from Deputy Norton when he described the subsidy being given to milk production as the most useless type of expenditure imaginable. I do not know what the milk producers of County Kildare will think of that contribution to the Budget debate yesterday.
On the whole, I think it can be said no attempt has been made to substantiate the allegation that the size of the bill the Minister for Finance had to meet was in any degree due to extravagance. Through all the speeches I have heard, there has been instead a tacit admission that the expenditure is all needed to meet the demands of social justice and of economic and social development. If it is agreed, as I think it is, that the expenditure the Government have to meet is necessary, then the only other point I propose to deal with is whether the extra taxation needed has been levied in a fair and equitable manner. As far as I am concerned, that means to investigate whether the lower income group have been safeguarded from hardship in the collection of the extra taxation.
I am a firm believer in the fundamental principle that taxation should be tailored to fit the capacity of the individual to pay. The net effect of the Budget is to do that effectively. The amount of total extra taxation to be raised was £7.5 million. It was first decided to raise a sum of £3 million by way of corporation profits tax, a tax on profits which does not affect the lower income group. Since those who make these profits will also pay the new turnover tax in proportion to their expenditure, the increased taxation is obviously going to be mainly obtained from those who can afford best to pay it. There is a further £4 million to be obtained by a tax on rents and a further £.6 million by tightening up the anti-evasion measures. The remaining £3.5 million is to be raised by means of the proposed turnover tax.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
It has been said that a tax directly proportional to expenditure, without providing for any tax-free allowances as in the case of income tax or without specifically exempting essentials, is unjust to a person of low income. That contention would need to be seriously considered if it were proposed to operate this tax in isolation or to collect a significant amount of total taxation in this manner. There are two considerations that make that criticism inapplicable in the present case. In the first place, the proposed tax is a very small one. In the second place, the proposed increases in children's allowances modify its effect very considerably in favour of the person of low income with a young family. It can be shown that any of the other forms of traditional taxation, if they were designed to produce the same amount of revenue, would weigh more heavily on the vast majority of people with low income.
In theory, income tax is a very equitable system, but it is no secret— it has been fairly well established over a long number of years—that there is an almost insuperable difficulty in assessing all incomes accurately and that because of that, many people escape paying their due share. The result is that those people whose incomes can be readily and fully verified—these people are mainly employees—have to contribute more than they should. This tax cannot be so readily avoided, so that all must pay their share. Since it is proportional to expenditure, it is obviously proportional to capacity to pay.
Just as income tax is adjusted in favour of people with low incomes by way of tax-free allowances, this Budget does the same thing in regard to the turnover tax by increasing children's allowances. It is blatantly untrue to say there is no attempt to make it equitable by making it fit the capacity of people to pay. A man with one child under 16 will have his weekly income increased by 2/3d. If he has three children, the increase will be 3/3d.; four children, 4/3d. and so on. Therefore, a person of modest means, who is in a position to pay £6 a week on the type of item that comes under this turnover tax—and presuming that the tax is fully passed on in respect of all items, which I do not think will happen—will be adversely effected by only 9d. per week if he has one child, and if he has three or more, will actually gain slightly from the provisions of the Budget. If he is in a position to spend £8, on that assumption, the extra cost if he has one child would be 1/9d. per week, and if he has four or more, his net position would be better than it was before.
Therefore, in addition to improving the position of all social welfare recipients, this Budget has arranged effectively that this extra tax will fall lightly on those with modest incomes. For instance, in the case of a man who smokes—and very many people with low incomes smoke as heavily as wealthy people—it will fall more lightly than would a tax arranged to bring in an equivalent amount placed on cigarettes and tobacco.
On the other hand, while the effect on people of low income is almost neutralised, if they have a family, by means of the children's allowance provision, the man in a position to spend £20 a week on the items affected by the new tax will be affected to the extent of 10/- if he has no children, 7/9d. if he has one or two, and 6/9d. if he has three. It is obvious that the combined effect of the increased children's allowances, plus the turnover tax, very definitely weights this tax heavily in favour of the lower income groups. It is done much more effectively than it could be done with any existing form of tax and that combined with the fact that half of the extra bill to be met is raised by corporation profits tax, I think, marks this Budget as one which presses very lightly, if at all, on those who are least able to bear taxation.
