We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).

Contributions 167–360 of 360. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Shame on you.

Comment on this

He says that and he does not know how much it has gone up.

Comment on this

The price of bread, butter, tea and sugar was put up by deliberate Government action. I suppose you will say that the price of bread, butter, tea and sugar did not go up since you came into office?

Comment on this

The people have more money to pay for it. That is the difference.

Comment on this

The old age pensioners has not got it. The Minister saved £9 million when he took off the food subsidies.

Comment on this

I wanted it to pay for your mistakes.

Comment on this

Whatever you wanted it for, you did not give it to the old age pensioners. You only gave them 2/6d. when you could have given them 22/6d.

Comment on this

You took a shilling off them.

Comment on this

In spite of the fact that the man who took it off is Mr. Blythe, you are very fond of him. You are pouring money down the drain to him in the Abbey Theatre.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise.

Comment on this

The Minister is looking for it and he will get it. They have given 2/6d. a week to the old age pensioners and to the unemployed. The unemployed man's wife will be delighted going into her grocer with her extra 2/6d. She will be able to get an awful lot for it now.

Comment on this

They were not used to getting anything from you.

Comment on this

There were 70,000 more in full employment when we were in office than there are now. That is your own figure for it.

Comment on this

Where do you get 70,000?

Comment on this

In Table 15. It is good that the farmers have been remembered in a small way. This has been long overdue. I remember chiding the Minister on three Budgets which he introduced when only a small paragraph was given to the farmers in each of them.

Comment on this

There is a big one this time.

Comment on this

It is not such a big one at all. It will not bring their incomes up by 12 per cent. You would want to come again. The Minister stated proudly that the cattle trade was booming and prophesied that cattle prices would continue to rise and that the farmers would benefit by several million pounds. I have lived to see the day. If the Minister wants to go back to the question of one shilling a week off old age pensions, I can bring him back to 1934, 1935 and 1936 and the 100,000 calf skins.

Comment on this

That was the time you put on the blue blouse.

Comment on this

I would rather wear the blue blouse than the brown shirt Frank Aiken wore when at that time he wanted Hitler to win the war. These are the men who sent the telegram to the Japanese Emperor congratulating him on the blowing up of Pearl Harbour. When the telegram would not be taken, they took it to the Japanese Embassy. And then they had the audacity to welcome President Kennedy to this country.

Comment on this

I never heard that one before.

Comment on this

You are hearing it now.

Comment on this

I never joined the British and put on a blue shirt.

Comment on this

We put on the blue shirts to resist the Bray Harriers and the blackguards you sent down to terrorise the farmers of Ireland. You recruited them the same as the Yeomen were recruited.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Lynch should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

I am delighted with you, Sir. When I was protecting the cattle trade, I was physically assaulted by the Minister's friends so I am well used to this kind of reception. The Government Party would attack anybody else who might change their minds but they can change their minds every few seconds and then what they say is supposed to be gospel.

I should like to point out that when my namesake, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, was speaking, he gibed at Deputy Dillon's record when in Government and as I am talking about cattle, I should like to point out that Deputy Dillon was not a month in office when he created the precedent of being the first Minister for Agriculture to go over to Britain. Of course the Minister for Finance would not like that; he would not have anything to do with Britain at all. As a result of that visit, we got the pact of 1948 which put millions of pounds into the pockets of our farmers. Mark you, it also saved our livestock trade. That is the best business and the greatest source of income we have. I should like to remind you, Sir, that on the day Deputy Dillon got into office, the biggest business the meat factories had at that time, and I remember it well, was the slaughter of young cattle and calves. They were making them into veal loaves and giving the farmers buttons for them.

Now we come to the No. 2 Budget of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. Our telephones are to go up by 50 per cent, if you have the phone in the house already. If some poor friend dies and we want to send a telegram, it will cost us 5/-. We have a penny extra on the letters. I notice that all these people who attend chambers of commerce dinners "blew their top" in the newspapers today but they would not have the pluck to say it to some of the Ministers when they sit down with them. The Minister has announced that those who apply for a telephone after 15th April will have to pay £10. We are going to see economic expansion and the efficiency of Fianna Fáil. Here is a little bit of efficiency. Every Deputy is inundated with letters from his constituents pleading with him to try to get telephones for them.

Comment on this

A sign of progress.

Comment on this

I agree. The Deputy has walked into my trap. I want to show the progress we are making. Here we have that decent man, Deputy Meaney, talking about the signs of progress. There is nothing like being innocent.

Comment on this

He is a picture of it.

Comment on this

Those who know nothing, fear nothing. He did not know anything about this. With a little anticipation, I went into the General Office the other day and put down a question to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs who yesterday got up and gave me what I call "the old one-two," so that the Press Gallery or anybody else would not get it. He replied that the answer was in the form of a tabular statement and would be included in the Official Report. Questions Nos. 82 and 83 in my name read:

To ask the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs the number of applications for telephones outstanding in each county in Ireland;

To ask the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs the total number of applications for telephones outstanding in respect of the whole country.

It worked out that there are 206 people in Carlow who want them. Cavan has 130; Clare, 117; and Cork, 1,004.

Comment on this

More progress.

Comment on this

But some of them have only been looking for telephones for three years and cannot get them. In Donegal, there are 295 and in Dublin, the capital of the country, there are 6,804. They have to send runners around the city with their business. We will be going back to the old days in Darkest Africa, and we will have people running around the streets with notes on top of sticks. Galway has 411; Kerry, 209; Kildare, 272; Kilkenny, 220; Leitrim, 41; Laois, 135; Limerick, 433; Longford, 75; Louth, 272; Mayo, 296; Meath, 259; Monaghan, 144; Offaly, 140; Roscommon, 91; Sligo, 144; Tipperary, 470; Waterford, 265; Wexford, 261; Westmeath, 230; and Wicklow, 274. There is a total of 13,198 people all screaming for telephones.

If the telephone service were not a State monopoly, if it were a private enterprise like the Bell Telephone Company in the United States, there would be men going around asking people to take the telephone. We have the position in reverse and we have the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, instead of encouraging people to take the telephone, saying: "I am going to stop these so-and-so's from looking for the telephone. I will put a penal tax on anybody who wants a telephone from tomorrow. I will finish them." This is a dreadful state of affairs. My information is that no linesmen have been recruited into the Post Office for a long time and that the Post Office engineers have been mainly engaged in laying main cables. I have nothing to say about that but the Post Office should have kept on recruiting staff. When the Minister sees the demand, he should recruit staff and ensure that the demand is met.

I made representations about one case and I was told it would require five telegraph poles to go down to this farmer's house and that the matter would take six months. When that period had passed, I went about the matter again and then I was told it would require two or three months more. That has been going on for three years. Now I have a gem. There was a man living in a district just outside Waterford city and he had a telephone. He went away and the man who went into his house cancelled the telephone. The wires are passing by another man's door and this man has been looking for the telephone for the past four months. He can do nothing about it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I allowed the Deputy to finish but this is not a matter for the Budget debate. It would be relevant on the Estimate for Posts and Telegraphs.

Comment on this

With the greatest respect, I would point out to you that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, in the No. 2 Budget, which is what I am discussing, will put a £10 penal tax on anyone who wants a telephone after today. I am asking the House is the reason for that that the Minister and his Department are so incompetent that they are unable to deal with the applications that have been pouring into them for years past.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Details of telephone installations are a matter for the Estimate. The Deputy is perfectly entitled to refer to the statement made by the Minister.

