We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

National Loan, 1966. - Nomination of Members of Government.

Contributions 1–150 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Before the debate is resumed, I should like to raise a point of order, Sir. I understand that on a previous occasion when a motion of this nature was being discussed in the House, one of your predecessors ruled that any Member of the House whose name had been proposed to be a member of the Government was not permitted to intervene in the debate. So far no member of my Party whose nomination to be a member of the Government I propose in this motion has offered himself. But in the event of one of them wishing to do so, I am asking you, Sir, to give an indication of what your interpretation of that ruling is.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The position at the moment is that where Members of the House are proposed to be members of the Government, there is a convention that they do not speak in their own behalf on the motion for their nomination.

Comment on this

Unless they want to tell us what good fellows they are. It is a pity this was not raised the first day.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Is it a convention you propose to follow, Sir?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is a convention I propose to follow. I do not see any reason to depart from it.

I now call on Deputy O'Leary to resume.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

As I was saying when the debate was adjourned last week, one of our main objections to the composition of the Cabinet designated in the motion and one of our fundamental criticisms of it, quite apart from their policy, was that it did not appear that the nomination of those proposed for membership of the Cabinet came about as a result of the crucial test of their performance in the previous 18 months. Rather did it appear to be the case that rewards are doled out irrespective of performance in the past. I mentioned in particular the Minister for Social Welfare, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and the Minister for Local Government, and I remarked that the record of these Ministers would not inspire confidence to the extent that they should be given appointments in the new Cabinet. I said that, although I was in opposition to Fianna Fáil, I would not have thought that their talent was so restricted that the selection of new Ministers should be confined in this fashion, ignoring the test of their performance in the previous 18 months.

The amalgamation of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs with the Department of Transport and Power is welcomed and the Leader of our Party has asked for further amalgamation. Nevertheless, I am apprehensive that the greater controls we have seen exercised recently over the working of the Television Authority will be further emphasised under the new Minister. I am apprehensive lest the intimation we have had of a further and more rigid control in the exercise of journalistic integrity in RTE should be further intensified under the new Minister. Only today I received word that he is not able to reply to a question of mine regarding the position of journalists in RTE in connection with the presentation of news items. As I pointed out previously, RTE are in a very different position from any other State Board. After all, they have a direct influence on the moulding of opinion in this country. They are in close touch with the people in the presentation of news items and they have a sensitive effect on the thinking of our people.

Therefore, it is all the more important that their activities should stem from an impartial assessment of the news and that, although they are a State body, they should not be under the direct influence of any Government in this country. We have expressed our dissatisfaction in this House at the increased tendency of the Government to consider RTE to be their creature and plaything, to be used purely in the interests of giving a Party slant in news items. I hope the new Minister will reassure us that it is his intention that RTE will be allowed greater independence, greater autonomy and will be permitted to preserve a reasonable impartiality in the conduct of their service. The profession and the work of journalists should be respected in the Authority. A journalist should not be merely a copy typist, taking directions from above, but should bear the mark of his profession and at all times be honest in his assessment or interpretation of news items and in programme work generally in Telefís Éireann.

With regard to social welfare generally, the whole system of the present structure of social welfare payments seems virtually unchanged from the great period of its institution in 1911. We consider that the day is long past when there should be an immediate revision of the entire background of social welfare. The payment of benefits to old age pensioners and other social welfare recipients should more closely be related to the wages and incomes of others in our community. Recently, the British Government introduced a method whereby their social welfare payments would be related to incomes. We suggest that the same thing should be done here.

The record of the Minister for Social Welfare does not inspire in us any confidence that he is aware that there should be a re-appraisal of the entire method of social welfare payments. His behaviour has demonstrated an extremely old-fashioned line of thought in this area. He holds to a plimsoll line in respect of payments and prefers to keep to the methods of the past. For his lack of results in his Department, he was moved to the Department of Local Government, an area where the previous incumbent did not shine in the building of houses. Neither of these two Ministers is a man whose behaviour and record are sufficient to inspire or to recommend him for a further period as a Cabinet Minister. The housing record has been a grave disappointment, especially in Dublin and in the urban areas. The programme for the future does not reassure us that sufficient houses will be built in the years ahead in the areas where they are so vitally needed to cater for the needs which exist and will exist. The Ballyfermot and other proposed schemes will not come near to supplying the urban housing needs we have before us at the moment.

For the past month, Dublin Corporation have been involved in a reassessment of our housing needs. They have been looking over their entire list. I understand that the result of that examination may be such that the people involved in it may be forced to say, far from the corporation being able to deal with the remaining numbers, the hundreds of cases of families of five in one room, that they will have to attempt to house the families of six or seven in one room which they have discovered, as a result of this examination, still exist in large numbers. This is not a record we can be proud of in the area of housing.

The programme proposed by the Government does not give any confidence that the future in regard to housing will be better than the past. Yet the position is that the status of both of these Ministers is enhanced in the new Cabinet. Certainly, a more realistic assessment of what they deserve in this new Government would not have pushed them into these new Ministers. One hopeful thing is that the constituency of Deputy Boland, the Minister for Local Government designate, includes Ballyfermot, Dublin. A way of ensuring that the Minister is sensitive to urban housing needs is that his constituency is in an urban area. The previous Minister for Local Government, Deputy Blaney, could afford to cast, so to speak, a cold eye on housing needs because his constituency is in Donegal. If, in the past, Deputy Boland has not shown himself sensitive to social welfare, he may perhaps show himself to be sensitive to housing in future. He will have many calls on his time from people in his constituency of Ballyfermot to see what he will do about housing. Deputies of all Parties must, I am sure, be completely weary of constant appeals in relation to housing, especially in urban areas. We are weary of the continuing bad state of housing, and of explanations as to why planning had not taken place in sufficient time. We are very depressed and pessimistic indeed about the future in regard to housing. No modern Government should have as their excuse that, like the poor, housing problems will always be with us.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin): Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

I expect that we shall always have regard to the necessity for improvements in our housing stock. It is no exaggeration to say that the position in Dublin now in regard to housing is at crisis proportions. I would hope that the new Minister for Local Government could suffer a large-scale change of heart. I do not know if he can. However, he should attempt the exercise. From his record, I have not much evidence that he will. The situation, unfortunately, is extremely serious.

At the outset of this Cabinet, the new Taoiseach should state that the concern of political Parties from now on, in a modern electorate, must be what we loosely call the social needs of the people and he should at least declare the priorities of this new Cabinet. It is important that the House should know the areas of legislation and administration which will have the prior attention of this Government in their remaining period and therefore they should at least state their priorities.

On the whole Government, of course, falls the rather bad news which was related to us in the unemployment figures of the past year which became available to us in the past fortnight. We learn that, in the past year, we created 700 new jobs in industry. This is the record of a Government whose policies in regard to employment, if they cannot be described as marking time, are certainly losing their foothold. The number of new jobs required each year in manufacturing industry if this country is to keep pace with the number of people chasing jobs is of the order of 20,000. Deputies can figure out the failure over the past year when we remember that, instead of 20,000 jobs, we provided only 700 new jobs in manufacturing industry. The unemployment figure is made up, among others, of the number of people who are leaving the land and the number of school leavers who are looking for jobs. Over the same period, 7,000 persons have left agriculture and, in the previous year, 14,000 persons left agriculture. If this trend is not arrested quite rapidly, the gains that we had been making as a result of increased production and the upturn in our economy in recent years will very seriously be reversed.

We must bear in mind that the greater unemployment which is expected in Britain later this year will mean that our unemployment figures will be inflated because of a number of Irish people returning from Britain due to unemployment there. Again, consider the number of people who would normally emigrate, the people who, by their emigration, keep discontent out of this country in great proportion. It must be admitted that the emigration from rural areas has had a certain effect on the relief of discontent. If these persons had not left the constituencies of South Kerry and Waterford, then, in the next few weeks, there might be a far greater problem than there is there at present for the Government candidates because with those emigrants has gone much economic discontent that could be a realistic factor in both these areas. We can expect a return home of some of these emigrants in the next few months, according as the unemployment position in Britain becomes more serious.

I understand that what is required and what has been promised is a reexamination right away of our Second Programme for Economic Expansion now and what remnants of it can be salvaged. The Second Programme had certain targets in regard to employment and production. The target in regard to employment has been obvious for quite some period now. These targets have acquired, moreover, the atmosphere of a fairy tale. They appear to have no relationship to reality, and that we can see from month to month in the unemployment figures.

Among many things said by the former Taoiseach, Deputy Seán Lemass, was his declaration once— and I think this is the real acid test of achievement in this country—that the creation of increased employment as a result of Government activity was the real yardstick. This has always been considered by us to be the only realistic test of a Government's effectiveness in this country. From that point of view, this Government have fallen down during the past few years. They have not achieved any of the targets under the Second Programme. Indeed their failure in the area of adequate employment presents a large question mark in relation to the entire future of this country as an economically viable unit and in relation to whether this country can make its way in an increasingly competitive world.

That brings me to this point. How can we clear up the confusion which exists in regard to the Common Market? On this subject, we have experts here every day of the week, self-styled experts, from Brussels. We have people going to Brussels. It will be necessary to set up immediately an authoritative mission led by the Taoiseach, or some Minister, to go to Brussels to find out what are our Common Market expectations. What are our chances? What are our chances of entry to Europe in all this confusion? I know our hands are tied to those of Britain. The only explanation for the Free Trade Agreement was that we had no opportunity, no possibility whatever, of admission to Europe until we were tied completely to Britain.

