We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Economic Situation.

Contributions 105–275 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is in order in referring to this particular motion and the subject matter of the Private Members' motion now before the House.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry may remember that when the then Taoiseach refused to pay the land annuities, Britain retaliated by putting an embargo on our livestock. The present Taoiseach, who was then Minister for Industry and Commerce, said we would put an embargo on British imports. The then Taoiseach went further and said that all state capital investments in this country would be 51 per cent Irish. At that point, for the first time in our history we were in isolation and we had an economic boundary between the Six and the Twenty-Six Counties.

It is also remarkable to note that in 1931 we exported to Britain 750,000 cattle, store and fat, and in 1947, after 16 years of Fianna Fáil rule we exported—I cannot get the figures accurately—but 112,000 head, less than half that number. If the Government of the day had listened to the sensible arguments put forward here by men who went before me, instead of trying to appeal to the Irish people who were still suffering from the effects of having fought an alien nation, and if they had looked at the realities of life, how much better would the economy of our nation be? Would we be borrowing money or would we have earned money in export markets? I shall allow Deputy Corry to explain this to the House, as no doubt he will when he speaks later in this debate.

We heard Deputy Lemass speak of social justice and give us a lecture on labour relations. Not so long ago a certain section of our society who were then in receipt of £121 per week got an increase of £17 per week and at the same time the old age pensioners got an extra 2/6d per week. Is that social justice ? I believe that society was formed and evolved around the thought that we must all share alike. It is a deplorable thing that a public representative should admit that while people here have got rich in the past four or five years a woman in this city died of starvation in the past few days.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy give some particulars about that?

Comment on this

The Deputy is a member of the housing authority of this city——

Comment on this

That is why I know more about it than the Deputy does.

Comment on this

——and if he were paying more attention——

Comment on this

The Deputy is evading the question.

Comment on this

Read all about it in the papers. The sensible thing is not to read about these things but to do something about them before they happen.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

That is what I am trying to preach to Deputy Moore. Is it not a terrible thing that public representatives and people out of public spirit must band themselves together and form voluntary societies to help the mentally handicapped, the disabled and the blind? Is not this part of the society? Is not this the responsibility of the Government? What has the Government done about it? Nothing, but if Deputy Burke were here he would tell us about the Constellations flying from Shannon to New York. These things are good but in my simple ethics I am a solid believer in putting first things first: charity begins at home.

I know people in my own constituency who go hungry one or two days a week, people who must go to bed to keep themselves warm, people who come on bended knees to public representatives and to the county council begging for houses. Is this social justice? I know of one case in County Donegal of a brother and sister. The brother is a handicapped person and the sister cannot go out to work. They have £2 2s. 6d. per week to live on. I wonder what these people think when they read in the newspapers that the Judiciary got £1,500 of an increase on top of a salary of £4,500. If communistic thoughts enter their minds who is to blame, we or they? For the past few years we have heard Ministers repeatedly telling of the different plans they have drafted for their own Departments. I am surprised the Minister for Local Government is not in the House, when we think of all the houses he was to build in 1957. As a member of the housing authority like myself the Chair will know the position as well as I do, as a person in possession of facts which would possibly make darkest Africa blush with shame. We can proudly say in Donegal that we build 32 houses a year and the late County MOH in a report submitted to the local authority based on his findings in an area in North Donegal bluntly told the county council that unless they stepped up their housing programme it would take 250 years to rehouse the people living at present in houses unfit for human habitation.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be embarking on a debate on housing in Donegal.

Comment on this

I am pointing out the reason the houses are not being built.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In a general way, yes, but the Deputy is talking about north Donegal now.

Comment on this

Come now; you are not that much embarrassed.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is not embarrassed at all but just wants to get his colleague back on the rails again.

Comment on this

On a point of order, surely, general statements unsupported by specific evidence such as Deputy Harte now tenders ought to be deplored in this House? Deputy Harte is giving facts, figures and specific cases.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Harte is going into too much detail on the housing question in this debate.

Comment on this

If the county manager says it will take hundreds of years to rehouse people in Donegal, it is relevant to this debate, I submit with respect.

Comment on this

I do not wish to take up the time of the House.

Comment on this

Go on. You are doing great—I never heard you better.

Comment on this

I should like to point out to the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that the economic situation in Donegal and the bad housing situation in Donegal enough to admit it, to the fact that they have no money in the kitty.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

There are contractors in the Leas-Cheann Comhairle's constituency who are the same type of people as those who build houses in my constituency. He is a public representative and people must have gone to him, as they have come to me, asking why the local authority are not advancing money.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle agrees that that is the position.

