We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 4—General (Resumed).

Contributions 130–257 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I can remember the Taoiseach's predecessor——

Comment on this

Nearly as good as Castlebar.

Comment on this

——could hardly open his mouth, could hardly make two sentences, but all the boys at the back cheered him. Now, no matter what punch lines the Taoiseach endeavoured to put into his speech today, there were only 20 Deputies behind him, including the Minister, that is, 19 and the Minister for Finance, and there was no cheering and most of them were looking very lonesome indeed. I think they have reason to be so but what I am cribbing about is that there were previous occasions when there were Budgets worse than this but when the Dublin Mafia of the Fianna Fáil Party organised the cheering and the roaring and the clapping from the back benches and all of them had to be in their seats. They could not be absent. As a Corkman, I resent that treatment of a Cork Taoiseach. I suppose you cannot blame the Deputies for their lack of enthusiasm.

Comment on this

Any more expulsions coming up in your Party?

Comment on this

I will deal with that later and I will deal with some of the expulsions that are pending in your Party also.

I want to say I cannot blame the Fianna Fáil backbenchers for their lack of enthusiasm because after their first show of hand-clapping on the Minister's Budget statement yesterday, they went away and they cooled off and asked themselves: "What exactly is in this Budget?" If they are honest with themselves, they will see quite clearly that it is an unimaginative Budget, a pedestrian effort. It doles out a shilling here and a shilling there. We feel that the introduction of a Budget and the statement of the Minister for Finance and certainly the statement of the Taoiseach, should be something more than a simple exercise in accountancy. I am afraid that is what the Minister has inflicted on the House and on the country, a simple exercise in arithmetic, no matter how much might be involved. The country expects more than that from a Budget Statement.

I should like to hear from the Minister, or the Taoiseach, what the prospects are. There is not much point in telling a docker or a factory worker: "The net result for you, as far as the Budget is concerned, is that you are going to pay more for your cigarettes and for your pint, but beyond that, we cannot guarantee you continuity of employment, cannot guarantee you your job or even that you will have a house to live in." It is that sort of undertaking which the average man requires if you expect him to become enthusiastic and make sacrifices for the general good when he sees others who are not asked to make any sacrifice. The only thing in the Budget for him, if he survives long enough to draw an old age pension, is that he will get 5/- more next October than he would have got last October.

Comment on this

August, actually.

Comment on this

August.

Comment on this

The Deputy should try to keep in touch.

Comment on this

I am trying to keep the Minister in touch. I am keeping him in touch with the common man and I know it is hard to do it because he is so far removed from that stratum. I can keep him in touch with other things if he wishes.

Comment on this

For heaven's sake, the Deputy is never here.

Comment on this

Does the Minister want that? Draw me sufficiently and he will get it.

Comment on this

Talk away.

Comment on this

Before the Minister's rude interruption, I was endeavouring to point out that there is little or nothing in this Budget for the ordinary man, for the wage or salary earner, for the middle-class man. There is a sop for the old age pensioners. God knows, it is nothing to give a great hurrah about that in this year we should say, and be applauded from the Government benches, that we awarded a pension of £2 17s 6d to old age pensioners. Incidentally, while the new taxes go on immediately, we say to the old age pensioner: "You are going to get 5/- extra if you live long enough but it will be in the sweet bye-and-bye". Why is it that while the taxes are going on immediately, the recipients of this miserable increase in old age pensions and social welfare benefits should have to wait? They are entitled to an explanation. It is a miserable saving. Many of them will be dead before the date arrives.

Having said all that, I want to say that we in the Labour Party, as we promised down through the years, voted for new taxation when we were told specifically what it was for. In fairness to the Minister, he did, unlike some of his predecessors, clearly indicate the sources from which he was getting the taxation and how he was going to apply it. We appreciate that and it was because of that clear-cut policy that we decided to vote for it. Our only criticism is that he did not go far enough and I hope he will remember that in the future.

I should like to ask him one question. This year we are to have the local elections. Can he give us any indication that this will be the only Budget we will have this year? Do not forget that his Government had two stabs at it last year. I would hate to impute any sinister or ulterior political motives, although I might have grounds for doing so, but I should like the Minister to give us an undertaking that this is the Budget for the coming financial year and that there will not be any more stabs or minis immediately after the local elections. Some people have serious doubts in that regard and in view of the past performance of the Minister's Party, they are entitled to them, and they are entitled to challenge the Minister to give an undertaking in that regard.

While there appeared to be an air of relief, if not of jollification, among the Fianna Fáil Deputies after the Budget Statement last night, they would want to steady up. They are describing it as a good Budget and I even heard one Fianna Fáil Deputy describe it as "a great Budget", God between us and all harm. They would want to look at this a little more dispassionately. Many of them are in the situation that they cannot see the wood for the trees. Every Deputy has to relate the implementation of the budgetary proposals to the people he knows best, the people in his constituency. As I said, a Budget should be an indication of the broad policy of the Government and not simply a book accounting exercise. It should deal with what they are going to do about housing, employment and redundancy. We have nothing like that in this Budget.

I can remember that when discussing the Free Trade Agreement between Ireland and England I described it as being rash and as it turned out, I was intelligent enough to forecast redundancy in the factories of Cork, arising from it. I was told at the time I was unpatriotic and I was unrealistic. I said that because of the Free Trade Agreement, there would be redundancy in two of our greatest factories in Cork, in Irish Dunlop and in Fords. I was scoffed at for my remarks. The fact is, as Cork Deputies can tell you, every week for the past few weeks workers have been laid off in Dunlops. It is not just a temporary lay-off; they have been told: "You are getting such and such compensation for the loss of your job; goodbye, God bless you, you will never work here again." That was the situation I forecast but I was told by Government spokesmen that I did not know what I was talking about. The proof of the pudding is in the eating. I want to place on record that what I said at that time has come true and I want some of the people who endeavoured to pooh-pooh my statement to get it into their skulls that far from getting better, it is going to get worse. That is my second forecast, that arising out of the Free Trade Agreement, bad and all as the employment situation is in Cork at the moment, it is going to be worse. I would be sorry that my forecast today would be as accurate as the one I made on the last occasion.

We did not hear much from the Government side during the Budget Statement about major national questions. Apparently several of these matters are not to be discussed in the House; it is thought better that they should be discussed at meetings of the Ard-Chomhairle Ceanntair of Fianna Fáil, at symposia of Tuairim or at the annual soirées of the junior and major chambers of commerce. It is most frustrating that people in the trade union movement should pick up their newspapers in the morning and find there that on the previous night, before a biased audience where there would not be any hecklers, the Minister for Industry and Commerce had made a statement about the incomes policy of the Government. It is extraordinary that he would not express these views at the annual general meeting of some trade union. If the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not available, the Minister for Transport and Power is always available and he will throw out statistics so fast that no one can assimilate them.

I do not mind them making these statements if they make them with all due responsibility. They say they must get the trade unions to exercise restraint in the matter of wage increases. Does it ever appear to them that there are people employed in this country, 250,000 of them, who are eaning less than £12 a week? It is useless to go to a man with a wife and four or five children who is earning £12 a week and tell him that he will have to tighten his belt, even though no effort is made to control prices. There is no mention of people who are earning their living —"earning" is probably the wrong word; I should say "getting their living from other sources"—from profits, dividends and directors' fees.

It is not good enough for any Government or any Minister of Government to pontificate to our people regarding our wages when they are turning the blind eye to other matters and when they are closing their eyes entirely to incomes available to other people, when they are doling out incomes themselves to their white-haired boys. The working man will look at this Budget and ask himself what is in it for him, what is in it for his unemployed son, what is in it for his son just leaving school. All of us will have to admit that as and from the day when the former Taoiseach promised 100,000 new jobs, the cold statistic of the matter is that there are now 64,000 fewer employed in this country than there were when he made that promise.

It is unfair, very unfair, to expect the people to be in any way enthusiastic about this Budget. All of us will welcome the social welfare increases and the other increases which, in a small way, benefit the community generally. We regret very much that there is no desire on the part of the Government to do any better. The Labour Party voted for the extra taxation to raise the money for the small increases that are being given but we feel that so far in this debate, and I was disappointed with the Taoiseach's speech, sufficient ground has not been traversed. We had expected that there would be some definite statement on the housing situation and on the dilemma in which many local authorities find themselves in that regard.

I remember when the present Taoiseach was a member of Cork Corporation with Deputy Healy, Deputy Barrett and myself. The inter-Party Government were in office at the time and our allocation for housing in Cork was £750,000. He nearly had a fit. I thought he would get a seizure when he was told of the allocation. I thought he would die but he survived to become Taoiseach of a Government who today give us £350,000 for housing in Cork and he and his cohorts will blandly tell us that they are doing the best they can. That is the biggest fraud that could be perpetrated on the people of Cork.

I do not want to detain the House any longer except to summarise what I have already said, that this is an unimaginative, pedestrian Budget that doles out a very few favours to a very small section of the community. It is something which certainly will not evoke the enthusiasm which the Minister sought from the ordinary people of the country when he suggested that they must work for their country.

I pointed out before you took the Chair, Sir, that there is nothing in this Budget to make these people excited, or imaginative, or intelligently involved in the progress of the country. Take the poor farmer in the west of Ireland. He picks up his paper and finds that we are going to build four satellite towns around Dublin. On the one hand, we have the Government expressing their concern—lipservice, I grant you—for the farmers in the West and in the South-West. On the other hand, we have voluntary organisations like Dochas, the Save the West Organisation, working day and night, pulling in shillings and pounds in order to set up a few co-operatives in the West in an endeavour to do something for the people who are fading away in those areas.

We have heard of the high and mighty, the commissions which are appointed, the alleged experts brought from Britain and further afield to study these problems. One of their latest eruptions is a suggestion that we should build four satellite towns for an anticipated increase in the population of Dublin and its surroundings. In other words, much as we disliked the word "Pale" historically long ago for historical reasons, it now appears to be official policy to set up the Pale again with an even more restricted boundary than heretofore, and forget the West, the South, the South-West and the North-West.

The ordinary people of the country will not "wear" that very much longer. They are bound to be disappointed in the Budget because of its lack of any proposals to do something concrete for them. They see no future in it. I suppose it would be much worse but for the fact that the local elections are coming along this year. In spite of the fact that some slight effort has been made to induce the people to vote for the Government in the local elections, it is not good enough, and it will be shown during the campaign for what it is.

Comment on this

I should like to ease Deputy Casey's mind by assuring him that the local elections are of no assistance whatever so far as politics are concerned. I have been fighting them since 1924, for 40 odd years. A councillor is elected because it is considered locally that he will look after the people there and that he will do his job in the local authority for the people he is elected to represent. It has damn all to do with politics.

