Finance Bill, 1963—Fifth Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–237 of 681. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 14 of 1963 ›
As I was saying earlier in relation to the speech we had from the Taoiseach this morning, it was one of those frothy speeches without any factual proposals to which we have become accustomed to hearing from him. It would not be unreasonable to say that we could paper every room in this building with the speeches the Taoiseach has made in relation to alleged plans over the years. We hear a lot of those plans at times of crisis for the Fianna Fáil Party when it is necessary to rouse their morale, but we hear virtually nothing about them at a later stage. I venture to say that the speech we heard from him this morning will be about as successful in providing the things people on all sides of the House desire as was his famous, or infamous, speech in Clery's Restaurant when he categorically promised he had a wonderful plan to provide 100,000 new jobs for our people. Of course, he never had any such plan. There was nothing there except a desire to take advantage of the fact that naturally everybody listening to him was anxious to see that employment would be provided.
Equally, today everyone of us wants to have economic growth balanced as well as it can be without straining our trade to a great degree. But the repetition of truisms, such as we heard from him today, are not any indication of a policy as such. The only indication we have of a policy is, first, what is included in this Finance Bill, and about which I shall have a word to say in a moment, and, secondly, that he believes that Government expenditure must go on rising and rising.
In an aside, the Taoiseach suggested that he now accepted and admitted that Fine Gael had a philosophy, although it was a philosophy of which he did not approve. We can all remember it is not very long since the Taoiseach was trying to say there was no place whatever for Fine Gael and that he was trying to court the Labour Party into a different policy. His normal form in this regard is to produce a statement of a principle with which everybody can agree but in respect of which he can produce no positive factual method of reaching a conclusion.
I gathered he was anxious for a scheme of greater capital investment. Greater capital investment on what? Greater capital investment on worthwhile projects that were going to increase employment and living standards throughout the country would obviously have the support not merely of every Deputy but of every person throughout the country. The fact is, of course, that the record of his Party in relation to capital investment has been a singularly unhappy one. During the years 1932 to 1939—I am not going to blame the Taoiseach for what happened during the war years—it is a fact which cannot be gainsaid that there was no capital investment of any sort in any worthwhile project undertaken by Fianna Fáil as a Government in that period.
It is a fact that cannot be gainsaid that the pattern Fianna Fáil were following after the emergency—the pattern initiated by the supplementary Budget of 1947—was the continuation of the anti-capital investment programme of the early 'Thirties. It was not until 1949 that there was any realisation by the Government at all of the necessity to have a vastly expanded capital programme, but one expanded on worthwhile projects. The changes that were made in 1949 were made in the teeth of Fianna Fáil opposition at that time, but they are changes that, having been made, have come to stay. I am glad they have come to stay. My regret, however, is that the record of performance in relation to capital investment by Fianna Fáil when in government has not been a very happy one.
As was indicated in an article in one of the papers this morning by a person who cannot be described as being a Fine Gael propagandist, the Taoiseach himself more than anyone else has been responsible for the failure of capital investment in relation to our transport. It is to him that that failure through the years must be mainly attributed. The whole problem in relation to capital investment has been not a desire by any Government since 1949 to refrain from State capital investment, but to find projects in which it was worth while to invest the people's money on behalf of the State—to find viable projects that would mean a permanent increase in employment and, therefore, in living standards.
The manner in which a vast sum was thrown away stupidly, instead of being invested productively, in Dundalk has already been discussed in this House. I am not going to anticipate a discussion in relation to a similar effort that will take place after this debate has finished. The fertiliser project which was recently started at Arklow was put up to us and was condemned by technical experts at that time as being a project that was not economically viable. The Government say that there has been a change since then, both in technical methods and in the economies of the project. When we asked them for particulars, they have taken the line of saying that it would be commercially harmful to the company for the change to be made public. In the circumstances, the Opposition have no option but to place the responsibility firmly on the backs of the Government. It must be on them alone that the responsibility for the investment lies.
