We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Members' Business. - Housing Bill, 1965: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–140 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Housing Bill, 1965
Enacted

No. 20 of 1965 ›

When progress was reported on this section, the Minister was about to give us some further explanation of subsection (b) and some examples, perhaps, of the type of person to whom it would apply. In the course of his comments, he remarked that this subsection was intended to widen the scope of the Bill and to make grants available to a greater number of people. That seems to me to be in conflict with the ruling of the Ceann Comhairle on my amendment which sought to have this subsection deleted. That amendment was ruled out of order on the ground that it would impose a charge on State funds. Now, either the Ceann Comhairle is right in ruling my amendment out of order or the Minister is wrong.

Comment on this

Which amendment?

Comment on this

To delete subsection (b).

Comment on this

Then what would we have?

Comment on this

We then have all these conditions eliminated. My amendment was ruled out of order on the ground that it would impose a charge on State funds. The Minister says that is not so, that the effect of this subsection will be that many more grants will be possible to a greater number of people. Was my amendment not ruled out of order on the ground it would impose a charge on State funds?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The ruling of the Ceann Comhairle was correct. The Deputy's amendment would have the effect of imposing a charge on State funds.

Comment on this

I can only deduce from that the Minister's statement must not be correct. The two things cannot be right. If this subsection will have the effect the Minister says it will, then my amendment cannot be ruled out. I should like to hear the Minister say he either accepts or does not accept that. In my view, this will have the effect of reducing the number of grants that may be made, if these conditions are imposed on top of the conditions set out in subsection (a). If they can stand apart and are separate from the conditions set out in subsection (a), there is a possibility that they could widen the scope of the grants. I should like to hear from the Minister examples of the people he has in mind who would be included under subsection (b). Would he give us specific definitions in relation to the various conditions laid down here or will the interpretation of that be left to certain officials, perhaps one or two officials, in the local authority? Is there any way in which to tie this up in legislation? I should like the Minister to deal with that before I come back to this table.

Comment on this

The previous section was referred to as the town and city dwellers' section. This section is referred to as the farmers' section. I do not think either description is strictly true. As I understand the section, if we delete subsection (b), as Deputy Clinton wishes us to do, this would be purely a farmers' section. Under subsection (b), farmers or industrial workers will be eligible for the grant mentioned in section 15. An industrial worker living in a rural area will, if he satisfies the conditions in subsection (b), qualify for a grant of £450. It is at this point I share Deputy Clinton's concern about the subsection.

Deputy Clinton asked for examples. I shall give an example now that I came across a few days ago. A farm on which a man worked as a steward and on which he had a house was sold. He acquired a site for a house on the farm. Living with him there was an unmarried son, a factory worker, and he put his name to the application form for the grant. He was notified that he was eligible for a grant of only £300. That is an example of the type of person who should qualify under subsection (b). This steward and his family lived on and worked the land all their lives. Due to circumstances outside their control, they had to get out of the house in which they lived. Now they find, having acquired a site, that they are entitled to only £300 by way of grant. Perhaps, if the steward had applied in his own name, the situation might have been different, but he is an old man now and apparently it was decided that the son should be the applicant. I believe these are the people who should qualify under subsection (b).

Comment on this

The ruling of the Chair and my statement as to what is or is not in this section have been questioned by Deputy Clinton. The ruling of the Chair is, of course, right. The Deputy should have known that before he asked the question——

Comment on this

Then the Minister was wrong.

Comment on this

——and he should not deduce from that that I must be wrong. As I see it, the point objected to by the Deputy and suggested to be deleted is an additional part of the subsection that is intended to bring in more people than were originally announced to be included. Presumably, he does not want these conditions to apply.

Comment on this

I may have misunderstood the provision. That is why I wanted the Minister to explain it. I was led further up the garden by the decision of the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this

No. The two are quite consistent. One is that we are introducing something additional to what was already announced in the earlier stages about these grants, enabling a further number of people to be considered for these higher grants. The Deputy wants to delete this, and by so doing, leave the matter that it may be interpreted more widely than it is now capable of being interpreted. In other words, I am prepared to go a bit further than we had intended to go but the Deputy wants to go the whole hog or near it.

Comment on this

The Minister is trying to misinterpret what I am saying. I have asked the Minister several times are the conditions laid down in paragraph (b) a further extension of paragraph (a) or does paragraph (b) stand on its own?

Comment on this

It stands on its own.

Comment on this

Surely, therefore, I am in a position to question the ruling of the Chair?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not.

Comment on this

He can make representations.