Comment on this

I am grateful to you. I come now to the forgotten men, the small shopkeepers of Ireland, who are fighting a rearguard action. They face the competition of very efficient supermarkets today. This has affected shopkeepers in small country towns where there are no supermarkets because the customers who normally would go to these small towns are going to the bigger centres to shop in the supermarkets. The small country towns are getting only the skim of the business while the supermarkets are getting the cream. The small shopkeepers are making a great struggle.

Thanks to the Minister for Finance and the members of the Fianna Fáil Party who trotted after him into the division lobby last year, when the turnover tax was imposed, and to the 12 per cent increase in salaries and wages, members of local councils had to face increases in rates. I attended a meeting of the council of which I have the honour to be a member and the manager wanted an increase of 7/-, bringing the rates up to £3 5s. in the £. This was rather appalling because the constituency that I come from has the highest rates in Ireland per head of the population. The valuations are high.

There was no mention, of course, of the forgotten small shopkeepers who have to face these enormous increases. We did not take four months to discuss the rates estimate, as other councils did. We know we have to provide the money. We struck the rate after an hour and ten minutes. It was a very simple thing. Of the 7/- increase, 5/9d. was directly due to the 12 per cent increase in wages and salaries and to the increased estimates that had been sent in from the various subsidiary bodies in respect of the 12 per cent increase in wages and salaries and the turnover tax.

I am not sold on the idea that the 12 per cent will keep the unions quiet for the next two years, as the Taoiseach said this evening. He can say that and he knows it is not true because nearly all the 12 per cent has gone since yesterday.

The tax on petrol will increase the costs of the small shopkeepers also because they usually keep a van for deliveries and in order to go around and try to sell stuff. I do not suppose tourists will be mad about it. I believe they will be able to buy petrol cheaper in Northern Ireland.

The Minister has increased the tax on cigarettes and beer. I do not think it is right for the Minister to tax beer. It has always been our wish to have great industries based on the land. The great brewing industry is based on the land, based on barley. A farmer who has a barley contract from the brewers has an asset. He has a guaranteed price which is higher than the price he can get for feeding barley. Ministers have come in and talked about the efficiency of industries and the need for industries to be efficient. We have one of the most efficient brewing industries in the world and the Minister for Finance puts a tax on it.

The Minister did not increase the duty on Irish whiskey. The distilling industry is also based on the land. Do the distillers deserve from the Government as much as the brewers deserve? The Lord Mayor of Dublin went off to sell whiskey in America and we heard about the millions that would be brought in. We export whiskey to the value of £800,000 or £900,000 whereas the Scotch distilleries are able to export whiskey to the value of £50 million. The Irish distillers should be told that they have had a lucky escape, that the Government do not want to be hard on them but that if they do not make a determined effort to sell whiskey abroad, and have regard to blends, something will have to be done about them.

As far as the 2d. for milk is concerned, as I said before, it will not increase the farmer's income by anything like 12 per cent. Of the entire farming community, the dairyman deserves most from us. The cow has to be milked Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday, Easter Sunday, Christmas Day and the August bank holiday. We are giving him twopence. The Minister was even pleased with himself when reading that out yesterday. The only thing I can say is: "Thank God I am a dairyman no longer."

There is 8/- a cwt. for the man who is able to get Grade A Specials out of his pigs. I have no doubt that with the ninth round increase, the cost of feeding stuffs will go up. People may say the farmer could produce them himself. He may, but he must have the raw materials processed and even that will cost him more because the mills and provender manufacturers will increase their prices. We hear of the great plans of Fianna Fáil for 1970 and 1972. I should like to hear the Minister tell us when all this will stop.

Does the Minister think it is to the advantage of this country to continue to increase taxation every year? Does the Minister think it is to the country's advantage to keep pouring money into a whole lot of chancy projects? Lastly, I would ask the Minister if he thinks the policy of CIE in destroying the railways will save this country the million pounds or so that the Minister for Transport and Power seeks from us here year after year.

Comment on this

Deputy T. Lynch has groaned a lot——

Comment on this

I did not groan at all.

Comment on this

——about the time of the Economic War and other things. He even attacked us for daring to send a message to the Japanese Ambassador to have the same treatment meted out to people in Singapore as was meted out to our comrades in West Cork.

Comment on this

Lovely.

Comment on this

He even went that far. What that had to do with this Budget, I do not know, but he tried it anyway. As the Taoiseach stated today, this Budget could have been balanced if it were not for the 2/6d. improvement in the social welfare benefits and if we were to forget the agricultural community. Everybody else had got their share. Deputy T. Lynch made me rather sick when he spoke about the turnover tax.

The turnover tax was discussed on the last Budget. It was dragged along here and in every hole and corner in this city and throughout the country until we had it tried last February. When it was tried the gentlemen over there got the people's opinion of what they thought of our action in regard to the turnover tax. They got it in Cork where we had the largest majority we ever got, and in the purely rural constituency of Kildare. Would you not think that would end it? Evidently the only thing worrying them now is that the farmers are getting something.

Comment on this

Very little.

Comment on this

That is the only thing that is worrying them. What was the attitude of Deputy Dillon when he had a bit of power? He stated that he wanted to know how long the people of this country would continue to subsidise milk delivered to creameries at the rate of £2 million a year. He said he hoped the price of milk would reach a level where it would no longer be necessary to subsidise it. He followed that up by an offer of 1/- a gallon for five years. The farmers never forgot it for him and do not think that they will.

Comment on this

A shilling a gallon was worth a lot then.

Comment on this

That was the line of action taken. We have come along now with a price for wheat and for barley.

Comment on this

How much?

Comment on this

An increase of 2/-. The price of beet has gone up by 11/1d.

Comment on this

What about the sugar?

Comment on this

You were damn glad to have it during the emergency.

Comment on this

It was a white elephant at one time.

Comment on this

There must be a lot of quare fellows in the Deputy's constituency. The Tuam beet factory is still going, and going strongly, despite their efforts to block it. We have come along now on milk and on the rates——

Comment on this

No thanks to you for the rates. The Kilkenny farmers won that battle.

Comment on this

For heaven's sake, we had that miserable gang here on two occasions. On one occasion they endeavoured to balance the Budget by taking a shilling a week off the old age pensioners. One of them made this statement—and you can imagine the condition of the finances of the nation which left us in this position:

In October, 1956, a requisition was made by the Clerk of the Dáil to have the paintings cleaned and in this connection an estimate was received for £11. The then Minister for Finance, however, decided that due to the serious economic condition of the country at that time, he would not be justified in approving of the estimate.

Eleven pounds, mind you.

Comment on this

Quotation, please.

Comment on this

I shall give the quotation all right. It is from columns 515 and 516 of the Official Report for 10th March, 1964.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

Despite the fact that the taxpayers had to pay £10,000, at least, for the printing of questions and for the time spent on them in the past couple of months, the nation could not afford, in October, 1956, £11 for the cleaning of two paintings.

Comment on this

We cleaned up more than that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

These interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

Did you ever imagine such misery? The cleaning of the portraits was subsequently sanctioned in June, 1957, by the present Minister for Finance. We had plenty of money then and the Minister had no trouble in finding £11. Imagine a team with two such Ministers for Finance—they should put them into "Facts about Ireland"—one who took a shilling from the old age pensioners and the other could not find £11 in the national finances to clean two paintings.

Money is required if we are to make progress. The last man to be looked after is the farmer. I disagree with the statement from the Labour benches today and I think it is high time a declaration was made about agricultural wages. We have seen the drain year after year of the lifeblood of the agricultural community, owing to the barrier, the differential, between the £6 or £7 on one side and the £12 and £14 on the other. We have lost every skilled worker we had on the land——

Comment on this

Does the Minister hear that?