I do not know what alternatives are proposed by the Opposition. They do not appear to complain about any of the expenditure. Tax on any of the traditional items such as tobacco, beer or spirits is scarcely justifiable because these things are not necessaries, but they are so widely consumed that they almost rank as necessaries. It is an undoubted fact that such taxes do not favour the lower paid workers to the same extent as income tax or the turnover tax because, as I said, there is many a man on a low income who spends more than very wealthy people on these items, of his own choice no doubt, but some people find it hard to change their habits. The amount paid on items such as these by even the most wealthy people is limited by their habits and physical capacity and of course expenditure on those items can be avoided by a decision to refrain from buying them. This tax, however, is proportionate to expenditure on a very wide range of goods and services, as Deputies opposite have not been slow to point out, and it cannot be avoided in that way.
This tax will cause no great hardship. I have shown that as far as social welfare is concerned it does the opposite. I have shown that so far as the person with the low income is concerned the effect is almost neutralised, if he has one child, and if he has three or more children, it is completely neutralised. I admit that a tax that is directly and absolutely proportionate to expenditure would appear to be unfair to people who must spend nearly all their income on necessaries or near necessaries of life and if this were a tax of significant proportions with no adjustments, such as there are in this Budget, that case could be made. However, since the tax is so small as to be insignificant even to the single man on a small income, and since all social welfare recipients are more than adequately compensated, and since the increased children's allowances have practically neutralised the effect on low income groups, surely it is a more equitable form of tax than a tax on any of the traditional items or an increase in income tax designed to bring in the same amount.
I do not agree that it will have any of the adverse effects that Opposition speakers have been trying to claim it will have on the economy of the country in general. It is certainly very effectively weighted in favour of the people who are least able to bear it, not only because it is proportionate to their expenditure but because the effect of the increased children's allowances is greater in their case than it is in the case of people who have more money to spend and who would find that increase of very little effect. As I said, I intended to deal with the Budget only from these two points of view, from the point of view of its effect on social welfare recipients and from the point of view of whether or not it was imposed in an equitable manner, which I interpret as being in a manner which will press as lightly as possible on people of low incomes.
Comment on this
Since the debate started, it appears to have centred around the turnover tax and I suppose some people will call it a "turnover Budget". I would prefer Deputy Mullen's description of the "Twist Budget" because obviously it is designed to twist money out of people who up to now could not be asked to pay any money because their incomes were too low. Immediately before the vote yesterday, I was struck by the fact that the Minister was not sure how this tax was going to work out, how it was going to affect various types of goods and was not sure that he had the right angle and promised to explain everything when the Bill was introduced.
Listening to some of the interruptions from Fianna Fáil backbenchers today, one gathers that they have not educated themselves on this particular item of Budget legislation. Some of the interruptions showed that they had not the foggiest notion about how the Budget was going to affect anybody, even themselves.
Comment on this
Deputy Cunningham will learn a little if he waits. One Deputy who is no longer in the House made the brilliant interruption that of course the first £100 was not going to be taxed. Apparently he was under that impression that that was how it was going to work.
Comment on this
Yes. Just wait a few minutes and you will learn a little more. When Fianna Fáil are on a sticky wicket, it is the usual thing to put in the Minister, then the Taoiseach and then another Minister and keep the backbenchers out of the House because they will usually say something stupid. The result is that Deputy O'Sullivan has had to call for a House on two occasions to get them in to listen.
Comment on this
This "Twist Budget" is designed to ensure that everybody will pay 6d. in the £ on every £1 he spends. There are a few exceptions. The Minister may shake his head and give the impression that the shopkeepers are a group of philanthropists who will be prepared to pay out of their own pockets the tax which the Minister hopes to get, but he knows quite well that there is a minimum tax of 2½ per cent on practically everything——
Comment on this
The tax is designed to ensure that, for instance, the farm labourer who is getting £6 per week and who is a married man and has from one to 12 children will have to pay 3/- per week if he spends the £6.