Comment on this

I can make representations. It is a case for making representations. Possibly the Minister is right in what he says that this will extend the scope, provided that paragraph (b) is not an additional qualification superimposed on paragraph (a). We have all asked the Minister to give examples of the people who might come within the scope of paragraph (b), and so far he has not done so. I want to know also on whose interpretation will it be decided whether a person is in an overcrowded house, a house unfit for human habitation or is in need of housing on medical, compassionate or other similar grounds? Who will make that decision? Is it an official of the Department? Is it the officials of the local authorities, or is it the chief medical officer who will decide that "the circumstances of the person or occupier are such that he could not provide a house for his own occupation without the aid of a grant under this section"?

There are so many conditions there, and the conditions are so difficult to determine, that I am greatly afraid they will be used by certain people to deprive of grants a class of people whom the Minister has in mind as being entitled to grants. I would like him to give us examples of the type of people to whom paragraph (b) would normally apply and if it could be tied up definitely in legislation and not left so much to the discretion of people operating the Bill afterwards.

Comment on this

I would draw the attention of the Deputy to the first and second lines of section 16 (2) which says: "Grants under this section shall be made only if, in the opinion of the Minister, the person providing the house...." In other words, the person who makes the decision in these cases will be the Minister or his agent, as his officers would ordinarily be regarded. As to the type of person envisaged under paragraph (b), there is an obvious example: a person ordinarily resident in a rural area living in an unfit or overcrowded house. This seems to be the type of person we are aiming at. Furthermore, he could be a person in need of housing on medical, compassionate or other similar grounds and, this is the really important part, "the circumstances of the person or occupier are such that he could not provide a house for his own occupation without the aid of a grant under this section." It might be better if we looked at this in the reverse direction. We could readily envisage a person living in unfit or overcrowded accommodation but known to be and demonstrated to be well off, much better off than the members of the community among whom he lives. I do not think we should be liable or compelled by law to give that person a higher grant.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

It makes it clearer to mention those who should not benefit than to enumerate all those who should come within this provision.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to make one point clear. The position, as I understand it is, first, all this is dependent on the opinion of the Minister. Secondly, the provisions in subsection (2) (a) are the provisions which govern the provision of houses for farmers and those deriving their livelihood principally from agriculture. Paragraph (b) is the one which applies to those who need not necessarily derive their livelihood from agriculture. In regard to paragraph (b), take a case where a person is qualified under this paragraph on grounds of health, over-crowding or whatever you like. If he uses his house for the purpose of some business or occupation, is it clear that is not a disqualification, that it is sufficient that it is used ordinarily for purposes of residence, that it will not militate against him that there is a business, a small shop or something of that sort carried on in the premises?

Comment on this

There again it is a question as to what the residence may be used for, apart from being resided in.

Comment on this

I am speaking about the house which is generally being used as a residence but also for another purpose.

Comment on this

Paragraph (b) says: "the said person or occupier is ordinarily resident"; it does not go on to deal with anything else that may be going on in the residence.

Comment on this

I think the case I am asking about would be included. I just wanted to pinpoint it.

Comment on this

I would say it would be, subject to the fact that whatever is going on in this house in the control of the person concerned is not of such commercial benefit to him as to put him out of court in so far as giving him special help is concerned.

Comment on this

I think that paragraph (b) has been fairly well clarified now and we know where we stand. I did not know where I stood up to the present. I said I would come back to the tables again because I could not get the Minister to see the point I was making, or perhaps he did not wish to see the point. I made a comparison between the table provided in relation to urban grants and the table now provided in relation to rural grants and I pointed out that there were three columns in the urban grants table and only two in the rural grants table. I was curious to know why there was not a third column in the latter table, in view of the fact that it would cost a man considerably more if he had to provide water and sewerage services by way of digging a well or providing a septic tank rather than connecting up to local mains passing his gate. The Minister has not yet explained why this additional amount provided in the case of an urban house is not provided in the case of rural houses. There is an extra £25 in the urban house grant and there is no such extra amount in the rural grant and no such distinction, although the Minister will have to agree that in a rural area, if water and sewerage services are passing the road where the house is being built, it will cost very much less than if the farmer had to provide these services by way of septic tank or digging a well. I should like the Minister to comment on that.

Comment on this

I am not being facetious when I say that we could easily insert a third column which would have the effect of giving less to those in circumstances where either or both services were publicly provided. Further, it does not follow at all that both services are going to be available in rural parts.

Comment on this

No, it does not follow.

Comment on this

It would be rather unusual to find sewerage services near a farmhouse or a rural house, unless they are in some little town. Another point is that frequently, not necessarily in all cases, although there may be a water service and even a sewerage service in some of the areas, it could be that the well at the foot of the garden would be a lot cheaper to provide than it would be to connect. In general, in regard to sewerage, I think the number of cases in which sewerage schemes are readily available would be small. The number having water may not be small, and there will be a growing number in the years ahead, but in those cases it is unlikely that the majority of them will be so near to the mains or otherwise that it will be much cheaper to connect them than it might be to provide one's own source of supply. To finish what I started to say, we could easily have the three columns but it would be going backwards.

Comment on this

You would be doing it by subtraction rather than addition.