This is an acknowledged fact. It is common knowledge in recent years. We are completely dependent on Britain. Judging from my own experience at conferences of the Labour Party at Brighton last year and at Blackpool and from what has been said by the British Government over the past years, Britain's entry into Europe will come later rather than sooner. Mr. Wilson last week merely reiterates pious aspirations in regard to Europe. He in no way binds himself to commitments in regard to entry and I think that the French future assessment of Britain's application is a realistic one. There was nothing new in Mr. Wilson's statement. It was merely a list of pious wishes in regard to European unity.

In any case, for our own peace of mind and to ease the economic grip in which this country will find itself in the future, it will be necessary for this Government to clarify immediately, or as soon as possible the commitments in relation to entry into Europe and to explore fully the possibility of associate membership of the Community.

From first to last, the Labour Party have been extremely concerned about the unprepared state of Irish industry in the face of the monopoly competition we will experience on our entry into Europe. On the part of many Deputies there is a kind of euphoria about our chances of entry to Europe, a kind of enthusiasm which must be based on their complete ignorance of Irish industry, the unpreparedness of Irish industry, and a complete unawareness of the ineffectiveness of the management we have.

There have been many official recommendations and reports over past years. The last report I read was the report of the Industrial Reorganisation branch which in no unmistakable terms said that Irish management was not making an effort to tailor its plans to freer trade conditions. In this situation it strikes me as being very foolish, indeed, to talk about our preparedness and our readiness to take on the challenge of entry to Europe. It appears to me that before anybody talks about freer trade, he should take the precaution of examining the situation that exists throughout this country. Picture that, and it will be accepted that there are no grounds for complacency. Can we not have fewer after-dinner speeches and can we not ensure that Irish management is doing its job?

This has been called a youthful Cabinet. There is one thing about youth; one can appear youthful in physical appearance but one's ideas may belong to the Stone Age. It is not sufficient to look to youth; one must also have regard to the corollary. One must at least be up to date as to what polities means in these days. In this sense I am not convinced that the proposed members of the Cabinet are youthful. They may appear to be physically youthful, but they have no youthful ideas. They are not disposed to pursue new and active policies in regard to the problems facing this country.

Another question facing this Government, on the home front as well, is the necessity of seeking some results in regard to Government reform and electoral reform in regard to Northern Ireland primarily. It appears to me that Captain O'Neill has become extremely popular on this side of the Border over the past year or so, and for no real reason. There has been no real improvement in the lot of Catholics in the Six County area during Captain O'Neill's term of office, apart from economic speeches and references to the need for more amity between the religions here and in the North. He has done nothing to improve the electoral position. He has done nothing about discrimination in regard to housing and employment. If there are to be any more cross-Border smiles and cordial meetings, we should ask about the progress or otherwise of better relations in the Northern area.

It appears to me that we must begin to search for the facts in Northern Ireland. It is all the more important that we should do so, in view of the fact that no Parliament has ever concentrated on the actual status of the Six Counties. At this period we would be fully doing our duty as people to look for greater democracy in that area, but we would not be discharging that duty if the people representing our own Government were themselves to be guilty of evading awkward questions in regard to the Northern area. I am all for the improvement of relations between North and South but I do not think improvements in the democratic position in that area will be made by ignoring the awkward reality, and if the awkward reality is nice talk from Captain O'Neill but no action, I think it is time we called his bluff and I do not think we will be the losers for it.

Comment on this

Do you think Captain O'Neill is bluffing?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

I certainly do. He has done nothing to improve the position.

Comment on this

The talks with Captain O'Neill were a tremendous breakthrough.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

Captain O'Neill and the Unionist administration of Northern Ireland have done nothing to improve the situation up there in regard to discrimination.

Comment on this

The Deputy should leave that to Gerry Fitt. Statements like that will not help.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

I stand over the statement. It is my honest assessment of the situation. I do not see why any Member of this Parliament should ignore the reality as he sees it. As I said, in my opinion, the time for bluff is over and we should begin to ask honest questions. We should ask Captain O'Neill whether he is the liberal he says be is or whether he is merely making sweet speeches with no action. I have in mind particularly what exactly he means by his reference to the "Trojan Horse" of the community in the area recently. At a time when the Westminster Parliament is concentrating on problems in that area. it is time our Government should also begin to ask questions. I do not think that evading awkward questions serves the cause of North-South co-operation, better relations, greater understanding and the advent of greater democracy in the northern area. For too long we have acted on the basis that we must not ask any awkward questions and must evade attempts to improve the situation up there. Now that the honeymoon is over, we must begin to ask questions and we will not be the losers for it.

This administration represents a break, probably the first real break in Irish politics over the past 40 years. Now, at last, we have turned the corner and the revolutionary legacy and that period is behind us. We must look to the 1970s and the remaining 35 years of this century. It appears to me that the time is opportune, speaking in a very impartial way, for the Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil Parties to come together in a more concrete fashion than heretofore.

The new Taoiseach can be described as a man with no personal enemies, and indeed most of the Ministers in his Cabinet have no personal enemies or no personal interest in the continuance of old quarrels. Since there is a great deal of agreement, we understand, between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael on such matters as their attitude to proportional representation and their attitude to the trade unions, it appears to me that this area of common interest should be further explored. There may be a possibility that if this were done and a domestic ecumenical movement opened up under a recognised third party to examine what are the current differences in 1966 between the chief Opposition Party and the Government, it would do a great deal to rationalise and clarify the position. The time has come to bury the hatchet and if neither Party has a grudge or quarrel between themselves, if their quarrels can be consigned to the period of the Civil War and thereafter, the time has come for a large gesture to be made. The seating arrangements of this House will be no problem. The Labour Party are quite prepared to sit over there on the left and we will allow you to sit on the right.

Comment on this

The right of the Chair, of course.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

This is something that could be examined in greater detail. I only throw it out as a thought since we have turned this corner and it should be definitely explored. I would appeal to the younger elements in both Parties to see that there is a career to be made and it would be an interesting development in our public life if they began to take a look at the reunification of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael as a strong conservative Party in this country.

Comment on this

Will you not lose a few in the process of going over there?

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin): Deputy Dillon was asking the Labour Party to join them the other day.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

Deputy Dillon is a very hospitable man. He asked us before and you know what we said.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Constitution Committee will legalise political divorce.

Comment on this

Perhaps we could deal with what is on the Order Paper.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary must remember he is a member of a politically divorced Party—divorced from Fine Gael since the last Coalition.

Comment on this

A very conservative Party.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

I throw this out as a helpful suggestion. It is a new period and from what we have seen in the past few weeks, there are elements in the Fianna Fáil Party who detest one another more seriously than in Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it this is a criticism of the nominees of the Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Mr. O' Leary

Yes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I should like to see it more closely adhered to. It seems to be very general.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

From the amount of coalition we have seen growing up in the Fianna Fáil Party, a coalition which now governs, it seems that the period has come when they should examine whether there are greater friends of theirs in the Fine Gael Party than may be present in the Fianna Fáil Party. I put it to the three camps or the two camps, or whatever number there are in Fianna Fáil, that the time has come when there may be more allies in Fine Gael than in their own Party.

It appears to me that political life would be improved if there were greater rationalisation and if the electorates in Kerry and Waterford had clear issues put to them. Political life would be better for it.

Comment on this

How are you going to do it?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

If the employment position cannot be improved and if we cannot reverse this disastrous trend over the past year, in which we created merely 700 new jobs, if this cannot be corrected, I do not see the sense of getting involved in manpower policies and training and re-training. The kind of activities that trade unions have been able to go through in Europe with the management and the experiments they have been able to make in Europe and the gains made by their economists have been made against a background of economies that were approaching full or near full employment. If the position, employmentwise, in this country disimproves still further, manpower policies and training and re-training and the Department of Labour will certainly be up against a great deal of trouble. With regard to the Minister for Labour, I certainly wish him well in his future activities and I see nothing in his record in the past that I would join issue with. As I said last week, it is not my purpose in speaking to bother myself overmuch about the personal habits, idiosyncrasies or failings of any of the incumbents but purely to trace their records in their Departments.

I would hope that the new Ministers would clarify the position that presently exists, the ambiguity that exists between the chief civil servants of their Departments and themselves in regard to the handling of their Departments. I have in mind the recent problem in regard to Mr. Whitaker in the Department of Finance and the new Minister designate.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

There was no problem. The Deputy should not be repeating untruths.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

I understood there was.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

None whatever.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

In general terms, it appears to me that principal officers and higher civil servants should not be asked to present purely political speeches, if they must present speeches because of the Minister's inability to be present. Any Minister in his use of civil servants should stick as far as possible to impartial assessments rather than use civil servants to relay a particular piece of purely Party slanted information on any particular occasion. It is expecting too much of civil servants to ask them to present views exclusive to the political Party in power. Their position should not be abused by asking them to pass on political messages.

We cannot hope that our criticism of the proposed Government will register in a majority vote. The assessment of the position must lie with the approaching by-elections. They will give us the nearest thing we can get for the moment to the verdict of the people on the record of Government. In giving their verdict, the people must bear in mind the present state of agriculture and all that was said about the new era in agriculture as a result of the Free Trade Agreement. They must judge whether in fact these improvements have come about and whether they can look forward in future to the prosperity they should enjoy. They must bear in mind that the population in both Waterford and South Kerry has fallen and that fall is itself an assessment of the effectiveness of government in the period since the last census of population was taken. These by-elections will be the first testing ground of this proposed Cabinet. It is our intention now to draw attention to the lack of progress made by Ministers in their respective Departments.