I have been in this House for nearly 40 years and this is the first time I saw a majority of over 40 trotting around the lobby to vote for the Budget. The figures were 80 odd to 40 odd. I must congratulate Deputy Casey on being one of the Deputies who trotted around with us, so it must not be such a bad Budget, even though he abuses it today. I would not pay too much heed to Deputy Casey, the Lord Mayor, or his legal adviser, Deputy Barrett, so far as their financial figures are concerned. They are the two gentlemen who came in here immediately after the last general election and held up this House for nearly two months fighting a boundary Bill through the House. They told the people of Cork and assured the country generally that the total amount of compensation which would have to be paid was £400,000, and they now find they are facing a bill of £1½ million, which is far below the figure we are entitled to, in my opinion.

Is it not a fine thing that a small body like Cork Corporation, in a country which according to Deputy Dillon is "bust", can find £1½ million to present to us before 1st May? That shows the financial standing of the country if ever there was a picture of it. A small body like Cork Corporation can hand over £1½ million to Cork County Council and, according to the arbitrator, it must be paid before 1st May. That is a lot of money. Instead of being so grabbing and looking over their neighbours' ditches, those people we hear wailing about houses could build a lot of houses for £1½ million in Cork city.

They could find the money to hand over to the county council but they could not find it to build houses for the people they are wailing and moaning about here. Why? Ask yourselves that. I had to spend weeks fighting against that iniquity here which was forced through by the Corporation, by the Aldermen and Burgesses and the legal adviser in Cork. After fighting it through, they said that the maximum compensation involved would be £400,000, but the arbitrator found they were liable not for £400,000 but for £1½ million. Do you not think that that pair would bring in a great Budget? Let us have a look at the two estimators, and at the difference between £400,000 and £1½ million on a couple of acres of land.

Deputy Cosgrave alluded today to something I am worried about. We have at present 25,000 civil servants and 8,000 temporary civil servants, that is, 33,000 civil servants. Evidently they are not satisfied with their pay. They do not think they are getting enough if one is to judge by the way they are voting in Dublin. There are 33,000 of them living in the city constituencies and they created a great racket when it came to endeavouring to deprive Eamon de Valera of the honour of being President of the State. They are all living here. There is no doubt about that, so I am not surprised at the figures you get around Dublin.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

A lot of them come from Cork.

Comment on this

No, they are not from Cork—not from my constituency anyway. There was a suggestion here before when Dr. Ryan was Minister for Finance that we have that matter investigated and cleared up. I suggest it is high time it were done now because I do not think that that old man of the sea can be carried by our people much longer. You could do with 50 per cent of them, I think, and get much better work.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Who is the old man of the sea?

Comment on this

The next thing I heard —and I was very pleased at the compliment—was a reference by Deputy Cosgrave to a constructive Opposition. You have no more an Opposition over there, God help us, as far as honest, constructive criticism is concerned than you have brains. You have none of it there because the brains are not there. You cannot think, honest to God. The most ineffective team I have met in my 40 years of public life, as far as an Opposition is concerned, are over there now—useless.

We hear complaints. Let us bear in mind that this country was described as being on the verge of bankruptcy—"financially burst" said my pal, James. We must compare that description with the condition of affairs in which a Budget could be introduced such as that which was introduced yesterday and we must wonder at the change. For the past 12 months, we have been listening to wails and moans. The only difference between our Government and the two mixum-gatherums is that we stuck it out. We said we were responsible for the people and that we would see them through the bad patch. The crowd opposite ran away twice: they had two chances and they ran away each time. They disappeared on one occasion after three and a half years and the next time they disappeared after three years. Out they went, with a complete majority.

I was rather surprised to hear sneers about disunity in the Fianna Fáil Party. When I heard those sneers yesterday, my mind went back to the time when I was sitting over there on the Opposition benches and when there was a legal array lined up on the Government benches. I remembered that I looked across the floor of this House and that, for three long days of the time of this House, they crucified their own Minister for Health, Dr. Browne. They spent three days in this House crucifying him: I could not describe it by any other term. He threw up his post as Minister for Health and got out. Then the crowd who did that talk about rumours of disunity in this Fianna Fáil Government. Sure, they were like a lot of tomcats that were tied together. I could not describe them in any other way when I recall the way they carried on.

We now find that this alleged bankrupt Government give an increase of 5/- a week to the old age pensioner. They come along on every line and look after each one of them in turn. Of course, I know, from what we heard here from Deputy Cosgrave earlier and from what we heard from the NFA last night, that credit for the benefits in this Budget is being withheld from Fianna Fáil. We had it from the creamery milk sellers also. The tune was to this effect: "We are the people who did it. We are the people who are responsible for it. Look at what we made the Government do". It is rather amusing to hear this line of argument from all those people.

During the past few months we have heard a lot about the small farmers. This Government have come very definitely to the relief and assistance of the small and uneconomic farmer. In my opinion, they have met him in a way he should be met. I do not think that the boys with ranches from 250 to 400 acres will be too pleased with the result of their argument. However, the small farmer has got help and relief and so has the creamery milk man—another man who must work on the land and who does not spend his time at the Curragh races. He, too, has got help and assistance and relief, and that is the line I like to see any Government take.

We hear a lot of noise about the number of people who leave the land and about the reduction in the rural community. Why would they not do so, when we take all the factors into consideration? Do you mean to tell me that any young Deputy—we are nearly all too old to work here—will refuse a job at from £15 to £25 a five day week and prefer to spend his time on a farm for a "tenner" for a seven day week? That is the kernel of the problem of the flight from the land. It is just as simple as that.

I have them, neighbours of mine. Anybody who passes my house on a Sunday morning will see a procession of them there all waiting for a letter to the steel merchant or to the Verolme Dockyard merchant. It is certain that the country lad who has been working for the farmer and who gets that letter will never again spend one day on the land because he has his five-day week and about £15 a week in wages and he would be a damn idiot if he settled for the less well paid job. That is what is wrong with the whole position as regards rural Ireland about which we hear so much noise. Let us face it frankly. So long as the rural community have to work a seven-day week for between £10 and £12 per week, then so long shall we have that condition of affairs.

The lad on the land must work a seven-day week. If we take the five-day week and calculate the overtime which would be due to him for finishing on the following Sunday night instead of on the previous Friday evening, an extra two days, and see what his wage should be then, in those circumstances, we shall realise that we are wrong in thinking we are doing a lot for him when we give him one penny a gallon on his milk. Let us look frankly at these things.

The cost of production on the land has gone up by 16½ per cent in the past four years. I state that as a member of an organisation which has the honour of being the only organisation in this country to succeed in getting costs of production carried out and fulfilled, the Irish Sugar Beet Growers Association.

I have figures here for the price of beet. In 1963-64, the price of beet was 125/- a ton. In 1964-65, the costings drove that price up by 11/1d to 136/1d. In 1965-66, we were entitled to 5/3d, but the Sugar Company told us they had no money and could not pay unless they increased the price of sugar— which, of course, could not be done on the five-day week fellow. We had to take our people out on strike, with the result that we got our 5/3d.

In the following year, 1966-67, when we met the representatives of the Sugar Company, they appeared at the door with outstretched hands and told us there was not a penny for anybody. I said: "Let us in anyway and we will have a few words about it," but the same statement was repeated inside. I asked them was there money for nobody or did they mean only the farmer. They said there was no money for either farmers or workers. I replied that in those circumstances we would accept the present price for the coming year, but on condition they signed an agreement that if there was any increase in wages of the workers during the next 12 months, the same increase would go to the beet growers. General Costello said that was fair enough and signed the agreement. We signed the contract in January and in June, General Costello came to me and said: "You caught me." I asked him: "For how much?" He said: "For the full year, it would be 8/9d a ton. You have the ground ploughed and beet sown. On the costings, that is 2/1d a ton up to the singling time. Therefore, you are entitled to 6/8d a ton and we will pay it to you." The year before we had to go on strike for 5/3d, but that year we got our 6/8d on the beet that went in up to January last.

This year there is added to that a further 3/-. Therefore, the price of beet has increased since 1963-64 by 26/- a ton or 16½ per cent. That is done on costings prepared by the Beet Growers Association and the Irish Sugar Company. That was started in 1947 and has been brought up to date every year since. If the grower has to pay his workers more or a higher price for fertiliser, that is the result. The present price is based on a wage of £10 a week for an agricultural worker or a farmer working on the land. Then you wonder why you have a flight from the land! Facts are very stubborn and bitter things, but they are facts. Those are the only costings ever taken of an agricultural crop in this country. That is our charter of freedom, on which we can base what we are entitled to. I wonder what those concerned with other commodities have been doing, those who can come out today and sneer at the Beet Growers Association. The facts are that in a ten-year period the price of beet has increased from 111/- in 1956-57 to 151/- this year.

This is an industry rooted in the soil of this country. It pays 70 per cent of the total freight income of CIE. It gives employment to between 5,000 and 7,000 people in our factories. That is the kind of industry we want in this country. It was built up by one man who is, to my mind, one of the greatest, if not the greatest, captains of industry in this country—General Costello. Not being satisfied with building it up from a twopence halfpenny showbox which it was when he came into it in 1946, he went into the new line of foodstuffs. Today there are close on 2,000 people employed in the factories producing foodstuffs. That is the kind of advance I want to see in this country.

Four years ago General Costello came down to my area and said: "Look, for every £1 you put up, the Sugar Company will put up £1 against you. Build up a little industry here." We collected £30,000, got £30,000 from the Sugar Company and started. We began with 230 acres of vegetables the first year. At present we are in what we call our second period of expansion with over 1,200 acres under vegetables for the coming year. As chairman of that organisation, I found myself in the unfortunate position of having applications for 2,800 acres of vegetables. I was only able to give less than one acre for every two applied for. That is why I blame the industrial arm and the sales arm. When the working farmers, as distinct from the drones, have faith in an enterprise, prove their faith with their money, their labour and their land, the least we expect is that the industrial side, the men with the finance, will be working on two lines, first, acquiring the money for the expansion and, secondly, providing the market for the produce.

I am very glad that Heinz stepped in with Erin Foods in that matter. I hope that within the next two years, we shall have 10,000 acres under vegetables in east Cork. When I hear figures given here for agricultural production, I begin to wonder whether the processed vegetables leaving our factories for export are put down as industrial items or as agricultural items. That is something that should be seriously considered. The opening is there and that opening is being used with equal success by the small farmers in Skibbereen and the large farmers in east Cork. I have seen a gross return of £210 an acre from carrots this year. If crops are giving that gross return, then you have made the paradise of the small farmer. That is far better for small farmers than doles or anything else you can give them. The remedy is there if there is anybody with the same outlook and the same courage as General Costello to apply it.

