We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).

Contributions 127–279 of 279. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Does the Deputy say only 40,000 out of work?

Comment on this

The facts are that 41,000 lost their employment in that calamitous year of 1956 when the Coalition Government were in power. Secondly, and this is even more important, in the year 1963, more people went into employment than lost their employment. For the first time in years, there was an overall increase of 1,000 in the total number at work.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

I suggest the Deputy should examine the figures in the booklet published prior to the Budget of 1964. He will then see whether or not this is nonsense.

Comment on this

I am not talking about industrial employment.

Comment on this

I am talking about the number who went out of work. It is time that particular untruth was nailed.

Comment on this

The Deputy is perfectly right.

Comment on this

It would be very helpful to this discussion on the Vote on Account if the Fine Gael Party would, before they come in here to speak, make up their minds as to what attitude they intend to adopt. We had Deputy O.J. Flanagan today following what I call the old Fine Gael Jine, talking about the very large amount of money the Government are looking for, the backbreaking load on the backs of the taxpayers. We had Deputy Sweetman, and some other members of the Front Bench of Fine Gael, changing from that particular attitude.

Year after year, since I came in here, I have listened to Fine Gael speakers on the Vote on Account following the line I have already mentioned in relation to Deputy Flanagan. This year there is a marked change in the attitude of Fine Gael. We find Deputy Sweetman and Deputy Donegan, as reported in today's Press, saying they are not so concerned about the amount; what they are concerned with is how the money is spent. We are glad to see them converted. Of course the reasons for the conversion are obvious. Fine Gael are a Party in search of a policy. Since before the 1961 general election we have had three policies from Fine Gael. I believe they are now in process of formulating a fourth policy. Secondly, in their television political broadcasts Fine Gael have been promising the moon. Agriculture is to get millions more. Health is to get millions more. Education is to get millions more, and so on. They are now in a cleft stick and they find it somewhat difficult this year to suggest that the amount we are asking is too much because they have already told the public in their television political broadcasts that, if they were in power, they would spend more millions than we are asking for.

The main reason Fine Gael have adopted this particular attitude now is, I think, that they have found that our fiscal policy is a successful policy. They have discovered that the people realise it is a successful policy. For that reason they have now decided that they had better try to filch one more part of our policy, as they have filched so many other parts over the years. To those who suggest the amount of money we are looking for is too much, I say they should remember that, in 1956, the amount which the Coalition Government looked for was very much lower. We must, however, remember that in that particular year 41,000 people lost their employment. There were 95,000 unemployed. Emigration was unparalleled at the highest figure since the Famine. We should remember, too, that national production was down, the national income was down, national loans were unfilled and the future of the economy was in the melting pot. Those who talk glibly about overspending should at least try to show us where we are overspending. If we are to go by the political broadcasts, the Fine Gael Party obviously intend, if they ever get into power again, to spend very much more than we are spending.

In the Estimates this year, there are increases under many headings. These are designed to increase productivity and, in so doing, to improve the standard of living of our people. It has been said that the money should be spent wisely. Everybody agrees with that. When we consider the results so far, and I judge on my own constituency, it is obvious that we are definitely making proper use of the money being made available. A few minor mistakes may have been made. We do not pretend that no mistakes are made. We should, however, remember the maxim that the person who never made a mistake never made anything.

Under Education, £1 million extra is being allocated for vocational education. No one can object to that. A small developing country like ours must base its hopes in the future on education. Lack of technical training is a serious lack in an era of developing economy. It would be interesting, if that were possible, to find out what industries we may have lost in certain areas simply because we did not have sufficient technical training in those areas. I know of many instances where industrialists decided to set up industries in this country and had intended starting with hundreds of workers but were forced to start with a very much smaller number because they had not sufficient people with the technical training necessary. As far as my own constituency is concerned, the people there will be very pleased with the increase in the money being allocated for vocational education and one reason will be that a technological college is about to be built in Dundalk.

Under the heading of agricultural grants, there is a very large increase. I do not think anybody can cavil at this increase, particularly when we remember that agriculture is our basic industry, that manufacturing industry is either directly or indirectly dependent on it—directly when it uses the produce of the land and indirectly when the produce of the land we export pays for the raw materials for our factories. For that reason we are very much dependent on the prosperity of our agriculture. We need these grants to help the farmers produce more and produce more efficiently.

There is also an increase in the amount being allocated for fisheries. It is a matter in which I am particularly interested, because I come from a constituency where there is a considerable number of fishermen. I believe that fisheries should rank next to agriculture. Anything that can be done to ensure it assumes its proper place in the economy is something which shall always have my support. One of the difficulties in relation to fisheries is the question of credit. If we can provide sufficient money to enable fishermen to have more credit than they have at present, that is all to the good.

There is also a considerable increase under the heading of Posts and Telegraphs. We know from questions put down here practically every day the Dáil sits that there is now a greater demand for telephones than ever before. This underlines the advances we have made in our economy. More telephones are needed only when the economy is moving rapidly in the right direction. When we recall the pressure being put on the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, both by Deputies on this side and on the other side of the House, we must all be in agreement with the extra money being made available for this purpose.

I should like to refer to the extra money being made available for industry. This is vitally important so far as our people and the economy generally are concerned. While agriculture is our basic industry, at the same time we are dependent, and will be so for a considerable time, on manufacturing industry to employ more of our people. It is our aim to employ all our people. Reference was made here to maintaining the number on our farms. That is a big problem at present. The fall in the number employed on the land is a fall not only evident in this country but in all the developed and developing countries of western Europe. It is essential, therefore, to ensure an increase in the number of people employed, that we should do our utmost to help develop our manufacturing industry.

I do not know whether to be amused or amazed at the efforts being made by the Fine Gael Party to claim they are responsible for the remarkable expansion of industry over the past few years. They are basing their claim on an Act they passed in 1956. It is strange that that Act was so ineffective and they had so little faith in it when they were in power that they ran out of office in 1957. As far as my constituency is concerned, it was ineffective for a number of years after we got into power. Our main effort at that time was to try to bring confidence back to our people, to try to get the economy on an even keel and to be in a position to provide money to help industry. It is going a bit too far to suggest that a Government, who were unable to pay even the low housing grants available in 1956, could be expected to finance industrialists wishing to set up industry in this country or Irish industrialists wishing to extend their industries or start new ones.

