Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 12: General (Resumed).
Contributions 172–392 of 392. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Some time ago I was speaking in the House in connection with employment and referred to the fact we were concerned that statistics had proved that the employment situation had worsened to some degree. When we came back to power in 1957, after you had run away from your responsibilities, there were 100,000 unemployed. You were not concerned about them or about the 70,000 emigrating. You were not concerned about the unfortunate people employed in Collinstown and Shannon in 1948 when the hatchet fell on the transatlantic air service. If we go back far enough, we were told by Deputy McGilligan that it is not the duty of the Government to provide work for the people.
Comment on this
He never said that. It is entirely out of its context. He gave the money to the local authorities and said it was their duty.
Comment on this
I have it here— volume 9, column 563, Deputy P. McGilligan:
If it is said that the Government has failed to adopt effective means to find useful work for willing workers, I can only answer that it is no function of the Government to provide work for anybody.
Comment on this
Earlier in the debate, at column 562 of the same volume, he said:
There are certain limited funds at our disposal. People may have to die in this country and may have to die from starvation.
Comment on this
"Neither the Deputy nor I stand for that"—go on, finish it. If he does not, we shall have to accuse the Deputy of prevarication.
Comment on this
I know what is in it. I must describe the Deputy as a prevaricator, which is better than the four-letter word, but means the same thing.
Comment on this
That indicates the pattern that had been set at that stage, when they said it was not the function of the Government to find work for willing workers. In 1948, they sent workers packing from Collinstown and Shannon and in 1956, we had 100,000 unemployed.
Comment on this
The only time we ever had over 100,000 unemployed was from 1934 to 1945 when Fianna Fáil were in power. At one stage there were 156,000 unemployed.
Comment on this
This Labour Deputy said:
Drastic as this devaluation of the pound is, it is one way of answering our problems.
I do not know whether that is the policy of the Labour Party or whether they have other policies. Many solutions to our economic problems have been indicated here but nothing done about it.
Comment on this
I saw you over there on one occasion with little cuttings out of the papers and Dáil debates.
Comment on this
A favourite one with the other side of the House has been the cutting of the calves' throats.
Comment on this
The Deputy quoted somebody. He did not give the name, nor did he give the volume or column number.
Comment on this
It is not the only thing you will have to learn from them before you become a useful Deputy.
Comment on this
I want to refer again to 1948. When you went out of office, you had a few torpedo boats left over from the war. After you had torpedoed the nation's finances and industry, you even sold the torpedo boats. One can never forgive the national sabotage of 1948. How they trapped the Labour Party into it is beyond me—to say they sold out the workers of this country. You are an honest man no doubt, and so is Deputy Jim Tully. He is a friend of mine. I do not know whether he was here at that stage. Never again allow yourselves to be trapped by the people who feel it is not the duty of the Government to find work for the people. I was working in Aer Lingus in 1948 when the hatchet fell. The same man was in command, Deputy McGilligan, in the Department of Finance. He was in command in Industry and Commerce in the other period. It was quite evident that the same trend of mind would be followed right through that period. However, you have learned something since then. You now agree with industrial development. Equipment in the chassis factory in Inchicore was sold out of containers before it was ever used, the most elaborate and up-to-date machinery that could be procured anywhere in Europe to start a heavy engineering industry.
Comment on this
The poor builders have plenty of machinery and cannot sell it. They have no work to do.
Comment on this
Deputies might get a great surprise in Potez. Many of them may be looking for jobs there yet.
Comment on this
Would Deputies please allow Deputy Dowling to make his speech? This is most disorderly.
Comment on this
In the 1965 Progress Report on the Second Programme for Economic Expansion there is reference to the position of air companies for 1964-65. Aerlínte made an operating profit of £1,181,000 compared with £799,000 in 1963-64. The number of passengers carried increased by 44 per cent, compared with 11 per cent the previous year. As I indicated earlier on, there is provision in this year's Budget for the expansion of airports and the other essential services that go with airports.
Deputy Larkin wanted to know what I had mentioned about local authority housing. Expenditure on local authority housing for 1966-67 is provisionally estimated at £11 million.
Comment on this
December, 1956, the year in which the Opposition ran away from their responsibilities when they were in government.
Comment on this
Look at last year's White Paper on housing to see what Fianna Fail did in the past few years.
Comment on this
Let Deputies listen to this:
The picture facing us in Dublin this year is not too pleasant. The number of houses completed in the period from 1st April to 31st October last year was 644: this year the number was 449. The number of men employed on housing, housing development work and allied occupations in Dublin city last year was 2,199: this year the number is 1,854. Bear in mind also the fact that last year's figures represented a 50 per cent reduction on the employment in 1951.
At column 2053 of the same volume, Deputy Denis Larkin said:
I will be fair. I am sure the Lord Mayor and every other Deputy here wants to be fair, too. Our officials also submitted an estimate showing in what way the corporation should confine itself to the total expenditure of £4,000,000 next year. The first step required the cutting of the new contracts for the Finglas area. That has been approved by the Minister, but now we will have to tell the contractor: "Sorry, we cannot continue with this contract now." That involved a reduction of £61,000 in the estimate. The next item was in reference to the direct housing scheme for the Finglas area. The scheme was not to be proceeded with either. It was also suggested that there should be a gradual diminution in employment on direct housing schemes and a gradual laying-off of the workers concerned. The next suggestion was that the Corporation would delay the giving out of other schemes or proceeding with them...