Comment on this

We lost them through that difference. The sooner we get down to this problem, the better. If we are to keep the rural community on the land, they must be at least somewhere near the level of their brothers in industry. We should work on that line. I have worked on it. In 1948 we brought in costings on wheat. That is the crop that Deputy Dillon referred to by saying: when will the people of this country realise that we are spending £3 million every year getting farmers to grow beet and manufacturing it in this country whereas if we brought in refined sugar, we could have that money for children's allowances". It is the one crop in this country that was costed and on which the farmer is paid his cost of production and a fair profit. I have seen to that. We got 11/1d this year and there is more to come as soon as we are finished with CIE freight and the extra £1. The sooner the £1 is put on, the sooner we will get money.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

The Deputy is not short of money, is he?

Comment on this

That is what is wrong with the Deputy. I think the sooner the problem of the rural community is tackled the better for everybody. A time will come if these conditions continue when there will be no skilled man left on the land.

Deputy Dillon told us about the purchase of land by foreigners. I do not know how much of that has gone on in other areas. I found some of it in my constituency and immediately I brought it up here in the week before the Dáil adjourned. I took 1,000 acres from them and I had no trouble, as far as the Minister for Lands was concerned, in getting it divided between the people down there.

Comment on this

You did not——

Comment on this

Do not draw me.

Comment on this

I was only thinking if you got 2,000 acres.

Comment on this

I see no danger in regard to this acquisition of land. I do not know who brought in the differential, whether it was Deputy Blowick or not, but one of those holdings of 425 acres was sold to an Englishman for £7,000 and we had to buy it back the other day for about £40,000. That is what comes of having an inter-Party Government for a few years.

Comment on this

Did you not sell Killarney to the Germans?

Comment on this

I wish we could get somebody to buy you but I am afraid he would have a bad "baste".

Comment on this

I will go on the stand with you any day.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Coogan should cease interrupting and allow Deputy Corry to make his speech.

Comment on this

I do not know where the famous unemployment figures come from, but I know——

Comment on this

Can you have it——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I asked the Deputy to desist from interrupting and I shall not ask him again.

Comment on this

He asked a question.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy need not reply to the question.

Comment on this

I know you will not find today an unemployed man from Youghal bridge to Cork city.

Comment on this

They have all emigrated.

Comment on this

Not one. The processing factory at present being built in Midleton will provide employment for some 150-200 more people and we expect the number to go up to 700 in two years. You must have money to get those industries going. The State grant alone for the Midleton factory will be about £300,000 or £350,000. That will benefit the farmers of east Cork to the extent of almost £500,000 a year when in full production, as well as providing additional employment. This is what counts. Let us do what we can—from what I know of the Government they are doing that—to keep our boys and girls at home in employment instead of going to the foreigners for work. Let us follow that policy.

I thought there would be joy in everybody's mind today when they saw that the one group, omitted from the 12 per cent increase, were now to get their share, the agricultural community. Instead of that, Deputies opposite sat with long faces complaining about it. The only man I saw smiling is the man from Limerick who was quite happy with the 2d. a gallon and relief of rates as well. I am sure he will tell his constituents that he did not take any part in the dirty milk campaign——

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

Tell us more about the small farmers.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will stop blathering, I shall give him a turn in a minute. If he does not make too much noise, he might after the next election come back here. Mind you, he has a chance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputy Corry please come to the motion?

Comment on this

I cannot help the interruptions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have to help himself.

Comment on this

He could not talk on that Budget.

Comment on this

If we are to carry on and to provide employment for our own people, we shall have to increase taxes from time to time. I cannot see what the growl is about over there in relation to the farmers. After all, when we look the matter in the face, we have to remember a few things. We have to remember that rates on agricultural land are paid here. They are not paid in Northern Ireland and they are not paid in Britain. Yet we have to compete with the British and the Northern Ireland farmers on the same market. That is why I consider that what the Minister for Finance has done today is at least a step in the right direction as far as rates on agricultural land are concerned.

We must also remember that our position has been worsened from time to time, and badly worsened, by the foolish action of people who went over to Britain and made agreements. This country has paid, you might say, during a period of around four years, something over £4 million to Britain for permission to send our sugar over there under an agreement made in 1956 before those people went out of office last. Remember these things. That £4 million would help out a lot today in balancing the Budget but it had to be paid in order to find a market for our surplus sugar. That was a cut-and-dried agreement that was brought home here by the Coalition Governmen when they were in office. The Minister for Agriculture denied knowing anything about it until he was questioned here in the House and until we came up against the awkward fact that we had to ration beet growing in order that we would not have the extra sugar. That was one of the difficulties our Minister for Agriculture had to tackle and to surmount.

People step into jobs, as the Coalition Governments stepped in here for a while, not knowing what they were doing, not knowing the harm they were doing, but the evil they did lived a long time after them and we have to remember that in relation to our experience of the Coalition Governments here.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

Is this cane or beet sugar the Deputy is talking about?

Comment on this

We do not hear much today about the day-old chicks.

Comment on this

There are a few old cocks around.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That cock will not crow any more.

Comment on this

Tell us about the cane sugar. He is a little bantam cock.

Comment on this

I am afraid of you. When Deputy Dillon was talking about the programme today, I wondered how much of that programme he would implement if he had won the by-elections in Cork and Kildare and were now sitting where the Minister for Finance is sitting. I wondered how much of that programme he would implement or whether he would again be offering the 1/- a gallon to the old farmer.

Comment on this

A penny on the pint of milk——

Comment on this

I would ask Deputies over there, now that they have got their beating, to sit down and to conduct themselves for a couple of years. I would ask them to endeavour quietly to do something, no matter how little, for the people who sent them here. They would be a lot more thankful for it than to have them up here shouting and trying to interrupt. Do a little job for the people who sent you here. If that is done by those gentlemen— they will have 2½ years now to do it, every day of it——

Comment on this

And qualify for the pension, and all.

Comment on this

——they can settle down there in the full knowledge that they are safe for 2½ years.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not seem to be very relevant to the motion. The Deputy will either be relevant or cease speaking.

Comment on this

Fighting words.

Comment on this

Those, to my mind, are matters to which we have to attend as far as the people in this country are concerned. I suggest to the Minister that, in respect of agriculture, the first necessity is to bring the minimum wage of an agricultural labourer up somewhere between £10 and £12 a week.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

You must remember that the ordinary agricultural labourer today has to be at least as well trained as, if not better skilled than, the worker in any factory.

A lot has been said here today about the money for education and secondary schools. I suggest that if a proper attempt were made by our vocational schools and our vocational teaching——

Comment on this

It is too late now.

Comment on this

——it would bring far better results for the ordinary people of this country. Our industries today are crying out for people with some technical training. It is far cheaper to turn out half a dozen from the technical school and to train them in the local industries which are going on around them and to give some skill there than to send some fellow on to the secondary school and to the university for five years and to make a doctor out of him for abroad or to make a solicitor or a lawyer out of him to be trying to drag his tail in here some time. That is the way I look on it. I suggest that, instead of this big drive for universities and secondary education, a decent drive be made to put at least a technical school with suitable technical teachers in each of the towns and cities in which industries are being started so that these men can get the technical training required for industry.

In conclusion, I should like to thank the Minister for Finance for the action he has taken as regards the agricultural community. I think their time had come and that they have been met fairly at least.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

This Budget reminds me very much of the old song in reverse: I know where I'm going and I know who's going with me. As far as I can see, the Minister for Finance and Fianna Fáil do not know where they are going and they do not know who is going with them.