Recently, the Fine Gael Deputy in my constituency charged me with taking the credit for the industries which have come into Louth. We have got four new industries in Drogheda and some in Dundalk. We have another industry coming into Greenore. There has also been a very considerable expansion of existing industry in Louth. As an example, one industry, which in 1956 was reduced to employing 211 workers on a four-day week, now employs 1,400 workers on overtime. As I said, I was charged with claiming credit for this. I do not need to claim credit for this. Everybody in Louth knows who is responsible for those industries. Who in Drogheda, for example, could visualise an industry coming into that town in 1956 when the industries in it were knocking men off every Friday and when confidence in the economy was completely gone? These industries came in here when we got the economy moving in the right direction.

I would be only too glad to bring some of those who have doubts about our industrial expansion down to Louth any time they like and show them the vast improvement in industrial employment in that constituency over the past few years. Our policy has been to provide employment for all our people. We never pretended that was going to be easy, that all you had to do was wave a magic wand and get employment started. We knew it meant hard work and unpopular decisions. We knew it meant taxation, and we knew taxation was not popular. But we knew where our duty lay. We felt it was far more important that we should employ our people at home, even when it meant taking unpopular decisions, than let them leave this country to work in some other country. We are succeeding in what we set out to do. We do not pretend for one moment that we have been completely successful. We do not pretend that we have been nearly completely successful. What we do say is that we are on the right road and that we intend to continue along that road and have no doubt as to what the final result will be.

Comment on this

My object in speaking in this debate is to refer to a matter mentioned in the House by the Taoiseach earlier today. In the course of what the Taoiseach had to say, he proceeded to criticise the Fine Gael proposals in relation to health policy. I can understand the Taoiseach voicing any criticism he wishes in relation to anything that I said in my television broadcast but I was somewhat surprised to hear from the Taoiseach that, not only was he criticising what I said on behalf of the Fine Gael Party in a television broadcast, but he also sought to criticise the proposals which I had put forward to the Select Committee on Health Services.

I circulated to the Dáil Select Committee in April of last year a comprehensive proposal for the reform and re-organisation of our general medical services. I regarded, and I was put in the position of having to regard, the circulation of that memorandum as being confidential and, although, since April of 1964, when no consideration of that memorandum took place and when criticism was expressed outside with regard to the work of the Dáil Committee, I was sorely tempted to disclose the fact that, so far as my Party are concerned, we had put forward constructive and concrete proposals, I felt I was not at liberty to do that by reason of the fact that this had been done at a Committee of the Dáil.

I find now that not only was the fact of this memorandum not confined to the Select Committee but it was circulated, apparently by a member of that Committee—I assume, the Tánaiste—and was handed for discussion to the Taoiseach. I do not object to that. But, certainly, I do object to the Taoiseach coming in here in this debate today and proceeding to misquote and misstate what is contained in our memorandum on health services. At least, if he thought it worth dealing with it at all in this debate, he might have taken the trouble to read it and, if he had taken the trouble to read it, he would not have made some of the rather silly statements which he made in the debate today.

Let me say at once that this memorandum deals with one particular facet of our health services, that is, the general medical services. It does not provide, as the Taoiseach apparently thought it did from the scanty reading he gave to it, that £6 million of new money will be required for the new services which we propose, nor does it provide, as the Taoiseach apparently thought it did, that farmers and other persons will be expected to come along to a post office once a week to pay 2/-or half a crown, or anything of that kind.

This memorandum, which was submitted in my name on behalf of my Party, was carefully considered and carefully worded. It was put forward in the view that the Select Committee in considering this important problem —and it is an important problem, whether the Taoiseach regards it as such or not—should not be inhibited in its work by the present accepted divisions of the population into particular income groups or by the system under which present services were provided. We were concerned, and it is so stated in the memorandum, that the Committee should consider as objectively as possible whether from a national point of view the essential needs and the welfare of our community as a whole require that essential health services should be organised on a wider and more general basis.

That was the object of this memorandum and, not only did it set out that object, but it endeavoured in a careful and reasonable manner throughout many pages to give details of the manner in which our health services could be organised in a better and a more suitable manner.

When the Taoiseach spoke as he did this afternoon, he was obviously not aware of what happened as a result of the circulation of this memorandum and I propose now to disclose to the House what did happen, and I propose also, a Cheann Comhairle, in collaboration and discussion with my colleagues, to feel free to circulate also at a later stage the full contents of this particular memorandum. But it should be recorded that the memorandum which the Taoiseach referred to was circulated and came before the Dáil Committee on Health Services at a meeting held on 9th April, 1964. The meeting was a short one. When the meeting convened, the Chairman of the Select Committee proposed, in view of the contents of my memorandum, that the Committee should adjourn so that the matter might be fully and adequately considered. The Minister for Health, who was present, seconded that proposal and went on to say that he would like to put the other side of the case against Deputy O'Higgins' memorandum. He went on to say: "I think we should congratulate and thank Deputy O'Higgins for putting the latter before us because we can at last get our teeth into something. I hope both memorandum and counter-memorandum will be considered on their merits".

The Committee then, on the proposi-Minister, adjourned to a later date to consider fully this proposal of mine and any counter-proposal that the Minister might wish to put forward. For the record, I should like to state that was the last meeting of the Select Committee on Health Services at which a discussion took place. There was never any counter-proposal circulated by the Minister, nor was the further meeting to discuss my proposal ever convened.

From 9th April until today, no step has been taken by the Minister to get that Committee together or even to put forward any criticism of what I, on behalf of my Party, took the trouble to put down in black and white, or any counter-proposal.

It is, therefore, perhaps, not surprising that certain members of the Committee, who sincerely felt that the Committee could be fruitful in its work for the people and that the problem of health services could get some real, non-controversial attention, should have become despondent and should have notified the House, as apparently they did today, that they were resigning from the Committee.

The fact is, a Cheann Comhairle, it is now apparent that this Dáil Committee on Health Services was a political gimmick by the Minister for Health. He never intended it to work; he never wanted it to work. All he desired to do was to tie up health and a discussion on health in some back committee room. The Committee was set up following a motion in my name which was discussed here in the autumn of 1961. The Committee held its first meeting on 20th May, 1962. It held, in all, 46 subsequent meetings and, as I have mentioned, the last meeting in a deliberative way was on 9th April, 1964.