Those were the terrible conditions prevailing during that period.
Comment on this
There were 100,000 unemployed then and 70,000 people emigrating because they were being laid off. I am very glad to have the opportunity of supporting any proposal that makes it possible for us to have better housing——
Comment on this
——to increase tourism, to develop the Shannon Free Airport Development Company and all the other schemes contained in this Budget.
Comment on this
There is a great deal more I should like to say, but I wish to give other Deputies an opportunity of speaking. I hope Deputies opposite will not distort the situation but will present the situation factually, knowing that they ran away from their responsibilities, knowing they made no provision for social welfare benefits. Small as they may be, there was no provision at all when they were in office.
Comment on this
I was not over-anxious to intervene in this debate at this particular juncture, but, having listened to Deputy Dowling, I must say I have never known such an exhibition of hard neck as that displayed by the Deputy in the rosy picture he tried to paint to illustrate the position of this country at the moment. I should like to congratulate him on his courage and his audacity in standing up here and seeking to defend a Government who are patently bankrupt and have brought this country to the very brink of economic disaster. The audacity of any Deputy in the Government Party casting aspersions on members of the Labour Party, himself a worker, is almost incredible. It is shameful that he should fail to realise that this country is in a worse position now than at any time since the foundation of the State in 1922.
Deputy Dowling used a great many official statistics and quoted from many booklets, seeking to show that we were attaining all the targets set in the programmes for economic expansion. We were realising, according to the Deputy, all the promises the Government had made. The facts are, of course, quite the contrary. Our growth rate in this year is down to a little over two per cent as against the target of 4½ per cent set in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion. Deputy Dowling alleged that he was concerned about the workers. Does he not realise there are fewer people employed today than ever before? The employment figures are down to 1,050,000, the lowest figure ever recorded.
Comment on this
No less than 44,000 jobs seem to have disappeared and there are 10,000 fewer people employed today than there were in 1963.
Comment on this
Let him do his own homework. These figures are very carefully compiled. The Deputy need not worry. Deputy Dowling sought to imply that everything is lovely and that the Government have achieved certain things. Anyone who looks around the country must realise despair and frustration deep in the hearts and minds of the people. Even the most ardent Fianna Fáil supporters are shocked and dismayed because of the sorry mess into which their leadership has led the country. The Fianna Fáil Party have led this country for a considerable number of years, first under the President, Mr. de Valera, and now under the Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass. These were regarded as virtually infallible, as men who could not make a mistake. It has shocked the most diehard Fianna Fáil supporters to realise that in 1966 the country is in this sorry predicament.
Comment on this
There is a yawning gap in our balance of payments and there is nothing in this Budget to relieve that situation, a situation in which there is a steady outflow of capital from the country, resulting in an acute credit squeeze affecting all services, and especially essential services. The audacity of Government speakers to pretend that all is well! It is an insult to the intelligence of the people. We all know things could not be worse. We are concerned that there is nothing in this Budget to indicate what steps the Government intend to take to get us out of the economic chaos. How long will this situation last? Will it improve? Can Government spokesmen tell us when we shall see an improvement and an acceleration in industrial and agricultural output, when we shall see a sufficiency of money to carry on essential services, such as health, education, housing, social welfare and all the others? Will the situation become progressively worse?
Comment on this
Talking about halfcrowns, this Budget has been referred to by leader writers as a vicious Budget, a Budget which takes all and gives nothing. On the day on which this Budget was introduced, there was a bannerline in the Evening Press, indicating that there was a 5/- increase for all social welfare recipients. Those of us who sat in this House and listened to the Minister's speech realised only too well that a means test applied to this pittance of 5/-. In the Budget of 1965 the means test was one of £26 a year, or roughly 10/- per week. Those who had 10/- per week did not get the 5/- increase in the Budget of 1965. On this occasion the Evening Press, the Pravda of the Government Party, implied that all would get the 5/-increase. The truth is, of course, that only those who are destitute will get this 5/- increase. That is a hideous insult to the old, the sick, the infirm and the unemployed. It is despicable that none but those who are destitute will get this increase. It is an indictment of this Government. It makes a mockery of the suffering of these unfortunate people who are only barely able to exist, the aged, the widowed, the unemployed who, as a result of excessive taxation and the high cost of living, have been forced down to a substandard of existence; and to talk about 5/- in the one instance and make capital out of this in the context of this Budget and then in the small print to say this applies only to those with no means, is surely one of the most despicable political tricks ever perpetrated by any Government on this House.
Even the most ardent supporter of this régime will not deny that things are very bad with the economy. I have already adverted to the acute shortage of money for all essential purposes. This has had terrible consequences. It has had the effect of holding up the re-housing of our people, countless thousands of whom are living in condemned hovels, rat-infested tenement flats. There is no hope now that any money will be made available to meet our commitments in regard to the rehousing of these people. In the history of the State, money has not been so scarce. The situation is a serious indictment of this régime who allowed the situation to arise.