Comment on this

There are 20,000 of them in Cork.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

20,000 what? 20,000 emigrants?

Comment on this

20,000 voters.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Oh!

Comment on this

They do not count, of course, with you, except at election time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has made his contribution——

Comment on this

What did you call it, Sir—contribution?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Coogan ought to restrain himself sometimes. He is constantly interrupting. At the next interruption, I shall ask the Deputy to leave the House.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Shortly before this time last year, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands went down to his constituency in Roscommon and made a speech on the eve of the Budget. We had all sorts of rumours of taxes on various commodities. The Parliamentary Secretary assured his listeners that any taxes which the Government would introduce would be on "furs, jewellery and expensive motor cars" and that food and clothing would not be interfered with in any way. A short time before that, the Taoiseach introduced his White Paper in which he said there must be a standstill in wages. Those were two clear-cut statements—one made by the Taoiseach and the other by a member of the Government.

Then, last year the Minister for Finance introduced this novelty, the turnover tax. He did not do as the Parliamentary Secretary said he would do—merely impose it on furs, jewellery, and expensive motor cars. He went further. He said he would have to impose it on all commodities. I quote the Minister's speech at Col. 82, Vol. 202 of the Dáil Debates of the 23rd April, 1963:

It is not safe to rely for substantially increased revenue on the duties on only four commodities—tobacco, beer, spirits and oil—the yield from which is liable to be seriously affected by changes in demand.

The Minister gave us the turnover tax because these four commodities had been taxed to saturation. By a strange coincidence, having got the turnover tax geared and working smoothly, he comes along this year and taxes the very four commodities he said he could not touch: tobacco, beers, spirits and oils.

These commodities are very essential commodities. May I be pardoned if I again quote? In his speech yesterday the Minister gave us the Ryan Budget, but announced that we would have the Hilliard Budget afterwards. We know what that will mean. We know that postage, telephones and telegrams are being taxed. I should like to say something about that particular taxation. I am quoting from Column 210, Volume 157 of the Dáil Debates:

I expect there is a surprise in store for those of us, particularly business people, who do the bulk of their business by means of the telephone. Surely the cost of the telegraphic service will not be increased, unless it is deliberately increased for the purpose of eliminating the telegram altogether? The minimum rate for a telegram to England today is 3/6d. If a friend dies and one wants to send a telegram with just "Sincere sympathy," it costs one 2/6d.

We are told now that there will be further increases in the postal and telegraphic services. Remember that the people who use the services of the Post Office most are the business community and these imposts, whatever they may be, will have to be borne by the business community. Last year when the cost of telegrams was increased I, in common with other Deputies, received hundreds of complaints from business firms as to the cost of these extra charges in the year. But we must wait for this Supplementary Budget and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will not come into the House quite as quickly as did the Minister for Social Welfare this morning. Remember, the Minister for Social Welfare came in to talk about some reliefs. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will be held in the background until the echoes of the present Budget have faded away somewhat. Then he will come along with his Supplementary Budget and tell us what these increases will be.

Who said that? The present Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach, Deputy Brennan. He told us at that time that if we increased the cost of the telegram from 3/-, it was going to hit the business community, and if we increased the cost of the letter from 3d, it was going to hit the business community. According to the Minister, the telegram is now to cost 5/- and the businessman's letter will cost 5d. As the then Deputy Brennan pointed out, this hits the business community of the country.

Deputy Brennan did not stop there. He went on to talk about the increase in the cost of petrol. I quote from the same column and volume:

The increase in the price of petrol is not something that can be received with enthusiasm by anybody. Of course, the new petrol tax could not be received with enthusiasm by anybody in the House. I was surprised to hear Deputy McQuillan trying to justify that tax by pointing out that he was prepared to support up to the hilt the taxing of anything imported. He did not tell us that the taxes on petrol and other imported goods were not for the purpose of preventing imports of those commodities but merely for the purpose of raising revenue....

At that time the tax was justified because there was the Suez crisis and petrol had to be imported. There is no such crisis today. As Deputy Brennan pointed out, the tax is being imposed today for one purpose, that is, to procure more money.

Deputy Brennan went on further, and I quote from Column 212 of the same volume. What he said about the tax on cigarettes is very interesting:

Cigarettes, which today are a luxury according to the Government Deputies, were an absolute essential in 1952, and it was a crime to tax them. Mind you, cigarettes have unfortunately become more and more essential to the community. This may not be included in reckoning the cost of living index figure but they are regarded as an essential today even in country districts. When the local housewife goes to the grocer to purchase her weekly requirements she sells a few dozen eggs——

he is talking about 1956, when she had a few dozen eggs to sell

—and gets her tea, sugar, salt, bread and other things but invariably there go into her basket two ounces of tobacco and 20 cigarettes at least. It has become an indispensable part of the household requirements, because the women take home the things the men require. Every penny imposed on these commodities is going to be just as difficult on the housekeeper in meeting her budget as if the taxes had been imposed on tea or sugar.

The taxes were imposed on tea and sugar by way of the turnover tax and we have this burden again on the housewife who no longer has the eggs to sell and the money for them she had in 1956. How right the then Deputy Brennan was, How essential these things have become to the ordinary housewife and how the Minister's Budget has hit the housewife again.

I do not wish to go over everything Deputy Dillon said this morning but there are a few things to which I should like to refer. There is no doubt that the population of this country is falling and has fallen considerably since 1956 when that Budget was introduced. We now have the highest rate of taxation ever levied on our people. It is the highest rate on the smallest number of people—and we will have another rise next year. So surely as we tax petrol and cigarettes, so surely as we increase the turnover tax as we do by increasing the tax on these commodities, so surely will the cost of keeping patients in hospital, of transporting them from their homes to hospital and of providing necessaries in hospital increase in the coming year.

Deputy Dillon pointed out that the cost of stamps for social security has increased. The costs of all these things, of bread, butter, flour, sugar, cigarettes, postage stamps, telephones, and telegrams have all gone up at a time when we have 70,000 fewer in employment here compared with the occasion on which Deputy Brennan made that speech. That is worth remembering. We still have about the same number of unemployed, about 60,000. Deputy Dillon told us of a quarter of a million people leaving the country since 1956. On last Sunday I got an example of that. I visited Aranmore island, and, to my utter amazement, I discovered that one of the teachers on the island, who had been there for 28 years, had now to leave his school because his average had fallen. There was not a school in the entire locality in which the average had risen sufficiently to employ him and now he has to seek a teaching appointment in Killybegs, 40 miles away. That is happening at a time when we have the highest rate of taxation ever levied on the people.

Although a quarter of a million people have emigrated since 1956, it is now costing twice as much to run the country as it did then. Can we account for that? I certainly cannot. I do not know what is happening. I think we have become more extravagant. I am sorry Deputy Corry has left the House because I have just read a speech of his made in 1956 in which he deplored the number of civil servants. The overall strength of the Civil Service has gone up since then but not a word was uttered about that by Deputy Corry in his speech tonight.