The members of my Party on that Committee attended all those meetings. We attended many times when the Dáil was not in session. We were frequently working at meetings of that Committee from early in the morning until late at night. We went into the Committee sincerely concerned to try in a non-political way to secure an improvement in our health services. All the time, apparently, we were just being fooled by the Minister for Health. He was sitting back determined that nothing would emerge. We took the trouble to put down in black and white our constructive proposals and we were fooled by the Minister saying: "All right; we will consider it and we will get another meeting together some time."

I want to protest as strongly as I can as an individual Deputy against the manner in which we have been treated on this Committee. This House also has been treated in an appalling manner. I should like to remind the House that when the Committee was established, it was provided in the Minister's amendment to my motion that the Select Committee would report to this House by 7th November, 1962. A time limit was put on the work of the Committee. The next thing this House heard of this Committee was a proposal passed by the Committee at the instance of the Minister that that time limit be extended for six months. Then there was another proposal from the Committee at the instance of the Minister that all time limits be removed.

Many people throughout the country who have been looking forward with hope to a report from this Committee, who have felt genuinely that something was at last being done to solve the perennial problem of health in this country, will be aghast at the disclosure today that the Minister for Health was not serious and was not prepared to have the Committee meet again to consider my proposal and any other proposal that might be put forward. It is a very bad thing and it illustrates more than countless speeches the bankruptcy of the Fianna Fáil Party in relation to worthwhile thought on a matter so important as health and the wellbeing of ordinary people. The Taoiseach could come in here illinformed and criticise my proposal. He is entitled to do that, but let him show me something better. Let him or any Deputy here show this House any better way of improving our health services than the way which has been suggested on behalf of my Party and on behalf of other Parties, too.

It may be that particular aspects of what is contained in this memorandum or what I have said can be improved. Of course, I would have hoped that in the discussions of the Select Committee improvements would be suggested. I certainly feel that in relation to contributions it might be possible to have them related as a percentage of a wage packet rather than as a fixed amount. All those things could be considered, but all we have had here from the Taoiseach today is a bland condemnation of a proposal put forward, not impulsively but after due and careful consideration, by a responsible political Party. The Taoiseach just sweeps it aside without even taking the trouble of reading what was in the document before him.

I am sorry that the situation has developed in such a way that Deputies from the Labour Party who were working well on that Committee, when the Committee was working, have found it impossible to continue. That is a decision the Labour Party were compelled to take by the manner in which the Minister for Health has acted. I have no doubt that my Party will in due course consider that matter also but I am not going into that now. However, I do want to say that, so far as this Committee is concerned and the work that went into it, it is to me and to my Party and, I believe, to the country, a very serious disappointment that the whole thing was a political subterfuge and that there was no sincerity behind it on the part of the Minister for Health

It now remains, so far as we are concerned, to advocate what we believe in in the political way that we have always endeavoured to do in the past. We never had any doubt when we went on to that Committee on Health Services about what we stood for. The Minister for Health and the Fianna Fáil representatives apparently had no policy and they sought to get it from us. We were quite prepared to help them in any way possible but if the situation now is, as apparently it is, that they are not going to budge from their Health Act and the policy it enshrines, then it will be our duty democratically to bring our proposals elsewhere. There will not be any Committee of this House. It will be the people themselves and I have little doubt that sooner or later, inevitably, the proposals which the Taoiseach so airily condemned today will represent the health policy of this country in due course.

Comment on this

I am rather amazed by the statement of Deputy O'Higgins that in relation to the Committee set up by this House of which he and other members of his Party, members of the Labour Party and members of our Party were members, he brought proposals before that Committee last April, ten months ago, and that the Committee did not meet since. That is rather an extraordinary and amusing statement by Deputy O'Higgins. If I were a member of a committee and believed in anything I proposed, I would take good care that the committee would meet to consider the proposal and if I did not succeed, this House would hear about it every week until that committee met. The only conclusion I can reach is that Deputy O'Higgins had no faith in the proposals he put forward. If he had, surely he would have insisted that the Committee would meet within a period of ten months. If he desires an example I shall give it to him. In 1956, members of that Party, when the Coalition Government were in office, went over to Britain and we had an agreement signed with Britain to collect not 12½ per cent but 33? per cent in this country for Britain. We paid some £2 million because of that idiotic agreement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The terms of that agreement do not arise for discussion now.

Comment on this

I am making comparisons, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is all right, but the Deputy may not discuss the terms of the agreement.

Comment on this

It took me two years fighting that agreement before I succeeded in having it removed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is very interesting, but it does not arise on the motion before the House.

Comment on this

The amount of cash to be spent, the manner in which it was spent and how it had to be spent——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Not in respect of that agreement.

Comment on this

No, thanks to the work our Minister for Agriculture and our Minister for Industry and Commerce put into it they succeeded in getting it removed.

Comment on this

Which Minister for Agriculture are you talking about?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise.

Comment on this

I will have a good look at you——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

It is a simple question; I only asked a question.

Comment on this

I shall ask a lot of questions. My suggestion to Deputy T.F. O'Higgins is, if his statement is correct, that he has no faith in the proposals he put forward. It was his duty to see that that Committee met during the ten months when he alleges they did not meet to consider those proposals. If he has any faith in his proposals surely that was what he should have done. He was lacking in his duty to this House in not doing so, seeing that he was appointed a member of that Committee to consider the matter.

Comment on this

Could they not have met to reject it if it was no good?

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Carty who was Chairman.

Comment on this

They had a Committee. Why did he not detail the Committee to meet and consider it? Why? Because he was too much afraid; his proposal was so idiotic that he was afraid of what the Committee would do with it.

Comment on this

If it were idiotic the Committee would have rejected it.

Comment on this

That is no reason why the Committee did not meet for ten months to consider proposals which Deputy T.F. O'Higgins considered were of the utmost importance. Why did they not meet?

Comment on this

The Deputy should ask the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister is too interested in the Beatles at the moment.

Comment on this

The Minister would have no power over a Committee of this House. I am stating the case as I see it on the statements made here.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is a bit of a Rolling Stone.

Comment on this

If I brought a red herring, I would not want anyone to look at it either.

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Carty who was Chairman:

Comment on this

I have heard complaints made here about the manner in which the money was spent. I am glad to see Deputy P. O'Donnell here——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The Deputy was always glad to see him.

Comment on this

Is Deputy P. O'Donnell prepared to object on behalf of his Party to the £25,000 that was given——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

For the Youghal bridge?

