Finance Bill, 1963—Fifth Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 438–681 of 681. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 14 of 1963 ›
I do not think so. The then Taoiseach said there was going to be another war, that it was just around the corner but: "We have a plan to keep you out again."
Comment on this
He won the general election in 1943, and lo and behold, there was another general election in 1944.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it not a fact that the Minister for Finance has stated that the former Taoiseach kept this country out of the war, and is it not a fact that the present Taoiseach is trying to embroil the country——
Comment on this
We come now to the 1948 general election. There was another plan, but this time the people did not fall for it.
Comment on this
Towards the end of that Dáil, the Taoiseach decided he would go to a dance in Clery's Ballroom. When the dance was over, he decided he would produce another plan known as the Clery's Ballroom plan, but this was the best plan of all, because the plan he produced in Clery's Ballroom was nothing less than 100,000 new jobs in five years, if he could get back. The Irish Press got to work and they published his speech in a free supplement for every reader and the plan he made when he was jigging around Clery's Ballroom. Lo and behold, if he did not get back——
Comment on this
The biggest joke, as the Parliamentary Secretary says, was that there were no 100,000 new jobs. All he wanted was votes, and he got votes, and the whole country which was expecting 100,000 new jobs could go and dance the same jig as he had danced in Clery's Ballroom the night he announced his great plan. There was never a word about the 100,000 new jobs since.
The next thing was that there was another plan. At the last general election, from every platform the Taoiseach said he was going to stop emigration and reduce the cost of living, but he never once said that there was to be a turnover or purchase tax. Since the Government got such a hiding from the people without mentioning a purchasing tax, what would they get today if they went to the people and mentioned a turnover tax? After 20 years' experience in this House, I know very well that Fianna Fáil will try to hang on to office as long as they can.
Comment on this
The Government are afraid to put this issue to the country. When I listen to Deputy Corry and Deputy Burke, I am reminded of a person whistling loudly while passing a graveyard. They are whistling loudly tonight saying there will not be a general election because of Deputy Lenehan and Deputy Sherwin. They will try to hold on as long as they can. I accuse the Government of cowardice. They are windy and afraid. They are afraid to look for a mandate from the people because this issue was already tested. The only election that took place since the turnover tax was mentioned was the by-election in Dublin where the Government were completely and entirely disgraced. I venture to say that there is no constituency in Ireland in which what took place in the recent by-election in Dublin would not be repeated.
Many people would like a general election before this tax is implemented, but I would prefer to see the tax going ahead for a short while and then have a general election, because the people will not fully understand the tax until they feel the pinch. When they feel the pinch, they will know who is responsible. As I have said before, if the people sow nettles, they cannot expect roses to grow. People get the type of Government they deserve. If the people voted for a Fianna Fáil Government at the last general election, what could they expect, judging them on their record since 1932? Our country must be the greatest in the world, because there are no other people who would survive under such a rotten administration for the past 30 years. The only progress that was made in this country was made during the terms of office of the inter-Party Governments.
Comment on this
Taxation was reduced; the cost of living was reduced; the price of foodstuffs went down——
Comment on this
The old age pensions went up two or three times. There was the Prices Advisory Body and control of prices which kept them within reach. A million acres of arable land were created as a result of the land rehabilitation scheme.
Comment on this
Yes. I want to repeat that because I feel some Deputies did not understand what I said. As a result of that scheme, land was created. Land which contained furze, bushes, rushes and rocks, land which was too bad to grow weeds, is now producing food for man and beast as a result of the inter-Party Government. There was the Local Authorities (Works) Act that drained the land and gave work to every county council worker in Ireland. It was scrapped by Fianna Fáil the minute they got into office, with the result that every county council in Ireland had to increase their rates to make up for the Local Authorities (Works) Act money which we were giving them and which we will give them when we get back again.
Comment on this
We propose to reintroduce the Local Authorities (Works) Act. The Voluntary Health Insurance Scheme was advocated and inaugurated by the inter-Party Government. Deputies opposite know better than anybody else that the only years of real progress were the years they were out of office and they are mad jealous. That is why they are so crickety. They do not like to hear these things and they are mad jealous.
When I see the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands touring the country and welcoming tourists to fish in our lakes, I notice that he never once refers to the fact that it was Deputy Dillon who instituted the Inland Fisheries Trust that makes it possible for him to make his important speeches today.