There are a few things in this Budget which are worth referring to. Now we are so heavily taxed that there can scarcely be any further taxation. I remember the present President of Ireland when, in 1956, he interrupted the then Taoiseach, Deputy John A. Costello, and said that we had reached the limit of taxation. I wonder what does he think today about the taxation being imposed on a quarter of a million fewer people than in his day. I notice it costs £60,313 to run the President's establishment. Can we afford that in this country? I am not here to criticise the President. I would not do it but I think we are far too extravagant in running the establishment over which he presides. We were told some time ago what it was going to cost the State to send the President and his party to the funeral of the late President Kennedy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I think that is administration.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I would not say it is administration. It could not possibly be.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not financial policy.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It might be because we are going to send him there again for another holiday.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think it arises. The Deputy will get an opportunity to raise it at another time.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It is out of this Budget the money must come.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The money must come out of the Budget for everything.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I accept your ruling in the matter and will not refer to it again.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy not suggest halving the amount so that when he goes there, he will have to stay?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

His going will make him happy and if he stayed there, it would make everybody in this country happy. However, I do not wish to refer any further to the present holder of the office. We have heard the Minister for Finance, Deputy Corry, and others wax enthusiastic about what we are going to do for agriculture. The Government were never too fond of agriculture in the early days. It is grand to hear Deputy Corry talk about the Sugar Company and the magnificent work they are doing and the fact that there is not an unemployed man north or west of Cobh. Remember what the present Government said about the sugar company. They said that the sugar company was a white elephant and that all the factories built by the sugar company were white elephants. The present Tánaiste said that and it is on record. He was evidently an expert on white elephants at the time.

We told them then the advantages that were to be gained from undertakings such as the Sugar Company. The then Minister for Agriculture, the late Deputy Hogan, told them that the policy should be one more cow, one more sow, one more acre under the plough. That was his policy and he was denigrated all over the country by Fianna Fáil for it. It took about 35 years to convert Fianna Fáil and during the course of that conversion, the cost to the agricultural community was more than we can ever estimate. That was the time when they advised us to slit the throats of the calves. Now they are advising us to do something else with them. That was the time they advised us to abolish the cattle industry. That was the time when the Minister for External Affairs said he hoped every ship crossing the Irish sea carrying four-footed beasts or two-footed human beings would go to the bottom of the sea.

Comment on this

There were no parades then.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

There were no parades then.

Comment on this

The parades shook them.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

What a tragedy that the policy of the late Paddy Hogan and of the predecessors of Fine Gael was not put into practice by their successors. If it had been, we now would have no need for this heifer subsidy; we would have sufficient cattle to keep our trade balance in order. Now, at the eleventh hour, we are trying to build up the cattle industry, something which is going to be most difficult to do because the people do not believe or trust Fianna Fáil as far as the cattle industry is concerned. It is all very fine to talk about the buoyancy of our economy but suppose the cattle trade, the beef and store trade, collapses, where do we go from there? It would be very, very serious indeed, but, as Deputy Dillon said, the Taoiseach is a gambler and he is surrounded by gamblers and they are gambling on this. If it does not come off, it will be very serious.

On the question of agriculture, we are delighted to see that the dairy farmers in the south are to get an extra 2d. a gallon for milk. They are entitled to it. It is the least they are entitled to. I wonder what will happen in Roscommon, Mayo and Donegal where milk is not produced. What is the incentive to farmers in these counties? We are told there will be a rebate on agricultural lands but we do not know what it is or how it is to work. It would have been appropriate for the Minister last night to tell us during his broadcast how it will affect farmers in non-dairying and non-milk producing counties. I cannot see any benefit under this Budget for the small farmers in these counties or any other counties other than the milk-producing counties.

We all know that the potato trade has collapsed this year. Farmers of the potato-producing counties like my own and that of Deputy Cunningham and of the volatile Deputy from Galway, know that the potato trade has collapsed in these counties.

Comment on this

The Minister has his chips now.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We do not know what we are to do with our potato surplus. If the same thing happens to our seed potatoes this year, farmers will be very badly hit. Still, there is no hope held out in the Budget for farmers in these counties.

Let me refer now to the impact of the tax on petrol and oil on the travelling community. As Deputy Brennan said in 1956, the car is now an essential. Why? Because the railways have been closed. We have no railways now. Fianna Fáil closed the railways and they said: "We will give you buses instead". They never told us that bus fares would go up 100 per cent. They are now up 100 per cent over what they were when people travelled by railway and in many cases they are up by as much as 200 per cent.

Let me tell a short story in regard to this. About ten days ago, there was a National Football League semi-final in Dublin, between Cavan and Down. For the occasion CIE had an advertisement in the daily newspapers offering, for that particular Sunday, a return trip from Monaghan to Dublin for 19/6d. The distance is in the neighbourhood of 70 miles. The same newspaper carried their advertisement offering a return trip from Cavan to Dublin, a distance of 80 miles or slightly more, at 13/6d. There was a difference of 6/- for a shorter journey. You may ask why. I will tell you. It is because there is an independent bus service in Cavan which could compete on most favourable terms against CIE but there is no private bus service in Monaghan and they could charge the people of Monaghan what they liked. They were afraid in the case of Cavan because the people could turn to the independent company and say: "Put on your fleet of buses" and they had to come down to the price of that company.

Comment on this

That is the way they rob the people of Ballyfermot, too.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Of course, and they are going to continue to rob them.

Comment on this

And in Limerick, too.

Comment on this

And you can include Wexford.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The trouble was we caught on to them and began to use the motor car and then along comes the Minister to hit us. He nails us now with this tax on petrol.

Comment on this

In spite of northern canniness.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

In spite of northern canniness. I am amused when I hear the people of Donegal talking about protest meetings because the Ulster Transport Authority are closing certain lines. What are they doing but following the example of the Taoiseach? He set the example and closed the railway lines. They are glad to point to the south. But to distract their minds from the impact of the cost of living and of the Budget here, we are protesting about the closing of the line from Portadown to Strabane. We set a nice headline.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Here is the big fish.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

We are very glad to see him back. Unfortunately he has not been available. Last year when he was available, the Minister for Finance did not take him into his confidence.

Comment on this

It was the other way around.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

That was the trouble but he got away with it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not arise on this.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I think it was most relevant because we are talking about what the Parliamentary Secretary said would be done last year, namely that there would be a tax on furs, jewellery and motor cars and nothing else, but the Minister for Finance paid no attention to him and came along and imposed the turnover tax on everything. This year he thought he was right. Mind you, the Parliamentary Secretary was only just one year late because this year the tax has been put on the things the Parliamentary Secretary said it would be put on last year.

What will be the effect of this Budget on the tourist industry? It will have a most serious effect, in my opinion. The tourist industry never thrived better than it did in the first few years after the Second World War. We had more visitors then than we have had in any year since. The reason was that things were cheaper here and there was an enticement to come. Intoxicating liquor, food, petrol and cigarettes were much cheaper here. That was one of the reasons people were enticed to come here. Our climate is somewhat similar to that of Great Britain. They cannot come here for better weather. They come here for these cheaper commodities just as we sometimes like to slip away to the Channel Islands where various commodities are much cheaper than they are in parts of Britain.

Here we are now levelling up. Not only are we levelling up but we are now almost on the tail of the prices charged by the British Exchequer. We will go a little further and tell them that if they come here, they must stop drinking the whiskey they drink at home, that they can no longer drink Scotch whisky except at a price, that they must drink Irish whiskey. I have no objection to that at all but they have to acquire a taste for Irish whiskey. They will not do it during the fortnight or three weeks they spend with us. It would suit us much better if we tried to push Irish whiskey into the English market and into the markets from which our tourists come, to give them an opportunity of acquiring a taste for it before coming here.

If we are serious in our ambitions to enter the Common Market, to bring down tariff walls, how can we reconcile that with putting a tariff on the importation of British spirits at this moment? There is only one reason: we want more money and we are putting it on to get money.

I would warn the Minister that the British Government might hit us back by putting an import duty on our whiskey going into Britain, and that would be serious, not from the Englishman's point of view, but from the point of view of the Irish migrant in Britain who is still fond of his glass of Irish. I sincerely hope there will be no repercussions as a result of this but it is quite possible.