Comment on this
The Minister may explain it in any way he likes. It is 75 per cent over the national expenditure, but if you go into a shop to buy a lb. of butter, which at present is 4/7d.——
Comment on this
——you will also pay tax on that 4/7d. and since 4/7d. is very close to 5/-, I suggest the shopkeeper will deduct 1½d. in tax. If the Minister knows of any way in which that can be avoided, I suggest that he should tell his colleague, the Minister for Finance, and have it included in the Bill so that these people will be prevented from collecting the tax in that way. I would also suggest that if a poor person in the country, no matter how poor, no matter if he has to beg for the price of a loaf, goes into a shop and buys a loaf, the nearest approximation to the tax is a halfpenny and I suggest that the tax on that loaf will be a halfpenny. We had evidence of that before when Ministers brought in certain types of legislation which resulted in halfpennies and farthings in the price of bread. A penny-halfpenny will be collected off the lb. of butter; it will be collected off the lb. of tea—perhaps a little more, if the tea is the dear type. It will be collected off the packet of cigarettes which the Minister said would not be so much affected. It will be collected off a lb. of bacon— perhaps a little more. It will be collected off the gallon of petrol.
There is no use in saying that because of the fact that the cost of the goods will be less than a unit of 5/-or a fraction of a £1 which can be easily divided, there will be no tax collected. We all know, and the Minister is well aware, that the tax will be collected by the shopkeeper and the shopkeeper would be a fool, I would suggest, if he did not collect it because if he does not collect it, he has to pay it out of his own pocket. No one can expect a man to stay behind a counter and sell goods and pay the Government tax on them.
There is the inducement that for the first £50 in any month, or if the turnover is only up to £50, a nominal 5/-will do. Correct me if I am wrong. If it is up to £100, 17/6d. will do, irrespective of what is collected. I would suggest that this tax is put on so loosely that there are certain people who will be running certain types of shops who will do quite well out of it. I would further suggest that the inducement is deliberately put there to encourage them to become tax collectors so that it can be said to them : "You will not be so bad. You will have a few shillings for yourself out of the deal when it is finished."
It is all right for the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Social Welfare to weave airy-fairy tales about how wonderful the Government are in making provision for everybody. Perhaps the Minister for Social Welfare would suggest to me how a poor person who at present has 32/6 to live on and who will be getting 35/- will be able to pay tax out of that of, at the very least, 1/9d. Such a person will not spend the whole 35/- at one time but will spend it in shillings and two-shillings all over the place when he is buying the small amounts he can afford and may in fact pay double that 2/6d. which he will get from the Department of Social Welfare under this Budget.
Comment on this
They will pay tax according to the way it is being spent. It may be much more than 1/9d.—it may be 2/6d.
Comment on this
It could not be practically nothing and the Minister is well aware of that. That sort of bluff will not carry. It may be useful on a Fianna Fáil platform in the by-election but it is no use in this House because we are not all that slow.
The Minister for Social Welfare said that it was a very honest Budget. It is the most dishonest Budget ever introduced because the Minister for Finance suggested when introducing the Budget that he hoped to collect £3½ million in the four months from 1st November to 1st March. Then he estimated that for a full year he would collect £10½ million. He said from 1st March to 1st April would not be counted in this financial year. He also said in a full year he would collect £10½ million. What he did not say was that everybody who has money and who requires something will make sure to buy it free of tax between now and 1st November next and, therefore, for the first four months, there will be very little except essentials being bought and on which tax will be paid. That is the correct position and if the Minister proposes in that situation to collect £3½ million, I would suggest that his comment that he proposes to collect £10½ million over a full 12 months is just a lot of hooey and that he hopes to collect a very substantial sum inside the next 12 months when the full tax is in operation and when people have to renew things, no matter how dear they may be.
It would appear to me that the Minister hopes to have a substantial balance at the end of the year as a result of his 2½ per cent tax. Why not be honest about the thing? Why not put the whole facts before the House, or does the Minister think we are all like the Fianna Fáil backbencher who thought the first £100 was not being taxed? Maybe the Deputy I am talking about usually spends his money in £100's. Maybe he goes out and buys £100 worth of everything he requires. That may be the answer. The ordinary people, the people for whom the Labour Party particularly are speaking, are people who can spend only in shillings, two-shillings and half-crowns. They cannot spend in £100's and thereby avoid the tax.
Comment on this
It might not do some people three months. We have another ill-informed backbencher in the House. Perhaps if he listened, he also might pick up a few tips before the debate is over.
Comment on this
We will hear his comments on that at a later stage. If the Minister for Finance needs a lot of money, and we understand he does, unfortunately the unemployment figures are going the wrong way for him, going the wrong way for the country. We have nearly 4,000 more persons unemployed than we had 12 months ago. There were a couple of hundred more unemployed last week than there were the week before that. There were 52,000 fewer people in jobs in this country than there were in 1956, which the people opposite refer to as the black year. That is from their own figures. That is from a cutting from the Irish Press.