I said at the outset that I could see no reason why Fianna Fáil should restrict themselves to the same old faces. Would it have been a different Cabinet, had some other contender achieved the chief executive position? The Taoiseach has not been adventurous enough in his choice of personnel. There are people on his back benches who would be just as good as some of those appointed to office.

We have entered a new era in politics. We have, I hope, left behind us the old quarrels; political division in the future should, I think, be based rather on the problems of the day rather than the problems of yesterday. The new Taoiseach represents the new man in Irish politics, someone who has no axe to grind because of the past. Our Party have always looked forward to the day when that situation would arrive and it would be possible for us to concentrate less on purely political issues. I suggest that some enterprising backbenchers in Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil should take their courage in their hands now and consider areas of co-operation between the two Parties.

Comment on this

I realise why Deputy O'Leary threw out that thought in the closing stage of his excellent address. He was running out of ideas. With charity in my heart for the slaves of history, may I say that the real victim of historical associations is Deputy O'Leary himself? He comes from a Fianna Fáil family. Like many who find themselves disillusioned with Fianna Fáil and who are unable, at one step, to cross the floor of the House to the Fine Gael Party, Deputy O'Leary has used the Labour Party as a step nearer; there is for him in the radical Party of the new Ireland, the Fine Gael Party, every opportunity to earn the laurels that young people like him should be anxious to earn.

The fact of the matter is that the one Party who have issued an historical thesis, the one Party who have set out at great length a social philosophy, are the Fine Gael Party. Neither of the other Parties has yet done this, although, at the last general election, we had the Taoiseach promising in desperation and in the excitement of the last few days of the campaign that, together with the Second Programme for Economic Expansion, his Party would produce a first programme of social policies. We are still waiting for that. Now he has gone and we are led to believe that those who encouraged him to go themselves believe in the same things. We shall wait with great interest to hear the social outlook of a Government who, over the past seven or eight years, have almost halved the share of the gross national product earned by social welfare recipients. That is the indication of their radical social approach.

The real difficulty with so many people here is that they are unable to think in terms of 1966 and their views are confined entirely to the kind of political muck manufactured and thrown by the Fianna Fáil Party in their political infancy. The result is that there are people who are unable to sit down now in independent judgment of events and trends in the 1960s and what will be the inevitable trend of events in the 1970s. One can only hope that, with the passage of years, wisdom will come to them and they will see and mend the error of their ways.

Of the outgoing Government, it can be fairly said, I think, that it portrayed very little ability. Whatever ability there was, Deputy Seán Lemass had a monopoly of it. In recent years many people concerned for the welfare of the nation had not a little sympathy for Deputy Lemass. Now the one man with a modicum of ability has gone and poor old Ireland is left with the duds to struggle through until such time as Ireland gets the Government she deserves, a Fine Gael Government.

The tragedy is that this one man with some ability left in such indecent haste. God knows, perhaps it was that in the autumn of his days, his conscience has begun to prick him and he realises that every promise he made in the last general election has been broken by him. Instead of his leading the country, the country has been shuffling and dragging its feet. On three different occasions I had to remind him of his promise to retire, but that the manner of his going should be so injurious to the national interest is something for which he will never be forgiven, because what he has done is to do untold harm to public morale.

Comment on this

It is you who are doing untold harm to public morale with these hysterics.

Comment on this

We in the Fine Gael benches have never doubted the lack of ability or never doubted the real ambitions of the individuals forming the Fianna Fáil administration and their loquacious backbenchers. We are concerned, however, that at a time when this country's standing financially and tradewise is so low the Taoiseach should have decided to leave the sinking ship like a certain class of vermin which parliamentary rules do not permit me to designate.

Comment on this

It is your interpretation and it is totally untrue.

Comment on this

These things are extremely serious. We have had a certain amount of pantomime in the course of this debate, however. We were asked to vote for the new mixture or, shall I say, for the same mixture after it has been shaken: because Deputy Aiken was a soldier of Ireland, when they were few, because Deputy Childers had a great father, because Deputy Boland, when Minister for Social Welfare, interpreted the laws as they were, because Deputy Lenihan is a kindly gentleman, because Deputy Haughey was a keen businessman before he came into the House, because Deputy O'Malley was one of the most lovable characters of all times, because Deputy Moran increased all farm holdings to 45 acres——

Comment on this

Fifty acres.

Comment on this

——because Deputy Dr. Hillery was a man of great patience and goodwill, because Deputy Hilliard was a very courteous and kindly fellow, because Deputy Blaney was not as successful as he might have been, because of the credit squeeze, because Deputy Flanagan was a young man, because Deputy Brennan had a kindly heart, and because Deputy Colley—guess the description —was a gracious man. Now this eulogy was given to us by one of the senior members of the Fianna Fáil Party, a member talking with the great wealth of 21 years of public experience behind him. These are the only things he can commend to the Irish people as justification for giving our votes to the new administration. We would be less than fair to the people of Ireland if we allowed our votes this evening to be swayed by such claptrap as that.

The truth is that in the Cabinet which the caretaker Taoiseach puts before us for approval, we have his deputy, the assistant Leader of the Government, Deputy Aiken, who thinks that Deputy Lynch should not be Taoiseach. We have indeed Deputy Lynch himself who thinks he should not be Taoiseach, and the only reason he is Taoiseach is that he is not quite as bad as either Deputies Haughey or Colley. We have Deputy Aiken, as I have mentioned, who thinks that Deputy Colley should be Taoiseach; we have Deputy Colley who thinks that Deputy Colley should be Taoiseach; and we have Deputies Haughey, Blaney, Lenihan and Boland who think that Deputy Lynch should not really be Taoiseach and that Deputy Colley should not be Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Tell us why you should be.

Comment on this

This is the Government supposed to have collective responsibility, supposed to be capable of discharging their national duty, but every other member of it has no confidence or faith in his neighbour. One might well ask why they hang together and the reason, of course, is fairly simple: if they did not, they would all hang separately and each Member going into the Lobby tonight will go in for that reason and that reason alone. It reminds me of what was once said about Voltaire. It was said of Voltaire that if he did not exist, nobody could ever invent him. Well, it can truthfully be said that if this Government and the motley Party behind them did not exist, nobody could ever invent them, no matter how sick might be his mind. If the division in the Government Party were an honourable one, even if this difference of opinion were honourably arrived at, one could respect men of dignity and independence in different opinions but we had the unseemly conduct of Prince Monolulu of Mid-Cork capering round the corridors of this House and elsewhere for days on end shouting that he had one political horse after another and inviting the members of his Party to bid on his political advice. Nor was he alone; there were two further Lana Machree dogs in Munster taking not two but several sides of the road with them, in the indecent hope that by lobbying for the right person at the right time, some Parliamentary Secretaryship or other position of status for themselves might be available.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is getting his metaphors mixed now.

Comment on this

Maybe the Deputy is getting his metaphors mixed but it ill becomes the Taoiseach to talk about mixtures at this time. The indignity of what has happened here has done untold harm to the national morale and nothing, except a complete flushing out of office of the Party on the opposite side of the House, will ever repair the national honour and conscience.

There are other difficulties facing this country and there will be so long as we have the present Administration. One was indicated in a fairly recent speech of the outgoing and now designate Minister for Justice. In the one speech which he delivered, he, rightly, condemned rowdy gangs and teddy boys, people who produced flick knives and bottles to damage their fellow beings and he rightly said that all the power of Government would be brought to bear to stamp out this tremendous social evil. But in the same breath as he uttered this, in the same breath as he issued this warning against the disreputable minority in our community who act in that particular anti-social manner, he also issued a similar threat and a similar warning in identical words against what he called the unofficial strikers.

Now it strikes me that there is a tremendously dangerous threat to our liberty and there is an appalling confusion of values when a Minister for Justice, who as well as keeping the law, must respect the rights of the individual, classifies in the same way the person who produces and harms his neighbour with a flick knife and a bottle and some person who rightly or wrongly takes what we term unofficial strike action. In one case you have a person who is clearly anti-social, without respect for his fellow human beings; in the other case, you have a worker who has a sense of grievance— whether or not it is justified does not matter—who uses strike action or some other protest to secure what he considers to be a fair reward for his services and labour. For any Government or Party to treat those two individuals as one and the same enemy of the community is particularly dangerous, and is an indication of the intolerance of the present Government. It should also be, for thinking people, a reason why this Government should be put out of office.

I was sorry to hear Deputy O'Leary, with his background of Fianna Fáil association, suggesting that Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have the same outlook on matters of trade unionism. He knows that is not so, and I think that on reflection he will agree it is not so. It is not so. In the heads of policy which the Government circulated some time ago to the trade union movement and others, they indicated that it was their intention to discipline the trade union movement, and that, according to their silly theories, they were going to bring about industrial peace through governmental sanctions.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

On a point of order, is Deputy Ryan's brother not a member of Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

We of the Fianna Fáil Party——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

"We of the Fianna Fáil Party"!

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has no knowledge of who is a member of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

His own brother is.