What is in the Budget for the urban dweller?

Comment on this

Gloom and misery.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Gloom and misery—the Deputy has summed it up. There is nothing in this Budget for the town and city dweller other than more blisters on his back. We were told that the ninth round was to compensate the employee for the burden imposed by the turnover tax. We were assured that that would amply compensate him and that everybody would be happy. Here we have the two budgets now and their impact upon the town and city dweller. The cost of transport, milk and cigarettes is going up and, as Deputy Joseph Brennan said, they are a household necessity at the moment. The price of the pint is going up.

Comment on this

What about the rates?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The rates have gone up. The differential rents have gone up. The cost of postage has gone up. The cost of the telephone has gone up. The telegram has gone up. There is no cut for telegrams saying "deepest sympathy", to which Deputy Brennan referred in 1956. When you sent a telegram, in 1956, with only the words "Deepest sympathy" you got a shilling off. That no longer obtains. I do not know whether Deputy Coughlan heard what Deputy Brennan said when the cost of telegrams was increased in 1956: "I, in common with other Deputies, received hundreds of complaints from business firms as to the cost of these extra charges." That was when the telegram was 3/-. He has not shown the bundle of telegrams he received since word got out that it has gone up to 5/-. I suppose every Minister, like the Parliamentary Secretary, has received a similar number of telegrams. We have received none because most of our constituents do not know when this extra charge will come on and are afraid to send a telegram in case they would have to pay the 5/-.

Comment on this

How could they afford to send them?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They could not. We will have plenty of callers at the week-end. In certain constituencies such as Deputy Coughlan's constituency, a Deputy can say: "You are getting 2d. extra for your milk." We cannot tell them they are getting anything back.

Comment on this

A halfpenny a pint is 4d. a gallon.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I could anticipate that there would be an extra 2/6 for non-contributory old age pensioners. Deputies might wonder how I knew. The investigation officer has been going around for the last two months checking up on the means of old age pensioners and increasing the amount assessed if at all possible, counting the hens, asking were they going to qualify for the £15 in-calf heifer subsidy scheme. As sure as a man endeavours to benefit by the in-calf heifer scheme, up goes his means assessment and down goes his pension. This, remember, is in reference to non-contributory pensioners. There is nothing for contributory pensioners.

In my constituency in the past fortnight, I have filled in at least ten appeals against assessment of means under the Unemployment Assistance Act. The Minister who is in the House at the moment knows how people on the western seaboard are being treated by the investigation officer. Day in and day out he is around investigating the means of unfortunate recipients.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely that will arise on the Estimate?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

There is an increase for them and I am explaining how the increase will be offset.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot get all that in in this debate.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The position is, a Cheann Comhairle, that the recipient of unemployment assistance will get an extra 2/6 from 1st August next. By that time they will have had time to complete the revision of the entire country in regard to the means test and I guarantee that by the time the extra 2/6 is implemented, the assessment of means will have increased and recipients will find themselves in the same position as they are in today. It has happened before. It will happen again.

Comment on this

People have emigrated out of the House.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I know. They are all gone. People are beginning to realise — nobody better than Fianna Fáil—that if they want Fianna Fáil they must pay for it. That is what is happening. You cannot fool all the people all the time. Nobody realises that more than those who should be on the empty benches opposite.

The Minister for Finance has fooled the people often. He cannot fool them all the time. Any Deputy from a poor constituency such as Connemara or any of these places will realise what a poor gesture this 2/6 of dole money is to the unfortunate recipient of unemployment assistance. In these poor parts of Ireland such as Donegal, Connemara, West Clare and Kerry, they train a team of investigation officers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow this discussion.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

More is the pity, if you cannot.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will find an opportunity on some other occasion.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I bow to your ruling on that, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Administration may not be discussed in this debate, whether you train a team or an individual.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

What I am trying to explain is that they will get an extra 2/6d. from 1st August but I maintain that by 1st August the 2/6d. will be taken from them in another way. If you rule against me on that, I cannot put it further than that.

Comment on this

Do they know when the hens are clocking?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The hen, when she is clocking, does not lay. She hatches. The old clocking hen is now thrown under the creel. They use the incubator. On the question of the incubator, may I say that even the fuel for it is gone?

Comment on this

Taxed out of existence.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Is there a single thing one can say in favour of this Budget? I cannot find it. Perhaps Deputy Coughlan can go back to his constituents and say there is an extra 2d a gallon for milk. The Deputies from Tipperary and other Golden Vale constituencies can say that also. But I wonder what Deputy Breslin and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach and I will say when we go back to the poor small farmer of West Donegal. We can tell him: "We have nothing for you in this Budget, not a thing, except that cigarettes will cost you more, your pint will cost you more, the car to the dance on a Sunday night will cost you more". But the dancehall proprietor must still be a contributor to Fianna Fáil funds.

Comment on this

He is a "dinger".

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I thought that since we did not touch the dancehall proprietor, we would at least tax the dance band proprietors. They are the boys who are making the money. Anyway, my story for my constituents is a sad one. I can tell the pensioner that he will get 2/6d on 1st August next.

Comment on this

If he lives that long.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I can tell him to stick it out and he will get the 2/6d, but I can also tell him that in the meantime his cigarettes will cost him more. I can tell him that if he is to write a letter to his son—and they all have sons and daughters in England——

Comment on this

Where would they be without them?

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

——it will cost him fivepence. I am not criticising the Budget but the Budgets of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. We must take both together. They are the most severe Budgets that have hit the country in a long time because they will hit the poorer sections. These Budgets are doing away with any little advantages we gave under the ninth round of wage increases. A sure sign that the Budget is unpopular was the speech Deputy Corry made. I know Deputy Corry. I know him to be an honest man.

Comment on this

That is the quote of the week.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

His criticism is always levelled in the right way. He was a prospective Minister for Agriculture. I shall say no more. I am sorry for holding up the House, but I thought it right to point these matters out in a realistic fashion.

Comment on this

This Budget increases taxation by nearly £10 million apart from the £14 million thrown on the people's shoulders by the turnover tax in last year's Budget. Those increases will be borne chiefly by the wage earners and their employers, who are the main contributors to this huge revenue. The expenditure now has gone over the £200 million mark for a population of fewer than 3,000,000. It is easy to calculate the heavy burden being carried by the earning section of our population.

Children and infants, widows, blind pensioners, those in ill health, all the subsistence classes, are not physically able to earn an income sufficient to enable them to keep body and soul together. When those classes are taken out of the population, it is obvious the earning section of the community, which is supporting the other sections —the aged, the disabled and the children, who represent a very high proportion of the population—is carrying a huge burden—more than £200 million.

The failure of the Minister yesterday to tell the full story is very significant. It was only today we learned that in addition to the very heavy burdens proposed by this Budget, he intends to take another £2 million from the business community. The new postal charges proposed are fantastic because they form a big proportion of the expenses of running a business. A letter now will cost fivepence while across the border it is threepence.

Telephone charges are to be increased considerably as well as the rentals on private and commercial lines, not alone those installed but those yet to be put in. Really, it is only the people in business who realise what a very heavy tax this will be. It was bad enough when the postal stamp was increased from threepence to four-pence. Any small firm which had a postage bill of £30 a week then has had a postage bill of £40 a week. It is now proposed to increase the bill to £50 a week. The same applies to firms who issue cards to their customers notifying them that their orders are ready.