Comment on this

I should like to know what is to be the definition of a rural area. There are many places in the country, and certainly in my constituency there are two, where you would have farmers operating as farmers and rural workers operating as such who are in an urban local area, as, for instance, in the Drogheda local area or the Drogheda borough. These people cannot get sewerage. They are not in a rural area such as the area which Louth County Council are administering. Is there to be a strict definition relating to the local authority area in which people live or is it to be decided upon in regard to how they live themselves or what sort of people they are? It is a problem we have to think about.

Comment on this

The question of definition was dealt with in this rather involved and probably confusing section 2. On page 9, at line 20, it says that " `rural area' means an area no place in which is within a county borough, borough, urban district, town, or non-municipal town." We go down then to the point where the general interpretation of this would apply, that in ordinary language the community of 1,000 or over would be the guiding line in this regard.

Comment on this

I am only trying to help the Minister——

Comment on this

I am not doubting that.

Comment on this

——I am not being difficult. I will use again the example of my own constituency. There are 17,000 or 18,000 people in Drogheda and also there are areas within the corporation area where people would be living within rural conditions, perhaps living in houses and working for farmers. They cannot get sewerage or water because these services are not going to be provided there by the corporation. Will they get this extra grant in the rural table or will they be precluded from getting it?

Comment on this

They are living within the rural area?

Comment on this

Yes, within the rural area. I agree that you have to take a figure. The Minister has taken the figure of over 1,000 as the population of an urban area, but at the same time the person is living within the rural area.

Comment on this

And going to build within it?

Comment on this

Yes, in a rural condition. I have one case with the Minister for definition at present, of a farmer whose workman desires to build a house and who falls within the urban area but who is living in rural conditions. Can we help him?

Comment on this

I do not think so, in the context the Deputy suggests. Let us go back to sub-paragraph (b) of section 16. Where the person is "ordinarily resident in a rural area", is what is set out there. Obviously, if he is ordinarily resident in an urban area, he does not and cannot, as a non-farmer, come within the terms of the improved grants. On the other hand, when I say non-farmer, a farmer at the same time may be in similar circumstances to this non-farmer but proposes to build his house outside the urban area. He could in those circumstances get the higher grant but the worker who is not ordinarily resident outside the urban area could not get it.

Comment on this

Our job on this side of the House is to look after the lowliest member of the population. It is our job to look after these people whether they are few or many. The Minister is well aware, as he has considerable experience of local authority areas, that in these urban areas there are farmers continuing to farm on land that will never be built on and where these workers or small farmers would if they were outside the urban area be entitled to an extra grant. They find themselves, because of the unhappy accident of being within the urban area, precluded from such grants.

Our position, I understand, is that if we put down an amendment on this matter, we may be ruled out of order on the basis of placing an extra charge on the Exchequer. That may or may not be so, but this has arisen in relation to this Bill already and so we would ask the Minister if he would be prepared himself to insert another subsection in section 16, or anywhere else the draftsman will agree to, covering the circumstances of a person who could produce a certificate from a local authority to the effect that water and sewerage would never be provided on that land and on this certificate, provide an extra grant for a person entitled to it——

Comment on this

Might I interject? This question of a certificate does not come into the matter at all. I wonder if the Deputy is pursuing something that has no real meaning? Nobody in his sane senses could give a certificate that there never would be water or sewerage provided in a certain place or even not provided within a reasonable time. But it has nothing to do with the qualifications or otherwise of persons for these higher grants whether there would be water or sewerage. This is not vital at all.

Comment on this

I accept immediately what the Minister has said. I accept his correction but I am sure he will agree that if a farm labourer or farm manager or a farmer under £25 valuation resides in an urban area and is precluded from getting an extra grant, an injustice would be done. We are precluded from putting down an amendment and having it decided. Therefore we ask the Minister, as is our right, to put it down. We should like to know what he will say about that.

Comment on this

The Deputy seems to want this to apply to urban areas?

Comment on this

Yes, to farm labourers or farmers with small valuation; in other words, the advantages proposed for those two classes outside.

Comment on this

This seeks to embrace that which is excluded?

Comment on this

Yes, in individual cases.

Comment on this

Yes, all the cases to which this new system of grants applies.

Comment on this

I think the case Deputy Donegan has in mind is somebody who perhaps happened to own 20 acres or 25 acres outside the urban area but had no residence on it and had to go into the urban area to live. He wants to get back to the land to live there and work on it. That seems to be a reasonable case to include, but it is excluded.

Comment on this

No; if he has land outside the urban area on which there is no residence and for various reasons he has had to live elsewhere but wants to build a residence on the land and live there, he is included.

Comment on this

Does paragraph (b) not apply only where he is ordinarily resident in a rural area?