I was very proud and glad to see General Costello appointed to the Agricultural Council. It is well worth the nation's while to have him there as a guide and adviser, if nothing else. I would advise any Minister for Agriculture, in our time anyway, to listen very carefully to advice General Costello will give and to carry it out, because it will not put him two feet astray. I have seen this old disused mill, which was closed down for seven years, reopened. Last year we paid £40,000 in wages and we paid £68,000 to the farmers for their crops. That is a good example to be followed. It involves the joint co-operation of the Sugar Company and the ordinary farmer. The farmer must be a worker, a man who is prepared to work his land and get the maximum production from his land.

I do not agree with the heifer loan scheme. That scheme has upset the applecart in regard to our Agreement with Britain on cattle. We have found ourselves with about 150,000 more young cattle than we had previously and there was no market for them. We succeeded last January 12 months in sending 10,000 of those cattle to Egypt. Nasser paid £9 10s a cwt for them. This year we started out on the same line to sell cattle to Italy, a country that would buy nothing but bullocks. We sent over 3,000 bullocks which are at present being tested on the farms of the Italian university, tested out in preparation for an order for 50,000 of them. One weekly paper that pretends to be the voice of the farming community said their correspondent, Mr. Joe Keane, went over to Italy and examined those cattle: they were flukey, worm-infested, lice-infested, and a disgrace to the country that reared them. That was a good step by an agricultural organisation pretending to represent the farmers, towards helping in the export of our stock. The whole thing was a lie. These cattle were bought by Italian buyers. They knew what they were buying. When next I come to speak on this subject, I hope to be able to give far more definite proof of the falsity of their statements because I expect by then the Italians will be put over a barrel. That is the kind of harm that is being done to this country and to our exports.

When you come to look at the difference between the 1,200 acres that earned the contract this year and the 2,810 acres my farmer offered to contract for, the difference in the gross income to the farmer is over £150,000 on that one item alone. In relation to the processed vegetable trade, we can get abroad and in our home market, at a conservative estimate, between £5 million and £10 million within two years. That market is there for our farmers. We need not import the raw material. The raw material can be grown on our own soil, delivered to our own factories and processed by our own workers. I believe this is the sheet anchor of our greatest hopes for agriculture in the future. Frankly it is in that light I look at it.

I have heard both sides here moaning about unemployment. My mind goes back to a couple of years ago, to the day on which Deputy Barrett came in here and endeavoured to sabotage the Verolme Dockyard. I remember the assistance he got, some of it halfhearted, if you like, from other parts of the House. That dockyard is today giving permanent employment to over 900 able-bodied men, 80 per cent of whom, I am sorry to say, come out of Deputy Barrett's and Deputy Casey's constituency of Cork city. This game of sabotage was considered so good that Deputy Fitzpatrick, who now occupies the Opposition Front Bench, considered it worth his while to tell his constituents in Cavan that the first job the Opposition would do, if they were elected as the Government, was to abolish extravagances like the Verolme Dockyard. That was in his election address to the people of Cavan. I suppose most of them had never heard of the Verolme Dockyard and so it was a safe bet up there. That is the kind of sabotage we have from a bunch of hypocrites who come in here subsequently crying and moaning about unemployment.

This is a good Budget. It is the job of our own people to establish industries which will provide employment for our own people, and decent employment at that. Side by side with employment must come the provision of housing. I judge the state of a country by the demand for housing. If there is a great deal of unemployment, nobody will be looking for a house. People will be looking for a boat to take them out. When a young man, however, finds he is in constant employment with a decent wage, the first thing he does is to look around for a good-looking lassie. He puts his arm around her and asks her to marry him. It is as simple as that. When we get a Government— I believe we will some time—who will work on the basis of, first of all, finding employment for our people and, secondly, providing them with decent homes to live in, then we will have what many of my comrades died for, but not until then. That is the main hope so far as this country is concerned. That will have to be done.

With regard to the Department of Local Government, they should get rid of the Jobs. They are living back in the days when they had all the time in the world to find excuses for not giving grants and loans, the time when there was no dough, the time the last inter-Party Government were in office. They have rules and regulations that would not be found in any other civilised country. Fancy a regulation that a local authority may not build a house for a man unless he is married.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not continue along those lines. Rules and regulations may be relevantly discussed on the Estimate, but certainly not on the Budget.

Comment on this

I am dealing, Sir——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I know what the Deputy is dealing with; he is dealing with housing and administration in the Department of Local Government. That matter is not relevant.

Comment on this

I will deal with it in another way. Six miles from Cork city in my constituency, an industrialist recently spent £250,000 expanding his industry. He had that much faith in this country, a country Deputy Dillon said was "bust". Having done that, he now finds himself in the position that he has to put three buses on the road to bring his workers 25 to 30 miles to work. I suggest it is the duty of the Taoiseach and the duty of the Minister for Finance to get over whatever obstacles are in the way of that man having his workers in their own village in their own houses.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter can be discussed on the Estimate but not on the Budget.

Comment on this

And I will have a field day on it. Those are the things that I have to look at. Those are the things my constituents send me here to speak of. It is because I am looking after them and their interests that I will be putting in my fortieth year here next June.

Comment on this
Deputies

Good man.

Comment on this

I do not wish to go further except on the line that I believe the salvation of our country lies in more industry and in finding some means of dealing with the agricultural community that will keep them at home working their own land at an income that will enable them to be as good as the five-day week industrialists. The Government who will work on that line will be here and those boys will be over there until their whiskers grow down to their knees.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

This Budget has been lauded on the Government side as being a very good affair and as giving a boost to the economy. If it had done that, we, on this side of the House, would have been in favour of it, but it has not done that.

The Taoiseach said that the Government spending will stimulate private spending. I sincerely hope so, but we have suffered in a strange way from a surfeit of Government spending in the past few years, with the consequence that the sources of money were dried up for the private spender, namely, the ordinary business person, which led to an extraordinary shortage of money. That had a very bad effect on the economy. I sincerely hope the Taoiseach is correct in saying that Government spending will stimulate private spending. I genuinely hope that this is so but it has not had that effect up to now. I see no clear reason why, on this occasion, Government spending will have any more than the effect it has always had in the past, of decreasing the amount available for commercial purposes. I do not know precisely why that particular argument was made by the Taoiseach because there is not any very great increase in capital expenditure in this Budget.

We, on this side of the House, welcome the social welfare aspect of the Budget but we do not think that there is anything particularly wonderful being done in that respect. However, I do not want particularly to talk about the medical expenses tax relief or the dependent relative relief or the child allowance increases because those amounts are very trifling. They have a political effect but they have very little effect on the actual income of the people concerned, nor, indeed, have they any great effect in cost on the overall increases in taxation. What they do is to give this political boost to the Budget.

I would like to see happening here what I described at the beginning as a boost, a lift to the economy because industry and business generally have been suffering from a real recession in the past few months and were suffering during most of last year from the effects of the credit squeeze. I know we cannot and I am not attempting to blame the Government entirely for the credit squeeze or even, perhaps, mainly for it. There has been a worldwide shortage of capital but certainly it was exacerbated in our particular economy by the fact that the Government were spending on public expenditure such a large proportion of the national income. Economies were urged in the private sector of the economy, namely, business, but the Government themselves were not practising what they preached.

It was admitted by the Minister in his Budget speech that our level of taxation is one of the highest in the world. That is a very unenviable position in which to find ourselves. We, on this side of the House, believe and I believe very strongly that an easing up of the tax situation as it affects business and a lowering and an easing of the tax burden on the community generally would in the short-term and more so in the long run have a very beneficial effect on the general level of employment and on general business turnover. A reduction in income tax and corporation profits tax would give industry a very much needed boost and would in a very short time result in increased employment and a generally higher level of prosperity in the country. We are being dragged down businesswise through high taxation. It is almost impossible for an average business to put by money for increases in prices of commodities.

We all know that the cost of living is going up each year by something like four per cent. That affects business in just the same way as it affects our ordinary household budget. It is costing that much extra to hold and maintain the same amount of stocks. They are increasing at that rate each year. To finance that, businesses find that they need to make higher profits. In addition, cost of repairs, of general improvements, of replacements and so on, is something that can only be borne out of profits. When profits are taxed, as they are here, to an enormous extent, we find ourselves very adversely affected. We are affected not only by the tax structure but by the rate of taxation.

I appeal to the Minister to give this matter a great deal of thought. When we go into the Common Market, as we hope we will, then not only will our export industries and manufacturing industries generally, about which there has been a great deal of talk and thought, be up against very strong competition, but so will every other form of business. Retail and wholesale businesses, the ordinary buying and selling of commodities, will be up against fierce continental competition and it will be extremely difficult for our businesses to carry on as they are, operating at a higher tax level than that which operates in continental countries, not to mention across the water.

The Minister referred to the earnings of younger executives and said it was difficult to keep these people unless a tax concession was made. A tax concession was made but I have not yet had time to work out just how far this is a real help or how far it is something about which one could say: "Well, thank you very much; you have given me almost nothing." I have sat on this side of the House for so many years that——

Comment on this

And for many more, we hope.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

It is very nice of the Minister to say so. I needed that boost to my morale but let him wait until he hears what I am about to say. I have been here long enough to view with suspicion anything in the nature of tax concessions because I never found any of them to be worth very much. They look better on paper than they work out in reality. I hope that on this occasion the Minister has provided this increased relief for the younger executive——

Comment on this

If the Deputy would tell me what his income is, I would give him the exact relief.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

I do not know what the younger executive's income would be, because I regret to say I have passed out of the younger executive class, and so I do not know.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say what this surtax concession amounts to in one year?

Comment on this

£150,000.

Comment on this

I do not think it was given in the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

It was. May I just say that it is mainly a readjustment inside the surtax system, plus £150,000?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

This policy of penal taxation on higher income levels does not help us as a country. In the long run, it is bound to affect the urge towards greater profits and the urge which all young people have to get the maximum return for their labour. It means that we are placed at a disadvantage in comparison with other countries. Yesterday evening I was talking to a solicitor who said that some years ago he was approached by many different wealthy individuals who were contemplating coming to Ireland to live but that when they went into it, they found that the rate of taxation was too high. This idea has been put forward in relation to death duties by a number of people who felt that if we cut down our death duties, we would gain by attracting an increased number of wealthy people who would give employment and provide much-needed revenue. We certainly follow a policy of taxing these people very highly and this has been to our detriment as far as revenue yield is concerned. We have lost by it.