Comment on this
If Deputy Meaney wants to make a comment, I suggest he should get ample time to explain away the 52,000 persons who were employed in 1956 and who are not employed now. Perhaps he would seek a proper opportunity of doing that instead of trying to do it by way of interruption.
Comment on this
One of the associate members of Fianna Fáil has decided that he will interrupt and this is going to be good. The biggest trouble about this tax is that everybody in the country who sells goods will become a tax collector. All of these must keep accounts and I assume the accounts will be checked, which will, in turn, mean extra staff. The Minister must be very careful here, lest we reach a stage similar to that reached in other countries where it is costing more to keep a check on the tax collectors than the amount collected in the tax. We could quite possibly reach that stage if the trend goes the wrong way here.
In his reference to the goods and services which will be excepted from the turnover tax, the Minister did not mention hospitals and other local institutions or the goods supplied to them. I am not referring merely to drugs and medicines but also to foodstuffs of various kinds supplied by contract to these institutions. The contracts have been made for his year and will presumably continue to the end of the year but perhaps increases in prices will be asked for and a clause may be allowed to be inserted into the contracts permitting increased prices. Even during the few months in which this tax will operate in the current year— remember local authorities operate to 31st March—the amount spent on such foodstuffs is so substantial that the 2½ per cent tax will mean a very substantial sum also. Will this involve the striking of an additional rate in many instances?
I do not know whether the Minister intends to exempt petrol and diesel for public transport from the operation of this tax. He says in his Budget Statement that public transport is one of the excepted services but if public transport must pay extra for its fuel does that not mean automatically increased costs, not alone increased bus fares but increased charges for all kinds of goods transport? The Minister did not explain that. Perhaps he would be good enough to do so when he is concluding.
During the debate, reference has been made to the intention to tax co-operative societies. Unlike some speakers I believe the people who are running what have been generally known as co-operative societies but which, in fact, have become limited liability companies, should have been taxed long ago. I do not see why not because some of the co-operative societies formed 50 or 60 years ago and which were run as such, have been allowed to fall into the hands of a few individuals. I do not see why these people should be allowed to compete under preferential treatment against other kinds of traders. The Minister was quite right to impose this tax on such undertakings but I do not see why all co-operatives should be included. I believe there are a number of genuine societies in the country which should be exempt and I would ask the Minister to be very careful in operating this provision. Some years ago this recommendation was made by the National Co-operative Council which, I suggest, was the brain child of a person who subsequently appears to have had a large influence on the present decision to include this tax in the Budget, and I would ask the Minister to be very careful not to take away, through the operation of this tax, the rights of these genuine co-operatives.
There is to be a further increase in pensions but is the Minister aware that the increases in pensions mentioned in last year's Budget, but in respect of which legislation is still before the House, in many cases have not been paid? The provision to level up pensions appears to have been lost sight of by some local authorities, some of which claim they have been overworked and some that they did not get adequate notification. The result is that many people entitled to pensions still have not got them. The Minister should ensure that, when he is introducing legislation to give effect to this year's proposals in respect of pensions, provision made for last year has been given effect to.
In this matter, the Minister mentioned local authority officers. Did he mean local authority employees? I do not see why he should differentiate between the serving grade and the officer grade: they are all in the same position as far as the necessity to compensate them for lower pensions is concerned. I am glad the Minister has decided to improve the pensions of a number of retired people. Representations had been made to him and to his predecessor and while I appreciate it is a slow process, it is good to see some effort being made along those lines.
The amount which it is proposed to give to social welfare recipients—mind you, only to those in receipt of assistance from 1st November next—is not adequate, despite what the Minister for Social Welfare said tonight. The Minister for Social Welfare should have realised the net benefit of this increase when various deductions have been made from it. He must be aware that these people spend it in shillings, two shillings and half crowns and that the extra halfcrown will be entirely inadequate. How did the Minister work out that those in receipt of contributory pensions do not require compensation until 1st January next? He then decides on 5/- to compensate them. How does he decide whether those in receipt of contributory pensions are in a better position to meet this new turnover tax with 5/- than the person in receipt of the non-contributory pension, who must meet the new tax with 2/6d.? I am sure the Minister feels, as I do, that the person entirely dependent on a non-contributory pension, who must live on 32/6d. a week, deserves at least 5/— the amount being given to contributory pensioners.