It is a fact that cannot be gainsaid that no Government since the change in outlook in relation to capital investment in 1949 have ever refrained from making any capital investment because they were against a capital programme as such. The only tests that have been made were whether the project proposed was a viable project or was something that was not likely to produce permanent results. As I have said a second ago, the judgment of Fianna Fáil in relation to those projects has been sadly lacking.
On the income expenditure side, the Taoiseach also gave us an indication that we could look forward to nothing but increasing Government expenditure to be met from current account all the time. If increasing Government expenditure were to be met by increases in the national income so that the proportion of national income set aside for Government expenditure would remain more or less constant and at a reasonable fraction, no one would object to Government expenditure as such going on; but when Government current expenditure is allowed to outrun the increase in national income and to outrun the normal revenue buoyancy that comes from increases in national income, then the situation arises that such increases require the imposition of additional taxation which may well have the effect of retarding economic growth. If Government expenditure is so allowed to run ahead and taxation has accordingly to be increased beyond the limits, then the effect is not going to be a consistent and permanent growth. It may provide a temporary inflation and a temporary sense of well-being but it will not provide the conditions in which we can hope to have any permanent increase in our living standards.
This Finance Bill which we are discussing today and which we have been discussing for some considerable period is based on the fact that the Government have allowed that expenditure to get beyond the point at which it could be met by revenue buoyancy or by the increase in national income. The natural and inevitable corollary of the statement made by the Taoiseach this morning that Government expenditure on current account is going to go on increasing is that the turnover tax of 2½ per cent imposed in the Budget and in this Finance Bill will equally be increased by Fianna Fáil for the purpose of meeting that expenditure. One cannot go without the other. If the Government said categorically that they are going to go on increasing current income expenditure over and beyond that amount by which revenue buoyancy may come, then we see the real reason for the turnover tax was that it is a very simple tax to increase at any time. It is as well, as I said earlier, that the Taoiseach should have made his speech so that stripped of the verbiage, not merely we but the whole country can see the mentality behind the imposition of this tax. In my view, an increase in taxation of that sort outstripping any rises in national income or revenue buoyancy is going to prevent further growth rather than assist it.
I was rather surprised, too, that the Taoiseach when about to make a fundamental speech of that sort—if it was intended to be a fundamental speech —did not advert at all to one of the vital things in relation to our economic progress, in relation to our position regarding the Common Market, GATT and EFTA, and did not say where we are to go in relation to our external trade and economic conditions. It is a fact that we are in the position at the moment of being alone and isolated in economic and world trade. We are not a member of the Common Market. I may say at once that I agree and always agreed with the Taoiseach in the final decision, not with the kite that he flew about joining the Common Market if Britain did not join. I always agreed that it would be impossible to join if Britain did not join. We are not a member of it. We are not a member of GATT and yet at the same time, we are reducing our trade tariffs.
We are not a member of EFTA, and I do not think that there is any very great advantage per se for an agricultural country in joining EFTA, if that agricultural country is to maintain a tariff selection. But it seems now that what we are doing is remaining, willy-nilly and without any choice outside the European Economic Community, outside EFTA and outside the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, and at the same time, committing ourselves to a policy of complete tariff reduction without getting from that policy any benefit whatever in direct negotiations with the people who will benefit by it. That seems to me to be getting the worst of both worlds.
Let me say at once that I was all in favour of joining the European Economic Community, if that had been possible and if Britain had joined. Then we were going to move into a world in which there would be a dismantling of tariffs by ourselves, a dismantling that I agree may be inevitable in the future, but a dismantling of tariffs by us in return for a quid pro quo—for our possibility of access to a much greater market than that to which we are able to have access at the present moment.
I cannot understand where the Government want to go in this matter. I accept that the free world ultimately is moving towards a period of tariff reduction and freer trade. Everyone else in the world is moving towards that by dismantling of tariffs in exchange for other benefits. We could obtain other benefits in the EEC or even outside that community but we have preferred to take unilateral action in our dismantling. For example, we could have done some bargaining in this trading respect in the direct Government order placed in France of £250,000 for helicopters. That was a direct Government trade operation. They know the ratio of our trade with France is about seven to one against us. As the Minister for Defence and his colleagues acknowledge, no effort was made by the Government at that time to get any reciprocity for a very substantial Government contract. That is one type of example. Another is that we are apparently committed by the Government to short-term tariff reductions without any negotiations or bargain in any other country where that would assist us in getting something worthwhile for ourselves in exchange.