The Minister referred to culture and leisure and speaking as another vulture for culture, I was glad to see that he referred to our love for, and interest in, the arts. I want to say to him that I wish he would get a move on with the Kennedy Concert Hall and its Committee. I am a member of that Committee and it has not met for a long time. It was and is doing very excellent work. The Concert Hall is not actually being held up to the extent it appears to be because the architect and his team have been working away but he has not had the financial support which he wishes for. The Committee wish to see the project progressing at such a rate that the hall will be completed in a fairly short time, or certainly within a reasonable time. It is a very beautiful design and well worthy of the man to whose memory the people and the Government are to erect it. I take this opportunity of asking the new Minister to push forward this project with all speed. There is also a high labour content in it and the amount that falls to be spent in any one year is very small.

I do not intend to speak very long on this Budget. It is mainly a political Budget, with a touch of social welfare thrown in. I am sorry the opportunity has been lost for another 12 months of stimulating industry and business generally. We badly need a Budget which will ease somewhat the appalling burden of taxation on industry generally. I would like to work out— I have never been able to do so—what the burden of taxation is on every employed individual in this country. It is very high. I refer to people employed right from the low levels. Every employed man in Ireland is carrying a very heavy burden of social welfare on his back and a very heavy burden of taxation generally. It is up to the Government to see that that burden is made as light as possible. Owing to the high level of taxation, the individual wage earner is now carrying a heavier burden than he should.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary

Having listened to the moaning and groaning of the Opposition speakers during the three weeks of the by-election campaign in South Kerry and having listened to their speeches here tonight, I have no doubt that the electors of South Kerry and Waterford were fully justified in demonstrating at the polls their confidence in the Government. I have heard Deputy Dockrell say that this Budget should have been designed to boost the economy more. I maintain that the economy is sufficiently boosted at the moment. The proof of that is that in order to provide additional services and benefits, it was necessary for the Minister for Finance to impose additional taxation to the extent of only £2½ million in the current financial year. This is a very popular Budget.

I want to refer to certain aspects of it. There is no doubt that the Government are fully conscious of the need to solve the problems confronting the people in the West, and in the congested and undeveloped counties. To my mind, the future of these areas depends on specialised lines of agriculture, fisheries and tourism. I welcome, in particular, the additional grant of £100,000 to Bord Fáilte to provide extra subsidies for the farm holiday schemes. Very many people in the rural communities, particularly in the tourist areas, could benefit immensely by these schemes.

The proposal to operate a scheme of grants for the development of caravan sites is another improvement in this direction. Recently there have been great developments in the acquisition, development and maintenance of these sites. It costs a considerable sum to do this. At present it appears that in Britain this tourist market is overtaxed and in all probability, over the next few years we are going to get much more caravan amenities. This scheme of grants has come just in time.

There is another aspect of this Budget which will be welcomed in the 12 western counties, that is, the provision of £250,000 for county development teams. These teams have done tremendous work since they were initiated 18 months ago. They have carried out very detailed surveys and it is well known that before any real scheme can be initiated, one must have a well carried out survey. These surveys, which are now available, will be of tremendous advantage to the Department of Finance, as well as to the county development teams themselves. In Kerry, the county development team were responsible for initiating small industries. They played a big part in the provision of a major industry in Killarney which was helped immensely by the conditions prevailing as a result of the Free Trade Agreement. The Minister was fully justified in providing an additional £250,000 for these teams which consist of the senior officers of the local councils, the vocational education committees and the county committees of agriculture.

The relief of rates on the first £20 of land valuation will be more than welcomed. I was amazed that Fine Gael allowed it to go on record that they voted against this yesterday evening. As regards rates generally, which are increasing yearly, I feel that they have now reached a peak. The Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government should pay special attention to the various schemes being carried out by local authorities, and particularly the schemes being carried out by county councils and borough corporations. Every effort should be made to have these schemes carried out as efficiently as possible, particularly the major water supply schemes, sewerage schemes and housing schemes. Very often what the local authorities should try is some pilot schemes, and instead of carrying out schemes by contract, they should do them themselves by direct labour under the supervision of a works study engineer. If they did that, I have no doubt that the profits accruing to the contractors would be there for the benefit of the ratepayers. Each local authority should have a contracts department, or a department which would specialise in carrying out these schemes under the supervision of a works study engineer. It is well worth trying.

I know that the people in the towns and village who have no agricultural land, when they realise that farmers with valuations of up to £20 will not now be liable for rates, will ask why they cannot get a reduction on somewhat similar lines. The answer is that the incomes of property owners in towns have increased far more than the incomes of the farming community. Over the past ten years or so, the gap has widened, and particularly over the past two years.

It should be of great concern to the Government and to the nation that the cost of the health services is increasing rapidly year by year without any expansion in the services. This is due mainly to increases in salaries and wages, and the high cost of the administration of the services generally. The increasing cost of the services is due, to a great extent, to the high and ever-increasing cost of drugs and medicines. I recommend strongly to the Minister for Health, and the health authorities in general, that some scheme should be initiated whereby a central pharmacy would be set up in each health authority. These central pharmacies exist in Limerick and Dublin, and considerable savings are made on drugs and medicines.

By having a central pharmacy, the health authorities could bulk-buy drugs, probably at a reduced rate. There would be no wastage because the stock could be taken back into the central pharmacy before going out of date. There would be more control of the system of ordering drugs and medicines, and more control of the drugs and medicines themselves. An effective saving could be made along these lines. I strongly recommend to the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Health that they should look at this aspect of the administration of the health services.

There is no doubt that the Fianna Fáil Government can be regarded as the Government for the poorer section of the community. The poorer sections of the community can thank the Fianna Fáil Government for the rapid increases in social welfare benefits over the past ten years or so. For the first time, 10,000 smallholders will be eligible for unemployment assistance throughout the whole year. This scheme is, to my mind, a remarkable achievement. It is something that could not even have been dreamed of a few years ago.

It is unfortunate that in this country, which is predominantly an agricultural country, about 70 per cent of the people are engaged in non-agricultural employment. That leaves about 30 per cent engaged in agriculture. This means a heavy subsidy in relation to agriculture. The Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture should take a hard look at our agricultural advisory service. There is no doubt that this service is manned by outstanding agricultural instructors. I think we are right in concentrating on pilot schemes and in thinking in terms of extending the pilot areas. Instead of having 20 or so agricultural instructors in each county, we should have 20 or 30 pilot farms in each county, each controlled by an agricultural instructor. The records would be available for inspection by the local farmers. These pilot farms should be a model for the other farmers who would be thinking in terms of improving their own holdings up to the same standard as the pilot farms, provided they were satisfied that the pilot farms were showing a good return.

This Budget is definitely a good Budget for the small farmers, one of the worst off sections of the community. A small farmer with a valuation of between £5 and £10, rearing a family on a farm carrying six to 12 cows, has very little income between 1st October and the time when his first milk cheque comes in May. He can definitely thank the Government for the extension of the unemployment assistance scheme to the whole year. This will help to supplement his income.

I heard Deputies criticising the Department of Finance, or the Minister for Finance, in that it was alleged that there are too many civil servants. Probably in relation to the population and the gross national expenditure, we have as great a number as any country, and perhaps a greater number; but, again, we must always remember that, in all probability, the same number of civil servants could cater for a larger population and could also control a much larger expenditure. We should thank the previous Minister for Finance, Senator Dr. Ryan, for initiating schemes of organisation, methods of work study and efficiency methods in State Departments. I welcome the statement of the Minister for Finance that he is keeping a close eye on developments in that regard.

It is being alleged that this is a political Budget and that it is perhaps geared for the local elections. I say that it is not a political Budget, that it is merely a good Budget. It shows up the poor case made by the Opposition against the Budget. It might be no harm if we did have political Budgets. I know of some councils which are controlled by Fine Gael and which have failed miserably to live up to their responsibilities, particularly as regards housing.

In Killarney Urban District Council, which is controlled by Fine Gael, 12 houses were built in ten years in a town with an increasing population, with a growing tourist industry and with three major factories. This council had the audacity to blame the Government for their failure to live up to their obligations and responsibilities. Then, when they failed to get away with that, they proceeded to lay the blame on Kerry County Council and stated that the county council were not prepared to acquire compulsorily land for housing in the county health district adjacent to the town of Killarney. This would be useful to them because it would save them the trouble of providing houses. They also said they had taken steps to acquire land compulsorily within the urban area. It is quite clear, from a reply I received from the Minister for Local Government to a question I asked last week, that no proposal came up to the Minister for Local Government to confirm a compulsory purchase order for the provision of housing there. It is just about time the public got away from Fine Gael control in local councils.

I shall conclude by saying that I believe that this is a very good Budget, a popular Budget. It reveals the progressive thinking of the Government. It fully justifies the confidence of the electors of Waterford and South Kerry recently.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Acting Chairman (Mr. P. O'Donnell) Fine Gael

Deputy Ryan.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the fact that we have been obliged to suffer in recent weeks——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy but the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Davern, offered and the Chair did not see him. It would have been the turn of Labour or Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

I shall give way to Deputy Ryan.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

As the Parliamentary Secretary gives way, the Chair calls upon Deputy Ryan.

Comment on this

Let us get rid of Deputy Ryan. Let us get him over and done with.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the fact that we have been obliged to suffer in recent weeks from an overdose of statistics and economic balderdash, I am obliged to Deputy J. O'Leary for drawing attention to the building problem because some interesting statistics were given today. In the course of a reply by the Minister for Local Government came these interesting statistics showing us what is happening in two county councils where Fianna Fáil have an overall majority. In Kerry County Council, we find that——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy but I did give Deputy J. O'Leary a certain latitude in view of the fact that it was his maiden speech. We cannot go into details of Estimates on the Budget debate. Housing would be much more appropriate on the Estimate for the Department of Local Government. However, the Deputy may refer to it.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. We have been given an overdose of statistics in recent weeks which nobody could possibly digest or comprehend. I have a desire to quote only about half a dozen statistics for the benefit of Deputy J. O'Leary. I crave the indulgence of the Chair: this is my maiden speech on the Budget from the Front Bench of the Opposition. For the benefit of Deputy J. O'Leary and so that he may concern himself in his conscience, if such he has left, with the figures of housing in two county councils in which Fianna Fáil have an overall majority, I put the following information on record. In Kerry County Council, about which I presume he would know something, the number of houses built last year was only 108 and in no year since the last year in which Fine Gael were in Government have they been able to equal the number of houses which we obliged them to build and which we saw to it every local authority built when we were in power.

Comment on this

When was that?

Comment on this

Fundamentally, it is the Government who either approve or do not approve of plans. It is the Government who set the pace. It is the Government who can abolish the county council which fails to do its task. If the county councils are responsible for the total failure in relation to housing in the past decade, as the Minister for Local Government alleges, why has he not abolished the lot of them?