Comment on this

But this man cannot claim to be ordinarily resident——

Comment on this

Not paragraph (b). It is under paragraph (a). If he has 20 acres outside, he would qualify under paragraph (a) and the conditions of paragraph (b) would not operate against him.

Comment on this

My anxiety is in respect of people living as small farmers within an urban area. They are a rarity but there are such people and we must accept them. With the extension of urban areas, there may be more of them. When an urban area is extended, one always finds a bit of a rural area comes in and it may be 25 years before that becomes a suburb of the expanding town. During that time, you have small farmers, perhaps, carrying on horticultural work of some kind, and just because they are within the urban area, they are precluded from receiving the extra grants. I do not want any red herrings: I want the Minister to say if he is prepared to meet this type of person. There are not 200 of them in the whole country and not more than ten or 30 of them would ever build a house. I want the Minister to consider that for an amendment even at a later stage and see if those who have a small amount of land within an urban area and wish to build a house to live in can get the extra grant proposed under this legislation.

Comment on this

Something that might help in a general way is that the terms and provisions of this particular section apply to persons deriving their livelihood solely or mainly from agriculture. This is subsection (a). This would include agricultural labourers living in an urban area, but if they want to avail of it, they must build outside the urban area.

Comment on this

I am sorry to persist, but I think we all understand the position completely. Would the Minister indicate whether he is prepared to act on this? He knows the position: of ourselves we can do nothing to bring in this amendment. Is the Minister prepared to meet us in regard to this category of persons living within an urban area but carrying on farming?

Comment on this

The Deputy is alluding solely to those who are either farming or deriving their livelihood largely or solely from farming and who wish to live in the urban area?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

All I can do is consider it but I am not inclined to give a great deal of encouragement to the Deputy.

Comment on this

Would they be covered by paragraph (a)?

Comment on this

Provided they build outside the urban area.

Comment on this

If you have a man in the urban area of Dundalk who is a small farmer and is perhaps at this stage delivering milk in the town or to Dealgan Milk Products or some other company that markets it and who wants to build a house on his land, just because he is in an urban area, he will not get the extra grant.

Comment on this

Does he get a supplementary grant?

Comment on this

The funny thing is that he does not. I am not a member of Dundalk urban authority but I am a member of Louth County Council and Drogheda Corporation, and they do give grants. The Minister should thank me for my efforts. To be serious, I want the Minister to consider deeply the position of these farmers in urban areas because there are very few of them. It seems wrong that a person earning his livelihood, either as a farmer or labourer, from agriculture should be precluded because he lives in an urban area.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy refer to a person in need of rehousing?

Comment on this

It is on that basis the section is being discussed.

Comment on this

I should like to add that the Minister's entire housing policy up to the present has been favouring urban dwelling. Therefore, will he not agree it is desirable that the type of person Deputy Donegan referred to should be included? There are two types of case. There is the man with a bit of land outside who is included in paragraph (a) even if he happens to live inside.

Comment on this

Not a man with a bit of land. The paragraph states "solely or mainly".

Comment on this

Then you have the agricultural worker. He is resident inside but he is very badly housed. Can he build in the urban area and still be entitled to this grant?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

He will be entitled to it, only if he comes out and builds in a rural area.

Comment on this

Deputy Donegan refers to a farmer living within the urban area who wants to build within the urban area.

Comment on this

I know two big farmers in Dundalk who have workers living within the urban area. Supposing one of them decides to give one of his workers a site for a house inside the urban area. Would it not be fair and equitable that such a worker would get the extra grant? The man would be a farm worker residing within the urban area, getting a site within the urban area from his employer.

Comment on this

The whole point of this provision is being missed. It has been almost forgotten by me. The provision is mainly directed to rural housing. It is what we set out to deal with in a special way. Therefore, this procedure of defining the thing with a fine comb is losing sight of the fact that the whole provision really originated in anxiety to deal in a special way with the category of people in rural Ireland whose housing conditions have not kept pace with the general national improvement in our towns and cities. That is what we should keep in mind.

Comment on this

Can the Minister see any difference between the badly-housed man who comes to milk my cows, to whom I give a site and who gets £900 in total grants, and the fellow in Dundalk urban area who is similarly badly housed? Should we not legislate for the latter person as well? We know there are only a few hundred cases in the whole country. I see Deputy Corry looking at me. I feel sure he is thinking of the situation in Cork since the borough boundary extension. His people can be affected by this as mine can be in Louth. I feel sure Deputy Corry agrees with me that we should legislate for this type of person.

Comment on this

The Deputy is trying to hop another ball.

Comment on this

The Deputy is forgetting that the borough boundary was extended to embrace areas outside it in order to relieve the pockets of the ratepayers inside. Those taken in will not any more be able to get the supplementary grants. The Deputy knows that as well as I do. The supplementary grants will not be paid by the urban district council.

Comment on this

That happened to me, too.