Comment on this

We of the Fine Gael Party have made it clear in regard to this admission of failure, that we regard this as treating the symptoms as the cause of the disease, and we completely repudiate this effort to discipline the trade union movement and to impose sanctions and penalties on people in a false effort to achieve industrial peace. I think the Labour Party and ourselves are in agreement on that. It may be that some people do not regard that as a fundamental difference between us and those on the opposite side of the House. I regard it as extremely fundamental, and it would trip me up from ever taking the step which Deputy O'Leary has suggested. We put down an amendment which the Labour Party prevented us from voting upon. We wanted to limit it to the duration of the emergency which existed, and I am sure the Labour Party would now join us in voting for our Bill which seeks to repeal the Act in question.

Comment on this

Did you not vote for the Bill?

Comment on this

One matter at a time.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not talk out of both sides of his mouth.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Deputy Ryan must be allowed to make his statement without interruption.

Comment on this

It is very difficult not to interrupt.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It may be difficult, but there are many difficult things that can be done.

Comment on this

This is good practice for the hustings. The people of Kerry and Waterford——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us leave that for the present. Let us have the nominees of the Taoiseach, and those alone.

Comment on this

For some time past the members of the outgoing Government have not been as attentive to their ministerial duties as they should have been. We are aware that some members of the Government have spent some time and effort and energy in attending to their own private professions, and business interests. This is an indication either that they have too little to do as Ministers or that they are neglecting their ministerial duties. That either situation should exist is deplorable. What is worse is——

Comment on this

We are entitled to the facts.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Andrews should restrain himself.

Comment on this

I find it difficult to restrain myself when the Deputy is making unsubstantiated statements like that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has his remedy. He must restrain himself.

Comment on this

It is terribly important——

Comment on this

That the Deputy should substantiate what he is saying.

Comment on this

——that Ministers should not engage in their private professions and business interests, because to do so is wrong, but it is equally important that they should not be in a position to give any reason for suspicion that in the operation of their professional or business interests, they made use of, or allowed use to be made of, their public office to their own advantage or to the advantage of their clients. What I am saying is known to the members of the Government. What I am saying is known to the Taoiseach. I suggest he is not discharging his public duty correctly if he fails to say to the members of the incoming Cabinet whom he hopes to get elected tonight, that they must cease engaging in professional and business interests of any kind so long as they are Ministers, and that if they are not agreeable to do this, they should not accept the seals of their new office. So long as the situation which existed in the past few years continues to exist, there will be every reason to doubt the integrity of the members of the Government, and to doubt the fairness of some decisions which have been made in some Departments which have worked to the great advantage of people in close proximity to Ministers who either made the decisions or were in a position to influence the decisions.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

This is the Deputy who was talking about mud-slinging a while ago.

Comment on this

This is quite true, and it will not take any great amount of research to establish how many hours some members of the Government have been spending in their offices, nor will it be difficult to ascertain where some of them have spent their long week-ends. If this matter is not rectified immediately by the incoming Government, they can expect that this matter will be brought very much to the fore, and that steps will be taken to purify the activities in the ministerial field. These things are very much in the minds of those of us who will be voting against the nominees whom the Taoiseach has put before us. Equally important is the failure of the same team under a different captain, a far more able captain, to achieve what they promised us they would achieve.

The rate of unemployment has multiplied in recent weeks. It has gone up by almost 8,000 in the past six weeks, and so far the Government have failed to take any steps to arrest this trend. This comes at the end of a continual increase which has been operating over the past year. We have now arrived at a position in which, if the unemployment figures were assessed on the old basis, we would have about 65,000 people unemployed. After we were assured that we would have 100,000 new jobs under the same Administration, we now have 65,000 unemployed and, as I say, this rate has multiplied in recent weeks and there is no indication that the Government are taking any steps to rectify that situation.

The loan which has been mentioned today will in substantial part be used to pay off old debts. The remainder is barely sufficient to maintain the already inadequate amount of work in the public sector and there is no indication whatsoever that the Government have been doing anything to arrest the speedy increase in the number of unemployed people in recent weeks.

The Government's much vaunted programme of expansion anticipated an annual emigration rate of 18,000 people. We in the Fine Gael benches expressed the view that this was an admission of failure, but if it had operated at that figure, at least it could be said that the Government were fulfilling their promise. But the rate now lies between 20,000 and 30,000 a year and last year it was more than 20,000 and all the indications are that the Government are not taking any steps to rectify this situation.

We were also promised in the Government's programme 78,000 new jobs by 1970. The number of new jobs provided to date is only 4,000, leaving us with 74,000 new jobs to be provided during the next three years. All the indications so far are that they have not the least hope of coming anywhere near their target. In educational matters, the Government have no policy whatsoever to meet the critical need for better educational facilities here.

Comment on this

What about the Just Society?

Comment on this

In our programme Towards a Just Society, the matter is extensively dealt with. The members of Fianna Fáil who are so interested may have it on paying one shilling but, lest they are unwilling to do so, I shall quote from sub-paragraph (6) on page 23:

Fine Gael will introduce a system to enable every child capable of benefiting from further education to proceed from the national school right through to the university, irrespective of the financial circumstances of the child's parents.

The matter is extensively dealt with in that document as a matter of the Party's policy. It is not the weekend fancy of a man invited out to dinner. It is not an effort by one individual to embarrass his Party by projecting something and then saying the Party cannot without loss of face let him down. It is a statement which was published more than 18 months ago; it is something which we in Fine Gael are unanimously behind.

We have yet to get any indication from the outgoing Government that they as a Government support the man in question who promised certain things at a weekend dinner a few months ago, but the man in question has had to issue a public threat to ensure he will get what he wants—that he will resign unless he gets it. Nobody in the Fine Gael Party has had to say he will resign from the Party unless he gets it. These are our views. This document, and many other documents already published and many others yet to be published will be in the name of the Fine Gael Party, without personal vendettas, and I trust that for as long as they may remain in power, the Government will study these Fine Gael documents as they have done in the past. Whatever good they have been able to produce in recent years has been stolen from us.

As another test of the Government's confusion in educational matters, let us deal with another promise, made three years ago. They promised a scheme under which they would pay 60 per cent on the repayment of capital and interest in respect of mortgage loans privately arranged by schools for their secondary school building programme. As a result of that statement, made by a predecessor of the present incumbent, many schools delayed their building programmes; many schools who had privately arranged to build out of their own resources and who had made arrangements for private loans, postponed them in the hope of getting something out of what Santa Claus had promised.

The result was that the secondary school building programme was delayed for two years. I am not sure what the total number of the schools involved is in November, 1966, but earlier this year the total number of schools that had been approved by the Department was 14 or 15. The capital commitment for this programme was about £4½ million, the State's involvement being in the region of £2½ million. In relation to this, the Government, who pretend to be interested in education and in doing something for it, have so far paid a measly £13,000 out of a commitment of £2½ million. Two schools were involved in this. Untold damage has been done by this delay in the building of urgently-needed secondary schools.

In the meantime, schools which had made their own arrangements for their own loans have found that because of the Government's mismanagement of the financial situation, the interest rates on the loans have been increased by one or two per cent so that even with the help they will now get from the Government, because of the delays the Government have created, their burden will be almost as great as it would have been if the State had never intervened with these reckless promises made without any regard to the Government's disposition to perform them.

Perhaps there is no field of social need which has been so neglected by the outgoing Government and the Government designate as the field of health. Fianna Fáil forced through the 1953 Health Act after years of division and unnecessary argument, notwithstanding the fact that they were shortly afterwards replaced by a Government who sank their political animosities in their anxieties to try to make that Act work.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

If the Act was no good, why did they not throw it out?

Comment on this

Though the Fianna Fáil administration have for 13 years tried to make that Act work, it has not done so. It has crumbled in their hands as Fine Gael forecast it would.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Why did you not throw it out?

Comment on this

We alone voted against the 1953 Act because we in Fine Gael regarded it as no more than a growth on a Victorian plant, something which could not provide for our people the type of health scheme which a modern society should have. In 1961 we in Fine Gael, in another effort to get things put right, tabled a motion here which was debated at length, seeking to have a new health scheme introduced on the basis of the Fine Gael programme for a national health service. Our efforts in that respect were defeated, not on the merits of the motion, because the Members of the House never got an opportunity to vote on the merits, but by a slick performance by the Fianna Fáil Party who, instead of voting on the issue, proposed to set up a Committee and this received the support of a number of so-called Independents and as a result delayed the provision of a decent health service for the country.

Comment on this

It is better to be a so-called Independent than a member of Fine Gael.

Comment on this

These are not matters for scoring political points. They are matters affecting the health, the convenience, the lives of the little people, the people who matter, and throughout those years there has been more unnecessary suffering in this country, more disabled people and deaths that could have been prevented simply because we dragged our feet in the matter of the provision of health services and because we still apply in relation to entitlement to free medical services the same tests as were applied by Queen Victoria 120 years ago—a test of whether an applicant is able out of his income or other lawful means to pay for health services.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is scarcely relevant in a debate on the formation of a Government.

Comment on this

Except that the Government we are asked to approve tonight are entirely composed of people who have followed policies which we in Fine Gael are unable to accept and because so far we have had no indication from any member on the Government side that there will be any change of heart. In fact, nothing has been said in the course of this debate by any Member on the Government side of the House.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We cannot speak.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach, I take it, is disowning the people behind him who spoke.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy referred to members of the Government.

Comment on this

I am talking about the people on the Government side of the House, the people who will go through the division lobbies tonight to vote for the Cabinet which the Taoiseach has put before us. They have not, so far, given any reason why we should support the administration which the Taoiseach has put before us, except that they will continue the policies which they have already been executing. On that account we are unable to give our support to the administration suggested by the Taoiseach.