Perhaps I am being particularly critical of the new type of tax being introduced here but I suggest we must be critical of it. While we appreciate that extra money must be found, that it is the duty of the Minister for Finance to find that money, at the same time, we think it is unjust and arbitrary to impose now a tax on people whose incomes were so low that previously they could never be caught for income tax. Willy-nilly, they are now made to pay a tax of 6d. in the £ for every £1 they spend.
Comment on this
Deputy Cunningham has ample time between now and 10.30 p.m. to make a speech but I know Fianna Fáil have great difficulty in getting anyone to keep the debate going, they are so ashamed that something like this has been introduced. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands went down the country a few weeks ago and gave a solemn guarantee that there would be no purchase tax——
Comment on this
——no turnover tax except on luxury goods. Now he finds that the Minister and the Government have introduced a tax on practically everything and if anybody thinks that a loaf of bread and a lb. of butter are luxuries, I do not know where they have been in recent years.
Comment on this
The great interest of the Opposition in the Budget debate is very evident. There are two members of Fine Gael here tonight, two Labour.
Comment on this
Of the Independents who last night wanted to join in the debate and were not allowed, there are also two present——
Comment on this
I would ask that Deputy Leneghan be allowed to make his speech as other Deputies were allowed.
Comment on this
I have very little to say on the Budget. Everybody except the clowns—we know the side of the House on which the clowns are—knew for weeks or months past that some type of sales tax was to be introduced. Those people went about the country deliberately and at some cost to themselves, trying to give the impression that a tax of about 15 or 20 per cent was being introduced. Even the leaders of some of the Parties changed their cars overnight simply because they thought they would be mulcted in the new tax. They did that deliberately to mislead the people. They traded in good cars before they intended to do so. That was their own foolishness and no fault of the Government. The big trouble is that instead of the Government introducing a tax of 15 or 20 per cent, the bottom fell out of the bucket for these gentlemen because a tax of merely 2½ per cent was introduced. If the Government had introduced a 10 per cent tax the Opposition would be highly delighted. Soon, they would go to the people in a certain area of Dublin and be able to blame the Government for the troubles of these people but nobody except a fool regards 2½ per cent as anything but a mere trifle. Consequently they have no case to make. That is all that is wrong with them. They are upset and they spent last night in silly arguments which got them nowhere and even many of their own people left the House in disgust and did not vote at all.
We must be realistic. If development is to take place and employment is to be given, money must be obtained somewhere. We cannot get it by wishing for it, or trying to conjure it up. It must come from the ordinary man in the street. No doubt the ordinary man does not begrudge paying reasonable tax so long as he feels a certain sense of security, but if he is placed in the position in which he was placed seven years ago, when he did not know where he would be the next day, he has a much different idea and has good reason for "cribbing". He has no great reason for doing so now. Many of those who come in here to represent the ordinary citizens are doing the country grave injustice. The people who went to England will have to pay far higher taxes and work much harder, probably, than they thought, and in many cases, will have little in return.
It is amusing to hear Deputies asking for reduced taxation on three days in the year and spending the remaining days on which they are here asking for improved facilities for the people, higher pensions, higher social allowances and higher wages. They come in on the day on which these provisions are to be made to ask that less money should be provided. That is typical of any county council meeting where the same thing happens. We spend the year asking for extra roads and bridges and employment and when the estimates come to be prepared, we ask for a reduction in the rates. Nobody but a fool would take any notice of that type of argument.
It is important that the ordinary social welfare allowances, such as old age pensions and unemployment assistance, should be maintained and increased but it is more important that capital expenditure within the State should be increased because it means giving badly-needed employment and involves a very important social uplift. It is very important that a man should be employed rather than unemployed, even though he gets economically as much when unemployed as when employed. Any sane person agrees with that. Therefore, I believe that any money spent on capital outlay is well spent. When wages increase— and there is always an outcry for an increase in wages—the Capital Budget must increase. That is money well spent and no matter where we get it, we must provide it.
Today we have in my constituency where we had practically nothing seven years ago, one of the most important power stations in the country, one of the biggest Bord na Móna works ; we have the grassmeal factory going into operation, the peatlands experimental station on our doorstep and up to 500 or 600 persons employed where a man could not get an hour's work in 1956. I am sure that that applies to many other constituencies and we should be very foolish if we overlook that, or if we overlook the fact that in 1954, 1955, 1956 everything was closed down in that area. I must be realistic and honest about it.
