Adjournment (Summer Recess).
Contributions 162–356 of 356. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Down in our county, ever since my arrival on Cork County Council, we have had a number of deputations of landowners living along the banks of our rivers. We have listened to and been impressed by the cases they made. We have contacted the Board of Works and, strangely enough, we find their place in the priority list is exactly the same as several years ago. They never seem to move up. We requested that a deputation be received in connection with this in an effort to speed up the drainage of the land in which we are interested. We are told, as always, by the Minister for Local Government when we request him to receive a deputation, that it could serve no useful purpose. I do not know how these farmers who live along the river and who are expected to increase production, whose lands are under water year after year and who see no hope of their being drained in the foreseeable future, can be expected to have confidence in the Government, especially when the scheme to have their lands drained never seems to move up on the list.
I do not see how the ESB workers can continue to have confidence in a Government which takes away the rights which they have always enjoyed, to withdraw their labour. I do not know how any group of workers, knowing that this could be applied to them in the morning if the Government felt like it, could continue to have confidence in the type of Government we have, with so few of the targets in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion being reached and with no likelihood of the promises now being made being carried out in the foreseeable future.
Day after day the Taoiseach and his Ministers refer to the type of society they are working for, without taking any of the necessary practical steps to make that society a reality. With so much hardship being allowed to continue, and being allowed to increase for some of the lower-paid sections, we believe that the Government no longer enjoy the confidence of Dáil Éireann. We are certain they no longer enjoy the confidence of the people whom they continue to govern.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach recently, apparently in jest but, I suspect, substantially in earnest, jeered at a recent address which I gave to this House, because in reference to industrial relations, I stressed the importance of the fundamentals—the fundamentals in industrial relations being the human relationships which exist between employers and employees. In the course of the Taoiseach's reply, he appeared to make little of the virtue of love, suggesting that I had gone so far as to say that God is love. I am prepared to concede, as the Taoiseach has a sense of humour, that he was overstressing the points I made, but I do think it is important that we should appreciate the intrinsic value and virtue of love, love of one's God, of one's fellow man and love of one's nation. The tragic thing in this country is that the exercise of patriotism has become very rare because the Fianna Fáil Party under the Taoiseach have indicated to the people that patriotism should never be exercised unless one is sure a temporal reward is available because of the exercise of it.
Comment on this
So it is that people are not prepared to make the sacrifices which once they felt it easy to make. Now, before any task is done, they want to know the price, the reward, and they want to know what they are going to get out of it. There are very few tasks that this Government perform for which there is not some ulterior motive, or which for them there is not a good, calculated chance that they are going to profit substantially out of it, if not politically, then personally. All this——
Comment on this
All this obliges me out of love of my fellow countrymen to make them aware of the dangerous trends and to make them aware of the fact that the Irish soul is being destroyed and damaged because of this new greed, the greed which is the philosophy of Fianna Fáil, because it is primarily the personal philosophy of the Taoiseach and most members of the Government. They have polluted and soiled many streams of national activity, cultural, agricultural and industrial. They have polluted them with their philosophy, greed for their personal gain. Combined with this, they have approached the problems of the nation and the people with an outrageous arrogance which is greater than the imperialism which was once the burden of this country when the Union Jack flew here. We now have a new imperialism under the badge of Fianna Fáil.
There may be members who feel that I am stressing it too much but I feel that when we have a Government activated solely by their own greed for power, a Government who allow that philosophy to percolate down to the humblest people in the land, then we have become the slaves of a new tyranny, the tyranny of Fianna Fáil. As I said this tyranny and this philosophy are combined. Last year I had to condemn the Taoiseach because he had personally addressed an appeal for subscriptions for the Fianna Fáil Party to many senior civil servants. That was for the last general election for which he sought funds for the Fianna Fáil Party and he asked that the subscriptions be sent to him personally and he undertook not to publish the list of names. He did not, of course, undertake not to keep it.
Comment on this
In the case of the recent electoral contest, the Presidential election, this piece of contemptible and deplorable arrogance was again repeated by the Taoiseach who sent out appeals for funds, not to industrialists alone, not to the rich and wealthy, not to the people of independent means, but once again to senior civil servants in their offices. They were addressed not alone by their own names but also according to their rank and title in the State service. Just what can we as an Opposition and as an essential political Party do to warn the people of the inevitable consequences of a trend of that kind? How can we have independent civil servants, public servants with integrity, when they feel that the consequences of their declining to send a personal subscription to the Taoiseach will be to deprive themselves of a fair promotion according to their ability? How can the most able civil servant who is entirely inspired by principles, not have regard to the fact that his own fortunes and the fortunes of his wife and family can be jeopardised unless he sends along a subscription to Seán Uasal Lemass?
Comment on this
——and as long as the people allow their souls to lie in the moribund spirit that Fianna Fáil have created in this country so far as matters of integrity and conscience are concerned.
Comment on this
It might be said that we should press for the publication of the names of the people who subscribed to the Fianna Fáil Party but that is not necessary. Instead, all one need do is stand at the gate of Dublin Castle whenever the Taoiseach throws a reception there. Then you will see going along the ill-bred and ill-mannered people of so many Fianna Fáil cumainn and many of the people who have taken out their cheque books and sent funds to the Fianna Fáil Party. At a recent jamboree, at which the Taoiseach was the nominal host, spending the taxpayers' money, there were three times as many people present as were present on a similar occasion in 1952. There were twice as many people present as there were present in 1959. One wonders where the extra thousands have come from since 1959? People with some knowledge of the rank and file members of the Fianna Fáil Party saw there, in so far as it was possible to see anybody, because of the vast multitude that were shouldering one another in the place, 27 chairmen and 19 secretaries of Fianna Fáil cumainn and their spouses, five members of the headquarters staff of Fianna Fáil, two members of the employees of the Fianna Fáil Party, who were seen with shears cutting down the posters of Deputy Tom O'Higgins, who was the opponent of the Fianna Fáil candidate. Also seen and heard there was a gentleman who admitted that, although he hated their guts, he had subscribed £100 to their funds.
Comment on this
When he was in a state of rather disgusting inebriation, and was reprimanded by his wife for being in that condition, he said: "I paid the so-and-sos £100 to be here and by God, I am going to get my value out of it." There used to be a phrase of contempt used here in the days when we had British imperialism as distinct from Fianna Fáil imperialism, in reference to those people: they were known as Castle Catholics. Now we have a new brand of contemptible citizens. We have the Castle-following crowd, those who want to be seen there, those people who have to be rewarded for the services given to the Fianna Fáil Party.