With regard to housing, we of the Fine Gael Party regard it as a matter of fundamental principle that social investment must progress side by side with economic development. That is another reason why notwithstanding the anxiety of some people who have political stepping stones provided for them we of the Fine Gael Party can never join forces with the Fianna Fáil Party. In the present administration's programme, it is a cardinal principle that what they regard as the most economic investment must be secondary. They say expenditure on housing, education, health services is a social expenditure and that it cannot assist economic growth. The present administration say it is wrong to spend money on such services which have not got a return in competitive goods and services. I am quoting from their own philosophy, from their own approach to things.

I believe the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party are at one in saying that social investment must move step by step with economic growth and it is a sham to suggest that we should slow down the pace of economic growth. This has happened here and because of this erroneous policy, there has been a great amount of human misery. The Government programmes for economic investment anticipated that there would be a decline in social investment. They made no effort to arrest what they assured us would happen. In fact, they did everything possible to hasten it. The result is the number of houses built by public authorities here and the number of new dwellings built by the public sector were sliced by three-fourths.

The situation in Dublin was even worse. Before the Fianna Fáil administration came into power, we were building 1,500 houses a year. This figure was reduced year by year during the Fianna Fáil administration down to the miserly number of 270. The result is that the chief medical officer has recommended that there are 650 families in urgent need of housing. Those families represent a husband, wife and three children, who are eating, sleeping, and washing in one room. We have over 1,500 families of husband, wife and two children who are eating, sleeping and washing in one room. We have on the chief medical officer's list 5,000 families who are in urgent need of priority in the matter of housing. This represents perhaps 20,000 to 25,000 human beings in those appalling housing conditions. The situation represented by the chief medical officer does not include more than 5,000 other families whose reward is ill-health and whose plight is so serious. That is a very urgent housing situation from the chief medical officer's point of view.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to refer to housing in a general way. He is not entitled to give a full description of the housing situation on the motion on the formation of the Government.

Comment on this

I have no anxiety to go into detail, but, with respect, I would submit that it is not incorrect to illustrate the argument by a few typical examples. Everything I have said about Dublin could also be said with regard to the rest of the country.

Comment on this

There are 1,000 houses vacant in Dublin.

Comment on this

I see opposite me, and I now hear him, bless his heart, Deputy Paudge Brennan, who was Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government. In 1965, he issued a pamphlet quoting a number of newspaper headlines from 1958 in which some builders were complaining about the pace of building activity. I invite him now to look at the newspapers published in this country during the past 18 months. He will find that builders and architects, local authorities, people seeking houses, have banded themselves together and are building houses in desperation because of the urgent need for houses. This is their condemnation of the Deputy and his Party for the colossal slump which has taken place in housing over the past few years. They have rightly condemned the Government for failing to maintain the same percentage of subsidy on housing as existed before this unfortunate administration took office. The Deputy knows that what I say is absolutely true and if he had even a modicum of conscience, he would admit it is right.

Comment on this

More money than ever was spent on housing.

Comment on this

Apart from what was acknowledged as the housing requirements by the bureaucrats, we have another desperate situation in Dublin. Prior to 1963, about 600 houses per year were condemned as unfit for human habitation, but since 1963 no examination of houses, basements, garrets, caravans or tents has taken place to assess whether or not they were fit for human habitation. No garret, basement room, return room, scullery or bathroom has been inspected to see whether or not it is unfit for human habitation and no such place has been condemned as unfit for human habitation.

Indeed, many of the places which were condemned as unfit for human habitation prior to 1963 are now occupied by families and public authorities are afraid to expel them from those places because they would have nowhere else to go. We are building up a new social evil, a new sore which one of these days will open and burst forth with a flow of evil, the consequences of which it is almost impossible to visualise. All the Government can do is to say: "We will take no notice of those things. We will not condemn any place as unfit for human habitation. We will not allow that on our conscience. We have enough on our conscience already."

We have, in the matter of industrial relations, a continuing increase in the number of industrial disputes and in no field of activity is this greater than in the public sector where there is an increasing amount of discontent. What have we from the Government in relation to this? We have not seen any effort on their part so far to assess the real causes of the disagreement which exists between people who produce wealth in this country. That is all that we have to try to arrive at and what we should try to prevent, but all that the Government have so far suggested are new rules for the declaration and waging of industrial war. We do not think that is the kind of assistance this country needs. We do not think that that is the kind of help people want in order to get this country moving along the correct lines again.

Reference has been made in this debate to the Free Trade Agreement which the Government put before us earlier this year and suggestions have been made by some people that we in the Fine Gael Benches gave that Agreement our unqualified support. I have to remind people—it should not be necessary, but apparently they consider that their political fortunes depend on misleading the people about what Fine Gael have done or will do —that we tabled a very seriously considered amendment to the motion seeking approval of that Agreement and we asserted quite clearly that we considered that the Government had failed to negotiate the safeguards which were necessary to protect our industry, and that they had also failed to take the steps necessary to buttress our agricultural industry.

If the events of recent months indicate anything, they indicate how correct Fine Gael were in their view that the Government had failed to take the steps necessary to protect industry and to provide the right kind of markets for agriculture. We are now paying the price. We have every reason to fear that in their belated negotiations with the European Economic Community they will make the same bloomers as they made in relation to the Free Trade Agreement. Nothing they have ever done in the field of international trade can give us any reason to believe that they will negotiate a safe entry— and I use that word advisedly—into the European Economic Community, or that they are capable of negotiating any interim arrangement such as has been negotiated by Denmark, Austria——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

What has Denmark done?

Comment on this

While we——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

What has Denmark done?

Comment on this

Austria.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Denmark has been trotted out here.

Comment on this

All right; Denmark has explained her position to the EEC——

Comment on this

And Greece.

Comment on this

——which is more than we have done. Some of us who were privileged to be in Brussels last year, the year before the Government thought of sending anybody there, found that the people in the EEC were bewildered by Ireland's performance. They knew that for centuries Ireland had waged war against Britain. They knew that we had a different economic structure from that of Britain and they knew that Britain's economic and financial hold on Ireland was something we were anxious to break. They were bewildered that instead of seeking new opportunities in Europe, we were concentrating our efforts on the British market. What we voted on last year only helped to increase the grip Britain has on our economy.

We in the Fine Gael Party have never made little of the opportunities which the British market affords us. We assert now as in the past that it would be sheer lunacy to ignore them. We think that the conduct of the Fianna Fáil Party in choosing to ignore them was unfortunate, to say the least. However, I am not going back over that field. We do say that in 1966 it is equally important to try to negotiate markets elsewhere. The Government have failed miserably in this regard. There are indications in the unemployment figures, and from the type of unemployment which is developing, that a significant proportion of it is coming as a result of redundancy and the rearrangements which are being made to face the more open market conditions which will flow from the British Agreement and any future agreements that may be made. Those indications are there, but notwithstanding those indications and the appeals made to the Government to provide an adequate system of redundancy payments and retraining, the Government in this field are also dragging their feet.

We therefore cannot say with any degree of confidence that the Cabinet now before us is one deserving the support of the people. Fine Gael believe that our people must be free from the restraints applied to them at present because of the slow growth rate of our economy, because of the poverty among large sections of our people and because of the inequality of opportunity which operates. Freedom of choice and equality of opportunity are not mere theoretical concepts to which lip-service should be paid; our economy and our society must be adjusted so that our people, in their time, can have freedom of choice and an equality of opportunity. In the few fields I have endeavoured to cover, I have indicated that the Government are not providing that equality of opportunity and not producing the standards which ought to exist in a just society. On that account, we are unable to give our support to the administration which the Taoiseach is now putting before us. We regret that the Taoiseach is not himself a person who inspires any of us with any great confidence in the future. His performances in the various Ministries and offices he has held certainly never set anything ablaze. All that we had while he was in charge of any Department was a continuation of outmoded policies or else some misjudged efforts——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will appreciate that we are not discussing the election of the Taoiseach. That has already been disposed of.

Comment on this

I do, Sir, but we are concerned with the Cabinet he is putting before us, and the influence he will have over that Cabinet and the influence they will have on him. Perhaps it is not without significance that he is putting before us 13 names. Politically, for his own Party and for the Taoiseach, I think it will be a very unlucky 13. It is also not without significance that in these 13 there will be under one roof, in the headquarters of Government in Merrion Street, a meek Taoiseach and with him Deputy Haughey, Deputy Blaney and Deputy Lenihan. Never was Julius Caesar surrounded by more treacherous conspirators. Never was any political character in greater danger and never was any weak monarch or political head surrounded by a worse trinity of connivers. We have that sorry situation in which the Head of this Government is to have these three conspirators who in recent weeks, in their efforts to get the office of Taoiseach for themselves, were prepared to assassinate their several so-called colleagues in Government and in their own Party, and who have the Taoiseach in the office he holds today because they promised their support to him in exchange for the Ministries they now hold, the Ministries for Finance and Agriculture in particular.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I do not like to interrupt the Deputy but I must say that that is untrue.

Comment on this

I would not expect the Taoiseach at this stage to acknowledge the truth of it and I do not suggest that he will ever lie in the Forum, saying: "Et tu, Charlie," or Brian or Neil.

Comment on this

"Yon Cassius has a lean and hungry look."

Comment on this

Remember that we of the Fine Gael Benches in charity forewarned him and in so doing warned the country that it is not the triumphant victim who was led home to a well organised hooley in Cork last week who will be in charge of the destinies of the country——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not discussing the election of the Taoiseach and therefore the Deputy is irrelevant.