I agree that the free world is moving towards tariff reduction in the long run and it is obvious that the position will be such that we shall have to compete on far less favourable terms in some of our best markets, notably Britain. This is the time, knowing that, at which steps should be taken to try to ensure that this disadvantage will be overcome and yet I have seen no moves in that direction by the Government. Therefore, if the Taoiseach was going to branch out from the Finance Bill into a discussion on general economic growth, as he did this morning, clearly that is one of the sides on which he should have given some lead or explanation to the country.
So far as the possibility of increasing exports and the possibility of Irish private enterprise increasing productivity are concerned, this Finance Bill does not help at all. On the contrary, it deals it a body blow. The imposition of retrospective corporation profits tax to be paid out of reserves can only diminish the amount of those reserves that would be available for further expansion, modernisation and employment and better conditions of employment. If the policy was to reduce dividends, there is a simple way of doing that—or even holding of dividends—by imposing a distributed tax at a differential rate from an undistributed tax but the way it is being done rules out any possibility of that. The reserves that would have been there for modernisation, expansion and improvement of productivity, which we must have if we are to compete for markets, have been dealt a bad blow in this Finance Bill.
It is a truism that nothing in relation to industry can stand still. Unless industry can be constantly modernising it will not be able to hold its own, much less improve. Perhaps, to some extent the shock of tariff abolition may provide some shake-up towards competitiveness in industry but it will be as nothing compared to the benefits available if the Government had done their part in negotiating a counterpart of the reduction. The target for a dynamic economy must be not only to modernise and expand continuously —a fair amount has been done in relation to free equipment by grant inducement—but this Finance Bill will prevent a great part of the modernisation that should go with it.
Before the Budget, everybody thought what was needed was a Budget to encourage saving and investment and to encourage exports. There is little prospect of anything done in this Finance Bill encouraging any of those features unless the Minister claims for the turnover tax a discouragement of consumption. I should like to know when he is replying if he does make that claim.
I want to draw attention to the fact that the turnover tax, the main feature of the Budget, is allegedly modelled on the Swedish pattern. The Minister cannot deny that his justification everywhere for this type of tax is that it is modelled on the Swedish retail turnover tax. It is not quite the same but he says it is modelled on it. I was particularly interested, therefore, to read in Skandaniviska, a banking quarterly review, No. 2 of 1963, an article on the value-added tax, an entirely different tax, which suggests that Sweden is going away from the type of tax we are introducing towards the French value-added tax. In other words, having based our tax on the Swedish pattern, we now find that is going to be thrown overboard by Sweden as entirely out of date and unsuitable even for them. I am sure the Minister has in the Department this particular banking review.
Comment on this
No. The tax the Minister has introduced is the worst form of all broadly-based taxes. I said that long ago and I repeat it. The one he has introduced is the worst form of all and, as I say, it is apparently going to be thrown overboard now by Sweden. I say to the Minister that I am sure this is in his Department, if he has not seen it himself, because from such time as I was over there, I knew this quarterly existed. I have been able to get it ever since and it has perhaps some of the best economic articles to be read in any quarterly in a language which I can understand.