I was present earlier this year at my one and only jamboree of that kind because I have no particular appetite for such functions. I went to the one which was thrown to commemorate and honour the survivors of 1916. My heart went out to the unfortunate septuagenarians and octogenarians, people who quite obviously were seriously disabled in the autumn of their days, and people who were very feeble and unable to get a chair. They were pushed and thrown everywhere between the many thousand members of the Fianna Fáil cumainn, who were being rewarded for their menial services, by being brought along, to be wined, dined and intoxicated at public expense. What a contemptible way to honour those brave men who sacrificed so much that Ireland might be free. Is it any wonder that many of them wondered if it was worth while when they had to witness such a contemptible performance to honour them after 50 years?
This thing is very wrong. It is entirely wrong that State functions of that kind should be graced by people who are in public service or, because of the rank they hold in the Fianna Fáil Party, have to be rewarded for the services they have given as officers of Fianna Fáil cumainn and comhairlí ceanntair, their directors and their various hierarchy. That is entirely wrong. If they want to do that, let them do it at the expense of the Fianna Fáil Party. If the Fianna Fáil Presidential candidate wants to do that, let him do it at his own expense on the green lawn of Arus an Uachtaráin rather than in Dublin Castle at the expense of the taxpayers.
Comment on this
Those things count as far as the Fianna Fáil Party are concerned. It is their helpers and subscribers who must be rewarded. Those are the important people and not the survivors of our fight for freedom. It is not those who on merit alone deserve to be there who are invited but those other people because of the jobs they hold. A symbol of the sickness and the decay of this country stands at the foot of the lower yard in the Castle. There is a building there which was evacuated 15 years ago because it was dangerous and unfit to house people. We were told even five years ago that this building was to be demolished three years ago. The paint on that particular building was peeling off like huge white horses on a stormy sea. Although the paint was peeling off that building, it was not doing people any particular harm. Then, just before the jamboree, one had the rather amusing sight of gentlemen up on ladders with garden houses knocking off the peeling waves of decayed paint and plaster. This was followed by putting on one coat of paint to impress, according to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, the distinguished guests attending the Presidential inauguration.
The interesting thing is that the distinguished guests, as distinct from the not so distinguished members of the Fianna Fáil organisation, had no occasion to go into the Lower Castle Yard at all. I was amused yesterday morning to read that one of our most skilled and able journalists suggested that remarks of mine about this referred to eminent clerics in the rank of members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Of course, one must be punctilious about this. The two eminent clerics had no occasion to go, and did not go, into the Lower Castle Yard. That was reserved for the lesser folk who drove their own cars and had to park them there. The eminent people referred to, and the other distinguished guests at ambassadorial level, went in by the Upper Yard so they never saw the symbol of the decayed building in the Lower Castle Yard that has now had a fresh coat of paint put on it. This only impressed those who came along at the behest of the Fianna Fáil Party.
This is not being said lightly by me; it is not being said just to have a go at the Government. I have not said all of this to hit back at the Taoiseach or anybody else. I want to say that this underlines the rottenness of the moral fibre of this country which has been damaged almost beyond repair by the activities during the past decade of the Fianna Fáil Government, without going back any farther than that. We think it essential that the people become aware of the horrid nature of those activities and being aware of them, that they will do something to put an end to what is happening. We have the Castle crawthumper, the member of the Fianna Fáil Party who demands that he be rewarded for his services by an invitation to the Castle, and I feel that people will reject that type of activity.
We in Dublin are proud of the fact that the people have at long last in Dublin become conscious of the arrogance of the Fianna Fáil Party. We think that the recent tremendous vote against Fianna Fáil in Dublin is not only a condemnation of their economic policies, social policies, or lack of them, but is also a condemnation of their arrogance and lack of patriotism; but the people in Dublin for a long time seemed to be inadequately concerned about the fact that tens of thousands of their neighbours were not properly housed. When I saw the vote which the Fianna Fáil Party secured in the last general election in Dublin, just a short 18 months ago, I was disappointed, not because of the insufficient number of votes which my Party achieved on that occasion, but because it seemed to indicate a frame of mind on the part of Dublin people who were well housed, who were fortunate, that they could not care less about the less fortunate amongst them. But, I do feel that the people of this country at long last realise that there are in Dublin 10,000 families who urgently require decent houses. They have not got them and cannot get them and cannot hope to get them in the present housing output for at least ten years.
This makes no allowance for all those as yet uncreated and unestablished families, unborn children, who will come into the housing market in the years ahead. We regret the Government have not taken steps over the years to watch the marriage figures, to watch the figures for births. Those figures are readily available to the Government through the Central Statistics Office. They are collected through the registry of births, deaths and marriages and also through the workings of the Department of Social Welfare, and the work of this Department and the information collected shows that over the past decade the number of marriages has been increasing, the number of early marriages has been increasing and, consequently, the number of births is increasing and the increasing demand for housing is multiplied, but the Government have failed to make any provision whatsoever for any of those additional burdens which are inevitable and they certainly have not allowed for them in their White Paper on housing requirements.
That is bad enough, but what is worse still is that they have not even yet bothered to tackle the problems which are so obvious. There are 10,000 families in need of houses and we are told in this House and elsewhere that there are not 10,000 but only 5,000 families in Dublin who require to be urgently housed. The situation is that of the 10,000 families, 5,000 are so critically in need of housing that the chief medical officer says there is a medical need for them to be rehoused, an urgent compelling medical need to have them rehoused. One can appreciate how low he sets the standard when there has been no building, no basement room, no attic room, no room with insufficient light or full of dampness or with fungus on the wall, condemned as unfit for human habitation since June 1963.
In Dublin, so considerable is the housing problem that the public authority, through the Department of Local Government and through the Government and the influences they exert on the local authority, do not want to acknowledge that the appalling housing situation is any worse than they are forced, by the number of applications, to accept. But, prior to this stoppage of condemnation as being unfit for human habitation, Dublin had on average 300 houses annually condemned as unfit for human habitation because they were damp or because of an insufficiency of light, because of rotten floor boards, or because of the fact that they were generally just decayed. But the only condemnation there has been in Dublin in the past three years is in respect of houses that were in danger of imminent collapse, that is to say, the walls were going to fall out or in, and there was danger of a catastrophe through the forces of the laws of gravity.