Some local authorities fail to co-operate with the Government and in many cases that brings great hardship to the people of these counties. It means a lessening of expenditure in cases where the Government are prepared to spend money and it is past time that steps were taken to ensure that there should be some type of uniformity in the operations of local authorities. In the case of the Land Project, where large sums of money are to be spent, some local authorities will carry out the work required and others will just say that they will not do it. That is causing grave hardship, especially in my county. It is a circumstance that leaves a great deal of money unspent and is something that the Government should deal with.
I will not take up the time of the House any further beyond saying that a great deal of play has been made on the operation of co-operatives. In nine cases out of ten, these co-operatives are fakes established for the purpose of evading taxation. In many parts of the country, they are not of very high standing. I see no reason why any organisation of any description should be able to set itself up to operate competitively against the ordinary trader. If these people who form co-operative societies and who get away with murder wish to operate, they should be treated in the same way as the ordinary publican or small shopkeeper is treated. I have no objection to them selling agricultural goods and being allowed to get away with that but when they go into competition in ordinary branded lines and then expect complete freedom from any type of taxation, I think it is most unfair and it is past time that they were pulled up.
On the question of the collection of this turnover tax, I would say that it will be open to a tremendous amount of abuse. It should be collected from the wholesalers. I know of small shopkeepers in the midlands who keep their money in a shoe box or in a stocking. How can they be brought to pay this tax? In all fairness to everybody, the tax should be collected on the purchases of such a trader rather than on the purchases of his customers. Most wholesalers today are of a fairly high standard and they have to keep some kind of accounts but I cannot see how a man who, in many cases, will sign a cheque with two X's can be brought into this category. It would be only fair to everybody if the tax in this instance were collected from the wholesalers.
It is very hard to see how the ordinary small publican or grocer could be asked to keep accounts of this kind. He has not been used to doing it and he is not going to get used to it in a matter of days, weeks or months. The Minister would be doing a good day's work if he collected that tax from the wholesalers rather than from the retailer. I am sure it is not beyond the imagination of the people in his Department to formulate some kind of scheme to have the tax collected from the wholesalers. It would be easy to calculate the difference in the tax between the wholesale and the retail prices.
Comment on this
Sir, no Budget in recent years has caused the shock to the country this Budget has caused. Most people expected that there would not be very much change and that whatever change might be brought about in the Budget, industry would get some kind of a fillip, some kind of a shot in the arm. The Government, and the Taoiseach especially, have spoken again and again of the necessity for business improving itself, of the necessity for exporting. I know that incentives have been given to business to export. These incentives are good but remember that there are very many businesses which do not export, which are not manufacturing, although they may be in the distributive trades. They do not want to be, and never will be, exporters.
There are some of them who have been doing something in that line and to these the incentives offered by the Government have been of assistance. But there are firms in this country which did not start up as a result of high tariffs. These are the older established firms which built up from their businesses on the home market the wherewithal to export. Many of our exporting firms and many of the most successful of them were in existence before the tariff wall was built. They built it up out of profits which they made and ploughed back into their business and so eventually they found themselves in a position to start exporting.
Well, that process, which was a good and healthy process for this country and for the work people in it, could still be going on with Government encouragement but unless the firm is right bang in the export business, it finds that the incentives given by the Government are very few. In fact, business is nearly taxed out of existence. Before I sit down, I want to talk about the taxes which have been put on in this Budget.
As I say, the business community expected and hoped that some sort of fillip would be given to them, a sort of shot in the arm. We heard what was done in the Budget of the neighbouring country. Industry was given a shot in the arm and has been given many shots in the arm. Our unfortunate industries have got shots in the back. I do not know how many of them have been able to carry on as they have.
Some very small increases have been given to old age pensioners, blind pensioners, widows, children's allowances, and so on. They are very small. However, I think, and I think the country will decide that the amount given to dependent people, whom we are all glad to see getting something, is in no way commensurate with the disbursements which other sections of the community have received.
We have had two Ministerial interventions—one from no less a person than the Taoiseach and the other from the Minister for Social Welfare. Perhaps the peculiar province of the Minister for Social Welfare is the welfare of the less fortunate members of the community. Nevertheless, listening to a great deal of his speech and to the Taoiseach's speech which was on the Budget in general, one might almost be pardoned for thinking there was nobody in this country except people who had to receive relief.