Let us go from Kerry along the western seaboard, in which Ministers pretend to be interested. In County Galway, on whose council Fianna Fáil have a majority, and with Fianna Fáil control over the council, they built only 30 houses last year as against 264 in the last year Fine Gael were in power. In the year before, they excelled themselves entirely because, in all of the County of Galway, they built one local authority house. Even allowing for all the emigration which Fianna Fáil have hastened and facilitated, even allowing for all the safety valves that have been opened, we know that, in the county of Galway —because they are there for anyone to see—there are some things which are like relics of the eighteenth century, mud cabins with weeds growing from the roof. The only sign of life comes from a hole which might pass as a chimney. To meet the housing needs of those unfortunate people, the Fianna Fáil county council and Government could build in one year one house. Nor is that the whole story.

In Dublin city, where today there are 10,000 families applying to Dublin Corporation for houses, we built last year only 1,141 to meet that demand. At the present rate, it will take ten years to meet the existing applicants, without making any provision for all the families that will come into being in the meanwhile, for all the people who will be evicted from houses by the Fianna Fáil so-called developers and for all the people who are going to crowd into this area in the next 18 years, if we are to believe some more of the dose of statistics we got from another source, the Wright Report, which the Government saw fit to have printed in Britain on British paper at a time when they were telling the rest of us to be Irish and buy Irish quality goods.

Comment on this

It was not printed by the Government.

Comment on this

We have printers here printing banknotes and stamps for countries right across the world. Yet we have the Government paying a foreign expert to come over here to write more of this statistical balderdash and to have it printed at our expense in Britain.

Comment on this

It is not true.

Comment on this

It is time we had the last of this hypocrisy with a capital "H", the last of the Haughey hypocrisy, or, if you want to make it really hypocrisy, the "Mahockey" hypocrisy. That is all we had yesterday and that is all we are likely to get in the course of this debate from the Government benches. Leaving aside all this sales talk from "Mahockey" and his associates, this year's Budget amounts to the payment of conscience money. That is all.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to me in those terms, Sir?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I take it the Deputy is not referring to the Minister?

Comment on this

If the Minister does not know his own name in Irish——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy should not refer to the Minister as such. He should refer to him as Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I am referring to the sales talk——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

When referring to the Minister, the Deputy must refer to him as such.

Comment on this

I am prepared to refer to the Minister as such, to isolate the Minister as such from the kind of sales talk we are given by the Fianna Fáil propaganda machine. It reflects on the dignity of the House to have that type of propaganda brought in here, by whomsoever it should be brought. Yesterday's Speech stripped of its verbiage, amounted to no more than a declaration and payment of conscience money.

Comment on this

You are a reflection on the dignity of this House: you are only a "gutty".

Comment on this

The vocabulary to which the Minister has access and is familiar with is beyond me. Therefore, I have not the ability to assess whether his remark is parliamentary or otherwise. I suspect it is not. The situation last year was that our unfortunate old age pensioners and other social welfare beneficiaries were deliberately led to believe they were to get an increase of 5/- in their pensions. Is there any old age pensioner who thought otherwise? Not one. But they found themselves deprived of this if they were believed to have as much as one penny beyond what was paid to them in a pension. Even if they could not be proved to be receiving a cash benefit, if they happened to have as much as a bundle of rags in the kitchen corner, that was regarded as ground for disqualifying them from getting the 5/- a week.

These unfortunate people have lived in great hopes that the money which should have been paid to them years ago would, in the long run, be paid. So it was that yesterday we had the declaration of intent to pay these unfortunate people their conscience money as from next August, if they should survive until then. There is an obligation on people to pay money to the estate of deceased persons when it is due. Even though many of these old age pensioners will go to their eternal reward in the meanwhile, there is a clear obligation on the Minister to pay to the next of kin this 5/-, which should be paid forthwith.

In addition to this conscience money Budget we have some benefits paid to a small fringe of our people. This indicates to me that the Minister is overconcerned with a small fringe of our population but does not understand the real problems facing tens of thousands of our working families, where the income is from £8 or £10 to £16 a week, where the people are lucky if they see butter on a Sunday, where they have meat but one day per week. Oh, there are many people in the drawing rooms and lounges of the wealthy houses who do not know, not how the other half lives, but how four-fifths of the people live-living from hand to mouth, depending on the children's allowances at the end of the month to pay the rent and, if they will stretch far enough, to pay the ESB bill.

We are exhorted to exercise restraint in wage claims: the people earning £8, £10, or £14 a week are exhorted not to look for any more. But the people who exhort them through deliberate Government action, have seen to it that these people have in the last year or so to pay at least £1 a week extra for the necessaries of life. As a result of a direction by the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Finance, the rents of local authority houses have been jacked up. For many workingclass families in this city, in which half the people now live in local authority houses, this has meant an increase in weekly rents of 6¾ or more. Since the last round of wage increases these people have been obliged to pay, if they are lucky, on average from 4/strain to 6/- extra a week in bus fares. The recent increases in the price of the staff of life, bread, means for many working families an increase in weekly expenditure of 5/-. That is about 15/- out of every wage packet already accounted for. There is nothing in this Budget, good, bad or indifferent, in relief of any person who finds the weekly demands on his pay packet unbearable.

The Budget shows a concern—and, I think, a fair one—for people in relation to their medical expenses. Accordingly, there is a certain allowance to be given if their medical expenses are above £50 and if they are paying tax. Certain reliefs are also being given to families with children under 11 years of age. It strikes me as a rather weird approach to the problem of relieving families to say we are giving you relief of £15 for every child under 11 but in respect of every child over 11, who costs more to feed, clothe and educate, who costs more in innumerable ways, you will get nothing.

Comment on this

They already have more.

Comment on this

It seems a weird approach to life to be giving this relief for the younger members of the family. For a baby crying in the cradle, there is to be £15 a year relief, but for a child who has to have his bus fares paid to and from school, who has to be clothed and kept in pocket money and have money for many other purposes, there is nothing by way of relief. That is weird and strange, but we are used to it from Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

We would not expect the Minister to recognise it as weird because his approaches are weird in many respects. I can understand his difficulty.

Comment on this

Why twist the facts? You are only a bunch of twisters.

Comment on this

It strikes us as not being a step in the right direction.

Comment on this

There are very many families in the categories I have mentioned.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no advantage in interrupting. I would ask Deputies to allow the speaker to proceed without interruptions.

Comment on this

And the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I ask everybody in the House; I am speaking to the House without any distinction.

Comment on this

I doubt, Sir—if it is any consolation to you—whether they will be able to interrupt me, no matter how loudly they shout. There is no relief for any family which is not paying tax. Although we know that the personal allowances, family allowances, children's income tax allowances and dependent relative allowances are inadequate, it is still true to say that those who are not paying tax at all are worse off than those who are. But there is no relief whatsoever for the families about which I am talking, for the wageearner who has £12 or £14 a week and is now called upon to pay 6/- extra for rent, 4/- extra for bus fares and 5/- extra for bread, not to talk about the price of milk and several other commodities.

If there is ever to be in this country a just society, if there is ever to be an equal distribution of whatever wealth or poverty we have, then it ought to be on the basis of helping poorer sections of the community. You do not do that by giving reliefs to the taxpayers but by giving it to those who are so poor that they are not paying tax at all.

We are not displeased that our voices have at last been heard and that an arrangement is to be worked out to allow old age pensioners, during the valley period, to travel on public transport free of charge, but one would think that it was going to cost CIE some money to provide this service for the old age pensioners. Are we to have an assessment made of the wear and tear of the seats occupied in buses and trains by old age pensioners during the valley periods, or of the wear and tear as a result of the marginally increased bus stoppages which may take place if only an old age pensioner is getting on or off a public service vehicle? That is the only increased cost which CIE will have to bear. I venture to say that the cost of measuring the marginal wear and tear involved there would be far greater than that of the wear and tear in question.

This is not a subsidy to the old age pensioners. It is a concealed subsidy to CIE, because this is money that CIE would not get otherwise, and it is something the old age pensioners need not say "Thank you" for at all, but Mr. Frank Lemass and his friends in CIE can say: "Thank you for this hidden gift," because that is what it is, a subsidy to CIE. If CIE needs a subsidy, let the Minister come to the House and say why he needs a subsidy and ask for it, but to act in this shabby way, trying to get a little bit of passing vulgar popularity for doing it, is somewhat disreputable.

The provision for the old age pensioners in relation to electricity again shows a lack of knowledge of how many old age pensioners live. Certainly in this city I think it is true to say that most of the old age pensioners cook by gas and if they do not cook by gas, they may try to boil a kettle or pot over the bag of "welfare" turf. Very few old age pensioners in the city of Dublin and, I suspect, in other urban centres where there is gas, cook by electricity. It seems to me only fair that if we are to provide something by way of relief of the cost of lighting and fuel for old people, it should not be confined to the State body, the ESB, but should also be given to the public gas companies in our cities and towns. Otherwise, the old age pensioners anxious to get some relief will be obliged to change over from gas to electricity and pay the capital cost of an electric cooker in the process.

I suspect that the Minister just did not think of that; I suspect his advisers did not think of that. I suspect that those who have been turning out the economic statistics and all the economic phraseology we have had poured out to us in recent weeks just did not think of that. These are the things that affect individuals and it is only when you understand the problems of individuals and of individual families that you know the kind of assistance they need.

In this city last year, there were nearly 2,000,000 penny dinners or free dinners, handed out. That is a statistic that is not to be found in the green, red and white coloured books issued by the Central Statistics Office and the Department of Finance. Why are these meals given? They are given because we have in our society tens of thousands of people who are on the border of starvation. It is time our people stopped feeling that everything was right in this land and that our obligations were only to people in poorer lands abroad. We are not for one moment making light of the needs of the world, but it is not fulfilling one's duty correctly to ignore one's neighbour, to pretend that he does not exist or to be ignorant about how he lives, and I fear there are in our community many people who are ignorant of how four-fifths of our people live.

The small relief to be given in respect of the electricity for light and power is less than the turnover tax which an old age pensioner has to pay for food, and it would have been far more to the point if the Minister had abolished the turnover tax on food and the necessaries of life. That would have been a worthwhile achievement and that would have given the old age pensioner far greater relief than this extremely costly scheme which he is going to provide in relation to electricity supply for old age pensioners.

At the moment we have a system of inspectors by the score, with Revenue Commissioners and employees by the hundreds, I suppose, collecting the turnover tax from, amongst others, old age pensioners, widows and blind and other social welfare beneficiaries. Now the State, which is taking more from those pensioners than the annual cost of electricity, is going to have some more inspectors on the Government side and more inspectors on the ESB side working out the system of doling back some of the money which has been taken from those pensioners in food. Is there no end to the operation to Parkinson's Law? To replace Nelson in O'Connell Street, we should now erect a monument to Parkinson because he is having a field day here. It is daft in the extreme that, when we are supposed to have control over our own affairs, we go through this rigmarole of taking tax from old age pensioners on the necessaries of life and then giving some of it back again so that they can pay their electricity bills. For that we are supposed to say: "Thank you." It seems to me quite crazy, incapable of any reasonable interpretation.