Comment on this

——to Father McDyer for his little factory in Glencolumbkille? I had to go up and see that he got it. I had to raise the matter here in the House to see that he got it.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Good man.

Comment on this

Those Deputies over there are asleep. It is all very fine for Deputy P. O'Donnell to support Father McDyer and all very fine for Deputy O.J. Flanagan to get up and condemn the grants.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Deputy P. O'Donnell put a good many pounds of his own for Father McDyer's scheme.

Comment on this

That is the position we are in today. In order to get employment for our people we are prepared to take any industry that is going. I know it. On the selfsame lines as Father McDyer's grants we went in for a processing factory in East Cork and in that processing factory today we have 100 people employed——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——and in time we will have 600 people there——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

—— if we are wise enough.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It took the Donegal man to show the Deputy how to do it.

Comment on this

That is the difference. Mind you from the hand the Fine Gael Party have had in industry it took several years to recover and we must remember that in the first instance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I am sorry, a Cheann Comhairle, I must go back a few years. It is a long time since we had a "mixum gatherum" Government here, thank God. We had an industry at that time in Haulbowline, Irish Steel, giving employment and good employment at that to some 600 men. The inter-Party Government came in. They said the iron was too good. Therefore, they were to buy no more billets. All the iron was to be manufactured from scrap. The next round came then; the scrap was too good; only third grade scrap should be bought. The result was when we got rid of the then Government there were 430 fewer people employed in that industry than were employed on the date they came into office. Today there are 950 men working in that industry. That is the difference. These attacks are the same as we had a few months ago about the dockyard, because 1,000 young Irishmen find a livelihood here who would otherwise have to go to Britain or some other country to find employment. That is the difference I see between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael in industry.

Nobody would trust them. Any industrialist, in any industry in this country, who found that team coming into office would pull out immediately. That is the trouble. We must have a Government that will inspire confidence in the people. Fine Gael will never inspire that confidence. I saw it in every town in my own constituency. The former Deputy Gorman, God rest his soul, was told of the conditions in Youghal. The people had no employment there except for three months in the summer time when holidaymakers came in. During the rest of the year every young boy had to go on the emigrant ship and look for employment elsewhere. When I visited the houses I was told: "Poor Michael, who was here last year, is over in England trying to earn a few shillings."

Comment on this

All his brothers, cousins and nephews are with him now. All his relatives are with him now.

Comment on this

They are.

Comment on this

The Deputy is an honest man.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry must be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

Today, there is not an idle man to be found in that town.

Comment on this

They are in England and in Scotland.

Comment on this

This poor child knows nothing about it. There was a time when sucking bottles were provided for the like of the Deputy. Unfortunately, that day is gone.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They are too hard to get now.

Comment on this

You will find the position changed in Youghal now. I challenge any Fine Gael Deputy to go down and——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

Thanks to Youghal Bridge.

Comment on this

——see for himself what the position is. When we started our little industry six months ago in Midleton we had to go to Cobh for female labour because there was no female labour in the area.

Comment on this

They were all in England.

Comment on this

They were all employed in O'Dwyer's factory in Midleton. We had to run a bus into Cobh for the workers. There is not a man unemployed in Cobh. They are all working and will continue to work, please God, so long as we can keep industries going to give employment. As a matter of fact, I am very glad to inform the Deputies that I am bringing in another industry——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It is coming near an election.

Comment on this

——to give employment to the female labour.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not tell anybody about it. It will go to Louth.

Comment on this

I guarantee that anything I put my tongue to comes to me.

Comment on this

It will go to Louth if the Deputy is not careful.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It will go further west on account of the by-election.

Comment on this

What is the use of talking? The Deputies over there will not wake up. Poor Deputy O'Donnell came here last Thursday seeking to have the by-law regarding fishing nets removed. I had to come up here a month ago to the Parliamentary Secretary for Lands to get that done. It was published in the papers when it was done. Poor Deputy O'Donnell cannot read the papers.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

It was only for Youghal.

Comment on this

Youghal is my baby, and I will look after it.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

They would do nothing for the fishermen in Donegal.

Comment on this

I am interested in the fishermen in Cork.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

The Deputy should stick to the gaff.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

The Deputy was too late. Deputies who are late go without.

Comment on this

There was a Fianna Fáil Deputy on the job before Deputy Corry.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy insists in interrupting, he will have to leave the House. I hope Deputy Harte heard me. If he interrupts again, I will have to ask him to leave the House. He is making a practice of interrupting.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

Anybody today looking around this country and looking at the population in it cannot but be aware— Deputies over there are aware of it— of the change for the better and the improvement so far as employment is concerned. There is plenty of employment in the country today. There is no use denying that fact.

I heard a shadow Minister or a ghost Minister making a complaint last Sunday at a certain chapel gate regarding our present Minister for Agriculture. One thing we can say about him is that he has done his job to the satisfaction of every farmer in this country.

Comment on this

He sent out the Christmas cards.

Comment on this

I admit that he knows a bit about poultry but I have not heard him say anything about the dual purpose hen. If the Deputy would look up the breeding of poultry and the dual purpose hen and tell the Minister for Agriculture about it, perhaps we might get an advance along that line.

Comment on this

Did he not get 9/- a head on the hens? He is an expert on hens. We have all heard about his hens.

Comment on this

The farmers, after making their proposals to the Minister in connection with feeding barley, got just the increase they asked for, of 5/-a barrel. They also got their increase in wheat. The Minister stepped in when the beet dispute was on and succeeded in settling that very acceptably. I praise the bridge when I cross it. We cannot get away from these facts as far as the Minister for Agriculture is concerned.

If we are to go ahead in this country, we must have a sensible Opposition who will realise that some time it must get down to bedrock and to facts. Instead, we have one fellow playing one tune on the fiddle and others playing something else, so that we have four different tunes altogether. The Opposition are not going to get anywhere that way. If they have a policy, let us know all about it. I have to be the Opposition in this House for the most of my time, and I would like to get a relief from that job some time, if the Deputies over there would only do their job.

Comment on this

You do not vote with us.

Comment on this

He was saved by the bell.

Comment on this

I think, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, there is a small bottle of milk there with a nipple on it. I think he would need it.

Comment on this

A very useful contribution.

Comment on this

You are too old for the milk bottle.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

We have to look at the condition of affairs and face it. It is all very well to stand up and shout, although we have not heard so much about it lately, about a general election.

