We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Land Bill, 1963—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 121–256 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1963
Enacted

No. 25 of 1963 ›

On a point of order, I said the Land Commission were notified of the position on Wednesday and bought it on Thursday at an auction. That was my statement.

Comment on this

Were houses built?

Comment on this

That was on the following Monday.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

So much for the lighter side of Deputy Corry's contribution. To get down now to the serious implications of the section, I want to tell the House that the auctioneering profession decided to seek the best possible legal opinion on the section. They did so. The auctioneering profession, I may say, hold the Minister for Lands in the highest possible esteem. He is the only Minister for Lands who ever did anything practical for the auctioneers. He was responsible for taking the necessary steps to pay the auctioneers the five per cent commission on land being disposed of and purchased from clients by the Land Commission. In that I think he was right. As one member of the profession, I applaud him for taking such a courageous step, a step with very gratifying and satisfactory results. I sing his praises. We all appreciate what he did.

The auctioneering profession has a very high opinion of the Minister for Lands. They appreciate his efforts. They look upon him as a Minister for Lands who has an intimate knowledge of the law since he is himself a very eminent professional man, or was before he became Minister for Lands, and, in that capacity, he shed great lustre and contributed in no small degree and in a very distinguished manner to his profession. Neverthetheless, the auctioneering profession decided, having read the Bill and having read section 12 particularly, that in order to get first-hand information on that section, they should seek the highest legal opinion they could obtain, and they did so. For the record, may I quote from the legal opinion which was obtained by the auctioneers association?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give us the name?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I quote:

It seems to us that section 12 is now so widely worded——

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I ask what the Deputy is quoting from?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am quoting from a memo which furnishes the Irish Auctioneers and Estate Agents Association with an expression of legal opinion on section 12 of this Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is it a document of the Irish Auctioneers Association?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Yes, to be used in connection with this section. It says:

It seems to us that section 12 is now so widely worded that it is very serious interference with the general right of property ownership. Indeed, a question may arise as to whether the section is unconstitutional. There may be some merit in controlling the disposition of land which has been acquired initially with the assistance of the Land Commission and in respect of which an annuity still may be payable. But the section will equally apply to land not held under any of the Land Acts and to land in respect of which all land annuities have been fully paid off. It seems a gross interference with the right of property ownership that the landowner in such a case cannot deal with his land without the consent of the Land Commission.

It seems a fair inference that this section has been put in so that the Land Commission may be put on notice of virtually all cases where land is being let because the landowner is not directly working the land himself. The Land Commission then has an opportunity of looking at the land with a view to acquisition. The Land Commission will then have an opportunity of negotiating from a position of strength for they can prejudice the landowner's own freedom of action through the expendient of refusing him permission to let the lands and then taking advantage of that to try to depreciate the price at which the land could be purchased.

If article 12 is allowed to stand unchallenged, it would be a serious interference with the right of property ownership.

That is the legal opinion the Irish Auctioneers Association got in connection with section 12.

Comment on this

May I ask for the name of the legal luminary who sent that?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy Flanagan says it is given by a qualified legal practitioner, I shall not force him to give the name.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

May I say that as a member of the Irish Auctioneers Association, I did not receive any of this legal advice at all?

Comment on this

The Deputy must not be on the inside.

Comment on this

I pay my subscription every year anyway.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I can assure the Minister that this legal opinion was expressed to the association for their guidance in relation to this important section. It will have a very serious effect on the auctioneering profession and I am sure that, as an auctioneer himself, Deputy Allen must realise the very serious effect this will have on the auctioneering profession, of which he is a proud and distinguished member.

Comment on this

The Irish Auctioneers Association agreed at one meeting I attended that if the Minister gave a definition of "to let" in section 12, they would be quite satisfied with that section.

Comment on this

If the Minister gave the definition?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The Deputy is easily satisfied.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

This expression of opinion is shared by all people of commonsense and average intelligence. They know quite well the serious implications it has in regard to the right of the individual who owns property. Let me leave aside for one moment the valuable expression of legal opinion obtained by the auctioneering profession and come to a further opinion with which I am sure Deputy Corry will not find fault. It comes from the National Farmers Association. The National Farmers Association is a very reputable and distinguished body, representative of all the farmers. The considered opinion of that body was sent, under the title "Observations on Land Bill, 1963" to members of this House and particularly to the Minister for Lands. The NFA had something very special to say about section 12 in this memorandum which was issued from their headquarters at 27 Earlsfort Terrace, Dublin. They say:

Section 12 provides that the subdivision, letting and subletting of all agricultural land in the State shall be subject to Land Commission consent.