Comment on this

Hear, hear, and the answer is that they have not got sixpence to rattle on a tombstone, and that is economics.

Comment on this

They did not allocate it properly.

Comment on this

Whatever they did with it, they have not got it. That is economics of the purest kind.

Comment on this

They had plenty of money over the last few years and did not allocate it properly, did not direct it into housing.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon.

Comment on this

There is a situation in Donegal that supplementary grants are, not refused, but not being paid. People have created debts for the purpose of improving their housing conditions because the local authority and the Government were not building sufficient houses. The people were promised State grants and supplementary grants. It was a secret up to a few weeks ago but now the position is that if a member of the council goes into the housing section and asks why there was a delay in the payment of a supplementary grant, he is bluntly told that there is no money in the kitty, that no money has come from Dublin or that certain papers which are required for the payment of the grant have not come through from the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

These are matters that one must think about when Deputy Lemass talks about social justice. A person who is entitled to get a house provided for him by the local authority but who knows that it will take three and a half years, at best, must produce two sureties in order to get an SDA loan. The Minister for Local Government is a representative from Donegal. Donegal is one of the few counties where two sureties must be produced for the purposes of an SDA loan.

Comment on this

Is that right?

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

Scandalous.

Comment on this

It is a scandalous situation. I know I have the support of Deputy Dunne.

Comment on this

Definitely.

Comment on this

The economic situation in Donegal is bad and rumour has it that road works are about to close down. Why? Is it because people in Donegal are not paying enough rates? I do not think so. The rate in Donegal is the third highest in the country. It is simply because the Department of Local Government, the Department of Finance, the Department of Health, the Department of Defence have slowed down the grants which they should have paid to Donegal County Council. Therefore, men must be paid off. In fact, the position is so serious that for the first time on record the county manager made an order last week to tax the motor lorries on credit in the hope that the money would come later from the Department of Local Government.

If this is prosperity, I do not know the meaning of the word. Is this the prosperity which Deputy Corry's Party boasted about? If this is the net result of the policy which Fianna Fáil have dangled in front of the Irish people for the past 35 years, it is time the Taoiseach abolished the Party and forgot about his policies.

Comment on this

Hear, hear:

Comment on this

It is a terrible thing for a young man newly elected to this Parliament to come into the House and listen to all the rosy flowery speeches by Ministers——

Comment on this

And all the nonsense by the Opposition.

Comment on this

At least, it is a contribution. I have yet to listen to the Deputy's.

Comment on this

Hear, hear, and he will not open his beak. There will not be a whimper out of him.

Comment on this

It is hard for him to open it in the situation.

Comment on this

I do not blame him.

Comment on this

Before I was so rudely interrupted by Deputy Dowling, I was saying that it is frustrating for a newly elected member of this House to listen in the House to flowery speeches by Ministers of Government as to the corner, which has been there for the past 20 years, which we are just about to turn, describing the plans for economic progress the Government have in store, while at the same time one remembers the 300,000 people who have emigrated since the Taoiseach made his promise of 100,000 new jobs and that people were killed in this city of Dublin when houses fell on top of them, that people die of starvation and spend their last few days——

Comment on this

Paddy McGilligan said that they died in this country on the side of the road, and they probably will die again, when your people were in power.

Comment on this

This statement is an ancient, hoary falsehood.

Comment on this

Completely untrue.

Comment on this

I will get you the volume.

Comment on this

Go out and get it.

Comment on this

Off you pop; go and get it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is listening to too many of the old men's tales. A young man like him should not be taken in.

Comment on this

It is contagious.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

In conclusion, let me say this——

Comment on this

Give Deputy Dowling time to go and get the quotation— the poor fellow.

Comment on this

Who is making the speech?

Comment on this

It is not Deputy Corry, anyway.

Comment on this

Whenever Deputy Corry gets up to make a speech, there is no one who sits more contented than myself listening to Deputy Corry telling us of the state of the nation.

Comment on this

I hope I am teaching you a little lesson.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that when I sit down, Deputy Corry will get up and I hope he will tell us some of the things he said and which I have read in the Dáil debates leading up to and during the Economic War. It would be most interesting if Deputy Corry were to go back and read some of the things he said then and, having read them, perhaps he might agree that some of the things he is advocating now are the things which he refused to accept during those times. I do not wish to hold up the proceedings of the House.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry is a very fair man. He never speaks well of his own Party.

