Committee on Finance. - Land Bill, 1963—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 116–247 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1963 ›
(South Tipperary): I do not know the level of the Minister's comprehension. Any suggestion of interference in the private relationship between a solicitor and his client upsets the Minister. I would be the first person to support the Minister in any attempt he might make to defend the private relationship between a solicitor and his client. It is a fundamental thing; it is something we should all protect. But what we are asking is no grave departure from what has existed for a number of years. We merely want the Land Commission informed by any legal agent purchasing land for a foreigner, or for a foreign trust, of the nationality of the purchaser. There is nothing revolutionary in that departure. I see no difficulty for the Minister or his parliamentary draftsman in accepting that amendment in principle and drafting regulations to make that practicable.
The Minister pretends not to understand. He says that is not in the amendment. The purpose behind the amendment is crystal clear. If it is not, it has been made clear by speaker after speaker. We merely want to give our own people a first crack at land if it is going, rather than that the foreigner with a lot of money should come in and buy it and our own people should wake up the next morning to find the land gone.
It is as simple as that. I do not know in what more simple language I can explain it. It appears the Minister rejects it because I am not able to draft some kind of legal formula. The Minister has more ability in that respect than I have, because it is his life's work. He is a lawyer. I do other jobs at which the Minister might not be so efficient. At least he understands the purpose of the amendment and, if he has any sympathy with it, which, of course he has not because he is antagonistic towards it, he would at once say that he accepts the principle, but thinks the amendment is badly drafted: "I would suggest you do so and so with it." He has given us no indication of how far he will go. He merely persists in the obstinate attitude he has consistently adopted all through this debate. He will not even answer the simple question: does he accept in principle the fact that an Irishman should have even that slight advantage over an alien in the purchase of land? Does he accept even that slight differential in favour of our own people?
Comment on this
May I suggest to the Minister that he has twice or three times offered to meet us, but what he offers us we cannot accept, and he has then more or less jibed at us and said the drafting of the amendment is wrong—it is unworkable, impossible, and so forth. May I respectfully suggest that the Minister is himself a lawyer and is considered to be quite an expert on land legislation, coming, as he does, from a county in which there is a good deal of that sort of work. Apart from that, he has expert advisers whose job it is to draft legislation and, if they are not in a position to draft it, they may refer it to more experts in order to produce something which will achieve the object we desire to achieve.
The last time the Minister intervened, he said he could not understand what we wanted and he said the Labour Party could not understand it, either. I learn with deep regret that the Labour Party are in difficulties as to what we want and I beg to intervene now to make crystal clear what we want and to ask the Minister if he could see his way to drafting something to meet our requirements, doing it himself, if he feels qualified, or, if he does not, doing it by falling back on his expert advisers. Where we join issue with the Minister is that he wants legislation whereunder no national, or anybody else who owns land, can sell that land without the consent of the Land Commission. In all fairness, I think my colleagues—I am glad to see those on the opposite benches are now listening to me with respectful silence —will see that it is desirable that Irish nationals with vested holdings, whether they are subject to a Land Commission annuity or otherwise, should have the right to free sale.
What we are asking the Minister to do is simply to perpetuate that right. We do not agree with interfering with the rights of Irish nationals and we are asking the Minister to draft an amendment whereby aliens will not have the same rights to buy. I have stated the reasons before. The Minister says he cannot understand them. May I briefly state them now?
Comment on this
The Deputy has stated the same thing at least four times since I came into this Chair. The same thing has been said repeatedly.
Comment on this
With respect, I said I was forced to repeat something and you ruled me out of order before I had an opportunity of saying it.
Comment on this
I rule that repetition is out of order, even if what is going to be said is indicated.
Comment on this
It will be extremely difficult for Deputies to debate in Dáil Éireann if the Chair rules them out of order before knowing what they are about to say. I am very doubtful——
Comment on this
The Deputy may be doubtful, but repetition is disorderly and the Deputy has given way to it on several occasions.
Comment on this
I will not repeat what the Deputy said. I am sure I cannot recollect everything the Deputy has said, but I do know he has repeated himself on several occasions.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister if he will get his advisers to draft an amendment to this Bill whereby aliens buying land will be forced to notify, or whoever is acting for them, the Land Commission so that the sale of Irish land to foreigners may be protected.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister will he do that and, through you, Sir, perhaps he would reply.
Comment on this
I should like to point out that there is a difference of opinion between the people on this side and the Minister with regard to this amendment. I wonder if the Minister introduced an amendment that all sales of agricultural land, other than land for industrial purposes, to non-nationals be subject to the consent of the Land Commission would that meet the position?
