Land Bill, 1963—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 121–244 of 244. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1963 ›
Provided it excludes conacre or agistment lettings, but it does not. It includes them.
Comment on this
I maintain it does not do so and I am satisfied about that. There is no point in reiterating what the Minister has already said, what to me is perfectly clear and what appears to be well founded in law.
Comment on this
If we were satisfied it was well founded in law, there would be no difficulty but to make sure it is well founded, could a provision not go in excluding conacre or agistment lettings?
Comment on this
If the Minister says he is prepared on Report Stage to insert in brackets, "excluding conacre or agistment letting", he will get the section at once.
Comment on this
Let me reiterate that not alone today, not alone in 1923 but away back in 1870, a conacre letting or agistment letting was not a letting by law, and it was so defined, but was regarded as the sale of a profit á prendre; in other words, it was what some colleagues of mine in the west of Ireland used to call the sale of the “eatage” of the grass—which, to my mind, is a good way of expressing it— and was consequently outside the Land Acts down through all those years. Now we come along to the 1923 Act and for Deputy Collins's edification, let me say section 65 of that Act does not say “voidable”. It reads:
(1) Where the Land Commission have after the date of the passing of this Act made any advance for the purchase of a holding or parcel, the proprietor thereof shall not subdivide or let the holding or parcel without the consent of the Land Commission, and every attempted subdivision or letting in contravention of this provision shall be void as against all persons, and on any such contravention the holding or parcel shall at the option of the Land Commission vest in them.
There is not one exception in section 65 relating to conacre or agistment lettings, which goes to show that the accepted law then was, as it is today, that conacre and agistment lettings are outside the provisions of the Land Acts and are in fact the sale of profit á prendre. The very same wording as is in the 1923 Act is used in this section of the Bill about lettings. That obviously covers lettings for more than 11 months, lettings outside agistment lettings and, of course, as everyone concerned in these matters knows, a lease of land or a letting of land for one, two or three years or for over a period of one year is void under that section, without the consent of the Land Commission.
Somebody says for the sake of argument that a shopkeeper is entitled to let his shop without any penalty. While it is not quite relevant, let me say it is not strictly true. If a shopkeeper lets his shop for a period of over three years, as lawyers know, under the Landlord and Tenant Act of 1931, the tenant is entitled to go to the court and get a lease for 21 years and keep renewing it in perpetuity. The shopkeeper who lets his shop for over three years parts with his shop for all time.
Comment on this
Since 1870, conacre lettings have been defined by law in the way I have set out and put on the records of this House and that has been accepted by all concerned, including by judicial decision, down through all those years.
Again let me deny as emphatically as I can—because evidently I can keep on repeating this until I am black in the face—that agistment or conacre lettings are not within this section, that they are outside this section. Let me reiterate that the wording of this section follows the wording of section 65 of the Land Act, 1923. Let me reiterate that it was necessary to get the Land Commission's consent to lettings of a period of a year or more. It is only because we are following it in other categories of land now that it is necessary to extend the same sub-division control and subletting control as was exercised under section 65 of the 1923 Land Act.
For those who have a real interest in the purposes of this Bill, let me also point out that if there were lettings for longer, without the consent being necessary, then any longer arrangements would be indistinguishable from permanent subdivisions and would make complete nonsense of the control machinery. If we did not extend this control provision about lettings for periods of over one year, it would mean that the Land Commission or anybody else would never know where they were, if consent were not necessary for these long lettings. The fact remains that this has been the law before and that this law is only now being extended with the new lands that are being brought under the scope of this Bill and this section does not interfere in any way with conacre lettings or agistment lettings, or the letting of after-grass lands to which Deputy Flanagan referred, or to any of these short, temporary convenience lettings under the 11-months system. I do not think it will serve any useful purpose for me to keep on repeating what the law has been, what it is and what is proposed here. That is as clear as I can make it.
Comment on this
I am convinced that the Minister is deliberately trying to mislead the House. He referred to section 65 of the Land Act, 1923. Every child knows that that applies to land which was still in the possession of the Land Commission but recently had been alloted to an allottee.
Comment on this
I know that much about the statute. Why has the Minister repeated it here? Why has he not repealed section 65 of the 1923 Act? Answer these questions.
Comment on this
Surely Deputy Collins does not support this statement about the effect of the 1923 Act?
Comment on this
I heard it from men who had spent a lifetime in the Land Commission and who even outside this country were considered to be authorities on land law. Men who had given a lifetime to it and who had been sitting in a Commissioner's chair for much of their life, told me that section 65 of the 1923 Land Act applied to land still in the possession of the Land Commission——
Comment on this
——where the land had been allotted to allottees but where the ownership had not been handed over. The Minister knows that and he has brought in this section to make sure. Now he tells us that agistment and conacre, by regular custom and probably by legal decisions down the years, is not included in a letting. He makes sure that all this custom is in by simple wording that a child can read or understand when he says in subsection (1) of section 12 that "an agriculture holding"—that is, a vested holding, or a holding that might be redeemed free of rent forever, or a free farm holding or a leasehold holding—"shall not be let, sublet or subdivided without the consent in writing of the Land Commission".