Comment on this

This I will say in conclusion: The Fianna Fáil Party took a wrong turn in 1932. Despite all the advice given by leaders from this side of the House, they remained steadfastly on that wrong course, which has cost this country millions and millions of pounds. Deputy Corry knows that statement is correct. When Ministers come into this House today and tell us that circumstances are different now, that instead of a policy of isolation, we must now have a policy of free trade, that they saw this position 30 years ago, and when we hear the Taoiseach conclude the debate on the Trade Agreement and modestly say to the House that he was born 20 years before his time, let me say that when in 1932 Deputy Corry was told the arguments put forward by the Taoiseach in 1966, he refused to believe them. When the Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, was told those arguments in 1932, he refused to believe them. When whatever members left in the Fianna Fáil Party who were present in this House during that vital stage of Irish history were told the course that should be taken to keep this country economically sound, they would not take it. It will bluff no one for members of the Fianna Fáil Party to stand up here now and say this is the end-product of a policy initiated by Éamon de Valera as Taoiseach in 1932.

This is a crystal-clear admission on the part of this Government that they were on the wrong course, but they would not listen to rational arguments from this side of the House. We have been told many things, but I am glad I have been a member of this House to see a Fianna Fáil Government freely admit and go on record as saying that the arguments put forward and the stand taken by the leaders of this nation in the 1920s and by the men who led the Opposition in the 1930s were right. All the things those men remained steadfast to have been vindicated by the Agreement which has just been signed. The only thing of which I am convinced is that that Agreement was signed 30 years too late. If it had been signed 30 years sooner, the economy would not be in the state it is in today.

Comment on this

It would be worse.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowling does not even know where the Border is. When we talk about the Border he thinks it is in a sitting-room.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party got a mandate from the people to hold the annuities in this country and use them for the service of the Irish people. They got that mandate in 1932, in 1933, in 1936 and again in 1938, right through the whole period of the Economic War.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

Despite the fact that the people gave that verdict, certain sections led by gentlemen who were the predecessors of Deputy Harte set to work here in an endeavour to force the people to pay that tribute to Britain. Despite the fact that 12 months afterwards, in 1933, Éamon de Valera again invited the verdict of the people and got it, those people still formed themselves into a semi-military mob known as the Blueshirts, came into this House in that uniform endeavouring to smash this Government and advocating the payment of tribute to Britain to which she was not entitled.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should get back to the motion.

Comment on this

I would not have gone so far, were it not for Deputy Harte. Deputy Harte told us about the number of houses built in Donegal. He said that some learned gentleman there stated it would take 250 years to build houses for all the people in that county who are living in houses unfit for human habitation. I have said here on many occasions that the housing position in any local authority area is the responsibility of that local authority. If in 1966 it would take 250 years at the present pace of the Donegal County Council to replace unfit houses——

Comment on this

Hear, Hear—it is a Fianna Fáil-controlled council.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte has served some time as a member of a local authority. How many houses did he propose to build, say, in 1955-56 or at any time during the past ten years?

Comment on this

Three times as many as Fianna Fáil did.

Comment on this

Why were they not built?

Comment on this

They were built.

Comment on this

If they were and if at the present speed of house building in County Donegal, it will take 250 more years to build houses for those who are living in unfit dwellings, what was that local authority doing?

Comment on this

It is being handled by the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Harte restrain himself?

Comment on this

It is very difficult.

Comment on this

It is a Fianna Fáil-controlled county council.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte made a statement here and I am proving its falseness. In Cork, in the area that was taken away from us, we gave supplementary grants amounting to over £600,000 in four years, and in those four years we lent £4 million to people building the houses.

Comment on this

You did not lend it to them.

Comment on this

What were Deputy Harte's people doing with their 32 houses a year in Donegal? Fianna Fáil policy obtains in the Cork County Council as well as up in Donegal.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil do not control Cork County Council. Donegal County Council is controlled by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputies allow Deputy Corry to make his speech?

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Deputy Harte when he was speaking because he was entitled to make his statement. I am now giving the facts as I see them, and I am referring to the facts as Deputy Harte put them before me, the Economic War and the houses. I have dealt with both matters.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil have ruined the country.

Comment on this

Our job was to build up this country not alone agriculturally but industrially as well.

Comment on this

They have done neither.

Comment on this

Within the past 12 months Deputy Harte and his friends over there did their best to wreck an industry that at the moment is giving employment to 1,100 men, that is, Rushbrooke dockyard. One of the gentlemen who now sits on that front bench, Deputy Fitzpatrick, based his election address on it and went before the people in Cavan stating: "If we are elected, we will do away with uneconomic industries of that kind."