Comment on this
If Deputy Barron gets the approval of the Fine Gael Party to put down an amendment on Report Stage to the effect that all sales must be subject to the consent of the Land Commission, I will accept that.
Comment on this
How is the Land Commission to know unless they are applied to for their permission? Foreigners cannot purchase Irish land unless Irish people sell it to them. Let us grow up now on this issue.
Comment on this
As far as the Labour Party are concerned, we are in complete agreement with any attempt to limit sales to non-nationals. There is, however, one matter in relation to which I am not clear. How can we give Irish farmers the right to free sale to anybody and, at the same time, say they cannot sell to non-nationals? If someone would explain that, perhaps we would be able to make up our minds. One or the other is wrong. Either you have free sale and everybody, including non-nationals, can purchase without the special permission of the Land Commission, in which case there would have to be an amendment, or you have not.
I suggest this amendment does not cover the point. The intention may be right. We are all with it if the intention is to prevent non-nationals purchasing land, but I am afraid the amendment here does not do that, and it has not been proven to us, no matter what discussion we have had here tonight, that it can in any way help to solve the problem. That is the difficulty.
Comment on this
I should love to help the Deputy but I feel certain you, Sir, would rule me out of order as I have explained it once or twice already.
Comment on this
This section is one of the most disastrous features of this Bill. It introduces a system of control on dealings in land in respect of which the Land Commission propose to institute, or actually have instituted, acquisition proceedings. No sale, no transfer, no letting, no subletting can lawfully be made without the consent of the Land Commission. Here, a real effort is made to prevent the sale of land, the transfer of land, without the consent and approval of the Land Commission. Beyond all shadow of doubt, this is prohibiting the sale of land.
Not alone does this section prohibit the free sale of land but it interferes with ownership. Certainly, it interferes with the right of a private individual to do what he likes with his property. It is an infringement of the right of a citizen. We have now reached the stage that if this section is passed, a person cannot sell his land, transfer it, let it, set it, sublet it or subdivide it, without the consent of a Government Department. In my opinion, this is State intervention in respect of private property. It is a case of the State preventing the citizen from exercising his lawful and democratic right as a citizen and it is wrong. That is why I oppose this section very strenuously.
But this section does more than that. It will now make it a serious offence for any person to transfer his property, to sell, set, let or sublet his property without the consent—in writing, I thank you—of the Land Commission. It does more than that and is more serious than that because this section 13 prohibits the sale, transfer, letting or subletting of all land in this State, except with the permission and approval of the Land Commission.
Comment on this
I am coming to that, It is more serious still when it comes to the question of the serving of the notice by the Land Commission because this is a case in which the Land Commission will have the right, the authority and the power to freeze the lands, according to this section, for a period of a year.
Last night, the Minister said he was prepared to come back to us on Report Stage and when I pressed him to have a period of three months, he said he might consider allowing a period of six months.
Where proceedings have been instituted, the control period runs until the termination of these proceedings. Where notice of inspection with a view to possible acquisition has been served, the control period—until the Report Stage of this Bill—runs for one year. That is as we see it here. This is a very drastic interference with the rights of ownership. Simply by serving a notice of inspection, a Land Commission officer, a senior inspector or any high-ranking officer of the Land Commission can freeze all dealings in respect of a holding for one year.
We appreciate the necessity of empowering the Land Commission to take prompt and effective action in certain circumstances but we consider that the period of control should very drastically be reduced. I hope that when the Minister comes to us on Report Stage, he will meet us very generously on this matter and that, when contemplating a six months period, on further consideration, he may perhaps agree to the three months period.
During the period when the lands are frozen, the owner will be deprived of any benefits or any profits from the land, whilst at the same time he is responsible for rent, rates and outgoings. We can also understand the more serious aspect that whilst the Land Commission may serve notice and freeze all dealings in relation to the land for a period of a year, the value of the land will very seriously be affected.
Everybody knows that the full market value of land will reduce drastically in the event of the Land Commission serving the notice. Consider the period when the lands will be left idle, when they cannot be set, sold or transferred. In my opinion, it is a very serious attempt drastically to devalue the property, to reduce the value of any man's farm or any man's holding. It is something to which we on this side of the House cannot subscribe. That is why I feel very strongly about this objectionable section.