I must congratulate the Minister on the clarity with which he has worded it. If he has brought in a tyrannical weapon against the small farmer, I certainly compliment with which he plainness and bluntness with which he has worded it. A child in the second class in national school could understand it. In case the custom in the past has been for agistment and conacre to be outside the scope of letting and sub-letting, he has made sure now. If the Minister is genuine in what he says and if he gives me an assurance that on the Report Stage he will just exclude conacre and agistment, I shall withdraw my amendment immediately; otherwise, I am not going to allow the Minister to bring in a tyrannical weapon for either his own hands or for those of whatever unscrupulous Minister may follow him, turning the Land Commission into a minor Gestapo for the purpose of annoying farmers.
Comment on this
Deputy Blowick has given still further evidence that he does not understand this section. It might be interesting to realise that under another Bill introduced recently the precise effect of this section would automatically be in operation in about 20 or 25 years' time when all title in this country would be registered anyway. All the Minister is doing is taking time by the forelock and bringing in unregistered land.
The Deputy might be interested to know the history of the section in the 1923 Act and why it was introduced. The fact was that the previous Land Act had been ineffectual in preventing subletting and subdivision inasmuch as the rider was added "until the Land Commission advance has been redeemed." Therefore where pre-1923 land was concerned, it was possible, on the redemption of the annuity, to carve up the land and to undo the work the Land Commission had been established to do and make nonsense of their efforts. It became essential to bring in this wording to make void any arrangement to sublet or subdivide, irrespective of whether the annuity was or was not redeemed.
That is the history and to suggest that the Minister is trying to bluff anybody or is bringing in something new or that the interpretation which Deputy Blowick has been putting on it is the interpretation which has been in force for over 41 years, is just plain childishness, to use a word so beloved of Deputy Blowick. It seems to me now that Clann na Talmhan and its remnant for some reason best known to themselves, have decided to join Fine Gael in obstructing a provision that is not merely late in 1964 but would have been late if Deputy Blowick had started it.
Comment on this
Deputy Flanagan went down to the Minister a few minutes ago and the Minister said: "Get up and take me out of this mess".
Comment on this
I strenously object to this. I did not have a copy of Deputy Blowick's amendment. I asked the Minister what the amendment was and the Minister told me. That is the only conversation I had. If Deputy Blowick has to stoop to this sort of thing, he is a disgrace.
Comment on this
Finally, let me say on this amendment and put it on the records of the House that what Deputy Blowick has stated about the effect of section 65 of the Land Act of 1923 is utter nonsense, is incorrect, is untrue, and that section 65 of the Land Act of 1923 applied to every holding purchased under that Act, not to holdings awaiting division by the Land Commission, but to every holding purchased under that Act and that under that section every holding purchased under the 1923 Act was subject to this control, that is, that if there was a letting for more than 11 months it was void without the consent of the Land Commission. I want to give the lie to the utter nonsense uttered by Deputy Blowick in regard to section 65 of the Land Act, 1923, and to point out that this control was there in respect of all lands purchased under that Land Act and that this particular control was there also.
Comment on this
I was under the impression, perhaps, wrongly, but if what the Minister said is correct, rightly, that under section 65 of the Land Act, 1923, permission and consent must be obtained and that no letting would stand legally unless the permission and the consent of the Land Commission were obtained. The Minister now agrees with me that that is so.
The reason why 11 months conacre lettings have taken place, particularly since 1923, is to avoid having to get the consent and permission of the Land Commission to let owing to family circumstances, for convenience and to assist people who must avail of conacre letting.
I am sorry that there appears to be a strong exchange of views between both sides of the House in relation to this matter but I feel rather strongly about this matter myself. In the event of legal proceedings being instituted by the Land Commission in relation to the letting of lands, can the Minister tell us what defence the defendants will have in court if the learned judge refers to section 12 and sees that as far as the law goes the letting and subletting of all agricultural land in the State is subject to Land Commission consent? It will be of no use to tell the learned judge that the Minister for Lands said in the Dáil when the Bill was going through that conacre and agistment lettings were outside the scope of the section.
Therefore I would ask the Minister to insert, on Report Stage, 12 words in the Bill, to which the learned judge can refer, to the effect that conacre and agistment lettings and temporary lettings do not come within the scope of section 12 of the Land Act, 1963. It is as simple as that. If the Minister would meet us on that I am sure Deputy Blowick and other Deputies who have spoken strongly on the matter would welcome any step he might take in that regard.