I began by quoting some building statistics. That was for the benefit of Deputy J. O'Leary while the point was still hot, he having concluded on it.

Comment on this

It was Deputy O'Leary won the South Kerry by-election.

Comment on this

It just shows that sometimes the truth does not pay.

Comment on this

Remember he won South Kerry by-election.

Comment on this

People who test everything by political success, and nothing else, have very low values. Thank God, there are in this country, and always will be, people who regard political success as secondary. A far more important test—it is the one with which we would concern ourselves— is the number of people in comfortable circumstances against the number in dire straits because of lack of money, food, clothing or shelter. Under Fianna Fáil, we have apparently forgotten that a man has a natural right to shelter. Mark you, I think they still recognise that he has a natural right to life and food. Shelter is just as essential to a decent and full life as are food and clothing. Yet we have in our society tens of thousands who have not got housing and have no reasonable prospect of getting housing for a number of years to come. Some may be near the point of getting housing a few years hence, but, at that point, they will go back down again on the waiting list because their children will have grown up and they will not have the numbers to qualify.

We are told we may not deal with statistics of housing, giving the number of houses which have or have not been built one year out and one year in; but we can look at another all important figure, namely, the percentage. Last year, at a time when the number of houses required to be built was not less than 150,000, we had a reduction of five per cent in building. That is not the whole story. A not inconsiderable proportion of the building which did take place was what I regard as non-essential building, the erection of offices to enable Parkinson to operate with greater speed and efficiency, non-essential building to improve the comfort of people who are not in what could be regarded as difficult working conditions. The kind of building we regard as of paramount importance is the building of homes for our people. In Britain recently people were shocked by a programme on television called "Cathy Come Home". The conditions depicted shocked many people in that much better-off society. They were shocked at the appalling housing conditions in which many people live. The housing conditions there depicted are no worse than those which tens of thousands have to tolerate in this country.

Some years ago Telefís Éireann had a 15 or 20 minutes programme on housing conditions. That shocked several people to such an extent that some of them gave it as their opinion that such films should not be shown on television. We will have to stop pretending these problems do not exist. These problems should be portrayed. We should all be aware of them. They are there, and it is only when we develop, as a community, a proper social conscience that the right steps will be taken to remedy the situation. As the Leader of the Opposition said today, the Government may boast all they like that they are paying out more money for housing, but they ought to complete the boast: they are paying more money for fewer houses because fewer are being built. It is not the amount of money that matters; it is the number of homes and the number of families that are housed in decent conditions, that do. So long as we do not approach the problem in the proper way, so long will we continue to regard half those on the housing waiting list as not in urgent need of rehousing.

I can give a case to illustrate what is not regarded as urgent. It is the case of a widow with three children, living in a very comfortable Dublin suburb, but in a derelict cottage, the roof sagging in the middle and covered with moss, a building so decrepit that, when she applied for a house improvement grant, she was denied the grant on the ground that the house was not worth saving. She is forced to cook, wash, live and sleep in one room because the second room is uninhabitable. In the room in which she sleeps she is obliged to spread across her bed and the bed of her children plastic sheets at night; she is obliged to string up a Health Robinson affair across the ceiling——

Comment on this

We will string the Deputy up.

Comment on this

——of pipes and plastic sheets to catch the rainwater and take it out through the window. The official designation of this woman's housing need is "Not in urgent need of rehousing." She is probably reflected in the statistics as a family of four in two rooms, not in urgent need of housing, and the city medical officer, not because his heart is not full of compassion for her plight but because of the dictation by the Custom House and the Fianna Fáil Government, is unable to give that woman a certificate to say that she is in need of housing. Because some of us honestly believe these matters should be brought home in this sovereign Parliament, there are those who would string us up for daring to air them. That is the kind of thing that happens in every reactionary Government; when people with consciences try to publicise real misery, it is said immediately that they are only fit to be strung up for daring to open their mouths. I could keep the House engaged for months with similar pitiable stories but you, Sir, would not allow me or, rather, I should say the rules of order; it is not you, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Does the Deputy blame me?

Comment on this

On the contrary; I have no wish to blame you. I give credit where credit is due. I abide by the rules and I expect others to do likewise.

I am aware of another family living in a basement seven feet below street level. This is in the area the music halls and the comic papers have for years spoken of as "Rawthmines". This unfortunate family — husband, wife and three children — are condemned to live in the basement of a house so damp that a fungus grows on the floor as quickly as the housewife removes it. Again, this family is described in the official housing statistics as not requiring rehousing. They are listed as a family of five in two rooms. The toilet is no more than an area separated from the livingroom by two pieces of plywood. These are the housing problems which are being ignored because if any Government were concerned to relieve the housing problems, they would regard those people as entitled to a medical certificate and entitled to immediate rehousing.

What is wrong is that people go through the modern housing schemes around our city and compare them with what they saw 30 or 40 years ago or what they san see sometimes in some of the back streets of Dublin, the old tenements. They think that this is great, that the housing problem has been solved. What they do not know is that even as I speak here tonight there are hundreds of families in which the man and woman and the children have to eat, cook, wash and sleep in what we call the box-room, the room which, in the better off houses, is used only to store the luggage they use for continental holidays because there is no room to put a bed. We have families living in these rooms with their beds and their cots. Some are unable to put in sufficient beds and cots for their children because there is no room for them. The pram is used for children of three and four years of age for sleeping and for sitting while they are taking their meals because there is no room for them anywhere else. These are multiplied not by two figures but by three figures and our people are not aware of it because the facade of those houses does not show the terrible circumstances of the people within. In another day and age such families would have lived in a large room in a Georgian house, the much condemned Georgian houses, but they would have had more cubic feet per person than people can get in the modern housing estate.

We in Fine Gael are quite well aware that our people do not appreciate that there are so many people living in such appalling housing conditions or if they do know, they could not care less because they are all right themselves. Because the people are not aware of it, the Fianna Fáil Government remain in office, and that is the only reason. That should not cause them any glory or satisfaction. If it eases their conscience that people are not aware of these things or could not care about them, it is a sorry day but it is something over which we have no control

There are those people who do not know better who have been led by the Fianna Fáil propaganda to suggest in recent times that Fine Gael are not concerned with getting into power, that Fine Gael would much prefer to remain in Opposition. Here we see the nodding heads of the boys opposite just to show the origin of this balderdash. I do not know what it requires. Does it require that members of Fine Gael or the people who are looking for decent housing should pour petrol over themselves and set themselves on fire to show how strongly they feel about this?

Comment on this

Neither Deputy Ryan nor any member of the Fine Gael Party attended the housing estimates meeting of Dublin Corporation this year.

Comment on this

It seems until such time as there is such a sacrifice or an identifiable tragedy, no proper steps will be taken to meet the housing needs of our people.

We are told that there is not sufficient serviced land on which to build houses. No individual can provide the serviced land. Land, to be serviced, must be land that Government concerns itself with acquiring for the public benefit. It is land in relation to which the Government must provide the money so that the necessary water and sewerage can be provided. It is no answer today to say in relation to housing problems; "We have not got the sites." The present Administration have been in power for ten disappointing years, ten years in which to provide the sites, ten years in which to do something about providing the money to provide water and sewerage and there is not even in this Budget at the end of ten years, one farthing to provide the necessary sites for all the houses that are to be built. What do they do to ease their conscience? They employ a foreign professor to come over here and have a few looks around and rush back to Liverpool to provide beautifully coloured maps and a lovely report printed in England on English paper. That is the solution of the housing needs. It is absolutely crazy. Why our people tolerate this is difficult to understand. One can only accept that they do not know, do not understand the problems and have been sadly misled.

For many years, we in Fine Gael have made clear that we believe our health services are grossly inadequate. We believe that the contention in the Government's White Paper that people in what they call the middle-income group do not suffer any hardship in meeting medical bills is an assumption which is groundless. We believe the Government themselves have now acknowledged that in the Budget, but again it is done in such strange terms, an admission given in the middle of the jungle of tax law and therefore not readily understood, but an admission none-the-less. By giving the relief they have given to people who are paying tax and who have medical bills in excess of £50 and under £300 a year, they acknowledge that there is hardship on people who have not got medical cards in meeting their medical bills. However, this is a relief which has been given to the taxpayer who is paying a fair amount of tax and who, on that account, one can safely assume, is somewhat better off than those who are not paying tax.

At present in Dublin city and county we have something less than 16 per cent of the population with medical cards. The remainder have to pay for all home medical services. The result is that we have hundreds of thousands of families denying themselves medical attention, postponing calling in the family doctor, because they fear that the cost of doing so is beyond their ability to pay. We have these families, of which there are hundreds of thousands also, not completing the course of drugs and prescriptions the doctor prescribes for them because they cannot afford the cost. It is no answer to say that, provided they can prove hardship after the event, they may get some assistance from the local authority. Few people know this.

We are conscious of the fact that the present rotten, crumbling, inefficient health service is costing more. We are conscious of the fact that it is going to cost another £4½ million next year. We are equally conscious that we could save money on the health services if we brought in a proper scheme of health insurance so that people could call upon a doctor of choice and could get drugs and medicines at half-price. That could be done at a cost similar to the increase this year. There would be this difference, however. There would be a saving equal to the additional cost of providing a proper home medical service. I can appreciate that the details of a health scheme are not proper in detail on a Budget debate but it is very important for us to emphasise that when there was a surplus, nothing was done to provide a health service which every other country in this part of the world has, bar Finland.

I fail to see how you can call a Budget progressive or good, if it leaves us as backward as the Laplanders in relation to our health services, and this is what we are doing. This is an indication to me that the Government are prepared to recognise that there is hardship, that as between the 16 per cent who have medical cards and those who are paying tax, there is hardship. They could have done something about that or could have removed some part of it.

State pensioners who retired prior to January, 1964, are to be given a 12 per cent increase. This does not yet overtake the amount those people should get to bring them up to a figure equal to what is paid to pensioners who retired since then. This 12 per cent is to be paid to pensioners who are below the level of what has obtained from January, 1964, onwards. Many of them will now receive a 12 per cent increase in their pension but they will receive it on pensions which are probably running 30 or 40 per cent below par. The amount will not relieve the distress of these people in the autumn of their lives. It will all depend on lady luck whether they will get any of this money at all; it depends on whether they can breathe until August next. The increase is payable only from August onwards and is not retrospective. This is deplorable, and I hope we will soon have a Minister for Finance who will do the right thing by State and public pensioners, that is, to relate their pensions to what is now being paid to serving public servants and not to what was paid to them on the date they retired.