It is a very serious matter to deprive by law the owner of land of his right to sell his property when and if he so desires. It is a very grave abuse of the authority of Government to interfere with the right of free sale which was obtained in this country after many years of struggle and very great sacrifices.
Comment on this
The debate on section 13 is restricted to lands in respect of which the Land Commission propose to institute proceedings.
Comment on this
That is quite correct, but if the Land Commission serve a notice or carry out an inspection, then, under this section, for a period of a year, the owner may not sell the land, set it or transfer it to his son or to a member of his family, or even give it away for love and affection. He can do nothing with it. That is why I say this matter is very grave and something which members of this House ought to view with very serious concern. This procedure can be used unfairly. The Land Commission can effectively leave a landowner in a very difficult position. As a result of the implementation of this section, a landowner can be forced to sell his land eventually at a price far less than its market value.
Comment on this
When a man is forced by the laws of the country to sell his land at less than market value, it is something the members of the House must view with the gravest concern. The section deals with the complete freezing of all lands on which the Land Commission serve notice. What is to stop any Minister for Lands from taking advantage of that? We may take the word of the present Minister for what it is worth that such notices will be issued by the Commission only after most serious thought and consideration of all circumstances but we have no guarantee that for political, business, personal or other purposes, the Land Commission on the instructions of any Minister for Lands will not serve notice on any farmer, whether there is an agitation for the division of land or not. They may leave that farm for 12 months in such a way that the owner cannot derive a penny benefit from it, no matter what its extent because they serve notice of intention to inspect with a view to acquisition.
Comment on this
When the Land Commission serve notice, the moment the inspection is carried out, the owner cannot sell after that; he cannot set and he cannot give it away. He cannot transfer the land. The lands are frozen under this section for 12 months and he can do nothing with them. That is an objectionable state of affairs that we cannot possibly tolerate. I am not too satisfied that there will not be reasons, political or otherwise, for which certain farmers may be served with notice and their lands frozen so that eventually they will be compelled to dispose of their land under value. That is a very serious matter and we must oppose it.
This is a most objectionable section. It could deprive farmers of their livelihood and eventually of their land. It will deny them rights and facilities they now properly enjoy as free citizens. This may cause a great deal of amusement to Fianna Fáil members, but when this section is passed and becomes law, many representations will be made to Deputies by landowners saying they are compelled to sell their lands under value, or that the lands are being allowed to remain in a position of giving no financial return for 12 months or whatever period the Minister fixes under this section. That is very serious and objectionable. It deprives farmers of the right of free sale. No civil servant, Minister, or State Department should have authority to devalue anybody's property or prevent him from doing as he wishes with it.
The section is not only objectionable but undemocratic and I seriously feel it is unconstitutional. Eventually, it will cause severe hardship to all landowners and farmers. There is nothing to prevent the Land Commission from serving notice and carrying out an inspection on any farm they like. It is one of the most objectionable sections of the Bill and I hope that the House in its wisdom will, as a result of the division which will take place on it, have it rejected.
Comment on this
On 30th of this month I shall have been 20 years in this House and during that time I have listened to Deputy Flanagan asking questions about why certain estates in Laois-Offaly were not acquired to relieve congestion in his constituency. The Minister is trying to do his job, and as a man who came from the land myself, I am very anxious that he should have an opportunity of doing so. In this section we are empowering the Minister to do a job in which we all hope he will succeed, that is, to bring about a state of affairs in which a man can have an economic holding. He should live solely on the land, and his holding should be A, B or C, according to the disposition of the Land Commission.
Deputy Flanagan cannot blow hot and cold. We have certain rights in this House and I have the same rights as Deputy Flanagan has. If I say anything personal outside the gates of the House, I can be charged with making a personal attack on someone, but here in the House we can say what we like.
Comment on this
John Jones or Oliver Flanagan or Brendan Corish may have a farm of land he wants to divide between four sons and it is time something was done to deal with a case of that kind.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Flanagan propose that the Land Commission should be abolished, and that everything should be let go haywire? In that case no land would be resettled. What Deputy Flanagan suggests is completely ridiculous. A man may fall on hard times and want to let his land for a few years. In that case the Minister wants him to tell the Land Commission that he wants to let the land for a few years. Is that not the position? Surely that is not too much to ask of anyone. The position in Dublin and every other part of Ireland is that the Land Commission cannot buy any land at all. They have no right to go in, good, bad or indifferent. Even if the Land Commission could buy land, it would be too expensive for the tenants——
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy is getting away from section 13, which introduces a system of control on dealings in respect of certain lands.