Finally, I should like to refer to Deputy Seán Flanagan's statement that there is a deliberate attempt on this side of the House to obstruct the speedy passage of this Bill. There is no such thing. I am sure the Minister will agree that we are reasonable on this side of the House. There must be an Opposition in order to produce the best possible legislation. We are here, not to obstruct, but to make honest and constructive criticism. That is why we are examining this Bill patiently, not alone section by section, but sub-section by subsection, line by line, word by word. The Bill deserves the fullest possible examination.
I would ask the Minister to let us discuss the Bill in a spirit of friendliness. Let what is said be said in an effort to make this section workable. I would make a genuine and sincere appeal to the Minister to review this matter. I am sure that his very capable officials could advise him. May I say with reference to the Department of Lands that we have the best civil servants in Ireland in the Land Commission and we have a high standard Civil Service. I would ask the Minister to consult his officials with a view to the insertion of some suitable subsection on Report Stage that would clear the air and ease the minds of persons who must conacre their lands.
I have met people in recent weeks since this Bill was circulated and reference has been made to it. They are people who as a matter of necessity conacre their holdings. There is a certain amount of fear and a great strain and a wave of depression over them because they feel the powers given in this Bill will react against them and that they will have to apply to the Land Commission in order to obtain permission and consent to conacre their lands, despite the fact that the auctioneering and legal professions have gone to great lengths to explain to them that there is no need for any uneasiness. There is a section of the legal profession who have serious doubts about this and maintain that, on the reading of the Bill as it stands, "all lettings within the State", as referred to in the Bill, would include conacre lettings, agistment and temporary lettings.
In order to remove these doubts, I would ask the Minister to bring in an amendment on the Report Stage. I do not know of conacre letting of one acre or under. In all the lands that I have set in years past, I do not ever remember making a conacre letting of one acre of land. Land is let in conacre in 30, 40, 70 acres and so on. If it is quite legal to set one acre or under one acre without having to get permission, then the permission and the consent are nonsensical. Nobody goes to the trouble of setting one acre of land. It might be a cottage plot. Those who have cottage plots work them wisely and well. They are the people who look for conacre so as to be able to work an additional piece of ground.
We on this side of the House want to see this Bill work because we are most anxious that the congestion problem should be tackled in the proper manner. We want to see the lot of smallholders improved. I would, therefore, ask the Minister, in order that he may get a greater measure of co-operation from this side of the House, to meet us on this and bring in a short amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
The slogan down the country among auctioneers and legal men at the moment is: "Sell as fast as you can before the Land Commission come in." If I had taken a "jorum", I might be inclined to believe Deputy Blowick, to take him seriously. As it is, I suggest he is taking leave of his senses. Here he is the big man's man. His speech on this section was directed against the small farmers of the west. Does he not realise that not only is there nothing extraordinary in this section but that there is nothing new in it at all? If justices and judges in this country since 1923 have been perfectly capable of interpreting this section, is there any reason why a new section, drafted in exactly the same way, should be misconstrued? I fail to see any merit in the opposition to this section. The extraordinary thing is that the opposition is coming from auctioneers and legal men, the only two categories who can benefit by holding up the Bill.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any necessity for me to reiterate that the only doubts about this matter are those raised deliberately by Deputy O.J. Flanagan that this does not, in fact, apply to conacre or agistment lettings. The Deputy has referred to learned judges. We must assume our judges are not imbeciles and that they are aware of the law of this land as it has existed since 1870——
Comment on this
I want to make my position clear. The only concern I have—I feel sure the Minister will agree with me here—is the protection of the ordinary small farmer who has a right to his land. Take a widow with a £10 valuation who wants to let her holding. She has been left with a young family; she does not know much about the management of land, but she wants to keep the holding for one of her sons.
Comment on this
I do not want to get hot and bothered. I want to give the Minister the section this minute. We are not talking through our hats. What is wrong with putting in the few words suggested by Deputy Collins?
Comment on this
I shall not waste further public time by reiterating what is no news to any legal schoolboy—that conacre and agistment lettings were never regarded as being legal lettings, creating a tenancy. That has been the law since 1870. It is utter tripe to try to pretend something is being done here which is not being done and which every reasonable Deputy knows is not being done. There is no such exception made in section 23 because these lettings were never legal tenancies under any of the Land Acts. It would look utterly ridiculous for the House to include some nonsense of this kind which has no meaning for anybody but which might be misinterpreted.
Comment on this
I cannot continue to reiterate that this opposition is in order to scare any hare that might be frightened under this Bill. Any lawyer dealing with land law or who has got anything to do with it, today or 60 years ago, knows that the position is quite clear—again, that this section has nothing to do with conacre or agistment lettings.