The telephone and postage bills in most businesses are already very high and the new charges will hit the commercial community most severely. Of course those extra costs will have to be passed on because the firms concerned cannot be expected to meet them. They must add the extra costs to whatever service they give.

Again, take the business firm with three, six, or ten telephone lines coming into a switchboard. The increase from something like £11 10s. a year to £14 a year and a proportionate increase for the other lines will be a very heavy rental. This charge will apply, apart altogether from the cost of telephone calls which have been increased by about 25 per cent. It is proposed now to apply a collection charge of £10 in respect of telephones. I am interested to know if that will be a deposit or will this £10 go? Is it to be in addition to the rental of £14 a year, making a total of £24 before a person can obtain a call on his newly connected telephone?

These costs are far beyond those which apply for similar services in Northern Ireland or in Britain. It has always been a fact that the Post Office shows a profit on its revenue but I feel that the Minister on this occasion, instead of just trying to provide a service and getting a modest profit from it, is using it as a method of taking in taxation. This is an ordinary method of communication, whether it be social and domestic or commercial, and it should not be taxed so heavily.

The Minister yesterday boasted about industrial production since 1959 having increased on an average of about 4½ per cent. This increase is small when we consider that this was an agricultural economy. Since the agricultural side of our economy would not be sufficient to provide a standard of living to which our people have become accustomed, it was necessary to bring up the industrial side of the economy. That increase of 4½ per cent is nothing to boast about when it is considered that we have the benefit of modern techniques in switching over to an industrial from an agricultural economy. It is fair to say that the average increase should be much higher in these circumstances.

The statistics show an ever-increasing volume of industrial production and export, with the result that revenue from these exports is increasing each year. When the first inter-Party Government were formed, we had a situation in which the agricultural side of our economy was responsible for less than £50 million in the matter of exports. After two periods under Deputy Dillon as Minister for Agriculture, that figure had gone up to £120 million.

Both inter-Party Governments set about encouraging industrial expansion by way of tax concessions and this has done more than any other device to increase our industrial exports. Our industrialists are enterprising people and when they got the opportunity to benefit from an expanding export market by reason of the favourable tax concessions, they succeeded in increasing the volume of exports substantially and that increase is still continuing. I hope they will continue to prosper in this sector and I feel that they can do better than the 4½ per cent average improvement about which the Minister boasted.

The Minister mentioned an extract from the OECD Report saying that in recent years we had gone through a period of the fastest economic growth. That report did not elaborate on the reasons for this growth amongst its members and one of them, at least as far as we are concerned, is that previous to this we were mainly an agricultural community.

The national debt is growing very rapidly. It is a fact that it is now about equal to the annual national income and it is also a fact that the cost of servicing the national debt is the same amount as the taxation which was needed to run the country when Fianna Fáil first came into office. The Minister did not emphasise the fact, but we must face it, that although industrial output has increased considerably and an improvement in our economy has been brought about, our agricultural output has fallen. It is no wonder, considering that approximately 20,000 working on the land left it last year and are continuing to leave. If the manpower continues to flee from the land, it is only to be expected that the output in agriculture will fall and of course the measure of prosperity in agriculture is bound to suffer.

In relation to employment, which was mentioned by the Minister, I would point out that the increased employment has taken place in the industrial sector and also if you like, in the sector of transportable goods. The workers have left the land and have moved into industry. In spite of that, we have around 50,000 or 60,000 people registered unemployed at the moment and seeking work.

We observed recently that in fact the average emigration over the past number of years, in spite of what the Fianna Fáil people tried to tell people, particularly in the by-elections some time ago, has been 33,000. The figures show that since Fianna Fáil came into office seven years ago now, for the last two terms, over 300,000 people have emigrated.

Comment on this

Where did the Deputy get that figure?

Comment on this

These figures are available. They were given in replies.

Comment on this

The OECD gave the emigration figures as 35,000 a year.

Comment on this

Since 1st March, 1957 the number is 210,000, not 300,000.

Comment on this

Where did the Minister get the figures? They are produced by the Government with no proof at all.

Comment on this

I will accept the Minister's figure.

Comment on this

I would not.

Comment on this

But it differs from official figures made available on previous occasions. However, probably, this is an up-to-date revised figure.

Comment on this

Do not be throwing figures around.

Comment on this

The Minister now tells us that 211,000 people ran out of this country——

Comment on this

——in seven years and 150,000 in three years for you.

Comment on this

Where did the Minister get those figures?

Comment on this

In this book here or in the previous book.

Comment on this

It must have been printed in the Department of External Affairs, so.

Comment on this

They are both regrettable but the Deputy might as well quote them correctly.

Comment on this

The booklet from the Department of External Affairs is regrettable. The Minister has now admitted that even the official statistics which he produced here show that 211,000 people have left—approximately 33,000 people a year.

Comment on this

And 50,000 for you.

Comment on this

And in spite of these 33,000 people leaving the country every year, we have 60,000 of them here at home, on the average, who cannot get work.

The Minister mentioned, that the deficit on the balance of payments last year amounted to £22 million and in the previous 12 months, it was £13½ million. The situation would have been worse but for the inflow of capital into this country. Unfortunately, some of that inflow is not of a desirable type. Foreigners are buying up good agricultural land at inflated prices. Similarly, they are coming in the back doors and purchasing house property and enterprises here. If we did not have that type of undesirable capital coming into this country, the deficit on the balance of payments would be very much greater than the £22 million. The £22 million, however, is nothing— it is something to gloss over—and we have a situation now, as a result of the 12 per cent wage increase, in which we can easily expect, next year, a deficit of anything up to £35 million.

The Minister has quite rightly said here—but remember that he and his Government must take the blame for it—that in fact he may find himself facing a problem. It is a very significant sentence and it is one that the country will, I believe, know all about before the end of this year. It is mentioned in his speech on the deficit on the balance of payments. He says: "The outlook for 1964 is good and the balance of payments deficit, though it will be higher than in 1963"—it certainly will—"will contain a temporary hump which we can surmount"—on the graph, I presume. This is the significant sentence: "If they are not, difficulties may develop requiring corrective action." If the deficit on the balance of payments continues to go as it is and if this temporary hump becomes difficult, we can expect that corrective action will be essential. The Minister did mention the danger of domestic inflation as a result of the economic policy being pursued by the Government at the present time. Certainly it is clearly one of expediency.

Last year, a White Paper was issued by the Government. Just this time last year we were recovering from the scars of the debate which took place over that White Paper. That White Paper endeavoured to bring about a wage standstill in this country and as a result of the debate which took place, the Taoiseach found it necessary to throw it in the wastepaper basket, having wasted so much time here in the Dáil on the debate and caused so much anxiety throughout the country. But his case for a wages standstill order envisaged in that White Paper of 1963 had been weakened by his statements of the previous year. When he decided the White Paper was something the nation would not accept and discarded it, he embarked on a policy which certainly will result in inflation.

In the course of his speech the Minister mentioned the danger of the domestic inflation which will probably result from higher consumption as a result of inflated incomes. It is all very well for the Minister to say inflation can be avoided if people run to the bank with their earnings. However, if they spend their earnings, they will create conditions of inflation, because that money will be spent on consumer goods rather than invested in productive enterprises. The ordinary wageearner, pensioner or anybody else on an income uses a high proportion of that income for consumer purposes. It is the consumer side of a person's spending which increases his standard of living. Naturally, if his income is increased substantially, he will use that income to improve his standard of living. He will not run to a bank or to his money box. He will see what this money can do for his standard of living. It is foolish for the Minister to tell these people that if they spend their money on consumer goods, inflation will result. That is the logical result of increased incomes.