Comment on this
That is what I am referring to—"Lands to be sold, let or sublet". We are asking the Minister to deal with a situation which was handed down to us by an alien Government, a situation which we have inherited. Is it too much to ask this Parliament to be just in the matter of the sale, letting or subletting of property with the consent or approval of the Land Commission? I welcome any change that will bring about an improvement in the position of uneconomic holdings today.
Deputy Flanagan was very vocal over a long number of years, and successive Fianna Fáil Ministers were abused by the honourable Deputy for not going in and buying land in his constituency. Now that the Minister wants to deal with a national problem, Deputy Flanagan says he is interfering with the rights of persons to set, sell or sublet property. I wonder is Deputy Flanagan serious? I do not think he is. I think he is just playing politics. If he went down to his constituency and made that statement, he would not get a vote. We are trying to deal with a national problem.
Comment on this
I believe the Irish people will be treated fairly under this Bill. The Minister wants to make progress which is long overdue. Is the House aware that the Land Commission and successive Ministers have been held up in dividing land because of the rundale system? There have been a number of court cases over land. I have known since my childhood the rundale system and other systems.
Comment on this
No. I saw many cases which arose out of that rotten system which the Minister is trying to deal with now.
Comment on this
I am trying to prove to the House how essential section 13 is, if we are to achieve anything so far as land division is concerned. It is no use trying to achieve anything by lukewarm methods. I know Deputy Flanagan has set himself up as an authority on land. He is entitled to his opinion and I am entitled to mine. Deputy Flanagan seems to maintain that a local uneconomic holder should not be considered, and dare the Land Commission go in and purchase any land at all. They should not go in. This is how I am interpreting Deputy Flanagan. On the other hand, he will go and cry around at the churches and say that all the poor——
Comment on this
He will say: "There is this farm of land and I am going to the Minister for Lands and I will see that it is divided." But he did not say that tonight.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that under section 13 if a man were an absentee landlord and had 3,000 acres and if there were 300 small uneconomic holders dare the Minister go in, that he had better keep out of that. That is the interpretation. I know, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that you are a kindly man and you will bear with me to develop this point——
Comment on this
The Deputy will be slaughtered by the Fianna Fáil Whips because he was told not to talk.
Comment on this
If there is a 5,000 acre farm in Laois or Offaly and if there are a couple of hundred small uneconomic holders in any parish in Rathdowney or in Portarlington or even in Mountmellick——
Comment on this
It is kind of the Deputy to try to help me with my speech but he will not put me off.
Comment on this
The position is that the Minister is not to buy this 5,000 acre holding in Laois, or the 10,000 acre holding or the 500 acre holding, put any figure you like on it, according to Deputy Flanagan, and the Minister dare not tell the owner, although he is an absentee landlord, to freeze his land or he will go in to acquire it for the benefit of the uneconomic holders in the area. He cannot do it according to Deputy Flanagan.
Comment on this
This is the gentleman who wants the Minister to acquire all the estates in the country.
Comment on this
When I was getting 2/6 for calves it was time to get out of farming under Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
You went to the Japanese and asked for the English General Staff in Singapore to be executed.
Comment on this
The Deputy will please resume his seat. Deputy Burke is entitled to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
He is not entitled to come along again with all this old British stuff. Is he in order?
Comment on this
I am doing that. I am trying to make an intelligent contribution to the debate and when you hear a man getting up and talking about the Civil War——
Comment on this
——and the Economic War, what can one do? As a national Party, we are trying to do the best we can for the community.
Comment on this
Section 13 is the section which is trying to do that for every section. I do not wish Deputy Flanagan any harm one way or the other because I have only one real enemy and he is Paddy Burke——
Comment on this
I cannot see how Deputy Flanagan is going to go down to Laois or Offaly and say that he is going to see that the man with 5,000 acres will have free sale and see that the Land Commission is not going to interefere with him. Then he will go to the cross roads and meet 20 small farmers and tell them: "I am going to see you will get some of that holding."
Comment on this
I shall not say: "This is your piece, Paddy, and there, where the coal fell out, is yours, Mick."
Comment on this
I want to emphasise how ridiculous is the contribution of Deputy Flanagan. I want to prove conclusively how he wanted to tie up the Minister, any Minister for Lands—Deputy Flanagan might be Minister for Lands himself in a few years——
Comment on this
I would give the Deputy a few acres. If you keep right on my side I will look after you. The Deputy would be entitled to a few.