The Minister has stated that this does not and is not intended to apply to conacre or agistment lettings. No specific exemption is written into the Bill itself, but amendment 24b, put down by the Minister, states that "The powers of the Land Commission under this section shall be so exercised as to prevent the creation or continuance of holdings which, in the opinion of the Land Commission, are not economic holdings". This indicates that the emphasis is on preventing fragmentation of holdings and we agree that such prevention is essential. However, bearing in mind that there are adequate provisions elsewhere in the Bill to control undesirable forms of conacre, we recommend that conacre and agistment lettings should be specifically exempted in Section 12.

We see no reason why a reasonable time limit, say, one month, should not apply to Land Commission consideration of applications under this section. Failing any objection by the Land Commission within one month the applications should be deemed to have been granted.

That is the considered opinion of the NFA, the farmers. In the NFA there are smallholders, uneconomic holders and conacre tenants as well as substantial farmers. Therefore, when the NFA speak, I presume they are speaking with the full knowledge that they are the mouthpiece of the farmers. I am glad I have placed on record the legal opinion obtained by the auctioneering profession, and the considered opinion, after lengthy consideration, of the farmers through their organisation, the NFA. What greater incentive could the Minister have than to act on the knowledge and advice obtained by the auctioneering profession and the farmers?

I ask the Minister even at this late stage to withdraw the section from the Bill entirely and completely, or to tell the House what does he propose to achieve by leaving it in the Bill. He has not done so. Every time the Minister rises to speak on section 12, he says he has dealt with it all before, that he will not go over it again, and sits down. I did not leave the House from the time the Land Bill was first mentioned today till this moment, and I did not hear the Minister deal with section 12. I heard him make rambling statements, roving and roaming through various Acts. He quoted the Hogan Act and other acts but we are dealing with the 1963 Bill, and section 12 of the 1963 Bill.

When the Minister gets up to speak again, I am sure he will comment on the legal opinion and the opinion of the NFA which I have quoted. Will he tell the House what does he propose to achieve by leaving section 12 in the Bill? Will he do what he was requested to do and make clear what he proposes to achieve with the section? Referring to Deputy O'Higgins's speech he said that every first year student knows that conacre lettings are excluded in the 1923 Land Act, and excluded from the terms of this section and this Bill. There is nothing in this Bill or in this section to indicate clearly and legally to me that conacre lettings are excluded.

As has been pointed out 20 times multiplied by ten in this House, when you are before a learned judge, he will be determining not what the Minister says, not what Deputy Corry says, not what any Deputy says, but what is in the Bill. That is why the NFA have asked in a reasonable, mild, cool and calm way that agistments and conacre lettings should be exempted from section 12 and that the Minister should say so.

The Minister wants the speedy passage of the Bill. Would it not be very easy for him to stand up and say: "In view of what has been said, in view of the expressions of opinion that have been quoted, and moved by the eloquence of Deputy Corry, on Report Stage I will put in three lines exempting agistments, conacre and temporary lettings"? If that were done, we could all sit down, pass the section, and say we had done a good night's work. The Minister would get a halo from the auctioneering profession to go around his head. We might even consider purchasing a bust of the Minister and putting it in the main hall of our office. The Minister appears to have lost his patience. From time to time we all lose our patience. The Minister may now be in a more pleasant mood than he was earlier, and I ask him to come back on Report Stage and exempt conacre, agistments and temporary lettings.

Comment on this

I was inclined to pay some heed to the legal opinion quoted by Deputy Flanagan until he followed it up with a statement of the losses the auctioneers would be at if section 12 went through. We all know what legal opinion is. If you could not get two legal opinions from two legal gentlemen, there would be no law cases and no judges. The first thing a legal gentleman asks is what will suit you. Certainly he had 100 per cent proof from Deputy Flanagan that what would suit the auctioneering profession was that he should condemn section 12 in all its moods and tenses, and he did so.

How often have we gone to one of those gentlemen and got five or six pages of a legal opinion? How often have we seen it sent to the local authorities and when the case was over, you would wonder what had happened when you came out and found you had lost the case, with costs given against you. That is all I care about legal opinion. They ask: "What does he want us to say—that the section is all right or that it is rotten, harmful, wrong and contrary to the Constitution? If he wants us to say that, we will do so." That is my point of view on legal opinion and I do not care who likes it and who does not.

I have given instances of the harm that has been done by this widespread letting of land, particularly in the vicinity of Dublin. I have mentioned the man with the cheque for £27,000. Either the auctioneers combined to take all the conacre for him, or they had their instructions: "Look, knock it down to So-and-So, no matter what happens and no matter what price it goes." That man had between 2,000 and 3,000 acres of land under wheat. That has driven the ordinary tillage farmer out of grain.

Comment on this

There is nothing in section 12 to catch that man.