We all know there are far too many people in this country in receipt of relief and who unfortunately have to be in receipt of relief. The aim of every Government should be—I hope it is but it certainly should be—to look after people who through old age or youth or illness are dependent on us for help. Whilst, on the one hand, we should do all we can for them, on the other hand, we should also help the people who can help themselves. One way of doing that is to do everything to speed the wheels of industry and commerce generally and farming also. We want those people in gainful employment to continue their work and we want to give as much employment as we possibly can.
This Government, with this Budget, have not done that at all. They have put crippling burdens on industry. First of all, I shall take the corporation profits tax. The levy has gone from 10 per cent to 15 per cent, which is an increase of 50 per cent. That tax has gone up 50 per cent. If a firm paid £5,000 last year they will pay £7,500 this year. That is what it means. It sounds nice. It looks as if it is not very much—a five per cent increase— but that five per cent increase is a 50 per cent increase on the tax that will be paid.
That is a burden which every industry or every business will have to bear after January, 1962. I have written down the exact words of the Minister: it will be levied on profits arising on or after January 1st, 1962. The accounts of businesses for the year 1962 are now closed. The tax computation has been made. In most cases whatever profits were in a business have now been distributed. The accounts are closed, finished with. How are those businesses to go back to 1962, which is now finished, and to find 50 per cent extra corporation profits tax which in many businesses amounts to a considerable sum? It is a very big item. In addition, they have got to find 50 per cent more than they had estimated and budgeted for and shown in their accounts—but they will have to do that.
At this stage, I should like to mention certain aspects of the 2½ per cent turnover tax. I was horrified to hear a number of people on the opposite benches, including the Minister for Social Welfare, say that this is a small tax. Do not think that for a moment. This is an enormous tax. That 2½ per cent turnover tax is the biggest tax that has been levied on industry and business in general. The country does not realise that yet. It will be levied on every business to which for want of a better phrase I shall say it applies—and it applies to practically every type of business and industry in the whole country except exports.
Apparently it does not apply to exports but that is by no means the major part of business in this country. If it were, this concession could not be given to exporting industry. The day when our exports are so big as to be nearly as big as or bigger than the rest of the turnover of the country, that day the export incentives will start to decrease because the Government will not be able to afford to give them. However, we are very far from that day. Roughly speaking, they are the only people who will find that this 2½ per cent is not levied on them. The rest of the business community, shopkeepers, and so on, will all have to find that. It is an enormous tax because— and many people except accountants and such people have not realised this —in the ordinary way when a firm pays taxes, it pays them on profits; after allowable expenses have been deducted and if a firm does not make any profit it does not pay any tax, but with this, you pay it whether you are a bankrupt or not. If a firm has a turnover of £100,000, even if it does not make a halfpenny profit, it will still have to pay £2,500 tax. It may not be paying anything like that in its ordinary taxation. I have been looking into some figures about which I know. For every £100 tax a business paid in 1962, when this tax is in full swing, that business will have to pay £250.
This tax will also hit the businesses which are working on a very low margin of profit. Cut-price shops which are presumably working on a very low margin of profit will have great difficulty in finding 2½ per cent because the greater the turnover the more 2½ per cents have to be found. This tax will undoubtedly put certain businesses out of existence. The idea that it will not be passed on to the consumer is absolute nonsense. It must be pased on to the consumer.
Comment on this
How can a firm operate without passing on this 2½ per cent? Unless it does so, it will be out of business.
Comment on this
Then there is the question as to how the tax is to be imposed. What will happen when somebody walks into a shop and buys a bottle of milk for 6d? This tax works out at a farthing on 10d. We have no unit of currency lower than a farthing. Farthings have gone out of existence and nobody would like to see them back again. However, even a farthing is twice too much to charge on 6d and I do not know how a person who is selling 6d. articles will collect the tax. How will he collect the tax on a box of matches? If you sell enough boxes of matches and do not collect the tax, you will find yourself on queer street. If you are selling matches by the gross, you can get it back but in the ordinary way, it will be very difficult. I do not say it will be impossible to do it. Business people will find a way but only with considerable difficulty. The lower the margin of profit on which a firm are operating, the greater will their difficulty be, or, to put it in another way, the better the value they are giving to the public, the more necessary it will be to pass that on to the consumer because they would have to close down in certain cases——
Comment on this
Surely that is contradicting the Deputy's earlier argument? If it is a tax on business, then it cannot, at the same time, be a tax on the consumer who is purchasing from the business.