Comment on this

That is completely untrue.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said he would do away with uneconomic industries.

Comment on this

I can produce in this House for the benefit of the Deputy and for the record Deputy Fitzpatrick's election address.

Comment on this

It does not state what the Deputy said.

Comment on this

I could produce it here.

Comment on this

The Deputy should have it with him.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said he would do away with uneconomic factories.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputies allow Deputy Corry to make his speech?

Comment on this

When I was speaking here last, I suggested to the Deputy that he was on the wrong side of the Border, and I think he proved that tonight.

Comment on this

Was the Deputy ever across the Border?

Comment on this

He was in Belfast Jail in 1918.

Comment on this

I made two trips across the Border, on both occasions with a pair of bracelets on my hands going to Crumlin Road Jail, if the Deputy knows where it is, and I smashed up their jail before I left it. I hate hearing the kind of stuff being dished up here by Deputy Harte. Either they believe in democracy or they do not. If a Government get a mandate to do a certain thing and they do it, what right has any section of the Opposition practically to go out in armed resistance to that Government? That is what they have done. They got their answer, though, on every occasion they went to the people afterwards.

Comment on this

The Deputy is confusing the Parties.

Comment on this

He is preaching Cumann na nGaedheal policy.

Comment on this

Our job here is to try to find out as well as we can how to remedy the present economic position. As I said before, our job in 1932 was to build up industries to give employment to our people and keep them at home.

Comment on this

Why did you not do it?

Comment on this

Shut up; if you have not got manners, get out. When we took over, in Haulbowline there was employment for a fortnight each year for seven men. Their job was to pick out certain parts of machinery left there by the British and get them ready for a scrap auction. That was the extent of employment in that town when we took over. All the young men in the town had to travel. Today, even with the slack, there are more than 600 employed in Irish Steel, and within a mile, in the Rushbrooke dockyard, which Deputies over there tried to wreck, we have 1,100 men employed. They were so sure they had wrecked it that Deputy Fitzpatrick prepared an election address on it for the people of Cavan.

Comment on this

Produce the election address.

Comment on this

He thought he was far enough away. I shall have it for the Deputy tomorrow, if the Leas-Cheann Comhairle will give me an opportunity of reading it. I hope it will shut them up. When we took over, there were three days' work each week for 20 men in the town of Midleton. Today in that town you cannot find a man idle—not one.

Comment on this

They are all in Birmingham.

Comment on this

Send us down some of your Donegal buckos and we will teach them how to work.

Comment on this

They are all in Birmingham.

Comment on this

Right through my constituency the same conditions prevail. During the couple of times when there was a change of Government, those people did their damnedest to wreck the industries there. If they want an example, there is a man in Dublin today who has started a fine industry. They drove him from Haulbowline when they were last in office. That is one side of the picture. There is another side about which I have been concerned for some time. I hope to make it sink in on this occasion. The people in charge of subsidising industry have been handing out money to foreign countries. I have asked questions about it but could not get answers to them. I did poke out that the Government and the country, in their wisdom, laid out some millions of pounds to start Irish Shipping Limited. Last year we took over the B & I. Altogether we have 26 ships. We have a dockyard at Rushbrooke capable of giving employment to 1,100 men and another on the Liffey capable of giving considerable employment also. Most of the ships we own derive their trade from this country. The "Innisfallen", for instance, trades into Cork three days a week and the "Munster" and the "Leinster" trade into Dublin daily. Surely, since these companies are deriving their trade from this country, they should give work on these ships to Irish dockyards.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The "Innisfallen" went to Dumbarton in Scotland, which never gave it a pennypiece worth of trade, and the "Munster" and "Leinster" went up to Harland and Wolffs in Belfast, Deputy Harte's pals. I found on investigation that 23 of the 26 ships, the property of this Government, of this country, went to foreign countries for their annual overhaul. They took out of this country in that way between £200,000 and £300,000. They are bitter facts to which we must face up. Like it or not, they are things we must remedy.

Comment on this

Very embarrassing for the Government.

Comment on this

Mention it to the Minister for Transport and Power. He will solve it.

Comment on this

Will you shut up sometime? If the Deputy will try to go to school he will get a few lessons. I shall send him across a few infant books if he is short.

Comment on this

What school does the Deputy go to?

Comment on this

While the "Innisfallen" is in Dumbarton in Scotland having her annual overhaul, the company must pay £1,000 a day for five weeks to hire a ship to take her place. Apparently we have loads of money.

Comment on this

Surely this is for a Fianna Fáil Party meeting and not for the Dáil?