The kind of appalling conditions that would lead a farmer to be prosecuted if he had those conditions for his animals are being tolerated in this city and throughout the country because the Government do not wish to accept that the housing conditions are any worse than the figures given. We have the tomfoolery which followed the Ballymun scheme. We were promised houses there almost a year ago. Then we were told that was excessive enthusiasm and the first house would not be available until last December when Dublin was to get a Christmas gift of 20 houses or more and a house per day in Ballymun thereafter.
Now, Sir, we are in July and there is not as much as a square foot in Ballymun that has been handed over to be occupied by the 700 families of five and more in one room crying to be housed in Dublin, not to mention the thousands of families of four in one room and many other people who urgently need houses.
Comment on this
People will say that we speak with too much heat in this House but parliamentary rules exhort us to speak with a limited vocabulary. But were we to express the remarks of the mothers who are forced to look after their children, to rear them, to dress them, to wash them, to feed them and make them sleep all in one room, and were we to recite the remarks of those women who have to eat, sleep and wash, all in the one room, the records of this House could not carry the language which these people out of their justifiable anger are using every day and there is not one member of the Dublin Corporation sitting opposite me who will dispute this.
Comment on this
In all fairness to them, nobody is more disappointed than the three Fianna Fáil members of Dublin Corporation opposite me because they know they have failed, and failed miserably, in the most contemptible way we have had ever to endure in this city of Dublin.
Comment on this
We saw, when houses could have been built in this city at less than half the present cost, the Fianna Fáil Government build only 270 houses in a year when, in fact, 2,700 were required, and not until we have in power a Government who will return to the record set up under a Government in which Fine Gael were the guiding party, will we have houses.
Comment on this
In one year, 15 years ago, 2,750 houses were built and until we return to that record, this miserable litany of human misery will be repeated day in day out and week in and week out. One would have thought that those who were brave enough this time last year to forecast houses for October would, in July, 1966, be able to forecast when the first house would be handed over. They are still not prepared tonight, unless there has been a change of heart this day, to say when the first keys of Ballymun will be handed over.
Comment on this
They tried to suggest recently that it was all due to the fact that we had bad weather. The fact is that the provision of houses in the traditional manner was held up for a couple of months earlier this year. But was it held up for 12 months; was it held up for eight months? It most certainly was not, because it is known and can be proved from the records, that the weather this year, apart from a rather large amount of rain in the early part of the year, was better than normal.
Comment on this
The weather is now being blamed for a plan which was ill-conceived, which was much vaunted and much boasted about. It was held out like a carrot to the people at the last general election that all their housing problems would be over because we were going to have what Deputy Noel Lemass called the "Blaney Heights". Would he call it "Blaney Heights" today or would he call it "Burke's Hole".
Comment on this
Methinks it is time some people remained silent on the question of Ballymun. We in Fine Gael cannot, because we share the desperation of the people, because we felt that if you were going to build houses for them, we would let you try. We gave the project our blessing when it was first proposed because we felt that if instead of these buffooneries, there was to be some house building in the traditional way, it would at least relieve some hundreds of families. But we are told by Deputy Moore that the houses are there and he expects us to thank them for that. I hope the 700 families of five in one room tonight will be glad to hear from Deputy Moore that the houses are there for the past six months but they cannot be let into them. It is strange to say that people should be grateful because they have houses there for them but they will not be let into them. That only makes matters worse.
Comment on this
The Deputy is entirely wrong, and he knows it. The figures for emigration of Dublin Corporation tenants were high in 1959-60 when yourselves were in power. Today your greatest contribution towards the relief of the housing crisis in Dublin is not the provision of houses but the emigration of fathers, mothers and children who have no hope of getting houses and who are obliged, because of that, to go, even when they are in jobs, to fly from the misery of the appalling housing conditions, or bad health itself. Their daily experience, as long as they live, has been not alone five in one room but sometimes 13, 15, 18 and, yes, 20 in a house which was only intended for five or six people.
We have built all around the perimeter of our city and these houses, as Deputies will know, are occupied by two, three, and even four families and, because they do not comply with the Fianna Fáil priority of statistics of five in the family of the applicant they have no prospect of being housed this year. God knows when they will ever have a chance of being housed. If you have any more children to comply with the Fianna Fáil requirements, you will be overcrowded. Mothers are suffering serious ill-health, physically and mentally, but all these things are not measurable according to the pitiable priorities we now have, that you must be able to establish five people per room in the family of the person applying. Even when you can establish that, you will probably have a fourth or fifth child before you can even get a house.
I have no wish to dwell upon the misfortunes of our fellow citizens but when I come up against the smug complacency of those who say that people should not complain—Fine Gael should not complain, Labour have no right to complain because there are houses there, but they will not be given out—I cannot refrain from doing so. I think it is time to expose the callousness of people who speak in that way. But, why? Because they are full of defects. Houses which were built six months ago cannot be given out because there are defects in them.
Comment on this
The great secret in Dublin is: "Do not tell anybody why the houses are not being given out in Ballymun. We will dig a hole and let Deputy Paddy Burke fall into it and that will be a good excuse for another few months." We must be the only public authority in the world who build houses and leave them standing there for a long time while 10,000 people remain on the housing lists, but we will not give the houses up to them. This is a very strange approach to it.
Comment on this
Deputy Paddy Burke fell into a hole but he was lucky enough to be dragged out. This is simply not good enough. We had about three years ago a great deal of clamouring and excitement, the kind of thing we will have again in view of recent changes in the Department of Education. But we will just test how valuable is the excitement you hear about today in the Department of Education. We were told that 66 per cent of the cost of providing new secondary schools was to be paid for by a benevolent Fianna Fáil administration. We learned this week, from that tremendous democratic weapon, that not as much as one brass farthing has been paid in respect of any new secondary school, not as much as a farthing has been paid.
We found out today that it takes the Department of Education up to two years to process an application before any sanction is given, and the consequence of all this has been that a large number of secondary school authorities who proposed, out of their own resources in 1964, to build new secondary schools were tempted by the carrot which Fianna Fáil put before them to postpone the operation of their plans until they got sanction from the Government so that the Government would share the burden of repaying the capital they borrowed and upon which they had to pay interest.
Now we see the purpose of this. When these promises were made in the summer of 1964, the Government knew then, as any person with reasonable understanding of economics knew then, that we were slipping down a slope towards a severe restriction in credit and they enticed all those secondary school authorities to postpone their building plans until they had gone into the Fianna Fáil web. Once they got them there, they would not be allowed out of the web until credit restrictions made it impossible for them to get the loans they could have got in the summer of 1964, The result is that all over this city urgently needed secondary schools have not gone up in the past two years, which would have gone up if Fianna Fáil had not held out this carrot. Although they held out this carrot, nobody has, as yet, got a nibbling of it, a smell of it, or even a sight of it, because nothing whatsoever has been paid.