That article makes it clear, as does one by the Economist Intelligence Unit published last month in Britain, that the European Economic Community operates an entirely different type of tax from this and that in those countries in the EEC where they have a tax based on something like this, they are moving away from it and the commission has recommended that they would move away from it and go to the value added tax as in France which is an entirely different operation. I might say that one of the things the Economist Intelligence Unit reports is that the tax sur la valeur ajouté as practised in France applies generally to all transactions in goods except retail sales and the other members of the Six who have not got such a form as the valeur ajouté in France are all now moving towards the French model. The Swedes are thinking of leaving the model the Minister thought so wonderful. The Common Market Commission issued a draft directive in November, 1962, for the harmonisation of turnover taxes in the Common Market. The recommendation was for those countries to replace it within four years by a non-cumulative tax. After the fourth year, all States were recommended to move over to an added value tax. That was one of the reasons why I asked whether the Taoiseach was still of a mind to get the country ready for ultimate acceptance, as he hoped, into the EEC when he had taken something as his model that has been discarded.
Comment on this
Not at all. It shows how little the Parliamentary Secretary knows about it if he thinks it is the same.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary could not have read the one by the Economist Intelligence Unit or he would not say——
Comment on this
The difference is vital between the two because the added value tax is a tax on the "add back" of each individual trader over a period and therefore it is not a question of endeavouring to keep down to the fictional decimal coinage which Deputy Sherwin wants of half a farthing. It is done in a block system which is entirely different.
Comment on this
It is not a question of mechanics. It is a question of substituting a different form of tax for what we understand as profits tax here or across the water in Britain, because it is on that added value that the company has its profits. It is a different system and if it were not a different system, the directive issued by the Common Market Commission last November would have absolutely no meaning at all. The Minister himself deliberately chose this particular model and he could not have chosen a worse one. He has varied somewhat from his initial announcement and the result of the variation is a worse hybrid than the initial announcement produced because he will get the worst of both worlds. The only reason I mention that at this stage is that——
Comment on this
He does, of course. Has he not voted for it? He also approves of the statement of the Taoiseach that Government current expenditure will rise over and above the rise in income and buoyancy.
Comment on this
He implied that beyond question. The Taoiseach said that anybody who believes that current expenditure was not going to go on increasing——
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is a very cute politician and he will not say something that can be quoted against him to slit his own throat, but he could not have meant all the things he said without one implying the other. It could not have been done. Everybody knows that is what he did mean. The Minister for Finance will enlighten the Parliamentary Secretary that the reason for the Bill we are discussing is that Government current expenditure has outrun the increase in national income and revenue buoyancy. Speaking from recollection, I would say the revenue buoyancy was £8 million this year but Government expenditure was greater, and we are told by the Taoiseach this morning that that pattern must continue. There was nothing else anybody could infer or draw from any of his statements.
The Taoiseach has told us, too, that we need an incomes policy and that he hoped to have one. The Government have been asked to provide an incomes policy for a long time and they have not done it because it is only recently they have realised the difference between an incomes policy and a wages policy. Their line of country has been to concentrate on restriction in wages alone and to forget about all the other constituent parts of an incomes policy. That is why they have been so unsuccessful. That is why there has been no balanced growth. I think they do realise, since the provocative publication of their White Paper in February, that an incomes policy governs more than pure wages, though they seem to be still inclined to fasten on the wages part alone, an incomes policy that should, in our circumstances of the necessity to expand exports, mean a reduction in our high-cost economy, this already high cost economy, which even the Parliamentary Secretary cannot deny, but, instead of that, the effect of this Bill will be, unfortunately, to put it even higher, and that will not help our competitiveness in relation to exports. We must be competitive if we are to survive at all.
The Taoiseach told us it is his desire to have widespread understanding of the policy he is adumbrating. I do not think there is a person in the House who will deny that the easiest, the best, and the most thorough way, of having widespread understanding of the policy of any political Party is to have that understanding tested in a general election. If the Taoiseach and the Parliamentary Secretary believe, as they pretend to believe, in the success of their policies, will they put them to the test? The result will be that they will get a much greater hammering than they got in North East Dublin. If the Taoiseach is honest, and if he is not being hypocritical in saying that the public will understand what they have in mind, there is an easy way to test that understanding, and one which we will welcome, and we have made it clear that we will welcome it.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary like to set an example? If he resigns his seat, we will test it in Roscommon.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Party know they are on the defensive. They know the country is itching to get a chance to give a verdict on this performance.