Comment on this
It must be a tax on the consumer. My argument is— and I do not like to call it an argument because I believe it to be an irrefutable fact—that if the cost of that is not passed on to the consumer, certain businesses will be smashed by it.
Comment on this
I cannot say that I have any tears to shed for the cut-price shops. I do not deal in them because I do not like them but one would think they were the blessed of the Lord who had come to serve the people of Ireland and that the old established family grocer was somebody who was putting sand in the sugar all his life and grinding the faces of the poor. That argument has been put forward and put forward in this House in my hearing, that the person who sells on the lowest margin of profit is doing the best service to the community. I do not hold with that but it was the basis on which the Prices Commission operated, fair trade, and so on. They were based on the idea that business should be a free-for-all. However, if business is to be a free-for-all with a large turnover and small profits and then on top of the large turnover is levied 2½ per cent, make no mistake, that is a colossal levy because up to this taxes were supposed to be levied on profits. This is not a tax on profits. It does not matter whether you are going bankrupt in the morning, when they come to make out your liabilities, heading all the other liabilities will be your liability to the Government for turnover tax. You will not have any corporation profits tax to pay because you will have gone "bust", but you will have to find that. It might be, strangely enough, that very figure which had pushed a business over into failure.
That is not only an aspect of this tax but it is an inevitable result of it. The corporation profits tax, which shows a 50 per cent increase on the previous figures, is levied now on financial returns which have been closed and assets and so on distributed. It is a monstrous thing to go back on accounts which are balanced and closed and assets distributed and expect them next year to bear a very much higher taxation. As a matter of fact, the year 1964 will have to bear a lot of strange things. It will have to bear the full impact of the sales tax, in respect of which it will be very difficult for many firms to recoup themselves. It will also have to bear— although goodness knows what will be put on in the way of extra taxation before then—50 per cent extra corporation profits tax. It will have to bear also the portion of the 1962 extra corporation profits tax which perhaps the year 1963 could not carry. There is going to be some difficulty when those matters are gone into by business people.
We had the Taoiseach speaking here today. I always find a great rush of excitement when the Taoiseach speaks about our economic expansion. I feel I am part of a great industrial army moving on. But then the light of reason floods my brain and I say: "What on earth is being done for that army on the march?" Nothing is being done. The Taoiseach talked about economic expansion. Economic expansion has come about in the past few years. Nobody quite knows why. He talked about detailed planning and the second economic plan. All that sounds magnificent to help industry. But what on earth in the Budget has been done to help?
The other Ministerial intervention was on the part of the Minister for Social Welfare. He did not claim that industry was being helped. He claimed that the pensioners were being helped. The Labour Party and we do not think that the aged, the infirm, the blind and the children are being helped to anything but a very small extent in this Budget, but we know very well that industry is not being helped. Even the Minister for Social Welfare, with his somewhat inconsequential approach to high finance, did not attempt to maintain that. But then the Taoiseach comes and claims in regard to a Budget which has pushed up corporation profits tax by 50 per cent and levied the biggest taxation on business and industry that has ever been levied on it, one which is quite out of step with the rest of our taxation code, that it is going to help industry. I sincerely wish I could see how that is to be done.
The truth is that, except for certain favoured industries engaged in export, the rest of the business community are finding taxation appallingly high. Make no mistake: taxation is appallingly high. This legislative assembly, which very naturally reflects a cross-section of Ireland, is mainly composed of people who understand very thoroughly, I am sure, the problems of the rural community. This is an overwhelmingly agricultural country, but we also have industry and business. We have not the same understanding inside this House of business problems as we have of farming problems. I do not think the average Deputy realises the extent to which industry in this country is handicapped.
Expansion of industry in this country has to be done in the classical way. There is no safe way of planning economic expansion and capital expenditure in a business except out of savings. It is nearly impossible for business to save and put by the money necessary to equip it. In business, if you do not keep renewing your plant and machinery and assets, your carpets, curtains, and so on, you go out of business very rapidly. It is not just for fun that people are always renewing and re-equipping. It has to be done in order to keep the business right. If it is not done, the business will suffer. It can only be done out of profits. Very inadequate allowances are made for that. They are much bigger in most other industrial countries.