Comment on this

Is there not? The Deputy will be surprised.

Comment on this

I wish there were.

Comment on this

I know there is.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know. The Deputy had better tell him.

Comment on this

The auctioneers association says there is. They are worried about it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

They are worried about what?

Comment on this

The Minister agreed with me that conacre and 11 months lettings are specifically excluded. He said that.

Comment on this

Anywhere there is a letting of land over a continued period——

Comment on this

The Minister will be very mad with the Deputy if he keeps that up.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen is right. It is not in the Bill.

Comment on this

He is assisting the Deputy's filibustering. That is all.

Comment on this

It is not in the Bill. We are all agreed now, except the Minister.

Comment on this

If any of these things are not in the Bill, what is Deputy Flanagan looking for? He said that if the Minister brought in three lines to keep conacre out of this, we would all go home happy.

Comment on this

He did not.

Comment on this

What does he mean, if it is not in it?

Comment on this

Three words—cut out the section.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

That is what we want to know. Deputy Flanagan tried to put the tail and horns on my statement about the holding the Land Commission purchased. The facts were that it had to be proved that portion of the holding was acquired from migrants or else it could be paid for only in land bonds. As an auctioneer, Deputy Flanagan knows that, if he knows anything at all about it. I can understand Deputy Flanagan's worry and the worry of other auctioneers in this matter. It is sticking out a mile. I have already given here the condition of affairs as I found them in my constituency which is supposed to be a completely non-congested area and the absolute necessity for getting hold of land there and it is my intention to get hold of that land come hell or high water.

Comment on this

I shall be brief on this occasion. I want to answer the remarks of Deputy Corry. He referred to the stub of a cheque for £27,000 for conacre wheat which somebody in Dublin or some wheat miller has in his possession. I accept the Deputy's word about it. I have referred also to 105 transactions in seven counties and the 105 transactions were in connection with the conacre letting of land for the growing of wheat. The total lettings were 40,000 acres.

I want to make my position clear in this matter. Section 12 will not strengthen, according to the Minister, his hands in the slightest degree in any effort he may make to take that land from those individuals who are letting it or the people who are exploiting it. There is nothing in section 12 that will enable the Minister to lay hands on the land for which Deputy Corry stated £27,000 was paid for the letting. That is the trouble.

While we oppose this section, I want to make it quite clear that we do so for motives completely different from those put forward by Deputy Donegan. I should like to quote what the National Farmers Association did say in their full comment on section 12. I agree with Deputy Flanagan that their criticism, as he quoted it here, is accurate but he should have finished it. They went on to say that the Minister had introduced amendment 24 (b) which states:

The power of the Land Commission under this section shall be so exercised as to prevent the creation or continuance of holdings which in the opinion of the Land Commission are not economic holdings.

In other words, the Minister was out to allay the fears of the National Farmers Association by saying: "Look, boys, I shall not touch the 100-, 200-, 500-acre farmers but I shall concentrate on the small farmer and on the uneconomic farmer in the congested areas".

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is right.

Comment on this

I quoted already the Report of the Committee on Small Western Farms to the effect that they believe the Minister should move on this. The Minister stated, as reported at Column 66 of the Official Report of 27th November last, in his introduction to this measure:

I have borne in mind particularly the demand of the people in the congested areas for a higher standard of living. The fact that in certain parts of the country many holdings lie vacant and let.... The Report of the inter-departmental Committee on the Problems of Small Western Farms was most revealing also in filling out the picture of the problems confronting us.

The Minister went to the report of the Committee on Small Western Farms in order to get a certain background to suit him in regard to this measure. He did so not for the purpose of improving the conditions of the congests but in order to get sufficient arguments that would enable him to bring in a measure to bring about the structural changes which in the process of bringing them about would eliminate the small holding.

Paragraph 11 of the inter-departmental Committee's Report states that the table attached to the report in Appendix D gives particulars of the lands let in the West of Ireland and in the congested areas. Even in this report, they sought to suggest that in the west the greatest amount of land was being let. On that basis, the Minister brought in this section to deal with that and to get rid of the small farmers.

What is the position? In fact, in the east and in the midlands of this country, according to Appendix D in the report of the inter-departmental Committee on Small Western Farms, over 10.4 per cent of the lands are either wholly or partly let and in the west of Ireland where all the talk is about and where the report concentrates, the figure is only 10.5 per cent. There is a difference of .1 per cent between the letting figure for the east and west of Ireland.

Let is look at the types of holdings in the east of Ireland which are being excluded according to the Minister. Here are the figures. In the 100- and 200-acre groups in the east of Ireland, 8.4 per cent of the lands are let. In the over 200-acre group in the east of Ireland, 12.9 per cent of the lands are let. If we compare the number of 200-acre holdings in the east of Ireland and in the west of Ireland it becomes really apparent to this House that there is no comparison whatever—if I might repeat that word again—with regard to the numbers.