Comment on this
I am disappointed with the Minister's attitude. While it may have applied for 100 years that a conacre or agistment letting did not mean a legal letting, by Jove it means it here. Since the Minister will not meet our suggestion, I am forced to conclude he has some sinister object in forcing the section through. He is taking a highly unwarranted power unto himself. I am speaking on behalf of a class of smallholders who, through accident, ill health or financial distress, have got to emigrate, to leave their holdings behind them and to earn money in order that they may come back and resume the holdings. I am concerned about a husband or wife who find themselves left without the life partner——
Comment on this
It is tough luck and hard law on the small farmer to be forced off his land through lack of interest by Government policy.
Comment on this
This section will be used against such a man. If I am forced off my little holding and have to go to England, I must do something with my holding. This section is designed to force me off my holding.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 27:
In page 8, line 32, after "persons" to insert the following:
"; provided, however, that in any case where the consent of the Land Commission under this Act is given after the attempted or purported letting, subletting or subdivisions, such consent shall, if the Land Commission so direct, so operate as to validate with retrospective effect such attempted or purported letting, subletting or subdivision."
Since Second Reading, I have noticed that this section does not clearly give the Land Commission power to grant post factum approval of a subdivision or subletting. It is possible that a man might innocently complete a dealing which, while being technically a breach of this subdivision control section, would be quite innocuous so far as Land Commission policy is concerned. In such a case, it would be too severe to have the dealing accounted “null and void as against all persons” with no possibility of redress and no account being taken of the merits of the case.
I feel that this element of rigidity must be removed from the section. At the same time, I must state for the record, that I have no desire to see this amendment—which is an escape clause —used to cover up the misdeeds of real offenders. However, it will transpire from time to time that innocuous sublettings or lettings would arise in respect of which there would be no objection from the Land Commission policy point of view. It might also transpire due to squatters on small areas that boundaries of folios would change. This amendment is designed, therefore, to give the Land Commission power to give post factum approval to such matters where they arise. It is for clarification purposes.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say if that would apply to a case such as the one I cited earlier this evening, where someone had a small acreage of bad land? Is that what he has in mind?
Comment on this
I would want the facts of any particular application for sub-division that may have been refused. I understand that is what the Deputy was speaking about. As I say, this amendment is to enable the Land Commission to give post factum approval in a case where they consider it should be given.
Comment on this
For either subletting or subdivision. It could arise in either case. To my own knowledge, there have been hundreds of sublettings of over a year that are completely void under the 1923 Act. Unless there was a row and they came into court, they went ahead. It may also have happened in cases under the 1923 Act, and perhaps if they were brought to the notice of the Land Commission, they would be inclined to give post factum approval. At present the law is not there to enable them to do so. Under this section, they can give post factum approval where they consider it should be given.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27a:
In page 8, after subsection (2) to insert the following subsection;
"() Subsection (1) of this section shall not apply to any holding which is not subject to purchase annuity or other payment payable to the Land Commission, and either— (a) the whole of such holding is situate within the boundary of any county borough, borough, urban district or town, or
(b) the Land Commission certify under their common seal that in their opinion such holding, by reason of its proximity to a county borough, borough, urban district or town, is required for urban development."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27b:
In page 8, after subsection (3) to insert the following subsection:
"( ) Where but for this section a title to a part or parts of a holding would be acquired by possession, the consent of the Land Commission under this section shall be required to such acquisition."
I know from my experience as a solicitor that there are ways in which parties who have been refused permission to subdivide a holding can enter into collusion to bring about an effective subdivision by what is commonly called "adverse possession". Lest there may be any doubt, I propose that this circumventory device be clearly controlled, as in the amendment now put forward. The person who is in process of acquiring squatter's title is essentially a trespasser. The purpose of the amendment is to make it clear that, for purposes of sub-division control, the squatter is in the same position as the legal owner or tenant. It would be quite absurd to put squatters at an advantage compared with legal owners. I must point out, at the same time, that the amendment will not affect the case in which a man establishes a possessory title over a whole holding; for example, the man who has only a possessory title to a family farm will be no less secure than he is at present.
It has transpired that where people have applied for permission to subdivide land and such permission was refused, they have simply gone on in possession, put up fences, squatted on the land, and acquired squatter's title. The purpose of the amendment is to stop that practice. As I have explained, it does not apply to a person who squats on a whole farm.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is not serious in telling us that there would be many cases of that kind, where people would remain in possession for ten years? Is it ten years undisputed ownership?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27c:
In page 8, after subsection (3) to insert the following subsection:
"() Every stipulation in a contract for the sale of land whereby the purchaser is precluded from making requisitions in relation to a letting, subletting or subdivision of an agricultural holding shall be null and void."
It has occurred to me that since sub-divisions without Land Commission consent will be null and void over a wider field than heretofore, it will become necessary for a purchaser's solicitor to demand proof that there is no such flaw in a vendor's title, especially in respect of purchases in the now limited category of unregistered freeholds. On the other hand, we might have a vendor's solicitor trying to stipulate in conditions of sale that requisitions based on section 12 of this Bill would be barred. Accordingly. I propose that restrictive conditions of this nature against a reasonable requisition of title should be declared null and void.