Comment on this
The people resent the tax of which the Parliamentary Secretary is now such an ardent protagonist, although he previously said it would affect only fur coats, and something else. The people resent the fact that this tax is being placed on the necessaries of life in exactly the same degree as it is being placed on fur coats. The people resent the fact that this tax will be completely unworkable, except in one degree. It will operate in the place of the dance tax.
We always said that a dance tax was workable, and Fianna Fáil always said it was not workable. I am glad that to that extent they have been converted to our view. The Minister is insisting on imposing this tax on sales that are effected between 1st August and 1st November on the credit, and paid for after 1st November. On the other hand, the person who has got the funds to anticipate can anticipate as much as he likes.
The tax will be unworkable because the divisions in our coinage are not percentage divisions. It will cost infinitely more than the one per cent that is being suggested. The reason that one per cent is being suggested is that the cost of administration will be used as an income tax cost rather than a sales tax cost. I suspect that the official purpose of this tax is not so much to have a one per cent administration cost, as the Minister has indicated, but to utilise a series of cross-references so that the cost of administration will, in fact, be met out of income tax cost and the cross references used for the purpose of verifying income tax returns.
I am informed this morning for the first time that the tax will have the effect of taking away from certain charitable institutions, rehabilitation institutions, more than the benefit the Minister alleges he is giving them under Section 97. The people do not want this tax. This is a financial and fiscal policy which was never envisaged at the time of the last general election. It is retrospective in certain respects, although in 1958 the Minister agreed that he would never introduce retrospective taxation again. It is an imposition on the necessaries of life which everyone would have shuddered at if challenged about it in October of the year before last. The only honest thing any honourable Government can do in these circumstances is not to take a referendum on this issue, but to submit themselves to a referendum of the people.
Comment on this
In the course of this debate and particularly because of remarks made by Deputy Sweetman, it is opportune and timely for the Fine Gael Party to get a lesson in the essential mechanics of democratic constitutional Government.
Comment on this
The first lesson is a very elementary one. Parliamentary constitutional democracy depends on a representative system. The people send their delegates here to Parliament to legislate and work for them.
Comment on this
The Fine Gael Party Deputies are here on that principle; Independent Deputies are here on that principle; and I am here on that principle. Unless that system is to degenerate into anarchy or chaos——
Comment on this
——it must be acknowledged that periodically and at regular intervals, elections are held at which the will of the people is sought. That will is expressed in the ballot boxes and it is reflected in Parliament.
Comment on this
Parliament then proceeds to elect a Government. That Government has been delegated its governmental functions by Parliament to whom the people have delegated their functions.
Comment on this
We are here on that basis and unless Parliamentary institutions here or in any other democratic country are to degenerate into chaos, the majority of the elected representatives of the people must elect a Government to govern.
Comment on this
Deputy Collins has been in and out of Parliament so often that he is now unhappy that he is, not in the Fianna Fáil Party or in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, but in a new jazzed-up version of the Irish Party.
Comment on this
I have my tradition. You have none. My family established this State. Yours did nothing to help it. Answer that if you like.
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman, and Deputy Norton the other night, offered us an entirely new notion of parliamentary institutions that when there is anything contentious, anything on which the Government must make a decision, it must be referred to the people in the form of a referendum or a general election. There is no obligation on this Government—or on any other Government; I will hand you that—to submit every item of legislation to the will of the people. We have been, through the members of this House, appointed to govern the country.
Comment on this
Three Independents were intimidated into going with you. One of them said it was the best Budget he ever heard.
Comment on this
Let the Parliamentary Secretary not get cross. Let him answer without losing his temper.
Comment on this
Some Deputies will vote without being paid. Deputy Flanagan does not understand that. He thinks they must be paid to vote.
Comment on this
We can remember the time when Deputy Flanagan was going about Laois-Offaly churning out money in the form of Monetary Reform.
Comment on this
It is necessary in this House to emphasise that we have the responsibility for governing.
Comment on this
I cannot allow this kind of interruption or we will not get on with this debate at all.