Having allowed it to arise, they resorted to borrowing money abroad. First of all, there was the abortive attempt in America, and then, to our shame, the negotiation of a loan with the Germans at an extortionate rate of interest. I have heard Opposition spokesmen say that the appropriate symbol for the present Government is the pawnbroker's balls. I fully concur in these sentiments. This is an administration who went to the pawnbrokers and whose pledges have not been redeemed. Any pledges that have been redeemed have been at extortionate rates of interest.
There are so many aspects of this Budget that it is difficult to know where to start. One aspect with which I am particularly concerned as a member of a local authority is the 25 per cent increase in motor taxation. That was bad enough, but on top of it the Irish motorist also has to pay an increased price for his petrol. Up to now, all revenue garnered from road tax was channelled into the Road Fund and that fund, as we all know, was devoted to the maintenance of the roads. On this occasion I understand that the 25 per cent extra revenue will be diverted to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
This is looting the Road Fund. If it happened under another Government at least that Government had the honesty and decency to come to the House and say to this Parliament that they were doing this for a specific purpose. Now the Road Fund is being rifled, a precedent has been created and the local authorities' revenue in future will mean less money for main and county roads. An amazing feature of this Budget is that it came to the House two months before its usual time and according to the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance, we may have another Budget in the autumn. The mismanagement of the financial affairs of the country has been clearly instanced on this occasion. Obviously, the Budget of 1965 lasted only ten months and the Budget of 1966, we are told, will last only about nine months. Was there ever an example of such mismanagement of the financial affairs of our country?
The occasion of the Budget, one would expect, is a time of assessment in regard to the economy and the trend of things to come. This Budget does nothing more than maintain things as they were, uphold the status quo. There are no indications whatsoever of an upsurge of economic growth, of increased employment, of a stemming of emigration, of adequate control of prices, of any of these desirable things. The Budget is not merely holding things as they were: it is now largely understood that there will be another Budget in the autumn. The design of the Government Party in this issue is now well known. They have squandered the resources of the country, wasted the precious years of unity and independence. There can be no excuse for them. They have been in power during 28 of the 36 or 37 years during which we have had native Government. Twenty-eight years in Government is a fair innings for any Party. Outside of the dictatorships in Russia, in North-east Ulster and possibly in Spain and Portugal, it cannot be matched. Very few Governments anywhere have been afforded such an opportunity to control the destinies of their peoples.
With the exception of a few short years of Coalition Government, Fianna Fáil have been in absolute power in this country. Time and time again in general elections the people placed full confidence in them and on many occasions gave them overwhelming majorities to govern and to implement their policies and programmes and to rectify the social and economic ills of the country. Since our early teens, since we came to the use of reason, we remembered their slogans and promises. We remember their promises of full employment. We remember the leadership of this Party stating time and time again that the acid test of good government was full employment. Full employment was the keynote of the social philosophy of this Government Party.
In the First Programme for Economic Expansion, again full employment came to the forefront and they told the people of this country they would provide 100,000 jobs. The people believed it and gave them the votes and the support to implement that policy. In that five year period, what transpired? Instead of the 100,000 jobs being realised 270,000 people were forced to emigrate. It is difficult to conjure up the mass exodus of human beings involved in that figure: the flower of our youth, our boys and girls, in those five years of that glorious First Programme for Economic Expansion, were forced, scourged out, to the four winds of the world. At the same time, we have had this chronic problem of unemployment at home standing at 50,000, 60,000 or 70,000 persons. Despite the exodus from the countryside and from the cities into the world at large, we still cannot maintain employment at home.
Nobody now would have the audacity to suggest that the Second Programme for Economic Expansion has any hope of success. It is nothing but a pious hope, economic guesswork, incapable of fruition. The facts are that in respect of these programmes for economic expansion, the Government failed to take the effective measures to make them realities and realise the things they said could be done in them. Without taking the necessary measures to see to it that the targets set in these programmes are attained, it is simply hoping for economic salvation in this country. In the light of this Budget and in the light of the situation in which we now find ourselves, let there be no more talk of programmes. I do not know who are the economic advisers to this Government but, whoever they are, they have a lot to answer for. Is it possible that this trend of events could not have been foreseen a few years ago? Is it possible that nobody saw the signs of this economic deterioration setting in——
Comment on this
——until after the general election of 1965? It is difficult to understand that just 12 months ago we were fighting a general election. We well remember the slogans and the promises and pledges of this Government Party. There was no sign or indication of any kind in the long statements, manifestoes or speeches uttered by leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party, that there was anything fundamentally wrong at all with our economy; everything in the garden was lovely and all that required to be done was to put them back in power, when, of course, they would give us the jobs, the prosperity, the security and the happiness which were just around the corner.
It shocked and appalled the people that a few months afterwards, in the summer of last year, this sorry trend of events revealed itself. Is it possible that for mere political gain this Government could, and in fact did, conceal the true state of affairs from the people? We know promises are made and political gimmicks are adopted in winning by-elections, and the two by-elections—one in Cork and another in Kildare—were the most costly by-elections this country ever had to contend with because the price this Government Party paid for them was a price the people of Ireland will pay for a long number of years to come. We are concerned at the kind of deceit perpetrated on the Irish people in concealing from them the true state of affairs with regard to our economy.
I have heard Government spokesmen give various explanations as to what is wrong with this country at the present time. The Government are obviously desperate to find some kind of scapegoat on which to hang the responsibility for the present situation. They are turning desperately around and they seem to have found one. The scapegoat would seem to be the Irish trade union movement, the workers of this country.