Comment on this

The man taken in has only the State grant because the people who brought him in to relieve the rates will not give him a supplementary grant.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give further consideration to the case made by Deputy Donegan? I assure the Minister I appreciate the position he is in. In these cases it is always difficult to cater for marginal instances that will be put by Deputies. By and large, most of us would prefer that in legislation of any kind, there should be clear-cut definition. There is a clear-cut definition in this Bill as to what a rural area is. On the other hand, the point made by Deputy Donegan is an important one. It is ridiculous when you think of some of the areas on the outskirts of Dublin.

Take Rathfarnham as an instance. It has developed in recent years very considerably as far as housing by private enterprise is concerned. The area I am referring to—I am sure Deputy Clinton is familiar with it— is a rural area within the definition of this Bill; yet it is now entirely built up and a person, under the provisions of this section, who derived his livelihood from agriculture—there are a number there—would be entitled to the increased grant because the area in question is not within a county borough, urban district, town or non-municipal town. It seems to me that is the kind of case the Minister does not intend to cover but which will be covered by the Bill.

On the other hand, Deputy Donegan is pleading the case the Minister himself would like to see covered by the Bill but which is not covered by the Bill as it stands. I appreciate the Minister's difficulty but I think Deputy Donegan has made a fair case for a handful of people in that situation. I should be satisfied—I am sure Deputy Donegan would be also—if we had an assurance from the Minister that he and his officials would examine this further to see if this handful of cases could be covered.

Comment on this

May I pose this question to the House? Assuming we were all of a mind to include this handful of cases, how and for what reason would we justify it? We would not be taking in the fellow who sweeps the streets in the urban area, not taking in the fellow who minds the car parks, not taking in the fellow who sells icecream in vans in housing estates. How can we justify taking in the group that is being pleaded for so forcefully here?

Comment on this

We are accepting the Minister's definition that the individuals referred to are those who are deriving their livelihood solely or mainly from agriculture. We are accepting that.

Comment on this

That is under clause (a). Why should we stop at taking only those who are deriving their livelihood solely and mainly from agriculture, according to clause (a) of this section, when, by moving to the other part, clause (b), we find that all these other people I have mentioned would have at least as good a case as those under (a)?

Comment on this

Clause (b) already refers to those ordinarily resident in a rural area.

Comment on this

The Minister will understand that I am not being argumentative when I seek to justify the claims of persons under (a) who earn their living either as agricultural labourers or small farmers as distinct from those he instanced, such as corporation workers who sweep the streets, and other urban workers in an area. The answer is: the income of the small farmer is accepted as being too low at the present time. That is why he is being given an extra grant. The income of the farm labourer is accepted as being too small. Whether we are farmers or not, we accept the fact that we would like to pay farm labourers considerably more. A man sweeping the streets has an urban wage. In many cases in my constituency, he is one of the lowest paid of the urban workers but he, nevertheless, has an urban wage and is expected to pay for a corporation or urban council house something in the region of £2 a week if there is no differential rents scheme. I, like the Minister, am in favour of differential rents but most local authorities do not find a majority of their members of that opinion. That must have conditioned the extra grants the Minister is giving for housing in rural areas. He realised that the sort of money that would have to be paid, if there were not an extra grant, would be just too much for the agricultural labourer and small farmer.

My view is that the man who has £10 or £11 a week can validly be rehoused in a corporation or urban council house at a higher rent. The man who is a farm labourer or small farmer could not pay this charge if he did not get the extra grant. The extra grant in most instances comes to a total of £300 because there is a full supplementary grant also from the local authority. Therefore, the question is simply and solely a question of money and we can justify the payment of this extra grant to a farm labourer with perhaps less than £8 a week, while we cannot justify its being paid to a man with £10 or £11 a week.

Comment on this

The Deputy has put his finger on what is really wrong. An urban resident, on a rural agricultural worker's wage, with the big or the small grant and no supplementary grant, cannot possibly afford to build himself a house in an urban area and should be housed by the local authority and on a differential rent that he can afford. If you put that fellow in that position, you might as well put a stone around his neck and drown him.

Comment on this

The Minister is suggesting that the grant should be merely the State grant.

Comment on this

I am saying that that is what it is.

Comment on this

The position is as I have instanced it in my constituency. In Drogheda Corporation, there is an extra grant of a sum equal to that paid by the State—at the moment it is a maximum of £300; in the Louth County Council area and Dundalk County Council area, there is not. If the Minister went this far for those people, it might be a further incentive, not that the incentives have worked too well in certain instances, for the urban authority to give a supplementary grant. The Minister cannot frame legislation on the basis that local authorities have not done what he and I agree should be done, namely, institute a supplementary grants system.

Comment on this

There is the other side to this that, if as has been instanced, an urban worker with £10 or £11 a week is the responsibility of the local authority within whose jurisdiction he lives and because of the fact that he has £10 or £11 a week, can afford to pay the rent struck by that local authority whereas the man with £3 a week less cannot afford to pay it, it is ludicrous to talk about providing incentives to the lesser paid to build his own house in that locality. It does not make sense.