There are few holdings left in the west over 200 acres but we have a large percentage of holdings in the midlands over 200 acres—and over 12 per cent of those are let. Section 12, according to the Minister, will not touch those holdings because at the moment they can be described as economic. But consider the small holding and the uneconomic holding in the west. Fifty per cent of the owners had to get out of the country and the same 50 per cent would like to come back to rear their families here at some stage. They will now be caught under this section. The very man Deputy Corry mentioned in Cork, with the 15 to 20 acres surrounding the 500-acre farm, waiting, and rightly so, for a division of that estate, can now be caught under section 12. If they attempt, in the meantime, to go to England and sublet their lands, they can now be caught by the Minister under this section.

Deputy Corry should think twice before supporting the Minister on this. It is bad enough to find that 47,000 people have left the land in six years because no attempt was made to hold them and allow them rear families on proper-sized holdings. We are now legislating to drive far more off the land.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy talking about farm labourers or farmers?

Comment on this

The Deputy is a bit "puggled." I see his brains are slightly addled this evening and he should keep quiet. By inaction, by criminal neglect, we have allowed the rural population to decline.

Comment on this

The relevancy of this to section 12 is beyond my comprehension.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is going wide of the section.

Comment on this

He wants to aid Fine Gael in their filibuster.

Comment on this

It is not a filibuster. The Minister intervenes and says it is out of order every time he is hurt and the House must accept his version.

Comment on this

All the filibustering did not come from this side of the House.

Comment on this

Section 12 relates to the small holder and the uneconomic holder. That is the man who is disappearing because of the inaction and neglect of all Governments. Are we seriously being asked to speed up that haemorrhage of people from the land by legislating for it? I do not think we should agree to do so.

There was a meeting in the west not long ago at which three bishops attended. I have never acted as spokesman for the bishops in this House. They have plenty of other spokesmen without calling on me.

Comment on this

I never heard the Deputy condemning them, all the same.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy would love to hear me. I would not be far down the corridor until he would be in front of me. They met to discuss the serious decline in population in the west. The meeting was addressed by a very eminent Donegal priest who put forward certain plans to stop emigration from the west.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I cannot see how the Deputy can discuss the economic ills of any area on section 12.

Comment on this

The section is to enable the Minister to wipe out the very people which this meeting sought to protect. We had the spectacle of Government spokesmen sneering at the idea that these people were in a position to offer expert advice on how to keep the remainder on the land. The key to it is co-operation and making available to these people credit, financial accommodation and educational facilities.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is wide of the section. The Deputy should relate his remarks to the section.

Comment on this

Instead of utilising section 12 for the purpose of getting rid of the small farmers and congests, the Minister should find alternative means of securing them on the land. For that reason I oppose the passage of section 12 as vehemently as I can. Deputy Corry should waken up to the fact that it is no help to the people in his constituency.

Comment on this

I gather from what Deputy Flanagan said that the Minister, intervening in this debate, referred to the view I expressed earlier with regard to the definition of letting and subletting in section 12. Apparently, the Minister said that any first year law student would know certain things. I am not a first year law student; I am a Deputy of this House, and anything I express I express as a Deputy. May I repeat what I said earlier that, as far as I am aware as a Deputy, in none of the Land Acts is there any definition of what letting or subletting means. In the Hogan Act passed by this House in 1923 provision was made that all tenanted land in Ireland would on an appointed day vest in the Land Commission. That was an Act designed by the late Paddy Hogan to end, once and for all, the idea of landlordism in this country. It achieved that by providing that every portion of agricultural land which happened to be leased or tenanted to a landlord would on an appointed day vest in the Land Commission. From that on until the property was dealt with, it would be held from the Land Commission. The Minister says in that Act there is a definition of letting which excludes conacre, pasturage and provisions of that kind. I challenge him to point out where it is.

Comment on this

Do not put up Aunt Sallys to knock down. I said no such thing.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister said.

Comment on this

Do not misquote me.

Comment on this

Then, I presume the Minister did not say that. May I repeat what I said earlier: in none of the Land Acts is there any definition of letting and subletting which excludes conacre, pasturage, agistment or lettings of that kind. There have been common decisions by judges, of which I am aware, but that is not an issue. The interesting thing in this Bill is that there is a definition section which defines a congested area and various other things but nowhere is there any effort to define the words we are concerned with in section 12 "letting or subletting" or "subdivide".