Comment on this

It certainly is relevant.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has already been ruled out of order on more than one occasion. The Deputy will appreciate that there was an earlier motion on the Order Paper dealing with the election of the Taoiseach. We have passed away from that and we are now dealing with the election of the Government.

Comment on this

What I am saying is that these three people who I say will be with the Taoiseach in Government Buildings will in fact be the trinity in whom power will lie. The country and the people may want to think again about what has happened here in recent days.

Comment on this

What happened about the Fine Gael Leader?

Comment on this

These three give no reason to have confidence in the future. We in Fine Gael are concerned only with the welfare of Ireland and not with the welfare of the Party opposite, or for that matter our own welfare. In the next few weeks we believe the people of Ireland will echo the cries we have been directing from these Benches to this caretaker Government, who will probably be elected tonight, to get out and make room for a worthwhile Irishman in Deputy Liam Cosgrave.

Comment on this

After the rather irrational and scurrilous attack by Deputy Ryan, I feel it incumbent on me to answer some of the more serious allegations. I had not intended to speak in this debate but, having interrupted Deputy Ryan on a number of occasions, I was informed by the Ceann Comhairle that I had my remedy.

Deputy Ryan dwelt for a considerable time on the suggestion that there is a split within the Fianna Fáil Party. Apart from the fact that their memories are short-lived, there is no substance in this allegation.

Comment on this

Or in the "alligator".

Comment on this

The Party is stronger than ever and I think this will be borne out by the by-election results in South Kerry and Waterford. The people talking about splits and divisions are people outside the Fianna Fáil Party: they appear to have knowledge that we on this side of the House do not possess. This, I think, arises from confusion of the democratic process within a democratic political Party. Even Deputies are entitled to vote. This is confused thinking by confused people, people who turn or try to turn the public spotlight away from their own weaknesses and lack of policies. I can assure the House and the country that our new Taoiseach has the total loyalty of every member of the Fianna Fáil Party, be he Deputy or ordinary member of the Party.

There has been a lot of criticism of the Government as a whole and of political motivations. What motivates a political Party or indeed individual politicians? What should be his raison d'être? In my view, the reason for someone wishing to govern is to give those who are suffering in squalor a better life using all our resources and this coupled with education will, in my view, be the task of our new Government.

There is a need that has been mentioned here and again, political play has been made of it and point-scoring indulged in. I refer to housing. This should be above politics, if at all possible. In my constituency one of the great social needs at present is housing. The squalor and division which exist under the roof of the badly-housed family is well known and it results in the womenfolk, usually, breaking down. Then the children become ill and the whole burden falls on the shoulders of the husband who finally breaks down. All the free education and all the free health and other services which have been excellently provided by the Government will be of little benefit to those who must endure such squalor.

The Deputy who is technically our present Minister for Local Government and who will be the new Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries had done much for the people of Ireland in respect of housing and I feel sure the new Minister will carry on with the programme in a vigorous manner so as to obliterate totally our housing needs. The dictum that the poor we must have always with us has no place for me in the Ireland of 1966.

I should like to deal with Deputy Dillon's most unfair attack on Deputy Molloy. Deputy Molloy has come out of this with honour and with the respect of right-thinking people. He is an example to the young people of the country in courage and integrity. Deputy Dillon's behaviour has been deplorable. The Deputy comes of a family which in dark and evil days, and indeed for generations, has given great service to the Irish people. Certainly, one would expect more of him than this type of personal bitterness.

The anxiety of the Opposition to believe the worst of our new Government and fellow Irishmen was never better illustrated than by a recent letter to the Irish Times dealing with the RTE programme “The Person in Question”. This letter was written by a decent and honourable member of the Fine Gael Party. Deputy Donegan betrayed a confidence and deliberately manipulated it for Party purposes. He was given the lie direct. This young man's whole career was placed in jeopardy by an allegation against our new Minister for Finance which has since been proved to have been without foundation. I am now entitled to ask Deputy Donegan and the Fine Gael Party what Deputy Donegan is going to do about this allegation?

Finally, I should like to ask the empty benches of the Labour Party what in fact are the Labour Party policies? It is difficult to speak to empty benches but I am sure the Labour Members will read my questions in the Report of this depate. What exactly are the Labour Party policies? Do they intend to nationalise Irish industries? Do they intend to amend the new Land Act so as to give more power to the Land Commission? Do they intend to create a social service out of CIE? These are some of the questions I should like to put to them and on which I am sure when they read the Dáil Report, despite the emptiness of the benches, they will reply to me and the people of Ireland at some future time. The people of Ireland are entitled to know. I should like to know as a matter of interest.

Deputy O'Leary is critical of our Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Aiken, in setting up a separate mission within the EEC. This mission had to come. Maybe it should have come earlier, but it is extraordinary that this criticism should come from a member of the Party who voted against the Free Trade Agreement with Britain and of a Party who advocated associate membership only of the EEC. This Free Trade Agreement is a testing ground for Irish industry prior to entry to the total market of Europe, and it should be recognised as such.

The late President Kennedy, when he was here three and a half years ago, paid tribute to Ireland's great contribution to world peace. The world has recognised the courage of our Army in the Congo. The world has recognised the courage of our Army in Cyprus, the courage of our Army officers on the peace missions on the India-Pakistan border, the courage of our Army officers in the Middle East. When people criticise our contributions to the UN, they should keep these matters in mind.

Deputies have not been very critical of the Minister for Labour, and rightly so. He has a tough task ahead of him. Over the next number of years he has to deal with some 120 unions, and he will have to spend a long time going through these organisations. However, I would ask him to consider very seriously the new move by women members of trade unions to look for equal pay for equal work. If a woman does a job as well as a man, she should receive equal reward pay-wise. There are many cases where this does not arise but, on the other hand, there are several instances where it does occur.

One wonders what a bitter debate like this achieves. In my view, nothing comes from it. Certainly we shall all have our names in the Dáil Debates and possibly in the newspapers, but in terms of achievement for Ireland, which is really what should motivate any politician, nothing has been gained. The debate has been used merely for the purpose of political point-scoring, and criticisms have been made with no alternative policy being propounded by the Coalition Parties. I for one would welcome alternative policies, alternative policies which have been costed.

Comment on this

Goodness knows, you need an alternative.

Comment on this

I should like to hear the alternative.

Comment on this

May I put a fair question? There are many plans for health and education. Are they costed?

Comment on this

I am sure they are or will be.

Comment on this

The Minister for Education did not know——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

Do not talk rot. Deputy O'Higgins was Minister for Health for three years and did sweet damn all for the health of the people. Except for the Voluntary Health Insurance Scheme he did nothing for the health of the people.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Let us hear the point of order.

Comment on this

I now have two points of order. The Ceann Comhairle has already said that the convention of the House did not allow Ministers to contribute to this debate. Secondly, the Minister designate has no right to usurp your position in the Chair.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They are scarcely points of order.

Comment on this

I have no personal objection to what has been said, Sir, but I know you have. Finally, I should like to say a special word of thanks to Deputy Seán Lemass from myself and my own generation. This man has been the builder of modern industrial Ireland, and when the history books come to be written, his name will appear as one of the great Irishmen of our time. To Deputy Jack Lynch, our new Taoiseach, I offer my congratulations. He is an honourable and dignified man whose integrity at no time during this debate was brought into issue. I am satisfied he will do well by the Irish people, and I can assure him once more of the total loyalty of every Fianna Fáil Deputy and every member of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

I intend to be very brief. I am sorry I was not here when Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Corish were paying their tributes to Deputy Seán Lemass. I want to be associated with the tributes which have been paid to him by those two Deputies and others. I am an Independent and I have no axe to grind for any Party. I want to congratulate Deputy Jack Lynch on his elevation to the office of Taoiseach. It has been universally stated that Deputy Jack Lynch is a decent man and he has the admiration, apart from political prejudice of everybody in this country. I have always had admiration for a great athlete, and if Deputy Jack Lynch captains this House as he captained his own county team for so many years, he will certainly make a success of it, and I am sure if he and his Party are defeated, he will be the first to take that defeat with a smile.

Political point-scoring has been mentioned by Deputy Andrews, and I must agree with him that there has been some sharpshooting. Some of the points that have been made here have been laughable. I never before saw so many people worried about the cattle trade in this country. I felt like getting some ashplants to put into their hands to see if I could make cattlemen out of them at all. Statements have been made that at certain fairs in Donegal and elsewhere lambs were being sold at 5/- each. I only wish I could purchase a thousand of them at that price.

Comments have been made on the reshuffle of the Cabinet. That is none of my business. I hold it is completely the business of the Fianna Fáil Party and the new Taoiseach, and I do not intend to pursue that. One thing, however, which is abominable to me as a farmer and a cattleman is that anybody should try to make capital out of the misfortunes of the farmers and cattle traders who are suffering hardship endeavouring to sell their animals at fairs and marts. This attempt to make capital out of the hardship that producers are experiencing will fail. Some of the people who pretend to be concerned are not concerned about this misfortune for the cattle trade. It is a misfortune that the cattle trade, which is the backbone of the country, has gone so low, but we hope that through the offices of the new Minister for Agriculture, there will be an improvement in the coming spring.