The Minister said that consumer spending would further upset our balance of payments. It is true that we may bring ourselves into a situation here where the purchasing power of the £ in this country will be less than the purchasing power of the £ in Great Britain. The question then arises of whether we will be able to get 20/- for the Irish £ in the Bank of England. At the moment our £ is guaranteed at the Bank of England for 20/-. But if the value of the people's money is upset by the economic policy of the Government, we may find ourselves in the position where the Irish £ will not fetch 20/- at the Bank of England. There is the example of Australia. There are approximately 25 Australian shillings for the English £ note. If the Government are not careful in guiding our economy, we may find a difficult situation for the Irish £ at the Bank of England.

One reason for being happy about the value of our exports is the export marketing conditions available for Irish cattle at present. It is unfortunate that the production of more cattle was not encouraged—in fact, it was discouraged—by Fianna Fáil in the past. Now, when it is almost too late in the day, they have brought in this heifer calf subsidy scheme, which will not begin to bear fruit for two or three years to come.

When the 12 per cent wage adjustment was under consideration early this year the arrangement was that it should stand for two and a half years, that the people should not ask for an increase in their incomes for two-and- a-half years after getting this 12 per cent adjustment. Proper consideration was not given to the fact that the cost of living is going to rise considerably according as this 12 per cent increase is paid out. There are thousands of workers who have not yet got this increase and are waiting for it. All these adjustments will have the effect of increasing the cost of goods and services. The result is that those wage-earners who have already got their 12 per cent increase will find their incomes cut down considerably by the rising cost of goods and services in addition to the rise in the cost of living, and no doubt they will be seeking an adjustment for that loss.

The Minister indicated that the 12 per cent increase means at least an increase of £40 million a year to the people who had the benefit of it. However, the £14 million in turnover tax is going to take a good slice of that and in this Budget the Minister proposes to take a further £8 million or £10 million from the taxpayer in general. As I said, the people who have to bear this big burden are the earning section of the community. They pay heavily by way of taxes for whatever national services we have. This £50 million increase will not be matched by an increase in hours worked. The trend is towards a reduction in the number of hours worked per week and per day. It has to be balanced, if possible, by better methods of production and increased output.

But many industries are working to capacity and with a very high degree of efficiency and they cannot hope to balance the increase now coming by greater output or efficiency with the result that the extra burden must be passed on to other sections of the community. No doubt costs in industry of consumer goods, processing and manufacturing and services, are bound to rise as a result of this adjustment. When all the increases are added up we may find ourselves almost priced out of the market for some of our goods. We can prosper so long as we can produce and sell at competitive prices, whether finished articles, agricultural produce or manufactured goods.

We found in recent times considerable difficulty in selling agricultural produce at economic prices. The Minister actually mentioned in his speech that in some respects prices available for agricultural produce are below the cost of production. Naturally, farmers are then driven to some other type of production in order to make a profit to balance their domestic economy. The danger is that goods which must bear these increases, especially where maximum efficiency is already reached leaving no possibility of bridging the gap, must be increased in price and that must be passed on. If the article must carry a higher price the question arises as to whether it can compete with goods of other countries selling in the same market.

We are lucky to have Britain so near us and taking a huge percentage of our agricultural exports and a substantial percentage of industrial exports also. Experience has shown that opportunities for selling Irish produce, agricultural or industrial, in other countries are rather limited. If we price ourselves out of the British market it will be very difficult to find an alternative.

Recently the Government have been accused by Fine Gael of gambling with the nation's assets and taking very serious risks with the future of our economy. They have done many scandalous things recently purely for political expediency. The Minister mentioned that among various items which caused a deficit last year was the £1 million that had to be given as a subsidy to a shipping interest in Cork. That crisis arose shortly before Christmas and £1 million of the taxpayers' money was immediately made available by the Government in order to keep going a concern which has no chance of making a success of ship building in Cork. But the Government won the by-election and that was the primary purpose for which this money was spent. The country cannot continue to afford the improper use of the nation's resources or a policy designed for political advantage instead of for the benefit of the nation generally.

The Minister, according to his figures, I note, will be short about £25 million on the capital expenditure side and I assume he will consider it necessary this year, as last year, to float a national loan to cover that expenditure. It is a remarkable fact that more than a quarter of the people's earnings—self-employed people, wage and salary earners and business people —is collected in taxes to meet the cost of public services. It is a very heavy charge on the people's income. Although the Minister on this occasion has given some benefits to the agricultural community we must accept that the average income of the ablebodied farmer, farmworker and farmer's son is far below the wage level of the lowest paid tradesman at present. Apparently that trend is to continue. They must depend on a ready market for their surplus produce from the land to make ends meet and so give them a reasonable income.

The flight from the land is continuing. From an examination of our economy at present, it is apparent that the good prices available from cattle exports are the backbone of our agricultural economy. The 2d. a gallon on milk being offered to creameries is of course at the expense of the taxpayers in general. The prices for liquid milk, mainly in Dublin and Cork, are related to a particular area which supplies either of these cities and the Minister indicated that a similar price may be expected by milk producers who sell their produce in that area, but they will not get it automatically from taxation; they must get this 2d. a gallon direct from the consumer. In order to get their increase, the battle must begin between the milk producers and the consumers of Dublin and Cork.

The Minister mentioned an increase in prices for Grade A and Grade B pigs but was careful to avoid mentioning that in fact these increases will barely meet the increased cost of feeding stuffs. If you take the increased price of Irish barley, the price of 8/- for Grade A pigs and 5/- for Grade B pigs is only an adjustment to meet the increased cost of feeding stuffs for these pigs. The Budget also indicated that £1¼ million is to be collected from beer. That is a very heavy tax, on both home-produced and imported beer. The Minister should have differentiated between what they call black beer and white beer. Black beer is the stout produced by various firms such as Guinness and Beamish and others. I feel the Minister has done a considerable amount of harm by applying the tax to black beer because it is recognised as the working-man's drink and the increased price is bound to affect his cost of living and encroach on his wages.

I expect that the Minister was approached by the licensed trade regarding this matter but it is regrettable that he could not see the difference between taxing the black beer and other beers because the produce of the country is used in the production of stout and naturally this is going to place a strain on the cost of production.

The Minister was very unfair to the contributory old age pensioners. He allowed half a crown a week only to the non-contributory old age pensioners and, of course, the blind pensioner, the widows, and unemployed, but he should not have left out the other old age pensioners. Nobody will claim that the increase of 2/6 a week, or approximately 4½d a day, is a decent increase to old age pensioners who must try to make ends meet and with prices rising as rapidly as they are. The Minister has been very mean in regard to the social welfare classes. He has set about a taxing rampage, taking all around, taxing petrol, beer, cigarettes and imported spirits.

I conclude by saying that the Minister has done a very bad job for the country. Before the end of the year, we may face an inflationary crisis which will be brought about by the foolish economic policy being pursued by the Government.

Comment on this

It had been apparent to me for a long time that since this Government took office a determined effort has been made in successive Budgets—as I suggested last year and the year before—to project the Taoiseach as the farmers' friend. We all know the prejudices the Taoiseach had to face when he assumed his present high office. It was said he was a city man and that his horizons were limited to the city boundary, that he knew nothing about rural conditions and that he did not care. Therefore it was necessary for the Taoiseach to redress this political imbalance by doing what he could to show that far from being concerned only with industry and the problems of people in towns and cities, he was also one who had the interests of the farmers at heart. This Budget is just another step on that road towards making the Taoiseach appear to the farmers as their friend and ally.

Comment on this