Comment on this

The Minister is now operating on the basis that he does not want to do this——

Comment on this

No; I am trying to get some sense into what is being put forward.

Comment on this

——for the reason that it is unlikely that it will be availed of because it does not make sense.

Comment on this

I have not changed ground. That is merely an additional reason.

Comment on this

It was the Minister who brought the local authority worker into the discussion.

Comment on this

In many instances within a few miles of where I live, in the rural area, farm workers have done a considerable amount of the work themselves——

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this

——and through being given a site by a relative or by their employer, at a cheap rate, have succeeded in producing a better house than could be provided as a Louth County Council cottage and at a cheaper repayment rate than the rate that would be charged by Louth County Council. If that is possible under the sky in a rural area, it is just as possible under the sky in an urban area. With the goodwill of the farmer, the goodwill of the relative who has a site and the hard work of the applicant who goes out to get £900 in grants at £7 5s. 6d. principal and interest per £100 borrowed, he can build a house that he owns and a better house than would be provided by Louth County Council or Cork County Council or any other county council as a county council cottage.

I am not operating on the basis that there will be thousands of these. The Minister produces an argument in my favour when he says that it is hardly practicable. This means that there will be very few. I do not want to see people excluded just because they are in an urban area, if they are farm labourers or small farmers. I know of numbers in my constituency. They do not all vote for me, but I would like to see them getting houses just as they would get them if they were in the rural area.

Comment on this

I am the last person to be taken as arguing that farm labourers cannot or do not provide houses for themselves, despite the fact that in view of costs as known and as quoted here, it seems to be an absolute impossibility.

Comment on this

Effort is the answer. They make the effort.

Comment on this

In my own county where, by Louth and Meath standards, 90 per cent of the farmers, I suppose, would be regarded as agricultural workers, they have been providing their own houses since Adam was a little fellow and will go on doing it, grants or no grants, and can do it on the grants available to them at the present time and that have been available for years past. I have always been saying that but this is not an argument for using what is intended for housing in rural areas, for providing houses in an urban district. This is what I am trying to get across.

Comment on this

Let us end the game of ping pong. I know very well the Minister's problem. There is a question of precedent. Take two people living side by side, one of whom by virtue of his occupation, would get the extra grant and the other who, by virtue of his occupation, would not. This, naturally, produces in any democracy a problem for the Minister. I am certain that members of his departmental staff would be horrified by this situation, if it developed. I am asking the Minister in a most friendly manner to consider the matter before Report Stage and to see if he could find it in his heart to introduce an amendment to grant this small alleviation for what are fewer than 100 people. Will the Minister consider it for Report Stage?

Comment on this

That was my first offer and it still stands.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 22, in the names of Deputy Corish and others, has been ruled out of order as it tends to impose charges on State funds.

Comment on this

I want to refer to the limitations of this section and to ask was it really necessary, in view of the very limited category of people it covers. As I see it, under this section, if a man builds a house of 499 square feet and has water and sewerage laid on, he gets £175. If, without this piece of legislation, they build a house a foot larger in floor area, they would be entitled to the same grant under section 15. There is one square foot in the difference but they are entitled to the £175 if they build it that extra foot. On that ground, I say it is unnecessary and that it will lead to the building of houses that will have very limited use.

This section seems to be designed to induce a farmer who is getting on in years to build substandard accommodation for himself so that he can move out and let his son carry on with the farm. That would be very desirable, if there was nothing to prevent him getting this grant already under legislation which has been in existence since 1948. The only case not covered in these subsections is where the Land Commission comes in to buy the house. If that happens, the Land Commission should be obliged to provide alternative accommodation for the old people. They should provide alternative accommodation, plus whatever they give for moving out, or include these benefits as a right.

It seems to me that this is an unnecessary section which gives the impression that a new set of benefits is being provided and, in my view, there are no new or additional benefits here at all. If there are, I would like the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary to tell us what additional grants or benefits are provided. I know that it will make it possible to get £175 for building one room but surely that is inducing people to go to live in very substandard conditions in their old age, which is the time when they need extra comforts. If this provision were being made for urban areas, there would be a great deal of criticism, if there were not central heating. Central heating is one of the things doctors say are needed for old people.

These substandard buildings will not be suitable for anybody else. If you were providing under this section a house that might be suitable afterwards for a farm labourer and his family, you would be providing a national asset, but here you will have an idle dwelling that will be unfit for any family. It could be described as another Fianna Fáil white elephant.

Comment on this

This is a new provision. Heretofore you could get a grant of £175 for the provision of a three-roomed dwelling with a minimum floor area of 500 square feet. Under this provision a house of up to a floor area of 500 square feet will be sufficient to get the grant. It is intended for the young fellow starting off in the home place who wants to make provision for his father and mother. Under the 1948 legislation, he could get a grant of £175 but the minimum floor area had to be 500 square feet; now he can get it for less than 500 square feet.