Comment on this
On this side of the House, despite our endeavours to establish among our people a constructive appreciation of the situation which now faces the Government, we have been faced and are faced at this minute——
Comment on this
——by a highly destructive approach by the Fine Gael Party. They have made no attempt during the debate on the Finance Bill to advance any alternative taxation system——
Comment on this
——in order to obtain the economic expansion which we need. The Fine Gael Party purport to be an alternative Government in this country.
Comment on this
The difference between the Fine Gael Party and the Fianna Fáil Party is a very simple one. We face up to our responsibility and believe when we are enjoined by the people to govern that we should govern. We do not intend to founder in the way previous Fine Gael and Coalition Governments foundered in the past. We do not intend to scuttle in the way the Coalition Government scuttled in February, 1957, although they had theoretically got the support they needed to carry on business.
Comment on this
Do not take me on on your father. He was a decent member of the National Army and so was Deputy Haughey's father.
Comment on this
I will not leave the House but if anyone provokes me, I will challenge him and answer him.
Comment on this
You were not in the Army either, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. It was a Collins who founded the National Army and who secured the freedom of the country. Tell that to anybody you like. Tell that to the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
I think the Fine Gael Party had a fairly good scheme by which they submitted Deputies like Deputy Collins to a course of rehabilitation in 1957 and in 1961. They had him under some such rehabilitation in some limbo in West Cork. At the present time he is back but on his present performance I would say that he was due another such course of rehabilitation.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary, I think, is inviting observations from this side of the House.
Comment on this
We, by virtue of the decision of the Irish people, find ourselves in the position in 1963 that we must devise taxation which is necessary in order to achieve further expansion and achieve by 1970 a total national income of £1,000 million, an increase in national income of 30 per cent in accordance with the four and five per cent rises in national income since the initiation of the Programme for Economic Expansion in 1958. We must decide whether we want to go forward as we have done since 1958 or whether we do not. We have come down definitely on this basis. We believe that in order to achieve the standard of living and the economic growth to sustain that standard in our community planning is necessary. Since 1958 we have had a certain success in the working out of the Programme for Economic Expansion first published in that year. We have exceeded by more than 100 per cent the target set. Inside the coming months the full details of our new programme for economic expansion designed to achieve the targets I have mentioned will be published.
In the achievement of any such targets, in the achievement of the progress we desire in the working out of the economic expansion and development of our community, one thing is clearly necessary in our circumstances; that is a continued involvement by the Government in all such expansion. It is quite clear that in our circumstances the Government, no matter what Government it is, must take a positive lead in all economic expansion. By reason of our late start in the industrial race this is one of the facts of life as far as this country is concerned. If the State is to take such a positive lead in the economic expansion and development of our community it is essential to devise a taxation system which will yield to the State the revenue necessary for such expansion.
Comment on this
It all comes down to one essential principle and a recognition of that principle; we in Ireland today must plan and work ahead for economic expansion; secondly, the State must play a positive part in that work of, first, planning and, secondly, providing the capital to ensure that both the private and the public sectors play their part in such planning. Lastly, we must devise here the necessary taxation measures designed to yield the revenue for this overall purpose.
This Finance Bill must be viewed in that context. Nobody here will deny that there are many improvements needed over various sectors of our economic life. I referred on the Second Stage, and again on the Committee Stage, to one particular field—the field of education. The Minister for Education has announced the policy proposals he is working on at the moment, proposals designed to ensure a broad range of technical and technological education for our people, a type of education we need here to gear the country over the 'sixties and the 'seventies, a type of education designed to ensure that the ordinary man's child can acquire through the technical school and the technological college the technical and other qualifications which are in such great demand in the world today.
Comment on this
That type of educational policy will, of course, need further financial assistance by way of scholarship development. More financial assistance will be needed to set on foot the extended scope of the institutions necessary to provide the technical and technological education. All of these could use to the full the entire amount which can be garnered in one year from the turnover tax alone. I would not be satisfied with an increased expenditure of £11,500,000, which is the increase we hope to get from the turnover tax, on education. I feel even more could be spent in this field alone in the 'sixties by any State anxious to equip itself as it should be equipped for the world today. I can go through various other fields where the State must and will have to in future take a positive lead. A Land Bill has been introduced here. We will take the Second Stage of that Bill after the Recess.