Comment on this

You are afraid to do it.

Comment on this

I would love to see you do it. I do not even know that kid's name yet and he will not be here long enough for me to know him. It would amaze you how many fellows I have seen coming in and out of here in the past 38 years and goodness knows who will be here when I have a look around in 20 years' time.

If this country is to go ahead and to progress, it must have a Government who are prepared to go ahead and not afraid even to make mistakes. It must have a Government prepared to see to it that our children will get employment in their own country and that if not enough provision is made for our children, the Government will step in and do their part. That is the main principle. If they are not to do that, if we have a Government who will do what those gentlemen over there did, it will be no good for the country. Maybe they had sound reason for it. It is hard to blame a man who has not a penny in his pocket and nothing to pay anyone and to stop him from groaning. You were in that condition in 1956 and nobody can deny that you did not have a penny.

Comment on this

We had 73,000 extra workers.

Comment on this

I had to get £300,000 and we in Cork County Council had to borrow it from the Munster and Leinster Bank. That amount was due for grants by a Government who could not pay it. We had contractors who were out of their money.

Comment on this

We were building the houses.

Comment on this

You broke them. You built nothing. That was the condition in which you left office. If the conditions were not such, there was nothing to stop you from remaining there. You had a big majority and everything you wanted, only the cash and the trust of the people. You had neither the one nor the other.

Comment on this

The people had houses.

Comment on this

You have to look things in the face and realise the condition of affairs when you were in. I take no notice at all of elections and by-elections. We all know what happens in by-elections. There is a thing called sentiment, and sentiment goes a long way. I have seen it working in every constituency in which there has been a by-election and working successfully. I have no objection to its working out successfully anywhere. That is not the way to judge. I suggest to Deputies over there that when they get back tonight, they should pray that the Taoiseach does not have any idea of taking them to the country, because if he does, we will see many vacancies when we look over there again.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

This Vote on Account could be described as unique for many reasons. Perhaps the main reasons giving it its unique value are, first, that it is the largest Vote on Account presented to this House since the foundation of the State, and secondly, that it is produced to the House at a time when the country was never more uncertain. It is not quite certain as to whether this House will live to implement the Vote on Account. I just make reference to that in my opening remarks because tonight reference has been made to the back-benchers of Fine Gael being afraid of a general election. As a back-bencher, I can speak only for myself, and I am satisfied that every other backbencher will also speak for himself.

It does not particularly bother me as a back-bencher whether there is a general election tomorrow morning, next month or in 1966. While this has been an uncertain Dáil, it has lasted longer than most. I understand the average life of a Dáil is two and a half years: we are now well into our fourth year. At any time, a man in public life must expect and be prepared for elections. Even the most secure Minister in this House will agree that elections are not pleasant. Political life can be rather hazardous and elections can be rather unpleasant, even if one is successful. Nobody likes the turmoil and the personal strain involved in fighting an election. However, as a back-bencher I am not afraid of a general election in the morning because of the condition of my Party or my standing in my constituency. I am quite happy in the morning to appear before my constituents in North Mayo and indeed I can say the same for every member of the Fine Gael Party. I feel we could never go to the country at a better time. Despite Deputy Corry's crocodile tears. I am sure he would not like to have to face the country now in view of the present unpopularity of the Fianna Fáil Party.

I want to make reference to another statement made here tonight. It is true that at Question Time today, in the interests of my constituents, I asked a question about a German industrialist who is reported to have plans for a nuclear shelter in my constituency of Mayo. Perhaps I might preface my remarks in this respect by saying that I have nothing personal against the industrialist, Mr. Hans Paul, and that I am not taking advantage of the privileges of this House to be derogatory. In fact, I do not know the man or his intentions. I want to say—and I hope I shall be reported as saying—that I welcome Mr. Hans Paul or any industrialist who will come into my constituency or into County Mayo to develop industry there. However, as a responsible citizen and a responsible representative, my attention has been drawn to rather startling statements which have appeared in the Irish Times, the Irish Independent and the journal Business and Finance Volume 1, No. 21 of 12th February, 1965, in which it is stated that a German industrialist plans a nuclear shelter in Mayo. With the permission of the Chair, I should like to quote from the journal Business and Finance, page 6, which states, under the heading “German Industrialist Plans Nuclear Shelter In Mayo”:

A rich German industrialist, who has bought thousands of acres in the west of Ireland in recent years, is now planning an approach to the Government for permission to build an international fall-out shelter where selected people could live through a nuclear war.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I fail to see how this could arise in any way on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

I do not wish to disobey in any way the ruling of the Chair but I understand that the Vote on Account provides money to be spent on industrial development in the forthcoming year.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I was allowing the Deputy to proceed on those lines but he seems to have changed from that and to have brought up an entirely new subject.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

There was a reference, in your absence, that I was trying to preclude, for personal reasons, an industrialist from coming into my constituency. That is not true. I shall finalise the matter by saying that rumours are current and that the matter is reported in what I consider responsible national newspapers. I want to lay the facts before the House. I have the utmost confidence in the various Ministers concerned that my constituency will not be used as a threat to the national security of the country.

I welcome Mr. Hans Paul into my constituency, where he has bought several thousand acres of land, but if his intention is to build an international nuclear fall-out shelter or to do anything which would constitute a threat to the security of the country, then I urge that he should not get permission for such activities. However, if he plans industrial expansion, it has my full approval. I shall be only too delighted to welcome him in any industrial development in my constituency, provided it is not as reported in those responsible papers.

I want to refer in general to the Vote on Account. I have been four years in this House. I have always found the Ministers courteous. I have always found the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, who is now presiding, courteous on any personal request I have made to him. Collectively, however, I want to criticise the Government for their failure in relation to the people of North Mayo.

When I made my maiden speech here approximately four years ago, I outlined the three main problems that affected the people of my constituency —the fishermen along the coast; the small farmers in the centre of the constituency and the people living in the towns. I regret to say that, after four years, very little, if anything, has been done for the fishermen along the coast. The Fianna Fáil Party or the Government, indeed, cannot be proud of the fact that the fishermen have been completely forgotten. Recently, in a storm, many fishing boats used by fishermen along the coast were destroyed due to very bad landing and tying-up facilities along the coast. The Government have failed to live up to their responsibility in that respect.