Nobody can prophesy as regards trends in the cattle trade. Nobody can say that the price of cattle will increase by £5 or £6 a head or that the price will decline. The trade depends entirely on the law of supply and demand. Any reasonable person must have regard to the factors which caused the present situation. Some say that it is due to the heifer subsidy scheme. Others attribute it to the Anglo-Irish Trade Agreement. I should have a little education in these matters and I maintain that the main reason for the decline in our principal export trade was the high tariffing against our cattle on the Continental markets and, secondly, the six weeks strike by British seamen. I am sure that strike could have been averted. It hit the cattle trade at a very critical time and crippled the very strong lamb trade which we had with France.

Another factor which militated against the cattle trade and against the Irish producer was the credit squeeze in England. There is a credit squeeze in operation in England as well as here and it is not helping to improve the situation.

However, I hope the new Minister will be a live wire in this respect. I was glad to read in the press that he has been out already trying to obtain licences for further exports. I am not afraid to say that, no matter what allegations have been made against that Minister in this House, he certainly has made an impact in another Department. Let money be scarce or otherwise, he has fought a good fight. Even in my constituency there is a little monument which will be there to his memory when all of us have gone out of this House and even when we have gone to eternity. I refer to the swimming pool in Longford. It is generally agreed now that a swimming pool is a necessary amenity in any town. As soon as the new Minister takes over in the Department of Local Government, we will be looking for a swimming pool in Mullingar.

There is another point that I should like to raise but I do not know if I am in order in raising it now. I am sorry that Deputy Blaney and Deputy Childers are not in the House at the moment. I should like to refer to a matter which is having a bad effect on the transport of cattle. I refer to a restriction imposed by CIE. Perhaps I should not refer to it now but I shall raise it on another occasion.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be a matter for the Estimate, not for a discussion on the formation of a Government.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

Deputy Ryan went through the whole Department of Education and the Department of Health, Sir.

Comment on this

I was not looking for something; I was condemning.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

That is all Fine Gael can do. They have a negative policy on everything.

Comment on this

There is no use in looking for anything from the present Administration, and you know it. They have not got a bob.

Comment on this

I am not looking for anything from them. The suggestion I have to make would involve no loss to funds. I will deal with it on another occasion. I shall not delay the House because I see Deputies on my right and Deputies on my left who are anxious to intervene. I should like to say, in conclusion, that it does not matter to me what Government rule the country, provided the policies have the right effect on the country and, first of all, on my constituents. It does not matter from which side of the House those policies come, I am willing to support them.

I conclude by saying that I wish the Taoiseach and his Government well until it is time to have a change. Neither the Deputies on this side of the House nor on that side, nor of any Party will decide what that change will be. It will be decided by the common lay people of Ireland.

Comment on this

As I was absent from the House earlier today I should like, first of all, to wish success to the National Loan which was announced by the Taoiseach today. The loan contains a very attractive proposal to investors and I have little doubt that it will command interest and the support sought for it. Certainly, it is necessary in the national interest that this loan should succeed.

We are debating here the approval or disapproval by Dáil Éireann of the Taoiseach's team of Ministers. The first impression created by the Taoiseach's list of names was that it was the same team as before, once again, changed a little, in the same way as one would shake a bottle. When the effects of the shaking had disappeared and the contents had settled down, one found that they were very much the same except that in this case there is a fresh cork. That is about the only difference. There is, of course, involved the usual shifting of Ministers.

I find that the Minister for Education is in a unique position. He is the Minister for Education and the Minister designate for Education but he has been shifted around the place, as all other Fianna Fáil Ministers have been in an increasing and accelerating way since the last general election. The Minister for Education has been shifted from Health because he opened his mouth too big there too soon. He is now in Education and he is barking away there in Education, but we do not know with what effect. It is too early to change him from there but, no doubt, he will go on in due course——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

No doubt.

Comment on this

——to fresh woods and pastures new. "No doubt", he said, in an intimidatory way. I hope the Taoiseach will listen carefully to that "no doubt" from the Minister for Education.

The past 18 months have seen great changes in Fianna Fáil, a great trimming of sails, to deal with the veering winds that have blown since the people passed judgment in the last general election and it is right that we should take stock now because the last election was held after a period of inflation, a period of inflation which is now clearly recognised, which was severe and well nigh disastrous for the country.

Each member of the team proposed by the Taoiseach played his part in permitting that period of inflation to arise. The Taoiseach himself, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, by lack of decision, by sins of omission, permitted, in particular, inflation to occur in 1964. Every other Minister played his part in trying to create amongst the people of this country a feeling of euphoria, a feeling that it did not matter, that the sun would never go down, that it would continue to shine, that money could be got for everything and nobody would ever have to pay. This was called prosperity. I think it is fair to say that when that prosperity was beginning to be discovered to be phoney, when the inflationary period was coming to an end and would have to be paid for, it was then and only then that the last general election was held, before the problems and the difficulties and the dangers were known by the people; in other words before the bubble burst.

That is so much water under the bridge. It was a period in which extraordinary things were done by those who shouted loudest. We then had a Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance who was able to go down and announce in the county of Roscommon the wonderful news that the Shannon was to be drained. Do not tell me his name, because that would be letting the cat out of the bag. The Parliamentary Secretary was to go on to bigger things and greater promises in his succeeding years, and he is not finished yet. The Shannon was never drained. I do not know whether the Shannon will ever be drained; but I am going to make a prophecy that no Fianna Fáil Minister, and in particular no Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, will ever again promise the draining of the Shannon. I challenge any of them to do it.

Where is this country 18 months later? We used to hear a lot of talk about the Second Programme for Economic Expansion. It is never spoken of now. It is something that this Government would wish the people to forget. The plain fact now is that the Government's policy, if it ever existed, is now in ruins. The people of the country are today bewildered and confused. The story can no longer be a matter for dissension and dispute. In the first half of this year economic growth came to a standstill. Not only in relation to agriculture—the ills of which no doubt Deputy Corry will shortly tell us about—but also in relation to industrial output, growth ceased. There has been at the same time, particularly in recent months, a rapid rise in emigration and a very disturbing increase in unemployment.

I believe this is a situation that will improve and that these factors will gradually disappear. But the present phenomenon does indicate more clearly than one hundred speeches that the Government do not control our economic situation and have no policy to do it. What has happened in the last 18 months indicates clearly how wrong, how ill-advised, how spurious were the claims made prior to and in the course of the last general election that Fianna Fáil and their Ministers had something to do with the apparent prosperity that then existed. They were not able to control it and in the succeeding 18 months economic trends have had their full effect with the Government standing by idle, incapable or unable to do anything. If today we have emigration increasing again, if we have unemployment again, if we have a situation in which there is stagnation in production, if from our farms and factories we are not producing what we should be producing, it is a situation no Government can be complacent about. Any Government that allows such a situation to exist after ten years in office must agree that it is a Government that has grown too stale and should be removed.

The Second Programme envisaged a four per cent growth rate each year. How many speeches did we hear from Fianna Fáil Ministers indicating that these targets were modest, that they would be achieved and that their achievement would bring about a situation in which there would be sufficient resources available to our community to provide better health services, better educational services, a higher standard of living for ordinary people, as well as providing each year an increasing number of jobs and providing for an increased labour force of something approaching 100,000? That was the general aim set out in the Second Programme. Today, that dream has been established to be a mirage. Instead of a four per cent growth rate, last year the rate was two and a half per cent. This year the best estimate has been threequarters of one per cent. In fact, the indications now are that there will be no growth at all this year. When you consider our little modest, rather puny effort at planning—or programming as Fianna Fáil prefer to call it —which the Second Programme represented and when you consider what little effort has been made in this country compared with what has happened in other European countries over the last decade, you begin to realise how far we have fallen behind. In the past ten years, the growth rate in many European countries has been of the order of five, six or seven per cent. Here we blew trumpets and beat the big drum when for a short period in 1964, in a period now realised to be an inflationary period, we reached four and a half per cent.

I mention that because I charge this Government with being devoid of policy. I assert that for the past 18 months, particularly for the past 12 months, the people of this country have had the experience of individual Ministers shouldering and jostling one another to get the headlines in the newspapers. I accuse, through you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle—I hope you do not mind being used in this way— those who are named as Government Ministers of having acted as so many individuals, 13 or 14, in the past 12 months without any clear policy to bind them together. The Second Programme represented all they knew or thought of economic philosophy or thinking in this country. Once it appeared to crack and fail, they had nothing else to say. In the general election of 18 months ago, the Taoiseach was anxious to emphasise that the Second Programme was a programme and not a plan. He was anxious to indicate what in fact was the truth—that his Government or his Party were not prepared to plan to achieve the targets set but in the Second Programme. In other words, as far as Fianna Fáil were concerned, they set the targets in the Programme. They sat back; they folded their arms and waited for these targets to be achieved. They did not do as any intelligent and efficient group of administrators would do. They did not proceed to overhaul our entire administrative machinery and, in many respects, other aspects of our life, to ensure that the targets set would be achieved. They hoped for the best and, when that was not realised, they were left with nothing to do except ask, for example, as the Minister for Finance asked last year: "What went wrong?" To this day, I do not believe any member of this team in this Government has the slightest idea as to what went wrong.

I want to say, through the Chair, to the Fianna Fáil Party that the reason the country has drifted, the reason the people are confused, the reason ordinary people are bewildered, the reason there has been an increase in emigration, the reason there has been an increase in unemployment and economic stagnation in the past 12 months is the present Government's lack of policy.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

In January, 1957, under the Coalition Government, there were 97,000 unemployed.