Comment on this
I hear the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce taking credit for factories but it was Deputy Sweetman who gave the tax concessions to commence those factories. The Government had nothing whatever to do with the tax concessions.
Comment on this
Those tax concessions were responsible for starting those factories. I remember that Mr. Dan Morrissey when Minister for Industry and Commerce was responsible for the Industrial Development Authority. There was no more bitter opponent of it than the present Taoiseach and every Fianna Fáil Deputy listening who was here in the House at that time. All opposed it but the very moment the change of Government came, the Taoiseach and the Minister for Industry and Commerce could not be loud enough in their praise of the Industrial Development Authority.
I really feel that the Fianna Fáil Party are envious. They are a group of envious men. They envy this side of the House their outstanding record. May I say for the record of the House that I do not wish to deny the Labour Party credit for the part they played as honourable patriotic men with the interest of the country at heart and for the contribution Labour Ministers made to that great inter-Party Government?
Comment on this
May I say again for the record that while we have had great Ministers for Local Government, the greatest and best who will go down in history is the late Tim Murphy. Deputies on all sides of the House will and must agree with that.
We do not believe a single word of what the Taoiseach said this morning. The country does not believe it. He knows in his heart that he made that speech for the purpose of rallying all the uneasy 69 or 70 behind him. Is it not true that over the length and breadth of the country it is now found impossible to call a meeting of any Fianna Fáil Comhairle Ceantair as a result of the turnover tax?
Comment on this
Is it not true that the Minister for Finance was not allowed to speak in his own constituency within the past month?
Comment on this
That is an old trick of Fianna Fáil Ministers. Every Fianna Fáil Minister has the same complaint against the Press. He was wrongly reported, a twist was put on what he said, an important word was left out, a "t" was not crossed or an "i" was not dotted. They are always wrongly reported when it does not suit them.
Comment on this
He would have a bit of a job to keep up with the standard set up by the boys on your side.
Comment on this
I do not propose to detain the House any longer. I have made my protest. I appreciate every syllable uttered here by the Leader of the Opposition. The country is behind Deputy Dillon and the House knows it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Parliamentary Secretary is sitting outside the House and he is continually interrupting Deputy Flanagan. If he wants to interrupt or address the Chair, he should take his seat.
Comment on this
On behalf of every shopkeeper in Laois-Offaly, big and small, I want to express open disapproval: the firm of D. E. Williams, Tullamore, P. & H. Egan, Tullamore, staff, managers and employees, M. P. O'Brien, Edenderry, branch houses, staff, managers and employees, the firm of Jessop & Co., Portlaoise, and every other firm in every town in the counties of Laois and Offally—I venture to say that some of these firms have already closed down some of their branch houses——
Comment on this
D. E. Williams have three or four branches closed down already. Do Deputies want any more information?
Comment on this
I venture to say there are thousands of small shopkeepers in business today who will close down as a result of this tax. It will put them out of business. Mark you, the Government are out to close up the small shopkeeper and put him out of business. This tax was designed by the friend of the millionaire ice cream merchant for no other purpose than to put the small shopkeepers of Dublin and of the country generally out of business. The more shops there are for sale in O'Connell Street, the cheaper the ice cream merchant will get them.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I ask you, Sir, did you hear that interjection of the Parliamentary Secretary's?
Comment on this
Do not run away from it. You have said occasionally that people here have a red streak in them. You have a yellow streak.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I suggest that the Chair must have heard the remark of the Parliamentary Secretary and the Parliamentary Secretary should be asked either to withdraw it or else withdraw from the House.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has stated he did not call Deputy Oliver Flanagan a perjurer. The Chair must accept that.
Comment on this
I have raised a point of order. The Parliamentary Secretary used the word "perjurer"——
Comment on this
My point of order is that the Parliamentary Secretary has not denied using the word "perjurer" in relation to a Deputy.
Comment on this
That is a matter of concern to every Deputy, and the Parliamentary Secretary must be asked to withdraw or else withdraw from the House.
Comment on this
The Chair has already informed Deputy O'Higgins that the Parliamentary Secretary replied to that that he did not call Deputy Oliver Flanagan a perjurer. The Chair must accept the Parliamentary Secretary's word.