I regret to say that the small farmers are gone and that the population in Mayo is a dying race. We have mass emigration from every part of the county. If, over the next 20 years, emigration from Mayo continues at the rate it has proceeded in the past, then it would appear that the population of our county will disappear. The acid test of any Government policy is that people remain on the land. They will do so only if it is remunerative for them. I want to support what Deputy Leneghan said tonight. I was particularly pleased to hear him say that the Government are trying to make the rich richer and the poor poorer. He mentioned grants in relation to various schemes. He mentioned the heifer grant and pointed out that the various rebates handed out in agriculture are not of maximum benefit to the small farmer. The small farmer is getting a very small percentage of these aids. It is the big farmer who is benefiting from them.

I have at all times maintained, and I think it is conceded by all economists, that the backbone of our country is the small farmers. Despite what Deputy Corry may say about the ability of the Minister for Agriculture to deal with the poultry problem and the matter of the dual purpose hen, poultry production in Mayo and indeed the west of Ireland has become extinct. There is virtually no poultry production there now. That is the result of inept Government policy. They have failed to get a market and a guaranteed price for poultry and fowl. The poultry industry to provide money for Christmas is becoming extinct among the small farmers— again, the result of inept policy. The pig industry was a mainstay in the west but there is virtually no pig production there now—again, the result of inept Government policy.

It is true to say that the bullock and the cattle are quite good at the moment and I am very glad they are. However, were it not for his foresight in the Agreement made by the present Leader of our Party whereby he tied the price on the British market to our price here, we should be taking more than £20 a head less today for our bullocks. It was through his efforts and the Government will have to concede that were it not for that, we might be in a much worse position with regard to our agricultural produce, like our industrial produce when the British Government imposed the 15 per cent levy.

I remember eight years ago, when I first became a member of Mayo County Council, the rates for the county were bordering on £2. Today the county manager has made a request for a rate which is close on £4. It is conceded that we are one of the largest counties and that the people are the most hardworking people in Ireland but we stand today with the rates demand the highest in the whole country. What have the people got in return? A dwindling population and ever-rising rates. My mind goes back to a unique problem created by increasing rates and which is a direct result of Government expenditure. We were told at one time that the Health Act would cost no more than 2/6 but today in Mayo the cost is well over £1, leaving aside the question of roads and other expenses which have to be met. The stage has been reached at which the people in the county cannot afford the ever-increasing rate burden placed upon them.

It will have to be recognised that there exist at the moment—and I do not wish to split any farming organisation—two types of farmer, the small farmer and the big farmer. The small farmer is not getting a fair crack of the whip. Something will have to be done for the counties along the western seaboard to ensure that the vast sums of money allocated to agriculture will be allocated in a more just manner. I am quite satisfied that the counties along the western seaboard have an equal and a very just claim for a rates equalisation fund. In my constituency, there is a vast amount of land which is waste land and because of that, valuations on average are small. Where you have small valuations, you have high rates. We have a vast expanse to be covered with roads and we have a great number of people who, due to their poor circumstances, require free medical services. While the Government pass legislation adopting schemes, it is the local authority which has to provide the money for them. Added to a high rate burden, the cost of living has increased by 28 per cent since the Government took office. The essentials, sugar, bread, butter and flour, have increased by 28 per cent in price but production from the farm has not increased but has dropped.

A great case could be made by all Deputies from the west, irrespective of their political views, that we in the west have a distinct problem. While it might appear that it would be a good policy for a Government to produce plans and finances for the country at large, the west is becoming the main sufferer. Today at Question Time Deputy M.P. Murphy asked if the Government had any plans to do something about the rates problem as promised by the Taoiseach a year and a half ago and he was told by the Minister for Local Government that they had not. Because of the cost of living and the very high rates, small shops are rapidly closing down in the west. I would appeal to the Minister, when allocating the various sums, especially for local government and agriculture, to treat the west as a separate unit with a separate problem, and indeed a very acute problem. Capital should be made available to the small farmer. As a businessman, my experience has been that while increased grants of all sorts have been allocated—for the erection of cow byres, hen houses, piggeries and so on —there is no practical use in giving me a big shop or a business to work, if I am not given the capital to run that shop or business. That seems to be the main problem of the small farmer. There is no point in giving a man a grant for an eight-head cow byre if he has not got the capital to put eight cows into the byre.

It is not true, as has been stated here tonight, that Fine Gael deliberately obstructed the Land Bill. I do not wish to make the Land Bill an issue and I will only touch on it. We on this side, in the main, accepted many sections in the Bill but opposed very firmly several sections which we considered repugnant.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I hope the Deputy is not going to go into those sections because the matter does not relevantly arise.

Comment on this

We are voting sums of money for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

It was stated earlier that we were deliberately obstructing the Bill. We were not. In fact, I might mention that our Party produced a new land policy some years ago and this was a quick rush on the Government's part to outdo our land policy. The Land Bill should have been tailored before it came to the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of legislation does not arise on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

Very well. The Chair has been rather indulgent with me, and for that reason I should not trespass on its generosity. I shall conclude by saying that the cost of living, especially in my constituency, has gone beyond the beyonds. High rates have made it impossible to live in the west, and, unless something is done to help the small farmer, unless some type of rates equalisation fund is set up for the western seaboard counties, it will not be possible for the people to meet the demands upon them.

Finally, I appeal to the Government, even at this eleventh hour, to pull up their socks and face the grim reality that there is complete unrest and dissatisfaction with their policies throughout the country. I hope that after the result of the by-election in Cork is known, the Government will realise it is time to change their tune.

Comment on this

Once again the House and the people are presented with the first instalment of what may be described as the annual debit note. We may be told by some Deputies, and even by some outside Dáil Éireann, that this represents an unbearable burden, an intolerable imposition. These charges might constitute valid criticism if it could be proved that the moneys asked for, or some substantial portion of them, are not moneys well spent. Nowhere in the list of moneys required is there any item of proposed expenditure to which any responsible Deputy could object. Indeed, there is a consistent demand for increased standards in every aspect of life. There are demands for a higher standard of living, for more extensive and better education, for greater aids to agriculture and industry. There are demands for more employment opportunities and for comprehensive schemes of social welfare. More and more people are looking to the Government to supply these almost insatiable demands.