Those who, out of sheer desperation, decided to get loans to build, pending the availability of the Govearnment money, now find themselves with colossal bills of interest to pay and no assistance from the Government towards meeting them. In the meantime the cost of building these schools has risen by ten to 15 per cent and the Government, with typical Fianna Fáil munificence and generosity, have insisted that not only should the classrooms which are urgently needed be built but that ancillary facilities which are not essential should also be built for children who will need secondary education during the next four or five years. I believe that kind of activity is contemptible.
Now the great promiser of all kinds of things has gone to the Department of Education. Promises have been made by people who are inclined to be reckless and that is how they will be broken in the future. We will know little by little but we know from past experience that very little will be achieved. We have seen what is happening in matters of health. During the past general election, under pressure from Fine Gael, the Taoiseach said something which gained the headlines of the newspapers, not only the Irish Press.
The Taoiseach said he hoped it would be possible to prepare a social programme on the lines of the economic programme and that he proposed to do so, if returned to power. What has happened is that we got no programme so far as an extension of social assistance or social welfare is concerned—none whatsoever, although they are there for the past 18 months. We did get this document in relation to the health services in which something like 40 per cent of the improvements which Fine Gael would give within months of being returned to power were promised in three or four years time. Before the great promiser had any opportunity three or four years' time. Before the his lack of performance, he was shifted to a safer stage.
All this must be considered in the light of the tax situation which is now 50 per cent worse than what was forecast by the Government's prophets. The burden of taxation is now 50 per cent higher than it was supposed to be in this great programme, and although it is 50 per cent higher, our rate of expansion is less than half of what it was promised it would be. We are not to be put off. The great optimist, the Taoiseach, says that because we held back at the beginning of the race, because we did not run as fast as we could or should have, we will have to put on an extra spurt in the closing stages. That is all very well, but when we see that it is the intention of the same coach to remain in control until the end of the race, we cannot see any real prospect of improving our rate of growth over the next four years. The result will be that while we are going further and further down the field, the rest of Europe which we had hoped to accompany across the tape at the end of the race will be several miles ahead of us.
This simply is not good enough. The nation cannot afford it. Because of that, we in Fine Gael and our colleagues in the Labour Party are confident that, although the Fianna Fáil Party, aware of their dwindling political fortunes will not accept our motions of no confidence, once the people get an opportunity, they will say in as clear a voice as that in which it was said in Dublin, Cork and other urban centres recently, that they have no confidence in the present Administration. One wonders why it is that there appears to be such a clash between the urban areas and the rural areas at present so far as political awareness is concerned. The reason is probably perfectly simple. It is that in many parts of rural Ireland the people are on subsistence level. Their ambition and their prospects have been stultified through the maladministration of the Fianna Fáil Party. They have never known better days and they have little to look forward to I suppose blessed is he whose ambition and whose hunger is not too great. The result is that they are not as acutely aware of the failure of the Fianna Fáil Party as are the people in other parts of the country who respond immediately——
Comment on this
——to any slackening by the Government in the tempo of public affairs. That is no slur upon rural Ireland. We are delighted to see that such a large proportion of the people of Ireland appreciate how much the Fianna Fáil Party have let them down. These people have swung in unprecedented numbers towards the Fine Gael flag. We are quite certain from recent events that the thought processes of these people are in operation again, that the light is shining, and that it is only a matter of time until the Irish conscience, the Irish mind, the Irish economy and outlook for the future will be purged of all the lassitude, indifference and greed which polluted it, and we can look forward to a better Ireland under the leadership of a man of intelligence, a man of ability, a man of new enthusiasms and new outlook, Deputy Cosgrave.
Comment on this
I listened to Deputy Ryan speaking for the past hour or so. He spoke of love of his fellow man. He spoke of pollution and corruption. He had many other phrases befitting a front bench member of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
We listened to the slime flow from the Fine Gael sewerpipe for some considerable time. We listened to the political hawkers in the Fine Gael Party, and unfortunately members of the Labour Party, who associated themselves with these censure motions. There is no doubt that the Parties opposite are very good on censure motions. They should be, after the number of years they have been in Opposition. They will probably perfect them in time.
Comment on this
It must be gratifying for responsible members of Fine Gael —and there are responsible members of Fine Gael—to have to listen to Deputy Ryan speaking on behalf of their Party. Deputy Ryan spoke about the housing situation. He spoke about the situation in Ballymun. Of course, Deputy Ryan knows nothing about the housing situation in Dublin. During the past seven years, he had the opportunity, week after week, of attending the meetings of Dublin Corporation Housing Committee. He could have done that even if he had not been a member of the Committee. He could have been there to make suggestions for improving the situation. But only once in the seven years did he attend a meeting.
Comment on this
People can express themselves without sitting for several hours on a certain part of their anatomy.
Comment on this
The members of the Housing Committee of Dublin Corporation accept responsibility to the full. Fine Gael have been trying to tie the responsibility, as do some Labour Members occasionally, on Fianna Fáil. Deputy Ryan is not alone in this effort to distort the truth about the position in relation to housing. One would think there were plenty of houses when the Coalition were in power. They say there were 1,500 houses vacant in Dublin then. There were because 1,500 families had emigrated, driven out by Coalition policies.
Comment on this
Let me quote what Deputy Larkin said. He is reported in volume 160 of the Official Reports at column 2060:
The picture facing us in Dublin this year is not too pleasant. The number of houses completed in the period from 1st April to 31st October last year was 644: this year the number is 449. The number of men employed on housing, housing development work and allied occupations in Dublin city last year was 2,199: this year the number is 1,854. Bear in mind also the fact that last year's figure represented a 50 per cent reduction on the employment in 1951.
Bear in mind also that Deputy Larkin said that in this House on 6th December, 1956. Earlier, Deputy Larkin had this to say about the Dublin Corporation's housing programme:
The first step required the cutting out of the new contract for the Finglas area. That has been approved by the Minister, but now we will have to tell the contractor: "Sorry, we cannot continue with this contract now." That involved a reduction of £61,000 in the estimate.
Comment on this
Deputy Larkin went on:
The next was in reference to the direct housing scheme for the Finglas area. That scheme was not to be proceeded with either. It was also suggested that there should be a gradual diminution in employment on direct housing schemes and a gradual laying-off of the workers concerned.
So the position was not so good when the other gang were in office.