Comment on this
That is utterly untrue. We here on this side of the House represent the trade union movement just as much as you people.
Comment on this
The Government are desperately turning round and seeking to hang the responsibility and the blame on some section of the community and it would now seem that the workers are the culprits.
Comment on this
It is my submission that a deliberate attempt is being made in this House and in the country to malign and misrepresent the trade union leaders and the working classes in respect of the present situation.
Comment on this
Every dissension, strike or lock-out which heretofore would get little publicity, is amplified in the press, on radio and TV. The situation is being grotesquely exaggerated in many instances.
Comment on this
We now have a situation in which Ministers of State are deliberately provoking the unions concerned. There is the instance of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs provoking the Post Office Workers Engineering Union to precipitate them into taking strike action. We have a situation where a responsible general secretary of a union is not allowed to negotiate on behalf of his people in the office of the Ministry of Posts and Telegraphs and is told to keep out. We have a situation in which people are deliberately locked out. People are dismissed on the flimsiest grounds. We wonder if it is the policy of this Government, or of some of its Ministers at least, to provoke the unions into taking action. I marvel at the restraint and the responsibility which the trade union movement is showing under present circumstances. In my opinion, this Government were responsible for the breakdown of the national agreement of some months ago. They took a lot of credit for the ninth round, in respect of the 12 per cent, and won votes from gullible workers on that account.
Comment on this
On this occasion, by reason of the bad state of the country, the Government have had the audacity to intervene and to talk to the Irish trade union movement and to the workers of this country in the context of three per cent—three per cent— which was a terrible insult at a time when we all knew that the cost of living had gone out of all proportion.
This Government have acted too late in respect of price control. The greater percentage of the twelfth round was dissipated by reason of increased prices and I regret to have to say that prices are still rising. We remember reading, a few nights ago, in the evening paper of a colossal increase in the price of meat which is becoming the luxury of the rich in this country. However, this mention of three per cent was disastrous in circumstances where the unions were negotiating our national agreement with employers.
The Government have always looked for a headline. The Labour Court are influenced by Government indicators and, so, likewise, are employers. This Government are responsible for the industrial unrest which is rife at the present time in this country by their opposition to a reasonable increase and the maintenance of decent living standards for our people.
Let there be no question about it: the Irish trade union movement will not be intimidated. The inference that insidious forces are at work is, of course, completely false and utterly unfounded. The industrial unrest at present which is bringing about ugly strikes and lock-outs and which is causing human hardship is a spontaneous reaction of Irish workers against an attack on their living standards by oppressive government. The Irish working classes, come what may, will maintain their living standards and take all necessary steps to improve them in accordance with the productivity and the wealth of this country.
I am concerned that, in order to bring this issue still further, the Taoiseach now talks of amending the Constitution. We wonder why the Taoiseach is now considering the amendment of the Constitution——
Comment on this
——which enshrines the fundamental rights of every man and woman in this country. It is a document which has been approved and applauded throughout the world as a model for any democracy. What has gone wrong now? Does the Taoiseach wish to filch from our people, or sections of our people, certain fundamental rights contained in that Constitution?
Comment on this
The American Constitution has also been amended. The Irish Constitution was introduced in 1937, almost 30 years ago. There is a difficult situation now and the Taoiseach's speech was very reasonable.
Comment on this
Is that why he was calling out for legislation for the unions? There is a growing momentum to invoke the Constitution to curb certain societies.
Comment on this
Very true. However, the right of free association is enshrined in that Constitution. It is sacred to our people. Heaven forbid that any Government would have the temerity or the audacity to interfere with it. Fianna Fáil sought to amend the Constitution some few years ago when they could see that they were being thrown out of office, when they were losing caste with the people. They wanted to rivet themselves to power in the country.
Comment on this
The Irish people are a freedom-loving people. They knew that if Fianna Fáil succeeded in abolishing proportional representation and substituted the straight vote system they would be riveted to power for an indefinite period of time and would become power drunk and, as we all know, power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Our people are wise in this respect. We shall carefully watch the actions of the Taoiseach in respect of these proposals to interfere with our Constitution. Obviously, the amendment of the Constitution is for ulterior, selfish, political motives solely. The Taoiseach is not concerned about the welfare of the Irish people, but about the welfare —and well he might be concerned about it—of his crumbling Party.
I have said that Government indicators very largely determine the kind of peace, progress and harmony we have in industry in this country. In 1964, we negotiated the ninth round. It was negotiated in an atmosphere of cooperation and cordiality. The workers were not responsible for what followed. We now have a situation in which the Government have set their faces against just and fair demands which are being made by Irish workers. They are opposed to anything like a fair increase in wages—the criterion used is three per cent and no increase whatsoever for any of those workers whose salary exceeds £1,200 a year.
I understand that a Deputy in the Government Party, only this very evening, expounded his theory—and I am sure it is well-founded within his Party, as well—that he is opposed to any of these fringe benefits which are so important to our working classes, the fringe benefits of pension schemes, sickness benefit, extra holidays and, of course, the important matter of a reduced working week. He was deliberately opposed to any reduction in working hours. In all progressive countries where Governments are concerned about the attainment of human happiness for their people, there goes with that ambition not merely the attainment of high standards of life and respect for cultural values but also a desire for more leisure time. That is an aim with all progressive people.