The Minister has offered us an opinion, based presumably on advice given to him, but has not offered to write it into the section. I think what Deputy Flanagan said is quite a reasonable observation. If the Minister is so clear that this section could not possibly refer to what Deputy McQuillan feels it does refer to, why not put the matter finally at ease one way or another by so providing in the section? Why is it that the section leaves it so vague using the terms "letting or subletting" without defining them, leaving Deputy Flanagan, Deputy Donegan and myself to draw one inference and leaving Deputy McQuillan to draw an entirely different inference, with the Minister quite happy in between? This is a section which is unnecessary and is kept in the Bill for some reason which has not been satisfactorily explained. If it is passed, it will give to some authority a power which should not be there and is unnecessary to the solution of the land resettlement problem. On all grounds, it is, in my view, obviously a wrong section to have in the Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy McQuillan has, in fact, produced an excellent argument regarding this problem. I am sure he can see that on our side we have, for different reasons, reached the same conclusion that this is a bad section. Why, as the Deputy said, when the Minister sought to placate the NFA by putting in amendment 24 (b), did he not go on to specify conacre lettings and agistments?

When I hear there is to be a list in the Land Commission—I maintain this is against the Minister because this is the first time such a list will be compiled of all lettings—I begin to worry whether this will result in land division by the officers of the Land Commission. For the first time also, in another section, the Minister has the right to start division proceedings where perhaps things should be left as they are. With the exception of the clearance people from Deputy McQuillan's area, I still insist there is no case for anything but the bid by the unknown bidder and the Land Commission at the auction.

I heard the other day from a reputable auctioneer that if an auctioneer sends in a list of clients with land to offer to the Land Commission, he will get full commission on the first £5,000 of any purchase and a lesser commission on the balance. What does that open up? It is another sort of list. Who is an auctioneer's client? Take the situation where an auctioneer comes up to a man that he thinks might sell his farm and says: "I may have a customer for your land. I take it the value might be £7,000 or £8,000. Have I the right to inquire for you?" The farmer says: "Yes, you have." Why should he not, if he is interested in selling or if he thinks the price would suit him? That is his first reaction and he is probably a friend of the auctioneer. But when this Bill is forgotten and is a piece of legislation, down goes his name on a list in the Land Commission. Later, some junior official in the Land Commission, looking at the number of congests in the area and the kind of land it is, reaches a conclusion and before the man knows where he is, the first bid is in from the Land Commission or perhaps acquisition proceedings are begun. At that stage his land may have changed in value by 50 per cent. Will this lead people to make investment in land?

I put down a question a few weeks ago about a particular estate, the name of which I did not mention and will not mention now. I asked if it were Land Commission policy to institute proceedings for the purchase of land when a farmer of £40 valuation with three boys and three girls growing up had paid a deposit on the land to purchase it? I got an inconsequential answer. I asked supplementary questions. Deputy Faulkner from my own constituency also came in. The next thing happened was that the Land Commission went in and bid more money. The good deed I did was to get more money for the owner of the land. More luck to him. I am delighted with that.

There are other factors to be considered. There is no use in saying that everything goes back to the Lay Commissioners, four people with the standing of High Court judges, and that the Minister, the Fianna Fáil cumann or the Fine Gael branch or the Labour Party branch has no influence on the Land Commission in the division of land. Under this section we are to have a list of all the land let in the country except the 11-month lettings and also a list of another kind and queer things can happen.

Regarding Deputy Corry and his £27,000 cheque for wheat, I think it was rather like his Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday purchase and sale and division of land. The snag about it is that the man mentioned does not buy himself but through agents. He could not have known the name of the individual farmer.

Comment on this

The cheque was to an individual farmer.

Comment on this

The Minister should accede to the very reasonable request of Deputy O'Higgins regarding an addition to the definition section. The Minister is taking a wide power that, no matter what he may have said earlier, this Parliament never attempted to take before. In that regard I want to protest against the terms of the explanatory memorandum issued in respect of this Bill and which is used by the Press and others for the purpose of explaining the Bill to the public. We are told in it, at page 3, that section 11 provides that the subdivision, letting or subletting of all agricultural land in the State shall be subject to Land Commission consent. It would be much fairer, more honest and explicit if the alleged explanation said the section provided that the subdivision, letting and subletting of all agricultural land in the State shall be subject to land Commission control. That is what it means, no matter what the Minister may say.

More and more control is being exercised over the ordinary citizen in regard to rights in his own private property. I should like to refer the House to what exactly "holding" means in relation to section 12.

In this section "holding", in relation to a particular tenant or proprietor, means all the property held by him at or after the passing of this Act under a single demise, whether fee simple, fee farm grant or leasehold or from year to year, etc.