Comment on this
Might I suggest, Sir, that you ask for the record because I have been in the House all the time and I did not hear the Parliamentary Secretary say he was not referring to a member of this House.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary was not referring to the Deputy who was speaking, to what Deputy was he referring?
Comment on this
I suggest that the way the Chair is leaving it at the moment is that we are all being accused by the Parliamentary Secretary, and I do not think that should be allowed to stay on the record.
Comment on this
I have enjoyed it for 21 years and, please God, I will enjoy it for 21 more and, when I fade away, I hope my son will take my place to continue against Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Yes, a doctor, and as good a man as myself. I was saying before the learned doctor arrived to intervene——
Comment on this
If the Minister for Health makes any more remarks while I am on my feet, I will make it the sad and sorry night he came into the House.
Comment on this
Listen, Flanagan, I know all about you from the beginning, from the time when you took bobs in the Fianna Fáil cumann to write letters to the Land Commission.
Comment on this
Order. Time is running out. Would Deputies allow Deputy Oliver Flanagan to speak? There are only 35 minutes left.
Comment on this
There is no Deputy or Minister in this House will silence me, or muzzle me either—not the Tánaiste, the Taoiseach or Minister for Finance, and least of all, the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Lenihan.
Comment on this
The strange thing is that this ass has a valuable foal in the House as well. Now that we have the Tánaiste in the House, I want to say that the Government are windy and cowardly. If they were not cowardly, they would be sufficiently courageous men to put this issue to the people, but they cannot do it and they will not do it because they have the wind up.
Comment on this
There is one further question I should like to ask and I should like to ask it without interruption. This proposal in this Bill is being brought in against the wishes of the people. The people should know the hidden facts behind it. The House is entitled to have these facts. The House should know the facts.
Comment on this
From the Government. I should like to know if the Press reports are correct or will the Minister for Finance deny them again? Will he deny that he interviewed Deputy Sherwin in connection with the batch bread and that he gave certain assurances to Deputy Sherwin that satisfied Deputy Sherwin to vote for this Bill? I should like to know if the papers published that interview correctly because this House is entitled to know what bargaining took place between the Minister for Finance and Deputy Sherwin and the only occasion on which we can get that information is on this Bill. Surely the Minister for Finance heard the rumours afloat in this city that both Deputy Sherwin and Deputy Leneghan got £3,500 cash for their votes. That is the rumour in this city and I want the Minister to tell the House if——
Comment on this
I should like a sworn inquiry into whether or not that is true so that the good name of this House will not be dragged in the mud any longer. The Deputy has stated he was offered £5,000. I demand a sworn inquiry as to who offered it and on whose behalf it was offered.
Comment on this
On a point of order, a specific allegation has been made by Deputy Flanagan that there was corruption on the part of a member of this House. I feel this matter is one for investigation by the Committee of Procedure and Privileges and should be referred to them by the Chair. It is a matter of concern to the House generally that irresponsible allegations of that nature should not be made without proper substantiation and proof. This is a matter which concerns the House generally and everybody's integrity in the House and to that extent I am with Deputy McQuillan.
Comment on this
If there is any reference to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges, I trust that the conduct of the Parliamentary Secretary will also be discussed.
Comment on this
Deputy McQuillan has made a suggestion to the Chair and would the Chair be good enough to give us a decision?
Comment on this
The suggestion made by Deputy McQuillan and the Parliamentary Secretary will be considered by the Chair.
Comment on this
When the Chair is taking a note of this, would he take a note of Deputy Flanagan's statement which he now reiterates that he heard rumours of this kind and one of the matters which should be investigated is from whom did he hear these rumours?
Comment on this
What makes the thing more serious is the admission by Deputy Leneghan that he was offered £5,000.
Comment on this
May I continue, Sir? I cannot understand that when I get up to speak, I draw anger from every member of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I am entitled to speak, provided I speak in accordance with your orders, Sir, and in accordance with procedure and no one will muzzle me on this Bill.
Comment on this
Having referred to the rumours which are in circulation, a Government denial should be made and the general public should be consulted in a general election on this issue. Again, in connection with this Bill, there is a rumour widely circulating in this House that Deputy Sherwin has been given an IRA pension which is retrospective for the past four or five years.
Comment on this
That is a damned lie. I was crippled and tortured in 1922, now that you have raised the matter.