The days of slavery and drudgery are over and our people have a right to reasonable leisure time, and to enjoy the good life, the full life, the rich and abundant life we should like to give them. It is a bit too late for Fianna Fáil to attempt to put the clock back and seek to exploit the workers by resisting reasonable demands in respect of wages and conditions of employment. At a time when progressive countries are seeking a 20 or 30 hour week, we are conforming very largely to a 40 or 42½ hour week. Is it suggested that we should remain in that position in this atomic age, at a time when other countries, comparable with Ireland, by reason of the scientific knowledge available, are reaching full employment, high living standards, the best social welfare services, equal opportunities in education, free health services and other such facilities?
It is truly a wonder of wonders that, close as we are to the flourishing economy of Britain under a Labour Government, with full employment and a welfare State which is the glory of Europe, we should not have risen above the archaic, outmoded and sometimes slavish and depressed conditions which we have tolerated in this country for too long. Deputy Andrews is very anxious about the Constitution. I see that his lawyer's mind is activated. He is concerned as to how he can place the trade union movement in some form of strait-jacket.
Comment on this
He would like, perhaps, to give legal powers to the Labour Court, and to turn the Labour Court into a political junta to be used for and at the behest of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
If that happens, industrial peace will be at an end for a considerable time. We will never agree to the democratic institutions of this country being turned into political juntas for the maintenance in power of any particular clique.
Comment on this
There is nothing whatsoever in this Budget to deal with the immediate problems of our people, and in respect of legislation long anticipated and much talked about by Government spokesmen, there is nothing whatsoever to indicate that money is being made available to implement the necessary and desirable legislation in this session.
I refer in particular to the desirability of implementing the manpower policy which has been talked about so glibly by many Government spokesmen for some time past. In this country, scourged by unemployment, and with a constant and recurring problem of redundancy, not to mention emigration, there is a dire need for a manpower policy. That is self-evident. It is the unanimous conclusion of the Committee of the National Industrial and Economic Council which has studied this matter for some considerable time past.
The Labour Party welcome a manpower policy. We have always advocated it. We urge the Government to bring this legislation forward at the earliest possible moment, but the only legislation we have been promised in respect of this manpower policy is a training scheme for workers, and the other desirable features of the policy are being shelved, it would seem, for some time. This important subject of redundancy payments for workers is a result of new techniques and methods, and adaptation measures being imposed or recommended by Government agencies and large numbers of workers are becoming redundant virtually every day.
By reason of the agreement now entered into with Britain in respect of the Common Market, and having particular regard to the reports of the Committee on Industrial Organisation, this House and the country should know that we will have a serious redundancy problem to contend with. Why is there the delay in respect of the implementation of this manpower policy and as regards the measure which would seem to be near fruition and may very well appear in the form of a Bill in this House very soon? A training scheme for workers is a very laudable thing in itself, because a manpower policy, let it be clearly understood, can best be implemented, and secure the best results, in an abounding economy of full employment, but we question the urgency of the training scheme for workers at the present time.
A training scheme for what? For what kind of employment, at a time when we have a surplus of labour constantly on the market, approximating 60,000 persons at the present time who are obviously out searching for work every day. Where are the opportunities? Where are the jobs for which we propose to train these people?
Comment on this
I should be glad to learn where they are and what proposals the Government have for implementing this kind of policy. I do not want to delve too deeply into this manpower policy at this juncture. We shall have a further opportunity on another debate to go into the matter in greater detail, but I want to make this point. It is not sufficient to have a manpower policy controlled by a Parliamentary Secretary only, and with the responsibility divided between two Departments, the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Social Welfare. We have not much hope of success from this haphazard approach to a manpower policy.
We in the Labour Party have always urged the Government to give us a distinct ministry to implement this manpower policy, a Ministry of Labour. Surely, with such vast resources untapped in the land and in the seas about our island homes, and with such a vast reservoir of labour to utilise, this Government should long before now have established a Ministry of Labour, whose sole function it would be to organise the economy of our country and develop it to provide the maximum employment. Is it not most appropriate in this year, the fiftieth anniversary of the Rising, that we should emulate the decision made by the First Republican Government in this country, the Provisional Government of the Young Republic, who thought fitting then 50 years ago to designate the great Countess Markievitz to be Minister for Labour? Would it not be a fitting tribute to her and to those with whom she fought, and particularly to the women and the workers of this country, to establish a Ministry of Labour which would re-dedicate itself to the principles of Markievitz and Connolly, seek to implement their philosophy in our time and seek to implement those words set out on the Proclamation: "Cherishing all the children of the nation equally and guaranteeing all equal rights and equal opportunities".
I shall not detain the House any longer. I was slow to intervene in this debate. I would not have done so, were it not for the provocative remarks made by other Deputies who sought to infer there was nothing fundamentally wrong with our economy. They seek to convince our people that their Party, and their Party alone, are the only Party capable of doing anything worthwhile for our people. Everyone now knows, certainly anyone with any commonsense realises, that it will take great, brave and courageous men to lift this country of ours and its people out of the rut, out of the gloom and despondency which surround it on every side today, put it permanently on the high road to prosperity and bring about the happy situation of the island of happy homes to which I know we all aspire.