All estates of any land are subject not to the consent—I defy the Minister to deny this—but to the control of the Minister and the Land Commission and some hidden hand somewhere over which the property owners have no control once this section passes. In these circumstances, the very least—I would deem it no concession—the Minister can do is accede to Deputy O'Higgins's request that people whose land is now to be subject to the control of some person or persons described here as the Land Commission, should know exactly what letting and sub-letting mean.

Let me protest again against the compendious terms of this section and against the manner in which it was submitted to the House by way of alleged explanation in the explanatory memorandum which goes on to say:

It is intended as a global provision taking the place of the unsatisfactory patch-work of control operating under existing enactments which are listed for repeal in the First Schedule.

I would understand that sentence to mean that the Land Commission already had these powers. That is not a fact. The Minister knows it is not and when this explanatory memorandum was submitted to Deputies, it was known that it was not a fact and this was, in my opinion, deliberately or otherwise, a misrepresentation of legislation which this House is asked to pass. It was never a fact that up to now all land, whether fee simple, fee-farm grant, or leasehold, or from year to year, or held jointly or in common or alone or in severalty, was subject to the control which the Minister now seeks to obtain over it for the Land Commission. Again let me protest against this: it is revolutionary in the extreme and it is a section which the House should not pass.

Comment on this

This debate has taken a rather extraordinary turn because we now have the Fine Gael Party making a submission, the Minister seems to think that what they are arguing is included in the Bill, and we have some Fianna Fáil back-benchers stating that they consider, although they did not know it at the time, that what the Fine Gael Party are saying is correct and we in the Labour Party——

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

The Deputy did not realise it but he said it.

Comment on this

Read the first two lines of section 12.

Comment on this

We are all grateful to Deputy Corry for the assistance he gave us in keeping the debate going but he should let somebody else in now.

Comment on this

The Minister is looking at Deputy Corry very kindly.

Comment on this

We are opposing the section for an entirely different reason. Perhaps the fairest thing to do at this stage would be to allow the Minister to have another look at the section. He must realise by now that it must be very confusing; otherwise the discussion could not possibly have taken the turn which it has. Unfortunately, I am not in the position that Deputy Corry is in and when I report a big farm with a number of small farms to the Land Commission, they tell me in six months' time that they had not been able to get around to it. Deputy Corry could report it and get it——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

In three days.

Comment on this

You would never get the houses built in three days.

Comment on this

The position as we see it is that conacre, and I am referring to conacre on a large scale and particularly to what remains of the wheat ranches, is not interfered with in the Bill. The Minister—I hope I am not misquoting him—says that conacre will still be allowed. If conacre is still allowed, wheat ranchers can without let or hindrance continue to take large tracts of land and make a fat profit, whether they come from Germany or from Cork. It does not matter where the farmer comes from—he can get the conacre and if the weather is fine, pick up a very substantial profit.

The Labour Party do not want the small farmers' rights interfered with but we do believe—and here is where I disagree with Deputy Donegan—that if there is a big farmer who is continually letting his land, whether for conacre or on the 11 months system, or for five years or ten years, it is right that the Land Commission should consider taking it from him. We have no objection to that and we would support the Minister on it.

Comment on this

And I would agree with that.

Comment on this

We do not say that the Land Commission should have the right to go to the holder of a small farm and have the further right to take the land from such people because through some unfortunate circumstances they had to let the land over a short period. I do not think there is anything wrong with that and it should be allowed. As Deputy McQuillan said, it is quite clear what the Minister wants to do here. He wants to get authority to get at the small farmer. What assistance this is going to give him in the relief of congestion I do not know. Perhaps I do not know enough about the west of Ireland but Deputy McQuillan certainly does and I am prepared to take his word for it. As far as Meath is concerned, there are large farms which can be taken over by the Land Commission but they do not seem to be in a hurry to do so. They have a sizeable amount of land and if there is talk about subletting, they should be the first to stop it because they have 9,000 acres sublet for a number of years and they will continue to do that as long as they feel like it. We will support the Minister on the question of subletting of large farms—the Land Commission should take them over— but we are not prepared to have the small farmer further abused.

Comment on this

The more one listens to Fine Gael and Labour speakers in this debate, the more one becomes confused. All sorts of irrelevant matters are being dragged in, even to the extent of Deputy McQuillan quoting high authorities. We must be fair and objective in our criticism of what the Minister is aiming at. I do not see why the Minister should be asked to make a distinction between one farmer and another. I know as much about congestion as Deputy McQuillan or Deputy Tully or any other Deputy.

Comment on this

Is he not making an exception?

Comment on this

He is not.

Comment on this

Of course he is.