The State regards these pensions as postponed payments and, that being so, there is an obligation on the State to ensure that when postponed pay is paid out, it has some relation to the value of money on the day on which it was taken from them. This is going to cost money in any one year but until such time as that sensible step is taken, we cannot say that we are treating our public service pensioners properly.

We are told by the Minister that there is to be an increase of 1d per gallon in the price of milk from 1st May. This will also mean an increase in the price of butter of 2½d per lb. It may be that the Minister has provided, in the figures he has given, an indication of how he is going to pay this money. I understand this is to be an Exchequer payment.

Comment on this

I said in my speech that it was going to be paid in full by the Exchequer.

Comment on this

That was said on 11th-12th April, 1967. I warn the Minister that if there is any increase to the consumer, particularly to people who only get a limited pay packet, we shall call him to account for it. We know the Minister has made the calculation of £4 million for errors of estimation. That could also be used to enable him later on in the year to impose an increase in the price of milk and butter to pay for this increase. Nobody criticises the small reliefs given to the farming community. They deserve anything they have got and a great deal more. Three million pounds of the money they are getting is due to them. They lost that amount last year and this £3 million is only a payment of conscience money by the Government for money taken from them. The other £2 million could not be regarded as being generous.

When we were in office with our colleagues of the Labour Party, we made no apology for subsidising the necessaries of life. We believed it was proper to subsidise the necessaries of life and we believe it is the reasonable thing to do when the Government are calling for wage restraint, when the Government are taking steps to bring in restrictive measures and to penalise anybody who works towards an increase in his wages. We believe there is an obligation on the Government to maintain prices and we are sorry that the Government did not make provision in the Budget to subsidise some of the necessaries of life as an indication of their intent to hold the prices of the necessaries of life at the existing figures.

That would not compensate people who have lost so much over the past 18 months through the increase in the cost of living but it would be an indication that the Government are prepared to do something about an incomes policy. You cannot have an incomes policy without price restraint and it is immoral to restrain wages and salaries without restraining other incomes. It is not incumbent on certain sections of the community, the less well-off sections, to make sacrifices unless the Minister ensures that everybody makes a sacrifice according to his status and wealth.

There is nothing in this Budget for people in the urban areas and we are entitled to complain about that. In the urban areas, the cost of living is much higher than it is in the less sophisticated societies but there is no relief in the Budget for people in the urban areas. There may be an explanation for this. A Party who measure everything according to their own satisfaction are unlikely to think kindly of the urban areas that walloped them in the last Presidential election. They are getting their own back now.

Comment on this

We took a seat from you in Dublin in the last election.

Comment on this

For every one you took, we will take back three. The reason the Government have done nothing for the people in the urban areas is that they know that they have lost these people and are not going to get them back. That is the reason the Government are making no effort to win them back. The situation is that the present administration got into power on a slogan that employment was the test. That was the test by which they wished the people to judge the outgoing Government. Applying that test now, we find that they have reduced the number in employment by 50,000 when they promised an increase of 100,000, so that they are now 150,000 behind their target.

In the past five years, the so-called Golden Years, we had 14,500 fewer employed. We are now well off course in relation to the number we are supposed to have employed by 1970. It is significant that amidst the library of gobbledegook passed out to us in recent weeks, we have not yet had any comment or explanation about the failures in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion. The simple fact is that you do not need expert committees to judge your failures and explain them away. The real reason is that the Government have applied wrong policies ever since they got into power. At last Ministers have come to accept the Fine Gael approach to development. They now accept—and it was accepted by the Minister yesterday— ten years too late, that you cannot have economic development in isolation, that you cannot have financial progress in isolation, that you cannot divorce economic prosperity from social welfare, and that a country which postpones improvements in housing, schooling, health services and in the various other humane services, is not making progress but is in fact building up untold trouble for itself. It gets an unbalanced economy and that is what we have at present.

The minor attempts that have been made to provide something in the form of capital for certain educational purposes is capital of a very perishable kind. I understand that we now have over 700 pre-fabs for primary schools. We are not confining this form of doubtful capital equipment to primary schools; we are also providing Garda stations in pre-fabs. What is this building up? This is building up huge arrears of capital investment which will have to be met in 15 to 20 years time. Of course, I realise that even the bloated ambitions of the Fianna Fáil Party do not extend to remaining in power all that time. They realise they will be found out by then and will be very far removed from power. It will be left to another administration to replace the 20th century hovels, the wooden huts now being erected, and being described as capital expenditure, for schools and Garda stations.

Then we hear about town planning. Daily I pass through Rathmines, which was built in all its glory without all the town planning paraphernalia and regulations that are now supposed to be applied. In that well-built suburb, you find no pre-fabs, no derelict buildings, no sign of bad planning other than a new wooden hut that has been erected for a Garda station. This is an indication of an avoidance of duty on the part of the Government. Instead of building for Rathmines what it badly needs, a proper Garda station, the Garda are provided with a wooden hut in which to carry out their growing duties in that important suburb.

That, to my mind, is an indication of a Government with very confused ideas. In that suburb, too, and in other parts of Dublin, not alone are the people being called upon to pay increased rates but they also have the greatest increase in valuation ever imposed. It is clear from the trend of events that a direction has been issued by the Department of Finance and by the Department of Local Government that properties in many areas in Dublin are to be increased in valuation. The result is that many people, without having their property inspected by anybody from the Rates Department of the corporation, or from the Valuation Office, have had their rateable valuation increased by as much as 50 per cent or 60 per cent, and in many cases, more.

There are many people who are going hungry in this city today in order to pay their rates; there are many people going without proper clothing in order to pay their rates; there are many people who deny themselves necessary medical treatment in order to pay their rates. Some of these people, in order to try to meet the crippling cost of rates, and to try to keep pace with the cost of living while their own pensions and other incomes depreciate, have sublet part of their houses at reasonable rents. As a result of a direction of the Fianna Fáil Government, they are to be milked for additional rates, not only for the 6/- increase which Dublin Corporation had no option but to impose in order to meet increased costs, but in increased valuation. There are many cases in which these increased valuations in Dublin will mean as much as 15/- extra per week. Take this 15/- extra per week for rates, your 5/- extra for bread and 4/- extra for bus fares, and you get some ideas of the pressures and anxieties of these people which drive them to call for an improvement in their wages and incomes.

I do not think our people are by nature selfish. I do not think there are many sections of our community whose sole desire is to better themselves and be indifferent to the welfare of others. I have met, and I am sure many other Deputies have met, people from all strata in our society who were concerned that they found themselves once again in a situation in which their last increase had been whittled away and they were concerned that they were forced again to look for more money to bring themselves to the level at which they previously were. In the main, that is the beginning of all wage demands. The improvement in living standards over the years has been insignificant compared with the pressures which have to be applied in order to maintain living standards as they were. That is particularly so under the present administration.

I was interested to read recently a comment from a former Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance, a man who held office for many years and who is mainly responsible for the present dangerous financial policies of the Fianna Fáil administration, Dr. Ryan, now Senator Ryan. He poured scorn on the first Cosgrave Government because it was concerned with the cost of government, because it was concerned with taxation and with maintaining money values.

Comment on this

The Deputy's Government refused to build houses because of the cost.

Comment on this

It is interesting that the Government in question multiplied the number of houses built in their ten years by 28, compared with the number of houses built in the previous ten years. It is extremely interesting if one does not confine oneself to the statistics published, but studies the whole problem. The figure which I quoted did not come from any official source but from a very reliable source, an OECD publication. It is also to be found in a most interesting paper published by the Institute of Public Administration. This shows that the most rapid increase in building in our history was during the first years of the State. Not nearly enough houses were built, of course, and not as many as might have been built if a great deal of public money had not been wasted on the destruction of public and private property by the enemies of the State. These exercises in history are matters of interest to those who are concerned with the development of our nation, but they give no relief to a person looking for a house in 1967. I have no wish to proceed any further on that line.

I want to complain about the very poor approach made in relation to the social welfare sections. We do not regard the 5/- which is being given as nearly enough.

Comment on this

Nor do we.

Comment on this

If you do not regard it as enough, it is for you and you alone to increase it.

Comment on this

It is a lot better than what you gave.

Comment on this

We find it hard to be patient with the letter writers, of whom there are not a few in this country, who write and say that Members of the Dáil are to be blamed because pensions or benefits of one kind or another are not better. It is important that we should underline the fact that the Ceann Comhairle has a duty to perform in relation to amendments put down to the Finance Bill. Any amendment which comes from a Member of the House other than a Minister which would impose any additional charge on the Exchequer is ruled out of order. No private Member of this House, not even a Government back bencher, has any power in our democracy such as it is, and under our rules of order such as they are, to do anything about improving pensions or benefits.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I hope the Deputy is not blaming the Chair.

Comment on this

No; I am talking about the rules of the House and the constitutional laws of the State which prevent any Member of the House other than a member of the Government from moving an amendment which would have the effect of giving any additional benefits to any section of the community.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

Fine Gael are concerned with developing the public conscience. Many people say that the weakness of Fine Gael is that we are too far ahead, that we are too progressive, that we cannot bring the people with us, that we have not yet convinced the people——

Comment on this

That is the truest thing the Deputy ever said—that you cannot bring the people with you.

Comment on this

We are not concerned with whether or not we have yet converted the people to appreciate what we are preaching about the need for an immense social reform and, indeed a social revolution. We will continue to preach it because we see year in and year out an unwilling Administration takinfi a little here and pretending to give a little there. We can only hope that the people will appreciate who are the real authors of the improvements. They just get these marginal reliefs which are not nearly sufficient to provide them with an adequate livelihood.

The Government have endeavoured to take credit for extending the period for the payment of unemployment benefit from six to 12 months. I am surprised to realise from my reading of the published reports of the Budget that it has not yet been driven home to the people that a larger proportion than heretofore of this improvement will have to be paid for by the people who pay insurance. We are told by the Minister that slightly more than two-thirds of the cost of the rate increase of the insurance contribution will be paid by the people who are making the contribution. That means that the people who are paying the insurance at the present cost, the workers and employers who are paying 60 per cent of the cost, will be called upon to pay something in the region of 68 to 70 per cent. Not only have they to pay more for whatever reliefs or improvements that are to be given on the proportion now paid but they are also called upon to pay an additional ten per cent or thereabouts of the total cost of social insurance. The gentleman who got the applause yesterday was in fact getting it in large measure on a pretence because the major part of the increased cost is to be borne by the workers themselves.