Comment on this
There used be a great character in Dublin and he was able to come out on the stage in a number of different roles. He was able to come out as a landlord, then as a tenant, then as a politician and then as a clergyman. There is one thing about it: Deputy Flanagan has him nearly beaten.
Comment on this
That is all I have to say, except to point out that in the matter of the selling, setting or subletting of land, Deputy Flanagan stands for the man with the big holding. He does not want any uneconomic holdings left. We know the act Deputy Flanagan has been playing here. We know the two acts he will play in his constituency: one is played at the crossroads for the benefit of the smallholders; the other is played for the benefit of the big fellow with the 7,000 acres of land.
Comment on this
Well, then, for the man with the 700 acres, 500 acres or even 300 acres. That is what the Deputy is at.
Comment on this
We have been accused here during the past few weeks of holding up the business of the House, of impeding the Minister in his endeavour to get the Bill through. I should point out, therefore, that the last piece of reminiscence by the Fianna Fáil Deputy from Dublin has cost the House exactly 30 minutes of its valuable time. All I want to say is simply that we believe the Bill, if it is to have the desired effect, must have teeth, and here are the teeth of the Bill. Last night the Minister told me —I believe he also told Deputy Flanagan—that he was prepared to consider reducing the period from one year to six months. If he implements that promise, it is all the safeguard that is needed.
The NFA, in their survey report, say they appreciate the necessity for empowering the Land Commission to take prompt action in certain circumstances but that they consider the period of control should be reduced to one month, with, perhaps, an extension of a further month in certain cases. As far as I am concerned, I believe a period of six months is reasonable. We know that in the interim period, a man will be deprived of the use of his land. In fact, the NFA report states that this has the effect of prohibiting the sale or transfer of land except by the consent of the Land Commission where the Land Commission have instituted, or propose to institute, proceedings for acquisition or resumption.
Objection is made to the method by which a senior inspector of the Land Commission has the power of freezing. What has been happening is that whenever the owner of a big piece of land which has not been properly worked has heard that the Land Commission have become interested, he runs off to sell it. I have addressed question after question to the Minister and the Land Commission requesting that something should be done. Deputy Flanagan has been working on the same idea. Our reason was to attempt to stop the leakage of thousands of acres of valuable land from the land pool. We must be prepared to support efforts of the Government to achieve this.
Comment on this
The Minister's offer of six months is not good enough because it would mean there would be a freeze of that duration on the disposal of land. Certain Deputies, particularly Deputy P. J. Burke, have talked about 5,000 acre holdings. I wish to talk about a man with 45 acres, perhaps in poor economic circumstances, perhaps because he still has not got over the effects of the Economic War, who has not been able to work that holding properly for that reason. He loves that land, but he has to leave it: he must go to England or elsewhere to try to get a few quid together so that he may be able to return to that land some day. Now, once the Land Commission put their dead hand on that land and freeze it, nobody will pay that man a bob for it. He is like a man under sentence of death; he will have to sell the land eventually at much less than market value.
Deputies have been talking about the people who may be looking for land; I am talking about people who are trying to sell land. What will Fianna Fáil Deputies say to a man who comes to them and says: "They have frozen my land"? I know what we shall say, if they come to us: "Go to the Fianna Fáil people—they made it possible". Why should the Land Commission be allowed six months in which to make up their minds as to whether or not they should buy a farm, let it be 20 acres or 1,000 acres? An ordinary individual must go out into the open market and make up his mind in two days. That is only as it should be.
I know the officers of the Land Commission. They are all over 21 years of age; they have been around; they know how to buy land, how to value it. If land is advertised in the newspapers, the Land Commission can nominate a buyer to go after it, to examine it first and buy it if it is suitable for their purposes. If a farmer can get a better price for his land from an Irish citizen than from the Land Commission, why should the Land Commission be permitted to go in and prevent that farmer getting that price? We have had a lot of clap-trap about the economic advances made in the country. Most of these advances were made because the price of land advanced, because it became easy to sell land, to realise money on it. Bankers were prepared to give people extra overdraft accommodation because of those circumstances. I have in mind one case of a farmer who had a bank overdraft, and when it became public property that land in the area was being sold at excellent prices, he was able to go to his bank manager and say, having pointed out the circumstances: "I owe you only £2,000. In the circumstances you should advance me another £2,000. Then I can go out and buy 12 cows."
Comment on this
And I am pointing out to the Minister the importance of leaving free sale to the farmers. If this provision is put into law, it will immediately depreciate the value of land.