This amendment deals with restrictive conditions of sale forbidding the purchaser to inquire whether lands are subject to this section. After discussions with Land Registry officials I am satisfied it is desirable to clarify the law, and to have this amendment dealing with title.
Comment on this
I am not objecting to the principle of the amendment but it does seem a bit cumbersome.
Comment on this
After careful consideration, we settled on this form: I am advised it was necessary to have it in this way to achieve the purpose we have in mind.
Comment on this
It strikes me that a lot of this work amounts to excessive regimentation and interference with the landowners' business.
Comment on this
It is not. I can see and I fear a trend which I do not care about and that is that the Land Commission are completely changing their outlook. They are getting away from what they were intended for, namely, the relief of congestion. Not one of these amendments deals with the relief of congestion or with the doing away of rundale or with the improvement of conditions for the farmers.
Comment on this
It is plain that the Deputy does not understand this amendment which is for the protection of the purchaser.
Comment on this
Deputy S. Flanagan is a legal man. I should like to see the Minister for Justice come into this House with a Bill that would regard the members of his profession in the same way as this Land Bill and this Minister regard the farmers. There would be sparks flying and I would admire him for it.
Comment on this
Not a bit of it. It is a good while since I felt so bitter about anything done in this House.
Comment on this
It is quite plain that the Deputy has not the slightest notion of what he is talking about but that he is determined to use his handkerchief to wipe away enormous quantities of crocodile tears which he sheds in bitter isolation on behalf of the said misguided and rejected small farmers.
This amendment is designed to prevent a solicitor for a vendor from putting into conditions of sale a clause which would preclude the purchaser from making certain inquiries as to whether or not the land has been the subject of section 11. It is, therefore, a protection for the purchaser and should commend itself as such to the great protector of farmers who has been speaking so volubly and irrelevantly on their behalf.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27d:
In page 8, to delete subsection (4) and to insert the following sub-section:
"( ) In this section—
"agricultural", in relation to a holding, means substantially agricultural or pastoral or substantially agricultural and pastoral in character;
"holding", in relation to a particular tenant or proprietor, means all the land held by him at or after the passing of this Act under a single demise or to which he has acquired title by possession, whether fee simple, fee farm grant, leasehold or from year to year (whether or not under statutory conditions), and whether held jointly or in common or alone or in severalty, and whether or not purchased under the Land Purchase Acts or registered or deemed to be registered under the Registration of Title Acts, 1891 and 1942; provided that where two or more than two such holdings stand consolidated they shall be deemed to be one holding and that, where two or more than two registered properties are registered in the same ownership and have not been consolidated by the Land Commission.
they shall be deemed to be separate holdings for the purposes of this section;
"subdivision" includes any claim whatsoever to title to a part or parts of a holding, whether by disposition to one or more than one person, and `subdivide' shall be construed accordingly."
This amendment is designed to enlarge the definitions subsection so as to cover several other points on which clarification may be needed. I shall deal with them separately:
The word "property" in line 38 is being replaced by the word "land" because it was not explicit enough. This is merely a drafting point.
Next we have, a line or two later, the introduction of the phrase "or to which he has acquired title by possession." In the original text the phrase "under a single demise" would hardly cover the assumption of title by what is called adverse possession or squatting and so we would have an unjust situation in which the squatter would be quite free of sub-division control while the ordinary purchaser or inheritor of land would be subject to it.
I should perhaps mention that this is not the same point as that which I dealt with on amendment No. 27b. Broadly speaking, that amendment related to the severance of a holding through the claim of the squatter; this new phrase introduces the idea of control over any subsequent action by the squatter in sub-dividing what he managed to get title to.
Now I come to the words in brackets in the amendment,—"whether or not under statutory conditions." This is purely a matter of drafting. It seems possible that the words "year to year" immediately preceding would not cover a judicial tenancy and so it is desirable that this small gap should be closed.
Another point which has caused some concern is the argument that, on the original wording of this section, any two folio holdings acquired by the one man and registered in his name might have to be treated thereafter as one unit—for the purposes of sub-division control—even though they were otherwise quite unrelated. They might be very many miles apart and obviously distinct and separate units for the purposes of any rational land-structure policy. I have no desire to introduce unreal paper consolidations of this type since they would be vexatious to the owners concerned and would raise unnecessary problems in the Land Registry. Accordingly, the second last passage in amendment No. 27d provides in effect that two folio holdings in this situation shall remain distinct units unless the Land Commission have specifically provided that they be consolidated.
In the last three lines of the amendment I have sought to deal with certain problems of evasion. There are legal devices by which a lawyer might seek to achieve an effective sub-division and at the same time maintain that he had not legally subdivided the holding within the meaning of this section as originally drafted. The amendment has had to be worded comprehensively so as to put all such dealings in jeopardy and deter people from attempting evasion by the devices I have in mind.