No Government worthy of the name, I submit, would wish to shirk their responsibility to meet reasonable demands. It cannot be too often stressed that the provision of every service requires money: everything must be paid for. It is inevitable, therefore, that the greater the demand for social amenities and rising economic standards the more money will be required to meet them. It may be asked—we all have a right to ask— are we getting good value for our money? The only way to answer that is by asking another question. Since the cost of Government has increased every year since the present Government took office, has the country progressed as a result of that increase? I submit every unbiased observer must agree there has been progress.

There are a number of pointers to this happy conclusion. First, there is the confidence shown by foreign industrialists in their willingness to invest here, to purchase land, to open branches of industry and to start new ones. These people are not alone expressing confidence in an Irish Government or an Irish Parliament but are also expressing confidence in the Irish people. The decision to invest in Ireland springs from a belief in the stability, intelligence and industry of the Irish people. The Government can do no more than emphasise these virtues and integrate and channel them into an ever-growing profitable economy. Deputies and others should be slow to denigrate these industrialists. They are risking their money, opening industries, and providing employment which we might find it impossible to provide by our own efforts. Fianna Fáil have approached this matter intelligently and with foresight and the result has been of incalculable benefit to the whole community. Would any Party, or combination of Parties, in this House dare to change that approach?

Another pointer to progress is to be found in the number of people wishing to purchase their own houses. Even newly weds and engaged couples are queuing in their thousands to avail of the loans and grants, secure in the knowledge that they will be able to meet their commitments. The building industry is working to full capacity. Never in the history of the State has there been such tremendous activity in this industry. In the financial year 1964-65, Dublin Corporation will be spending over £5 million on acquisition and construction. I believe this is the largest sum spent on housing since the inception of the State, and this will be supplemented by the 3,000 houses to be built in Ballymun at a cost of £10 million, about which we hear very little from the Opposition.

In this connection tribute must be paid to the Minister for Local Government for the energy and initiative he has brought to the job of providing homes for all who need them. We have come a long way from the conditions which obtained six or seven years ago when the demand for houses fell at such an alarming rate that Dublin Corporation found it necessary to suspend or slow down its building programme. Under a Fianna Fáil Government, and the economic progress which goes with it, such a situation will never arise again.

A further indication of the improved circumstances of our people is to be seen in the vast numbers of children attending secondary schools. No longer is it necessary for boys and girls to leave school at 14 in order to go to work and subscribe to the family exchequer. Thousands of families can now afford to send their children to secondary or vocational schools. These schools are bursting at the seams, a sure indication of greater economic prosperity.

In the field of social welfare, the Government have nothing of which to be ashamed. It has always been the aim of Fianna Fáil to provide as far as the economy would allow for the old and infirm. Social service benefits are not all that might be desired but we are moving nearer to a more comprehensive scheme. This scheme will eventuate when it becomes obvious that the people can bear the cost of it. With an expanding economy, more jobs becoming available and more money circulating among a rising population, that day may not be far distant.

It is well to remind those who like to compare our social services with those obtaining in Great Britain that the stamp which costs 11/10 here costs 26/- in Great Britain. If my information is correct, I think the British stamp was further increased recently. Great Britain is, of course, a highly industrialised country with a population of some 50 million. It may be that we will have to introduce a less ambitious scheme but, whatever the scheme, it will have to be financed. You cannot get something for nothing. The money must come from somewhere.

It is fashionable to blame the Government for every inequality or imperfection which appears in the country's economy. This is nowhere more evident than in the matter of an incomes policy. From the point of view of the trade unions, this is a very sensitive matter. Such a policy can come only from negotiations between employers and employees. Any attempt by this or any Government to impose a settlement of the division between workers and employees would be resisted by the trade union movement. The trade unions are, quite rightly, jealous of rights which have been won at great sacrifice over the years. The best a Government can do is provide the machinery for negotiation where such is obviously required. Our desire is to see all men and women in secure and well paid employment and we express the hope that both Parties to negotiations will pay due regard to the country's needs.

The State should not be looked on as a sort of fairy godmother, who can by waving a magic wand resolve all our difficulties. State control is not, of itself, a sure cure for all our ills. Fianna Fáil are neither a doctrinaire socialist nor doctrinaire capitalist Party. It is striking just the right balance between State and private enterprise. Only by striking such a balance can we, employers, workers and trade unions, preserve the democratic liberties to which we have a right.

The country is moving forward on all fronts. This is a fact which cannot be denied except by those who do not wish to see. Therefore, this House should give its approval to the Vote on Account and demonstrate its faith in intelligent and well-ordered Government.

Comment on this

We had an interesting discussion on the Vote on Account, with speakers ranging from the Taoiseach to Deputy Corry and the Deputy who has just sat down. I am struck very forcibly by the change of policy which has taken place in that Party over the years. Perhaps it would be a bit boring if one were to examine all the twists they have made in their policy over the past 30 years. The last speaker said they were neither a doctrinaire socialist nor doctrinaire capitalist Party. I heard that used many times in another context—that they were not doctrinaire something else also.

The Taoiseach intervened today and made two or three interesting statements. The first that struck me forcibly was that there will be no general election declared between now and tomorrow night. He was quite clear on that. But from the taking of the Vote tomorrow night until the date this Dáil is due to end, it can happen any time in certain circumstances. I can assure him the people are anxious for it. I am anxious, although I am not as young as I was, to face an election. I am anxious that the people get an opportunity of deciding whether this Government retain their confidence or not. I am satisfied they do not.

The next point the Taoiseach made was in regard to the memorandum on health services by Deputy T. O'Higgins. The Deputy has already dealt with this. The Minister condemned that memorandum out of hand. However, Deputy O'Higgins need not think he is alone when condemned by the Taoiseach. We know that previously the Taoiseach condemned very vigorously Dr. Dignan's plan for health, which was then shelved. But, strange as it may seem, an OEEC observer recently resurrected that plan and recommended it for reexamination. Deputy Corry told us that if he had been a member of the Committee on Health Services it would not have remained without a meeting since last April. Deputy Corry forgets the Commission set up on vocational education, over which a very learned, honoured and reliable ecclesiastic presided. The Taoiseach declared its report to be a very slovenly one.