Comment on this

He is catering specifically for the small landholder. When he is trying to do that, I submit he is entitled to fair play, whatever criticism we may express about the Bill. We know that there are derelict small holdings in Deputy McQuillan's county. Why should the Minister not have the same control and be able to say to the owners of these derelict small holdings: "You must return here from abroad and indulge in some form of husbandry; otherwise I cannot permit you to continue to let your land whilst I am at the same time going to penalise a landholder in Meath, Longford or Westmeath"? Why should Deputy McQuillan or Deputy Tully seek to introduce a form of partition, if you like, into section 12?

We have heard a great deal from the opposite benches about foreigners buying land and every Order Paper carries questions regarding the division of lands. We must look at this matter in a reasonable fashion. As we know, there is a demand for more land division. There is pressure in this House every day in the week in regard to it and there is also pressure from outside, as Deputy McQuillan has stated. From platform and pulpit, we hear the call for more land division.

It is assumed that if the Minister wants the Land Commission to play an active part in the rearrangement of holdings and the division of land, they must have the necessary powers so that their intentions in this regard will not be exploited as, we happen to know, their intentions were exploited in the past. All of us know that if a holding is for sale and it is mentioned in the locality that the Land Commission is a potential buyer, the value of the land automatically goes up. We must have sufficient common sense to realise that if the Minister is to allow the Land Commission to stand by powerless while manipulation of the kind we have talked about is going on, he could be deemed to have no power or authority over land division.

Comment on this

The Deputy is getting bogged down.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not getting bogged down. The Deputy knows more about land division than Deputy McQuillan knows. I want to bring that home to the Deputy. I may not be as long-winded in this House but I happen to know the demographic pattern in this country just as well as the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Deputy is in the Bog of Allen now.

Comment on this

I am not in the Bog of Allen. I can go to the Deputy's own door and point out derelict holdings to him, some of which have been derelict for the past ten or 12 years. It should be our aim to encourage a pattern of good husbandry, not merely on large farms but on small farms. As I have said at the outset, no one has given me or has given the House a blueprint for an economic holding. I want to ask the Deputy: why should the Minister not have the same power of consent in regard to land in the congested areas as he would have, say, in regard to land elsewhere?

As regards Deputy Donegan's argument, I do not think he favours land division at all. He comes from a very good county. He was candid enough to say that much; that, in fact, he does not agree with the policy of land division or rearrangement at all.

Comment on this

And particularly compulsory acquisition.

Comment on this

The net point is this: Every Deputy would need a Land Bill of his own and none of us would be satisfied even if we got permission to introduce a Private Member's Bill. It might be the easiest solution for the Minister if he were to say, "I will leave it to the House. Let each Deputy bring in a Private Member's Bill to suit himself." Each of us would do that. The more I listened tonight to the various arguments made, the more I am convinced that each Deputy would want to divide land in his own way, to suit his own locality and the people living there.

Comment on this

My Bill would be the shortest of all.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I would support Deputy Corry's Bill—to take the land on Wednesday and divide it on Friday.

Comment on this

Whatever long-winded arguments we may have heard about the NFA, the NFA, if I interpret their intentions correctly, issued documents regarding foreginers buying land here and the NFA were as long-winded on this subject as any other organisation or as any Deputy.

Comment on this

Including Deputy Carter.

Comment on this

Including Deputy Carter and Deputy McQuillan and others. There is also the fact that the NFA did not formulate a blueprint, so far as I am aware, for land division. It is a matter that the NFA or any other voluntary organisation would shy away from because it is a difficult problem. As we are all aware, it is tied up with historical emotions which have been handed down to us from the past. Land has been the cause of major conflicts here and of minor conflicts also and, to that extent, no one will begrudge the Minister for Lands whatever power he seeks in this Bill, short of, as he said himself, setting out to exterminate the farmers. The powers he seeks in the Bill are powers with which we are all familiar and some of the powers, as the Minister said, have existed since the 1923 Land Act. Therefore I cannot see why the Labour Party, in particular, take such a strong view of section 12. I cannot see anything in it that will operate to the detriment, shall we say, of the small holder.

Comment on this

I intervene to try to alter Deputy Carter's view of this question of creating a new form of partition in the country. It has been suggested that Deputy Tully's speeches and my speeches have sought to create a sort of partition in so far as land is concerned. In fact, it is the Minister and Deputy Carter who are seeking to create a form of partition in this matter.

My reading of the section, and the Minister's expressed interpretation of the National Farmers Association document on it, make it quite clear that the large holding set to conacre is to be excluded from the terms of the section, but the small farmer—the congest in Roscommon and elsewhere, with ten or 15 acres of land, who could not live on it economically, who has set it and is living in England pending the time he can return and resume occupation—is to be included. This section enables the Land Commission to acquire that man's holding, whereas the 200-acre holding set for conacre in County Longford is to be excluded.

Comment on this

We have not any 200-acre holdings in Longford.