Comment on this
At the beginning of this debate, there were very many remarks made by the members of the Opposition Party, especially the Fine Gael Deputies, that Deputies on this side of the House did not wish to speak in this Budget debate.
Comment on this
They tried to give the impression that there was nothing good we could say about this Budget: we were sitting here without contributing. I would like it to be put on record now that Fine Gael have run dry. The debate has gone from Fianna Fáil to Labour and back to Fianna Fáil. None of the Fine Gael Deputies has contributed.
Comment on this
That is because the Leas-Cheann Comhairle did not call them. Several of our Deputies offered but they were not called. They are still here. There are at least six of them if you want them.
Comment on this
Increased taxation is not the kind of thing that evokes spontaneous joy. It is a recognised means whereby responsible Governments throughout the world can ensure that the wealth, which they help to create, can be collected and used in a manner which will benefit all the people in the country, especially the more needy section of the community. Nobody likes paying taxes at any time, even though one knows one will benefit by them in the long run. Fianna Fáil were never afraid to tell the Irish people, in order to achieve the progress everybody desires, there was an obligation on everybody to contribute, according to his means, to the achieving of those desired ends.
Comment on this
If the Opposition Deputies object to the services on which this Fianna Fáil Government propose spending the taxpayers' money then let them be specific and state the services to which they object. At this stage, which I think is the seventh day of this debate, the only objection we have heard is to the taxes themselves. When the Opposition Deputies placed themselves for election before the people 12 months ago, did they tell the people they were going to be so irresponsible? Did they feel, when they made themselves candidates, they were not going to be honest in their dealings?
Comment on this
The only Opposition Deputy, to my knowledge, who publicly stated he was going to act irresponsibly is Deputy Oliver Flanagan. He is the only honest man among you.
Comment on this
To show you how honest he is, he told them that if Fine Gael were elected to government, nobody would get jobs but their own supporters.
Comment on this
That is the kind of thing you like to put out to the people, trying to deceive them. I can tell you that what I say is right. I am speaking with inside knowledge.
Comment on this
If Deputies want to hear what we have to say, then let the ten or 11 of them who are here listen to what I have to say. This Budget has been called everything by them from the hairshirt Budget to what that Deputy from North Mayo, Deputy Lindsay, called a very savage Budget. According to Deputy Lindsay, the worst aspect of this Budget is the increase of 25 per cent on motor taxation. Deputy Lindsay stated, on that occasion, that he particularly deplored the increase in the tax on private motor vehicles. Now we have the position where every private motorist is being asked to pay roughly 3/- a week in tax to help the economy of this country, and Deputy Lindsay deplored that.
Comment on this
He was speaking about the increase in the motor taxation. I think really in their hearts and souls the Opposition were terribly disappointed that this Budget was not stiffer. Certainly they must admire the ingenuity of our Minister for Finance in bringing in this Budget which really did not hit anybody very severely at all and has avoided taxing any one section of the community.
Comment on this
It is on top of all the extra taxes which have been brought in during the last nine years.
Comment on this
There is a deficit of £12½ million to provide the services which the people demand and which you have demanded on every Estimate here and at Question Time. In every economic debate you demanded more for this and more for that without any indication of where the money was to come from.
Comment on this
The only constructive suggestion made here today was that made by Deputy John A. Costello. He suggested taxing cosmetics. If you study the benefits received from taxation and where the increased taxation is imposed, you will find that there was no section of the community overtaxed. If you tax cosmetics, you are taxing the lipstick and every lady in the country——
Comment on this
The Deputy might find some on his hankerchief. These Opposition Deputies who have continually ridiculed the Government's programme for economic expansion should remember to take economics seriously, but not too seriously. I shall recall for them what a well-known economist, Keynes, once said when proposing a toast before the Royal Economic Society in 1945. He said: "I give you the toast of the Royal Economic Society, of economics and economists who are the trustees, not of civilisation but of the possibilities of civilisation." I would ask those who try to ridicule our programme for economic expansion to remember those words. Fianna Fáil have laid before the people of Ireland what they think are the possibilities for the country and are striving to attain them and, instead of the jeering and ridicule offered by them the Opposition should concentrate on constructive co-operation, such as we had from Deputy Costello this evening.
The present difficulties which the economy is experiencing stem from the adverse trends in our balance of payments which deteriorated at a very rapid pace in the first few months of 1965. In that period cattle exports were substantially below the high level of a year earlier while industrial exports remained static. Coupled with this fall in exports was the tremendous increase in imports and although a substantial amount of the goods which contributed to this increase were purchases of capital equipment which will in time contribute to the wealth of the country, there was also a tremendous upsurge in consumer demand which resulted in increased imports of consumer goods. I should say that unwise spending of our increasing new wealth was one of the main reasons for the present difficulties with our balance of payments.
It is easy for Deputies without responsibility to come in here as we have seen and say that the Government withheld the true facts from the people last year at the time of the general election. The many speeches made by the Taoiseach and the Dáil candidates prior to election day on April 7th were made at a time which preceded the publication of trade statistics for the first quarter of 1965 and they could not have known what the figures would be. If the Opposition Deputies had some knowledge at that time which they felt was important they should have let the country know.