Comment on this

Those are the facts. If all the little dwarfs over there would shut up, we might get somewhere.

Comment on this

Now, hangman, keep quiet.

Comment on this

It is an awful pity that some hangman did not get the Deputy.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think Deputy Corry should be allowed to make his contribution.

Comment on this

Such a contribution.

Comment on this

Some lawyers come in here to make a livelihood when they cannot make it outside.

Comment on this

The Deputy could not make one outside, that is certain.

Comment on this

There is one thing Deputy Sweetman says. That is only one part of the story. I want to see that money kept in this country to help to straighten out our balance of payments.

Comment on this

Why can the Deputy not tell it to his own Minister?

Comment on this

Ah, shut up, you idiot.

Comment on this

That is most unparliamentary, is it not?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not address a Member of the House in that fashion. He must withdraw that expression.

Comment on this

I withdraw it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would ask Deputies to refrain from interrupting Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

I withdraw it, but I think the same anyway.

Comment on this

The Deputy found himself in the wrong.

Comment on this

The next thing I want to deal with is the position where a State firm in my constituency has to lay off men, whilst at the very time that is happening another State-subsidised company is using that State subsidy paid by the taxpayers in this country to bring in foreign iron and steel. I think that is a scandal.

Comment on this

So do I.

Comment on this

It is nothing less than a scandal to have that condition of affairs here today. Surely we did not get a present of that iron and steel from Britain.

Comment on this

Is this free trade?

Comment on this

It had to be paid for. It has gone in against our balance of trade. If I were to continue on that line, I could straighten out a lot of our adverse trade balance altogether. Is there any justification for this? I remember Deputy Sweetman coming in here one time and he thought he could straighten out the adverse balance of trade by putting a tariff on ladies' curling pins. You know what they are.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not know much about them, that is certain.

Comment on this

The Deputy's Minister put a tariff on icecream cones.

Comment on this

He thought of curling pins. However, those are matters, to my mind, for which there is no justification. Is there anyone here who can justify, or who thinks he can justify, the importation into this country during the past 12 months of musical instruments costing over £1 million?

Comment on this

I knew the Deputy would come back to that. The Deputy has to have something to play on.

Comment on this

That money left this country and that is portion of our adverse trade balance.

Comment on this

Somebody has to make up for the Garda Band.

Comment on this

There is no justification for that. You could stop an old banjo when you could not catch them with curling pins.

Comment on this

Not a banjo band.

Comment on this

Those are only some of the things that are in my opinion causing a lot of disturbance. Over £3 million worth of printed matter came into this country during the past 12 months. Where did that come from?

Comment on this

Free trade.

Comment on this

There was no free trade when that was here.

Comment on this

They do not make musical instruments here.

Comment on this

Those people are bringing in printed matter and if they can bring in foreign iron and steel under present conditions without free trade, where do we find ourselves? I compare the position with the position of the ordinary farmer and the ordinary agricultural community. If I go to build a haybarn and I put one sheet of British corrugated iron on to that barn, I lose my £60 grant straight away, but my money and the farmers' money which goes to subsidise CIE is used to purchase foreign iron and brought in here.

Comment on this

And bus scrolls.

Comment on this

There is no justification for it. I suggest that £2 million subsidy which CIE is getting is something which could be practically wiped out. There is no justification today for handing over the whole road freight of this country to a monopoly. There is no justification whatever for that. I want to say one other thing on that. The agricultural community are not prepared to take those people on their backs. That is what they are doing.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy talking about?

Comment on this

Last July we had occasion to invite tenders for the removal of some 3,500 tons of farm produce within a six mile radius into a little factory we had.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see how the Deputy can relevantly discuss the administration of CIE on this particular motion.

Comment on this

It is not exactly relevant but——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not seem to arise.

Comment on this

It arises because we are losing £2 million. It arises because of the fact that the difference between the CIE tender and the tenders of the local hauliers was 25 per cent.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

Surely this is a time when we could find very good use for the £6¼ million that we paid under the 1956 Agreement for permission to send our sugar to Britain?

Comment on this

I knew the Deputy would come to that.

Comment on this

This is a time when we could find room to build all the houses which Deputy Harte wants. We paid roughly £1,200,000 a year for permission to export our sugar to Britain.

Comment on this

What about your butter?

Comment on this

You were given that free with a 1/6 postal order wrapped around it.

Comment on this

We paid that, and Deputy Sweetman sat silent here, and we did not hear anything about that agreement. Poor Jim Dillon knew nothing about it.

Comment on this