Comment on this
In any progressive attempt to get down to the roots of the land distribution problem, much more money needs to be spent. Under the proposed new Bill, I envisage the Land Commission taking increased powers to engage in the acquisition and distribution of land. That inevitably will require more finance. It goes without saying that any attempt to put the Land Commission on a sound basis and equip it with the necessary powers to adopt a more progressive distribution policy in regard to land must require extra money. If the Land Commission is to function as it is envisaged it should function under the proposed Bill it will require at least another £2 million a year to carry out its job and perform its functions.
Comment on this
It has been doing its job, but I feel it can do more. The purpose of the Bill is to give the Land Commission increased powers and, consequentially, the increased finances necessary to carry on a proper distribution policy, particularly in the congested areas.
Comment on this
Education, land policy, agriculture. In regard to agriculture it is acknowledged that there is a disparity——
Comment on this
——which has arisen in recent years between urban and farm incomes. We must aim at an agricultural policy which will reduce that disparity.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary's Government have been aiming at that for the past 20 years and have not hit the target yet.
Comment on this
In regard to industry, we have to work out a balanced incomes policy. I was glad to hear Deputy Sweetman speak about this. That policy will have to be worked out within the broad framework of economic policy generally. That is why——
Comment on this
——the Government are asking employers and trade unions to come together in the council which is in the process of being established and which will help towards the forward planning of our economy for the 'sixties and the 'seventies within the broad framework of our development. In that broad framework of our national economy the industrial council and the trade union and employer representatives can help the Government to work out a balanced incomes policy.
Comment on this
Aiming at certain targets for increase in the national income, trade unions and employers can hammer out an incomes policy directly related to anticipated increases in productivity.
Comment on this
If there were a tax on ráiméis, the Parliamentary Secretary would be worth a million. Will he say something specific about something?
Comment on this
It is here the new council can perform a very real function. Again, this is a matter which will require additional Government finance and Government assistance in the future. In regard to the sphere of social welfare legislation, I agree with many members of the Labour Party and with the National Progressive Democrats——
Comment on this
——that social welfare legislation could be put on a more rational basis, a basis which would provide greater good for our people. Again, it is a question of finance.
Comment on this
What, in the Parliamentary Secretary's opinion, should social welfare be related to?
Comment on this
I would relate social welfare increases, income increases, and all necessary increases for the welfare of the community to the framework of an over-all national plan.
Comment on this
I would ask Deputies to cease this barrage. The Parliamentary Secretary is entitled to speak just as other Deputies.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is agreeable to hearing me. I merely want to ask him would he relate tax revenue to tax income?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary was told to leave Deputy Collins alone if he wants to be left alone.
Comment on this
The Labour Party is rightly concerned with the future planning of our economy and how we are to achieve the targets we propose to set out in the new Programme for Economic Expansion in the various sectors. They are concerned and we are concerned that one thing necessary to ensure the future of this State is a broadly-based system of taxation that will yield the revenue necessary to carry out the plans in the fields I have mentioned—in education, in agriculture, in industry, in social welfare legislation. To carry out the improvements in these sectors so often advanced by those people who are concerned with them, there is one thing necessary, that is, that the State in our circumstances, and charged with the responsibility of ensuring those improvements, will have a steady flow of revenue coming in to ensure that these various functions are discharged. The issue is as simple as that. It comes to the simple issue that people are expected to face up to the fact that improvement is necessary and if improvement is necessary, the taxation measures to sustain that improvement must be devised.