It is also interesting to know that the reason for increasing the unemployment benefit period from six months to 12 months is the expectation of prolonged employment. That is the test we wanted to apply ten years ago. We have here a Budget which does a little here and a little there but overall does nothing for the economy, a Budget which is prepared to accept as a sine qua non of the economic conditions of the country that next year the unemployment figure will stay as it now is. It is now at 77,000. Do not worry about juggling statistics and economics which removed from the public mind 14,000 unemployed people last year by pretending they did not exist. Remember we have 77,000 unemployed on the basis of the calculations used in this country for 40 years and the Government do not intend to do anything next year to give any relief to those people. In fact, they accept the OECD report and the Department of Finance Report which suggest that possibly the trend will be the wrong way.

Perhaps one of the most sensitive barometers of economic activity is a Deputy's mailbox, his letterbox, the mail he gets. We have found over the past year or so a huge increase in the number of constituents who are looking for employment and in the number of constituents who are cut off from unemployment benefit and are unable to get unemployment assistance. That figure has been multiplied since last year and shows no sign of relaxing. There is nothing, simply nothing, in this Budget to give those people any hope whatsoever that their needs will be attended to. That is why, above all else, we say this Budget is a failure. That is why we protested yesterday by voting as we did. We were quite well aware, having heard these clever bucks in the past 40 years, that they would misrepresent what we did but we knew, likewise, that, if we did not vote against the Budget, they would also misinterpret it.

We are here to protest, to oppose, to criticise and to indicate to the people the points on which we disagree with the Government. We say that, when a Government are already beyond the target which they themselves fixed for taxation three years hence, the Opposition have a duty to protest that the Government have exceeded the target. They are already far beyond the target of 1967 and they are beyond the target of 1970. The only way left open to us to protest against that and to pinpoint that failure is to protest against the increase in the price of the workingman's pint. God knows, there is not much left to him now. It would have been a small consolation to him to leave even that much to him. I think most old age pensioners can spare little for what amenities or luxuries this life can afford, other than the pint. They still make the sacrifice. There are many to be seen in the snugs and pubs in this town drinking their pint. But, lo and behold, that is the commodity that is picked on to provide money for other marginal reliefs for the executives——

Comment on this

Dry martinis, no pints.

Comment on this

I have yet to see a young executive drinking a pint.

Comment on this

A cocktail.

Comment on this

They are leaving the spirits, which are relieved. If the Government had taxed the spirits, we should not have protested. We do not see that there is any tax upon the cocktails, the dry martinis. These have not been increased. We have to concern ourselves with the young executives who, we are led to believe, are flying from the country.

Comment on this

Mohair socials.

Comment on this

Lord bless us and save us, they must be hairy executives in Taca. These were the young executives and I suspect they are. Does the Minister seriously contend that there is a brain drain from this country from among the young executives, from the operators of Parkinson's Law? Does he seriously contend that that is so? Or is it because he says some members of Fine Gael say it that Fianna Fáil accept it? We are most impressed that they should do so. I know there is no section of the community any Government would not like to relieve of tax burden but we suspect very much a Government who do so little for the poor man, for the man who is so poor that he does not pay tax, but who find it necessary to give relief to the young executives—not, mind you, to the wealthy executives, whoever they may be. I do not know what the Minister hopes to get from them but is is quite clear that this little treat was given. It will be interesting to know—I think Deputy Corish was trying to get this information—just how much this will mean for any young executive. Just how much will it mean? Would it be £100 a year?

Comment on this

£138.

Comment on this

That is the price of a dinner.

Comment on this

You see, Sir, our people are not gullible. Our people can see through this fraud. This is the compensation for the young executives. People might wonder, betimes, who these people are who are prepared to buy their way and buy their influence and pay for protection, for political and social protection. It is not hard to find out. They may have been entertained recently at a function to which the gentleman of the Fourth Estate were not admitted but anybody may see them at hoolies in the Castle. Wherever the Taoiseach or a Government Minister is running a "do", a hooley, a what have you, a cocktail party, a reception with a capital "R", in the Castle, who are to be found at it but all the gauleiters of the Fianna Fáil Party? When the State very properly wanted to honour the men of 1916 who had sacrificed all when it seemed impossible to achieve the goal at which this country was aiming, namely, the goal of national independence, when our society and our State very properly wanted to honour these men and gave a reception in the Castle so that they might see, for the first time, the inside of the former headquarters of British Imperialism in Ireland——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is nothing about that in the Budget. If the Deputy cannot relevantly speak to the Budget, I shall ask him to sit down.

Comment on this

There is money provided in the Taoiseach's Estimate for this purpose and the Deputy is entitled to discuss it.

Comment on this

Part of the cost of government is the cost of State receptions. With respect, we are entitled to say——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has pointed out that the Deputy must speak relevantly to the Budget. The Chair will take no advice from Deputy L'Estrange on how he should order anything in this House.

Comment on this

On a point of order, it is in the Taoiseach's Estimate and therefore Deputy Ryan is entitled to discuss it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not discussing the Taoiseach's Estimate on the Budget, and if the Deputy does not accept that, he can leave the House.

Comment on this

Surely this debate has been so broad that it is not right to rule out Deputy Ryan on this point?

Comment on this

I think Deputy Ryan was referring to the Fianna Fáil Party fund, all right.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Receptions in the Castle do not arise on the Budget debate.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil receptions, no, but State receptions, yes.

Comment on this

The majority of them had to be carried home from the State reception in the Castle.

Comment on this

Some of your compatriots were there, sínte fada siar. I tripped over some of your friends.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary should not have got so drunk and he would not have tripped over people.

Comment on this

I was not drunk but one of them had his legs stretched out.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Ryan, on the Budget.

Comment on this

The old heroes could not sit down because of the crowd of Fianna Fáil cumann members at the function. The old people there had to leave early because of the insufferable conditions and because the place was so crowded out with Fianna Fáil subscribers who were brought along— the new "Castle hacks" of the 20th century who are being provided for in the marginal reliefs being given to the executives, to the people who pay surtax. I have no doubt they will be rewarded again by invitations to places which, according to the ruling of the Chair, I am not permitted to mention. I am satisfied they will be entertained at public expense, if not there, elsewhere. We, in Fine Gael, do not think this is good enough and another reason why we voted against the penny on the pint was so that it would not be used for the entertainment elsewhere of people buying their way, the new "Castle hacks".

Comment on this

We did not finance the Presidential election out of the tenants' funds.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

These problems embarrass the Government. They prefer these things not to be noticed. If the people of Dublin and Ireland want to know who is behind the Government, it will not cost them a penny to see. They just have to stand at the City Hall at the corner of Parliament Street any time there is a "do" on at the Castle.

It is not so long since the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party said taxation had reached the limit in this country and that it could not afford to go any further. I believe that was 11 or 12 years ago. It is interesting to note that in the past five years the figure has practically doubled. That may be no more than a reflection of the gross inflation taking place under the present administration, who scorned the first Cosgrave Government because they were concerned with endeavouring to keep down the cost of government.

These overall figures are meaningless unless you appreciate the value of money. Let us look at it in the terms of their own gobbledegook, what they call the current Government expenditure as a percentage of GNP. For those who do not know by now, that means Gross National Product.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowling thought it was another fund raising organisation.

Comment on this

This has increased from 21.1 per cent in 1961-62 to 21.7 per cent in 1962-63, to 22.5 per cent in 1963-64, to 23.2 per cent in 1964-65, to 24.4 per cent in 1965-66, to 25.5 per cent in 1966-67 and in 1967-68 to 28 per cent. This means that, at a time when the Government are reducing their own contributions to the Social Insurance Fund, notwithstanding the fact that they are passing part of the social welfare buck on to the workers and employers, they are taking another chunk of 2½ per cent as the Government's share of the GNP.

If the Government were spending the money wisely or better than anybody else, one might say it was excusable, but there are no signs that they are doing so. In fact, all the indications are that the economic trend is in the opposite direction. As Deputy Corish said, a balanced Budget is no proof of a sound economy. I believe this country was never in such a dangerous economic position. The indications are that we are in for a further period of recession and all the brave talk yesterday about reflation indicates that this is another economic term they do not really understand. We can expect a new commission to be established about five years hence to explain what they meant by reflation in 1967.

What we need here is a proper boost to our economy. By that I mean not just only a boost for exports. There are a large number of small family businesses which are on the verge of bankruptcy or liquidation. There is no assistance being provided by the Government: quite the reverse. These are small, traditional family businesses which have a stake in this land. if they make a profit, they spend the money in this land. These businesses have been run by people whose roots are in this land. But the people being encouraged to compete with these small businesses are foreign developers who, if they make profits—as they most certainly will and as they are doing—will take those profits out of this country and spend them abroad. This is profit which in many cases will not pay tax here.

It is time an end was put to the invasion of our economy by so many foreigners, particularly in the distributive traders. It is appalling to see the number of workers in the distributive trades dwindling at a catastrophic rate. Again and again the Government have been asked by the Fine Gael benches to restrict the invasion of foreigners into our distributive trades, but they have done nothing about it. It is not only the land of Ireland that belongs to the Irish people. The businesses and shops of Ireland and the welfare of Ireland belong to them also. There is just as much obligation on the Government to keep out those unnecessary and unwanted foreigners in the distributive trades. One is at a loss to understand why the Government have failed to take the necessary steps to protect our people.

We believe that the situation, bad and all as it is at the moment, is likely to get worse. Many of these concerns are part and parcel of huge British combines which manufacture their own foodstuffs and other articles. Under the various rules for import licences and tariffs we have at present, these people are unable at present to bring in in any significant quantity their own goods from their own factories or otherwise in Britain. But, as the free trade plan comes into operation and the various protections we have at the moment melt away, these concerns will reduce their rate of purchase from Irish factories and firms. There will be nothing to stop them bringing in their own goods from Britain and distributing them to the monopolised retail outlets they are developing. It will be too late to endeavour to control this after the damage has been done. Now is the time to control it. It would be quite easy to impose a significant stamp duty on these property developers, on these huge British supermarket firms and so on. I believe if a sufficient stamp duty were imposed, we would be able to keep these people out.

While on the question of stamp duties, we in Fine Gael wish to complain that this Government, while they have displayed anxiety to amend various tax laws in order to keep pace with Britain, have not yet done something Britain has long since done. We in Fine Gael do not advance as a reason why it should be done that it has been done in Britain, but we do advance as a reason for doing it the needs of the Irish people. I refer to stamp duty on houses. It is unforgivable that we extract three per cent stamp duty from anybody who goes to buy a house here. Why do it? Are those people engaged in anti-social expenditure? If they are buying their own house, they are relieving the community of the payment of subsidies and other expenses they might otherwise have to provide.

The continuation of this stamp duty is a blot on our society and a matter the Government should have done something about in a year in which there was some money available. The removal of the stamp duty on houses up to £4,000 would have cost less than the surplus which the Government had on last year's Budget. It would have been fully justifiable. It would have given the necessary impetus and encouragement to the building industry which is so badly needed. As I started on building, I shall conclude on it.

Comment on this