Comment on this
We should look at this clearly and not continue to talk about 1,000 acre holdings. If one goes into the west of Ireland, one finds small holdings from which people have been driven through economic circumstances. Why should the disposal of such holdings by the owners be frozen if those owners can get good prices from Irish citizens?
My colleagues have put up a very good case to the Minister. We want to see the sales of lands to foreigners controlled and if the sale is to a foreigner or to an agent of a foreigner, the Land Commission should step in. We consider this section to be wrong. It is wrong to freeze a man's land for six months. It would be wrong to go into a fair and say to a man: "You may not sell your cattle for another three hours until we go into a hotel and decide what we shall give you for them" while there are plenty of people at the fair to buy them.
The Land Commission have a job to do. They have people who know how to value and how to carry out the various transactions. The only thing that is wrong is that they are too slow about it. I would exhort the Minister to make the period three months. Three months is long enough to hold up any man's place. It is a terrible thing we are doing here. There were some irresponsible Deputies here like Deputy Burke talking about Irish people who owned land as if they were Hottentots. They have the right to sell their land. If a man is broke and wants to sell his farm and can get a good price for it so that he will have money in his pocket, is it Fianna Fáil policy to prevent him doing so?
I made a statement here tonight that the Minister and the Land Commission are trying to set themselves up as head landlords of Ireland. We do not want any more landlords in Ireland. This is the kind of section that would make a Minister—and he might not want it— the head landlord. The Minister could come along to take over a farm in accordance with a provision dealt with last night where the Land Commission can, after the passing of this Act, make an advance for the purchase of a holding. Then the man's land can be fenced off and he is prevented from selling it at the market price.
The man who owns that land is a citizen of this State. He was probably born on that farm and his father before him. Nevertheless, we talk lightly here of putting him out of it. The poor man does not want to sell. They run down the value of the place. The owner is out of his depth and is often frightened of the whole business. This is a scandalous state of affairs.
I grew up among people whose proudest boast was what their people did in the Land War and the fact that they stuck to their lands. Now if their sons or grandsons want to sell their land the Parliament of Ireland will go coldly into these lobbies and vote to deny them that right. I have looked over at the Fianna Fáil Party's empty benches in the long watches of this debate. Nobody spoke except Deputy Burke and he spoke out of turn. Nevertheless, when the bell rings, they will go into the lobbies like the trained dog I saw in the Gaiety Theatre long ago and pass the section if we challenge a division.
Comment on this
They do not know what is going on in the House. The Minister should look at this again. I want to give the Minister every possible chance of taking over land that should be taken over. I want to prevent the Minister and the Land Commission being put in a position to say in regard to a holding: "We have made an advance on this holding and, therefore, nobody within 50 miles may buy it."
In regard to subdivision, I do not know why we must write down everything. If a man has 60 acres of land and wants to sell 20 acres, he must reapportion the land annuities. I have known "slickers" in this country who would sell portion of their land and who would endeavour to have all the land annuities on the holding imposed on the portion they were selling, giving them a freehold. It is not a bad idea if one can get away with it. However, my experience of the Land Commission is that they will not allow people to do that. They go back even to the Brehon laws. As we were told on one famous occasion: "To every cow its calf and to every book its copy." The Land Commission have added: "To every acre its annuity." It is not necessary to put that down solemnly in an Act that people must get permission from the Land Commission to subdivide their land. I am sure the Minister in his professional capacity, when a sale takes place and he is acting for the vendor, will automatically write to the Land Commission and ask the Land Commission to reapportion the land annuities. There is a great deal of deadwood in this Bill that will only make the whole land issue more complicated. The more complicated it is made, the worse it will be from the point of view of selling land.
Deputy Flanagan was criticised here for remarks in regard to division of land. My memory is not bad. I have never seen a question down from Deputy Flanagan where he wanted an ordinary farm to be taken over. It might be a big estate that was not being farmed properly. I remember when this Party were over there and Deputy Blowick was Minister for Lands, Deputy Flanagan stormed him on the question of taking over these estates in his constituency. Deputy Flanagan was right and Deputy Flanagan will do it again. I am thankful that I represent a constituency where even though there are land hungry people, as there are everywhere in Ireland, they are not coming to me in this connection. Most of the big estates in County Waterford that were not being run properly were taken over and divided, and rightly so. There are big estates left in County Waterford and the Land Commission would have no business entering them at all because they give an enormous amount of employment. The employers are generous and they have the sign of good employers in the age of the people working for them. They have people working for them who worked in these estates for three generations.