Comment on this
I shall tell about Ballymun, a scheme which Fine Gael and Labour try to decry. When the scheme was introduced in the corporation, the Fine Gael and Labour members accepted it. They said the scheme was a very good idea. The Corporation were producing fewer houses at the time because the traditional methods and labour services available would not meet needs. The Minister for Local Government sent members of the Corporation, including Fine Gael and Labour members, to the Continent. They came back and Ballymun was begun. It was indicated that the programme laid down would take a certain course. Then there was a dock strike and the materials could not be landed at Dublin.
Comment on this
They were returned to France. When eventually they were landed in Dublin, some of the materials were found to have been damaged and as no workshop in the country would undertake to carry out the necessary repairs, they again had to be returned to France. There was also the problem of the laying of the underground services—water, sewerage, electricity and so on. That work had to be done in adverse conditions. At the time, Fine Gael and Labour members agreed that tremendous work was being done in the circumstances.
However, I shall leave the housing situation. I am quite sure they heard enough about the situation when they were in power to keep them going for a while. One would think every house in Dublin had been built by Fine Gael and Labour. In this House there is no lack of experts on topics such as housing. There is, though, a terrible lack of honesty. We have Deputy Ryan, a past master in dishonest dealing.
Comment on this
The lost leader. All day they have been going from one inaccuracy to another. They will be all dealt with one by one before this debate concludes. They know nothing of the realities before us. Not one constructive suggestion has come from them.
Comment on this
We must take into consideration our resources and our prospects for the future. The Government are examining them in real terms. The message for the survival of the economy is that there must be collective responsibility and the Opposition are included in that. They have responsibility just as the Government have but they have always shied away from responsibility.
Comment on this
We must examine the record of the people who are trying to censure the Government now. Take the Labour Party. They tried to indicate anxiety for the workers but in actual fact they do not represent the workers.
Comment on this
What have that Party done in the past 12 months? What single suggestion for the workers' real benefit have they made? They have made nothing but destructive suggestions during the debate on the supplementary Budget.
Comment on this
It was opposed by Fine Gael and Labour. The moneys necessary to give the workers in Government services the additional £1 a week——
Comment on this
Then there are the farmers about whom we heard so much from Deputy Dillon and his colleagues prior to the general election. Salt tears were shed for them but when the Government indicated that they were prepared to make money available for farm reliefs, Deputy Dillon and the Labour Party turned their backs on them. They stabbed the workers in the back; they stabbed the workers in the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, the workers in this House and in other sections of the Government service. It is not the first time they stabbed the workers in the back.
Comment on this
It is a good job that they were not in production or you would have sold them out, too.
Comment on this
These people are unable to take any kind of criticism whatever. The only people allowed to criticise the Labour Party and the trade union movement are the paid officials. Otherwise, nobody is supposed to say a bad word about them or to say anything that might bring about a betterment and an improvement of the trade unions. Let us see what one of these paid trade unionists has to say about it. In the Irish Independent of 9th June, 1966, under the heading of “Union Official Warns of Pink Ginger-Groups” Mr. John F. Carroll has this to say:
We have got to be prepared to speak out and not allow ourselves, either at individual union level, or at national congress level to be steamrolled, unduly pressurised or hamstrung, because of sentiment, too liberal expressions of the right of the individual or fear of splinter groups being formed, or pink ginger-groups making their pressure felt.
He went on to say:
There can be no denying that the broad structure of the Irish trade union movement today is out of line with modern concepts and requirements.
Comment on this
I have the greatest admiration for this man. If the Labour Party think anything about the workers or the country, they will attempt to put their own house in order first. Quite recently there was a meeting in O'Connell Street organised by the Labour Party to discuss the housing situation in Dublin. It was addressed by the vice-chairman of the Labour Party, Proinsias Mac Aonghusa and Members of this House spoke at that meeting. The Chairman of the Housing Committee of Dublin Corporation was not invited to that meeting or, if he was invited, he did not go. That was one of the Red-style rallies held in this city. Twelve months ago we had one or two Deputies marching to Griffith Barracks and they seemed to have very original ideas.
Comment on this
These people appeared before the television cameras and in the photographs in the yellow press and down at the corner of Abbey Street we had one of these less well-known agitators and disruptionists kicking people in the back because they would not clap. When an attempt was made to protect one of these people, the vice-chairman of the Labour Party pointed and said: "The police are taking the man away". These same people also took part in a march carrying banners which said "We want homes" and the man who carried that particular banner was not married. The same people marched outside the gates of this House. They interfered in other strikes too. It is a pity that some of them could not be got to interevene with some of the people who are on strike here at the moment.
Comment on this
They are being kept out on strike by an American strike breaker whom you encouraged to come into the country.
Comment on this
I would appeal to Deputies to cease interrupting. Deputy Dowling is entitled to make his speech.
Comment on this
He has not told us about Singer going out of this country with £1 million of Irish money.
Comment on this
The Party opposite, the Fine Gael Party, are responsible for much of the disruption that has taken place in this country over the years. We listened tonight to Deputy Donegan, the man with the tinhut mentality, who felt that there were too many carpets in the Fine Gael rooms. It is the same type of mentality as wanted to retain the corrugated structure at Aston's Quay some years ago. Deputy Mrs. Desmond spoke about the unfortunate men and women who are on low wages and we all agree that £1 and 15/- a week is too low. There are better times coming.
Comment on this
Deputy Donegan— unfortunately he is not present—spoke about aircraft and said he would probably be prepared to sell them again, dislodge the workers and let them go to far distant shores.
Comment on this
One would think, to listen to members of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party, that there was no industrial development in the past four or five years. The facts of the situation are that in 1965 there were an additional 47 factories established with a share capital of over £10,000.
Comment on this
In 1966 to date, there have been 23 factories with a share capital of £10,000 either started or in the course of extension.
Comment on this
They are scattered throughout the country. The industrial policy of Fianna Fáil is to provide factories in various centres.
Comment on this
These factories are attracting back people who had to go to Brimingham and Coventry during the term of office of the Coalition Government. I have a deep interest in the welfare of Irish workers, in seeing that they enjoy proper conditions of work. I want to see full employment coming about and the necessary improvements being made. I am quite certain all these things will come in time. Many progressive steps for the betterment of workers have been made under the Fianna Fáil Government. On no occasion did the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party, who shout so loudly about the rights of workers and about the conditions under which they are employed, bring about any easement of the situation.
Tonight there has been a new injection into the Front Bench of Fine Gael when one member spoke about the lot of his fellow-man and proceeded to stab him in the back or cut his throat.