Comment on this
We want and we stand for cleanliness in public life and freedom of speech. We stand for honesty and decency and we stand for everything that is four-square with the electorate. The electors are our masters and we are always prepared to accept their verdict, whether it is for us or against us. Our history goes back to the earliest days when they always took the majority vote of the people—always. They always accepted the verdict of the people. You are afraid of the verdict of the people.
Comment on this
You are cowardly about the verdict of the people. I feel this is a Bill which we cannot debate with kid gloves on. This is a Bill on which we must fight, which must be exposed to the last letter. This is a treacherous Bill, a bad Bill, an insane Bill and an unsound Bill. It is a Bill——
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister for Finance is listening attentively to what I have to say. This Bill is evilly conceived and evilly disposed and it is a Bill which is being passed by the majority of this House, with a majority vote of the people against the Government. Every voter in the last election who voted for Deputy Sherwin and Deputy Leneghan had Fianna Fáil candidates to vote for on the panel if they wanted Fianna Fáil, but they voted against them by voting for Deputy Sherwin and Deputy Leneghan. Therefore the Irish people are being betrayed in this Bill. They voted against Fianna Fáil by voting for the two men who are plunging this country into an additional £13½ million unnecessary taxation.
Comment on this
Locke's put you out. You went out flying in 1948 after that. Everyone in this House knows that this taxation is unnecessary and that already this Government have put on £63 million taxation since they got back into office. Despite that, there is record unemployment and emigration, and depression in agriculture. Today the farmers are begging. They cannot sell their wheat. They cannot sell their oats. They cannot sell their barley. They can sell nothing they produce. Fairs are becoming depressed and there was no effort by the Government to negotiate properly with the British to guarantee prices for farmers' livestock and produce. England is our nearest neighbour, the best consuming public in the world, the best people for agricultural produce.
Members of this Government went over to England and came back with their hands hanging. No wonder British members of Parliament are ashamed of those who go there with ministerial rank to negotiate on behalf of the Irish people. Is it any wonder that recently it was publicly stated that the only man who ever went over, with commonsense, ability and intelligence, went there in 1948—John A. Costello, with Daniel Morrissey and James Dillon. This Government are bankrupt of policy, of ideas for the future; they are stagnant, backward. The first time the Irish electors get a chance they will wipe them off the face of the political map forever. We have been reading the speeches of different Ministers almost every weekend to the effect that we never had it so good, that the people were never more prosperous. Side by side with those speeches was the report in recent months that we were one of the most backward countries in the world today, thanks to Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
That report placed this country on a level with countries where starvation and extreme poverty are rampant. If that is the progress some of our Ministers are talking about, it is not what we in Fine Gael consider progress. I admit this is a good Government for the Ministers.
Comment on this
They have their racehorses; they are living in the lap of luxury, very far removed from the blind and the lame and the sick, far from the old age pensioners. They are concerned only about the millionaire types, their companions about whom we read so much every weekend.
To come back to this disgraceful Bill, I would go so far as to assert that in no other democracy in the world would such a measure be perpetrated without first consulting the electorate. Deputy Norton suggested a referendum. They are afraid of a referendum after the fate of the last one when they tried to steal the votes of the people so that Fianna Fáil would provide the Government in saecula saeculorum. The Irish people, thanks to the trade unions and to every other section of the community, gave them their answer. They were beaten badly on that.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is the Parliamentary Secretary to be allowed to refer to a Deputy as a perjurer?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary may not address a Deputy in that manner. The remark must be withdrawn.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary obey the ruling of the Chair? I understand the Chair to give a ruling to the Parliamentary Secretary and I am now asking whether he will obey it.
Comment on this
A Deputy may not be addressed as a perjurer. A charge has been made by the Parliamentary Secretary and it must be withdrawn.
Comment on this
Was not a definite ruling given by the Chair that the remark must be withdrawn? The Parliamentary Secretary has not obeyed the Chair.
Comment on this
Have I the right to ask that Deputy Flanagan withdraws his allegation about me? If I have not the right to do it now, I shall claim that right later.
Comment on this
You will not get away with it. It is in black and white what you are. Have I the liberty to explain what I mean?
Comment on this
I would rather have him on my side than the Parliamentary Secretary. At least he has the courage to say what he thinks.