Comment on this

Surely a floor area of 500 square feet is a very humble dwelling?

Comment on this

I agree, but they are not confined to that. If they want to build a bigger house, they can still do so and get the grant, but this provides a chance for the old couple to build a smaller house if they want to, and I do not see anything wrong with the section.

Comment on this

It is only wrong in so far as it is a pretence that it is providing something new and additional. It is inducing people to move into substandard accommodation and to spend money on accommodation that will be useless from the day they die.

Comment on this

In section 15 you have grants provided for houses with a floor area of more than 500 square feet and less than 1,400 square feet. Here, where there is a question of the second house being built, the floor area cannot exceed 500 square feet. Why not run the two together and let the second house grant be obtainable, even if the floor area is over 500 square feet?

Comment on this

They can get that under section 15. If a couple decide to build a house for themselves in which the floor area is only 400 square feet, they would not qualify for the grant under section 15, but they will qualify for it under this section.

Comment on this

This qualifies them to get a grant for a house with a floor space under 500 square feet?

Comment on this

Yes, if the people themselves are prepared to settle in that accommodation. Then this section will qualify them for the grant of £175. Under section 15, the minimum floor area must be over 500 square feet.

Comment on this

Do you think it is a good thing that people should build houses of such very small size? Is it good policy for the country?

Comment on this

What we are trying to do is to provide accommodation for a farmer and his wife in which to live so that their son can marry and bring in his wife. These people are getting on in years and they want some accommodation for the remainder of their time. If they are prepared to settle in a house with a floor area of under 500 square feet, they can have that house built and qualify for a grant of £175. This is a new provision. It certainly cannot take from the scheme in any way. It has nothing whatever to do with section 15. Under section 15 the minimum floor area is 500 square feet. Under this, it can be 350 or 500 square feet.

Comment on this

I agree with what the Minister is trying to do, that is, to make it as easy as possible for an old couple to leave their house and farm to the son coming after them. There is no doubt that this is a human problem. Some old people have sufficient accommodation to bring the new daughter into the family and live happily under the same roof; but the new woman often prefers to be in a house on her own. Perhaps the Minister would consider extending this plan to cover extra accommodation on an existing farm by the addition of a couple of rooms and, perhaps, a kitchen? In this way they could be all under the same roof. Perhaps the newly-married couple would agree to live in the small new dwelling for a number of years. Then, by agreement, the old people would get out of the house and switch with the son when his family increases. I would like to see them all under the same roof. I would like to see the necessary money provided so that the premises could be extended to accommodate both families. Perhaps the Minister would examine those points.

Comment on this

I believe Deputy Healy has made an excellent suggestion. This proposal had practically nothing to recommend it up to now, but now it has something. The Minister should seriously consider it. If the conditions of this section could be fulfilled by the addition of a couple of rooms to the existing dwelling, or at least the provision of an inter-connecting passage way or door, it would be a matter of great importance. There is no doubt that most elderly people require some attention. If they could get that minimum attention, daily perhaps, they could live without having to go into a hospital or other institution. That would be much more desirable. This accommodation, that would otherwise be useless, could be used as additional accommodation for the son's family as they grew up. Personally, I should like to support Deputy Healy in this suggestion and I hope that the Minister will consider it.

Comment on this

This section is primarily concerned with the provision of a dower house. I would agree with Deputy Healy and Deputy Clinton. The suggestion of a dower house originated many years ago in order to encourage early marriages in Ireland. I have experience of one dower house that was built voluntarily at the time as an experiment, without any subvention from State or local authority funds. Being associated with housing over a number of years, I took a keen interest in it. Some years after it was built, I went to see the old couple and asked them how they liked their new house. The answer I got disappointed me very much. They felt they were cut off too much, even though they were within 200 yards of the old residence. The old woman said: "It is only a little bit better than the county home." They preferred to be within the walls of the old dwelling. The occupants of that dower house eventually finished up by going back to the old home. As time went on, the new couple were blessed with a family and the old people went back as grandparents to rear the children.

There is a social problem here and I think Deputy Healy's suggestion is an excellent one. The Minister should consider making provision for the addition of two or three rooms to the old dwelling. I would give them a choice. This is something we would all wish to see coming into operation. At the same time, I am in agreement with the section.

I think there is a bit of confusion in regard to the point Deputy Clinton was making which dealt with a different matter. In respect of the three-roomed type of house we have been building in rural Ireland, there has always been a minimum floor area of 500 square feet to qualify. I would ask the Minister to give every attention to the point made by Deputy Healy, but, at the same time, I should like to have the section as it stands given a trial.