With the exception of drafting amendments and, the last one, the point which was brought to our notice that you have, of course, some owners having two or three folios in different parts, perhaps widely separated, and in places where they are not consolidated, we thought it better to make the law clear here in this section and to set out that they would be regarded as separate units. These are the purposes of this comprehensive amendment on points that were raised as between the Land Registry and others on the legal effect of this section.
Comment on this
In this Bill, and dealing with land law, it is a very technical field. It was only after considering the different aspects of these sections, and their effect with the sections clarifying the ideas, that we have provided for what might turn up.
Comment on this
I take it that the Minister is running this Bill on the basis of consultation between the Land Registry and the Land Commission?
Comment on this
It is not fair to the House to introduce a Bill of this sort with an explanatory memorandum and to introduce shortly afterwards a list of amendments and to introduce, shortly after that, another list of amendments—and we are now presented with another list of amendments. There is nothing to prevent the Minister from introducing, every week the Dáil sits to discuss this Bill, a list of amendments. I am sure he would not, knowing it to be so, but he will admit it is rather unfair to Deputies and to Parties who have considered this Bill, discussed what was before them and decided to take a certain line of action, to find that, at this stage, the whole face of the Bill is being changed. The Minister says they are only drafting amendments. An amendment which requires one-third of a page of highly technical terms can hardly be considered one which is put in as just a drafting amendment. The Minister is being unfair to the House and to Deputies who want to discuss this Bill with him and who want to see it go through as a proper Land Bill.
Comment on this
It would be very remiss of me if, on consideration after the Second Reading, I found there were certain matters which might bear a different interpretation and I failed to deal with them. This is the place to deal with such matters. Not one amendment interferes with the original principles enshrined in the Bill. Their purpose is to make the law clearer and to deal with these odd cases of a very technical legal nature for which it is necessary to make provision.
Comment on this
Deputy Tully's point is very simple. The Minister should have been aware before he brought in the original draft of the Bill——
Comment on this
Certainly; I meant no discourtesy to the Chair. Deputy Tully believes that all these special cases were within the knowledge of the Land Commission or the Land Registry. Deputy Tully is quite entitled to say that the Minister could have delayed the printing of the Bill until such time as he could cover all the difficulties he is now trying to cover by amendment. This is leading to confusion in the case of those who are not aware of the technical difficulties or the purpose of the Minister's amendments. It is in the Minister's own interest to clarify simpliciter rather than technically the reasons for these amendments. I am anxious the Minister should get this Bill quickly but, at the same time, Deputy Tully's protest should register with the Minister. It is unreasonable to find the Land Bill, in the course of a couple of months, being amended in this fashion by amendment and counter-amendment and amendments to amendments.
Comment on this
These amendments are mainly drafting amendments. They are of a very technical nature. Deputy Collins will appreciate it is not easy to explain in layman's language the effect of some of these dealing, for instance, with squatter's title and what can happen with registered titles under the Local Registration of Title Act and the position that could arise with regard to squatters under the provisions of this Bill. In very odd cases, too, there are fears of evasion. Either I, or someone else, after the Second Reading, saw the possible legal way in which the intention of the Bill could be evaded. It is to prevent such evasion that these technical amendments are introduced. The principles have not been departed from. The law has been made clearer and we are trying to foresee technical evasions and trying to make provision to make sure they will not occur.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree it is unreasonable on the Committee Stage of a Bill to put in an amendment like amendment No. 24 to section 12 and, after that had been in the possession of Deputies for almost a week, then amendments Nos. 24a and 24b, and so on, right down the line, are put in? Does it not appear as if the Bill is changing its face completely, despite what the Minister says? The wording of the Bill is being changed very considerably. Subsections are being deleted.
Comment on this
I grant that they could be improved, but this looks to me like a sloppy attempt at legislation. I am not blaming the Minister but the Bill should be in more concise form before it comes before the House.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
To add to the section the following subsection:
"( ) In this section a holding shall be deemed to be let or sublet where it is held by virtue of any instrument in writing, whether under seal or not, containing a contract of tenancy in respect of holding, in consideration of a rent or return and shall not include a letting for the purpose of temporary depasturage, agistment or conacre or for temporary convenience or to meet a temporary necessity."
The purpose of this amendment is to clarify the law in relation to these lettings. I shall not repeat what I have already said but, if the Minister is making an attempt over the weekend to improve the Bill by the circulation of further miscellaneous amendments, I really think a genuine effort should be made to improve the Bill by accepting this amendment.
A farmer should be free to let his land for temporary convenience and legitimate conacre. It is a serious handicap on any farmer to be prevented from making such lettings or put to the inconvenience of having to seek permission from and the consent of the Land Commission. I presume there will be a section specially set up for the purpose of dealing speedily with applications and that a farmer will be assured of a reply in the course of a week or ten days. It is desirable no time should be lost in giving decisions.