Comment on this
In the words of their own economic journalist, Senator Garret FitzGerald, "everything happened at once". That was an honest statement made by a man who does his homework and was aware of the facts and if Deputies over there are not aware of them I shall quote from the Irish Times Annual Review of 1965. This was written by their own Senator FitzGerald whom they have been continually contradicting here for the past three or four weeks.
Comment on this
He wrote:
Growth without growing pains was for all practical purposes our experience during the period from 1959 to 1964. This couldn't last indefinitely—it was probably inevitable that at some stage the expansion of the economy would create excessive pressures on our resources.
This has now happened. While the expansion of the economy is continuing—although at a somewhat slower rate—we must for some time to come accept constraints on the growth of expenditure, until output and spending are once again brought into a reasonable relationship with each other.
The year 1964 ended with a disturbingly high external payments deficit—£31½ million. Moreover, this figure would have been higher still but for a fortuitous rise in world meat prices, which pushed up our export earnings more rapidly than the actual increase in the volume of our exports warranted. An external deficit of this magnitude was not, however, beyond our means at that time, for the inflow of capital in 1964 was very large—so large indeed that our external assets were actually somewhat higher at the end of the year than at the beginning, despite the alarmingly large current deficit. But a deficit of this size left little or no room for manoeuvre; any further deterioration was likely to eat into our external reserves, especially as there was good reason to expect a fall in the inflow of capital during 1965.
At this stage everything happened at once.
This was not known at the time of the election.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy want me to continue? It goes on:
The capital inflow did in fact decline, but—even more important —the trade deficit widened sharply between February and May.
I would ask Deputies opposite to note that the difficulties arose between February and May and that the election took place on April 7th, enough of the election speeches being made at the end of March. It continues:
Exports of cattle were much lower than a year earlier while the British import levy, imposed in October, 1964, virtually halted the growth of industrial exports. At the same time imports rose sharply, for a variety of unconnected reasons. Cereals imports were heavy because of the bad 1964 harvest, and there were also larger imports of machinery and equipment — including additional jet aircraft for Aer Lingus.
A boom in car sales at the turn of the year seems also to have led to substantial imports of car aggregates by assemblers rebuilding their stocks, and there were increased imports of materials required by exporting industries such as the oil refinery and the pharmaceutical industry.
I assume Deputy L'Estrange has had enough of his journalistic economic friend.
Comment on this
It is ludicrous for any member of the Opposition to accuse this Government of withholding information from the people. Never were greater efforts made by any Government to keep the people fully informed of economic trends. I have not very much experience but everybody concerned knows that never was more information put before the people than by the present Government. It has already been mentioned by my colleague, Deputy Dowling, and Deputy Harte stood up and said— no, he was actually sitting down when he said it—that if he was to read all the literature provided for him by the Government Departments he would not have time to do anything else. One wonders what else he does. Deputy Dillon says that the country is bust and in true sheep-like fashion that line is taken up by all the Fine Gael backbenches.
Comment on this
They all come in and follow the line of Deputy Dillon. I thought he had retired as their leader but they are certainly following him still. They will not allow anybody else to speak——
Comment on this
The Deputy must restrain himself and allow Deputy Molloy to make his speech.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has several times stated here that his personal ambition is to have Fianna Fáil removed from Government. His political plans in being here would be justified for him if he saw Fianna Fáil leaving the Government benches.
Comment on this
We heard that before but when you went to the polls, you got the answer. Yet when Deputy Dillon was asked about the "utter failure"—and I am quoting the words of a former Minister in a Coalition Cabinet—Deputy MacBride in one of the last speeches made in this House before the dissolution of that Government——
Comment on this
The Deputy may not quote from memory.
Comment on this
Of course I can quote from memory. I have not got the volume here but it is definitely there and it was one of the last speeches made before the dissolution.
Comment on this
Do not start quoting something unless you know what it is. The Deputy is not entitled to quote if he has not got the reference.
Comment on this
For the sake of the record, if my memory serves me right, this occurred in one of the last speeches made here at the time of the Coalition. Deputy MacBride was the former Minister who made the statement that their activities in Government had been an utter failure.
Comment on this
Surely you cannot blame that on the inter-Party Government. Deputy MacBride was not a Minister.
Comment on this
He would not know. Give the gossoon a chance.
Comment on this
Has it occurred to Deputy Dillon that external factors may be playing some part in our present difficulties and that no matter what political Party sits in the Government benches, these difficulties will have to be faced?
I should like to quote the Irish Banking Review, Quarterly, December, 1965.
Comment on this
I quote:
In estimating the Irish situation it is very important to avoid over statement.
If what we have heard from Deputy Treacy tonight and from other Deputies over the past few weeks is not overstatement, then I will sit down.
Comment on this
Planning always creates difficulties and some miscalculations may be unavoidable. Every country has periods of different rates of growth. It has become a commonplace to speak about the accelerator and the brake in economic policy. But even a strong application of the brake produces a slowing down but not a stoppage. The slowing down of economic activity may involve inconvenience for many people.
Comment on this
There is urgent need for restraint, discipline and co-operation. But it must be emphasised and understood that the Second Programme has not been frustrated. It may even proceed at a faster rate than originally intended, if the present troubles are correctly treated.
I believe the Government are taking the proper corrective action.
Comment on this
Could I point out that I was here for several hours listening to Opposition Deputies speaking without interruption and it is only fair that a Government Deputy should be given an opportunity to speak?