Comment on this
I sympathise with you, Sir, that the House has fallen into such disorder. Deputy McGilligan is now trying to tell the House about the votes I got. I do not like that, for I am a humble man.
Comment on this
The people tried him. He got the biggest first preference vote given in the general election.
Comment on this
Even though I beat Mr. de Valera once, I am a humble man and I shall not brag about it.
I was dealing, before these rude interruptions, with the question of the referendum. It was suggested by a Deputy that this issue should be put to a referendum of the people. This is an important and an urgent issue. I respectfully say that equally as much afraid as the Government are of a general election, they are clouded in cowardice on this issue. Every single one of them, without exception, has cold feet.
Comment on this
I challenge any Fianna Fáil Deputy in my constituency to resign from this House along with me.
Comment on this
If all the Deputies for Laois-Offaly resign, I shall gladly do so and they will come back one or two less.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I want to ask a question in relation to a remark by the Tánaiste. Are the Government prepared to have a general election if they are defeated in a by-election arising on this? If they are, any Deputy on these benches will provide them with the opportunity.
Comment on this
A question was put to me and I presume I may answer the question. The Government will abide by the Constitution. So long as they have the support of a majority in this House, they intend to govern in spite of slanders and people whose veracity has been found to be unbelievable.
Comment on this
Since the Tánaiste has now satisfied himself by his latest explosion, I may continue. From the point of view of the Government, a referendum is out of the question and a general election is out of the question because they are afraid. I want to deal with what I consider to be the most dangerous aspect entirely of this Bill, that is, the right of any civil servant to break the bond of confidence between a bank and a customer. Here we see that in this Bill the secrecy and confidence that has always prevailed between the business man, between the farmer, aye, and the thrifty labourer if he has £1 in the bank, and the bank no longer exists. I put it to you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that there is a political move behind this, as well.
Comment on this
There have been widespread withdrawals of deposits from the banks and it is only right that people who have money on deposit in the bank should know that the Government have a right now fully to investigate their affairs and to impose taxes upon them.
Comment on this
That is the type of legislation you would expect from Khrushchev. That is the type of legislation you would expect Fidel Castro to implement. That is the type of legislation you would expect Marshal Tito to implement. But when you have Tito and Castro and Khrushchev all together in Fianna Fáil, it is only right that those who have money in this country should know that, from any church gate now, any Fianna Fáil tout can announce what they have or what they own.
Comment on this
That is dangerous for business people. It is dangerous for people in commercial life and for people in important positions in this country who never had their financial position made known to anyone. It is a bad and a dangerous precedent to set here and no Government should interfere with the privacy that exists between bank and customer. I want to object to the infringement of that privacy.
Comment on this
I want this on record that it is the first step towards Communism for the State to examine the bank accounts of any citizen of this country, no matter who he is.
Comment on this
Whether he is on the right side or whether his account is in the red, the State should not interfere and I object strongly to any such inspection.
Comment on this
I object strongly to any legislation passing through this House which deprives any citizen of his rights and I object to breaking the confidence that exists between him and his bank. It is wrong and unjust. It is legislation that is ill-conceived and evilly disposed. As I have said, if we have now sitting in the Department of Finance or as the head of this Government an Irish Khrushchev, an Irish Castro or an Irish Tito, the Irish people should be given an opportunity to put them down.
Comment on this
It should not be tolerated. I do not know why, with all the speeches delivered on this Bill for the past month, I should have been picked out for the barrage.
Comment on this
I say this, and I say it without the slightest fear of contradiction, that any Party, no matter what kind of a tail is wagging it— whether a Sherwin-Leneghan tail or any other—that tries to impose Communist rule in this country will be beaten and must be beaten because I feel that this is the first serious invasion by the State of the rights and the privacy of the citizen. I think it is wrong.
This House should reject this Bill. This House should now put the nail in the coffin of this Bill for all time and those of Fianna Fáil whom I have so worried tonight by the striking movement of their conscience. I hope there may be a lasting striking of conscience on their part and that they will take the right step in the Division Lobby within the next few minutes and will see to it that this disastrous Bill which is unwanted——
Comment on this
——will be beaten by this House as it will be beaten by the country when the people get the opportunity. Thank God, we have a James Dillon in Ireland to-day——
Comment on this
——in showing the serious defects of this brutal, unnecessary, unwarranted, bad and cruel legislation.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?