This amendment should be accepted particularly in the light of the recommendation made to the Minister by the NFA in their observations on the Land Bill. They state clearly that they appreciate the fact that the Minister has stated that the usual conacre or legitimate lettings are not covered by this section but they also recommend that agistment and conacre should be specifically exempted from the section. The one way in which that can be done is by accepting this amendment. I have considered the matter very carefully and I believe the amendment is worthy of consideration by the House.
Comment on this
There is no difference between this amendment and the amendment moved by Deputy Blowick. I do not propose to weary the House reiterating that this Bill does not deal with conacre or agistment lettings. The law on that has been quite clear since 1870. I see no reason why the Land Commission should need any staff to deal with consent to lettings when, in fact, the law of the land is sinnce the passing of the 1923 Act that consents were necessary in respect of land purchased under the Act. The staff dealing with that can continue to deal with the matter in the future. I have dealt very fully with the whole position on the amendment moved by Deputy Blowick and the same arguments apply to this amendment.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether a subletting or agistment has ever been defined in any Act? I do not want to raise any heat over it, but I cannot see a judge putting any interpretation on this Bill when it becomes law other than that which is written into it. It is a judge's function to interpret the laws we make, whether they are good or bad. It would ease my mind enormously if I could be assured that no judge in the future would interpret subsection (1) in the way I am afraid of.
Comment on this
The Minister should be less naïve than he is. We have had a welter of verbiage in successive amendments from him. Since we have graciously consented to all kinds of long, technical amendments from the Minister, it is not unreasonable for us to ask him to bring in a simple two or three-line amendment on Report epitomising Deputy O.J. Flanagan's amendment to show it is clearly statutorily declared that, whatever the interpretation of agistment or conacre lettings may be, for the purposes of the 1963 Act, they are specifically included.
Comment on this
For the past 90 years, the law has been that a conacre or agistment letting is not, in fact, a legal letting at all. It does not create any tenancy but is a sale of a profit à prendre out of the lands or the eatage of lands, as we describe it in the west. That is the reason why there is no necessity to exclude conacre or agistment lettings in any of the Land Acts. What is the use wasting time on this when that is the law known to everybody, and there is no doubt about it. Every legal schoolboy knows that. I have used all these arguments before on Deputy Blowick's amendment and I do not think I should take up more of the time of the House dealing with it.
Comment on this
In the event of the Minister being Minister at some future date when some judge has given a contrary decision to that, would the Minister be opposed to a Private Member's Bill setting aside such a decision?
Comment on this
From my varied experience of 18 years, I do not think there has been any legislation so clumsily and ineptly presented as this legislation. The ink on one set of amendments was hardly dry before they were followed by more.
Comment on this
With respect, the Chair must listen to my submission. The Minister is moaning about wasting time. Surely I am entitled to deal with criticism made by the Minister in regard to the waste of time?
Comment on this
The Minister has been allowed to raise it, and with respect, I am entitled to answer him.
Comment on this
I do not want to challenge the Chair, but, with respect, the Chair does not seem to be interpreting the amendment properly either.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister to prevent further waste of time. He referred to a legal schoolboy. There is no such thing as a legal schoolboy. You are at an advanced stage of adult education before you become a legal student at all. Today the Minister tried to quote for a precedent Cherry and some archaic memoirs.
Comment on this
The argument is that there is no need for Deputy O.J. Flanagan's amendment. The Minister has stated that every legal schoolboy knows that. The Minister says that position is created by precedent. There is a simple way of confirming precedent, that is, by statutory inclusion. If the Minister wants to copperfasten the precedent and enshrine it in perpetuity, he can put it into the statute in the form of the amendment moved by Deputy O.J. Flanagan or in the very much shorter and simpler form I suggested earlier. He can do that, if his interpretation of the law is right, without any effect except enshrining a statutory provision in the Bill which will make it a statutory law as distinct from precedent as he has described it. If that is done, the speed with which all the other amendments go through will stagger him.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): This subject has been debated already and there has been a division on it. However, the Minister maintains that under the law conacre is not a letting at all. I presume what he means by that, in my language, is that the interpretation of the law up to the present has been that conacre is not a letting. I submit that it has never been statutorily written into any Land Bill that conacre as such was not a letting and it has merely been left to the interpretation of the law. Will the Minister not agree that something that is written in by statute is stronger than something which is left to legal interpretation? It is on that basis we are asking him to accept this amendment. Interpretations may alter at some future date. None of us knows what a future judge may decide or what a future High Court may do. I would ask the Minister to incorporate this provision in the Bill. That is what we on this side of the House have been asking for and what the Minister has been resisting.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I am sorry to waste my own time but I am not sorry about wasting the Minister's time.
Comment on this
Section 12 of this Bill can be described as a disastrous section in any Bill but particularly disastrous in the Land Bill where steps are being taken to prohibit letting, subletting or subdivision without the consent of the Land Commission.