Comment on this
The Minister was not here when some of the interruptions were taking place.
Comment on this
Deputy Tully, Deputy Treacy and Deputy L'Estrange will please refrain from interrupting.
Comment on this
The Chair is aware and will not tolerate being dictated to. The Deputy will await his turn, if he has not already spoken.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister and the Chair. I should like to make it clear to Fine Gael and Labour that we on this side of the House have the will to govern. The Cabinet have the will to govern and we have the will to be Deputies in the Government Party and we have the determination and will to govern as long as the Irish people ask us to do so and will not run away like Deputy Dillon and his Government did on two previous occasions.
Comment on this
Wishful thinking. It is most significant that the unemployment figures have been steady during the crisis. Anybody who compares the graph of the unemployment figures in 1956 with that of 1965 can see the competent way in which this Government have handled a difficult situation and we have not denied that there has been a difficult situation. It might be very embarrassing for Deputy L'Estrange if I were to show him the graph of some figures in 1957. I think it is on page 65 of the Irish Times Annual Review, 1965.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, on that occasion the Irish Times had not enough room to show in the graph of 1957 the number of persons who emigrated as the graph goes up over the top of the page, and the Deputy must be very proud to come in and try to shout us down with these statistics that he loves quoting. If he were more interested in the people rather than in figures he might be serving a useful purpose. Deputy L'Estrange continually interrupts every Deputy, shouting across the floor meaningless statistics. It seems to me he got his education in statistical matters from Deputy Coogan.
Comment on this
Deputy Coogan recently stated to the Galway Press that there were something like 2,000 persons unemployed in Galway city and that he had got his information from no less a personage than the Taoiseach. I challenged him to prove his figures which had got lovely black headlines in the local Connacht Tribune. The following week I contradicted his statement and pointed out that he had been grossly inaccurate— 80 per cent inaccurate—and that the actual unemployment figure there was that there were only about 200-300 persons unemployed. When I told him that his figures were wrong, and that he was misreading the figures the Taoiseach gave him, he never had the courage to reply. I assume when Deputy Coogan declined to comment that he had not the courage to admit his mistake, if mistake it was. Deliberate deception is something I do not like.
Comment on this
It does not become one who sets himself up as a representative of honest people. As a matter of fact, I should like to give the same advice to Deputy L'Estrange as I gave to Deputy Coogan on that occasion when I told him to leave figures alone and to speak for himself. Deputy Coogan had said that the figures speak for themselves.
Comment on this
Ever since he came into the House, Deputy L'Estrange has been trying to give statistics, shouting meaningless figures across the floor of the House, figures which do not convince anyone because probably of his own simple way of defining them.
Comment on this
I have referred to external factors and would like to read to the House, for the benefit of Opposition Deputies who believe that economic difficulties are being experienced only in this country and that we are out of step with progress being made in western Europe and Britain, extracts from an Irish Press report of 21st March of the United Nations Economic Report:
The annual Review of the Economic Commission for Europe (ECE) states that soaring wages, reduced productivity and a relatively slow growth rate are threatening Western Europe with inflation. Most of Western Europe is "temporarily" in a phase of relatively slow expansion. It was provisionally estimated that the combined national output of the whole of Western Europe rose by only 3½ per cent in 1965, compared with 5½ per cent in 1964. The report forecast that the 1966 growth rate will be 4 per cent. This slight increase is the result of continued recovery of the economies of France and Italy and a probable improvement in Ireland and Belgium. The growth rate in Ireland was substantially reduced in 1965 the report says. Exports were affected by the British import surcharge and there was a substantial rise in prices following the very big wage increases in 1964.
The Report also states that Britain is expected to maintain an economic growth rate of about two per cent this year. It will be the only country with a growth rate of under three per cent in 1966.
It is clear from this that the international opinion is that Ireland will make greater progress than Britain in this coming year. Progress, however, will be achieved only if all sections of the community co-operate in the necessary restraint. In the private sector, this entails a large reduction in imports of consumer goods, increased productivity on the part of each individual and a substantial increase in savings.
In the public sector, the Government must give the lead in reducing expenditure of public funds. The Government have not been slow in trying to effect savings in the economy and any Deputy who takes up the Estimates for 1966-67 can see there clearly illustrated under very many headings the savings that have been effected by the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
Any Deputy who takes the trouble to examine the Estimates can see the savings plainly. As a member of the Committee of Public Accounts, I have become greatly aware over the past 12 months of the complexity of public financing. The thousands of headings under which State funds are spent can all be justified and each one in itself is providing a much needed service or assisting financially some service which different sections of the community greatly appreciate. Collectively, all these moneys are being spent for the purpose of increasing the wealth of the country by utilising to the full the existing sources of wealth and providing the opportunity for developing new sources of wealth.
The amount in the Book of Estimates for Public Services for the year ending 31st March, 1967 is £239,265,720. Although a more detailed discussion will be allowed when the Estimates are before the House, I should like to mention some of the more important Estimates as I feel emphasis should be laid on the fact that provision has been made for increases in nearly all cases. In the case of agriculture, there is an increase of £3,544,000.
Comment on this
On page 106 of the Book of Estimates—I told Deputy L'Estrange to wait and I would give him the figures——