Comment on this

I should like Deputy Carter to get his mind clear. If they have not got any such holdings in Longford, such holdings are not too far away from his constituency. It is not so many years since I raised questions here on a number of farms, including a chain of farms in County Longford which had been bought by the jodhpurred gentlemen. We have now got the truth from the Deputy. Is it the Fianna Fáil view now, as expressed by Deputy Carter, that the ten-acre holder in the west, who through economic circumstances was forced to emigrate, must now return on the direction of Fianna Fáil and resume occupancy or get out? Is that the purpose of the section?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has made that point on more than one occasion.

Comment on this

Deputy Carter made a charge against me in reference to Roscommon. He suggested that I knew farms sublet, with the owners in England. Of course I do, but I also know the reason why.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is merely pointing out that the Deputy is repeating himself.

Comment on this

I do not wish to do that. I merely endeavoured to point out the number of farmers who are leaving my constituency and the fact that they are doing so against their will. They leave but they did not want to go. They go because they have to. Now we have this segregation, this partition being imposed. They are the people who are being got at in this section, not the farmers in Meath or Westmeath, or the occasional one in Longford about whom Deputy Carter does not seem to be aware.

The Minister will not have any difficulty, as far as the Labour Party are concerned, if he makes it clear that the section is to embrace the type of farmer Deputy Tully and I have been referring to. I do not want to be repetitious. I want the Minister to say whether or not it is correct that 200-acre holdings in the midlands which are being let and used for conacre purposes are to be excluded.

Comment on this

The Deputy is getting preference throughout the entire Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Carter will realise that the small farmer who depends on the production of pigs to a great extent is not in the same position in regard to subsidies as the rancher——

Comment on this

That has nothing to do with section 12.

Comment on this

It is the small farmer, at present existing on the production of pigs because he cannot make a reasonable living otherwise on his ten-acre holding, who is being hit while the man subsidised for wheat growing on 200 acres is to be excluded. Where is the genuine equality of treatment? If it is there, I cannot see it, and I am surprised at Deputy Carter from Longford taking the view that there should be one law for the small, the weak, the uneconomic and another for the rich and the well to do.

Comment on this

Equity.

Comment on this

There is no equity in it.

Comment on this

Deputy McQuillan is either retiring into second childhood or inviting the Minister to commit suicide. Can one imagine the Minister, from County Mayo, coming into the House with the intention of taking a 20-acre or 15-acre holding from a congest? Would that not be suicide?

Comment on this

That is why he will not say what his intention is.

Comment on this

I saw people on that side of the House committing suicide often enough, but surely not Deputy Michael Moran from Mayo.

Comment on this

Perhaps before the end of the Bill.

Comment on this

The section says that an agricultural holding shall not be let, sublet or subdivided without the consent in writing of the Land Commission. That is the provision before the House. It applies to the conacre man and the rest of them. This Minister or any other Minister cannot change that section, once it has been enacted by the House.

Comment on this

He brought in an amendment to it and the Deputy supported it.

Comment on this

We shall see the amendments when they come before us.

Comment on this

It has been passed —amendment No. 24b.

Comment on this

Has it to do with quack lawyers? This seems to be a home for them.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy in order in referring to any Deputy in those terms? He may be referring to his own Minister or to Members of either this side or his own side of the House.

Comment on this

If the dirty milk man would keep quiet, we could get on.

Comment on this

Is this general charge in order? Is it in order for a member to refer to other members of this House, whether they be of Ministerial rank or otherwise, as "quack lawyers"? Is it in order or not in order?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As it is a general remark and not one applying to any Deputy, it is quite in order.

Comment on this

That is one for——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That ruling does not give the Deputy the right to be Ceann Comhairle as well.

Comment on this

I put a new road into your graveyard the other day. That should satisfy you.

Comment on this

It would not be the first time.

Comment on this

I was about to say that no Minister or Deputy may change an Act of Parliament. It is the duty of Deputies in their constituencies to see that where 200-acre and 500-acre farms are let in conacre year after year, they will be dealt with under legislation enacted in the House.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

We cannot help noting the silence of the Minister on section 12. I really feel——

Comment on this

The Deputy really feels he might get me to aid and abet him in his obstruction.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I would not accuse the Minister of something I should not like to be guilty of myself.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not as innocent as he looks.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister will not find any Deputy from this side of the House guilty of obstruction.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been guilty of obstruction since the day the Bill first came before the House.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The most constructive ideas have come from this side of the House. They have been suggestions based on commonsense and intelligence——

Comment on this

On what?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

——and backed by sincerity, supported by an intimate knowledge of conditions in rural Ireland. I just wanted to inquire what is the reason for the Minister's silence on this section.

Comment on this