Therefore, Deputy O'Higgins is in fairish good company when his memorandum is condemned out of hand like that. If Deputy O'Higgins' memorandum is as bad as the Taoiseach pretends, the Tánaiste could have called the Health Committee together any time since April and condemned it out of hand. The fact is that the Committee have not been called together. In fact, they adjourned for the purpose of considering that memorandum. The Tánaiste was even good enough to thank Deputy O'Higgins for having produced it, with the comment "Now we have something to get our teeth into." He got his teeth into it; they are still stuck in it and his mouth is shut ever since. I make these comments in reply to the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach should not on a Vote on Account like this bring in these matters, unless he has his tongue in his cheek in regard to the question of a general election. He is preparing something. He got in a preliminary canter today. However, these preliminary canters may be instructive sometimes but they are not always reliable

There are two other points I want to make before I come to the Vote on Account itself. It has been said here that no Deputy has pointed out where reductions can be made. I am glad the Minister for Finance is here now. Deputies will recall that, last year, on the Vote on Account and the Budget I pointed out that the Minister had made no provision for overestimation and that, in my opinion, he should have taken credit for at least £10 million in the Budget. The Minister very properly said that he could not do that because he had to make provision for the payment of the increased salaries to civil servants, the guards and so on and that would eat up that £10 million. He intervened in the course of my speech to say that. The truth of the matter is that he had that £10 million and had a buoyant revenue of £25 million.

Comment on this

Where did the Deputy see that? I did not see it.

Comment on this

Well, £20 million.

Comment on this

I did not see it.

Comment on this

How much had you?

Comment on this

I wish the Deputy were right.

Comment on this

Had you £15 million?

Comment on this

We had about £5 million of a deficit.

Comment on this

You had a buoyant revenue on last year's expenditure. You had £15 million more than you budgeted for.

Comment on this

I wish you were right. You have seen money that I have not seen.

Comment on this

The truth of the matter is that the Minister for Finance refused to accept the point that over-estimation would account for five per cent—a shilling in the £.

Comment on this

I was right.

Comment on this

What the Minister for Finance said was that he needed the £10 million that would be there to pay the civic guards, the Army, and the others the increased sums that would be coming for payment and for which no provision had yet been made and that he was keeping that in reserve.

Comment on this

And it is not there.

Comment on this

Is not that correct?

Comment on this

No; it is not there at all.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance said that then. But, together with the amount that he budgeted for, he has, in my calculation, an extra £15 million that he collected. There was a buoyant revenue to that extent and all that is eaten up; it is all gone. Now he says he has a deficit for the year now under review of £15 million.

Again, on £220 million, a five per cent allowance for over-estimation gives him over £12 million. So that the deficit that he is, or that he pretends to be, faced with is practically infinitesimal and he is erecting an aunt sally to shy at, as has been the Fianna Fáil tactics and practice for a number of years. It is alleged that we are going to have a tough year and a difficult year and then they are able to do so much that it shows what great fellows they are. That is playing fast and loose and the sooner the Government get down to brass tacks and say what the position is, the better for all concerned—Government, Opposition, and the people as a whole—because then we would know where we are.

Today there were objections when the Taoiseach was speaking about the Marshall Aid being spent. I remember the then Taoiseach saying that when they came in there was only a remnant of £22 million. Prior to that it was stated there was none at all but in Fermoy he made the statement that there was £22 million unspent. There was never any Government in the history of this world that left as much ready cash to another as did the first inter-Party Government.

Comment on this

There was not a bob in it.

Comment on this

Was the then Taoiseach telling an untruth? Was the remnant of £22 million not there?

Comment on this

It was all put against borrowing, was it not?

Comment on this

Is it not true that there is some of the Marshall Aid money not spent yet?

Comment on this

A lot of it has not been paid back yet.

Comment on this

There is no use in interjecting that it has to be paid back.

Comment on this

I was trying to keep the Deputy to the truth.

Comment on this

The Minister would like to get me off this particular line because it is a flat contradiction of everything they said, which they said up to a time and then admitted it was incorrect. Deputy Childers went to Newtownforbes and described our own budget proposals as the rake's progress because there was a £2 million increase and suggested that we were spending right, left and centre. I shall not comment on the rake's progress except to say that while I am delighted, and hope it will be a success, that an Irish Government have bought over the B and I line—I assume some of the money we are voting today will be earmarked for it or that it will be coming in course of payment soon—it is a reversal of the view expressed by the Minister for External Affairs that he wished every ship was at the bottom of the sea. In Athlone, in my presence, he declared that if every ship was sunk, then, instead of the Irish people having to tighten their belts, we would have so much to eat that we would have to loosen them. That is a complete reversal. It is a great conversion, which I welcome. Unfortunately, it has taken too long—30 years—to educate them.

I want to comment on the very heavy expenditure that is taking place on this House. While accommodation is needed and while it is important that Deputies should have suitable offices and accommodation the expenditure has been too great. When I consider that expenditure and look at this Chamber I feel that, if that £800,000 was being spent on Leinster House, then there should have been 51 additional seats created here so that the Government could say: "There are 51 seats in Leinster House for people from Northern Ireland to occupy whenever they feel like it." Planning is required in connection with the expenditure of such a large amount of money. There is no planning about it. If there were planning, it would be a very big day if there were 51 seats available here that the Government could point to and say: "Gentlemen, the seats are ready."

Comment on this

Fine Gael planning.

Comment on this

Oh, no—a tea party.

Comment on this

I am glad that after 35 or 40 years North and South can meet. Would to God that there was as much wisdom 40 years ago as there is today.

Comment on this

They have not enough seats in Westminster for the dozen or so they send over there.

Comment on this

Forty years ago when an agreement was made between two Heads of Government——

Comment on this

A secret agreement.

Comment on this

——we know what happened. I shall not review it now but I hope some student of history will do so.

Comment on this

An agreement to give the Six Counties away.

Comment on this

Do not spoil it.

Comment on this

When the Minister for Finance makes a statement like that he is, again, talking with his tongue in his cheek and he knows thoroughly well the situation that was agreed and that there was a Six County Government in being before any of us left. Before any representative of this country left, it was in existence.

Comment on this

You sold out. You sold the Irish people's rights away in a secret agreement. Talking about 40 years ago!

Comment on this

Will you stop?

Comment on this

These are matters that you should be reminded of.

Comment on this

Get up and say it.

Comment on this

I will get up and say it later on.

Comment on this

Do, and tell us all about it. I would be very grateful. I am glad that that meeting has taken place. I wish it well. I can only say with confidence that nobody on this side of the House will rebut any agreement that is made between an Irish Government and the representatives of the Six Counties. We will stand behind it in the belief and in the firm confidence that every approach and every consultation is a good one and better than none.

Comment on this