Comment on this

I want to put the other point of view. There is very great strength in the arguments put forward by Deputy Healy, Deputy Clinton and Deputy Collins with regard to a grant for the addition of rooms and flats to existing houses. Generally speaking, the idea contained in this section is a good idea, but, while there is great force in the point of view expressed by the three Deputies, while I would like to see that provision contained in the section, we would strengthen the legislation if at the same time we permitted the building of a house of this type, even on another holding.

There are two different sets of circumstances that can arise. One is the set of circumstances about which Deputy Collins spoke, where the old couple, having gone to a dower house, found themselves cut away, unhappy, and eventually went back into the old homestead. There is also the set of circumstances which can arise where the old couple would prefer to go away to a different part of the country or county. It is unduly restrictive in this section to provide that the grant will only be given provided they build on the same holding. I do not think it would weaken the section, or the thinking behind the section, if it were to be provided that the grant would be available on a house of this type without necessarily restricting the building of it to the particular holding. I agree that in the vast majority of cases the situation is that described by the last two speakers, where the old couple would like to stay as near the homestead as possible. Those probably are, as I say, the vast majority of cases, but there are the other cases and I do not think these should be cut out.

Comment on this

One of the things we have to keep in mind is why, by and large, there is likely to be a demand for dower houses or separate homesteads for the old people, or the not so old these days, when a young couple, a son and his bride, take up residence in the original home. In most cases, the older woman and the young bride do not hit it off. Is that not the real reason why semi-detached or detached accommodation must be provided for the old people? It is a problem of incompatibility as between two people, one of whom, by tradition and practice, feels she is entitled to insist that the house must be kept in the way in which she kept it and the other of whom feels that, as a new broom, she must sweep clean. That is the basic problem in the majority of cases. The addition of a couple of rooms to the original homestead will not solve the problem and the idea of the dower house is to obviate the unpleasantness that can arise because of incompatibility.

There are cases, of course, in which there is no incompatibility. The older woman is of great assistance to the younger woman, does not insist on her way of doing things and takes it for granted that the young woman will step into her shoes. Where that is the case, a reconstruction grant for the purpose of providing additional accommodation solves the problem. It must be remembered that if there is intercommunication, then the dwellings are not separate.

The basic idea here is a dower house for the old people, a completely separate dwelling suited to their needs. The idea is to abandon the requirement of 500 square feet minimum. It has been said that nothing worth while can be built under 500 square feet. Take a room of 160 square feet and another of 150, and add a little bit for a scullery, and you are still under 500 square feet. This is to cater for a relatively small number of people wishing to have a separate dwelling as distinct from an addition to an existing dwelling. Where an addition is required, the reconstruction grants will take care of that. If a bigger house is required—three rooms, four rooms, five rooms, or six rooms—the grants available under existing law will cater for that situation. Where it is sought to have the old people in very close proximity to the original homestead, or actually living in an addition to the homestead, I certainly undertake to look into that to see whether or not reconstruction grants are suitable and capable of application. We provide the grants. I shall certainly look into this from the point of view of those who may want to have some structure built up against the original homestead but without being internally connected, but I shall retain the basic idea of a separate detached dwelling, with no specification as to the distance that dwelling must be from the original homestead. All we say is that it must be on the holding.

Comment on this

Why insist that it must be on the holding?

Comment on this

That is an aspect we can consider. We can consider dower houses being provided in numbers in parish or county. One can visualise half a dozen of these dower houses. When the old people pass on, who will occupy them? Will they be allowed to fall into disrepair because of having no care or maintenance in the interim between the deaths of the old people and the son and daughter-in-law, in time, moving into them?

Comment on this

The Minister misses out the fact that, if the son or prospective daughter-in-law has a small holding, the dower house could be built on that small holding. Reverse the order.

Comment on this

If the young couple have a holding of their own and there is no house on it, they qualify for the £450 grant, not the £175.

Comment on this

They could move out and let the old people get the dower house on the small holding for £175.

Comment on this

That is shuffling the deck. I do not know which card is going to come up.

Comment on this

It depends on what way the Minister shuffles them.

Comment on this

There are those few things which require to be looked at. A great deal of what has been said here can more readily be catered for under the reconstruction section, with some amendment, if necessary, rather than by broadening this to take in everything that has been referred to. It should be remembered that this section is designed to help the erection of a small house, smaller than normally accepted, for people in special circumstances and that anything beyond that falls in naturally under the normal grants system. If a grant of £175 is given in this special case, undoubtedly the relationship of the grant to the total cost is more favourable than it will be when a house is built at greater cost and gets the same grant.

Comment on this

The supplementary grant will not apply to the smaller house.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

It is under 500 square feet.

Comment on this

It will apply.

Comment on this

No, it will not.

Comment on this

Not in Dublin County Council.

Comment on this

Do not tempt me as to what is allowed in any particular county.

Comment on this

In any county.

Comment on this