Comment on this
The housing position is certainly not as it was in 1956 when the Coalition Government ran away from their responsibilities.
Comment on this
I would advise the members of the Opposition to read Volume 202 and if they do I am sure they will learn something.
Comment on this
It was amazing to listen to Deputy Dowling speaking on the housing situation at the present moment. One would get the impression that there was no slowing down in housing and that every effort was being made to improve housing conditions. We are tired listening to statements of that kind for a long number of years. I was amazed at the time of the last general election in North-East Cork, the area where I have the honour of representing the people, when in the town of Mallow public speeches were delivered by the Taoiseach and by the candidates of the Fianna Fáil Party. A large procession gathered outside the town, headed by four pipe bands who paraded to a platform in front of which was the slogan: "Let Lemass Lead On." They promised more houses for the people, more work, increased pay, better conditions—everything that could be promised was promised that night.
Deputy Corry stated today there was no unemployment at the present moment. I represent North-East Cork, the very same place as Deputy Corry, and I know the amount of unemployment there now. I do admit that in some of the bigger towns, large industries were established but not by the Fianna Fáil Party. I will give credit to anyone who provides employment in North-East Cork, and it was the late William Dwyer, who was a member of this House, who put the towns of Youghal and Midleton on their feet many years ago. As a result of that, we have two towns in particular where no unemployment problem exists. However, throughout the remaining parts of North-East Cork, unemployment is just as rife today as ever it was.
The Deputy stated that migrants had to be drafted in to do a certain amount of work this year. Everybody knows it is customary in the large beet-growing areas of Cork County for people to come from Mayo and Galway for the beet harvest. That is nothing new. They have been there over a long number of years and are still coming down.
Having regard to what has been said over a long period and the promises made to the people, the time is ripe for the Leader of the Government to decide to test the country. This Government have not lived up to the promises they made. In 1932, at the Market Square in Kanturk, the former leader of Fianna Fáil said that if Fianna Fáil were returned to power their first job would be to bring down the price of the poor man's tobacco to the prewar level of 3rd an ounce. That statement was made by the man who now holds the highest post in this country. It is interesting to note the price of tobacco at the present time. That promise was, like many others, completely forgotten.
We are told now that the country is not in any financial difficulty. I have been a member of Cork County Council for 25 years. Not once before in that period have we ever had to take a vote in the county council as to whether we would erect cottages in one town or village as against another place. The Minister for Local Government has continually written letters directing local authorities to formulate plans and submit plans and specifications. What happens when they are submitted? There is delay. The plans are not returned to the local authorities because there is no money to meet the cost of the erection of the houses. The only suggestion forthcoming from the Minister for Local Government during the past three months in regard to our financial position was that Cork County Council should sell any property they had. What property do local authorities possess?
Comment on this
That is right. We have a considerable number of labourers' cottages but the Minister for Local Government has put an embargo on the sale of labourers' cottages to tenants. That will have the effect of halting cottage purchase, a matter in which everyone here has been interested for a long number of years.
In Cork county, our housing programme has come to a standstill. In North Cork, which is equal in size to the entire county Limerick, we had a programme in October, 1965, to erect 39 houses. We accepted tenders for 13 houses. Tenders had been received but not approved in respect of the remainder. The result is that quite recently the manager informed the members that we could proceed only with the erection of the 13 houses and could make up our minds where they would be built. Even at that, the manager pointed out that the amount of money available would not be sufficient to complete the 13 houses.
I have listened to Deputy Healy here tonight talking about the amount of money now available for housing and the amount available roughly ten to 14 years ago. Everybody knows that the cost of erecting a house is twice what it was in 1950 or 1951. In 1948, the late Deputy T.J. Murphy was Minister for Local Government. We decided on a large scheme of housing for Cork County. The same applied probably to other counties. In 1951-1952, we were in a position to hand over to 354 persons 354 new rural cottages in the North Cork rural district. In addition, we had large schemes of houses in Mallow, Fermoy, Midleton and Youghal, where the urban councils are operating. That came about as the result of activity within the Government and, in particular, within the Department of Local Government.
Comment on this
He did. He went to Cork. He was not satisfied even with the progress made by the officials of Cork County Council and employed a housing inspector to make quite sure that sites were selected and houses erected as speedily as possible. At that time the Northern Committee of the Cork County Council needed only submit an application for the erection of a house to the Custom House and within a month or, at longest, six weeks, the matter was attended to.
There are housing schemes in the Department of Local Government for a long time, in some cases a year or a year and a half, and we are now told that there is no scarcity of money, that we can go ahead with the job. Surely the people are not fools? Surely the Members of this House are not fools? Everybody in the country knows what the position is. Throughout Cork county there is an outcry for improved housing. There are people living in mudwall cabins and slums. Our ambition is to provide the people with houses. The Government have failed in their responsibility in this connection and, as a result, the Labour Party have moved this Motion of no Confidence, which is fully justified. The people should be given the opportunity to decide the type of Government that is best for them.
I have said enough about housing. I now come to the local sanitary services. In this connection we are not in a position to do any extra work this year. I had the honour of participating in a by-election in mid-Cork. During the campaign I listened carefully and attentively to the Minister for Transport and Power speaking at Millstreet on 1st March, 1965. Having listened to him, I was quite sure that the country was to be made a paradise for all time. Every good thing was promised in regard to the housing of the people. The interests of the agricultural community were to be safeguarded. One got the impression that the Department of Transport and Power was the most important aspect of government, that the Minister had done a perfect job. One month later there was a general election, immediately after which the truth came to light. Those who had been prophesying prosperity found that they were not in a financial position to create prosperity. There was a by-election in mid-Cork. The Government had failed in the by-election in Roscommon and made quite sure that they would offer everything possible to the electorate of mid-Cork in an effort to secure the return of their candidate. There were promises of houses, retention of railways, provision of new schools. All these were offered to the electorate of mid-Cork on the eve of the by-election.
Comment on this
Before I was interrupted, I was dealing with the promises made to the people. We knew the purpose of the promises. Be it known to this House that I never knew I was such an important man until the by-election for mid-Cork took place and I was director of elections. They sent the Taoiseach down to Boherbue where I was bred, born and reared and he spoke at 3 o'clock on a Saturday afternoon and outlined the position of the country. His message was to go out and tell everybody that this was a land flowing with milk and honey and that there was no fear of anything but that Fianna Fáil might lose the election.