Comment on this
——is an alternative taxation system designed to yield the revenue we hope to obtain from the turnover tax. What we want from the Labour Party or anyone else who expresses criticism is a concrete suggestion as to how the alternative revenue can be obtained for the purposes we mention. The Labour Party and ourselves are with each other, as it were, on the forward looking planning that is so necessary to our State today. They are with us on the need for the improvements I have mentioned in the sectors I have mentioned. I say to them that they have not gone the whole way and faced up to their responsibility. We have faced up to our responsibilities and devised the necessary taxation system to yield the revenue to carry out the proposals and objectives which we seek.
We have nothing but contempt for the Fine Gael Party. Fundamentally, they are not with us. They are not with us in planning for economic expansion and more equitable social services. The Fine Gael Party are essentially negative, opportunist and expedient. They are not planning ahead; they are merely concerned with the immediate, narrow objective of dislodging the present Government.
Comment on this
The aim and ambition of the Fine Gael Party do not go beyond that immediate narrow objective of dislodging the Government. We have heard proposals from the Labour Party, particularly regarding education. We have heard constructive suggestions as to future planning in regard to national economic policy. We have not heard anything of that nature from the Fine Gael Party who, as I say, are concerned with the narrow expedient of dislodging the Government.
Comment on this
I dealt with that very fully on the constitutional issue. The people have expressed themselves. They expressed themselves last October 12 months.
Comment on this
The expression of their will resides in the fact that there is a Government here today to govern the country.
Comment on this
I was honest about it anyway. There was not a single word about the turnover tax in the last general election.
Comment on this
At the risk of repeating myself, I feel that it is again necessary to point out to Deputy Flanagan the essential nature of the constitutional system, that this Government or any other Government, or any political Party facing the electorate are not required to tell the electors in full what they propose to do.
Comment on this
The main plank on which we fought the last election was the Programme for Economic Expansion initiated in 1958. We asked for a mandate to continue that work. That was the mandate we sought from the people and in accordance with that mandate, we, as the people's representatives, have the duty and obligation to devise the necessary taxation measures which we consider necessary to ensure that that programme is carried out.
Comment on this
I have mentioned the various improvements which we seek, and which the Labour Party seek, in various sectors of our economy.
Comment on this
Apart from that, there is one basic requisite for any Government and without it, it cannot hope to succeed.
Comment on this
That is the creation of a climate of confidence. Most logical people would agree that what we have done since 1957, what Time referred to last week——
Comment on this
What Time referred to last week was that since 1957 a new climate of confidence has been created in this country. How has that been done?
Comment on this
It has been done on essential principles again concerned with the constitutional question of government. Since 1957——
Comment on this
It cost about £537 to erect a mahogany, silver-topped tall hat cabinet up in the Park.
Comment on this
A desperate tall story. All his life Deputy Flanagan has been at it. He is the most acknowledged tall story writer and teller in this country.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it in order for the Minister for Finance to say a lie has been told here. He said a lie was uttered here.
Comment on this
The Deputy will resume his seat. I would remind him this is the national Parliament and that this sort of conduct can only bring it into disrepute.
Comment on this
I shall go on to another constitutional lesson. It concerns the behaviour now of the Fine Gael Party. If anything is calculated to bring this Parliament into disrepute, as you, Sir, feared, it is the behaviour of some of the comic people the Fine Gael Party have transferred to their Front Benches in the past few months. All the comic artists in that Party find themselves in the Front Benches under the circus master who does not happen to be here at the moment.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it in order for the Parliamentary Secretary to describe a Deputy as a circus master?
Comment on this
That is a matter for the Chair to decide, anyway. Is it in order for the Parliamentary Secretary to describe a member of this House as a circus master?
Comment on this
Surely the Chair is not going to allow the Parliamentary Secretary to refer to the Leader of the Opposition as a circus master?
Comment on this
I was not aware the Parliamentary Secretary referred to the Leader of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
He named him in my hearing. He named Deputy Dillon when he was asked whom he was referring to as a circus master.
Comment on this
Did he or did he not name Deputy Dillon when he was asked who the circus master was?
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Parliamentary Secretary has denied to us now that he named Deputy Dillon. I heard him do so and I am asking him, through you, Sir, did he or did he not name Deputy Dillon as a circus master?