This is certainly a very serious infringement of the rights of the farming community or of the right of the owner of land to do what he likes with his own property. This section can be described as unreasonable. It carries, in my opinion, a great deal of dictatorship from the Government in regard to the owners of property. This House has given every subsection of this section very serious thought. I have been wondering whether this section is at all constitutional. I am not so sure that at some future date it might not be contested as to whether it was in conformity with the Constitution. It is very wrong that the right of the ownership of land should be endangered and that the landowner should be deprived of the right to set his land as he thinks fit. On that principle I strongly and bitterly oppose this section.
Comment on this
It would appear there is a great deal of opposition to this section from this side of the House but the Opposition is based on different interpretations of what is contained in the section. It is my belief that this section is aimed at the congests in the west of Ireland and that the purpose of section 12 and the pile of amendments to strengthen section 12 is to get rid of the small farmers and congests in the west by legal means. The Minister was asked today to come out into the open and tell the House frankly what he had in mind and I restrained myself from contributing on a number of these amendments because I wanted to find out, as clearly as it was possible to do so, what exactly the Minister and the Government had in mind in this section.
I shall not bore the House by repeating what other Deputies have said but not content with producing the section itself originally, the Minister proceeds to tag on a number of amendments to that section. Deputy Seán Flanagan and other legal luminaries sought to suggest that some of these amendments were very good amendments and a form of protection. That was the kind of argument put to Deputy Blowick and the suggestion was made that Deputy Blowick was unaware of the legal implications of one or two of these amendments. I think Deputy Blowick was perfectly correct in his interpretation in this sense, that even though the amendments, on the face of it, appear to be a safeguard, when that safeguard was put on to a bad section, all that is done at that stage is to safeguard somebody who should not be safeguarded.
The Minister sought to hoodwink the House in regard to the real purpose of these amendments. If you clear out a room and then proceed to lock the door, you will strengthen the locks and strengthen the barricade if you put wedges in the door; you will make it harder to prise it open and if you get a dozen wedges and ram them in all round, you will make the place completely safe against penetration. The amendments put forward by the Minister were wedges so that, once the tenants or the small farmers were out, the door would be wedged to prevent their holding on to what the Minister describes as squatters' rights or by any other method by which they were entitled to remain.
On that basis, we shall have to make it clear to the general public and to the small farmers in the west that this Government brought in a series of amendments to section 12 as a smokescreen to hide their true aims. There is page after page of amendments to the section. If they were aimed at the acquisition of the large tracts of land which have been set for years to the wheat rancher and to the limited companies which have engaged in the growing of wheat as a speculative form of enterprise, there would be complete agreement in this House to strengthen the Minister's hand in dealing with that type of person or groups, but in fact there is nothing in these amendments or in section 12 which will strengthen the Minister's hand in dealing with those people or groups. The Minister's hand is being strengthened in this section to deal with the small man who, perhaps through no fault of his own, through economic circumstances, had to close the door of his house and go to England for two or three years in order to make sufficient money to help his family at home. He is the man who will be harried or hounded under section 12. The aim is to clear out the remainder of the small men who are still clinging hopefully to their holdings in the west and in the congested areas.
The Minister sought, unsuccessfully, I must say, to sidetrack Deputies from this aspect of section 12 by his smokescreen and by a form of diversion to the effect that there was a great danger of this evil of subdivision in the small holdings and in the congested areas being allowed to continue. His argument was: "We have to tighten up this law to prevent further subdivision in uneconomic farms." In fact, the position today is that there is no danger whatever of any large scale subdivision of uneconomic holdings. That day has gone and some Deputies who have sought to suggest that a farmer in the west with three or four sons and 20 acres of land was still inclined to divide that land between his sons are either deliberately trying to mislead the House or are completely out of touch with the situation in the west of Ireland. I challenge any Deputy who has made that statement, particularly when it affects Mayo, with betraying the small farmer and the congest in the western areas.
The position in Mayo, south and north, in Roscommon, Galway and in all these counties, is that a number of smallholders have been forced, through the ineptitude of this and other Governments, to clear out for a period of years to try to make sufficient money to enable them to return and rear their families here. In their absence, there is now an attempt to acquire the small bit of land they have. At the moment wherever a bit of land becomes available in the west, instead of a question of subdivision arising, it is a question of consolidation which is taking place. In fact, we have a new breed of landlord, the local rich individual. I will not describe what his form of living is at present but the local speculator is now in the process of buying up land in every parish and bringing the country back to the state which obtained here a number of years ago.
The aim of section 12 should be to prevent an entire townland being gobbled up by one individual. That is the real illness today in rural areas. Instead, the Government seek to suggest that there is a danger of further subdivision. Is it not proof positive that this Government are trying to hoodwink the smallholder and condoning this consolidation on the part of the rancher, the speculator and all the men out to make profit from the land?