Comment on this
Immediately after the general election, the picture was different. I was interrupted a while ago by Deputy Meaney about what occurred in North Cork and what can be done in North Cork at the present moment. As a member of the Northern Committee, I want to tell the Deputy now that his father is a member of the Northern Committee——
Comment on this
We embarked on a water scheme which covers the entire area of Newmarket, Cullen and Knocknagree. We engaged a consultant, and members who have experience on local authorities know the fees consultants charge, and he submitted plans and specifications. The planning documents were sent to the Department and the Minister for Local Government had a good idea and wrote to us saying that we would have to re-examine the plans because there was a considerable amount of the locality in which this scheme was to operate already served by private pumps and minor water schemes. Back came the plans of the consultant and despite the fact that this water scheme had been promised to the people of Mid-Cork in a by-election and in the general election that followed because it would serve the entire Mid-Cork area, nothing has been done because the Minister has not tuppence ha'penny to spend on any scheme. I have been a member of the Northern Committee for upwards of 25 years and I know that the same applies as regards sewerage schemes. Probably before the next general election, they will all be revised, and we shall have somebody coming along trying to resurrect things of the past for the purpose of fooling the people of the future. I think, however, that business is rather overworked. Our people are more enlightened today than they were years ago.
I was dealing with the Minister for Transport and Power. When he spoke in Mallow and when the Taoiseach spoke to the electorate there, they did not tell the electorate, nor did Deputy Meaney or Deputy Crowley or Deputy Corry point out, that they would be closing down the railways and closing down the schools. They concealed that from the people.
We have now reached a stage when everybody knows that the Government have not sufficient money to run the country and as a result we are closing some of the schools and closing some of the railways. They are cutting down on sewerage, water and housing schemes. In addition, very little attention is paid to the weaker sections of the community and those in receipt of social welfare benefits. It is a very strange thing that when you have an increase given to a specific section of social welfare recipients, the old age pensioners, they are not entitled to get these increases until a specified time. It is no wonder that people are alarmed and starting to grumble and grouse about the Administration when they find the unfortunate old age pensioners, those receiving disablement allowances and widows' and orphans' pensions, must wait until next October to get their increase but the retiring Chairman of CIE got £8,000 and a £3,000 a year pension for life.
The people are sick of this and as a result we in the Labour Party decided to submit this no confidence motion to the House. No doubt it will have its effect in the country. Surely every Deputy is aware of the position. I want to tell the personal representative of the Taoiseach who is present that we have a considerable number of disgruntled people because they know how things are going at present. They know that down through the years they have been fooled by Fianna Fáil when they voted for Fianna Fáil. The writing is on the wall for the Government and I believe that if the Taoiseach gave the people an opportunity to vote they would quickly make up their minds on what form of Government they want.
Comment on this
It is usual to call alternate speakers. Is the Minister afraid to listen to me? I rose before the Minister.
Comment on this
In fairness, I should say that so far Fianna Fáil have taken up 2 hours 13 minutes; Fine Gael, 3 hours 2 minutes and the Labour Party 4 hours 20 minutes.
Comment on this
I am 34 years in this House and I have never yet seen any other procedure but that Fianna Fáil will offer to speak followed by Labour, followed by ourselves, followed again by Fianna Fáil, but if the Minister is afraid to hear me tonight, he will have to listen to me tomorrow.
Comment on this
(Cavan): On a point of order, could the position arise where 11 Ministers would troop in one after the other and speak one after the other for two hours each and exclude everybody else from this debate?
Comment on this
It would be most unlikely. The Chair would not agree to that if there were opposing speakers offering as debate would not be balanced.
Comment on this
Since the debate opened, four Fine Gael Deputies have been called, five Labour and four Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Why then should the Chair be blamed when a Fianna Fáil Deputy does offer and is called on?
Comment on this
May I say with respect that whatever the ruling of the Chair is, it does not reflect much credit on the Minister or the Government to which he belongs but he will hear me tomorrow.
Comment on this
I mean no personal discourtesy to the Minister. I merely claim the right on behalf of individual Deputies to be here. I am now a back bencher. I know that back benchers are entitled to the same protection from the Chair as Ministers or members of the Front Bench. This old tradition has existed which makes the House work. We are all equal here for the purpose of being heard. I am particularly anxious to intervene at this stage because of two things. Deputy Dowling, whom I always like to hear, complained that we had offered the Government of the day no advice. I want to submit to the Chair that we offered the Government of the day the only advice relevant to the situation in which we find ourselves: get out; go away; we will pay you to go away.
Comment on this
You are shouting for that for the past 30 years and, when you get the chance, you never can win. You could never win an election.
Comment on this
Let me deal with him. I shall go into the whole story. I have a great affection for the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. I represented him, and all belonging to him, for a long time here, before he ever got here at all. They are decent people. There are no better people in Ireland than the people of Donegal.
Comment on this
Coming from the part of the country from which he does, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs ought to observe better behaviour.
Comment on this
So far as Deputy Dowling is concerned, he got what he sought—constructive, useful advice, not from the point of view of any particular political Party but from the point of view of the country as a whole. I was particularly anxious to intervene at this stage because I was grateful to Deputy McAuliffe for dealing with the housing problem and I am particularly grateful to him for recalling the work of one of the most disinterested men I ever knew to sit in this House, the late Deputy Tim Murphy. I do not think it exaggeration on my part to say that he is amongst that select company of persons who killed himself in the service of our people. I remember the day he first fell ill at a meeting of the Government of which we were members together. He fell ill through overwork and his obsession was the housing of the people. I am happy to remember that that sense of obligation passed on to the late Deputy Michael Keyes and, in due course, to Deputy Pa O'Donnell. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said today that we put Fianna Fáil out of office only once and never got back again. Of course we got back again. We got back in 1951 and that was the period——
Comment on this
You voted for three different policies and you will not do it and you announced that you will not. You have officially stated that you will never do it again.
Comment on this
In respect of the period of the first inter-Party Government, 1948-51, I look back with satisfaction and gratification on the fact that we took the tubercular out of houses where they were dying and built sanatoria to such good effect that half of the sanatoria we built are now standing empty today. That was part of the work the late Deputy Tim Murphy did and the then Minister for Health, the former Deputy Dr. Browne, a disinterested public servant of our people. But that is not the end of the story.
When we returned to office in 1954, we found that the work to which we had put our hands to help our people had been allowed to falter and had been arrested by the Fianna Fáil Government but we put our hands to it again. I do not call in evidence any Deputy sitting on this side of the House. I call in evidence the present Taoiseach, Deputy Seán Lemass. He had it to tell in my presence in this House, within the past 12 months, that when the Government of which he was a member returned to office in 1957, he, as Tánaiste and Minister for Industry and Commerce, sent for the Dublin City Manager to know what requisitions Dublin Corporation would make on the resources of labour and material for housing in the city of Dublin and the City Manager's reply to him was, in effect: "Minister, we want no resources. Our problem in Dublin is that we have too many houses." That involved us in considerable financial difficulties but they were difficulties of which I am proud.