Comment on this

The Minister designate for Education need not think he is having a meeting of his Fianna Fáil friends now. He will not shout me down.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Malley

Deputy O'Higgins should not be so sensitive to criticism. It is all right for Fine Gael to interrupt.

Comment on this

It cannot be achieved here and now but it will be achieved, I have no doubt, sooner or later: there is an urgent need for a change of Government. I have the highest regard personally for many members of the Government, including the Minister designate for Education. I have reserves and doubts about others. But, even if they were a team of angels, even if they represent all that occasionally their public relations officers write about them, they have been too long there. They have grown stale in office and, worst of all, they have begun to think that they are God Almighty—and that is a real source of danger.

I believe that even the best of present Ministers have grown far too arrogant in office. Consider the recent trouble with farmers. How did that come about? Did Deputy Haughey, who was Minister for Agriculture, regard himself, in his dealings with Irish farmers, as their servant and as the servant of the people? Not at all. He had grown so accustomed to the exercise of power, to the prestige which his position brought, that he had begun to think that he, and he alone, knew what was right and proper. Of course, this kind of madness, which happens to every person who is too long in office, led him to the fundamental error of creating a situation in which there was no possibility of dialogue between himself, the Government of which he was a member and the National Farmers Association. We had an absurd position in which two sides began and succeeded in digging a trench and put themselves into it without providing any room for manoeuvre. That is the direct result of a man or a team of Ministers being too long in office.

I want to know from the Taoiseach, at the close of this debate, what precisely happened with the same Deputy last Friday night or last Saturday morning. Had he a new outbreak of ministerial madness which almost led to the resignation of the Secretary of his designated Department? I see here reported in a newspaper, under a heading relating to the Secretary of the Department of Finance, the following:

No reasons were being put forward for Mr. Whitaker's reported resignation. However, one story circulating among top civil servants was that Mr. Whitaker had had a disagreement over his reading on behalf of the Minister for Finance of a speech at the inaugural meeting of the Solicitors' Apprentices Debating Society in Dublin on Friday night ... Mr. Whitaker left the hall during the meeting— it was reported that he was taken ill—but returned later to read parts of the speech which he deemed to be "of national importance."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think it is relevant. We are not discussing a civil servant.

Comment on this

I am certainly not discussing a civil servant for whom I have the highest regard.

Comment on this

There is nothing of truth in that story.

Comment on this

That story appears in the Evening Press of Monday, 14th November, 1966. How did it get into the Evening Press? Will we have another situation in which Deputy Haughey, as Minister for Finance, will create more difficulties for the proper running of the administration of this country?

Comment on this

I just said that there is nothing in the story.

Comment on this

How did that story get into the Evening Press, then?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to spread rumours, he may do so.

Comment on this

I am not spreading rumours. I am referring to an item of news which was printed in the Evening Press of Monday, 14th November, 1966.

Comment on this

That is not a rumour; it is the truth

Comment on this

It seems to me that there are individual Deputies who normally are reasonably rational human beings and who, as Opposition Deputies, would probably give excellent service through the Dáil to the people but there comes a time when they are too long in office, when they think they breathe a special air of their own, that they speak a language particular to themselves and are entitled to a treatment unique to them because they are Ministers of the Government. When that situation comes about, there is an urgent need for a change of Government. I believe we have that situation now. I believe that Ministers have become unduly arrogant and that there is a great danger that unless they are changed, our democracy itself will suffer.

Arrogant—yes: I believe, also, some of the Ministers are incompetent. I do not know what will happen to this Government, now that the former Taoiseach has left it. I believe they will flounder and mess around the place because I do not see, amongst all of them, what will add up to the kind of Government this country will need in the immediate future. I do not believe that in the past 12 months, the outgoing Taoiseach was in a position effectively to lead the Government. I think that is why so many individual Ministers made so many individual hames of what they were called upon to do—and the list has been rather staggering in recent months. We had a loan floated in London which was an entire flop because anyone with any sense would have known it was the wrong time to float it. We had the same position with an American dollar loan, ill thought out, ill-planned, costing as a result nothing but difficulty for the country and for its credit abroad. We had in the past 18 months three Budgets and the Minister for Finance standing up here in this House on the first Budget of this year asking what went wrong with his Budget of 1965. Then we had a situation that even the Budget introduced this year had to be followed by a second Budget.

There have been a whole series of miscalculations and mistakes of one kind or another which just does not augur well for the future. While all that is going on, there are urgent things requiring to be done in this country and I want to serve notice on the Government that, so far as the Fine Gael Party are concerned, we have no intention of permitting the Government to forget the issues involved in the general election of 18 months ago. We fought that election for a just society. We fought it in order to provide better health services, better social conditions, better housing conditions, better educational facilities for our people. We made that the aim of our programme and the aim of our policy and we put before the people the means whereby these aims could be achieved under our policy of economic planning.

After the election was over, after it had finished, the newly elected Fianna Fáil Government, through the mouth of Deputy O'Malley, entered into an undertaking to provide at least part of what we were seeking in health services. Having produced a White Paper on Health Services, the then Minister for Health promised that in this month on November, this particular month, Dáil Éireann would see his legislative plan for improving our health services. I want to know where is it? I want to ask the Taoiseach to tell us tonight in closing this debate where is the Fianna Fáil legislative proposal promised to this Dáil for this month to bring some minimal improvement in our health services.

The tragedy is that despite all that was said in the last general election, despite all that was said in the last Dáil, despite the setting up of a Select Committee some three of four years ago, despite all that has been said from these benches over the past ten years, despite every attempt made to attend to one's social susceptibilities, the plain fact is that today, in 1966, towards the end of this year, we still have an outmoded, antiquated, creaking Victorian system of making provision for the ill-health of our people. So far as I can see, there is no evidence, despite all the promises, that some improvement will be made.

We will not allow this Government to forget that and we will not allow them to forget the need also for a greatly expanded educational policy and for the provision, as a matter of urgency, of vastly increased educational opportunities for our people. These are urgent social requirements. If we were serious about them, if we had a Government in office who not merely wished, because I am sure every Government and every Deputy wish for these things, to improve health services or education or housing, but who had the ability to plan, to plan in a systematic way, to plan our economic effort towards the achievement of these aims, I have little doubt that progress would have been made many years ago. If it is to be made now, it is a good thing, but más maith é is mithid, and I hope we will see more effort being made now to achieve these things.

There is a danger, a very real danger, with the creaking to a standstill of our economic growth this year, that it may emerge that the Second Programme underestimated the investment required for the achievement of its targets. There is a danger that those who try now to wind up the clock again in an effort to get the economy going again will be forced to provide some of our limited resources towards investment purposes. If that happens, we will hear again the old excuses we heard so often in the Dáil from the Taoiseach and different Ministers: "We cannot afford this year to improve health services; we cannot afford this year to provide better opportunities in education or in health; we will have to postpone these until a later stage, until such time as our economic resources have grown and certain targets we have set ahead of ourselves have been attained." I hope we will not have that experience from this Government and these Ministers. Those promises have been made too often, too explicitly, and have emerged after such concentrated demands from all sides of the House that it would be tragic to hear again of postponement.

I shall not delay my friend, Deputy Corry, from getting in because I know verbal frustration is a very damaging sensation. I am sure he has a strong message of support to give from the people of his portion of Cork but I do say, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that we cannot justly in accordance with our rule here give any support to this team of Ministers. I have indicated my reasons. I do not believe they measure up to the job. I say that without any personal ill-will against any of them. I do not think they have the calibre, the stature or the ability to do as is required for Ireland now. Furthermore, I think whatever possibility they might have of measuring up to their tasks has been reduced by the fact that they have been too long there. They live in a particular atmosphere of ministerial euphoria which has led in the past to miscalculation and to grave errors, and will I have no doubt if they are re-appointed by Dáil Éireann, lead to a repetition of so many of the mistakes we have seen in recent months.

Comment on this

When I went home last weekend, I was asked what the dickens we were doing here in this House on Thursday and Friday, and again this week. The Taoiseach was elected by what we have been told are the minority Party with a majority of seven votes, and if there was any danger or any fear that he would not be elected, he would have been elected with a majority of 21 because there would be a big number of the boys over there afraid of their lives that they would have to go to the country and would not come back. Every one of them knows that very well. One poor devil, in fact, forgot to come in for the voting. Some of my farmer friends who are here with me today and who read the papers over the weekend suggested that if the muck and filth that was scattered around this House on Thursday and Friday and will, I presume, be continued today, was down in East Cork, they would be able to manure a couple of acres of spuds, which is about the best use it could be put to.

I can only compare it to two and a half days that were spent here when we had a mixum-gatherum Government and when they decided to get rid of the Minister for Health. Poor Dr. Noel Browne was here and he was attacked by every laddy-o-lee of a lawyer that existed on those benches, which is where the boys were at the time. Every filth and muck that could be slung at their own Minister was slung at him until he resigned. Honestly, I do not know what is wrong with them, whether it is that having a Cork Taoiseach now instead of a Dublin one is getting the Dublin jackeens going. That must be largely the reason why we are here for three days.

I have seen a lot of Taoiseachs elected here. I saw in the days of the mixum-gatherum Government Deputy John A. Costello elected Taoiseach. He was most noted for what my friend, Deputy Seán Collins, afterwards called "the John A. Costello pint" which had a parish priest's collar on top, three inches of froth.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will appreciate that we are not discussing the election of Taoiseach. We are discussing the appointment of the Government.

Comment on this