I consider that a good Government of this country is a Government that gets itself into financial difficulties housing the people. When I was Leader of the Fine Gael Party and an aspirant to the position of Taoiseach, I warned the people that if ever they elected me to that high office, I would put the finances of the country in jeopardy as often as necessary to house the people and that that would have a first charge upon the resources of this Party before skyscrapers were built, before any luxury offices were built to be leased by Government Departments for the accommodation of the bureaucrats of this country.
I do not deny that if we were the Government of this country, there might not be skyscrapers built in this city but we would not have it to tell that no Christian or other family in the city of Dublin today living less than five in a room will even be considered for a house—because that is the result of the nine years Fianna Fáil have been in office since 1957. Let us put this clearly in issue. If I had been Taoiseach, if Fine Gael had been the Government of this country, no skyscrapers would have been built until those families living five in one room had been housed in Christian decency. Let us join issue on that. Should we have had the skyscrapers or should we have had houses for the people? I said we should have houses for the people and those who did not like that could lump it so far as I was concerned and the plutocrats and the bureaucrats and all the other "crats" could sit wherever they sat for the past ten, 15 or 20 years——
Comment on this
——while I was providing houses for the people who are now living five in a room, with nowhere to go. But do not imagine that that truly paints the picture.
Do Deputies realise that since 1963 not one single residential unit in this country has been declared unfit for human habitation by Dublin Corporation? I know rooms in houses in this city which are rat warrens. I know rooms in this city in which elderly people are dying of neglect, through damp and cold, because Dublin Corporation does not dare to declare their place of residence unfit for human habitation until the architect warns them that, if they do not so declare it, it is liable to fall down.
Do you realise that at this moment, over and above the 700 families who have five people living in one room— and there are hundreds of families, in addition to them, who are four in one room and three in one room—there are hundreds of residents in this city who do not come within that category— elderly people, elderly married couples, elderly people living alone—who are living in accommodation that would have been, and should be, condemned as unfit for human habitation, but is not being condemned because, if it were, they would go on to the list of people in a preferential position, and Dublin Corporation has neither the money nor the means to house them?
Now, let us put these two policies in issue. I am proud of our effort. I am proud of the fact that the day we went out of office we were straining our resources, and asking the people to bear substantial burdens to get the economy back on an even keel, because we had deliberately sailed straight into the teeth of a storm in order to house the people; and, when the winds grew adverse, and the storm began to blow, there were a great many people in the Fianna Fáil Party who said: "Trim your sails; pull back; you are running into danger." Bill Norton's answer, Michael Keyes's answer, John A. Costello's answer, Gerard Sweetman's answer, and Pa O'Donnell's answer was: "We will ride it out until we put roofs over the people of this country and we will ask the people to bear whatever burden of inconvenience that may involve us in." And we did it, and we so disposed the resources of this country.
Having created an adverse balance of payments of close on £40 million a year in order to do it, within 12 months of the remedial measures we initiated, we presented this country, for the first time, outside the years of the war, since the State was founded, with a favourable balance of payments of £12 million. That is the bequest we left to the incoming Fianna Fáil Government. Before I am finished talking in this House on this motion of censure, I am going to tell the story of how they used that. I am going to tell the story of how they frittered it away; and I am going to tell it because it is part of the reason why the time has come to give them the answer that Deputy Dowling cried out for today: "Tell us," he asked, "what we ought to do?" The answer is: "Go away."
We will give every single one of them, and we have more Ministers in the Government today than we have ever had before, the maximum number that the Constitution will permit, and I will bind this Party now to give the whole gang of you a life pension of your total salary, if you will do one thing: simply go away. And it will be the best bargain the people of this country ever struck; and I am prepared to certify before the people value for their money they could not conceive or get.
Comment on this
We will do that cheerfully and, mark you, some of you are lively enough young pensioners, but I will take a chance on it, and I wish you well. And even if you lived to be nonagenarians, it would still be a good bargain.
Comment on this
It is true to say, I think, that with all the asperity of our debate, which is a healthy thing, no one will doubt that we would all wish to see you all nonagenarians in your own good time, as no doubt you are hoping and praying I also may be.
Comment on this
I agree that reflection on things past—rechercher le temps perdu—is perhaps an appropriate occupation for Marcel Proust, but not for Dáil Éireann; but, nevertheless, from le temps perdu there is much to be learned. I see some of the younger members of the Fianna Fáil Party here who find it hard to believe that what I am saying is true. I would urge them not to be too tragic about it. It is all true. It is the seamy side of the political life on which they are embarked. But they have all got the remedy in their own hands, and they can use it in God's good time: when these younger chaps have found what frauds they have for leaders, there is always the honourable course to follow—cross the floor.
Comment on this
Very aptly spoken, but luckily this country is in a formidable position and can build the dam to keep the deluge back. I will take the risk. Here is one finger that will go into the hole in the dam which your absence may create, and there will be no irreparable deluge, and that is something we ought to rejoice in. I once said to a distinguished fellow citizen that I thought the great difference—perhaps I had better not tell that story here. But there is a topic upon which I want to touch, and this also is for the instruction of the younger members of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
You will. I have great hopes of you. You are sitting very conveniently. You have only one more river to cross.
Comment on this
It is but a step from the Capitol to the Tarpeian Rock.
Comment on this
The exact relevance of that escapes me at the moment and I am anxious not to pursue it further, lest I strain your admirable patience, but, more especially, because I want to place it on the record that the matter with which I wish to deal now is the American Loan Counterpart Fund. It has been alleged by Fianna Fáil that we borrowed this money and spent it recklessly.
Comment on this
Squandered it. I want to make this clear now; not one single penny of the money received by way of grant or loan was spent by the Government of the Irish Republic. And, remember, it was we who declared that Republic. Every penny of that money was spent by citizens, who used the currency we borrowed from the United States of America to finance essential transactions, to preserve the housing industry, to preserve the agricultural industry——
Comment on this
I am only beginning. I will tell the rest of the story tomorrow. Here it is, 15 pages of it, an account for every year from 1949 down to today. I will read every figure in it tomorrow and I will show that we left the incoming Fianna Fáil Government £24 million intact and Fianna Fáil spent it in one month.